Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Assis 2017
Assis 2017
PII: S0720-048X(17)30260-7
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2017.06.014
Reference: EURR 7874
This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication.
As a service to our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript.
The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof
before it is published in its final form. Please note that during the production process
errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that
apply to the journal pertain.
Imaging department organization in a stroke center and workflow processes in acute stroke
1. Zarina Abdul Assis, DNB, DM, Department of Diagnostic imaging, Foothills medical Centre, University of
2. Bijoy K. Menon, MD, MSc, Calgary Stroke Program and the Department of Radiology, Clinical
Neurosciences and Community Health Sciences, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, Canada
mgoyal@ucalgary.ca
Abstract:
The imaging department is an integral part of the stroke management task force and plays a critical role. Accurate
and timely interpretation of images obtained in the emergency department and involvement in decision-making
has contributed immensely in stroke care. In fact, the treatment paradigm has changed considerably after the
recent positive endovascular clinical trials; and so is the hospital workflow and treatment site. As a result, the
1
imaging department has become the site of maximum activity during an acute stroke protocol. Time management,
In this review article, we emphasize the critical role an Imaging department’s organization plays in a stroke center
Abbreviations:
MR CLEAN- Multicenter Randomized Clinical trial of Endovascular treatment for Acute ischemic stroke in the
Netherlands
EMS- Emergency Medical Services
ESCAPE-Endovascular Treatment for Small Core and Proximal Occlusion Ischemic Stroke
EXTEND-IA-Extending the Time for Thrombolysis in Emergency Neurological Deficits–Intra-Arterial
REVASCAT-Endovascular Revascularization with Solitaire Device Versus Best Medical Therapy in Anterior
Circulation Stroke Within 8 Hours
SWIFT-PRIME-Solitaire with the Intention for Thrombectomy as Primary Endovascular Treatment
HERMES- Highly Effective Reperfusion Evaluated in Multiple Endovascular Stroke Trials (HERMES) collaboration
CSC- Comprehensive Stroke Center
PSC- Primary Stroke Center
ASRH- Acute Stroke Ready Hospitals
ASPECTS- Alberta Stroke Program Early CT Score, CTA- CT angiogram, CTP- CT Perfusion, PACS- Picture Archive and
Communication System, tPA- Tissue Plasminogen Activator, IV- Intravenous
Introduction:
Time is critical and non-negotiable for patients with acute stroke. Having a right, well-organized center with
seamless lean workflow for stroke management will contribute immensely towards positive outcomes in patients
with acute stroke. The imaging department is an integral part of the stroke management task force and plays a
critical role in accurate and timely interpretation of images obtained in the emergency department.
Results of each of the recently published clinical trials (MR CLEAN, ESCAPE, SWIFT-PRIME, EXTEND-IA, REVASCAT)
favored emergency endovascular intervention in the management of large proximal vessel occlusions in eligible
2
patients in addition to standard care [1-5]. These endovascular trials emphasized the role of imaging in patient
Here we show the reader the critical role an Imaging department’s organization plays in a stroke center and the
Summary of “The 3-Stroke certifications” for defining the role of acute stroke care centers [6]:
The Joint Commission has implemented a three level certification process based on level of stroke care and
expertise.
Primary stroke centers (PSCs): These centers are equipped to manage most of the acute ischemic stroke, do basic
imaging (including CT/ CTA/ MR/ MRA, cardiac imaging) and laboratory investigations, perform emergency
thrombolysis and access to neurosurgery within 2 hours. Complex cases needing neuro-endovascular or neuro-
critical care are transferred to the nearest comprehensive stroke center (CSC).
Comprehensive stroke care centers (CSCs): Comprehensive stroke centers are typically the largest and best-
equipped hospitals in a given geographical area that can treat any kind of stroke (both ischemic and hemorrhagic)
or stroke complications. The Joint Commission (JC) for Hospital Accreditation in United States and other countries
have adopted the pathway of sequestering stroke patients in CSCs, which possess the necessary personnel and
equipment to provide multimodal treatment. This approach benefits patients and also spares non-CSC facilities
Acute stroke ready hospitals (ASRH): Recently designed by the Joint Commission for those areas without ready
access to PSCs or CSCs within 60 minutes (which accounts for at least 50% of the population in United States),
these ASRHs will have the ability to perform basic diagnostic imaging (like CT/ MR) round the clock. The acute
stroke team will have the ability to perform thrombolysis if needed, prior to transferring the patient to PSC or CSC
[8].
