Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ElectricityRetailWheelingHandbookSecondEditionByJohnM Studebaker
ElectricityRetailWheelingHandbookSecondEditionByJohnM Studebaker
com
Electricity
Retail Wheeling
Handbook
Second Edition
www.engbookspdf.com
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
www.engbookspdf.com
Electricity
Handbook
John M. Studebaker
Published by
THE INC.
700 Indian Trail
Lilburn, GA 30047
www.engbookspdf.com
Studebaker,
Eleclnclty retad wheeling handbook/ byJohn M. St~debaker.-2~.
HD9685.US
S794
2000 333.7793’24~21 00-031698
700
GA 30047
of
l 0 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
to
NJ 07458
(UK)
of
Toronto
of New
of
www.engbookspdf.com
Dedication
www.engbookspdf.com
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
www.engbookspdf.com
Acknowledgments xi
Introduction x111
Index 281
vii
www.engbookspdf.com
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
www.engbookspdf.com
This publication is divided into four basic sections: Section 1, Un-
derstanding Electric Utility Basics (Chapters 1-3); Section 2, Electricity
Retail Wheeling-The Processes Involved (Chapters 4-6); Section 3,
Electricity Retail Wheeling in Action (Chapter 7); and Section Appen-
dices A-E, important background data to assist in reducing electric
utility costs.
www.engbookspdf.com
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
www.engbookspdf.com
I wish to express my thanks to the many individuals whose infor-
mation, insight and comments have assisted in making this publication
possible.
Every effort has been made to provide dependable and accurate
information. However, changes occur almost on daily basis due to the
very active environment that encompasses electricity retail wheeling.
This publication will address the issues they currently exist
well provide insight for the future so that the electricity purchaser can
be assured that their electricity costs remain competitive regardless of
what the future brings.
www.engbookspdf.com
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
www.engbookspdf.com
Introduction
www.engbookspdf.com
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
www.engbookspdf.com
Understanding
Electric UtiLiv Basics
www.engbookspdf.com
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
www.engbookspdf.com
Many changes have occurred in the electric utility industry since
the last edition (1995) of this publication. Deregulation of the electricity
industry has progressed on rather ununified state-by-state basis in the
last 5 years. Since deregulation of electricity at this time is entirely
state-by-state procedure, there sometimes seems to be no rationale for
particular state‘s position on deregulation. If the current pace of deregu-
lation is maintained, it could conceivably be many years before some
states will ever allow their electricity users the opportunity of choice in
electricity commodity providers.
Electric utilities must become market responsive if they want to
remain viable in their industries. Failure to do so may subject them to
federally mandated regulatory imposition of retail wheeling of electric-
ity. The long-term outlook for electrical power alternatives is good and
for many companies the savings realized through these various alterna-
tives will be great. To be able to understand how changes occur in elec-
tric utilities, knowledge of what they are and how they regulated
must be available.
Probably one the most discussed, least understood area in elec-
tricity today is retail wheeling. This is the process whereby the customer
purchases the generation portion of their electricity usage from sup-
plier other than their own serving utility. This procedure, from the
customer’s viewpoint, is very similar to customer transportation natu-
ral where the customer purchases the actual natural commodity
themselves and through the services of marketer utilizes the serving
utility only to transport the natural to the point-of-use.
While this process works well in natural and causes no real
supply or cost problems, the same is not true for electric utilities where
www.engbookspdf.com
retail wheeling of electricity takes place. The reason for this is that most
natural utilities do not actually have the natural they sell, but
purchase their system supplies on the open market. In electricity, the
serving utility may generate all or at least portion of the electricity they
sell the customer. When customer elects not to use the serving utility’s
generated the utility’s generation utilization is reduced, theo-
retically at least, causing increased incremental costs to occur for the
utility.
In electricity utility service, the commodity being sold generally is
produced, at least partially, by the utility that serves the customer. In this
case, if the customer obtains their electricity from source other than the
local serving electric company (retail wheeling,) the electric utility suffers
real loss-potentially not having sale for the electricity being pro-
duced. Retail wheeling can have very real impact on the existence of
electric utility. How the origination points of the commodity (electricity/
natural vary are shown on Figure 1.1.
Figure 1.1shows that while electric utility usually generates its
commodity (electricity), natural utility usually purchases its com-
modity (natural While this difference may seem to be of no particu-
lar concern to the customer, it is of great importance to electric utility.
Since the electric utility generates its commodity, it relies, at least in part,
upon its retail customers to purchase the electricity it generates. If cus-
tomers have the choice to not purchase the generated electricity, the util-
ity has to find other customers or reduce its generation output, which
affects its overall system efficiency.
Another electric utility worry is customer self/cogeneration of elec-
tricity. In this scenario, the customer installs generation system that
provides both electrical well thermal (heat) outputs to supplement
and reduce dependence upon utility supplied electricity. Although co-
generation is not new process, its use has become more common
utility-supplied electricity has become more costly. Many electricity cus-
tomers currently, or in the near future, will have options to typical util-
ity-supplied electricity. The question an electricity user will have to an-
swer will be-which method of electricity purchasing is most reliable
and cost effective?
answer this question, it is important to know what is available
and how tomost effectively utilize the best options. This publication will
provide information needed by customer to utilize the least expensive
electricity available while assuring that supply integrity is maintained.
www.engbookspdf.com
NATURALGAS
Interstate Interstate
Transmission Grid Transportation
Intrastate
Distribution Grid
1
Meter Meter
www.engbookspdf.com
User
www.engbookspdf.com
REGULATION IN GENERAL
INTERSTATE REGULATION
(Between States)
www.engbookspdf.com
For-Profit. Municipal, Rural Cooperative Electric Utilities
INTERSTATE
I
FERC
I
INTRASTATE
(Indmdual
INTRASTATE
www.engbookspdf.com
Washington DC 20426
Telephone 202-208-2356
202-208-2320
http://www.ferc.fed.us
Establishes and enforces rates and charges for electric energy trans-
mission and sales for resale. (Very important to retail wheeling of
electricity.)
Establishes and enforces rates and charges for distribution and sale
of natural
www.engbookspdf.com
04-24-96) can be obtained fromFERC. Of particular interest in this ruling
are the following excerpted provisions.
1. Introduction/Summary
On April 24, 1996 the Commission issues three final, interrelated
rules designed to remove impediments to competition in the wholesale
bulk power marketplace and to bring more efficient, lower cost power to
electricity consumers. 1 n h e legal and policy cornerstone of
these rules is to remedy undue discriminationin access to the monopoly
owned transmission wires that control whether and to whom electricity
can be transported in interstate commerce. A second critical aspect of
the rules is to address recovery of the transition costs of moving from a
monopoly-regulated regime to one in which all sellers can compete on a
fair basis and in which electricity is more competitively priced.
In the years since the proposed rules were issued, 2/the pace of
competitive changes in the electric utility industry has accelerated. Cur-
rently the majority of electric public utilities have filed wholesale open
access transmission tariffs with the Commission. Prodded by such com-
petitive changes and encouraged by the proposed rules, the majority of
public utilities that own, control, or operate 3/transmission facilities used
in interstate commerce have filed some form of wholesale open access
tariff. In addition, since the time the proposed rules were issued, numer-
ous state regulatory commissions have adopted or are actively evaluat-
ing retail customer choice programs or other utility restructuring alterna-
tives. These events have been spurred by continuing pressures in the
marketplace for changes in the way electricity is bought, sold and trans-
ported. Increasingly, customers are demanding the benefits of competi-
tion (retail wheeling) in the growing electricity commodity market.
The Commission estimates the potential quantitative benefits from
the Final Rule will be approximately $3.8 to $5.4 billion per year of cost
savings, in addition to thenon-quantifiablebenefits that includebetter
use of existing assets and institutions, new market mechanisms, techni-
calinnovation,andlessratedistortion.Thecontinuingcompetitive
changes in the industry and the prospect of these benefits to customers
make it imperative that this Commission take the necessary steps within
its jurisdiction to ensure that all wholesale buyers and sellers of electric
energy can obtain non-discriminatory transmissionaccess, that the tran-
sition to competition is orderly and fair, and that the integrity and reliabil-
www.engbookspdf.com
ity of our electricity infrastructure is maintained.
In this Rule, the Commission seeks to remedy both existing and
future undue discrimination in the industry and realize thesignificant
customer benefits that will come with open access. Indeed, it is the
statutory obligation under sections 205 and 206 of the
Federal Power Act (FPA) to remedy undue discrimination. To do so, the
Commission must eliminate the remaining patchwork of closed and open
jurisdictional transmission systems and ensure that all these systems,
including those that already provide some form of open access, cannot
use monopoly power over transmission to unduly discriminate against
others. If the Commission does not take this step now, the result will be
benefits to some customers at the expense of others. The Commission
has learned from its experience in the natural gas area the importance
of addressing competitive transition issues early and with as much cer-
tainty to market participants as possible.
Accordingly, in this proceeding and in the accompanying proceed-
ing on OASIS, the Commission, pursuant to its authorities under sections
205 and 206 of the FPA:
requires all public utilities that own, control or operate facilities used
for transmitting electric energy in interstate commerce;
www.engbookspdf.com
Open
The Final Rule requires public utilities to file a single open access
tariff thatoffersnetwork,load-basedserviceandpoint-to-point,con-
tract-basedservice.TheRulecontainsaproforma tariff that reflects
modifications to the proposedtermsandconditions and also
permits variations for regional practices. All public utilities subject to the
Rule,includingthosethatalreadyhave tariffs on file, will berequired
to make section 206 compliance filings to meet the new pro forma tariff
non-priceminimumtermsandconditions of non-discriminatorytrans-
mission. Utilities may propose their own rates in a section 205 compli-
ance filing.
The rule provides that public utilities may seek a waiver of some
or all of therequirements of theFinalRule. In addition,non-public
utilities may seek a waiver of thetariff reciprocity provisions.
The Final Rule does not generically abrogate existing requirement
contracts, but will permitcustomersandpublic utilities to seekmodifi-
cation,ortermination, of certainexistingrequirementscontractsona
case-by-case basis. As to coordination arrangements and contracts, the
Rulefindsthatthesearrangementsandcontracts may need to be
modified to removeundulydiscriminatorytransmissionaccessand/or
pricingprovisions.Sucharrangementsandagreementsincludepower
poolagreements,public utility holdingcompanyagreements,andcer-
tain bilateral coordination agreements. The Rule provides guidance and
timelines for modifying unduly discriminatory coordination arrangements
and contracts, and specifies when the members of such arrangements
mustbegin to conducttrade with eachotherusingthesameopen
access tariff offered to others. The Rule also provides guidance regard-
ingtheformation of independentsystemoperators (ISOs).
The Rule does not require any form of corporate restructuring, but
will accommodatevoluntaryrestructuringthat is consistentwiththe
policies.
As discussed in the NOPR, not all owners or controllers of inter-
state transmission facilities are subject to jurisdiction
under sections 205 and 206 of the FPA and therefore are not subject
to
retains the proposed reciprocity provision in the pro forma tariff. Without
such a provision, non-open access utilities could take advantage of the
competitive opportunities of open access, while at the same time offer-
ing inferior access, or no access at all, over their own facilities. Thus,
www.engbookspdf.com
openaccess utilities would be unfairly burdened. We notethatsome
non-jurisdictional utilities have expressedan interest in amechanism
for obtaining a Commission determination that their transmission tariffs
satisfy the reciprocity provisions in the pro forma tariffs, and we provide
suchamechanism in theRule.
The Final Rule does not generically provide for market-based gen-
eration rates. prior deci-
sion that there is no generation dominance in new generating capacity,
intervenors in cases may raise generation dominance issues related to
new capacity. In addition, to obtain market-based rates for existing gen-
eration, public utilities will continue to be required to show, on a case-
by-case basis, that there is no generation dominance in existing capac-
ity.Further, in all market-based rate cases,theCommission will con-
tinue to look at whether an applicant and its affiliates could erect other
barriers to entryand whethertheremay beproblemsdue to affiliate
abuseorreciprocaldealing.
Finally, contemporaneously with this Rule the Commission issues
a NOPR on capacity reservation tariffs as an alternative, and perhaps
superior,means of remedying undue discrimination.
3. Transmission/Local Distribution
The Rule clarifies of the Federal/
state jurisdictional boundaries over transmissionand local distribution.
While the Commission continues to reaffirm their conclusion that they
have exclusive jurisdiction over the rates, terms, and conditions of un-
bundled retail transmission in interstatecommerce by public utilities,
they nevertheless recognize the very legitimate concerns of state regu-
latory authorities as they contemplate direct retail access or other state
restructuringprograms. Accordingly, theCommissionspecifiescircum-
stances under whichthey will givedeference to staterecommenda-
tions. Although jurisdictional boundaries may shift as a result of restruc-
turing programs in wholesale and retail markets, the Commission does
not believe this will change fundamental state regulatory authorities, in-
cluding authority to regulate the vast majority of generation asset costs,
the siting of generationandtransmission facilities, anddecisions re-
garding retail service territories. The commission intends to be respect-
ful of state objectives so long as they do not balkanize interstate trans-
mission of poweror conflict withtheinterstateopenaccess policies.
www.engbookspdf.com
4.
Withregardtostrandedcosts,theFinalRuleadoptsthe
Commission's supplemental proposal. will permit utilities to seek extra-
contractual recovery of stranded costs associated with a limited set of
existing (executed on or before July 11, 1994) wholesale requirements
contracts and provides that the Commission will be the primary forum for
utilities to seek recovery of stranded costs associated with retail-turned-
wholesale transmission customers. It also will allow utilities to seek re-
covery of stranded costs caused by retail wheeling only in circumstances
in which the state regulatory authority does not have authority to address
retail stranded costs at the time the retail wheeling is required. The Rule
retains the revenues lost approach for calculating stranded costs and
provides a formula for calculating such costs.
Open access.
2. Transmission/local distribution.
3. Stranded Costs.
INTRASTATE REGULATION
(Within the State)
www.engbookspdf.com
For-profit electric utilities are regulated on statewide basis by
commission or group of individuals appointed or elected at the state
level. This commission or group of individuals regulates all for-profit
electric utilities, regardless of their geographic location within given
state.
Municipal electric utilities (utilities owned/operated by city or
county) generally are self-regulated. Also, they are generally autono-
mous and structure their rates they see necessary with minimal or no
state supervision or legislation.
Cooperative electric utilities are similar to municipal electric utili-
ties in that they are generally self-regulated with little state oversight.
Cooperative utilities often come into being when for-profit utility does
not provide service to given area, generally because of lack of suf-
ficient profit making opportunity. cooperative utility is usually created
when group of potential users form their own utility to provide com-
modity (electricity, natural water/sewer) for themselves that oth-
erwise would not be available.
Both municipal and cooperative utilities are generally self-govern-
ing with little state intervention except with relation to rate case proce-
dures and public notification guidelines. Ordinarily the state will require
that affected customers (intervenor groups) follow normal rate case pro-
tocol with relation to due process and input.
It is very important to know what is happening at the state regu-
latory level because of the impact of rate case decisions on customer
costs. At the federal (FERC) (interstate) level, electricity is more deregu-
lated than at the state (intrastate) level. Since regulation at the intrastate
level is generally more restrictive and in many instances results in tariff
provisions that cause customer rates to be more costly than they could
be, it is important to always be aware of pending rate cases in the state
where the user’s electricity serving utility is located so that strategy
based upon fact and not hope can be developed.
Structures
In the case of electricity, the following areas are very important to
the customer.
www.engbookspdf.com
Retail Wkeelinp
2.
3.
(Rates that compete with alternate sources of electricity)
4.
(Transportation of the retail customer’s electricity through the
serving utility’s distribution system on firm basis.)
5.
(Transportation of the retail customer’s electricity through the
serving utility’s distribution system on an interruptible basis.)
www.engbookspdf.com
federal and state regulations that apply.
The state regulatory agencies usually take the form of Public Ser-
vice Commissions (PSC) or Public UtilityCommissions (PUC). The func-
tions of these entities are to regulate the intrastate distribution and op-
eration of utilities. These agencies also determine and approve indi-
vidual utility rates of return, grant franchises to utilities for specific areas
of operation, and in general, regulate the operation of utilities which are
within given state.
Although PSC or PUC structures are the most common forms of
state regulation, other methods are used. In some states, these commis-
sions regulate utilities only outside the incorporation limits of munici-
pality or city such in the states of Georgia, Texas, etc. Also, there are
some strange situations that occur in few states. For instance in the
State of Texas, the Public Utility Commission regulates electricity outside
of municipalities; however, outside of these same municipalities is an
entity called the 'Railroad Commission of Texas' regulates natural
Generally, retail customer will have more contact with the state
regulatory agency than with the federal agencies. Since state agencies
determine rate of return and approve or disallow rate increase requests
of utilities, the likelihood of involvement with these agencies will be
greater.
To remain informed on utility matters, knowledge of the opera-
tion and function of the state agencies is required. To follow state regu-
latory matters can be very time-consuming and costly if done on an
individual basis. One alternative to this is to become member of state
energy users group commonly called State Intervenor Groups. These
groups are comprised numerous individuals that have common con-
cerns, typically electricity and natural costs and regulations.
Collectively these groups can accomplish much at the state regula-
tory level. All user or intervenor groups are required to register with the
appropriate State Regulatory Agency. Therefore to determine whether
state has intervenor groups, contact the appropriate State Regulatory
Agency, and also check the Internet for intervenor groups with websites.
www.engbookspdf.com
issued on weekly basis and provide data on all currently pending rate
cases within their jurisdictions. Copies of these reports are available to
anyone who request them in either mailed hard copies or via the Inter-
net. If public utility commission regulates the customer’s utility, it is
important to keep updated on what is going on at the commission level.
Typically the following information is detailed in these reports:
www.engbookspdf.com
upon testimony presented at rate case hearings, approves ac-
tual rates that will be put into effect.
www.engbookspdf.com
Similar to for-profit investor-owned utilities.
