Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Catharsis: Journal of Arts Education: Pendidikan Kesenian
Catharsis: Journal of Arts Education: Pendidikan Kesenian
Catharsis: Journal of Arts Education: Pendidikan Kesenian
Article History: The dimension and power of the arts reviewed from an artistic and aesthetic
Received 26 May 2019 aspect of this article are assessed by its empowerment in the educational process
Accepted 25 as a teaching and creating medium in The Floating School (TFS) to the discourse
September 2019 toward the arts education problematic holistically. This primary subject
Published 24 December constitutes a base of the study to analyze the idea of TFS founders and
2019 facilitators to the artistic and aesthetic aspect in its learning object and model, in
the study of Ki Hadjar Dewantara’s Pendidikan Kesenian (arts education). The
Keywords:
research on this article uses a qualitative-interpretative approach with a study
artistic expression,
aesthetic creation, case model to the TFS 2017 program. The viewpoint and understanding of
power, arts ,arts founders and facilitators become a primary data collection through a review of
learning the study document, an applied of a deep interview, and a base of participative
observation. The validity of the data collection result is tested by the
commensurability test of the data and data resources. By focusing the data on an
account and transcript of the interview, data analysis uses an illustrative method
through five stages: (1) appreciating the account and transcript of interview; (2)
giving a note; (3) formulating a theme; (4) conceptualizing a topic; and (5)
adjusting a problem topic, to narrating the result of interpretation with the
critical discourse analysis. Thereby, this article shows that the TFS art
workshops have a position and role in accompanying and fostering the students
to express a story or their understanding of object material and create a message
or their processing into the artwork. Those processes and progress finally
develop the TFS student’s curiosity and confidence in cultivating their skills and
knowledge. This study case is expected to be a power and contribution towards
a discipline of arts education.
364
Jalaluddin Rumi, Wadiyo, Triyanto/
of the growth of usage of arts forms and objects The result of this study document becomes
into learning, through the teaching and training, an initial framework in the deep interview
in the natural or alternative schools in the form of consisted of two stages: the first, namely an initial
regular or collaborated program. conversation to the founders about a notion of
The study toward Ki Hadjar’s Pendidikan TFS program (idea, facilitator, lesson plan,
Kesenian conception itself becomes a critical study learning object and model), while to the
of this arts education problematic that is still less facilitators about a stage of collaboration
studied comprehensively and contemplatively. (meeting, acquaintanceship, discussion, lesson
The one main problem—its research has more plan preparation); the second, namely a sequel
focused on Ki Hadjar’s philosophy of education discussion to the facilitators concerning the TFS
in general by skipping the arts position and role learning process and joyful learning (arts-media-
in Perguruan Tamansiswa—also holds the main literature object and workshop model), while to
matter to the understanding and embodiment of the founders concerning the object and model of
art education in Indonesia. learning (arts-media-literature object and
In the other words, this study is regarded workshop model) accompanied by a
to become the study case to looking a context of confirmation of the whole data collection. This
its relevance and challenge in the virtual era with deep interview has the shape of a relevant account
the millennial which is identical with the creative, and transcript. Whereas the participative
active, and innovative subject. Regarded to the observation holds the supporting data in the form
complex problematic, this article efforts to of rechecking the data collection result by directly
scrutinize in a centralized scale and different seeing the current situation and condition of TFS
perspective. Thereby, arts education as the 2017 program.
aesthetic education constitutes the focus of this Further, to validating the data collection,
study case by concentrating its analysis and study the result of data collection is tested by using a
in the visual arts dimension, accordance with the commensurability test of the data and data
learning object and model of TFS, to discourse resources. After sorting and organizing the data
the embodiment of arts dimension and power in collection result, the account and transcript of
education holistically. interview are analyzed into five stages by
confirming from the result of study document and
METHODS participative observation, textually and
contextually, in its analysis process: (1) reading
the result of data sorting repeatedly, to obtain an
This article scrutinizes and studies the
early view; (2) giving a reflection note of the data
focus study using a qualitative-interpretative
sorting result, after appreciating and checking its
approach with a study case model. As for the data
with a response note; (3) raising a illustration of
collection is started with a study document,
theme by giving a comment to the transcript
followed up and deepen its discussion and review
context that will be presented accordance with
through a deep interview; then bolstered up and
the focus study; (4) taking a particular topic by
supported with repeated observation to the three
giving a review to the comment from the theme
islands. The data collection from study
to present the data descriptively; (5) organizing
document, namely a lesson plan of each
the topics toward the proposed themes that has
workshop, a curriculum vitae of the three
adjusted to the research problem.
