Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 5

Matt Fernley

matt.fernley@gmpeurope.com At the Open


+44-20-7647 2806 February 2, 2010

Vedanta Resources PLC BUY


VED - LSE 2624p (intraday) Target: 3500p
What's changed
New Old
Slightly disappointing production results; good
Rating NC Buy progress of aluminium expansion
Target 3500p 3650p
EPS FY10E (US$) 1.68 2.47
EPS FY11E (US$) 5.65 6.80  Vedanta reported slightly disappointing FQ3/10
NAV/share (p) 3,015 3,161
Share Data production results with Zambian copper production
Shares - m (basic/fully diluted)
52-week high/low
288.2m/289.4m
2,967p/493p
particularly weak. Sales were also weaker than
Free float 40% expected in Zambian Copper and Iron Ore where
3M average daily volume
3M average daily value
1.7m
£41.4m
realised prices were lower than expected.
Market capitalisation US$12,042m
Enterprise value
Dividend yield
US$20,456m
1.0%
 The company surprised by including revenue from its
Total projected return 34% Phase 1 smelter at Jharsuguda for the first time;
Key financials
Revenue (US$m)
03/09
6,579
03/10E
7,836
03/11E
14,049
previously this had been capitalised.
EBIT (US$m) 1,139 1,856 5,035
Net income adj. (US$m) 244 533 1,792  We have cut our FY10-12E EBITDA by 12%, 6% and
EPS adj./dil. (US$) 0.84 1.68 5.65
CEPS adj./dil (US$) 2.48 3.43 8.06 2% respectively, due mainly to cuts at KCM, Sesa
Net DPS (US$)
Summary metrics
0.41
03/09
0.55
03/10E
1.87
03/11E
Goa and the Indian copper operations.
EBIT margin % 17.3 23.7 35.8
ROIC (EBIT) % 9.0 10.3 27.4  We lower our price target to 3500p from 3650p, but
EV/EBITDA x 13.9 9.3 3.9 re-iterate our BUY rating on the company’s strong
PE x 49.6 24.9 7.4
P/CF x 16.9 12.2 5.2
near-term production growth, diversification and
exposure to Indian demand.

SLIGHTLY DISAPPOINTING FQ3/10 PRODUCTION RESULTS


Vedanta reported FQ3/10 production results that were slightly below our estimates, with Zambian
Copper the most disappointing. Revenues were particularly disappointing in the Zambian Copper and
Iron Ore (Sesa Goa) businesses with weak production impacting in Zambia and lower than expected
realised prices impacting at Sesa Goa.
The company reported revenues and EBITDA from phase 1 of the Jharsuguda aluminium smelter for
the first time which buoyed the results for the aluminium division.

Prepared by GMP Securities Europe LLP


See important disclosures at end of this report. February 2, 2010
Matt Fernley
matt.fernley@gmpeurope.com
+44-20-7647 2806

Vedanta FQ3/10 results (unaudited) vs GMP estimates

FQ3/10
GMPe Actual Diff
Sales
Aluminium (incl. Power) 205 287 39%
Indian Copper 825 753 -9%
Zambian Copper 341 265 -22%
Zinc 433 446 3%
Iron ore 495 390 -21%
EBITDA
Aluminium (incl. Power) 33 82 147%
Indian Copper 56 39 -31%
Zambian Copper 75 36 -52%
Zinc 293 291 -1%
Iron ore 336 217 -35%

Source: Company data, GMP estimates

CHANGES TO OUR FORECASTS


 The continuing underperformance from the Zambian copper division has led us to cut our
production, and hence earnings, forecasts substantially for FY10-12E. We have also increased
our unit cost estimates, resulting in a reduction of our EBITDA estimate for FY10E by 31%, for
FY11E by 15% and for FY12E by 4%.

 We have cut our EBITDA estimates for Sesa Goa in FY10E to reflect the weaker than
expected FQ3/10 sales and have further lowered our FY11E and FY12E forecasts.

 We have cut our forecasts at the Indian Copper operations to reflect slightly higher than
expected operating costs.

 We have increased our FY10E forecast for the aluminium division to reflect the fact that the
company is now including the Jharsuguda phase 1 smelter in the P&L.

 These changes result in a 12% decline in our FY10E forecast, a 6% cut in FY11E and a 2%
cut in FY12E.
Changes to our estimates

Sales EBITDA
Mar-10 Mar-11 Mar-12 Mar-10 Mar-11 Mar-12
Aluminium 4% 0% 0% 12% 0% 0%
Indian copper -5% -4% -4% -17% -10% -9%
KCM -15% -15% -4% -31% -15% -4%
HZL 1% 2% 4% -1% 0% 3%
Sesa Goa -15% -7% -7% -25% -10% -9%
Total -6% -4% -2% -12% -6% -2%

Source: GMP estimates

February 2, 2010
Matt Fernley
matt.fernley@gmpeurope.com At the Open
+44-20-7647 2806 February 2, 2010