A. Public notification.
B. Adequate notification period.
C. Presentation of rate request.
D. Allow input from interested customer groups.
www.engbookspdf.com
of
FEDERAL ENTITIES
Power Administration
Juneau, AK 586-7405
(907)
www.engbookspdf.com
8. U.S. Bureau of Indian Affairs
Mission Valley Power
Polson,
883-5361
(406)
MT
www.engbookspdf.com
THE FLOW OF ELECTRICITY
Generation of
Transmission of
Electricitv
Distribution of
Electricitv
l
Retail Customers
www.engbookspdf.com
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
www.engbookspdf.com
The first step in this undertaking is the obtaining of accurate infor-
mation relating to the subject being investigated. In the case of electricity,
the first step in understanding begins with the obtaining of data that
relates to the pricing on unit basis of the commodity (electricity) being
purchased. Since all utilities are regulated in one way or another, written
records of usage and pricing data it relates to customers must be
available to any interested party that requires it.
www.engbookspdf.com
well the potential for cost being assessed for the material.
Remember, all utility rate information that is approved by regu-
latory body for use in determining rates and conditions to which cus-
tomer is subject,must be matter of public record, and such, available
for public inspection. Typically, the utility service representative respon-
sible for the customer involved is contacted and request is made for the
information needed. It is always more beneficial for the customer to
obtain this information in person, but if not possible, then by telephone
or e-mail. The importance of obtaining the information following cannot
be overstated since these items are basic to understanding utility costs.
With relation to information that is required from the state, the best
way to proceed is to contact the state agency involved directly. As rule,
there should be no problem in obtaining either sales tax or economic
development/enterprise zone information from the state. It is always
best to contact the proper state agency directly by telephone since letters
seem to get lost or misplaced rather frequently.
In Figures 3.1 and following is shown the various items needed
prior to analyzing any electricity billing. Figure 3.1 lists the items that are
normally obtained from the service representative of the utility involved.
Figure 3.5 lists the items that are obtained from the state where the cus-
tomer is located. If all of the items described in these two figures are
obtained, thorough comprehensive analysis of the specific utility in-
volved can be done.
www.engbookspdf.com
Obtain from the Complete Tariff
Utility Service Or
Rate Schedule
Representative
i
Off-Tariff Schedules
Unregulated Marketing
Affiliate Programs
Lrc
sized since only then can comparisons be made between different rates
and options. A typical complete tariff or rate schedule will contain the
following items:
Complete list of all items or riders that modify or change rate costs.
www.engbookspdf.com
4. Information on 'special' rates that may be available in certain cir-
cumstances.
www.engbookspdf.com
Strategy Costs
www.engbookspdf.com
Experimental Tariff Schedule
Schedule: EX-RPT-3 (Experimental Real Time Pricing)
Applicability: Applicable to any general service customer with service
delivered at a voltage level of 4,160 or greater. To qualify for this rate, the
customer must have maintained a monthly billing demand level of at least
500 kW for the last 12-month period.
This rate is available on an experimental basis and the minimum term
is for a one-year period.
Base Monthly Rates:
A. Customer Charge $500.00
B. Demand Charge-per incremental kW (None)
C. Energy Charge:
Base Energy Charge-per k w h (Fuel Cost) $.0067
(2) Energy Charge-per kwh (Variable) ($.0175-$.4325)
Cost Data: Cost data shall be calculated on an hourly basis every day. No
later than a.m. every day the next hourly rates beginning at
12:Ol a.m. will be provided to the customer via a telecommunication link
with the customer mandatory dedicated telephone line. This data will pro-
vide the (24) hourly variable energy charge components for the next billing
period. This data will be provided every day of the year. The energy charge
components will reflect the actual costs as detailed in the Public
UtilityCommissionapprovedrate filing 21 1 dated 12-01,pages126
through 131.
5. Variable Energy Charges: Variable energy charges will range from a
minimum of $.0175/kWh to a maximum of $.4325/kWh per hourly measure-
ment period.
Minimum billing: The minimum monthly billing shall consist of the follow-
ing item:
A. Customer charge $500.00
Miscellaneous Provisions:
A. There shall beno demand (kW) charges applied to this rate.
B. The utility will provide and maintain the appropriate metering and re-
lated equipment to accurately measure the k w h consumption on an
hourly basis, at no cost to the customer.
C. The utility retains the right to limit the number of customers on this
rate.
D. The utility retains the right to withdraw this rate upon one
notice.
www.engbookspdf.com
this rate. In this particular rate, the customer must be served at
primary voltage level of 4,160 or greater. Also, the customer must
have maintained minimum billing demand level of 500 W
monthly for the last 12 months. Generally, applicability provisions
are instituted because the utility has determined that this minimum
voltage/demand threshold would be required by customer to
benefit from the rate. Also sometimes, especially on rate of this
type (experimental), the utility may want to test the rate's validity
or applicability only to certain type or class of customers.
A.CustomerCharge-($500.00)
This is the minimum monthly charge that an individual cus-
tomer would have to pay to be served on this rate. This charge
covers the utility's cost of maintaining and reading the meter
and miscellaneous other monthly billing cost items.
B. Demand Charge-(NonelkW)
This particular type of rate has no demand charge such.
Nevertheless, demand costs are calculated and included in the
energy charges associated with this rate. Although rate with
no demand (kW) charge may seem to be very 'cost effective'
type of rate, the truth of the matter is that demand costs are
calculated and included in the energy charge portion of this
rate. In fact, rate of this type actually would probably be more
expensive for most customers that could not shift usage pat-
terns on daily/hourly basis, which i s very difficult to do. Just
because demand is not included specific billing item does
not mean that its impact on the utility's costs has not been
considered. It has, and in this particular type of rate, is in-
cluded in the variable energy charge portion of the billing.
C. Charge:
Base Enerev Charge-per kwh (Fuel Cost)
This energy charge of $.0067/kWh represents the
utility's fuel cost to operate their generation equipment.
This charge is sometimes called fuel cost adjustment and
it is always applied to the energy (usage, kwh) portion
of the billing. All customers of utility are assessed the
www.engbookspdf.com
same charge on each kwh used. All these charges are
approved by the appropriate regulatory agency.
kWh
www.engbookspdf.com
In this hourly kWh data is the cost of electricity during the (24)
hours of this particular day (Wednesday), the kwh cost ranges from
$0216 (2:Ol a.m./3:00 a.m.) to $.l910 (1:Ol p.m./2:00 p.m.) with the
higher costs being between 6:Ol and 1O:OO p.m. If customer uses
the majority of the electricity during these hours, then the cost for the
electricity will be very high. If however, customer has the majority of
the usage between the hours of11:Olp.m.-7:00 a.m., then the cost per
kwh would range from $.0312(12:Ol am/l:OOam) to $.0476 (6:Olaml
7:OOam).This amount could result in savings when compared to a typical
tariff schedule rate for this same type of usage pattern.
Basically real time pricing rate is generally only cost effective if
customer can vary their electrical loads on daily time related basis, or
if they ordinarily operate during periods of low utility load demand
intervals of time-typically evening, night, early morning and weekends.
If customer were served on this rate, they would receive daily print-
out of data similar to the one shown here for every day of the month,
including weekends and holidays.
4. Cost Data
This section explains how the hourly kwh charges will be calcu-
lated.
Minimum Billing
This section details what will constitute minimum monthly CUS-
tomer bill. Basically the minimum charge will consist of the cus-
tomer charge ($500).
7. Miscellaneous Provisions
This section enumerates miscellaneous provisions associated with
this tariff schedule rate. As can be seen from analyzing the provi-
sions of this example of real time pricing rate, it is not rate for
all customers. Generally, rate of this type will not be cost effective
for customers who operate on one-shift basis during normal first-
shift work. However, if customer operates hours other than these,
or can shift their usage on daily and hourly basis, or can work
many hours on weekends (Saturday and Sunday), then rate of
www.engbookspdf.com
this type may prove to be very cost effective. Before changing to
rate of this type, always have the utility do an analysis of the past
year for the facility/operation in question to determine the cost
effectiveness of change.
www.engbookspdf.com
Availability: Available at discretion to Commercial and Indus-
trial customers that have electric service requirements which are subject to
effective competition. Effective competition exists if a customer is located
in service territoty and has the abilitv to obtain its enerav re-
auirements from an enerav supplier not rate reaulated bv the State Reau-
latorv Aaency.
Rate: Standard service rate provisions apply except the level of the de-
mand and/or energy charges may be decreased for a customer based on
a consideration of load characteristics and lowest cost competi-
tive energy supply.
quired to preserve or retain their load. This type of rate is becoming more
common with the introduction of retail wheeling of electricity. A serving
utility could utilize rate of this type to effectively retain customer that
could leave the serving utility’s generation base which could increase the
serving utility’s incremental base generation costs.
When rate of this type is utilized, any cost reduction related rev-
www.engbookspdf.com
36 Electricity Retail Wheeling
Availability
A rate of this type is inherently discriminatory since the utility can,
within this rider’s written boundaries, choose which, if any, indi-
vidual customers it will offer this ratemaking process to. Since any
utility shortfalls caused by revenue discounts offered through this
type of rate making process normally cannot be passed through to
any other customer, the discrimination factor is minimized. Also,
the offering of this type of discount can preserve generation base
load which can positively impact other customer classes by poten-
tially reducing utility base generation costs which ultimately effects
overall utility costs.
Rate
This provision defines the rate or cost considerations applicable to
this rate rider. Note that there are no definitive numbers in this
section since the actual costs are determined with relation to each
customer’s worth to the utility.
www.engbookspdf.com
rants, small commercial multiple location establishments, or
any multimeter customer with an aggregate total of over 500
kW for all meter points in the serving utility’s service territory.
B. Maximumratereduction.Notwithstandingsection (A)
previously or section following, the utility is not going
to offer any customer a discount larger than they have to
order to retain that customer. This section states that the
customer will probably have to demonstrate or document
what competitive offers they have received in order for the
utility to make competing offer. This type of provision
can cause problems for the utility customer in confidential-
ity agreements they may have with potential non-utility
providers. Sometimes utility customer can simply execute
an RFP (request for proposal) to alternative electricity
providers [marketers other utility ESCOs (energy service
www.engbookspdf.com
38 Electricity Retail Wheeling
D. Size of load (kW) served. The minimum load (kW) that the
utility will consider for discounts in this rider is 500 kW,
but there is no maximum kW limit. Items that should be
considered by the customer when considering this section
are follows:
www.engbookspdf.com
AFFILIATE
Some electric utilities currently have peak power demand (kVA/
kW) deficits. This means that even though utility may not have base
load (kwh) problem, they may experience generation capacity shortfall
during some periods of 24-hour day. The utility can do several things
to compensate for this generation capacity shortfall. They can construct
new generation plants (supply side planning) that are very expensive or
they can offer their customers financial incentives to reduce demand
during the utility’s generation shortfall periods (demand side planning).
Many utilities, through their unregulated marketing affiliate
(ESCO), offer programs that encourage customers to reduce their de-
mand needs by paying for or providing incentives for the particular
items that favorably impact the utility’s demand shortfall problems.
These programs range from, ‘not worth much’ to ’extremely beneficial.’
These programs change frequently and sometimes specific amount of
money is allocated for program which means that when the money is
gone, the program is ended.
If the marketing affiliate has program, they will also generally
have in-house specialist that can be utilized for on-site evaluation
of facility to determine the applicability of the program to particular
situation. The utility service representative can provide program infor-
mation well arrange for an on-site evaluation by the appropriate
specialist. These programs typically include the following items/pro-
cesses although not all items are included in all programs.
www.engbookspdf.com
40
(Utility Customer)
www.engbookspdf.com
Strategy
Due to the vast number of customers most utilities serve, and the
changes and revisions their customers are constantly experiencing, it
would be impossible to assure that any customer is at all times on the
most economical rate available.
Unfortunately, many
utility customers are unaware of the rate that forms the basis of their
utility billing.
Through information provided in this publication, the correct ap-
proach to reducing electricity costs can be understood. With this knowl-
edge, the customer can determine the steps needed to be assured their
electricity costs are what they should be.
www.engbookspdf.com
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
www.engbookspdf.com
Electricity
Retail Wheeling-
The Process IitvOlved
www.engbookspdf.com
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
www.engbookspdf.com
Electricity
Retail Wheeling Basics i
www.engbookspdf.com
tomer will be the same quality and be distributed through the same
transmission/distribution wires p d meters that are used by the utility
that serves the customer.
In the purchase of natural in the majority of instances, the
commodity (natural does not originate within the provider’s service
territory but is simply purchased by the provider and resold to the retail
customer.
Although these differences between electricity and natural may
seem to be of little importance to retail electricity customer, they actu-
ally are critical to the utilities/providers and their differing attitudes
towards the customer’s direct purchase of the commodities that they sell.
Since most natural providers purchase the commodity they sell from
someone else, it does not disrupt their operation or profitability to any
great extent whether their customers purchase ’provider’ natural or
arrange for their own natural and simply utilize provider pipes,
meters, and services. If the provider charges are based upon true cost of
service principles, most natural providers would probably rather
retail customers obtain their own natural since it would result in less
headaches for the provider.
electric utility, however, takes very different view of direct
purchase of electricity by its retail customers since generally the serving
electric utility, in theory at least, generates quantity of electricity equal
to what it sells to retail customers. When retail electricity customer
purchases the electricity commodity from some source other than the
serving utility, the potential lost electricity generation sales for the serv-
ing utility result in lost revenue. The lost generation revenue may not be
capable of being replaced by the serving utility.
If this is true, retail customers choose to purchase their electricity
commodity from sources other than the serving utility, the utility will be
required to increase electricity incremental rates to offset the reduced
electricity commodity sales. As this happens, more and more retail cus-
tomers might opt to obtain their electricity commodity from other than
the servingutility. Thisscenario has name called the ’death spiral.’ This
means that less and less electricity generation is sold to retail custom-
ers by their serving utilities, the incremental electricity cost will continue
to rise. Ultimately, the serving electric utility’s incremental rates will
become prohibitively expensive, resulting in financial losses for the util-
ity involved.
Will wide-spread electric utility bankruptcies result retail wheel-
www.engbookspdf.com
ing becomes more common? Possibly, but has happened in many
industries when competition has presented itself, the affected entities
will find ways to compete.
The question at this point might be-what happens if my electric
utility company declares bankruptcy? If utility bankruptcy occurs, an
interim administrator would be appointed by the courts until pur-
chaser for the utility assets could be located. Utility bankruptcies, while
not common occurrence, have happened with the results being that the
utilities declaring bankruptcy have been purchased and continue to op-
erate.
Retail wheeling of electricity isinherently neither good nor bad, but
depending upon your view, valid case can be made both for and
against the process. From customer’s viewpoint, due to the large varia-
tion in electric utility rates caused by lack, in part, of true competition,
retail wheeling of electricity would seem to be welcomed option. From
an electric utility viewpoint, someone has to pay for its investment in
materials and generation capacity; and, if customers can purchase their
electricity anywhere on the power pool, the utility may have no way to
recoup its costs. Both of these views have some validity, but what will
ultimately determine the reality of the process will be retail customers
causing it to happen.
If retail electricity customers take ‘wait and see’ attitude, then
retail wheeling will probably never be widely available since electric
utilities, especially high generation cost utilities, are not going to push
for process that could ultimately force them to lose customer base.
Retail wheeling of electricity is not something that is technologi-
cally impossible to do since almost all electric utilities currently ’whole-
sale’ wheel electricity between themselves on daily basis. The real
problem electric utilities have with retail or customer wheeling of elec-
tricity is that it will require them to obtain and keep their retail customer
base through competition, not through regulatory commission mandated
service territory boundaries.
It is best to keep the lines of communication open between the retail
customer and the electric utility-seeking the utility’s opinion regarding
retail wheeling of electricity and asking your electricity utility’s service
representative questions, such
Does the utility think that retail wheeling willeffect how it oper-
ates; and if so, how?
www.engbookspdf.com
When and how does the utility think retail wheeling of electricity
will effect them and the way they market electricity?
www.engbookspdf.com
Wheeling
www.engbookspdf.com
more complicated worst-contingency analysis, voltage constraints define
transmission lines. Even when power flows do not approach the thermal
limits of the system and the transmission lines appear to have excess
capacity, voltage limits can constrain the transfer capacity.
Voltage constraints inevitably require attention to both thereal and
reactive power loads and transfers in the alternative current (AC) trans-
mission system. Recall that real power (the power that lights out lamps)
is measured in watts or megawatts (MWs) and reactive power (power
factor) is measured in voltage-reactive or VARS and megaVARS
(MVARS). Power generation, load, and flow in an AC system are divided
into both real and reactive power components. Without voltage con-
straints, the only matter of concern is the real power flow; it is common
practice to ignore the associated reactive power analysis. But voltage can
be affected by both real and reactive power loads, and the interaction
between the two is critical in determining the induced limits on real
power flows.
In reality, voltage limitations and the associated reactive-power
compensation are prevalent. For example, recent power shortages in
New England and New York were largely attributed to voltage and re-
active power problems. Consequently, accounting for the congestion lim-
its created by thermal limitations on transmission lines may not by itself
prevent losses of real power flows. Any new regime for transmission
access must address the congestion problem created by reactive power
and voltage constraints. The most direct method is to account for both
real and reactive power when designing wheeling prices.
Existing transmission and distribution lines are capable of provid-
ing electrical service to all electric customers currently with utility’s
service territory. Today’s transmission and distribution system was pri-
marily designed and constructed to transmit electricity from utility’s
on-system generators at specific locations to its customers within its ter-
ritory, and secondarily to transmit electricity from interconnection points
for reliability and economy power transactions. This same transmission
system may therefore be incapable of transmitting large quantities of
power from outside sources to its retail customers or to other utilities.
