Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Submitted A Note On The Separation of The Four
Submitted A Note On The Separation of The Four
S. S. BERMANAND \;IT.
A. E . MCBRYDE
ABSTRACT
Distribution coefficients for the chlorides of ruthenium, rhodium, palladium, iridi~un(II1
and IV), and platinu~nhave been deternli~ledbetween the anion exchanger Amberlite IRA-400
and hydrochloric acid solutions of various molarities. Separations of various combinations'of
rhodium, iridium, palladiu~ll,and platinum in amounts of 0.5 mg. or less are described.
When, in the course of these separations, the four metals are present together, special pro-
cedures are required t o ensure conlplete recovery of p l a t i n u ~ l ~ .
Can. J. Chem. Downloaded from cdnsciencepub.com by 82.210.178.95 on 05/14/21
There have been several attempts to employ ion exchange in the separation of the
platinum metals, but only a limited degree of success has been achieved. MacNevin and
Cruinmett (1) suggested t h a t a separation of rhodium, iridium, palladium, and platiilum
might be possible owing to the graded stabilities of the chloride and ammine complexes
of these metals, but presented no experimental data. Another report by the same authors
(2) elaborated on a separation of iridium from palladium achieved by converting the
palladium to a cationic diammine, leaving the iridium as an anion, and separating the
two on this basis. Stevenson et al. (3) submitted a note on the separation of the four
metals on the cation exchanger Dowex-50, based on the formation of perchlorates of
these metals by fuming their solutioils with perchloric acid. No d a t a were given, but
For personal use only.
this separation is of questionable value because of the inability to keep even milligram
quantities of platinum and iridium from precipitating in this medium. Blasius and
Wachtel (4) achieved separations of from the other three metals by adsorbing
the platinum complex on the anion exchanger Permutit-ES in the hydroxide form. T h e
other three metals were eluted by a solution of sodium hydroxide, and the platinum
recovered by elution with nitric acid. WIacNevin and McI<ay ( 5 ) have prepared spectro-
graphically pure rhodium through the formation of a cationic rhodium species, the
other metals being left as anions. This separation is not quantitative. T h e separations
of rhodium and iridium have been discussed in a previous paper (G).
The only equilibrium data recorded c o ~ l c e r ~ l i ~
the
l g behavior of platinum metal com-
plexes toward ion exchangers are those of Kraus et al. (7). These worlters measured the
distribution coefficients of chloroplatinate (IV) and chloropalladate (11) relative to the
anion exchanger Dowex-1 in hydrochloric acid solutions.
In the followi~lgreport the measurement of the distribution coefficients of ruthenium,
rhodium, iridium, palladium, and platinum in hydrochloric acid solutions relative t o
the anion exchanger Amberlite IRA-400 is described, as well as a series of separations
of these metals.
EXPERIMENTAL
Standard Solutions
Pal1adiunz.-A stock solution was prepared by dissolving pure palladium sponge in
aqua regia, evaporating several times to dryness with hydrochloric acid, and then
dissolving the residue and diluting with 0.1 M hydrochloric acid. This solution was
standardized gravimetrically by precipitation with salicylaldoxime (8). Analyses for
palladium were generally made colorimetrically by the potassium iodide method (9),
'Manz~scriptreceioed Decevzber 3, 1957.
Contribz~tionfrom the Department of Chenzistry, Unioersity of Toronto, Toronto 5, Ontario, Canada.
but very small amounts (less than 10 pg.) were determined by the 9-nitrosodimethylalli-
line procedure (10).
P1atinz~m.-The stocl; solution was prepared by the dissolutioll of pure platinum
spoilge in aqua regia and treatment similar t o that described for palladium. The solution
was staildardized by precipitation with 4-phenylthiosemicarbazide (11). Colorimetric
analyses were made by the tin(I1) chloride method (12).
