Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Jurnal Tentang Amonia-Water Menggunakan Metode Drew (ScienceDirect)
Jurnal Tentang Amonia-Water Menggunakan Metode Drew (ScienceDirect)
Jurnal Tentang Amonia-Water Menggunakan Metode Drew (ScienceDirect)
www.elsevier.com/locate/ijrefrig
Received 14 September 2000; received in revised form 10 September 2001; accepted 1 November 2001
Abstract
This article develops a general thermodynamic framework for the modeling of an irreversible absorption chiller at the
design point, with application to a single-stage ammonia–water absorption chiller. Component models of the chiller
have been assembled so as to quantify the internal entropy production and thermal conductance (UA) in a thermo-
dynamically rigorous formalism, which is in agreement with the simultaneous heat-and-mass transfer processes occur-
ring within the exchangers. Local thermodynamic balance (viz. energy, entropy, and mass balance) and consistency
within the components is respected, in addition to the overall thermodynamic balance as determined by the inlet and
outlet states of the components. For the absorbers, Colburn-and-Drew mass transfer equations are incorporated to
describe the absorption process. Furthermore, the impact of various irreversibilities on the performance of chiller is also
evaluated through the use of a general macroscopic equation. # 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd and IIR. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Chiller; Absorption system; Ammonia/water; Operating; Thermodynamics; Modelling
Mots cle´s : Refroidisseur d’eau ; Système à absorption ; Ammoniac/eau ; Fonctionnement ; Thermodynamique ; Modélisation
0140-7007/02/$22.00 # 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd and IIR. All rights reserved.
PII: S0140-7007(01)00101-3
H.T. Chua et al. / International Journal of Refrigeration 25 (2002) 896–906 897
entropy and mass balance, within those components various entropy-generating mechanisms within the chil-
undergoing heat and mass transfer, in addition to just ler can then be performed. This analysis would enable
obeying the overall thermodynamic balance as is com- attention to be more focused on the design of those
monly practiced by the ‘‘black box’’ approach. With a chiller components that generate more dissipative losses.
more thorough analysis, the number of arbitrary The methodology developed herein should contribute to
assumptions required for a system analysis could be the recent development in absorption system design
reduced. A more exact and detailed quantification of the process [4] and is meant solely for the design point. Any
898 H.T. Chua et al. / International Journal of Refrigeration 25 (2002) 896–906
dQgen dTvap
Fig. 1. Schematic diagram of a single stage ammonia–water ¼ mvap cp Pgen ; Tvap ; yvap Pgen ; Tvap
dTgen dTgen
absorption chiller. (The numbering refers to the salient state
points used in the simulation code.) msol cp Pgen ; Tgen ; xsol Pgen ; Tgen
Fig. 1. Schematic diagram of a single stage ammonia–water X2
@H dmi;vap
þ Pgen ; Tvap ; yvap Pgen ; Tvap
i¼1
@mi dTgen
attempt to extend it to off-design conditions must be X2
@H dmi;sol
performed with careful considerations of the additional Pgen ; Tgen ; xsol Pgen ; Tgen ð1Þ
i¼1
@m i dTgen
phenomena associated with the situations where the
various heat-and-mass exchangers are off-designed.
All heat quantities are positive. For consistency with
the present chiller design [7], the path of integration is
2. Component modeling within a typical from the solution
outlet to inlet with the initial condi-
ammonia–water absorption cycle tion Qgen Tout
gen ¼ 0.
