Professional Documents
Culture Documents
These PERALES
These PERALES
! "$#%'&(
*)+,- .- )/0
1 254!64
3
798;:=<>8;?=@BACEDF<>GHAI;<BJLKEAMKEA
NPORQTSVUWYX NYU Z-[\WY]_^a`RU%XYbc^;S U d * O ]eSVfVU%Z$Z$^;UX g^ ^
h FD ikj
DF7=GFDFC=Aml no
j
JaCEDFpq:EALr9sMoCEDFAnojtJaC=DFpq:EAMA@uso
CEDHAvwDHxyDFG
z 8a<|{}JL@BDH8;C h 8yj@|8;<BJaGHAml+no
j
JaCEDFpq:EAKEAi~{}JL@|o
<|DFJa:gA@KEAi{DFGHDFA
:y0j8;{7EGFA=Ai
r
KEA
i~ik@|<|:Ej@B:E<kA
i~A@~ikyik@|
{A
i
j8;GFA h 8yj@|8;<BJLGFAml C=\8;<|{}JL@|DF8;CEiry@|<|:Ej@B:E<kA
irqgi@B
{}Ai
7E<|oi|ACq@|o
AA@~i|8;:g@BA
Cq:EA7E:E?=GFDFpq:EA{}AC@
7EJa<
X$y*fVUXRZmU/b
GFA;mi|A7=@BA{m?E<kAmaa
\'
)-'
,M¡) (¢(£M¢¤¢$,-&-c,¢(
)
$0(
!)
R-,.-
!5,(%
*)¢
%>
¦¥
(§£+,¨©,¨)-ªc¡)V«¬ (
*)¤(c,m£
®--ª9,-&-
¯¥
°- ±
n/nT² z e ² ³´µu¶ h>· ¸ ¹ <k8a\A
iki|A
:=<
r9n8;C@B7ºA
GHGFDHA
<ck ¹ <|o
ikDFKEAC@
nT²$v>´Mn/´ ¹ <k8a\A
iki|A
:=<
rµ~CEDHxaA
<|ikDH@B»KEDm¶8;{}J¼~´¶ ¶JL7E798a<k@BA:E<
½ ¶>s · ¼ · r¾¶8;{A
nT²$³ · ¸ h DF<|Aj@|A
:E<MKEA(<|AjÀ¿EA
<kjÀ¿EA0o{}o<|DÁ@BAv ¸ ¶9r ¶JL7E798a<k@BA:E<
nJa<|ikA
DFGHGFA k
nT² ¸u n/´Mºà CEikA
DHI;CJaC@kÃÅvw¿EA
<kjÀ¿EA
:=<
r j8;GFAKEAi¯nDHCEA
i EJL{}DHCJL@BA:E<
s · ÅÄÆÄ · ¶ h KÇ · GF
i
vu²3È>´É · ¼> ¶ ¹ <k8a\A
iki|A
:=<
rºÄn/svRÃwn8;C@B7ºA
GHGFDHA
<ck h DF<kA
j@BA
:=<~K=AM@|¿E
ikA
nT² ½ ¸ vcÉ CEikA
DHI;CJaC@kÃÅvw¿EA
<kjÀ¿EA
:=<
r j8;GFAKEAi¯nDHCEA
i vw8LÃK=DF<|Aj@|A
:E<
KÇ · GF
i
¼Ê<|JtxaJL:g<|o
JaGFDHi|oi»(GËÇ j8;GFAKEAi n%DFCEAi~KÇ · GF
iwÃwvwAC@B<|AKEAi nJÌ@Bo
<kDÍJa:y-KEAs<BJaCEK=A h DHÎ9:Ei|DH8;C
F EX()%*;/I%u?46.)%$&%*?EFw9!#%$&%!#'%()%!2t4G-9%$&@A%[o46(0.0.R46!#B= %*;#%(0uJ*n46*WE
'#:%!#'#:%1,!v4613TV2c[d]jm?C4d'<@A*;XED46*WE#
BC();X+ @A*,(0S,(0.0(0E#IJ=W.R4fqW1n46.0(0E#IvB,v;D<;'<@A*;#%(0.);VB46*;/B,v*@A$S,!#%1CG3B,@A$h46(0*<;VED46*WEV;X1,!/.)8+,.R46*Y;#'%()%*?EX(_pnqW1qW1
+ %!#;#@A*,*%.%E/;#@A*h;#@A1,EX()%*3$&@A!D46.+O%*B46*WE/.)<;$&@A$&%*?E#;VBC(_h'%(0.)<;/B,".R4oEX:l<;#"@A*WE/I%E#I"B,I%E#%!X$-(0*n46*WE#;8B46*;
.bKM46S @A1,EX();#;#%$&%*WEB,o'<oEX!D4>NA46(0.bm
Y!#%$&%!#'%()LuJ!D46*B,%$&%*?EP.)<;j$&%$S,!#<;hBC1y{46SO@A!D46E#@A(0!#B,\2I<'>46*,()qW1\%EhB,U[dI%*,()UT/(0NH(0."B,\2@A*WE
+ %.0.0()%!8+O@A1,!8.)%1,!v4A'<'%1%(0..)@A!#;"B,d$&<;8*@A$S,!#%1CGL;#IX@A1,!#;"46(0*;X(
qW1d.)d+O%!#;D@A*,*%.4ABC$-(0*,();XEX!D46EX(_",v%(0*J=
.0();¡46SO%EX:
