Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 7

DOI: 10.1111/dial.

12449

THEME ARTICLE

The dangers of religious nationalism: Lessons from Srebrenica

Noreen Herzfeld

College of St. Benedict and St. John's


University
Abstract
Correspondence What are the consequences of the politicization of religious myths and symbols for
Noreen Herzfeld, St. John's University religious communities? The ethnic cleansing that culminated in the massacre of Sre-
Collegeville, MN 56321, USA.
brenica was promoted to the Serbian population, both in Serbia proper and in Bosnia,
Email: NHerzfeld@csbsju.edu
through the use of religious mythology and symbols. In Bosnia, religious language
lost its meaning, religious observance remained low and it became difficult for reli-
gious leaders to join together to address community issues. We see a similar use of
religious language and symbolism today in the U.S., particularly from evangelical
leaders justifying the current president and his jingoistic actions. We can look to the
conflict in Bosnia as a warning to the U.S. not to link religion and nationalism.
KEYWORDS
Bosnia, evangelical nationalism, genocide, Milosevic, nationalism, Srebrenica, Trump

1 G E NOC I D E AT S R E B R E N I CA We should take the results of co-opting religion and religious


language to serve the cause of ethno-nationalism in Bosnia as
Twenty-three years ago, more than 8,000 Muslim men and a cautionary tale. The war in Bosnia, culminating in the geno-
boys were killed in Srebrenica in a genocidal attack by Ser- cide at Srebrenica, provides a lesson in the dangers of going
bian forces, part of a war that resulted in more than 100,000 down the road of religious nationalism, for both the short and
casualties, 50,000 rapes, and almost a quarter of the popula- the long term.
tion eventually displaced. What did religion have to do with
this?
Articles of religious faith did not motivate the war in
1.1 The Bosnian war: A quick overview
Bosnia, nor was it fought to convert or to impose the insti- The ethnic cleansing that culminated in the massacre at Sre-
tutions of a religion. Thus, it was not a religious war, per brenica was part of the dissolution of the former Yugoslavia,
se. Religion, however, was instrumental in this war in two a dissolution that began formally with the secession of Slove-
important ways. First, religion became the primary factor nia in 1991, though it had been brewing since the death of
in defining the warring parties, providing a mechanism for Josip Broz Tito in 1980 and the economic collapse brought
the ethnic separatism that was a primary political goal. Sec- about by the opening of Eastern Europe to the West following
ond, religious rhetoric and religious symbols were used both the fall of the Berlin Wall. Not having any sizable minorities,
to gain public support for the war and to provide a jus- especially of Serbs, the Yugoslav army was withdrawn from
tification for Serb aggression, and the subsequent Bosniak Slovenia nine days after its secession. Croatia seceded shortly
response. after Slovenia and found itself immediately at war with Serbia.
But twenty-three years is a long time since this conflict Bosnia was caught in the middle.
ended. Why should we care about a war that now seems long In 1991, 44 percent of Bosnians were Muslim (Bosniak),
ago and far away? Mark Twain is reputed to have said, “His- 31 percent Serb, 18 percent Croat, and 6 percent simply called
tory doesn't repeat itself, but it rhymes.” Today in the U.S. themselves Yugoslavs. The Croats wanted to secede and join
we hear echoes of a similar cadence. Religious language and the newly proclaimed Croatia. The Serbs wished to remain,
symbolism are being used to foster a nationalist ethnocen- since Serbia now represented the primary force in what was
tric ideology that underlies a naked bid for power and to jus- left of Yugoslavia. Bosniaks feared being a minority in a
tify actions that would normally be considered unjustifiable. Serb-dominated country, but knew Bosnia was too small and
16 © 2019 Wiley Periodicals and Dialog, Inc. wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/dial Dialog. 2019;58:16–21.
HERZFELD 17