It is clear from the above discussion, that the diagnostic imaging department plays an indisputable role in stroke
care, regardless of the level of hospital certification for acute stroke management. Hence there is need for re-
3
organization of the radiology departments in these stroke centers in order to impart quality care as per the current
guidelines.
“Time is brain”:
The concept of ‘time is brain’ is not only intuitively obvious but is backed by excellent data [9, 10, 11, 12]. Results
from the IMS III study shows that every 45-minute delay in angiographic reperfusion reduced the likelihood of
good clinical outcome by 10% [9]. The STAR study shows that for every one-hour delay in stroke onset to final
digital subtraction angiography time, there is a 38% decrease in outcome [11]. In ESCAPE trial, every 30-minute
increase in CT to-reperfusion time reduced the probability of achieving a functionally independent outcome by
8.3% . [13]
In a recent meta-analysis of the five successful endovascular clinical stroke trials (HERMES collaboration)
conducted over 89 international sites, each 1-hour delay to reperfusion was associated with a less favorable
degree of disability (cOR, 0.84; ARD, −6.7%) and less functional independence (OR, 0.81, ARD, −5.2%). [14]
In fact, every passing minute, 1.9 million neurons, 14 billion synapses, and 12 km (7.5 miles) of myelinated fibers
While teamwork is critical for success of any business (for example: travel, healthcare, pharma, sports, automobile,
media, etc), it is even more important in situations that are time critical and the outcome is directly correlated with
the efficiency of the overall process. The closest analogy that is commonly used is the changing of the wheels
during an F1 race where in approximately 10 seconds all the wheels of the race car are changed and the
4
A well-organized collective multi-specialty team work is critical for success. A stroke team consists of specialists
from various departments, inclusive of and not limited to neurology, neuroradiology, neurosurgery, anesthesia and
Imaging department as the new hub for acute stroke diagnosis and management decision-making:
With the recent change in the treatment paradigm after the positive endovascular clinical trials; there needs to be
a corresponding change in the hospital workflow. The imaging department needs to become the site of maximum
activity during an acute stroke protocol [16]. Starting from patient triaging, image acquisition, image
interpretation, decision-making, discussion and consent taking as well as treatment, almost all of the important
aspects of acute stroke management will take place within the imaging department (Figure 2).
Speed, Efficiency, Consistency, and Teamwork are the basic fundamental principles of imaging department in a
Comprehensive Stroke Centre. These principles echo with the requirements in an acute trauma care set-up, as in
Dedicated stroke paging system: Fast and accurate communication within the stroke team plays
a crucial role in acute stroke treatment. Integrating radiologists in this process ensures faster imaging and
interpretation, influencing better clinical outcomes. A 24 x 7 stroke paging system for CT technical staff,
Endovascular team and on-call CT radiologist will enable them to know ahead of time about a potential
acute stroke patient approaching the hospital [16]. This in-turn will ensure availability of the CT scanner
for rapid image acquisition and interpretation. The endovascular team can meanwhile get ready for a
o CT and CT angiogram (CTA): Because of its quick and widely available acquisition, non-
contrast CT remains the primary imaging technique for stroke syndrome presentations. It helps
to quickly differentiate ischemic and hemorrhagic stroke and to measure the extent of early
5
All recent clinical trials used CTA technique to detect proximal intracranial occlusions [1-5].
Additionally, collateral status can be measured on multiphase CTA by assessing backfilling pial
arteries distal to the intracranial occlusion compared with the unaffected contralateral
hemisphere [18]. Recent articles suggest that CT, CTA is now the standard of care in the work up
Imaging department in a stroke center must be equipped with a fully functional Emergency CT
scanner with CTA (preferably multiphase CTA) and possibly CT Perfusion capabilities.
Because acute ischemic stroke treatment is time sensitive, front-line physicians, including stroke
neurologists, general neurologists, emergency room physicians, and trainees have important
roles in image interpretation. A separate dedicated imaging station with access to PACS should
be available round the clock for these non-radiologists to review the CT/ CTA images as soon as
they are acquired. A computer system with access to old health records of the patients should
o Decision on CT perfusion (CTP): Not all centers have the ability to perform and process
CT perfusion studies. Also, CT perfusion as an imaging modality in acute setting has some
disadvantages, including limited brain coverage, susceptibility to motion, and increased time
consumption for image acquisition, processing and interpretation [20]. Generally, the type of
information from CTP may not influence current clinical decision-making with regard to offering
endovascular therapy [21]. Hence it should be left to the discretion of the Institution regarding
the utilization of this modality, potentially for research purposes. At our centre we do not use
CTP routinely. Based on the recent data, it is clear that centres that do continue to perform CTP
should be able to demonstrate no deterioration in overall workflow and no significant time loss.
o MRI versus CT: Magnetic resonance (MR) imaging has definitive advantages over CT,
including tissue viability assessment with diffusion weighted imaging. However, the availability of
MR imaging in the hyperacute setting is limited [16]. In addition, MR is usually quite time
6
consuming especially the process of ruling out contraindications to MRI such as pacemakers etc.
