Professional Documents
Culture Documents
250 Hectares of Technogenic Desert - 5 Years Later: Original Scientific Paper
250 Hectares of Technogenic Desert - 5 Years Later: Original Scientific Paper
4
Original Scientific Paper
Dražić, G., Dželetović, Ž., Lazarević, M. (1997): 250 hectares of technogenic desert -
5 years later. - Ekologija 32(1): 35-42.
Lagoons I and III of ash and bottom slag deposit of power plant "Nikola Tesla" A in
Obrenovac, with total area of 250 ha, represented in 1990 a technogenic deserts, very susceptible
to wind erosion. During that and the following years, a temporary reclamation of the ash was
performed, by formation of continuous biocover composed of 12 species of meliorative
herbaceous and 7 species of trees and shrubs. During the subsequent years the development of
biocover was monitored along with the application of complex measures of its maintainance and
protection. The results indicate that the applied protection technology against wind erosion gave
the expected results. Of the investigated plants, the extreme conditions on ash deposit are best
born by legumes, among perennial grasses by red fescue (Festuca rubra L.), and among trees and
shurbs by tamarisk (Tamarix gallica L.).
INTRODUCTION
Building of big power plants, like "Nikola Tesla" A near Obrenovac, with the total power of
1652 MW, induces the problems of ash depositing and rational utilisation of surfaces with deposited
ash, in order to avoid aeropollution of surrounding area with dust. In this power plant, low-caloric
lignite coal, that contains 15-20% of ash, is burnt. On average, the power plant spends 12·106 t of coal
per year, which requires provision of space for accomodating of approximately 35·105 m3 of ash and
bottom slag (KNEŽEVIĆ 1982). Because of that, the surface of deposit covered 400 ha of arable soil of
fluvisol type, on the right bank of the river Sava.
By its size and ash production, this deposit is among the largest in the world. The highest ash
production is achieved by power plants in USA where it ammounts to more than 120·106 t (ARTHUR et
al. 1993). In accordance with its chemical composition, ash may be a convenient material for versatile
purposes in building and building materials industry (NEŠIĆ 1982; DESAI, RAIJIWALA 1987;
HAVUKAINEN 1987), agriculture (CERVELLI et al. 1988; DAVIDOVA, VOLKOVA 1990; ĐIKIĆ et al. 1995)
and forestry (BOGDANOVIĆ, MANOJLOVIĆ 1981; BOGDANOVIĆ et al. 1989). In these instances, deposits
of ash and bottom slag may serve as a potential base of raw materials, whose utilization may be
defined by time, space, purpose and quantity, in order to avoid environmental pollution (DŽELETOVIĆ
et al. 1993). However, as it is not often the case, it is necessary to bring the surface of ash deposit to
some more permanent purpose. Most commonly it is foundation of forest stands, using trees and
shrubs, that may grow on such substrate (BARBER 1974), which does not exclude agricultural
Author’s address:
Instit. for the Application of Nuclear Energy (INEP), Banatska 31-b, P. Box 46, 11080 Zemun, Yugoslavia
36 EKOLOGIJA 32(1): 35-42, 1997.
Foundation of biocover: In September 1990., sowing of meliorative grasses was performed over
previously fertilized ash (800 kg·ha-1 of mineral fertilizer NPK 15:15:15). In March 1991, additional
fertilizing was performed with 200 kg·ha-1 of the same fertilizer, and the same was repeated in March
1992. Shrub cuttings were planted during March-May 1991, in rows, with the distance of 1 m between
and within the rows.
Plants: Meliorative mixture is composed of:
a) carrier culture: winter rye (Secale cereale L.);
b) perennial grasses: tall oatsgrass (Arrhenatherum elatius (L.) Presl. Mert et Kock.), italian
ryegrass (Lolium italicum L.), blue grass (Poa pratensis L.), red fescue (Festuca rubra L.), fescue-
grass (Festuca pratensis Huds.), timothy grass (Phleum pratense L.) and cocksfoot (Dactylis
glomerata L.);
c) legumes: common birds foot (Lotus corniculatus L.), red clover (Trifolium pratense L.) and
alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.);
d) Brassicaceae: winter raps (Brassica napus L.); and
e) trees and shrubs: tamarisk (Tamarix gallica L.), white willow (Salix alba L.), harper willow
(Salix viminalis L.), poplar (Populus x euramericana (Dode) Gunier), Van Houtt's spirea (Spirea x
Vanhouttei (Briot) Zbl.), balkan bells (Forsythia europaea Deg. et Bald.) and oleaster (Elaeagnus
angustifolia L.).
