Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Antennas and Circuits For Ambient Energy Harvesting in Wireless Body Area Networks
Antennas and Circuits For Ambient Energy Harvesting in Wireless Body Area Networks
Track
Abstract-In this paper, we identify the spectrum opportunities In this work, we have identified the opportunistic radio
for radio frequency (RF) energy harvesting through power frequency bands for RF energy harvesting. Moreover, based on
density measurements from 350 MHz to 3 GHz. The field trials power density measurements, we have been able to identify the
have been performed in Covilhi by using the NARDA-SMR best spectrum opportunities that may be considered in order to
spectrum analyser with a measuring antenna. Based on the conceive multiband antennas for electromagnetic energy
identification of the most promising opportunities, a dual-band harvesting. Besides, we present the guidelines for the
band printed antenna operating at GSM bands (900/1800) is development of wearable flexible antennas and designing of
proposed, with gains of the order 1.8-2.06 dBi and efficiency 77.6- circuits to harvest RF energy. The RF energy harvesting system
840/0. Guidelines for the design of RF energy harvesting circuits
to be developed in the context of the PROENERGY-WSN
and choice of textile materials for a wearable antenna are also
project [4] consists of an impedance matching circuit, rectifier
discussed. Besides, we address the guidelines for designing
circuits to harvest energy in a scenario where a wireless body and energy storage.
area network (WBAN) is being sustained by a TX91501 The remainder of the paper is organized as follows. Section
Powereast" RF dedicated transmitter and a five-stage Dickson II addresses the spectrum opportunities based on the field trials
voltage multiplier responsible for harvesting the RF energy. The that were held in Covilha, Portugal. Section III describes an
IRIS motes, considered for our WBAN scenario, can perpetually efficient dual-band antenna for collecting RF energy. The
operate if the RF received power attains at least -10 dBm. guidelines for the choice of textile materials to be used in
future wearable antennas are also presented. Section IV
I. INTRODUCTION presents the simulation and experimental results for the
dimensioning of a 5-stage Dickson voltage multiplier for
Future improvements in radio frequency (RF) energy
collecting RF energy followed by the discussion of the results.
harvesting technology will facilitate the creation of a network
with no need of dedicated transmitters, as a reliable source of Section V discusses the variation of the power harvested in a
WBAN being sustained by dedicated RF energy transmitters.
wireless energy power [1]. This can be accomplished by
Finally, conclusions are drawn in Section VI.
enabling the capture of electromagnetic energy from multiple
available ambient RF energy sources, such as mobile base II. INDOOR AND OUTDOOR SPECTRUM OPPORTUNITIES
stations, TV and radio transmitters, microwave radios, and
mobile phones. Moreover, since wireless body area network In order to seek the best spectrum opportunities for RF
(WBAN) nodes are battery operated, energy recharging is a energy harvesting, we have conducted several field trial
possibility, avoiding the need of battery replacement. However, measurements in Covilha, Portugal, in both indoor and outdoor
the service lifetime of the electronic components could be a environments, by using the NARDA-SMR spectrum analyser
major concern if there is no possibility to collect enough with a measuring antenna.
energy to generate the voltage needed to drive the sensor node. A. Average Received Power
Medium access control (MAC) and routing protocols also play
an important role in the network performance [2]. As a By analysing the power density measurements in 36
consequence, choosing the best opportunities poses a high different locations, we intend to find the best frequencies for
effect on the overall network performance, as well as on the RF energy harvesting. Besides, the identified spectrum
energy consumption. In the context of WBAN s, opportunities are being considered to conceive multi-band
electromagnetic RF energy harvesting is accomplished by antennas. The location for the measurements is shown in Fig.
using wearable antennas that allow for power supplying the 1. To determine the received power, F; of the spectrum
sensor nodes [3]. Ubiquitously available RF sources, operating analyser, we multiply the power density, P d , by the effective
at different bands, are therefore exploited for RF receiving area of the antenna, A e , and gain, G =1, as follows:
electromagnetic energy harvesting purposes. (1)
96
-30
-35 .................~4~ ..
391
-40
e
-45 9~~. 9<50 .1. ~~.5 2.U~ ..
~ -50
Figure 1. Locations of the measurements in Covilha, Portugal. ~"-
-55 ................... J.~~4. 1. ~7.o
To choose the best frequency bands for electromagnetic energy -60
harvesting, we have determined the average of each of the n
values of the received power, P ri [W] in linear units, in five -65
Rr·t[w] ) f [MHz]
(
--- ~~- 1
~,,-
Pr[dBm] = 10 . log n + 30 (3) Figure 3. Average received power for the outdoor scenario.
