Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 69

Synopsis

of
QUALITY COMMUNICATION MEET
2020

This is strictly for reference only & not for circulation


© 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
1
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Topics Covered Page No.
• Sustaining Quality in Challenging Times 3-12

• New Model Parts Development 13-26

• Mass Production Quality Status & Way Forward 27-46


• Moving towards Zero Defect
- Zero Defect Approach – Learning & Way forward 47-54
- Training & Skill Development – DOJO Training Center 55-57
- Operator observance System through 10 Cycle 58
- Abnormality Handling 59

• Global Environment Regulations : Restrictions on


60-67
Substance of Concern (SOC)

2
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Sustaining Quality in Challenging Times

Vipin Garg
Executive Vice President
Quality Assurance
Maruti Suzuki India Ltd.
3
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Quality Communication Meet (QCM) Journey

 Recap - ZD Methodology
 Mold maintenance guidance manual

 10 Cycle check

 TISP preparation
 Revalidation of Parts “QCM-3
 Plant Maintenance
“QCM-2
 Zero Defect Concept
 Mini DOJO concept
 Zero Defect methodology  Best Practice Sharing
 DOJO concept  Tier-2 assessment - Red/Yellow/Green
ACHIEVE & SUSTAIN
 Focus on New Model “QCM-1 ZERO DEFECT
 Tier 2 Control
 Revalidation of Parts 2018 2019 2020
 4M Change Mgt
Traceability
4
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Key Activities initiated Post lockdown
Advisory to Vendors- Part & RM Storage Mass Communication session
Training session
Process Wise Check sheets
 Process Readiness & Dry Run  Tool ,Die &Plant Maintenance
 Abnormality Handling
 Things To Do- Before & After Production Re-start  Operator Observance -10 cycle check
Advisory for Tier-2 Control & Operator
Training (Dojo Centre) Joint Review with Tier-1 & Critical Tier-2

 Resume Normal Operations:


 Focus on improvement Journey
 Post Lockdown – Main Focus was on  Drive Tier-2 Audits & Guidance
Re-starting the operations & Volume  Bring back focus on Tool, Die & Plant Maintenance
Ramp-up  Strengthen Quality Systems & Processes

Apr’20 May’20 Jun’20 Jul’20 Aug’20 Sep’20 Oct’20 Nov’20 Dec’20

Extensive virtual engagement and 3G audit- Vendor Plant & Warehouse 5


Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Quality Performance & Analysis

Sudden Increase In FY'20 ~21 (Post Lockdown)


Man Related Defects

System Non
Adherence
Operator Skill

Q4 FY19-20 Q1 FY20-21 H1 FY20-21 Q3 FY20-21

6
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Reasons for Increase in Man Related Defects
 Manpower shortage
 Frequent changes in manpower
 Lack of training and supervision
Manpower Training – [Dojo Concept]
Objective : All Manpower - Trained at Dojo Training Centre before deployment at Shop floor

 Majority Vendors utilized Dojo Training


Centres for Training of New Manpower-
Post Lockdown
 Request Vendor Partners to implement
and utilize Dojo facility.

Ensure Training Of Manpower Before Shop floor Deployment 7


Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
‘10 Cycle Check’ system of Operator Observance

Objective : Evaluation of System adherence at Gemba for Operators & Inspectors

Check
Check Check Cross
WI Availability
5 General Points WI Adherence Inspection
& Awareness

Dedicated Team to Conduct this ‘10 Cycle Check’

8
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Quality Challenges: New Model Parts

Key Concerns in New Model parts Other Challenges - New


Development Features / New Technologies

• Inadequate PFMEA: Capturing All Advanced Technologies:


Failure Modes • Electronics, Connected Cars
• Defects in Common Parts : - Less Know how & Skill
[Revalidation Before Usage in New Model ]
• New Regulations (CAFÉ
• Pre ECN/Trial Parts Mix up Norms & Whole Vehicle
• PPVT & IFM at Tier – 2 Safety)

9
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Substance of Concerns (SOCs) Compliance

