Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Human Bodies, Antibodies and Other Bodies Durham University 24 April 2018
Human Bodies, Antibodies and Other Bodies Durham University 24 April 2018
Admir Jugo
Alec Ayers
Alice-Amber Keagan
Guy Lavender-Forsyth
Janelle Wagnild
Jiangnan Li
Mei Xue
Misheck Nkhata
Vasiliki Bathrelou
Images:
PROGRAMME
Alice-Amber KEEGAN:
Parenting in the first 24-hours:
Trialling an intervention to
improve parent-infant caregiving
in the immediate postnatal
period
Water ‘Bodies’ and Human ‘Bodies’ in the Context of CKDu Epidemic in Sri Lanka
Upul K. WICKRAMASINGHE (Durham University)
In Sri Lanka, an epidemic of Chronic Kidney Disease of unknown aetiology (CKDu) is currently
affecting farming communities in the irrigated ‘dry zone’ of Sri Lanka. To date, more than thirty
scientific hypotheses have been proposed to explain the cause/s of the disease, none of which
has been successfully proved. However, many of these theories do suggest that irrigation water is
the likely medium that causes CKDu, and as such both scientific and public discourses around
the disease have been dominated by discussions of water pollution. Drawing from preliminary
ethnographic fieldwork conducted in Ginnoruwa, a village with a very high incidence of CKDu
in the east of Sri Lanka, in this paper I discuss local understandings of CKDu as a problem
related to the contamination and decontamination of ‘bodies’ in two senses – water bodies
(subterranean and irrigation) and the bodies of villagers. I discuss idioms of pollution used to
describe ‘dirty’ water and ‘clean’ water, and water’s effects of the experience and management of
the disease. In particular, I focus on how villagers describe the experience of switching from well
water, believed to be polluted by nephrotoxics, to rainwater, in terms of its corporeal effects. I
argue that paying attention to disease and pollution narratives offers an insight into how CKDu
is understood by local people as a problem that connects human bodies with water bodies within
broader irrigation infrastructures.
Negotiating the Body, Identity, and Selfhood through Materials in the Upper
Palaeolithic
Isobel WISHER (University of York)
Materials, both in the contemporary and the past, are frequently used to negotiate identity.
Through a dependency on materials to communicate social information, persons become
entangled with materials; the boundary between person and material becomes blurred.
Theoretical concepts of extended minds and selves elucidate the blurring of this boundary
further, critically questioning the dichotomy drawn between material and person within
archaeology.
This research seeks to understand the negotiation of body, identity, and selfhood through
materials by evaluating the use of personal ornamentation in the Magdalenian period (late Upper
Palaeolithic). Personal ornaments have been demonstrated to not merely be superfluous
decoration, but rather crucial to the communication of cultural and personal identity in
Palaeolithic societies. The exploration of the significance and social role(s) of personal
ornamentation in Magdalenian societies has the potential to reveal intricate information
regarding how Magdalenian people embodied themselves within their social worlds. I aim to
achieve this through the application of theoretical frameworks regarding human-thing
entanglement, extended self, and identity to Magdalenian personal ornaments, particularly those
from burial contexts and those made from people (e.g. perforated human teeth).
“Who do I look like?” Body, Identity and Relatedness for Donor Conceived Adults in an
Anonymous Context Period
Anaïs MARTIN (École des Hautes Études en Sciences Sociales, Norbert Élias Centre)
Bodies are at the core of donor conceived families’ stories. More specifically, people conceived
through an anonymous donation often question their appearance: “Who do I look like?”. On the
basis of a social anthropology perspective, the paper will examine the importance of the body in
the experience of adults conceived in the French strictly anonymous context, focusing more
specifically on the resemblance and transmission talk. It will show how the mention of the body
is a medium to talk about their relations and their identity for donor offspring. The paper will
use the data collected through face-to-face interviews with fifteen French sperm donor
conceived adults. This study has shown how, by mentioning the body, the participants talk on
the one hand about their bond with and affiliation to their father. On the other hand it allows
them to address the impossible relationship with their absolutely anonymous donor – whom
they do not consider as a father – and how genetic transmission has nevertheless an impact on
their own identity. Their body thus simultaneously contains the evidence of their relationship
with their father and of the donor’s existence. Through this analysis the mention of genetics and
of the biological body will be questioned.
Between “Anatomical Waste” and “Child”: the Reconfiguration of the Liminal Status of
the Unborn in France
Anne-Sophie GIRAUD (Queen Mary University)
My paper will analyse the transformation of institutional and private practices around the dead
foetus in France since the 1980-1990s, observed during an ethnographic study conducted
between 2010 and 2015. These practices resist the association of dead foetus with “anatomic
waste” and tend to “personify” it by the possibility to bury and name it. However, and as a
contradiction, these practices coexist with the authorization of the late termination of pregnancy.