landlocked to prosper on its own. Nonetheless, Bosnia Zetra stadium, Karadžić proclaimed “Tonight even God is a
declared independence in March of 1992. Serb!”6
Despite the war between Croatia and Serbia, the Bosnians Such rhetorical references to religion do not stem from reli-
hoped for a peaceful exit. On April 5, more than 100,000 gious devotion. After years of communism, few of the Serbs
people marched for peace in Sarajevo. Serb snipers fired who fought in paramilitary militias and in the Bosnian Serb
on the crowd, killing six. War broke out within days. Inter- army were religiously observant. That did not prevent them
national horror at the genocide of Srebrenica precipitated from wearing religious symbols on their uniforms and using
the end of the war, as the U.S. and European allies forced semi-religious rituals. A gross example is the wedding of the
Serbian president Slobodan Milošević to the peace table at militia leader Željiko Raznjatović, better known as Arkan,
Dayton. which was steeped in religious symbolism—he wore a huge
cross and his bride was dressed as the “maiden of Kosovo,”
a Mary Magdalene figure in Serbian religious iconography.
1.2 Religious rhetoric in the Bosnian war: A In this use of religious symbolism is always the implica-
quick overview tion, stated by Arkan himself, that “we are fighting for our
The genocide at Srebrenica, like the larger war, was not faith.”7
directly religiously motivated. It was neither rooted in tenets
of the Orthodox faith, nor directly promoted by religious lead-
1.3 The primacy of community
ers. However, religious mythology, ritual, and overtly reli-
gious language were used to promote aggression. Faith referred to the community rather than the tenets of
We find the roots of a religio-nationalist mythology in Orthodoxy. After all, Orthodoxy, like all forms of Christian-
nineteenth-century Serbian folklore, which created a cult of ity, follows Jesus, who taught that we should love our enemies,
the doomed medieval Serbian kingdom, defeated and lost in turn the other cheek, and do good to those who hate us. “Our
the 1389 battle against the Ottoman Turks at Kosovo Polje.1 faith,” in Arkan's statement, is not a reference to doctrine, but
This battle became a nation's defining historical and spiritual is coterminous with “our people.” This primacy of community
event. In the context of this myth, the defeated Prince Lazar is is reinforced in the words of theologian Georges Florovsky:
a symbol of both the suffering Christ and the suffering Serbian “Christianity is a liturgical religion and the Church is first of
people.2 all a worshipping community.”8 Fr. Želko Teofilic, Orthodox
Serbian president Slobodan Milošević referred directly to priest in Srebrenica shortly after the war, confirmed this, stat-
this myth at a rally marking the six-hundredth anniversary of ing that his primary work is the liturgy. However, the auto-
the battle at Kosovo Polje in 1989, in which he noted that cephalous nature of Orthodoxy links state and church, and,
Serbia was “the bastion that defended the European culture, at times, this link has allowed the Serbian Orthodox Church
religion, and European society in general.” Milošević’s sug- (SOC) to “leave behind its primary duties” for a political
gestion of battles yet to come was the first intimation of the cause; then Orthodox Patriarch Pavle was reputed to have said,
war, “not armed battles, though it may come to that.” The “a priest has to be a teacher and a judge, and to pull a gun to
crowd chanted slogans such as “Kosovo is Serb” and “We love defend himself and his family.” Fr. Želko wryly noted that a
you, Slobodan, because you hate the Muslims.”3 Although church labeled Serbian Orthodox does seem to put ethnicity
the mention of religion in this speech is brief, the subtext is first and confession second. Religion follows the state.9
obvious: Serbia was and remains the last bastion of Christian The use of religious rhetoric and symbolism was not con-
Europe against the Muslims. More explicit were posters sold fined to the Serbian side. Although the Bosnian government
at the rally depicting Christ, Prince Lazar, and Milošević him- consistently supported a multi-ethnic state, critics pointed
self, as a new iconic Trinity.4 to Alija Izetbegović’s 1970 Islamic Declaration (republished
References to religion among the Serbs, by both ecclesias- in 1990) in which he wrote: “the first and foremost con-
tical and military leaders, become more explicit and frequent clusion is always the incompatibility of Islam and non-
during the war. I illustrate with a few examples. Metropolitan Islamic systems. There can be neither peace nor co-existence
Nikolaj, the primate of the Orthodox Church in Bosnia, pro- between the Islamic faith and non-Islamic social and political
claimed at Easter 1993 that those who accepted the leadership institutions.”10 Bosniak forces, like their Serb counterparts,
of Bosnian Serb leader Radovan Karadžić and General Ratko used Islamic symbols—green bands or bands with Quranic
Mladić were “following the difficult road of Christ.” Mladić inscriptions tied around the forehead, units named Muslim
stated that the problem of Bosnia would be solved if only Brigades, El Mujahidin, etc. Izetbegović was described as a
the Muslims would convert to Orthodoxy,5 while Karadžić “fighter for Islam, sent by God to lead the Muslims along
declared in 1994 that, “Our faith is present in all our think- the true path” and awarded a Saudi medal by King Fahd for
ing and decisions, and the voice of the Church is obeyed as contributing to the spread of Islam.11 Both imams and priests
the voice of supreme authority.” At a rally held in Sarajevo's blessed the troops for battle.
18 HERZFELD