Ruthenium.-A stock solution was prepared in 0.5 M hydrochloric acid from ammonium
chlororuthenate crystallized from a solution of sodium chlororuthenate in hydrochloric
acid. The solutio~lwas standardized by the evaporation of a measured quantity, followed
by reduction of the salt to inetallic ruthenium with hydrogen. Analyses were made
Can. J. Chem. Downloaded from cdnsciencepub.com by 82.210.178.95 on 05/14/21
TABLE I
DISTRIBUTIOS
COBPPIC~ENTS
D
HCI, ill Rh Ru Ir(II1) Ir(1V) Pd(I1) Pt(IV)
BERMAN AND McBRYDE: PL.4TINGM METALS 837
The amounts of resin and solution were selected to limit loading of the resin to no
more than 2% of capacity.
The results are summarized in Table I and in Fig. 1.
A comparison of these values with those obtained by Icraus et al. (7) for Pd(I1) and
Pt(1V) shows good agreement in the low-adsorption range where these worlcers had low
degrees of loading. In the high-adsorption range where these worlcers allo\vecl the loading
t o become large there is a marked divergence, their distribution coefficieilts being much
lower than those given here.
I t is readily seen that Pt(1V) and Ir(IV) are very strollgly adsorbed throughout the
whole hydrochloric acid range, and Pd(I1) a t low hydrochloric acid concentrations.
Can. J. Chem. Downloaded from cdnsciencepub.com by 82.210.178.95 on 05/14/21
According to Walton (15) practically all ion-exchange distribution data can be ex-
pressed by the Rothmund-Kornfeld equation
where iWz and M, are the moles of s and y per gram of exchanger and ( x ) and (31)
are their molar concentrations in solution; K and p are constants. Theii by plotting
log(A/l,/fif,) against log((s)/(y)) one shoulcl obtain a straight line.
For personal use only.
FIG. 1. The distribution coefficiellts of rhodium, iridiiuun, platinum, palladium, and ruthenium in
hydrochloric acid solutions. A : chloroiridate(lV), B : cl~ioroplatinate(IV),C: chloropalladatc(ll), D:
chlororuthenate(lII), E: chloroiridate(I1 I), F : chlororhodate.
FIG. 2. 'I'he clistribution data plotted according to the liothmund-ICornfeId equation. A : chloroiridate
(IV), B : chloroplatinate(IV), C : chloropalladate(1 I).
This is, more or less, what happened when the data for Rh, Ru, and Ir(II1) were
plotted. However, the three other complexes produced iilteresting curves (Fig. 2). In
regions of very high adsorptioil MZ/iW,' (the squared term arises since these complexes
are doubly charged) is seen to be almost independeilt of the conceiltration ratio of
complex to chloride in solution; i.e., p = 0.
This might indicate that in these instances simple exchange equilibria are not taking
place and t h a t some mechailism other than ion exchange is the predominant factor.
838 CANADIAN JOURNAL O F CIIEMISTRY. VOL. 36. 1958
An analogy may be seen here between this strong adsorption and the solubility of
quaternary amine platiilum metal chlorides. I t is well ltnown that Pt(1V) and Ir(1V)
form relatively iilsoluble salts with quaternary amines of the type (R,1N)J'tCl6. Since
the anion exchanger is in effect a polystyre~ledivinylbellzenequaternary amine, it may
be that the same forces that produce the insoluble salts contribute to the strong adsorp-
tion of these complexes on the resin. Palladium(I1) is ltnown to form a number of in-
soluble diammine dichloride complexes, the solubility of which is greater in concentrated
hydrochloric acid than in neutral solution. The behavior of palladium toward the resins
may be, in the same fashion, compared with the formation of ammine precipitates of
this sort.
T o further illustrate this analogy 5 ml. of 0.2 M tetrabutylammoilium chloride was
Can. J. Chem. Downloaded from cdnsciencepub.com by 82.210.178.95 on 05/14/21
added to 10 mg. of each of the six complexes in 5 ml. of 0.5 iM hydrochloric acid. Precipi-
tates formed in the tubes containing Pd(II), Pt(IV), and Ir(1V). When 1 1111. of concen-
trated hydrochloric acid was added to each of these, the palladium precipitate dissolved
instantly and the iridium precipitate partially dissolved. Further addition of hydrochloric
acid resulted in the complete dissolution of the iridium precipitate, but the platinum
precipitate could only be partially dissolved by this means.