The mass balance equations for each species under a
This article will focus on the modeling of the gen- counter flow scheme are
erator(s), rectifier and absorber(s) where multi-stream
dmi;vap dmi;sol
non-isothermal heat-and-mass transfers occur, while the ¼ ð2Þ
dTgen dTgen
modeling of evaporator, condenser, regenerator(s), solu-
tion pump and throttling valves will follow conventional From the consideration that the vapour and liquid
‘‘black-box’’ approach. streams are separately saturated, the definitions of xsol
Component models are assembled for the computer and yvap and Eq. (2), it can be shown that
simulation of a typical absorption chiller modeled after
an ARKLA ammonia–water chiller (model No. ACC dxsol Pgen ; Tgen
3600) [5]. Fig. 1 depicts the schematic diagram of the msol 1 yvap Pgen ; Tvap
dT
gen
chiller model used in the analysis. dyvap Pgen ; Tvap
In the present analysis, the generator has been taken mvap 1 xsol Pgen ; Tgen
dm1;vap dTgen
to be the natural gas direct-fired type. Ref. [5] provides a ¼
detailed engineering description of the aforementioned dTgen yvap Pgen ; Tvap xsol Pgen ; Tgen
chiller configuration and its various components. ð3Þ
2.1. Generator/analyzer dxsol Pgen ; Tgen
msol yvap Pgen ; Tvap
dT
gen
For simplicity, the characteristics of the processes dyvap Pgen ; Tvap
mvap xsol Pgen ; Tgen
within the generator and analyzer are assumed to be dm2;vap dTgen
generally identical under isobaric conditions. Short of ¼ ð4Þ
dTgen yvap Pgen ; Tvap xsol Pgen ; Tgen
more detailed design information, they are also taken to
be isobaric with respect to the condenser and refrigerant out
heat exchanger. In the present chiller design [5], the first with the initial conditions m1;vap Tout
gen ¼ m2;vap Tgen
vapour pocket appears at the bottom of the generator ¼ 0.
H.T. Chua et al. / International Journal of Refrigeration 25 (2002) 896–906 899
From energy balance and assuming adiabatic mixing dSgen;total
gen dQgen 1 1
of the saturated vapour phase, the vapour-phase tem- ¼ þ mvap cp
dTgen dTgen Tgen Theating
perature within the generator can be expressed as
dTvap 1 1
Pgen ; Tvap ; yvap Pgen ; Tvap
dTgen Tvap Tgen
2 3 2 3
dmgen @H
h Pgen ; Tgen ; ysol Pgen ; Tgen 6 @mi P gen ; T gen ; y sol P gen ; T gen 7
6 dTgen 7 6 7
6 dmsolmix 7 6 @H 7
6 7 6 7
6 h Pgen ; Tvap ; xvap Pgen ; Tvap 7 P ; T
6 @m gen vap vap gen vap 7 ; y P ; T
6 dT 7 2 6 7 dm
6 gen 7 X 6
i
7
4 P 2 @H dmi;vap 5 þ 6 Tgen 7
i;vap
Pgen ; Tvap ; yvap Pgen ; Tvap 6 7 dTgen
dTvap i¼1 @mi dT i¼1 6 @S 7
¼ gen 6
6 @mi Pgen ; Tgen ; ysol Pgen ; Tgen 7
7
dTgen mvap cp Pgen ; Tvap ; yvap Pgen ; Tvap 6 7
4 @S 5
ð5Þ þ Pgen ; Tvap ; yvap Pgen ; Tvap
@mi
ð9Þ
with the initial condition Tvap Tout out
gen ¼ Tgen as the first
vapour pocket is assumed to be in thermodynamic The subscript ‘‘gen’’ refers to generator, while the
equilibrium with the solution. superscript ‘‘gen’’ refers to generation, with the initial
The quantities mgen and msolmix can be determined condition Sgen;total
gen T out
gen ¼ 0: Applying the general defi-
from a mass balance consideration: nition of process average temperature [1,2,6], T gen can
be expressed as
dmgen 1
¼ Ð Tingen dQgen
dTgen ysol Pgen ; Tgen dTgen
ð6Þ Tout
gen dT
dmsolmix gen
dm2;vap T gen ¼ Ð in ð10Þ
þ xvap Pgen ; Tvap Tgen 1 dQgen
dTgen dTgen Tout
dTgen
gen T
gen dTgen
dmsolmix dmgen X 2
dmi;vap For the analyzer, the above equations for the gen-
¼ ð7Þ erator also apply by replacing dTgen with dTana, with the
dTgen dTgen i¼1 dTgen
addition of an extra relation for the hot, strong absor-
bent that emanates from the bottom of the generator
out which acts as the heat source:
with the initial conditions mgen Tout gen ¼ msolmix Tgen
¼ 0. dTgenheat dðUAana Þ Tana Tgenheat
¼ :
To arrive at the thermal conductance, UA, the heat dTana dTana mgenheat cp Pgenheat ; Tgenheat ; xgenheat
source is assumed to be characterized by a uniform, ð11Þ
representative temperature and in thermal contact only out
with the bulk liquid phase, so that the following relation The corresponding initial condition is Tgenheat Tana ¼
is invoked Tout
gen .