1.4 Mimetic rivalry previously held in the country. So, did religion benefit from
its politicization?
This pattern of mimetic rivalry exemplifies the theories of
Omer Spahić, the first Muslim to return to the town of
theologian René Girard.12 Girard understands the relation-
Srebrenica, finds the frenzy of religious construction ironic.
ship between violence and religion as following a pattern in
“People turned to religion [after the war] but it was an illu-
which the desires, followed by the actions, of those who are
sion. Now the mosques and churches are empty. Religion is
locked in conflict become imitative. Though the Bosniaks
not that important.”
initially showed little use of Muslim symbols and rhetoric,
The rate of religious observance is low among all faith
as Serbian attacks on religion mounted and the Serbs them-
groups. Religious literacy, despite the teaching of religion
selves used religious motifs, the Bosniaks began to do like-
in the schools, remains equally low. Hate crimes continue.16
wise. The use of religious symbols increased, and the trap-
General Jovan Divjak, an ethnic Serb who defied sectarian-
pings of state became increasingly Islamic.13 We see an eerily
ism and led the defense of Sarajevo against Serb nationalist
similar mimesis between the Catholic Croats and the Serbs.
forces, noted in 2012, “The hate is worse now than it was
Croatian President Franjo Tudjman said “Whatever the Serbs
just after the war. It's not getting better. It's getting worse.”17
do, we do also.”14
Milorad Dodik, the newly elected Serb member of a tripartite
The importance of religious symbols also can be seen in
presidency, echoes this continuation of a quasi-tribal hatred.
the wide and intentional destruction, then reconstruction, of
This October he said of the U.S. and Britain, “they are forc-
sacred buildings and monuments. It is estimated that through-
ing us again to live with those we couldn't live with in a
out Bosnia approximately 1000 mosques, and 340 Orthodox
big Yugoslavia. The only response is to strengthen the Serb
and 450 Catholic churches and monasteries were destroyed.
national identity.”18
Some 92 percent of the mosques and virtually 100 percent of
Twenty-three years later, fear of the other still drives Bosni-
the minarets in Serb-held territory were destroyed or heavily
ans to vote within their ethnic and religious enclaves, even
damaged. In Srebrenica all five mosques were destroyed, one
for politicians whom they know are deeply corrupt. In the
in 1997, two years after the Dayton accords.
end, it is precisely these voters who suffer. An imam and the
The locations of these mosques (except for the White
Orthodox priest serving in Srebrenica spoke of the same prob-
Mosque, reconstructed in 2002) are given over to weeds and
lems among the faithful in their community, problems of drug
rubbish, or, as has so often been the case throughout his-
addiction, depression, loss of faith, loss of meaning. The loss
tory, symbols of the victor are superimposed on the ruins of
of trust in religion, of a spiritual anchor, is perhaps the greatest
the vanquished to mark one's territory. In Srebrenica, a cross
tragedy of the religio-nationalist link.
erected in the old town and a new church, built in 2013 in
Politically motivated religious rhetoric demeans our reli-
nearby Potočari where the disinterred bodies of the Muslim
gious vocabulary. Theologian William Schweiker, speaking
victims have been buried, remain flashpoints of controversy.
of his own country, the U.S., notes that, “at stake … is the
In the nearby village of Konjic Polje, an Orthodox church con-
reach, depth, and nuance of human existence. What is defaced
structed on land belonging to a Muslim woman (Fata Orlović)
is the universe of discourse for articulating the highest human
has been a locus for violent clashes and death threats that con-
aspirations as human aspirations whatever else they might
tinue to the present day. It now stands empty, awaiting removal
be.”19
to another location.
There are immediate practical losses as well. Several years
ago, the two religious leaders in Srebrenica spoke to me of
2 RELIGION: T H E U SE D O R T H E joining together to address these problems within the commu-
USER? nity. The political rhetoric of the priest made this an impos-
sibility. Religion co-opted is religion destroyed for the use of
Was religion the instrument of nationalism or nationalism the the people.
instrument of religion? One might think war led to renewed
religious identity and thus, a religious revival. Churches and
mosques were among the first objects restored or rebuilt after 3 DA NGER S IG NS I N T H E RH Y M E S
the war. Reconstruction of sacred spaces brought in monies OF HISTORY
from religious and political communities of various nations,
including Greece, Saudi Arabia, Egypt, and Italy. Religion is I visited a Serbian war memorial in a town near Srebrenica.
now taught as part of the regular curriculum in the Bosnian Striking up a conversation with a few old men who were sit-
schools.15 Women in downtown Sarajevo, who previously ting there, we told them we were Americans. One of them said
thought scarves were only for grandmas, appear in hijab. The there had been some fine American leaders. When asked who,
January 2004 Law on Religious Freedom confers on reli- he said “Robert E. Lee.” Many Serbs draw a parallel between
gious communities a legal status and protection beyond any Kosovo Polje and Appomattox, lost battles, lost causes.20
HERZFELD 19