founders and four facilitators, an evaluation
Finally, the result of an initial analysis is re-
report of each class meeting, a catalogue of
scrutinized by its correlations toward the result of
exhibition, the photos of process and progress of
the study document (frameworks) and re-
each student’s artwork, and the testimony videos
observation (pieces of evidence) thus generates
of TFS founders and facilitators and also
the description that has obtained from the initial
students.
analysis review. This description is afterward
365
Jalaluddin Rumi, Wadiyo, Triyanto/
Catharsis: Journal of Arts Education 8 (4) 2019 363 - 373
366
Jalaluddin Rumi, Wadiyo, Triyanto/
Catharsis: Journal of Arts Education 8 (4) 2019 363 - 373
The Artistic and Aesthetic Aspect of Arts in student’s intelligence in processing and creating
The Floating School’s Learning various material objects which sharply foster their
Positioning the arts dimension and power feeling beauty.
to the artistic and aesthetic aspect, as the This aspect can become a medium to train
approach in education besides, also put it to the student’s imagination sensibility through
habituate the student’s mind and feel toward the aesthetic experience (the cultivation of
beauty in integrated. Regarding this subject, perception, conception, and visualization) from
Salam (2014: 2) asserts that a similarity between the artistic practice of artworks: a view-mind
arts and creativity holds in the experience to (interpretation) and an express-power
creating something in artistic; where it enables (representation) to the reality and life experience
the students can process their intelligence and through the arts (Tedjoworo, 2017: 132). That
imagination as well as free. power can emerge because it is directly contacted
This power, according to Sugiharto (2017: with the sensibility and capability in assessing
37), emphasizes that the whole aspect and object something (Lufiani, Sabana, & Haldani, 2017:
of arts can be functioned to any spheres with its 47); that involves feeling, imagination, and
capacity of imagination and sensation. This is the awareness (Iryanti, 2016: 10); to understand what
role of artistic ability in expressing the object it is experienced (Sunarto, 2011: 199). Besides,
material and an aesthetic ability in creating a according to Green & Kindseth (2011: 338), the
form; in another way by Triyanto, Mujiyono, & artistic practice aligns with a stimulant function
Sugiarto (2017: 262), see it as an aesthetic that stimulates an individual development
adaptation in general that reflect a cultural influenced on the reflection in the context of arts
mechanism toward the circumstance changes. learning.
That manifestation following Eisner’s (2002: 76) By habituating the students in creating will
depiction about how the arts gives the deep form a perspicacity and shrewdness to express
teaching medium to the student’s intelligence whose they have caught as the knowledge.
growth and imagination development through Therefore, a method of giving subject matter is
the artistic expression and aesthetic creation. attempted to hone the student’s technical skill
This pattern is directly related to the artistic thus they can understand that the technics can
and aesthetic aspects contained in arts learning. affect the beauty of artworks. Another given
The experience has effects on the imagination method to support the learning is by giving an
development supported by the artistic reflection example of artworks (see Figure 4). The process
toward the student’s intelligence growth in makes the students to easier understand the
responding and representing the forms of technics of artworks that affects on a message of
artworks. Concerning to this subject, Sunarto the artwork, as Iqbal’s (interview, March 20,
(2017: 105) sees the learning in aesthetic way 2019) description of photography class’s
consisting of three stages of fosterage: facilitator.
objectification of aesthetic dimension about the
object material; conceptualizing the result of
objectification through interpretation and
representation; visualizing the form of
objectification.