The above-mentioned set of coupled ordinary differ-
ential equations is solved in double precision with the
dQgen fifth-order Gear’s backward differentiation formulae
d UAgen dTgen found in the DIVPAG subroutine of the IMSL Fortran
¼ ð8Þ
dTgen Theating Tgen library, using a tolerance of 1106. Except otherwise
stated, the abovementioned computational scheme and
tolerance are applied for subsequent analyses.
Since part of the present objective is to estimate the
with UAgen Tout gen ¼ 0 as the initial condition. rate of internal entropy generation, hence on account of
In the generator, since boiling and condensation is the dissipative nature of vapour and liquid mixing, the
regarded as proceeding in equilibrium, the evolution of the path of integration has to proceed from the bottom of
rate of entropy generation can be attributed to be that due the generator towards the top, i.e. outlet to inlet solu-
to heat transfer as well as vapour and liquid mixing. tion temperature. For a given value of Theating, the
Exploiting
the fact that i P gen; Tgen; ; xsol Pgen; Tgen; ¼ computation will start with a given Tout gen and march
i Pgen; Tgen; ; ysol Pgen; Tgen; at equilibrium, therefore towards a prescribed Tin gen , and thereby provide the
900 H.T. Chua et al. / International Journal of Refrigeration 25 (2002) 896–906
" #
other corresponding results. Should another parameter, dm2;sol m Dvap;12 dðUAabs Þ ym
vap 2
instead of Tout
gen , be used as a constraint, the present for- ¼ W2 ln ð14Þ
dTabs zG Uabs dTabs ym
vap
mulation could be nested within an optimization routine,
so as to search for the compatible Toutgen that satisfies the
new constraint.
" #
m
sol Dsol;12 xmsol
m
vap Dvap;12 ym
i
ln ¼ ln ð15Þ
2.2. Absorbers zL xmi zG ym
vap
For the present system analysis, there is an internal Eq. (15) can be solved for by Newton’s iterative
regenerative solution-cooled absorber and an air-cooled method at every differential step taken throughout the
absorber. The following absorber analysis pertains to a integration process. The gas diffusivity values are
falling-film absorber where the vapour and liquid are computed from an empirical correlation attributed to
flowing concurrently with the coolant flowing counter- Fuller et al. [cited in 22 and 23], while the liquid diffu-
current to the solution. Short of detailed design infor- sivity values are compiled from the NH3–H2O experi-
mation, isobaric condition is assumed to prevail in the mental data from Frank et al. [24]. Since they have
evaporator, refrigerant heat exchanger, solution-cooled reported the mass diffusivity values up to a molar con-
absorber and the air-cooled absorber. It is envisaged centration of 0.312, the values at higher concentration are
that pressure drop in the evaporator can result in a sig- extrapolated from their work. The mass balance equations
nificant lowering of the pressure in the absorber which are:
in turn results in a reduction in the efficiency of the
absorption process. Should more design information dmi;sol dmi;vap
pertaining to especially the evaporator and refrigerant ¼ ð16Þ
dTabs dTabs
heat exchanger be available, they could be incorporated
into the present formulation. The following equations
can be easily reformulated for GAX absorbers. The temperature profile of the vapour phase can be
The energy balance for the falling-film absorber is: determined from:
dQabs dTvap
¼ mvap cp Pabs ; Tvap ; yvap 2
dTabs dTabs Ug dðUAabs Þ 3
Tabs Tvap
msol cp ðPabs ; Tabs ; xsol Þ 6 Uabs dTabs 7
6 2 dmi;vap 7
6 P 7
X2
@H dmi;vap ð12Þ 6 þ h Pabs ; Tvap ; yvap 7
Pabs ; Tvap ; yvap 6 dT 7
@mi dTabs 6 i¼1 abs 7
i¼1 4 P 2 @H dmi;vap 5
Pabs ; Tvap ; yvap
X
2
@H dmi;sol dTvap i¼1 @mi dTabs
ðPabs ; Tabs ; xsol Þ ¼ ð17Þ
i¼1
@mi dTabs dTabs mvap cp Pabs ; Tvap ; yvap
Table 1
Properties of the various state points for the chiller depicted in Fig. 1
Note: ‘‘A’’ refers to the corresponding state point that follows immediately after the previous point. ‘‘M’’ refers to the corresponding
state point after mixing of streams. ‘‘L’’ refers to the corresponding state point of the liquid phase. ‘‘V’’ refers to the corresponding
state point of the vapour phase.
