Chapter One

Theoretical Debates

Harm in the Context of Obscenity

and Indecency Law in Canada

<PQ[ JWWS \ZIKM[ \PM [WKQWTMOIT PQ[\WZa WN  \PM KZQUQVITQbI\QWV WN  JW\P

XWZVWOZIXPa IVL ¹JI_La PW][M[º QV +IVILI 7]Z IQU Q[ \W XZW^QLM
IV PQ[\WZQKIT I_IZMVM[[ WN  W]Z XZM[MV\ KQZK]U[\IVKM _Q\P ZM[XMK\ \W \PM
+IVILQIVTI_WN WJ[KMVQ\aIVLQVLMKMVKaIVL\W[PW_\PI\KWV\MUXWZIZa
VWZU[XZWL]KMLQVTI_IZW]VLWJ[KMVMIVLQVLMKMV\[M`]ITXZIK\QKM[IVL
KWUUWLQ\QM[IZM^MZaU]KP[PIXMLJa\PMXI[\,M[XQ\M\PMQUXTMUMV\I\QWV
WN \PM+PIZ\MZWN :QOP\[IVL.ZMMLWU[QV! \PMZI\QWVITQ\a]VLMZXQVVQVO
WJ[KMVQ\a KZQUQVITQbML [M`]ITTa M`XTQKQ\ M`XZM[[QWV IVL QVLMKMVKa
KZQUQVITQbML [M`]ITTa M`XTQKQ\ KWVL]K\ TI_[ PI[ [PQN\ML WVTa UIZOQVITTa
[QVKM+WVNMLMZI\QWVQV 1VLMMLQ\UIaJMIZO]ML\PI\\PM¹KITK]T][º
WZXZWKM[[NWZLM\MZUQVQVO_PM\PMZ[WUM\PQVOQ[WJ[KMVMWZQVLMKMV\PI[
VW\KPIVOMLI\ITT1V[\MIL_PI\PI[KPIVOMLQ[_PI\Q[XMZKMQ^ML\WKI][M
PIZU0IZUQ[TQJMZITQ[U¼[R][\QÅKI\QWVNWZ][QVO\PMXW_MZWN \PM[\I\M\W
KZQUQVITQbM
 7]ZMUXQZQKITNWK][Q[WVPW_\PM[\I\M_WZS[W]\\PM\MV[QWVJM\_MMV
TQJMZ\aI[[MTNOW^MZVUMV\IVLKWMZKQWVI[VWVTQJMZITM`MZKQ[MWN XW_MZ
QVIVL\PZW]OP\PMKW]Z\[¼R][\QÅKI\QWV[NWZQV\MZNMZQVOQV\PM[M`]ITTQ^M[
WN  Q\[ KQ\QbMV[ \PZW]OP KMV[WZ[PQX IVL KZQUQVIT [IVK\QWV +WV\MUXWZIZa
R]ZQ[XZ]LMVKMWN WJ[KMVQ\aIVLQVLMKMVKaQ[_WZSQVOW]\\MV[QWV[QVPMZMV\
\W TQJMZITQ[U# \PM \MV[QWV[ JM\_MMV [M`]IT NZMMLWU I[ I NWZU WN  [MTN
OW^MZVUMV\ UIZSM\ NZMMLWU QVKT]LQVO \PM NZMMLWU \W UIV]NIK\]ZM
LQ[\ZQJ]\MIVLXZWÅ\NZWU\PMKWV[]UX\QWVWN KWUUWLQ\QbML[M`]ITTaM`XTQKQ\
UI\MZQIT[IVL[MZ^QKM[IVL[\I\M[IVK\QWV<PM[M\MV[QWV[IT[W[WUM\QUM[
[]XXWZ\R][\QÅKI\QWV[NWZKMV[WZ[PQXIVLKZQUQVIT[IVK\QWV_PMV[M`]IT[MTN
OW^MZVUMV\Q[XZM[]UML\WPI^MIVMOI\Q^MQUXIK\WV_WUMVQVI[WKQM\a
KPIZIK\MZQbMLJa\PMKWV[\Q\]\QWVITKWUUQ\UMV\\WMY]ITQ\aI[O]IZIV\MMLJa
[MK\QWVWN \PM+PIZ\MZ?M\ZIKM\PMTMOITI]\PWZQ\QM[\MKPVQY]M[IVLTQVM[
WN [\I\MNWZKM\PI\IZMLMXTWaML_PMZMKWUXM\QVOLQ[KW]Z[M[WN TQJMZ\aIVL
KWMZKQWVJW\PKWV\M[\IVLLMNMVLOW^MZVUMV\IT[\ZI\MOQM[:W[MIVL>IT^MZLM

8
 Theoretical Debates 9

!! "?MTWKI\MW]ZIVITa[Q[QVW\PMZKZQ\QKQ[U[WN TQJMZITQ[UWZ_PI\

PI[KWUM\WJMSVW_VI[¹VMWTQJMZITQ[Uº_Q\P\PMOWITWN ]VLMZ[\IVLQVO
PW_WJ[KMVQ\aIVLQVLMKMVKaR]ZQ[XZ]LMVKMKZMI\M[[M`]IT[]JRMK\[\PZW]OP
ZMTI\QWV[ WN  XW_MZ IVL []JR]OI\QWV 3MMX QV UQVL NZWU \PM W]\[M\ \PI\
KZQUQVIT WJ[KMVQ\aQVLMKMVKa TI_ Q[ WVTa WVM [W]ZKM WN  []JR]OI\QWV \PI\
QVÆ]MVKM[ [M`]IT []JRMK\Q^Q\a IVL \PI\ \PM [\I\M IT[W QUXTMUMV\[ W\PMZ
\MKPVQY]M[WN KWV[\ZIQV\.W]KI]T\!!"
 *MOQVVQVO ZW]OPTa QV TI\M ! [ \PM XWZVWOZIXPa QVL][\Za PI[
ÆW]ZQ[PML ]VLMZ \PM [WKITTML ¹NZMM UIZSM\º KWVLQ\QWV[ WN  VMWTQJMZITQ[U
_PQKPKPIZIK\MZQbM[?M[\MZVTQJMZITLMUWKZIKQM[)VOMTI0IZZQ[[]UUIZQbM[
VMWTQJMZITQ[UI[NWTTW_["

6MWTQJMZITQ[U MV\IQT[ I KWUUQ\UMV\ \W \PM LQ[UIV\TQVO WN  \PM

MKWVWUQK IZZIVOMUMV\[ [WUM\QUM[ KITTML ¹.WZLQ[Uº IVL \PMQZ
ZMXTIKMUMV\_Q\PIVMKWVWUaLZQ^MVJa[]J[\IV\QITTaLMZMO]TI\ML
UIZSM\[\PMU[MT^M[LZQ^MVJa\PMQV\MZM[\[WN KWZXWZI\MIVLÅVIVKM
KIXQ\ITIVMKWVWUaQV_PQKPKIXQ\IT¼[]XXMZPIVLW^MZTIJW]ZPI[
TML\WLZIUI\QKITTaQVKZMI[QVOQVMY]ITQ\QM[WN QVKWUMIVL_MIT\P
6MWTQJMZITQ[U IT[W MV\IQT[ \PM LQ[UIV\TQVO WN  [\I\M QV[\Q\]\QWV[
UMIV\\WK][PQWVKQ\QbMV[IOIQV[\MKWVWUQKZQ[SIVLIVIXXZWIKP
\W OW^MZVIVKM \PI\ NI^WZ[ ¹XZQ^I\QbI\QWVº ¹LMZMO]TI\QWVº IVL
W\PMZ XWTQKQM[ \PI\ \ZIV[NMZ XWTQ\QKIT XW_MZ NZWU OW^MZVUMV\[ \W
UIZSM\[ .QVITTa VMWTQJMZITQ[U MV\IQT[ I [MZQM[ WN  [WKQIT XZWRMK\[
WN\MVLM[KZQJMLI[¹K]T\]ZM_IZ[º\PI\ILLZM[[\PMIV`QM\QM[WN \PM
QVKZMI[QVOTaMKWVWUQKITTaXZMKIZQW][IVLXWTQ\QKITTaLQ[MUXW_MZML
UQLLTMIVL_WZSQVOKTI[[M[JaKWV[\Z]K\QVOI[MV\QUMV\ITQbML^Q[QWV
WN \PMQVVWKMV\aM\^QK\QUQbML\I`XIaQVO[]J]ZJIVOWWLKQ\QbMVIVL
\PMVI\\IKSQVO\PI\KQ\QbMV¼[X]ZXWZ\MLMVMUQM[¸ZMTQIJTaY]MMZ[
TQJMZIT[NMUQVQ[\[IVLJTIKS[#MXQ[WLQKITTa)[QIV[IVLQUUQOZIV\[#
IVLUW[\ZMKMV\TaXMWXTMQV\PM=VQ\ML;\I\M[IVLIJZWIL_PW
¹PI\M)UMZQKIº6MWTQJMZITQ[U\PMVQ[IKWUXTM`[M\WN XZWRMK\[\PI\
WXMZI\M[QU]T\IVMW][TaWVMKWVWUQKXWTQ\QKITIVLK]T\]ZITNZWV\[
6W\[]ZXZQ[QVOTaVMWTQJMZITQ[UPI[IT[WMV\IQTML[QOVQÅKIV\KPIVOM[
QVTMOIT\PW]OP\IVLXZIK\QKM0IZZQ["·

