O&M

Understanding Net Positive Suction Head Requirement

A centrifugal pump that performs well under steady-state conditions may be found to cavitate when transitioning betwe

Pump cavitation occurs when a decrease in suction pressure causes the liquid to begin boiling. Vapor bubbles form and vio

What Is Pump NPSH?

Anyone who has sized a pump should be familiar with the term net positive suction head (NPSH). Simply put, pump NPSH

NPSHa = (HP – HVPA) + (HST – HFS)

where HP is the absolute pressure on the surface of the liquid source upstream of the pump converted to head units; H VPA

psi = feet / (144 x V)

NPSH Margin
The manufacturer determines the required NPSH (NPSHr) for a pump in units of feet-absolute, by steady-state testing the

If the pump is required to provide its full design flow capacity without any cavitation loss, NPSHa must exceed NPSHr by an

margin = [(slope x QFW x 3) / (NPSHr x 100)] + 1.0

where the slope of the pump’s NPSHr curve at the maximum pump flow (Q FW) is ∆H/∆Q. This margin is typically a factor of

The American National Standards Institute (ANSI)/Hydraulic Institute (HI) standard ANSI/HI 9.6.1-2017 “Rotodynamic Pum

Note that the margin recommendations do not account for unique operating conditions or equipment arrangements. If th

Pumps Susceptible to NPSH Transients

A NPSH transient occurs when the variables in the NPSHa expression change during the pumps transition between operati

Theoretically, any liquid pump can experience NPSH transients. However, systems that pump low-pressure, high-temperat

■ FW pumps that take their suction from a low-pressure deaerator storage tank containing high-temperature water are

■ In a combined cycle (CC) power plant there are many variations of deaerator configurations. Some don’t have a separ

■ Heater drain pumps operate with little NPSHa and high temperatures making them susceptible to transients.

■ Condensate pumps convey low-pressure, high-temperature condensate from the condenser hotwell. They are not no
FW Pump NPSH Transients
A typical FW heating system with overpressure deaeration is shown in Figure 1. The deaerator scrubs out air and heats the
1.
Simplified
schematic
of the
feedwater
(FW,
green),
condensa
te (blue),
and
extraction
steam
(red)
systems
in a
typical
steam
power
plant.
Pump
recirculati
on, FW
pump
discharge,
and low-
pressure
(LP) FW
heater
drains are
not
shown.
Source:
Michael F.
Czyszczew
ski, PE

When a steam power plant decreases load, the steam turbine will reduce or stop sending extraction steam to the FW heat

Meanwhile, the mass of FW in the suction pipe acts like a plug to isolate the pump from the temperature and pressure cha
2.
Pressure
decay
during a
net
positive
suction
head
(NPSH)
transient
event.
Cavitation
occurs
when
NPSH
available
(NPSHa)
is less
than
NPSH
required
(NPSHr).
Source:
Michael F.
Czyszczew
ski, PE

The green curve shows the sum of the vapor pressure at the pump and the NPSHr. This is the minimum acceptable pressur

The Thurston Equation

The subject of NPSH transient formation in FW pumps received a lot of attention by notable pump researchers such as I.J.
Without going into the details of Thurston’s derivation, he showed that NPSH transient cavitation would not occur if a min

FT = (M / m) x ln[(h1 – hC) / (h2 – hC)]

where M is the mass of FW contained in the deaerator storage tank (lbm); m is the mass of FW contained in the suction pi

P2 = P1 + (NPSHr – HST + HFS) / (144 x V1)

The liquid specific volume is a function of the saturation pressure in the deaerator at the start of the transient. A high valu

The value assumed for the minimum condensate enthalpy entering the deaerator (h C) is critical to the solution. Colder con

If a transient factor of less than 1.0 is calculated, a more rigorous evaluation based on fewer simplifying assumptions may

■ Use a pipe flow modeling program to determine the pipe flow head loss.

