Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Clostridial Toxins
Clostridial Toxins
Clostridium perfringens gas gangrene is, without a doubt, the most fulminant necrotizing infection that affects
humans. In victims of traumatic injury, the infection can become well established in as little as 6–8 h, and
the destruction of adjacent healthy muscle can progress several inches per hour despite appropriate antibiotic
coverage. Shock and organ failure are present in 50% of patients and, among these, 40% die. Despite modern
medical advances and intensive-care regimens, radical amputation remains the single best life-saving treatment.
Over the past century, much has been learned about the pathogenesis of this disease, and novel therapies are
on the horizon for patients with this devastating infection.
toxins [1]. Thus, these studies support a principal role for thiol- opment of shock. For example, a prompt reduction in cardiac
activated cytolysins in the pathogenesis of their respective index (CI) occurred in rabbits that received either PLC or a
diseases. crude toxin preparation [9] (figure 1). Although many physi-
PLC and PFO each contribute to the morbidity and morality ological mechanisms could contribute to such a reduction, we
of gas gangrene by uniquely different mechanisms, which are subsequently demonstrated a direct reduction in myocardial
detailed in the following sections. PLC is hemolytic, is cytotoxic contractility (dF/dt) in isolated atrial strips bathed with recom-
to platelets and leukocytes, and increases capillary permeabil- binant PLC (rPLC) [9]. As reflected by the increased mortality
ity—effects that are likely related to its ability to cleave sphin- in the rabbits that received rPLC and crude toxin, a greater
gomyelin and the phosphoglycerides of choline, ethanolamine, reduction in CI was also measured in these groups compared
and serine present in eukaryotic cell membranes. PLC requires with those that received recombinant PFO (rPFO) or normal
calcium for optimal activity. Zinc enhances a-toxin production saline [9]. Similarly, a marked decline in mean arterial pressure
in culture and is essential for its activity in vivo. Histidine (MAP) was observed in rabbits treated with rPLC and crude
residues have been shown to be essential for the binding of toxin, although these effects were delayed until the later stages
zinc ions. Basak et al. [7] have recently crystallized a-toxin and of the experiment (figure 2) [9]. Thus, rabbits that received
have provided preliminary X-ray diffraction analysis of the pro- PLC-containing toxin preparations maintained MAP in the face
tein. Titball et al. [8] have determined that the protein is com- of a falling CI by as-yet-uncharacterized compensatory mech-
posed of 2 functional domains: the N-terminal domain pos- anism for a brief period before hypotension ultimately oc-
sesses the phospholipase C activity and the C-terminal domain curred. The physiological mechanisms that maintained MAP
binds to eukaryotic cell membranes. did not include significant changes in heart rate or central
venous pressure until the terminal stages of the experiments,
if at all [9].
PATHOGENESIS OF SHOCK AND ORGAN
In contrast, rabbits treated with rPFO demonstrated changes
FAILURE
most characteristic of “warm shock,” with profound falls in
Hemodynamic collapse is a common occurrence in patients peripheral vascular resistance after ∼1 h of toxin infusion [9,
with gas gangrene caused by C. perfringens. In experimental 10]. Of interest, rabbits that received crude toxin (containing
studies, both PLC and PFO uniquely contribute to the devel- both PLC and PFO activity) demonstrated peripheral vascular
resistance (PVR) values intermediary to the other toxin groups. reduction occurs undoubtedly through the induction of en-
This latter observation provides insights into possible antago- dogenous mediators that cause relaxation of blood vessel wall
nistic interactions between rPFO and rPLC in terms of PVR. tension [15]. Reduced vascular tone develops rapidly, and, to
In total, these experiments suggest that PLC initially augments maintain adequate tissue perfusion, a compensatory host re-
cardiac function, counteracting the vasodilatory effect of rPFO. sponse is required to either increase cardiac output or rapidly
Later, decreased cardiac output, hypotension, and death oc- expand the intravascular blood volume. In contrast, patients
curred. In addition, PLC may contribute indirectly to shock by with gram-negative sepsis compensate for hypotension by
stimulating production of endogenous mediators such as TNF markedly increasing cardiac output; however, this adaptive
[11] (figure 3) and platelet-activating factor [12]. mechanism is abrogated in C. perfringens–induced shock be-
PFO likely contributes to septic shock through indirect cause of direct suppression of myocardial contractility by PLC
routes, including the augmented release of TNF, IL-1, and IL- [10].