President Donald Trump also recently referenced Robert Christian identity and a cult of personality that is almost mes-
E. Lee as “a great general” and stoked division and con- sianic. Milošević promised to reinstate a “Greater Serbia.”
troversy by saying there were “fine people” on both sides Trump will “Make America Great Again,” and has claimed
of the deadly rally in Charlottesville in 2017, a comment he came to protect Christianity. Both encourage a nostalgia
with a similar ring to one heard frequently from Serbians for an earlier and better time.
that “all sides were guilty” during the war. Like Miloše- Third, as in Serbia, where the state supported the church
vić at Kosovo Polje, Trump hinted at violence to come, and the church the state until it became difficult to separate the
telling a recent gathering of evangelical pastors that should two, evangelicals and Trump have become locked in a similar
Democrats win elections they will “overturn everything that circle of mutual reinforcement. Trump promises an evangeli-
we've done and they'll do it quickly and violently … these cal agenda that includes appointing justices who might over-
are violent people.” He added that the midterms are “very turn Roe v. Wade, revoking the Johnson amendment that pro-
much a referendum on not only me, it's a referendum on your hibits political endorsement from the pulpit, supporting Israel
religion.”21 at the expense of the Palestinians, and pushing back recent
President Trump has said a lot of things. To what should rights gained by the LGBT community. In their turn, evan-
we pay attention? It is hard to say. Words and symbols often gelical pastors overlook Trump's lack of religious interest or
have a cumulative effect. I'll highlight here three parallels that knowledge, give him a “mulligan” on his infidelities, and bless
I see between the U.S. and the Bosnian experience. him at every opportunity.
First, as before the war in Bosnia, Americans are see- If the Bosnian experience is anything to go by, this will not
ing a rise in nationalistic ethnocentrism concurrent with serve evangelicals well. Evangelical pastor Timothy Keller
a loss of observant religious participation. Journalist Peter notes, “‘Evangelical’ used to denote people who claimed the
Beinart notes, “As Americans have left organized religion, high moral ground; now, in popular usage, the word is nearly
they haven't stopped viewing politics as a struggle between synonymous with ‘hypocrite.’”26
“us” and “them.” Many have come to define us and them in As we saw in Bosnia, religion bound to a cult of nation-
even more primal and irreconcilable ways.”22 According to alism suffers, becoming a violent symbol rather than a way
the Public Religion Research Institute (PRRI), the percent- of life. Young people, in particular, are quick to note when
age of white Republicans with no religious affiliation has actions and words no longer coincide. White evangelicals in
nearly tripled since 1990.23 These Americans have weaker America have begun to experience the decline in membership
community ties, higher divorce rates, more joblessness, and that was once the province only of mainline Protestants. The
a generally darker view of the times. They are more hos- share of evangelicals in the U.S. population has dropped from
tile to immigrants and Muslims. And, lacking strong com- 23 percent to 17 percent over the last decade and much of this
munity ties, they are susceptible to nationalism, ethnocen- has come from a loss of youth, with 62 percent of evangelicals
trism, or a cult of personality as a source for a sense of now over the age of 50.27
belonging. At Trump's rallies we have seen all three of these, Hatred hardened between differing factions is very slow to
just as we did at Milosevic's. As Alex Wagner writes, “If heal. Fyodor Dostoevsky wrote: “A man who lies to himself,
mainline Protestantism is a bastion of the educated, upper- and believes his own lies, becomes unable to recognize truth.”
middle class, the Church of Trump is a gathering place for its So do such a person's followers. We know what Milošević's
castoffs.”24 words led to. Yugoslavia went through five years of war, eth-
Second, there is an eerie similarity in much of the rhetoric nic cleansing, rape camps, and the displacement of hundreds
we are hearing, particularly from evangelical ministers, in the of thousands of refugees, most of whom have not returned
drawing of analogies between political and religious figures to their ancestral homes. Bosnia remains a failed state, with
and in the stoking of the fear of others, particularly Muslims. deeply entrenched ethnic factions and political parties and
Televangelist Pat Robertson has compared Trump to Jesus, structures that fan division rather than promote unity. Young
saying that in a dream he saw Trump sitting at the right hand of people continue to leave; 35,000 left Bosnia in the past year.28
God. Pastor David Jeremiah drew a similar analogy between We cannot say the same for the U.S. But have we started down
Jared and Ivanka and Joseph and Mary, saying, “It's just like a similar road?
God to use a young Jewish couple to help Christians.” Jerry
Falwell, Jr. believed evangelicals have “found their dream
president” whom he says will be more effective than Jesus.25 4 CONC LUDING S EEDS O F H O PE
And, like Milošević, Trump rally-goers approve of the fact
that “he hates the Muslims” and cheer when he sanctions vio- Despite the above, I would like to conclude on a note of hope.
lent acts. Reconciliation and change is possible in both groups and
Both leaders, Trump and Milošević, mobilized their base individuals who work toward rebuilding trust. This happens
by stoking fear and anger coupled with an appeal to their most easily when persons of differing religions, ethnicities, or
20 HERZFELD