LVhile the above experiment does not prove that stable resin-platinum metal com-
pounds are formed analogous to iilsoluble precipitates, the parallel between these obser-
vations and subsequent column experiments was strilting. For example, it was possible
to remove Pd(I1) from the resin by elution with concentrated hydrochloric acid. Pt(1V)
For personal use only.
and Ir(1V) cannot be completely recovered by this means. The iridium complex may be
removed by a hot extraction with hydrochloric acid, but even this rather violent treatment
will only partially remove the platinum complex.
The Separation of Palladiz~mand Platinum
The purpose of this research was to develop an ion-exchange procedure for this separa-
tion which could be integrated with the rhodium-iridium separation previously reported
(6). Also, the recovery of Pd(I1) and Pt(1V) from anion exchangers by a wet method has
long been a problem and an obstacle in the application of anion exchange in the separation
of platinum from base metals.
I t was confirmed that Pd(I1) and Pt(1V) can be quantitatively adsorbed from dilute
hydrochloric acid solutions on an anion exchanger, Amberlite IRA-400.
The Recovery of Palladium
Five milliliters of 1 M hydrochloric acid containing approximately 500 y of palladium
were fed onto 2.5-cm. resin beds in the larger columns which had been previously washed
with 25 ml. of the acid solution. Complete recovery of the palladium was achieved by
100 ml. of 12 iM hydrochloric acid.
Number of esperi~nents 5
Palladium taken 478 -y
Palladium recovered (range) 476-480 -y (see Fig. 3 )
I t was found that no platinum was eluted provided these beds were a t least 2.3 cm.
deep.
The work was repeated with 3-cm. beds in the smaller columns. Complete recovery
was achieved by 40 ml. of 12 A[ hydrochloric acid or by 60 ml. of 9 Macid (see Fig. 3).
The use of 6 M acid resulted in too much tailing to be of value. However, it was found
that 40 ml. of 12 M hydrochloric acid eluted much platinum, whereas 60 ml. of 9 M
acid eluted none.
BHRlvIAN A N D McBIIYDE: PLATINUM MET.\LS
ML. ELUANT
Can. J. Chem. Downloaded from cdnsciencepub.com by 82.210.178.95 on 05/14/21
FIG.3. Some typical elution curves for chloropalladate(l1) and chloroplatinate(1V). A : chloropalln-
date(I1) el~rtetl\\.it11 12 11J hydrochloric acid solution (small c o l u m ~ ~B:
) , chloropalladate(I1) eluted with
!I Jf hydrochloric acid solution (small column), C : chloropalladatc(ll) eluted with 12 116 hydrochloric acid
solution (large column), D : chloroplatinate(lV) eluted with 2.4 ilf perchloric acid solution (small column),
E: chloro1~latr~iate(IV)
eluted with l 5 7 i (I\,/\.) zinc chloride in 9 Af hydrochloric acid solution a t 96' C.
(large column).
I t was also shown that Pd(I1) could be easily recovered by elution with dilute per-
chloric acid solutions. The recoveries observed for elutioil with 40 ml. of 0.5 M perchloric
acid were as follows:
Number of experiments
Palladiu~ntaken
Palladium recovered
For personal use only.
Since perchloric acid was later shown to be a good eluant for Pt(1V) this reagent caililot
be used to separate the two metals.
Recovery of Platinum
Platinum was fed onto 2.5-cm. resin beds in the larger columns in a manner similar
to the palladium.
I t was verified that solutions of hydrochloric, nitric, or sulphuric acids, either dilute
or concentrated, elute only part of the Pt(1V). The same is true forammoniacal eluants.
Workiilg a t elevated temperatures produced only minor improvements in the recoveries.
