Professional Documents
Culture Documents
(27-40) Publication Updated File - Modeling of Overvoltage Protection
(27-40) Publication Updated File - Modeling of Overvoltage Protection
(27-40) Publication Updated File - Modeling of Overvoltage Protection
Abstract
The solar power system has been widely developed due to its environmental friendliness and
sustainability. Normally, PV panels would be preferable to set up on rooftop of building or
free-standing in unsheltered areas. Therefore, the negative impacts on these systems from bad
weather conditions, like storms and lightning, have been evident. Vietnam is located in the
region of tropical monsoon weather, especially one of the three strongest thunderstorm areas
in the world. And the overvoltage by lightning transient currents on a PV system not only
could fault, damage to electrical/electronic equipments, but also effect adversely on the
human health and economic. In this paper, our team has chosen the lightning strokes of
single-peaked current forms and has simulated it under the equivalent engineering models by
Matlab-Simulink. The obtained results allowed the analysis of overvoltage scenarios in grid-
tied solar power system in Vietnam and the assessment of the surge protective device activities
of Metal Oxide Varistors during overvoltage.
Keywords: Solar power, Metal Oxide Varistors, Overvoltage Protection, Lightning, Vietnam
JoAEST (2020) 27–40 © STM Journals 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 27
Modeling of Overvoltage Protection by Lightning Dong and Hang
In fact, the overvoltage surges from external case of primary protection device failed [24,
causes must be prevented by protection tools, 25]. MOVs often have higher on capacitance
especially when the line insulation level is low and resistance than other SPDs for the same
like in PV systems [15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21]. application, but they could fail if the
The atmospheric overvoltage surges are operating voltage is in a continuous
described by standard IEC 61643 including maximum due to thermal overloading [24,
wave shapes of 10/350 µs, 8/20 µs, and 1.2/50 25, 26]. The requirements of insulation or
µs [15, 17, 18, 22]. reinforcement would be under IEC standard
“Protection against electric shock” like IEC
Therefore, although Vietnam has a high 60364-4-41 in [27]. The voltage of the
solar potential with the average intensity up protection device should be lower than the
to 5kWh/m 2, protecting overvoltage by voltage of the equipment protected at least
lightning strikes for solar power systems still 20%, and the SPDs should be set up in
has been a big challenge here and now [23]. parallel with the protected systems, referred
Normally, using Surge Protective Devices to CLC/TS 50539-12 in [28]. Depending on
(SPDs) are a basic solution for overvoltage the complexity of power system and
protection from lightning strokes. G. B. Lo weather conditions at site, the SPDs could
Piparo et al. in [24] mentioned that these be used independently or in combination to
SPDs must self-extinguish the electric arc ensure the high reliability in overvoltage
quickly and not discharge when there is an protection for the electric-electronic
internal overvoltage. Popular technologies systems [15, 18, 21].
today are Metal Oxide Varistor (MOV) and
Spark Gap/Gas Discharge Tube [18, 24, 25]. Our study focuses on analysis of overvoltage
Spark Gap/Gas Discharge Tube is widely scenarios in grid-tied solar power system in
used in overvoltage protection due to its Vietnam and assessment the behaviours of
simplicity, and often placed in parallel with MOVs during overvoltage by simulation and
other SPDs to provide back-up protection in the equivalent engineering models. The tested
JoAEST (2020) 27–40 © STM Journals 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 28
Journal of Alternate Energy Sources & Technologies
Volume 11, Issue 2
ISSN: 2230-7982 (Online), ISSN: 2321-5186 (Print)
PV system was set up at a building in Hanoi In PV system, the major components included
(Vietnam). 64 PV panels (4 arrays), a inverter, distribution
board and controller. The MOVs were selected
MATERIALS AND METHODS to protect inverters from overvoltage, and
Materials placed at inverter and MDP-PV board.
The experimental PV system was a grid-tied
solar power system on the rooftop of a Some main characteristics of the considered
building of Vietnam Electricity (EVN) in PV system, MOVs and inverter SMA were
Hanoi shown in Figures 2 and 3. given in Table 1, Table 2 and Table 3.
(b)
(a) (c)
Fig. 2: Rooftop Solar Power System at EVN Building. (a) PV panels, ( b) Inverter SMA,
(c) MDP-PV board.
JoAEST (2020) 27–40 © STM Journals 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 29
Modeling of Overvoltage Protection by Lightning Dong and Hang
IL I I
+ +
RS REqual
Photovoltaic cell
+ ID ISh RSh V V
-
- -
1 1 1
Methods = + (2)
In order to observe, monitor and evaluate the R equal R Sh R S
behaviors of MOVs in overvoltage protection
for the system, MATLAB software was used where: RSh - shunt resistance, /m2; RS - series
to simulate their activities under overvoltage resistance, /m2; Requal - equivalent resistance,
conditions. /m2.