6 [13, 14], platelet-activating factor (PAF), and prostaglandin
I2 [15]. Perhaps PFO-induced synthesis of nitric oxide by host
THE PATHOGENESIS OF TISSUE NECROSIS
cells such as macrophages or endothelial cells could also play
a role in early hypotension. In addition, PLC and PFO may act C. perfringens gas gangrene is an aggressive infection in which
synergistically in inducing hypotension, hypoxia, and reduced viable tissue is rapidly destroyed despite appropriate antibiotic
cardiac output. This latter point should be considered when therapy, leaving the modern physician with few treatment al-
interpreting results from experiments that have used isogenic ternatives save the centuries-old practice of radical amputation.
mutants or single toxins. Trauma introduces organisms into the deep tissues and pro-
Thus, shock associated with gas gangrene may be attribut- duces an anaerobic niche with a sufficiently low redox potential
able, in part, to direct and indirect effects of toxins. PLC directly and acid pH for optimal clostridial growth. Histologically, clos-
suppresses myocardial contractility [10], thereby contributing tridial myonecrosis is remarkable for both the absence of acute
to profound hypotension via a sudden reduction in cardiac inflammatory cells in tissues and the accumulation of leuko-
output [9]. PFO reduces systemic vascular resistance and mark- cytes between fascial planes and within small vessels (leukos-
edly increases cardiac output [9, 10]. PFO-induced after-load tasis) [1, 16, 17]. This picture is distinctly different from in-
fections caused by bacteria such as Staphylococcus aureus, human platelet/neutrophil responses and reduced perfusion def-
Haemophilus influenzae, or S. pneumoniae, which are charac- icits in the rat model [18].
terized by minimal tissue destruction and a luxuriant leukocytic Although P-selectin binding of polymorphonuclear leuko-
response at the site of infection. The rapid progression of in- cyte (PMNL) glycoproteins has been the paradigm for platelet/
fection and tissue necrosis associated with clostridial gas gan- PMNL interactions, other investigators have demonstrated that
grene is related to the absence of an acute tissue inflammatory the platelet fibrinogen receptor, gpIIbIIIa (CD41/CD61), also
response, to tissue perfusion deficits resulting from toxin-me- participates in the adhesion of activated platelets to PMNL in
diated vascular dysfunction and injury, and to the elaboration vitro [20–22]. These studies have shown that this interaction
of potent cytotoxins and proteases. is fibrinogen-dependent [21, 22], that CD11b/CD18 serves as
Mechanisms of vascular dysfunction. We have recently the PMNL ligand for fibrinogen [23, 24], and that this inter-
shown that the rapid destruction of muscle involves toxin- action is further enhanced when the functionally active con-
mediated impairment of local and regional blood flow [18]. formation of CD11b/CD18 is expressed [25]. The observation
Intramuscular injection of either a clostridial toxin preparation that injection of PLC into muscle caused the rapid formation
that contains both PFO and PLC activity or of recombinant of freely mobile intravascular aggregates consisting of activated
PLC into rat abdominal musculature caused a rapid, dose- platelets suggested that PLC stimulated the conformational
dependent, and irreversible decrease in blood flow (figure 4) change in gpIIbIIIa necessary for platelets in circulation to bind
that was not due to vasoconstriction but did parallel the for- soluble fibrinogen. Indeed, PLC-induced platelet/neutrophil ag-
mation of freely moving intravascular aggregates initially in gregation could be neutralized by antibody against gpIIbIIIa or
venules (!2 min) and, later (8 min), in arterioles [18]. Im- competitively inhibited by peptides and proteins that mimic
munohistochemistry demonstrated that these early aggregates the fibrinogen molecule binding site (figure 6) [19]. In contrast,
consisted of activated (i.e., P-selectin positive) platelets. Later strategies that targeted P-selectin had no effect (fucoidan, figure
(20–40 min), aggregates enlarged and consisted of platelets, 6) [19]. Thus, it is likely that PLC-induced activation of gp-
fibrin, and neutrophils [18]. These heterotypic aggregates be- IIbIIIa is responsible for PLC-induced platelet/platelet and
came lodged within vessels, completely obstructing local and platelet/neutrophil aggregation in vivo.
