Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Zebala: A Garbage Story in Al-Darb El-Ahmar
Zebala: A Garbage Story in Al-Darb El-Ahmar
February 2011
Ayah O Moustafa
A scientific paper on garbage in Cairo: Al-Darb El-Ahmar
Garbage | 2
Abstract
All photos and designs put into this research paper are
copyright originals and are not to be copied, altered, or used
in any way without the full knowledge and written consent of
the author. This project research is for full academic purposes.
cairogarbage.blogspot.com Abstract | 3
Preface
Preface | 4
Contents
3 Abstract
4 Preface
Contents
6 Introduction
i. Motivation
ii. Purpose of this Study
7 iii. Overview
Chapter 1
8 Methodology
1.1 Zebala
9 1.2 Observation
1.3 Interaction
1.4 Documentation
Chapter 2
10 Results
2.1 Garbage Barrier
2.2 An Action-Reaction Sort of Thing
11 2.3 For Academic Purposes Only
Chapter 3
12 Discussion
3.1 A Real Act
13 3.2 A Garbage Reformation
Chapter 4
14 Design Application
4.1 Logo
4.1.1 Early Designs
4.1.1.1 Arabic Calligraphy
15 4.1.1.2 One-Letter Symbol
4.1.1.3 Recycle
16 4.1.2 Final Implementation
4.2 Choosing Layout & Format
18 4.2.1 Format
4.2.2 Layout
19 4.3 Font
20 4.4 Garbage Box
4.5 Blog
21 References
Contents | 5
Introduction
i. Motivation
cairogarbage.blogspot.com Introduction | 6
Garbage, as a matter of fact, can be very complicated. Take a
minute now and step back to look at the whole picture. We live,
we consume, and we dispose. Have you ever thought that what
we dispose, can actually be used to tell your grandchildren’s
children a bedtime story for years to come? Like any painter,
an idea is first developed, then a suitable canvas is selected for
composition, setting and layout. I cannot figure out which
puzzles me more: the fact that people create this smelly art or
that they complain about it even more. I will not (because I
cannot) declare that I am at complete peace with things the way
they currently are. The true heros of this story are the men who
work with these artifacts for a living. They do not complain
and treat our pungent leftover material with such care like a
valuable piece of gold. Who are we to complain?
iii. Overview
Introduction | 7
Chapter 1: Methodology
1.1 Zebala
cairogarbage.blogspot.com Methodology | 8
1.2 Observation
1.3 Interaction
Regardless what many may call research, the best way to reach
full capacity results, is through getting in touch with factors
outside ones comfort zone. The Egyptian people are unlike the
people of the West who usually tend to keep their nose and
business to themselves. Where on the contrary, Egyptians are
used to life as an open book; my business is yours, and yours
is mine. I find this to be the case due to the circumstances
people here live in. In the west, the weather is cold for a the
greater majority of the year, drawing people indoors, and close
to those they know. Where as in the Middle East, countries
experience frequent heat waves, humidity, and rarely have rain
all winter long. This encourages outdoor activities and life with
neighbors, kids, cars, dogs, and passing tourists. Where terms
like private zone, and privacy have no existence.
1.4 Documentation
Methodology | 9
Chapter 2: Results
Unlike those who were beneficial and went out of their way
to make sure I find what I am looking for, some were completely
sarcastic, or just plain rude. The line, “Take my picture, I look
and smell better”, was frequently heard as it was thrown in
my direction by younger high/middle school students. Most
of these retorts were often followed by accusations that I was
not a true Egyptian, and that I was looking for what was ugly
to photograph and make it look bad. Some tried to offer other
alternatives to photograph, such as historical buildings, the
cairogarbage.blogspot.com Results | 10
Citadel, or Al-Azhar park (because it was full of greenery and
beautiful spots), if I was so hungry to photograph.
Results | 11
Chapter 3: Discussion
cairogarbage.blogspot.com Discussion | 12
Thinking that I was out in the street with my camera out to
document a problem and analyze it elaborately (based on how
close they saw me get with garbage when I photograph it), they
believed that I had a good vision in store and was going to help
them reach out to someone who could do anything about their
sticky situation. It was times like this where being honest, felt
dishonest.