Additionally, every transmission line is designed to carry certain maxi-
mum amount of electric current. If this maximum current is exceeded,
then the transmission line will be damaged. Consequently, wheeling
transaction may overload and damage the line.
www.engbookspdf.com
Line Losses
Even if wheeling transaction does not cause transmission line
damage, it can increase transmission line power losses. Transmission line
power loss can be defined the loss of power, in the form of wasted
heat, associated with transmitting electrical current over transmission
line. Line loss is generally unavoidable and is directly proportional to the
mathematical square of the current. Therefore, doubling the current on
transmission line would cause quadrupled line losses. Line losses also
are directly proportional to transmission distance-the greater the dis-
tance of electrical transmission over the same size transmission line, the
greater the line losses associated with the flow of power. Wheeling trans-
actions can increase transmission line losses substantially.
Metering Problems
The electricity requirements of system constantly fluctuate. The
actual power supplied to the system is dependent upon its load require-
ments at any given time. Thus, the party selling power must be sensitive
to these load fluctuations. Two different methods are commonly used to
handle this problem.
The first and most efficient method focuses on the use of meters at
the purchaser’s delivery point(s). The amount of power delivered to the
delivery points is instantaneously summed and telemetered to the gen-
eration dispatch center of the utility selling the power. In this way, the
seller is constantly aware of the purchaser’s instantaneous power re-
quirements.
In the second method, the seller of power provides schedules allo-
cations of power to the purchaser on day-to-day basis. The party
wheeling the power is responsible for providing the actual power re-
quirements to the purchaser and for load fluctuations on the purchaser’s
system. Since metered delivery points are requirement of any party
purchasing off-system power, the exact amount of power supplied to the
purchaser is known. The meters are read on periodic basis (usually
monthly) and the actual power supplied to the party purchasing off-
system power is determined. The amount of actual power supplied is
compared to the amount of scheduled power provided and the differ-
ence is calculated. If more power was actually supplied during the pe-
riod than was schedules, the seller would reimburse the party wheeling
the off-system power for the previous month” deficiency in its following
month” schedule power.
www.engbookspdf.com
The metering problems associated with retail wheeling could be
complex and cumbersome. In order to accurately track customer’s load,
network of meters and telemetering would have to be installed from
retail customers to the parties generating and supplying their power.
Since the system load is adjusted automatically, the computer would
instantaneously sum the demands of the retail customers and automati-
cally adjust for the increase or decrease in load.
www.engbookspdf.com
Retail
www.engbookspdf.com
greatly improved their performance. They include direct light firing of
thyristors, the development of higher voltage cells that lead to lower
losses, greater control flexibility through the use of micro-processors and
sophisticated new control functions (for example, multiterminal opera-
tion, real and reactive power control, and damping of subsynchronous
oscillations), the reduction of converter transformer losses, and better
protection of equipment against over-voltages with the development of
zinc oxide arresters. HVDC should play an increasingly important role in
enhancing the capability of the transmission network to accommodate
increased wheeling and competitive activities.
An economical way to increase the power transfer capability of an
AC line is to install capacitors in series with the line to reduce its elec-
trical impedance. Using zinc oxide discs with high-energy handling ca-
pability, series capacitors can be reliably protected against over-voltage
by connecting series-parallel arrays of discs directly across the capaci-
tors. The protection of turbine generators against subsynchronous oscil-
lations, which may arise when series capacitors are used, has been ac-
complished using either passive filters or active thyristor dampers.
Another means of increasing the power transfer capability of exist-
ing transmission lines is the addition of shunt compensation of the form
of switched capacitor banks or static VAR controls. Static VAR controls
were initially applied to control the voltage flicker produced by electric
arc furnaces. More recently, static VAR controls were applied to control
rapid voltage fluctuations power transmission systems and to im-
prove the stability of large networks. Static VAR controls consist of thy-
ristor switches, sometimes in conjunction with mechanical switches, to
regulate the amount of inductance or capacitance connected to the trans-
mission line for purposes of voltage regulation and increased power
transfer.
These measures should significantly enhance the overall reliability
and capability of electric power systems to comply with the new com-
petitive regime. They have limitations and costs, however. In recent
study, the enhancement potential and installation costs of five options of
different technical measures were compared. These options, proposed to
enhance the network transfer capabilities, are (1)fixed series capacitors,
static VAR compensators (SVCs); (3) adjustable series and SVCs, plus
(4) parallel paths controlled; and (5) the rapid response generation. The
study concludes that power transfer could be increased by 35 percent, 50
percent, 60 percent, 70 percent, and 90 percent with the adoption of
www.engbookspdf.com
options 1 through 5, respectively. Assuming option 1 is the bench mark,
the study found that the installation of option 2, 3, 4, and 5 are approxi-
mately percent, 150 percent, 500 percent, and 800 percent more ex-
pensive that the installation cost of option 1. The savings that would
result from the transfer of cheap power by the enhanced network should
be accounted for when conducting cost/benefit analysis. The question
remains whether utilities would be willing to invest in such measures if
the economic benefits and rewards accrue mainly to consumers.
FINAL COMMENTS
Society has limited tolerance for actions which may disrupt electric
service over wide area. If numerous players are encouraged to engage
in any sort of competition in the electric network, some workable en-
forcement procedure should be established to ensure that variances from
the rigorous and unforgiving nature of operations on the grid are not
compromised because of competitive pressure. Unlike natural trans-
mission, electric wheeling can affect the reliability and stability of service
over wide area. Because electricutilities are interconnected and operate
in parallel, the actions of one utility affect other utilities.
ECONOMIC/POLICY CONSIDERATION
www.engbookspdf.com
their status the sole supplier of power within their franchise areas.
Fifth, it would cause the industry to become more cost conscious and
accommodating to the needs of individual customers.
No.
Market forces can do better than any government or regula-
tory agency in determining prices for commodity such electricity.
www.engbookspdf.com
Principle 6
Resource planning is not natural monopoly. The types and
market shares of generation and end-user technologies that will be sup-
plied in wholesale and retail markets should be decided in the market-
place.
Principle 7
Legitimate and verifiable transition costs that develop result of
competition should be recovered by equitable split amount
ratepayers, shareholders and taxpayers. The costs of assets that were
uneconomical in the existing regulatory regime are not transition costs.
Principle 8
The potential for transition costs should not be used excuse
to prevent or delay the onset of competitive electricity market.
www.engbookspdf.com
REGION NAME (POWER
POOLS) GEOGRAPHIC AREA
SERVED
4. ERCOT
Electric Reliability Texas (partial)
Council of Texas
5. MAIN Illinois
Mid American Interpool Missouri (partial)
Network Wisconsin
8. FRCC Florida
Florida Reliability
Coordinating Council
www.engbookspdf.com
Basics
www.engbookspdf.com
the Pools)
wscc
MAPP
SPP
ERCOT
MAIN
ECAR
SERC
FRCC
NPCC
MAAC
Note: Electric generation/production costs/and retail rates for each of the NERC
regions varies each hour, day, week and month. The figures shown are typical
and are not intended to represent any actual month. This data is presented
only to provide insight to differencesbetween the regions in actual generation
amounts, production costs and retail rates.
Production Costs include fuel prices and non-fuel costs.
count rate withthe customer to retain their base load. It must bere-
membered thatin utility that generates electricity, their good retail
base load customers are critical to the profitability of that utility.
Based upon actual negotiations with electric utilities in
client’s behalf, there have been instances where utility was willing
to negotiate rates, project cost concessions and various other cost
reductions with client even where there was no opportunity for
the client to leave the serving utility. Why do these types of nego-
www.engbookspdf.com
tiations occur? Because the serving utility really does want to keep
their good electricity load profile retail customers satisfied, if pos-
sible.
www.engbookspdf.com
quality level is to ’condition’ the electricity on the user’s side of
the electricity delivery meter point. Quality of power should
not be reason for not investigating retail wheeling electricity
savings potentials.
www.engbookspdf.com
Electricity Retail Wheeling Basics 63
www.engbookspdf.com
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
www.engbookspdf.com
THE CURRENT STATUS OF RETAIL WHEELING OF ELECTRICITY
www.ferc.fed.us/electric/order888.htm
This site contains FERC Order titled-”Promoting Wholesale
Competition Through Open Access Nondiscriminatory Transmis-
sion Services by Public Utilities; Recovery of Stranded Costs by
Public Utilities and Transmitting Utilities.”
Although the title of this order seems somewhat cumbersome,
it is well worth investigating especially if you want to be aware if
the legislation that was enacted prior to but was instrumental in
retail wheeling occurring. (See general discussion of this ruling in
Chapter of this publication.)
www.serve.com/commonpurpose/dereg.html
www.EIA,DOE.gov/cneaf/electricity/chgstr/tab5rev.html
These two sites provide state-by-state retail wheeling information
on very timely basis. It is the best to utilize both web sites since
they each provide retail wheeling information in slightly different
manner that seems to compliment rather than repeat each other.
www.engbookspdf.com
4. www.me3.org/projects/dereg/stranded.html
This site presents an in-depth analysis of stranded investment/cost
recovery strategies used by electric utilities and the related poten-
tial problems of the issues that surround the recovery methodolo-
gies utilized.
1. Electricity .060/kWh
2. Propane .50/gal
3. Fuel Oil #6 .50/gal
4. Natural 3.00/dth
5. Coal 25.00/ton (2,000 lb.)
www.engbookspdf.com
67
By using the information shown in Figure 5.1, the true cost of electricity
per the Btu standard of measure of(1,000,000 Btu) is as follows:
www.engbookspdf.com
68
Btu
4. $S.OO/Dth $3.00/1,000,000Btu
Examples of how these efficiencies could affect true energy costs follow:
www.engbookspdf.com
Wheeling
www.engbookspdf.com
70 Electricity Retail Wheeling
cost to implement the savings, the actual effect on what would haveto be
generated in new sales at various profit margins would be as follows:
Firm Service
Electricity that is purchased under this category is the type that is
typically purchased from the serving utility and has the highest priority
of delivery. If any electricity is available, it will flow to firm service cus-
tomers. Generally firm service customers have no back-up generation
capability and result, pay the highest tariff rate applicable. Depend-
ing upon the serving utility’s tariff schedules, firm category customers
may or may not be eligible for other than firm service electricity. Prob-
ably retail wheeling customer, if they require an uninterrupted flow of
electricity, will purchase firm distribution capacity from the serving util-
ity or back up their operations with on-site generation capacity uti-
lize interruptible service.
Interruptible Service
This category of service is the type that is the most cost effective to
retail wheeling customers. Those retail wheeling customers who can
accommodate interruption of electric service on short notice, generally in
peak load seasons or situations, will benefit from this class of service.
www.engbookspdf.com
Process 71
www.engbookspdf.com
competition, even those not directly affected in many cases find that they
too can benefit from the process. One thing that electric utilities say will
happen if retail wheeling becomes widely available, is that some
customer’s rates will increase result of lost utility revenue. This
would only be true if the utilities were to continue to operate in the same
method that they currently do.
What is happening is the electric utilities are taking either one of
two possible positions-to view retail wheeling new opportunity for
growth, or resist and fight the process see their market share con-
tinue to erode. Those that see it as an opportunity will grow and all of
their customers will benefit from the process. Those that resist will ulti-
mately fail, go bankrupt, or be purchased by company that through
vision sees opportunities rather than disaster. Retail wheeling is here
regardless of what electric utilities want, there are problems and failures
but once the transitional period is over, electricity will become com-
modity rather than protected monopolistic service regardless of indi-
vidual feelings about the process.
In flow chart form, Figure 5.3 shows the various steps that are
present in the retail wheeled electricity process. Remember that the pro-
cess shown here is typical and may not be completely accurate with what
may occur in given circumstance. Utilize this data only guide to the
incremental steps that are present in retail wheeling transaction.
EXPLANATION OF FIGURE
WHEELED ELECTRICITY FLOW CHART
www.engbookspdf.com
< T I
f
Wheeled Electricity
Supply Transmission
Serving Utility
(Interstate)
Serving Utility
Distribution System
Grid
This is the transmission grid that links the wheeling generator to
the wheeled customer’s utility. This grid is governed by the Federal
Energy Regulatory Commission. Generally, the wheeled to customer has
choice of firm or interruptible transmission service.
www.engbookspdf.com
This point is where the wheeled to customer’s utility receives,
meters, and takes title to the wheeled electricity. The costs at this point
include the wheeled electricity costs accumulated in Price Point No. 1,
the agent fees and the transmission grid costs to deliver the wheeled
electricity to the wheeled to customer’s utility. Included in the transmis-
sion costs is line loss factors due to the resistance of flow of electrons
through the transmission grid.
This is the point at which the wheeled electricity passes through the
retail customer’s on-site electricity meter. Remember, the electricity the
retail customer actually receives may never include any of the actual
wheeled electrons that were generated for the retail customer. The reason
for this is that the retail customer’s wheeled electricity is co-mingled
with all other electricity that is present in the transmission grid, both
between the wheeled electricity supply and the serving utility receipt
point, well between the serving utility receipt point and the retail
customer’s meter point.
There is no problem with this since actual electrons of electricity are
the same.The actual electrons of electricity that the customer receives
in the retail wheeling transaction are the same prior to the wheeling
arrangement, much like the natural transportation process. The
wheeled electricity received and metered at the serving utility receipt
point is recorded and credited to the retail wheeling customer much like
deposit in bank savings account.
During the billing month, the retail wheeling customer has these
deposits available to utilize determined by the retail wheeling agree-
www.engbookspdf.com
ment. The exact electrons deposited in the wheeling customer’s account
may not be the same electrons that are utilized by the wheeling customer,
but so long there are not more withdrawals than deposits, the overall
system will remain in equilibrium. This may sound inordinately compli-
cated, but basically this same process goes on daily where utilities wheel
among themselves on wholesale basis. It would be very difficult to
trace given electron from generation point to use point, but the system
works and remains in balance long the same quantity of deposits
of electricity are available there are withdrawals made.
Since electricity cannot be practically stored, this electricity genera-
tion/use system must be essentially balanced all of the time-no small
feat given the complexities of electricity generation/distribution in the
United States. Physically, retail wheeling works. The problem is all of the
metering and related billing calculations concerning, for example-line
losses (under or over), usage of electricity by the customer, and many
other cost items that need to be addressed by all of the entities involved.
The total retail wheeled electricity cost to the using customer will be the
sum of the costs accumulated in Price Points Nos. 1 and 2 and totaled in
Price Point No. 3.
In some scenarios, the retail wheeling customer utilizes inter-
ruptible electricity generation and transmission up to the serving utility
receipt point because of the differentials between firm and interruptible
electricity costs to these points. If retail wheeling customer requires
firm or non-interruptible electricity, it may be possible to negotiate
back-up arrangement with the serving utility for supplemental electricity
in the event of interruption of the customer’s wheeled electricity. Al-
though retail wheeling of electricity is nothing like customer transporta-
tion of natural in technical and operation characteristics, it is similar
in the process to the natural transportation transaction. In Figure 5.4
following, is typical retail wheeling cost flow chart that will help to
explain the various costs.
www.engbookspdf.com
1. Price No. 1Point
Wheeled Electricity Supply
2.
Agent Charge
3.
Interstate Transmission
Grid
4.
Serving Utility Receipt
Meter Point
5.
Serving Utility Intrastate
Distribution Grid
Loss
Fees
6. for
Wheeling Customer #l,
Meter Point Charge
www.engbookspdf.com
The Retail Wheeling 77
www.engbookspdf.com
interruptible. Generation in this class would occur during the high-
est usage of generation on the power pool. Normally, generation
on-peak will continue for period of-from 12 to 16 hours daily,
Monday through Friday. Typically, Saturdays and Sundays and
holidays are considered to be off-peak periods, 24 hours day.
This charge represents the retail customers cost for the agent (mar-
keter) utilized to acquire the electricity generation needed. Most wheel-
ing customers utilize the services of third party (agent) to initiate and
follow-up on the wheeling process much is generally done in cus-
tomer transportation of natural These third parties, whether brokers,
marketers or producers, are technically know agents since they act in
the customer’s behalf and can legally bind them to contractual agree-
ment. These entities will perform at least the following functions for the
retail wheeling customer:
www.engbookspdf.com
The Wheeling Process
Wheeled Electricity
Contract Commodity Supply
Transmission Grid
Contract
of
www.engbookspdf.com
80 Electricity
HandbookRetail Wheeling
www.engbookspdf.com
81
This price point includes all of the serving utility costs fol-
lows:
www.engbookspdf.com
Total Wheeling Costs.
This total includes all wheeling costs from wheeled electricity sup-
ply point (item #l on the flow chart) through the serving utility distri-
bution costs (item #5 on the flow chart) are follows:
The total cost at this point would be compared to the total cost the
retail customer had been paying to their serving utility prior to retail
wheeling.
www.engbookspdf.com
6
The Retail Wheeling
Contract Process
The section details the various agents for retail wheeled electricity.
This information provides the background necessary to be able to intel-
ligefftly determine the type of agent that should be used to provide the
electricity needed at the reliability required. The information given
herein provides the foundation for doing retail wheeling transactions.
www.engbookspdf.com
The thing to remember is that since title does not pass to the bro-
kers, their warranty to availability is no better than their source pro-
vides. In general, the fewer steps required to arrive at the actual electric-
ity generation source, the more reliable the supply. Do not necessarily
disregard broker-supplied electricity but remember brokers are able to
provide no better title to the electricity they market than what they
have-which is none.
If broker is used, make sure"(1) their source is identified, (2) the
supply is assured for the duration of the contract, and (3) their source
does have title to the electricity that they provide to you. In general, it is
probably better, both on long-term cost and reliability, if you contract
with either marketer or an electricity producer.
Marketers
Marketers differ from brokers in that they take title to the electricity
they sell the wheeling customer. A marketer takes title to the electricity
but does not have or own the generation facilities. Marketers, or market-
ing affiliates, are also known in the electric industry "traders." While
all of this may seem confusing, remember the difference between this
category and the broker category is that title to the electricity does pass
with the marketer where it does not pass with the broker. The difference
between marketers and producers is that producers own electricity gen-
eration facilities and marketers do not.