VALUATION UPDATE
We value Vedanta using a simple average of two valuation metrics; a DCF-derived sum of the parts
(SotP) valuation and a multiple on our CY11E EBITDA forecast.
Our SotP valuation is based on DCFs for the company’s major operating divisions for the period
FY10-20E using the parameters in the table below. It yields a value of 3015p per diluted share.
Vedanta Resources SotP valuation

Sterlite Vedanta
Copper KCM HZL MALCO BALCO Aluminium Sesa Goa Power Other Group
PV of cash flow 2010-20E US$m 479 1,927 5,630 -30 2,164 4,804 6,280 892 -420 21,725
PV of TV US$m 306 19 2,709 -51 1,570 4,503 227 2,665 0 11,948
Total PV US$m 785 1,946 8,339 -81 3,733 9,308 6,507 3,557 -420 33,674
Net debt / (Net cash) US$m 4,773 4,773
Minority interests US$m 337 401 3,852 -6 2,648 1,181 2,790 1,529 12,733
PV of Equity US$m 447 1,545 4,487 -76 1,085 8,127 3,717 2,027 -5,193 16,167
No. of shares in issue m 317 317 317 317 317 317 317 317 317 317
Value per share (fd) US$ 1.41 4.87 14.14 -0.24 3.42 25.61 11.71 6.39 -16.37 50.95
Value per share (fd) GBp 83 288 837 -14 202 1516 693 378 -968 3,015

Discount rate % 8% 11% 11% 11% 11% 11% 11% 8% 8%


LT growth rate % 1.5% 2.5% 2.5% 2.5% 2.5% 2.5% 2.5% 3.5% 2.5%

Vedanta's interest % 57% 79% 54% 93% 29% 87% 57% 57%

Source: GMP estimates


Our multiple-derived valuation metric yields a value of 5704p per diluted share, based on a 5.0x
EV/EBITDA multiple.
While the two metrics seem to yield widely disparate valuations, we note that they are measuring
different things. The multiple-based approach is highly leveraged to near-term growth, which we expect
to be significant, while the DCF valuation measures cash flow across the cycle.
We believe that both approaches are relevant when deriving a fair value for the company, so we take
an average of the two which yields a value of 4360p. We apply a 20% discount to this valuation
because of the company’s conglomerate structure.

CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATION


Following slightly weaker than expected FQ3/10 production data, we are lowering our price
target to 3500p from 3650p. However we still believe Vedanta is one of the most attractive
metals and mining stocks in the sector due to its strong near-term growth outlook, diversified
product offering and exposure to strong Indian materials demand growth.
We re-iterate our BUY rating.

Prepared by GMP Securities Europe LLP


See important disclosures at end of this report. February 2, 2010
Matt Fernley
matt.fernley@gmpeurope.com At the Open
+44-20-7647 2806 February 2, 2010

y/e Mar (US$m) 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010E 2011E 2012E
PROFIT & LOSS
Revenues 3,702 6,502 8,204 6,579 7,836 14,049 18,705
Cost of sales 2,635 3,798 5,193 4,967 5,424 8,248 9,729
EBITDA 1,067 2,704 3,010 1,612 2,412 5,801 8,977
D&A 158 195 430 473 556 766 843
EBIT plus investment income & pension items 944 2,504 2,577 1,139 1,856 5,035 8,134
Net interest income/(expense) -57 -63 -219 -288 -458 -400 -336
Other financials income/(expense) 48 45 265 362 362 362 362
Pre-tax income 934 2,487 2,637 1,181 1,746 4,701 7,594
Adjusted PTP 934 2,488 2,626 1,213 1,746 4,701 7,594
Taxation -280 -673 -758 -281 -415 -1,117 -1,804
Post-tax income 653 1,814 1,880 900 1,332 3,585 5,790
Minority interests -281 -878 -1,127 -681 -799 -1,792 -2,895
Net income (reported) 372 936 753 219 533 1,792 2,895
Net income (adjusted earnings) 372 938 745 244 533 1,792 2,895
Per share data (US$)
EPS (adjusted, basic) 1.30 3.27 2.59 0.85 1.85 6.22 10.05
EPS (adjusted, diluted) 1.27 2.95 2.33 0.84 1.68 5.65 9.12
Cash EPS (adjusted earnings plus dep. & amort, diluted) 1.81 3.56 3.68 2.48 3.43 8.06 11.78
Shares outstanding (period average, basic) 286.8 286.9 287.8 287.2 288.2 288.2 288.2
Shares outstanding (fully diluted) 293.5 317.9 319.5 289.4 317.3 317.3 317.3

Source: Company data, GMP estimates

GMP Securities Europe LLP (“GMP”) is authorised by the Financial Services Authority and is a member of the London Stock Exchange.

