Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Alternative Dispute Resolution and The Arbitration Law-Merged
The Alternative Dispute Resolution and The Arbitration Law-Merged
The Alternative Dispute Resolution and The Arbitration Law-Merged
CHAPTER ONE
ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION
ACT OF 2004
1.01 DOES R.A. NO. 9285 LIMIT THE POWER OF THE SUPREME
COURT TO ADOPT ANY ADR SYSTEM?
No, this Act shall be without prejudice to the adoption by the
Supreme Court of any ADR system, such as mediation, conciliation,
arbitration, or any combination thereof as a means of achieving speedy
and efficient means of resolving cases pending before all courts in the
Philippines which shall be governed by such rules as the Supreme
Court may approve from time to time. (Section 2)
C)Court-Annexed Mediation
"Court-Annexed Mediation" means any mediation process con-
ducted under the auspices of the court, after such court has acquired
jurisdiction of the dispute. (Section 3)
D) Court-Referred Mediation
"Court-Referred Mediation" means mediation ordered by a
court to be conducted in accordance with the agreement of the par-
ties when as action is prematurely commenced in violation of such
agreement. (Section 3)
E) Early Neutral Evaluation
"Early Neutral Evaluation" means an ADR process wherein
parties and their lawyers are brought together early in a pre-trial
phase to present summaries of their cases and receive a nonbinding
assessment by an experienced, neutral person, with expertise in the
subject in the substance of the dispute. (Section 3)
F) Convention Award
"Convention Award'" means a foreign arbitral award made ina
Convention State. (Section 3)
G)Convention State
Convention State" means a State that is a member of the New
York Convention. (Section 3)
PARTI 3
Chapter One- Alternative Dispute Resolution Act of 2004
J) Mediation-Arbitration
Mediation-Arbitration" or Med-Arb is a step dispute resolution
process involving both mediation and arbitration. (Section 3)
K Mini-Trial
"Mini-Trial" means a structured dispute resolution method
in which the merits of a case are argued before a panel comprising
senior decision makers with or without the presence of a neutral
third person after which the parties seek a negotiated settlement.
(Section 3)
L) Model Law
Model Law" means the Model Law on International Commer
cial Arbitration adopted by the United Nations Commission on Inter-
national Trade Law on 21 June 1985. (Section 3)
or disprove a
claim
(6) sought or offered to prove
misconduct or mal
or complaint of professional
or
claim
sought or offered to prove or disprove
a
(7)
of complaint of professional misconduct
of mal
practice filed against a party, nonparty par
ticipant, or representative of a party based
on
principles:
Before accepting a mediation, an individual who is
(a)
to serve as a mediator shall:
requested
make an inquiry that is reasonable under the
(1)
circumstances to determine whether there are
a reasonable individual
any known facts that
would consider likely to affect the impartiality
of the mediator, including a financial or personal
interest in the outcome of the mediation and
any existing past relationship with a party
or
or foreseeable participant in
the mediation; and
The parties may agree to refer one or more or all issues arisin8
in a dispute or during its pendency to other forms of ADR such as but
not limited to:
(6) Either party may apply with the Court for assistan
in interim ance
implementing or enforcing
an arbitral tribunal.
an measure
ordered by
(7) A party who does not comply with the order shall
be
liable for all damages resulting from noncompliance, includina
all expenses, and reasonable attorney's tees, paid in
obtainino
the order's judicial enforcement. (Section 28)
Article 10. (1) The parties are free to determine the number
of arbitrators
(2) Failing such determination, the number ofarbitrators
shall be three.
THE ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION
18
AND THE ARBITRATION LAW
(3) The award shall state its date and the place of
arbitration as determined in accordance with Article 20(1). The
award shall be deemed to have been made at that place.
arbi-
(4) After the award is made, a copy signed by the
trators in accordance with paragraph (1) of this article shall be
proceedings;
the arbitral tribunal finds that the continuation
of the proceedings has for any other reason
omission.
(7) Aparty who does not comply with the order shall
be liable for all damages resulting from noncompliance,
including all expenses, and reasonable attorney's fees, paid
in obtaining the order's judicial enforcement.
(6)
(c)
d)The parties may agree in the settlement agreement
that the mediator shall become a sole arbitrator for the dispute
and shall treat the settlement agreement as an arbitral award
which shall be subject io enforcement under Republic Act No
876, otheruwise known as the Arbitration Law, notwithstanding
the provisions of Executive Order No. 1008 for mediated dispute
outside of the CIAC.
(4) Interim or
provisional relief is requested by
written application transmitted by reasonable
means to the Court or arbitral tribunal as the
case may be and the party against whom the
relief is sought, describing in appropriate detail
the precise relief, the party against whom the
relief is requested, the grounds for the relief,
and the evidence supporting the request.
(Section 42)
RESOLUTION
THE ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE
ARBITRATION LAW
AND THE
6.10 WHEN AND WHERE SHALL THE COURT SEND THE NOTICE
OF PROCEEDINGS TO THE PARTIES?