=,[9(0.0S %!XE>m0m0mWqW1,(O4'<@A*?EX!X(0S,1Io4613;X1,(0NH(%EFwo.R4SO@A*,*v!#I>46.0();D46EX()@A*YB,v$&@A*3+n46!#'<@A1,!#;V;D'%()%*?EX(_pnqW1Jm
/£\
O
T PEX!D4<NJ46(0.8*
KM461,!D46(0E-+,1y46SO@A1,EX(0!&;¡46*;g.bKM46()B,Y(0*'<@A*BC(0EX()@A*,*%.0.)B,P$h4Lb46$-(0.0.)J=%*}+n46!XEX()'%1,.0()%!-$&<;j+n4
V
!#%*WE#;v%E8$&@A*\ !#l%!#fqW1,($LKi@A*?EvE#@A1AX@A1,!#;"%*'<@A1,!D46u Ig%E";#@A1,E#%*?1E#@A1,E461\.)@A*,uhB,f'<<;v46*,*I<<;~m
!#"%$&''
()'
*&
+,"-&
*"-,.
/,0,1'
23
4 m 4 {
<;vI%.)I%$&%*WE#;'<@A!X+; momfmfmomfmomfmmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom 506
4 m 4 m 4 {
<;8$h46E#I%!X(R461CGL$-(0*I%!D461CG mmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom 506
4 m 4 m75 {
<;8$h46E#I%!X(R461CGU@A!Xu?46*,()qW1<; momfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom 508
4 m 4 m76 {
<;8$h46E#I%!X(R461CGLN I%u I%ED461CG mmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom 508
4 m75 {
<;vI%.)I%$&%*WE#;B,*9 X@A(0*?E#;:9 momfmomfmmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom 508
4 m7C5 m 4 @A*'%EX()@A*;vBC1U$&@A!XEX()%!tmomfmmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom 508
4 m7C5 m75 ]9(_^ I%!#%*WE#;"$h46E#I%!X(R461CGL'<@A$-+O@J;¡46*?Ev.)d$&@A!XEX()%!momfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom 5;
4 m76 ¢!#I<;#%*WED46EX()@A*tB,<;"BC(_^I%!#%*?E#<;$h4<< @A*,*%!X()<; momfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom J5
4 m = {sKM46+,+n46!#%(0.ymfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom 64
4 m = m 4 ¢@J;#(0EX()@A*B,<;"I%.)I%$&%*WE#;vB46*;".bKM46+,+n46!#%(0.0.R46u cmmomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom 605
4 m = m75 vl%uJ.)<;"BKM46+,+n46!#%(0.0.R46u Zwj!#<;X+ <'%E#%! momfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom 61=
4 m7> ]jK 1,*L+O@A(0*WEvB,oNH1d$&I<'>46*,()q?1o.)<;"I%.)I%$&%*?E#;'<@A!X+;}momfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom 608
4 m7C> m 4 s;#;D46();v%E8!#I<;X1,.0ED46E#;vB,d.R4j!#I<;#();XED46*'<f%*L'<@A$-+,!#<;#;X()@A*U1,*,(R4GH(R46.) mfmfmomfmomfmmom 6;
4 m7C> m75 s;#;D46();v%E8!#I<;X1,.0ED46E#;vB,d.R4j!#I<;#();XED46*'<wZ.R4ZEX!D4A'%EX()@A*Q` $&I%EX:@HB,o(0*BC(0!#<'%E#~eZmomfmmom 6J
4 m7C> m76 7(0E#<;D;#oB,<;"@A*B,<;"I%.R4A;XEX()qW1<;mfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom =0=
