Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Softened Drinking Water: The Facts, The Myths, The Regulations The Options and The Solutions
Softened Drinking Water: The Facts, The Myths, The Regulations The Options and The Solutions
The Facts, the Myths, the Regulations; the Options and the Solutions.
Softened Drinking Water.
The Facts, The Myths, The Regulations; the Options and the Solutions.
The concerns relating to sodium and hardness levels in drinking water have been raised
spasmodically over the last forty years. The current position of the World Health Organisation,
(WHO), as published in the Water Quality Guidelines 2003, is that there is no concern relating
to sodium and hardness.
However, the recent inclusion of Eastern European countries into the EU and a WHO Workshop
in 2003 have again raised the question of minerals in drinking water. There is also a concern
relating to large scale municipal reverse osmosis water treatment.
Because of this the World Health Organisation is organising a symposium to review nutritional
aspects of calcium and magnesium, and assess any potential benefits from these minerals in
drinking water. The results of this conference and subsequent expert consultation are expected
to be made available during 2006. If there is any change in the WHO Guidelines, and con-
sequent changes to the Drinking Water Regulations, the advice given in this booklet will be
updated accordingly.
Published by Harvey Softeners Ltd/Softener Supplies: retailers and wholesalers to the domestic
Point of Entry/Point of Use water treatment industry.
Drinking water supplies in the UK are of a very high quality. There is however a considerable
variation in the level of hardness, due to regional differences in geology. Although rainwater is
naturally soft it tends to pick up minerals, such as calcium and magnesium, as it seeps through
the ground. When it passes through soft rocks, like chalk and limestone, it can pick up high
levels of these minerals and result in hard water.
Hard water causes many problems: scaling and subsequent loss of boiler efficiency, formation
of scum on sanitary ware, increased use of cleaning products and subsequent expenditure, extra
household cleaning, aggravation of eczema etc. To remove these problems many people fit a
water softener.
Water softeners work by treating the water by ion exchange to remove the hardness minerals
and replace them with sodium which does not cause scaling. Water softeners are commonly
installed in private and commercial premises and the question is often posed: is the softened
water suitable for drinking purposes?
This booklet has been written to explain to consumers the opinions relating to the drinking of
softened water and the options available. It incorporates the current scientific, regulatory and
industry points of view and advice.
Section 1
Drinking Water Regulations set a limit of 200 advice.
milligrams per litre (mg/l) for sodium.
4. Maintenance.
In most areas of the UK, the resultant increase A domestic water softener should be kept
in sodium stays within this limit but in some in continuous use and maintained correctly.
very hard water areas the increase in sodium Whilst there is little to go wrong with a
may breach the statutory limit laid down by domestic softener and it will normally “fail-
these regulations. Whilst this may be of no safe”, long periods of stagnation of water
significance to the majority of the population, within the softener (after extended holidays
it may be unsuitable for certain sectors of the for example), may affect the quality of the
population. water until it is flushed and returned to normal
service again. Although not a health risk,
2. Hardness level. the aesthetic quality (taste and odour) of the
When water is softened all the hardness min- drinking water may be impaired.
erals are removed. The current Drinking Wa-
ter Regulations do not contain requirements Q. How much sodium is added to
for a minimum level of hardness but there are water during softening?
some studies which have demonstrated that
This is directly related to the hardness of the
presence of these hardness minerals may have
water. For every 100 mg/l of calcium carbon-
some health benefit. These studies associated
ate hardness taken out, 46 mg/l of sodium go
areas of the country that are served with natu-
in. Add to this any sodium originally in the
rally soft water with increased frequency of
water and you have the total sodium in the
heart attacks amongst the population and the
water after softening.
assumption was made that drinking artificially
softened water might carry the same risk.
To keep below the 200 mg/l threshold for
sodium, you can soften water containing up
3. Corrosion.
to 435 mg/l of calcium carbonate hardness,
Because naturally soft water sources (lakes,
depending on the original concentration of
rivers, etc) are often low in pH (slightly
sodium in the water supply, which must also
acidic), they can be corrosive to metals. Hard
be allowed for.
water that has been softened has been incor-
rectly assumed to suffer the same disadvan- Q. Yes, but how much salt is that?
tage. Softening water with a salt-regenerated,
ion-exchange softener does not change the At a typical calcium carbonate hardness of
chemical properties that affect water corrosiv- 300 mg/l, such as Greater London, the sodium
ity. in the water as a result of softening would
increase by 138 mg/l. Therefore each litre of
This erroneous concern has been extended drinking water would contain an additional
to lead pipework (normally not present in 138 milligrams of sodium over and above that
modern buildings) but again, softening will which was in the water to start with.
not affect the corrosivity of the water towards
lead. However, this is the sodium content – not the
salt (sodium chloride) content; to equate it to
The Drinking Water Regulations 2000 have salt, the chloride must be added. 138 mg/l of
introduced tighter standards for lead. Should sodium is equivalent to 348 mg/l of sodium
you have concerns over the presence of lead chloride. Therefore, the equivalent increase in
pipework within your premises, you should salt intake by the average individual drinking
contact your water company for further two litres of softened water a day is 0.696 g.