“Lead” “Hex chromium” “Asbestos”

SOC causes health hazards

To Safeguard Humans & Environment:

Strengthen System to ensure Create Awareness at Sub


Compliance to Environment Suppliers for SOC Control
Regulations

Ensure SOC Compliance & Monitoring for MSIL Parts 10


Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Key Quality Initiatives
Revision In Defect Punching Criteria : Defect Punching
Criteria Revised
FY’19-20 Dec’19 FY’20-21

Apr’20
Communication sent to vendors
regarding “Other Quality Concerns”

Other Quality Concern :


• All Appearance Defects
• Wrong Part & Mix up issues
• GCA : Appearance defects
• Bar Code Wrong/NG

A step towards our goal of achieving “ZERO DEFECT” -Started treating “Other Quality Concerns” as “DEFECTS”

11
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Summarization of Quality Challenges & Way Forward

Resume Normal Operations & Drive Improvement Activities

Manpower Skill in New Normal & Adherence to Rules

Focus on Preventive Maintenance of Tools,Dies&Equipments

Increase Tier-2 Engagement, Audit & Guidance

Compliance to Regulations, SOC & Traceability requirements

Development Team to work towards YNC ZD Lines

Ensure Quality System Sustenance to achieve “Zero Defect” 12


Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
New Model Parts Development

By:
AVN Rao
AVP (QA-Parts Quality)
13
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Recap – Previous “Quality Communication Meetings”
 Implement Past Defect Learnings  Off -Tool (OT) Parts in PP Trial
 Tier-2 Quality Planning
 Off Tool – Off Process (OTOP) Parts in MPT
 Quality Milestones in Development Schedule

Spec Quality
Meeting Planning
New Model
Parts :
Focus Areas
PPVT IFM

 Plan Facilities –Ensure OTOP before MPT  IFM for 3 months after SOP
 PPVT at MPT- Actions before Pilot  Monitor Break-downs, Rejection & Re-work
Thanks for implementing these activities at your end . 14
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
New Model Quality Performance & Learning
Line Defects at MSIL Learning
Overall defects are
improving but Single
defect are still a concern. Inadequate PFMEA

Defects in Common Parts

Handling & part Mix-up

Defects from Tier 2

Single defect cased also to be Reduced. Need to achieve Zero Defect.


15
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
PFMEA: Methodology & Concerns

Past Defect Failure mode Actions for defect Standardization of


identification prevention Control plan/WI
Drawing
Requirements All Past defects not considered
Process flow PFMEA Submitted Joint PFMEA review Less Involvement of Production & QA
To MSIL ( YCA , Y1K )
Base PFMEA not Elaborative
Recommended Actions
• Poka Yoke must be Implemented for all Past Failures
• Change points & Possible Human Errors are additional inputs for PFMEA
• Involve expert members from Production, QA & Engineering for Review
• PFMEA must be a live document – timely update learnings
16
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Common Parts Evaluation in New Model
Requires Periodic health check for Common Parts
Assess Tool condition of common Parts thoroughly
Revalidation Guidelines

① Inspect Parts as per drawing ④ Capacity & Quality


② Verify Process as as per PCS confirm through PPVT
(if volume ≥ 20%)
③ Check Tool Condition -
If required
Refurbishment / Re-tooling

Complete Evaluation of Common parts of YNC by End Dec’20


17
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Trial & Pre ECN Parts mix-up
Request to Vendors:

① Train manpower for Abnormality Handling Procedure

② Identify trial parts with Tag at separate location

③ Ensure Physical Disposal against scrap note

18
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Extension of activities to Tier2 – Request to Vendors
Tier-2 Tier-1 MSIL

PPVT PPVT

IFM IFM

IFM by few vendors at Critical Tier-2 in Y1K


Decided IFM Check Training to IFM IFM station Setup Increased Audits
Points (CTQ) inspectors at Tier-1 & Monitoring during IFM

Request : Extend PPVT and IFM to all your Tier-2 Vendors.


