Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

Dental Science - Review Article

Forensic radiology in dentistry


T. Manigandan, C. Sumathy1, M. Elumalai2, S. Sathasivasubramanian3, A. Kannan4

Department of Oral ABSTRACT


Medicine and Radiology,
Radiography can play an important part in forensic odontology, mainly to establish identification. This may take
Sree Balaji Dental College
and Hospital, Bharath the precise form of comparison between antemortem and postmortem radiographs. Radiographs may also be
University, 1Department taken to determine the age of a minor victim and even help in the assessment of the sex and ethnic group.
of Oral Medicine and Comparable radiographs are an essential factor to confirm identification in a mass disaster.
Radiology, Meenakshi
Ammal College and
Hospital, 2Department
of Pharmacology, Sree
Balaji Dental College and
Hospital, Pallikaranai,
3
Department of Oral
Medicine and Radiology,
Sri Ramachandra Dental
College and Hospital,
4
Department of Oral
Medicine and Radiology,
SRM Dental College and
Hospital, Ramapuram,
Chennai, Tamil Nadu,
India

Address for correspondence:


Dr. T. Manigandan,
E‑mail: manident@yahoo.com

Received : 31-10-14
Review completed : 31-10-14
Accepted : 09-11-14 KEY WORDS: Ante mortem, postmortem radiographs, radiography

F orensic radiology has a long tradition in the forensic


sciences. Its history started in 1895 when the first
radiograph was made by Conrad Roentgen. Three years
Uses and utilization of radiology in forensic dentistry

Radiographs have helped to solve difficult cases in the forensic


later, in 1898, postmortem radiographic examination was science.[1-3]
introduced. Forensic radiology, so far as depended almost
exclusively on the X‑ray and the static image captured on Identification of victims
the roetgenogram.
Radiographs are helpful to determine the age of an individual
Access this article online
Quick Response Code:
by assessing the stage of eruption of teeth. Skull radiographs can
Website: be used in the identification by superimposing on antemortem
www.jpbsonline.org radiograph or photograph. Since frontal sinuses are known for
greatest normal variations among individuals, they are used
DOI: for this purpose. Yoshino et al. have classified frontal sinuses
10.4103/0975-7406.155944 based on size, bilateral asymmetry, superiority of side, outline
of upper borders, presence of partial septa and supraorbital cells

How to cite this article: Manigandan T, Sumathy C, Elumalai M, Sathasivasubramanian S, Kannan A. Forensic radiology in dentistry. J Pharm Bioall Sci
2015;7:S260-4.

 S260 Journal of Pharmacy and Bioallied Sciences April 2015 Vol 7 Supplement 1
Manigandan, et al.: Forensic radiology in dentistry

and reported a criminal case in which frontal sinus was used to Nonaccidental injuries of children
identify a person.
Radiology places an important role in diagnosing child abuse.
Sassouni has suggested use of measurements in postero‑anterior Accidental cranial fractures in infants are usually simple, linear
and lateral radiographs of the skull to match the ante and and unilateral, affect the parietal bone and do not branch or
postmortem radiographs, which includes cross sutures. Forensic radiologists suggest different techniques
• Bigonial width for specific head injury. CT is recommended for detection
• Cranial height (from mastoid to vertex) of subarachnoid hemorrhages while magnetic resonance
• Bimaxillary breadth imaging (MRI) is superior in revealing subdural hematomas,
• Height from bigonial width to temporal crest concussive injuries, and shear injuries. CT and MRI are equally
• Maximum cranial breadth efficient for demonstrative epidural hematoma, and CT
• Frontal sinus breadth advocated detection of fractures.
• Incisor height
• Facial height. Forensic anthropology

Evidence in the identification of the suspect Establishing biological age and identification of human
remains are issues addressed by forensic anthropologists.
Cases have been reported where suspects were identified The most common radiograph used for establishing age up
because of fractured tooth parts of victims in the body of the to 16 years old are dental radiographs and hand radiographs.
suspects or fractured tooth of suspect in the victim as in the bite Postcranial radiographs of specific ossification centers
mark cases. Deliberate alteration in the shape of the teeth in depending on the reputed age of the individual are useful
suspects can be identified with radiographs in bite mark cases. estimating older individual. Panoramic radiographs which
visualize most structures of the jaws and related areas
To determine the cause of death on a single radiograph, have been advocated for mass screening.