Table 2
Performance parameters of the chiller depicted in Fig. 1
Reversible pump power=31.3 W, COP=0.519. T gen =399.5 K, T abs =330.1 K, T evap =277.8 K, T cond =330.4 K, !=0.605,
Sgen;int gen;total 2 2 2
system =2.867 W/K, Ssystem =13.237 W/K. Effective U values:Uabs=288.7 W/m .K, Urec=650.0 W/m .K, Usabs=3100.0 W/m .K
H.T. Chua et al. / International Journal of Refrigeration 25 (2002) 896–906 903
dQrec Table 3
dðUArec Þ dTrec Relative impact of various mechanisms on 1/COP of the
¼ ð26Þ ammonia–water absorption chiller
dTrec Trec Tcooling
Carnot limit requirement 0.068
dTcooling dQrec =dTrec Heat Transfer with environment 0.484
¼ ; ð27Þ
dTrec mcooling cp Tcooling Heat Transfer in solution-cooled absorber 0.004
Vapour heat-and-mass transfer in solution-cooled 0.024
and absorber
dSgen;total
rec dQrec 1 1 Liquid mass transfer in solution-cooled absorber 0.003
¼
dTrec dTrec Tcooling Trec Solution streams mixing in solution-cooled absorber 0.007
Vapour heat-and-mass transfer in air-cooled absorber 0.005
dTvap 1 1
þ mvap cp Prec ; Tvap ; yvap Prec ; Tvap Liquid mass transfer in air-cooled absorber 0.048
dTrec Trec Tvap
2 3 Heat transfer in analyzer 0.049
@H
Vapour mixing in analyzer 0.002
6 @mi P rec ; T vap ; y vap P rec ; T vap 7
6 7 Vapour mixing in generator 0.004
6 @H 7 Heat transfer in rectifier 0.062
6 ðPrec ; Trec ; ysol ðPrec ; Trec ÞÞ 7
6 @m 7 Vapour heat-and-mass transfer in rectifier 0.105
X62 6 i 7 dm
7 i;vap Heat transfer in refrigerant heat exchanger 0.025
þ 6 Trec 7
6 7 dTrec Expansion between state 8 and state 9 0.020
i¼1 6 @S 7
6 Prec ; Tvap ; yvap Prec ; Tvap 7 Expansion between state 15 and state 15A 0.016
6 @mi 7
6 7 Heat transfer in solution heat exchanger 0.049
4 @S 5
þ ðPrec ; Trec ; ysol ðPrec ; Trec ÞÞ Solution streams mixing (states 13 and 18 to state 19L) 0.019
@mi Vapour streams mixing (states 19V and 20 to state 21) 0.000
ð28Þ
in
The initial
conditions are inaccordingly,
Qrec T rec ¼ 0,
Ug
UArec T in in
rec ¼ 0, Tcooling T rec ¼ T cooling . Urec is taken to
be 0.1 in the simulation. This ratio is estimated from thermodynamic properties procedures developed by
previous simulation results for a smooth tube coil con- Tillner-Roth and Friend [27].
figuration [16], and generally does not exhibit significant The properties of the various state points for the
variation throughout the length of the rectifier. The chiller depicted in Fig. 1 is delineated in Table 1. Table 2
approximation of Ug is observed to have only a slight tabulates the corresponding energetic performance and
influence on the modeling results [14]. the component thermal conductances. Table 3 presents
the impact of the various dissipative mechanisms on the
chiller 1/COP based on the macroscopic equations of
3. Simulation and analysis of a single-stage Refs. [1,2,28], with the results of the abovementioned
ammonia–water absorption chiller formulations being used as inputs.
