Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Special Report:: What's Ahead For Canadian Energy Trusts?
Special Report:: What's Ahead For Canadian Energy Trusts?
Special Report:: What's Ahead For Canadian Energy Trusts?
| 1
DECEMBER 2010
Special Report:
What’s Ahead For
Canadian Energy Trusts?
Euro Pacific Capital’s response to a changing regulatory environment.
Euro Pacific Capital specializes in international investments. International investing may not be suitable for all investors. To find out more about the
above company, and to see if this investment may be suitable for you, CLICK HERE.
You can also call one of our investment consultants directly. They can give you share price information and help you determine if these equities
88 Post
meet your particular investment objectives andRoad West,
risk tolerance. Call3rd Floor
toll-free: | Westport, CT 06880
1-800-727-7922.
ph: (800) 727-7922 | fax: (203) 662-9771 | www.europac.net
Euro Pacific Capital | (800) 727-7922 NY
Branches: New York, | Los Angeles, CA | Newport, CA | Scottsdale, AZ | Palm Beach, FL
| www.europac.net
Click here to Share this report! Special Report: What’s Ahead For Canadian Energy Trusts? | 2
Peter Schiff
Peter is one
of the few
Founded in 1980 and today headquartered in Westport, Connecticut, non-biased
Euro Pacific Capital is a full service broker/dealer, member FINRA/ investment
SIPC, that has historically been recognized for specializing in advisors (not
foreign markets and securities. Through its direct relationships with committed
foreign trading desks, the firm’s clients may gain access to narrower solely to the
spreads as compared to domestic market-makers of foreign short side of the market) to have
securities, thereby helping to reduce overall transaction costs. correctly called the current bear
market before it began and to have
We are a small, boutique firm, offering customized brokerage positioned his clients accordingly.
services to individuals, corporations, pensions and institutions. As a result of his accurate forecasts
We have offices in Los Angeles and Newport Beach, California; on the U.S. stock market, economy,
Scottsdale, Arizona; New York City, New York; Palm Beach, Florida; real estate, mortgage meltdown,
and Westport, Connecticut. credit crunch, subprime debacle,
commodities, gold and the dollar,
The firm develops investment strategies for its clients consistent with he is becoming increasingly more
the macroeconomic philosophy of its founder and president, Peter renowned.
Schiff. Peter believes that the dollar is in a long term decline due to
excessive public and private debt, loose monetary policy, and over- Peter has been quoted in many of
regulation. We believe that long term value can be found outside the nation’s leading newspapers,
the U.S. in non-dollar securities and that investors should include including The Wall Street Journal,
some precious metals and natural resources in their overall portfolio Barron’s, Investor’s Business Daily,
allocation. The Financial Times, The New York
Times, and The Los Angeles Times
Combine our full array of services with our no nonsense investment and appears regularly on CNBC,
advice, and we believe that all investors will find a home here for a CNN, Fox News, Fox Business
portion of their portfolios. Network, and Bloomberg TV.
Peter Schiff’s New Book: How An Economy Grows And Why It Crashes
For those who would normally prefer to watch paint dry than delve into economic theory,
Peter Schiff's new illustrated book, How an Economy Grows and Why It Crashes, offers
an enjoyable introduction to the subject.
With wit, humor, and over 150 original illustrations, Peter and Andrew Schiff offer a
straightforward story of fish, nets, savings, lending, trade, job creation, and inflation.
The allegorical tale of a small, primitive, island nation discusses the roots of economic
growth and the reasons economies decline.
LEARN MORE ABOUT THE BOOK
Canadian Energy
Trusts?
Is the Party Over?
After years of angst in Canada’s oil patch, the percentage for investment in their own growth
income trust model, which had been the bedrock and development. Although the system worked
of the industry for decades, will finally be laid to well for income investors, it created a two-tiered
rest on December 31st. The attractive dividends energy industry (divided between developers and
that were enabled by low corporate taxes will be producers) which arguably imposed some structural
effectively legislated out of existence. While many inefficiency on the industry.
investors may be feeling that a great party is
coming to an end, there are reasons to believe that It has been persuasively argued that the elimination
the new era will provide fresh momentum in the of this imposed bifurcation will spur investment in
energy sector as former income trusts return to the exploration, development and technology. The net
corporate fold. effect of such spending may be to increase well-
drilling activity and encourage strategic acquisitions
Rather than selling Canadian energy trusts in an and partnerships. There is some evidence that
immediate response to the changing regulations, these moves are already underway.