The marketer category is the largest supplier of retail wheeled elec-
tricity. As with any group of individual entities, there are good and bad
available. So be certain that any contracts to be negotiated conform in
general to the one that is described in this section.
Producers
Producers have title to and own electricity generation facilities.
They are the original owners of the electricity and are responsible for its
generation and distribution to an interstate transmission grid receipt
point. Some producers market their own electricity directly to retail
wheeling customers. Sometimes, several generators join together to form
quasi-cooperative that in turn markets the electricity to retail wheeling
customers. Producers, such, probably are not the major force in the
retail wheeling market. In general, they sell their electricity production to
either transmission grid, serving utility, or marketer, who in turn
supplies the retail wheeling customer.
www.engbookspdf.com
Basic Differences Between Brokers, Marketers and Producers
Brokers-Do not taketitletoor do not own generation facilities.
2. Marketers-Take title to but probably do not own generation facili-
ties.
3. Producers-Havetitleto and own generation facilities.
Synopsis
Generally, there will be no reason to limit the choice of your sup-
plier strictly on the basis of the category (broker, marketer, or producer).
The criteria for selecting supplier will be based upon data such
1. Reliability of supply.
2. Price.
3. Transmission distribution routing.
4. Contract language.
5. Retail wheeling customer service.
6. Congeniality between buyer and seller.
www.engbookspdf.com
86 Wheeling
Figure 6.2 RFP for Electricity Commodity Only, With (3) Pricing
Options.
A. Fixed Discount.
B. Minimum Guaranteed Savings.
C. Shared Savings.
Figure 6.3 RFP for Electricity, Natural Gas, and Energy Services.
These RFP samples, while for informational purposes only, are typi-
cal of actual materials being utilized in transactions between providers
and retail customers.
www.engbookspdf.com
RFP Electricity Commodity Only
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I. OVERVIEW 2
1. Explanation 2
2. Scope of Services 2
3. Process 2
BIDDING PROCEDURE 2
Phase l-Bidding Requirements 3
Phase 2-Proposal Return 3
Phase 3-Evaluation of Proposal 3
Phase &Final Negotiations
PROPRIETARYINFORMATION 3
V. QUALITYSPECIFICATIONS
1. Performance
2. Response
www.engbookspdf.com
88 Wheeling Retail Electricity
OVERVIEW
1. Explanation.
This Request for Proposal (RFP) will be used to evaluate proposals
for the reduction of electricity commodity costs at the prop-
erties.
Under this Request for Proposal, energy cost reduction will include
the price of the electricity commodity only. Information submitted by
bidders will provide the basis for consideration of a contract with the
customer. In addition to being cost competitive, the successful bidder
must have the ability to work effectively with the personnel
and management.
Scope of Services.
The Customer is soliciting proposals for electricity commodity cost
reduction for all facilities included in this RFP.
Process.
This RFP contains four phases, as follows:
Phase Bidding Requirements
Phase Proposal Return and Initial Review
Phase 3- Evaluation of Proposals and Interviews with
Selected Bidders
Phase Final Negotiation and Award of Contract
II.
BIDDING PROCEDURE
All bidders will receive relevant materials about the current con-
sumption of electricity and costs at facilities and will also be
provided a copy of the RFP describing the services being sought by the
Customer. Each bidder will receive the terms and conditions under
which their bid should be made, and upon which a contract may be
awarded.
Page 2
www.engbookspdf.com
Wheeling
PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
www.engbookspdf.com
Commodity
v.
GENERAL CONDITIONS
1. Independent Contractors.
The Customer and successful bidder shall not be subject to direc-
tion by the other in the performing of their respective work under any
agreement reached pursuant to this RFP process. Each shall do such
work as an independent contractor.
Insurance Indemnity.
The successful bidder,when entering into an agreement for ser-
vices with the Customer, agrees and promises:
www.engbookspdf.com
b) indemnify and hold harmless the Customer from and against
any claims, suits and judgments for property damage, bodily injuries
and deaths caused by any act or omission of the successful bidder, its
agents and employees.
V.
QUALITY SPECIFICATIONS
1. Performance.
Services will continue to be provided through wires, transformers,
meters and other facilities as provided prior to the initiation of any ser-
vice contract. No risk of interruption of delivery of a commodity, except
under conditions specifically noted and offered as an option to the
base proposal, and no change in the quality of the commodity
delivered will be allowed.
2. Response.
The successful bidder, upon execution of an agreement for ser-
vices, shall immediately respond to any and all service problems pre-
sented by the Customer including problems associated with delivery to
the serving utility receipt point.
VI.
PROPOSAL SPECIFICATIONS
1. Proposal
Requirements.
All bids received must meet the following minimum requirements for
consideration by the Customer:
A. facilities included in this must be included in
proposed arrangements.
A one-year minimum term agreement.
www.engbookspdf.com
EvaluationCriteria.
All submitted proposals will be evaluated based upon the level of
the proposed electricity commodity savings.
VII.
REQUIRED SERVICES
www.engbookspdf.com
93
3. Billing.
The discount amount will be clearly identified each individual
monthly invoice. The successful bidder will provide a billing
summary for all facilities included in this RFP a monthly
basis. The successful bidder will provide each individual facility with a
monthly accounting of the cost savings generated by the discount and
will institute an open book accounting policy for the Customer to audit
actual costs.
VIII.
SPECIAL PROVISIONS
1. Changes:Non-Assignment:Successors.
Any contract entered into between the successful bidder and the
Customer pursuant to this RFP process shall represent the entire agree-
ment between the parties with respect to the subject matter hereof. Any
such agreement shall not be assignable by either party without the prior
written consent of the other. Any inconsistencies between the represen-
tations contained in this RFP and any other agreement between these
two parties shall be resolved in favor of the RFP contract.
2. ForceMajeure.
Failure or delays in the performance of the work contemplated
hereunder, as more specifically described in a contract between the par-
ties, by either party, shall excuse both parties from performance of their
respective obligations hereunder if, and so long as, caused by acts of
God or the elements, law or governmental restrictions, labor distur-
bances, war or the results thereof, or any other causes like those enu-
merated, which are beyond the reasonable control of the party whose
performance is affected. If either party anticipates that circumstances
beyond its control may occur, that party shall promptly furnish written
notice of such circumstances to the other party, and shall take all re-
sponsible steps to carry out the terms of this RFP and the contract as
soon as reasonably practicable, subject to delays as may be caused by
such an event. In the event delaying circumstances occur andshall
continue for a period of thirty (30) continuous days, the party entitled to
such performance shall have the right to terminate the unperformed
portion of the contract.
www.engbookspdf.com
Notice that this RFP is for electricity commodity only. (See VII-
”Required Services” in RFP) In this type ofRFP, for electricity commod-
ity only, customer savings in the range of to 4% of their total electric-
ity expenditures are reasonable. An electricity-commodity-only arrange-
ment is not what most potential providers prefer. Since the typical mar-
gin for providers on electricity commodity is very small, there generally
is not much interest for this type of arrangement there would be for
an electricity commodity and engineering services structure. Most of
potential provider’s margin will be in the providing of engineering ser-
vices, not in the providing of the electricity commodity.
EXPLANATION OF
FIGURE 6.1-RFP FOR ELECTRICITY COMMODITY ONLY
Overview
Bidding Procedure
www.engbookspdf.com
to the bidders understanding of what is wanted by the customer. Infor-
mation and data are the keys to successful experience in this process.
This section outlines the required bid receipt date mandated by the
RFP. Generally the time period from receipt of the RFP by potential
bidder to its completion and return to the Customer should be 4 to 6
weeks at minimum. Do not shorten this period to unrealistic time
because to do so can very negatively impact the quality the bids re-
ceived. The types of described here, are for the most part, rather
new to the industry andwill require time by bidders for them to under-
stand and respond to.
IV. General
Here respondents to the RFP are told that they are not employees
of the Customer but independent contractors.
Outlined here are the EEOs with which any bidder must comply.
www.engbookspdf.com
Outlined here is the fact that delivery of services (electricity) will
continue to be performed in the same or at an improved quality level
the Customer is currently receiving. This section is put in to assure that
electricity commodity cost reductions are not the result of reduced reli-
ability, delivery quality or any other physically altered characteristic of
electricity to the Customer. This RFP is for the cost reduction of the elec-
tricity commodity only with its physical characteristics remaining consis-
tent with whatwas being delivered prior to the contract between the suc-
cessful bidder and the Customer.
Here the minimum agreement term limits are set forth. Generally,
the minimum term for contract for electricity commodity pricing
would be for at least year. Terms shorter than (1)year are more dif-
ficult to structure with potential providers because of their limited profit
potential.
This section is the most important part of the RFP.In it are listed the
components to be considered in the discount. As can be seen there are at
least 12 different items to be considered (Items A-L). The main thing to
remember here is that any discount for electricity commodity (Item A)
must be represented at (Item M) which is the total Customer use-point
meter cost.
www.engbookspdf.com
TheContract
Retail Wheeling Process
www.engbookspdf.com
Electricity Retail Wheeling
As
These costs, if present, represent the actual reduction in electricity
it travels across the transmission grid system. This loss is result
of resistance to flow of electrons in an electrical system. These
losses are stated averages and are under the jurisdiction of FERC.
Typically they can be of total flow of electricity. There is no
discounting of these loss factors.
These costs vary by power pool and may include many items,
taxes, system maintenance, expense recovery items, etc. They are
not negotiable. FERC approves these types costs.
H.
These costs are basically the same those described in Item
C previously, except that they occur within the Customer’s state of
electricity usage. Discounts on this intrastate distribution system
are typically not available. The state regulatory agency approves
the various costs relating to distribution.
www.engbookspdf.com
previously, except that they occur within the Customer’s state of
electricity usage. Typically these losses can be of total flow
of electricity. There is no discounting of these costs. The state regu-
latory agency approves loss factors.
1.
These costs are basically the same those discussed in Item
G previously, except that they occur within the Customer’s state of
electricity usage. They are not negotiable. The state regulatory
agency approves these types of fees and charges.
K.
Sometimes this item is referred to competitive transition
cost. Either description means the same to the Customer-extra
electricity costs. These costs are supposed to compensate the
Customer’s serving electric utility for the potential losses sustained
when the Customer elects not to purchase the electricity commod-
ity from the serving utility’s generation.
Since, in practice, no one knows where any specific electricity
commodity generation output is going, it is difficult to understand
how any serving utility knows whose electrons were used by any
given Customer at any given time. However, in this case, percep-
tion is good reality, and serving utilities are being granted
relief from these perceived problems every day. These costs are
under the jurisdiction of the state regulatory agency and are not
negotiable by an individual electric utility Customer.
This is the total of all cost Items A-L and represents the actual
use-point cost to the Customer. Any and all discounts Items A-
www.engbookspdf.com
L have their ultimate impact on this use-point cost. Always calcu-
late total discounts against the current cost at this point to deter-
mine the actual overall value of any contract agreements with
potential provider.
VIII. Provisions
Events over which neither party has control are covered in this
section.
www.engbookspdf.com
RFP for Electricity Commodity Only With (3) Pricing Options
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I. PREFACE 2
A. Definitions 2
Customer 2
2. Services 2
3. Bidder Candidate 2
4. RFP 2
5. Bidder 2
6. Facilities 2
7. Supplier(s) 2
B. Overview 3
C. Explanation 3
1. Evaluation and Qualification Process 3
2. Proprietary Information 4
GENERAL REQUIREMENTS 4
1. Introduction
Equal Employment Opportunity Requirements
3. Legal Documents, Laws and Regulations 4
4. Insurance Requirements
5. Substitutions
QUALITYSPECIFICATIONS 7
A. Performance Specification 7
Electricity
2. Response Specification
IV. PROPOSAL SPECIFICATIONS
A. Proposal Options
1. Option #l-Fixed Discount Standard from Serving
Utility Retail Tariff Rate
2. Option #2--Shared Savings with a
Minimum Guarantee Discount
3. Option #3-Shared Savings Only-
No Guaranteed Savings
4. Bidder Conditions-Applicable to All Pricing Options 9
V. SPECIAL PROVISIONS
Type of Contract(s)
2. Proposed Contract(s) Term 10
VI.AWARD OF CONTRACT
1.Award of Contract 10
www.engbookspdf.com
1.
PREFACE
DEFINITIONS
Services
Bidder Candidate
4. RFP
5. Bidder
Facilities
Supplier(s)
www.engbookspdf.com
(3)
B. OVERVIEW
C. EXPLANATION
www.engbookspdf.com
Wheeling
2. Proprietary Information
Any specifications (technical or business data) which in any
way represents “information” furnished to BIDDER(S) under
this RFPor in contemplation hereof, will remain
property; and all copies thereof, will be returned to Customer
if BIDDER(S) decline to participate, is eliminated in the evalu-
ation at the end of Phase IV, orat any time upon request.
BIDDER@) agrees to keep information confidential associated
with this RFP and not use same for any other purpose except
upon such terms as may be agreed upon by BIDDER@) and
Customer in writing.
www.engbookspdf.com
All potential SERVICES to be executed and MATERIALS delivered
under this RFP are subject to applicable laws and regulations of
federal, state, county, and local governments and any/all city or
municipal laws or ordinances.
No BIDDER(S) shall disclose to others that Customer has tendered
this RFP to them, except as may be required to complete the re-
quirements of this RFP and Proposal Information Package. If such
a disclosure is required by the BIDDER(S), in order to prepare a
proposal response, the BIDDER(S) will require any party to whom
it does disclose such information to sign a Non-Disclosure Agree-
ment.
INSURANCE REQUIREMENTS
The successful BIDDER shall be required, at a minimum, to carry
the types of insurance coverage in the amounts required by the
Customer including Workman's Compensation, employee liability,
bodily injury and property damage.
www.engbookspdf.com
E. SUBSTITUTIONS
Whenever any subcontractor is specified by name, all BIDDER(S)
shall base their quotations only on that specific subcontractors
costs.
In order not to limit competition, and so that Customer may con-
sider alternatives which may be of benefit, the bidders may propose
substitutions which they consider equivalent to, or better than, the
specified items contained in the RFP
All proposed substitutions must be submitted in writing as part of
the bid submission. After the bids are received, no alternative prod-
ucts or subcontractors will be considered by Customer.
All subcontractors' names, specified and alternatives (if used) must
be submitted as part of the bid along with their proposed prices.
QUALITY SPECIFICATIONS
It is the intent of the proposed contract to ensure that the included fa-
cilities of Customer shall, after the issuance of the contract, continue to
receive utility (electricity) services at the same or improved level of
quality, deliverability and reliability as was available prior to the issuance
of the contract.
A. PERFORMANCE SPECIFICATIONS
1. Electricity.
Electricity services will continue to be provided through wires,
transformers, meters, etc., as is currently provided prior to is-
suance of the contract. No change in quality of the electricity
commodity will be allowed.
2. Response Specification
The BIDDER@) shall respond to problems presented by
designated Customer representatives upon notification. This
would include, but not be limited to, delivery reliability to serv-
ing utility receipt point.
www.engbookspdf.com
Iv.
PROPOSAL SPECIFICATIONS
A. PROPOSALOPTIONS
Option #l-Fixed Discount from Serving Utility Retail Tariff
Rate.
BIDDER(S)willofferCustomeradiscountfromthetotal
monthly bill that Customer would have otherwise paid if it had
taken service from the Serving Utility. In any month, the stan-
dard retail tariff schedule rate applicable to Customer plus any
taxes that would be applicable and included in the total Serving
bill to Customer shall serve asthe baseline against
which this fixed discount is calculated.
CHART 1
www.engbookspdf.com
108 Electricity Retail Wheeling
www.engbookspdf.com
2
c. Warranty that sets forth terms and conditions that protect Cus-
tomer for all electricity purchased from bidder during the term
of the Agreement as follows:
www.engbookspdf.com
110 Electricity Retail Wheeling
OF
B.
www.engbookspdf.com
Notice that this RFP is for electricity commodity only. (See IV-A,
Proposal Options in RFP.) However, it allows the flexibility forthe poten-
tial vendors to select from one of three pricing options for the electricity
commodity-Fixed Discount, Shared Savings with Minimum Guaran-
teed Discount, and Shared Savings Only. (See IV-A, 2, and 3, Proposal
Options in RFP.)
NOTE: Portions of this figure are very similar to Figure 6.1 (RFP for
Electricity Only). Items I,11,111,IV, V, VI,VI11 and IX in Figure 6.1 are
similar to Items I, 11,111, V, VI in Figure 6.2. Item VI1 in Figure 6.1 and
Item IV in Figure 6.2 are where the real differences between these two
figures occur. These two figures are structured slightly differently from
each other in the areas described for purpose.
The purpose is to make the reader of this publication aware of
different structures that can be utilized in documents of this type without
impacting the viability of the RFP. Generally individual customers and/
or their legal representatives will have standard contract provisions with
which they are familiar and feel comfortable. In these instances the ques-
tions may arise to what “standard” contract provisions can be utilized
in “utility services” RFP. The answer is that many of the generic stipu-
lations and requirements that customer may typically utilize in con-
tract can be used in “utility services” RFP.
The major thing that has to be specific in each ”utility services” RFP
is the portion of the RFP that relates to the “utility services” being re-
quested. This portion of the RFP is generally relatively small, but very
critical, part of the total RFP. Structuring ”utility services” RFP is sim-
ply seeking provider of ”utility services” much other services might
be solicited.
Do not make the RFP process more difficult than is required, but do
recognize that the portion of the RFP relating to the specific ”utility ser-
vices being solicited” is critical to successful contract with provider.
A.
Customer. The legal name of the Customer.
www.engbookspdf.com
Services. A brief description of the services being requested.
3. Bidder Candidate. Definesthe term ”bidder candidate.”
4. RFP. Defines what ”RFP” means.
5. Bidder.Defines the word ”bidder.”
6. Facilities. Defines what ”facilities” means in relation to this
RFI?
Supplier(s). Defines what ”supplier(s)” means.
B. Overview. Describes the required qualifications that bidders
must possess.