4 m7C> m = T/:@A(_GYB,<;v$h46E#I%!X(R461CGYGC%$-+,.)f;#1,!81,*f;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#o$h4<< @A*,*I<3C1,*f'<@A1,+&A? .) m ='>
4 m7C> m7> TV@A*'%.01;X()@A* momfmfmomfmomfmmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom ='8
4 m78 ]jK 1,*L+O@A(0*WEvB,oNH1d$&I<'>46*,()q?1o.)<;"I%.)I%$&%*?E#;s
@A(0*WE#;C.)o$&@A!XEX()%! mommomfmfmomfmomfmmom ='8
4 m7C8 m 4 @ 1,NW!D46S,(0.0(0E#I momfmfmomfmomfmmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom =;
4 m7C8 m75 ¢!X();#cmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom ='A
4 m7C8 m76 vI<;X();#ED46*'<<;8$&I<'>46*,()q?1<; mmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom ='A
4 mB; ¢!#@A+,!X()I%E#I<;9B,o.bK (0*?E#%!
b4A'< momfmomfmmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom >4
4 mBH; m 4 *WE#%!
4A'<fS,.)@W'C S,.)@H' mfmomfmmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom >05
4 mBH; m75 *WE#%!
4A'<fS,.)@W'C $&@A!XEX()%! mfmmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom >;
4 m7A ¢!#@A+,!X()I%E#I<;9B,<;8$h4<< @A*,*%!X()<; momfmmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom 84
4 m7CA m 4 TV@A$-+O@A!XE#%$&%*WEB,<;v$h4<< @A*,*%!X()<;v%*U'<@A$-+,!#<;#;#()@A*L1,*,(R4GH(R46.) momfmfmomfmomfmmom 84
4 m7CA m75 TV@A$-+O@A!XE#%$&%*WEB,<;v$h4<< @A*,*%!X()<;v%*LEX!D4A'%EX()@A*L1,*,(R4GC(R46.)Lmfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom 805
4 m7CA m76 TV@A$-+O@A!XE#%$&%*WEvS,(R4GC(R46.B,<;8$h4<< @A*,*%!X()<; mmomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom 806
4 mM TV@A*'%.01;X()@A*Lmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom 8;
2 DE)131FG3,)#H1IJ,K,EL3HNM
E,)O#"%$&' PQ
C5 m 4 2@HB,I%.0();D46EX()@A*U'<@A*WEX(0*?1ZB,<;8$h4<< @A*,*%!X()<;}mfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom ;5
C5 m 4 m 4 2@HB,I%.0();D46EX()@A*L+n46!81,*U$-(0.0()%1wZ1,*o+,:n4A;#&C$h4A'%!#@6b$&@HB,I%.0();D46EX()@A* mfmomfmomfmmom ;6
C5 m 4 m75 2@HB,I%.0();D46EX()@A*L+n46!81,*U$-(0.0()%1wZ+,.01;X()%1,!#;"+,:n4A;D<;f,$-()'%!#@6b$&@HB,I%.0();D46EX()@A* momfmmom ;A
C5 m75 T/:@A(_GLB,o.R4Z$&I%EX:@WB,B,o$&@WB,I%.0();¡46EX()@A* momfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom A1=
C5 m76 [dI%*I%!D46.0(0E#I<;9;X1,!8.)<;8$&I%EX:@HB,<;"+n46!"I%.)I%$&%*?E#;9BC();#'%!#%E#; mfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom A08
>
?PC
1"-+N#N&!