This is about one tenth of a teaspoonful.
Q&A
The Food Standards Agency has published
5
In the USA there is no limit on sodium in
data on the dietary intake of salt and the aver- the National Primary or Secondary Drinking
age salt content of typical foods. The average Water Regulations.
total daily salt intake is about 9,500 milli-
grams for an adult, so the contribution from In the new, Third Edition of the World Health
softened water would be about 7% in a typical Organisation’s Guidelines on Drinking Water
hard water area, assuming a 2 litre daily Quality, 2003, there is no sodium guideline.
consumption. By comparison, white bread It only states that concentrations in excess of
contributes 10.2% to the average daily salt 200 mg/l may impart a taste.
intake, bacon and ham = 8%, and breakfast
cereals = 4.9%. So to say you shouldn’t drink It is the Department of Health that recom-
softened water is the same, in these terms, mended limiting sodium concentrations to
as saying you shouldn’t eat bacon, a bag of 200mg/l in drinking water for babies and
crisps or eat white bread! those individuals on a medically-prescribed,
salt-restricted diet.
5 McCance & Widdowson on behalf of the Food Standards Agency
Q. I thought salt was bad for you? There are some bottled waters containing over
1700 mg/l of sodium and they are marketed
There is conjecture about the contribution of as a health related benefit!
salt to hypertension (blood pressure) and its
possible effect on health consequences. Cer-
tainly, reduced salt has been found to reduce
blood pressure, at least in the short term, in
older, hypertensive patients. Whether the
reduction in blood pressure from reduced salt
intake has reduced ultimate health outcome,
such as heart attacks, is less conclusive.
The policy of the Department of Health is 1,708ppm
Sodium
to reduce the average daily adult intake of
salt from the 9,500 mg (see above) to 6,200
mg. The Government included a mandatory
standard for sodium of 200 mg/l in the Drink-
ing Water Regulations, primarily as a measure
to help prevent infant hypernatraemia and
secondly to assist reducing the sodium intake
in the general population. 6 Council Directive 98/83/EC of 3rd November 1998 on the quality of
water intended for human consumption
Section 1
Q. Can I use softened water for mix- the correlation disappeared. However, people
ing baby feeds if the sodium com- began to extend the theory from naturally soft
water to softened water and this has led to the
plies with the Water Regulations? precautionary conclusion that it is preferable
Yes you can, provided the softened water has to drink the unsoftened, hard water.
a sodium concentration below the maximum
of 200 mg/l for sodium, specified in the However, tests then conducted in some cities
Drinking Water Regulations. This level was where the water supply was softened by the
adopted to ensure that the total sodium of water supplier did not support the correlation.
the baby feed plus the water does not exceed
350 mg/l which is considered a safe level for In November 2003 the World Health Organi-
infants. sation held a consultation on the issue of nu-
trition and drinking water, which considered
Q. How can I find out how much the new data on hardness and cardiovascular
sodium will be in my water when disease. The group also requested advice re-
softened? lating to home water softening devices in rela-
tion to the advisability of retaining a source of
The simplest route is to call the customer water containing calcium and magnesium.
services number for your water supplier. Ask
for the sodium level in the water supply and The World Health Organisation currently
calcium carbonate hardness. (N.B. both so- states that “..the available data are inad-
dium and calcium carbonate hardness must be equate to permit a conclusion that the as-
expressed in mg/l. Divide the calcium carbon- sociation is causal. No health based guide-
ate hardness level by 2.175 and add the so- line value is proposed for hardness.” The
dium in the water supply.) This result should Drinking Water Regulations do not include a
be no more than 200 mg/l of total sodium to specification for a minimum level of hardness.
comply with the Water Quality Regulations.
As a “rule of thumb” if the calcium carbonate
hardness level of the water supply is greater Q. How many people drink softened
than 400 mg/l, there is a higher probability water?
that the softened water will be close to or Millions! During the 1920’s and 1930’s water
above the sodium limit in the Drinking Water softeners started to be sold to home owners
Quality Regulations. and others, to improve the taste of drinking
water. In the USA there is no myth surround-
Or phone us on 01483 753401 for details of ing softened water use for drinking purposes
your nearest installer who can give you local and over 1 million people a year have a water
advice. softener installed. There are millions of water
Q. But what about the removal of softeners in everyday use in American homes
which are used for drinking water purposes. In
hardness? some parts of the US, almost everyone needs
Some epidemiological studies carried out over one because of the hardness of groundwater
the last 50 years have indicated that people but millions of others are bought as a prefer-
living in areas where the water supply was ence item.
naturally soft are slightly more prone to car-
There has never, in over 90 years of history,
diovascular disease (heart attacks) than those
been a health related problem reported that
living in areas with a hard water supply. When
was associated with a water softener.
the studies have then focused on specific
components of the water such as calcium,
Q&A
Q. What does softened water taste
like?
