Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Growth and Production Performance of Threatened Snakehead Fish, (Bloch), at Different Stocking Densities in Earthen Ponds
Growth and Production Performance of Threatened Snakehead Fish, (Bloch), at Different Stocking Densities in Earthen Ponds
Growth and Production Performance of Threatened Snakehead Fish, (Bloch), at Different Stocking Densities in Earthen Ponds
Correspondence: M Aminur Rahman, Laboratory of Marine Science and Aquaculture, Institute of Bioscience, Universiti Putra Malay-
sia, 43400 UPM Serdang, Selangor, Malaysia. E-mail: aminur1963@gmail.com
natural depressions, £oodplains, inundated paddy There were three treatments with three replicates
¢elds, etc. C. striatus usually breeds during the onset for each experiment. Fingerlings were stocked
of monsoon in ditches, ponds and £ooded at 5000 ha 1 in treatment-1 (T1), 6250 ha 1 in
paddy ¢elds. The fecundity of the ¢sh varies from treatment-2 (T2) and 7500 ha 1 in treatment-3 (T3)
16330 to 56 467 in the size range of 34.2^51.50 cm respectively.
(M.A. Rahman unpublished data). The young remain Fish in all the experimental ponds were fed with
at the surface in shoals guarded by their parents supplementary feed comprising of ¢sh meal (30%)
hiding below the surface of water. During the past and mustard oilcake (70%) at the rate of 3^6% of es-
few years, the natural population of this ¢sh has de- timated body weight two times per day. In addition,
creased rapidly due to habitat degradation and chopped trash ¢sh were supplied at the rate of 2^3%
man-made catastrophes in the aquatic ecosystem. of the estimated biomass on each alternate day. After
These factors not only caused havoc to the biodiver- stocking, cowdung was applied to the ponds
sity but also destroyed the feeding and breeding (1000 kg ha 1) fortnightly. Ten individuals of ¢sh
grounds of this important ¢sh species. This species from each pond were sampled monthly to determine
is now considered to be an endangered ¢sh in the growth rate and feed adjustment.
Bangladesh (IUCN, Bangladesh 1998). Therefore, the In situ water parameters such as temperature ( 1C),
present experiment has been undertaken to develop a transparency (cm), DO (mg L 1), pH, total alkalinity
culture technique of C. striatus for better production (mg L 1), ammonia nitrogen (mg L 1), nitrate nitro-
and conservation. gen (mg L 1), nitrite nitrogen (mg L 1) and phos-
phate phosphorous (mg L 1) were analysed
fortnightly (APHA 1992). After 8 months of rearing,
¢sh were harvested from all the ponds. The ¢sh were
Materials and methods
counted and measured individually to assess the to-
The present experiment was conducted at the Fresh- tal production, growth and survival. One-way ANOVA
water Station, Bangladesh Fisheries Research Insti- was used to test the density e¡ect. The level of signi¢-
tute, Mymensingh, Bangladesh, for a period of 8 cance was set at Po0.05. All statistical analyses were
months between October 2005 and June 2006. Nine performed using SPSS version 1.5.
earthen ponds were used in this experiment. The sur-
face area and average depth of each pond was
0.048 ha and 1.5 m. The pond was prepared with
quicklime (CaO, 250 kg ha 1) after drying. After 3 Results
days, each pond was ¢lled with ground water of about
Water quality parameters
1.5 m and a similar depth was maintained for the
entire experimental period. After 7 days of liming, Pond water quality parameters of C. striatus culture
the ponds were fertilized with cowdung are summarized in Table 1. The average temperature
(2000 kg ha 1), urea (25 kg ha 1) and triple super ( 1C), DO (mg L 1), pH, total alkalinity (mg L 1), am-
phosphate (25 kg ha 1). Seven days after the applica- monia nitrogen (mg L 1), nitrate nitrogen (mg L 1),
tion of fertilizers, ponds were stocked with the ¢nger- nitrite nitrogen (mg L 1) and phosphate phosphor-
lings of C. striatus at di¡erent stocking densities. ous (mg L 1) did not di¡er signi¢cantly (P40.05).
