Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Agusan Marsh Crocodile Survey - Final Report
Agusan Marsh Crocodile Survey - Final Report
April 2012
ACKNOWLEDGMENT .........................................................................................vi
1. INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................... 1
2. METHODS .................................................................................................... 3
REFERENCES ................................................................................................... 14
APPENDICES .................................................................................................... 17
Key results
More than 60% of the expanded protected area coverage are explored
and verified for the presence of crocodiles in reported rivers and lakes. Eighteen
(18) lakes reported as micro habitat of crocodile. Twelve of these lakes are
verified and surveyed while other lakes are inaccessible due to isolation of the
area and navigational hazard.
MRR Mark-Release-Recapture
APPENDIX 13. NEWS CLIPS ON THE CROCODILE POPULATION STUDY IN AGUSAN. ........ 30
1. INTRODUCTION
The CFI Project shares the IUCN-CSG position and recognizes the
urgency of this matter considering the rapid human population growth leading to
the destruction of wetland habitats due to population encroachment competing
for the much needed wetland fauna habitat and habitat fragmentation.
During the CFI project life, the saltwater crocodile farming technology was
transferred to qualified farmers in year 2000 together with the number of farm
bred individuals. To date, more than 70% of the CFI, now Palawan Wildlife
Rescue and Conservation Center or PWRCC, captive stock have been
dispersed. However, considering the scarce population status of C. mindorensis
in the wild, the scheme used for C. porosus in the early stages of the CFI project
could not be adapted without first re-establishing a viable wild population for the
species.
1.1. Objectives
The main objective of this study is to assess the present state of the
marsh, riparian habitat, ecology, behavioral pattern and actual situation of the
species in their natural habitat in Agusan Marsh. Specifically, this aims to:
Verify/confirm the presence of crocodiles in their habitats based on current
sightings; and
Establish baseline data for the present distribution, abundance and habitat
use of crocodiles as basis for developing long- term management plan for
the species as well as interventions addressing crocodile-human
conflicts.
2. METHODS
The study was carried out from November 2011 to March 2012
which covers inundation and recession periods in floodplain areas. There
were three (3) major activities done by a team of three (3) researchers.
The distribution and habitat assessment was conducted using day
exploration survey, night spotlighting and key informant interviews (KII)
with sustained effort of drawing together information in areas identified for
conservation. Researchers utilized a small outboard motorboat that
passes through tributaries to facilitate movement in larger areas as well as
water areas dominated by thickets of water lily. Surveys on foot were done
to areas that prohibit access by a motorboat. The following activities were:
Plate 2. Adult crocodiles found basking in Agusan River in January 2011(left) and
Subaon Creek in March 2011 (right) both in the municipality of Loreto.
ADB, 2011. Asian Development Bank TA7258 - PHI Agusan River Basin
Integrated Water Resources Management Project. Final Report. Pöyry
IDP Consult, Inc. in association with Nippon Koei, U.K. Schema Konsult,
Inc. Vol 1:19.
AMWS, 1992. Agusan Marsh Wildlife Sanctuary management plan and boundary
delineation and land use report, DENR Office of the Provincial
Environment and Natural Resources, Governance Center, Prosperidad,
Agusan Del Sur. Vol. 1:75.
Arreza, G.R. 1999. A report on the floral survey of Agusan Marsh Wildlife
Sanctuary. Unpl Report Pp.8-12.
Bracamonte, N.L., A.G. Roxas, T.O. Poblete, L.V. Gomez and R. Seronay. 2008.
Social and Economic Aspects of the Agusan Marsh Key Biodiversity Area.
In: Proceeding of the 1st scientific conference on the Agusan Marsh.
Philippine Council for Aquatic and Marine Research and Development,
UNESCO Jakarta Office. Pp.85-97.
Cassion, K.E. 2002. Villagers probed for eating, killing croc, Philippine Daily
Inquirer Newpaper. Vol. 17:52p. Published on 17 April 2002.
CFI, 1996. The Beauty of the Beast: conserving the Crocodiles of the Philippines,
Comprehensive Report (1987-1995), Crocodile Farming Institute, Puerto
Princesa City, Palawan, Philippines.
CFI, 1999. Crocodile Farming Institute accomplishment report 1st quarter 1999.
Crocodile Farming Institute, Puerto Princesa City, Palawan, Philippines.
p11.
