Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Irb Proposal Apn 615
Irb Proposal Apn 615
IRB Proposal:
and supplement over a 12 weeks period improve blood serum levels in vegans with
Hypotheses:
supplement.
B12 supplement?
education and vitamin B12 supplement produces changes in blood serum levels in a
Introduction
The nutrient of interest for the institutional review board (IRB) proposal is vitamin
B12. The purpose of the research study is to assess vitamin B 12 levels in Seventh Day
Adventists who have been vegans for more than five years. Studies show that
vegans are particularly vulnerable in becoming deficient because of their dietary intake.
Vitamin B12 is only found in foods from animals and vegans do not eat animal flesh. 3
There are vegans who may be living with a vitamin B 12 deficiency of which they are not
aware. Vitamin B12 can be stored in the body for years.4 If one does ingest the vitamin
over a period the nutrient will be depleted. The deficiency could be present with non-
specific symptoms.5
who are vegan may be deficient in this vitamin because they refuse to take vitamin B 12.
The argument for refusing to take supplements is that they can have adverse side
effects.8 The recommended daily allowance (RDA) for vitamin B 12 is 2.4 mg daily for
adults therefore, it should not be difficult to ingest that recommended daily allowance.
If vitamin B12 is lacking in vegetarian diets hence vegans will be at greater risk for
having B12 deficiency.5 Many vegans do not have nutrition knowledge, this prevent them
from planning their meals to include vitamin B 12 enriched foods and the taking of
supplements. If vegans do not get vitamin B12 from fortified foods or supplements their
health will suffer.9 It is recommended that oral intake of vitamin B 12 supplement be used
3
in the treatment of the vitamin B12 deficiency.10 Vitamin B12 fortified foods and milk
substitutes that contain vitamin B12 can be successfully used to treat the deficiency.11,12
Vitamin B12 is a water -soluble vitamin required for many bodily functions. Vitamin
B12 assists in making red blood cells, which transports oxygen throughout the body. 13 It
is essential for the function and development of brain and nerve cells. 14 It helps to break
down a protein called homocysteine Vitamin B12 must bind with the foods we eat. In the
stomach hydrochloric acid unbinds it, turning it into free form. It then mixes with intrinsic
factor protein it is then absorbed into the body via the small intestines.
The symptoms of vitamin B12 deficiency can be irreversible if they are left
untreated for a long time. It is important that vegans get regularly testing for the
deficiency. To confirm if there is a vitamin B12 deficiency lab work is necessary. Tests
can be conducted to measure the serum vitamin B 12 level.15 One test the MMA gives the
best result for vitamin B12 because it explains the extent of the deficiency. 16 Lowered
serum holoTC concentration another test can show early deficiency. The result of this
test shows that the body does not have enough available vitamin B12. 17
There are 375 million vegetarians worldwide. 18 With growing vegetarian levels, the
prevalence of individuals who has vitamin B12 will increase. There could be many
persons who exclude meat from their diet and do not take supplements are at risk for
Vitamin B12 deficiency is a highly researched area. 5,8 In 2014 Mearns and
(B12) deficiency in South Asian women before conception. South Asian women, 18–50
years old) were stratified by dietary practices, then randomized to three treatment
Dietary Advice (n=20).18 Primary outcome measures were changes in B12 biomarkers
6 months.19
From the analysis, half of the women of childbearing age in the study had either
deficient or insufficient B12 stores. Women who were vegetarians were found to be of
higher risk for developing B12 deficiency.19 The findings support low-dose oral
dietary B12 intake. The researchers suggest closer monitoring and prevention of B12
Vitamin B12 deficiency happens because of poor dietary intake. 20 Since animal
foods are the only source of vitamin B12 is common in diets with little or no meat. 20
Inadequate intake of folate and vitamin B12 leads to low serum or plasma
take supplement.8
5
are associated with plasma concentrations of vitamin B 12.21 The aim was to identify the
dietary sources of vitamin B12 intake from supplements, fortified foods, and animal
source foods (that include meat, fish, milk, and eggs) in a health-conscious population. 21
A total of 728 participants were assessed. The median age was 58 years and Serum
determination of vitamin B12 in human serum.20 Diet was assessed using 24 h dietary
recalls (24 HDR) and a previously validated food frequency questionnaire. Intake of
vitamin B12 was estimated from two sets of three 24HDRs, which included information
on all foods, beverages, and supplements consumed by each subject during the
previous 24 h.21
From the findings it was ascertained that most of the respondents got their B 12
