Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Magazine 1
Magazine 1
too beautiful to be true, it probably is. If they promise you of losers against the average size of winners but also
quick wealth, quick is how you need to get out. the average holding period of losers against that of
winners. Also having a rising equity curve with small
New Quality Metrics drawdowns and more losers than winners is a strong
If returns are not the way to measure achievement, then indication of a good trader.
what is? Well, in true science we have to keep track of the One remarkable psychological study even showed
misses, not just the hits! Likewise a good trader is to be how long term performance of traders was, to a certain
spot by looking at his losses. extent, inversely correlated with how frequently
Take Figure 2. A picture we frequently (re)use performance was measured (by return). So the more
to explain that profits come from balancing the traders look at their returns, the less they seem to have
average size of profits and losses over their relative them. But we cannot deduce any causality from this
frequency. Since we have far more control over the without further study. It could just as well be that bad
average size of our profits and losses than we have traders look at their returns more. But even then it is a
over their frequency, we should focus on minimising correlative indicator, nevertheless.
losses and maximising gains. From this it follows
that a good portfolio or trader must be recognisable In Conclusion
from an overall historical picture showing (lots of) Returns, in the end, will be the result of being a consistent
small losses and (probably fewer) big winners. In trader focusing on self-reflection while keeping a
contrast though, with each momentarily look at such constant eye on risk management and position sizing.
a portfolio, chances are that you will find just the So as bad as metric returns are on short time scales,
opposite. For there will be few small losses and almost as inevitable they will be in the long run as the ultimate
only (big) winners. Because losses need to be weeded proof of being able to do the right things instead of
out quickly. So metrics might include the average size doing things right. «
23
INSIgHTS www.tradersonline-mag.com 07.2014
Trading Seasonalities
Part 12: Next and randgold resources Long
In the previous parts of this series, mostly commodities, currencies, and US stocks were presented as trading ideas. In
Part 12, we will be showing two British shares that are among the FTSE 100 that from a certain point in July, are both long
candidates and can also be traded via leveraged instruments such as CFDs or leverage certificates.
24
insights
accessories, and shoes. Profits have F2) Trading Idea: Randgold Resources Long
been on the rise for five years and
shareholders can look forward to
a dividend yield of more than three
per cent. On average, there has been
an increase of more than ten per
cent during the period mentioned.
At its peak, the stock managed to
rise by 19.51 per cent during the
holding period with the average loss
amounting to 12.48 per cent.
Figure 1 shows the intact upward
trend. In the chart, you can see a
resistance at 67 pounds which, if
exceeded, would be an entry point for
trend followers. The stock is near its
all-time high. As long as the medium As of 23rd July, Randgold Resources is a buy with a holding period until 28th November. The high correlation
term uptrend does not go below 54 between the stock and gold must be paid attention to here. An upward breakout from the wedge would be
ideal.
pounds, the stock is a buy solely for
Source: www.lp-software.de
reasons of a good return. The shares
may also be traded inexpensively in
Stuttgart. However, attention should
be paid here to the tight market. By the end of the holding July, a long position can be built here whose holding period
period, the stock might rise to the 90-pound range after a lasts until 28th November. Seasonally, this also marks the
breakout. That is where the upper parallel trend limitation simultaneous beginning of a seasonally positive time for
runs at the time of exit. the troy ounce of gold itself. The market plunge of the
yellow metal, which began in late May, could consequently
Trading Idea: Randgold Resources come to an end at this time. Due to the high correlation
The second idea indicates the seasonally ideal entry between the mining stock and gold, there is, therefore,
point at the end of July and refers to the mining stock of also the probability of a trend reversal upwards.