Table 1 Mean ( SD) values of pond water quality parameters over the 8 months rearing period
Temperature ( 1C) 28.33 2.25a (24.80–31.20) 28.40 2.28a (24.70–31.30) 28.30 2.22a (25.60–31.10)
Dissolved oxygen (mg L 1) 5.66 1.19a (3.38–7.30) 5.39 1.22a (3.28–6.70) 5.28 1.12a (3.20–6.50)
a a
pH 7.88 0.35 (7.40–8.40) 7.70 0.38 (7.30–8.30) 7.60 0.41a (7.20–8.20)
Total alkalinity (mg L 1) 148.50 38.65a (88.50–210.00) 140.88 36.65a (96.50–215.00) 138.66 32.33a (92.50–190.00)
Ammonia nitrogen (mg L 1) 0.42 0.32a (0.01–1.22) 0.46 0.35a (0.01–1.30) 0.49 0.36a (0.01–1.45)
Nitrate nitrogen (mg L 1) 1.27 0.25a (1.00–1.60) 1.24 0.26a (0.96–1.55) 1.21 0.22a (0.94–1.52)
Nitrite nitrogen (mg L 1) 0.026 a
0.01 (0.017–0.039) a
0.024 0.01 (0.016–0.037) 0.023 0.01a (0.015–0.036)
1
Phosphate phosphorous (mg L ) 1.38 0.75a (0.30–2.80) 1.35 0.70a (0.40–2.74) 1.30 0.68a (0.30–2.70)
Mean values in the same row having the same superscripts are not signi¢cantly di¡erent (P40.05).
Table 2 Growth performance, survival, feed utilization and production of Channa striatus after 8 months of rearing;
mean SD with ranges in parentheses
Treatments
1 1 1
Parameters T1 (5000 ha ) T2 (6.250 ha ) T3 (7500 ha )
Initial length (cm) 13.21 0.52a (12.00–14.50) 13.21 0.52a (12.00–14.50) 13.21 0.52a (12.00–14.50)
Final length (cm) 40.40 0.45a (40.11–40.92) 38.40 0.49b (38.06–38.96) 35.83 0.54c (35.23–36.28)
a a
Initial weight (g) 17.63 1.23 (16.00–20.20) 17.63 1.23 (16.00–20.20) 17.63 1.23a (16.00–20.20)
Final weight (g) 445.67 3.79a (443.00–450.00) 326.06 3.60b (323.05–330.05) 294.54 4.20c (290.00–298.30)
Weight gain (g) 428.04 3.79a (425.37–432.37) 308.43 3.60b (305.42–312.42) 276.91 4.20c (272.37–280.67)
Length gain (cm) 27.19 0.45a (26.90–27.71) 25.19 0.49b (24.85–25.75) 22.62 0.54c (22.02–23.07)
Specific growth rate 1.34 0.01a (1.34–1.35) 1.21 0.01b (1.21–1.22) 1.17 0.01c (1.17–1.18)
(SGR) (%/day)
Food conversion ratio 2.10 0.09a (2.02–2.19) 2.38 0.09b (2.31–2.48) 2.68 0.09c (2.61–2.78)
(FCR)
Survival (%) 67.33 2.08a (65.00–69.00) 62.67 1.53b (61.00–64.00) 54.67 1.53c (53.00–56.00)
Gross production 1540.17 38.83a 1277.06 32.81b 1207.31 18.68c (1185.74–1218.20)
1
(kg ha ) (1506.20–1582.50) (1239.41–1299.57)
Net production 1479.24 37.80a (1446.26–1520.50) 1208.01 31.31b (1172.19–1230.15) 1135.02 16.79c (1115.66–1145.47)
1
(kg ha )
Figures in the same row having the same superscripts are not signi¢cantly di¡erent (P40.05).
lower than those in T2 (6250 ha 1) and T3 might have been a¡ected by stocking density i.e., the
(7500 ha 1). This might be due to competition for higher the stocking density, the higher the FCR va-
food and space in higher density and the carnivorous lues. Generally, the FCR increases with increasing
mode of life of C. striatus (Qin & Fast 1996, 2003; Qin feed application rates above optimal. With intensive
et al.1997). Similar phenomena were also observed in ¢n¢sh culture with a dry formulated palletized feed,
the bottom-dwelling and carnivorous ¢sh mahseer the FCR is typically 2.0 or less (Parker 1987). In inten-
(Tor putitora) (Islam 2002; Islam et al. 2002; Rahman sive culture trials, rainbow trout, Oncorhynchus my-
et al. 2005, 2007). In African cat¢sh, Clarias gariepi- kiss, and channel cat¢sh, Ictalurus punctatus,
nus, cannibalism increases with increasing density showed FCR values that ranged from 1.2 to 2.0 (Hu-
and thereby decreases growth and survival (Hecht & ner & Dupree1984). Snakehead fed with a formulated
Pienaar, 1993). In the present study, growth and sur- feed at 5% body weight had an FCR value of1.0 (Qin &
vival were dependant on density, suggesting that the Fast 2003).