Working the art, that reforms a reality with
a composition of scratches and color in drawing
or painting, motion and sound rhythm in dance,
notes and tempos oscillation in music, words and
tenses sequence in literature, artistically, arouses
Figure 4. The Method Case of Exemplification in
the student’s feeling beauty who have habituated
in appreciating the objects or artworks. This the Process of Giving Subject Matter in
artistic reflection invents the capacity to the Photography Class by Iqbal
(Photo Document: TFS, 2017)
367
Jalaluddin Rumi, Wadiyo, Triyanto/
Catharsis: Journal of Arts Education 8 (4) 2019 363 - 373
368
Jalaluddin Rumi, Wadiyo, Triyanto/
Catharsis: Journal of Arts Education 8 (4) 2019 363 - 373
In the other words, the artistic aspect is Also as mentioned, the dolanan or play in
directed to the problem of what and how students the conception of Ki Hadjar’s Pendidikan Kesenian
can (related to the skill) express (recognizing the is the base forming of the feeling beauty, besides
self and environment), and the aesthetic aspect is with the gending and lakon and also another
about what and why the students want to (related developed form of the arts. The play by
to the knowledge) create (presenting the message Dewantara (2004: 339) is explained as the joyful
through artwork) something. This process can be matter directly experiencing the base element of
easily conducted because of the learning object the arts dimension and power in harmony to
and model designed as well by TFS (the case cultivate the student’s sense.
shown by Figure 7). The whole process becomes The play domain in this case, is explained
the embodiment of joyful learning as the concept by Driyarkaya (2006: 250-253) that it has the
of TFS program, through the giving of an power to perceive the aesthetic experience to
applicative subject matter with an interactive deepen the student’s feeling beauty
method, started or interspersed with playing or independently. Through the joyful learning, the
hearing the student’s story before starting the students are invited to reflect the understanding
learning. of object material (artistic reflection) and
The path and pattern of this joyful arts experience the creation of artwork (aesthetic
learning, practically, aligns with the conception experience) to develop their skill and knowledge
of Ki Hadjar’s Pendidikan Kesenian that puts a (intelligence and imagination).
dolanan (play), gending (instrument), and lakon
(drama) as the base to embed the feeling beauty The Arts as Learning and Creating Medium
to the students in the formulation of cipta-rasa- The learning and creating medium in this
karsa with wirama (related to rhythm) from the case is the technical subject matter in each class
practice of processing the body (dimension of from the arts-media-literature derivative to give
artistic reflection) and the feel (dimension of room for the students to learn and work. By this
aesthetic experience), continuously. The room and medium, the students get the room to
materialization is how ngerti or understanding convey something about themselves and their
(sensing or perceiving; affective process), ngroso island. After knowing how to learn and work,
or feeling (reflecting to understand; cognitive they are expected to recreate the same or new
process), and nglakoni or doing (experiencing to work according to their creation. Alike this
do; conative process) as according to the kodrat- viewpoint, Moelyono (1997: 45) more positions
alam (natural law). The wirama by Dewantara the arts as an aware power in forming a common
(2004: 311-312) is elaborated on the joyful insight to build a critical awareness through the
situation and happy condition. working arts towards the environment and its
social context.
Furthermore, the design computer class’s
facilitator regards the software of computer as a
medium publication: offering something more
like just visualizing the student’s ideas, but also
able to support and strengthen the other medium,
creatively and innovatively. This becomes
Duncum’s (2017: 4) attention in seeing how the
students nowadays, more use and refer to the
Figure 7. The Giving of Technical Subject Matter
thorugh Interactive Method in Handicraft Class
by Indi the Facilitator (Photo Document: TFS,
2017)
369
Jalaluddin Rumi, Wadiyo, Triyanto/
social media (particularly YouTube) in their harmonize and cultivate the power of cipta (root
everyday life thus also affect their behavior and of intelligence) and karsa (fruit of imagination) in
principle. This arts dimension and power have order to build the student’s budi pekerti luhur
also become the discussion by Munaf, Piliang, & (nobility).