investors should understand, and consider, that the
internal changes in preparation of the regulatory In the meantime, trusts currently converting to
changes have been long underway at many firms. corporate structures are trying to strike the right
Due to these steps, and other economic factors, balance between how much of their earnings to re-
many former energy trusts may be poised for long, invest and how much to pass through to investors
prosperous, and sustainable futures. as taxed dividends. The good news is that those
trusts-turned-corporations that succeed should be
In truth, the distinct legal structure of income trusts, healthier long-term investments than any of their
which allowed the companies to pass tax-free trust-based predecessors. Investors should pay
earnings through to unit holders (the equivalent to attention to those firms that find the best solutions.
shareholders), did not come without a downside
forEuro
thePacific
Canadian energy industry.
Capital specializes The
in international structure
investments. Themay
International investing world
not bewill continue
suitable to crave
for all investors. energy
To find and,
out more about the
above company, and to see if this investment may be suitable for you, CLICK HERE.
left trusts with a strong incentive to pay out a high currently, Canada has it in abundance.
degree
You canof earnings
also call one of rather than consultants
our investment retain a healthy
directly. They can give you share price information and help you to determine if these equities
meet your particular investment objectives and risk tolerance. Call toll-free: 1-800-727-7922.
A Look Back at
The Halloween Surprise
The whiff of optimism in the air today is far
different from the scent of betrayal that wafted
through the hallways of oil and gas trusts on
October 31, 2006. That was the day Canadian
Finance Minister Jim Flaherty stunned the
markets with his “Halloween surprise.” His
decision that income trusts would be taxed as
corporations as of January 1, 2011 resulted
in one of the worst days in the history of the
Toronto Stock Exchange. Anticipating lower
dividend payouts and falling share prices,
investors stampeded towards the exits. When
the dust settled, share prices for trusts had
fallen more than 30% in a single day.
In the ensuing years, the shock and anger have been influenced by these rules.
subsided and companies have drawn up transition Energy trusts themselves became a
plans. With no alternatives, trusts have assessed staple on the income investor’s buffet.
the new rules of the game and have adjusted to Trusts typically had low operating costs and
the new conditions. Today, as we approach the paid sparse or no corporate tax. The income flowed
deadline, the stronger companies have already directly through to the trust unit holders who were
converted toward corporate structures or have laid taxed individually. These attractive distributions
significant groundwork. Many of the weaker ones were sought by tax-deferred retirement plans and
have been simply taken over by those who have. individual investors searching for income and
stability. Based on the share price premium that
To understand the great apprehension that has trusts were awarded, many larger energy producers
accompanied the transition, it helps to understand converted to trusts. When they did, their priorities
the history of trusts in the Canadian energy sector. changed. Yield and payout ratios became their
guiding lights.
The regulations that made trusts possible were
enacted in 1985. To a large extent, the shape of With the bigger companies focused on distributions,
the entire Canadian energy sector since then has other energy corporations, mostly the smaller ones,
Euro Pacific Capital specializes in international investments. International investing may not be suitable for all investors. To find out more about the
above company, and to see if this investment may be suitable for you, CLICK HERE.
You can also call one of our investment consultants directly. They can give you share price information and help you determine if these equities
meet your particular investment objectives and risk tolerance. Call toll-free: 1-800-727-7922.
Euro Pacific Capital specializes in international investments. International investing may not be suitable for all investors. To find out more about the
above company, and to see if this investment may be suitable for you, CLICK HERE.
You can also call one of our investment consultants directly. They can give you share price information and help you determine if these equities
meet your particular investment objectives and risk tolerance. Call toll-free: 1-800-727-7922.
Euro Pacific Capital specializes in international investments. International investing may not be suitable for all investors. To find out more about the
above company, and to see if this investment may be suitable for you, CLICK HERE.
You can also call one of our investment consultants directly. They can give you share price information and help you determine if these equities
meet your particular investment objectives and risk tolerance. Call toll-free: 1-800-727-7922.
