Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 9

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/285323442

Subsea multiphase pumping system X gas lift: an exergo-economic


comparison

Article · December 2004


DOI: 10.5380/ret.v3i2.3531

CITATIONS READS

10 239

3 authors, including:

Silvio De Oliveira Junior Elisio FILHO Caetano Filho


University of São Paulo Petróleo Brasileiro S.A.
197 PUBLICATIONS   1,642 CITATIONS    26 PUBLICATIONS   325 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Ejetores na Elevação de Petróleo View project

Worldwide Exergy Community: aeronautics View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Elisio FILHO Caetano Filho on 30 May 2016.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


Subsea Multiphase Pumping System x Gas Lift:
An exergo-economic comparison

Celso Y. Nakashima – celyukio@usp.br


Silvio de Oliveira Júnior – silvio.oliveira@poli.usp.br
Polytechnic School - University of São Paulo – Mechanical Engineering Department - Av.
Prof. Mello Moraes, 2231 - Cidade Universitária Armando de Salles Oliveira - CEP
05508-900 - São Paulo, SP – Brazil
Phone: 55 11 3818-5561 ext. 220; Fax: 55 11 3813-1886

Elisio F. Caetano – ecaetano@cenpes.petrobras.com.br


PETROBRAS – R&D Center (CENPES)
Ilha do Fundão - Quadra 7 - CEP 21949-900 - Rio de Janeiro, RJ – Brazil
Phone: 55 21 3865-6581; Fax: 55 21 3865-6796

ABSTRACT P – pressure (bar)


