13 Screw Design: 13.1 Conveying

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 9

13 Screw Design

Screw design was touched upon briefly in Chapter


12 while discussing polymer behavior in the extruder
and the different segments in screw configurations
required for feeding, conveying, melting, mixing,
venting or devolatilization, downstream feeding, and
pumping molten polymer to the die. This chapter will
discuss the particular screw elements in more detail
to provide a better insight into which elements to use
in particular situations.
The available barrel sections determine the screw
length. Assume a particular extruder has 10-barrel
sections, each barrel section L/D (length-to-diameter
ratio) is 4:1, and the screw diameter is 60 mm. When Figure 13.1 Setup for assembly of new screw
designing the screw configuration, what is the screw design.
element length in millimeters required to completely
fill the screw shafts? Each barrel section with a barrel assembly. The screw shafts are clean, a screw config-
L/D of 4:1 is 240 mm long (60  4 ¼ 240 mm); with uration or design is available to use as a guide in
10-barrel sections present, the screw length is assembling the screws, and the appropriate screw
2400 mm. The actual screw shafts are slightly shorter elements are arranged in identical pairs, ready to be
than 2400 mm; with 2400 mm of screw element inserted on to the screw shafts.
length, the screw tips force the elements tightly toge- Screw elements are available in discrete lengths to
ther, preventing polymer from flowing between the be combined in any of a number of ways to provide
screw elements on the shaft. The tip is threaded into flexibility in locating the melting, mixing, conveying,
the end of the screw shaft; it is tightened, squeezing the feeding, etc. zones in unique configurations for
screw elements together since the last element extends different product formulations. Screw design con-
past the end of the shaft. When constructing the screw figurations are the key to operating efficiency. By
configuration (placing the elements on the shafts), designing the operating stepsdi.e. melting, mixing,
verify that each element mating surface is flat with no addition of other ingredients, venting, and so forthd
scratches or nicks and that the shaft and inside surface to optimize the melt temperature, die pressure, and
of the screw elements are clean. Screw elements slide throughput rates, each extruder is optimized for the
onto the screw shafts easily. Shafts and keyways have processes and products being produced on that
a thin coat of antisieze applied to them during screw extruder.
construction to assist element removal at a later date
when changing the screw design. It is advisable to lap 13.1 Conveying
the end of each element on a flat surface with fine
emery cloth prior to assembly. Excess antisieze is Available conveying elements have a distinct
avoided; otherwise, it builds up between the elements, pitch, a defined length, and a specific conveying
preventing a good contact seal that allows polymer to direction. The screw element nomenclature is pitch/
flow between the elements. If polymer flows between length, so that a 60/60 element has a 60-mm pitch (a
the elements in high-pressure regions of the screw flight makes one complete revolution around the
during processing, over time the polymer degrades screw element every 60 mm in length), and its length
and chars, making element removal very difficult. is 60 mm. A 60/30 element has a 60-mm pitch and
Figure 13.1 shows a new screw design that is ready for a 30-mm length. Forward conveying elements move

Extrusion. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/B978-1-4377-3481-2.00013-2
Copyright Ó 2014 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. 171
172 E XTRUSION