Radiographs may provide evidence of bullets or foreign bodies in Record keeping


the soft tissues following firearm incidence and explosion. After
air crash accidents, the cause of the crash may be elucidated by Careful record keeping, in medical facilities and private
the presence of radio opaque objects in the soft tissues. This practices for as long as feasible, is extremely important. In most
is due to contamination with molten aircraft metal producing
countries, radiographs pertaining to inactive patient’s files are
irregular shaped radio opacity.
stored for at least 5 years. Radiographs are generally regarded
as the property of the hospital or office in which they were
To find faulty charting of teeth
produced although the law guarantees patient access to them.
Sometimes, while charting postmortem data teeth may be
Expert testimony
wrongly numbered especially in cases where adjacent tooth
migrate into the extraction space. This can be connected using
It is important to remember to present the biological data both
radiographs.
in scientific and layman terms. Before submitting the data
circumstances, the radiographs were produced. The expert
Legal matters
should know if the radiograph is original or a copy and the
whereabouts of the radiographs at all times.
Following injury or assault radiological imaging is commonly
obtained by medical expert interpretation of these images may
provide useful evidence in criminal and civil jurisdiction. Basic principle used for postmortem radiograph

Body identification When a radiograph of postmortem remains is performed to


compare with ante mortem radiograph “Identical projection”
Along with dental and DNA analysis, radiographic images are must be achieved with similar magnification, exposure factors,
used in the unknown victims. This requires the securing of and angulations so as to reproduce the ante mortem radiograph
premortem examination e.g.,  Computed tomography  (CT) like image. This is carried out using various angles of projection
scan or radiograph of the suspect individual and the matching and by varying technical factors.[1-4]
of specific anatomical details with similar postmortem studies.
General considerations
Postmortem examination
Radiograph should be taken before and after head and neck
Nortje  (1986) stated “radiographic appearance of teeth and autopsy. Whenever possible, radiograph should be made at the
bone of the face is a permanent record of these tissues even scene of accident or crime. They should be properly labeled
when teeth and sections of bone are removed for histopathologic with identification number, site, and date of examination for
examination.” future reference.

Journal of Pharmacy and Bioallied Sciences April 2015 Vol 7 Supplement 1 S261 
Manigandan, et al.: Forensic radiology in dentistry

All intra and extra oral projections including panoramic Table 1: Intensity of extra oral radiographs
radiographs have to be taken as and when it is needed depending View kVp mAs Time (s)
on the case and type of remains. PA townes 65 30 0.3
Lateral 55 30 0.3
Intra oral radiographs OM 65-75 60 0.3
PA: Posterio Anterior view, OM: Occipital Mental view
Intraoral radiographs are difficult to perform particularly
when there is restricted mouth opening. It may be necessary
to remove soft tissues from the floor of the mouth or cheeks to directed centrally at right angles to the object and film. An
insert the film. A miniature intraoral X‑ray source may be used. anode – film distance of at least 40 cm is recommended to
give more parallel beam.
Resected maxilla may be split through the midpalatal suture.
The posterior mandible and maxilla are placed on occlusal film Comparisons of antemortem and postmortem
to produce an “enlarged bite‑wing film.” radiographs