In a special proceeding for recognition and enforcement of an
arbitral award, the Court shall send notice to the parties at their
address of record in the arbitration, or if any party cannot be served
notice at such address, at such party's last known address. The
notice shall be sent at least 15 days before the date set for the initial
hearing of the application. (Section 48)
6.11 DOES R.A. NO. 9285 REPEAL THE JURISDICTION OF THE
KATARUNGAN PAMBARANGAY UNDER R.A. NO. 7160?
R.A. No. 9285 shall not be interpreted to repeal, amend or
modify the jurisdiction of the Katarungan Pambarangay under R.A.
No. 7160, otherwise known as the Local Government Code of 1991.
(Section 53)
CHAPTER TWO
A. IN GENERAL
32
PARTI 33
Chapter Two- Special Rules of Court on Alternative Dispute Resolution
to
Yes, a Certification Against Forum Shopping shall be
all initiatory pleadings except a Motion to Refer
anne
EQUIREDM
the Diude
Alternative Dispute Resolution. Dispute ta
A Certification Against
Forum Shopping 18 one
0ath by the petitioner or movant: (a) that he has made n .
not theret.
commenced any action or filed any claim oiore
involving the samme issues
in any court, tribunal or
quasi-judicial agency and, to the best of
knowledge, such other action or claim 1s pending
no his
there is such other pending action or
claim, a complete
therein; (
the present status statement ofof
thereof, and (C) if he should thereafter
the same or similar action or claim
has been filed or is
learnthat
tha
shall report that fact within five
days therefrom
pending,. ha
to the court
his aforementioned
petition or motion has been filed. (Rule wherein
1.5)
1.08 WHAT ARE THE
PROHIBITED PLEADINGS IN THE
GOVERNED BY THE SPECIAL ADR CASES
RULES?
The following
allowed in the cases pleadings, motions, or
petitions shall not be
not be
governed by the Special ADR Rules, and shall
accepted for filing by the Clerk of Court:
a. Motion to dismiss
b. Motion for bill of
particulars;
C. Motion for new trial or for
d. Petition for relief from
reopening of trial;
e. Motion for
judgment;
parte temporary orderextension,
of
except in cases where an
ex
f.
protection has been issued;
Rejoinder to reply;
g Motion to declare a party in
h. Any default; and
other pleading
any provision of the specifically disallowed under
Special ADR Rules.
The court shall motu
determined proprio order a
(Rule 1.6)
to be
dilatory in nature be pleading/motion that ithas
n
expunged from the re rds.
PARTI 35
Chapter Two- Special Rules of Court on Alternative Dispute Resolution
SITUATIONS WHEREIN NO
1.14 WHAT RULE WILL APPLY IN
UNDER THE SPECIAL ADR
SPECIFIC RULE IS PROVIDED
RULES?
rule is provided under the
In situations where no specific
resolve such matter summarily
Special ADR Rules, the court shall
36 THE ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION
AND THE ARBITRATION LAW
Court ofthe place where any of the petitioners or respondents has his
orincipal place of business or residence.
DISPUTE
ALTERNATIVE
THE LAW
40 AND THE
ARBITRATION
has no
resolve
jurisdiction to resolye the
t
arbitral tribunal
result of which the
dispute.
CONTENTS OF THE PETITION
REQUIRED
3.04 WHAT ARE THE
state the following:
The petition shall
The facts showing that the
person named as peti.
a. to s u e or be sued:
tioner or respondent has legal capacity
substance of the dispute between
b. The nature and
the parties;
circumstances relied upon h.
C. The grounds and the y
the petitioner; and
D. REFERRAL TO ADR
ceedings.
ARBITRATION
4.02 IS THE ORDER REFERRING THE DISPUTE TO
APPEAL
SUBJECT TO A MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION,
OR PETITION FOR CERTIORARN
arbitration shall be imme
No, an order referring the dispute to
to a motion for reconsidera-
diately executory and shall not be subject
tion, appeal or petition for certiorari.
AN ORDER DENYING
4.03 WHAT IS THE PROPER REMEDY TO
DISPUTE TO ARBITRATION?
THE REQUEST TO REFER THE
the dispute to arbitration
An order denying the request to refer
be the subject of a motion
shall not be subject to an appeal, but may
for certiorari.
for reconsideration and/or a petition
PROTECTION
E. INTERIM MEASURES OF
arbitration;
b. Preliminary attachment against property or garnish-
ment of funds in the custody of a bank or a third person;
C. Appointment ofa receiver;
d. Detention, preservation, delivery or inspection of
property; or
(c)where
(c) the evidence may be found.