■ Use a spreadsheet to collect the data and perform the NPSHa calculations. The columns should contain the paramete

■ Spreadsheet rows should represent an incremental advancement of time and should cover the entire duration of the

■ Steam property functions, which are available for many commercial spreadsheet programs, are needed to simplify th

■ Input data representing the static operating conditions that exist before and after the transient should be per the pro

■ Input a description of how each of the variables that make up NPSHa change during the transient. Ideally, the change

■ Plot how NPSHa and NPSHr change over the course of the transient to demonstrate that sufficient margin exists at all

For reference, the Thurston equation is based on the following simplifying assumptions:

■ The volume of FW in the suction pipe at the start of the transient remains at a constant vapor pressure as it passes th

■ All FW leaving the deaerator is a saturated liquid.

■ Condensate flowrate into the deaerator equals the FW outflow and is constant.

■ There is complete mixing between all fluids in the deaerator.

■ No extraction steam flow to the LP FW heaters or deaerator occurs during the transient.

■ No FW recirculation or high-pressure heater drain flows enter the deaerator during the transient.

■ Heat retention of the pump, piping, deaerator, and FW heater metal mass is neglected.

A few additional words concerning the last assumption might be helpful. The metal mass of the pump will tend to store he

An additional steam flashing situation could occur if there are long horizontal runs of suction piping at high elevations. The
FW Pump Transient Solutions
The most commonly recommended options for preventing FW pump transients attempt to eliminate the vapor pressure d

Pump Inlet Cooling. NPSHa can be increased by injecting a small amount of cooler condensate near the pump inlet. The m

QB = [1 – e^(–m / M)] x QFW

and

TFW = T1 + [(QB / QFW) x (TB – T1)]

where TB is the temperature of the bypass source and T 1 is the temperature of the saturated FW in the suction pipe before

The control system can be designed to monitor the deaerator and pump inlet pressures and bypass enough cold condensa

The main disadvantage of this option is that it increases the oxygen content of the FW. To minimize this effect, the bypass

Deaerator Pressure Control. The initiating cause of the transient is the deaerator pressure decay that results from the loss

The control system can be designed to monitor the internal deaerator pressure and pump inlet pressure. A pressure reduc

The option’s disadvantages are that robust components suitable for steam service are required. There will also be a very h

Additional Options. The following options are reliable because they are not dependent on the operation of a control syste

Pump Specifications. Confirm the basis for the pump NPSHr curve. Ask the manufacturer what cavitation level basis was
Decrease the Suction Pipe Diameter. Decreasing the mass of FW stored in the suction pipe will create a beneficial decre
Increase the Quantity of FW Stored in the Deaerator. The mass of FW in the deaerator stores heat. Increasing the mass
Raise the Deaerator Elevation or Lower the Pump. It is common practice in new plant design to place the deaerator abo
Reduce the Length of the Suction Pipe. NPSHa is increased by reducing pipe pressure drop. Also, reducing the pipe lengt
Add a Booster Pump. A low-speed, low-head, single-stage booster pump installed upstream of the FW pump will increa

—Michael F. Czyszczewski, PE (mczyszczewski@asme.org) is a mechanical engineer with 44 years of design experience in t

SHARE this article

#engineering #design #pump #fundamentals #cavitation #NPSH #net positive suction head

More O&M News

  Webinars
Sponsored by Evoqua

Eliminate DI Water Rental Costs and Reduce OPEX with Ionpure CEDI solutions

Available on demand until Feb 24, 2022

Learn more

Sponsored by Centrica

The Drive to Digital for Modern Utilities: Centrica's Transformation Story

Available on demand until Feb 11, 2022

Learn more
Learn more
equirements for Pumps
when transitioning between operating modes. Resolving a transient cavitation problem can seem daunting because many thermod

apor bubbles form and violently implode when they enter higher pressure regions of the pump. This creates noise, pitting, erosion, fla

). Simply put, pump NPSH is the excess head (or pressure) exerted on the pump’s suction that keeps the liquid from boiling. The availab

verted to head units; H VPA is the pump suction absolute vapor pressure (the pressure at which a liquid at a particular temperature begi

y steady-state testing the pump with water. NPSHr increases with flowrate, and typically represents the point at which a 3% loss in pu

a must exceed NPSHr by an appropriate margin: NPSHa ≥ margin x NPSHr. The margin required to compensate for a 3% output loss can

rgin is typically a factor of about 1.2.