political parties work together on a common project, and such monastery in Sid, Serbia), as shown in the recently released videotape
projects have been sponsored in Bosnia by a variety of reli- of the execution of Muslim prisoners from Srebrenica. In a statement
gious and non-religious NGOs.29 Hope is also possible in issued June 12, 2005, the SOC condemned the killings, yet noted that
the blessing of soldiers is traditional in Orthodoxy.
the return of pastors, teachers, and believers to the teachings
10 Izetbegović, A. (1990). Islamska Delkaracija (2nd ed., p. 98).
inherent in all of our religious traditions regarding treatment
Sarajevo. Online at http://www.angelfire.com/dc/mbooks/Alija-
of the other and the holy work of hospitality.
Izetbegovic-Islamic-Declaration-1990-Azam-dot-com.pdf (accessed
I experienced this hope for Bosnia during a brief visit to a
Dec. 8, 2018).
farm outside of Bratunac. There, two women, one Serb, the 11 Veliknoja, M. (2001, Oct.). In hoc signo vinces: Religious sym-
other Muslim, shared a stove in a burnt shell of a house that
bolism in the Balkan wars 1991-1995. Religion in Eastern Europe
stood between their respective houses. They joked and argued 21(5), 9.
together as to whose cups were the better ones to serve the 12 Girard, R. N. (1977). Violence and the sacred. (P. Gregory, Trans.).
visiting American scholar. For them, the war was long over, Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University. See Ted Peters’ article for more
ethnicity had ceased to matter, and religion was all about serv- on Girardian scapegoat theory applied to religious nationalism in this
ing the wayfarer. issue of Dialog: Peters, T. (2019). Covenant, blood, and violence:
Pope John Paul II gave us a sign of hope in his 1997 visit America at war with itself and others. Dialog: A Journal of Theology
to Sarajevo: 58(1).
13 For example, at a rally in Grebak in 1996, an address by Izetbegović
Building a true and lasting peace is a great task was mixed with Islamic music and verses from the Quran.
entrusted to everyone. Certainly, much depends 14 The relationship between the Catholic church and the HDZ is beyond
on those who have public responsibility. But the the scope of this paper. As a church that is not autocephalous and
future of peace, while largely entrusted to institu- that must take leadership from Rome, this relationship was never as
tional formulations, which have to be effectively clear cut as that between the SOC and the Milošević regime. Although
drawn up by means of sincere dialogue and in the Catholic paper Veritas published rhetoric that sounds similar to
respect of justice, depend no less decisively on that used by the SOC (For example, in 1992 an article by Josip
Beljan states “The cross of Christ stands next to the Croatian flag.”
a renewed solidarity of [individual] minds and
See Banac, I. (1989). The national question in Yugoslavia: Origins,
hearts.30
history, politics (p. 108). London: Cornell.) notes “the ideologists of