Sampling procedure: From each of the lagoons I and III, 6 representative samples of seedlings
were taken three weeks after sowing, for testing of the germination potential. Shoot samples for
biomass determination were collected on three occasions (in the middle of August 1991., in the middle
of August 1992. and in the middle of August 1996.), from 1m2 areas from 12 sites on the lagoon I and
18 sites on the lagoon III. Shrub samples were taken at the same time from 100 m long rows. Dry mass
was determined after drying at 100°C till reaching a constant weight.
DRAŽIĆ, G. et al.: 250 HECTARES OF TECHNOGENIC DESERT 37
RESULTS
Germination potential was monitored on 6 selected plots on lagoons I and III. Three weeks after
sowing, the best germination was found with rye and italian ryegrass (90%) and the poorest with tall
oatgrass (30%) (Tab. 1). Similar results were obtained for both lagoons. In order to find out if the
differences of germination potential are due to quality differences of commercial grains or they depend
on their adaptability to ash conditions, laboratory germination tests of the same grains were performed.
Under laboratory conditions, winter rye and italian ryegrass also express a high germination potential,
together with alfalfa, while tall oatgrass under these conditions has a very poor germination.
Table 1. Germination potential of the grains of meliorative plants on ash deposit and in laboratory.
Results are mean values ± SD (n = 6). T-test: there was no significant differences between
lagoons I and III.
Development of biocover was monitored on 30 sites on the both lagoons. The change of ratio of
individual meliorative species in total biocover was monitored over 5 years period (Tab. 2). Rye grew
in the first year on all observed sites and was the dominating crop. High abundance of rye in the next
year is explained by autoreproduction. Later on, rye nearly disappears. Red fescue was found on 26
sites in the first, and on 25 sites in the second and sixth years. This year, red fescue is the most
abundant grass on the ash deposit. The remaining perennial grasses grow on smaller number of
locations and produce lower biomass quantity, while tall oatgrass and italian ryegrass disappear.
Legumes grow on 50% of sites. Common birds foot disappeared, while the ratio of red clover and
alfalfa increases, so, alfalfa is the dominating species after 6 years of biocover development.
Taking into consideration total plant number and shoot mass per area unit (Tab. 3),
high diversity of samples may be noticed, which is due to different abundance of individual
plant species, as well as of differences in micro-conditions on ash deposit, first of all of
water regimen and substrate structure. During the 5 years, number of plants per area unit
decreases, but the total biomass does not decrease.
38 EKOLOGIJA 32(1): 35-42, 1997.
Table 2. Ratio (%) change of shoot dry biomass of meliorative plants during the 6 years of
development od biocover (Results represent mean values ± SD (n = 31). T-test: a -
significant differences when compared to 1991 (p<0,05), aa - very significant differences
when compared to 1991 (p<0,01), b - significant differences when compared to 1992
(p<0,05), bb - very significant differences when compared to 1992 (p<0,01)).
Table 3. Characteristics of biocover on ash deposit during the 6 years of development (Results
represent mean values ± SD(n=13 for lagoon I, n = 18 for lagoon III). T-test: a - significant
differences when compared to 1991. (p<0,05), aa - very significant differences when
compared to 1991. (p<0,01), b - significant differences when compared to 1992. (p<0,05), bb
- very significant differences when compared to 1992. (p<0,01)).
Table 4. Changes of abundance (%) of woody species during the 5 years of development from
cuttings. Results represent mean values ± SD (n = 10).
Development of trees and shurbs from cuttings that were planted on the ash deposit was
monitored during the same period (Tab. 4). The highest percent of plants developed from cuttings of
tamarisk and these plants were best preserved. To the lesser extent, white willow and spirea developed,
while the remaining species disappeared.
DISSCUSION
soil quality, it stands well sandy and salty soils (ŠILIĆ 1990), which explains its good taking and
development on the surfaces of ash deposit.
We explain the noticed transformations of vegetation on ash deposit as a consequence mostly of
its poor water regimen and physical properties (during summer months the plants are exposed to
severe drought), which are followed by: alkaline soil reaction (that comparatively increases the
abundance if calciphyllic species, legumes); low and unevenly distributed microbiological activity
through different seasons; and the presence (or rather absence) of nutritive elements.
According to the presented results, it may be concluded that, in spite of significant changes
of the abundance of certain species, the changes that occur in biocover during the five years do not
interfere with its protective role.
Acknowledgments: This work was supported by the Ministry of science and technology of Serbia.
REFERENCES
ADRIANO, D. C., PAGE, A. L., ELSEEWI, A. A., CHANG, A. C., STRAUGHAN, I. R. (1980): Utilization and disposal
of fly ash and other coal residues in terrestrial ecosystems: a review. - Journal of Environmental Quality 9:
333-344.
