Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Hemophagocytic Syndrome Associated With Hematological Neoplasias
Hemophagocytic Syndrome Associated With Hematological Neoplasias
Hemophagocytic Syndrome Associated With Hematological Neoplasias
Abstract
Hemophagocytic syndrome (HPS) is a reactive process that complicates several diseases including hematological neoplasias
(HN). It has been suggested that HPS may be a negative prognosis factor for neoplastic diseases. In this retrospective analysis,
13 cases with HPS associated to HN were compared with two age, sex, diagnosis, disease stage and treatment matched controls
in order to determine the impact of this syndrome on the survival. Cases with HPS were adult patients with a male:female ratio
of 1:1 and their clinical picture was characterized by fever, lymphadenopathy, hepatosplenomegaly, and pancytopenia. Median
survival since HN diagnosis was 7 and 48 months for the HPS and control groups, respectively (P= 0.0001). In ten patients who
died, median survival after HPS presentation was 1 month. These results suggest that the presence of HPS is a negative prognosis
factor in patients with HN. Due to its high mortality rate, an individualized, early, and intensive chemotherapeutic regimen may
be required for HN complicated with this syndrome. © 1998 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
antibodies, disseminated intravascular coagulation or viral infections: cytomegalovirus (CMV), Epstein Barr
hypogammaglobulinemia [9 – 11]. The clinical course virus (EBV, IgG anti-EBV nuclear antigen, and/or IgM
depends on the resolution of the primary disease. In anti-EBV viral capside antigen), herpes virus (HV),
those patients who survive the acute phase of HPS, hepatitis A and the hepatitis B surface antigen
improvement begins within 8 weeks, and relapses have (HBsAg).
not been documented [9,10]. Sometimes, however, the The histopathological classification of the cases was
evolution of patients with this disorder is worse, result- made based on the International Working Formulation
ing in highly variable mortality rate during the acute for lymphoma, the FAB Classification for acute and
phase[9]. chronic leukemia, and the Rye Conference Classifica-
Based upon a classification of histiocytic abnormali- tion for Hodgkin’s disease.
ties [12], secondary HPS is considered an entity associ- Follow-up since HPS diagnosis was evaluated in
ated either to infectious process [13 – 17], autoimmune terms of time to last visit and survival status. For those
disease [18], drugs [19], congenital or acquired im- patients who died, the cause of death was recorded; for
munodeficiency [20], myelodysplastic syndrome [21], or those who were alive, bone marrow aspirates were
neoplastic illness, including hematological neoplasias re-reviewed for hemophagocytosis. Furthermore, we
(HN). Based on clinical observations, it has been pro- performed a histological review of the biopsies available
posed that HPS could represent a worse prognosis from each patient in order to confirm the original
factor for patients with neoplasia, however, there is no hematologic diagnosis and the presence of hemophago-
evidence about its true prognostic value in oncological cytosis. To undertake survival comparisons, two pa-
diseases. tients with HN but without HPS (controls) were
The aim of this study was to analyze the clinical, matched to each HPS case by age at HN diagnosis, sex,
histological, and laboratory characteristics of HPS as- HN diagnosis, clinical stage and phase of the disease,
sociated to HN and to determine the impact of this and treatment. If treatment was not the same, controls
syndrome on the clinical outcome of the patients. with a treatment of similar effectiveness were chosen.
Results were summarized in terms of medians and
ranges. To analyze the differences between the groups
2. Patients and methods we used a X 2-test and a Two-Sample Wilcoxon Rank-
Sum test. Based on HN evolution time, Kaplan-Meier
The clinical records of 1836 patients with HN (acute survival curves were plotted and differences between
and chronic leukemia, lymphoma, Hodgkin’s disease, the curves were analyzed by means of the log-rank test.
and multiple myeloma) seen in the last 20 years at our We performed a Cox regression analysis in order to
hospital were reviewed. We included those patients with determine which variables affected the survival. Differ-
hemophagocytosis of one, two or three cell lines by ences were statistically significant when PB 0.05.