material down the barrel from the feed throat to the are normally used in either the feed or venting section.
die, whereas rear conveying elements move material Medium-pitch conveying elements are approximately
back toward the feed throat. Figure 13.2 shows 1D or 45/45 on a 45-mm extruder, 60/60 on a 60-mm
forward and rear conveying elements. extruder, or 90/90 on a 90-mm extruder. (The element
length does not have to equal the pitch, as suggested in
the examples above. A 90-mm extruder may be a 90/45
element, where the flights complete a 1/2 revolution
and the element is 45 mm long.) Medium-pitched
elements have medium conveying speed with a higher
percent fill compared to large-pitch conveying
elements. They are used for feed or melt compression
after large-pitch conveying in either a feed zone or
venting area. Small-pitch conveying elements have the
slowest forward conveying speed and the highest
percent fill. Their pitch is normally 0.25De0.75D.
These elements have the maximum percent fill without
generating significant melt pressure and are used for
pumping and heat transfer.
Figure 13.2 Conveying screw elements. Non-inter-meshing twin screw extruder conveying
elements usually employ a square pitch, where the
pitch equals the extruder diameter. A 60-mm
The pitch influences the percent fill in intermeshing non-inter-meshing extruder square pitch screw has
extruders. A large-pitch element after a melt seal or a 60-mm pitch. Although alternative pitches are
restrictive element has a low percent fill. As the screw available, square pitch is normally standard.
pitch is reduced, the percent fill increases. A sche- The screw flights on each conveying element can
matic for this is shown in Figure 13.3. As the pitch vary from one to three. Single flighted elements are
standard for non-inter-meshing twin screw extruders,
while most intermeshing, parallel twin screw
extruders are bilobal, having two lobes or two channel
flights on each element. The early intermeshing,
Figure 13.3 Degree of fill with different pitch
parallel, corotating twin screw extruders had three
conveying elements.
lobes or three flights per element. Most triple flighted
elements in more recent twin screw extruders are
decreases, the mean residence time in the extruder specialized kneading blocks. Single flighted elements
increases, since the material must make more revo- used in two-lobed extruders are principally employed
lutions around the screw shaft to be conveyed forward in the feed section. As mentioned in Chapter 12, the
the same distance in the barrel. An example is a 60/60 melt is divided into channels depending on how many
element; the material makes one complete revolution lobes or flights there are in the element design. The
while moving downstream 60 mm. Material in a 30/30 number of polymer channels is given by Eqn (13.1):
element must make two revolutions to move forward
by 60 mm. Polymer channels ¼ 2=n  1 (13.1)
Pitch is normally related to the element diameter.
Conveying elements shown in Figure 13.2 are from where n ¼ the number of lobes or flights on each
a 40-mm corotating, intermeshing twin screw extruder. element.
A 60-pitch element is 1.5 times the diameter or 1.5D. Single flighted elements have large flight widths
Large-pitch elements normally have a 1.5D or 2D with a very good pumping efficiency and feed capac-
pitch. In a 90-mm twin screw extruder, large-pitch ity. The shear generated in single flighted elements is
elements have either a 135- or 180-mm pitch. A typical low in comparison to that in multiflighted elements.
large-pitch element on a 90-mm twin screw might be Figure 13.4 compares intermeshing screws with single
180/180 or 135/90. Large-pitch elements have the flighted elements in both corotating and counter-
lowest percent fill and the highest conveying rate. They rotating extruders.
13: S CREW D ESIGN 173

screw kneading block is a 45/5/60 with the first disk


in the vertical direction, the second rotated 45 , the
third rotated another 45 from the second, and so
forth. There are five disks on the kneading block with
Single flighted counterrotating an overall length of 60 mm. See Figures 12.12, 12.13,
and 12.16 in Chapter 12 for pictures of standard
kneading blocks. The width of the disk can vary,
depending on the mixing to be accomplished. Wide
disks are used for dispersive mixing, whereas narrow
disks are used in distributive mixing. Figure 13.5
Single flighted corotating

Figure 13.4 Single flighted screw elements.

Double flighted or bilobal elements have been


discussed in detail in Chapters 11 and 12. They are the
standard in the industry today for high torque, high
throughput extruders. Double flighted elements are
normally located downstream from any single flighted
elements, dividing the polymer stream into two
Figure 13.5 Comparison of wide (left) and narrow
channels. Conveying elements are used principally for kneading blocks.

 Feeding
 Conveying shows two approximately equal length kneading
 Downstream feeding blocks with different disk widths. The narrower disks
 Devolatilization are more open, allowing polymer to flow around the
 Pumping blocks in both the forward and reverse directions,
resulting in the melt stream splitting and recombining
Triple flighted elements are still present in older numerous times. In the narrow kneading blocks, each
twin screw extruders. They generate higher shear disk has a shoulder on each side of the disk at the
than either single or double flighted elements do screw element root, resulting in a smaller width disk
because the channel depth is shallower. These to work the polymer.
elements are used for the same applications as double The ability of the kneading blocks to convey melt
flighted elements in newer machines. forward in the barrel depends on the individual disk
rotation on each block. Forward conveying kneading
blocks convey polymer toward the die, whereas
13.2 Mixing Elements reverse kneading blocks convey the melt back toward
the feed throat. With reverse kneading disks, all
Numerous mixing element designs are available polymer flows between the disk gaps as it is conveyed
with different functions based on their geometry. forward in the extruder. Using a combination of
Kneading blocks are the most common mixing reverse kneading blocks and/or conveying elements in
element. They are characterized by their succession leads to a significant increase in both melt
pressure and melt temperature. The smaller the stagger
 Length angle, the greater is the reverse flow and work put into
 Stagger or offset angle the polymer, yielding better mixing accompanied
 Number and width of disks by higher melt temperature and pressure. Reverse
 Number of flights kneading blocks, like reverse conveying elements, are
 Conveying direction used to develop melt seals before downstream feeding
or venting. Neutral kneading blocks convey material
Kneading block nomenclature is disc/kneading neither forward nor reverse. Each disk is rotated 90
block stagger or offset angle/number of disks/ from the previous disk (Figure 12.16, Chapter 12).
kneading block length. A common 40-mm twin Long, wide, neutral kneading blocks work the polymer
174 E XTRUSION