Discussion | 13
Chapter 4: Design Application
4.1 Logo
Figure 4.1
Figure 4.2
cairogarbage.blogspot.com Design Applications | 14
4.1.1.2 One-Letter Symbol
4.1.1.3 Recycle
The logo did not feel right just yet. The box gave me the
impression of a suppressed, tortured letter. In a way preventing
garbage from what it does naturally: spreading out, and
littering our world. I removed the box and tried cloning the
letter multiple times.
The logo needed a lot less frill and a lot more simplicity:
reduction to the max. I starting thinking outside the box and
remembered this one assignment we had in typography years
ago where we were asked to design a font using grids. I went for
modular shapes of squares. The idea that something so simple
could create something of greater value, resembled the impact
of garbage in the streets of Cairo, especially in Al-Darb El-
Ahmar.
Figure 4.8
Figure 4.7
Figure 4.9
Figure 4.10
Figure 4.7 was the first attempt in this series showing basic
letter structure. In Figure 4.8, the baseline rule was eliminated
putting the second half of the logo, down below its baseline
and on the descender: bad idea; a new letter was born. In the
cases of Figure 4.9 and Figure 4.10, emphasis on the first letter
was put to, as in earlier cases, try and find an iconic identity
for the magazine where that letter could be used at times alone.
Finally, Figure 4.11 shows the logo in a solid fill, unifying it all.
I found this look to much stronger than just the emphasis of
one letter, and the color can easily be adjusted to suit the issue’s
color scheme.
Figure 4.11
Design Applications | 16
The garbage portrayed in this project is Egyptian and cannot
be given a catchy foreign name. It needed its Arabic name to
accompany it, Zebala. The struggle however came when I
realized that my target group involved both educated, higher
class Egyptians (not the people of Al-Darb El-Ahmar) and
foreigners who do not read Arabic. Translation of the logo was
needed somewhere in between otherwise the concept of project
may loose it’s gravity. I must admit that I unsure before if I
would include the people who were under the microscope in
the final target group. After research, interaction proved that
they are not interested in garbage the way I am: from a design
perspective and would not stop to even look at pictures of it.
Garbage Garbage
Figure 4.12 Figure 4.13
A4
A3
A1
A2
Figure 4.14
Design Applications | 17
The original plan for the editorial part of this project was to
execute a photo book through which I can portray my view.
However, I started to realize that there was a better, suitable
option. Most advertising and design agencies run monthly
magazine issues with in-depth articles, tutorials, and sources
of inspiration for aspiring designers. This path of development
seemed more fit to the topic and was immediately adjusted so.
4.2.1 Format
4.2.2 Layout
article article
text 1
phrase image
text 2
article article
text 4
Figure 4.14
Design Applications | 18
the page are four pictures of, what I call, Garbage Boxes (which
will be discussed later in the chapter). Accompanying every box
is a small, short-story text which gives the reader an idea of
what each location is like. The back side, shown in Figure 4.15,
is the final collection of images of garbage I took that build
one great poster. Every row is set according to the location the
dump/garbage was at.
site 1
site 2
site 3
site 4
Figure 4.15
4.3 Font
• Blackout
• Old Rubber Stamp
• Unisketch Limited/Light Limited
• DCC Sharp Distress Black
• Dirtybag
• Illuminate by Brittney Murphy
• Dirty Play
• Franklin Gothic Book
• Meta
• Arial
• Adobe Garamond Pro
• Geneva
• Gill Sans
Design Applications | 19
• Bell Gothic Std
• Bebas
• LaPresse
• [ank]*
• Kingthings Printing Kit
from every location into one small box. Like a final masterpiece.
Additional photos of these garbage boxes were taken and posted
onto the project blog online.
4.5 Blog
Design Applications | 20
a preview) reaching potential clients internationally within
seconds of posting. Zebala at http://www.cairogarbage.com
was set to help display this project to both Egyptians and non-
Egyptians who have never seen garbage like this before in hopes
of encouraging them to respond back with their own ideas and
thoughts of the topic.
Figure 4.16
References
cairogarbage.blogspot.com References | 22
11 Wikipedia, 2011. Manshiyat naser. [online] Available at:
<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manshiyat_naser> [Accessed 7
October 2010]
References | 23