Kraus and his co-worlters (7, 16) noted the high affinities of zinc and cadmium chloride
in hydrochloric acid solutions toward anion exchangers. Preliminary experiments with
2.5 M solutions of both these salts in 9 M hydrochloric acid showed better recoveries of
platinum than had been previously achieved. I t was found that 93% of the Pt(1V) could
be recovered by the zinc chloride solution, and that quantitative recoveries could be
achieved if the column were surrounded with a hot-water jacltet a t 96' C. The following
recoveries were made by elution with DO ml. of a 15% ((w/v) solution of zinc chloride in
9 M hydrochloric acid a t D6O C. (see also Fig. 3).
Number of experiments
P l a t i n ~ ~taken
m
Platinum recovered
Experimeilts showed that the Pt(1V) could also be quantitatively recovered by 90 ml.
of 2.4 M perchloric acid. T h e same observation was made with 3-cm. resin beds in the
smaller columns; in these cases the platinum was recovered by 60 ml. of the 2.4 M
perchloric acid (see Fig. 3).
Number of experiments 7
P l a t i n ~ ~taken
m 490 y
Platinum recovered (4 cases) 488-492 y (I)*
( 3 cases) 488-490 y (s)*
*I means larger column, s smaller.
840 C.AXADIAN JOURN.AL O F C H E M I S T R Y . VOL. 30, 1958
save for the bit of fused glass wool. Results of the analysis of this solution after filtration
are given below, ancl indicate that this procedure is n simple and satisfactory one for the
recovery of the metal.
Number of experi~nents
Platinum taken
Platinum recovered
2.5 cm. deep and were eluted with 100 ml. of 12 ill hydrochloric acid followecl by 90 ml.
of 2.4 d l perchloric acid. The smaller columils c o ~ ~ t a i n eresin
d beds 3 cm. deep, and were
eluted with 60 ml. of 9 M hydrochloric acid follolved by 75 ml. of 2.4 ill perchloric acid.
The results are su~nmarizedbelow:
Nurnber of experiments
Platinum taken
Platinum recovered ( 4 cases) 487-496 (1)
(3 cases) 490-491 -i (s) 97-102 7
Palladiu~ntaken 478 y 96 y
Palladium recovered ( 4 cases) 468-480 y (I)
( 3 cases) 476-47s -y ( s ) 95-96 7
were evaporated to dryiless with G mg. of sodium chloride, redissolved in one or two
milliliters of water, and fed onto the bed with a dropper. Elutions were made with 50 ml.
of "M hydrochloric acid followed by 50 ml. of 9 M hydrochloric acid. The results are
included in the following table.
Number of experiments 6
Rhodiurn taken 409 -j
Rhodium recovered ( 3 cases) 499-500 1 (1 )
(3 cases) 500-501 y (s)
Palladium taken 478 -1
P a l l a d i ~ ~recoverecl
m (3: cases) 478-479 y (I)
(3 cases) 476-478 y (s)
I t was noticed in this separation that as the rhodium was being eluted with the 2 M
Can. J. Chem. Downloaded from cdnsciencepub.com by 82.210.178.95 on 05/14/21
hydrochloric acid the palladium band slowly moved and diffused part way down the
bed. This is the only instance in this work where a platiil~immetal band was seen to move.
Owing to this partial nligratioll it was possible to recover the palladium with 40 ml. of
0 M hydrochloric acid (Fig. 4) in contrast to the 60 ml. needed in the palladium-platinum
separation.
For personal use only.
ML, ELUANT
FIG.4. Elution curves for the separation of rhodium, palladium, and platinum (small colurnn). R h :
eluted with 50 ml. 2 111 hydrochloric acid solution, Pd: eluted with 50 ml. 9 1
11hydrochloric acid solution,
Pi:-eluted with 75 rnl. of 2.4 il/l perchloric acid solution.
chloride and the residues redissolvecl in 1 ml. of water. The iridium was recluced with a
few drops of 1% hydroxylammoniu~nchloride solution, and the solutions fecl onto 3-cm.
beds in small columns. These beds hacl been previously washed with 10 ml. of 2 M h~.clro-
chloric acid. The be+ were eluted with 80 ml. of the acid solution to recover the rhodiu~ll
and iridium, followed by 50 ml. of 9 M hydrochloric acid for the palladium. The first
effluents were evaporated to clr>.ness and the residues redissolved in 2 ml. of 0.8 111'
hydrochloric acid (also containing cerium(1V) sulphate a t a concentration of 0.001 M).