Through the specific study of the practices around the dead body of the foetus, swaying
constantly between “anatomic waste” to “child”, between object and person without being
assimilated to one or the other, I will show that the coexistence of these opposites is allowed by
the liminality of the unborn’s status. Even if the French law does not recognize intermediary
categories, the French State endows the unborn of a liminal status, strictly organized as situations
of instituted choices granted to intended parents. By delegating to them the possibility, to some
extent, to consider the dead foetus as a “quasi-infant” or, on the contrary, as a “failed
reproduction” or “anatomical waste”, the State organizes both the destruction and the protection
of the unborn, handling simultaneously biopolitics and thanatopolitics.
“Breathing Together”: Studying Support Groups for People with Chronic Breathlessness
in Northern England
Fredrik NYMAN (Durham University)
“Breathing is something we all do, day in, day out, every day of our lives. It is so innate that most of us rarely stop
to think about it. We think less of breathing than of the life it sustains. For millions of people across the UK,
breathing is something they have had to think about. These are people for whom the beautiful but delicate organs
with which we breathe – the lungs – do not work as they should.” (Marmot, 2016: 3)
Breathing may be a basic physiological process, but its bodily function exceeds the lay and
biomedical discourses and clinical paradigms that define it. It is a very personal experience that
contains deep cultural and spiritual significance, which goes beyond the simple act of keeping us
alive. Yet, although being resonant and urgent topics, breath and breathing have never been the
subjects of any systematic cultural or literary study. This paper is based on early findings from
my ongoing ethnographic fieldwork. The project in question is a novel anthropological study of
breathlessness as a symptom and somatic sensation, where I am currently investigating how
people with chronic lung disease, in northern England, use support groups to self-manage their
respiratory conditions..
Poster Session
The use of Regenerating Forest by Woolly Monkeys and Spider Monkeys in Peru
Lucy MILLINGTON (Durham University)
More than 60% non-human primate species are currently threatened with extinction. Habitat
modification following deforestation is one of the primary threats to primates in the 21st
century. A growing body of literature suggests that areas that have previously been cleared for
logging and agriculture can be vital habitats for endangered species as the forest regenerates,
however few of these studies have focussed on primates. This study will investigate the ability of
two endangered primate species: the woolly monkey (Lagothrix cana tschudii) and spider monkey
(Ateles chamek) to use regenerating forest habitat in a buffer zone at Manú Learning Centre, Peru.
By collecting behavioural and ranging data for the two species simultaneously at the same site, I
will be able to compare the two species’ use of regenerating forest. I will examine any differences
and similarities between their coping strategies for surviving in an anthropogenically modified
landscape. Founded on the hypothesis that woolly monkeys are able to exploit a greater diversity
of foods than spider monkeys, I predict that woolly monkeys will spend more time foraging and
feeding in regenerating forests than primary forest.
Burial Customs in Anatolia during the Bronze Age
Latif OKSUZ (Durham University)
The Bronze Age saw the emergence one of the first cities and states in Anatolia. The Early
Bronze Age (EBA) covers a period between around 3000-2000 BCE. This period is defined as a
period of urbanization, when complex societies emerged. The Middle Bronze Age (MBA) covers
2000-1600 BCE. In this period, long distance trade increased. Lastly, the Late Bronze Age (LBA)
dates to 1650-1100 BCE. During this period, Anatolia was home to several states and population
groups. Excavations and survey materials from Anatolia help us to understand changes and
variability in the mortuary practices during this time of massive social change. In western
Anatolia, where pithos burials, are the norm, sites like Yortan, Karatas-Semayuk, Troy, and
Demircihoyuk and from eastern Anatolia Titris Hoyuk, Birecik Dam Cemetery, Lidar Hoyuk and
more sites clarify our understanding of mortuary practices during the Bronze Age. My research
project aims to synthesize the burial data for the Bronze and Iron Ages, which has not been
synthesised in an overall study of geographic and chronological patterns. This poster will present
the first stages of research, focussing on the Bronze Age materials, mapping its distribution..
CAMILLO, Ana (Irish World Academy of Music and Dance, University of Limerick): With an
interdisciplinary research field, Ana Camillo is an accomplished Ethnochoreologist and Designer.