Randgold Resources Limited. As the name suggests, the In the last ten years there has been an average increase
company has specialised in the mining of gold. On 23rd of 9.59 per cent during the above-mentioned period in
70 per cent of cases. At its peak, investors were able to
earn as much as 45 per cent. However, it should be noted
T1) Seasonal Trades of the Month that downward pressure will massively increase, if gold
continues to fall. On average, the potential loss here is
Randgold nearly twelve per cent, but may also be significantly higher
Instrument Next
Resources
(Table 1). This stock may also be bought at low cost via
Direction bullish bullish
the Stuttgart Stock Exchange. Figure 2 shows a bullish
Entry 02.07.2014 23.07.2014
downward wedge, where the ideal time for a breakout in
Exit 03.11.2014 28.11.2014
the entry period is recognisable. Stocks will usually leave
Hit Rate 92% 70%
such formations upwards, but there are also exceptions. «
Backtest History 12 10
Average Profit 10.42% 9.59%
Maximum Profit 19.51% 45.97% Update
Average Loss -12.48% -12.08%
Maximum Loss -12.48% -29.00%
On 2nd and 23rd July, an update is available on
www.tradersonline-mag.com, where the stocks are re-
Holding Period 124 128
examined based on the current price development. In
The table contains the key parameters of the two trades presented.
Source: www.logicalline.com addition, specific price targets are developed there.
25
insights – news www.tradersonline-mag.com 07.2014
NYSE Investor
Credit and the Market
In the U.S., BATS reported 20.1 per cent U.S. equities a new one-day record of €26.8bn on May 13. Moreover,
market share in May, up from 10.4 per cent a year ago. BATS unveiled new pricing and a lead market maker
BATS Options reported 3.8 per cent market share, in (LMM) program for its U.S. Listings business. With the
line with one year ago. In Europe, BATS Chi-X Europe new pricing, exchange-traded products (ETPs) that
reported overall market share of 20.6 per cent. Over the trade more than 400,000 shares per day will be eligible
course of the month €411.2bn was reported to BATS’ for a free listing on BATS Exchange.
trade reporting facility, BXTR, setting a new record, with Source: www.bats.com
BlackRock CEO Larry Fink recently argued his view that leveraged exchange-traded funds contain structural
problems that could “blow up” the whole industry one day. Fink runs a company that oversees more than $4
trillion in client assets, including nearly $1 trillion in ETF assets. “We’d never do one (a leveraged ETF),” Fink
said at Deutsche Bank investment conference in New York. Fink spoke during a conversation with Deutsche Bank
co-CEO Anshu Jain in a broader discussion about regulating financial companies. Currently, leveraged ETFs
account for about 1.2 per cent of the $2.5 trillion in global ETF assets under management.
Sources: www.businessinsider.com, written by Tim McLaughlin, www.reuters.com
26
Insights – news
Managed Futures Still Having a Hard Time BTOP50 Index since 1987
A venture capital firm has appointed a computer algorithm when making decisions – including financial information,
to its board of directors. The program – called Vital – will clinical trials for particular drugs, intellectual property
vote on whether to invest in a specific company or not. The owned by the firm and previous funding. ”On first sight,
firm it will be working for – Deep Knowledge Ventures – it looks like a futuristic idea but on reflection it is really a
focuses on drugs for age-related diseases. It said that Vital little bit of publicity hype,” said Prof Noel Sharkey of the
would make its recommendations by sifting through large University of Sheffield.
amounts of data. The algorithm looks at a range of data Source: www.bbc.co.uk
27
insights – news www.tradersonline-mag.com 07.2014
Brokers‘ Corner
Forest Park FX is a registered forex introducing brokerage firm OANDA has officially opened its offices in Australia. With its new
that offers custom trading solutions for retail traders, service office in Sydney, OANDA is poised to deliver its local customers
providers, institutional traders, money managers, and hedge the same service as in their other offices all around the word.
funds. It offers cash-back rebates for retail traders; custom OANDA already has several thousand active traders in Australia
programming of trading algorithms; administrative and and intends to double the company’s market share in the CFD and
operational support for money managers; market access through FX sector in 2014. The launch in Australia is part of OANDA’s overall
various forex brokers; and customised liquidity for hedge funds growth strategy in Asia Pacific (APAC) – a market that represented
and high-volume traders. 24 per cent of the company’s global growth in 2013.