19
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Way Forward

1 Root Cause Analysis – Trial Problems

2 Learning implementation - SOR

3 Planning for New Technology Parts

20
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Adequate Closure of Development Stage Issues
Feedback
Sources Part Inspection
Bench Testing Root Cause Analysis &
Trial at MSIL / Vendor Countermeasures
Vehicle Trial

Process Rejection

Mass Defect at Trial Stage


Production
PP MPP Pilot SOP Root cause not analyzed

Repeat Issue at SOP

• Hold Up
• Delay in SOP/ Launch
21
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Adequate Closure of Development Stage Issues
PP Trial MPT Trial Pilot SOP
QPCR - Development

Record all defects during Trial

Proposed Method :
Record all issues
during Trials
Deep Analysis by CFT
(QA, Engg ,Prod)
Review Actions by
Plant head
Actions must be taken
before next Trial

Countermeasures must be verified and approved by Plant Head


Actions must be implemented before next Trial 22
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Need For Standardization – Quality SOR

Concern Best practices are not horizontally deployed.


Learning Need for Standard Quality Requirements.
SOR : Statement of Quality Requirements
Raw Material Requirements


Storage
Testing
Methodology:
Part Specific Requirements
• Part handling
• Process Equipment
Discussion of Implementation verification in
Sharing of Quality Implementation Plan process
Process Requirements Requirements ( During spec meeting ) ( During Process Audit )
• Poka yoke

Inspection requirements
• Frequency
• EOL

Plan the process as per SOR from next Model


23
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Advance Planning for New Technology Parts
New Technologies - Increased Electronics & Features
□ Lack of Past database Need for
□ No Previous Experience Advance Planning
□ Inadequate Skill

Quality Benchmark with Collaborator & Collect Past failures and actions
Data Study Local Usage Conditions and Revise Test Standards

Process Involve Collaborator for PFMEA


Know-How
Early Process set up – Target by PP Trial

Fix Operators and Train for New Tech Processes


Skill
Impart Training at Collaborator Plant (Wherever possible)

Need to Advance Development Activities 24


Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Challenge in Pandemic Situation – Request to Vendors

YNC is the 1st Model under development in this Challenging situation


Priority : Bring Focus on YNC - Realign resources & actual 3G Visits
Challenges Immediate Actions

 Delay in Facility Setup  Actual Tool Trials & Evaluate Parts


 Focus on Line Trials – Prod & QA
 Tools & Process Audits on
Virtual Mode  Train manpower in DOJO center
 OJT on actual Production line
 Manpower Concerns
 Review Tier 2 readiness
 Tier 2 : Limited engagement
 Evaluate Child Parts & Process
25
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Summary

Extend PPVT & IFM to Tier-2 Vendors

Thoroughly Evaluate Common Parts

Strengthen PFMEA – Must Include all Past Defects

Let’s work to Deeper Root Cause Analysis of Trial Stage Problems


achieve
“Zero Defect”
in YNC Plan the process as per Quality SOR

Advance Development activities for New Technology Parts

26
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Mass Production Quality
Status & Way Forward

Sushant Bose Kanchan Kishor Srivastava


GM (Parts Quality -Gurgaon) DGM (Parts Quality-Manesar)
Maruti Suzuki India Limited Maruti Suzuki India Limited
27
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Post SOP –Challenges for Quality Sustenance

Major gaps observed

1.System non Adherence

2.Operator skill

3.Tools & Die maintenance

4.Others

Majority of defects are Man related defects 28


Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Non Adherence to System

Last Year – we requested to implement 10 cycle check

• Guidelines launched
• Please Adopt 10 cycle check system

Operator Skill improvement and Assessment - DOJO

Make best use of DOJO

Ensuring 100% Operator training and assessment in DOJO centers before deploying on line
29
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Tool &Die Maintenance Concern
Increase in Tool & Jig
Defects Post Lockdown
Inadequate Tool Preventive Maintenance