J. CONFIDENTIALITYIPROTECTIVE ORDERS
O. REFERRAL TO CIAC
15.00 MAY THE COURT DISMISS A CONSTRUCTION
BEFORE IT? DISPUTE
A Regional Trial Court before which a construction
filed shall, upon becoming aware that the parties have dispute io
an arbitration
entered into
agreement, motu proprio or upon motion made not
later than the pre-trial, dismiss the case and refer the
arbitration to be conducted by the Construction
parties to
tion Commission (CIAC), unless all parties to
Industry Arbitra.
arbitration,
by their respective counsel, submit to the court a written assisted
making the court, rather than the CIAC, the body that wouldagreement
sively resolve the dispute. exclu.
Appeals to theCourtofAppeals
18.00 WHEN IS THE FILING OF APPEAL?
The petition for review shall be filed within 15 days from
notice of the decision of the Regional Trial Court or the denial of the
petitioner's motion for reconsideration.
PARTI 53
Chapter Two-Special Rules of Court on Alternative Dispute Resolution
DISPUTE
LAW
54 THE
A L T E R N A T I V E
A R B I T R A T I O N
AND THE
a domesti.
vacating
or correcting tic arbi
f. Confirming,
tral award;
proceedings to set
aside an ins
Suspending the
commercial arbitral award
and referring the case bad terna-
s to
onal
the arbitral tribunal;
to enforce a n international co
arbitral award;
enforce a foreign arbitral awa.
. Allowing a party to
pending appeal; and
party.
The following, while neither controlling nor fully measuring
the court's discretion, indicate the serious and compelling, and
necessarily, restrictive nature of the grounds that will warrant the
exercise of the Supreme Court's discretionary powers, when the
Court of Appeals:
a. Failed to apply the applicable standard or test for
judicial review prescribed in these Special ADR Rules in ari
ving at its decision resulting in substantial prejudice to the
aggrieved party;
b. Erred in upholding final order or decision despte
a
the lack of jurisdiction of the court that rendered such ina
order or decision;
C.Failed to apply any provision,
contained in these Special ADR Rules
principle, policy or ru
resulting in substanta
prejudice to the aggrieved party; and
d. Committed an error so
egregious and harmrul
party as toamount to an undeniable excess of jurisdicuio
PARTI 55
Chapter Two- Special Rules of Court on
Alternative Dispute Resolution
Chapter 1
GENERAL PROVISIONs
RULE 1-Policy and Application
1.00 WHAT IS THE PURPOSE OF THESE
RULES?
Article 1.1 provides that these Rules are
scribe the procedures and promulgated to pre.
ADR Act.
guidelines for the
implementation of the
1.01 WHAT IS THE DECLARED
POLICY OF THE STATE?2
It is the policy of the
State
(a) To promote party autonomy in the
resolution of dis
putes or the freedom of the parties to make their
own arrange
ments to resolve their
disputes;
(b) To encourage and
Alternative Dispute Resolutionactively promote
the use of
means to achieve
("ADR") as an important
speedy and impartial justice and declog cour
dockets;
(C)To provide means for the use
tool and an alternative
of ADR as an efficient
procedure for the resolution of app
priate cases; and
56
PARTI 57
Chapter Three- Implementing Rules and Regulations of the Alternative
Dispute Resolution Act of 2004
(d) To enlist active private sector participation in the
settlement of disputes through ADR. (Article 1.2)
1.02 WHAT ARE THE CASES WHEREIN THE ADR ACT DOES NOT
APPLY?
The provisions of the ADR Act shall not apply to the resolution
or settlement of the following:
AND THE
follows: deined a
A. Terms Applicable to All Chapters
1. ADR Provider
The institutions or persons accredited
6. Award
Any partial or final decision by an arbitrator in
resolving the issue or controversy.
7. Confidential Information
Any information, relative to the subject ofmedia-
tion or arbitration, expressly intended by the source
not to be disclosed, or obtained under circumstances
that would create reasonable expectation on behalf
of the source that the information shall not be dis-
closed. It shall include:
(a) communication, oral or written, made in a dis-
pute resolution proceeding, including any me
moranda, notes or work product of the neutral
party or non-party participant;
8. Counsel
A lawyer duly admitted to the practice of law in
the Philippines and in good standing who represents
a party in any ADR process.
9. Court
The Regional Trial Court except insofar as
otherwise defined under Model Law.
AND THE
ARBITRATI LAwLUTION
judicial power or the power to resol
the governmentr ot adiade
disputes involvingi
instrumentalities or private persons
.
agencea
11. Model Law
The Model on International Com
tration adopted by the United Natio mmercial
on International
Trade Law on 21 O omm
June 1985.
12. Proceedings
The judicial, administrative or othes
cative process, including related pre-he her
hearing motions, conferences and disco 0
very.
13. Record
The information written on a tangible.
or stored in an electronic or other similar
retrievable in a perceivable form. netiun
14. Roster
A list of persons
qualified to provide ADR
vices as neutrals or to serve as arbitrators,
2. Institutional Mediation
8. Mediator
A person who conducts mediation.
9. Non-Party Participant
A person, other than a party or
mediator, who
participates in a mediation proceeding as a witness,
resource person or expert.
