Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 17

Lecture Biodiversity

Metastudies

Overview:
• What is a meta-analysis?
• How to do a meta-analysis?
• What is an effect size?

Lecture Biodiversity Metastudies| FSU Jena | Ulrich Brose | 1


Study types

What is a meta-analysis?

Lecture Biodiversity Metastudies | FSU Jena | Ulrich Brose | 2


Study types
Quantitative Results Conclusion

Individual
studies:

Lecture Biodiversity Metastudies | FSU Jena | Ulrich Brose | 3


Study types
Quantitative Results Conclusion A
Study A
Individual
studies:

Study B Conclusion B

Study C Conclusion C

Lecture Biodiversity Metastudies | FSU Jena | Ulrich Brose | 4


Study types
Quantitative Results Conclusion A
Study A
Individual
studies:
Review
Study B Conclusion B studies
&
Method A Vote
Condition A Study C Conclusion C counting
Method B
Condition B
Method C
Condition C

Lecture Biodiversity Metastudies | FSU Jena | Ulrich Brose | 5


Study types
Quantitative Results Conclusion A
Study A
Individual
studies:
Review
Study B Conclusion B studies
&
Method A Vote
Condition A Study C Conclusion C counting
Method B
Condition B
Method C
Condition C

Meta-analysis

Lecture Biodiversity Metastudies | FSU Jena | Ulrich Brose | 6


Study types

Lecture Biodiversity Metastudies | FSU Jena | Ulrich Brose | 7


Study types

Lecture Biodiversity Metastudies | FSU Jena | Ulrich Brose | 8


Study types

Lecture Biodiversity Metastudies | FSU Jena | Ulrich Brose | 9


Procedure of meta-analyses

How to do a meta-analysis?

Lecture Biodiversity Metastudies | FSU Jena | Ulrich Brose | 10


Procedure of meta-analyses

Lecture Biodiversity Metastudies | FSU Jena | Ulrich Brose | 11


Procedure of meta-analyses

Lecture Biodiversity Metastudies | FSU Jena | Ulrich Brose | 12


Effect sizes

What is an effect size?

Lecture Biodiversity Metastudies | FSU Jena | Ulrich Brose | 13


Effect sizes
Hedge’s D:
• Comparing two groups such as treatment versus control
• Comparison of means by Hedge’s D
• Differences in means
• Standardized to different variance in data (sample size, power)
Treatment - Control
D= Jm
Example: Hedge's D SDPooled

(n t -1)sdt + (n c -1)sdc
SDPooled =
nt + nc - 2

Problems:
• Different D due to
(a) large differences in means (nominator) or
(b) small pooled variance (denominator)?

Lecture Biodiversity Metastudies | FSU Jena | Ulrich Brose | 14


Effect sizes
Ratios and log ratios:
• Comparing two groups such as treatment versus control
• Ratio of means or log of the ratio

Problems:
• Ratio is not symmetric (doubling = 2, halfing = 0.5, mean = 1.25)
• Log ratio is symmetric but requires:
(a) only positive values
(b) non-zero values

Lecture Biodiversity Metastudies | FSU Jena | Ulrich Brose | 15


Effect sizes
Other effect sizes:
• Pearson’s correlation coefficient r (Fisher’s z-transformation)
• Mantel correlations
• Slopes from linear regressions
• … many more ….

Lecture Biodiversity Metastudies | FSU Jena | Ulrich Brose | 16


Overview

Overview:
• What is a meta-analysis?
• How to do a meta-analysis?
• What is an effect size?

Lecture Biodiversity Metastudies | FSU Jena | Ulrich Brose | 17

You might also like