stocking density of snakehead for grow-out culture Productions (gross and net) of snakeheads found
in earthen ponds may not be increased beyond in this experiment were higher in T1 (5000 ha 1)
5000 ha 1. than those obtained in T2 (6250 ha 1) and T3
Signi¢cantly higher SGR (%/day) was obtained in (7500 ha 1). Kohinoor et al. (2004) found a gross pro-
T1 (1.34% day 1) than those in T2 (1.21) and T3 (1.17) duction of 1370^1535 kg ha 1 following the culture
respectively. Rahman et al. (2007) reported that SGR of small indigenous cat¢sh (Mystus cavasius) for 6
of catla, rohu, mrigal and mahseer in di¡erent treat- months at 40 000^60 000 ¢ngerlings ha 1 stocking
ments under a polyculture system were 1.09^1.12%, densities. Akhteruzzaman, Kohinoor, Hussain and
1.13^1.14%, 1.10^1.12% and 1.15^1.16%, which are Shah (1996) observed that under the monoculture
lower than those in the present study. Kohinoor et al. condition, the production of Puntius sarana was
(2004) observed the SGR values of indigenous cat¢sh 1200 kg ha 1/6 months. Rahman, Hossain, Azad,
(Mystus cavasius) to be 1.16^1.23% under a monocul- Kamruzzaman, Rashid, Rahman and Hasan (2006)
ture system in earthen ponds, which were much clo- also obtained the range of total production from
ser to the present study. The higher SGR values in this 1248 to 1593 kg ha 1/120 days when Thai sharpunti
study might be due to the consumption of natural was cultured together with indigenous and exotic
and supplementary feed for growth. carp species at di¡erent densities in seasonal ponds.
In the present study, signi¢cantly lower (Po0.05) It is revealed that the growth, survival and produc-
FCR values were obtained in T1 (2.10) than those in tion of snakehead ¢sh are inversely related to the
T2 (2.38) and T3 (2.68). The FCR values in this study stocking densities of ¢ngerlings. The stocking density
of 5000 ¢ngerlings ha 1 demonstrated the highest to the Fish Farmers: The Status of Warmwater Fish Farming
performance compared with those obtained at high- and Progress in Fish Farming Research (ed. by H.K. Dupree
er stocking rates. The ¢sh farmers might be recom- & J.V. Huner), pp. 44^82. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service,
mended to use a stocking density of 5000 ¢nger Washington, DC, USA.
lings ha 1 for rearing of C. striatus in earthen ponds. Islam M.S. (2002) Evaluation of supplementary feeds for
semi-intensive pond culture of mahseer, Tor putitora
These results represent the ¢rst successful attempt to
(Hamilton). Aquaculture 212, 263^276.
culture the critically endangered snakehead in cap-
Islam M.S., Dewan S., Hussain M.G., Hossain M.A. & Mazid
tivity. Because of over-exploitation and various ecolo-
M.A. (2002) Feed utilization and wastage in semi-
gical changes in the aquatic ecosystem, C. striatus intensive pond culture of mahseer, Tor putitora (Ham.).
may become extinct from the natural habitats. BangladeshJournal of Fisheries Research 6, 1^9.
Under the prevailing situation, the ¢ndings obtained IUCN, Bangladesh (1998) List of threatened animals of
from the present study would be immensely helpful Bangladesh. Paper presented in the special workshop on
for the development of aquaculture and conservation Bangladesh Red Book of Threatened Animals, 22
of this important ¢sh. Further studies are also February 1998, Dhaka, 13pp.
recommended to determine more appropriate, Kohinoor A.H.M., Begum M. & Hussain M.G. (2004) Culture
stocking densities and culture techniques of this potentials of gulsha (Mystus cavasius) in monoculture
important ¢shery. management under di¡erent stocking densities. Bangla-
deshJournal of Fisheries Research 8, 95^100.
Mat Jais A.M., Dambisya Y.M. & Lee T.L. (1997) Antinocicep-
tive activity of Channa striatus (haruann) extracts in mice.
Acknowledgments Journal of Ethnopharmacology 57,125^130.
Ng P.K.L. & Lim K.K.P. (1990) Snakeheads (Pisces: Channi-
We are much indebted to the Director General and
dae): natural history, biology and economic importance.
Chief Scienti¢c O⁄cer, Bangladesh Fisheries Re- In: Essays in Zoology. Papers Commemorating the 40th An-
search Institute, Mymensingh, for providing ¢nan- niversary of the Department of Zoology (ed. by L.M. Chou &
cial and experimental facilities.We would also like to K.L.P. Ng), pp. 127^152. National University of Singapore,
thank the research assistants and ¢eld workers, who Singapore.
helped during the experiment. Parker N.C. (1987) Feed conversion indices: controversy or
convention? The Progressive Fish-Culturist 49, 161^166.