1. Appointing Authority
As used in the Model Law shall mean the person
or institution named in the arbitration agreement as
arbitration
the appointing authority; or the regular
institution under whose rules the arbitration is
Where the parties have
agreed to be conducted. to institutional arbi
agreed to submit their disputehave
tration rules and unless they agreed to a diffe-
rent procedure, they shall be deemed to have agreed
such arbitration rules for the
to the procedure under
of arbitrators. In ad hoc
selection and appointment
arbitration, the default appointment of an arbitrator
DISPUTE RESOLI
THE
ALTERNATIVE
ARBITRATION LAW lON
62 AND THE
(under the
isher d
2. Arbitral
Tribunal
Model La
A sole arbitrator
or a panel of arhi, aw
nel of arbitrators
3. Arbitration
4.
a permanent
arbitration
Commercial Arbitration
institution
ministered
An arbitration that covers
matter
all relationships of a commercial nat
contractual or not. ionships of a
arising ton
nature include, but
commercial transactions:
are not limited
any trade
cOmmer ca
olowing
ansactdistr
the supply or exchange of goods or services;
tion agreements; construction of works.
representation or agency; factori
comm
leasing Consu.
ting; engineering; icensing;
banking; insurance; JOint venture and othem.
investment, financne
industrial or business cooperation; carria forms
of
or passengers by ar, sea rail or road. goms
5. Convention Award
A foreign arbitral award in a
Convention State
6. Convention State
A state that is a member of the New York Cn
vention.
7. Court
Under the Model Law, it means a
of the body or organ
judicial system of the Philippines (i.e., te
Regional Trial Court, Court of
Court). Appeals, and Supren
8.
International Arbitration
An Arbitration where
(a) the parties to ement
arbitration agreeothat
an
have, at the time of the conclusion
agreement, their places of business
different states; or
PARTI 63
Chapter Three- Implementing Rules and Regulations of the Alternatve
Dispute Resolution Act of 2004
(b) one of the following places is situated out-
side the Philippines in which the parties
have their places of business:
)the place of arbitration if determined
in, or pursuant to, the arbitration
agreement;
11) any place where a substantial part
of the obligations of the commercial
relationship is to be performed or the
place with the subject matter of the
dispute is most closely connected; or
(c) the parties have expressly agreed that the
Subject matter of the arbitration agree
ment relates to more than one country.
For this purpose:
(a) if a party has more than one place of busi-
ness, the place of business is that which
has the closest relationship to the arbitra-
tion agreement;
6) if a party does not have a place of business,
reference is to be made to his/her habitual
residence.
In the absence
of an agreement, tho
tration
President of the IBP
or his/her duly
authorizeNatie
sentative. repra,
Guidelines
3. Appointing Authority
The set of rules approved or adopted
appointing authority for the making of a Requeby
Appointment, Challenge, Termination of
of tthe
Man.
date of Arbitrator/s and for taking action thena
thereon.
4. Arbitration
A voluntary dispute resolution process in wh:
one or more arbitrators, appointed in accord which
with the agreement of the parties or these Rail ordante
resolve a dispute by rendering an award. ules
5.
5. Arbitral Tribunal
A sole arbitrator or a panel, board or committe
of arbitrators.
6.
6. Claimant
A person/s with a claim against another and
who commence/s arbitration against the latter.
7. Court
Unless otherwise specified in these Rules,
Regional Trial Court.
8. Day
A calendar day.
9. Domestic Arbitration
An arbitration that is not international
defined in Article 1(3) of the Model Law.
10. Institutional Arbitration
which
An arbitration administered
by an entity,
is registered as a domestic corporation with theSecu
PARTI
65
Chapter Three- Implementing Rules and Regulations of the Alternative
Dispute Resolution Act of 2004
12. Representative
person duly authorized in writing by a party
to a dispute, who could be a counsel, a person in his
her employ or any other person of his/her choice, duly
authorized to represent said party in the arbitration
proceedings.
13. Respondent
The person/s against whom the claimant com-
mence/s arbitration.
2. Mediation-Arbitration or Med-Arb
A two-step dispute resolution process involving
mediation and then followed by arbitration.
RESOLUTION
DISPUTE
ALTERNATIVE
LAW
66 THE ARBITRATION
AND THE
3. Mini-trial
dispute resolution
A structured
the merits of a
case are nethod
argued before
which
with apa
a
of senior
decision-makers,
pan
comprising
the of a neutral third person, ho
withou
(Articlewhi1.ch6
presence
negotiated settlement
theparties seek
a
Chapter 2
THE OFFICE FOR ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION
RULE 1-Office for Alternative Dispute Resolution (QAnp
DR
1.00 WHAT IS THE OFFICE FOR ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE R
LUTION? RESO
The OADR is an agency attached to the Department of .uos
It shall have a Secretariat and shall be headed by an ustios
Execu
Execut
Director, who shall be appointed by the President of the Philippine
taking into consideration the recommendation of the Secretaru
Justice. (Article 2.1) of
at least once
all meet
shall meet regulaty
regula
every two months, or upon call by the
(Article 2.6) Executive Direr
Chapter 3
MEDIATION
RULE 1 General Provisions
1.00 WHAT IS THE SCOPE OF
APPLICATION OF THE IMPLEMEM
TING RULES?