Source: www.forestparkfx.com Source: www.swissquote.com
28
TOOLS www.tradersonline-mag.com 07.2014
New Products
News from the World of Technology
» FXBeat, the FXStreet produced feed covering Forex website or platform. Their clients will also be able to read
market news and commentary written by Jamie Coleman’s the news in their MetaTrader platform (on “single text
team, has been upgraded to become a Premium service mode”). Besides this monthly subscription to the feed,
for private traders as well as a product available for brokers can also buy the FXBeat white-label app. More
third-party companies. Inspired by readers’ requests, information can be found at www.fxstreet.com.
FXBeat’s interface has been improved: Now hosted on
a responsive website (available on any device: mobile, » Fusion Analytics announced it released Fusion IQ
tablet or desktop) with a refreshed design, FXBeat offers Model with stop-loss system. Fusion IQ is a data-
a new and easier-to-use commentary system. Another driven tool that fuses technical and fundamental
major change is the launch of the FXBeat App (IOS and metrics to generate proprietary stock scores and
Android), on which traders can read and comment on all algorithmic buy and sell signals. It seeks to help
posts. The new FXBeat can be trialed by private traders traders remove the emotion from their investment
for 30 days. After that period, to keep access to the feed, and trading decisions. The model ranks stocks, ETFs,
one of the subscription options has to be selected: one and groups of stocks, and provides Intelli-Stops to
month, six months or one year. help control risk. Fundamental inputs to the model
Another novelty is that FXBeat is now offered to include Proprietary EQ, an earnings-quality metric, as
Forex companies. Brokers can choose to integrate well as fundamental research on markets, groups, and
the white-labelled version of the FXBeat feed on their individual stocks. Subscribers can also join biweekly
strategy session webinars. A 14-day free trial is
available to subscribers. For more information please
Fusion Analytics visit www.fusioniqrank.com.
30
TOOLS
DailyFX Plus includes an on-demand trading course » Recognia Inc., a firm that performs technical analysis
along with tools such as trading signals, a technical and quantitative research, announced its launched and
analyser, and FXCM’s proprietary sentiment indicator. enhanced version of its flagship product, Technical
360° Course focuses on the key factors of technical and Insight. The enhanced version includes fundamental
fundamental analysis and the process of probability- analysis along with quantitative strategies. The
based trading with consideration of risk, trade, and enhanced quantitative analytics and additional mobile
money management. It offers private weekly webinars, capabilities were designed to meet the needs of
with market analysis given for the following week. investors, not just active traders. The enhanced version
DailyFX on Demand provides real-time setups based on of Technical Insight includes a new featured ideas
prevailing market conditions and feedback on questions. hub, where investors and traders can see actionable
The service focuses on fundamental events, data trade ideas based on both technical and fundamental
announcements, and real-time data. Additional details strategies. They can also view backtested performance
can be found at www.dailyFX.com. of these strategies to see how well you would have
worked in the past. Recognia covers more than 90
» NinjaTrader, LLC, welcomes Active Indicators to exchanges worldwide and analyses more than 85,000
its expanding ecosystem of Add-On partners. Active instruments daily including equities, indexes, ETFs,
Indicators provides professional market studies and forex, and futures. For more information, click on
indicators built for the NinjaTrader 7 trading platform. www.recognia.com.
Active Indicators was founded with the specific purpose
of providing the opportunity for willing traders to
benefit from exciting and powerful technical tools. recognia Inc.
Founder and Chief Technology Officer, Martin Asher
has devoted the past three years to understanding the
software development process which has enabled him
to automate technical analysis methods previously only
believed to be applied manually. The result is the launch
of their signature product, GeoKing v1.0 for NinjaTrader, a
comprehensive market level identifier providing both the
long- and short-term trader with the information needed
to make informed trading decisions. The Active Indicators
model is designed to not only save their clients time
and workload, but also reduces the risk of overlooking
significant market areas allowing them to more easily
and safely manage their trading. For further information,
please visit www.ninjatrader.com.