Section 2
Scientific and Regulatory
Support Information
Sodium.
The World Health Organisation
“Sodium salts (e.g. sodium chloride)
The World Health Organisation (WHO) are found in virtually all food (the main
publishes the “WHO Guidelines for Drinking- source of daily exposure) and drink-
Water Quality”. These contain health criteria ing-water. Although concentrations of
and other supporting information to give the sodium in potable water are typically
governments of the world the guidance and less than 20mg/litre they can greatly ex-
information they need to establish regulations ceed this in some countries.....It should
to secure safe drinking water supplies. be noted that some water softeners can
add significantly to the content of drink-
The European Commission take the WHO
guidelines into account in the preparation ing water. No firm conclusions can be
of the European Drinking Water Directive. drawn concerning the possible associa-
The UK Government and all other national tion between sodium in drinking-water
governments of the EU are required to adopt and the occurrence of hypertension.
legislation to implement the requirements of Therefore no health-based guideline
the Directive. value is therefore proposed. However,
concentrations in excess of 200 mg/l
The third edition of the WHO guidelines, may give rise to unacceptable taste.”
published in 2003, state in section 8.7.1 the
following regarding hardness and sodium:
The European Drinking Water
Hardness. Directive
Scientific and Regulatory Support Information
The UK Water Quality Regulations
Section 3
Advice from the
Concern about the suitability of softened wa-
Government and ter is not restricted to sodium concentrations
Regulatory Advisors. from salt-regenerated ion-exchange water
softeners. There is also concern that the well-
Department of Health documented but unexplained epidemiological
This is the advice received from the Depart- relationship between naturally soft water and
ment of Health. mortality from cardiovascular disease may
apply also to artificially softened water. Fur-
The reasons for limiting sodium concentra- ther information on this aspect may be found
tions in water supplies are: in Department of Health Report on Health
and Social Subjects 46 “Nutritional Aspects of
(a) concentrations greater than about Cardiovascular Disease (1994, HMSO) paras
200mg/l may give rise to an 6.9.1.1-2.
unacceptable taste;
Other concerns about water softeners are:
(b) the kidneys of young babies (especially plumbosolvency; and the potential for mi-
premature babies) are inefficient at crobial contamination if the softener is not
excreting sodium, so that too much adequately maintained.
sodium in the feed may produce the
condition of infantile hypernatraemia. Water Regulations Advisory Scheme
For this reason, it is recommended that The Regulations that govern the requirements
the sodium concentration of for the installation of water fittings, including
reconstituted infant feed should not softeners, are contained in the Water Supply
exceed 350mg/l (there should be an (Water Fittings) Regulations 1999 for England
adequate safety margin in this limit). and Wales and the Water Byelaws 2000 for
If the water used to reconstitute the feed Scotland. They can be read from the website
contains 200mg/l or more, the
recommended limit is likely to be
exceeded;
www.opsi.gov.uk/si/si1999/19991148.
htm.
(c) sometimes, patients are put on strict
salt-restricted diets (although, The Water Regulations Advisory Scheme
nowadays, drug treatments usually (WRAS) has published a book – the Wa-
make such diets unnecessary). At water ter Regulations Guide. The WRAS Guide
concentrations of about 200mg includes the text from the Regulations, gives
sodium/litre, it is difficult or impossible “guidance” from the Department of Envi-
to construct such diets. ronment, Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA)
and “recommendations” from the WRAS
Another consideration is that sodium (mostly representing the water suppliers, on the
as common salt, sodium chloride) is consid- interpretation of, and how to comply with, the
ered to be a risk factor in high blood pressure Regulations.
and its consequences (such as hypertensive
heart disease) and therefore reductions in The Fittings Regulations, themselves, do not
dietary salt intake in the general population make any reference to softened water provi-
are recommended. However, water which is sions. Regulations 26 and 27 require “...at
not obviously salty to the taste will least one tap conveniently situated...supplied
contribute only a small fraction of the average with water...from a supply pipe.” In the Water
daily dietary intake. Fittings Guide, DEFRA guidance note G27.3
Advice from the Government and Regulatory Advisors.