&"%
!
, "%'IJ,
!"%)M" & "-,.#"%$&''
£Q
=m 4 vI<;#@A.01,EX()@A*U.)@W'>46.)fB,d+,!#@AS,.)l%$&<;9;XED46EX()qW1%$&%*?E(0*B,I%E#%!X$-(0*I<; momfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom 4 ?=
, , '# :#N& LH'"-)IJ, )'
/1,0,:
O1H'NM M
%"-M " & 3,LH
IJ, 1L
)NM M %Q
)M :"%F) 2£
?PC
\
-<
.R4gpuJ1,!#oB,dBC!#@A(0E#J=,BC1YBC(R46uJ!D46$-$&'<@A*?EX!D46(0*?E#B,I%+,.R4A'<%$&%*WEh` <;XEF.R4g!#I<;X();XED46*'<fwg.R4
-< 5 08
46./` {
@A1,!#%* <@` JJ eXe fmo 84
'<@A$-+,!#<;#;X()@A*tBC1\$&@A!XEX()%!>=n{
@A1,!#%* <@ mfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom
m0
4 m ='5
z<;XE-B,3EX!D4A'%EX()@A* B46*;.R4BC(0!#<'%EX()@A*}+n46!D46.0.)l%.)Y461Q+,.R46* B,fX@A(0*?E>=|x84A'# <; 46.9` x84A'# <;
4 0A0>
` eXe9momfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom 805
4 m ='6
z]9(R46uJ!D46$-$&f'<@A*?EX!D46(0*WE#B,I%+,.R4A'<%$&%*?Ef;#@A1;8B,<;8<;#;¡46();8B,dEX!D4A'%EX()@A*LB46*;8.R4ZBC(0!#<'%EX()@A*L+n4
WC
+O@A1,! momfmfmomfmommfmomfmomfmomfmmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommfmom
x y
484
= m 4 = vI>4A'%EXF()@A*=
x
;v*10000N
@A!X$h46.)<;v%E"ED46*,u %*WEX()%.0.)<;9461CGY*@W%1B,;BC1\+,!X();X$&o+ @A1,! mfmom 4 805
=m 4 z> vI>4A'%EX()@A*;v*@A!X$h46.)<;v%E"ED46*,u %*WEX()%.0.)<;9461CGY*@W%1B,;BC1\+,!X();X$&o+ @A1,! M = −200N m mom x F = 10000N
4 806
=m 4 z8 v%+,!#I<;#%*WED46EX()@A* B,<;\4A'<'<I%.)I%!D46EX()@A*;\.0(0*I>46(0!#<; Γ = Γ %E\B,!#@AED46EX()@A* Ω̇ 461a'<%*WEX!#cB, z
uJ!D4<NH(0E#IBC1\+,!X();X$&f+O@A1,! x y
mfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom
z
4 81=
=m 4 y; vI>4A'%EX()@A*;v*@A!X$h46.)<;v%E"EDM46*,u %=*WEX−60000N
z
()%.0.)<;9461CGYm*@W%1B,;BC1\+,!X();X$&o+ @A1,! m 4 80>
=m 4 zA vI>4A'%EX()@A*;v*@A!X$h46.)<;v%E"ED46*,u %*WEX()%.0.)<;9461CGY*@W%1B,;BC1\+,!X();X$&o+ @A1,! F = −m ∗ g ∗ f z M = −60000N m
4 808
=m 4 [dI<@A$&I%EX!X()BC1'%1,SO momfmfmomfmomfmmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom x
4 8;
=m7J5 zvI>4A'%EX()@A*;*@A!X$h46.)<;d%EvED46*,u %*?EX()%.0.)<;f461CGL*@H%1B,;vBC1t'%1,SO+O@A1,! F = 1000N %E F =
mfmmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmfmomfmomfmommfmomfmomfmomfmmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmfmom
x y
4 80A
= m75 4 v%+,!#I<;#%*WED46EX()@A*3B,<;4A'<'<I%.)I%!D46EX()@A*;.0(0*I>46(0!#<;
−1000N
%E 461&'<%*?EX!#"B,FuJ!D4>NW(0E#IvBC1&'%1,SOF+ @A1,!