Transition Uncertainty
In the two years that followed the carnage
of the Halloween Surprise, unit prices of
energy trusts largely rallied. In no small
part, these results were helped by surging
oil and gas prices. By the time oil prices hit
record levels by mid-2008, most energy
trusts had erased the losses from 2006. But
in the 3rd and 4th quarters of 2008, when
oil and natural gas prices plummeted, unit
prices for the entire sector took a nosedive.
When a number of trusts cut dividend
distributions — a few more than once —
investors were treated to a jarring wake-up
call that times were changing.
The recovery in energy prices since 2009 has In essence, conversion pathways boiled down to a
provided some relief for trusts, allowing most of few key strategies:
them to modestly raise payouts over the past 12 to
18 months. With current cash flow stabilized, trusts • Acquiring exploration companies with
then focused more intently on conversion strategy impressive or promising assets.
over this past year. Some trusts that felt they had • Assembling unconventional (read: unprofitable)
sustainable yields converted early. Those that did properties and investing in breakthrough
were no longer bound by growth-limiting legislation technologies to help unlock hidden potential.
and were able to become first bidders on attractive • Cutting exploration and development costs via
acquisition targets. three-dimensional seismic surveys and next-
generation mapping technology.
Late-converters, which may have missed out on • Looking to be acquired by a converting trust.
choice land and company acquisitions, have gone
back to the drawing board to microscopically re- All these strategies (except the last) involve
examine their property portfolios. Legacy assets spending money. Companies that have been
containing unconventional resource plays drew making such moves have had less ability to raise
renewed interest. With their backs to the wall, many distributions back to pre-2008 levels. But given
trusts have turned to the engineering and scientific the conspicuous lack of yield in other sectors of
communities to help unlock the potential of fields the market (bonds), these relatively lower payouts
that had previously been considered exhausted. haven’t encouraged investors to quit the asset
class.
Euro Pacific Capital specializes in international investments. International investing may not be suitable for all investors. To find out more about the
above company, and to see if this investment may be suitable for you, CLICK HERE.
You can also call one of our investment consultants directly. They can give you share price information and help you determine if these equities
meet your particular investment objectives and risk tolerance. Call toll-free: 1-800-727-7922.
Euro Pacific Capital specializes in international investments. International investing may not be suitable for all investors. To find out more about the
above company, and to see if this investment may be suitable for you, CLICK HERE.
You can also call one of our investment consultants directly. They can give you share price information and help you determine if these equities
meet your particular investment objectives and risk tolerance. Call toll-free: 1-800-727-7922.
Euro Pacific Capital specializes in international investments. International investing may not be suitable for all investors. To find out more about the
above company, and to see if this investment may be suitable for you, CLICK HERE.
You can also call one of our investment consultants directly. They can give you share price information and help you determine if these equities
meet your particular investment objectives and risk tolerance. Call toll-free: 1-800-727-7922.
What’s A Frack?
Multi-stage fracturing, known as “fracking,”
is a game changer. If it hadn’t come along,
many more income trusts would have faced
considerable difficulty in the transition. The
process allows drillers to more quickly and
methodically capture oil or natural gas deeply
embedded in rock. The process is particularly
useful for natural gas.
Bakken Action
One notable area of consolidation has been around
an area called the Bakken Formation. This vast
agglomeration of shale and hard rock runs under the
Canadian provinces of Manitoba and Saskatchewan, as
well as the US states of Montana and North Dakota.
Euro Pacific Capital specializes in international investments. International investing may not be suitable for all investors. To find out more about the
above company, and to see if this investment may be suitable for you, CLICK HERE.
You can also call one of our investment consultants directly. They can give you share price information and help you determine if these equities
meet your particular investment objectives and risk tolerance. Call toll-free: 1-800-727-7922.
Euro Pacific Capital specializes in international investments. International investing may not be suitable for all investors. To find out more about the
above company, and to see if this investment may be suitable for you, CLICK HERE.
You can also call one of our investment consultants directly. They can give you share price information and help you determine if these equities
meet your particular investment objectives and risk tolerance. Call toll-free: 1-800-727-7922.
Hedging
Their Bets
Most trusts are expected to present their budgets and
projected yields once they can assess the 2010 oil and natural
gas price movements. Even with the lower payout ratios,
some conservative former trusts are highly hedged to
ensure capital will be available to maintain distributions
even in case of a steep drop in oil and gas prices (tax
pools play a role in this). While energy prices may see
some volatility in the years ahead, there are many
reasons for investors to believe that prices will stay
strong over the long term. Much of the growing
demand that supports high prices is coming from
emerging economies in Asia and South America.
