TRANSPORTATION LAWS

Case Outline
Atty. Melissa Romana P. Suarez

COMMON CARRIERS

I. COMMON CARRIERS IN GENERAL

Art. # Case Title Citation/GR #/Date
A Laws Applicable 1753 PAL v. CA 207 SCRA 100 [6 Mar 1992]
1766 American Home Insurance v. CA 208 SCRA 343 [5 May 1992]

B Contract of British Airways v. CA 92288 [9 Feb 1993]

Carriage

C Definition of 1732 De Guzman v. CA 22 Dec 1988

Common Carrier Bascos v. CA 7 Apr 1993
National Steel v. CA 12 Dec 1997
Fabre v. CA 26 Jul 1996
First Philippine Pipeline v. CA 29 Dec 1998
Calvo v. UCPB 19 Mar 2002
FGU Insurance v. Sarmiento 6 Aug 2002
Philamgen v. PKS Shipping 9 Apr 2003
Asia Lighterage v. CA 19 Aug 2003
Crisostomo v. CA 25 Aug 2003
Schmitz Transport v. TVI 22 Apr 2005
Philippines First v. Wallem 26 Mar 2009
Unsworth v. CA 26 Jul 2010
Loadmaster v. Glodel 10 Jan 2011
Malayan v. PFIC & Reputable 11 Jul 2012
Pereñ a v. Zarate 19 Aug 2012
Westwind v. UCPB 25 Nov 2013 [200289]
Manay v. Cebu Air 4 Apr 2016 [210621]
Spouses Fernando v. Northwest 8 Feb 2017 [212038]
LTFRB v. Valenzuela 11 Mar 2019 [242860]
Unitrans v. Insurance 11 Mar 2019 [203865]
Tan v. Great Harvest 20 Mar 2019 [220400]

D Nature and 1733 Cangco v. Manila Railroad
Basis of Medina v. Cresencia
Liability/Breach PAL v. CA
of Contract DOH v. Lorenzo Shipping
Northwest Airlines v. Chiong
Aboitiz v. ICNA
Philippines First v. Wallem
Villoria v. Continental
Fernando v. NW Airlines
FedEx v. Antonino
38 PHIL 768 [14 Oct 1918]
99 PHIL 506 [11 Jul 1956]
106 S 391 [31 Jul 1981]
153563 [7 Feb 2005]
155550 [31 Jan 2008]
06 Aug 2008
26 Mar 2009
16 Jan 2012
08 Feb 2017 [212038]
27 Jun 2018 [199455]

E Benedicto v. IAC 187 SCRA 547 [19 Jul 1990]

BA Finance v. CA 215 SCRA 715 [13 Nov 1992]
 Liability of
registered
owner
F State Regulation 1765 Fisher v. Yangco Steamship 31 PHIL 5 [31 Mar 1915]
Pantranco v. CA 70 PHIL 221 [26 June 1940]
PAL v. CAB 270 SCRA 538 [26 Mar 1997]

G Can a common Home Insurance v. American 23 SCRA 24 [4 Apr 1968]

carrier become Arada v. CA 210 SCRA 624 [1 Jul 1992]
a private Planters Products v. CA 226 SCRA 476 [15 Sep 1993]
carrier? Loadstar Shipping v. CA 315 SCRA 339 [28 Sep 1999]

II. COMMON CARRIER OF GOODS

Art. Case Title Date/GR#
A Vigilance Over Goods
1 Liability for Loss; 1734 Ynchausti v. Dexter Dec. 14,1920
Presumption of 1735 Mirasol v. Dollar Mar 27, 1929
Negligence Standard Vacuum v. Luzon Stevedoring Apr 18,1956
Fireman’s Fund v. Metro Port Feb 21,1990
Aboitiz v. CA Aug 6,1990
Bankers and Manufacturers v. CA Oct 2,1992
Summa Insurance Corp. v. CA Feb 5,1996
Sarkies Tours v. CA Oct 2,1997
Belgian Overseas v. Phil. First Insurance Jun 5,2002/143133
Aboitiz. v. ICNA Aug 6, 2008
Asian Terminals v. Allied Guarantee Oct 14, 2015 [182208]
Transimex v. Mafre Asian Sep 14, 2016 [190271]

