Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Changes in Flexibility According To Gender
Changes in Flexibility According To Gender
Changes in Flexibility According To Gender
Copia para uso personal, se prohíbe la transmisión de este documento por cualquier medio o formato.
10
O R I G I N A L A RT I C L E S
aBSTRACT RESUMEN
Flexibility is one of the basic physical qualities that are La flexibilidad es una de las cualidades físicas básicas que se
worked on both in elementary and secondary education trabaja tanto en los ciclos de primaria como de secundaria,
but not at the university stage. Of the four basic physical pero no en la etapa universitaria. De las cuatro cualidades
qualities, flexibility is the only quality that progressively di- físicas básicas, la flexibilidad es la única que disminuye con-
minishes with age. forme aumenta la edad.
We selected a sample of 410 subjects (42% males vs. 58% Para realizar el estudio se ha contado con una muestra de
females) aged 6 to 30 years old from Granada and Almería. 410 sujetos (42% varones frente al 58% de mujeres) de 6 a
To collect data, the deep trunk flexion test was used, estab- 30 años de Granada y Almería. Se empleó el test de flexión
lishing that the mean flexibility among the sample was 22.25 profunda de tronco para la recogida y toma de datos, esta-
cm. By gender, females (X = 22.82 cm) were more flexible bleciendo que la flexibilidad media de la población era de
than males (X = 21.46 cm). The highest flexor capacity val- 22,25 cm. De igual forma, por sexos, las chicas (X = 22,82
ues were achieved between the ages of 10 and 11 years, cm) eran más flexibles que los varones (X = 21,46 cm). En
with these values steadily decreasing with age. Consequent- cuanto a la evolutividad, es en el rango de 10 a 11 años
ly, the highest peaks of flexibility were found in primary cuando se alcanzan los valores más altos de capacidad
education (24.98 cm) while the lowest values were found in flexora, produciéndose una disminución constante confor-
university education (19.50 cm). me aumenta la edad cronológica de los individuos, por lo
Finally, as reported in the literature consulted, the results of que el nivel de enseñanza de primaria (24,98 cm) es el que
this study found that average flexibility decreases with age. mayores picos de flexibilidad presenta frente a los universi-
tarios, que son los que obtienen los valores más inferiores
(19,50 cm).
Finalmente, se ha determinado que al igual que toda la bi-
bliografía consultada, la flexibilidad media disminuye confor-
me aumenta el rango de edad.
KEY WORDS: Flexibility. Deep trunk flexion. University. PALABRAS CLAVE: Flexibilidad. Flexión profunda de
College. School. tronco. Universidad. Colegio. Escolares.
a p u n t s m e d e s p o r t. 2 0 0 9 ; 1 6 1 : 1 0 - 7
Documento descargado de http://www.apunts.org el 25/01/2011. Copia para uso personal, se prohíbe la transmisión de este documento por cualquier medio o formato.
11
O R I G I N A L A RT I C L E S
a p u n t s m e d e s p o r t. 2 0 0 9 ; 1 6 1 : 1 0 - 7
Documento descargado de http://www.apunts.org el 25/01/2011. Copia para uso personal, se prohíbe la transmisión de este documento por cualquier medio o formato.
12
O R I G I N A L A RT I C L E S
University None
measured using the deep trunk flexion test. The main problem • Age groups: 6 to 30.
in this study lay in obtaining reliable measurements for this • Sex: male and female.
variable. The expert teachers and scientists chosen presented
a highly standardised protocol for intervention in this study. Our sample was made up of school children and university
The corresponding reliability tests for the deep trunk flexion students from the provinces of Granada and Almeria. The
test were carried out in the same way and 60 male and female study was based in the city of Almeria and in two schools in
pupils aged between 8 and 12 were assessed. The first sessions Granada’s metropolitan area.
which involved about 10 pupils were filmed. The footage was A total of six centres were selected (two primary schools,
later analysed and discussed in a group session and the two secondary schools and two universities) from different
methodological aspects that could produce differences and/or areas, according to their characteristics (number of classes per
mistakes during the data collection process were highlighted. year group, type of school and pupil characteristics), with the
The remaining 50 students were assessed in blocks of 10 and, aim of obtaining a representative population sample. “Main”
after collecting the data in each group, the relationship centres and “reserve” centres were chosen, which would be used
between the data series of the different observers was in case any of the main centres declined to participate.
