Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sag Generator
Sag Generator
Abstract -- Power line voltage sags are among the most class of electronic loads, which includes power electronics
frequent and costly power quality problems. Most equipment based motor drives (inverter drives), constant power type
must be designed such that they can tolerate voltage sags (within loads draw large current during deep voltage sags and trip the
limits defined according to some standards). Furthermore, some drive (due to current overloading) or blow the fuses bringing
equipment must continue proper operation even under extreme
sag conditions (critical loads) and this property often may not be the system to a halt. During a deep sag, constant impedance
accommodated inside the device itself and sag compensating type loads may be forced out of their intended operating
power conditioners have been developed for such purposes. region, rendering the load partially ineffective or more
While in practice voltage sags are not wanted, generating sags drastically leaving it out of operation. In addition to the
becomes necessary for the purpose of experimentally verifying downtime of the installation using the sag affected
the performances of the equipment (both the equipment under equipment, the equipment damages and hazards are often
sag condition and the sag compensating power conditioner)
under sag conditions. In this work, a simple and economical, yet very high. In manufacturing lines, processes, public
highly performing sag generator is developed, its design infrastructures, etc., the cost of voltage sag based failure is
discussed, and its feasibility demonstrated by experiments. The usually unacceptable that a method to mitigate the sag effect
proposed SSR (solid state relay, a semiconductor power module is mandatory [1], [2].
of triac characteristics) and variable transformer (variac) based In order to avoid the voltage sag problems, the sensitivity
sag generator is built for three-phase 10kVA ratings and
of the equipment fed from the AC grid to voltage sags can be
balanced/imbalanced voltage sags are demonstrated in the
laboratory. The performance under resistive and inductive loads decreased to sufficient levels by design or by utilization of
is evaluated and finally the utilization of the sag generator in the auxiliary devices. For example, in electronic boards fed from
test of a series active filter based power quality conditioner is switch-mode regulators and in inverter drives using AC/DC
demonstrated. The proposed approach provides an effective rectifier stage, the rectifier stage can be designed to sustain
solution for voltage sag generation. operation during voltage sags. In such systems, the rectifier
stage involves an electrolytic capacitor bank for rectifier
Index Terms-- DVR, generator, power quality, sag, sag
generator, series active filter, solid state relay, SSR, thyristor,
output voltage filtering. By increasing the size of the
variable transformer, voltage sag electrolytic capacitor, the energy storage capability of the
device can be increased to a sufficient level to maintain
I. INTRODUCTION power to the load during a voltage sag. Alternatively the
design may involve a DC bus voltage control stage (using a
Power line voltage sags may typically be triggered by
PWM boost rectifier) and the load can ride-through a sag
natural causes (by lightning or by icing of transmission lines)
adequately. Further, in some applications, external (auxiliary)
or by some loading conditions (start-up of large motor drives
units can be utilized for sag ride-through. For example, an
or rectifiers without soft-starters/precharge circuits which
energy storage unit may be interfaced with the DC bus of the
draw large inrush currents, arc furnaces exhibiting low
rectifier (using a power electronic converter) and transfer
impedance and imbalanced load characteristics and drawing
energy to the DC bus of the load during the sag such that the
large magnitude imbalanced currents). They are the most
rectifier DC bus is sustained at/above the critical level for
frequent power quality problems in the power grid and they
proper operation [3]-[5]. In the more radical and usually more
usually have high economical impact on the voltage sensitive
expensive approach, sag compensating power quality
loads. In process control systems, control boards and motor
conditioning devices (sag correctors, dynamic voltage
drives, which are sensitive to sags may be adversely effected
restorers (DVRs), uninterruptible power supplies (UPSs),
due to voltage sag and processes may be halted. Repair and
etc.) are inserted between the AC grid and the sensitive loads
restart of the processes usually is involved and costly. In the
[6].
4050
circuit current would flow due to the output short-circuit of SSRS and SSRR are continuously enabled (SSRS=SSRR=1) and
the variable transformer. In such a design, either the power in this case since RT exhibits a high impedance path
circuit would have to be derated or stresses in the circuit compared to the SSRS path, the current flows through SSRS
would be increased. Thus, this condition is avoided and the only. Once a sag is commanded (Ssag:1→0), the turn-off
resistive transition path is favored in the design. An SSR can signal is transmitted to SSRS. After SSRS is turned-off at the
only turn-on at the first voltage zero-crossing after a turn-on first current zero-crossing, the load current transfers to the
command and can only turn-off at the first current zero- path involving SSRR. In order to ensure that SSRS is turned-off
crossing after a turn-off command. Therefore, these three before turning-on the path with SSRV, the turn-on signal to
SSR devices are controlled (their gate signals are SSRV is generated by at least a half electrical period delay
programmed) in the sequence shown in Fig. 2 in order to such that a load current zero-crossing occurs and therefore
generate a voltage sag and to recover from it. SSRS turn-off is guaranteed [for 50Hz power line considering
a 10ms half cycle (Te/2=10ms), a delay of approximately
td=Te/2+Te/8=12.5ms is sufficient]. Following the generation
+ vsag − of the SSRV turn-on signal (approximately Te/8=2.5ms later),
the turn-off signal for SSRR is generated and at its zero-
SSRS crossing the load current transfers to the path involving the
RT variac, which gives the demanded sagged output voltage at
eS vS the load terminals. While the pre-sag condition output voltage
SSRR is the nominal utility grid voltage and the final voltage is the
Utility Variac Load
demanded sag voltage, during the transition, the load voltage
is a gracefully decaying sine voltage. The decaying sine
SSRV voltage shape is determined by the pre-sag load current
magnitude and the RT value (which can be specified by
Fig. 1. The voltage sag generator with 3-SSR (per phase) design).
For recovery from the voltage sag condition, the voltage
sag command removal (Ssag:0→1) is followed by the SSRR
SV 1 turn-on signal and approximately 2.5ms later the SSRV turn-
0 t off signal is generated. Hence, the load current transfers from
the path involving the variac to the path involving RT at the
SR 1
0 t first current zero-crossings after the SSRV turn-off command.
At least 10ms (approximately 12.5ms) later, the turn-on
SS 1 signal is applied to SSRS and the load current transfers from
0 t the path with RT to the path with SSRS. Hence, nominal load
S sag1 voltage resumes.
0 t The SSR gate signal patterns described in this section
12.5ms 2.5ms ensure both no voltage/current discontinuity at the load
terminal and no output short-circuit of the variac (regardless
1 the load type). The load voltage during the transition is
SV 0 t determined by the transition resistor RT and the load current.
While the load current is defined by the load characteristics
SR 1 external to the sag generator, the transition resistor is a design
0 t variable, and its design will be addressed in the next section.
SS 1
0 t III. POWER CIRCUIT DESIGN
The design of the power circuit of Fig. 1 is relatively
S sag1 simple. In a single-phase application, three single-phase SSR
0 t
modules, one variac and resistor are sufficient. In three-phase
2.5ms 12.5ms
applications, if only balanced sag is required a three-phase
variac can be used. If unbalanced sag is required, three
Fig. 2. Logic signals for initiating (top) and terminating (bottom) single-phase variacs become necessary. The three-phase
a voltage sag
applications require three resistors and three three-phase SSR
The sag command is provided with an external input to the modules. If only sag tests are required the voltage rating of
system via the logic signal of Ssag and “0” corresponds to the variac becomes the line nominal voltage. If surge is also
starting a sag while “1” corresponds to returning to normal considered, then maximum surge voltage becomes the variac
conditions. Under nominal load voltage conditions (Ssag=1), rating. The variac current rating is the nominal load current.
4051
In the design, the line voltage is assumed to be at its application (4.4Ω). The variac voltage levels are adjusted
nominal value, Es. A voltage sag with an amount of V*sag is according to the demanded sag value. Various tests have been
generated by the sag generator. When there is no sag, the conducted to demonstrate the performance of the sag
output voltage Vs is equal to Es, (V*sag=0 or 0% sag) and when generator. The performance has been demonstrated on two
there is full sag, the output voltage is zero (V*sag=Es or 100% distinct load types corresponding to two different use
sag). Depending on the intended sag amount the variac must purposes. First, generating a sag for the purpose of testing the
be adjusted properly. The output voltage during the sag behavior of a load under voltage sag conditions has been
transition is determined by the transition resistor RT and the considered, and here resistive (R) and inductive (RL) loads
load current IL as given in (1) for unity power factor (PF=1). have been employed. Secondly, to evaluate the performance
For gradual fall of the sagging voltage, the RT resistor voltage of a power quality conditioner under sagged utility voltage
drop should be less than the sag reference value as given in conditions, the sag generator is employed, and here a series
the inequality of (2). Defining a base resistance value of RB as active filter as harmonic isolator and load voltage regulator
in (3), and assuming that the sag range is 10-90% and the has been used as a sag compensator. For both experiments,
load current range is 10-100% of the nominal load current, the voltage sag command signal Ssag and the SSR gate signals
the inequality of (2) gives the required range for RT as 0.1RB SS, SR, SV generated via the electronic circuit are in
and 9RB. For example, a 220V-10kVA three-phase sag accordance with the proposed timing (of Fig. 2) and shown in
generator requires a variable resistor with a range between Fig. 5.
1.5Ω and 135Ω. Staying in conduction only for one
fundamental cycle in a sag test, the power rating of RT should
be selected considering the sag test frequency.
VS = ES − RT I L (1)
*
V sag ≥ RT I L (2)
RB = ES I L , rated (3)
4052
TABLE I the full functionality of the circuit and proper emulation of a
THE SAG GENERATOR COMPONENT LIST
real sag condition. In Fig. 9, the inductive load test provides
Component Type #
SSR Celduc SVT868394 520V 50A 3
detailed information on the sag generator internal behavior.
Chromium-Nickel
Not only it shows that RT is necessary for voltage/current
Resistor 3 continuity at the load terminals, but also it indicates that there
wound porcelain 10Ω
3-phase variac 380V (in) 435V (out) 26A 1 is a circulating current in the variac. As a current larger than
Heatsink 170AS 300mm 1 the load current flows through the resistor during the
Miniature circuit breaker 400V 40A 2 transition, it becomes apparent that this current limited by RT
Diode 1N4001 3 circulates through the variac via and resistor branches. Thus,
Timer 555 (in monostable mode) 1 this circulating current should be taken into account during
BJT 2N2222 3 the design step. In Fig. 10, the three-phase voltage
Inverter logic gate 74HC00 1 waveforms for the inductive load are shown for the balanced
30% sag and its recovery sequence, which proves that the
proposed circuit is able to generate the three-phase voltage
sag commanded by the signal Ssag.
iS c
eS SSRS ab vS LY
SSRR RY
R SSRV
Utility Load
n
n
Variac
Fig. 6. Three-phase sag generator inductive (RL) load test circuit diagram
4053
Fig. 8. For the 21Ω resistive load, at the beginning of a %30 voltage sag, the
sag generator output terminal voltage (purple, 100V/div), terminal current
(blue, 10A/div), SSRR current (green, 20A/div) and Ssag (yellow, 5V/div)
waveforms (time axis: 10ms/div) for the cases with SSRR (top) and without
SSRR (bottom)
Fig. 10. For the 16+16j Ω inductive load, the three-phase output terminal
voltage waveforms (100V/div) and Ssag (yellow, 5V/div) when the voltage
sag generator emulates %30 balanced voltage sag. (top): Sag and recovery.
(center): Zoom on the voltage sag initiation. (bottom): Zoom on the voltage
sag termination
4054
compensated properly. The sag generator helps test the
voltage regulation capability of the SAF under a line sag vLDC : 5V/div (480V offset)
condition. Fig. 12 shows the SAF response to the 30%
balanced voltage sag generated by the proposed circuit and vSa : 100V/div
shown by Fig. 13 at steady-state. Note that the nominal
voltage is 220Vrms and after the transient the sag condition
voltage is in the 142.6-146.4Vrms range (corresponding to
vSAFa : 50V/div
70% of 220Vrms). With the voltage sag generated as shown in
the figure, the SAF responds with high dynamics and restores
the load voltage such that the load DC bus voltage vLDC drops
by at most 5% and recovers this drop within 50ms while the iSa : 10A/div
source voltage vS drops by 30%. Thus, the sag generator
provides a good voltage sag emulation behavior and evaluates
the capability of the SAF as the power line conditioning
equipment. t : 50ms/div
In addition to the balanced sag case, Fig. 14 shows the
SAF response to the single-phase 30% voltage sag (as an Fig. 12. The compensation of the balanced 30% voltage sag by the SAF
based power conditioner. Top to bottom: Load DC bus voltage (vLDC,
unbalanced voltage sag) shown in Fig. 15. Similar to the 5V/div), sag generator phase-voltage (vSa, 100V/div), SAF phase voltage
balanced sag case, the sag generator creates appropriate sag (vSAFa, 50V/div), and load current (iSa, 10V/div)
voltages and the SAF restores the load voltage such that
negligible amount of second harmonic voltage content due to
the unbalance remains on vLDC.
+ vSAF −
iS c
eS vS
ab +
vLDC
vL
Utility −
c Nonlinear
ab
Rd C f Lf Load
n
Fig. 13. The three-phase terminal voltages of the sag generator at steady-state
Voltage Sag SAF for the 30% three-phase balanced sag
Generator
Aux. Power Supply vLDC : 5V/div (500V offset)
Fig. 11. The application of the voltage sag generator to the series active filter
based power conditioning system
vSa : 100V/div
TABLE II
SERIES ACTIVE FILTER PARAMETERS
eS Line phase-to-neutral voltage (50 Hz) 220 Vrms
LS Line inductance 200 µH vSAFa : 50V/div
CL Load capacitance 2.2 mF
RL Load resistance (10 kW) 24 Ω
N Transformer turns-ratio 2.5
VDC SAF DC bus voltage 500 V iSa : 10A/div
Lf Switching ripple filter inductance 2.2 mH
Cf Switching ripple filter capacitance 2.0 µF
Rd Switching ripple filter resistance 5.6 Ω
fPWM PWM frequency 20 kHz t : 50ms/div
Fig. 14. The compensation of the single-phase 30% voltage sag by the SAF
based power conditioner. Top to bottom: Load DC bus voltage (vLDC,
5V/div), sag generator phase-voltage (vSa, 100V/div), SAF phase voltage
(vSAFa, 50V/div), and load current (iSa, 10V/div)
4055
improve performance,” IEEE Tran. Ind. Applicat., vol. 35, pp. 1440-
1448, Nov./Dec. 1999.
[5] J. Holtz, W. Lotzkat, “Controled ac drives with ride-through capability
at power interruption,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Applicat., vol. 5, pp. 1275-
1283, Sept./Oct. 1994.
[6] W.E. Brumsickle, R.S. Schneider, G.A. Luckjiff, D.M. Divan, M.F.
McGranaghan, “Dynamic sag correctors: cost-effective industrial
power line conditioning,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. 37, no. 1, pp.
212-217, Jan./Feb. 2001.
[7] Information Technology Industry Council (ITIC), 1250 Eye Street NW
Suite 200, Washington DC, (http://www. itic.org).
[8] IEEE recommended practice for monitoring electric power quality,
IEEE Standard 1159-1992, 1992.
[9] A. McEachern, “Sag generator with switch-mode impedance,” U.S.
Patent 6 285 169, Sep. 4, 2001.
[10] W.M. Grady, R. Chan, G. C-Y. Chung, D. Gerez, W.B. Leuschner,
G.P. Olson, “Voltage sag/swell testing station,” U.S. Patent, 5886429,
March 23, 1999.
[11] M.L. Rockfield, T.P. Singh, S.C. Bhatt, “Non-rotating portable voltage
Fig. 15. The three-phase terminal voltages of the sag generator at steady-state sag generator,” U.S. Patent 5 920 132, July 6, 1999.
for the 30% single-phase unbalanced sag [12] D.J. Nastasi, S.D. Bunton, “Power disturbance generator,” U.S. Patent
7 218 122, May 15, 2007.
[13] EPRI Solutions, Voltage Sag Generator, Porto Sag
(http://www.eprisolutions.com).
V. CONCLUSION [14] E.R. Collins, R.L. Morgan, “A three-phase sag generator for testing
In this study, a simple and economical, yet highly industrial equipment,” IEEE Trans. Power Delivery, vol. 11, pp. 526-
532, Jan. 1996.
performing sag generator has been developed and its [15] Y. Ma, G.G. Karady, “A single-phase voltage sag generator for testing
application for the test of a power quality conditioner has electrical equipments,” IEEE-PES T&D 2008 Conf. Rec., pp. 1-5, April
been demonstrated. The proposed SSR and variable 2008.
[16] T. Jimichi, H. Fujita, H. Akagi, “Design and experimentation of a
transformer based sag generator has very simple design and dynamic voltage restorer capable of significantly reducing an energy-
can be easily manufactured and operated, therefore it is storage element,” Ind. Applicat. Conf. IAS, vol.2, pp. 896-903, October
suitable for most R&D and test labs to evaluate the 2005.
[17] SVT868394, Celduc, Three Phase Solid State Relay datasheet
performance of equipment under sag conditions (device (www.celduc.com).
under test or a sag compensating power quality conditioner). [18] O. S. Senturk, A. M. Hava, ‘‘High-performance harmonic isolation and
In the paper, the design of the SSR system has been discussed load voltage regulation of the three-phase series active filter utilizing
the waveform reconstruction method,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. 45,
and a design example has been given. To verify the proposed no. 6, pp. 2030-2038, Nov./Dec, 2009.
approach, the proposed SSR and variable transformer based
sag generator has been designed for three-phase 10kVA
ratings and balanced/imbalanced voltage sags have been
generated. Resistive and inductive load tests have illustrated
the feasibility of the method. Finally, the utilization of the sag
generator in the test of a series active filter based power
quality conditioner has demonstrated that the proposed
method provides an effective method for voltage sag
generation.
It is possible to replace the thyristor based SSRs of the
proposed circuit with the newly developing IGBT or
MOSFET based SSRs such that instantaneous sags (creating
phase jumps in three-phase systems) could also be generated.
Furthermore, automation of the sag tests via a microcontroller
based system is possible when using variable transformers
with DC motor based voltage regulation hardware.
REFERENCES
[1] R.C. Dugan, M.F. McGranaghan, S. Santoso, H.W. Beaty, Electrical
power systems quality, McGraw-Hill, 2nd edition, 2002.
[2] M. F. McGranaghan, D. R. Mueller, and M. J. Samotyj: “Voltage sags
in industrial systems,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. 29, no. 2, pp. 397-
403, 1993.
[3] K. Stockman, B. Didden, F. D’Hulster, and R. Belmans, “Bag the
sags,” IEEE Ind. Appl. Mag., vol. 6, pp. 59-65, Sep./Oct. 2004.
[4] J.L. Duran-Gomez, P.N. Enjeti, B. Ok Woo, “Effect of voltage sags on
adjustable-speed drives: A critical evaluation and an approach to
4056