-2017 “Rotodynamic Pumps Guideline for NPSH Margin” gives recommendations on how much margin to use based on the pump’s se

pment arrangements. If there are uncertainties in your design that could increase the potential for transient cavitation, a greater marg

ransition between operating states. Because the variables generally do not change at the same rate, NPSHa might temporarily drop be

w-pressure, high-temperature liquids are most likely to experience problems. Some examples include:

gh-temperature water are strong candidates for experiencing NPSH transients during a turbine load reduction.

s. Some don’t have a separate deaerator, but instead rely on the condenser for deaeration. Some deaerators operate under vacuum co

tible to transients.

r hotwell. They are not normally susceptible to transients because the large quantity of condensate in the hotwell stabilizes temperatu
crubs out air and heats the FW by direct contact with steam extracted from the steam turbine. It stores a mixture of FW in both the va
tion steam to the FW heaters and the deaerator. The pressure in the deaerator will begin to decrease due to the loss of steam pressur

perature and pressure changes taking place in the deaerator. This isolation lasts until the full volume of FW in the suction pipe has a ch
 nimum acceptable pressure head at the pump suction. The black curve shows the actual pressure head at the pump suction (H P + HST –

mp researchers such as I.J. Karassik and G.S. Liao from the 1950s through the 1970s. Rodney S. Thurston of Cornell University authored
n would not occur if a minimum quantity of FW was stored in the deaerator. By rearranging his equation, a “transient factor” (F T) can

ontained in the suction piping; h C is the minimum value of enthalpy (Btu/lb) for the condensate entering the deaerator during the resi

the transient. A high value of P 1 will give a more conservative solution; therefore, the safety valve pressure is typically used.

to the solution. Colder condensate entering the deaerator will accelerate the pressure decay. Assuming that some of the low-pressure

plifying assumptions may show the design is acceptable. Some tips on performing this evaluation follow:

ould contain the parameters needed to calculate NPSHa over the time of the transient.

the entire duration of the transient. Some flow modeling software has the capability to simulate time by combining the results of mul

, are needed to simplify the work effort.

ient should be per the project heat balances.

nsient. Ideally, the change rates should be based on instrument data gathered during an actual transient. However, if data is not availa

fficient margin exists at all times.

por pressure as it passes through the system.

pump will tend to store heat after shutdown. The temperature (and vapor pressure H VPA) of the FW it contains will, therefore, be at a h

ing at high elevations. These pipe runs are prone to flashing because there is no increase in static head to compensate for the pressure
 nate the vapor pressure differential between the pump and deaerator by either cooling the FW at the pump inlet or increasing the de

ear the pump inlet. The most reliable and coldest source of condensate for this is the condenser hotwell. A bypass line can be installed

in the suction pipe before the transient.

ass enough cold condensate, when needed, to lower the pump vapor pressure sufficiently to provide a margin over NPSHr. Other cont

mize this effect, the bypass should be designed for only the minimum flow necessary. Another concern is to ensure the cold condensate

y that results from the loss of extraction steam. Pump NPSHa can be increased by supplying the deaerator with additional steam to com

pressure. A pressure reducing control valve on the supplemental steam supply line will only admit enough steam as needed to maintai

There will also be a very high pressure drop across the control valve requiring a severe service valve be used. The control system will b

peration of a control system. However, they can be difficult and costly to implement into an existing installation, or offer only modest

t cavitation level basis was used and whether a manufacturer margin was included. Ask the manufacturer to determine the feasibility
ll create a beneficial decrease in the residence time; unfortunately, it increases the pipe’s flow resistance. Studies have shown, howeve
heat. Increasing the mass will slow the pressure and enthalpy decay rates. Increasing the deaerator storage capacity usually gives mor
o place the deaerator above the pump as high as possible to maximize the static head at the pump suction. Unfortunately, relocating
so, reducing the pipe length reduces the volume of FW in the pipe, which gives the benefit of reducing the transient residence time. Tr
f the FW pump will increase its NPSHa. However, the booster pump will also be susceptible to NPSH cavitation; therefore, it will also n

s of design experience in the power industry.