mature histiocytes in the presence of a normocellular or
hypercellular bone marrow, and who fulfilled the crite-
ria for the primary hemophagocytic syndromes [7]: 3. Results
fever ] 38.5°C for 7 or more days, splenomegaly,
bicytopenia or pancytopenia (HbB10g/dl, platelet We found 29 cases with hemophagocytosis in the
count (PC)B100× 109/l, neutrophils (PMNs)B1× bone marrow during the last 15 years of the study
109/l), and low fibrinogen (Fg) level. At the time of period, but only 13 fulfilled the criteria for HPS. The
HPS diagnosis the following data were recorded, age, general characteristics and evolution of the group with
sex, presence of other illnesses (including infectious HPS are summarized in Table 1. All were adult subjects
diseases), constitutional symptoms, hepatomegaly, and with a median age of 56 years and a male:female ratio
lymphadenopathy as well as, diagnosis, stage, phase of 1:1. Duration of symptoms before admission was few
(first treatment or relapse), treatment and follow-up of days to 4 weeks, and none of them responded to broad
the HN. Also, we recorded the results of liver enzymes spectrum antibiotics although three patients had evi-
(alkaline phosphatase (AP) and lactic dehydrogenase dence of bacterial disease at the time of HPS presenta-
(LDH)), white blood cell counts (WBC), coagulation tion (positive blood cultures for P. aeruginosa, E. coli,
assays (partial thromboplastin time (PTT) and S. pneumoniae). Clinical and laboratory data of the
prothrombin time (PT)), Coomb’s test, antinuclear anti- entire group are shown in Table 2. Seven patients had
bodies, and the hystopathological findings in the bone a Coomb’s test but it was positive in only one patient.
marrow, spleen, liver, and lymph nodes. Finally, in Antinuclear antibodies tests were performed in five
order to determine the presence of simultaneous infec- patients and were negative in all of them. Serological
tious diseases as the cause of HPS, we recorded the tests for viral infections were performed in 11 patients,
available data about nasopharyngeal, blood, and urine and in four the screening was completely negative. A
cultures as well as the results from serological tests for total of three patients had a positive anti-EBV IgG test
A. Majluf-Cruz et al. / Leukemia Research 22 (1998) 893–898 895
Table 1
General characteristics and evolution of patients with hemophagocytic syndrome
1 30 M HDNS III-B 2 1 HN
2 56 F HDMC II-A 6 1 Sepsis
3 79 M LCL II-B 1 1 HN
4 73 F LCL II-B 5 1 PT
5 48 M HDMC IV-B 3 3 HN
6 68 F HDNS III-A 6 1 HN
7 83 F SNCL II-B 4 1 HN
8 83 M CLL I 20 24
9 53 F HDMC IV-B 12 12
10 39 M HDMC II-B 6 2 Sepsis
11 18 M HDLC III-B 1 56
12 56 F CLL III 2 1 HN
13 44 M HDMC IV-B 8 2 HN
a
at the initial diagnosis of HN or at relapse, according to the staging systems described in Section 2.
b
since HN diagnosis to HPS presentation.
c
After HPS presentation
PT, pulmonary thrombosis; HDNS, Hodgkin’s disease. nodular sclerosis; HDMC, mixed cellularity; LCL, large cell lymphoma; CLL, chronic
lymphocytic leukemia; SNCL, small non-cleaved cell lymphoma; HDLD, lymphocyte depletion.
(cases 3, 8, and 13). One patient (case 4), was HV+ , matched. Among the eight HPS cases with Hodgkin’s
another one was CMV + (case 1), and 2 were HB- disease, seven received MOPP (Nitrogen mustard, vin-
sAg + (cases 2 and 10). cristine, procarbazine, and prednisone) and one re-
None case with HPS was diagnosed as having MH ceived ChlVPP (Chlorambucil, vinblastine,
and all were associated with active HN. In cases 3 and procarbazine and prednisone). Patients with lymphoma
11, HPS was found simultaneously with the HN while received CHOP (Cyclophosphamide, doxorubicin, vin-
cases 9 and 13 had relapsed after an initial remission of cristine, and prednisone), and those with chronic
the HN. The remaining patients were under their first lymphocytic leukemia received chlorambucil (0.25 mg/
treatment for the HN when HPS appeared. For each kg per day per 4 days) and prednisone (60 mg/m2 per
case, the histopathological review confirmed the initial day per 4 days) each 4 weeks. One control patient with
HN diagnosis. The immunophenotypic characterization Hodgkin’s disease was treated with ChlVPP while his
of lymphomas showed a B-cell lymphoma in patients 3 HPS counterpart received MOPP while two other con-
and 7 and a T-cell phenotype in case 4. Case 8, a trol patients with lymphoma received CHOP-
chronic lymphocytic leukemia, also had a B-cell pheno- Bleomycin. All chemotherapeutic regimens were
type as the flow cytometry analysis demonstrated. Bone administered at currently accepted doses.
marrow aspirates showed hypercellularity in nine cases Fig. 1, shows the survival curves for both cases and
and normal cellularity in four. Essentially, all cell lines controls. Median survival was 7 and 48 months for the
were well conserved without evidence of dyspoietic HPS and control groups, respectively (P= 0.0001). Be-
changes. Hemophagocytosis in the bone marrow biop- side the presence of HPS, only the differences in Hb,
sies was found in only eight cases and it was present in which were almost different between cases and controls
lymph node and/or spleen biopsies in only seven cases. (P= 0.06), significantly affected the survival for both
A total of three patients had a long-term survival groups (P= 0.015).
