Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Epidemiology of Cutaneous Melanoma in Germany and Worldwide: Claus Garbe Andreas Blum
Epidemiology of Cutaneous Melanoma in Germany and Worldwide: Claus Garbe Andreas Blum
Epidemiology of Cutaneous Melanoma in Germany and Worldwide: Claus Garbe Andreas Blum
Epidemiology of Cutaneous
Melanoma in Germany and Worldwide
Claus Garbe Andreas Blum
Department of Dermatology, University of Tübingen, Germany
mid-1990s with the median thickness de- the European countries were found to be
creasing from 1.3 to 0.8 mm. Lower Breslow’s clearly lower. In the following, recent develop-
tumor thickness at first diagnosis of cuta- ments of melanoma epidemiology in Germa-
neous melanoma has only been reported ny and in Caucasian populations worldwide
from Australia. This development indicates are summarized.
improved early recognition of cutaneous
melanoma which is presently the main factor
for a more favorable prognosis. Incidence
Copyright © 2001 S. Karger AG, Basel
plateau phase. Increases in mortality rates working until today, presently registering
have been less distinct as compared to inci- about 5,000 new melanomas per year.
dence rates. Probably, improvement in the
early detection of melanoma with more favor-
able prognosis have contributed to slow down Gender and Age
the mortality rates at a time point when still
clearly increasing incidence rates have been The percentage of females among all mela-
registered. noma patients was more than 60% during the
1970s and 1980s in Germany, until the 1990s
an increasing percentage of males has been
Clinical Epidemiology observed with a nearly balanced proportion
between males and females at the end of the
The present data of the clinical epidemiol- 1990s [26, 27]. In the mid-1990s, the percent-
ogy of cutaneous melanoma derived from the age of males exceeded 45%. In the worldwide
Central Malignant Melanoma Registry of the comparison, a higher percentage of females
German Dermatological Society to which has been reported from areas with low mela-
more than 60 Departments of Dermatology noma incidence like England, whereas the
contributed within the German-speaking gender relation is more balanced in countries
countries [1]. From 1983 to September 2000, with higher incidence rates [10, 28]. In Aus-
48,928 cutaneous melanomas have been re- tralia where the highest incidence rates have
gistered within this multicenter project. In been found the percentage of males exceeds
Germany, about half of all melanoma cases that of females [15–17].
are registered by the Central Malignant Mela- Based on the data of the Central Malignant
noma Registry and the data are fairly repre- Melanoma Registry most melanoma cases
sentative for the development of the epidemi- were diagnosed in the middle of life [3, 29].
ological development of cutaneous melano- The highest percentage of diagnoses is made
ma. The Central Malignant Melanoma Regis- between the 50th and 60th year of age (23%).
try has been initiated by C.E. Orfanos and C. More than 40% of all diagnoses are already
Garbe in 1983 and has been continuously made before the 50th year of age and 22% are
already diagnosed before completion of the with a median age of 56 years. Lentigo-malig-
40th year of age (fig. 3). Based on the mortali- na melanoma is diagnosed clearly later at a
ty statistics of the USA, a loss of 17 life years median age of 68 years.
has been calculated for every death case
caused by cutaneous melanoma [30].
The age at time of diagnosis is nearly the Histological Subtypes
same in males and females. However, there
was a clear variation of age according to the In the data of the Central Malignant Mela-
different histologic subtypes of cutaneous noma Registry 57.4% of all melanomas are
melanoma. Superficial spreading melanoma superficial spreading melanomas (table 1).
was diagnosed at the earliest age of 51 years The second most common tumor subtype is
(median age), followed by nodular melanoma nodular melanoma with a percentage of
important indicator for the evaluation of early to an increase in the frequency of the type of
melanoma recognition. In Western Germany, non-metastasizing melanoma [42]. In fact, cu-
a clear decrease of tumor thickness was recog- taneous melanoma is increasingly diagnosed
nizable in the eighties. The average tumor in its horizontal growth phase having not yet
thickness dropped from 2 to 1.5 mm and the developed the capacity for metastasis. This
median tumor thickness from 1.3 to 0.8 mm has most frequently been observed in Austra-
(fig. 4). An analysis of this development dur- lia. In this country, the lowest median tumor
ing the 1990s still revealed a slightly recogniz- thickness at first diagnosis has been reported.
