CHAPTER 1

PRELIMINARY

1.1 Background

Critical review journals in the form of this paper contain conclusions from comparisons that we
will make in two journals. The author also includes a summary of each journal, where both
journals have almost the same title in the discussion.

       In criticizing the journal, the writer can find out the difference between the two journals.
And also know the advantages and disadvantages of each journal. The making of the Critical
Journal Review aims to fulfill the group tasks of the KKNI. Hopefully this effort can be
beneficial for the general reader and for the compilers in particular.

1.2 Problem Formulation

The formulation of the problem in writing Critical Journal Review is:

1. How is the review or summary of the journal?

2. What is the comparison of the contents of each journal?

3. What are the advantages and disadvantages of the journal?

1.3 Purpose

The aim to be achieved by writers in critical writing of this review journal is to be able to
provide information from each journal and can be understood by readers in depth about each
journal through the contents of the summary followed by weaknesses and strengths of each
journal.

1
 CHAPTER II

CONTENTS OF JOURNAL SUMMARY

2.1 Journal Identity

2.1.1 Identity of Main Journals (1)

Title of Journal Implementation Of Structural Employment Efficiency Beam

Column ConventionalMethods And Precast Seen From The
Aspect Of Time And Costs (Case StudyProject Sport Center
Jember, Jember)

Volume and page Vol. 13 No. 03

Author Maria Ulfa, JojokWidodo&AnikRatnaningsih
Publishing Year 2014
Website Address http://scholar.google.co.id/scholar?journal+implementation
Publication Jember University
ISSN 1693-7619

2.1.2 Identity of Comparative Journal (2)

Title of Journal The Effect Of Archive Management On Employment

EfficiencyIn The Sub Section Of Civil Servants Dr.
SoedirmanKebumen
Volume and page VOL. 2. NO.1
Author Uswatunkhasanah&Sutriono
Publishing Year 2018
Website Address http://jurnal.politeknik-kebumen.ac.id/index.php/E-
Bis/article/view/79
Publication Politeknik Dharma Patria Kebumen

ISSN 2443-0455

2.2 Journal Summary

2
2.2.1 Summary of Main Journals (1)
Research purposes
Research subject
Data Assessment
Research methods
Research result
2.2.2 Summary of the Comparative Journal (2)
To Comparing conventional method in the construction
project of the Jember Sport Center Stadium (JSC).
With the precast method
The study was conducted to Employment of Jember Sport
Garden
Data used in this study consisted of analysis unit prices,
implementation methods and worker productivity. The
data is then entered into the plan cost budget so that the
comparison is known.
In this study researchersusedusing primary data processing
and management analysis starting from stages like the
following: implementation techniques,unit price analysis,
total cost, time duration.
From the results of calculations and analysis in the
discussion previously concluded. Based on the results the
calculation of the total cost in the conventional method of
IDR 23,409,447,924.19 and the total cost on the
preprinting method in the amount of IDR
16,880,605,889.37. Difference from second use the
method is IDR 6,528,842,034.82 or amounting to ±
27.89% of the total beams and columns with using
conventional methods. Project duration analysis the
conventional method is 244 days and analyzed the
duration of the project in the conventional method is 229
day. Total time needed by using the preprinting method
only takes 93.9% of the total timethe time taken using the
method conventional.
3
Research purposes To know how the effect of management of the archives of
employment efficiency in Sub-section of staffing RSUD
Dr. SoedirmanKebumen.
Research subject Officials or employees in the sub-section of staffing.
Data Assessment In this study researchersused Observation, Interview,and
Questionnaire method with the final results through
regression
Research methods The research method used in this research is the
quantitative descriptive correlational research method,
which is the methods used to describe or explain the
problem by finding, collecting and studying data from a
particular population or sample.
Research result From the results of this research, it is known that there is
strong positive relationship between the management of
the archive of work efficiency in sub-section of staffing
RSUD Dr. SoedirmanKebumen . It is evident from the
pearson correlation test results earned value 0,910 and
calculation of questionnaires that States 82,8% work
efficiency in sub-section of staffing RSUD Dr.
SoedirmanKebumen influence by management of archive
while 17,2 % influence by another factor. The problem of
management of the archive is limitedness of officer to
handle the archive. Thus, the need for special officer in
managing the archive.

CHAPTER III

DISCUSSION

4
3.1 Discussion of Journal / Comparison Contents

Journal 1
In this journal discuss about Implementation Of
Structural Employment Efficiency Beam Column
ConventionalMethods And Precast Seen From The
Aspect Of Time And Costs (Case StudyProject
Sport Center Jember, Jember)
Journal 2
In this journal discuss about The Effect
Of Archive Management On
Employment EfficiencyIn The Sub
Section Of Civil Servants Dr.
SoedirmanKebumen

In this study researchers using primary data
processing and management analysis starting from
stages like the following: implementation
techniques,unit price analysis, total cost, time
duration.
Based on the results of the research obtainePre
cast methods are more efficient than conventional
methods in terms of both cost and time
This study used quantitative descriptive
correlational research method, which is
the methods used to describe or explain
the problem by finding, collecting and
studying data from a particular
population or sample.
Based on the results of research there is
strong positive relationship between the
management of the archive of work
efficiency in sub-section of staffing
RSUD Dr. SoedirmanKebumen .

3.2 Journal Strengths and Weaknesses

Journal Strengths Weaknesses

Main (1)  The author takes an  The language used is

interesting theme because it
directly compares the use of
conventional methods in the
field of construction with the
latest methods in the field of
construction, namely the pre-
cast method as an example of
the case of course this will
make the reader easier to
understand the contents of the
research
 Authors Used Previous
Research That Take Similar
Themes To Strengthen This
Research result as an
example of research
conducted by Tomy
Febryansyah on case study of
5
complicated.for example
in the defenition of pre-
cast methods that do not
explain directly to the
point
 The author doesn't
provide a more detailed
explanation related to this
journal disscusion as an
example in introduction
section the author only
explains the pre-cast
method without explaining
what conventional
methods are for
comparison. this will
certainly confuse the
 SoekarnoHatta Apartment in
Malang (Febryansyah, Tomy
2008) [2].
reader to understanding
this journal because it has
no reference at all about
conventional methods.

Comparative  Explanation of journal  In the results of the study

material is very detailed. the the authors do not
(2)
author gives a clear describe include the results of
of what is will research as an
interview and
example in the introduction.
with an explanation like this questionnaire data so
in introduction will certainly that the validity of the
make it easier for readers to data from this study can
understand the contents of the be doubtful.
research
 The language used is easy to
understand. For example, in
the introductory sentence the
reader easily discusses the
contents of the introduction
as well as the other parts

CHAPTER IV

CLOSING

6
 4.1 Conclusions

After analyzing it as a whole, in our opinion the two research journals are quite good.
Researchers use research methods that are in sync with the objectives of the study.

4.2 Suggestions

In the advantages and the two journals to be more maintained and strengthened again, and about
the lack of journals to be more focused on achieving maximum results.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

http://scholar.google.co.id/scholar?journal+implementation
7
http://jurnal.politeknik-kebumen.ac.id/index.php/E-Bis/article/view/79