 8IZ\WN W]ZIQUQV\PQ[JWWSQ[IT[W\W]VLMZ[\IVLWJ[KMVQ\aIVLQVLMKMVKa
TI_I[IQUXWZ\IV\NMI\]ZMWN [M`]ITKQ\QbMV[PQXIVLIZMÆMK\QWVWN [M`]IT
^IT]M[QVPMZMV\\W6WZ\P)UMZQKIVTQJMZITQ[U
 4QJMZITQ[UPI[KZMI\ML\PMÅK\QWVWN ¹NZMMºUIZSM\[JaKPWW[QVO_PMV
IVL_PMZM\WNWK][OW^MZVUMV\QV\MZ^MV\QWV6MWTQJMZITQ[UQ[[IQL\WJMU]KP
UWZM¹TIQ[[MbNIQZMº\PIVMIZTa\WUQL\_MV\QM\PKMV\]ZaNWZU[WN TQJMZITQ[U
_PQKP NWK][ML WV [WKQIT _MTNIZM [XMVLQVO ?PMV \PQ[ NWZU WN  [XMVLQVO
LMKTQVMLIKWVKWUQ\IV\QVKZMI[MQVMKWVWUQKQVMY]ITQ\QM[XIZ\QK]TIZTaNWZ
10 Sex and the Supreme Court

VWV_PQ\M[IVL_WUMVQV\PMNWZUMZ;W^QM\=VQWVIVL-I[\MZVJTWK[\I\M[
XIZ\QK]TIZTa\PM*ITSIV[N]MTTML\PMZIXQLM`XIV[QWVWN \PM[M`\ZILMQVL][\Za
5ITIZMS<PQ[\QUMXMZQWL_Q\VM[[ML\PMLQ[UIV\TQVOWN \PM_MTNIZM
[\I\MQV+IVILI\PM=;IVL*ZQ\IQVITWVO_Q\P\PM]X_IZLLQ[\ZQJ]\QWV
WN  [WKQIT IVL MKWVWUQK ZM[W]ZKM[ \W \PM _MIT\Pa <PM _QLM[XZMIL ][M WN 
KWUX]\MZ[QV\PMPWUMIVL\PMQUXTMUMV\I\QWVWN QVNZI[\Z]K\]ZM\WXZW^QLM
MIKPIVLM^MZaPW][MPWTL_Q\PKPMIXIVLMI[aIKKM[[\W\PM1V\MZVM\N]Z\PMZ
M`XIVLML_PI\Q[VW_TIZOMTaIKaJMZXWZVUIZSM\IVL[M`\ZILMQVL][\Za
)KKWZLQVO\W5IKTMIV[8WTIS "¹\PM6WZ\P)UMZQKIVKaJMZXWZV
QVL][\ZaJZQVO[QVIJW]\JQTTQWVLWTTIZ[XMZaMIZº7VTQVMXWZVWOZIXPaQ[
MI[QTaIKKM[[QJTMIVL^QZ\]ITTa]VZMO]TI\ML1V+IVILIVWKWZXWZI\QWVPI[
M^MZJMMVKWV^QK\MLWZXMZPIX[M^MVKPIZOML_Q\PXW[[M[[QVOWZLQ[\ZQJ]\QVO
¹WJ[KMVQ\aº;]KKM[[Q^M+IVILQIVOW^MZVUMV\[PI^M^QM_ML\PQ[XWZVWOZIXPa
UIZSM\I[[WUM\PQVO\PI\[PW]TLVW\JM[]JRMK\\W[\I\MQV\MZ^MV\QWV_MTTQV
SMMXQVO_Q\PVMWTQJMZITQ[U¼[\ZIV[NMZWN XW_MZNZWUOW^MZVUMV\[\WUIZSM\[
<P][\PM[\I\MKWV[\Q\]\M[\PMKWUUWLQÅML[M`\ZILMI[W]\[QLMWN XWTQ\QK[
IVL \PMZMNWZM WXMZI\QVO _Q\PQV \PI\ ¹XZQ^I\Mº [XIKM \PI\ LWM[ VW\ JMTWVO
\WOW^MZVUMV\7VTa_PMVXZQ^I\MQVLQ^QL]IT[KWUXTIQV\W\PMI]\PWZQ\QM[
IZMXZW[MK]\QWV[TQSMTa\WJMTI]VKPMLI[_M[I_QV\PMKI[MWN 5WV\ZMIT
¹bWUJQMXWZVºUISMZ:uUa+W]\]ZM)[IZM[]T\\PM[MXZW[MK]\QWV[IZMIL
PWKIVLPQOPTaQVLQ^QL]ITQbML
 4QJMZITQ[UPI[LM^MTWXMLQ\[TMOIT\MKPVWTWOQM[NWZQV\MZ^MVQVOQV\W\PM
\MZZIQVWN ¹\PM[WKQITºLMÅVMLI[\PM¹X]JTQKº[XPMZM_PMV]VZ]Ta[]JRMK\[
NIQT\W[MTNOW^MZVQVIUIVVMZKWV[Q[\MV\_Q\PQ\[^Q[QWVWN I_MTTWZLMZML
XZWXMZTa N]VK\QWVQVO [WKQM\a _PI\ _M \MZU I N]VK\QWVITQ[\ IKKW]V\ *]\
\PQ[QV\MZ^MV\QWVQ[UIQVTaQN VW\MV\QZMTaLQZMK\MLI\\PM[M`]ITKWVL]K\WN 
QVLQ^QL]IT[<W\PMM`\MV\\PI\OW^MZVUMV\[PI^MILWX\MLITIZOMTaTIQ[[MbNIQZM
IXXZWIKP\W\PMZMO]TI\QWVWN \PMXWZVQVL][\ZaIVL_MIZMVW\IZO]QVO\PI\
\PMa[PW]TLWZ[PW]TLVW\\PMVW\QWVWN ¹\PM[WKQITº_Q\PZM[XMK\\W\PM[M`
\ZILMPI[TIZOMTaLQ[IXXMIZML:W[M!!!
 )[ XIZ\WN  IV W^MZITTXWTQ\QKITXZWRMK\W]Z IQU Q[ \W\ISM]X 0IZZQ[¼[
"   KPITTMVOM \W ¹»XWTQ\QKQbM¼ \PI\ Q[ UISM ^Q[QJTM \PM XWTQ\QK[
ITZMILaPQLLMVJ]\ITZMILa_Q\PQV\PM»XZQ^I\M¼[XPMZMº1VWZLMZ\WIKPQM^M
\PQ[XWTQ\QKQbI\QWV_MXZW^QLMILM[KZQX\QWVWN \PMOW^MZVUMV\ITZI\QWVITM[
IVL\MKPVQY]M[NWTTW_QVO\PM;]XZMUM+W]Z\LMKQ[QWVQV:^4IJIaM¸\PM
TIZOMTaQOVWZML+IVILQIVKI[M_PQKPZ]TML\PI\IXWX]TIZ[_QVOMZ[KT]JQV
5WV\ZMIT_I[VW\IVQVLMKMV\JI_LaPW][M]VLMZ\PM+ZQUQVIT+WLM<PM
4IJIaMKI[MQ[XIZ\QK]TIZTaQV\MZM[\QVOJMKI][MQ\ZMLMÅVML\PMR]LQKQIT\M[\NWZ
M[\IJTQ[PQVOQVLMKMVKaIVLWJ[KMVQ\aQV+IVILI1V\PMXZWKM[[Q\ZM^MITML
\PMTWVO[\IVLQVOZI\QWVITMNWZKZQUQVITQV\MZ^MV\QWVQV\PMKWV\M`\WN \PM
TI_[WN [M`]ITM`XZM[[QWVIVLKWVL]K\
 ?M[PW_PW_MIZTaWJ[KMVQ\aKI[M[MVNWZKMLZMTQOQW][IVLKTI[[JI[ML
 Theoretical Debates 11