ng because many thermodynamic and dimensional factors are involved. This article will help the reader understand the causes of pum

noise, pitting, erosion, flashing, and vibration. If the bubbles collect and form into a vapor cavity, the pump can experience a water ha

d from boiling. The available NPSH (NPSHa) for a pump is given in units of feet-absolute and is defined as follows:

articular temperature begins to vaporize) converted to head units; H ST is the static head on the pump suction (the vertical distance bet

nt at which a 3% loss in pump output occurs due to cavitation (called NPSH3). Unfortunately, manufacturers sometimes use a 1% or 0%

te for a 3% output loss can be calculated as follows:

se based on the pump’s service. Additionally, some engineering firms apply system specific margins based on their experience. For exa

cavitation, a greater margin would be warranted. Use the largest of the margins applicable for your pump’s service when checking for

might temporarily drop below NPSHr during the transition.

operate under vacuum conditions. Many stations have a deaerator that is integral to the heat recovery steam generator (HRSG), whe

otwell stabilizes temperature, pressure, and level fluctuations. Also, vertical-can pumps are typically used to provide the submergence
xture of FW in both the vapor and liquid states. The internal pressure of the deaerator is equal to the vapor pressure of the liquid. This
o the loss of steam pressure, the condensing of steam in the deaerator, and the inflow of colder condensate.

in the suction pipe has a chance to move through the pump and is calculated by dividing the mass contained in the suction pipe by the
he pump suction (H P + HST – HFS). You don’t want the black curve to fall below the green curve. The intersection of the black and green c

ornell University authored a 1961 American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) paper titled “Design of Suction Piping and Deaera
“transient factor” (F T) can be defined where a value equal to or greater than 1.0 indicates an acceptable design. The equation is:

e deaerator during the residence time; h 1 is the enthalpy of saturated water based on the pressure in the deaerator at the start of the

is typically used.

some of the low-pressure (LP) FW heaters are out of service at the start of the transient adds some cushion to the calculation results.

mbining the results of multiple steady-state runs. This software feature would eliminate or reduce the calculations required with the sp

owever, if data is not available, assumptions will need to be made. This typically includes assuming that the liquid enthalpy decay in the

ns will, therefore, be at a higher temperature than the FW in the deaerator. When the pump is restarted, the pressure at the suction w

mpensate for the pressure decay in the deaerator and the friction losses that occur as the FW travels through the pipe. Avoid routing
 inlet or increasing the deaerator pressure.

bypass line can be installed to take a portion (about 10%) of the condensate exiting the hotwell for cooling the pump inlet. The minimu

gin over NPSHr. Other control options are possible. For example, a simpler but less accurate system would be to use a bypass valve wit

nsure the cold condensate injection does not cause high thermal stresses. If this is possible, the injection point should be moved a safe

ith additional steam to compensate for the loss of extraction steam. The steam drum or the cold reheat system can be used as the sup

eam as needed to maintain deaerator pressure. This option does not have the oxygenated water, thermal shock, and pressure drop di

. The control system will be more complex than that required for the inlet cooling option. For example, in the case of a load reduction

tion, or offer only modest gains in NPSHa. Regardless, each situation encountered will be somewhat different, so keep these alternativ

determine the feasibility of pump modifications such as adding an inducer or making impeller material changes to increase its resistan
udies have shown, however, that for a small decrease in pipe size, the benefit is usually greater than the penalty.
capacity usually gives more benefit than decreasing the suction pipe size. If the storage capacity cannot be increased, try raising the lo
Unfortunately, relocating an existing deaerator is unlikely to be practical.
ansient residence time. Try rerouting the suction pipe to reduce its length, number of valves, and sharp bends. Replace horizontal pipe
on; therefore, it will also need to undergo a transient evaluation.
derstand the causes of pump transient cavitation, present a simple screening technique for identifying poor designs, and describe wh

can experience a water hammer when the cavity collapses. The accumulated damage from these short-term transient events can even

n (the vertical distance between the minimum liquid level of the source and the pump impeller’s centerline); and H FS is the head loss du

sometimes use a 1% or 0% criterion and occasionally, the pump’s NPSHr curve includes a manufacturer’s margin. If the basis for your

n their experience. For example, when sizing a FW pump, a margin of 1.8 might be used for the design point, and 1.5 at runout.