These Rules apply to voluntary mediation, whether ad hae a
institutional, other than court-annexed mediation and only in deiu
of an agreement of the
parties on the applicable rules
These Rules shall also befare
apply to allpending agred
cases
administrative or quasi-judicial
agency that are subsequenuy *
upon by the parties to be referred to
mediation. (Article
3.1)
PARTI 69
Chapter Three- Implementing Rules and
Dispute Resolution ActRegulations
of 2004
of the Alternative
1.01 WHAT IS THE STATE POLICY ON
MEDIATION?
In applying and
construing the
consideration must be given to the need toprovisions
of
these Rules,
and mediators through confidentiality of thepromote candor of parties
mediationresolution
policy of fostering prompt, economical and amicable process, the
of
disputes in accordance with principles of integrity of determination
by the parties and the policy that the
the mediation process rests with
decision-making authority in
the parties.
A party may petition a court before which an action is
turely brought in a matter which is the subject of a mediationprema-
ment, if at least one party so requests, not later than the agree-
conference or upon the request of both parties pre-trial
thereafter, refer the
to
parties to mediation in accordance with the agreement of the parties.
(Article 3.2)
RULE 2-Selection of a Mediator
2.00 DO PARTIES HAVE THE RIGHT TO SELECT A
MEDIATOR?
Yes, the parties have the freedom to select mediator. The
may request the OADR to provide them with a list or roster or the
parties
résumés of its certified mediators. The OADR
may be requested to
inform the mediator of his/her selection. (Article
3.3)
2.01 WHEN MAY A MEDIATOR BE REPLACED?
If the mediator selected is unable to act as such for
any reason,
the parties may, upon being informed of such
fact, select another
mediator. (Article 3.4)
(d) If continuation
of the process ould violate an
would v.
cal standards:
the rties would be
(e) Ifthe safety of any of
Ifthe mediator is
unable to provide e f jeopar
( ifective eri
of interest; and
(g) In c a s e of conflict
(h) f tho
In any of the following instances, if the mediat
satisfied that:
one or more
of the parties is/aro
) not
good faith:
the
accepted by parties, a
(c) serve only when his/her qualifications, tran
and
bleer
experience enable him/her to meet the reason
pectations of the parties and shall not hold himst
Chapter Three- PARTI 71
Implementing Rules and Regulations of the Alternatve
Dispute Resolution Act of 2004
herself out
not have.
or give the impression that he/she does
D I S P U T E
LAW
A L T E R N A T IA
VERBITRATION
72 THE
AND
THE
available
option
the he
caucuses,
natives to
the
issues,
non-settlement,
whatever
and that
choices
each
specific
regarding party,
believes that a
understand,.
mediator to
Ifa counsel, is unable
represented by mediation
oceedings
proceedinpe
the
participate,
fully either:
mediator may
reason, a
mediation proceed:
of the
i) limit the scope th
with the party's ab
consistent
that th
that the pan
manner
a recommend
and/or
participate, assistance in ordo
obtain appropriate
or
process;
tinue with the
F. Charging of Fees
With respect to charging of fees:
disclose and explain to the
(a) A mediator shall fully
parties the basis of cost, fees and charges.
The mediator who withdraws from the mediation
(b) shall return to the parties any unearned fee and un-
used deposit.
AND THE
EL IN
OF A COUNSEL
4.01 ENUMERATE
PROCEEDING.
THE ROLES
76 HE
THE AND THE ARBITRATION LAW
ALTERNATIVE
of the mediator;
() opening statement
i) individual narration by the parties;
(1i) exchange by the parties;
iv) summary of issues;
A R B I T R A T I O N
LAW
AND THE
profession.
PARTI 79
Chapter Three Implementing Rules and Regulations of the Alternative
Dispute Resolution Act of 2004
(e) The protections of the ADR Act shall continue to
apply even if a mediator is found to have failed to act impartially.
commercial arbitra-
to international
(a) This Chapter applies between the Philippines and
in force
tion, subject to any agreement
other state or states.
or seat of arbitration
only if the place
(b) This Chapter applies
default of any agreement
of the parties on
1s the Philippines and in
only
COrding to r
arbitration
submitted to acco.
arbitration or may be
VIsions other than those of
the ADR Act. (Article 4.1)
reter
least one party so requests of both parties thereafter,
arbitration
the parties to arbitration unless it finds that the
agreement is null and void, inoperative or incapable of being
performed.
CEEDINGS?
with an arbitration agreement for a
determination,
the number of
Failing such
three (3). (Article 4.10)
DISPUTE RESOLUTION
ALTERNATIVE
86 THE ARBITRATION
LAW
AND THE
ARE APPOINTED.