states that “water that has been softened on Recommendation R27.3 states that chemi-
site should only be used for drinking pur- cal composition change due to softening
poses when the treated water is wholesome.” may result in non-compliance with “whole-
The only parameter at risk of not meeting some” water and that improper operation and
the standard of the Drinking Water Regula- maintenance may affect quality such that the
tions would be sodium and then, as already Drinking Water Regulations are contravened,
mentioned, only for those areas with high- and it then recommends that only unsoftened
hardness-level supplies. Guidance note G6.1b water is used for drinking purposes.
identifies domestic softened water as fluid
category 2 which is defined in Schedule 1 of The rationale for this recommendation is not
the Regulations “...category 1 whose aesthetic explained but the only parameter that could
quality is impaired ....” (see Backflow preven- be exceeded as a consequence of softening is
tion above). sodium and this would not be adversely af-
fected by operation and maintenance - but by
The Water Supply Industry recommendations influent hardness level.
(R26.2) include
Conclusion
Confused? Most people are. Whilst there is no evidence to suggest that drinking softened water
is detrimental to health, there is a suspicion that drinking hard water may provide a health
benefit to some people. Why that is, nobody knows. You have the choice of drinking softened
water or having a separate hard water drinking tap.
Section 4
Separate
Hard Water
Drinking Tap
Hard Water
Connection
Installing a separate hard water tap can be car- A typical installation will look like the
ried out at the same time as installing a water diagram above. Note the connection prior to
softener, or retrofitted at a later date. the rising main and the use of small diameter
plastic tubing.
In houses where the rising main comes up
under the kitchen sink the installation is In many houses, approximately 60%, the
relatively straight- rising main comes up somewhere other than
forward. Whilst it is under the kitchen sink. These installations
possible to convert require more pipework and the diagrams op-
the existing cold tap posite show the various options.
to supply unsoftened
drinking water, it is As an alternative,
generally preferred to the existing kitchen
install a separate tap. sink tap can be changed to
These are usually of a three way version: hot, cold
the “spring faucet” and hard.
type.
10
Hard Water Drinking Tap Installation Guide
Option 1. 15mm pipework to feed drinking Option 4. Sometimes it is not convenient to
tap and outside tap fit a separate tap at the kitchen sink and in
Option 2. 3/8” for normal installations. these circumstances a tap providing hard wa-
1⁄4” if you want the pipework to be less ter can be installed in an alternative position.
obtrusive, provided there is sufficient pressure
of at least 3 bar. A mounting bracket can enable the tap to be
Option 3. 3mm if you want the pipework to installed in a cloakroom beside a wash basin.
disappear. The spout can be swivelled to aid the filling of
kettles etc.
The use of 3mm pipework requires the ad-
dition of a small accumulator tank under Contact your local water softener dealer for
the sink to provide up to 4 litres of water further advice re installation. In case of dif-
instantly. The tank then refills in about ten ficulty contact Softener Supplies on
minutes ready for the next draw off of drink- 01483 753 401.
ing water. The 3mm pipework can be run over
any distance.
OPTION 1.
15mm pipework to feed
drinking tap and outside tap.
Storage
Tank
Outside
Tap
Hard
Where the outside garden tap is situated behind the kitchen sink and both are at the opposite
end of the house from where the rising main enters, it is sometimes possible to run a 15mm pipe
from the position of the water softener through to the kitchen sink. This can feed the new drink-
ing tap and the outside garden tap.
11
Section 4
OPTION 2.
3/8” or 1/4” plastic drinking water line.
Storage
Tank
New
Outside
Outside
Tap
Tap
(Hard)
(Soft)
Often it is not practical to run a 15mm pipe from the point of entry to the kitchen sink, so the
best option is to run a small 3/8” white plastic pipe instead. This is sufficient for a separate
drinking tap.
The existing outside garden tap can be left on softened and if possible a new one fitted near the
point of entry connected to the hard supply before the softener.
Where there is sufficient pressure, over 4 bar, and the run is not too long, then 1/4” drinking line
can be used.
12
Hard Water Drinking Tap Installation Guide
OPTION 3.
3mm plastic drinking water line.
Storage
Tank
New
Outside
Outside
Tap
Tap
(Hard)
(Soft)
13
Section 4
OPTION 4.
Separate hard water drinking tap at a
different location.
Storage
Tank
Sink
Main
A bracket is available to
mount a drinking tap beside
a wash basin. The supply
is best run in 3/8” drinking
water line or 1/4” if there is
sufficient pressure.
14
Hard Water Drinking Tap Installation Products
Available Products
Products are available to make the installation of a separate hard water drinking tap easy and
inconspicuous.
For your nearest installer contact Softener Supplies on 01483 753 401.
15
Hello, I’m Harvey.
Thank you for taking an interest in
softened drinking water.
During the research and drafting, consultations have taken place with the
following: