Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Health Policy: The Role of Occupational Therapy in The Management of Depression
Health Policy: The Role of Occupational Therapy in The Management of Depression
Health Policy: The Role of Occupational Therapy in The Management of Depression
A
though in the United States, oc- and psychiatric hospitals, nursing inner and public lives. These activities
cupational therapy had its roots homes, psychosocial and physical reha- require and contribute to the goal-
bilitation centers, sheltered workshops, directed use of time, energy, interest,
in psychiatry, beginning with the clinics, public and private schools,
Moral Treatment era of the early 1800s group homes, correctional institutions,
and attention (S. B. Fine, personal com-
(Hopkins, 1988), a cluster of outcome home health agencies, community munication, December 11, 1990).
studies relating to the effect of occupa- mental health centers, day care cemers, For example, a person whose life
private practice, physician's [sic I of- roles include those of wife, mother,
tional therapy on the treatment of de-
fices, as well as industry and business.
pression has been reported in the litera- daughter, and chemical engineer might
(Fine, 1983, p. 1)
ture just within the past 10 years (see have performance deficits different than
Table 1). Depression does take its toll on oc- those of a person whose life roles en-
Reference to occupation in the title cupation - in fact, the condition is char- compass those of wife, student, and
is in the context of goal-directed use of acterized by changes in capacities to en- part-time phlebotomist, though both
time, energy, interest, and attention gage in goal-directed use of time, are experiencing severe depression. The
(American Occupational Therapy Associ- energy, interest, and attention. Addi- overall treatment goals would be similar
ation [AOTA], 1972) to foster adapta- tionally, occupation, in its broadest con- for both (namely, to overcome those
tion and productivity, to minimize pa- text, is precisely that: the goal-directed performance deficits, perhaps through
thology, and to promote the use of time, energy, interest, and atten- adaptation or through learning new
maintenance of health: tion. However, occupation that is rel- skills), but the treatment plans would
evant and appropriate to a given per- be individualized in ways meaningful to
Occupational therapists work in a son's capacities and needs may also each person. The focus of treatment for
broad range of practice areas and set-
tings. Within the scope of general psy-
serve to alter his or her mood by cap- the first person, for example, might be
chiatry, services are provided to chil- turing interest, focusing attention, creat- time management; for the second per-
dren, adolescents, adults and elderly of ing a meaningful time structure, dim in- son, skill development.
Fine (1988) Adult psychiatric in- Experimental two- Life skills cumcu- Problem-solving Preliminary results
patients, short-lerm group design lum: Educational skills; communica- suggest sustained
acute care selling, social-learning ap- tion skills; commu- improvement in
with bipolar or ma- proach to skill ac- nityadjustment problem-solving
jor depressive affec- quisition designed and communication
tive disorders (ages to enhance commu- skills at conclusion
18-55 years) nity adjustment of treatment. Func-
Standard occupa- tional gains general-
lional therapy ly sustained in spite
of significant in-
crease in depressive
symptoms at 6-
week follow-up. All
results based on
small initial sample
(n=5).
Gangl (1987) Chemically depend- Single-group pretest- Open occupational General, interperson- Over time, improve-
ent and emotionally posllest design therapy treatment al, and work behav- ment was noted in
disturbed adoles- centering on work iors (based on the general behavior
cents at a residen- skills and/or rela- Jamestown Occupa- ( + 0.5), interper-
tial treatment cen- tionship skillS tional Therapy sonal behavior
ter (ages 13-14 (n = 33) Assessment) ( + 0.8), and work
years) behavior (+ 0.6).
(Effect size esti-
mates are based on
mean change scores
divided by change
score standard
deviations.)
Good-Ellis, Fine, Recently admilled in- Single-group pretest- Occupational ther- Role performance Unipolar and bipolar
Haas, Spencer, & patients with major posllest design apy services, based (based on the Role groups demonstrat-
Glick (1986) affective disorders, on the occupational Activity Perform- ed different pat-
including unipolar behavior model, ance Scale) terns of recovery.
and bipolar disor- featuring emphasis Trajectory of im-
ders (ages 15-45 on activities of daily provement during
years) living, goal selling, 6-18 month period
future planning, showed social and
recreation, and pre- leisure role im-
vocational services provement preced-
(in conjunction with ing work, school,
standard hospital and other primary
treatment with em- roles.
phasis on family in- At both 6 months
tervention) (n = 50) and 18 months
follow-up, more
subjects improved
than worsened in
their role activity
performance (re-
spective effect size
estimates = + 0.1
and +0.4).
Kielhofner & Brin- Hospitalized psychi- Randomized posttesl- Treatment [?I"Qup Recidivism; the KatZ Suhjects in the ex-
son (1989) atric ratients with only experimental (n=20): Adjustment Scales; perimental group
at least 6 months of design Small group ses- The Occurational were nonsignificant-
rsychiatric history sions with struc- Questionnaire (a Iy less likely to
and 2 or more hos- tured objectives and daily activity experience rehospi-
pitalizations (ages activitic, related to assessment) talization following
25-40 years) skills, roles, leisure discharge (+ 0.5).
Control group Katz scores were
(n = 14) nonsignificantly dif-
ferent between
groups ( + 0.0).
On the Occupational
Questionnaire. ex-
perimental subjeers
had a nonsignifi-
cantil' higher mean
for the amount of
work than did con-
trol subjects
( +06)
Kremer, Nelson, & Chronic rsychiatric Randomized posuest- Cookinft (n = 9): Rated evaluation, Participation in cook-
Duncombe (19H4) patients (mainly only experimental Engagement in power. and action ing produced high-
schil.Ophrenics) design cookie making with of the activitv er evaluation ratings
rarticipating in a group (based on Osgood's than either craft or
day treatment pro- Crali (n=H) Semantic Differen- ~cnsory awareness
gram (average age Participation in col- tial Scale) following (+ 1.7) activities
49.6 years) lage making participation in the Engagement in cook-
Sensol)' awareness activjt~' ing led to nonsigni-
(n = S): ficantl)' lower ra!-
Participation in ings of power than
group senson' exer- did craft or sensory
cises and awareness (-0.5).
movements Action rallngs did
not meaningfully
differ among the
three activities.
Stein & Smith (19H9) Acutely depressed Single-group pretest- Occupational/hera- S-Anxiety Scale of the Subjects were signifi-
rsychiatric inpa- posw:st design p)'-hased stress State-Trait Anxietv cantly less anxious
tients (ages 20-45 marzaRement train- InventorY al the conclusiun of
years) ing. including the program than
group discussion. they were prior to
biofeedhack, relax- its initiation (+ 0.8).
'Hion training, be-
havioral rehearsal,
and attention to
evel)/cby Stressors
and activities useful
in controlling stress
en =7)
"The occupational therapy groups are underlined within each studv. °Positive effcet sil.e estimates reOeet a heneficial treatment effect, where relevant.
Effcct size estimat<:~ arc ha~ed on the d statistic and arc corrected for sample size bias (Glass. ;VkGaw. & Smith. 1981).
In their study of depressed women, paired patients to give ur work, the a 6-month time lag in returning to a pri-
Weissman and Paykel (1974) found that findings suggested that a job outside m level of social functioning (Dever-
despite the social impairments and ac- the home has a rrmective effect. eaux, 1986). Several studies have shown
companying discomforts of acutely de- Of particular importance for occu- that rharmacotherary is effecrive in
pressed patients, a reasonable number pational therapy intervention is the find- controlling many of thc symptoms of
of these women continued to work dur- ing that many depressed patients have derression but has little or no influence
ing the acute episode. Within this group persistent symproms and psychosocial on the adaptive skills required fm living
of subjects, women who worked outside and occupational impairment even after in the community (Blackburn, 1983;
the home showed less impairment than recovery from an acutc episode (Dever- Murphy, Simons, Wetzel, & Lustman,
housewives. The authors noted that eaux, 1986; Keller et aI., 1982). Follow- [984; Rush, Beck, Kovacs, Weissen-
though these differences could be relat- ing the remission of depressive symp- burger, & Hollon, 1982). A study hy
ed to the tendency of the most im- toms, the person may experience up ro Neville-Jan (1987) revealed the presence