Crocodile Specialist Group 1996. Crocodylus mindorensis. In: IUCN 2011. IUCN
Red List of Threatened Species. Version 2011.2. <www.iucnredlist.org>.
Downloaded on 28 March 2012.
Crocodile Specialist Group 1996. Crocodylus porosus. In: IUCN 2011. IUCN Red
List of Threatened Species. Version 2011.2. <www.iucnredlist.org>.
Downloaded on 28 March 2012.
IUCN. 1996. 1996 IUCN Red List Categories. IUCN species survival commission,
IUCN council; Gland, Switzerland. Pp.15-17.
Mercado, V.P. 2008. Current status of the crocodile industry in the Republic of
the Philippines. In: National Museum Papers Vol. 14:26-34.
Messel, H.F., W. King, G.J.W. Webb and C.A. Ross. 1992. Summary report on
the workshop on the prospect and future strategy of crocodile
conservation of the two species (Crocodylus mindorensis, Crocodylus
porosus) occurring in the Philippines. In: Crocodile Conservation Action. A
Special Publication of the Crocodile Specialist Group of the Species
Survival Commission of the IUCN-The World Conservation Union. Gland,
Switzerland. P 98-101.
Ortega, G. V. 1996. The Beauty of the Beast: Conserving the Crocodiles of the
Philippines. Crocodile Farming Institute Comprehensive Report (1987-
1995). 41pp.
Pontillas, U.F.A. 2000. New breeding sites for the Philippine Crocodile, Crocodile
Specialist Group Newsletter 19(2): 10-12.
Ross, C.A. and A.C. Alcala. 1983. Distribution and status of the Philippine
Crocodile (Crocodylus mindorensis). Kalikasan, Phil. J. Biol. 12(1-2).
Schmidt, K.P. 1935. A new crocodile from the Philippine Islands. Field Mus. Nat.
Hist. Zool. Ser. 20: 67-70.
NAME
LOCATION
1 Lake Himbang San Nicolas, Talacogon
2 Lake Talacogon Poblacion, Talacogon
3 Lake Casawangan Caimpugan, San Francisco
4 Lake Tugno La Flora, Talacogon
5 Lake Binoni Desamparados, Talacogon
6 Lake Kibatasan Poblacion, Talacogon
7 Lake Kilobidan San Marcos, Bunawan
8 Lake Kanimbaylan Poblacion, Loreto
9 Lake Bokugon Poblacion, Loreto
10 Lake Martinez San Marcos, Bunawan
11 Lake Tagsubon San Marcos, Bunawan
12 Lake Mihaba San Marcos, Bunawan
13 Lake Mambagongon La Paz
14 Lake Kangno San Marcos, Bunawan
15 Lake Kapaton Mantuod, Loreto
16 Lake Ginhalinan La Flora, Talacogon
17 Lake Kalambugan San Marcos, Bunawan
18 Mayat Creek Desamparados, Talacogon
19 Magsagansang Creek Nueva Era, Bunawan
20 Tagbuaya Creek Poblacion, Bunawan
21 Subaon Creek Panlabuhan, Loreto
22 Agusan River Agusan River Basin
23 Gibong River Sabang Gibong, Talacogon
24 Umayam River Loreto
HC1 Captured crocodile Apr-02 Tagbuaya Creek, Nueva Era, Bunawan N8 08.500 E125 55.519
HC2 Croc lover jaw retrieved Jun-06 Lake Kibatasan, Sabang Gibong, Talacogon N8 19.363 E125 53.649
HC3 Human Attack Feb-09 Lake Martinez, San Marcos, Bunawan N8 12.105 E125 54.449
HC4 Human Attack Mar-09 Lake Mihaba, San Marcos, Bunawan N8 10.755 E125 54.728
HC5 Captured crocodile Sep-11 Magsagangsang Creek, Nueva Era, Bunawan N8 09.707 E125 56.769
BA1 Observed Basking Area Jan-12 Lake Tagsubon, San Marcos, Bunawan N8 11.980 E125 55.202
BA2 Observed Basking Area Jan-12 Lake Tagsubon, San Marcos, Bunawan N8 11.779 E125 55.225
BA3 Observed Basking Area Feb-12 Lake Binoni, Desamparados, Talacogon N8 21.134 E125 49.008
BA4 Observed Basking Area Feb-12 Lake Binoni, Desamparados, Talacogon N8 21.008 E125 49.144
BA5 Observed Basking Area Feb-12 Lake Binoni, Desamparados, Talacogon N8 20.871 E125 49.123
RS1 Reported Sightings Feb-10 Lake Bokugon, Panlabuhan, Loreto N8 13.433 E125 53.152
Mar-11