31
TOOLS www.tradersonline-mag.com 07.2014
Pairtradefinder
How to Use Differences between Stocks Statistically
There is a lot of good charting software on the market, but if you want to use special market-
neutral strategies, it gets difficult. We would like to introduce an English program from Australia that
automatically provides recommendations to buy one stock and sell another after extensive backtests.
» Pairs trading – as the name says – deals with trading a Installation and Minimum Requirements
pair of stocks. One stock will be bought and one stock will There is a 30 day trial period available for Pairtradefinder.
be sold. You will not achieve profits of several hundred The installation file extracts the SQL-database with a
per cent, but the risk is very small. Hedge funds and huge amount of data. The installation is completed in
professional investors especially use these strategies about 15 minutes.
to gain continuous profits independent from the market The backtest is very extensive therefore eight GB and
movement. Jesse Livermore, the best-known trader of all a Quadcore-Chip is recommended. We tested with four
times, also used this strategy in the 19th century. GB RAM and have to confirm this. If you compare more
The software offers the ability to create a watchlist than 70 pairs of stocks, you receive an error indication, if
after an intensive analysis of stock combinations that you are running other programs simultaneously. But 70
delivers signals in realtime. A money-management pairs are a lot.
function helps to divide the capital and tells the user when
he should trade correlating stocks and when to close the Start and Working Principle
position. The hit rate is more than 70 per cent according After starting the user sees an interface with several
to the producer – of course you always have one loser and menu points in the upper screen area. The strength of
one winner in your portfolio, but the difference counts. the program is its automatic delivery of signals as well as
32
tools
the individual analysis of different F1) Single Analysis and Control Centre of Pairtradefinder
pairs and the tracking of the orders
generated in realtime.
You can choose from all the
world’s stock exchanges and
compare all individual shares
using the ticker symbol. The user
can compare sectors, countries,
commodities, currency pairs and
indices. The main purpose of the
software is the automatic generating
of signals after extensive backtests.
The software needs online access
for the data history and realtime
data for generating signals. Traders
can use Yahoo! free data delayed
by 15 minutes or subscribe to the
provider’s iQFeed. You can analyse every pair based on different charts and backtest the signals on the left for a period of ten
years.
Source: www.pairtradefinder.com
Single Analysis Welcome
The software can be used to
automatically generate trading
signals as well as for making extensive manual analysis. RRGB long and 222 stocks WEN short. You can also select
Figure 1 shows the working screen as well as the a predefined number of stocks, for example 100 stocks on
analysis of the stocks Red Robin Gourmet Burger Inc. each side.
(ticker symbol RRGB) and The Wendy´s Company (WEN) For about two months both stocks increased –
from the restaurant sector. On the left you find the signal RRGB more than WEN. This stock generated a profit of
history and the right bigger part of the screen shows $277.80 whereas the stock WEN achieved a loss of
four charts. $24.42. The difference is nearly $250 – the profit
The signals are generated, if the difference between excluding trading fees, an ideal and profitable signal
the green ratio-line and the moving average is greater that was generated based on backtests of stocks of
than the 2,70 standard deviation – plus or minus. The ratio American restaurants.
equals the price of the first share divided by the price of
the second. If the green line returns below 1,0 standard Backtesting Preparations
deviation, it is recommended to close the position. The You can choose endless shares for backtesting. You
right part of the upper screen shows the current standard name the catalogue, the stock market and with the help
deviation graph that triggered the entry. The left lower of the ticker symbol you can download the appropriate
corner shows the RSI indicator based on the ratio to price history. Figure 2 shows a catalogue for advertising.
recognize divergences. Professional trader Joe Ross There are 13 stocks. There could be more of course,
introduced this technique years ago. The difference but that would increase the necessary computing time.
between the two stock prices is shown as a line on the The number of stocks to the second shows the number
right lower corner. of cycles because every pair is combined with another
On 13th January 2014 an entry signal is generated. one. For 100 stocks this equals 10,000 single calculations,
Long RRGB (entry day green)/short WEN (entry day red). whereas there are only 169 necessary for the advertising
We follow a common strategy in pairs trading, where catalogue to filter the right candidates.
extreme differences in pairs are traded: You bet on the You can use the appropriate ticker symbols and
approximation of the pair. settings of the German stock exchange XETRA to
Each position should be entered with the same amount compare the 30 DAX-shares. It makes sense to analyse
of money. Therefore you have to divide the amount by the the maximum number of years available. Ten years of
stock price. For example $2000 – the position is 30 stocks history are analysable – but the computer will need to
33
tools www.tradersonline-mag.com 07.2014
F2) Create a Backtesting Catalogue remain from a total of 169. Below the results the user can
display the equity curve of the signals of the chosen pair
as well as the ratio chart that was analysed for generating
the signals. After highlighting the most promising shares,
the user saves the pairs.
From this moment on these shares are listed on the
“home” page and they are supervised. After extensive
backtests the site shows the ideal pairs that are checked
daily. Figure 4 shows a table where the saved backtesting
results were filtered further. The correlation of the pairs
should be over 80 – you recognise the strength by the
green bars. And another filter called “Cointegration” was
implemented.
This indicator is especially useful for pairs trading
You can create individual catalogues based on the ticker symbols and backtest and was developed by hedge funds. Pairtradefinder
them over the past ten years to find possible pairs.
offers this indicator to private investors for the first
Source: www.pairtradefinder.com
time. It shows the probability of a pair returning to
the average. Cointegration equals a value between
0.01 to 0.99. Ideal trading pairs should have a value
work the whole night because of the enormous data of over 0.90. The table only shows pairs with a value
involved. above 0.80. You can see that there are already five open
positions and two recommended entries. The column
Observe the Best Pairs (by the Computer) “last refreshed” is important. Here you can see, when
It takes two hours to finish all comparisons for the 13 the data was updated. Based on this data new signals
advertising companies for a backtesting period of ten are generated.
years. The user can filter the results further with different In actual trading the list can include more than 200
parameters. Figure 3 shows the filtered results of one combinations. To avoid false signals we recommend
backtest where the hit rate and the correlation of the pairs analysing individual pairs based on key fundamental
should equal at least 60 per cent. Only four combinations figures and the four charts shown in Figure 4. Key data
from Yahoo Finance is included for
comparing the particular stocks
F3) Backtest Results fundamentally.
34
tools
The user can change that or add F4) Daily Observation with Entry and Exit Signals
marks further away. The developer
recommends this for experienced
pairs traders only.
Conclusion
Pairtradefinder is a professional
investing tool for private investors
for little money in an area that is
usually only implemented by large
hedge funds. You can use this
method with a discount broker with The menu “Home” observes all saved backtest candidates realtime. The coloured marks are hints that the
positions are open or you should take action. Open trades are yellow, entry and exit signals are black.
a small account. There are no costs
Source: www.pairtradefinder.com
for data feed – short of the possibility
of trading the signal exactly the same
minute it was delivered. A position
can stay open weeks and months; therefore this is not per month. If you want to make extensive backtests, you
really necessary. The software costs $395 once or $39 need a computer with a huge internal memory. «
COVERSTORY PEOPLE
35
TOOLS www.tradersonline-mag.com 07.2014
Trading
Weekly Options
Pricing Characteristics and
Short-Term Trading Strategies
by russell rhoads
36
WHY LEARN TO TRADE WITH US?
Free
Private
Live
Bloomberg
The Free App for Investors and News Fans
Bloomberg is one of the must-haves regarding data and information for professional market
participants. Most private investors cannot afford the high monthly fee for the distinctive
terminals but Bloomberg offers an interesting app for all iPhone- and iPad-lovers – for free!
Read on about the benefits of the tool for the analysis and the observation of the markets.
