Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Digital Marketing Strategies For Firms in Post COVID-19 Era: Insights and Future Directions
Digital Marketing Strategies For Firms in Post COVID-19 Era: Insights and Future Directions
net/publication/348417568
Digital Marketing Strategies for Firms in Post COVID-19 Era: Insights and
Future Directions
CITATIONS READS
0 1,033
1 author:
Neeraj Pandey
NITIE-National Institute of Industrial Engineering
75 PUBLICATIONS 276 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
A Study on Internet Usage Patterns of General Physicians and Specialists for Devising Internet Based Pharmaceutical Promotions View project
Implementation of Universal Healthcare System in India: Issues, Approaches and Challenges View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Neeraj Pandey on 11 February 2021.
Neeraj Pandey1
Abstract: The COVID-19 has been the worst pandemic in human history in
terms of size and scope of global spread, casualties, economic impact, and
negative effect on public health. The COVID-19 crisis has also impacted
the approach of implementation of integrated marketing communication
(IMC) and its related spend in businesses. Digital marketing, as a part of
IMC, has received more attention and spend during this crisis. Most of the
customers have moved online and are spending more time on the internet.
The customer is at the center of all marketing activities. The digital marketing
strategies adopted by organizations for connecting with customers has
also changed in this pandemic. This study focused on digital marketing
practices during the post-COVID-19 period of five companies using an
abductive case study analysis approach. It analyzed their digital marketing
strategies, growth drivers, the shift in approach, challenges, and strategies
used to manage the crisis by these organizations. The findings from the
primary data using semi-structured interviews from executives working in
the industry highlighted the importance of safety-related communication,
creative persuasive communication, paid media, adaptability, and support
from top management as key aspects in managing crisis by organizations.
The learning from the academic and managerial perspective besides future
directions for managing the pandemic crisis have also been proposed in
the study.
Introduction
COVID-19 crisis had an impact on every aspect of business irrespective
of size and kind of ownership. The majority of organizations have been
struggling to survive and grow during the pandemic crisis. The organizations
like Pizza Hut, Gold Gym, JCrew retail chain, Hertz car rental company,
and Aldo shoe firm filed for bankruptcy during the coronavirus pandemic.
However, the companies with a strong digital platform like Zoom, Amazon,
Uber Eats, and Slack acquired many new customers and had a healthy growth
rate while the majority of the firms struggled for revenue and retaining
customers. Firms like Mahindra Tractors were able to achieve sales growth
in rural markets using digital marketing (www.business-standard.com).
Various researchers (Donthu & Gustafsson, 2020; Hwang, Nageswaran
& Cho, 2020; Habes et al., 2020) have emphasized that embracing digital is
one of the efficient ways of managing this pandemic. Many of the hospital
and physicians around the world have adopted telemedicine for attending
patients during the pandemic. The number of video-based physician
consultations for COVID-19 patients hadconsistently increased since the
start of the pandemic (Greenhalgh et al., 2020). The customers were spending
more and more time on digital channels like Facebook, Instagram, Zoom,
and WhatsApp during the COVID-19 lockdown duration (He & Harris,
2020). Therefore, the use of digital marketing to reach out to customers
became important for organizations.
The use of digital marketing communications has steadily increased
in the B2B industry also since the last decade (Pandey, Nayal & Rathore,
2020). However, understanding the domain of digital marketing and how
other organizations – both B2B and B2C, are using it strategically to build a
brand and market its product and services would be critical for building its
own digital marketing strategy.
Literature Review
The COVID-19 pandemic has forced many conservative firms to go online
(Hwang, Nageswaran & Cho, 2020). The retailers are turning to omni-channel
to reach out to customers. The sellers who had an omni-channel distribution
network were quick to adapt to the government-imposed lockdown situation
whereas retailers having no or less presence in online channels took time
to build or ramp it up (Hwang, Nageswaran & Cho, 2020). The COVID-19
crisis also witnessed the phenomenon of competition. In this phenomenon,
the competing firms were also sharing information with each other, and
displayed cooperation between the firms. The examples include sharing
of technical knowledge in the manufacturing of products, joint efforts to
develop a vaccine, and sharing stock level information during the pandemic
(Crick & Crick, 2020).