Keihin v. Tokio Jan 28, 2019 [212107]

B Exemption from Liability

1 Natural Disaster 1734[1] Tan Chiong v. Inchausti Mar 8,1912
or Calamity 1739 Martini v. Macondray Jul 28,1919
1740 Eastern v. IAC May 29,1987
Eastern Shipping v. CA Apr 30,1991
Arada v. CA Jul 1,1992
Philamgen v. CA May 17,1993
Delsan Transporp. v. CA Nov 15,2001
Philamgen v. MCG Marine Mar 8,2002
Edgar Cokaliong v. UCPB General Jun 25,2003
Asia Lighterage and Shipping v. CA Aug 19,2003
DSR-Senator Lines v. Federal Phoenix Oct 7,2003
Central Shipping v. Ins. Co. of North Amer. Sep 20,2004
FGU Insurance Corp. v. CA Mar 31,2005
Schmitz v. Transport Venture Apr 22,2005
Lea Mer Industries v. Malayan Sep 30, 2005
RCL of Singapore v. Netherlands Sep 4, 2009
 2 Act of Shipper 1734[3] Compania Maritima v. CA Aug 29,1988
1741 Tabacalera v. North Front May 16,1997

3 Character of 1734[4] Government v. Ynchausti, Sep 29,1919

Goods 1742 Southern Lines v. CA Jan 31,1962
Calvo v. UCPB Mar 19,2002
Belgian Overseas v. PFIC Jun 5,2002
Iron Bulk Shipping v. Remington Dec 8,2003/136960
AF Sanchez Brokerage v. CA Dec 21,2004/147079

4 Order of 1734[5] Ganzon v. CA May 30,1988

Competent 1743
Authority

II. COMMON CARRIER OF GOODS [cont…]

C Duration of Liability 1736 Compania Maritima v. Insurance Oct 30,1964
1737 Lu Do v. Binamira Apr 22,1957
1738 Servando v. Phil Steam Oct 23,1982
Samar Mining v. Nordeuscher Oct 23,1984
Ganzon v. CA May 30,1988
Tabacalera Insurance v. North Front May 16,1997
Phil. Home Assurance Corp. v. CA Jun 20,1996
PAL v. CA Mar 14,1996
PAL v. CA May 17,1996
Baliwag Transit v. CA May 15,1996
Macam v. CA Aug 25,1999
Schmitz Transport v. Transport Venture Apr 22,2005
Neddloyd v. Glow Laks Nov 19, 2014 [156330]

D Agreement Limiting Liability

1 As to Diligence 1744 Home Insurance v. American Apr 4,1968
Required 1745 De Guzman v. CA Dec 22,1988
Valenzuela Hardwood v. CA Jun 30,1997

Torres Madrid v. FEB Mitsui Jul 11, 2016 [194121]

2 As to Amount of 1749 H.E. Heacock v. Macondray Oct 3,1921

Liability 1750 J. Ysmael v. Barreto Nov 25,1927
Northern v. Prince Line Feb 29,1960
Shewaram v. Philippine Airlines Jul 7, 1966
Ong Yiu v. CA and Philippine Airlines Jun 29, 1979
Sea Land v. IAC Aug 31,1987
Pan American World Airways v. IAC Aug 11, 1988
Citadel Lines v. CA Apr. 25,1990
Everett Steamship v. CA Oct. 8, 1998
Edgar Cokaliong v. UCPB General Jun 25,2003
PCIC v. Neptune Orient Jun 12, 2008 [145044]

3 Passenger Baggage 1754 Robles v. Santos Sep 6,1947

 Pan American v. IAC Aug 11,1988
Alitalia v. IAC Dec 4,1990
PAL v. CA Mar 6,1992
Cathay Pacific v. CA Mar 5,1993
Sarkies Tours v. CA Oct. 2, 1997
Sulpicio Lines v. Sesante Jul 27, 2016 [172682]

E Delay in the Delivery of Cargo Maersk Line v. CA May 17,1993

III. COMMON CARRIER OF PASSENGERS

Art. Case Title Date/GR#
#
A Nature of 1732 1 Ampang v. Guino-o Transit Apr 30, 1953
Responsibility 1733 2 Landicho v BTC Sep 20, 1956
Definition 1755 3 Isaac v. A.L. Ammen Aug 23, 1957
4 Laguna v. Tiongson Apr 30, 1966
5 La Mallorca v. De Jesus May 14, 1966
6 Anuran v. Buñ o May 20, 1966
7 Maranan v. Perez Jun 26, 1967
8 BTC v. Caguimbal Jan 24, 1968
9 Del Castillo v. Jaymalin Mar 17, 1982
10 Vasquez v. CA Sep 13, 1985
11 Mecenas v. CA Dec 14, 1989
12 Gatchalin v. Delim Oct 21, 1991
13 Trans-Asia v. CA Mar 4, 1996
14 Negros Navigation v. CA Nov 17, 1997
15 Cervantes v. CA Mar 25, 1999
16 Calalas v. CA May 31, 2000
17 Jose v. CA Jan 18, 2000
18 Baritua v. Mercader Jan 23, 2001
19 Cathay Pacific v. Fuentebella Jul 10, 2016
20 Sulpicio Lines v. Sesante Jul 27, 2016 [172682]
21 People v. Go Dec 10, 2018

B Presumption of 1756 1 Picart v. Smith Mar 15, 1918

Negligence 2 Macawili v. Panay Mar 1,1956
3 Sy v. Malate Taxicab Nov 29,1957
4 Abeto v. PAL July 30,1982
5 PAL v. NLRC Sep 2,1983
6 Bachelor Express v. CA July 231,1990
7 Mallari v. CA Jan 31, 2000

C Breach of 1 Singson v. CA Nov 18, 1997, GR 119995

Contract of 2 Cathay Pacific v. Vazquez Mar 14, 2003, GR#150843
Carriage 3 Singapore Airlines v. Andion Dec 10, 2003, GR142305
4 Japan Airlines v. Asuncion Jan 28, 2005, GR#161730
 5 Northwest v. Chiong Jan 31, 2008, GR 155550
6 Vector Shipping v. Macasa Jul 21, 2008, GR 160219
7 Japan Airlines v. Simangan Apr 22, 2008
8 Philippine Airlines v. CA Sep 22, 2008
9 Northwest v. Hashan Feb 3, 2010
10 Spouses Villoria v. Continental Jan 16, 2012

D Fortuitous Event 1 Lasam v. Smith 45 PHIL 657, Feb 2, 1924

as a Defense 2 Necesito v. Paras 104 SCRA 84, Jun 30, 1958
3 Juntilla v. Fontanar May 31, 1985
4 Yobido v. CA Oct 17, 1997
5 Gacal v. PAL 183 SCRA 189
6 Pilapil v. CA Dec 22, 1989
7 Fortune Express v. CA 305 SCRA 14, Mar 18, 1999
8 JAL v. CA Aug 7, 1998
9 Singapore Airlines v. Andion Dec 10, 2003, GR142305

III. COMMON CARRIER OF PASSENGERS, cont…

E Duration of 1 Bataclan v. Medina Oct 22, 1957
Responsibility 2 La Mallorca v. CA July 27, 1966
3 Phil. Rabbit v. IAC Aug 30, 1990
4 PAL v. CA Sep 15, 1993
5 Trans-Asia Shipping v. CA Mar 4, 1996
6 Baliwag Transit v. CA May 15, 1996
7 Negros NavigationCo., v. CA Nov 7, 1997
8 JAL v. CA Aug 7, 1998

F Limited Liability; 1757 1 Lara v. Valencia June 30, 1958

Validity of 1758 2 Bataclan v. Medina Oct 22,1957
Stipulations 3 Maranan v. Perez June 26,1967
4 Baliwag Transit v. CA May 5,1996
5 Fabre v. CA July 26,1996
6 Mallari v. CA Jan 31,2000

H Contributory 1761 1 Cangco v. MRR Oct 14,1918

Negligence of Pax 1762 2 Del Prado v. MRR Mar 7, 1929
3 Briñ as v. People Nov 25,1983
4 PNOC v. CA Oct 4,1985
5 Dangwa v. CA Oct 7,1991
6 Fortune Express v. Ca Mar 18,1999
7 Isaac v. Al Ammen 101 PHIL 1046

I 1763 1 MRR v. Ballesteros Apr 29,1966

2 Bacarro v. Castañ o Nov 5,1982
 Responsibility for 3 Gacal v. PAL Mar 15,1990
Acts of Strangers 4 Fortune Express v. CA Mar 18,1999
and Co-pax 5 LRT Authority v. Marjorie Navidad Feb 6, 2003
6 GV Floridav. Heirs of Battung Oct 14,2015 [208802]

J Liability for 1 China Airlines v. CA May 18,1990

Quasi-Delict 2 Calalas v. CA May 31, 2000
3 Thermochem v. Naval Oct 20, 2000
4 Phoenix Construction v. IAC Mar 10, 1987
5 Tiu v. Arriesgado Sep 1, 2004
6 PNR v. CA Oct 15, 2007
7 Dy Teban v. Ching, Liberty Forest Feb 4, 2008
8 Vallacar v. Catubig May 20, 2011
9 Philtranco v. Paras Apr 25, 2012 [161909]
10 Greenstar v. Universal Robina Oct 17, 2016
11 Caravan Travel v. Abejar Feb 10, 2017
12 Torreon v. Aparra Dec 13, 2017 [188493]
13 Cacho v. Manahan Jan 17, 2018
14 Imperial v. Bayaban Oct 3, 2018 [197626]

IK Liability for 1 Sulpicio Lines v. CA July 14, 1995

Injury to
Stevedores

MARITIME COMMERCE

I. Introduction
Topic Sec. # Case Title Date
PD 474 – Definition of Vessel Sec. 3
RA 1937
Vessels eligible for river license Sec. 911
Vessels exempted from river Sec. 912
license

II. Code of Commerce

A. 573-585 - Introduction
Art. # Topic Case Title Date/Citation
573 Ownership of Rubiso v. Rivera Aug 18,1920
vessels

B. Persons Who Take Part in Maritime Commerce

1. Art. 586 – Ship Agent
Art. # Topic Case Title Date/Citation
586 Liability of ship Standard Oil v. Castelo Oct 18,1921
owner and ship Macondray v. Provident Dec 9, 2004
agent
2. Art. 609-651 - Captains and Masters of Vessels
Art. # Topic Case Title Date/Citation
609 Qualifications of a Coastwise Lighterage v. CA
Captain 245 SCRA 796
610 Functions of a Inter-orient Maritime v. NLRC
Captain 235 SCRA 268
612 Obligations of the Haverton Shipping v. NLRC 135 SCRA 685
Captain Far Eastern Shipping v. CA 297 SCRA 30
Wildvalley Shipping v. CA Oct 6, 2000
Centennial v. Dela Cruz Aug 22, 2008

614 Prohibited Acts Sweet Lines v. CA 121 SCRA 769

615
603 Discharge of Madrigal Shipping v. Ogilvie Oct 30, 1958
608 captain and crew Wallem v. Minister of Labor 102 SCRA 835

C. Doctrine of Limited Liability

Art. # Topic Case Title Date/Citation
587 Doctrine of Limited Yu v. Ossorio Jun 14,1922
590 Liability Yangco v. Lasema Oct 29,1941
837 Manila Steamship v. Abdulhaman Sep 19,1956
Chua Yek Hong v. IAC Sep 30, 1988
PhilAmGen v. CA Jun 11,1997
Negros Navigation v. CA 281 SCRA 532
Heirs of delos Santos v. CA 186 SCRA 649
Aboitiz Shipping v. General Accident Jan 21,1993
Vasquez v. CA 138 SCRA 553
Monarch Insurance v. CA Jun 8,2000
Aboitiz Shipping v. New India Assurance May 2,2006
Central Shipping v. Insurance Sep 20, 2004
Aboitiz Shipping v. Equitable Oct 17, 2008
Dela Torre v. CA Jul 13, 2011 [160008]

D. Art. 652-689 – Charter Parties

Art. # Topic Case Title Date/Citation
Kinds Planters Products v. CA 226 SCRA 476
Ouano v. CA 211 SCRA 740
Caltex v. Sulpicio Lines 315 SCRA 709
Loadstar Shipping v. Pioneer Asia Jan 24,2006