Whenever fragmented remains consisting teeth, restorations, Antemortem and postmortem radiographs are compared
bone pieces, appliances are recovered they have to be separated noting similarities and differences. The most current films are
by the method proposed by Johanson. examined first because they will show the greatest similarity
to the postmortem status of the teeth and jaws. Comparison
Johanson’s method is done on
• Number and arrangement of teeth (missing teeth, rotated
• Place the debris on the plastic grid. teeth, spacing, extra teeth, impacted teeth)
• Place the film on a wire grid identical to the plastic grid. • Caries and periodontal bone loss
• From the resultant radiograph type of remaining can be • Coronal restorations
identified. • Hidden restorations (posts, implants, root canal fillings)
• Bony pathology
Radiographic Techniques Used in Forensic Dentistry • Dental anatomy
• Trabecular bone pattern
Extra oral radiography • Anatomic bony landmarks
• Maxillary sinus and nasal aperture
With the oblique – lateral technique, it is necessary to increase • Frontal sinus.
the anode – object distance in order to enlarge the field of
irradiation. The minimum distance is 40 cm which will project Age estimation of adults from dental radiograph
onto the film a 10 cm diameter beam of X‑rays. The exposure
factors using high definition intensifying screens will be 55–60 With the advancing age, the size of the dental pulp cavity is reduced
kVp and 20 mAs [Table 1]. When using faster screens, the as a result of secondary dentine deposit so that the measurements
milliampere seconds is reduced.[4] of this reduction can be used as an indicator of age.[5-9]

Panoramic radiographs Secondary dentine as also been measured indirectly on


radiograph of extracted teeth. Such measurements were
The X‑ray tube and film rotate around a stationary patient; suggested use in nondestructive method to predict the age.
specimens must be elevated in position, articulated, and The ratio between pulp and the root has also been used in
oriented with the occlusal line or Frankfort plane parallel to age estimation as the size of the pulp is reduced with age.
the ground. A setting of 8 mA at 80 kVp is a good starting Radiographs of the middle phalanx of the third finger are taken
exposure; a previously exposed black film can be placed in the to know the skeletal maturation status of the child.
cassette against the unexposed film to reduce the effect of
intensifying screen. Diversity of dental patterns in the orthopantomography
for human identification
Investigatory Methods in Forensic Dentistry by
Means of Various Radiographic Interventions The comparison and antemortem and postmortem dental
characteristics are a commonly applied method to perform
Bite marks personal identification. Orthopantomography is broadly applied
standard method in dentistry. It provides the complete view of
Radiographs may be used to assist in the identification by bite the teeth and both jaws and one image. Gustafson was the first
marks. The impressions are made with dental modeling wax to use orthopantomography in forensic practice for the purpose of
and cut to size of an occlusal film. The resultant impression identification, according to the theory proposed by Paatero, Rocca
is then filled with radiopaque dental alloy and placed with et al. considered orthopantomograms to be the most important
occlusal surface downwards on film. The X‑ray beam is antemortem source of information outside the written treatment

 S262 Journal of Pharmacy and Bioallied Sciences April 2015 Vol 7 Supplement 1
Manigandan, et al.: Forensic radiology in dentistry

records. The use of orthopantomography is practically applicable routine diagnostic skull radiograph was verified by examining
for the identification of victims of mass disasters as well as wars.[4] the skull skiagrams preserved in the radiology department and
can be more effectively used in personal identification problems.
Personal identification on the basis of antemortem and A positive method of identification of the skull is suggested by
postmortem radiographs the comparison of radiographic with visible skull suture pattern.
The added advantage in the process of identification through
There are many parts of the human skeleton, which because suture pattern is that they cannot be altered or destroyed in
of their anatomical variability are very applicable to the case of finger ridges.[16]
identification process. The first authority to point this out was
Schuller, who found that X‑rays of the frontal sinuses are very Individual identification by means of conventional
good tool for identification.[10,11] bite‑wing film and subtraction radiography