Fx = 40000N
%E
Fy = −40000N
Γ Γ
mfmomfmomfmoxmfmmoymfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommfmom 4 J8
%2
WC
vI>4A'%EX()@A*;v*@A!X$h46.)<;v%E"ED46*,u %*WEX()%.0.)<;9461CGY*@W%1B,;BC1L'%1,SOf+O@A1,!
=m751= v%+,!#I<;#%*WED46EX()@A* B,<;\4A'<'<I%.)I%!D46EX()@A*;\.0(0*I>46(0!#<; Γ = Γ %E\B,!#@AED46EX()@A* Ω̇ 461a'<%*WEX!#cB, M = −400N m
momfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom 4 ;5
z
£Y
WC
> & W
4 m4 4 ;:=
TF46!D4A'%E#I%!X();XEX()qW1<;v$&I<'>46*,()qW1<;vB,<;8!#@H'#:<;v(0*?ED4A'%E#<;>=xV()%*n4 ";XH(/` xV()%*n4 ";XH(/` WeXeFmmom ='6
4 m75 TF46!D4A'%E#I%!X();XEX()qW1<;Y$&I<'>46*,()q?1<;\B,<;P!#@H'#:<;P$&@> %*,*%$&%*WE\ !D4A'%EX1,!#I<<;~=/xV()%*n4 ";#W(&` xV()
4 ;:=
*n4 ";XH(/` WeXe mommomfmfmomfmomfmmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom '= 6
4 m76 TF46!D4A'%E#I%!X();XEX()qW1<;d$&I<'>46*,()q?1<;9B,<;v!#@H'#:<;v@A!XE#%$&%*?E9 !D4A'%EX1,!#I<<;~=xV()%*n4 ";#W(F` x/()%*n4 ";XH(
4 ;:=
` WeXe9momfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom '= 6
>Cm 4
5 4 ` JJ eXe9momfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom
T/:n46!Xu <;fN %!XEX()'>46.)<;g%Ef:@A!X(0>@A*?ED46.)<;g$&<;X1,!#I<<;>m
{j$1,!g<;#EfB,I<;X(0uJ*Ij+n46!Zm *
m $ @c$
<;XE.)v*@A$S,!#dB,"$g1,!#;/;D@A1,$-();Vwf.R4f'#:n46!Xu N %!XEX()'>46.)9*` %*PHoe= v@H'>4 46.` @W'>4o%EF46.bm
4 A05
>Cm75 <
>Cm76
TF46!D4A'%E#I%!X();XEX()qW1<;/$&I<'>46*,()qW1<;FB,<;$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;FBC13+O@A*WE8HoTVrB,".R42U(0.0.)%EXE#J=W]d@A$&l<B,
5 08
46.` ]d@A$&l<B,3` JJ eXe mfmomfmomfmmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom J
TF46!D4A'%E#I%!X();XEX()qW1<;/B,8.bK (0*WE#%!
4A'<vS,!X()q?1b$&@A!XEX()%!VBC1-+O@A*WEVHoTVV=?]9@A$&l<B, 46.` ]d@A$&l<B,
4
5 08 ` JJ eXe9momfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom 4 4
>Cm = &?