From Table 3, one can appreciate that the impact of
The above-mentioned system modeling formalism is heat exchange with the environment on 1/COP is most
illustrated with a single-stage absorption chiller. The dominant. The bulk of internal dissipation occurs due to
current analysis is based on the ammonia-water mixture combined heat and mass transfer within the vapour phase
in the rectifer. Approximately 19% of the thermal energy is
dissipated by sensible heat transfer losses within the
regenerative components in the chiller. Simultaneous heat-
and-mass transfer within the vapour phase in the absorbers
and rectifier also contributes about 13% to the 1/COP of
the chiller. The table also highlights the significant con-
tribution of the refrigerant expansion on the machine’s
performance. The impact of mass transfer within the liquid
phases in the absorbers tends to contribute about 6% to
the 1/COP of chiller. The present analysis shows that
while mass transfer is an important mechanism that
actually makes absorption induced evaporation possi-
ble, it is only a significant, though not a dominating
mechanism. The table also highlights the significant
contribution of the refrigerant expansin and mixing
Fig. 2. Local temperature profiles of the streams within the losses on the machine’s performance; each mechanism
generator. accounting for nearly 3–4% of the thermal power input.
904 H.T. Chua et al. / International Journal of Refrigeration 25 (2002) 896–906
Fig. 3. Mass flow rate profiles of the streams within the Fig. 5. Local concentration profiles of the streams within the
generator. air-cooled absorber.
We have also developed a thermodynamically con- ammonia and water mass flow rate profiles in both
sistent T-s diagram formalism to analyze the present phases.
result. Interested readers may refer to Ref. [29] for
details. 4.2. Air-cooled absorber
References
process while the water flux changes from negative
(desorption) to positive (absorption) at about 30% [1] Chua HT. Universal thermodynamic modeling of chillers:
special application to adsorption chillers. PhD thesis,
along the length of the absorber.
Mechanical and Production Engineering, National Uni-
versity of Singapore, 1998.
4.3. Rectifier [2] Chua HT, Toh HK, Malek A, Ng KC, Srinivasan K. A
general thermodynamic framework for understanding the
Fig. 7 depicts the temperature profiles and the flow behaviour of absorption chillers. International Journal of
directions of the streams within the rectifier. Partial Refrigeration 2000;23:491–507.
condensation of the vapour occurs within the rectifier [3] Ng KC, Tu K, Chua HT, Gordon JM, Kashiwagi T, Aki-
which results in an increase in the ammonia content sawa A, Saha BB. Thermodynamic analysis of absorption
within the vapour stream. Fig. 8 depicts the mass flow chillers: internal dissipation and process average tempera-
rate profiles of the streams within the rectifier. ture. Applied Thermal Engineering 1998;18(8):671–82.
[4] Priedeman DK, Christensen RN. GAX absorption cycle
design process. ASHRAE Transactions 1999;105(Part 1):
769–79.
5. Conclusions [5] Klein, SA. A model of the steady-state performance of an
absorption heat pump. US Department of Commerce,
In this article, a component-by-component model has National Bureau of Standards, National Engineering
been developed for the analysis of a typical ammonia- Laboratory, Center for Building Technology, NBSIR 82-
water absorption chiller at the design point. The corre- 2606, Washington. 1982.