intake from supplements. multiple Although not all subjects in the current study obtained
vitamin B12 from supplements, multiple linear regressions showed that supplements
were the strongest predictor of holoTC and serum vitamin B 12.21 The writers concluded
that vitamin B12 supplements are important in a vegetarian or vegan diet to prevent
There is a potential risk of that vitamin B12 deficiency could be present without
any symptoms, the question remains if some groups are more prevalent to the
deficiency?22 One study conducted in 2019 found that, elderly people, pregnant women,
and vegans are more susceptible to B12 deficiency. These groups may have symptoms
be conducted for patients with suspected vitamin B 12 deficiency, including blood count
and serum level. 22 A level of less than 150 pg per mL (111 pmol per L) is diagnostic for
deficiency.23 Patients in high risk groups should be evaluated to find out if they have
Persons who prescribe to vegetarian diets are at risk for vitamin B 12 deficiency
based on a study done in 2002.24 The current work was undertaken to investigate some
Subjects were stratified into three groups, based on their habitual dietary pattern.
(Bayer). Complete blood count was performed, using a hematology analyzer (Sysmex
XE‐2100TM). Based on the findings of the Eighty‐five percent of the subjects had
metabolic evidence that indicates vitamin B12 deficiency.24 The lower platelet count, and
the giant platelet form were accompanied by metabolic evidence that indicated vitamin
B12 deficiency.
Foods fortified with vitamin B12 and vitamin B12 supplements have been used to
how B12 status could be improved over 6 months in a group of South Asian women of
Sixty-two South Asian women aged 18–50 years living in Auckland, NZ participated in
estimations of dietary B12 intake were collected at baseline and at 2 and 6 months.
Participants in the Placebo and B12 Supplement groups were advised to swallow
either one cyanocobalamin or placebo capsule with a full glass of water each day for 6
Sustainability and adherence to the treatment were assessed from the number of
capsules returned over the six-month period.24 Dietary Advice group participants
B12-containing foods in order to meet the 2.4μg minimum recommended daily intake
status was moderately correlated with dietary B 12 intake (r=0.5, 95% CI (0.3–0.7)) and
44% women reported insufficient dietary intake (o2.4μg/day). 24 The B12 supplement
treatment was associated with substantial increases in both serum B 12 (geometric mean
increase of 30%, 95% CI (11–48)) and holoTC (42% (12–72)) over 6 months.
8
being effective in improving B12 status for women with insufficient dietary B12 intake.24
Vitamin B12 deficiency can happen if persons do not eat food from meat source,
eat fortified foods or take supplements.8,10,11, 19,20 Persons who are vegans are at serious
risk of developing B12 deficiency, so they require fortified foods and supplements to
meet their nutritional needs. It is possible to improve blood serum level with
including nutrition education and an oral supplement changes low B 12 serums levels in
Significance of Study:
The aim of this study is to determine if oral supplement can improve low serum B 12
levels in Seventh Day Adventist vegans. Vegans are at risk for vitamin B 12 deficiency
because their diets do not contain meat and many of them do not take supplements.
Contribution to Field:
This research will add to the body of knowledge and will also provide information for
Seventh Day Adventist who are vegans. This will help them to plan their diet to have
Discoveries/Interventions
There are interventions that are associated with this research. Participants are expected
to attend nutrition education class, once per week for the duration of the study. This
Participants will learn about foods which are fortified with the vitamin. They will also
learn about functions of the vitamin and importance of supplementation. The second
Subject Recruitment:
The participants of the study will be male and female members of the Seventh Day
Adventist church in DeKalb County, Georgia. To qualify for the study, participants must
be between 50 and 65 years of age and must meet the following requirements: The
doctor through physical examination and the use of a health questionnaire. This health
questionnaire will give information on the general health of the participants. Persons will
be excluded from the study if they have diabetes, renal insufficiencies, gastrointestinal
disorders, have had bariatric or stomach resection, take medications, smoke, drink or
take supplements. Persons will be included in the study if they meet the following
requirements:
Study Activities
Participants will be entered into the study if they fulfill all the requirements. The study is
expected to last for three months. Once the study is completed, data will be compiled
and analyzed. Participants will have their blood drawn a week before the study begins.