C. Explanation. Explains the purpose of the RFP.
1. Evaluation and Qualification Process. Explains the evalua-
tion and qualification process.
Phase 1. Explains the bidder selection process.
Phase 2. Explains bidder interview process.
Phase 3. Explains method of contract awarding process.
2. Proprietary Information. Defines propriety information
utilized in this RFP.
www.engbookspdf.com
Wheeling
www.engbookspdf.com
tual cost data on what is generally referred to an "open
b o o k arrangement. a customer is not adverse to some
margin of risk or uncertainty in their savings structure, this
option is probably better choice than Option #l. this
option is utilized, the customer will have to be satisfied that
the provider is allowing the customer to have an unre-
stricted look at the provider's books so that the shared
portion the savings truly reflect what they should be.
V. SPECIALPROVISIONS-
A. Type of Contract(s). Outlined here are the types of contracts
that will be considered by the customer.
B. Proposed Contract(s) Terms. This section describes the contract
lengths or time periods that will be considered by the customer.
www.engbookspdf.com
Retail
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PREFACE
A. Definitions
Services
2. Bidder Candidate
3. RFP
4. Bidder
5. Facilities
6. Supplies
B. Overview of Bidders
C. Explanation
Evaluation and Qualification Process
2. Proprietary Information
GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
A. Introduction
Equal Employment Opportunity Requirements
2. Permits, Laws, and Regulations 5
3. Insurance Requirements 5
4. Substitutions
QUALITY SPECIFICATIONS
A. Performance Specifications
Electricity
2. Natural Gas 7
3. WaterISewer 7
4. Response Specifications 7
5. Energy Service Projects 7
V. SPECIAL
PROVISIONS 9
A. Type of Contracts 9
B. Proposed Contract Terms 9
C. References 9
www.engbookspdf.com
116 Retail Electricity Wheeling Handbook
PREFACE
A. Definitions
Services
SERVICES refers to all tasks, procedures, activities and work-
associated with electricity, natural gas and waterlsewer energy
cost reduction, as defined in this document.
2. Bidder Candidate
BIDDER@) refers to the single or multiple companies selected
as candidates to participate in the RFP Process.
RFP
RFP refers to “Request for Proposal.”
4. Bidder
BIDDER(S) is qualified company(s) in the business of providing
integrated energy and facility management services including-
gas and electric commodities, engineering and construction ca-
pabilities,and energy equipment management and/or SER-
VICES.
5. Facilities
The term FACILITIES incorporates any real estate utilized by
Customer included in this RFP.
Supplier(s)
SUPPLIER(S) are those BIDDER(S) under contract with Cus-
tomer to provide Goods and/or SERVICES at mutually agreed-
upon prices, standards and intervals for a specified term in ac-
cordance with the Terms and Conditions specified in a contract
between the parties.
B. OverviewofBidders
www.engbookspdf.com
Only a BIDDER, who has an established strategy, structure and man-
agement process for providing the highest level of professional ser-
vice, will be considered.
C. Explanation
This Customer is soliciting proposals for utility cost reduction SER-
VICES for its FACILITIES as outlined in this RFP. is this
intention to identifythebestmatchbetweentheirneedsand
capabilities.
1. Evaluation and Qualification Process
The participation and information requested by the RFP are in-
tended to facilitate the evaluation and qualification process. This
process serves as the means for selecting the B I D D E W ) who
appears best suited to meeting the needs of Customer.
PHASE A description of the services required, the key FACIL-
ITY statistics and the various terms and conditions under which
a contract agreementmay bereachedwiththesuccessful
BIDDER(S) will be provided. Any questions will be answered at
the mandatory RFP Conference. At that time, ad-
ditional documents and forms will be distributed for your use in
the proposal process. Companies who successfully complete the
Phase 1 requirements will be evaluated under the next phase of
the process.
PHASE Responses will be evaluated by Customer to identify
those BIDDERS whose proposals appear “most likely” to satisfy
the needs. The evaluation will also include an inves-
tigation of ability to perform and related experi-
ence. BIDDER(S) who satisfactorily complete this phase of the
selection process will be eligible for the next phase of the pro-
cess.
PHASE Customer willconductfinalinterviewswiththe
and ask any questions necessary to make the de-
cision for the final award of a contract.
PHASE 4. Customer/BIDDER will finalize pricing and contract
terms. Awarding of the contract will be at the sole discretion of
Customer.
www.engbookspdf.com
2. Proprietary Information
GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
A. Introduction
This document is part of a RFP from the Customer. This RFP is not
intended to constitute an offer or binding agreement between the
parties, nor does it consummate a contract between Customer and
any BIDDER(S). The only legal obligations between the parties shall
be those set forth in an executed contract subsequent to the RFP.
The Customer reserves the right to refuse any offer made to it at its
sole discretion. In the event a contract is not consummated, the Cus-
tomer shall not be obligated for any expenses of any BIDDER(S) or
for any charges or claims whatsoever arising out of this
The Customer does not seek to obtain any of propri-
etary or confidential information. All information and data contained
in the submitted proposal must be and will be treated as material
Customer may use or distribute without restriction. However, Cus-
tomer does not intend, and will use all reasonable efforts not to
disclose, any information from proposal to those sub-
mitting competing proposals. All proposals become the property of
Customer upon receipt and will not be returned. Customer reserves
the right to reject any or all proposals received if such action is
considered to be in the best interest of Customer.
This RFP is contingent upon compliance with all provisions con-
tained herein. Consideration will be given only to BIDDER(S) that
respond to all requirements.
www.engbookspdf.com
3-RFP
3. Insurance Requirements
The successful BIDDER(S) shall be required, at a minimum, to
carry Workman's Compensation, employee liability, public liabil-
ity, bodily injury, and property damage insurances as required by
law.
www.engbookspdf.com
120 Electricity Retail Wheeling
4. Substitutions
Whenever any product or subcontractor is specified by reference
to name, trade name, make, model or catalog number of any
supplier, all bidders shall base their bids only on those specified
products or subcontractors.
In order not to limit competition, and so that the Customer may
consider alternatives that may be of benefit, the bidders may
propose substitutions that they consider equivalent to the speci-
fied products, manufacturers andlor subcontractors.
All proposed substitutions must be submitted in writing as part of
the bid submission. After thebids are received, engineering
project alternative products or subcontractors will be considered
by Customer based upon the specific engineering project being
undertaken.
All subcontractors' names and alternatives (if used) must be
submitted as part of the bid along with proposed prices.
It is the intent of this RFP to ensure that the facilities of Customer shall,
after the issuance of the contract, continue to receive utility services at
the same or improved level of quality, deliverability and reliability as was
available prior to the issuance of the contract.
PerformanceSpecificationUtilityServices(Electricity,Natural
Gas, Water/Sewer)
Electricity
Electricity services will continue to be provided through wires,
formers, meters, etc., as is currently provided prior to issuance of a
contract. No greater risk of interruption except as agreed-to by the
parties on a specific facility-by-facility basis will be considered in the
delivery of the commodity (electricity); no change in quality of the
commodity (electricity) volts, hertz, interruptions; etc., will be allowed.
www.engbookspdf.com
Wheeling
Natural Gas
Natural gas will continue to be provided through pipes, meters,
etc. as is currently provided prior to issuance of this contract. No
greater risk of interruption except as agreed-to by the parties on
a specific facility-by-facility bases than is currently allowed will
be considered in the delivery of the commodity (natural gas), no
change in the quality of the commodity (natural gas) will be al-
lowed.
WaterISewer
Water/Sewer will continue to be provided through pipesand
meters as is currently provided prior to issuance of this contract.
No change in the quality of the commodity (watedsewer) will be
allowed.
4. Response Specification
The BIDDER(S) shall respond to all problems presented by des-
ignated Customer representatives upon notification. This would
include, but not be limited to, delivery reliability to serving utility
(electricity, natural gas, and watedsewer) receipt point.
www.engbookspdf.com
IV.
PROPOSAL SPECIFICATIONS
www.engbookspdf.com
‘d.)
l
V.
SPECIAL PROVISIONS
A. Type of Contracts
The resulting Contract(s) will be for a term not to exceed ten (10)
years from date of initial signing by both parties (Customer/selected
BIDDER).
www.engbookspdf.com
‘d.)
OF
An award of a Contract will not be made until the necessary inves-
tigations have been made of proposals and other re-
quirements in evaluation process. Award of any Contract
will be made in a period of time as may be decided by Customer.
Customer reserves the sole right to decline to award any Contract
resulting from this evaluation process.
NOTE: The provisions of this RFP that relate to commodity items (elec-
tricity, natural water/sewer) are structured in the same manner in
Figures 6.1 and 6.2, and the explanations will not be repeated here.
This RFP is the only one of the (3) detailed here that part of
its structure-energy services. This type of RFP for both electricity, natu-
ral and water/sewer commodity, well engineering services, is
the most frequently utilized structure in use at this time. The key to
satisfactory agreement of this type is that the customer understands the
energy services savings structure in detail.
The most important aspects to understand, well the most
confusing, are the energy services structure and savings calculations.
Before energy service projects are instituted, the customer has to under-
stand and approve the specific projects well their structure and
impact potentially on employees, products, services provided, quality,
length of pay-back and/or other customer specific criteria.
Energyservicesagreementsstartwith evaluation of
customer’s facilities for potential energy savings opportunities. Gener-
ally these evaluations start with simple walk-through analysis the
customer’s facilities. If opportunities are found andagreed upon by both
the customer well the potential energy services provider, at least
to the viability of the opportunities, more detailed analysis is required.
Generally there will be no cost to the customer for the simple walk-
www.engbookspdf.com
through analysis. As potential energy savings opportunities are agreed-
to by both parties, much more detailed evaluations will be required.
These evaluations, because of their complexity and time requirements,
will incur cost to someone. The best way to structure the cost for the
comprehensive evaluations is to attempt to structure an agreement simi-
lar to the following example that is fair to both the customer as well
to the potential provider.
www.engbookspdf.com
Are savings tied to current utility rates? If so, how are utility rate
changes factored into actual vs. projected savings?
How are changes in utility usage levels factored into projected sav-
ings levels? What if usage is increased? What if usage is reduced?
What if utility usage characteristics change-first shift vs. second
and third shifts, 5 days week vs. 6 or 7 days week?
5. Are there provisions early buy-out options? If so, are they real-
istic insofar penalties are concerned?
www.engbookspdf.com
Wheeling
HOW TO STRUCTURE
AN ELECTRICITY COMMODITY
PURCHASE (RETAIL WHEELING) CONTRACT
Now that the various forms of RFPs have been analyzed, the next
step in the process is contract with the selected provider. Following in
Figure 6.4 is outlined typical contract that can be altered in three sepa-
rate configurations.
www.engbookspdf.com
128 Wheelinx Retail Electricity
Between
www.engbookspdf.com
Wheeling Sale
l
Cover Sheet
Index
Definitions
2. Purchase and Sale
3. Term of Agreement
5. Deliveries 9
7. Transmission Agreements
8. Title to Wheeled Electricity 11
9. Force Majeure 11
Notices 12
11. Miscellaneous 13
Signatory Page 14
Acknowledgments 14
Exhibit “ A (Point of Usage) 15
Exhibit “B” (Point of Delivery) 15
Exhibit “ C Fee) 15
www.engbookspdf.com
Retailed Wheeled Electricity Sale Agreement
By and Between:
Definitions.
1.3
serving electric utility.
2. Purchaseand Sale.
www.engbookspdf.com
BUYER may use any volume for any specific month or months.
3. Term of Agreement.
OPTION l - A
www.engbookspdf.com
Wheelin2
Generally, the fixed price method is more costly than the spot
market method because the supplier has to speculate on what the cost of
wheeled electricity will be at some point in the future. Fixed price con-
tracts are generally for or 12 months. The longer the term, the more
uncertain is the cost of wheeled electricity. Unless for some reason,
known wheeled electricity cost is required on month-by-month basis
for some future period of time, it is less costly to utilize the spot market
or monthly pricing scenario for wheeled electricity purchases. If fixed
wheeled electricity price is required, then it is best to utilize some bench-
mark to at least make the process logical and not pure speculation.
One of the most readily accessible electricity price indices is the ”D.
J. Electricity Price Index” which is found daily in The Wall Street Journal
in the Money and Investment Section. This electricity price data is gen-
erally located adjacent to the Futures price sheets.
The electricity prices in this index represent actual weighted aver-
age prices for electricity traded atvarious delivery points in the power
www.engbookspdf.com
pool regions. Prices are quoted in dollars per megawatt and are for Firm
Delivery-on- and off-peak, and for Non-Firm Delivery (interruptible)-
on- and off- peak. Although not all delivery points on all power pools
are currently listed in this index, retail wheeling becomes more widely
available, more delivery points will be developed.
Remember, if any index is utilized, it will only include the com-
modity (electricity) at point of generation or delivered to common
transmission power pool point. Added to the costs shown in an index
will be the agent’s fee, the transmission costs to the wheeling customer’s
serving utility receipt point, and the serving utility’s specific costs in-
cluding distribution, transformation and miscellaneous customer fees.
OPTION l - B
www.engbookspdf.com
Retail
OPTION l - C
Electricity Commodity Only
METER POINT PRICING-FIXED DISCOUNT
4-C. 1 Thefixeddiscountshallbecalculatedbasedupon
total use point meter electricity cost at time of
contract signing and will be adjusted monthly during the
term of this contract to reflect any changes that would occur
in the use point electricity meter cost if this fixed
discount contract were not in effect.
OPTION l - D
Electricity Commodity Only
METER POINT PRICING-
FIXED DISCOUNT WITH SHARED SAVINGS
www.engbookspdf.com
at time of contract signing, and will be adjusted monthly
during the term of this contract to reflect any changes that
would occur in point meter electricity cost
if this fixed discount with shared savings contract were not
in effect.
OPTION l - E
Electricity Commodity Only
METER POINT PRICING-
SHARED SAVINGS WITH NO FIXED DISCOUNT
Page
www.engbookspdf.com
136 Retail Electricity Wheeling
Sale
OPTION l-F
5. Deliveries.
www.engbookspdf.com
6.2 Monthly billings will be made based on the monthly quantities
ordered by BUYER pursuant to Section 2 and corrections to
billings (if any) will be reflected in the next billing rendered after
the need for correction is discovered. Payment (or credit) for
corrected monthly billings will be made or reflected in the next
due payment. Corrections will not be made more than one (1)
year after the original billing date.
6.3 BUYER shall pay all amounts due less any penalties incurred
by incorrect order quantities which would result in
serving utility company penalties, surcharges and/or supplying
of tariff electricity, natural gas, waterkewer at a cost in excess
of what could have been purchased under provisions of this
contract.
6.4 The interest equal to prime rate at the Escrow Bank plus two
percent (2%) per annum shall be paid on all late payments.
BUYER shall, in addition, be responsible for paying for collec-
tion costs and reasonable attorney fees incurred by SELLER in
its efforts to collect delinquent payments.
6.5 If failure to pay shall continue for ten days after receipt of
a billing by BUYER, SELLERmay, in addition to any other
remedies available, suspend further deliveries to BUYER until
all amounts due are paid.
Page 10
www.engbookspdf.com
mutually satisfactory credit arrangements are made, SELLER
may terminate this Agreement without further obligation here-
under.
Transmission Agreements.
9. Force Majeure.
9.1 All obligations of the parties to this Agreement (except for the
payment of money for wheeled electricity, natural gas, water/
sewer delivered) shall be suspended while and for so long as
compliance is prevented in whole or in part by an act of God,
strike, lockout, war, civil disturbance, explosion, breakage, ac-
cident, federal, state or local law, inability to secure materials
or right-of-way, or permits or approvals or licenses, binding
order of a Court or Governmental Agency, the failure, inability
or refusal of any or serving utility to accept wheeled electricity,
natural gas, watedsewer for delivery, or otherwise transport,
the default of any part to Other Contracts (other than BUYER
or SELLER), or by any other cause beyond the reasonable
control of BUYER or SELLER.
www.engbookspdf.com
The
SELLER BUYER
Payments Payments
Name Name
Address Address
Attention Attention
Correspondences Correspondences
www.engbookspdf.com
140
Sale
11.5 This Agreement shall be binding upon and shall inure to the
benefit of the parties hereto, there respective heirs, succes-
sors and assigns.
13
www.engbookspdf.com
EXECUTED
SELLER
BY
Title
BUYER
BY
Title
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
SELLER
of STATE
County
State
My Commission Expires
BUYER
STATE of of COUNTY
My Commission Expires
www.engbookspdf.com
EXHIBIT “A”
POINT OF USAGE
Company Name:
Serving Utility:
EXHIBIT “B”
POINT OF DELIVERY
(To be completed by SELLER)
Transmission Grid
Point of Delivery:
All interconnect points on:
Transmission Grid
EXHIBIT “C”
AGENT’S FEE
(Used with Options 4-A and 4-B only.)
Fee per unit delivered from generation point to serving utility receipt
point will be-
per MW/kWh
Page 15
www.engbookspdf.com
EXPLANATION FIGURE 6.4 CONTRACT TERMS
Definitions
1.1 “Demand”
This item identifies the measurement criteria to be used for
delivery of the electricity. Demand is measured in kVA/kW.
1.2 “Usage”
This item identifies the measurement of megawatt-hours/
kilowatt-hours and is function of connected electrical load,
times hours in use. Usage is measured in MW/kWh.
Purchaseand Sale-
The six paragraphs contained in this section constitute the Agree-
ment between the SELLER and BUYER (customer) in its entirety. It
outlines the conditions for acceptance of wheeled electricity and
limits the BUYERS responsibility to the SELLER.
www.engbookspdf.com
2.2 “Agreement setting forth the BUYERS optionsrelating to
wheeled electricity volumes delivered.”
The BUYER has the right to purchase all electricity used
set forth in 2.1 above.
Term of Agreement-
This section defines the Agreement time boundaries both beginning
and ending.