13.01 EXPLAIN HOW ARBITRATORS
are governed by the f
The appointment of
procedure:
arbitrators
be produced by reason oe
lowng
(a) No person shall an arbitrator, unle isher
nationality from acting
as nless otherwis
agreed by the parties.
b)The parties are free to agree on a
procedure ne
pointing the arbitrator or arbitrators, subject
to provision
paragraphs (d)
and of this Article.
(e)
(c) Failing such agreement:
with three arbitratoro
) inan arbitration each
party shall appoint arbitrator, and the
one
within days
lenge an arbitrator shall, tribunal or after becoming
arbitral
of the constitution of the
of
aware of any
circumstances referred to in paragraph (b)
send a written statement
Article 4.12 (Grounds for Challenge,)
to the arbitral tribunal. Unless
of the r e a s o n s for the challenge
THE ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION
88
AND THE ARBITRATION LAW
iv)
(1v) Interim or provisional relief is
requested by write
application transmitted by reasonable means to the
arbitral tribunal and the party
Is sought,
against whomh the
describing in appropriate detalls
precise relief, the party against whom the
requested, the ground for the relief, and the evidene
supporting the request.
(v) The order granting or denying an applicato forthe
interim relief shall be binding upon the paru
tes.
assistance
(V1) Either party may apply with the court for
assure s u r e
in
implementing or
enforcing an interD
ordered by an arbitral tribunal.
PARTI 91
Chapter 1Three- Implementing Rules and
Dispute Resolution ActRegulations of the Alternative
of 2004
(vii) A party who does not comply with the order shall be
liable for all damages,
resulting from noncompliance
including all expenses, and reasonable attorney's
fees, paid in obtaining the order's
ment. (Article 4.17)
judicial enforce
3.
3. On Venue of Arbitration.
free to agree on place of arbitra-
the
(a) The parties are
the place of arbitration
tion. Failing such agreement,
Manila unless the arbitral tribu-
shall be in Metro
to the circumstances of the case,
nal, having regard
92 THE ALTERNATIVE
RESOLUTIONT
DISPUTE
ARBITRATION LAW
AND THE
of the partian
including the
convenience
s. shall de
on a different place of arbitration.
THE
ALTERNATIVE
ARBITRATION
LAW
96 AND THE
state that it is an
shall
an award has the
tents of Award),
andsame status and effect ard
any
case. (Article 4.30)
award on the merits of the
Contents of Award.
14. On Form and
be made in writing and
The award shall shall e
(a)
the arbitrator
or arbitrators. Tn Snal
arbitrator, arbitrl
signed by than one
more
proceedings with the
naturesof the majority of
all members of the
a
se
suffice, provided that the
tribunal shall reason f
stated.
omitted signature is
any
b) The award shall state the reasons upon which
ment of the
part
in obtaining
final a
dispute;
(11) The parties agree the termination of nepro
ceedings;
(11) The arbitral
tion of the tribunal finds that the reas0
become proceedings has for any
other
unnecessary or impossible
PARTI 97
Chapter Three - I m p l e m e n t i n g Rules a n d Regulations of t h e A l t e r n a t i v e
nature;
(i) A party may, if so agreed by the parties and
with notice to the other party, request the arbi-
tral tribunal to give an interpretation of a spe-
cific point or part of the award.
(b) If the arbitral tribunal considers the request to be jus-
award as to claims
make an
additional
of
a
cou
aforeign country, shall be recognized and enforcea a
RECOGNITION
GROUNDS FOR REFUSING
16.01 WHAT ARE THE
OR ENFORCEMENT OF
CONVENTION AWARD AND NON
CONVENTION AWARD?
enforcement are as
grounds for refusing recognition
or
The
follows:
With Respect to Convention Award.
A.
of an arbitral award,
Recognition or enforcement
the New York Conven-
made in a state, which is a party to
of the party against
tion, may be refused, at the request furnishes to the
whom it is provoked, only if the party
Regional Trial Court proof that:
arbitration agreement are, under
(a) The parties to the
under some incapacity;
the law applicable to them,
or the said agreement
is not valid under the law to
which the parties have subjected it or; failing any
indication thereon, under the law of the country
or the
Provided, however, That the court in which the action
order to prevent or prohibit
appeal is pending may issue a protective
disclosure of documents or information containing secret processes,
information where it is shown
developments, research and other
an authorized
that the applicant shall be materially prejudiced by
disclosure thereof. (Article 4.41)
RECoGNITION AND ENFORCEMENT OF
16.12 IS A PETITION FOR
NATURE?