This procedure will be done by a phlebotomist. These blood samples will be sent to the
The purpose of the labs is to find out if the participants have low levels of serum B 12.
The best indicator of vitamin B12 deficiency is a laboratory analysis which provides
low-cost method of assessing vitamin B12 status. 25 Serum B12 levels by themselves may
not show reserves in the participants. A serum holotranscobalamin II (TC2) test will be
conducted along with the serum levels test. TC2 is a protein that carries vitamin B 12 in
the blood, if its levels are reduced then there is a vitamin B 12 deficiency.26
Persons who are assigned to the study must attend a nutrition education class as part
of the research. The purpose of the nutrition education class is teaching the participants
about the importance of eating foods fortified with vitamin B 12 and taking supplements.
This class will also provide information about the functions of the vitamins, the effects of
its deficiencies, common symptoms, dietary needs and supplementation. Patients will
learn that it is necessary to take supplements for their duration of their lives because
Each class will last for one hour, once per week for the duration of the study. As an
incentive for attending the class the participants will get a snack that is fortified with
vitamin B12. After completing the first two weeks of the class the participants will receive
supplementation for the study is 50 mcg per day. Toxicity of this vitamin is rear and
those participants who have low serums levels need to take a higher dosage to increase
their serum levels. Compliance will be checked by counting the unused capsules
remaining in the capsule dispensers and by verifying pill counts in the participants’
diaries.
11
All participants will be asked to complete TrackMyStack to record their daily intake of
capsules.27
The patients’ information will be kept confidential for the duration of the study. The study
will take place at the Seventh Day Adventist conference center. The Health Insurance
Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) Privacy Rule will be applied to the data. 28 The
HIPAA ensures that medical records are protected such as medical history. When
working with research subjects, additional steps will be taken to ensure confidentiality.
information. All identifiable data for the participants in the study will be encrypted. All
Only the researcher will have access to confidential records such as medical records.
There will be no paper records associated with the study. Patients will be provided
information about the HIPAA when they enter the study. 27 Signatures of the patients are
mandatory for the researcher’s team to have access to medical information related to
The research team will not have access to all the participants records. They will be able
to view information names, date of birth and certain medical history. All the participants
will have an identification number instead of a name to protect their identity. Clinical
staff will make documentation based on the number assigned to each participant.
12
On the completion of the study and collection of data a study identification number will
be used to represent the participants. Participants will be issued copies of the result of
the study.
Research Setting:
The study will be conducted at the Mountainside Seventh Day Adventist church in
Dekalb County, Georgia. This church is ideal because it has a health and wellness
department which offers privacy. Data will be collected from five churches in the Dekalb
County. The medical doctor and phlebotomist who are part of the study attend the
Mountainside church. All interactions and appointments concerning the participants will
church and the blood works will be safely stored and transported for testing.
Consent/Assent Process
For this research the Belmont report will be utilized, and this entails respect, justice, and
beneficence for all participants. As soon as the participants are accepted in the study
All the participants will meet with the researcher and the study will be discussed at
length with them, this is to decide if the participants want to be part of the study. The
information presented to participants will be at the grade eight reading level to make
sure that they understand what the study is all about and what is required of them.
13
All information regarding the research team will be available to the participants and their
contact number. When the participants meet with the research team, they can sign the
document for the study at that time. If they do not sign at that time, then they will have a
Risks/Benefits to Participants
The participants of this research study could benefit directly, and their B 12 serums levels
could increase. However, the possibility exists that there could be risks associate with
the study. The following are foreseeable risks that may happen with this study.