These solutio~lswere fed with a dropper onto small colum~lscontaining 3-cm. beds of
resin which had been prepared with quadrivalent cerium, and the rhodium-iridium
separation was carried out as described in the previous communication (ti).
The procedure was repeated but the palladium was eluted with 50 ml. of 0.5 ill per-
For personal use only.
chloric acid. The rhodium and iridium were not determined in these experiments. 'The
various results are summarized below.
N ~ ~ m b of
e r experiments
Iridi~imtalcen
Iridium recovered
Rhodi~nntalren
IZhodium recovered
Palladium talien
Palladium recovered 476-479 y (elut& with HC1)
476-479 7 (3 eluted with I-IC104)
Further examination showed t h a t some platinum was being eluted along with t h e
palladium b u t had not been noticed since this small quantity produced a negligible
interference in the palladium determinations. I t is believed t h a t this early elution of the
platinum was due t o a partial reduction of the quadrivalent metal t o the bivalent state
by the hydroxylamine used t o reduce the iridium. T h e bivalent platinum evidently has
much the same affinity for the resin a s the bivalent palladium.
An unsuccessful search was made for a reducing agent which would reduce the quadri-
valent iridium but not a n y of the quadrivalent platinum. Best results (94% recovery
of the platinum in the "platinum fraction") were obtained by the slow reduction of
the iridium in neutral solution by sodium oxalate.
An a t t e m p t t o reoxidize the platinum on the exchanger with cerium(1V) after the
Can. J. Chem. Downloaded from cdnsciencepub.com by 82.210.178.95 on 05/14/21
Solutions of the four metals were treated as above, a n d again all t h e platinum was
found in the filtrates, indicating i t s separation from t h e other three metals.
T h e oxide precipitate from one of these experiments was dissolved in concentrated
hydrochloric acid, evaporated t o dryness, a n d the three metals separated as described
above. A quantitative separation of t h e four metals was accomplished b y this means.
Talien Found
Rhodium
Iridiuin
Palladium
Platinum
microgram scale.
REFERENCES
1. MACNEVIN, 117. M. and CRUMMETT, W.B. Anal. Chem. 25, 1628 (1953).
2. MACNEVIN, W. M. and CRUMMETT, W. B. Anal. Chim. Acta, 10, 323 (1954).
3. STEVENSOX, P. C., FRANK, A. A,, BORG,R., and NERVII~, W. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 75, 48761(1953).
4. BLASIUS, E. and ~VACHTEL, U. Z. anal. Chem. 154, 341 (1954).
5. MACNEVIN, W. M. and McICAY,E. S. Anal. Chern. 29, 1220 (1957).
6. BERMAN, S. S. and MCBRYDE, W. A. E. Can. J . Chem. 36, 845 (1958).
7. KRAUS, I<. rl., NELSON, F., and SMITH, G. W. J . l'hys. Chem. 58, 11 (1954).
8. HOLZER, 'I. Z. anal. Chem. 23, 299 (1951).
9. FRASER, J. G., BEXMISH, F. E., and ~/ICBRYDE,\v. A. E. AnaI. Chem. 26, 495 (1954).
10. YOE,J. I-I. and I<IRI<LAND, J. J . Anal. Chem. 26, 1335 (1954).
11. FRASBR, J. G. M.A. Thesis, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario. 1951.
12. AYRES,G. 1-1. and MBYER, A. S. Anal. Che~n.23, 299 (1951).
13. AYRES,G. 13. and YOUXG, F. Anal. Chem. 22, 1277 (1950).
14. FISHER, S. and I<UNIN, R. Anal. Chem. 27, 1191 (1955).
15. WALTON, 13. F. Chap. 1. In Ion exchange. Edited by F. C. Nachod, Acadenlic Press, Inc., New York.
1949.
16. KRAUS, I<. A. and WIOORE, G. E. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 75, 1460 (1953).
17. SUSSMAN, S., NACHOD, F. C., and WOOD, W. Ind. Erlg. Chem. 37, 618 (1945).
18. GILCHRIST, R. Chap. 20. 171 Applied inorganic analysis. 2nd ed. By Hillebrand, Lundell, Bright, and
Hoffman. John Wiley Sr Sons, Inc., New York. 1953.