906 H.T. Chua et al. / International Journal of Refrigeration 25 (2002) 896–906
[6] Toh HK. Thermodynamic modeling of an ammonia-water [18] Kang YT, Chen W, Christensen RN. A generalized com-
absorption chiller. MEng thesis, Mechanical and Produc- ponent design model by combined heat and mass transfer
tion Engineering, National University of Singapore, 1999. analysis in NH3-H2O absorption heat pump systems.
[7] Colburn AP, Drew TB. The condensation of mixed ASHRAE Transactions 1997;103(1):444–53.
vapours. Transactions of the AIChE 1937;33:197–215. [19] Potnis SV, Gomezplata A, Papar RA, Anand G, and Erick-
[8] Lewis WK, Whitman WG. Absorption symposium. son, DC. GAX component simulation and validation,
Industrial and Engineering Chemistry 1924;16:1215–20. ASHRAE Transactions, 1997;103(1):454–59.
[9] Price BC, Bell KJ. Design of binary vapour condensers [20] Kang YT, Christensen RN, Kashiwagi T. Ammonia–
using the Colburn–Drew equations. AIChE Sympo Ser water bubble absorber with a plate heat exchanger. ASH-
1973;138(70):163–71. RAE Transactions 1998;104(1):1565–76.
[10] Ferreira CA, Keizer C, Machielsen CHM. Heat and mass [21] Erickson DC, Gomezplata A, Papar RA. Use of the Col-
transfer in vertical tubular bubble absorbers for ammonia- burn–Drew equations to model mass transfer. Int Comm
water absorption refrigeration systems. International Heat Transfer 1998;25(1):93–8.
Journal of Refrigeration 1984;7(6):348–57. [22] Sherwood TK, Pigford, RL, Wilke CR. Mass transfer,
[11] Perez-Blanco H. A model of an ammonia–water falling- Chemical Engineering Series. McGraw-Hill, 1975.
film absorber. ASHRAE Transactions 1988;95(1):467–83. [23] Reid RC, Prausnitz JM, Poling BE. The properties of
[12] Arman B, Panchal CB. Absorption analysis of ammonia gases and liquids. McGraw-Hill, 1987.
in an aqueous solution. 28th Intersociety Energy Conver- [24] Frank MJW, Kuipers JAM, Swaaij WPM. Diffusion
sion Engineering Conference 1993;1:873–8. coefficients and viscosities of CO2+H2O, CO2+CH3OH,
[13] Kang YT, Christensen, RN. Development of a counter- NH3+H2O and NH3+CH3OH liquid mixtures. Journal
current model for a vertical fluted tube GAX absorber. of Chemical Engineering Data 1996;41:297–302.
International Absorption Heat Pump Conference, ASME, [25] Chilton TH, Colburn AP. Mass transfer (absorption)
AES-Vol. 31. 1993. coefficients. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry 1934;
[14] Herbine GS, Perez-blanco H. Model of an ammonia-water 26:1183–7.
bubble absorber. ASHRAE Transactions 1995;101(1): [26] http://stokes.lance.colostate.edu/tools/diffus.html.
1324–32. [27] Tillner-Roth R, Friend DG. Helmholtz free energy for-
[15] Conlisk AT, Mao J. Nonisothermal absorption on a hor- mulation of the thermodynamic properties of the mixture
izontal cylindrical tube- 1. The film flow. Chemical Engi- {water+ammonia}. Journal of Physical and Chemical
neering Science 1996;51(8):1275–85. Reference Data 1998;27(1):63–96.
[16] Kang YT, Chen W, Christensen RN. Development of design [28] Ng KC, Chua HT, Han Q. On the modeling of absorption
model for a rectifier in GAX Absorption Heat Pump sys- chillers with external and internal irreversibilities. Applied
tems. ASHRAE Transactions 1996;102(1):963–72. Thermal Engineering 1997;17(5):413–25.
[17] Kang YT, Chen W, Christensen RN. Design of ammonia- [29] Chua HT, Toh HK, Ng KC. Temperature-entropy dia-
water condenser with a fluted tube. ASHRAE Transac- gram for an irreversible absorption refrigeration cycle.
tions 1996;102(2):587–95. Journal of Applied Physics 2000;88(1):446–52.