Purnomo (2016: 315) in elaborating its function Such room, in essence, is the manifestation
and domain in the social, cultural, ideological, form of student’s affective, cognitive, and
and political spheres, particularly its conative growth and development, based on the
communicative capacity. psychomotor element (artistic reflection and
Concerning empowerment in such, aesthetic experience) for nurturing the student’s
according to Zimmerman (2009: 394), it is a vital skill and knowledge by working arts: the room of
matter to foster critical awareness responding to expression and creation. The advanced analysis
any kind of change. The same becomes the concerning the student’s process and progress to
Smith’s emphasis (2006: 120), namely the artistically expressing and aesthetically creating
understanding of artistic awareness is needed in each class, is formulated accordance with the
again to grow human’s sensibility and capability cross-link and strength of each own visual
that, in turn, requires a resuscitation of aesthetic medium (see Figure 8): drawing class to see
sensitivity through the reflection and experience. student’s ability in abstracting object material;
This dimension by Sugiarto, Rohidi, & Kartika photography class to see student’s ability in
(2017: 94) is also reviewed in assessing the understanding object material; handicraft class to
formation of arts education value: the arts as skill see the student’s ability in processing object
and cultural values preservation. For Fariyatul & material; and basic & design computer class to see
Bandono (2017: 73), the same medium can foster student’s ability in making a presentation of
the student’s curiosity and knowledge. object material.
370
Jalaluddin Rumi, Wadiyo, Triyanto/
illustration shows Agus’s creation in arranging analyzing their artworks form as a standard
and forming his drawing to express what he reference in evaluating or assessing (appreciating)
wants to convey. their achievements to the following stage. This
Illustration B in Figure 8, represents room of artistic expression and aesthetic creation
Randy’s (19 years old, Sapuli Island) photo-story have embodied as the learning and creating
artwork: illustrating his perceiving of the object to medium through the applicative subject matter
which he wants to convey through photography with the interactive method to foster the student’s
medium. The photo focuses on skill and knowledge. Amorino (2009: 228) in this
the marrakkang (catching crab method in the sea) case, indicates that the understanding of the
pieces of equipment in the boat. This photo also artisticness can sharpen the student’s creativity
shows or indicates a direction of photo focus that and sensibility.
becomes the main message of his artwork, Daeng By way of artistic reflection and aesthetic
Colleng, his grandfather. In outline, this photo experience in such, Burton (2009: 328) seeing as
illustration more contains rakkang equipment, but well the student’s creative development that is so
then all objects are directed to focus on his influenced by their understanding of the
grandfather. This Randy’s photo can give a strong perceived objects, affects their the awareness and
impression in concentrating his artwork message sense development from the direct practice
aesthetically. indeed. In a simple praxis, da Ary (2019: 185)
Illustration C in Figure 8, is a joint artwork through his Pacitanian Art-Edu program, proposes
of the moneybox by the handicraft class students. the study case to responding the environment
The base form of this artwork is made with a resources based on arts in the learning to develop
carton till forms a moneybox, then the students the student’s competence and creativity
coat with sand from the island around and accordance with their tendencies and natural
decorate it with cockles. In the process, the environment. Such creative and innovative case
students are always trained until they can create models become a kind of an alternative track to
like this. The progress shows how the students re-deconstruct what and how the embodiment of
have able to process their island resources in arts dimension and power in education is.
creating new artwork with distinctive arts and
usage value. CONCLUSION
Meanwhile, illustration D in Figure 8,
represents Rian’s presentation from Sapuli The empowerment of arts dimension and
Island: showing his skill and knowledge in power from its artistic and aesthetic aspect has the
making a presentation using PowerPoint, which creative and critical power in facilitating the
in the first meeting he has still very less students to hone their skills and nurture their
knowledge about operating the computer, knowledge. This capacity can become the
particularly its menus and functions. This medium to fostering the student’s intelligence
artwork shows the student’s distinctive capability and imagination sensibility. That
achievement than the medium of the other embodiment represents the planning of the TFS
classes. The artwork himself is good enough and program in providing the expression and creation
minimalist with red color as the background of room for the students to recognize themselves
the title. The title position itself is parallel in the and their environment by working arts thus have
bottom of the red color, adding a listing of his awakened their curiosity and confidence.
name in the form of an Instagram account. The Thereby, the arts learning object and model of
listing name shows Rian’s understanding toward TFS as the learning and creating medium have
an excess of his class medium as the publication provably able to foster the student’s skill and
medium using a social media. knowledge through expressing the story of their
Those four illustrations depict Eisner’s artwork object, and creating its message of their
(2002: 171) emphasis on student’s potency by
371
Jalaluddin Rumi, Wadiyo, Triyanto/
artwork; as the study case to the discourse of arts Green, J., & Kindseth, A. (2011). Art All Day:
education discipline. Distinction and Interrelation of School-
Based and Out-of-School Arts Learning.