38
tools
and “Most Read” to keep up with the news. Here • PER, PER to stock market index, PBR, PCR, PUR
you will find the articles that are most-read by the • Dividend yield, historical growth in dividend
community – a good way to stay informed about the • Market capitalisation
important topics in short. For those who like audio- • Next quarterly statement and so on
visual content, we recommend the area on the right
side of the screen. Many videos and spoken articles The interested stock holder finds further important
are offered on different topics like capital markets, key figures regarding P+L, balance sheet and cash flow
economics and politics. in the area “Financials”. They are shown in structured
If you are a news fan, we recommend entering diagrams for the last year as well as the past five years. The
directly into the area “News”. Here it is all about news user can learn about the most important data regarding
from the world of finance – it is divided into different the development of sales, net profit and margins as well
areas like politics, economy, technology, comments as the structure of the balance sheet or the cash flow. The
as well as sport, lifestyle or science. Bloomberg offers
up-to-date quality videos. If you are only looking for
information on a certain sector, like pharma or energy, F1) Homepage
you will also find it with this app. The dynamic price-
ticker on the lower end of the screen helps the user to stay
up-to-date regarding price development – although it is
15 minutes delayed.
39
tools www.tradersonline-mag.com 07.2014
In the field “Markets” users can check individual stocks – based on fundamental Users can start an individual portfolio in the area “Watchlist“ and compare it
as well as on technical factors. with the respective benchmark.
Source: Bloomberg Source: Bloomberg
current news is displayed in the news-bar. What more performance as a white line. Another feature that
could you want? should be of use for larger portfolios is the visualisation
of the portfolio based on asset class, sector, region, the
Checking Your Portfolio – with the Watchlist weighting in the portfolio or market capitalisation. The
A tool for investors and traders has to offer one thing portfolio owner has all important information at hand
for sure – a watchlist. The app from Bloomberg has and can make changes, if necessary.
an optimal solution for keeping a constant watch on
your portfolio. We made a virtual portfolio; entering Simple, Structured, Good
the positions including price, date and number of Bloomberg’s free app is a really good tool for stock market
stocks was quick and easy. After entering all shares the fans of all kinds. Offering the latest news, interesting
overview shown in Figure 3 is displayed – and it offers videos, market overviews or fundamental key figures for
several functions for the analysis of your portfolio. First a certain stock – you will find all you can wish for quickly
you have the possibility of displaying and analysing and easily. Of course, you can save the contents and read
the portfolio in different currencies. Especially with it later offline. Users who do not want to miss important
worldwide portfolios that include several stocks news can receive top-news as alarms on a tablet or
in different currencies, this is a convenience. The smartphone.
comparison of the portfolio to the price development Our conclusion: The structured display and the quality
of a benchmark is important as well. Bloomberg has of the information and the features speak for the app.
a good solution, because the user can compare the The tool is clear enough for constant market observation
portfolio to several indices as benchmarks. Figure 3 and the ease of use is especially noticeable on the iPad
shows the S&P 500 as a green line and the portfolio display. Thumbs up! «
40
strategies www.tradersonline-mag.com 07.2014
Pairs Trading
According to Perry Kaufman
How to Profit Regardless of Market Direction
Perry Kaufman is a household name among traders (interview in TRADERS´ 04/2014). His
standard work “New Trading Systems And Methods” was first published in 1978 and by now is
in its fifth edition. In his book “Alpha Trading” published in 2011, Kaufman describes pairs trading
strategies for stocks, indices, and futures. Being a futures trader himself, Rudolf Wittmer wants
to get to the bottom of this and try to implement the approaches for some markets.
» The basic idea of pairs trading is to be independent you will bet on a return of this spread by simultaneously
of the direction of a market or a stock. It is designed to entering a long position in the poorer-performing stock
eliminate directional risk and bet only on the relative price and a short position in the better-performing stock.
change between two financial instruments. Other terms A typical example of such a pairs trade would be a
for pairs trading therefore include “statistical arbitrage” long BASF position versus a short Bayer position (or vice
or “relative-value strategies”. Of course, this will only versa). Both stocks are from the chemical industry and
work if there are short term inefficiencies between two are highly correlated in a longer term comparison.
markets that are connected by a fundamental correlation.