-40
e -45
~ -50
~"-
-55
-60
533
sections of the antenna an electrotextile (Zeit), with an electric wearable antennas. However, some characteristics of the
conductivity 1.75x105 Sim was considered. The variation of materials highly influence the performance of the antenna,
the return loss obtained from numerical simulations and e.g., the dielectric constant and the loss tangent, for a specific
measurements is presented in Fig. 5 for the proposed dual- frequency, the thickness, the moisture content in a specific
band antenna, considering a return loss 8 11 < -10 dB. environment (Regain), as well as the geometrical and
The lowest frequency band considered is from 820 MHz to mechanical stability of the fabric. In general, ordinary textiles
1000 MHz, covering the entire E-GSM band, while the highest present a very low dielectric constant, in the range between 1
considered band is in the range 1690 MHz to 1930 MHz, and 2 (as they are very porous). However, textile materials are
covering the entire DSC1800 band. It is a worth noting, constantly exchanging water molecules with the environment
however, that the radiation pattern for the dual-band antenna which might increase their dielectric constant. Therefore,
suffers a deformation at 1800 MHz. The obtained radiation fabrics for dielectrics should present a low Regain. For the
pattern in the YZ and XZ planes for the proposed antenna conductive components of planar antennas, specific electrical
(where dimensions are presented in Fig. 4), is based on conductive textiles have been successfully used, and are
numerical simulation and is shown in Fig. 6. available on the market.
The choice of the textile materials for the antenna design
impacts on the performance, where the construction of the
antenna assumes a particular importance because textiles are
highly deformable materials. In [7], the authors have shown
that the assembly of the conductive patch with the dielectric
substrate is critical, and the geometrical dimensions should
remain stable when connecting these two components. The
mechanical stabilization of both materials is thus essential to
preserve the desired characteristics of the antenna. Therefore,
is important, that at least one of the components, the dielectric
substrate or the patch, is made of highly rigid materials as for
instance a rigid woven made of high tenacity fibres [7].
Furthermore, the cut of the materials must be very accurate.
Figure 5. Simulated and measured return loss for the proposed dual-band As the conductive material is thinner than the dielectric, its cut
antenna.
is critical. Therefore it is advisable to use a woven as patch
rather than knit. In the woven one can follow the direction of
the yams, which facilitates the cutting accuracy [7]. Also, for
the very narrow parts, the cut should be made in the transverse
direction of the fabric avoiding the fraying of the yams.
When choosing the connection technique between the
various layers one needs to be very careful because it should
not affect the electrical properties of the patch, particularly its
electrical resistance. The authors from [7] have shown that
adhesive sheets enable to achieve very promising results.
Figure 6. Simulated radiation pattern for the dual-band antenna in the YZ IV. RF ENERGY HARVESTING CIRCUITS
plane (dashed) and:XZ plane (blue solid), at a) 900 MHz and b) 1800 MHz.
One of the main factors that influence RF energy harvesting
The gains for the dual-band antenna are about 1.8 dBi and is the path loss. The Friis free-space equation relates the
2.06 dBi, with a radiation efficiency of 82% and 77.6% for the received power, P n at a distance, d, with the transmitted
lowest and highest operating frequency bands, respectively. power, P t , as follows:
B. Guidelines for the development ofwearable flexible A 2
antennas Pr = P; · G; ·G; · (41fd) (4)
In the near future, people might contain upon himself a
where, G, and G, are the antenna gains of the transmitter and
wide range of devices and sensors embedded in clothing.
receiver, respectively. Based on equation (4), we can observe
Thus, the new generation of garments will be able to perform that, the received power depends on the frequency (the higher
a continuous monitoring in various fields, such as health and the frequency is the lower the received power is), and decreases
sport [6], communicating the data generated to remote with the square of the distance (path-loss exponent equal to 2).
receivers. Wearable antennas are the link that integrates cloths To conceive an RF energy efficient rectifier which enables to
in the communication system, making the integration of rectify and amplify the input voltage (corresponding to P r ) , the
electronic devices more discrete and less intrusive. Cockcroft-Walton and Dickson voltage multiplier circuits can
Specific requirements for wearable antennas are the planar be considered, as shown in Figs. 7 a) and b). This work only
structure and flexible materials. Textiles, being universally addresses the Dickson voltage multiplier since, according to
used and easily available, are appropriate materials to design [8], both topologies have a similar performance.
534
the Dickson voltage multiplier, by assuming a load impedance
~TITVmrt :.---1 . of 100 Idl. The simulation results were obtained through an
harmonic balanced analysis (i.e., a frequency domain method)
that evaluates the steady state solution of a nonlinear circuit.