able decrease of tumor thickness. In Eastern In Western Australia median tumor thickness
Germany, a similar trend of decreasing tumor dropped from 1.9 to 0.77 mm from 1975/76
thickness was observed with initial higher tu- to 1980/81 [43]. Similar values have in Ger-
mor thickness as compared to Western Ger- many only been reported since the mid-1990s
many. In Eastern Germany the trend to de- in its western part.
creasing tumor thickness continued likewise
during the 1990s. However, the average tu-
mor thickness values were found to be higher Tumor Spread and Prognostic
in Eastern Germany as compared to Western Factors
Germany until the mid-1990s.
A clear decrease of tumor thickness at first In the data of the Central Malignant Mela-
diagnosis was also reported from other coun- noma Registry, 90% of males and 93% of
tries. Between 1960 and 1990 tumor thickness females were diagnosed with primary cuta-
decreased in Australia from a median of 2.5 to neous melanoma alone without recognizable
1.1 mm and in Alabama from 3.3 to 1.4 mm metastases. In 8% of males and 6% of females
[39]. Similar developments have been re- loco-regional metastasis was present and in
ported from Great Britain, Italy and Scandi- 1.6% of males and 1.1% of females already
navia with clearly decreasing tumor thickness distant metastasis was present at first diagno-
at first diagnosis [6, 10, 40, 41]. This develop- sis (table 3). Unfortunately, comparable eval-
ment has been interpreted that the rapid de- uations of the tumor spread at first diagnosis
crease in melanoma incidence is mainly due have not been reported from larger collectives
TANS = Upper Trunk, upper Arms, Neck and Scalp; SSM = superficial
spreading melanoma; NM = nodular melanoma; LMM = lentigo-maligna
melanoma; ALM = acral lentiginous melanoma.
1 Classification of age: ^30; 31 – 60; 1 60 years.
ther increasing incidence rates is due to earlier All efforts to improve primary prevention,
recognition of cutaneous melanoma with however, and keeping people out of the sun
many tumors diagnosed at a time point when have not yet resulted in decreasing frequen-
the potential for the development of a metas- cies of this highly malignant tumor. Improve-
tasis had still not been gained. Earlier recogni- ment of the public awareness of melanoma
tion of melanoma is the main factor for the and skin cancer is still a major goal for derma-
improvement of the prognosis in cutaneous tologists and public health workers.
melanoma.
References
1 Garbe C, Bertz J, Orfanos CE: Ma- the German Dermatologicalal Soci- 6 Armstrong BK, Kricker A: Cuta-
lignes Melanom: Zunahme von Inzi- ety. Pigment Cell Res Suppl 1992;2: neous melanoma. Cancer Surv
denz und Mortalität in der Bundes- 285–294. 1994;19–20:219–240.
republik Deutschland. Z Hautkr 4 Rauh M, Paul E, Illig L: Incidence of 7 Osterlind A, Hou Jensen K, Moller
1986;61:1751–1764. malignant melanoma in Central Jensen O: Incidence of cutaneous
2 Garbe C, Orfanos CE: Epidemiolo- Hesse, Germany. Anticancer Res malignant melanoma in Denmark
gie des malignen Melanoms in der 1987;7:447–448. 1978–1982. Anatomic site distribu-
Bundesrepublik Deutschland im in- 5 Garbe C, Thiess S, Nürnberger F, tion, histologic types, and compari-
ternationalen Vergleich. Onkologie Ehlers G, Albrecht G, Lindlar F, son with non-melanoma skin can-
1989;12:253–262. Bertz J: Incidence and mortality of cer. Br J Cancer 1988;58:385–391.
3 Garbe C, Orfanos CE: Epidemiolo- malignant melanoma in Berlin 8 Thorn M, Bergstrom R, Adami HO,
gy of malignant melanoma in central (West) from 1980 to 1986. Acta Ringborg U: Trends in the incidence
Europe: Risk factors and prognostic Derm Venereol 1991;71:506–511. of malignant melanoma in Sweden,
predictors. Results of the Central by anatomic site, 1960–1984. Am J
Malignant Melanoma Registry of Epidemiol 1990;132:1066–1077.