Company disclosures

1 GMP or any of its group affiliated companies has, within the previous 12 months, provided paid investment banking services or acted as underwriter to the issuer.
2 GMP or any of its group affiliated companies is a market maker for the securities of the issuer.
3 non-voting
4 subordinate-voting
5 restricted-voting
6 multiple-voting
7 the analyst who prepared this report has viewed the material operations of this issuer.
8 the analyst who prepared this research report owns this issuer's securities.
9 limited voting
10 GMP or any of its group affiliated companies owns 1% or more of this issuer’s securities.
* The analyst is related to a member of the Board of Directors of [name of company], but that individual has no influence in the preparation of this report.
**[Other disclosure]

Prepared by GMP Securities Europe LLP


See important disclosures at end of this report. February 2, 2010
Matt Fernley
matt.fernley@gmpeurope.com At the Open
+44-20-7647 2806 February 2, 2010

Disclaimer

This report is intended for the sole use of the person for whom it is addressed and is distributed only so far as may be permitted by applicable law. Securities
described herein may not be eligible for sale in all jurisdictions or to certain categories of investor. The information contained herein should not be relied upon by any
other recipients including private clients. The information contained in this document is provided at the date of publication and is drawn from sources believed to be
reliable but has not been independently verified, therefore, the accuracy or completeness of the information is not guaranteed, nor does the information purport to
cover all information available on the subject, nor in providing it does GMP Securities Europe LLP (“GMP”) or any group company or firm or associate assume any
responsibility or liability except to the extent required by applicable law. The information contained in this report may be based on assumptions and different
assumptions may produce materially different information. The analyst responsible for preparation of this report may interact with sales and trading personnel and
other departments in collating and interpreting market information. Information on which this report is based is retained in accordance with regulatory requirements
and may be made available upon request. This report is published for information purposes and is not to be construed as an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to
buy any securities in any jurisdiction. Past performance is not indicative of future performance. Investors should be aware that the value of investments can rise or fall
and need to be aware of these risks in exercising investment decisions. Foreign currency exchange rates can also adversely affect investment returns. GMP
Research will initiate, report and cease coverage at the sole discretion of GMP and is under no obligation to update information herein.

GMP and group affiliated companies or persons or employees thereof may participate in an underwriting of, have a position in, or make a market in, the securities
mentioned herein, including options, futures or other derivative instruments thereon, and may, as principal or agent, buy and sell such products. Griffiths McBurney
Corp., an affiliate of GMP, accepts responsibility for the contents of this research subject to the foregoing. U.S. clients wishing to effect transactions in any security
referred to herein should do so through Griffiths McBurney Corp. GMP will provide upon request a statement of its financial condition and a list of the names of its
principals and senior officers.

Each research analyst and associate research analyst who authored this document and whose name appears herein certifies that (1) the recommendations and
opinions expressed in the research report accurately reflect their personal views about any and all of the securities or issuers discussed herein that are within their
coverage universe and (2) no part of their compensation was, is or will be, directly or indirectly, related to the provision of specific recommendations or views
expressed herein.
GMP Analysts are compensated competitively based on several criteria, including performance assessment criteria based on quality of research. The Analyst
compensation pool is comprised of general revenue sources including that from sales and trading and investment banking. GMP policies do not allow the issuer to
pay any expenses associated with a visit to its material operations by the Analyst. GMP prohibits any director, officer, employee or Canadian agent of GMP from
holding any office in publicly traded companies.

Key
The GMP research recommendation structure consists of the following categories:
FOCUS BUY. Small cap stocks (defined as stocks with less than $500 million market capitalization) in this category have a total return potential (including dividends
payable) of greater than 25% and large cap stocks a greater than 20% total return potential, as well as superior qualitative and timing characteristics.
BUY. These stocks will have 15% or greater (small cap) or 10% or greater (large cap) total return potential.
SPECULATIVE BUY. These stocks will have a 30% or greater total potential return and they will have a speculative component which could be material to the return
expectations.
HOLD. Small cap stocks ranked Hold will have a total return potential of 0% to 15%; large cap stocks ranked Hold will have a total return potential of 0 to 10%; and
stocks that have a speculative component which could be material to the return expectations ranked HOLD will have a total return potential of 0% to 30%.
REDUCE. Companies ranked Reduce have a negative potential total return.
FOCUS REDUCE. Companies ranked Focus Reduce have a significant negative potential total return and materially compromised qualitative and timing
characteristics.
Note: Analysts have discretion within 500 basis points of the upper and lower limit of each rating to determine the recommendation.

All disclosures contained in this document are governed by English law.

United Kingdom: this information is issued for the benefit of persons who qualify as eligible counterparties or professional clients and should be made available only
to such persons and is exempt from the restriction on financial promotion in s21 of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 in reliance on provision in the
Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (Financial Promotion) Order 2005 particularly Article 19(5) for Investment Professionals and Article 49(2) for entities of
prescribed net worth.

Other countries: circulation of this report may be restricted by laws and regulations in other countries and persons in receipt of this document must satisfy legal
requirements in that country.

© GMP. All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is


prohibited. 4 Albemarle Street, London W1S 4GA Tel 0044 20 7647 2800 Fax 0044 20 7647 2801.

Prepared by GMP Securities Europe LLP


See important disclosures at end of this report. February 2, 2010

You might also like