Vmr~··············· Vmr~ v.,
~
(~
~
~)
T.
Figure 7. Voltage multiplier circuits with two stages: a) Cockcroft-Walton
and b) Dickson.
535
substrate. The performance was evaluated by using the E8361C Based on the simulation results we can conclude that the
PNA Microwave Network Analyser and the Agilent E4433B optimal conversion efficiency is achieved when the load
Signal Generator. impedance is 50 kQ. If the resistive load value is too low or
By comparing the simulation (Sim.) and the experimental too high, the conversion efficiency greatly decreases. In
(Exp.) results, we conclude that there are an average deviation WBAN the nodes equivalent impedance is different for each
of 59 % between the simulation and experimental results for radio operation state (i.e., RX, TX and SLEEP). According to
the output voltage, whereas the experimental saturation value [12], the value of the impedance from Mica2 mote in the deep
occurs at the RF input received power of 16 dBm. Besides, sleep state is 100 kQ. This value is considered as the
there are an average deviation of 75 % between the simulation
impedance reference load for the IRIS motes.
and experimental results for the conversion efficiency. The
-,
-,
10 '.
maximum conversion efficiency is approximately 8 %. By
analysing the experimental and simulation results we conclude
<.
8
that the deviations for the output voltage and conversion
efficiency can be explained by the impedance mismatching
between the antenna and the 5-stage Dickson voltage multiplier
:§:
Q)
6
<,
(,) <,l'iI
a.s 4
prototype as shown in Fig. 10. The prototype measured c ...............-
impedance is Zin = 262.49 + j401.65 .n at 945 MHz. ....................s....
The measured return loss is presented in Fig. 10. .............................-
2 ..•.-.-._.
.....- ....._ ........._ ....._ .....£]
o -10 -5 0 5 10
RF Received Power [dBm]
Figure 12. Distance between wireless sensors versus amount ofpower
harvested by the 5-stage Dickson voltage multiplier.
536
away from each other corresponding to the received power perpetually operate if the RF received power is at least -10
higher than -1 dBm. dBm. However, the transmission opportunities must be
By analysing Figs. 9 and 10 the range of power (higher carefully selected according to the estimated battery lifetime
than -10 dBm by simulation) corresponds to values of the based on the electromagnetic RF energy harvested. A scenario
conversion efficiency in the descendent part of the curves where RF dedicated transmitters are used has been briefly
(with load impedance of 100 kQ). Besides, for short-range analysed in the PROENEROY-WSN [14]. It enables future
applications the 5-stage Dickson voltage multiplier could be WBAN to operate without the need of replacing batteries.
used for store the RF energy directly into a battery. However, ACKNOWLEDGMENT
for longer-range applications, it is advised to accumulate the
energy in a supercapacitor before directly powering up circuits We would like to thank Prof. Luis M. Correia and Eng. Daniel
or charging batteries, since it is only possible obtain Sebastiao for making the NARDA-SMR spectrum analyser
intermittent pulses of energy. The use of supercapacitors with measuring antenna available to us.
allows faster charging times, better discharge performance and REFERENCES
"unlimited" virtually life cycles. The choice of the
[1] H. Jabbar, Y. S. Song and T. T. Jeong, "RF energy harvesting system
supercapacitors is justified by the fact that batteries suffer and circuits for charging of mobile devices," IEEE Transactions on
from some non-linear characteristics, such as degradation and Consumer Electronics, vol. 56, no. 1, pp. 247-253, Feb. 2010.
saturation (due to high constant current drain). Note however [2] N. Barroca, J. M. Ferro, L. M. Borges, J. Tavares and F. J. Velez,
that the main disadvantage of supercapacitors is their high "Electromagnetic Energy Harvesting for Wireless Body Area Networks
with Cognitive Radio Capabilities," in Proc. of URSI Seminar of the
"self-discharge" characteristic. Based on the presented Portuguese Committee, Lisbon, Portugal, Nov. 2012.
characteristics, a system is envisaged where both batteries and [3] J. S. Bellon, M. Cabedo-Fabres, E. Antonino-Daviu, M. Ferrando-
supercapacitors are used, enabling to overcome the saturation Bataller and F. Penaranda-Foix, "Textile MIMO antenna for Wireless
and degradation problem from the batteries, if they are only Body Area Networks," in Proc. of the 5th European Conference on
used during the mote's sleep state (i.e., very low current Antennas and Propagation (EUCAP), Rome, Italy, Apr. 2011, pp. 428
432.