In fact, PV system has operated on signals at Moreover, the assumption was that IGBTs are
various frequencies: 50 Hz for output AC ideal, the impedance was zero in conducting
signals, switching frequency of inverter at mode, and the internal resistance of source
several kHz, and especially overvoltage was extremely small. And the equivalent
signals at 50 kHz of a pulse 0.02ms. circuit of an inverter could be determined as in
Therefore, an equivalent circuit of PV system Figure 5 below (R1.2).
has been considered under the influence of
high frequency overvoltage signal, and its The overvoltage scenarios in our study were
structure was presented in Figure 4. (R1.2) the fabricated solar power system with or
without SPDs, and the SPDs were installed at
The current produced by a solar cell could be the start and end points of inverter for
expressed as in (1). protection itself in fabricated PV system (see
Figures 6, 7, and 8). The behaviors of SPDs,
I = IL – ID – ISh (1) inverter, and load would be observed during
overvoltage phenomenon.
where: I - output current, A/m2; IL –
photogenerated current, A/m2; ID- diode where: the parameters of elements of fabricated
current, A/m2; ISh- shunt current, A/m2. model was showed in Table 4 below.
JoAEST (2020) 27–40 © STM Journals 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 30
Journal of Alternate Energy Sources & Technologies
Volume 11, Issue 2
ISSN: 2230-7982 (Online), ISSN: 2321-5186 (Print)
C
EQUIVALENT
CIRCUIT
A
C
B
D2
IGBT5
IGBT2
D3
D6
IGBT3
IGBT6
D1
D4
IGBT1
IGBT4
C
-
+
VDC
JoAEST (2020) 27–40 © STM Journals 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 31
Modeling of Overvoltage Protection by Lightning Dong and Hang
JoAEST (2020) 27–40 © STM Journals 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 32
Journal of Alternate Energy Sources & Technologies
Volume 11, Issue 2
ISSN: 2230-7982 (Online), ISSN: 2321-5186 (Print)
JoAEST (2020) 27–40 © STM Journals 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 33
Modeling of Overvoltage Protection by Lightning Dong and Hang
JoAEST (2020) 27–40 © STM Journals 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 34
Journal of Alternate Energy Sources & Technologies
Volume 11, Issue 2
ISSN: 2230-7982 (Online), ISSN: 2321-5186 (Print)
JoAEST (2020) 27–40 © STM Journals 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 35
Modeling of Overvoltage Protection by Lightning Dong and Hang
JoAEST (2020) 27–40 © STM Journals 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 36
Journal of Alternate Energy Sources & Technologies
Volume 11, Issue 2
ISSN: 2230-7982 (Online), ISSN: 2321-5186 (Print)
In a scenario with only MOV1 (see Figure 7), voltage on inverter increased to the protection
the overvoltage signal hit on cable near PV voltage level of MOV2, and was fixed at 286
modules. Only PV panels were under the full V after 45μsth. The voltage on load has
overvoltage signal as showed in Figure 11. fluctuated within 230 V as soon as the inverter
voltage was in a stable.
The voltage of MOV1 has quickly reached 585
V, and then slowly decreased to 535 V. Under CONCLUSION
MOV1 operation, the voltage on the inverter All overvoltage stresses by lightning could
and the load has gradually increased to about cause a severe damage. And the overvoltage
500 V. It is clear from Figure 11 that the protection in solar power system appear to be
voltage signal on load was much lower than very significant, especially in tropical
the input overvoltage signal, but this voltage countries like Vietnam.
level was still very dangerous for the electrical
devices with a rated voltage of only 220 V. Due to the advantages of capacitance and
resistance higher than other SPDs, MOVs
In a scenario of overvoltage protection with should be chosen for overvoltage protection in
both MOV1 and MOV2 (see Figure 8), the electrical systems, including grid-tied solar
lightning hit on cable near PV modules. systems, especially at locations in
Similar to the scenario of only MOV1, only thunderstorm areas like Vietnam. Depending
PV panels were affected fully by this on weather conditions and system structure,
overvoltage signal. The MOV1 voltage has the quantity and installation position of SPDs
climbed to 585 V in just 6 μs, and then kept at should be carefully considered to ensure the
535 V from 45μsth as displayed in Figure 12. cost and safety requirements.
The protection mode of MOV has been
activated to dissipate the overvoltage signal to In our study, due to the small system
ground. Following the MOV1 change, the structure and the short distances from the
JoAEST (2020) 27–40 © STM Journals 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 37
Modeling of Overvoltage Protection by Lightning Dong and Hang
main equipments, only two MOVs have been 6. Iromi Ranaweera, Mohan Lal Kolhe and
selected and installed at two locations for Bernard Gunawardana. Hybrid Energy
protecting the inverter and ensure the System for Rural Electrification in Sri
operation voltage on load. The simulations Lanka: Design Study, Green Energy and
were performed to understand the effects on Technology. Heidelberg: Springer; 2016.