Delayed Correction of Tools

Inadequacy of Weld Equipment

Q1' 20 Q2'20 Q3'20 Non-adherence to Spares Management


Tool / Jig Defect Trend (2020-21)

Tool Maintenance System collapsed post lockdown and subsequent increase in volumes

Implement & ensure compliance to Die & Tool Maintenance Systems as given in our guidance manuals
30
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Plant Maintenance Improvement Activity

CONCERN AREAS IMPLEMENTATION APPROACH


- Relying on Breakdown Maintenance Implementation of Model Machine
- Poor Basic condition of machine concept through CLIT activity
- Poor workmanship (Cleaning, Lubrication, Inspection and
- Lack in Spare part planning Tightening

MODEL MACHINE ACTIVITY FLOW :

Model Machine On job Pre-assessment & Correction & Post- assessment &
selection Training abnormality capturing improvement Re-validation

31
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Importance of Compliance to Regulation

Dispatch Suspension

Financial loss & Heavy Penalties


Impact of Non
Compliance
Legal Issue / Recalls

Loss of Sales, Brand Image

Compliance to Regulation is not a Choice 32


Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Homologatory Requirements

PP Stage MPP Stage Pilot / SOP Stage After SOP

Suppliers
Part Level Type Approval/Homologation

OEM
Suppliers + OEM
Vehicle Level Type Approval / Homologation
Conformity of Production Cycle Starts

Examples of Homologation parts:


Windscreen Tyres Safety Belts IRVM Headlamp Fuel Tanks Brake Assembly
33

Suppliers need to ensure the Valid COP is established through Testing Agency before expiry

Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Key Learnings in Regulation compliance

Create awareness of Regulations in your organization

Dedicated team for Periodic Verification of R-Marking

Approval from authorized agency for Manufacturing location change

Ensure Regulatory marking in Child Part Drawing, MISP & on Parts

Timely renewal of Type approval certificate from authorized agency

34
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
TRACEABILITY

MSIL VEHICLES HOLD UP DATA INDICATES NEED OF STRONG TRACEABILITY

• Even one critical


process/ child part
can result in
incomplete linkage

• Ensure TISP to
include Traceability
for Process / Critical
Child parts

35
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Frontend Traceability Method
MSIL Policy for Front end Traceability to be implemented from YNC Onwards

Method 1: Method 2:
100% Frontend Traceability Batch Level Traceability

Scanning Part before Scanning trolley/bin at


fitment in Vehicle receipt or at line feeding

36
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Safety Defect (Maru A) Concerns
Some Reduction
observed Recommendations After thorough Analysis
• Process fool proofing to avoid human error
• Special drive for Contamination controls
• PFMEA review to address potential failures
• EOLs test cycle review / Vehicle level
replication
FY 19~20 FY20~21
• CCTV installations to capture
• Some Reduction observed
abnormalities
• But Nos. Still Very High
37
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Un-Approved Changes

4M
Man
Machine
Material
Method

18~19 19~20 20~21


Projected

Unapproved changes- A Major concern area


Changes should be transparently communicated and validated 38
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Vehicle Dispatch Hold – Parts Defect
Hold up results in repair and inspection at MSIL in difficult situation

 High Man-hours
lost in clearing
holdup
Checking using endoscope (underbody and engine room)
 Hold up results in
tedious repair at
MSIL

Brake check by Multiple time pedal Repair inside cabin

Request to Focus on Defects leading to Vehicle Hold 39


Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Horizontal Deployment of Learnings
Defect Reported - MSIL
Implement Actions at All Plants

Line 1 Line 2 Line 3


Ensure Parallel Actions at All Lines of Same Plant Ensure Actions Across All Plants

 Maru A , Regulatory , Functional Defect- Ensure HD across your Lines and Plant
 MSIL to announce a structured IT mechanism for this soon 40
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Adherence of MISP Parameters

Inspection MISP
Std.