regional blood flow. Flow cytometry of human whole blood Mechanisms of toxin-induced suppression of the acute in-
confirmed that PLC induced formation of both activated plate- flammatory response. Several plausible mechanisms exist to
let/platelet (not shown) and platelet/neutrophil aggregates (fig- explain the lack of a tissue inflammatory response in clostridial
ure 5) [19]. Neutralization of PLC activity completely abrogated gas gangrene. First, an absence of bacterial- or host-derived
chemoattractants could account for the paucity of leukocytes the leukostasis and anti-inflammatory response characteristic
in the tissues; however, studies have shown that both an ex- of clostridial gas gangrene. Furthermore, such dysregulation
tracellular component of bacterial culture and serum incubated could lead to local and regional ischemia, thereby extending
with killed bacilli were potent chemoattractants [17]. Second, the region for optimal clostridial proliferation.
both PLC and PFO are cytolytic for leukocytes in high con- Effects of clostridial toxins on endothelial cell function.
centrations [26], and the destruction of any infiltrating phag- Successful transmigration of leukocytes through the vessel and
ocytes at the site of active bacterial proliferation and toxin to the site of infection is the culmination of a complex cascade
elaboration likely contributes to the marked reduction of in- of both leukocyte- and endothelial cell (EC)–dependent ad-
flammatory cells in these areas. However, were this the only herence and activational events. Initially, the circulating, in-
mechanism responsible for the absence of a tissue inflammatory activated leukocyte is tethered to the activated EC and rolls
response, abundant phagocytes should be found in tissues distal along the vessel’s luminal surface—processes mediated by se-
to the nidus of infection, but, as the infiltrating phagocytes lectins. Tethering results in juxtacrine activation of the leuko-
approached the site of infection, they would be abruptly halted cyte by PAF, functional up-regulation of leukocyte CD11b/
at the point where toxin concentrations reached cytolytic pro- CD18, and firm adhesion to intercellular adhesion molecule–1
portions. Thus, cytotoxicity alone could account for what is (ICAM-1; CD54) constitutively expressed on the EC [27]. Local
classically observed in both human and experimental cases of production of cytokines (e.g., TNF and IL-1) augments the
gas gangrene—the paucity of inflammatory cells in the tis- inflammatory response by stimulating EC to produce the neu-
sues—but it does not explain the characteristic leukostasis in trophil chemoattractant/activator, IL-8, to increase ICAM-1 ex-
adjacent vasculature. pression, and to transiently express endothelial leukocyte ad-
A third possible mechanism involves the effects of sublytic hesion molecule–1 (E-selectin). Strongly adherent, activated
amounts PLC and PFO on the function and interaction of leukocytes move to EC junctions and emigrate between en-
leukocytes and endothelial cells. PLC and PFO each uniquely dothelial cells, aided by platelet-endothelial cell adhesion
affect the normal, physiological mechanisms of leukocyte ac- molecule–1.
cumulation, adherence, and extravasation (see below). Toxin- Our work has shown that PLC strongly induces the expres-
induced dysregulation of these events, which orchestrate the sion of E-selectin and ICAM-1 on cultured human umbilical
pyogenic responses with other infections, could, in part, explain vein endothelial cells [28]. The magnitude and duration of these
responses were similar to that reported in other studies that function. Indeed, sublytic concentrations of PFO dose-de-
used either TNF or IL-1 or lipopolysaccharide from gram- pendently stimulated random migration of neutrophils but de-
negative organisms. In addition, PLC also stimulated produc- creased directed migration toward n-formyl-methionyl-leucyl-
tion of endothelial cell–derived IL-8 [28]. The local production phenylalanine or a complement-derived chemoattractant [26]
of physiological concentrations of IL-8 in gas gangrene could and prevented F-actin polymerization by leukocytes in response
both amplify the recruitment of leukocytes and prime them to chemotactic factor stimulation [17]. Thus, in vivo, desen-
for enhanced respiratory burst activity. Alternatively, high con- sitization of neutrophils could contribute to the lack of phag-
centrations of IL-8 attenuate transmigration of leukocytes ocyte emigration into tissues infected with C. perfringens.