652 Formal Marimperio Compania v. CA 156 SCRA 368

Requirements
Interpretation of Santiago Lighterage v. CA Jun 21, 2004

E. Art. 706-718, 353-375– Bills of Lading

Art. # Topic Case Title Date/Citation
Definition Macondray v. Commissioner 62 SCRA 427
 Keng Hua Paper Products v. CA Feb 12,1998
Iron Bulk Shipping v. Remington Dec 8, 2003
Provident v. CA Jan 15, 2004
Malayan v. Jardine Sep 18, 2009
MOF v. Shin Yang Dec 18, 2009
Eastern Shipping v. BPI/MS Insurance Jan 12, 2015

353 Surrender of BL Macam v. CA Aug 25,1999

RP [DOH] v. Lorenzo Shipping Feb 7,2005

Designer Baskets v. Air and Sea Mar 9, 2016

366 Prescriptive Period Roldan v. Lim Ponzo 37 PHIL 285

New Zealand v. Chua Joy 97 PHIL 646
Lorenzo v. Chubb Jun 8, 2004
Federal Express v. American Home Aug 18, 2004
PCIC v. Chemoil Jun 29, 2005
Aboitiz v. ICNA Aug 6, 2008
UCPB v. Aboitiz Feb 10, 2009

370 Delay in Delivery of Uy Chuaco v. Admiral Line 46 PHIL 418

Goods

F. Art. 719-731 – Loans on Bottomry & Respondentia

G. Art. 806-843 – Damages and Accidents in Maritime Commerce

Art. # Topic Case Title Date/Citation
806- Averages Magsaysay v. Agan 96 PHIL 504
816 Standard Oil v. Castelo Oct. 18, 1921
660- Goods Not Liable
661 for Payment of
Freight
665 Liability of Goods
for General Average
677 Effect of International v. Hamburg Jul 29,1918
Declaration of War Compagnie v. Hanburg 36 PHIL 590
723 Liability of Lenders
for Average
819- Arrival Under
821 Stress
826- Collisions National Development v. CA 164 SCRA 593
838 Smith Bell v. CA 197 SCRA 201
Mecenas v. CA 180 SCRA 83
Luzon Stevedoring v. CA 156 SCRA 169
Lopez v. Duruelo 52 PHIL 229
Sulpicio Lines v. CA Mar 29,1999
Caltex v. Sulpicio 315 SCRA 709
Manila Steamship v. Abdulhaman 100 PHIL 32
 840- Shipwrecks
842

III. COGSA [Carriage of Goods by Sea Act]

Sec. # Topic Case Title Date/Citation
Applicability American Insurance v. Compania Maritima 96 PHIL 504
3[6] Prescriptive Period Wallem v. SR Farms Jul 9, 2010
New World v. NYK-Fil Japan Aug 24, 2011
ICNA v. Asian Terminals Feb 15, 2012
Cua v. Wallem Jul 11, 2012

Failure to give notice E.E. Elser v. CA Nov 29, 1954

of loss UCPB v. Aboitiz Feb 10, 2009

What constituted Mitsui OSK v. CA 287 SCRA 366

loss or damage
Prevailing law Maritime Agencies v. CA 187 SCRA 346
Chua Kay v. Everett Steamship May 27, 1953

Effect of extra- DOLE v. Maritime 148 SCRA 118

judicial demand
Interruption of Stevens v. Nordeutcher 6 SCRA 180
prescriptive period Aetna Insurance v. Luzon Stevedoring 62 SCRA 11
ICNA v. Philippine Ports Jul 18, 1965
Ang v. American Steamship Jan 27,1967

Effect of prescriptive Mayer Steel v. CA 274 SCRA 432

period on liability of Filipino Merchants v. CA 179 SCRA 209
insurer

4[5] Limitation of Eastern Shipping c. IAC May 29, 1987

Liability Eastern and Australian v. Great American 108 SCRA 248
Belgian Overseas v. First Insurance Jun 5, 2002
PCIC v. Neptune Orient Jun 12, 2008
Unsworth v. CA Jul 26, 2010
Philam V. Heung-A Jul 23, 2014

IV. Miscellaneous
Topic Case Title Date/Citation
Arrastre ICNA v. PPT Jul 18, 1955
Marina v. AHA Aug 12, 2015
ATI v. Guarantee Oct 14, 2015