AWARDS SUMMARY IN
and enforcement of awards
Yes, a petition for recognition and dealt with summarily in
be heard
brought before the court shall
ADR Rules. (Article 4.42)
accordance with the Special
reasonable; and
autho-
of the appointing
(v1) Any fees and expenses
rity.
be reasonable
(b)
b) The fees of the arbitral tribunal shall
the com-
in amount, taking into account the amount in dispute,
arbitrators
the time spent by the
plexity of the subject matter, the case.
circumstances of
and any other relevant
by the
If an appointing authority has been agreed upon
schedule of fees for
parties and if such authority has issued a
all be appointe
as
provided above.
Tf all the claimants or
all the
respondents cannot decide among
homselves on an arbitrator, the appointment shall be made for them
by the appointing authority. (Article 5.10, par. j)
The appointing authority may adopt guidelines for the making
ofa Request for AppOintment. (Article 5.10, par. k)
Except as otherwise provided in the guidelines of the appoint-
ing authority, if any, a Request for Appointment shall include, as
applicable, the following:
) the demand for arbitration;
offthe
t
withdrawal from
revocation of his mandate office for any other reason or becausee
by
other case of termination of his/heragreement of the parties or in any
mandate, a substitute arbitrator
shall be appointed according to the rules
being replaced. (Article 5.14) applicable to the arbitrator
RULE 4-Jurisdiction of Arbitral Tribunal
20.00 WHAT ARE THE GROUNDS FOR
JURISDICTION OF THE ARBITRAL TRIBUNAL?OBJECTION OVER THE
(a) When a demand for arbitration made a
pute is objected to by the adverse party, the by party to a dis-
arbitral tribunal shal1,
in the first instance, resolve the objection when made on
any of the
following grounds:
the arbitration agreement is in existent, void, unen-
forceable or not binding upon a person for any rea-
son, including the fact that the adverse party is not
privy to said agreement;
(i) the dispute is not arbitrable or is outside the scope of
the arbitration agreement, or
ii) the dispute is under the original and exclusive juris
diction of a court or quasi-judicial body. (Article 5.15
par. a)
(b)If a party raises any of the grounds for objection, the same
shall not preclude the appointment of the arbitrator/s as such issue
is for the arbitral tribunal to decide.
The participation of a party in the selection and appointment of
an arbitrator and the filing of appropriate pleadings before the arbi
tral tribunal to question its jurisdiction shall not be construed as a
waiver of
Submission to the jurisdiction of the arbitral tribunal or of a
his/her/its right to assert such grounds to challenge the jurisdiction
award.
of the arbitral tribunal or the validity of the resulting
in the arbitration may invoke any such
(c) The respondent
court the existence, validity, or en-
grounds to question before the
the invoke the
agreement, or propriety of the arbi-
orceability of the arbitration
of the arbitrator and pendency
tration, the jurisdiction
or
of the arbitration proceeding.
of such action as ground for suspension circumstances of the case,
to the
The arbitraltribunal, having regard of the dispute,
the need for the early and expeditious settlement
and raised to question its jurisdic-
n light of the facts and arguments
the a r b i t r a t i o n until the court has
decide either to suspend
1on, may continue with arbitration.
made a decision on the issue or
124 THE ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION
AND THE ARBITRATION LAW
C. On Place of Arbitration
The parties are free to agree on the place of a
(a) tion. Failing such agreement, the place of arbita
shall be in Metro Manila unless the arbitral
nal, having regard to the circumstances of th u
including the convenience of the parties, shall acase
on a different place of arbitration. ecide
(b) The arbitral tribunal may, unless otherwise agr
by the parties, meet at any place it considers ann agreed
priate for consultation among its members, forappro-
hea
ear.
ing witnesses, experts or the parties, or for inspecti
of goods, other property or documents. (Article 5 1
9)
d. On Commencement of Arbitral Proceedings
hearing.
(h) Only parties, their respective representativesi rbi-
Witnesses and the administrative staff of the ar
fthe
tral tribunal shall have the to be
parties, upon
right present
being informed o f t h e presence or
pose
obligation;
(cc) To produce or preserve evidence;
or
act omi-
(dd) To compel any other appropriate
or
SSions.
ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE
RESOLUTION
134 THE
LAW
AND THE ARBITRATION
(vii) A party who does not comply with the order shall he
liable for all damages, resulting from noncompliange
including all expenses, and reasonably attorneys
fees, paid in obtaining the order's judicial enforo
ment.
(d) The arbitral tribunal shall have the power at any time
before rendering the award, without prejudice to the rights of any
party to petition the court to take measures to safeguard and/or con-
serve any matter which is the subject of the dispute in arbitration.
to the disna.
arbitral tribunal or party
(b) The
rested in enforcing a n order
a
) confidentiatolitythe
Protective orders with respect to confidens
AWARD
21.14 WHAT MAY THE PARTIES DO WHEN A PETITION TO
OR SET ASIDE AN AWARD IS FILED?