UWZITQ\a_PQTMTI\MZKI[M[NWK][MLWVKWUU]VQ\a[\IVLIZL[WN \WTMZIVKMIVL
\PMN]Z\PMZIVKMWN VWZUI\Q^MXWTQ\QKITWJRMK\Q^M[<PM[MMIZTQMZKI[M[_MZM
QVZM[XWV[M\W\PM[\I\M¼[I\\MUX\[I\ZMXZM[[QVO[M`]ITTaM`XTQKQ\UI\MZQIT[
\PI\ [I\QZQbML IVL [M`]ITQbML ZMTQOQW][ ÅO]ZM[ WZ UILM IVa ZMNMZMVKM[
\W PWUW[M`]ITQ\a I[ _MTT I[ UI\MZQIT[ \PI\ XZW^QLML ML]KI\QWV IJW]\
ZMXZWL]K\QWVIVLJQZ\PKWV\ZWT
 4I\MZ QV \PM \_MV\QM\P KMV\]Za IVL \PZW]OPW]\ \PM XW[\+PIZ\MZ MZI
TQJMZIT[IVLNMUQVQ[\[_MZMKZQ\QKITWN \PMR][\QÅKI\QWV[NWZKMV[WZ[PQXILWX\ML
JaR]LOM[[MMQVO\PMUI[NWZU[WN UWZITZMO]TI\QWV<PMQZKZQ\QKQ[U[_MZM
TM^MTTMLUIQVTaWVTQJMZITIVL^IZQW][NMUQVQ[\OZW]VL[QVZMIK\QWV\W\PM
KWV[MZ^I\Q^M ZMTQOQW][ IVL KTI[[JI[ML R][\QÅKI\QWV[ NWZ KMV[WZ[PQX 1V
ZM[XWV[MKWV[MZ^I\Q^M[ZMIK\MLVMOI\Q^MTa\W\PMTQJMZITIVLNMUQVQ[\KZQ\QKQ[U[
WV\PMOZW]VL[\PI\\PMQZ[_I[\WWTQJMZITWZ\WWNMUQVQ[\IVIXXZWIKPNWZ
LMITQVO_Q\P[M`]ITTaM`XTQKQ\UI\MZQIT[TIZOMTaJMKI][M[]KPUI\MZQIT[KW]TL
KWZZ]X\\PMUWZIT[WN \PM]VZ]TaKWV[]UMZ2WPV[WV!!6W__Q\P\PM
IXXIZMV\Ta VM]\ZIT TIVO]IOM WN  ¹PIZUº IVL ¹ZQ[S WN  PIZUº \PM +W]Z\
KWV\QV]M[\W][MXWTQ\QKIT^IT]M[\WR][\QNaKMV[WZ[PQXWN WJ[KMVQ\aIVL\PM
KZQUQVITQbI\QWVWN QVLMKMVKaQVIUIVVMZ\PI\UIa[I\Q[NaITTQ\[KZQ\QK[IKZW[[
\PMXWTQ\QKIT[XMK\Z]U<PM;]XZMUM+W]Z\LMKQ[QWVQV:^4IJIaMKZMI\ML
I[MMUQVOTa¹WJRMK\Q^Mº\M[\NWZKZQUQVITQbQVOWJ[KMVQ\aIVLQVLMKMVKaJa
ZMKWVÅO]ZQVO\PMPIZU[JI[MLWJ[KMVQ\a\M[\M[\IJTQ[PMLQV:^*]\TMZC!!E
<PMLMKQ[QWVPI[JMMVXW[Q\Q^MTaZMKMQ^MLIVL[MMVJa[WUMKWUUMV\I\WZ[I[
I^QK\WZaNWZTQJMZITQ[UIVLNMUQVQ[UQVJW\P+IVILIIVL\PM=VQ\ML;\I\M[
*WaKM #+ZIQO !

Law and the Censorship of Obscenity

1V \PM VQVM\MMV\P KMV\]Za \PM >QK\WZQIV[ I[[WKQI\ML VWVUWVWOIUW][
IVL VWVPM\MZW[M`]IT [M`]ITQ\a _Q\P ¹^QKMº TMILQVO \W \PM KWZZ]X\QWV WN 
UWZIT[<PM>QK\WZQIV[ZMO]TI\ML\PM[MVWVVWZUI\Q^M[M`]ITQ\QM[\PZW]OP
IZMTQOQW][IVLKTI[[NWK][MLIXXTQKI\QWVWN KZQUQVITTI_WV\PMOZW]VL[
\PI\ ]VKWV^MV\QWVIT [M`]ITQ\a KI][ML UWZIT PIZU \W \PW[M [][KMX\QJTM \W
LMXZI^Q\aIVLKWZZ]X\QWV_PQKPUMIV\M[XMKQITTa\PW[MI\\PM¹JW\\WUºWN 
\PM[WKQITPQMZIZKPa<PM[M¹LMXZI^MLIVLKWZZ]X\MLºOZW]X[_MZMQV\]ZV
]VLMZ[\WWL\WPIZU[WKQM\aI[I_PWTM<PQ[XMZKMQ^MLKWZZ]X\QWVWN UWZIT[
]VLMZUQVML\PMXZWXMZN]VK\QWVQVOWN [WKQM\aL]ZQVO\PM>QK\WZQIVMZIIVL
KW]Z\[[W]OP\\W[\MMZ[WKQM\aQV\PMLQZMK\QWVWN IKPQM^QVOUWZITMY]QTQJZQ]U
WZ PWUMW[\I\QK XMZNMK\QWV <PQ[ N]VK\QWVITQ[\ XZWRMK\ PI[ ZMUIQVML \W \PM
XZM[MV\LIa2WPV[WV!!
 +W]Z\[ KWV\QV]M \W XZM[]UM \PI\ [M`]ITTa M`XTQKQ\ QUIOMZa IVL
]VKWV^MV\QWVITIVLKWUUMZKQIT[M`XZIK\QKM[KI][MPIZU\W\PMNIJZQKWN 
[WKQM\a;\I\MQV\MZ^MV\QWV\PZW]OPKZQUQVITQbI\QWV_PQKPXTIKM[TQUQ\I\QWV[
WV NZMMLWU WN  M`XZM[[QWV QV \PM KTI[[QK R][\QÅKI\QWV NWZ WJ[KMVQ\a IVL
12 Sex and the Supreme Court

QVLMKMVKaTI_[Q[NWZ\PMX]ZXW[MWN XZM^MV\QVO\PQ[OMVMZITUWZITPIZU
<PQ[ Q[ MY]ITTa I [\ZI\MOa NWZ VWZUITQbQVO [M`]IT XZIK\QKM[ IVL I\\Q\]LM[
8ZW\MK\QVO\PMUWZITNIJZQKWN [WKQM\aQ[\PMXZQVKQXITR][\QÅKI\QWVNWZJW\P
WJ[KMVQ\aIVLQVLMKMVKaTI_[WVM\PI\KIVJM\ZIKMLJIKS\WMIZTaWJ[KMVQ\a
KI[M[<PMX]ZXWZ\MLIQUWN WJ[KMVQ\aIVLQVLMKMVKaTI_Q[\WXZW\MK\][
NZWU \PM VMOI\Q^M I\\Q\]LM[ KZMI\ML Ja [M`]ITTa M`XTQKQ\ X]JTQKI\QWV[ IVL
]VKWV^MV\QWVITIVLKWUUMZKQIT[M`XZIK\QKM[I[_MTTNZWUI[\PMINNZWV\\W
KMZ\IQVSQVL[WN KWV[\Q\]\QWVITTaMV[PZQVMLXWTQ\QKIT^IT]M[[]KPI[TQJMZ\aIVL
MY]ITQ\a<PMZMO]TI\QWVWN \PM[M`\ZILM\PZW]OPQVLMKMVKaTI_Q[TIZOMTa
JI[MLWV\PMVW\QWV\PI\X]JTQK[M`Q[IX]JTQKV]Q[IVKMJMKI][MQ\M`XW[M[
VWVKWV[MV\QVOXWX]TI\QWV[\W[M`]ITTaM`XTQKQ\IK\Q^Q\QM[¸\PI\Q\LQ[Z]X\[
\PMXZM^IQTQVO[WKQITWZLMZ2WKPMT[WV!I!J
 7]ZIVITa[Q[LMUWV[\ZI\M[\PI\\PM[WKQITLMUIVL[NWZMY]ITQ\aIVLKQ^QT
ZQOP\[_Q\PZM[XMK\\W[M`]ITM`XZM[[QWVWN \PM! [IVL!![WN \PM^IZQW][
NMUQVQ[\[IVLOIaTM[JQIVJQ[M`]ITIVL\ZIV[OMVLMZML/4*<UW^MUMV\[
PI^M JMMV \ZIV[TI\ML QV\W WJ[KMVQ\a IVL QVLMKMVKa R]ZQ[XZ]LMVKM Ja \PM
;]XZMUM+W]Z\LMKQ[QWVQV:^4IJIaMQVIUIVVMZ\PI\ZMJZIVL[TQJMZITQ[U
\WUISMQ\JW\PNMUQVQ[\IVLY]MMZNZQMVLTa<PQ[NItILMWN NZQMVLTQVM[[UI[S[
IVQV[QXQL^IZQIV\WN NZMMLWUJMKI][MQ\MUXW_MZ[\PMVM_¹ZQ[SWN PIZUº
\M[\NWZWJ[KMVQ\aIVLQVLMKMVKa)[>IT^MZLMIZO]M[QVZMTI\QWV\WMIZTQMZ
QVLMKMVKaKI[M[\PMTMOITKI\MOWZQM[WN ¹PIZUºIVL¹ZQ[SWN PIZUº¹CIK\EI[
^MZQ\IJTMRWSMZKIZL[\PI\KIV[MZ^MKWUXTM\MTaLQNNMZMV\X]ZXW[M[LMXMVLQVO
WV\PMKWV\M`\º!!!" <PMPIZU\M[\IZ\QK]TI\MLQV4IJIaMQ[XZM[MV\ML
Ja\PM+W]Z\I[IUWZM[WXPQ[\QKI\ML\M[\NWZPIZUZWW\MLQVWJRMK\Q^Q\aIVL
MUXQZQKQ[U0W_M^MZ_M[PW_\PZW]OPIVM`IUQVI\QWVWN QVLMKMVKaKI[M[
NWTTW_QVO\PM4IJIaMLMKQ[QWV\PI\PIZUIVLZQ[SWN PIZUIZMÆ]QLKI\MOWZQM[
\PI\KIZZa_Q\P\PMUVWKWV[Q[\MV\WZXZIOUI\QKUMIVQVO<PM[MKI\MOWZQM[
IZMMUX\aKWV\IQVMZ[ZMILa\WJMÅTTML)KKWZLQVO\W>IT^MZLM!!!" "