746.)%1,!#;vB,<;^ @A!XE#;";#1,!8.)<;";#@A$-$-()%!#;vB,d.R4&'<@A1,+ A.) momfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom J 5 1=
>Cm7> 9 90505
TF4A;*@A*CbuJ.0();D;D46*?E>mW746.)%1,!#;B,<;/!#I>4A'%EX()@A*;/;#1,!'#:n4AqW1"*@H%1BhBC1h'%1,S 8$&I%EX:@WB, %'<@A1,+,.)I< J
>Cm78 9
TF4A;9*@A*CbuJ.0();#;D46*?E>m746.)%1,!#;dB,<;v!#I>4A'%EX()@A*;d;X1,!9'#:n4AqW1*@H%1BUBC15'%1,S o/$&I%EX:@HB, %'%.R4A;
;X()qW1od,TV] 9 mfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom J 505
>CmB; !9 9 505 4
TF4A;"uJ.0();#;¡46*?E>m,746.)%1,!#;B,<;8!#I>4A'%EX()@A*;v;X1,!"'D:n4Aq?1*@W%1B\BC1'%1,SO9$&I%EX:@HB, %'<@A1,+,.)I<
>Cm7A 9
TF4A;9uJ.0();#;D46*?E>mO746.)%1,!#;dB,<;!#I>4A'%EX()@A*;o;X1,!9'D:n4Aq?1g*@H%1BBC15'%1,SOF$&I%EX:@WB, %'%.R4A;#;X()qW1
d,TV] 9 mfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom 505 4
>CmM TF4A;vB,dSn4A;#'%1,.)%$&%*WE>mn746.)%1,!#;B,<;8!#I>4A'%EX()@A*;v;#1,!"'#:n4AqW1o*@W%1BUBC1L*@A1,N >461L+ @A.0 l<BC!#d
9 9
$&I%EX:@WB, %'<@A1,+,.)I< momfmfmomfmomfmmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom 50505
>Cm 4 TF4A;vB,dSn4A;#'%1,.)%$&%*WE>mn746.)%1,!#;B,<;8!#I>4A'%EX()@A*;v;#1,!"'#:n4AqW1o*@W%1BUBC1L*@A1,N >461L+ @A.0 l<BC!#d
9
$&I%EX:@WB, %'%.R4A;#;X()qW1od,TV] 9 momfmmomfmomfmomfmfmommomfmomfmfmomfmommomfmfmomfmomfmmom 50505
> h?
P
O
O
{ 45+,!#%$-()l%!#\+n46!XEX()UB,L'<%EXE#\EX:l<;#\GC+O@J;DY.R45B,Ip*,(0EX()@A*B,<;&BC(_^I%!#%*?E#;3'<@A*;XEX(0EX1n46*?E#;3BK 1,*\$h4
< <@A*,*%!X()Z%E".)%1,!#;$-();#<;v%*+,.R4A'<B46*;1,*;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#Jm{
<;'<@A*;#EX(0EX1n46*?E#;d;#@A*?E9B,B,%1CGL;#@A!XE#<;Z,S,.)@H'%E
$&@A!XEX()%!>m {
%1,!#;o46u %*'<%$&%*?E#;o;D@A*?EdB,BC(0N %!#;#<;@A!X$&<;%EdB,I<'%!X(0E#;9+n46!1,*N @W'>46S,1,.R46(0!#j;X+ I<'%(_pnq?1JmO.%*
GC();XE#d+,.01;X()%1,!#;94<N <'fB,<;8!#l%uJ.)<;BKM46+,+n46!#%(0.0.R46u ZwZ!#<;#+O<'%E#%!>m
¢|@A1,!9'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();D%!v.)'<@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?E9$&I<'>46*,()qW1B,<;S,.)@W'<;"%E9B,<;"$&@A!XEX()%!#;>=n+,.01;X()%1,!#;9B,<;#'%!X(0+,EX()@A*;GH
+ I%!X(0$&%*?ED46.)<;o;#@A*WE+,!#I<;D%*?E#I<<;>mO{sKi@ASCX<'%EX(_/<;XEBKi@A+,EX(0$-();D%!9.)g+,.R4A'<%$&%*?EoB,<;S,.)@W'<;9%EdBC1U$&@A!XEX()%!oB46*;
<
.R4Z$h4 <@A*,*%!X()+O@A1,!8b4<N @A!X();D%!".R4-;XED46S,(0.0(0E#IfB,d.R4&;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#Jm
C C
*gI%EX1B,jB,Z.bK (0*?E#%!
b4A'<ZS,.)@W' S,.)@H'j%EdS,.)@W' $&@A!XEX()%!o<;XEd^ <'%EX1I<Z.)@H'>46.)%$&%*?E4p*cB,jB,I%E#%!X$-(0*%!o;#<;
@
BC(_^I%!#%*?E#;$&@WB,<;oB,j!X1,+,EX1,!#&%*5@A*'%EX()@A* B,<;o'D:n46!Xu %$&%*?E#;>m *rGH+,.)@A(0E#-%*;#1,(0E#&wP1,*c*,(0N >461ruJ.)@ASn46.