The organizations used digital marketing based on analytics to reach out
to the target customer as direct channel options have reduced or were not
functional due to the COVID-19 pandemic. The use of augmented reality,
virtual reality, and artificial intelligence (AI) is also being used to target
customers. The use of channels like WhatsApp, Zoom, and Google Meet
Digital Marketing Strategies for Firms in Post COVID-19 Era: Insights and Future Directions | 109
increased multi-fold during the COVID-19 crisis (He & Harris, 2020; Donthu
& Gustafsson, 2020). Hence, digital marketing is excessively being used by
organizations to target customers including high-involvement products like
real estate, automobiles, and servers.
Amazon is using augmented intelligence which emphasizes using
the optimal use of human inputs and machine learning applications in
its predictions and customer-based processes (https://aws.amazon.com/
augmented-ai/). Amazon calls this service Amazon A2I. It uses an AI-
based chatbot and automated website curation based on the customer
search history on the portal. The automated digital advertisements are
delivered to customers based on search words and browsing history.
Techniques like text mining and image analytics also help digital marketers
in enhancing their precision in reaching out to the target customers during
the pandemic.
Many organizations used social media campaigns as part of corporate
social responsibility to make citizens aware of social distance and mask
to bring attitudinal change in citizens (Habes et al., 2020). The iconic
Nike brand which advocated playing outside with advertisements like
“Move more move better” has recently changed the advertisement tagline
and emphasized playing indoors, rather than venturing outside. The
advertisement by Nike became an instant hit on social media. The brands
required creativity to be used in more agile ways to create a timely impact
during the pandemic (Balis, 2020). Mende and Mishra (2020) compared the
enormity of COVID-19 situation implications with global climate change.
There was found a need to develop dynamic capability in organizations to
respond to such crises by realigning systems for product re-development,
developing new strategic alliances, and taking initiatives for value-creating
activities during pandemic (Seetharaman, 2020).
Methodology
The study used two methodologies for exploring the finding and drawing
conclusions from the case study and semi-structured interviews. Firstly,
the study used the abduction method of case study analysis (Dubois
& Gadde, 2002). The abductive case study analysis was based on the
inference philosophy given by Charles S. Pierce (Timmermans & Tavory,
2012). This approach sequentially built inferences from case studies and
allowed variation based on in-case patterns (Tavory & Timmermans, 2014).
Secondly, a long interview using McCracken’s (1998) method was used for
interviewing the executives working in the industry.
110 | The New Normal
Asian Paints
The paint is a non-essential item. The months of April and May 2020
were tough months for Asian Paints. The organization got positive media
mentions due to its announcement of salary increments for its employees
and payment of dues to its contractors. The Asian paints started a creative
digital campaign named “Beautiful Homes Your Way” where it provided
customized home paint solutions to the customers. It used paid, owned, and
earned social media to promote the campaign. The campaign started as a
paid media campaign and later was seeded with its own and earned media
campaign. However, there was no use of any influencers in the campaign.
The July month saw double-digit growth due to the digital marketing
campaign (Malviya, 2020).
Asian Paints started a ‘Safe Painting Service’ two-part digital marketing
campaign. The campaign highlighted the contactless safe painting protocol.
The digital campaign explained emotionally how Asian Paints had trained
the painters regarding safety, well-being, and customized painting services.
Along similar lines, Asian Paints also launched “Do it Yourself” and “Above
the Line” digital marketing campaigns in the post- lockdown that resulted
in positive sales.
Ceat Tyres
The top management of Ceat Tyres, an RPG group company, used bold
digital marketing strategies to connect with customers during the pandemic.
It chose new digital channels to reach out to the customers during COVID-19
besides connecting with its dealers. The Ceat Tyre management gave the
dealer full incentive in April 2020 based on the historical sales data as the
March sales were quite low due to the outbreak of the pandemic in that
month and subsequent complete lockdown by the Indian government. This
boosted the dealer network morale and loyalty towards the organization.