RS2 Reported Sightings Agusan River, San Isidro, Talocogon N8 27.396 E125 47.112
RS3 Reported Sightings Dec-11 Agusan River, Sabang Gibong, Talacogon N8 19.833 E125 53.081
RS4 Reported Sightings Dec-11 Agusan River, San Marcos, Bunawan N8 13.448 E125 54.284
RS5 Reported Sightings Dec-11 Agusan River, San Marcos, Bunawan N8 13.183 E125 54.463
RS6 Reported Sightings Jan-12 Agusan River, La flora, Talacogon N8 26.440 E125 47.642
RS7 Reported Sightings Jan-12 Mayat Creek, Maharlika, Talacogon N8 21.438 E125 48.753
RS8 Reported Sightings Jan-12 Lake Martinez, San Marcos, Bunawan N8 12.130 E125 54.389
RS9 Reported Sightings Jan-12 Agusan River, Purok 3, Katipunan, Loreto N8 10.382 E125 53.810
RS10 Reported Sightings Feb-12 Gibong River, Sabang Gibong, Talacogon N8 20.212 E125 53.460
RS11 Reported Sightings Feb-12 Umayam River, Purok 2, Katipunan, Loreto N8 10.799 E125 53.791
RS12 Reported Sightings (C. m) 2010 Lake Kanimbaylan, Panlabuhan, Loreto N8 13.693 E125 52.482
RS13 Reported Sightings (C. m) 2010 Lake Kanimbaylan, Panlabuhan, Loreto N8 13.567 E125 52.383
RS14 Reported Sightings (C. m) 2010 Lake Kanimbaylan, Panlabuhan, Loreto N8 13.425 E125 52.458
PS1 Photograph sighting Jan-11 Agusan River, Katipunan, Loreto N8 11.337 E125 54.112
PS2 Photograph sighting Mar-11 Subaon Creek, Panlabuhan, Loreto N8 14.694 E125 53.505
S1 Observed Tapetal reflection Nov-11 Simulao River, San Marcos, Bunawan N8 13.329 E125 54.623
Remarks and
Date Visited Place Brief Description of the Area Current Reports Survey Results
Recommendation
October, 2011 Simulao River, Bunawan, This river is located on the buffer No reports Conduct of day survey and Sighted along Simulao River
Agusan del Sur zone of the protected area and the night spotlighting sighted within the area of Bgy. San
river itself is no longer a part of the one (1) juvenile crocodile Marcos, Bunawan.
IPAS. This waterway is the main (est: 2.5') swimming in
entrance to the marsh from the shallow water on edge going The river could not provide
town of Bunawan. towards the riverbank. a good habitat for crocodiles
because the people had
exploited and disturbed the
area so much. It is also less
protected than the inside of
the marsh. Evidence of
riverbank erosion on both
Simulao and Agusan River.
October, 2011 Umayam River, Loreto, Flowing water with unidirectional Report of sightings were Conduct of day survey and Alleged sightings of
Agusan del Sur flow and some minor tributaries. limited on upstream river night spotlighting revealed crocodile in Sitio Mantuod,
no sightings of crocodiles in Nueva Gracia, Loreto.
the area. Some reports on
the presence of C.
mindorensis in the upstream
river of Umayam.
October, December, Agusan River, Bgy. The Agusan river is the main Interviewed Mr. Rusjano Spotlight surveys did not Electronic copy photo of
January, 2011 Katipunan, Loreto, waterway of the marsh. It drains Navarro, being attack by an result any crocodile large crocodile taken in
Agusan Marsh Wildlife water from the lakes and rivers of alleged large crocodile on Feb sightings. January 30, 2010 was
Sanctuary, Agusan del the marsh and brings it downstream 9, 2009. secured.
Sur to the coast of Butuan City. It also
forms as the boundary area within Photo of large crocodile taken Initial photo analysis results
the marsh dividing the last January 30, 2010 by Mr. that the crocodile resembles
Municipalities of Loreto, Bunawan, Noli Centina. with that of the C. porosus.