In this paper, it is presented a methodology for Q – heat rate (kW)
an exergetic comparison between two artificial R – universal gas constant (kJ/kmol.K)
lift systems: a gas lift and a twin-screw SMPS – subsea multiphase pumping system
multiphase pump system. A software SMPS-00 – SMPS at lower operational limit
(Hysys.Process v2.1) was used to simulate an SMPS-60 – SMPS at upper operational limit.
offshore platform with the artificial lift methods V – flow rate (m3/s)
and calculate all properties (including exergy) W – power (kW)
of the material and energy streams. The twin- c – specific cost (US$/kWh), mass fraction of
screw multiphase pump behavior was carbon; component
simulated with a thermodynamic model h – mass fraction of hydrogen
developed recently. The operational n – mass fraction of nitrogen
conditions of the PETROBRAS 7-MRL-72D- o – mass fraction of oxygen
RJS well operating with the cited systems s – sulfur
were predicted by an internal study conducted x – molar fraction
in PETROBRAS (BARUZZI et al. [1] and Greek symbols
partially published in BARUZZI et al. [2]). The ∆ – variation, difference
comparisons cover the range of 2000 to 2020, α - relation chemical exergy/ heating value
the same range adopted in the study. Results η - efficiency
show that in general the production costs are Subscripts
lower when the multiphase pump is used. The bo – boiler
main advantages of this method over the gas ch – chemical
lift is the absence of material (gas) recycle el – electric
and a better energy management. gas – gas
gl – lift gas
he – heat exchanger
NOMENCLATURE i – component
rej – rejects
Symbols tg – gas turbine
B – exergy (flow rate (kW); specific (kJ/kmol)) wp – water circuit pump
GL – gas lift system Superscripts
GVF – gas volumetric fraction 0
– initial, standard, reference
NHV – net heating value (kJ/kmol)
INTRODUCTION make possible exploitation in ultra deep
The objective of this paper is to present the waters.
results of a comparative analysis, which was
carried out to check the influence of a subsea GAS LIFT SYSTEM
multiphase pumping system (SMPS) in deep- The gas lift system is the most common
water petroleum boosting. The balance of artificial lift method used in subsea petroleum
costs of two boosting systems, SMPS and boosting. In this system, part of the gas
Gas Lift (GL), working with an off shore separated in the platform is recompressed
platf orm wer e calculated in an exergetic with a gas lift compressor and returns to the
basis. With these balances, it is possible to well where it is downhole injected in the
determine production costs of the two production column, as shown in fig. 3. With
systems. The costs evaluated in an exergetic this gas injection, the petroleum specific
basis allow the performance of the systems to weight is reduced, the pressure in the well
be compared in a rational way. Moreover, it is head is lowered and the production increases.
possible to identify the main sources of
irreversibilities (inefficiencies) and directly
compare similar processes that occur in EXERGO-ECONOMIC ANALISYS
petroleum boosting systems. The evaluation
of SMPS’ performance among other Introduction
alternatives is necessary since there are The process plant of Marlim platform, which
several intrinsic advantages and was used as basis to all comparisons in this
disadvantages associated to the SMPS. paper, is represented in fig. 2. The plant is fed
Which must be assessed in order to establish with petroleum boosted from the well. This
the best operational conditions and scenarios petroleum is mixed with the recirculated liquid
for the best performance. and goes to the heat exchanger. The heated
mixture proceeds to the separators where it is
divided in oil, gas and water. Oil and gas are
TWIN-SCREW MULTIPHASE PUMP exported to the coast through pumps and
The twin-screw multiphase pump is a positive compressors and part of the gas is separated
displacement device with an axial flow through to be used as fuel in a cogeneration system.
the screws. In this kind of pump, the rotation The turbine is responsible for supplying
and meshing of the screws create one or electricity to pumps and compressors and the
more cavities which moves continuously from rejected gases are used in the boiler to heat
the suction to the discharge region (fig. 1). the water of the heat exchanger. Additional
Therefore, any type of product (liquid, gas or fuel is burned in the boiler when the rejected
solid) that can be introduced into the cavities
will be carried along to the discharge. This
characteristic allow the pump to transport
multiphase fluids with GVF varying from 0 to
95% (100% if 5% of liquid can be
recirculated). By simultaneously “pumping”
gas and liquid the multiphase pump could
minimize facilities in deepwater and reduce
operational costs, as cited by CAETANO et al.
[3]. For example, PETROBRAS has a subsea
system (SBMS-500) based in a twin-screw
multiphase pump, which will be installed in the
7-MRL-72D-RJS well, Campos Basin (see
BARUZZI et al. [2]). Its objective is to increase
well production through direct energy transfer
to the unprocessed fluids. The use of twin-
screw pumps is seen as a feasible option to
Figure 1: Twin-screw multiphase pump.
gases can not supply the required energy. Which would be valid for ideal mixtures only.
The efficiencies used in the platform However, as shown by RIVERO et al. [5],
equipments for the simulations are as follows: even though petroleum mixtures can not be
- isentropic efficiency of compression: 0.75; considered ideal, the calculations with this
- mechanical efficiency of compressors: 0.90; equation do not cause significative errors. The
- transmission efficiency: 0.95; standard exergy for the light components of
- isentropic efficiency of usual pumps: 0.75; the petroleum is tabulated in KOTAS [6]. The
- thermal efficiency of gas turbines: 0.30; composition of the heavy fraction of petroleum
- thermal efficiency of boiler: 0.80; is unknown. In this case, the heavy fraction is
- heat recov. system thermal efficiency: 0.60. divided in pseudo-components and the
standard chemical exergy of these
The methodology for exergy analysis of components have to be calculated based on
offshore platforms was presented by the net heating value (KOTAS [6]):
OLIVEIRA and VAN HOMBEECK [4]. In this
paper, this approach was further developed 0
B ch
with the inclusion of chemical exergy α = (2)
NHV
calculations. The exergo-economic analysis h o
was carried out by assuming a unitary value of α = 1,0401 + 0,1728 + 0,0432 +
the feed streams of the process. The c c
(3)
increment in the costs occurs only due to the s h
0,2169 1 − 2,0628 
irreversibilities associated with the processes. c c
Both chemical and physical exergies must be
calculated, otherwise an inconsistency would In this paper, it was considered that α has a
occur. The boiler and turbine use the gas constant value of 1.0401. The contaminants
chemical exergy in burning processes and the where not taken into account and the value
exergy balances would never be consistent h/c for heavy fractions is generally about 0.1.
without taking into account such values. The Therefore, its influence over α is less than 2%.
physical and chemical exergies were The heating value can be estimated using the
calculated with the software Hysys.Process equations suggested by GUTHRIE [7].
v2.1. The chemical exergy, following RIVERO
et al. [5], is calculated through equation (1): The cogeneration systems were simulated
apart with EES (Equation Engineering
C
Software). With the electricity and heating
Bch = ∑ (x B
i =1
i
0
ch,i + RT0 x i ln(x i )) (1)
demands, it is calculated the fuel consumption
and the exergy associated to the heat. As the
costs of electricity and rejects are unknown in
Gas Fuel
compressor
Wtg 3-phase separator
separator
heat exchanger