<PM ZMTQOQW][ ZQOP\ KIV ZMIL \PMQZ UWZIT KWVKMZV[ WV\W ¹ZQ[S WN 
PIZUº [QVKM \PMa JMTQM^M XWZVWOZIXPa Q[ PIZUN]T \W \PM [W]T#
UWLMZVQbQVOIK\]IZQIT\aXM[KIVJZMI\PMI[QOPWN ZMTQMN ]XWVPMIZQVO
\PI\ZQ[SQ[JMQVOIKSVW_TMLOML#IVLNMUQVQ[\[KIVIT[WWV\PMQZXIZ\
NMMTXTMI[ML\PI\_PI\\PMa\PQVSWN I[\PMPIZU[WN XWZVWOZIXPa
IZMÅVITTaZMKWOVQbML

 <PM[M KI\MOWZQM[ IZM ZMXZM[MV\ML I[ WJRMK\Q^M J]\ ITTW_ NWZ \PM
LMXTWaUMV\ WN  XWTQ\QKIT UWZIT ^IT]M R]LOUMV\[ _PQKP QV \]ZV KZMI\M
KI\MOWZQM[WN [M`]ITLIVOMZIVL[M`]ITPMIT\P7]ZIVITa[Q[WN 4IJIaMIT[W
LMUWV[\ZI\M[ \PI\ \PM +W]Z\¼[ QUXW[Q\QWV WN  XIZ\QK]TIZ ^IT]M R]LOUMV\[
IJW]\LIVOMZW][[M`]ITQ\a][QVOPIZUIVLZQ[SWN PIZUQV[KZQJMI^Q[QWV
WN IKWV[MV[]ITUWZITWZLMZ\WJMXZW\MK\MLJa\PM_WZSWN KW]Z\[<PQ[
^Q[QWVQ[IT_Ia[JMQVO¹XZW\MK\MLºQV^IZQIJTM_Ia[<PMKI\MOWZQM[WN [M`]IT
 Theoretical Debates 13

LIVOMZIZMIT_Ia[QVIXZWKM[[WN ZMKWV[\Z]K\QWVIVLWN\MVKWUU]VQKI\M
VWZUI\Q^MQLMI[IJW]\[M`]IT[MTNZMO]TI\QWV<PMaIT[WKIVKIZ^MW]\\PI\
[XIKMLMMUMLXZQ^I\MXZQ^I\MXZWXMZ\a\PMUIZSM\M\KQV\W_PQKP\PM[\I\M
KIVVW\^MV\]ZM_PMVKW]Z\[LMKQLMR]ZQ[LQK\QWVITQ[[]M[<P][LM\MZUQVI\QWV[
WN _PI\Q[[M`]ITTaLIVOMZW][^MZ[][[M`]ITTaPMIT\Pa_PQKP IZMXWTQ\QKIT
PI^MJMKWUMLMXMVLMV\]XWV\PMXZMLQTMK\QWV[WN IXIZ\QK]TIZR]LOMQVI
XIZ\QK]TIZKW]Z\QVIXIZ\QK]TIZKWV\M`\IVLN]VK\QWVTQSM¹^MZQ\IJTMRWSMZ
KIZL[ºR][\I[>IT^MZLMXZMLQK\ML<PI\\PM[MR]LOUMV\[IZMZMXZM[MV\MLI[
¹WJRMK\Q^Mº[QUXTaZM^MIT[\PM+W]Z\¼[NI]`MUXQZQKQ[U¸\PMPIZU\M[\[\QTT
LMXMVL[WV\PMR]LOM¼[^QM_[ZMOIZLTM[[WN Q\[ZWW\[QVKWV[\Q\]\QWVIT^IT]M[
TQSMTQJMZ\aWZMY]ITQ\a
 )Va LM^QI\QWV NZWU \PM VWZU QUXW[ML Ja \PM +W]Z\ ZMY]QZM[ XMVIT
QV\MZ^MV\QWVI[IUWLMWN KWZZMK\QWV\WXZM[MZ^MQ\[W_V^Q[QWVWN IXZWXMZTa
N]VK\QWVQVO[WKQM\a<PQ[LM^QI\QWVQ[LMTQVMI\MLJa\PM4IJIaM+W]Z\I[I\aXM
WN ¹PIZUº\WJMI^WQLML1V\PMKWV\M`\WN \PMQVLMKMVKaIVLWJ[KMVQ\a
LMJI\M\PMKWVKMX\WN ¹PIZUºPI[JMMVKMV\ZIT\W\PMKZQUQVITQbI\QWVWN 
IK\[WZ[XMMKPWN I[M`]ITVI\]ZM

Liberalism and Harm

<PM[\IZ\QVOXWQV\NWZ]VLMZ[\IVLQVOPW_PIZUQ[]VLMZ[\WWLJa\PMKW]Z\[
QV\PMKWV\M`\WN WJ[KMVQ\aIVLQVLMKMVKaZM[\[WV\PMTQJMZITXZQVKQXTM\PI\
IOW^MZVUMV\W]OP\VW\QV\Z]LMQV\PMTQ^M[WN \PMKQ\QbMV]VTM[[Q\IK\[\W
XZM^MV\PIZU\WIVQVLQ^QL]ITWZ[WKQM\a?PQTMI[MMUQVOTa[QUXTMKZMI\QWV
LMÅVQVO_PI\Q[IVLQ[VW\PIZUN]TQ[PQOPTaKWV\QVOMV\]XWV\PMKWV\M`\
IVLW\PMZ^IZQIJTM[1\Q[IVM[\IJTQ[PMLTQJMZITXPQTW[WXPQKITXZQVKQXTM\PI\
UI\MZQIT[\PI\KI][MWNNMVKMIVLM^MVM`\ZMUMWNNMVKM\WWVM¼[UWZITWZXWTQ\QKIT
^IT]M[W]OP\VW\JMKMV[WZMLJa\PM[\I\M.MQVJMZO! 1VW\PMZ_WZL[
JMQVOWNNMVLMLJaIUMZMQLMIWZXZIK\QKMMVOIOMLQVJaW\PMZ[QVITQJMZIT
LMUWKZI\QK[WKQM\aQ[WV\PQ[XPQTW[WXPQKITZMILQVOWN PIZUVWR][\QÅKI\QWV
NWZ[\I\MKWMZKQWVQV\W\PMTQ^M[WN Q\[KQ\QbMV[<PMZMNWZMNWZ[WUMTQJMZIT[
JMQVOWNNMVLMLWZPI^QVOWVM¼[UWZIT[KPITTMVOMLQ[VW\IR][\QÅKI\QWVNWZ
KMV[WZ[PQXJMKI][MWNNMVKMNITT[[PWZ\WN I\PZM[PWTLWN PIZUZMY]QZML\W
\ZQOOMZ\PMKWMZKQ^MXW_MZWN \PM[\I\M<PW[M_PWIZO]MNWZ\PQ[\PZM[PWTL
WN\MVXWQV\\W\IVOQJTMPIZU[[]KPI[XPa[QKITPIZU[\WXIZ\QKQXIV\[I[\PM
TQ\U][\M[\NWZ[\I\MQV\MZ^MV\QWV7N KW]Z[M\PQ[Q[VW\IÅ`ML]VLMZ[\IVLQVO
WN  PIZU J]\ Q\ Q[ VWVM\PMTM[[ ][ML ZMO]TIZTa \W R][\QNa [\I\M QV\MZ^MV\QWV
<PW[M_PWIZO]M\PI\M^QTQLMI[_PQKPUIaWZUIaVW\TMIL\WM^QTLMML[
W]OP\\WJMR][\QÅKI\QWVNWZKZQUQVIT[IVK\QWVIZMÅZUTaQV\PMWNNMVKMKI\MOWZa
WN PIZU1VJW\P+IVILQIVIVL=;TI_\PMKZQUQVITQbI\QWVWN WJ[KMVQ\aQ[
IVWUITW][JMKI][MKWV[\Q\]\QWVITXZW\MK\QWVM`\MVL[\WITT[WZ\[WN [XMMKP
\PI\Q[]VXWX]TIZWNNMV[Q^MIVLM^MVPIZUN]T.WZM`IUXTM0Q\TMZ¼[5MQV
3IUXN !! IVL 3IZT 5IZ`¼[ ,I[ 3IXQ\IT   -VO \ZIV[  
14 Sex and the Supreme Court