Two pricing methods are provided: “Fixed Price” and ”Spot Market
Price.” The Fixed Price Method is detailed following:
www.engbookspdf.com
4A.1 “Wheeledelectricitypriceperspecified quantity(MW/
kwh).”
This item sets the agreed-upon price for the wheeled electric-
ity during the term of the Agreement.
www.engbookspdf.com
The price established in 4A.1 applies to all wheeled electric-
ity delivered by the SELLER. This clause is important since
its utilization means that the SELLER cannot change the
wheeled electricity costs because of monthly usage varia-
tions. (Always have this provision in the contract.)
www.engbookspdf.com
the SELLERS responsibility to pay any sales, local, utility or
other taxes. Also, it is not their responsibility to pay for any
transmission handling or distribution charges after transfer
of title to the BUYER occurs. (Title transfer is detailed in 8.1)
“Fixed Discount.”
This option is different from either 4-A or 4-B in that it is
addressing fixed discount from the entire use point meter
cost not just the electricity commodity cost. This type of dis-
count and 4-D, 4-E and 4-F following consider the entire
electricity cost so that the commodity cost becomes simply
part of the total overall cost reduction process.
www.engbookspdf.com
Assume situation where the total meter point cost of elec-
tricity is $.OG/kWh and the electricity commodity portion of
this total cost is $.02/kWh. In this scenario, would 10%
discount on electricity commodity cost be better than
discount on the entire meter point cost?
"Buyer will pay all state and local sales, use and public util-
ity taxes, etc."
Buyer will be required to pay any/all sales, local and/or
utility taxes the same they do on their bundled tariff rate
schedule through their serving utility.
www.engbookspdf.com
change the electricity costs because of monthly usage varia-
tions. (Always have this provision in the contract.)
www.engbookspdf.com
This option is the same Option 4-C except there are no
fixed or guaranteed savings associated with it. Again, if
more risk is acceptable,this option has the potential to result
in greater bottom line savings than either Option 4-A, 4-B, 4-
C or 4-D.
www.engbookspdf.com
The contractual agreement for this type of arrangement is
highly individualized depending upon both the customer’s,
well the provider’s needs. There is no ”standard” con-
tract language for these types of arrangements, but there are
some generally items that should be considered by the cus-
tomer they develop the contract guidelines.
A. Pay-back periods for energy service projects and meth-
ods to quantify savings.
B. Guideline qualifications for energy service projects.
C. Rationalization criteria for energy service projects.
D. Maximumcontracttermbetweentheparties (6-10
years typically).
Contract language with respectto:
Increased/decreased electricity, natural and
water/sewer usages.
2. Added/deleted customer facilities.
3. Change in electricity, natural and water/sewer
usage patterns.
4. Individual customer facility input into approving/
rejecting energy service projects.
Contracts of this type are only successful if both parties
want to establish long-term partnership with each
other. No matter what contract does or does not ad-
dress, it is no better than the parties good faith in want-
ing to have honest arrangement that is beneficial to
each of them.
www.engbookspdf.com
This item sets forth the billing periods, in this case and nor-
mally-monthly.
6.2 “Monthly billing amount computation.”
This item details what shall constitute monthly billing
amount.
“6.3 ”Payments of amounts due by BUYER.
This item outlines the time parameters agreed-to by both the
SELLER and BUYER for payment of monthly billings by the
SELLER. Also, identified are those items that the BUYER
may deduct from the payment due, caused by the SELLERS
incorrect nomination procedures. (Always have this provi-
sion in its contract.)
“Delinquent payment charges.”
The interest penalty amount and the SELLER’S legal re-
course in the case of delinquent payments by theBUYER are
outlined here.
”Suspension of delivery for delinquent payments.”
Detailed here is the SELLERS recourse in the event of non-
payment in excess of specified period of time by the
BUYER.
6.6 ”Determination of credit worthiness ofBUYER.”
This item covers any special provisions that might be neces-
sitated due to an unusual credit circumstance of BUYER.
Before any provisions can be attached to this item, they must
be mutually agreeable to by both parties.
This section covers where the BUYER wants the wheeled electricity
delivered and outlines the BUYER’S responsibility in assisting the
SELLER in obtaining the transmission Agreement.
*8
*8.1 “When title passes to BUYER.”
This item defines when title passes to the BUYER. Also,
when the BUYER becomes responsible for taxes and other
costs (when title passes from SELLER to BUYER). Title
passes at 3 distinct locations-(l) electricity generation meter
point, natural wellhead point, (2) serving utility receipt
meter point, and BUYER’S electricity usage meter point.
www.engbookspdf.com
Generally, the best place for title to pass from the BUYER’S
viewpoint is at the electricity/natural serving utility re-
ceipt point. This is because state sales tax normally is not
charged on the portion of the transaction from the electricity
generation to the serving utility receipt meter point if title
passes to the BUYER at the electricity generation location.
For BUYERS in states that levy sales tax on electricity pur-
chases, title pass point is an important consideration. (Al-
ways have this provision in the contract.)
www.engbookspdf.com
“Benefit of this contract.”
This details the intended beneficiaries of the Agreement
”Entirety of Agreement.”
This item states that the Agreement signed by the SELLER
and BUYER is complete written with unattached side
clauses or agreements.
Acknowledgments Page-
Both parties are identified by company and name and the signa-
tures of the responsible parties are notarized in the SELLER’S and
BUYERS individual locations. When both parties properly sign this page
and notarized it, the Agreement becomes binding upon both parties.
www.engbookspdf.com
Exhibit "A"-
This exhibit identifies the point-of-use of the wheeled electricity
contracted for and the serving utility who will deliver the wheeled elec-
tricity to the BUYER.
Exhibit "B"-
This exhibit identifies the points-of-delivery by the SELLER to the
transporting transmission grid. It also identifies the receiving transmis-
sion grid that would deliver the wheeled electricity to the serving utility.
*Exhibit "C"-
This exhibit requires the SELLER to list their fees per unit of elec-
tricity delivered to the BUYER. This is an important exhibit to the
BUYER since the SELLERS charge effects the overall cost of the wheeled
electricity to BUYER. Many wheeled electricity SELLERS do not like this
provision but should provide the required information if the BUYER is
insistent. (Always have this exhibit part of the contract.)
HOW TO BE ASSUREDTHATTHECONTRACTWILLSERVETHE
NEEDS OF THE WHEELED ELECTRICITY BUYER
www.engbookspdf.com
wheeled electricity delivered. It includes-(l) electricity, (2) inter-
state transmission grid transportation and line loss, and (3) serving
utility intrastate distribution grid transportation and line loss. This
is the buyer use point meter cost and will be the one to use in de-
termining savings.
Always obtain quotes and terms from more than one seller and
compare them to see if one is more favorable than the other.
After doing the other six steps in this questioning exercise, do what
is probably the most important step-find seller you will feel
comfortable working with and one that will sincerely wants your
business. If the right seller is selected, they will be able to provide
much insight and assistance in all steps of this wheeled electricity
process.
www.engbookspdf.com
www.engbookspdf.com
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
www.engbookspdf.com
Cbupter
Where Do We
Go Here?
www.engbookspdf.com
Electricity Commodity and Engineering Services Agreements
Electricity commodity and engineering services agreements will
require customer commitments that are longer than for electricity com-
modity only. Because of engineering services pay-back periods, agree-
ments for electricity commodity and engineering services will typically
be for time period from 5 to years.
Since electricity commodity and engineering services do extend for
many years, make certain that you will feelcomfortable with the selected
provider over period of years. Also make certain, to the extent possible,
that the contract language adequately addresses any questions that could
effect the long-term benefits of the agreement.
www.engbookspdf.com
ment process and content than do you the customer. Whether this is
true or not, the fact remains that generally the customer will get what
they ask or negotiate for. No more and no less!
Following are the steps that should be considered by any customer
that expects to have satisfactory relationship with provider over time:
Recognize that you the customer must set the agenda for any
potential provider meetings.
Potential providers will be willing to discuss many options and
strategies but the customer will be the primary mover in the process. It
will also be the customer’s responsibility to document, schedule and
follow-up on the process. It is best to have definite method of action
planned before ever entering into dialogue with any potential provider.
A structure follows in Figure 7.1 could be utilized if appropriate.
The total time that typically elapses between Items l.A. and 3.C. is
from 9 to months. While this may seem to be an inordinately long
period of time, there are many things to determine and people to be
involved. Since the time period is lengthy, it is critical to the success of
the process to keep all of the involved parties updated on at least
monthly basis. this responsibility falls to the customer, not the
provider. A time period might be follows in Figure 7.2.
A successful arrangement between customer and provider
whether for an Electricity Commodity Only Contract or for Electricity
Commodity and Engineering Services Contract is to great extent de-
pendent upon the customer’s input to the process. To assist customer
they try to figure out what to do to make the process valuable
possible, the list following in Figure 7.3 is given.
This list is intended to serve general guide to things that any
customer should at least consider before doing anything with potential
provider of wheeled electricity commodity/services. This list will not
answer all questions, but it can raise the right questions that might oth-
erwise have been overlooked.
After reading this chapter, you may feel that the effort required to
achieve cost reductions through retail wheeling processes is more trouble
than it is worth.If this is your feeling, you are not alone, but with any
new endeavor, there is uncertainty and misunderstanding initially.
The thing to remember is that time passes, there will be more
and more requirements for individual participation in electricity procure-
www.engbookspdf.com
CUSTOMER RESPONSIBILITIES POTENTIAL PROVIDER
RESPONSIBILITIES
1. RFPProcess
Contract/Post-Contract Process
www.engbookspdf.com
DevelopRFPScopeandLanguage
1-3 Months
www.engbookspdf.com
CUSTOMER CHECKLIST
7. Is “cheapest” least expensive in the long run? How do you decide this?
10. Is what the potential provider receives in the contract realistic in terms
of what you receive? Can you measure this? If not, why not?
11. What happens if your utility usage changes-Up? Down? Hours used?
Days used? Characteristics of use?
12. Are cost reduction guarantees in the contract? If so, can you quantify
them? Do your financial people agree with the quantification rationale?
13. Are there early contract opt-outs and if so, are they fair to both par-
ties?
www.engbookspdf.com
14. What happens if guaranteed savings are not achieved? Who makes up
the deficit? Is contract cancelable if guaranteed savings do not mate-
rialize?
15. Have your company financial and legal entities been involved in all
aspects of the RFP contract process? Do they understand its financial
and legal implications?
16. Have all people that will be involved/affected been included during the
entire RFP/contract process so they buy into the process?
ment and pricing. There may be time, not to distant in the future,
where an electricity customer will have choice except to select their
own provider or have some third party do it for them. If you learn the
process correctly now, you will be much better prepared for the deregu-
lated future that awaits all electricity users, even residential customers.
www.engbookspdf.com
These companies may be unregulated affiliates of for-profit electric
utilities or they may be independent non-utility affiliated companies.
These companies sometimes are regional in their scope of activity and
sometimes are national in scope.
The first place to investigate is your serving electric utility. Find out
whether they have an unregulated services group (ESCO) that might
have an interest in partnering with you in your effort to reduce your
electricity costs. Many times these (ESCO) groups will have real inter-
est in working with you to reduce your electricity well general
energy costs. Even if your local utility (ESCO) has an interest in working
with you, it is good to investigate more than one supplier.
To help you in this, Figure 7.4 is following with the names and
telephone numbers of 70 different (ESCO) type companies. The compa-
nies in this list are both utility and non-utility affiliated. There are large
and small companies represented. There are no "best" or "worst" com-
panies in this list, but these are ones that may be better for specific
purpose, location or financial consideration. I do not purport that this is
complete or comprehensive list or isevery "good" company listed. This
list is simply included place to start your investigation for potential
providers. Most of these companies provide the following services:
Construction management.
Electricity commodity marketing.
3. Design engineering.
4. Shared savings/performance arrangements.
New construction services.
6. Retrofit services.
Project financing.
www.engbookspdf.com
Custom Energy LLC
Aguila Energy
-D-
Alliant Industrial Services
DTE Energy
Energis Resources
-C-
www.engbookspdf.com
ER1 Services -J-
Johnson Controls
EUA Cogenex Corporation
Evantage -K-
Landis Staefa
-G-
www.engbookspdf.com
SCANA Energy Marketing
-V-
ProSolutions
Viron Energy Services
-Q-
QST Westar
-R/S- -WIZ-
www.engbookspdf.com
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
www.engbookspdf.com
Appendix A
REGULATORY AGENCIES
www.engbookspdf.com
1400 Independence Avenue SW
Washington, 20250
Tel.202-720-9540
Fax 202-720-1725
http://www.rus.usda.gov
www.engbookspdf.com
A
10 Franklin Square
New Britain, CT 06051
Tel. 860-827-1553,
47 Trinity Avenue
Atlanta, GA 30334
Tel. 404-656-4501, http://www.psc.state.ga.us
www.engbookspdf.com
465 South King Street
Honolulu, HI 96813
Tel.808-586-2020
www.engbookspdf.com
http://www.state.me.us/mpuc/
MD
http://www.psc.state.md.us/psc/
http://www.magnet.state.ma.us/dpu/
MI
http://ermisweb.cis.state.mi.us/mpsc
MN
Tel.
19th
MS
http://www.mslawyer.com/mpsc/mpsc.html.
www.engbookspdf.com
Truman State Office Building
Jefferson City, MO 65102
Tel. 572-751-3234, http://www.ecodeve.state.mo.us/psc/
1200 N Street
NE 68509
Tel. 402-471-3101
http://www.nol.org/home/npsc
Suncook
Concord, NH 03301,
Tel.603-271-2442
http://www.state.nh.us/puc/puc.html
PO Box 1269
Santa Fe, NM 87504
Tel. 505-827-4500
www.engbookspdf.com
A 177
PO Box 3265
Harrisburg, PA 17105
Tel.717-783-1740,
http: /www.state.pa.us/PA-Exec/Public-Utility,
Puc.paonline.com
www.engbookspdf.com
Wheelina
www.engbookspdf.com
Appendix A 179
Tyler Building
kchmond, VA 23218
Tel. 804-371-9967, http://www.state,va.us/scc
www.engbookspdf.com
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
www.engbookspdf.com
B
Listing o f
For-Profit Utilities
Listed in this section are the for-profit electric utilities or investor
owned utilities (IOU’s). These electric utilities, listed state-by-state, gen-
erate in excess 75% of all electricityused in the United States. Included
in this listing are the utility companies’ telephone numbers and the web
site numbers, when available.
ALABAMA
ALASKA
181
www.engbookspdf.com
787
ARIZONA
www.engbookspdf.com
B 183
Tel. 501-377-4000
http:/ /www.entergy.com
Tel. 501-954-5000
http://www.entergy.com
Tel. 405-553-3000
http://www.oge.com
Tel.318-673-3000
http://www.csw.com/ele/swep/swep.html
Tel. 415-973-7000
http: www.pge.com
Tel.503-464-5000
http://www.pacificorp.com
Tel.619-696-2000
http://www.sdge.com
Tel.626-302-1212
http://www.sce.com
www.engbookspdf.com
284 Electricity Retail Wheeling
COLORADO
CONNECTICUT
DELAWARE
DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
www.engbookspdf.com
B 185
FLORIDA
GEORGIA
HAWAII
www.engbookspdf.com
Hawaii Electric Light Company
Tel.808-935-1171
http://www.hei.com/heco/heco.html
IDAHO
Avista Corporation
Tel. 509-489-0500
http://www.avistacorp.com
PacificCorp
Tel. 503-464-5000
http://www.pacificorp.com
ILLINOIS
AmerenCIPS
Tel.217-523-3600
http://www.ameren.com
AmerenUE
Tel.314-621-3222
http:/ /www.ameren.com
www.engbookspdf.com
B 187
INDIANA
www.engbookspdf.com
188 Retail Electricity Wheeling
IOWA
KANSAS
www.engbookspdf.com
189
KENTUCKY
LOUISIANA
Cleco Corporation
Tel.318-484-7400
http://www.cleco.com
www.engbookspdf.com
Entergy Gulf States, Inc.
Tel.409-838-6631
http://www.entergy.com
MAINE
MARYLAND
www.engbookspdf.com
B
Tel. 302-429-3011
http://www.delmarva.com
Tel.301-790-3400
http: www.alleghenypower.com
Tel.202-872-2000
/www.pepco.com
Tel.888-423-2364
http://www.eua.com
Tel.617-424-2000
http: www.bedison.com
Tel.617-225-4000
http:/ /www.cornenergy.com
Tel. 508-291-0950
http://www.comelectric.com
Tel.617-357-9590
http://www.eua.com
Tel.888-301-7700
http://www.unitil.com/Profile/fitchbrg.htm
www.engbookspdf.com
Wheeling
Tel. 508-389-2000
http://www.nees.com
Tel. 508-389-2000
http://www.nees.com
Tel. 617-357-9590
http://www.eua.com
Tel. 413-785-5871
http: /www.nu.com
Tel.517-357-2293
Tel.517-788-0550
http://www.cpco.com
Tel. 313-235-8000
http:/ /www.detroitedison.com
Tel. 906-632-2221
http://www.eselco.com
Tel.219-425-2111
http://www.aep.com
Tel.906-487-5000
http://www.wpsr.com
www.engbookspdf.com
B
Tel. 414-221-2345
http://www.wisconsinelectric.com
Tel.920-433-1598
http://www.wpsr.com
Tel.319-582-5421
http: wwwinterstate-power.com
Tel.218-722-2641
http://www.mnpower.com
Tel.612-330-5500
http://www.nspco.com
Tel.218-739-8200
http://www.otpco.com
Tel.601-969-2311
http://www.entergy.com
Tel.228-864-1211
http://www.mispower.com
www.engbookspdf.com
MISSOURI
AmerenUE
Tel.314-621-3222
http://www.ameren.com
MONTANA
Avista Corporation
Tel. 509-489-0500
http://www.avistacorp.com
www.engbookspdf.com
B 195
Tel. 503-464-5000
http://www.pacificorp.com
Tel.702-367-5000
http: www.nevadapower.com
702-728-4422
Tel.775-834-3600
http:/ /www.sierrapacific.com
Tel. 802-773-2711
http://www.cvps.com
Tel. 800-852-3339
http://www.unitil.com/Profiles/concord.htm
Tel.603-543-3188
http:/ /www.cvx.com
Tel. 800-582-7276
http:/ /www.unitil.com/Profile/exeter.htm
www.engbookspdf.com
Granite State Electric Company
Tel.603-448-0363
http:/ /www.nees.com
NEW JERSEY
NEWMEXICO
www.engbookspdf.com
197
NEW YORK
www.engbookspdf.com
NORTH CAROLINA
NORTH DAKOTA
OHIO
www.engbookspdf.com
Tel.216-622-9800
http://www.illuminatingco.com
Tel.614-223-1000
http://www.aep.com
Tel. 937-224-6000
http://www.waytogo.com
Tel.330-384-5100
http://www.ohioedison.com
Tel. 330-456-8173
http://www.aep.com
Tel. 419-249-5000
http:/ /www.firstenergy.corp.com
Tel.417-625-5100
http://www.empiredistrict.com
Tel. 405-553-3000
http://www.oge.com
Tel.918-599-2000
http://www.csw.com/ele/pso/pso.html
www.engbookspdf.com
Southwestern Public Service Company
Tel.
http://www.ncenergies.com
OREGON
PacificCorp
Tel.
http: www.pacificorp.com
PENNSYLVANIA
www.engbookspdf.com
Pennsylvania Electric Company
Tel. 610-929-3601
http://www.gpu.com
PP&L, Inc.
