Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Effect of Degree of Corrosion On The Properties of Reinforcing
Effect of Degree of Corrosion On The Properties of Reinforcing
361᎐368
Abdullah A. AlmusallamU
Department of Ci¨ il Engineering, King Fahd Uni¨ ersity of Petroleum and Minerals, Dhahran 31261, Saudi Arabia
Received 15 February 2000; received in revised form 10 November 2000; accepted 5 January 2001
Abstract
This paper reports results of a study conducted to assess the effect of degree of corrosion of reinforcing steel bars on their
mechanical properties. Reinforcing steel bars, 6 and 12 mm in diameter, that were corroded in reinforced concrete specimens
were removed and tested in tension. Results indicated that the level of reinforcement corrosion does not influence the tensile
strength of steel bars, calculated on the actual area of cross-section. However, when the nominal diameter is utilized in the
calculation, the tensile strength is less than the ASTM A 615 requirement of 600 MPa when the degree of corrosion was 11 and
24% for 6- and 12-mm diameter steel bars, respectively. Furthermore, reinforcing steel bars with more than 12% corrosion
indicates a brittle failure. 䊚 2001 Published by Elsevier Science Ltd.
reductions resulting from the hydrolysis of corrosion mm, specific gravity of 2.64 and water absorption of
products w8x. According to Sagoe-Crentsil and Glasser 2.3% was used as coarse aggregate, while beach sand
w9x, both CaŽOH. 2 and C᎐S᎐H gel form a buffering with a specific gravity of 2.64 and water absorption of
pair and a high pH is as readily maintained by C᎐S᎐H 0.56% was used as fine aggregate. A coarse to fine
as by CaŽOH. 2 . aggregate ratio of 1.68 and a waterrcement ratio of
Corrosion of the reinforcing steel bars is caused 0.45 were kept invariant in all the concrete mixtures.
either due to diffusion of the chloride ions to the steel Two groups of concrete specimens were prepared. The
surface or due to carbonation of concrete. Corrosion of first group of specimens was prepared with 6-mm di-
reinforcing steel and the subsequent cracking of con- ameter steel bars while the other group was prepared
crete due to the ingress of chloride ions to the steel with 12-mm diameter steel bars. Deformed reinforcing
surface is more predominant than that due to carbona- steel bars meeting the requirements of Grade 60 of
tion of concrete. A number of mechanisms by which ASTM A 615 were utilized in the concrete specimens.
chlorides break down the passive layer have been pro- After casting, the concrete specimens were cured for
posed, e.g. the chemical dissolution of the film w10x, the 28 days. The corrosion of reinforcing steel was acceler-
build up of the metal holes at the filmrsubstrate inter- ated by impressing an anodic current of 2 mArcm2 .
face w11x and also, the high chloride concentrations at This was done through an integrated system incor-
the iron oxiderpore solution interface which leads to porating a DC rectifier with a built-in ammeter to
local acidification and pitting w12x. Leek and Poole w7x, monitor the current and a potentiometer to control the
based on SEMrEDS studies of the passive film break- current intensity. The concrete specimens were par-
down on steel in mortar prisms, have shown that chlo- tially immersed in 5% sodium chloride solution in a
ride ions initiate corrosion by breaking the bond fiberglass tank so that the reinforcing steel bars were
between the film and the metal. Whatever the cause, above the solution. This type of arrangement was se-
corrosion of reinforcing steel leads to cracking of con- lected to assure that the corrosion product formed is
crete and subsequent loss in the load-carrying capacity not washed away and cracks are formed in the concrete
of a reinforced concrete member. specimens. The direction of the current was adjusted so
The reduction in the load-carrying capacity of a that the reinforcing steel became an anode and a
reinforced concrete member due to reinforcement cor- stainless steel plate placed on top of the concrete
rosion is attributed to the combined effect of a de- specimen served as a cathode. A schematic representa-
crease in the bond between concrete andror reduction tion of the test set-up is shown in Fig. 1. In order to
in the tensile strength of the bars. While some data are induce different levels of reinforcement corrosion, a
available on the effect of reinforcement corrosion on calibration curve establishing the relationship between
the bond strength of concrete w13,14x, its influence on the duration of the impressed current and the corre-
the mechanical properties of reinforcing steel is scantly sponding degree of reinforcement corrosion was pre-
investigated. Maslehuddin et al. w13x evaluated the ef- pared prior to conducting the actual experiments. The
fect of atmospheric corrosion on the mechanical current supplied to each concrete specimen was
properties of steel bars. However, it should be noted checked on a regular basis and a drift was corrected by
that atmospheric corrosion does not affect the mechan- adjusting the potentiometer. The desired degree of
ical properties of reinforcing steel as much as its corro- reinforcement corrosion was obtained by applying the
sion in concrete. Also, corrosion of reinforcing steel anodic current for the time period assessed from the
induces cracks in concrete, thereby affecting the in- calibration curve.
tegrity of a structural component. The degree of rein- After the desired level of reinforcement, corrosion
forcement corrosion and the resulting decrease in the was obtained, the concrete specimens were split along
load-carrying capacity of both steel bars and the struc-
tural component needs to be evaluated to assess the
residual strength of concrete and formulate repair
strategies.
This study was conducted to evaluate the relation-
ship between the degree of corrosion of the steel bars
in concrete on their mechanical properties.