REFERENCES Studies in Art Education, 52(4), 337–341.
Iryanti, V. E. (2016). Kenikmatan Estetis dalam
Amorino, J. S. (2009). The Artistic Impetus Seni Suatu Tinjauan Filosofis. Imaji: Jurnal
Model: A Resource for Reawakening Seni Dan Pendidikan Seni, 14(2), 139–145.
Artistic Expression in Adolescents. Studies https://doi.org/10.21831/imaji.v14i2.12
in Art Education, 50(3), 214-231. 177
https://doi.org/10.1080/00393541.2009. Ki Nayono. (1992). Pendidikan Kesenian. Dalam
11518769 Ki Soeratman, Ki Hariyadi, dan Ki B.
Burton, J. M. (2009). Creative Intelligence, Boentarsono (Penyunting), Pendidikan dan
Creative Practice: Lowenfeld Redux. Pengembangan Sumber Daya Manusia:
Studies in Art Education, 50(4), 323-337. Peringatan 70 Tahun Tamansiswa (hlm. 248-
https://doi.org/10.1080/00393541.2009. 257). Yogyakarta: Majelis Luhur
11518779 Persatuan Tamansiswa.
da Ary, D. (2019). Pacitanian Art-Edu (Jalan Lufiani, A., Sabana, S., & Haldani, A. (2017).
Alternatif Menuju Hakekat Tujuan Aesthetic and functions of craft art in
Pendidikan Seni di Indonesia). Mudra: public art space. Harmonia: Journal of Arts
Jurnal Seni Budaya, 34(2), 177–185. Research and Education, 17(1), 41–47.
http://doi.org/10.31091/mudra.v34i2.69 https://doi.org/10.15294/harmonia.v17i
9 1.7469
Dewantara, Ki H. (2004). Karya Ki Hadjar Moelyono. (1997). Seni Rupa Penyadaran. (H.
Dewantara Bagian Pertama: Pendidikan. Wiyanto, Editor). Yogyakarta: Yayasan
(Cetakan Ketiga). Yogyakarta: Majelis Bentang Budaya.
Luhur Persatuan Taman Siswa. Munaf, D. R., Piliang, Y. A., & Purnomo, D. H.
Duncum, P. (2017). Responding to Big Data in (2016). Art as a Cultural Politics and
the Art Education Classroom: Diplomacy. Mudra: Jurnal Seni Budaya,
Affordances and Problematics. 31(3), 308–316.
International Journal of Art & Design https://doi.org/10.31091/mudra.v31i3.4
Education, 0, 1–12. 5
https://doi.org/10.1111/jade.12129 Pamadhi, H. (2012). Pendidikan Seni: Hakikat,
Driyarkara, N. (2006). Karya Lengkap Driyarkara: Kurikulum Pendidikan Seni, Habitus Seni dan
Esai-esai Filsafat Pemikir yang Terlibat Penuh Pengajaran Seni untuk Anak. Yogyakarta:
dalam Perjuangan Bangsanya. (A. Sudiardja, UNY Press.
G. B. Subanar, S. Sunardi, & T. Sarkim, Read, H. (1961). Education through Art. London:
Eds.). Jakarta: Gramedia Pustaka Utama. Faber and Faber.
Eisner, E. W. (2002). The Arts and the Creation of Salam, S. (2014, 2 Desember). Menyongsong
Mind. New Haven: Yale University Press. Masyarakat Ekonomi Asean (MEA)
Fariyatul, E., & Bandono, A. (2017). The Use of dengan Kekreatifan: Mengeksplorasi
Value Clarification Technique-Based- Peran yang Dapat Disumbangkan oleh
Picture Story Media as an Alternative Pendidikan Seni. Seminar Nasional
Media to Value Education in Primary Pendidikan Seni Pengembangan Sumber Daya
School. Harmonia: Journal of Arts Research Manusia melalui Seni dan Pendidikan Seni.
and Education, 17(1), 68–74. Samho, B. & Yasunari, O. (2010). Konsep
https://doi.org/10.15294/harmonia.v17i Pendidikan Ki Hadjar Dewantara dan
1.7469 Tantangan-Tantangan Implementasinya di
Indonesia Dewasa ini. Penelitian dan
372
Jalaluddin Rumi, Wadiyo, Triyanto/
373