Graduated with First Class Honours in Product Design at Centro Universitário Belas Artes de
São Paulo (University of Fine Arts of Sao Paulo), Ana is a costume design specialist. She initiated
her dance studies in 2006 with Arabian dances, and later began studying Romani (Gypsy) dances,
flamenco, and Irish dance. She graduated in 2013 as a Dance Technician specialised in classical
ballet and jazz and in 2014 completed the Gypsy Dancing Improvement Course. In 2017 she
graduated with First Class Honours as Master of Arts in Ethnochoreology at the Irish World
Academy of Music and Dance, University of Limerick, where her research examined the role of
body movements and dance within pagan rituals in present day Ireland. She is currently a PhD
candidate at the Irish World Academy of Music and Dance, where the focus of her research is
Romani (Gypsy) dances within a festival/ritual context. Ana aims to advance her career as
interdisciplinary scholar and festival practitioner.
Contact: Ana.Camillo@ul.ie
GIRAUD, Anne-Sophie (Queen Mary University of London): Her research is cantered on the
constitution of personhood in the process of engendering, focusing on reproductive
technologies and human intervention on reproduction. Her research is at the interface of kinship
studies, anthropology of personhood and Science and Technology Studies. She holds a Ph.D. in
social anthropology from the Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences Sociales in Paris. Her Ph.D.,
entitled “The Statuses of the prenatal being: processes of relational humanization. New
Reproductive Technologies and in utero death and/or stillborn”, investigates the current
transformations of the statuses of embryos and foetuses in France and the process of the
constitution of personhood during engendering. In 2017, she was a postdoctoral research
assistant at Queen Mary University of London. She joined the research project “Remaking the
Human Body: Biomedical Imaging Technologies and Professional Visions”, funded by the
Wellcome Trust, supervised by Dr. Manuela Perrotta. It explores the relations between
professional and lay visions in the field of reproductive technologies and how these relations are
interwoven with a changing social/cultural understanding of the body. Anne-Sophie Giraud is
currently a researcher at the National Centre for Scientific Research (CNRS) within the Centre of
Social Anthropology (LISST-CAS) in Toulouse (France).
Contact: a.s.giraud@qmul.ac.uk
KEEGAN, Alice-Amber (Durham University): I am a first year PhD student funded by the
Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) and I am part of Durham University Parent-
Infant Sleep lab. I completed my MSc by research in 2016 looking at the efficacy of providing an
infant safer sleep box compared to a standalone cot in the same room on reducing the
occurrence of modifiable risk factors associated with SIDS whilst bed-sharing. My PhD research
is looking at the influence of sleep location on the ease of caregiving in the immediate postnatal
period and breastfeeding outcomes.
Contact: alice-amber.keegan@durham.ac.uk
KING, Abby (Durham University): Abby is a first year PhD student in Medical Anthropology at
Durham University. She is interested in the use of information and communication technologies
in healthcare, and the reciprocal influences these technologies and forms of care have on one
another.
Contact: abigail.r.king@durham.ac.uk
KISS, Boglarka (University of Exeter): Boglarka Kiss gained her MA degrees in English
literature and Hungarian literature at the University of Debrecen (Hungary). After the
completion of her MA studies she completed a taught PhD course at the same university. In
2017, she received an “Excellence in Philosophy, Sociology and Anthropology” award from the
University of Exeter to study for an MA in Philosophy and Sociology of Science. Her research
interests include the cultural and medical representations of reproduction, science and
technology studies, material agency and ontological politics.
Contact: bk296@exeter.ac.uk
MARTIN, Anaïs (École des Hautes Études en Sciences Sociales, Norbert Élias Centre): is a
French PhD-student in social anthropology. She works on the experience of being donor
conceived in France and in the UK, addressing the representations of incest prohibitions. Her
research falls within the scope of new kinship studies, anthropology of the body and
personhood, and gender studies. She conducted a first study on the experience of French donor
conceived adults for her Master thesis, which got rewarded by the CNAF (French national
institution dealing with family and social care). Anaïs Martin is currently conducting her PhD-
study in the UK and in France. She has received a three-years doctoral fellowship from the École
des Hautes Études en Sciences Sociales for her PhD.
Contact: anais.g.martin@gmail.com
MILLINGTON, Lucy (Durham University): I am a first year PhD student in Biological
Anthropology at Durham University. My research interests are firmly rooted in biodiversity
conservation, and more specifically in primate conservation within the Neotropics. I am
particularly interested in the importance of regenerating forest as a viable habitat for primates, as
large areas of primary forest continue to be deforested at an unprecedented rate. My PhD
research is a reflection of these interests, I will investigate the use of regenerating forest by
woolly monkeys and spider monkeys in an area characterised by regenerating and primary forest
in South Eastern Peru. My Masters research was my first foray into primate conservation work,
where I collected data on the distribution of numerous species of Neotropical primates within an
anthropogenically modified landscape in Peru. Following the completion of my Masters degree, I
continued to work in the field with wild primates as a research assistant, where I collected data
on social behaviour in woolly monkeys at Tiputini, Ecuador. I went on to work as a research
assistant in South Africa for a project investigating the nutritional ecology of chacma baboons
within a human modified landscape.