Tel.610-774-5151
http: www.papl.com
RHODE ISLAND
www.engbookspdf.com
Block Island Power Company
Tel. 401-466-5851
SOUTH CAROLINA
SOUTH DAKOTA
www.engbookspdf.com
MidAmerican Energy Company
Tel. 515-281-4300
http://www.midamerican.com
TENNESSEE
TEXAS
www.engbookspdf.com
El Paso Electric Company
Tel. 915-543-5711
http://www.whc.net/epec/
PacifiCorp
Tel. 503-464-5000
http://www.pacificorp.com
www.engbookspdf.com
05
UTAH
PacifiCorp
Tel.503-464-5000
http://www.pacificorp.com
VERMONT
VIRGINIA
www.engbookspdf.com
Delmarva Power Light Company
Tel.302-429-3011
http://www.delmarva.com
WASHINGTON
Avista Corporation
Tel. 509-489-0500
http://www.avistacorp.com
PacifiCorp
Tel. 503-464-5000
http:/ /www.pacificorp.com
WEST VIRGINIA
www.engbookspdf.com
Monongahela Power Company
Tel.301-790-1766
http:/ /www.alleghenypower.com
WISCONSIN
www.engbookspdf.com
http://www.wpl.com/wplh/subs/sbwgl.html
/www.wisconsinelectric.com
http://www.wpsc.wpsr.com
/www.blackhillspower.com
www.engbookspdf.com
B
PacifiCorp
Tel. 503-464-5000
http://www.pacificorp.com
www.engbookspdf.com
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
www.engbookspdf.com
Appendix
Table 1 State Regulatory Agencies That Regulate Rates On Retail Sales to End-
Users
Table 3 State Regulatory Agencies That Require Uniform Practices For Electric
Billing Format
Table 4 State Regulatory Agencies That Do Not Require Uniform Practices For
Electric Billing Format
Table 5 State Regulatory Agencies That Allow Electric Utilities To Offer Tariffs
Designed To Promote Sales Of Electricity For Specific End-Users
Table 7 State Regulatory Agencies that have the Authority to Determine the
Rate of Return for For-Profit Electric Utilities
www.engbookspdf.com
Table 8 StateRegulatory Agencies That Allow Interruptible Rate Tariffs For
Commercial Electricity Customers
Table 9 State Regulatory Agencies That Do Not Allow Interruptible Rate Tar-
iffs For Commercial Electricity Customers
Table State Regulatory Agencies That Do Not Allow Interruptible Rate Tar-
iffs For Industrial Electricity Customers
FOR-PROFIT
I. ELECTRIC
UTILITIES
All states, except-
Nebraska PUC which has for-profit utilities
11. MUNICIPAL
ELECTRIC
UTILITIES
PUC New Hampshire PUC
Connecticut DPUC (limited) New York PSC
Washington DC PSC Pennsylvania PUC
Florida PSC Rhode Island PUC
Indiana URC Texas PUC
Kansas SCC West Virginia PSC
Maine PUC Wisconsin PSC
Maryland PS Wyoming PSC
Mississippi PSC
111. COOPERATIVEELECTRICUTILITIES
Alaska PUC Mississippi PSC
Arizona CC New Hampshire PUC
Arkansas PSC New Jersey BPU
Delaware PSC New Mexico PUC
Washington DC PSC New York PSC
www.engbookspdf.com
C
FOR-PROFIT
I. ELECTRIC
UTILITIES
All states, except-
Nebraska PSC
New Mexico SCC
11. MUNICIPAL
ELECTRIC
UTILITIES
Alaska PUC New Jersey BPU
Iowa PUC New York PSC
Kansas SCC North PSC
Kentucky PSC Rhode Island PUC
Maine PUC Utah PSC
Maryland PSC Vermont PSB
Massachusetts DPU West Virginia PSC
Montana PSC Wisconsin PSC
New Hampshire PUC Wyoming PSC
111. COOPERATIVEELECTRICUTILITIES
Alaska PUC Colorado PUC
Arizona CC Delaware PSC
Arkansas PSC Indiana URC
California PUC Iowa UB
www.engbookspdf.com
Kansas SCC New Mexico PUC
Kentucky PSC North Dakota PSC
Louisiana PSC Oklahoma CC
Maine PUC Texas PUC
Maryland PSC Utah PSC
Michigan PSC Vermont PSB
Minnesota PUC Virginia SCC
Mississippi PSC West Virginia PSC
Nevada PSC Wyoming PSC
New Hampshire PUC
Washington DC PSC
Florida PSC
Illinois CC
Nevada PSC
Ohio PUC
Tennessee PSC
www.engbookspdf.com
Alabama PSC Minnesota PUC
Arizona CC Mississippi PSC
Arkansas PSC Missouri PSC
Delaware PSC New Hampshire PUC
Washington DC PSC New Jersey BPU
Florida PSC New Mexico PUC
Illinois CC Ohio PUC
Indiana URC Oklahoma CC
Kansas SCC Pennsylvania PUC
Kentucky PSC South Dakota PUC
Louisiana PSC Tennessee PSC
Maine PUC Virginia SCC
Maryland PSC Wyoming PSC
Massachusetts DPU
www.engbookspdf.com
Alabama PSC Missouri PSC
Alaska PUC Montana PSC
Arizona CC Nevada PSC
Arkansas PSC New Hampshire PUC
California PUC New Jersey BPU
Colorado PUC New Mexico PUC
Connecticut DPUC New York PSC
Delaware PSC New Carolina UC
Washington DC PSC North Dakota PSC
Florida PSC Ohio PUC
Georgia PSC Oklahoma CC
Hawaii PUC Oregon PUC
Idaho PUC Pennsylvania PUC
Illinois CC Rhode Island PUC
Indiana URC South Carolina PSC
Iowa UB South Dakota PUC
Kansas SCC Tennessee PSC
Kentucky PSC Texas PUC
Louisiana PSC Utah PSC
Maine PUC Vermont PSB
Maryland PSC Virginia SCC
Massachusetts DPU Washington UTC
Michigan West Virginia PSC
Minnesota PUC Wisconsin PSC
Mississippi PSC Wyoming PSC
www.engbookspdf.com
Arizona CC Nevada PSC
California PUC New Hampshire PUC
Colorado PUC New Jersey BPU
Connecticut DPUC New Mexico PUC
Delaware PSC New York PSC
Washington DC PSC North Carolina UC
Florida PSC North Dakota PSC
Georgia PSC Ohio PUC
Hawaii PUC Oklahoma CC
Illinois CC Pennsylvania PUC
Iowa UB Rhode Island PUC
Kansas SCC South Carolina PSC
Maine PUC South Dakota PUC
Massachusetts DPU Virginia SCC
Michigan PSC Washington UTC
Minnesota PUC Wisconsin PSC
Missouri PSC Wyoming PSC
Montana PSC
www.engbookspdf.com
For
Not
For
Washington DC PSC
Tennessee PSC
www.engbookspdf.com
Appendix D
www.engbookspdf.com
Accelerated Depreciation. Accounting methodallowingcompanyto
write-off more quickly in early years, with progressively smaller
increments in later years.
www.engbookspdf.com
Allocation of Costs. See Cost Allocation.
www.engbookspdf.com
Automated Mapping/Facilities Management (AM/FM). Digitized geo-
graphic maps on which is shown the infrastructure of interest (such
location and type of utility poles, transmission lines, substations,
generating plant, etc.)
Average Demand. The demand on, or power output of, an electric sys-
tem over any interval of time, determined by dividing the total
number of kilowatt-hours by the number of units of time in the
interval.
Avoided Cost. The cost an electric utility would otherwise incur to gen-
erate power if it did not purchase electricity from another source.
Also the basis of the rate required to be paid to QFs (Qualifying
Facilities) for purchased power under PURPA (Public Utility Regu-
latory Policy Act of 1978).
www.engbookspdf.com
D
Base Bill. A charge calculated by taking the rate from the appropriate
electric rate schedule and applying it to the level of consumption.
Base Load Capacity. Generating capacity which serves the base load,
usually the utility’s largest, most efficient facilities with the lowest
operating cost.
Base Rate. A fixed per kilowatt-hour charge for electricity consumed that
is independent of other charges and/or adjustments.
www.engbookspdf.com
combustion source is transmitted to fluid contained within the
tubes in the boiler shell. This fluid is delivered to an end-user at
desired pressure, temperature, and quality.
British Thermal Unit (Btu). The standard unit for measuring quantity of
heat energy. The amount of heat energy needed to raise the tem-
perature of one pound of water one degree Fahrenheit.
Broker. A retail agent who buys and sells power. The agent may also
aggregate customers and arrange for transmission, firming and
other ancillary services as needed.
Bulk Power Supply. Often this term is used interchangeable with whole-
sale power supply. In broader terms, it refers to the aggregate of
electric generating plants, transmission lines, and related-equip-
ment. The term may refer to those facilities within one electric
utility, or within a group of utilities in which the transmission lines
are interconnected.
Bundled Rate. Several serviced combined into one tariff offering for
single charge. See also Unbundled Rate and Vertical Service.
Bus Bar. A conducting bar that carries heavy currents to supply several
electric circuits.
www.engbookspdf.com
D
-C-
Capacity Costs. Fixed costs of facilities required for the utility to provide
service.
Capitalized Costs. Costs are capitalized when they are expected to pro-
vide benefits over period longer than one year. Capitalized costs
are considered investments and are included in rate base to be re-
covered from customers over number of years.
www.engbookspdf.com
Census Divisions. The ten geographic divisions of the United States
established by the Bureau of the Census, U S Department of Com-
merce for statistical analysis. The boundaries of Census divisions
coincide with State boundaries.
Circuit Breaker. automatic switch that stops the flow electric cur-
rent in an overloaded or otherwise abnormally stressed electric cir-
cuit.
Coincidental Peak Load. The same of two or more peak loads that occur
in the same time interval.
www.engbookspdf.com
D
CombinedPumped-StoragePlant. A pumped-storagehydroelectric
power plant that uses both pumped water and natural streamflow
to produce electricity.
Common Costs. Costs incurred jointly for two more types of opera-
tions that must be allocated among the operations.
www.engbookspdf.com
Consumer Charge. An amount charged periodically to consumer for
such utility costs billing and meter reading, without regard to
demand or energy consumption.
Contract Path. The most direct physical transmission tie between two
interconnected entities. When utility systems interchange power,
the transfer is presumed to take place across the ”contract path,”
notwithstanding the electrical fact that power flow in the network
will distribute in accordance with network flow conditions. This
term can also mean to arrange for power transfer between systems.
www.engbookspdf.com
D
era1 income tax laws. Most electric cooperatives have initially been
financed by the Rural Electrification Administration, US Depart-
ment of Agriculture.
Costs. The amount paid to acquire resources, such plant and equip-
ment, fuel or labor services.
Cost of Service. A ratemaking concept used for the design and develop-
ment of rate schedules to ensure that the filed rate schedules re-
cover only the cost of providing the electric service at issue. These
costs include operating and maintenance expenses, depreciation
and amortization expenses, and income and other taxes found just
and reasonable by the regulatory agency for ratemaking purposes
plus, in the case of privately owned electric utilities, an allowance
for return on capital (usually computed by applying rate of
return to the rate base). This concept attempts to equate the cost
incurred by the utility to the revenue received for the service pro-
vided to each of the consumer classes.
www.engbookspdf.com
of the facilities needed to be served or the quantity of electricity the
customer uses.
Declining Block Rates. As more energy is consumed the unit price goes
down. For example, the first 500 kilowatt-hours cost 8 cents each;
the next block of 500 kwh is priced at 6 cents each; etc.
Deferred Fuel Costs. Those fuel costs spent in one accounting period
which are not reflected in billings to customers until later billing
period.
Deferred Tax Treatment. Actual taxes plus deferred taxes are included in
the income statement.
Demand Charge. That portion of the consumer’s bill for electric service
based on the consumer’s maximum electric capacity usage and
calculated based on the billing demand charges under the appli-
cable rate schedule.
www.engbookspdf.com
Demand Interval. The time period during which the flow of electricity
is measured (usually in 15-, 30-, or 60-minute increments.
Direct Load Control (DLC). When the utility has the ability to directly
control customer’s devices and can turn them on or off neces-
sary to control load.
www.engbookspdf.com
tion, dispatch/control, transmission, distribution). The terms
”deintegration,” ”disintegration” and ”delamination” are some-
times used to mean the same thing.
Distribution Line. For electricity, the line which carries electricity from
substation to the ultimate consumer.
Divestiture. The stripping offof one utility function from the others by
selling (spinning-off) or in some other way changing the ownership
of the assets related to that function. Most commonly associated
with spinning-off generation assets so they are no longer owned by
the shareholders that own the transmission and distribution assets.
www.engbookspdf.com
D
Dual-Fuel Plant. Any plant which can operate on either of two different
fuels, such coal or natural
www.engbookspdf.com
Electric Rate. The price set for specified amount of electricity in an
electric rate schedule or sales contract.
www.engbookspdf.com
D
Energy Charge. A component of rates which covers the cost of the en-
ergy actually used.
Energy Cost Adjustment clause. The utility may adjust its rates to offset
changes in the cost of fuel used to produce electricity. In some
states, these adjustments may be made automatically by the utility,
subject to Commission review; other states require an Adjustment
Clause Hearing first.
Equal Life Group Method of Depreciation. Utility plant items with the
same life expectancy are depreciated under common formula.
www.engbookspdf.com
Excess Deferred Taxes. When utility collects from its ratepayers some
portion of the income taxes it will owe in the future, the difference
between the amount collected (including future tax obligation) and
the amount of its current tax liability.
-F-
Fair Rate of Return. The rate of return utility is entitled to have the
opportunity to earn on either its rate base or its common equity.
Fair implies balancing keeping rates low for ratepayers, financial
integrity of the utility, and investment return for shareholders.
www.engbookspdf.com
D
Flat and Meter Rate Schedule. electric rate schedule consisting of two
components, the first of which is service charge, and the second
price for the energy consumed.
Flow-Through Tax Treatment. Only actual taxes to be paid for the period
are included in the income statement and collected from ratepayers.
Forecast Test Year. Use of future 12-month period projected utility finan-
cial data to evaluate proposed tariff revision.
www.engbookspdf.com
markets by the fact that forward contract is customized, non-ex-
change traded, and non-regulated hedging mechanism.
Fossil Fuel. Any fuel, such coal, oil and natural derived from the
remains of ancient plants or animals.
www.engbookspdf.com
D
Geothermal Energy. The natural heat available in the rocks, hot water
and steam of the earth’s subsurface. Geothermal energy can be
used to generate electric power.
www.engbookspdf.com
Gigawatt-hour (GWh). One billion watt-hours.
Historical Test Year. Use of past 12-month period (usually the imme-
diately preceding period) utility financial data to evaluate pro-
posed tariff revision.
Horsepower. unit for measuring the rate of work (or power) equiva-
lent to 33,000 foot-pounds per minute 746 watts.
www.engbookspdf.com
D
www.engbookspdf.com
Integrated Demand. The summation of the continuously varying instan-
taneous demand averaged over specified interval of time. The
information is usually determined by examining demand meter.
Interim Rates. Rates that are allowed to go into effect, usually subject to
refund and sometimes under bond, until the Commission issues its
final order.
www.engbookspdf.com
Internal Combustion Plant. A plant in which the prime mover is an
internal combustion engine. internal combustion enginehas
one or more cylinders in which the process of combustion takes
place, converting energy released from the rapid burning of fuel-
air mixture into mechanical energy. Diesel or gas-fired engines are
the principle types used in electric plants. The plant is usually
operated during periods of high demand for electricity.
Interruptible Rates. Special rates for energy consumers who are willing
to have their energy delivery service interrupted by the utility
when necessary. This is low-priority service with generally lower
unit rates.
Inverted Rate Structure. A rate design in which the unit price increases
with usage.
Joule. The International System unit of energy, equal to the work done
when current of one ampere is passed through resistance of one
ohm for one second. (To convert (1)joule into watt-hours, multiply
by 2.778 X 10-4.)
www.engbookspdf.com
Jurisdictional. Within thejurisdiction,orauthority,of particular
agency.