PV panels, MOVs, inverter, and load doi: 10.1007/978-3-319-14663-8_7 (R1.3)
following a lightning strike. The results 7. Vietnam. Prime Minister. Decision No.
showed that lightning strikes to a fabricated 11/2017/QD–TTg dated 11/04/2017 on
system could cause high overvoltage signals Mechanism for encouragement of
at sites without surge arresters. Short development of solar power in Vietnam.
distances from terminals also were Hanoi: Vietnam Government;
advantageous for reducing the number of 2017,Available:https://vanbanphapluat.co/
SPDs and limiting damages from lightning decision-no-11-2017-qd-ttg-mechanism-
strikes to small and medium-sized power for-encouragement-of-development-of-
systems in urban areas in Vietnam. solar-power-in-vietnam-2017.
8. Vietnam. Prime Minister. Decision No.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS 02/2019/QD-TTg dated 08/01/2019
The authors are grateful to Vietnam amendments and supplements Decision
Electricity, University of Science and 11/2017/QD-TTg on Mechanism for
Technology of Hanoi, and Institute of Energy encouragement of development of solar
Science had sponsored for our study. power in Vietnam. Hanoi: Vietnam
Government; 2019.
REFERENCES 9. Vietnam. MoIT. Circular 16/2017/TT-
1. Klaus Jäger, Olindo Isabella, Arno H.M. BCT dated 12/09/2017 on Project
Smets, et al. Solar Energy: Fundamentals, development and model Power Purchase
Technology, and Systems. Delft: Delft Agreements applied to solar power
University of Technology; 1- projects. Hanoi: Ministry of Industry and
408,Available: Trade; 2017.
https://courses.edx.org/c4x/DelftX/ET.303 10. Vietnam. MoIT. Circular No. 05/2019/TT-
4TU/asset/solar_energy_v1.1.pdf,2014. BCT dated 11/3/2019 amendments and
2. Saurabh Kumar Rajput. Solar Energy - supplements Circular 16/2017/TT-BCT on
Fundamentals, Economic and Energy Project development and model Power
Analysis. Ghaziabad: Northern India Purchase Agreements applied to solar
Textile Research Association; 2017. power projects. Hanoi: Ministry of
ISBN: 978-93-81125-23-6 (R1.3) Industry and Trade; 2019.
3. Naveen Shankarappa, Mufassireen 11. Hoang Hai Son, Nguyen Xuan Anh, Le
Ahmed, Shashikiran N, et al. Solar Viet Huy, et al. Determination of lightning
Photovoltaic Systems – Applications & activity parameters from lightning
Configurations. International Research simulation data. Vietnam Journal of Earth
Journal of Engineering and Technology Sciences 2011; 33(2): 134-8p.
2017; 4(8):1851-5p. 12. Hugh J. Christian, Richard J. Blakeslee,
4. Parimita Mohanty, K. Rahul Sharma, Dennis J. Boccippio, et al. Global
Mukesh Gujar, et al. PV System Design frequency and distribution of lightning as
for Off-Grid Applications, Green Energy observed from space by the Optical
and Technology. Heidelberg: Springer; Transient Detector. Journal of
2016. doi: 10.1007/978-3-319-14663-8_3 Geophysical Research 2003; 108(D1): 1-
(R1.3) 15p. doi:10.1029/2002JD002347 (R1.3)
5. Ajay Kumar, Nitin Gupta and Vikas 13. Vietnam. Ministry of Construction of
Gupta. A Comprehensive Review on Grid- Vietnam. Vietnam Building Code: Natural
Tied Solar Photovoltaic System. Journal of Physical & Climatic Data for
Green Engineering 2017; 7:213–42p. doi: Construction, Hanoi: Ministry of
10.13052/jge1904-4720.71210 (R1.3) Construction of Vietnam; 2008, Available
JoAEST (2020) 27–40 © STM Journals 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 38
Journal of Alternate Energy Sources & Technologies
Volume 11, Issue 2
ISSN: 2230-7982 (Online), ISSN: 2321-5186 (Print)
JoAEST (2020) 27–40 © STM Journals 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 39
Modeling of Overvoltage Protection by Lightning Dong and Hang
Transactions on Electromagnetic
Compatibility 2012; 54(4): 880-9p. doi: Cite this Article
10.1109/TEMC.2011.2176131 (R1.3) Ngo Nguyen Dong, Le Thi Thuy Hang.
31. Alberto De Conti, and Silverio Visacro. Modeling of Overvoltage Protection by
Analytical Representation of Single- and Lightning for a Grid-tied Solar Power
Double-Peaked Lightning Current Wave System: A case of Vietnam. Journal of
forms, IEEE Transactions on Electro Alternate Energy Sources & Technologies.
magnetic Compatibility 2007; 49(2): 448- 2020; 11(2): 27–40p.
4p. doi: 10.1109/TEMC.2007.897153 (R1.3)
JoAEST (2020) 27–40 © STM Journals 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 40