La Paz and Rosario. Size estimates could be
around more 15 feet in total
length.
December, 2011 Lake Kilobidan, Bgy, San A large open water ecosystem with No accounts on the presence Night spotlighting survey Due to a very large area, the
Marcos, Bunawan, clear water habitat which is of crocodiles in the past and reveals no evidence or conduct of night survey
Agusan Del Sur generally acidic and colored by present time. tapetal reflection observed proved to be complex.
humic acid because of the in the surveyed areas.
decomposition of organic materials
from aquatic plants.
December, 2011 Lake Kanimbaylan and Mixed swamp forest with primary A Manobo tribe differentiate Night spotlighting reveals Lake Kanimbaylan: most
Lake Bukogon, Sitio vegetation dominated by that there are three (3) no evidence or tapetal likely have three (3)
Panlabuhan, Bgy. Barringtona and Nauclea. These individuals of smaller and reflection of crocodiles. individuals of somewhat
Poblacion, Loreto, two lakes were very adjacent to slightly lighter colored describe to be of C.
Agusan Del Sur each other which can share water crocodiles thriving in the area A community in this area mindorensis.
resources and might have been of Lake Kanimbaylan. While considers the crocodile in
result to an interaction between two a large and black colored this Lake only seek refuge Lake Bukogon: one (1)
species of crocodiles if physically crocodile is in the area of during high water and strong visiting crocodile being
prove to be present. Lake Bukogon that was current in Agusan River. described to be of that with
accidentally entangled in their C. porosus.
fishnets sometime in the last
quarter of 2010.
January, 2012 Magsagangsang Creek, This creek is located on the buffer A 20ft. C. porosus were No crocodile sightings There were several small
Bgy. Nueva Era, zone of the protected area and is no caught last September, 2011. during the conduct of day lakes which were reported
Bunawan, Agusan Del longer a part of the IPAS. This survey and night harbors crocodile population
Sur waterway connects downstream Reports were confined in last spotlighting traversing in Bunawan like
rivers of Lake Tagsubon adjacent three (3) months. Magsagangsang Creek Kambangaw to Tagbuaya,
to lake Mihaba going to main heading towards Kalambugan, Binayay,
Agusan River. downstream of Bgy. Kangkala, Mandagao, and
Mambalili near Lake Kabahian.
Tagsubon.
A 19ft. C. porosus was
caught in Tagbuaya Creek
last April, 2002 by the
resident of Sitio
Mandangaw, Bgy.
Poblacion, Bunawan.
January, 2012 Sabang Kawayanan, This is the start of the protected Crocodile sighting last Night spotlighting did not Constant use of the
Bunawan, Agusan del Sur area from Sumilao and the middle December 28, 2011 at the reveal any crocodiles. waterway by motorized
portion of the marsh. This is where whirlpool area. bancas and paddleboats
waters from Umayam River, Lake coupled with electric fishing
Mihaba, Lake Danao and Sumilao had possibly driven the
River meet forming a whirlpool on crocodiles away.
the Agusan River
January, 2012 Lake Mihaba, Lake Herbaceous swampland dominated Sightings are limited only Day survey and mapping of A possible basking area was
Tagsubon and Lake by sedges, grasses, and ferns and during last two months. Lake Tagsubon reveals observed in Lake Tagsubon,
Martinez, San Marcos, other thick vegetation which is hard evidence of possible basking
Bunawan, Agusan Del to penetrate. There were around Some reports on the presence area of a large crocodile.
Sur seven (7) floating houses presently of C. mindorensis and C. While night spotlighting
seen within the Lake Mihaba and porosus sharing the same reveals no evidence of
one (1) going to Lake Tagsubon. water basin in the Lake. crocodile in three lakes.
January, 2012 Upstream Umayam River bank habitat wherein Upon interview, some Exploration on the upstream It was verified that the
River, Loreto, Agusan vegetation slightly different from resident mentioned that in the Umayam river going to headwaters of Umayam
Del Sur. lower marsh areas. areas where there are upland Barangays of Loreto River was the Pulangi River
rock/limestone walls, provide some areas with in Bukidnon that is known
crocodiles are sometimes similarity on the habitat viable habitat of Philippine
observed crossing in the preference of C. Crocodiles.
shallow part. mindorensis.