There has been progress in Bosnia, albeit slow. It is my hope Croat nationhood, almost to the last practicing Catholics, resisted the
that Bosnia will continue down this path to reconciliation. It equation of Catholicism and Croatdom.” See also Bellamy, A. (2002).
The Catholic church and Croatia's two transitions. Religion, State, and
is also my hope that we in the U.S. will recognize the dan-
Society 30(1).
gers of religious nationalism, heed the lessons of the past, and 15
In theory, religious education classes in public schools in BiH are
turn away from the religious rhetoric and divisiveness of our
optional. The reality is that in some municipalities children who do
current, or indeed any, administration. not choose to attend these classes are subject to pressure and discrim-
ination from peers and teachers. In other locales, including most of
the RS, only the religion of the majority of the population is offered in
E N D NOT E S the public schools. Adult religious education is practically non-existent
among the three religious groups in Bosnia. This has led to a percep-
1
The development of such a myth was not uncommon in Europe dur- tion, expressed to me by the architect in charge of the rebuilding of the
ing the rapid transformation and rising nationalism of the nineteenth bridge in Mostar in June 2003, that religion is only for children and not
century. needed for adult life. See also Russo, C. (2000). Religion and educa-
2 tion in Bosnia: Integration not separation? Brigham Young University
The parallel between Lazar and Christ extends so far as a description of
Law Review.
a mythic Last Supper between Lazar and his comrades and a betrayal
16
by one of them. There have been 198 such crimes between 2010 and 2016, according
3 to the U.S. State Department.
Sells, M. A. (1996). The bridge betrayed: Religion and genocide in
17 Borger, J. (2012, April 4). Bosnian war 20 years on: Peace holds but
Bosnia (p. 87). Berkeley: University of California.
4 conflict continues to haunt. The Guardian.
Malcolm, N. (1996). Bosnia: A short history. London: Papermac.
18 Emric, E. and Geco, J. (2018, Oct. 5). Bosnia election seen as key for
5 Ibid.
future of war-ravaged nation. AP News.
6 Mahmutćehajić, R. (2000). The denial of Bosnia. University Park, PA: 19 Schweiker, W. (2018, Oct. 22). Mute religion. Sightings. Online at
Pennsylvania State University.
https://divinity.uchicago.edu/sightings/mute-religion (accessed Dec.
7 Sells (1996), 82. 8, 2018).
8 Quoted in Mylonas, C. (2003). Serbian Orthodox fundamentals: The 20 The rhetoric of the “lost cause” has become popular again in the South,
quest for an eternal identity (p. 37). Budapest: CEU. paralleling a rise in the display of the Confederate flag. See Sellers,
9A more problematic example is the blessing of the Serbian Scor- F. S. (2018, Oct. 22). Confederate pride and prejudice: Some white
pion unit by an Orthodox priest (Abbot Gavrilo from Holy Angels Northerners see a flag rooted in racism as a symbol of patriotism. The
HERZFELD 21