Later, Ceat Tyres tied up with Amazon to use its portal for selling tyres
directly to the customers. It provided free contactless installation of tyres
Digital Marketing Strategies for Firms in Post COVID-19 Era: Insights and Future Directions | 111
at the customer’s doorstep (Express Drives Desk, 2020). The Ceat Tyres
ran a digital marketing campaign to popularize it. This was a significant
shift in two ways – one was selling tyres directly to customers as
traditionally it was done the dealer network; and secondly, it gave Ceat
Tyres direct touch with customers and data about customer preferences
and buying patterns. The online B2C sales on Amazon went from 2 percent
to approximately 14 percent which was happening the first time in the
organization.
Ceat Tyres invested heavily in upgrading its own B2B e-commercial
portal so that it was the best in the industry. The entire organizational setup
moved online quickly after the pandemic outbreak which reflects the agility
of the organization. For example – the permanent journey plan of the sales
employees was submitted and monitored online. It also started new revenue
streams by starting the GoSafe range of products. These included branded
masks and personal protective equipment (PTI, 2020). Ceat Tyres kept an
eye on the business environment during the pandemic and was able to get
new orders after many Chinese tyre players exited the Indian market. In
May 2020, it partnered with Ogilvy India to launch a social media campaign
regarding its support and gratitude to truck drivers carrying essential
commodities (Tewari, 2020). It created high goodwill for Ceat Tyre due to
the high visibility of the campaign on social media besides positive mentions
in the popular press.
in the USA and India had therefore banned its services (Steinhoff &
Palmatier, 2020).
Mahindra Tractors
Mahindra Tractors was able to clear its inventory in post-COVID by using
digital marketing with a focus on rural and smaller towns. There have
been large migration from urban areas to rural areas during the COVID-19
pandemic. Most of them had adequate purchasing power as they had spent
considerable time working in urban areas. A part of such a population
was planning to stay back for a year or more and undertake farming in a
more organized manner. Mahindra Tractors targeted this population using
digital marketing. The majority of the population in rural areas in India
access the internet on their mobile. The good Kharif crop backed by a
digital campaign targeted at rural masses led to growth in sales of Mahindra
Tractors to the tune of 69% year-on-year basis in August 2020 (Jaiswal,
2020).
Mahindra Tractors used paid media including search and display
advertisements to reach out to the target customers. This was in addition
to the owned media where it advertised on its social media handles. It was
able to attract media buzz of its social media campaigns, thereby providing
it earned media advantage also. Mahindra Tractors also gave promotional
offers for discounts and financing options to prospective customers. The
campaigns with promotional offers nudged the target customers who
were thinking about buying tractors. Swaraj Tractors, which is part of the
Mahindra and Mahindra group, has also created a Facebook community page
for farmers as a part of their overall digital strategy. (www.socialsamosa.
com/2020). This helped in building emotional connect with the farming
community besides boosting sales of tractors.
Uber Eats
Uber Eats is a food delivery app company. Uber Eats, based in California,
used digital marketing practices to reach out to small businesses during the
COVID-19 pandemic. The pandemic led to a sort of customers going on
strike. The small restaurants relied heavily on day-to-day cash flow coming
from dining customers. They, unlike large restaurant chains, did not have
deep pockets to weather the pandemic storm. The small restaurants explored
alternate channels to deliver the food. A large number of small restaurants
joined the Uber Eats platform during the pandemic (Raj, Sundararajan
& You, 2020). Uber Eats used data-driven online campaigns to attract
Digital Marketing Strategies for Firms in Post COVID-19 Era: Insights and Future Directions | 113
Semi-structured Interviews
The employees working in the above organizations were approached for
a semi-structured interview. A total of fourteen semi-structured long
interviews were conducted. The respondents were from the marketing
functional area and had an average experience of eleven years in the industry.
The central research question was “How their organization was managing
the digital marketing strategy during the COVID-19 pandemic situation”.
There were leading general questions followed by below four specific
questions:
• RQ1: How were your sales affected during the pandemic?
• RQ2: What was the marketing strategy of your organization during the
pandemic?