KWV\IQVMLQLMI[\PI\\PZW]OP\PMQVKQ\MUMV\WN IK\QWVKI][MLKWV[QLMZIJTM
PIZU\WUQTTQWV[WN XMWXTM
 )KKWZLQVO\W3WXXMTUIV \PMQLMI\PI\UWZITTaZMX]OVIV\
TQ\MZI\]ZM ZM[]T\[ QV UWZITTa ZMX]OVIV\ Å`ML VWZU[ Q[ VW\ I UI\\MZ \PI\
WJ[KMVQ\a TI_ KIV Å` 3WXXMTUIV IZO]M[ \PI\ M^MV QN  WJ[KMVM UI\MZQIT[
XZWUW\MJILÅ`MLVWZU[¹VW\PQVOIJW]\Q\[MNNMK\[WVQ\[ZMILMZ[VMKM[[IZQTa
NWTTW_[NZWU\PQ[NIK\º "1VW\PMZ_WZL[NWZ3WXXMTUIV\PMNWK][
WV[M`]ITWJRMK\QÅKI\QWVIVL\PMMZW\QKQbI\QWVWN KZ]MT\aI[\PMUWZITPIZUWN 
XWZVWOZIXPaKIVVW\OZW]VL\PMIZO]UMV\[NWZKMV[WZ[PQXÅZUTaQVITQJMZIT
PIZUXZQVKQXTMJMKI][M\PM[MKTIQU[IJW]\XWZVWOZIXPa\MTT][VW\PQVOIJW]\
Q\[IK\]ITMNNMK\[WVZMILMZ[)L^WKI\M[WN \PQ[XW[Q\QWVXWQV\W]\\PI\[WKQIT
[KQMV\QÅK ZM[MIZKP WV \PM KWVVMK\QWV JM\_MMV XWZVWOZIXPa IVL ^QWTMVKM
IOIQV[\_WUMVQ[_MISIVLQVKWVKT][Q^M[WUM\QUM[[PW_QVOTQUQ\MLTWVO
\MZUMNNMK\[QN IVaNWZW\PMZM`IUXTM[[MM+W[[UIV#;]UVMZ
<PQ[[WZ\WN ZM[MIZKPPI[VM^MZJMMVIJTM\W[WZ\W]\\PMQV\MZIK\Q^MMNNMK\[WN 
JZWILMZITZMILaM`Q[\QVO[WKQM\ITVWZU[KWVKMZVQVO_WUMV¼[[M`]ITQ\a8]\
[]KKQVK\Ta[\]LaWN \PMKI][ITMNNMK\WN M`XW[]ZM\WWJ[KMVMUI\MZQIT[PI[
aQMTLMLZM[]T\[\PI\IZMMY]Q^WKITIVLTQJMZITXPQTW[WXPMZ[OMVMZITTaJMTQM^M
\PI\\PMKI][ITKI[MNWZPIZUPI[VW\JMMVUILM:I\PMZ\PIV^QM_QVO\PM
MNNMK\[I[PIZUN]TKMZ\IQVTQJMZIT[KPWTIZ[KWV\MVLI\UW[\\PI\\PMMNNMK\WN 
W]ZM`XW[]ZM\WWJ[KMVMUI\MZQITQ[[WUMSQVLWN LIUIOM\WW]ZKWVKMX\QWV
WN  PW_ I [WKQM\a W]OP\ \W N]VK\QWV 1V \PQ[ ZMOIZL TQJMZIT[ OMVMZITTa IZM
]V[]XXWZ\Q^MWN \PMTMOITQLMI\PI\M`XW[]ZM\W[M`]ITTaM`XTQKQ\UI\MZQIT[
ZM[]T\[QV^MZQÅIJTMPIZU\WW]ZI\\Q\]LM[IJW]\_WUMVIVL\P][]VLMZUQVM
[WKQM\IT^IT]M[.ZWU\PQ[XMZ[XMK\Q^M\W[]OOM[\\PI\\PM[\I\MU][\QV\MZ^MVM
\WKZQUQVITQbMWJ[KMVQ\a\PI\Q[PIZUN]T\WI\\Q\]LM[Q[\WI[[]UM\PI\WJ[KMVQ\a
[PWZ\KQZK]Q\[W]ZIJQTQ\a\WKWVL]K\IZI\QWVITI[[M[[UMV\WN [M`]ITTaM`XTQKQ\
IVLW\PMZUWZITTaWNNMV[Q^MUI\MZQIT[
 <PQ[ZM[Q[\IVKM\WXI\MZVITQ[UQ[M^QLMV\QV\PMMIZTa_WZS[WN KTI[[QKIT
TQJMZITQ[U)KKWZLQVO\WTQJMZITLWK\ZQVM[QVKMI\TMI[\\PM_ZQ\QVO[WN 5QTT
 !\PM[\I\MPI[JMMVR][\QÅMLQVK]Z\IQTQVOQ\[KQ\QbMV[¼TQJMZ\aWVTa\WXZW\MK\
W\PMZ[NZWUPIZU1V7V4QJMZ\a2WPV;\]IZ\5QTTM`XTWZML\PMTMOQ\QUI\M
M`MZKQ[MWN [WKQM\ITXW_MZWV\PMQVLQ^QL]IT5QTT !"XIZI!0Q[IZO]UMV\
_I[\PI\¹\PMWVTaX]ZXW[MNWZ_PQKPXW_MZKIVJMZQOP\N]TTaM`MZKQ[MLW^MZ
IVaUMUJMZWN IKQ^QTQbMLKWUU]VQ\aIOIQV[\PQ[_QTTQ[\WXZM^MV\PIZU
\WW\PMZ[#PQ[W_VOWWLMQ\PMZXPa[QKITWZUWZITQ[VW\I[]NÅKQMV\_IZZIV\º
 !"XIZI!.ZWU\PQ[XMZ[XMK\Q^MKQ\QbMV[QVITQJMZITLMUWKZI\QK[WKQM\a
PI^M\PMQV\ZQV[QKNZMMLWU\WM`XZM[[PI\MN]TWZWJ[KMVMUWZITTaM^QTQLMI[
UIQVTaJMKI][MNZMM[XMMKPXTIa[IVQUXWZ\IV\ZWTMQVLMUWKZI\QK[WKQM\QM[
<PQ[ ¹LMUWKZI\QKº IZO]UMV\ IOIQV[\ KWMZKQWV WN  ]VXWX]TIZ WNNMV[Q^M WZ
PIZUN]TM`XZM[[QWVPWTL[\PI\_Q\PQV\PMZMITUWN X]JTQK[XMMKPNZMMLWUQ[
IJ[WT]\M#NWZTQJMZIT[LMUWKZI\QKOW^MZVIVKMZMY]QZM[NZMMIVLWXMV[XMMKP
 Theoretical Debates 15

I[IUI\\MZWN [MTN OW^MZVIVKM8MWXTMVMMLNZMM[XMMKP¹JMKI][M\PMaPI^M

LMKQLMLQVILWX\QVOUIQV\IQVQVOIVLQV\MZXZM\QVO\PMQZ+WV[\Q\]\QWV\W
OW^MZV\PMU[MT^M[ZI\PMZ\PIV\WJMOW^MZVMLJaW\PMZ[º5MQSTMRWPV!"
@@<PQ[ITQOV[_Q\P\PMTQJMZITKWV\MV\QWV\PI\UWZM[XMMKPZI\PMZ\PIVTM[[
[XMMKPQ[\PMXZM[KZQX\QWV\W[WT^QVO\PMXZWJTMU[QVPMZMV\QVKWV\ZW^MZ[QIT
M`XZM[[QWV.WZQV[\IVKM;\ZW[[MV_ZQ\M[\PI\¹IKMV\ZIT\MVM\WN°NZMM[XMMKP
R]ZQ[XZ]LMVKM"CQ[E\PI\\PMIXXZWXZQI\MIV\QLW\M\W[XMMKP_Q\P_PQKP_M
LQ[IOZMMWZWNNMVL[][Q[UWZM[XMMKPº;\ZW[[MV!!" 
 )N]Z\PMZTQJMZITZI\QWVITMIOIQV[\KMV[WZ[PQXIVLQVLMNMVKMWN NZMMLWU
WN  [XMMKP Q[ KWVVMK\ML \W \PM ZQOP\ WN  KQ\QbMV[ \W I]\WVWUa .ZWU \PQ[
XMZ[XMK\Q^MI]\WVWUaZMY]QZM[XMZ[WVIT[W^MZMQOV\aQVLM\MZUQVQVO_PI\
\W JMTQM^M IVL QV _MQOPQVO KWUXM\QVO ZMI[WV[ NWZ IK\QWV# _PMV \PM [\I\M
QV\MZ^MVM[ \W UISM \PW[M KPWQKM[ Q\ JMPI^M[ QV IV QTTQJMZIT UIVVMZ <PM
I]\WVWUaJI[MLIKKW]V\WN NZMM[XMMKPNWK][M[WV\PMQVLQ^QL]ITQV^WT^ML
QVI[XMMKPM^MV\_PM\PMZQ\JM\PM[XMISMZWZ\PMTQ[\MVMZ)VaIZO]UMV\
QVNI^W]ZWN KMV[WZ[PQX\PI\Q[JI[MLWV\PMQLMI\PI\UWZITTaZMX]OVIV\
QLMI[ KI][M PIZU QVKT]LQVO \PM NWZUI\QWV WN  NIT[M JMTQMN[ IJW]\ _WUMV
IVL PIZUN]T IK\[ I[ I ZM[]T\ WN  \PW[M JMTQMN[ Q[ I NWZU WN  \aZIVVa -^MV
_PMZM I KI][IT TQVS UIa JM M[\IJTQ[PML JM\_MMV \PM XZWUW\QWV WN  NIT[M
JMTQMN[IVLUWZITTaZMX]OVIV\QLMI[TQJMZIT[IZO]M\PI\\PM[\I\MQV\MZNMZM[
_Q\PW]ZI]\WVWUa_PMVQ\QV\MZ^MVM[\WKZQUQVITQbMUWZITTa]VLM[QZIJTM
QLMI[;KIVTWV!" ·!<PMZMNWZMQN \PMOW^MZVUMV\QV\MZNMZM[_Q\P
W]ZNZMMLWU\WKWV[]UM[M`]ITTaM`XTQKQ\UI\MZQIT[\PI\XZM[MV\P]UIV[QV
LMOZILQVOWZ^QWTMV\[M`]ITIK\Q^Q\QM[\PMa^QWTI\MW]ZNZMMLWU\WLM\MZUQVM
NWZ W]Z[MT^M[ _PM\PMZ WZ VW\ \PM UI\MZQIT[ IZM UWZITTa ZMX]OVIV\ 1V IVa
NZMM[WKQM\aQVLQ^QL]IT[U][\JM\ZMI\ML[]NÅKQMV\Ta[WI[\WJMKIXIJTMWN 
NWZUQVOIVLIK\QVO¹]XWVQV\MTTQOMV\KWVKMX\QWV[WN PW_\PMQZTQ^M[[PW]TL
JMTQ^MLº,_WZSQV! "<PQ[ITQOV[_Q\P5QTT¼[ !KWVKMZV[\PI\
\PMX]Z[]Q\WN \Z]\P_PQTMQUXWZ\IV\I[IR][\QÅKI\QWVNWZNZMMM`XZM[[QWVQ[
J]\WVMN]VLIUMV\ITXWTQ\QKITKWVKMZV5QTT !IT[WIZO]ML\PI\U]T\QXTM
^QM_XWQV\[MVPIVKMR]LOUMV\IVLQV\MTTMK\.WZ5QTT !\PMXIKQÅKI\QWV
WN \PMUQVLQ[WVMKWV[MY]MVKMWN KMV[WZ[PQX.ZMM[XMMKPM^MVQN Q\KWV^Ma[
¹M^QTºQLMI[IZMQUXWZ\IV\IK\[WN KWUU]VQKI\QWVJMKI][M\PMX]JTQKLMJI\M
\PI\WN\MVZM[]T\[NZWUUWZITTaM^QTQLMI[VM^MZ\PMTM[[MVPIVKM[¹SVW_TMLOM
NZQMVL[PQXIVL[MTNOW^MZVUMV\ºIVLW\PMZ[WKQITTaIVLXWTQ\QKITTa^IT]IJTM
IK\Q^Q\QM[5QTT !"!#5WWV
 3WXXTMUIVIZ\QK]TI\M[\PM[M\ZILQ\QWVITTQJMZITQLMI[QVIUWLMZVKWV\M`\
XWQV\QVOW]\\PI\\PI\KMV[WZ[PQXWN ¹M^QTºQLMI[QM\PZW]OP[]XXZM[[QVO
¹WJRMK\QWVIJTMºUI\MZQIT[[]KPI[PIZLKWZMXWZVWOZIXPa¹L]TT[º[WKQM\QM[
\W_IZL[M^QTJMKI][M¹M^QTQ[ZIZMTaKWUUQ\\MLJaU][\IKPM\_QZTQVO^QTTIQV[
5WZMWN\MVQ\Q[LWVMJaXMWXTM_PWPI^M[]KKMMLMLQV_MI^QVOIVMTIJWZI\M
\Q[[]MWN [MTNR][\QÅKI\QWV[W_MTTKZIN\ML\PI\Q\KWUXTM\MTaUI[S[\PMZMITQ\a
16 Sex and the Supreme Court