Current data show ongoing strength in those
economies. In addition, there is ample evidence of
widespread monetary expansion in many of the world’s
leading economies, including the United States, China,
and the eurozone. Expanding money supplies tend to push
commodity prices higher over the long term.
Euro Pacific Capital specializes in international investments. International investing may not be suitable for all investors. To find out more about the
above company, and to see if this investment may be suitable for you, CLICK HERE.
You can also call one of our investment consultants directly. They can give you share price information and help you determine if these equities
meet your particular investment objectives and risk tolerance. Call toll-free: 1-800-727-7922.
Are US Trusts A
Viable Alternative?
With the dissolution of the Canadian
trust sector per se, some American
investors may wonder if the
US energy trust sector
will emerge as a viable
alternative. There are
reasons to doubt this. US
trusts have always served
a different investment
purpose than their
Canadian counterparts.
They are unable to
finance acquisitions
and development,
so they behave like
derivative investments
on particular oil and
gas assets, rather
than vital corporate
concerns. They carry
no debt, but typically
have a lower payout
and dividend due to
their finite existence.
By contrast, Canadian energy trusts were holding that would factor into the comparison of US
always able to finance new acquisitions and trusts. Canadian energy companies use, hold, and
generally behaved more like traditional joint- pay dividends in Canadian dollars. For investors
stock corporations, albeit with different legal looking for alternatives to U.S. dollar holdings,
consequences in tax law and unit holder liability. Canadian investments would offer a source of
currency diversification.
There is also the currency impact on an equity
Euro Pacific Capital specializes in international investments. International investing may not be suitable for all investors. To find out more about the
above company, and to see if this investment may be suitable for you, CLICK HERE.
You can also call one of our investment consultants directly. They can give you share price information and help you determine if these equities
meet your particular investment objectives and risk tolerance. Call toll-free: 1-800-727-7922.
Takeaway
While initially derided as a mere tax grab, the abolition of
trusts may actually be a blessing in disguise. Very rarely do the
distortions created by government tax policies create benefits
for an economy. While the Canadian trust structure offered
advantages to certain classes of investors, it also had many
unintended side effects. Canada may be better off without it.
Under FINRA Rule 2310, broker-dealers are required to make sure that every investment recommendation
is suitable for each client’s unique investment objectives and risk tolerance. The company overviews
provided here are meant to give an indication of the type of recommendations a Euro Pacific Investment
Consultant may make, depending upon your unique investment goals, risk tolerance, and profile. If you
have questions
Euro Pacific about the
Capital specializes companies
in international described
investments. in thisinvesting
International report,may
or not
think they may
be suitable for all be suitable
investors. foroutyour
To find more about the
above company, and to see if this investment may be suitable for you, CLICK HERE.
portfolio, please call (800) 727-7922 and a Euro Pacific Investment Consultant will assist you, with no
obligation to one
You can also call buyoffrom us.
our investment consultants directly. They can give you share price information and help you determine if these equities
meet your particular investment objectives and risk tolerance. Call toll-free: 1-800-727-7922.
Company 1
This company is
in energy services.
It pipes crude oil,
natural gas, and
synthetic crude
produced from tar
sands. It converted
to a corporation
earlier in the year
and maintained its
dividend at the same
level. It plans to keep
its dividend at the
same amount for the
next three years. Its
dividend is about 50%
higher today than it Company #1 Stock Chart, December 2007 – December 2010 (Bloomberg, December 2010). Prices in CAD.
was 10 years ago.*
■■ 7.3% yield.
Euro Pacific Capital specializes in international investments. International investing may not be suitable for all investors. To find out more about the
above company, and to see if this investment may be suitable for you, CLICK HERE.
You can also call one of our investment consultants directly. They can give you share price information and help you determine if these equities
meet your particular investment objectives and risk tolerance. Call toll-free: 1-800-727-7922.
Company 2
This company
produces only natural
gas. It is at the forefront
in its niche because it
has the lowest cost of
production, and this
company is profitable.
Its cost per barrel of
production currently is
below US$4 while many
competitors are over
US$10. It has employed
multi-stage horizontal
fracking and doubled its
daily gas production per
well. Company #2 Stock Chart, December 2007 – December 2010 (Bloomberg, December 2010). Prices in CAD.