• RQ3: What digital marketing strategy your firm is adopting to handle
the crisis and promote sales?
• RQ4: What according to you is the best coping mechanism, from a
marketing perspective, to handle this crisis?
The responses varied, however common themes emerged out regarding
how organizations were handling the COVID-19 pandemic, from a
marketing context (Table 1). It was found that it is more about the leadership
role (style) and the agility of the organization to adapt to the new normal
that is making a difference in the organization. The sample responses and
emerged theme has been identified below:
114 | The New Normal
Grouping of
S. Key Words (S.
Quote by Respondents Key Words Theme
No. No. Source in
Bracket)
6. Agility is key to success in the Agility, faster, change (3),
pandemic. The faster one gets digital mode, brands (4),
to digital mode with respect processes pertinent (4),
to processes and customer Content (5, 17),
interface, would be the winner. emotional bond
7. My take is that the campaign Paid media, (5), connect (5),
starts with paid media and earned media, digital mode (6),
ends with earned media. The sustained earned media
desired results are quick with engagement, (7), sustained
paid advertisements. However, owned media, engagement
if one wants a sustained shared media, (7), owned
engagement, we also need to working from media (7),
be owned and shared media home shared media
to support it. Interestingly, the (7), humour
consumers have more time (9), informative
for the internet as he or she (4, 9), utility
is working from home due to (9), consumer
COVID-19. engagement (9),
brainstormed
8. The banner advertisement Banner (14), brand
using Google Adwords has advertisement, message (17)
worked quite well for my Google
organization. It is quite cost- Adwords, cost,
effective, given the click click conversion
conversion we have got during
the pandemic.
9. The advertisement should humour, Digital Paid
have humour or be informative informative, communication Media
or have some utility to utility, consumer (4, 13), visibility
consumers, then only it engagement (4), engagement
will have high consumer (4, 13), cyber
engagement. fraud (4), a
10. We were able to pull off Top management chatbot (4),
well in time due to the top support, paid media (7,
management support. We freedom, 13, 15), banner
were given full freedom to transform, faster advertisement
transform into a digital system. decision making, (8), Google
It led to faster decision making experiment AdWords (8,
and gave space to experiment. 16), cost (8),
click conversion
11. Analytics is an important Analytics, (8), digital
part of our digital strategy. digital strategy, strategy (11, 15),
It provides insights into my insights, insights (11),
e-commerce sales funnel. e-commerce e-commerce
It helped to navigate and sales funnel, sales funnel
optimize our marketing budget marketing (11), marketing
allocation for search and budget, search, budget (11),
display based advertisement in display based search (11),
this pandemic. advertisement display based
116 | The New Normal
Grouping of
S. Key Words (S.
Quote by Respondents Key Words Theme
No. No. Source in
Bracket)
advertisement
(11, 16), unique
visitors (16)
12. Ours is a customer-driven Customer-driven Initiatives Adapt-
organization. We are adapting organization, (1), agility ability
and changing to align with the adapting, (6), faster (6),
new normal. changing, align processes (6),
with the new transform (10),
normal analytics (11),
13. We started the digital Digital customer-driven
communication on social communication, organization
media as a paid. We saw high paid, user (12), adapting
user engagement in terms of engagement (12), changing
likes, shares, and comments. (12), align with
Maybe COVID-forced WFH the new normal
(work from home) is helping (12)
individuals spend more time
on the internet.
14. We brainstormed and thought Brainstormed,
out of the box. The top top management
management involvement kept involvement,
us motivated to work closely motivated
with agencies. All the digital
campaigns that we ran were
highly successful.
15. Leadership style is very Leadership style,Top management Support
important in such challenging connecting, support (10), by Top
situations. Connecting with digital strategy,freedom (10), Manage-
employees, channel partners paid media faster decision ment
and customer is much more making (10),
important than digital strategy. experiment (10),
No doubt, we focused strongly top management
on paid media to reach out to involvement
the customers in a big way. (14), motivated
16. I have found Google AdWord Google AdWord, (14), leadership
and Facebook display Facebook style (15),
advertisements effective in display connecting (15)
getting unique visitors. advertisement,
unique visitors
17. In each digital campaign, Digital
we highlighted the safety campaign, safety
aspects – both for employees aspects, message
and customers. The message content, brand
content was more important. message
The brand message came
in the latter part of the
advertisement content.