Where a petition to vacate or set aside an award is filed, the pe-
titioner may simultaneously, or the oppositor may in the alternative,
the arbitral tribunal for the
petition the court to remand the same to
revised final and definite award or to
purpose of making a new or
arbitral tribunal, the
direct a new hearing before the same or new
manner originally provided
members of which shall be chosen in the
submission. In the latter case, any
in the arbitration agreement or
the
(a) The fees of the arbitrators shall be agreed upon by
to the arbitration.
parties and the arbitrator/s in writing prior
the parties as to the amount
In default of agreement of
arbitrator's fees, the arbitrator's fees
and manner of payment of
with the applicable internal
shall be determined in accordance
institution under whose rules the
rules of the regular arbitration
the schedule
arbitration is conducted; or in ad hoc arbitration,
RESOLUTION
THE ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE
146 ARBITRATION LAW
AND THE
ings
iv) The travel and other expenses of witnesses to
the
the extent such expenses are provided by
arbitral tribunal;
for legal representation and asis
(v)The costs were
tance of the successful party if such costs
claimed during the arbitral proceedings, an
tribunal
only to the extent that the arbitral l
determines that the amount of such costs
reasonable;
(vi) Any fees and expenses of the apponting au
thority.
ble
(d) The fees of the arbitral tribunal shall be reasona
com
in amount, taking into account the amount in dispute, the C
tors
and
With respect to the costs of legal representation
assistance referred to in paragraph (c) (i) of this Article,
account the circums-
the arbitral tribunal, taking into
tances of the case, shall be free to determine which party
such costs between
shall bear such costs or may apportion
that appointment is reason-
the parties if it determines
able.
issues an order for the
When the arbitral tribunal
or makes an
termination of the arbitral proceedings
shall fix the costs of arbitration
award on agreed terms, it
of this Article in the context of
referred to in paragraph (a)
that order or award.
148 THE ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION
AND THE ARBITRATION LAWW
After the award has been made, the arbitral tribunal shall
render an accounting to the parties of the deposits received and
return any unexpended balance to the parties. (Article 5.46)
Chapter 6
ARBITRATION OF CONSTRUCTION DISPUTES
23.00 WHAT AGENCY GOVERNS ARBITRATION OF CONSTRUC
TION DISPUTES?
The Construction Industry Arbitration Commission (CIAU%
which has original and exclusive jurisdiction over arbitrationo o
struction disputes pursuant to Executive Order No. 1008, s. 1o
otherwise known as the "Construction Industry Arbitration La erm
third person. If a
neutral third person
is agreed neutral
chosen, he/she shall preside
over the mini-trial pon
and e
to appoint one or more (but e
parties may agree
number per party)
senior executive/s,
on its behalf to si
members.
as mini-trial panel
executive/s
seniormust
The
(d) members
chosen to sit
be duly authorized to negotiate
as
mini-trial pane
mini-trial
settle
the dispute with the other party.
The appointment ofa min
shall be communicated to the of
trial panel member/s ther
shall constitute a representati
party. This appointment
mini-trial panel member/s ha
ation
to the other party that the hasl
have the authority to enter
into a settlement agreemer
without any further action or
binding upon the principal
ratification by the latter.
ments.
7.7)
RULE 4- Mediation-Arbitration
9700 WHAT ARE THE RULES ON MEDIATION-ARBITRATION?
The rules are as follows:
(a) A Mediation-Arbitration shall be governed by the
rules and procedure agreed upon by the parties. In the absence
of said agreement, Chapter 5 on Mediation shall first apply and
thereafter, Chapter 5 on Domestic Arbitration.
(b) No person shall having been engage and hav1ng
acted as mediator of a dispute between the parties, following a
failed mediation, act as arbitrator of the same dispute, unless
the parties, in a written agreement, expressly authorize the
mediator to hear and decide the case as an arbitrator.
AND FEES?
28.00 WHAT ARE THE RULES ON COSTS
the rules costs and fees:
The following are on
C.
If the dispute is not settled, the Board shall intervene upon
initiative and
request of either or both parties or at its own
The
immediately call the parties to conciliation meetings.
Board shall have the power to issue subpoenas requiring
It shall be
the attendance of the parties to such meetings.
and promptly in
the duty of the parties to participate fully
Board may call;
the conciliation meetings the
in the Board, the par-
d. During the conciliation proceedingsact which
may disrupt
ties a r e prohibited from doing any and
settlement of the disputes;
or impede the early
ami-
all efforts to settle disputes
e. The Board shall exert their case to a
and encourage
the parties to submit
cably Section RA. No.
20,
voluntary arbitrator. (As amended by
6715, March 21, 1989)
155
156 THE ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION
AND THE ARBITRATION LAW
Agreement.
OR
1.05 CAN INJUNCTION BE ISSUED IN ANY CASE INVOLVING
GROWING OUT OF LABOR DISPUTES UNDER ARTICLE 254
OF THE LABOR CODE?
No temporary or permanent injunction or restraining order in
out of labor disputes shall be issued
any case involving or growing
by any court or other entity, except as otherwise provided in Articles
218 and 264 of this Code. (As amended by B.P. Blg. 227, June1, 1982)
-End of Part I-