Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Art. 48. Complex Crimes: Lecture Notes #4
Art. 48. Complex Crimes: Lecture Notes #4
LECTURE NOTES #4
by: Atty. Sed A. Cabangon
Before we discuss complex crime, let us take up the principle of pro reo.
It means “when in doubt, rule for the accused”. But intertwined with this
rule is the “rule of lenity”. It is a doctrine that a court in construing ambiguous
criminal statute that sets out multiple or consistent punishment should resolve
the ambiguity in favor of the more lenient punishment.” (People v. Temporada,
G.R. No. 173473)
In Art. 48, there are multiple crimes, or plurality of crimes when the
accused commits several crimes with specific penalties, but the law --- applying
the doctrine of pro reo or leniency of penalty --- imposes only one penalty “for
most serious crimes”.
1
In short, complex crime is only ONE CRIME because the perpetrator who
commits 2 crimes with a single criminal impulse demonstrates lesser perversity
than different acts with different criminal purposes. (See People v. Hernandez,
99 Phil. 815, p. 690 Reyes)
The underlying philosophy of complex crimes in the RPC --- which follows
the pro reo doctrine --- is intended to favor the accused by imposing a single
penalty irrespective of the crimes committed. The rationale being, that the
accused committed 2 crimes with a single criminal impulse demonstrates lesser
perversity than when the crimes are committed by different acts and several
criminal resolutions. (People vs. Comadre, G.R. No. 153559, June 8, 2004)
2
a) Compound Crime – a single act constitutes 2 or more grave o less
grave offenses. Example, throwing of a hand grenade resulting in
several crimes.
2. Special Complex Crimes – these are 2 crimes but which the RPC
penalizes as ONE crime.
Example:
◦ Robbery with homicide under Art. 294, RPC
◦ Kidnapping with murder, Art. 267, RPC
◦ Rape with homicide.
- END -