Growing Demand: This graph from ExxonMobil shows gas demand potential is
strongest in Asia.
Euro Pacific Capital specializes in international investments. International investing may not be suitable for all investors. To find out more about the
above company, and to see if this investment may be suitable for you, CLICK HERE.
You can also call one of our investment consultants directly. They can give you share price information and help you determine if these equities
meet your particular investment objectives and risk tolerance. Call toll-free: 1-800-727-7922.
Company 3
This company’s
production
includes both oil
and gas, with less
than 50% of oil and
the balance of gas.
It uses multi-stage
horizontal fracking
to enhance its
production in each of
its locations. Of the
wells it plans to drill
in 2011, a majority
will be horizontal.
Management is
a big key to the Company #3 Stock Chart, December 2007 – December 2010 (Bloomberg, December 2010). Prices in CAD.
company’s success.
The CEO and CFO
have been with the company since its inception in
• US$6.8 billion in market cap.
1996.
• 4.8% yield.
Its Bakken production is ~8% of the company’s
total, but will receive ~29% of the 2011 well drilling.
Dividend yields change as stock prices change, and
companies may change or cancel dividend payments in the
This company will convert by New Year’s, and
future.
plans to pay the same amount of cash as a
dividend as it does as a trust.
Euro Pacific Capital specializes in international investments. International investing may not be suitable for all investors. To find out more about the
above company, and to see if this investment may be suitable for you, CLICK HERE.
You can also call one of our investment consultants directly. They can give you share price information and help you determine if these equities
meet your particular investment objectives and risk tolerance. Call toll-free: 1-800-727-7922.
Company 4
This
company
produces
conventional
oil and gas in
Alberta and
Saskatchewan,
with one of its
locations among
the largest
conventional
pools found
in the last half
century. The
entire field,
across the USA Company #4 Stock Chart, December 2007 – December 2010 (Bloomberg, December 2010). Prices in CAD.
and Canada, is
one of the most abundant oil finds in North America
• US$11.2 billion in market cap
since Alaska’s Prudhoe Bay.
• 6.4% yield.
The company is aggressively acquiring companies
and developing oil land. Oil reserves have about
Dividend yields change as stock prices change, and
doubled over the last three years.
companies may change or cancel dividend payments in the
future.
The company has already converted to a
corporation and did not change the amount it paid
as a dividend.
Euro Pacific Capital specializes in international investments. International investing may not be suitable for all investors. To find out more about the
above company, and to see if this investment may be suitable for you, CLICK HERE.
You can also call one of our investment consultants directly. They can give you share price information and help you determine if these equities
meet your particular investment objectives and risk tolerance. Call toll-free: 1-800-727-7922.
Company 5
Though this
Company produces
conventional oil and
gas, it also specializes
in other oil production.
Not as easily flowing, the
heaviest oil is found in tar
sands and must be boiled
in a factory to separate
the oil from the sand.
Sometimes it must be
heated in the ground to a
point where it will begin
to flow. Once flowing, it
comes out of the ground
via wells. Company #5 Stock Chart, December 2007 – December 2010 (Bloomberg, December 2010). Prices in CAD.
Euro Pacific Capital specializes in international investments. International investing may not be suitable for all investors. To find out more about the
above company, and to see if this investment may be suitable for you, CLICK HERE.
You can also call one of our investment consultants directly. They can give you share price information and help you determine if these equities
meet your particular investment objectives and risk tolerance. Call toll-free: 1-800-727-7922.
Risks In Investing In
Canadian Oil & Gas:
• Prices of oil & gas can fall.
• Unknown environmental issues could arise, raising the cost of operations.
• Potentially promising energy fields could turn out to be dry.
• Financing could be tight or unavailable when needed, reducing potential revenue.
• Drilling, pipelines, and other well services may not be readily available, causing the company to lose
expected revenue.
• The US dollar could rise in value, resulting in foreign currency losses.
Euro Pacific Capital specializes in international investments. International investing may not be suitable for all investors. To find out more about the
above company, and to see if this investment may be suitable for you, CLICK HERE.
You can also call one of our investment consultants directly. They can give you share price information and help you determine if these equities
meet your particular investment objectives and risk tolerance. Call toll-free: 1-800-727-7922.