Gaps Identified in MIS-P

MSIL Management
Communication Review Process
Periodic Review

Request to Align Internal Standards & Periodically Review the same 41


Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Focus on Trolley / Bin Maintenance
Line Rejection Analysis at MSIL
1. Packaging
Approval

5. Supply as per 2. Packaging


Major Line approved OK Maintenance
Packaging Plan
Rejections Qty is
due to Transit
Damages
4. Maintenance 3. Packaging
as per Plan Check sheet

Ensure Periodic Maintenance of Trolleys / Bins and maintain in Good condition 42


Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Request to Vendor Partners
Steps for Ensuring Sustenance – 3C

Involve Operators in defining


Collaborate Rules easy to implement

Communicate Communicate Frequently


≥80 70~80 60~70

Importance of
Strong Internal Audit management
Check & Improve with qualified auditors Strong Systems

43
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Vendor System Audit in the new Normal
Pre-Covid

Audit Audit at
VSA report
Schedule and Vendor
released
Intimation Location

The NEW VSA Process

Online Audit
Shop Floor
Audit • Online Provisional Final VSA
Audit at
Schedule and applications VSA report report
Vendor
Intimation like WebEx/ released Released
MS Teams etc Location

44
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Revalidation : Sustaining Part & Process Quality

2019~20 2020~21
• Selected Parts Revalidation • Regulatory marking verification
MSIL • Process Verification • Regulatory process audit
• Revalidation System Audit

Vendor • Part Revalidation (As per Drawing) • Report submission on MSIL Portal
Partners • Report Submission by mail
Strengthen Revalidation System at Tier2
Become Self Sufficient in Revalidation in 2 Years…. 45
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Let’s Summarize – Request to vendors
Implement 10 cycle check to improve adherence of process.

Ensure each Operator goes through DOJO Training before deployment

Timely Preventive Maintenance of Tools, Dies and Plant

Ensure adherence & awareness to Regulations

Prepare TISP and ensure adherence to improve Traceability

Ensure all MISP Parameters covered in Vendor Inspection Standards

Become Self Sufficient in Revalidation & Sustain robust Quality systems


46
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
“Moving towards

Zero Defect”
Sanjay Thakar
Senior Vice President
Quality Assurance
Maruti Suzuki India Ltd. 47
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Recap - Zero Defect Approach

Zero Defect Structure


 Process Strengthening  Organization Structure  Material handling  Maintain as New
• PFMEA Review • Adequate, Empowered Quality • Review of material flow and mix up • Implementation of PM
• Change point / CTQ control • Role Clarity : DWM • Handling method of sensitive child guidelines
parts
 Poka Yoke control  Manpower Planning  Tool Health monitoring
• Timely recruitment  Traceability & FIFO • Timely corrective action
 Strong Outflow Control • Manpower Mapping : Skill Matrix
• Manpower continuity on Critical  Capable Equipment for Zero
 System & Process stations  Receipt inspection & pass thru Defect
Adherence improvement characteristics of Tier 2 parts • Evaluation of machines tool jigs
 Trained Manpower at Tier 1 being used on line
 Process Audit/Review of • Dojo Centre • Machine capability study
Action on Past defect • Multi-skilling  Tier2 up gradation activity by
• Training on New Technology Tier1

METHOD MAN MATERIAL MACHINE


Robust Quality Systems

Robust Product Development

People Motivation & Involvement

Top Management - Zero Defect Commitment


48
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Key Concern Areas

Inadequate PFMEA Non Adherence to Inadequate Material Weak Tier II Controls Inadequate
shop floor rules Handling Maintenance

49
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
B. Non Adherence to Rules - Gaps & Recommendations
Setup Part Handling Inadequate

Recommendations
What Went wrong?
Set-up Part Handling rule not followed Frequent Awareness on Set up Part handling rule

Check on Check System to be strengthened

Ensure Set-up Part Handling Rule Awareness & Adherence by Operators

50
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
B. Non Adherence to Rules - Gaps & Recommendations
Non-adherence to 4M Change Management

Defect : Fitment
problem due to Hole
Blockage

Hole blockage in Plastic part Extra Material on Lock

What Went wrong? Recommendations


Retroactive inspection not done after M/c Break down
(Change not validated) Validation of 4M change to be ensured as per 4M change
matrix
4M change rule not adhered