to a greater degree than forward conveying kneading Figure 12.17. The Polygon is a six-flighted kneading
blocks do, and to a lesser degree than rearward block with a reverse pitch that has multiple screw-
conveying kneading blocks. Wide neutral disks tend to to-screw clearances as the screw rotates. The continuous
capture the melt pool, leading to dispersive mixing, mixing element has both forward and reverse pitch
while narrow neutral disks divide and recombine the angles. This particular geometry evolved from Farrel’s
melt, resulting in distributive mixing. continuous mixer technology. Numerous companies
The stagger angle determines the polymer back- have gear or turbine-type mixing elements, shown in
flow that passes through the gaps between the disks. Chapter 12, Figure 12.14. Although each manufacturer
The higher the stagger angle, the greater the open has slight variations on its gear mixer geometry, they are
area allowing backflow, with a decreased forward all designed to convey material forward in the barrel
conveying capacity. A 30/7/45 kneading block has while dividing and recombining the melt stream to
more forward conveying capacity and less polymer provide distributive mixing. Although gear mixers are
flowing backward through the gaps toward the feed typically used for mixing liquid additives with molten
throat than a 60/4/45 kneading block has. Neutral polymer, they have been tried with glass fibers and other
kneading blocks have more open area for backflow applications. Gear teeth are arranged to provide
compared to forward conveying kneading blocks, a forward, reverse, or neutral conveying. The number of
since they exhibit no forward conveying. If there is gear teeth is varied to change the mixing intensity.
no melt pressure forcing material toward the die, Orifice disks or blister rings are used for dispersive
molten polymer in a neutral kneading disk is as likely mixing. These elements form a flow barrier that creates
to go forward as backward. 100% fill prior to the disk. Single kneading elements,
Three-lobe kneading blocks are used in two-lobe shown in Figure 12.15, Chapter 12, and Figure 11.24,
machines to improve mixing in a shorter length. Chapter 11, are used for dispersive mixing and reactive
Transition elements are required to go from two-lobe extrusion [1]. Leistritz lobal elements are used in
to three-lobe elements and then back to two-lobe both corotating and counterrotating extruders and
elements after the kneading blocks. can be forward, reverse, or neutral conveying. Lobal
Table 13.1 shows the relative characteristics of the elements shown in Figure 13.6 are designed to run at
different kneading blocks for mixing and conveying 100% fill.
performance. In intermeshing twin screw extruders, most
Other specialized mixing elements are available elements are self-wiping and self-cleaning, meaning
from different twin screw manufacturers. Farrel the rotating screws continuously wipe the molten
Corporation has its patented Polygon element for resin from each other and the barrel walls, respec-
distributive mixing and the continuous mixing ele- tively, during processing to prevent polymer build-up
ment for dispersive mixing, shown in Chapter 12, and degradation over time. Most intermeshing

Table 13.1 Effect of Kneading Block Size and Type on Processing

Narrow Wide
Narrow Narrow Wide Wide
Neutral Neutral
Forward Reverse Forward Reverse
Kneading Kneading
Conveying Conveying Conveying Conveying
Block Block
Conveying Good Negative None Poor Negative None
efficiency
Distributive Good Excellent Excellent Poor Okay Okay
mixing
Dispersive Poor Okay Good Excellent Excellent Excellent
mixing
Shear heating Low Average Average High Very high High
Pressure Average High High Very high Exceptionally Very high
generation high
13: S CREW D ESIGN 175

meshing staggered flights used for mixing. Disper-


sive mixing is obtained using a series of elements
including a blister-type cylinder followed by forward
and then reverse conveying elements. The reverse
conveying element creates 100% fill upstream,
forcing the molten polymer to be worked. Figure 13.8

Figure 13.6 Lobal element [1].