Washington Post. Online at https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/ 28 There is even a Facebook page devoted to urging young people
national/wp/2018/10/22/feature/some-white-northerners-want-to- to leave and easing their process. http://www.balkaninsight.com/
redefine-a-flag-rooted-in-racism-as-a-symbol-of-patriotism/?utm_ en/article/facebook-group-urges-bosnians-choose-life-choose-to-leave-
term=.bc3b0cda05ae&wpisrc=nl_most&wpmm=1 (accessed Dec. 8, 10-23-2018
2018). 29 Fora summary and case studies of successful NGO projects in BiH,
21 Bort, R. (2018, Aug. 29). Why Trump will never lose evangelical sup- see Peuraca, 2003.
port. Rolling Stone. 30 John Paul II (1997, April 13). Address to the Representatives of
22 Beinart, P. (2017, April). Breaking faith. The Atlantic. Authorities of Bosnia-Hercegovina. Sarajevo. http://www.instesw.
23 Cox, D. and Jones, R. P. (2017). America's changing religious identity. ebox.lublin.pl/ed/1/janpawel.html.en.
PRRI. Online at https://www.prri.org/research/american-religious-
landscape-christian-religiously-unaffiliated/ (accessed Dec. 8, 2018).
24 Wagner, AU T H O R'S B I O G R A P H Y
A. (2018, August). The church of Trump. The Atlantic.
25 Gerson, M. (2018, April). The last temptation. The Atlantic.
Noreen L. Herzfeld is Nicholas and Bernice Reuter Professor
26
Keller, T. (2017, Dec. 19). Can evangelicalism survive Donald Trump
of Science and Religion at the College of St. Benedict and St.
and Roy Moore? The New Yorker. Online at https://www.newyorker.
John's University in Collegeville, Minnesota. She is author of
com/news/news-desk/can-evangelicalism-survive-donald-trump-and-
roy-moore?mbid=social_facebook&fbclid=IwAR3fBLWNcFXP7Z2 In Our Image: Artificial Intelligence and the Human Spirit
6YYwRW6S8VQoXk3r5fSfCEvmZ5mnWy8nAmAHVWGgo_wA (Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2002).
(accessed Dec. 28, 2018).
27
Cox, D. (2018, Jan. 24). Are white evangelicals sacrificing the How to cite this article: Herzfeld N. The
future in search of the past? FiveThirtyEight. Online at https://
dangers of religious nationalism: Lessons
fivethirtyeight.com/features/are-white-evangelicals-sacrificing-the-
from Srebrenica. Dialog. 2019;58:16–21.
future-in-search-of-the-past/ (accessed Dec. 28, 2018).
https://doi.org/10.1111/dial.12449
Copyright of Dialog: A Journal of Theology is the property of Wiley-Blackwell and its
content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the
copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email
articles for individual use.

You might also like