Digital Marketing Strategies for Firms in Post COVID-19 Era: Insights and Future Directions | 117
Perceived Safety
The digital communication during the pandemic from the organizations had a
safety message in it. This was done to make the customers aware of COVID-19
related safety guidelines besides showing that the organization was sensitive
to these issues not only for customers but also for the employees and other
stakeholders. This helped organizations win the trust of the customers. The
“safety” was the topmost concern for customers while ordering online or
visiting retail stores. The organization’s digital communication strategy
must have this element. This boosted customer confidence in the brand. For
Example – one of the most successful advertisements of Asian Paints “Har
Ghar Kucch Kehta Hai” (literal translation – every home communicates
a message) had “stay home, stay safe” as a central theme. The entire
advertisement had focused on safety and celebrating being at home, and the
brand appears only in the last 4 seconds in a 60-second commercial.
The perceived safety provided confidence to the customers to visit
the store and order products online. The digital communication to the
customers shared the standard operating procedures (SOPs) being followed
at the physical store and warehouses of the organization. The keyword
like safety, priority, protocols, stay home, social distancing, and care; in
digital marketing communication to the customers will help in retaining old
customers and attracting new customers. The safety message in social media
also helped in getting earned media as employees, customers, regulators,
and other individuals share this message in their respective social media
handles.
likes, shares, and comments. For example – Uber Eats launched a creative
banner advertisement as “Your go-to restaurant in the comfort of your
home”. The banner advertisement had moving visuals of local cuisine as per
the location of the user (www.thinkwithgoogle.com). This advertisement
became an instant hit and garnered a lot of views, likes, shares, and mentions
on social media. Many of the existing Uber subscribers engaged with the
advertisement.
The content, which is logical, emotive, and authentic will qualify as
persuasive content. The team-lead of the digital marketing strategy must
ensure that the advertisement content qualifies on these criteria. The
advertisements with creative persuasive communication help in bringing
attitudinal change in consumers. During the COVID-19 pandemic,
organizations like Asian Paints, Ceat Tyres, Uber Eats, etc. released various
digital content to motivate citizens to maintain social distancing, wear
a mask, and sanitize their hands after touching public open surfaces like
ATM and biometric screens. The consistency of such messages had helped
in bringing attitudinal and behavioral changes among the masses. Similarly,
the “hand washing campaign” by the Dettol brand using creative persuasive
communication had resulted in the desired results of behavioral change
towards hygiene. The digital marketing team must brainstorm to come up
with content, which is persuasive, authentic, and must have an emotional
appeal for getting sustained customer engagement with the brand.
Paid Media
The majority of the respondents felt that managing the promotion budget
between different advertisement channels is a tight rope walk. The search
advertisement has its own advantage of precise reach with higher click-
through-rates (CTR[1]) but inhibits higher investment in this channel due to
its comparatively higher cost. However, all the respondents agreed that the
paid media was giving them the best and faster results. The campaigns started
with the paid media which was supported by the owned and shared media of
the organization and the partner advertisement agency. The pandemic saw
the highest spike in investment in paid media as the organization was under
revenue pressure to get assured CTR results. The reliance on the owned and
earned media had reduced during the COVID-19 period. The organizations
were not willing to take chance or experiment as there was already enough
business environment uncertainty due to the ongoing pandemic situation.
The paid media during the pandemic was dominated by Google search
and Facebook display advertisements in the organization. The respondents
CTR is number of the clicks divided by number of impressions. It is one of the
[1]
Adaptability
The analysis of the case study and semi-structured interviews with marketing
executives consistently highlighted that adaptability of organizations was
the key to emerge as a winner from this pandemic crisis. The organizations
which were agile to adapt to digital mode and built-in system and processes
quickly as the pandemic started have started showing positive financial
results from the third quarter of the year 2020. The adaptability was not
only in terms of putting digital infrastructure in place in the organization but
also change in the employee mindset and organizational culture for being
productive in a digital business environment. The adaptability in the current
pandemic situation was also forced on organizations as it was sudden and
prolonged with no precedence in size and scope.