Forwarders Malayan v. Reputable Jul 11, 2012

 AIR TRANSPORTATION

Sec. Case Title Date/Citation

A RA 776
1 Definition of an Air Carrier 3 [f]
2 Kinds of Air Transportation 3
3 Composition of CAB 5
4 Power of CAB 10[A]
5 Duties of CAB 10[C]
6 Government Requirement 11 PAL V. CAB 270 S 538
7 Peculiarity PAL v. CA 226 S 423
8 Authority [RA 6235] 8

B Warsaw Convention Art Case Title Date/Cit

1 Applicability 1.1
Meaning 1.2 Mapa v. CA Jul 8, 1997
Successive Air Carriers 1.3 American Airlines v. Salas Mar 9,2000

2 Liability of Carrier 17,18 Northwest v. Cuenca 14 S 1063

19 Alitalia v. IAC Dec 4,1990

Limitation of Liability; 22 Pan Am v. IAC Aug 11, 1988

Applicability 25 PAL v. CA Mar 6,1992
PAL v. CA Ma4 14,1996
British Airways v. CA 285 S 450
Santos v. Northwest Orient Jun 23, 1992
Sabena v. CA 255 S 38
Luna v. CA Nov 27,1992
Northwest v. Torres Jan 29,1998
Pan American Airways v. CA May 19, 1992
Cathay Pacific v. Alcantara Mar 5, 1993

Complaint to the carrier 26 Savellano v. Northwest Jul 8,2003

Federal Express v. AHA Aug 18,2004

3 Venue/Jurisdiction for Filling 28

Actions Santos v. Northwest Orient Jun 23, 1992
Lopez v. Northwest Jun 17, 1993
Mapa v. CA Jul 8, 1997
American Airlines v. Salas Mar 9,2000

4 Prescriptive Period 29 United Airlines v. Willie Uy Nov 19,1999

PAL v. Savillo Jul 4, 2008

5 Successive Carriers 30 KLM Royal Dutch v. CA Jun 22, 1975

Lufthansa v. CA Nov 24, 1994
 China Airlines v. Chiok Jul 20, 2003

DAMAGES RECOVERABLE FROM COMMON CARRIES

Art. # Case Title Date

A General 1764 Alitalia v. CA Jul 24,1990
Provisions 2197 MMTC v. CA Nov 16,1998
Fortune Express v. CA Mar 18,1999
Caltex v. Sulpicio Sep 30,1999
Yu Eng Cho v. Pan Am Mar 27,2000

B Actual or 2199 Cariaga v. LTB Dec 29,1960

Compensatory 2201 Villa Rey v. CA Feb 18,1970
2203 Pan American v. IAC Aug 31,1987
Gatchalin v. Delim Oct 21,1991
Korean Airlines v. CA Sep 24,1987
Pantranco v. CA Oct 8,1998
Jose v. CA Jan 18,2000

1 When Damages 2205 Soberano v. MRR Nov 23,1966

May be Marchan v. Mendoza Aug 30,1968
Recovered
2 Damages in Case 2206 [1] De Caliston v. CA June 24,1983
DEATH Occurs PAL v. CA May , 1990
Heirs of Amparo v. CA June 2, 1990
Negros Navigation v. CA Nov 7,1997

C Moral Damages 2206 [3] Cachero v. Manila Yellow May 23,1957

2216 Fores v. Miranda Mar 4,1959
2217 Lopez v. Pan-Am Mar 30,1966
2219 LTB v. Cornista, May 29,1964
2220 Tamayo v. Aquino May 29,1959
Air France v. Carrascoso Sep 28,1966
Northwest Airlines v. Cuenca Aug 31,1965
Zulueta v. Pan-Am Jan 8,1973
Ortigas Jr. v. Lufthansa June 30,1975
Phil. Rabbit v. Esguerra Oct 23,1982
Sweet Lines v. CA Apr 28,1983
Pan Am v. IAC Aug 31,1987
Korean Airlines v. CA Sep 24,1987
TWA v. CA Aug 30,1988
Armovit v. CA Apr 20,1990
PAL v. CA Aug 13,1990
China Airlines v. CA July 29,1992
Korean Airlines v. CA Aug 3, 1994
PAL v. Miano Mar 8, 1995
Kierulf v. CA Mar 13,1997
PAL v. CA July 17,1997
 Singson v. CA 282 SCRA 149
Ong v. CA Jan 21,1999
Cervantes v. CA Mar 2, 1999
Tan v. Northwest Mar 3,2000
Calalas v. CA May 31,2000
UA v. Fontanilla Apr 20, 2001
Bernales v. Northwest Airlines Oct 5, 2015 [182395]