-K-
Load Factor. The ratio of the average load supplied during designated
period to the peak load occurring during that period.
www.engbookspdf.com
D 245
Marginal Cost. In the utility context, the cost to the utility of providing
the next (marginal) kilowatt-hour of electricity, irrespective of sunk
costs.
www.engbookspdf.com
Market-to-Book Ratio. Comparison of the market and book value of
stock. A one-to-one market-to-book ratio means the stock is selling
on the market at book value.
Master Metering. Installation one bulk power meter for multiple ten-
ants.
Maximum Demand. The greatest of all demands of the load that has
occurred within specified period of time.
www.engbookspdf.com
D 247
Natural Monopoly. A situation where one firm can produce given level
of output at lower total cost than can any combination of multiple
firms. Natural monopolies occur in industries which exhibit de-
creasing average long-run costs due to size (economies of scale).
According to economic theory, public monopoly governed by
regulation is justified when an industry exhibits natural monopoly
characteristics.
Net Generation. Gross generation minus plant use from all electric util-
ity owned plants. The energy required for pumping at pumped-
storage plant is regarded plant use and must be deducted from
the gross generation.
Net Original Cost. The original cost of utility property minus any accu-
mulated depreciation.
www.engbookspdf.com
Non-Discrimination. In general usage, reasonably equal treatment for
all.
www.engbookspdf.com
D 249
www.engbookspdf.com
Operating Unit or System. Complete and self-sustaining facility or
group of facilities acquired and operated intact.
Original Cost Method of Valuation. The cost of the property to the per-
son first devoting it to public service.
www.engbookspdf.com
-P-
Parallel Path Flow. AS defined by NERC, this refers to the flow of electric
power on electric system’s transmission facilities resulting from
scheduled electric power transfers between two other electric sys-
tems. (Electric power flows on all interconnected parallel paths in
amounts inversely proportional to each path’s resistance.)
Peak Load (or Peak Demand). The electric load that corresponds to
maximum level of electric demand in specified time period.
Peak Load Pricing. Pricing which reflects different prices for system
peak periods or for hours of the day during which loads are nor-
mally high.
www.engbookspdf.com
252 Electricitu
Handbook
Retail Wheelina
Peak Shaving. Means by which an electric utility lowers the peak de-
mand on its system.
www.engbookspdf.com
D
Plant Use. The electric energy used in the operation of plant. Included
in this definition is the energy required for pumping at pumped-
storage plants.
www.engbookspdf.com
(A). This is equivalent to 1 watt (W) for direct current system and
unit of apparent power is separated into real and reactive power.
Real power is the work-producing part of apparent power that
measures the rate of supply of energy and is denoted kilowatts
(kW). Reactive power is the portion of apparent power that does
no work and is referred to kilovars (kvar); this type of power
must be supplied to most types of magnetic equipment, such
motors, and is supplied by generator or by electrostatic equipment.
Voltamperes are
usually
divided by 1,000 and called
kilovoltamperes (kVA). Energy is denoted by the product of real
power and the length of time utilized; this product is expressed
kilowatt-hours (kwh).
www.engbookspdf.com
D 255
Prime Mover. The motive force that drives an electric generator (e.g.,
steam engine, turbine, or water wheel).
www.engbookspdf.com
256 Retail Electricity Wheeliny
-R-
Rate Base. Investment in operating plant, less depreciation, upon which
regulated utility is entitled to earn profit.
www.engbookspdf.com
D
Remaining Life. The expected future service life of an asset at any given
age.
www.engbookspdf.com
Renewables. Energy sources that in theory are indefinitely sustainable,
such solar energy, geothermal heat, hydropower and wind.
RenewableResources.Renewable energyresourcesarenaturally
replenishable, but flow-limited. They are virtually inexhaustible in
duration but limited in the amount of energy that is available per
unit of time. Some (such geothermal and biomass) may be stock-
limited in that stocks are depleted by use, but on time scale of
decades, or perhaps centuries, they can probably be replenished.
Renewable energy resources include: biomass, hydro, geothermal,
solar and wind. In the future they could also include the use of
ocean thermal, wave, and tidal action technologies. Utility renew-
able resource applications include bulk electricity generation, on-
site electricity generation, distributed electricity generation, non-
grid-connected generation, and demand-reduction (energy effi-
ciency) technologies.
www.engbookspdf.com
Reseller. In general, any entity which purchases goods or services to in
turn sell the same goods or services to third party.
Retained Earnings. Corporate earnings that are not paid out in divi-
dends.
www.engbookspdf.com
260 Wheeling Retail Electricity
www.engbookspdf.com
Seasonal Rates. Rates designed to encourage conservation during time
of the year when energy consumption is high.
www.engbookspdf.com
Service Area. Territory in which utility is required or has the right to
supply service to ultimate customers.
Service Life. The period of time from the date unit of property is place
in service until it is taken out of service. Average service life is the
weighted average of the lives for all units within plant account or
group.
Service Value. The difference between original cost and net salvage
value of utility plant.
www.engbookspdf.com
D
www.engbookspdf.com
Sunk Cost. A cost that has already been incurred and therefore cannot
be avoided by any strategy going forward.
-T-
Tail Block. The last or lowest priced block of energy in declining block
rate structure.
Take and Energy sales contract which requires payment only for
energy actually delivered.
Take or Pay (TOP). Energy sales contract which requires payment for
given amount of energy whether the customer takes it or not.
www.engbookspdf.com
D
www.engbookspdf.com
Transmission. The movement or transfer of electric energy over an inter-
connected group of lines and associated equipment between points
of supply and points at which it is transformed for delivery to
consumers, or is delivered to other electric systems. Transmission
is considered to end when the energy is transformed for distribu-
tion to the consumer.
www.engbookspdf.com
D
-U-
Universal Service. Electric service sufficient for basic needs (an evolving
bundle of basic services) available to virtual all members the
population regardless of income.
Used and Useful Test. Criteria for determining the admissibility of util-
ity plant component of rate base. Generally, plant must be in
use (not under construction or standing idle awaiting abandon-
ment) and useful (actively helping the utility provide efficient ser-
vice).
Utility Plant. The summation all equipment used for the purpose of
generation, transmission and/or distribution of utility service. Or,
recorded explanation is maintained of this equipment.
www.engbookspdf.com
-V-
Vertical Service. The utility company performs all major utility services
for its customers, including production, transforming, transmittal
anddistribution. Monopoly utilities in thepastfrequentlypro-
vided vertical service; with increasing competition, rates for com-
ponent parts of service are being disaggregated (or unbundled) and
offered separately.
Volt. The practical mks unit of electrical potential difference and electro-
motive force equal to the carrying constant current of one ampere
when the power dissipated between these two points is equal to
one watt and equivalent to the potential difference across resis-
tance of one ohm when one ampere is flowing through it. A unit
of electrical potential difference and electromotive force equal to
1.00034 times the International System unit.
www.engbookspdf.com
Watt (W). The absolute mks unit of power equal to thework done at the
rate of one absolute joule per second or to the rate of work repre-
sented by current of one ampere under pressure of one volt and
taken the standard in the US; horsepower.
www.engbookspdf.com
70 Wheeling
-Y-
www.engbookspdf.com
Appendix E
TOCONVERT MULTIPLY BY
6.452
10-4
0.1550
1,550.0
6.452
3,600.0
0.03731
1.257
2.540
100.0
1.257
0.3937
39.37
0.4950
0.01
0.0254
0.01257
-B-
10.409
1.0550 1O1O
71
www.engbookspdf.com
TO CONVERT INTO MULTIPLY BY
www.engbookspdf.com
7
-E-
www.engbookspdf.com
74 Wheeling
www.engbookspdf.com
E
MULTIPLY BY
-H-
horsepower Btu/min
horsepower foot-lbs/min
horsepower foot-lbs/sec
horsepower (metric) horsepower
ft lb/sec) ft Ib/sec)
horsepower horsepower (metric)
ft lb/sec) ft lb/sec)
horsepower kg-calories/min
horsepower kilowatts
horsepower watts
horsepower (boiler) Btu/hr
horsepower (boiler) kilowatts
horsepower-hrs Btu
horsepower-hrs ergs
horsepower-hrs foot-lbs lo6
horsepower-hrs gram-calories
horsepower-hrs joules lo6
horsepower-hrs kg-calories
horsepower-hrs kg-meters lo5
horsepower-hrs kilowatt-hrs
joules Btu
joules ergs 107
joules foot-pounds
www.engbookspdf.com
2 76 Electricity Retail Wheeling
joules kg-calories
joules kg-meters
joules watts-hrs
kilograms-calories Btu
kilograms-calories foot-pounds
kilograms-calories hp-hrs
kilograms-calories joules
kilograms-calories kg-meters
kilograms-calories kilojoules
kilograms-calories kilowatt-hrs
kilogram meters Btu 10”
kilogram meters ergs lo7
kilogram meters foot-pounds
kilogram meters jaules
kilogram meters kg-calories
kilogram meters kilowatt-hrs
kilowatts Btu/min
kilowatts foot-pounds/min lo4
kilowatts foot-pounds/sec
kilowatts horsepower
kilowatts kg-calories/min
kilowatts watts
kilowatts-hrs Btu
kilowatts-hrs ergs
kilowatts-hrs foot-pounds lo6
kilowatts-hrs gram-calories
kilowatts-hrs horsepower-hrs
kilowatts-hrs joules lo6
kilowatts-hrs kg-calories
kilowatts-hrs kg-meters lo5
kilowatts-hrs pounds of water
evaporated from
and at
www.engbookspdf.com
TO MULTIPLY
-L-
lumens/sq ft foot-candles 1
Lumen Spherical candle power .07958
.001496Lumen Watt
lumen/sq ft Lumen/sq10.76
meter
lux foot-candles 0.0929
megohms microhms
megohms ohms
microfarad farads
micrograms grams
microhms megohms
microhms
microliters liters
www.engbookspdf.com
TO MULTIPLY BY
-R-
www.engbookspdf.com
Avvendix E
-T-
temperature temperature
-V-
Volt/inch Volt/cm
Volt (absolute) Statvolts
watts Btu/hr
watts Btu/min
watts ergs/sec
watts foot-lbs/min
watts foot-lbs/sec
watts horsepower
watts horsepower (metric)
watts kg-calories/min
Watts (absolute) Btu (mean)/min
Watts (absolute) joules/sec
watt-hours
watt-hours ergs
watt-hours foot-pounds
watt-hours gram-calories
www.engbookspdf.com
TO CONVERT INTO MULTIPLY BY
watt-hours horsepower-hrs
watt-hours kilogram-calories
watt-hours kilogram-meters
watt-hours kilowatt-hrs 0.001
Watt (International) Watt (absolute)
-X-
none
-Y-
yards centimeters
yards kilometers
yards meters
yards miles
yards miles (stat.)
yards millimeters
none
www.engbookspdf.com
Index
Cogeneration 121
Agents 83 Commodity 46, 160
Agent Charge 78 Commodity Origination Points 5
Aggregator 220 Competitive Service k d e r 35
Agreement (Retail Wheeling Sale) Complete Tariff 26, 27
128 Confidential Information 118
Alaska Power Administration 21 Contracts 79, 83
Alternative Current (AC) 50 Electricity Commodity Only 87
Amperes 271 Explanation 94
Analyzing Utility Costs 27 ElectricityCommodityOnly
Avoided Cost 222 with (3) Pricing Options 101
Explanation 111
-B- Electricity, Natural Gas, Water/
Balancing 144 Sewer Engineering Services
Basic Data Needed 27 115
Bidders 94, 102, 103, 109, 116 Explanation 124
Billing 93, 100, 136 Conversion Factors (Appendix E)
Boiler/Water Heaters 39 271
Bonneville Power Administration Cool Storage 40
21 Cooperative Utilities 20
British Thermal Units (Btu) 66 Cost-of-Service 22
Energy Comparisons 67 Customer Check List 164
Brokers 78, 83 Customer Equipment Fees 92, 99
Bundled Rates 149 Customer Meter point 155
Buss 49
-D-
-C- Daily Usage Cost Printout (Ex-
Capacitors 54 ample) 32
Categories of Retail Wheeled Elec- Death Spiral 46
tricity 70 D. Electricity Price Index 77, 132
Coal 66, 69 Dekatherm (Dth) 66
www.engbookspdf.com
Deliveries 136, 151 (EMS) 40
Demand 143 Energy Partnerships 86
Demand-Side Planning 39 Energy Service Companies (ESCO)
Direct Current (DC) 53 37,39,165,167,168,169
Discounts 92, 96 Energy Services 121, 122, 124
Distribution Charge 80 Engineering Services 115, 124, 160
Distribution Grid 74 Ergs 273
Docket Number 18 Experimental Rates 27,
Due Process 19 Experimental Tariff Schedule 30
Dyne 272
www.engbookspdf.com
For-Profit Utilities 16, 181 Intrastate 15
Fuel Costs 92, 97 Distribution Line Losses 92, 98
Fuel Oil 66 Investor-Owned Companies 16,
Futures Price 77 181
-G- -F
Gas-fired Air Conditioning 39 Joule 243, 275
Generation 52, 80 Jurisdictional 244
Generator 239
Gigawatt (GW) 239
Kilovolt (kV) 244
Gilberts 274
l l o w a t t (kW) 244,276
Glossary (Appendix D) 219
Kilowatt-hour (kwh) 66
Gram-Calories 274
Kirchoff’s Laws 48
Gram-Centimeters 274
Grid 240 -L-
Letter of Understanding 136
Lighting Controls 39
Harmonic Levels 61 Line Capacity 49
Heat Pumps 39 Line Losses 51, 74
Hedging Contracts 240 Line Loss Fees 79, 92, 98
Hertz 61,120 Loop Flow 48
High Intensity Discharge Lamping Low-Income Home Energy Assis-
39 tance Program (LIHEAP) 245
High Voltage DC (HVDC) 53, 80 Lumens 277
Horsepower 275
www.engbookspdf.com
Wheeling
(MAAC) 59 -P-
Mid Continent Area Power Pool Parallel Path 48
58, 59 Passive Filters 54
Minimum Guaranteed Discount Peak Power Demand 39
111 Peak Shaving 121
Miscellaneous fees 81 PerformanceSpecifications 106,
Municipalities 19 112
Municipal Utilities 15 Periodic Reports 17
Permits 119
-N- Point-of-Usage 143
Natural Gas 115, 121 Potential Provider Partners (ES-
Negotiable Rate COS) 167
Negotiated Incremental Rates 71 Poundals 277
Newton 277 Power Factor, Correction Factors
Nominations 144 40
Non-Firm (Interruptible) Delivery Power Pools 58, 59
77, 133 Power Quality 61
North American Reliability Coun- Pre-Bid Meeting 94
cil Regions (NERC) 57, 59 Pricing Criteria 15
NortheastPowercoordinating Producers 78, 84
Council 59 Pro Forma Tariff 12
Not-for-Profit 19 Propane 66
Notice of Proposed Rules (NOPR) ProposalSpecifications 107, 113,
122
Proprietary Information Clauses
89,95,104,118
OASIS 11 Provider’s Gross Margin 92, 98
Occupancy Sensors 39 Public Service Commissions 17
Off-peak Generation Service 77 Public Utility Commissions 17
Off-Tariff Schedules 27,34
Ohm 277
On-Peak and Off-peak Schedules Quadrants 278
77, 133 Qualification Process 117
Open Access 12 Quality Specifications 106, 120
Open Book Arrangements 114 Quasi-Cooperative 84
Options 14
Origination Points 5
Out-of-Merit Dispatch 49 Radians 278
Overview of Electricity 3 Railroad Commission of Texas 17
www.engbookspdf.com
Rate Schedule 26 Southwestern Power Administra-
Reactive Power 50 tion 21
Real Time Pricing 28 Spot Market Pricing 146
Receipt/Meter Point 74 State Fees 92, 99
Reflectors 39 State Intervenor Groups 17
Regulation 8 State Regulatory Agencies 172
Interstate Miscellaneous Information (Ap-
Intrastate 14 pendix C) 211
Regulatory Agencies 171 Static VAR Compensation (SVCs)
Federal 54
State 172 Static VAR Controls 54
Request for Proposal (RFP) 37,85, Stranded Costs 14
86,87,102,115, 116 Stranded Investments 81
Response Specification 106 Recovery Costs 81, 99
Retail Wheeling 45 Substitutions, (Contract) 106, 120
Basics Subsynchronous Oscillations 54
Categories Suppliers 102,116
Contract Process 83 Surcharges 137
Electricity Sale Agreement 128
Processes 65
Rooftop Air Conditioning 39 Tariff15,26
Rural Electric Cooperative Utilities
Temperature 279
20 Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA)
Rule #S88 9 21
Thermal Insulation 40
Thermal Storage 40
Sample: Utility Data Request Form Thyristor Converters 53
Letter 40 Time Tracker 163
Seconds (Angle) 278 Title 84, 138, 153
Self-Regulated 20 Traders 84
Services 116 Transformation Costs 80
Serving Utility 143 Transmission Agreements 138, 152
Shared Savings 107, 108 Transmission Grid 73
Shunt Compensation 54 Transmission/Local Distribution
Southeastern Electric Reliability 13
Council (SERC) 58 Transmission Planning 52
Southeastern Power Administra- Turbine Generators 54
tion 21 True Energy Cost Basis 66, 68
Southwest Power Pool (SPP) 58 Truing Up 62
www.engbookspdf.com
-U-
Unbundled 13 Water/Sewer 115, 121
US Army Corps. of Engineers 21 Watts (\V) 50,269
US Bureau of Indian Affairs- Watt-hours (Wh) 279
Coolidge, AZ 22 Web Sites 65,66
US Bureau of Indian Affairs- Western Area Power Administra-
Polson, MT22 tion 22
US Bureau of Reclamation 22 Western Systems Coordinating
Unregulated Marketing Affiliate Council (WSCC) 58, 59
Programs 27 Wheeling 74,269
Usage 143 Window Air Conditioning 39
Use-Point, Meter Cost 92, 99 Window Film 40
Utility Audits 39 Workman's Compensation 105,119
Utility Charges 80
Utility Services 111 -X-
XY Recorder 270
www.engbookspdf.com