WN  _PI\ \PMa IZM LWQVO \W W\PMZ XMWXTMº "  1V W\PMZ _WZL[ QV
WZLMZ\WTMIZVIJW]\M^QT_MKIVVW\XMZUQ\W]ZOW^MZVUMV\[\WKMV[WZQ\
3WXXMTUIVKQ\M[)bIZ6IÅ[Q¼[:MILQVO4WTQ\IQV<MPZIV\WJ]\\ZM[[PQ[IZO]UMV\
1VLQ[K][[QVO\PMLQK\I\WZ[PQXWN )aI\WTTIP:]PWTTIP3PWUMQVQ6IÅ[Q_ZQ\M[
\PI\¹1[TIUQKN]VLIUMV\ITQ[UKITTMLNWZUQKZWUIVIOQVO\PMTQ^M[WN M^MZaWVM
IVLWN _WUMVQVXIZ\QK]TIZº_PQKPQVKT]LMLJIVVQVO?M[\MZV\M`\[TQSM4WTQ\I
3WXXMTUIV" .WZ6IÅ[Q\PM^IT]MQVZMILQVO[]KP\M`\[TQM[QV¹I
XIZITTMTJM\_MMV_PI\0]UJMZ\\ZQML\WLW\W4WTQ\IIVL_PI\3WPUMQVQ
\ZQML\WLW\WPQ[[]JRMK\["JW\PQV^WT^M»\PMKWVÅ[KI\QWVWN WVMQVLQ^QL]IT¼[
TQNMJaIVW\PMZ¼º3WXXMTUIV" *MKI][M\PM\M`\\MIKPM[][IJW]\\PM
XIZITTMT[JM\_MMV1[TIUQKLQK\I\WZ[IVL[M`]ITLQK\I\WZ[¹\PMXWZ\ZIaIT[WN M^QT
[]KPI[WKK]ZQV4WTQ\IIZMZQ[SaJ]\UWZITTa^IT]IJTMXZMKQ[MTaJMKI][M\PMa
PMTX\WLQ[XMT\PMKWUNWZ\IJTMVW\QWV\PI\M^QTQ[_PWTTaW\PMZ<PI\VW\QWV
\MVL[\WJMOM\\PM\PW]OP\\PI\_PI\_MIZMLWQVOKIVVW\XW[[QJTaJMM^QT
[QVKM_MIZM\PMWVM[_PWIZMLWQVOQ\º3WXXMTUIV" 1VW\PMZ_WZL[
\PMZMQ[XZWNW]VLML]KI\QWVIT^IT]M\WJMPILQV\PM_QLMLQ[[MUQVI\QWVWN 
UWZITTaM^QTQLMI[
 <PM[MTQJMZITIKKW]V\[WN NZMMM`XZM[[QWVPI^MXZW^QLMLIUU]VQ\QWV
NWZ \PM ZMRMK\QWV WN  \PM NMUQVQ[\ OW^MZVUMV\IT ZI\QWVITQ\QM[ \PI\ IVQUI\M
\PMIZO]UMV\QVNI^W]ZWN KMV[WZ[PQXQVWZLMZ\WNW[\MZ_WUMV¼[MY]ITQ\a
7\PMZTQJMZIT[UWLMZI\M\PMQZXW[Q\QWV[ZMOIZLQVOKMV[WZ[PQX^QM_QVO[M`]IT
[XMMKPIVLIK\Q^Q\QM[VW\I[IJ[WT]\MJ]\ZI\PMZI[IK\QWVIJTM_PMVIKMZ\IQV
\PZM[PWTLWN ¹PIZUºQ[UM\\PI\Q[[WUMIK\Q^Q\QM[WZM`XZM[[QWVKW]TLJM
TQUQ\MLQV\PM[MZ^QKMWN I^WQLQVOPIZU<PM[MUWLMZI\MLTQJMZIT^QM_XWQV\[
ZMY]QZMUWZM\PIV\PMUMZMI[[MZ\QWVWN PIZUWZZQ[SWN PIZUIVLTWWS
NWZ[WUM\PQVOUWZM\IVOQJTM]XWV_PQKP\WR][\QNa[\I\MQV\MZ^MV\QWV.WZ
QV[\IVKM[WUM_W]TLIZO]M\PI\[M`]ITM`XZM[[QWV[PW]TLWVTaJMTQUQ\IJTM
_PMVQ\[MNNMK\[IUW]V\\W\PM_QTTN]TXZWUW\QWVWN PI\ZMLIOIQV[\_WUMV
2WKPMT[WV!I#;]UVMZ#:aLMZ)V\QXWZVWOZIXPaNMUQVQ[\[
\MVL\WMY]I\MPIZU[\W_WUMV¼[MY]ITQ\aI[IUU]VQ\QWVNWZ[]XXZM[[QVO
[M`]ITIK\Q^Q\aIVLM`XZM[[QWV<PM[MKTIQU[NITT[PWZ\WN \PMPIZUN]TTQVS[
[W]OP\JaUWLMZI\MLTQJMZIT[J]\VWVM\PMTM[[\PMIVITa\QK[WN PIZUI[I
R][\QÅKI\QWVNWZ[\I\M[]XXZM[[QWVPI[XZW^QLMLXW_MZN]TN]MTNWZUIVaIV\Q
XWZVWOZIXPaIK\Q^Q[\[2WKPMT[WV!I!J

The Mutant Harm Principle

<PM NWTTW_QVO KPIX\MZ[ [PW_ \PI\ \PM 4IJIaM +W]Z\ PI[ IZ\QK]TI\ML I
R][\QÅKI\QWVNWZKMV[WZ[PQXWN WJ[KMVQ\aIVLKZQUQVITQbI\QWVWN QVLMKMVKa
\PI\Q[VW\KWVÅVML\WI[QVOTMTWOQK*a[PQN\QVO\PM\M[\I_IaNZWU\PM^IT]M[
IVLWXQVQWV[WN \PM¹KWUU]VQ\aº\W\PMIJ[\ZIK\^IT]M[WN TQJMZITQ[U\PM
VM_\M[\KIVMI[QTaJMZMILQVU]T\QXTMLQZMK\QWV[QVKT]LQVOINMUQVQ[\WVM
<PQ[IXXZWIKPPI[JMMVMUJZIKMLJa\PW[M_PW_IV\\W][M\PMXW_MZWN 
 Theoretical Debates 17