established. The 6th block was considered the most reliable Afterwards, a meeting between the person responsible for the
after the relationship between the collaborators’ results in any programme and the head of the selected primary school,
of the given tests was over 95%, thereby establishing the secondary school or university was arranged, during which
corresponding test (r = 0.92) that produced low variability they were given a letter/application addressed to the school
between assessors. The statistical analysis was carried out in board or university directors, explaining the whole process and
SPSS version 13.0, which used contingency tables for the requesting the centre’s collaboration, following the approval of
data analysis and the frequency analysis. The Student’s t-test all the different bodies involved (school council, teachers,
was used to compare means and Pearson’s chi-square test was parents, medical staff, etc.) A standard modified letter template
used to identify any links. was requested in order to inform parents of the study and
request authorisation to participate. In the case of the
universities, the individuals themselves had to provide
Sample selection
consent.
The selection process was based on the criteria established Once the proposal had been accepted, an agreement was
in the studies carried out by Casajús,18 Ureña19 and Zurita11 reached regarding when and where the study would be carried
with regard to the pedagogical objectives in the field of school out (in the gym or multipurpose classroom with an adjoining
children’s health. The selection of the school and university room), the rules to be followed (mainly in relation to the sports
study population was carried out using a combination of clothing to be worn) and the collaboration of the members of
stratified, proportional and randomised sample selection the centre (teachers, psychologists, etc.) In order to ensure
techniques to include the following variables: anonymity, all subjects were identified using the number in
their registration file which enabled us to send out personalised
• Level of education: primary, secondary and university. reports to the centres and to the parents of the school children
a p u n t s m e d e s p o r t. 2 0 0 9 ; 1 6 1 : 1 0 - 7
Documento descargado de http://www.apunts.org el 25/01/2011. Copia para uso personal, se prohíbe la transmisión de este documento por cualquier medio o formato.
13
O R I G I N A L A RT I C L E S
detailing the results obtained. Registration took place during Study variable
February and March 2008.
With regard to the study variable, a consistent test was
A sample of the population was taken and the natural
carried out to assess flexor muscle performance, determined by
composition of the groups in the chosen centres was taken into
the modifications in the vertebral column during anterior
consideration. There were no other inclusion or exclusion
trunk flexion and the measurements obtained using the deep
criteria apart from consent to participate in the study which
trunk flexion test, used by a number of authors such as Arregui,3
was 100%. The final sample used in this study was made up of
Martínez,5 Bajo2 and Zurita.11
410 subjects aged 6 to 30 from the provinces of Granada and
The test is carried out while the subject is standing barefoot
Almeria. The composition of the final sample reflected the
with his/her heels positioned where zero is marked on the
natural composition of the groups in which 42% were male (n
metre-stick. The subject begins the deep trunk flexion test by
= 172) and 58% were female (n = 238), (fig. 1.)
bending the knees and stretching as far back as possible with
The distribution of the subjects aged between 6 and 30
the hands (through the legs) in order to reach the metre-stick.
across the different centres was reasonably homogenous, as
shown in table II, taking into consideration that the sample
was made up of primary school children from Reception to
Year 6 (n = 177), 116 (28.3%) secondary school pupils (Year 7
to Year 10) and 1st, 2nd and 3rd year Physiotherapy students
(n = 117.) However, the age ranges in this last group are hardly Table II Population distribution according to level
representative although they were still included so that the of education
groups would be 100% complete.
The ages of the individuals in this study (6 to 30) were Level of education n Percentage
grouped together in ranges that spanned 2 calendar years in Primary 177 43.2
order to show a greater proportion of individuals in each of the Secondary 116 28.3
groups (table III.) University 117 28.5
As table III shows, range 3 (10-11 years) has the best
Total 410 100.0
representation (n = 87). In contrast ranges 10, 11 and 12 have
around 1% and were the least well represented.
a p u n t s m e d e s p o r t. 2 0 0 9 ; 1 6 1 : 1 0 - 7
Documento descargado de http://www.apunts.org el 25/01/2011. Copia para uso personal, se prohíbe la transmisión de este documento por cualquier medio o formato.
14
O R I G I N A L A RT I C L E S
Certain rules must be followed when doing the test: the feet The mean flexibility of 27.38cm was obtained by primary
must stay on the floor or board at all times, the subject must school girls and was the highest result, compared to 19.23cm
keep his/her balance, leave the test from the front and not which was the lowest mean flexibility result obtained by female
move until the distance has been measured. Two attempts were university students.
made and the best result was recorded, fractions of a centimetre
were not taken into account and results were rounded to the
nearest whole number. The equipment used was a wooden
platform (0.76 by 0.88m) with a movable yardstick, as shown Figura 2 How a deep trunk flexion is performed.
in figure 2.
Results
flexibility of 19.50cm obtained by university students in Total 22.25 410 7.223 52.176
Almeria (n = 117.)
There are significant differences (p = 0.00) between the
subjects from the three levels of education included in the Figure 3 Flexibility according to age range.
study.
Figure 4 shows the mean flexibility results obtained by 12 14.40
11 16.60
subjects according to age range and sex.
10 23.00
It is possible to deduce from figure 4 that female subjects
9 23.13
from range 3 were the most flexible (X = 29.02cm), compared
8 18.79
with a mean of 17.27cm which was obtained by the girls in 7 21.23
range 8. Similarly, the mean of 29cm obtained by the males in 6 17.66
range 10 cannot be considered reliable given that only one 5 20.06
subject was tested and that the mean flexibility of range 12 was 4 21.77
10.50cm by comparison. 3 25.71
2 24.17
Finally, table VI shows the mean flexibility of the subjects
1 24.39
from the different levels of education according to gender.
a p u n t s m e d e s p o r t. 2 0 0 9 ; 1 6 1 : 1 0 - 7
Documento descargado de http://www.apunts.org el 25/01/2011. Copia para uso personal, se prohíbe la transmisión de este documento por cualquier medio o formato.
15
O R I G I N A L A RT I C L E S
Table V Distribution of flexor muscle performance Figura 4 Comparative analysis of mean flexibility
according to level of education by sex in each of the age ranges.
Level of 12
Mean N Standard deviation Variance
education 11
Primary 24.98 177 6.821 46.528 10
9
Secondary 20.84 116 6.210 38.567 8
University 19.50 117 7.356 54.114 7
6
Total 22.25 410 7.223 52.176
5
4
3
2
Discussion 1
a p u n t s m e d e s p o r t. 2 0 0 9 ; 1 6 1 : 1 0 - 7
Documento descargado de http://www.apunts.org el 25/01/2011. Copia para uso personal, se prohíbe la transmisión de este documento por cualquier medio o formato.
16
O R I G I N A L A RT I C L E S
downward trend continues more steadily after this, confirming • The maximum mean flexibility of our study was obtained
the findings of Brent29 and Sánchez.10 in range 3 (10-11 years) which coincides with the onset
With regard to age range and sex, the data from our study of puberty.
only confirms what has already been established by Mafulli23 • Women have greater mean flexibility than men across
(1994) and Arregui3 (2001), who stated that females most of the age ranges and different levels of education
demonstrate greater mean flexibility and that this decreases although there are no significant differences between the
with age. These findings correspond with the results in figure sexes.
4 that show the same trend in relation to the level of education • Flexor muscle performance increases until the age of 12
and sex. which coincides with primary level education. It
progressively decreases from this age onwards. Older
university students were the least flexible, which indicates
Conclusions
that flexibility decreases with age, with the exception of
The conclusions of this study are as follows: the age ranges that included sportsmen or women who
were responsible for peaks in flexibility in the results.
References
1. Torres J. Teoría y práctica del entrenamiento deportivo. Conside- 11. Zurita F. Screening de las alteraciones raquídeas (escoliosis e hiper-
raciones didácticas. Granada: Torres Guerrero; 1996. cifosis) en la población escolar de 8 a 12 años de Granada y pro-
2. Bajo S. La flexibilidad y la educación física escolar: evolución y vincia. Tesis doctoral. Granada: Universidad de Granada. 2007.
aplicación en la escuela. En: Guillén del Castillo M, editor. Medi- 12. Achour-Junior A. Bases para exercícios de alongamento, relacio-
cina deportiva y educación física en edad escolar. Córdoba: Uni- nando com a saúde e no desempenho atlético. 2.a edicao. Sao
versidad de Córdoba, Servicio de Publicaciones; 2003. p. 421-40. Paulo: Phorte Editora; 1999.
3. Arregui Eraña JA, Martínez de Haro V. Estado actual de las inves- 13. Ramos D, González J, Mora J. Diferencias en las amplitudes ar-
tigaciones sobre la flexibilidad en la adolescencia. Revista interna- ticulares entre varones y mujeres en edad escolar. Apunts. 2007;42:
cional médica de las ciencias de la actividad física y el deporte. 153.