Adittional. Gas Fuel boiler


gas turbine
water feed pump
Feed

Gas

Oil

Figure 2: Process plant of Marlim platform.


the turbine, a partition criterion –equality or almost negligible and the increments are
extraction – must be adopted to allow small. Only in the cogeneration system the
calculations. In the equality method, the cost increase is higher owing to the elevated
electricity and rejected gases are both irreversibility of the combustion process. The
considered products of the turbine and the equality criterion seems to be more adequate
cost increment is shared equally among them. for this study. First because both electricity
The extraction method considers the and rejects are used in the process and
electricity generation as the objective of the second, as shown in table 2, the reduction in
turbine and the cost increment is transferred the turbine efficiency cause, in the extraction
only to the electricity by equalizing the costs of criterion, a reduction in the cost of the
rejected gases and fuel. The heat cost is produced oil. The cost increase, in this case,
calculated considering a control volume is transferred to the gas and this behavior is
including the set water circuit/boiler: not adequate unless one consider the gas as
the main product of the platform. Based on
c rej B rej + c gas B gas ,bo + c Wel W wp = c Qhe BQhe (4) these results, the equality criterion was used
for all the following calculations.
With these considerations, and having all
exergies calculated, all the costs of the
process can be calculated. It is an iterative SMPS x GL: Studied cases
calculation because the cost of the produced In this paper, two systems (SMPS and GL)
gas must be used to calculate the costs in the and three operational conditions were
cogeneration system. compared. The GL process plant used in the
simulations is in fig. 3. The GL was
Tables 1 and 2 show previous results, for considered as a compressor that injects the
three different turbine efficiencies, used to outlet gas in the petroleum flow downhole in
choose the partition criterion. The obtained the well.
costs show a small increase between the feed
and the discharge (oil and gas). This behavior
is due to the high chemical exergy values. Gas
Compared to such values, the destroyed Lift
exergy in the equipment of the process is

Table 1: Equality criterion – specific costs.


well
Exergy Flow ηtg
Stream
Rate (MW) 0.30 0.20 0.15 Figure 3: Platform/GL schematic process plant.
Feed 4134.5 1.000 1.000 1.000
Oil 3753.4 1.006 1.007 1.007 The SMPS is placed at the sea bed, in the
Gas 329.2 1.025 1.027 1.028 production line between the well and the
Electricity 6.3 1.932 2.085 2.140 platform. The SMPS have a broad range of
Heat 6.0 5.125 5.166 5.362 operational conditions and two limit situations
were chosen in this paper. The first one,
Table 2: Extraction criterion – specific costs. denoted here as SMPS-00, is the SMPS
working in order to give the same oil
Exergy Flow ηtg production obtained when the GL is used
Stream (dashed line in fig. 4). Due to the low flow rate,
Rate (MW) 0.30 0.20 0.15
the multiphase pump operates far bellow its
Feed 4134.5 1.000 1.000 1.000 maximum capacity. In the second one,
Oil 3753.4 1.006 1.005 1.004 denoted as SMPS-60, the pump operates with
Gas 329.2 1.034 1.048 1.061 the maximum allowable differential pressure
Electricity 6.3 2.725 3.825 4.874 (60 bar) with a higher flow rate (continuous
Heat 6.0 4.368 3.508 3.749 line in fig. 4). Table 3 shows the operational
Table 3: SMPS and GL operational conditions (Baruzzi et al. [1]).

GL SMPS-00 SMPS-60
Year 2000 2001 2010 2020 2000 2001 2010 2020 2000 2001 2010 2020
P (bar_g) 68 67.3 70.7 74.1 51.9 62 53 43.7 29 35 29.5 30
V (m3/h) 180 187.5 165.9 167.1 146.5 173.9 128.3 109.6 347.3 438.1 276.1 171.8
FVG 0.65 0.68 0.59 0.59 0.57 0.66 0.47 0.38 0.73 0.79 0.65 0.49
Vgl (Sm3/h) 4167 1667 4167 5833 - - - - - - - -
∆P (bar) - - - - 13.6 2.5 18.8 37 60 60 60 60
W (kW) - - - - 83.1 33.5 99.1 174.3 645.1 822 519.1 346

conditions for the three cases. All these petroleum processing. Which means that
values refer to the production line position maximum or minimum rotation, power and
where the SMPS will be installed. flow rate were ignored. For all the simulations,
some parameters were considered fixed:
2200 - Platform feed pressure: 21.6 barg;
2000 - Gas pressure at platform outlet: 172.6 barg;
SBMS - Oil pressure at platform outlet: 67.6 barg;
Oil flow rate (Sm3/d)