Ensure strict adherence to 4M change rules


51
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
C.Material Handling - Gaps & Recommendations
Child part mix-up during Changeover

Non-coated
child part used
Defect : Part Fitment NG in place of
coated
1 Hole missing Coated Child Part : 3 Holes Non-Coated part : 2 Holes
observed
Coated-Non-Coated Mix-up

What Went wrong? Recommendations


Line Drainage System not followed during variant
change Check on Check System to be ensured during line change over

52
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
C.Material Handling - Gaps & Recommendations
Material storage condition inadequate

Defect : Crack observed in


Rubber Part

Joint Crack due to


contamination Parts Kept in open condition

What Went wrong? Recommendations


Packing Std. for WIP parts to be made & approved
Packing Standard for WIP parts not available internally
53
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Self Sustenance – Zero Defect Line
• Inadequate Top Management Review
Non sustenance of Zero defect lines
Gaps • Non adherence to Quality Systems
deteriorated over a period after SOP

Recommendations
• Make Sustenance check-sheet for monitoring the Zero defect line periodically
• Analyze defects from Zero defect lines & take countermeasures

Way Forward
Top Management Horizontal Tier II Upgradation People
Detailed PFMEA
Review Deployment
ZD
Line

54
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
“Training & Skill Development” - DOJO Training Center
55
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
DOJO Journey & Concerns
Concern Areas
• Non Utilization
• Inadequate Training Facility
• Non Adherence to Training System

Areas of Improvement
• Management Review
• Trainer
• Training Duration
• Production Rule & Process Dojo
Available on MSIL extranet

All Vendors are requested to implement DOJO centers at their Plants by Mar’2021

“No manpower should be deployed on shop floor without DOJO training”


56
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Mini Dojo for Tier-2’s
Concept: Less space and limited budget Mini Dojo Layout Glimpses of Mini Dojo

Approx. Area Required 15 m2

Investment (Approx.) Rs.50,000/-

8 Steps:
Mini Dojo Methodology - 03 Steps on LED Display
- 05 Steps practical

Guidance
Manual

57
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Operator Observance System through 10 Cycle
Guidelines for Operator Observance - Handbook

This system checks & Background and Need for


Operator Observance

Improve
Operator Observance for 10
- Availability & Adequacy Cycles Methodology

- Awareness
Planning, Role and
- Adherence of work Responsibility

Instruction
Analysis, actions &
Effectiveness Monitoring

58
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Abnormality Handling : List Of Abnormalities
S.No. Abnormalities covered under Module
1 Fallen Part
2 Handling of NG part in inspection
3 Set up NG Part Handling
4 Unidentified Part
5 Part Handling at Inspection Table
6 Power Failure Part
7 Incomplete Processed Part
8 Incomplete Inspection
9 Handling of FG Part
10 Handling Of Child Part
11 Similar Looking / Child part Mix
12 Traceability Abnormality
13 Handling of Similar Looking Parts
14 Handling of Trial / Pre ECN Part
15 Model / Variant Changeover Control
16 Handling of Rework Part
17 Abnormal Situation Handling- STOP-CALL-WAIT Rule
59
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Global Environment Regulations :

Restrictions on Substance of Concern (SOC)

Amit Sharma
General Manager
Quality Assurance – Material Analysis
60
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Presentation Contents

 SOC based Regulations & Related Health Effects

 Supplier SOC Adherence & Sustenance

 SOC Monitoring & Control

 Labelling & Packaging of Hazardous Chemicals

61
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
SOC based Environment Regulations
Substances of Concern pose potential risk to Humans & Environment

End-of-Life Vehicle Classification, Asbestos POPs & Phthalates


Directive Labelling & Packaging Restriction Restriction
Restriction of Heavy metals (Europe) (Japan) (Global)
2009