Figure 13.8 Non-inter-meshing dispersive mixing.
twin screw extruders are built to be self-wiping
and self-cleaning. Some mixing elements are non- shows a dispersive mixing section in a counter-
self-wiping, such as gear mixers and blister rings. rotating, non-inter-meshing twin screw extruder.
Care must be taken when using these elements if
the polymer being processed is subject to thermal
degradation over time. 13.3 Screw Design Applications
Distributive mixing in non-inter-meshing twin
screw extruders is provided by staggered screw To construct the proper screw design, it is impor-
flights in counterrotating geometry. Optimum mixing tant to know the objectives to be accomplished with
is obtained with 50% adjacent screw flight stagger. the extruder. A sheet containing the barrel sections as
This geometry promotes molten polymer transfer they are configured is combined with the screw
from one screw to the other screw. During transfer, element arrangement to design a screw geometry that
the polymer melt is split by the adjacent screw flights. melts, mixes, pumps, conveys, and so forth. As an
It recombines with the melt when transferred back to example, assume a new screw configuration is being
the original screw. Figure 13.7 shows the non-inter- designed for an intermeshing, corotating extruder
with eight-barrel sections. A typical configuration,
shown in Figure 13.9, has

 Polymer feed in barrel section 1


 Atmospheric or vacuum vent in barrel section 7
 Side feed extruder in barrel section 5
 Venting, gravity feed, or liquid injection ports
in barrel sections 2 and 4
Figure 13.7 Distributive mixing non-inter-meshing
twin screw.

Figure 13.9 Typical barrel


configuration with eight-barrel
sections.
176 E XTRUSION

Figure 13.10 Typical barrel


configuration with 10-barrel sections.

A 10-barrel configuration is shown in Figure 13.10 atmospheric or vacuum vent, depending on the volatile
with concentration and how hard it is to remove. The melt is
pumped to the die in barrel section 8. The left-handed
 Feed in barrel section 1 kneading block and left-handed conveying elements in
 Downstream feed via a side feed extruder in barrel section 4 ensure a restrictive barrier and
barrel section 6 complete melting in barrel section 4. The left-handed
 Atmospheric or vacuum vent in barrel section 9 elements at the end of barrel section 6 provide a melt
 Barrel sections 2, 4, and 8 available for other seal to improve vacuum venting at the vent in barrel
feed streams or venting section 7. Mixing elements used in sections 5 and 6
 Closed barrel sections 3, 5, 7, and 10, where no ensure both good distributive and good dispersive
material feeding or venting is possible mixing. The screw elements used in these examples are
These two barrel configurations will be used in the based on a 40-mm corotating, intermeshing twin screw
following compounding examples to develop different extruder. To scale up from a 40-mm extruder to a larger
screw designs to process specific formulations. diameter extruder, first calculate the ratio of element
In example 1, two resins, A and B, are to be com- length and element pitch to the element diameter. Then
pounded together to produce a new resin blend, C. Both apply the calculated ratios from the small diameter
resins have similar thermal stability. Resin A is powder, extruder to the larger diameter extruder to obtain the
and resin B is pelletized. The objective is to develop an scaled length and pitch. As an example, assume this is
appropriate screw design to mix and compound these to be scaled to a 60-mm twin screw. The 60/60
ingredients. Although either the 8- or 10-section barrel conveying element in the 40-mm extruder feed section
configuration will work, Figure 13.11 with eight-barrel is 1.5 times the pitch and 1.5 times the length. A similar

Figure 13.11 Potential screw design to mix resins A and B.

sections shows a screw configuration that meets this element in a 60-mm extruder is a 90/90 SK screw
example’s objective. Both resins A and B are fed into element. The 40/40 in the 40 mm becomes a 60/60 in
the feed throat with two different gravimetric resin the 60 mm, and the 25/25 conveying element in the
feeders to maintain the proper resin A to B ratio. The 40 mm becomes approximately a 40/40 in the 60 mm.
formulation is preheated and compressed in barrel This 60-mm screw design is another design that will
sections 2 and 3 and melted in barrel section 4. The accomplish the objective. Any particular screw design
melt is conveyed downstream with additional mixing used in a specific production or R&D environment
in barrel sections 5 and 6 and vented to remove any needs to be optimized for the resins and formulations
volatiles in barrel section 7. The vent can be either an being produced.
13: S CREW D ESIGN 177

For example 2, let us use the same resin formu- barrel section 5 by replacing the conveying
lation in the example above with the same barrel elements with kneading blocks. Filler is added in
configuration, but with resin B that is more thermally barrel section 6 by a side feed extruder, heated and
stable than resin A. compressed in barrel 7, and mixed in barrel 8. The
Consequently, resin A is added to the resin B melt vent in barrel 9 removes any volatiles or gases
downstream. What is an appropriate screw design to entrapped in the melt.
accomplish the objective in this second example? In a fourth example, similar to example 3, the filler
Figure 13.12 shows a screw modification to feed is replaced with a fiber reinforcement fed down-