2001;1:127-135. 14. Bale P, Mayhew J, Ball TE, Williman MK. Biological and perfor-
4. Álvarez del Villar C. La preparación física del fútbol basada en el mance variables in to age in male and female adolescent athletes.
atletismo. Madrid: Gymnos; 1987. J Sports Med Phys Fitness. 1992;32:142-8.
5. Martínez López EJ. La flexibilidad: pruebas aplicables en educa- 15. García JM. Bases teóricas del entrenamiento deportivo. Princi-
ción secundaria-grado de utilización del profesorado. Revista Di- pios y aplicaciones. Madrid: Gymnos; 1996.
gital, Educación Física y Deportes. 2003;8:58. 16. Garcías D, Capablo M. Valoración y estudio de las deformaciones
6. Araujo C. Flexitest: an innovative flexibility asseessment method. ortopédicas en personas con parálisis cerebral. Revista Fisiotera-
Champaing: Human Kinetics; 2003. pia. 1999;21.
7. González Montesinos JL, Martínez González J, Mora Vicente J, 17. Mac Dougall JD, Wenger HA, Green HJ. Evaluación fisiológica
Salto Chamorro G, Álvarez Fernández E. El dolor de espalda y los del deportista. Badalona: Paidotribo; 1995.
desequilibrios musculares. Revista internacional médica de las 18. Casajús J. Actividades físicas en el niño en edad escolar; caracte
ciencias de la actividad física y el deporte. 2004;4:18-34. rísticas antropométricas, composición corporal y madurez. Tesis
8. Leiva de Antonio JH. Capacidades físicas de trabajos de la pobla- doctoral. Zaragoza: Universidad de Zaragoza; 1990.
ción en edad escolar, matriculada en instituciones educativas de 19. Ureña F. Valoración y baremación de la aptitud física en el alum-
la ciudad de Cali. Colombia: Revista Corpus; 2000. nado de 2.o ciclo de Educación Secundaria obligatoria de la co-
9. Grosser M, Müller H. Desarrollo muscular: un nuevo concepto de munidad autónoma de Murcia. Su utilización según los postula-
musculación (power-stretch). Barcelona: Hispano-Europea; 1992. dos de la reforma. Tesis doctoral. Murcia: Universidad de Murcia;
10. Sánchez EG, Águila MQ, Rojas JY. Consideraciones generales 1996.
acerca del uso de la flexibilidad en el béisbol. Revista Digital, 20. Navarro M. La condición física en la población adulta de la isla
Educación Física y Deportes. 2001;7:2001. de Gran Canaria y su relación con determinadas actitudes y hábi-
a p u n t s m e d e s p o r t. 2 0 0 9 ; 1 6 1 : 1 0 - 7
Documento descargado de http://www.apunts.org el 25/01/2011. Copia para uso personal, se prohíbe la transmisión de este documento por cualquier medio o formato.
17
O R I G I N A L A RT I C L E S
tos de vida. Tesis doctoral. Las Palmas: Universidad de las Palmas 25. Garagorri JM. Hipercrecimientos: Sistema diagnóstico. An Esp
de Gran Canaria; 1998. Pediatr. 2004;60 Supl 4:291-5.
21. Weineck J. Entrenamiento óptimo. Barcelona: Hispano-Europea; 26. Draper O. The carry-over effects of diathermy and stretching in
1988. developing hamstring flexibility. J Athletic Training. 2002;37:37-
22. Porta J, Martín R. Metodología del entrenamiento para el desa- 42.
rrollo de la velocidad y la flexibilidad. Módulo 2.2.3. Madrid: 27. Grobbe B. Reliability of common coger extremity muculoskeletal
Centro Olímpico de Estudios Superiores; 1993. screening tests. Physical Therapy in Sport. 2004;5:90-7.
23. Maffulli N, King JB, Helms P. Training in elite young athletes 28. Zaragoza J. La medición de la educación física saludable: aplica-
(the Training of Young Athletes TOYA): injuries, flexibility and ción de la batería de Eurofit para adultos. Revista digital de Bue-
isometric strengt. Br J Sports Med. 1994;28:123-36. nos Aires. 2004;10:68.
24. Docherty D, Bell RD. The relationship between flexibility and 29. Brent JW, Myrer W, Merrill RM. Acute changes in hamstring
linearity measures in boys and girls 6-15 year of age. Journal of flexibility: PNF versus Static Stretch in senior athletes. Physical
Human Movement Studies. 1995;11:279-88. Therapy in Sport. 2001;2:183-93.
a p u n t s m e d e s p o r t. 2 0 0 9 ; 1 6 1 : 1 0 - 7