through an endothelial cell monolayer in response to che-
moattractants—a process termed “heterologous desensitiza-
SUMMARY
tion” [29]. This desensitization results from inhibition of neu-
trophil F-actin polymerization in response to chemotactic These pieces of evidence can be assimilated into a molecular
factor stimulation [30]. Of interest, we have shown that PFO, and cellular model of pathogenesis that is initiated by direct
but not PLC, at sublytic concentrations also prevents F-actin toxin effects on venous capillary EC function, leading to the
polymerization in response to chemotactic factor stimulation expression of proinflammatory mediators and adhesion mol-
(see below) [17]. Finally, toxin-induced expression of PMNL ecules and initiation of platelet aggregation. Toxin-induced hy-
and endothelial cell adhesion molecules could result in reduced peradhesion of leukocytes with enhanced respiratory burst ac-
diapedesis [17]. tivity due to toxins directly or to toxin-induced IL-8 or PAF
Effects of clostridial toxins on neutrophil function. In synthesis by host cells and toxin-induced chemotaxis deficits
contrast to PLC, PFO caused a modest, but significant, increase could result in neutrophil-mediated vascular injury. Direct
in endothelial ICAM-1, had no effect on E-selectin expression, toxin-induced cytopathic effects on EC may also contribute to
and did not induce detectable IL-8 synthesis [28]. Yet intra- vascular abnormalities associated with gas gangrene. Over pro-
muscular injection of PFO in mice produces marked vascular longed incubation periods, PLC at sublytic concentrations
leukostasis adjacent to the site of toxin injection [17], which causes EC to undergo profound shape changes similar to those
suggests that PFO may impair the inflammatory response by described after prolonged TNF or IFN-g exposure. In vivo,
primarily affecting neutrophil, rather than endothelial cell, conversion of EC to this fibroblastoid morphology could con-
tribute to the localized vascular leakage and massive swelling become affected, causing regional vascular compromise, in-
observed clinically with this infection. Similarly, the direct cy- creased compartment pressures, and rapid anoxic necrosis of
totoxicity of PFO could disrupt endothelial integrity and con- large muscle groups. When toxins, or the cytokines they induce,
tribute to progressive edema both locally and systemically. reach arterial circulation, systemic shock and multiorgan failure
Thus, via the mechanisms outlined above, both PLC and rapidly ensue, and death is common.
PFO may cause local, regional, and systemic vascular dysfunc-
tion. For instance, the local absorption of exotoxins within the
capillary beds could affect the physiological function of the References
endothelium lining the postcapillary venules, resulting in im- 1. Bryant AE, Stevens DL. The pathogenesis of gas gangrene. In: Rood
pairment of phagocyte delivery at the site of infection. Toxin- JI, Titball R, McClane B, Songer G, ed. The clostridia: molecular biology
induced endothelial dysfunction and microvascular injury and pathogenesis. London: Academic Press, 1997:185–96.
2. Awad MM, Bryant AE, Stevens DL, Rood JI. Virulence studies on
could also cause loss of albumin, electrolytes, and water into chromosomal a-toxin and v toxin mutants constructed by allelic
the interstitial space, resulting in marked localized edema. These exchange provide genetic evidence for the essential role of a-toxin in
events, combined with intravascular platelet aggregation and Clostridium perfringens–mediated gas gangrene. Mol Microbiol 1995;
15:191–202.
leukostasis, would increase venous pressures and favor further 3. Tweten RK. Cloning and expression in Escherichia coli of the perfrin-
loss of fluid and protein in the distal capillary bed. Ultimately, golysin O (theta-toxin) gene from Clostridium perfringens and char-
a reduced arteriolar flow would impair oxygen delivery, thereby acterization of the gene product. Infect Immun 1988; 56:3228–34.
4. Tweten RK. Nucleotide sequence of the gene for perfringolysin O
attenuating phagocyte oxidative killing and facilitating anaer-
(theta-toxin) from Clostridium perfringens: significant homology with
obic glycolysis of muscle tissue. The resultant drop in tissue the genes for streptolysin O and pneumolysin. Infect Immun 1988;
pH, together with reduced oxygen tension, might further de- 56:3235–40.
crease the redox potential of viable tissues to a point suitable 5. Kehoe MA, Miller L, Walker JA, Boulnois GJ. Nucleotide sequence of
the streptolysin O (SLO) gene: structural homologies between SLO and
for growth of this anaerobic bacillus. As infection progresses other membrane-damaging, thiol-activated toxins. Infect Immun
and additional toxin is absorbed, larger venous channels would 1987; 55:3228–32.