D Exemplary 2229 Munsayac v. DeLara

Damages 2232 LTB v. Diasanta June 30,1964
2233 Sarkies Tours v. IAC Sep 2,1983
Prudenciado v. Alliance Mar 16,1987
Cervantes v. CA Mar 2,1999

E Nominal, 2221 Saludo v. CA Mar 23,1992

Temperate & 2224 Alitalia v. IAC Dec 4,1990
Liquidated 2226 Lufthansa v. CA Apr 21, 1995
Damages JAL v. CA Aug 7, 1998
Pantranco v. CA Oct 8, 1998

Sulpicio v. Karaan Oct 3, 2018

F New Cases MMTC v. CA Nov 16, 1998

Cathay Pacific v. Vazquez Mar 14, 2003
Singapore Airlines v. Fernandez Dec 10, 2003
Philippine Airlines v. CA Dec 8, 2003
Victory Liner v Gammad Nov 25, 2004
Japan Airlines v. Asuncion Jan 28, 2005
Northwest Airlines v. Steven Chiong Jan 31, 2008
Japan Airlines v. Simangan Apr 22, 2008
Philippine Airlines v. CA Sep 22, 2008
Northwest v. Heshan Feb 3, 2010
Sulpicio Lines v. Curso Mar 17, 2010
Heirs of Ochoa v. G&S Transport Mar 9, 2011
Philtranco v. Paras Apr 25, 2012
Sulpicio Lines v. Sesante Jul 27, 2016
Ramos v. China Southern Sep 21, 2016
Estrada v. Philippine Rabbit Jul 19, 2017 [203902]
Darines v. Quinones Aug 2, 2017 [206468]

PUBLIC SERVICE ACT

Topic Sec. Case Title Date/Citation

1 Public Service 13 Luzon Stevedoring v. Visayan Sep 16, 1953

PCI Leasing v. UCPB Jul 4, 2008

Spouses Cruz v. Sun Holidays Jun 29, 2010

Governing Bodies
Royal Cargo v. PAL Jan 26, 2004
Henares v. LTFRB Oct 23, 2006
Kuwait Airways v. PAL May 8, 2009
Hizon v. TRB Oct 19, 2010
International Freeport v. Danzas Jan 26, 2011
Lorenzo Shipping v. DMA Aug 31, 2011

2 Rules in Issuing 15 Guico v. Buan Aug 30, 1957

CPC Manila Yellow v. Castelo May 30, 1960
Mandbucso v. Francisco 32 SCRA 405
Villa Rey v. Pangasinan 5 SCRA 134
Raymundo Transport v. Cuervo May 18, 1956
Angeles v. Vda. De Lat Feb 26, 1988
San Pablo v. Pantranco Aug 21, 1987
Brillo v. CA Aug 7. 1996

LTFRB v. Valenzuela Mar 11, 2019

3 Fixing of Rates 15[c] Panay Autobus v. PNR

Padua v. Ranada Oct 14, 2002
Hizon v. TRB Oct 19, 2010
International Freeport v. Danzas Jan 26, 2011
Lorenzo Shipping v. DMA Aug 31, 2011

4 Revocation or 15[n] Manzanal v. Ausejo 164 SCRA 36

Suspension of CPC

5 Public Service Act 19/20 Meralco v. CA 157 SCRA 243

– Unlawful Ammen v. Francisco Nov 29, 1957
Services/Acts Cogeo-Cubao v. CA 207 SCRA 346
Montoya v. Ignacio Dec 29, 1953
Benedicto v. IAC 187 SCRA 547
Gelisan v. Alday 154 SCRA 388
Roque v. Malibay Transit Nov 18, 1955
Halili v. Herras 10 SCRA 769
Manzanal v. Ausejo 164 SCRA 36
Spouses Andrada v. Pilhino Feb 23, 2011

5 Kabit System Santos v. Sibug 104 SCRA 520

Jeroes v. CA 117 SCRA 395
Lisa Enterprises v. IAC 129 SCRA 79