2002 2009 2012 2018 onwards

2008 2011 2012 2018 


Restriction of POPs and
First MSIL model ELV Labelling of applicable Asbestos Verification
other SOCs (22 substances)
compliant Export parts Activity
Restriction of Phthalates
(4 substances)

India to adopt similar substance registration, authorization, restriction & labelling rules (2021 expected)
62
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
SOC – Substances of Concern
Types, Applications & Effects in Automotive
Types of SOC’s SOC suspected parts Health Effects of SOCs

Heavy metals: Pb,Cd,Hg,Cr6+ Passivation on Zinc Mercury


(Plating, Coatings, Plastic Parts)
Coatings (MFZn etc) Brain & Liver Lead
damage Brain & Nerve
damage

Asbestos
Clutch Disc
(Brake pad)

Chromium6+ Cadmium
Eye Injury Asbestos
Phthalates DNA damage Lung cancer
PVC Coated Parts
(Plasticizers in PVC) Kidney failure

POPs Grease
(Grease, Coatings, adhesives)

VOCs Phthalates & POPs


Eye Irritation Hormonal Disorders
Volatile Organic Compounds Interior Plastic Parts Skin cancer
(Interior Parts of vehicle)
63
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Supplier SOC Adherence & Sustenance
MSIL has established Green Procurement Guidelines with all its suppliers

Compliance with Environmental Regulations

IMDS Data Input for all models

Compliance to Standards

Restriction of Prohibited Substances

Control of Tier-down suppliers

Supplier must strictly comply with Green Procurement Guidelines


64
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Supplier SOC Evaluation
MSIL SOC Audit
A-Rank
OK

All Suppliers B-Rank Take


Self Audit MSIL Audit
Countermeasures
C-Rank
No further business

Key Improvement Areas

Green Procurement Supplier Awareness Control Procedures


Strengthen awareness on latest
Establish Green Procurement Establish SOC Compliance Procedures
regulations through Standards and
Contracts with Tier-down suppliers in Quality Systems
GADSL List

Suppliers must identify gaps and take countermeasures to sustain SOC Compliance 65
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
SOC Monitoring: IMDS & Declarations / Reports Submission
International Material Data System:
SOCs Verification (Asbestos, POPs etc.)
Tool to collect, validate, manage supplier substance level data for SOC and RRR

• Activity Timeline : ~ 6 – 8 Weeks*


IMDS Request to Vendors IMDS SUBMISSION WITHIN 90 DAYS*

Including sub suppliers


• Through Declaration & Test Reports

Concern: IMDS submission is not being done within 90 days Concern: Delay in submission of documents

Reasons for Delay Impacts


 High IMDS Rejection  Increase in lead time during product development

 Attrition of IMDS trained members at vendors  It may affect compliance to environment regulations

 System for IMDS control not adequate

*These deadlines may be reduced based on model development requirements, request your timely support

Develop system to ensure timely and correct SOC related submission 66


Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
GHS Label With Hazardous Products
GHS is Globally Harmonized System of Classification & Labelling of Chemicals

GHS Regulation Applicability : Suppliers submitting spare parts to MSIL for EU, Japan & Australia Exports

GHS Applicable Products Actions to be taken by Vendors


Applicable Products EU Japan Others*
Desiccant o 1. Provide SDS for GHS products (e.g. grease)
Volatile Corossion Inhibitor o
Oil, Paint, Grease, Adhesive, etc. o o o
Tire Repair Kit o o 2. Provide GHS Label when product is given as a
Airbag Inflator & Pretensioner o separate item with spare part (e.g. grease packet)
Wind Washer Fluid (Spare Part) o o o
* Exact information may differ country-to-country. This is a generalised form.

1 2

MSIL Standard Formats


1. MSIL Standard GHS Label

2. Ensure proper leak-proof packaging

Strengthen your dispatch systems to ensure compliance at all times.


67
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
68
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited
This is strictly for reference only & not for circulation

© 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited

69
Strictly for reference only and not for circulation Quality Excellence across value chain in New Normal © 2020 Maruti Suzuki India Limited

You might also like