'<%EXE#"I%EX1B,"+n46!B,<;s<;#;D46();B,";XEX!X1'%EX1,!#<;4p*hBKi%*P46*n46.0H;#%!.)8'<@A$-+O@A!XE#%$&%*WE/$&I<'>46*,()qW1v;#@A1;BC(0N %!#;#<;
Y
O
;#@A.0.0()'%(0ED46EX()@A*;~m
{ 4-;#<'<@A*B,d+n46!XEX()f$&%Ev%*LI%NW()B,%*'<f.)<;"BC(_^ I%!#%*WE#<;46+,+,!#@H'#:<;v*?1,$&I%!X()qW1<;GC();XED46*?E#<;"+O@A1,!8$&@HB,I
<
.0();#%!1,*-$h4 <@A*,*%!X()Jm{KM46+,+,!#@W'D:h+n46!f.R4\$&I%EX:@WB,&B,<;gI%.)%$&%*?E#;p*,();<;XE.0(0$-(0E#I<&B46*;f.)&'>4ABC!#3B,<;
<
$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;s%*j!D46();#@A*-B,<;BC();#'<@A*WEX(0*?1,(0E#I<;su I<@A$&I%EX!X()qW1<;s%EB46*;|.R4+,.01,+n46!XEsB,<;'>4A;|B,V.R4*@A*CGC();XE#%*'<
BK 1,*\N @A.01,$&fI%.)I%$&%*WED46(0!#f!#%+,!#I<;#%*WED46EX(_
m v*o46+,+,!#@H'#:o+n46!I%.)I%$&%*?E#;vBC();D'%!#%E#;";#%$S,.)d+,.01;46+,+,!#@A+,!X()I<
<
+ @A1,!o;X(0$1,.)%!B,<;o;#EX!X1'%EX1,!#<;o$h4 <@A*,*I<<;o!#I<%.0.)<;>m{
<;g4<NJ46*?ED46u <;f%Eo(0*'<@A*WN I%*,()%*?E#;ZB,<;oBC(_^ I%!#%*WE#<;o$&I
EX:@HB,<;8+n46!vI%.)%$&%*WE#;BC();#'%!#%E#;v;#@A*?E46S @A!#B,I<;>m
{4fEX!#@A();X()l%$&+n46!XEX()vEX!D46(0E#9B,".R4B,I%E#<'%EX()@A*PB,<;V'<@A*?ED4A'%E#;>mH]o46*;1,*3$&@WB,l%.)9BC();#'%!#%E>=?.R4B,I%E#<'%EX()@A*YB,<;
'<@A*WED4A'%E#;v<;XEFEX!#l<;F(0$-+ @A!XED46*?E#f%E"'<@A*BC(0EX()@A*,*o.R4jqW1n46.0(0E#IdBC1L'>46.)'%1,.
B,o;XED46S,(0.0(0E#IoB,<;8;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#<;>m,{KiI%EX1B,
B,<;"BC(_^I%!#%*?E#;946.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&<;vB,oB,I%E#<'%EX()@A*UB,<;v'<@A*?ED4A'%E#;vGC();XED46*WE#;vB46*;8.)<;8B,@A$h46(0*<;B,d.R4Z!#@ASO@AEX()qW1f%E
B,Z.R43!#I>46.0(0E#IjNW(0!XEX1%.0.)J= t'<@A$-+,!X();d.bKM46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&-(0$-+,.)I%$&%*?E#If1;Dq?1
KMwh*@AEX!#-'<@A*?EX!X(0S,1,EX()@A* B46*;f.)Z'<@HB,
B,o'>46.)'%1,.|{
25[TFJj$&%E"%*UI%NH()B,%*'<fB,<;8+,!#@AS,.)l%$&<;9B46*;8.R4ju <;XEX()@A*LB,<;'<@A*?ED4A'%E#;>m
]d%NJ46*?E1,*hB,I%E#<'%EX()@A*+ %!