drain), whilst the supercapacitors are being charged. During
[4] PROENERGY-WSN, "Prototypes for Efficient Energy Self-sustainable
the active state, nodes can be power supplied by Wireless Sensor Networks," http://www.e-projects.ubi.pt/proenergy-
supercapacitors, turning off the batteries. This way, higher wsn, Apr. 2013.
current consumptions will not degrade batteries, increasing the [5] 1. Tavares, N. Barroca, H. M. Saraiva, L. M. Borges, F. 1. Velez, C.
network lifetime. Moreover, we can also conclude that the Loss, R. Salvado, P. Pinho, R. Goncalves and N. B. Carvalho,
"Spectrum Opportunities for Electromagnetic Energy Harvesting from
spectrum opportunities presented in Section II may not be 350 MHz to 3 GHz," in Proc. of The 7th International Symposium on
enough to power supply the current WBANs platforms. This is Medical Information and Communication Technology (ISMICT 2013) -
due to the insufficient energy available, which corresponds to Special Session on Antennas and Propagation for Body Area Network,
powers in the range of -27 dBm to -37 dBm. To mitigate this Tokyo, Japan, Mar. 2013.
very low received power we envisaged the use of highly [6] B. Annalisa and D.D.R. Danilo, Wearable Monitoring Systems, 1st ed.,
Springer, New York, USA, 2011.
efficient DC-to-DC boost converter (e.g., BQ25504 highly
[7] I. Locher, M. Klemm, T. Kirstein, and G. Troster, "Design and
efficient DC-to-DC boost converter [13]) placed between the Characterization of Purely Textile Patch Antennas," IEEE Transactions
rectifying antenna circuit and the storage device. This device on Advanced Packaging, vol. 29, no. 4, pp. 777-788, Nov. 2006.
manages power from a variety of sources (such as solar, [8] H. Yan, J. G. M. Montero, A. Akhnoukh, L. C. N. de Vreede, and J. N.
thermal electric, electromagnetic and vibration energy) in the Burghart, "An integration scheme for RF power harvesting," in Proc. of
The 8th Annual Workshop on Semiconductor Advances for Future
range between microwatts (f.lW) and milliwatts (mW). Electronics and Sensors, Veldhoven, Netherlands, Nov. 2005.
VI. CONCLUSIONS [9] Advanced Design System software, http://www.home.agilent.com/en/pc
-1297113/advanced-design-system-ads?&cc=PT&lc=eng, Jan. 2013.
In this paper we have identified the spectrum opportunities [10] U. Karthaus and M. Fischer, "Fully integrated passive UHF RFID
for RF energy harvesting to power supply the wireless sensor transponder IC with 16.7~W minimum RF input power," IEEE J. Solid
nodes in real indoor/outdoor scenarios. The set of State Circuits, vol. 38, no. 10, pp. 1602-1608, Oct. 2003.
indoor/outdoor most promising frequency bands are 79 to 96 [11] Y. Zhou, B. Froppier and T. Razban, "Schottky Diode Rectifier for
MHz (mobile/radio broadcast stations), 391 MHz (emergency Power Harvesting Application," in Proc. of The IEEE International
Conference on RFID-Technologies and Applications (RFID-TA), Nice,
broadcast stations), 750 to 758 MHz (digital television France, Oct. 2012.
broadcast stations), 935 to 960 MHz (OSM 900 broadcast [12] P. Nintanavongsa, U. Muncuk, D. R. Lewis and K.. R. Chowdhury,
stations), 1855 to 1868 MHz (OSM 1800 broadcast stations) "Design Optimization and Implementation for RF Energy Harvesting
and 2115 to 2160 MHz (UMTS broadcast stations). For the Circuits, " IEEE Journal on Emerging and Selected Topics in Circuits
and Systems, vol. 2, no. 1, pp. 24-33, Mar. 2012.
OSM (900/1800) frequency bands, a dual-band printed
[13] BQ25504, "Ultra Low Power Boost Converter with Battery
antenna has been proposed, with gains of the order of 1.8-2.06 Management for Energy Harvester Applications ,"
dBi and 77.6-84% efficiency. The design of RF energy http://www.ti.com/product/bq25504. Apr. 2013.
harvesting circuits and the choice of textile materials for a [14] N. Barroca, J. M. Ferro, L. M. Borges, 1. Tavares and F. 1. Velez,
wearable antenna have also been analysed. We have also "Electromagnetic Energy Harvesting for Wireless Body Area Networks
simulated the behaviour of a 5-stage Dickson voltage with Cognitive Radio Capabilities," in Proc. of URSI Seminar of
the Portuguese Committee, Lisbon, Portugal, Nov. 2012.
multiplier for power supplying an IRIS mote, which can
537