(cases 8, 9 and 11). They achieved a complete remission
of the HN without subsequent evidence of hemophago-
cytosis in the bone marrow, lymph nodes and/or spleen. 4. Discussion
Both HPS and control groups were comparable in
terms of age at HN diagnosis, sex, HN diagnosis, Histiocyte abnormalities encompass a broad scope of
clinical stage, and phase of the disease. However, cases clinical syndromes, from benign (spontaneous remis-
and their respective controls were significantly different sion) to lethal [22]. Hemophagocytosis is a reactive
in terms of WBC (P = 0.004), PC (P= 0.0002), AP histiocytic abnormality not always associated with full-
(P =0.0007) and presence of hepatomegaly (P = 0.001). blown HPS. In this review, only 45% of cases with
A total of 23 non-HPS controls received the same HN hemophagocytosis developed HPS. Hemophagocytosis
treatment as the HPS cases to whom they were is likely due to cytokines produced in excess by neo-
896 A. Majluf-Cruz et al. / Leukemia Research 22 (1998) 893–898
Table 2
Clinical and laboratory data at diagnosis of HPS
n F/LN H/S Hb/PC (g/d, ×109/l) WBC/PMNs (×109/l) PT/PTT (s) LDH/AP (IU) Coomb’s test Fg (mg/dl)
F, fever; LN, lymph node enlargement; H, hepatomegaly; S, splenomegaly; ND, not done; IU, international units.
plastic T-cells (T-cell lymphomas), or immunologically ing with previous studies reporting mostly pediatric
dysregulated T-cells (VAHS or HPS) [23 – 26]. In the populations. Therefore, our frequency of HN-related
last two entities, cytotoxic T-cells may be activated to HPS may be under-estimated. HPS diagnosis was com-
combat infected or neoplastic cells producing histio- pleted with the expected clinical and laboraratory ab-
cyte-activating cytokines [9,27]. Then, a cascade of bio- normalities. Thrombocytopenia was a common finding
logical and pathological events may be triggered likely worsened by a coagulopathy supported by abnor-
resulting in full-blown HPS [28 – 30]. Therefore, it seems mal Fg levels and coagulation tests. The high AP and
that, depending upon its presence and intensity, LDH levels support liver impairment.
hemophagocytosis could have a role in determining the We consider that our patients had a secondary HPS
clinical presentation of the primary disease; from clini- because of the benign morphological findings of the
cally silent events to fulminant evolutions. macrophages (low nucleus:cytoplasm ratio, absence of
We used the criteria of the Histiocyte Society in nucleoli, abundant cytoplasm, relatively condensed nu-
order to diagnose HPS [7]. Although these guidelines clear chromatin, and active hemophagocytosis) [9,32],
were designed for the primary HPS, they are applied to and the evidence of HN. For a long time, MH was
clinical settings with a similar picture (secondary HPS). classified as a distinct clinical entity, however, today is
Our cases had an aggressive picture characterized by considered as a manifestation of the broad spectrum of
fast evolution, fever, and great malaise resembling pa- the HPS, an uncontrolled hemophagocytic phe-
tients previously reported with HPS early in the course nomenon leading to a clinical over-expression of the
of HN [25,31]. Because our hospital is an adult-care HPS. Reassessment of cases initially diagnosed as hav-
facility, the patients were middle-age or older contrast- ing MH has revealed that most of them were indeed
lymphoid neoplasms of T-cell lineage or HPS [31,33].
Moreover, T-cell lymphoma with hemophagocytosis
mimicking MH is difficult to distinguish from benign
HPS clinically and pathologically [33], a fact leading to
propose that previous HPS reports may include cases of
unrecognized T-cell lymphoma. Although challenged by
the ubiquitous nature of EBV, a strong relation among
EBV infection, HPS, and T-cell lymphomas has been
found [30]. In T-cell lymphomas, it seems that EBV
permits an uncontrolled production and release of cy-
tokines by neoplastic T-cells or inflammatory cells al-
lowing the HPS, a phenomenon similar to that
observed in EBV-associated Hodgkin’s disease [34]. The
role of EBV in HPS associated with T-cell lymphomas
is unquestionable, however, HPS complicating other
Fig. 1. Kaplan – Meier survival curves of patients with hematological
neoplasias has been reported without evidence of simul-
neoplasia and hemophagocytic syndrome (HPS) and controls (non- taneous infection [35–39]. Although we can not discard
HPS). any contribution of EBV, our results suggest that this
A. Majluf-Cruz et al. / Leukemia Research 22 (1998) 893–898 897
[22] Komp DM, Perry MC. Introduction: the histiocytic syndromes. [32] Udden MM, Bañez E, Sears DA. Bone marrow histiocytic
Semin Oncol 1981;18:1. hyperplasia and hemophagocytosis with pancytopenia in typhoid
[23] James LP, Peterson V, Schumacher HR. Abnormalities of bone fever. Am J Med Sci 1986;291:396.
