Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 3

Tribology International 34 (2001) 577–579

www.elsevier.com/locate/triboint

Book Review

Applied tribology – bearing design and lubrication wear, fretting wear, impact wear, rolling contact fatigue,
M.M. Khonsari and E.R. Booser, John Wiley and Sons, erosive wear, etc. While only some of these types of
Inc., 2001 wear relate to bearings, the main emphasis of the book,
the student should still be made aware of the breadth of
The number of new, tribology-related books seems to tribology, if only to place the wear of bearings into a
be on the rise in recent years. Like the tribology hand- proper perspective. There are plenty of reviews of wear,
books, some of these books are edited compilations of and the citation of one or more of them would help round
chapters by different contributors. Less common are the out this part of the introduction.
so-called tribology textbooks. I use the phrase ‘so-called’ The chapters in Part I provide excellent reviews of
because few of them actually contain features like sam- lubricant chemistry, additives, types of oils, viscosity
ple problem solutions and end-of-chapter exercises that grades, and more. Alignment charts and tables enable
are normally associated with a college textbook. Applied the reader to estimate properties of lubricants for use
Tribology is introduced by the authors as a textbook suit- in the book’s problem sets, and serve nicely for future
able for a one-semester (university) senior-level, elective reference. As required for a textbook, Applied Tribology
engineering course; a graduate-level course; or a refer- contains a number of step-by-step illustrations, and
ence book for practicing engineers and machine design- adequately defines new quantities when they are first
ers. Admirably, the book more than meets those objec- introduced. Chapter 3 provides a useful, practical dis-
tives. Considering the detailed nature of the material cussion of the measurement of surface texture, including
contained within the book’s 496 pages, it is unlikely that relevant symbols used in industry and applicable engin-
a one-semester course would allow sufficient time to do eering practice.
it justice. Chapter 4 of Part I, concerns bearing materials and
Applied Tribology is not simply an introduction to tri- their selection. It begins with a discussion of asperity
bology with an emphasis on bearing design. It also pro- contact and a brief description of the origins of dry fric-
vides a wealth of useful reference data, giving some of tion. Like the introduction, the discussion of ‘Wear’
its sections more of a handbook flavor. The combination emphasizes mainly sliding wear and concludes with two
of instructional text and tables of data is attractive short paragraphs of other forms of wear: one on surface
because it not only introduces the reader to basic con- fatigue and one on abrasive wear. Again, there is no
cepts, but also provides the data needed to apply them. mention of erosive wear, impact wear, etc. Despite their
One of the co-authors (Booser) is certainly experienced association with wear, contact fatigue and bearing life
in handbook development, having edited the well-known prediction are not found in the discussion of wear, but
series of three handbooks on lubrication (CRC Press, rather are placed in other parts of the book, as in the
Boca Raton, Florida). The advantages of that co-author’s section on ‘Load-Life Predictions’ (Chapter 13.8). It
work, and his access to a great deal of lubricant and might have been useful to cross-reference this later sec-
bearing materials data, increases the value and utility of tion since it also relates to wear and durability.
this book. The table of representative properties of sliding bear-
Applied Tribology is divided into three parts. Part I, ing materials that appears in the early pages of Chapter
called ‘General Considerations’, contains a brief dis- 4 is useful, but perhaps a little misleading because
cussion of the history of tribology. While the authors classes of materials are grouped together with only one
state that they will provide ‘…a few historical stepping typical value of each property. For example, only one
stones…’, they include only a brief, and in the set of representative properties is given for ‘steel’ despite
reviewer’s view inadequate, mention of the history of the fact that there are hundreds of steel alloys whose
wear research. It consists of a paragraph, barely six lines heat treatment and alloying gives them a wide range of
long, that mentions JF Archard’s wear equation. Any properties. It might be misleading therefore for design
new tribology student at least should be told that wear students to assume that they can choose only one rep-
occurs in different forms, like abrasive wear, sliding resentative value from the table for an entire class of
materials, like ‘aluminum’ and ‘cast iron’. Later in the
chapter, however, the discussion of compositions and
* Tel.: +1-423-574-5377; fax: +1-423-574-6918. properties of certain materials is expanded, and overall

PII: S 0 3 0 1 - 6 7 9 X ( 0 1 ) 0 0 0 5 9 - 7
578 Book Review / Tribology International 34 (2001) 577–579