February, 2012 Lake Binoni, Bgy. A small herbaceous swamp in an Reports on video clips of two Day survey revealed that a Camera traps were installed
Desamparados, inundated forest surrounded by (2) large crocodiles taken last vast area of lake margins by member of RPAdveture
Talacogon paddy fields. Numerous basking September, 2011 by serves as the basking area of in strategic areas around the
areas were found in Lake margin, it RPAdvetures. crocodile/s. Night survey Lake, no live traps for
is made up of slender and broad revealed no sightings on the crocodiles were found set-
leaf grasses (locally called as Ba’as presence of crocodiles. up.
and Bangiba) that overgrown in
dense vegetation of water hyacinth
stitch with ferns making them a
floating vegetation.
February 2012 Lake Himbang and lake Lake Himbang is a floodplain lake Reports were confined within No crocodiles observed In lake Talacogon, a large
Talacogon, Poblacion, bounded by mountainous areas in last 5 years during the conduct of day population of Philippine
Talacogon the Eastern part. Lake Talacogon is survey. ducks and wandering
a large lake with seasonal whistling duck was observed
inundation wherein some part is in the area. Likewise, the
considered peatland. presence of Philippine Eagle
was seen in the area.
February 2012 Gibong River, Sabang River tributaries of Agusan River Recent reports on the No sightings recorded Six cable snare traps and
Gibong, Talacogon in the mid section of Agusan River sightings of an alleged large during the conduct of day one net trap were observed
Basin. This is characterized as size crocodile near the river and night spotlighting. in strategic sites along the
unidirectional river drainage of San delta of Agusan River. river being deployed by
Francisco and Rosario. RPAdventure trappers.
February 2012 Lake Tugno, La flora, Small floodplain lake near the Reports were confined within No crocodiles sighted during Night spotlighting was not
Talacogon margin of Agusan River. This last 5 years the conduct of day visual conducted due to
serves as drainage waterway of encounter navigational hazard.
Lake Casawangan. The open water
in this area is slightly acidic due to
the presence of peatland in the
upper portion of the Lake.
March 2012 Lake Casawangan An isolated Lake near the Reports were confined within Ocular site survey was done Possible local extinction in
Caimpugan Peatland known to last 5 years in the vicinity of the lake. micro habitat
have crocodiles in the past. The Surveys were not conducted
lake shore is composed of organic due to navigational hazard
materials but the water is acidic due
to the effect of adjacent peatland
INTERVIEW QUESTIONNAIRE
(to be translated into the local dialect)
1. Did you ever _____ see or ______ hear something about crocodiles here in the Island?
_____ Yes ______No
If seen, continue to 1a. If heard, continue to 1d;
If No, discontinue interview.
If Yes, a) Where did you _____ see the crocodiles?
(Specific location/s in the park) Location 1: ________________________________
Location 2: _______________________ Location 3: ________________________
b) When did you see it (latest) Location 1: __________________________________
Location 2: _______________________ Location 3: __________________________
c) How big is/are the crocodile/s (estimate in foot)
Location 1: ______________ Location 2: _______________ Location 3: __________
d) What is/are the name/s of the place where you heard crocodiles occur?
Location 1: _______________________ Location 2: __________________________
2. Do you know of areas where crocodiles are known to be plenty? _______ Yes _______ No
If No, proceed to 3.
If Yes, a) What is the name of this place? ___________________________________
3. Do you know that two kinds of crocodiles exist in the park? _______ Yes ________ No
If No, discontinue interview.
If Yes, a) How do you call this crocodiles?
Name 1. _________________________; Name 2. ___________________________
b) Do you know where Name 1 could be found? ________ Yes ________ No
If No, proceed to 3d.
If Yes, c) What is the name of this place? ___________________________________
c) Do you know where Name 2 could be found? ______ Yes ______ No
If No, discontinue interview.
If Yes, what is the name of this place? _____________________________________
Other Comments:__________________________________________________________
Name: _____________________________________________________
Age: _______________________ Sex: ___________
Address (optional) ___________________________________________
Occupation: ______________________
No. of Years in the Island: _____________
BIOMETRICS
Head length 700mm
Snout Eye length 496mm
Max Head width 450 mm
Cranial Width 228 mm
Inter Orbital 84 mm
Cranial Height 363 mm
Snout Height 255 mm
Snout vent length 2, 851 mm
Snout to scute Junction 4,982 mm
TOTAL BODY LENGTH 6,170 mm