Contact: lucy.a.millington@durham.ac.uk
NKHATA, Misheck Julian (Durham University): I am a third year PhD student in medical
anthropology at Durham University. I studied medical anthropology at the University of
Amsterdam and sociology at the University of Malawi. I conducted fieldwork on diabetes
management at two health facilities in Southern Malawi, Southern Africa. Previously, my
research has been around the experiences of HIV and AIDS treatment in Malawi. My current
interests are chronic diseases and use of medicines, especially antibiotics and herbal medicines.
Contact: misheck.j.nkhata@durham.ac.uk
NYMAN, Fredrik (Durham University): is a PhD student at Durham University (UK) in the
Department of Anthropology and the Centre for Medical Humanities. He is a research student
in the interdisciplinary Wellcome Trust-funded project “Life of Breath” led by Professor Jane
Macnaughton (Durham University) and Professor Havi Carel (University of Bristol).
Theoretically Fredrik relates to medical anthropology, and his research interests have come to
turn towards questions of biosocialities, health and illness. His doctoral research will explore
how people with chronic breathlessness and lung disease (living in northern England) use
support groups to self-manage their respiratory conditions.
Contact: fredrik.l.nyman@durham.ac.uk
RAMNATH, Dhruv (SOAS University of London): After completing his Bachelor’s in English
Studies from India, Dhruv worked as a filmmaker and photographer for various organisations
and NGOs until he, followed by a long stint as an intern with Swarajya magazine and then as a
copywriter for the Times of India, found his way to the School of Oriental and African Studies
as a student of Social Anthropology. He is interested in the mainstream media’s role in shaping
opinion on Hindu gurus as well as in how guru organisations leverage the media to attract
transnational followings. He has increasingly found himself writing about the Sharavana Baba
movement due to his anthropological association with it for over ten years.
Contact: 642535@soas.ac.uk
SAVVA, Elena (Panteion University of Social and Political Sciences Athens): I am a Phd
student in Panteion University of Social and Political Sciences in the Department of Sociology,
Athens. My doctoral thesis deals with clients of prostitution and especially why do they prefer to
"buy" sex. (50 interviews in depth and field notes) Αreas of my scientific interest are feminism,
post-feminist sexism, narcissism at the time of social media, new masculinities, gender identity,
prostitution and many others.
Contact: helensabba@yahoo.gr
TUPPER, Emily (Durham University): am currently in the 1st year of my PhD, having
completed my MA in Research Methods here in the Durham anthropology department last year,
and my undergraduate degree in Social Anthropology at the University of St Andrews in 2015.
My research is funded by a 1+3 doctoral studentship from the Economic and Social Research
Council. I am part of the Anthropology department’s Physical Activity Lab and the Durham
University Research in Sport and Exercise Science research group.
Contact: emily.c.tupper@durham.ac.uk
WISHER, Isobel (University of York): I am currently studying an MSc in Early Prehistory and
Human Origins at the University of York, specifically looking into the use of materials in identity
construction and communication in the late Upper Palaeolithic (Magdalenian period). My
research interests are in the Middle and Upper Palaeolithic, particularly material agency, identity,
and cognition. My undergraduate dissertation studied the cognitive abilities of Neanderthals,
reflected in their use and management of space. Recently, I have presented on the extended self
and manifestations of identity at the Cambridge Annual Student Archaeology (CASA)
conference, and on the social significance of Neanderthal site re-use at the Theoretical
Archaeology Group (TAG) conference. Revealing the behaviours and minds of our ancestors
through studying the material record intrigues me, particularly with regard to how they perceived
and understood their world. I believe that through in- depth study of artefacts, we can gain an
insight into the most intimate behaviours of past peoples. This has ramifications for
understanding modern minds, particularly with regard to how certain cognitive systems may have
evolved to interpret the world, and the plasticity of the mind to incorporate external materials
into our neural networks.
Contact: icw509@york.ac.uk
Department of Anthropology, Durham University
Dawson Building
South Road
Durham, DH1 3LE
Tel: +44 (0) 191 334 1612 Fax: +44 (0) 191 334 1615
Email: anthropology@durham.ac.uk