1800

1600
- Well outlet flow’s specific cost of: 1.0 $/kWh.
GL
1400
The specific costs were calculated for the
1200
years of 2000, 2001, 2010 and 2020. These
1000
years were chosen because the oil is
800 considered the main petroleum product and,
600 as shown in fig. 4, the oil production has two
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 distinct tendencies: one, between 2000 and
Year
2010, where the production is kept almost
Figure 4: Volumetric oil flow: GL e SMPS-60 constant, and the other, between 2010 and
(BARUZZI et al. [1]). 2020, where there is a linear reduction in the
oil flow. The year of 2001 was simulated
Production data because it is predicted a sudden increase in
Well production data with the use of artificial GVF in the first years which differs from the
lift methods were reported by Baruzzi et al. tendency of continuous decrease of the
[1]. In the report the 7-MRL-72D-RJS well following years. With this increase the
operating with SMPS or GL was simulated. multiphase pump have to deal with a higher
SMPS discharge conditions and absorbed volumetric flow rate and, in the GL case, there
power were calculated by using a is a lower necessity of lift gas. In this way, the
thermodynamic model for twin-screw behavior of the systems suffers a
multiphase pumps developed recently considerable change, which must be taken
(NAKASHIMA [8] or NAKASHIMA, OLIVEIRA into account in the comparisons.
and CAETANO [9]). Geometric parameters of
SBMS-500 were used for this purpose. SMPS Results: Heat and electricity
electrical motor efficiency was set to 0.8 Table 4 shows the total energy (heat and
during calculations. This low value is due to electricity) consumed in each case. These
the canned conception adopted for subsea results show that heat consumption with the
operation. The GL compressor adiabatic GL is slightly higher. This is due to the higher
efficiency was taken as 0.75. Heat exchange gas flow rate, a consequence of the lift gas
between ducts and environment was not recirculation. The difference is somewhat
considered, nor was the electricity lower in 2001, because there is a decrease in
transmission efficiency of the SMPS energy the necessity of lift gas, and rise a little again
cable. In this paper no operational limits were in the following years. The heat consumption
considered for any equipment involved in the with the SMPS-60, which should be the
Table 4: SMPS & GL – Heat and electricity consumption.

SMPS-00 GL SMPS-60
Year Electricity Heat Electricity Heat Electricity Heat
(kW) (kW) (kW) (kW) (kW) (kW)
2000 908.9 1330.3 1302.8 1581.4 2139.2 1170.6
2001 1154.1 1402.5 1319 1510.8 2900.1 1025.3
2010 779.3 1591.7 1173.5 1856.4 1693.1 1562.8
2020 551.9 1939.2 1066.6 2276.4 946.6 2038.3

highest values due to the high oil and gas flow instead of the GL. With the GL, part of the
rates, have a reduction in the first years owing produced gas will be burned to generate
to the higher shaft speed and friction power electricity that will be used to compress the
inside the pump. In 2020 the volumetric flow gas again. The compressed gas is, then, re-
decreases with the consequent reduction in injected downhole in the well in order to
the shaft speed and friction power and the reduce the specific weight of the petroleum. In
heat consumption raises. this case, besides the losses caused by
successive conversions of energy, part of the
The electricity consumption of the GL is driven gas is being processed (separated and
mainly by the compressors consumption, compressed) in a redundant way since this
which is large and approximately constant due gas, after previous processing, is re-
to the lift gas. Despite its variation, the compressed and mixed again with petroleum.
electric power of the pumps is a small part of Related to this aspect, the SMPS-00 has an
total power and its influence is not significant. advantage because has no material (gas)
The electricity consumption of the SMPS goes
along with the gas volumetric flow, which Feed
explains, in both cases, the initial increase 1.008
followed by a reduction of the consumed 1.007
electricity. With the SMPS-60, however, the
Specific cost ($/kWh)

SMPS-00
1.006
SMPS-60
electricity consumption is much higher. In this 1.005 GL
case, there is a considerable increase in the 1.004
mass flow of liquid and gas owing to the 1.003
reduction in the well head pressure. The 1.002
increase in the volumetric flow, however, is 1.001
much higher due to gas expansion. The large 1
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020
volumetric flow, together with the elevated Year
differential pressure, causes a higher power
consumption as seen in table 4. Figure 5: SMPS x GL – feed specific costs.