ARTHUR, M.A., RUBIN, G., WOODBURY, P.B., WEINSTEIN, L.H. (1993): Gypsum amendment to soil can reduce
selenium uptake by alfalfa grown in the presence of coal fly ash. - Plant and Soil 148: 83-90.
ARTHUR, M. F., ZWICK, T. C., TOLLE, D. A., VAN VORIS, P. (1984): Effects of fly ash on microbial CO2 evolution
from an agricultural soil. - Water, Air and Soil Pollution 22: 209-216.
BARBER, G. (1974): Land reclamation and environmental benefits of ash utilization. - In: Faber, J.H., Eckard, W.E.
and Spencer, J.D. (Compiled), Ash Utilization (Proceedings of Third International Ash Utilization
Symposium, 13-14. March 1973., Pittsburgh), U.S.D.I. - Bureau of Mines, Inf. Circular 8640: 246-257,
Washington.
BOGDANOVIĆ, M., MANOJLOVIĆ, G. (1981): Ožiljavanje reznica ukrasnog šiblja na pepelu termoelektrana. -
Šumarstvo 5-6: 41-50.
BOGDANOVIĆ, M., MARTINOVIĆ, B., VUČKOVIĆ, M., SIMIĆ, S. (1989): Primena nekih industrijskih otpadaka kao
podloga za gajenje drvenastih ukrasnih biljaka.. - Šumarstvo 1: 25-28.
BOGDANOVIĆ, V. (1990a): Zastupljenost nekih grupa mikroorganizama u deponiji pepela pod bagremom (Robinia
pseudoacacia) TE "Lazarevac". - Zemljište i biljka 39: 139-145.
BOGDANOVIĆ, V. (1990b): Prilog proučavanju zastupljenosti asimbioznih azotofiksatora i celulolizatora u deponiji
pepela TE "Lazarevac". - Zemljište i biljka 39: 203-208.
CERVELLI, S., PETRUZZELLI, G., PERNA, A., BONARI, E. (1988): Efficient use of nitrogen fertilizers in the presence
of waste materials (fly ash). - In: Jenkinson, D.S. and Smith, K.A. (Eds.), Nitrogen Efficiency in Agricultural
Soils. Commision of the European Communities, 158-170, / Elsevier Applied Sci., London / New York.
DAVIDOVA, Н. Д. (1983): Влияние выбросов ГРЭС на почвы, ландшафтно-геохимические процессы. - В кн.:
Природа, хозяйство района первоочередного формирования КАТЭКа, Наука, 195-208, Новосибирск.
DAVIDOVA, N. D., VOLKOVA, V. G. (1990): Выбросы теплоэлектростанций КАТЭК-а, воздействие,х на
ландшафты (современное состояние, прогноз). - In: Геохимия техногенных процессов.,нститут
геохимии,м. А. П. Виноградова СО АН СССР / Наука, 83-94, Москва.
DESAI, M.D., RAIJIWALA, D.B. (1987): Buildings materials from industrial waste of coal based power plant. - In:
Rainbow, A.K.M. (Ed.), Advances in Mining Science and Technology, Vol. 2: Reclamation, Treatment and
Utilization of Coal Mining Wastes. Proceedings of the Second International Conference (7-11. Sept. 1987.,
Nottingham). Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 661-667.
ĐIKIĆ, A., ILIĆ, Z., MARIĆ, S., BABOVIĆ, M. (1995): Influence of fly ash of Kosovo termoelectric powerplants on
properties of soil type districh cambisol. - I Regional symposium: "Chemistry and Environment" (25-29.
Sept. 1995., Vrnjačka Banja), Proceedings 2: 687-690, Srpsko hemijsko društvo, Beograd.
DRAŽIĆ, G. et al.: 250 HECTARES OF TECHNOGENIC DESERT 41
ĐOKIĆ, M., BOGDANOVIĆ, M. (1983): Mogućnost gajenja drvenastih vrsta na pepelu termoelektrana. - Zbornik
radova sa naučnog skupa: "Planiranje i uredjenje prostora u zonama velikih strukturalnih promena, na
primeru REIK Kolubara" 2: 155-157, I.A.U.S., Beograd.
DRAŽIĆ, G. (1993): Mogućnosti biološke rekultivacije odlagališta pepela i šljake termoelektrana. - Zbornik radova
II Savetovanja mladih istraživača Srbije: "Proizvodnja hrane i životna sredina", 167-169, Poljoprivredni
fakultet, Zemun.
