Clty
Business Torts
Cimizal wrongs reauie gity parts to ay a debt o society through 8 fn,
imprisonment, and/or community service. However, criminal wrongs also
have victims who have suffered financial losses, injuries, and, sometimes, per
manent disabilities, Those who are harmed by the conduct of others are the vic-
tims of torts, Torts are civil wrongs that provide remedies. This chapter answers
these questions: What are the different types of torts? What must you prove to
recover for these torts? What are the business and public policy issues in torts?
uppare
For up-to-dto lw and ethic news, goto
rijerniings-oorngis the lettuce you eat at Burger King.
i van atta moro Thee Buncen Kove FUROVES UST
rita ans
a es opi Ga thigh ats dP
Tec at on he ae ormoncan th Pe
ee enter Caco a es oboe
(Consider we 91
ag rafter buying lunch, Chaney sat down near that the seating area in its café, Should Chaney be able to
> tron. When Chaney rose from his chait 20 minutes recover?
a Pe a hectare casainene oe
What Ts a'Tort? Roots of Law
and Commerce
‘orf comes from the Latin term fortus, which means “crooked, dubious, twisted.”
A tort is some type of interference with someone or with someone's property that
results in injury to persons or property. For example, using someone else’s land
without permission is interference with that person’s property rights and is the tort
of trespass. If you held a concert on someone else’s land and the concert crowds
destroyed the property's vegetation or left litter that had to be removed, then you
committed the tort of trespass. Tort law provides the basis for recovering the costs
of restoring the property damaged by the concertgoers.
e412 Tort Versus Crime
tort is a private wrong. When a tort is committed, the party who was injured is
entitled to collect compensation for damages from the wrongdoer for the private
wrong, A crime, on the other hand, is a public wrong and requires the wrongdoer
to pay a debt to society through a fine or by going to prison. For example, in the
shooting cleath of Michael Brown by a Ferguson, Missouri, police officer, a grand
jury found that there was no crime committed by the officer. However, the family
of Mr, Brown brought a civil suit against the city of Ferguson andl the officer for the
shooting death. The criminal justice system found no crime was committed, but
the civil justice system ean impose liability for the young man’s death. The case
Was settled,
4b Types of Torts
The three types of tort liability include intentional torts, negligence, and strict tort
liability. Intentional torts are those that involve deliberate actions. For example, &
battery, or hitting another person, is an intentional tort. Hitting someone in the nose
liberately is the tort of battery. Suppose that you stretch your arms in a crowd
and you hit a man in the nose and hurt him. You have not committed the tort of,
tery, but you may have committed the tort of negligence. You were carelessly296 Part 2 Business: Its Regulatory Environment
swinging your arms in a crowd of people, Such careless conduct, ot actions dong
without thinking through the consequences, is the tort of negligence. You are sti,
responsible for damages to the nose because when you fail fo act cautiously any
thoughtfully, you are negligent. Strict tort liability does not turn on state of ming,
or knowledge of possible harm. For example, when contractors use dynamite tg
raze a building, they have strict liability because the incendiary devices are 55
risky and consequences could be so great that we hold them responsible regardless
of the precautions they take. Product liability, discussed in Chapter 13, isa form,
of strict liability. You will see that a company can be held liable for injuries when
a customer has misused its product because even the failure to provide enough
‘warnings results in strict liability
‘82 The Intentional Torts
Defamation
Defamation is an untrue statement made by one party to another about a third
party. It consists of either slander or libel; siander is oral or spoken defamation,
and libel is written (or, in some cases, broadcast) defamation, The elements of def-
amation are the following:
1. Astatement about a person’s reputation, honesty, or integrity that is untrue
2, Publication
3, Astatement that is directed at a particular person
4, Damages
5. In some cases, proof of malice
Publication
Defamation requires that whatever is said or written be communicated to a third
party. A contractor who untruthfully tells developers that one of his competitors
uses workers who are undocumented aliens has met the publication element. So
has a supplier who notifies other suppliers that a business is insolvent when it is
not. The more folks who hear the statement, the greater will be the defamation
damages.
Internet messages and blog postings meet the publication requirement, They
provide instantaneous and international communication, so damages can be
substantial
everriaw
‘Statement about a Particular Person
‘To qualify as defamation, the statement made must be about an individual or &
small enough group that all in the group are affected, For example, the general
statement “All accountants are frauds” is too broad to be defamatory. But the state-
ment “All the Andersen audit partners who worked on the Enron accounts were
dishonest” is specific enough to meet this requirement.
Product disparagement is defamation of a product. For example, a Consumer
Reports evaluation of a product that is not truthful about its qualities or abilities
would be product disparagement. In Base Corporation v Consuniers Union of United
States, Inc. 466 U.S. 485 (1984), the U.S. Supreme Court dealt with whether prod~
uct disparagement of the Bose speaker system actually occurred when Consumer
Reports described individual sounds from the speakers, such as those of violins, a8lone pe =—-
still poconsider