Hence radiology department should focus on better organization and workflow improvement in
The Joint Commission already mandates that unenhanced CT of patients suspected of having acute
ischemic stroke be performed within 25 minutes of admission to the emergency department and that
unenhanced CT scans be interpreted within 20 minutes of being obtained. These targeted times should be
even further shortened in CSCs. The “ideal” times suggested by the Society of Neurointerventional
Surgery are door-to–unenhanced CT scan interpretation of less than 15 minutes and door-to–CT
In an ideal scenario, patient may be transferred from “Door-to-Scanner”, by-passing the Emergency
department. In this way, patient can be transferred directly on the EMS stretcher to the scanner. Clinical
examination can be performed on the EMS stretcher while transferring to the CT scanner. Detailed
patient clinical history from the EMS paramedical staff can also be obtained during the transfer, ensuring
no delays [23].
Clear written imaging protocols should be available with the CT technologists for non-contrast CT and CT
angiogram of head and neck vessels. These protocols should be uniform across the regional stroke
network. At our institution, we have a standard ‘acute stroke protocol’ consisting of a plain CT head and a
multiphase CTA (the first phase includes arch and neck vessels). The details of this protocol have been
previously described [18]. We do not hold up doing a CTA for availability of kidney function tests. There is
literature data available to suggest that there is no significant difference in the incidence of acute renal
injury between contrast enhanced and non-enhanced CT scans, irrespective of the baseline renal function
[24].
7
Round-the-clock availability of experienced radiologist and CT technologist:
performing CTAs and CT perfusion is not to be ignored. In many institutions, 24x7 availability of a trained
neuroradiologist may not be feasible [25]. In such scenarios, the staff radiologist on duty must be capable
of rapidly interpreting changes of acute ischemic stroke on non-contrast CT (preferably give ASPECTS
scoring) and identify vascular occlusion on CT angiography [16]. Radiology departments must focus on
continuous training to further improve efficiency of stroke treatment and accurate and timely image
interpretation. In many institutions, residents (and fellows) play a key role in emergency radiology
services especially after hours. In light of the recent data, it is imperative that radiology residency
programs adapt to these changes in workflow and create a curriculum to have effective, accurate and
acute stroke studies in the first year of residency. Our experience suggests that residents find multiphase
CTA extremely useful for quickly detecting the site of occlusion, assessing collaterals and correlating these
Quick review of plain CT head images to rule out intracranial hemorrhage and large ischemic core, while
the patient is still in the scanner, enables immediate decision regarding administering intravenous tPA.
This time can be utilized for the preparation and administration of intravenous tPA, which can be started
Historically, the workflow around IV (Intravenous) rtPA administration has been time-consuming as it was
administered in a dedicated space away from the angiography suite and sometimes patients were
assessed for clinical improvement before notifying the endovascular team [27]. The recent trials have
however proven that endovascular therapy is effective with or without IV rtPA. Hence it is not imperative
8
to wait for clinical improvement, and the patient should be transferred as soon as possible to the
angiography suite.
It is ideal to have a prearranged stroke tray ready for use in the angiogram suite at all times so that the
procedure can be initiated without delay [23]. We also emphasize using standardized techniques and
devices as much as possible [28]. We have implemented what we call BRISK (Brisk Recanalization Ischemic
Stroke Kit). It comprises of a stroke tray where all the necessary materials are already set up (in the order
of when they would be needed) and ready to go (excluding expensive materials such as stent retrievers).