Participants B12 serum levels may not increase to expected levels after the ten weeks
interventions with supplements. They could have allergic reactions to the supplement.
To prevent harm to the patients the doctor will check each participant after one week of
taking the supplement to see if there are any allergic reactions. All participants will have
a visit with the doctor every two weeks after that. If the participants develop allergies at
any time, they will get medical attention and will stop taking the supplement. Patients
In the same way there are risks associated with the study there are also benefits to be
gained from it. Taking a vitamin B12 supplement can increase blood serum levels B 12
and this will decrease the risk of deficiency. The nutrition education will help the patients
to plan and prepare meals that have vitamin B 12 fortified foods. The participants will get
valuable information about the functions of vitamin B 12 in the body. This will help them to
improve their health and well-being. They may also be able to educate other vegans
about the importance of eating fortified foods or taking supplements to reduce the risk of
deficiency.
14
Data Analysis:
Once the research is completed the quantitative data will then be assessed. Statistical
analysis of the research data will be performed; analyses will include standard
descriptive statistics. The significance level was chosen as 0·05. SAS version 8.02
(SAS Institute, Inc., Cary, NC, USA) will be used for all statistical analyses. Data that
will be assessed are vitamin B12 serum levels and frequency of intake of oral B 12
supplement. A blood test will be conducted before the study commences. Another blood
test will be conducted at the end of the study. Each blood test will be recorded as soon
as results are available. The purpose of the aggregated data is to explain the summary
Data will be presented as means and standard deviations or medians and ranges, as
and percentage. Categorical values will be assigned to the various serum B 12 levels of
the participants. The Spearman (R) test will be used to estimate correlation between the
experiencing a reduction in vitamin B12 serum levels after three months of oral intake of
B12 supplements. The study data could prove if vitamin B 12 supplementation is enough
to maintain vitamin B12 stores in vegans who have low B12 serum levels. The data will
help to ascertain if there are any relationships in the variations of serum levels and
The information obtained from each subject will be anonymous and be combined so that
the findings will a group. The summarized quantitative data will include lab values and a
Track-My-Stack chart.
The Track-My-Stack chart will provide information on how often the subjects ingest the
supplement. The study data will show if supplementation is enough to increase blood
serum levels in vegans who have low B12 serum levels. The nutrition education aspect
of the study will provide information as to how much the participants took the
supplements. If the supplements were taken as directly on all the days, then the
The expected results are that the prevalence of low serum level vitamin B 12 will be
higher among subjects who are vegans. Some of the participants will have very low
vitamin B12 serum levels because they have been vegan for more than ten years. These
vegans may already have been experiencing deficiency of the vitamin. The B 12
months. The findings will encourage vegans who did not take support low-dose oral
Discussion:
Assessing the impact of vitamin B12 supplement in vegans’ diet is very important. It will
It will allow the research team to see how supplementation can help in preventing
vegans from having vitamin B12 deficiency from a diet that is free from meat.3 As noted
from the literature, persons who subscribe to vegan diets are at greater risk for getting
vitamin B12 deficiency. The deficiency is also prevalent in this group. 5,6 If vegans can
meet their B12 needs through supplementation then the deficiency can be avoided. 28
There are many potential risks for the study population. Some of the subjects may not
be able to take the supplement orally and as such their B 12 serum level might not
increase. Also, there is a risk that they may not meet their nutritional needs through
daily recording of the supplements on the Track-My-Stack chart and this could be a set-
Participants must not be taking any form of supplementation before the intervention. If
any participant having extremely low lab values at the pre-assessment will be monitored
Since there are possible risks involved with the study, the patients will be monitored
closely by clinicians during the study. This will prevent the subjects from having a lower
risk of becoming deficient. The group will be provided with supplements which is an
added benefit and decreases the burden of extra costs of purchasing supplements
17
The small sample size and the study being confined to a small geographical location
means that the result cannot be generalized for the larger population. The use of Track-
My-Stack chart is self-reported data and participants may not be truthful which can
cause bias to the research and thus affect the results. The intervention will only 12
weeks long and longer interventions may be needed to address the long-term effects on
determinants of dietary behaviors. Serum B12 levels of participants may remain the
FUTURE OPPORTUNITIES
The possible results of this study can contribute to this area of research by underlining
the validity of supplementation for vitamin B 12 deficiency treatment. Other future studies
could build off these results by increasing the intervention timeline or population to
further support the alternative hypothesis. This study could be the first step for future
studies in the Greater Atlantic Conference of Seventh Day Adventist Church. These
studies could look at the importance of vegans in the church getting nutrition
intervention to increase their vitamin B12 serum levels. Other groups of vegans like the
REFERENCES
2019;38(2):575-583.doi.org/10.1016/j.clnu.2018.02.008.