Figure 13.12 Screw configuration for example 2dresins A and B fed in different barrel locations.

resin A downstream, with the side feed extruder, and stream through a side feed extruder. Figure 13.14
provides acceptable melt mixing with resin B prior to shows a screw design to process the reinforcing fiber,
the vent. where the major concern is fiber attrition. The melt
The third example has resins A and B added to section is changed slightly from example 3 to
the extruder in barrel section 1 and filler added example 4 by separating the kneading blocks with
downstream at 30% by weight. As it is filler being conveying elements. This helps to minimize the melt
added and not a reinforcement that requires good temperature rise by decreasing the work in the
dispersion, there is no concern for particle attrition. kneading blocks. Kneading blocks are not used after
The 10-barrel extruder configuration is used for the side feed extruder to minimize fiber attrition. The
this example. Figure 13.13 shows a screw design left-handed conveying element prior to the vent was

Figure 13.13 Resins A and B are fed in barrel 1 and filler in the side feed extruder.

that adds filler downstream with the side feed removed, decreasing the shear and fiber attrition.
extruder. Melting of resins A and B, added at the In a last screw design example, use the situation in
feed throat in barrel section 1, is complete by example 4 with fiber reinforcement, but add a liquid
barrel section 4. If the two resins require additional colorant to the formulation so the resulting product is
mixing before filler addition, it can be done in a colored reinforced thermoplastic composite. The
178 E XTRUSION

Figure 13.14 Screw design to process fiber reinforcements with downstream feeding.

Figure 13.15 Compounding of two resins with liquid colorant and reinforcement.

colorant is pumped into the resin melt in barrel section These examples demonstrate appropriate screw
4. Figure 13.15 shows an appropriate screw design to designs and an understanding of how to arrange the
add liquid with the proper mixing. Gear mixers can be various screw elements to accomplish specific
used in place of the kneading blocks in barrel section 5 objectives. In actual practice, screw designs may
to mix the liquid colorant. In all examples presented have to be modified slightly for different formulation
here, specialized mixing elements are intentionally components to obtain
avoided to gain a better understanding of what can be
accomplished with conveying elements and standard  Optimum throughput
kneading blocks. Melting is complete in barrel section  Dispersive and distributive mixing
3, and the liquid is injected into barrel section 4 and  Correct melt temperature profile
mixed with kneading blocks in barrel sections 4 and 5.  Optimum feed locations
Although conveying elements are used where the
liquid is injected, it is possible to inject liquid directly
over kneading blocks or gear mixers, assuming that
the pressure supplied by the liquid feed pump is Reference
greater than the melt pressure generated in the
[1] W. Thiele, Reactive compounding with your
extruder. Barrel sections 6e10, where the reinforcing
extruder, Plastics Formulating & Compounding, 2
fiber is fed and the extruder is vented, are essentially
(6) (1996).
unchanged from example 4.
13: S CREW D ESIGN 179

Review Questions
1. What is the difference between conveying elements and kneading blocks?
2. What preparation is required for constructing a new screw design?
3. What are some typical large-pitch conveying screw elements for 135-, 57-, and 90-mm twin screw
extruders?
4. What are some typical small-pitch conveying elements for 30-, 45-, and 60-mm twin screw extruders?
5. What are the differences between forward and reverse conveying elements and forward, reverse, and
neutral kneading blocks?
6. What are the differences between single flighted, double flighted, and triple flighted conveying
elements?
7. What are some mixing elements other than kneading blocks, and do they work better as distributive or
dispersive mixers?
8. Design a screw to make a color concentrate (liquid colorant) on the eight-barrel extruder shown at
below. The extruder is 60 mm in diameter, and each barrel section has a 4:1 L/D. Determine what
elements to use based on the extruder size, and arrange them in the proper screw configuration to
produce an acceptable product for the customer.

9. Develop a screw design to plasticize resin C by adding a liquid plasticizer to the extruder. The
formulation calls for 75% resin C and 25% plasticizer. Use a 45-mm twin screw corotating, inter-
meshing extruder with the same barrel geometry shown in question 8 with a 4:1 L/D barrel ratio.
10. Develop a screw design and define the process to compound resin D with a two-component flame
retardant system (both flame retardant ingredients are powdersd3% S and 7% H in the final
formulation), a reinforcing fiber at 22% of the final formulation, and a liquid colorant at 4.5% of the
total formulation. Use the 10-barrel, 40-mm twin screw extruder shown below, assuming a 4:1 L/D
barrel ratio.

You might also like