We implemented this widely across the ESCAPE trial sites as part of the ESCAPE quality improvement and
workflow efficiency process. All the recent trials have used new generation stent retrievers in majority of
cases [1-5]. Different centers may use different techniques in stroke intervention (For example: Use of
anesthesia, use of balloon guide catheter, use of intermediate aspiration catheter etc.) depending on their
comfort level. It is advisable to stick to the Institution protocol as much as possible to avoid confusions
among the team members and time delay. Cross-training x-ray and CT technicians to help in the
angiography suite may speed up the process on weekends or during nights [23]. As most of the hospitals
have 24x7 availability of an x-ray and/or CT technologist, it’s a good idea to train them in the basic angio-
suite procedures. Knowledge about putting-on the angio-machine, entering the patient demographics
into the angio-console, positioning the patient on angio-table, location of important devices and materials
like contrast, heparin etc can avoid delays while waiting for the endovascular team to arrive.
restructure the radiology department. The emergency CT scanner must be located in very close
proximity to the emergency department. Separate image reviewing stations for 24 x7 access to stroke
9
team should be made available for seamless workflow. Emergency CT reading rooms should be
placed closer to the scanner, so that real time protocoling and decision on repeating the scan can be
taken without delay by the on-call radiologist. Finally, the neuroangiography suite can be favorably
located in close proximity to the CT scanner, for faster patient mobilization [16].
Documentation: Onset-to-reperfusion time and imaging-to-reperfusion time are the two critical
steps in the stroke management and recent endovascular trials have demonstrated that fast
reperfusion is the key to a good outcome. Centers should keep detailed time records of their
workflow and times for image acquisition, transfer, post-processing, and interpretation.
recommended.
and neurosurgical team to discuss and challenge the existing stroke patient management with
Conclusion
A well-organized Imaging department plays a critical role in stroke center contributing seamlessly for the
management of acute stroke patients thereby improving functional outcome. Challenging workflow at regular
intervals with iterative feedback and aggressive time goals will further enhance efficient workflow environments.
Having standardized and simple imaging protocols and investing early in resident education are critical steps for
workflow efficiency. We recommend a simple imaging protocol of non-contract CT and multiphase CTA.
Conflicts of Interest:
10
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank all the members of the Calgary Stroke Program for the excellent team work.
11
References:
1.Berkhemer OA, Fransen PSS, Beumer D, et al; for the MR CLEAN Investigators. A randomized trial of intraarterial
2. Goyal M, Demchuk AM, Menon BK, et al; for the ESCAPE Trial Investigators. Randomized assessment of rapid
3. Campbell BC, Mitchell PJ, Kleinig TJ, et al; for the EXTEND-IA Investigators. Endovascular therapy for ischemic
4. Saver JL, Goyal M, Bonafe A, et al; for the SWIFT-PRIME Investigators. Stent-retriever thrombectomy after
5. Jovin TG, Chamorro A, Cobo E, et al; for the REVASCAT Trial Investigators. Thrombectomy within 8 hours after
7. Nazli Janjua; Adnan I Qureshi; Osama O Zaidat. Systemization of Advanced Stroke Care: The Dollars and Sense of
8. Alberts .M.J, Wechsler L.R, Jensen.M.E, Latchaw.R.E, George.M.G, Baranski.J, Bass.R.R, et al. Formation and
function of acute stroke-ready hospitals within a stroke system of care recommendations from the brain attack
coalition. Stroke. 2013 Dec;44(12):3382-93. doi: 10.1161/STROKEAHA.113.002285. Epub 2013 Nov 12.
9. Khatri P, Yeatts SD, Mazighi M, et al. Time to angiographic reperfusion and clinical outcome after acute
ischaemic stroke: an analysis of data from the Interventional Management of Stroke (IMS III) phase 3 trial: A
10. Hill MD, Goyal M, Demchuk AM, Fisher M. Ischemic stroke tissue-window in the new era of endovascular
12
11. Menon BK, Almekhlafi MA, Pereira VM, et al. Optimal workflow and process-based performance measures for
endovascular therapy in acute ischemic stroke: analysis of the Solitaire FR thrombectomy for acute
12. Marc Ribo, Carlos A. Molina, Erik Cobo, Neus Cerdà, Alejandro Tomasello, Helena Quesada et al; For the
REVASCAT Trial Investigators. Association Between Time to Reperfusion and Outcome Is Primarily Driven by the
Time From Imaging to Reperfusion. Stroke. 2016;STROKEAHA.115.011721, published online before print March 8,
2016.
13. Menon B.K, Sajobi T.T, Zhang Y, Rempel J.L, Shuaib A, Thornton J, Williams D et al. Analysis of Workflow and
Time to Treatment on Thrombectomy Outcome in the Endovascular Treatment for Small Core and Proximal
Occlusion Ischemic Stroke (ESCAPE) Randomized, Controlled Trial. Circulation. 2016 Jun 7;133(23):2279-86.