2. Experimental program
Table 1
Tensile strength of 6-mm diameter steel bars
diameter of 12 mm is less than the value specified by A huddin et al. w13x exposed reinforcing steel bars of six
615 for reinforcement corrosion of 24% and above. different sizes to the atmosphere for 16 months and
The above results indicate that even at high levels of concluded that the effect of rusting of reinforcement
corrosion, there is no significant change in the tensile due to atmospheric exposure for 16 months on the
strength of bars calculated using the actual cross-sec- yield and ultimate tensile strength of reinforcing steel
tion. However, when the nominal diameter of the bars is insignificant. Their test results indicated either a
is utilized to calculate the tensile strength, these values slight increase or no change in the strength of steel
fall below the ASTM A 615 specifications of 600 MPa with increasing period of exposure. However, in their
for reinforcement corrosion of 11.6% or more for 6-mm tests, nominal diameter of bars was utilized to calculate
diameter steel bars and 24% or more for 12-mm di- the yield and tensile strength. Aldridge et al. w14x
ameter steel bars. Also, the brittleness of steel bars is exposed steel bars of various sizes conforming to ASTM
affected by the degree of reinforcement corrosion as A 350-56T to three different corrosive environmental
will be discussed in the latter part of this paper. Masle-
Fig. 4. Variation of ultimate strength with the degree of corrosion in Fig. 5. Stress᎐strain curve for 12-mm diameter steel bar with 11.7%
6-mm diameter steel bars. corrosion.
A.A. Almusallam r Construction and Building Materials 15 (2001) 361᎐368 365
Fig. 6. Stress᎐strain curve for 12-mm diameter steel bar with 32.7%
corrosion.
Uomoto et al. w15x evaluated the tensile strength of
conditions, namely, normal out-doors, moist room with steel bars obtained from structures affected by rein-
100% relative humidity and simulated sea-water spray forcement corrosion. Their study indicated that both
for an exposure time varying up to 12 months. Their the yield and ultimate strengths of corroded steel bars
study indicated that tensile strength of indoor and were within the range of 90᎐95% of the non-corroded
outdoor corroded bars was not affected by the degree bars. Also, Uomoto and Misra w16x conducted strength
of surface corrosion, while the ultimate tensile strength tests on the corroded bars from beams and columns
of the 3 months sea water rusted bars was reduced by exposed to marine environment for varying periods.
approximately 3.7% w14x. They reported that the reduction in both the yield
Table 2
Tensile strength of 12-mm diameter bars
Fig. 8. Load-elongation curves for 6-mm diameter steel bars with Fig. 9. Effect of corrosion on the configuration of reinforcing steel
varying degree of corrosion. bars.
strength and the ultimate strength of steel bars ranged thinned section of the steel bars is stretched by a
from 5 to 10% of the original bars. tensile force, the strain would be concentrated at the
notch and the overall strain of the bar will be less at
3.2. Effect of corrosion on the mode of failure of the bars failure than in an uncorroded bar. Hence, as the notch
becomes deeper, the stress concentration progressively
increases at the locations of notch and the rebar behav-
Fig. 8 shows the load-elongation curves for 6-mm ior effectively becomes more brittle.
diameter steel bars, corroded to different levels. This
comparison indicates that as the degree of corrosion
increases, the corresponding elongation of the bar be-
fore failure decreases. There is a systematic pattern
wherein with increasing corrosion, the bars fail with
decreasing amount of yield strain compared to the
non-corroded bars, which show a large amount of yield-
ing before their ultimate failure. This indicates that
corrosion of reinforcing steel increases its brittleness.
Reinforcing steel bars with 12.6% or more reinforce-
ment corrosion indicate a brittle behavior. Also, the
elongation of bars with 12% or more corrosion is
generally less than that specified by ASTM A 615, i.e.
9%. Fig. 9 shows the effect of increasing corrosion on
the rebar configuration. It is seen that as corrosion
progresses beyond 40%, relatively small lengths of re-
bars show thinning, thereby demonstrating the ten-
dency for notch formation with increasing corrosion.
Figs. 10 and 11 show several severe notches for bars
corroded to 75 and 80%, respectively. This preferential
corrosion is characterized for high levels of chlorides or
for situations where concrete is cracked or honey-com-
bed at specific locations providing ingress to chloride
ions and oxygen to the steel surface at such locations.
Preferential corrosion resulting in the thinning of steel
bars over small lengths would have the effect of reduc-
ing considerably the cross-sectional area of the bars
locally and hence, reducing the load-carrying capacity
of the bars. Preferential corrosion and notch formation
also alters, as seen in Fig. 8, the load-deformation
characteristics of the rebars. When a notch or locally Fig. 10. Effect of 75% corrosion on rebar configuration.
A.A. Almusallam r Construction and Building Materials 15 (2001) 361᎐368 367
Band Bar Spacing on Bond Properties of Reinforcing Bar in w17x Almusallam AA, Al-Gahtani AS, Aziz AR, Dakhil FH, Rashee-
Concrete. University of Oklahoma Research Institute, 1970. duzzafar P. Effect of reinforcement corrosion on flexural be-
w15x Uomoto T, Tsoji K, Kakizawa T. Deterioration mechanism of havior of reinforced concrete slabs. ASCE J Mater Civil Eng
concrete structures caused by corrosion of reinforcing bars. 1996;8Ž3.:123᎐127.
Trans Jpn Concr Inst 1984;6:163᎐170. w18x Ting SC, Nowak AS. Effect of reinforcing steel area loss on
w16x Uomoto T, Misra S. Behaviour of Concrete Beams and Columns flexural behavior of reinforced concrete bars. ACI Struct J
in Marine Environment when Corrosion of Reinforcing Bars 1991;88Ž3.:309᎐314.
takes Place. Detriot: ACI Spec. Publ. SP-109, American Con-
crete Institute, 1984:127᎐146.