Market Selection in Futures
The Basic Idea In his book “Alpha Trading”, Perry Kaufman concludes
As far as stocks are concerned, the idea of pairs trading that it will only be possible to make good money with
is easily explained. You need to have two shares – i.e. a pairs trading in equities, if a correspondingly extensive
pair of stocks – of the same industry that had a similar use of leverage is chosen. In principle, this is the case
price development in the past. Then you will form either with all relative-value strategies.
the absolute (stock A minus stock B) or the relative We will restrict ourselves in this paper to the use
difference (stock A share divided by stock B) between the of commodity and foreign-exchange futures. Naturally
two shares. If the difference widens up to a certain level, this raises the question of which markets are best
42
strategies
suited to pairs strategies. The author has decided on other hand, if the indicator falls below -40, crude oil will
one pair each from the fields of energy (crude oil vs be traded long against natural gas being traded short.
natural gas), precious metals (gold vs silver), and In the period of about 15 months shown here, a value of
cereals (corn vs soybeans). The market combination of +40 was exceeded and undercut respectively a total of 18
euro vs crude oil will add an intermarket pairs trade. times whereas a value of -40 was exceeded or undercut a
This pair had been chosen because over the short term, total of 15 times.
a weak euro correlates with declining crude oil prices
and vice versa. Position Sizing
Before a signal can be traded, you need to think about
Calculating the Relative Difference the position sizes ahead of time. One method that has
Kaufman suggests using the stochastic indicator to proven to be particularly effective in futures trading
calculate the relative difference. Here, the unsmoothed is that of volatility-adjusted position sizing. Here,
version is used in the following form: the number of contracts when opening the position
is determined in such a way that both positions have
Stochastic Formula approximately the same absolute volatility range. This
closing price - low of the last n days is achieved by weighting them with the Average True
Stochastic =
high of the last n days - low of the last n days Range (ATR).
The following example may serve as an illustration:
Let’s trade futures on crude oil (CL) against natural gas
This means that the indicator indicates the relative (NG). There are basically two ways to determine the
positioning of the current price in relation to the price number of contracts. One is to start from the existing
spread of the last n days. For a stock that had been capital and adjust the positions to it. However, we will
trading in the last ten days at a high of 22 and a low of choose the other – the second – variant to serve as our
18, the above formula results, at a current price of 19, in example. To this end, we will arbitrarily determine ten as
a stochastic of 0.25 and 25 per cent respectively. Thus, the number of contracts to be traded, i.e. we will trade
the maximum figures of the stochastic are zero when the ten CL contracts with each signal. We will then determine
stock is trading at the low of the observation period, or the ATR over the past eight trading days for CL and NG
100 in the event that the stock is traded at the high of the respectively. Suppose the ATR for CL is $5000 per day
observation period. and contract while the corresponding ATR value for NG is
$10,000. This will then result in the number of contracts
Stochastic Difference
To calculate the spread between two
stocks, simply subtract the respective F1) Stochastic Difference
stochastic values from one another.
The result is a new stochastic
indicator which may vary between
+100 and -100. In both extreme cases,
one share each has a stochastic
value of zero while the other shares
have a stochastic value of 100.
Figure 1 shows the development of
the stochastic difference indicator,
illustrated by the example of crude oil
and natural gas.
As trigger lines, the limits were
initially set purely arbitrarily at +40
and -40. Once the indicator rose This figure shows the stochastic difference (blue line) between crude oil (red) and natural gas futures (green).
above the 40s level, it is assumed At values below -40, a long crude oil/short natural gas spread will be purchased while at values above +40 a
short crude oil/long natural gas spread will be bought.
that the spread has widened too
Source: www.tradestation.com
much in favour of crude oil. On the
43
strategies www.tradersonline-mag.com 07.2014
to be traded for NG being five (the ATR value being twice • Crude oil vs natural gas: CL vs NG
as high). This ensures that, in terms of their value, the ten • Crude oil vs EUR: CL vs EC
CL contracts will have the same fluctuation range per day • Soybeans vs corn: S vs C
as the five NG contracts. • Gold vs silver: GC vs SI
At this point, it is necessary to add an important note.