\PM[\I\M\WXZWUW\M_WUMV¼[MY]ITQ\a+ZIQO!1V\PQ[JWWS_M_ZM[\TM
_Q\P\PM_IaQV_PQKP\PMPIZUXZQVKQXTMPI[JMMV][ML\WR][\QNaKMV[WZ[PQX
QV\PMKWV\M`\WN WJ[KMVQ\aIVLQVLMKMVKa4QJMZIT[PI^MKZQ\QKQbML\PM][M
WN \PMPIZUXZQVKQXTMJa\PM[\I\MIVLW\PMZILUQVQ[\ZI\Q^MJWLQM[\WR][\QNa
KMV[WZ[PQXWV\PMJI[Q[WN ¹NMMTQVO[]JWZLQVI\MLWZNMMTQVO[QTMVKMLCJaWJ[KMVQ\a
IVLWZQVLMKMVKaE_PQKPQV\]ZVCQ[EQVM`\ZQKIJTaJW]VL]X_Q\PNMMTQVOX]\
]XWVW]\ZIOMLWZWNNMVLMLI\_PQKPXWQV\_MUIaIXXZWIKPUWZITQ[UWN 
\PMWTL[WZ\º/ZMMV"!MUXPI[Q[QVWZQOQVIT+ZQ\QKQ[U[IZMIT[WTM^QML
IOIQV[\\PM][MWN \PMPIZUXZQVKQXTM\WR][\QNa[\I\M[IVK\QWV_PMVQ\Q[][ML
\WKMV[WZ[M`]ITTaM`XTQKQ\UI\MZQIT[_PQKPIZM[IQL\WKI][MPIZU_PM\PMZQ\
JMLQZMK\WZQVLQZMK\PIZU?MIZO]M\PI\R]LOM[KWV\QV]M\WWXMZI\QWVITQbM
¹UWZITQ[UWN \PMWTL[WZ\º#WV[WUMWKKI[QWV[\PMaM^MVLW[W¹QV\PMVIUM
WN NMUQVQ[Uº_PQKP_MÅVLQV\MZM[\QVO
 +]ZZMV\TaQV+IVILQIVTI_KZQUQVITQbI\QWVQ[TMOQ\QUQbMLJa\PMKW]Z\[
QVZMTI\QWV\W\PMSQVL[WN PIZUWZZQ[SWN PIZUKI][MLJaWJ[KMVQ\aIVL
QVLMKMVKa 0IZU Q[ NZIUML KPQMÆa I[ ¹PIZU \W [WKQM\aº I KI\MOWZa \PI\
QVKT]LM[PIZU\W_WUMVIVLUMVINNZWV\[\WW]ZXMZ[WVITTQJMZ\QM[IVL
LIUIOMLWVM\WW\PMZKWV[\Q\]\QWVIT^IT]M[[]KPI[MY]ITQ\a2WKPMT[WV!I
!J>IT^MZLM!!!LM[KZQJM[[]KPPIZU[I[U]T\Q^WKIT_PQKPQTT][\ZI\M[
\PMU]T\QXTMINNMK\MLXMZ[XMK\Q^M[WN \PM\IZOM\[IVLXIZ\QKQXIV\[WN [M`]IT
[XMMKPIVLKWVL]K\?MIZO]M\PI\QV+IVILI\PM\M[\_PQTM_MIZQVOI^MQT
WN U]T\QXTQKQ\aWN KWV\M`\[PI[IK\]ITTaJMMVKTWISMLQV\MZU[WN \PM¹XZWXMZ
N]VK\QWVQVOWN [WKQM\aº<PMU]T\Q^WKITQ\aWJ[MZ^MLJa[WUM[KPWTIZ[PI[
JMMV []J[]UML ]VLMZ I JZWILMZ KI\MOWZa WN  PIZU _PQKP \PM KW]Z\[ [MM
\PMU[MT^M[I[\I[SML_Q\PXZM^MV\QVO¸IKI\MOWZa_MKITT¹[WKQM\ITPIZUº
0IZU\W_WUMVPIZU\WUMVIVLPIZU\WXWTQ\QKIT^IT]M[[]KPI[TQJMZ\a
IVLMY]ITQ\aPI^MPQ[\WZQKITTaJMMVLMXTWaML\WKWV[\Q\]\MIKWV[MV[]ITUWZIT
WZLMZ¸I]VQ^WKITOWIT
 6M^MZ\PMTM[[ _M IOZMM _Q\P >IT^MZLM \PI\ \PM KPIZIK\MZQbI\QWV WN 
+IVILQIV[M`TI_[I[I¹ZMTI\Q^MTa[UWW\PXZWOZM[[\W_IZL[UWLMZVQbI\QWV
IVLZI\QWVITQbI\QWVºQ[IVIZZI\Q^M¹_Q\PW]\NW]VLI\QWVº>IT^MZLM!!!" 
1VLMMLIVaI\\MUX\[\WZMILIVM_NW]VLTQJMZITQbI\QWVIVLWZNMUQVQ[U
QV\W\PMTI_WN WJ[KMVQ\aIVLQVLMKMVKaIZMQTT][WZaXW[\4IJIaM?MIZO]M
\PZW]OPW]\\PQ[JWWS\PI\\PMMTQUQVI\QWVWN \PM^WQKM[WN [M`]ITKWUU]VQ\QM[
NZWUR]LQKQITLMKQ[QWVUISQVOIJW]\_PI\KW]V\[I[JIL[M`IVLJaM`\MV[QWV
_PI\KW]V\[I[OWWL[M`Q[ILM^MTWXUMV\\PI\\WWSXTIKMOZIL]ITTaJ]\_PQKP
ZMIKPMLNZ]Q\QWV_PMV\PM;]XZMUM+W]Z\ZM\QZMLQ\[KWUU]VQ\a[\IVLIZL[
WN \WTMZIVKM\M[\QV4IJIaMZMXTIKQVOQ\_Q\P\PMPIZU\M[\I[\PMLM\MZUQVQVO
NIK\WZQV_PM\PMZWJ[KMVQ\aWZQVLMKMVKaPI[WKK]ZZML
 <PM][MWN PIZUI[LMÅVMLJa\PM4IJIaM+W]Z\[MTMK\[NWZI]VQ^MZ[ITQbQVO
¹XWTQ\QKITUWZITQ\aWN PIZUº_PQKPMZI[M[\PMXW\MV\QITNWZKWV\M`\JI[ML
[M`]ITLQ[KW]Z[M[JI[MLWVLQ^MZ[MM`XMZQMVKM[;QVKMI\TMI[\\PMXI[[IOMWN 
18 Sex and the Supreme Court

\PM+IVILQIV+PIZ\MZWN :QOP\[IVL.ZMMLWU[QV! LQ^MZ[M^WQKM[_MZMPMIZL

I[NWZUITTMOITQV\MZ^MVMZ[QV;]XZMUM+W]Z\KI[M[WNNMZQVOIZO]UMV\[QV
\PMKWV\M`\WN KWV[\Q\]\QWVITTQ\QOI\QWV?MM`XTWZM_Pa\PW[M^WQKM[PI^M
JMMVITTJ]\[QTMVKMLNWTTW_QVO\PMLMKQ[QWVQV:^4IJIaM*MNWZM_MXZWKMML
\PW]OPQ\Q[^Q\IT\PI\_MJZQMÆaZM^QM_\PMUW[\KWUUWVIZO]UMV\[QV\PM
KMV[WZ[PQXLMJI\MQVZMKMV\+IVILQIVPQ[\WZa<PQ[QVKT]LM[UW[\[ITQMV\Ta
WN\MV JMKI][M WN  \PMQZ QV^WT^MUMV\ QV \PM TQ\QOI\QWV XZWUQVMV\ NMUQVQ[\
IKKW]V\[WN WJ[KMVQ\aQV\PM+IVILQIVKWV\M`\