Results: specific costs


Figures 5 and 6 show the feed and oil specific Oil
1.0160
costs, in exergetic basis, calculated for the
1.0140
three studied cases. Comparing the GL and
Specific cost ($/kWh)

SMPS-00
1.0120
SMPS-00 cases, the resulting specific costs SMPS-60
show that the SMPS-00 allows lower feed and 1.0100 GL

oil specific costs. The main advantage of this 1.0080


system, when compared to the GL, is that 1.0060
there is not gas recirculation. The absence of 1.0040
this recirculation provides a reduction in the 1.0020
electric power consumed by the compressors, 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025
so the total electric power used in the platform Year

is lower when the SMPS-00 is employed


Figure 6: SMPS x GL – oil specific costs.
recirculation. The electric power produced in with the petroleum flow. Therefore, the
the plant is transferred directly to the influence of electricity and heat costs over the
petroleum flow through the multiphase pump, stream is stronger. Physically this means that
there is no gas recirculation. Therefore there part of the energy inputs are consumed to
is less gas to be processed by the separators process a substance with low value (water)
and compressors, which causes a reduction in which will not be part of the products. In the
the consumption of heat and electricity. heating process, for instance, the water is
Another advantage of the SMPS-00 is its heated, since it is part of the petroleum, and
subsea operating position. This is a high thrown away later on. The cost of the gas is
pressure location and, compared to surface lower with higher GVF because, in this case,
operations, allow the multiphase pump to work the percentage of dissolved gas, which is
with lower volumetric flow and, so, lower more difficult to separate, is lower.
energy consumption. These advantages,
however, depend clearly on the amount of When the GL is considered, the gas and oil
recirculating lift gas. In 2001, for instance, costs have a tendency to follow the magnitude
there is an increase in GVF – due to reservoir of the lift gas flow. The higher is this flow, the
characteristics and production conditions - larger are the costs. The lowest cost is
and a consequent lower necessity of lift gas. obtained in 2001 when the necessity of lift gas
Within this scenario, the multiphase pump is marginal. Before 2010 the lift gas flow
performance decreases and also decreases raises again and, besides, the amount of
the impact of gas recirculation in the GL. The water increases continuously as in the SMPS
consequence is a reduction in the difference case. These two factors causes the costs to
between SMPS-00 and GL production costs. increase again.
In 2010 and 2020, with the opposite situation,
the difference in production costs raises The SMPS-60 has in general the same
again. Therefore, the higher is the necessity of behavior of the SMPS-00. However, as shown
lift gas, the better is the advantage of the in the previous item, there is an increase
SMPS for the studied well. mainly in the electricity consumption, which
modifies the use of the energy inputs.
The cost of the heat decreases as the
electricity consumption increases. With the When the costs for the two conditions (SMPS-
higher electricity demand, the turbine 00 and SMPS-60) of the SMPS are compared
consumes more fuel and it is possible to have (figures 5 and 6), it is possible to see that the
a further use of the rejected gases in heat cost in the platform feed increases in the
generation. This means that more fuel is used SMPS-60 case. Several parameters
to produce electricity and less fuel is burned in contribute to this increase: higher viscous
the boiler. The better use of the gas fuel losses due to higher shaft speeds, higher
allows a reduction in the heating cost. The backflow rates due to higher differential
electricity cost has just a little fluctuation and pressures and higher GVFs, which causes
follows the cost of the fuel gas. higher internal recirculation inside the
multiphase pump. The lower multiphase pump
By analyzing only the SMPS-00, one can see efficiency causes higher feed costs. However,
that the cost of the produced oil enhances when the oil costs are compared, it is possible
continuously. In 2001, the small cost to realize that the SMPS-60 has lower costs
increment is due to performance degradation despite of the higher feed values. Due to the
in the multiphase pump owing to high GVF. In high electricity consumption, all the heat