The analysis also showed that the speed of adaptability was of critical
importance. Organizations like Zoom Video Communications, Inc., Asian
Paints, and Mahindra Tractors were achieving a better financial result in the
post-pandemic situation because of the early changes these organizations
made as the pandemic started. Zoom brought many policies and feature
changes to its platform as the pandemic started. It is the fastest-growing
video communication platform which is also reflected in the growing share
prices of the company. The adaptive approach backed by digitization and
robotics technology infusion in manufacturing and warehouses is the new
normal during the pandemic. However, it would require resource allocation
by the respective organizations besides the top management support.
References
Balis, J. (2020). Brand marketing through the coronavirus crisis. Harvard Business
Review.
Buil-Gil, D., Miró-Llinares, F., Moneva, A., Kemp, S., & Díaz-Castaño, N. (2020).
Cybercrime and shifts in opportunities during COVID-19: a preliminary
analysis in the UK. European Societies, 1-13.
Crick, J. M., & Crick, D. (2020). Coopetition and COVID-19: Collaborative
business-to-business marketing strategies in a pandemic crisis. Industrial
Marketing Management. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.indmarman.2020.05.016
Digital Marketing Strategies for Firms in Post COVID-19 Era: Insights and Future Directions | 123
Pandey, N., Nayal, P., & Rathore, A. S. (2020). Digital marketing for B2B
organizations: structured literature review and future research directions.
Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing. https://doi.org/10.1108/JBIM-06-
2019-0283
Pereira, M. (2020), Zoom’s Rise to Fame and Challenges During COVID-19:
Lessons for Marketers, accessed on August 21, 2020. https://www.toolbox.com/
marketing/marketing-strategy/articles/zooms-rise-to-fame-and-challenges-during-
COVID-19-lessons-for-marketers/
PTI (2020), COVID-19 update: CEAT Tyres makes foray into PPE segment, launches
S95 mask, accessed on August 14, 2020. https://www.business-standard.com/
article/companies/COVID-19-update-ceat-tyres-makes-foray-into-ppe-segment-
launches-s95-mask-120070600678_1.html
Raj, M., Sundararajan, A., & You, C. (2020). COVID-19 and Digital Resilience:
Evidence from Uber Eats. arXiv preprint arXiv:2006.07204.
Savage, M. (2002). Business continuity planning. Work study, 51(5), 254-261.
Seetharaman, P. (2020). Business models shifts: Impact of COVID-19. International
Journal of Information Management, 54, 102-173.
Scudellari M. (2020). How the pandemic might play out in 2021 and beyond. Nature,
584 (7819), 22–25. https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-020-02278-5
Sloan, M. (2020), The 3 Secrets Behind Zoom’s Triple-Digit Growth, accessed on
August 21, 2020, https://www.drift.com/blog/how-zoom-grew/
Steinhoff, L., & Palmatier, R. W. (2020). Commentary: Opportunities and challenges
of technology in relationship marketing. Australasian Marketing Journal
(AMJ). https:/10.1016/j.ausmj.2020.07.003
Tavory, I., & Timmermans, S. (2014). Abductive analysis: Theorizing qualitative
research. University of Chicago Press.
Teece, D. J., Pisano, G., & Shuen, A. (1997). Dynamic capabilities and strategic
management. Strategic management journal, 18(7), 509-533.
Tewari, S. (2020), Ceat Tyres campaign salutes truck drivers for supplying essentials
amid lockdown, accessed on August 14, 2020. https://www.livemint.com/
industry/advertising/ceat-tryes-campaign-salutes-truck-drivers-for-supplying-
essentials-amid-lockdown-11588486343463.html
Timmermans, S., & Tavory, I. (2012). Theory construction in qualitative research:
From grounded theory to abductive analysis. Sociological theory, 30(3), 167-
186.