2. Elorinne A, Alfthan G, Erlund I, et al. Food and nutrient intake and nutritional
doi.org.une.idm.oclc.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0148235.
3. Rizzo G, Laganà AS, Rapisarda AM, et al. Vitamin B12 among Vegetarians:
doi:10.3390/nu8120767.
4. Antony AC. Vegetarianism and vitamin B-12 (cobalamin) deficiency. Am. J. Clin.
http://search.ebscohost.com.une.idm.oclc.org/login.aspx?
8, 2019.
https://www.cancer.org/treatment/treatments-and-side-effects/complementary-
19
and-alternative-medicine/dietary-supplements/risks-and-side-effects.html. 2019.
9. Pawlak R, Scott, Parrott SJ, Raj S, et al. How prevalent is vitamin B12 deficiency
org.une.idm.oclc.org/10.1111/nure.12001.
10. Stabler SP, M.D. Vitamin B12 deficiency. N Engl J Med. 2013;368(2):149-160.
https://search-proquest-com.une.idm.oclc.org/docview/1283052115?pq-
11. Damayanti D. Foods and nutrients associated with vitamin B12 biomarkers
9, 2019.
https://www.longdom.org/scholarly/vitamin-b12-deficiency-journals-articles-ppts-
22, 2019.
14. Zeuschner CL, Hokin BD, Marsh KA, et al. Vitamin B12 and vegetarian diets.
16. Herrmann W, Obeid R. Causes and early diagnosis of vitamin B12 deficiency.
http://search.ebscohost.com.une.idm.oclc.org/login.aspx?
direct=true&db=ccm&AN=105696007&site=ehost-live&scope=site. Accessed
17. World Population of Vegetarians. The Economic and Social Research Institute.
18. Mearns GJ, J Koziol-McLain J, Obolonkin V, Rush EC. Preventing vitamin B12
19. Antony AC, Vegetarianism and vitamin B-12 (cobalamin) deficiency. Am. J. Clin.
20. Damayanti D, Jaceldo-Siegl K, Beeson WL, Fraser G, Oda K, Haddad EH. Foods
and supplements associated with vitamin biomarkers among vegetarian and non-
21. Manolis AS, Manolis TA, Poulidakis E, Melita H. Beware of the ailments of
https://une.idm.oclc.org/login?url=https://search-proquest-
com.une.idm.oclc.org/docview/1689877221?accountid=12756.
21
clinicalkey-com.une.idm.oclc.org/#!/content/playContent/1-s2.0-
org.une.idm.oclc.org/10.1034/j.1600-0609.2002.02798.x.
24. Mearns GJ, Koziol-mclain J, Obolonkin V, Rush EC. Preventing vitamin B12
trial comparing an oral vitamin B12 supplement with B12 dietary advice. Eur J
https://www.mja.com.au/journal/2013/199/4/vitamin-b12-and-vegetarian-
26. Ubbink JB. What is a desirable homocysteine level? In: Carmel R, Jacobsen DW,
https://www.mja.com.au/journal/2013/199/4/vitamin-b12-and-vegetarian-
website. https://www.privacyrights.org/consumer-guides/health-privacy-
28. Ryan-Harshman M, Aldoori W. Vitamin B12 and health. Can Fam Physician.
2008;54(4):536–541. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2294088/.
Appendix 1.