DŽELETOVIĆ, Ž., FILIPOVIĆ, R., ANTIĆ-MLADENOVIĆ, S., JAKOVLJEVIĆ, M. (1993): Prikaz mogućih rešenja
korišćenja odlagališta pepela i šljake termoelektrane "Nikola Tesla A" i "B". - Zbornik radova sa
savetovanja: "Energetika Beograda, stanje i perspektive", 380-390, Savez društava inženjera i tehničara
Beograda, Beograd.
DŽELETOVIĆ, Ž., FILIPOVIĆ, R. (1995): Grain characteristics of crops grown on power plant ash and bottom slag
deposit. - Resources, Conservation and Recycling 13(2): 105-113.
FILIPOVIĆ, R., MARKOVIĆ, D. (1983): Sadržaj fitotoksičnih jona i teških metala u pepelu i biljkama koje su rasle na
pepelu TENT-A u Obrenovcu. - Zbornik radova sa naučnog skupa: "Planiranje i uređenje prostora u zonama
velikih strukturalnih promena na primeru REIK Kolubara", 139-144, IAUS, Beograd.
FILIPOVIĆ, R., SIMIĆ, S., ĐUKNIĆ, P., LAZAREVIĆ, M. (1981): Utvrđivanje najpovoljnijih melioracija i
navodnjavanja pepela za intenzivnu ratarsku proizvodnju važnijih ratarskih kultura. - Zbornik gozdarstva in
lesarstva 19(1): 351-366.
FILIPOVIĆ, R., SIMIĆ, S., STOJANOVIĆ, D., DRAŽIĆ, G., DŽELETOVIĆ, Ž., LAZAREVIĆ, M. (1993): Termoelektrane
kao potencijalni zagađivači ekosistema, s posebnim osvrtom na deponije pepela. - Zbornik radova sa
savetovanja: "Energetika Beograda, stanje i perspektive", 371-379, Savez društava inženjera i tehničara
Beograda, Beograd.
HAVUKAINEN, J. (1987): The utilization of coal ash in earth works. - In: Rainbow, A.K.M. (Ed.), Advances in
Mining Science and Technology, Vol. 2: Reclamation, Treatment and Utilization of Coal Mining Wastes.
Proceedings of the Second International Conference, 245-252, Elsevier, Amsterdam.
KNEŽEVIĆ, D. (1982): Nova tehnologija deponovanja pepela i šljake u TE "Nikola Tesla - A". - Rudarski glasnik.
3: 40-43.
MONEVSKI, B., ANĐELKOVIĆ, B. (1989): Supstitucija kreča kao regulatora pH sredine pepelom iz termoelektrane
Gacko u flotaciji bakra Bučim. - Rudarski glasnik 2: 28-32.
NEŠIĆ, B.LJ. (1983): Proučavanje procesa dobijanja i hidrotermalne obrade portland-cementa sa dodatkom
elektrofiltarskog pepela kao sekundarne sirovine. - Magistarski rad, , Cenar za multidisciplinarne studije,
Beograd.
SIMIĆ, S., FILIPOVIĆ, R., LAZAREVIĆ, M. (1980): Mogućnost proizvodnje sadnica topole i tamariksa na deponijama
pepela uz istovremenu zaštitu deponije. - Zemljište i biljka 29: 201-209.
STOJANOVIĆ, D., BOGDANOVIĆ, M., RASTOVIĆ, A. (1975): Deposits of the pulverized fuel ash as a substrate for
plant growth. - Zemljište i biljka 24: 163-168.
ŠILIĆ, Č. (1990): Ukrasno drveće i grmlje. - Svjetlost, Sarajevo.
ŽAK, М., ŠPINDOR, М. (1988): Рекультивация золоотвалов. - Сборник докладов, IX Международный
симпозиум: "Рекультивация ландшафтов, нарушенных промышленной деятельностью", том I: 177-
186, Kомпольт / Дьондьош.
Sažetak
Kasete I i III odlagališta pepela i šljake termoelektrane “Nikola Tesla” A u Obrenovcu, ukupne
površine 250 ha, su 1990. godine predstavljale tehnogenu pustinju veoma podložnu eolskoj eroziji. U
toku te i naredne godine izvršena je privremena rekultivacija pepela, obrazovanjem kontinualnog
biopokrivača od 12 meliorativnih zeljastih i 7 vrsta drvenastih biljaka. U toku narednih godina
sistematski je praćen razvoj biopokrivača, uz primenu kompleksinih mera njegovi zaštite. Rezultati
ukazuju da je primenjena tehnologija zaštite od eolske erozije dala očekivane rezultate. Od ispitivanih
biljaka ekstremene uslove na odlagalištu pepela najbolje podnose leguminoze, od višegodišnjih trava
crveni vijuk (Festuca rubra L.), a od drvenastih tamariks (Tamarix gallica L.).