The Censorship Debate

7VMQUXWZ\IV\Q[[]M_Q\PZM[XMK\\WWJ[KMVQ\aPI[\WLW_Q\P\PMY]M[\QWV
WN  _PM\PMZ XWZVWOZIXPa Q[ ¹[XMMKPº *W\P NMUQVQ[\ IVL KWV[MZ^I\Q^M
KWUUMV\I\WZ[ PI^M IZO]ML \PI\ XWZVWOZIXPa Q[ VW\ [XMMKP ^QM_QVO Q\
QV[\MIL I[ [WUM\PQVO LQNNMZMV\ _PQKP KI][M[ LQZMK\ XIZ\QKQXI\WZa IVL
QVLQZMK\MY]ITQ\aJI[MLWZUWZITTaKWZZ]X\Q^MPIZU[5IK3QVVWV! 
+WV[MZ^I\Q^M[PI^MIZO]ML\PI\WJ[KMVMXWZVWOZIXPaW]OP\\WJMKMV[WZML
\WXZW\MK\XI\ZQIZKPIT^IT]M[_PMZMI[IV\QXWZVWOZIXPaNMUQVQ[\[PI^MIZO]ML
\PI\WJ[KMVMXWZVWOZIXPaW]OP\JMKMV[WZML\WXZW\MK\_WUMVIVLUWZM
IJ[\ZIK\Ta_WUMV¼[MY]ITQ\a2WKPMT[WV!I!J0W_M^MZ\PMVW\QWV
\PI\ XWZVWOZIXPa Q[ VW\ I NWZU WN  ¹[XMMKPº PI[ JMMV TIZOMTa LQ[KZMLQ\ML
3WXXMTUIV IUI\\MZ\PI\+IVILQIVKI[MTI_PI[KTMIZTa
ZM^MITMLI[_MTT[MMNWZM`IUXTM*]\TMZC!!E
 1V\PMKWV\MUXWZIZa+IVILQIVKWV[\Q\]\QWVITMZI\PQ[KZQUQVITQbI\QWV
WN JW\PWJ[KMVQ\aIVLQVLMKMVKaQ[R][\QÅML\WXZW\MK\I[WKQM\a\PI\KTIQU[\W
JMKWUUQ\\ML\WXZM[MZ^QVOTQJMZ\aIVLMY]ITQ\aIVLQ\Q[VW\]V][]ITNWZ\PM
KZQUQVITQbI\QWVWN XWZVWOZIXPaIVLXZW[\Q\]\QWV\WJMR][\QÅMLI[VMKM[[IZa
\W XZW\MK\ _WUMV¼[ MY]ITQ\a 0W_M^MZ _PMZM NMUQVQ[\[ [MMS \W XZWUW\M
_WUMV¼[MY]ITQ\aQVIVQVPMZMV\Ta]VMY]IT[WKQM\a\PMKW]Z\[PI^M\ISMVI
U]KPLQNNMZMV\IXXZWIKP+W]Z\[^QM_[WKQM\aI[\PZMI\MVMLJa\PMM`Q[\MVKMWN 
WJ[KMVQ\aIVL[MMS\WKWV\ZWTQ\I[I_IaWN XZW\MK\QVOI¹XZWXMZTaN]VK\QWVQVO
[WKQM\aº _PQKP Q[ VW\ KPIZIK\MZQbML Ja [WKQIT QVMY]ITQ\a 2WPV[WV !!!
1VXIZ\QK]TIZKW]Z\[QUIOQVM_WUMVIVLUMVI[IXXZWIKPQVOIXZWXMZTa
N]VK\QWVQVO[WKQM\aI[MY]IT[]JRMK\[IVLI[WKQM\a_Q\PW]\WJ[KMVQ\aIVL
QVLMKMVKa []XXWZ\[ \PQ[ _WZTL WZLMZ <P][ QV LMXTWaQVO \PM PIZU \M[\
KW]Z\[[MM\PMU[MT^M[I[UW^QVO[WKQM\aI_IaNZWUWZQVWK]TI\QVO[WKQM\a
NZWU\PMXW[[QJQTQ\aWN I¹\ZIV[QMV\XI\PWTWOQKIT[\I\Mº<PMa[MM\PMQZZWTM
I[[MTMK\QVONWZUWZITMY]QTQJZQ]UWZPWUMW[\I\QKXMZNMK\QWV1UXWZ\IV\Ta
\PQ[PWUMW[\I[Q[I[[]UM[IJI[MTQVMMY]ITQ\aWN Q\[[]JRMK\[#\PMZMX]LQI\QWV
WN WJ[KMVQ\aZM\]ZV[\PM[]JRMK\[JIKS\W\PMMY]ITJI[MTQVM<PQ[UWLMTWN 
[WKQM\aQ[Y]Q\MI\WLL[_Q\P\PMUWLMT\PI\]VLMZXQV[UW[\NMUQVQ[\LMJI\M[
QVZM[XMK\WN XWZVWOZIXPaIVLKMV[WZ[PQX)NMUQVQ[\IZO]UMV\_W]TLI^WQL
KWV[\Z]K\QWV[WN I¹XZWXMZ[WKQM\aº_PQKPIZMZWW\MLQV\PMQLMIWN IV]VZ]Ta
 Theoretical Debates 19

KTI[[WN UWZITTaKWZZ]X\QJTMQVVWKMV\[¸IVW\QWV[\MMXMLQVQ\[W_VJZIVL
WN XI\ZQIZKPITPM\MZWVWZUI\Q^Q\aIJW]\_PQKPUIVaNMUQVQ[\[ZMUIQVLMMXTa
[][XQKQW][1VXIZ\QK]TIZUW[\NMUQVQ[\XMZ[XMK\Q^M[_W]TLKWVKMQ^M\PI\UMV
IVL_WUMVZIZMTaIXXZWIKPITMOITKWV\M[\I[MY]IT[]JRMK\[+W[[UIVM\IT
!!
 <PM \M[\ NWZ WJ[KMVM XWZVWOZIXPa M[\IJTQ[PML QV : ^ *]\TMZ Ja \PM
;]XZMUM+W]Z\QV!!_I[\PMÅZ[\KWV[\Q\]\QWVITKPITTMVOM\W\PMWJ[KMVQ\a
XZW^Q[QWV[WN \PM+ZQUQVIT+WLM<PMWJ[KMVQ\aXZW^Q[QWV_I[]XPMTLJa\PM
*]\TMZ +W]Z\ WV \PM OZW]VL[ \PI\ ¹WJ[KMVMº XWZVWOZIXPa Q[ PIZUN]T \W
[WKQM\aIVL\PMZMNWZMQ\[KZQUQVITQbI\QWVQ[R][\QÅML\WXZW\MK\[WKQM\a<PM
*]\TMZ+W]Z\KWV\QV]ML\WZMTa]XWVIKWUU]VQ\a[\IVLIZL[WN \WTMZIVKM\M[\
QVSMMXQVO_Q\P\PMKI[MTI_[QVKM\PM![_PMV\PMK]ZZMV\WJ[KMVQ\a
XZW^Q[QWV_I[XI[[ML<PM+W]Z\KWV[\Z]K\MLPIZUN]T[M`]ITM`XZM[[QWVI[
UI\MZQIT[_PQKP\PMI^MZIOM+IVILQIV_W]TLVW\WZKW]TLVW\QUIOQVMW\PMZ
+IVILQIV[^QM_QVO<PMZMTM^IV\[MK\QWVWN \PM+ZQUQVIT+WLM[MK\QWV
KZQUQVITQbM[IVa[M`]ITTaM`XTQKQ\UI\MZQIT[XWZVWOZIXPaI[WJ[KMVM_PMZM
¹ILWUQVIV\KPIZIK\MZQ[\QKWN \PMUI\\MZWZ\PQVOQ[\PM]VL]MM`XTWQ\I\QWV
WN  [M` ^QWTMVKM KZQUM PWZZWZ KZ]MT\a WZ \PM ]VL]M LMOZILI\QWV WN  \PM
P]UIVXMZ[WVº<PMZMNWZM\PMKZQUQVITTI_KWVVMK\[WJ[KMVQ\a_Q\P\PM
]VL]MM`XTWQ\I\QWVWZ\PM]VL]MLMOZILI\QWVWN \PMP]UIVXMZ[WVIVLIQU[
\WXZM^MV\\PM[MPIZU[WV\PMOZW]VL[\PI\\PMa]VLMZUQVM[WKQM\a¼[XZWXMZ
N]VK\QWVQVO?M[PW_\PI\4IJIaMQ[IKWV\QV]I\QWVM^MVI[\ZMVO\PMVQVOWN 
\PQ[N]VK\QWVITQ[\XZWRMK\
 1VXZIK\QKITXWTQ\QKITIVLTMOIT\MZU[TWJJaOZW]X[TQSM\PM+IVILQIV+Q^QT
4QJMZ\QM[)[[WKQI\QWV++4)!PI^M[W]OP\\WXZW\MK\NZMMLWUWN M`XZM[[QWV
QV KI[M[ LMITQVO _Q\P [M`]ITTa M`XTQKQ\ UI\MZQIT[ _PQTM NMUQVQ[\ IL^WKIKa
WZOIVQbI\QWV[TQSM\PM?WUMV¼[4MOIT-L]KI\QWVIVL)K\QWV.]VL4-).
PI^M[W]OP\\WXZW\MK\MY]ITQ\aZQOP\[NWZ_WUMV+WV[MZ^I\Q^MZMTQOQW][
TWJJQM[ []KP I[ ?QVVQXMOJI[ML /)8 /ZW]X )OIQV[\ 8WZVWOZIXPa IZM
WXXW[ML\WJW\PTQJMZITIVLKMZ\IQVNMUQVQ[\XW[Q\QWV[WV\PM[\I\M¼[ZWTMQV
ZMO]TI\QVO [M`]ITTa M`XTQKQ\ UI\MZQIT[ [MMQVO I U]KP [\ZWVOMZ ZWTM NWZ \PM
[\I\M;QUQTIZTa5][TQUZMTQOQW][OZW]X[[]KPI[\PM+IVILQIV+W]VKQTWN 
5][TQU?WUMV++5?JMTQM^M\PI\\PM[\I\MW]OP\\WKZQUQVITQbMUW[\
NWZU[WN XWZVWOZIXPaIVLW\PMZ[M`]ITTaM`XTQKQ\UI\MZQIT[<PMa[PIZMI
KWV[MZ^I\Q^MJMTQMN \PI\XWZVWOZIXPa]VLMZUQVM[\PMZMTQOQW][^IT]MXTIKML
]XWVPM\MZW[M`]ITUWVWOIUaIVL\PMV]KTMIZNIUQTaIVL\PI\XWZVWOZIXPa
XZWUW\M[\PM[M`]ITIJ][MWN _WUMVIVLOQZT[
 1\Q[KWUUWVTaIKKMX\MLQV[WUMNMUQVQ[\KQZKTM[\PI\IV\QXWZVWOZIXPa
NMUQVQ[\[ PI^M NZIUML \PMQZ IZO]UMV\[ QV U]KP WN  \PM [IUM TIVO]IOM I[
UWZITKWV[MZ^I\Q^M[QVZM[XMK\WN XWZVWOZIXPQKM`XZM[[QWV+W[[UIVM\IT
!!)KKWZLQVO\W/W\MTT!!""