2010 and 2020, the increment occurs mainly required by the process is obtained from the
due to the decreasing oil flow. The total (water turbine reject and there is no necessity of
+ oil) liquid flow rate is kept almost constant - additional combustion in the boiler. This
Fig. 3 shows only the oil flow rate - and the means that the gas is burned only to generate
increasing flow of water causes a reduction in electricity (and increase production) and not to
oil production and in the exergy associated heat the petroleum.
CONCLUSIONS do Brasil S.A. and Engo. Marcos Pereda in
The developed comparisons between GL and supporting the Hysys.Process v2.1 usage and
SMPS and presented in this paper indicate Dr. J.R. Fagundes Netto (PETROBRAS) for
that the employment of the SMPS could bring the supplied information on fluid prediction.
significant benefits in the offshore oil and gas
production. When the costs of the produced
oil are compared, the SMPS has always the REFERENCES
lowest values, which means that the [1] BARUZZI, J.O.A.; FAGUNDES NETTO, J.R.
operational flexibility provided by the e CAETANO, E.F. Operational Conditions
multiphase pump can be fully profited. With Forecast for the SBMS-500 in the Well 7-
this flexibility it is possible manage the pump MRL-72D-RJS, Technical Partial Report.
so the gas is burned only to generate CENPES/PETROBRAS, 2001.
electricity and increase the production while [2] BARUZZI, J.O.A., CAETANO, E.F. and
the heat is obtained entirely from the rejected FAGUNDES NETTO, J.R. “Production Forecast
gases. Such flexibility do not exist with the GL. for a Subsea Multiphase Pumping System in the
Marlim Field”, SPE Annual Technical
Conference and Exhibition, New Orleans, LA,
The advantage of the SMPS is much more
Sept. 30th.- Oct. 3rd.,2001.
evident when the GVF values are not so high.
[3] CAETANO, E.F. ; SILVA, R.M. ; da SILVA,
In this case, the multiphase pump R.G. ; CAMARGO, R.M.T. e ROHLFING, G.
performance increases and the need of lift gas “Petrobras and Bornemmann Pumpen
is higher. When the GVF is high, the Cooperation on Multiphase Flow Pumping”.
performance of the SMPS could be improved Proceedings of the 1997 29th Annual
by installing the SMPS in a high pressure Offshore Technology Conference, OTC'97,
position (nearer the well head). This could v.3, Houston, TX, USA, p. 109-118, 1997.
reduce the volumetric flow and the power [4] OLIVEIRA Jr., S and VAN HOMBEECK, M.
consumption (not considering the electricity “Exergy Analysis of Petroleum Separation
transmission efficiency). Processes in Offshore Platforms”. Energy
Conversion and Management,, v.38, No. 15-
The cost values can change according to the 17, p. 1577-1584, 1997.
platform configuration since the processes [5] RIVERO, R.; RENDÓN, C. and MONROY, L.
involved in petroleum production will define “Calculation of the Exergy of Crude Oil
the costs. For different process plants it is Mixtures”, Proceedings of the International
necessary to evaluate the methods again. The Congress ECOS´98, v.1, p. 211-218, July of
production costs when the platform operates 1998.
bellow its capacity would be higher. The lower [6] KOTAS, T.J., The Exergy Method of
is the production, the higher is the cost. In Thermal Plant Analysis, Butterworths, London,
theory, this would increase the advantage of 1985.
[7] GUTHRIE, V.B. Petroleum Products
the SMPS over lower productivity methods. It
Handbook. McGraw Hill Book Company.
is possible to use the SMPS to fulfill the
London, 1960.
platform capacity. An exact evaluation, [8] NAKASHIMA, C.Y. Thermodynamic Model
however, must take into account equipment of a Twin-Screw Multiphase Pump, MSc
and operational costs. Dissertation, Polytechnic School of the
University of São Paulo, 2000 (in Portuguese).
[9] NAKASHIMA, C.Y.; OLIVEIRA Jr., S. and
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS CAETANO, E.F. “Thermodynamic Model of a
Authors are thankful to: CTPETRO and Twin-Screw Multiphase Pump”, ASME
PETROBRAS, for their support in the referred Engineering Technology Conference on
study and also for their permission to submitt Energy, Paper ETCE2002/PROD-29164,
this paper to publication; the Chemical February 4-6,2002, Houston, TX. (accepted for
Engineering Department at USP, which the proceedings).
allowed the use of the Simulation Laboratory [10] HYPROTECH , Hysys version 1.1 –
and the program Hysys.Process v2.1; Soteica Reference vol. 1 e 2. Hyprotech Ltd., 1996.

View publication stats

You might also like