Currently, there are three main comparison methods of personal The digital subtraction technique used in clinical trials for the
identification used in Hungarian forensic practice: evaluation of small tissue changes. It may, however, also be able
• Examination of dental records to determine hard tissue similarities for use in forensic dentistry.
• Superimposition of photographs Principle of digital subtraction included features for correction
• Comparison of radiographs. of variations in exposure geometry and density. Subtractions
were performed between identical images (images of the same
New horizons in forensic radiology – multislice individual) and between nonidentical images (images of two
computed tomography different individuals).[17,18]

Alternatives to classic autopsy to collect forensically relevant Bite‑wing radiography is considered as a good candidate for
data the potential of multislice computed tomography can be potential victim identification [Figure 1]. A quantitative analysis
used. With this modern method, the scan time for a full body of subtraction images based on bite‑wing radiographs as recently
examination with a gunshot wound to the head is approximately been reported. The subtraction images derived from identical
60 s. This method is rapider, based on nondestructive photographs significantly more homogenous than those derived
documentation process and in some respects is more precise from nonidentical radiographs originating in individuals with
than the standard forensic autopsy.[12-14] and without simple dental restorations.

Dental Computed Tomography Screening Tool for Sex determination by lateral radiographic cephalometry
Dental Profiling
In general, male skulls are identifiable by being more robust.
Female skull is characterized by weaker development of its
The newer CT imaging based software called  Dentascan (GE
super‑structures. All bony ridges, crests, and processes are
Health care, UK)  used for identification purpose. Using the
smaller and smoother in the female skull than in the male
Dentascan software, reformatted panoramic images could
skull, especially true for the temporal line, mastoid processes,
be reconstructed for each case that was compared to the
nuchal lines, external occipital protuberance, and superciliary
antemortem dental periapical radiographs, bite‑wing films, and
arches. Sella to nasion, Frankfort horizontal place and basion to
panoramic radiograph.[15]
nasion as reference lines or planes are commonly used in lateral
radiographic cephalometric analysis. Thus, morphometric traits
A reformated panoramic overview created by Dentascan delivers
in a noninvasive way to overview jaws showing basic components
of teeth,  (enamel, dentin, pulp) anatomic structures of
alveolar bone  (mandibular nerve canal or floor of nasal
cavity and maxillary sinus), pathology (caries, radiolucencies,
radio‑opacities, or position of third molars), and restorations.

The most important advantage of Dentascan in contrast


to classical methods is that documentation can be made
a
noninvasive and digital way without jaw resection, which is often
performed to facilitate classical radiological documentation on
decomposed, charred, and mutilated corpses.

Identification of skull by its suture patterns

The examination of 320 skulls collected at random revealed


ectocranial suture patterns in them are highly individualistic b
and that no two skulls can ever have an identical pattern. The Figure 1: (a) Antemortem bite-wing radiographs (b) Postmortem lower
possibility of the suture patterns being recorded incidentally in bite-wing radiographs

Journal of Pharmacy and Bioallied Sciences April 2015 Vol 7 Supplement 1 S263 
Manigandan, et al.: Forensic radiology in dentistry