Position sizing in the case under discussion is static. This The resulting capital curves are shown in Figure 2.
means that at the beginning of the trade the number of All the pairs strategies eventually close in positive
territory, but it also becomes clear
that none of the strategies have a
F2) Capital Curves of the Four Pairs of Futures smooth upward ride. Instead, there
is temporarily a more or less large
1,600,000
CL vs. EC CL vs. NG S vs. C GC vs. SI drawdown in each pair of futures.
1,400,000
Since these setbacks occur at
1,200,000
different times, however, combining
1,000,000
the four strategies into one portfolio
800,000
should lead to a significantly
600,000
smoother development as a result
400,000
of diversification. If all four pairs
200,000
of futures are combined into one
0
portfolio, the result for the entire
-200,000
portfolio will be the equity curve
-400,000
shown in Figure 3.
-600,000
31.12.2007 31.12.2008 31.12.2009 31.12.2010 31.12.2011 31.12.2012 31.12.2013 For the portfolio equity curve
The rising overall trend over the entire period is temporarily interrupted by major drawdowns.
in Figure 3, the following notes will
Source: Compiled by the author
also be important: The size of the
44
STrATEgIES
profit shown can only be assessed F3) Capital Curve of Overall Portfolio
correctly, if it is also known how
4,800,000
much capital needs to be invested to
achieve this profit. To this end, the
author has calculated the margins 3,800,000
capital curve, initial maximum Due to the diversification into four strategies with different pairs of futures, there is a much smoother
development in comparison to the individual strategies.
margin utilisation is slightly more
Source: Compiled by the author
than 70 per cent for a short time,
and then continuously decreases
to percentage rates of between ten
and 20. is about 70 per cent. Percentage-wise, however, the
On the basis of a starting capital of a million dollars, average profits for a winning trade are lower than the
the portfolio shown in Figure 3 will achieve an annual corresponding losses in a losing trade. Only for CL
return of 32 per cent. A risk-averse investor operating vs EC are the average profits (+4.47 per cent) slightly
with a start capital of two million dollars will still achieve higher than the average losses ( -4.29 per cent). At the
an annual return of 21 per cent on the capital he has extreme ends, too, the pendulum swings significantly
invested. higher on the negative side than it does on the positive
side because the largest winning trade is about 20 per
Statistical Key Figures cent, while the biggest losing trade is as much as -35
To get a better sense of the dynamics of the approach per cent. This trend is also confirmed by a comparison
presented, key figures are listed in Table 1. Trading of the standard deviation for positive and negative
frequency is not very high with a total of 328 trades trades. Still, the end result is a respectable profit factor
for the entire portfolio and about 100 trades per of 1.83 at the portfolio level.
single strategy over six years. In the case of the Overall, the statistical analyses show that the
highly correlated gold/silver pair of futures, only 34 approach presented generates predominantly positive
trades were generated. The hit rate for all strategies trading results. If a trade goes wrong, however, things
will be rather uncomfortable and strong drawdowns will
have to be faced. That is why it is very important in pairs
Strategy Snapshot trading for you to bet on several pairs and not to try and
Strategy Name: Pairs trading according to Perry Kaufman be successful with only one pair. «
Strategy Type: Futures pairs trading
Time Horizon: Daily chart
Long A and short B when stochastic difference of the
Setup and
Entry:
A-B pair falls below -40; short A and long B when rudolf Wittmer
stochastic difference of the A-B pair exceeds +40
Rudolf Wittmer, who has a university degree in
Exit: When zero line is exceeded or undercut
engineering, has been active as a fund manager
Risk and Money and hedge-fund consultant in recent years and
ATR-adjusted position sizing is a passionate trader who turned his hobby into
Management:
a career more than 20 years ago. By constantly
Number refining his trading models, he has made a name for
Approx. 1 signal per month and strategy himself as a systems trading specialist in Germany.
of Signals:
rudolf.wittmer@hrconsult.li
Hit Rate: 70% on average
45