14. Saver J.L, Goyal M, van der Lugt A, Menon B.K, Majoie C.B, Dippel D.W et al. Time to Treatment With
Endovascular Thrombectomy and Outcomes From Ischemic Stroke: A Meta-analysis. JAMA. 2016 Sep
27;316(12):1279-88.
15. Saver JL. Time is brain- quantified. Stroke. 2006; 37: 263-266.
16. Mayank Goyal, Colin P. Derdeyn, David Fiorella, Jeffrey Ross, Pamela Schaefer, Robert Tarr, Morgan C. Willson,
Eric Bartlett, Max Wintermark, and David Kallmes. Recent Endovascular Trials: Implications for Radiology
Departments, Radiology Residency, and Neuroradiology Fellowship Training at Comprehensive Stroke Centers.
17 .M. Artigas Martína, Martí de Graciab, L.M. Claraco Vegac, P. Parrilla Herranzd. Radiology and imaging
18. Menon BK, d’Esterre C, Qazi E, et al. Multiphase CT angiography: a new tool for the imaging triage of patients
13
19. Demchuk A M, Menon B K, Goyal M. Comparing vessel imaging: Non contrast computed tomography/
computed tomographic angiography should be the new minimum standard in acute disabling stroke. Stroke. 2016
Jan;47(1):273-81.
20. Goyal M, Menon BK, Derdeyn CP. Perfusion imaging in acute ischemic stroke: let us improve the science before
21. Bijoy. K. Menon, Mayank Goyal. Imaging Paradigms in Acute Ischemic Stroke: A Pragmatic Evidence-based
22. McTaggart RA, Ansari SA, Goyal M, et al. Initial hospital management of patients with emergent large vessel
occlusion (ELVO): report of the standards and guidelines committee of the Society of NeuroInterventional Surgery.
23. Zerna C, Assis Z, d'Esterre CD, Menon BK, Goyal M. Imaging, Intervention, and Workflow in Acute Ischemic
Stroke: The Calgary Approach.AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2016 Jun;37(6):978-84. doi: 10.3174/ajnr.A4610. Epub 2015
Dec 10.
24. Robert J. McDonald, Jennifer S. McDonald, John P. Bida, Rickey E. Carter, Chad J. Fleming, Sanjay Misra, Eric E.
Williamson, and David F. Kallmes. Intravenous Contrast Material–induced Nephropathy: Causal or Coincident
25. Mark J. Alberts, Richard E. Latchaw, Warren R. Selman, Timothy Shephard, Mark N. Hadley, Lawrence M.
Brass, et al; for the Brain Attack Coalition. Recommendations for Comprehensive Stroke Centers: A Consensus
Statement From the Brain Attack Coalition. Stroke. 2005; 36: 1597-1616.
26. Yu AY, Zerna C, Assis Z, Holodinsky JK, Randhawa PA, Najm M, Goyal M, Menon BK, Demchuk AM, Coutts SB,
Hill MD Multiphase CT angiography increases detection of anterior circulation intracranial occlusion. Neurology.
14
27. Fonarow GC, Smith EE, Saver JL, et al. Improving door-to-needle times in acute ischemic stroke: the design and
rationale for the American Heart Association/American Stroke Association’s target: stroke initiative. Stroke
2011;42:2983–99.
28. Almekhlafi MA, Hockley A, Desai JA, et al. Overcoming the evening/weekend effects on time delays and
outcomes of endovascular stroke therapy: The Calgary Stroke Program experience. J Neurointerv Surg 2014;6:729–
32.
15
Biography
Bijoy K Menon reports membership of the steering and executive committee, ESCAPE trial that received
support from Covidien Inc., site principal investigator, SOCRATES Trial, sponsored by AstraZeneca,
honoraria from Penumbra Inc., a provisional patent 62/086077 for triaging systems in ischemic stroke,
research funding from CIHR, HSFC, AIHS, HBI, and the Faculty of Medicine, University of Calgary, and
reports board membership of QuikFlo Health Inc.
Mayank Goyal is a consultant for Covidien for teaching engagements and for design and conduct of
SWIFT PRIME trial; University of Calgary received partial funding for ESCAPE trial provided by Covidien
through an unrestricted grant to the institution. Dr. Goyal has a patent systems and methods for
diagnos-
ing strokes (PCT/CA2013/000761) licensed to GE Healthcare.
16
Figure Legends:
Figure 1: Pictorial representation of stroke management being multi-departmental and the need for team-work.
17
Figure 2: Infographic representation of role of imaging department in acute stroke management.
18