of the skull super‑structures and intracranial structures are study of clinically based and regression models with the Operation
Desert Storm victims. Am J Forensic Med Pathol 1994;15:303‑18.
easily assessed. This enables us to use them as morphometric
5. Willems G, Moulin‑Romsee C, Solheim T. Non‑destructive dental‑age
variables.[19] calculation methods in adults: Intra‑ and inter‑observer effects.
Forensic Sci Int 2002;126:221‑6.
X‑ray screening system at a mass disaster 6. Liversidge HM, Lyons F, Hector MP. The accuracy of three methods
of age estimation using radiographic measurements of developing
teeth. Forensic Sci Int 2003;131:22‑9.
A security scanning system known as line scan unit was used 7. Liversidge HM, Molleson TI. Developing permanent tooth length as
which allows screening where space may be limited. They an estimate of age. J Forensic Sci 1999;44:917‑20.
8. Kvaal SI, Kolltveit KM, Thomsen IO, Solheim T. Age estimation of
operate on 105–125 VAC, and the X‑ray voltage is 160 kVp.[20]
adults from dental radiographs. Forensic Sci Int 1995;74:175‑85.
9. Madhu S. Age estimation through finger radiographs. Med Legal
Summary and Conclusion Update 2006;6:37‑9.
10. Angyal M, Dérczy K. Personal identification on the basis of antemortem
and postmortem radiographs. J Forensic Sci 1998;43:1089‑93.
The radiological identification of individual human remains 11. MacLean DF, Kogon SL, Stitt LW. Validation of dental radiographs for
depends entirely on matching specific and unique visual findings human identification. J Forensic Sci 1994;39:1195‑200.
or features on both ante mortem and postmortem radiological 12. Aghayev E, Thali MJ, Sonnenschein M, Jackowski C, Dirnhofer R,
Vock P. Post‑mortem tissue sampling using computed tomography
images of that person. Postmortem findings confirming the sex, guidance. Forensic Sci Int 2007;166:199‑203.
age, stature, or race may be either confirmatory or exclusionary. 13. Thali MJ, Yen K, Schweitzer W, Vock P, Ozdoba C, Dirnhofer R. Into the
decomposed body‑forensic digital autopsy using multislice‑computed
Dental identification is also scientific, relying on the patterns of tomography. Forensic Sci Int 2003;134 (2‑3):109‑14.
14. Thali MJ, Schweitzer W, Yen K, Vock P, Ozdoba C, Spielvogel E,
missing, filled, and decayed teeth as well as anatomic variation et al. New horizons in forensic radiology: The 60‑second digital
of the teeth, jawbones, and sinuses. Teeth and bones are also autopsy‑full‑body examination of a gunshot victim by multislice
durable, surviving decompositional and destructive forces. computed tomography. Am J Forensic Med Pathol 2003;24:22‑7.
15. Thali MJ, Markwalder T, Jackowski C, Sonnenschein M, Dirnhofer R.
Dental CT imaging as a screening tool for dental profiling: Advantages
The decedent’s teeth are compared to ante mortem written records and limitations. J Forensic Sci 2006;51:113‑9.
although the most accurate and reliable method is by comparison 16. Chandra Sekharan P. Identification of skull from its suture pattern.
of ante mortem and postmortem records. Unlike subjective Forensic Sci Int 1985;27:205‑14.
17. Andersen L, Wenzel A. Individual identification by means of
records, which lack detail and can include errors, radiographs conventional bitewing film and subtraction radiography. Forensic
supply objective data through precise recording of unique Sci Int 1995 21;72:55‑64.
morphology of dental restorations and dento – osseous anatomy. 18. Kogon SL, McKay A, Maclean DF. The validity of bitewing radiographs
for the dental identification of children. J Forensic 1995;40:1055‑7.
19. Hsiao TH, Chang HP, Liu KM. Sex determination by discriminant
 References function analysis of lateral radiographic cephalometry. J Forensic
Sci 1996;41:792‑5.
1. Dayal PK. Textbook of Forensic Odontology. 1st ed. Putli bowli, 20. Goodman NR, Edelson LB. The efficiency of an X‑ray screening
Hydrabad: Paras Medical Publisher; 1998. system at a mass disaster. J Forensic Sci 2002;47:127‑30.
2. Kahana T, Hiss J. Forensic radiology. Br J Radiol 1999;72:129‑33.
3. Clark DH. Practical Forensic Odontology.  Malaysia: Butterworth; 1992.
4. Morse DR, Esposito JV, Kessler HP, Gorin R. Age estimation using Source of Support: Nill, Conflict of Interest: None declared.
dental periapical radiographic parameters. A review and comparative

 S264 Journal of Pharmacy and Bioallied Sciences April 2015 Vol 7 Supplement 1
Copyright of Journal of Pharmacy & Bioallied Sciences is the property of Medknow
Publications & Media Pvt. Ltd. and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites
or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However,
users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.

You might also like