Qin J.G. & Fast A.W. (1996) E¡ects of feed application rates on
growth, survival, and feed conversion of juvenile snake-
References head Channa striatus. Journal of the World Aquaculture
Akhteruzzaman M., KohinoorA.H.M., Hussain M.G. & Shah Society 27, 52^56.
M.S. (1996) A study on the semi-intensive culture of Qin J.G. & Fast A.W. (1998) E¡ects of temperature, size and
Puntius sarana (Ham.). Bangladesh Journal of Fisheries 14, density on culture performance of snakehead, Channa
69^72. striatus (Bloch), fed formulated feed. Aquaculture Research
APHA (1992) Standard Methods for the Examination of Water 29, 299^303.
andWastewater. American Public Health Association,Wa- Qin J.G. & Fast A.W. (2003) Intensive culture of snakehead
shington, DC, USA, 1268pp. (Channa striatus) during larval, juvenile and growth
Boyd C.E. (1982) Water Quality Management for Pond Fish stages. American Fisheries Society Symposium 38, 33^41.
Culture. Elsevier,The Netherlands, 318pp. Qin J.G., Fast A.W., DeAnda D. & Weidenbach R.P. (1997)
Chen T.P. (1976) Aquaculture Practice inTaiwan. Fishing News Growth and survival of larval snakehead Channa striatus,
(Books) Limited, Farnham, UK. fed di¡erent diets. Aquaculture 148, 105^113.
Dewan S., Wahab M.A., Beveridge M.C.M., Rahman M.H. & Rahman M.A., Mazid M.A., Rahman M.R., Khan M.N.,
Sarker B.K. (1991) Food selection, electivity and dietary Hossain M.A. & Hussain M.G. (2005) E¡ect of stocking
overlap among planktivorous Chinese and Indian major density on survival and growth of critically endangered
carp fry and ¢ngerlings grown in extensively managed, mahseer,Tor putitora (Hamilton) in nursery ponds. Aqua-
rainfed ponds in Bangladesh. Aquaculture and Fisheries culture 249, 275^284.
Management 22, 277^294. Rahman M.A, Hossain M.K., Azad M.A.K., Kamruzzaman
Hecht T. & Pienaar A.G. (1993) A review of cannibalism and M., Rashid H.A., Rahman M.M. & Hasan K.M.M. (2006)
its implications in ¢sh larviculture. Journal of the World Culture potential of Thai sharpunti, Barbodes gonionotus
Aquaculture Society 24, 246^261. with major carps in seasonal ponds. Pakistan Journal of
Huner J.V. & Dupree H.K. (1984) Methods and economics of Biological Sciences 9, 1891^1897.
channel cat¢sh production, and techniques for the cul- Rahman M.A., Rahman M.R. & Rahman M.S. (2007)
ture of £athead cat¢sh and other cat¢shes. In:Third Report Evaluation of growth and production of the mahseer, Tor
putitora (Ham.) in polyculture with indigenous major Uddin M.M. (2002) E¡ects of addition of small ¢sh on pond ecol-
carps. In: Mahseer: The Biology and Conservation (ed. by ogy and production in polyculture. MS Thesis, Faculty of
S.S. Siraj, A. Christianus, N.C. Kiat & S.S. De Silva), pp. Fisheries, Bangladesh Agricultural University, Mymen-
161^175. Malaysian Fisheries Society Occasional Publica- singh, 31pp
tion No 14, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. Wahab M.A., Ahmed Z.F., Islam M.A. & Rahmatullah S.M.
Rahman M.S. (1992) Water Quality Management in Aquacul- (1995) E¡ect of introduction of common carp, Cyprinus
ture. BRAC Prokashana, Dhaka, Bangladesh, 84pp. carpio (L) on the pond ecology and growth of ¢sh in poly-
Sarkar M.R.U, Khan S., Haque M.M. & Haq M.S. (2006) Eva- culture. Aquaculture Research 26, 619^628.
luation of growth and water quality in pangasiid cat¢sh Wee K.L. (1982) The biology and culture of snake-
(Pangasius hypophthalmus) monoculture and polyculture heads. In: Recent Advances in Aquaculture (ed. by J.F. Muir
with silver carp (Hypophthalmichthys molitrix). Journal of & R.J. Roberts), pp. 180^211. Westview Press, Boulder,
the Bangladesh Agricultural University 4, 339^346. CO, USA.