service when checking for adequate NPSHa.

am generator (HRSG), where the deaerator steam comes from the low-pressure steam drum, not the steam turbine. Some units use pe

provide the submergence needed for sufficient NPSHa.

pressure of the liquid. This is known as “saturated conditions.” Vapor pressure is a function of FW temperature. The FW temperature a
in the suction pipe by the pump’s mass flowrate. The lag is called the “residence time,” and is illustrated in Figure 2.
on of the black and green curves at the end of the residence time creates a design point that can be used to solve for the minimum acc

Suction Piping and Deaerator Storage Capacity to Protect Feed Pumps.” In it, Thurston derived a simple expression for evaluating a FW
gn. The equation is:

aerator at the start of the transient (P 1); and h2 is the enthalpy of saturated water based on the pressure in the deaerator at the end o

to the calculation results. Thurston recommended using the outlet enthalpy of the lowest-temperature FW heater.

ations required with the spreadsheet.

quid enthalpy decay in the deaerator follows an exponential function.

e pressure at the suction will suddenly drop and the hot FW could flash to steam. This differs from a NPSH transient, as the pressure ch

gh the pipe. Avoid routing the pipe this way.

he pump inlet. The minimum required flow (Q B, lb/min) and the new pump inlet temperature (T FW, F) after mixing will be:

e to use a bypass valve with a full open/close actuator that responds to the same turbine signals that control the extraction steam flow

int should be moved a safe distance away from the pump and a static mixer installed in the suction pipe to insure complete thermal m

em can be used as the supplemental steam source.

hock, and pressure drop disadvantages of the pump inlet cooling option.

e case of a load reduction, the deaerator pressure must eventually be allowed to drop to the level associated with the new load. Also,

t, so keep these alternatives in mind:

nges to increase its resistance to cavitation. Consider reducing the pump speed to lower NPSH requirements.

ncreased, try raising the low-water level.

ds. Replace horizontal pipe runs with 45-degree downward-sloping runs, where possible.
 r designs, and describe what corrective measures to take.

m transient events can eventually cause a catastrophic pump failure.

and H FS is the head loss due to friction in the suction piping at the maximum flowrate. Note that head and pressure terms are often bo

argin. If the basis for your NPSHr curve is not clear, the manufacturer should be asked to clarify what it represents.

and 1.5 at runout.

turbine. Some units use pegging steam extracted from the intermediate-pressure steam drum as a backup steam supply for use when
ure. The FW temperature and vapor pressure in the deaerator and at the pump suction are the same.
solve for the minimum acceptable deaerator storage capacity.

ession for evaluating a FW pump’s susceptibility to NPSH transients.

he deaerator at the end of the residence time (P 2). To calculate P2, the following equation is used:

ansient, as the pressure change is initiated by the pump and is, therefore, known as a “hot start” transient event.
mixing will be:

the extraction steam flow to the FW heaters. The bypass would be a low-temperature and -pressure system, which allows the use of c

nsure complete thermal mixing. The mixer must not have a high head loss, as frictional losses will reduce the NPSHa.

d with the new load. Also, the supplemental steam source must also be in an operating state whenever the FW system is operating.
ressure terms are often both used when discussing NPSH. Use the liquid specific volume (V) in units of ft 3/lb, to convert head in feet to

team supply for use when turbine extraction steam pressure is low. Because the HRSG is a more stable and reliable source of deaeratio
m, which allows the use of carbon steel standard wall pipe components.

FW system is operating.
, to convert head in feet to pressure in psi:

eliable source of deaeration steam than the steam turbine, CC FW pumps are generally less likely to experience NPSH transients, as lo
nce NPSH transients, as long as the HRSG is correctly operated.