marrow simulating histiocytic medullary reticulosis in a patient [33] Su J, Hsu YH, Lin MT, Cheng AL, Wang CH, Weiss LM.
with gastric carcinoma. Am J Clin Pathol 1971;71:600. Epstein-Barr Virus-containing T-cell lymphoma presents with
[24] Linn YC, Tien SL, Lim LC, Lee LH, Teoh G, Goh YT, Tan P. hemophagocytic syndrome mimicking malignant histiocytosis.
Haemophagocytosis in bone marrow aspirate—a review of the Cancer 1993;72:2019.
clinical course of 10 cases. Acta Haematol. 1995;94:182. [34] Pallesen G, Hamilton-Dutoit SJ, Rowe M, Young LS. Expres-
[25] Falini B, Pireli S, DeSolas I, Martelli MF, Mason DY, Delsol G, sion of Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) latent gene products in tumor
Gatter KC, Fagioli M. Peripheral T-cell lymphoma associated cells of Hodgkin’s disease. Lancet 1991;337:320.
with hemophagocytic syndrome. Blood 1990;75:434. [35] Okuda T, Sakamoto S, Deguchi T, Misawa S, Kashina K,
[26] Jaffe ES, Costa J, Fauci AS, Cossman J, Tsokos M. Malignant Yoshihara T, Ikushima S, Hibi S, Imashaku S. Hemophagocytic
syndrome associated with aggressive natural killer cell leukemia.
lymphoma and erythrophagocytosis simulating malignant histio-
Am J Hematol 1991;38:321.
cytosis. Am J Med 1983;75:741.
[36] Falini B, Bucciarelli E, Grignani F, Martelli MF. Erythrophago-
[27] Chen JR, Su IJ, Lin KH, Lee SH, Lin DT, Chuu WM, Lin KS,
cytosis by undifferentiated lung carcinoma cells. Cancer
Huang LM, Lee CY. Fulminant chilhood hemophagocytic syn-
1980;46:1140.
drome mimicking histiocytic medullary reticulosis: an atypical
[37] Wakefield JJ, Hicks RM. Erythrophagocytosis by the epithelial
form of Epstein-Barr virus infection. Am J Clin Pathol
cells of the bladder. J Cell Sci 1974;15:555.
1991;96:171.
[38] Marı́n-Padilla M. Erythrophagocytosis by epithelial cells of a
[28] Mroezek EC, Weisenburger DD, Grierson HI, Markin R, Pur- breast carcinoma. Cancer 1977;39:1085.
tilo DT. Fatal infectious mononucleosis and virus associated [39] Foadi MD, Slater AM, Pegrum GD. Erytrophagocytosis by
hemophagocytic syndrome. Arch Pathol Lab Med 1987;111:530. acute lymphoblastic leukemia cells. Scand J Haematol
[29] Craig FE, Clare CN, Sklar JL, Banks PM. T-cell lymphoma and 1978;20:85.
the virus-associated hemophagocytic syndrome. Am J Clin [40] Rai KR, Sawitsky A, Cronkite EP, Chanana AD, Levy RN,
Pathol 1992;97:189. Pasternak BS. Clinical staging of chronic lymphocytic leukemia.
[30] Wilson ER, Malluh A, Stagno S, Crist WM. Fatal Epstein-Barr Blood 1975;46:219.
virus-associated hemophagocytic syndrome. J Pediatr [41] Sonneveld P, Lom KV, Klunne MK, Prins MEF, Abels J.
1981;98:260. Clinicopathological diagnosis and treatment of malignant hystio-
[31] Wilson MS, Weiss LM, Gatter KC, Mason DY, Dorfman RF, cytosis. Br J Haematol 1990;75:511.
Warnke RA. Malignant histiocytosis: a reassessment of cases [42] Tseng A, Coleman CN, Coox RS, Colby TV, Turner RR,
previously reported in 1975 based on paraffin section im- Horning SJ, Rosenberg SA. The treatment of malignant histiocy-
munophenotyping studies. Cancer 1990;66:530. tosis. Blood 1984;64:48.
.
.