it succeeds in imparting the need for careful attention to appropriately presented, clearly explained, and useful
material grades when making selections. for reference.
It might also be helpful if mechanical engineering stu- While the overall presentation of material throughout
dents were made more aware that the surface properties the book follows a logical and appropriate sequence,
of materials, particularly metals, can change once they Chapter 15 seems to stick out oddly at the conclusion
are placed in service and worn-in. Work-hardening dur- of Part III. Not only does its title, ‘Friction, Wear, and
ing sliding, for example, can change the relative hard- Lubrication’, nearly duplicate that of Chapter 1
ness of two mating bearing surfaces. While there is men- (‘Tribology – Friction, Wear and Lubrication’), but the
tion of solid lubricants and polymer composites, there is material probably should have been integrated into earl-
little mention made of hard coatings or surface treat- ier sections. There is little information presented in
ments. The discussion of bearing materials provides Chapter 15 that requires background information from
good general guidance; but it does not have the same having studied the previous 14 chapters. While it con-
depth and richness of detail as the mechanical engineer- tains some useful information, Chapter 15 seems some-
ing-oriented chapters that comprise the bulk of the book. how disconnected from the otherwise orderly structure
The student’s need for a good mathematics back- of the book.
ground surfaces in Part II of the book, titled ‘Fluid Film Appendices on unit conversions and viscosity conver-
Bearings’. Chapter 5 on the ‘Fundamentals of Viscous sions conclude the book. The subject index is adequately
Flow’ not only derives key relationships step-by-step, detailed. It is not clear whether an answer booklet is
but also discusses the principles of common experi- available for the end-of-chapter exercises. Availability
mental methods used to measure the magnitudes of the of such a guide would encourage faculty who might be
variables contained in these relationships. To understand contemplating the book’s use for their classes.
these concepts requires some knowledge of partial dif- A final comment concerns the choice of units of meas-
ferential equations and a familiarity with special tech- ure. The authors note in their Preface that sometimes SI
niques in integration. That approach is better than simply units are used, sometimes the older English units are
providing a ‘plug-in equation’, as is common in a num- used, and sometimes, dual units of measure are used. It
ber of other introductory tribology books. If the student is argued that the use of different types of units reflects
is prepared to spend the extra effort, there is adequate current practice; however, the decision to use non-metric
information in this book to provide the fundamental units is unfortunate because it continues to perpetuate
basis for understanding the origins of most of the the old system. Textbooks for 21st century students
important equations used in bearing design and analysis. should be forward looking, and the authors’ decision to
Chapter 6 contains a nicely-explained derivation of include archaic units will probably diminish the book’s
the Reynolds equation. It is presented in sufficient detail appeal to students and practicing engineers who are
to enable the modifications for special cases to be under- training and working outside of the USA.
stood. Thirteen problems at the end of that chapter test Applied Tribology has a great deal to offer mechanical
the student’s grasp of the material. Chapters 6–12 delve engineering students and practicing tribologists. It will
into the intricacies of bearing designs: thrust bearings, be a welcome addition to my own bookshelf. I wish,
journal bearings, squeeze-film bearings, hydrostatic however, that a discussion of just a few additional topics
bearings, gas bearings, and dry and starved bearings. had been included for the sake of completeness. These
Again, there is a nice set of problem-solving illustrations largely relate to materials aspects of tribology that
and case studies. For example, in describing squeeze- should be communicated better to mechanical engineers
film bearings, there is a table of closed-form solutions and designers. In addition to offering better coverage of
for the load-carrying capacity of various bearing geo- alternative forms of wear, the inclusion of more infor-
metries. This is followed by two practical examples: a mation on surface treatments, and some recognition of
piston pin and a human knee joint. Unlike some books the wear research that goes beyond the work of Archard,
on design theory that manipulate dimensionless quan- one additional subject related to bearings seems to have
tities whose significance may at times elude the student, been largely overlooked. That subject is running-in.
the current authors provide students with a tangible, There is no mention of the terms running-in, wear-in, or
physical connection to real components that have finite break-in in the book’s index. In only one place – a men-
physical dimensions and measurable properties. tion of the change in lambda ratio with running time
Part III of the book is devoted to ‘Rolling Element (Chapter 3) – could I find a mention of such phenomena.
Bearings’. Sections on nomenclature and codes will be Proper running-in can be important to the longevity of
helpful to those new in the field. Engineering details, bearings and when replacing worn parts with new ones.
like fits, chamfers, tolerances, and lifetime calculations Consequently, I was disappointed to see so little mention
are an excellent resource for the aspiring and practicing of it. On the other hand, research and education on run-
engineer alike. As in earlier sections, information is ning-in in the US trails that in other parts of the world,
Book Review / Tribology International 34 (2001) 577–579 579

so the omission of a discussion of that subject, while computational illustrations, exercises, and useful data, all
disappointing, is nevertheless understandable. presented in a format highly suitable for instructional
Despite the few shortcomings mentioned earlier, the purposes and future reference.
reviewer highly recommends acquiring a copy of
Applied Tribology – Bearing Design and Application. P.J. Blau*
The co-authors are to be commended on preparing a Oak Ridge National Laboratory, PO Box 2008,
clear and cogent treatment of practical bearing design Mail Stop 6063
and lubrication. This archival book is one of a rare few Oak Ridge, TN 378310-6063, USA
in our field that offers a well-tuned balance of theory, E-mail address: blaupj@ornl.gov

You might also like