<'%EX(0S,.)hB,<;f+ @A.0 l<BC!#<;g%*WEX!#h%1CG=1,*r*@A1,N %.V46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&PB,&B,I%E#<'%EX()@A*}B,<;
<
'<@A*WED4A'%E#;g4\I%E#I-B,I%N %.)@A+,+ IJm|TV%.01,(_'%(<;#Ef;X+OI<'%(_pnqW1&461CG5$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;gB46*;o.)<;Dq?1%.0.)<;o.)h'<@A*?ED4A'%Eg%*WEX!#
C
C C
;#@A.0()B,<;9<;XE9<;#;#%*?EX()%.0.)%$&%*WEoB,EW+ ob4A'< ~4A'<g%E946!#l%E# ~b4A'<Jm]d<;9;X(0EX1n46EX()@A*;dB,'<@A*WED4A'%E#;+n46!XEX()'%1,.0()l%!#<;
C
B,gEH+Oj46!#l%E# A46!#l%E#-%Eo46!#l%E# ~4A'<Z+ %1,N %*?Ef46+,+n46!D4 )EX!#jB46*;9'<%!XED46(0*<;o;#EX!X1'%EX1,!#<;>m]o46*;d'<%EXE#Z+n46!XEX()J=
.bKih'>4A'%(0E#ILB,Y'<P*@A1,N %.v46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&L<;XEj$-();#Y%* I%NH()B,%*'<\;X1,!-B,<;-'>4A;&4A'>4AB,I%$-()q?1<;-+,1,();&wEX!D4>N %!#;
.bKM46*n46.0C;#dBC1L'<@A$-+O@A!XE#%$&%*WEvB,d;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#<;"'<@A$-+ @J;#I<<;8BK 1,*\uJ!D46*BY*@A$S,!#oB,dS,.)@H'<;>=,wgu I<@A$&I%EX!X()d+n46!
EX()'%1,.0()l%!#J=@A1L'<@A$-+,!#%*n46*?EdB,<;"BC();X+ @J;X(0EX(_ ;8B,f+,!#I<'<@A*?EX!D46(0*?E#Jm
{ 4h'%(0*q?1,()l%$&g%EvB,%!X*,()l%!#+n46!XEX()EX!D46(0E#B,o.bKiI%EX1B,g%EB,o.R4-NA46.0()B46EX()@A*t*?1,$&I%!X()qW1B,.bKM46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&
<
B,\B,I%E#<'%EX()@A*y$-();-%*y@H%1,NH!#PB46*;hB,<;j$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;h%* EX!#@A();-BC(0$&%*;X()@A*;>m{
<;-!#I<;X1,.0ED46E#;j$&%EXE#%*WE3%*
6
I%NH()B,%*'<P.R4U!#@AS,1;#E#<;#;#PB,3.bKM46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&J=B,I%N %.)@A+,+ I\B46*;Z.R4+n46!XEX() C=wtB,I%E#<'%E#%!j.)<;-'<@A*?ED4A'%E#;>m¢|@A1,!
'<%.R4C= B,<;d;X(0$1,.R46EX()@A*;BCW*n46$-()qW1<;o;#@A*?Ed!#I>46.0();#I<<;dB46*;d.)<;#qW1%.0.)<;9.)<;9S,.)@W'<;9+ %1,N %*?Ef;#ZB,I%+,.R4A'<%!fB46*;
C C
+,.01;X()%1,!#;BC(0!#<'%EX()@A*;v%*WEX!D4 )*n46*?E9E#@A1;8EH+O<;B,o'<@A*?ED4A'%Ej`46!#l%E# A46!#l%E#J=;#@A$-$&%E ~b4A'<J=;#@A$-$&%E 6;D@A$-$&%E>=C
%E#'Jm em TV<;"E#<;XE#;v+O%!X$&%EXE#%*WE9B,N I%!X(_pn%!v.R4-*@A*Cb(0*WE#%!X+OI%*I%EX!D46EX()@A*rB,<;vS,.)@W'<;%*?EX!#g%1CGU%EvB,B,I%$&@A*WEX!#%!
.bKih'>4A'%(0E#IgB,d.bKM46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&Jm
{4NJ46.0()B46EX()@A*LB,<;/!#I>4A'%EX()@A*;8B,9'<@A*?ED4A'%E#;8<;#EV^<'%EX1I<9+n46!/1,*o46*n46.0C;#'<@A*'%!#l%E#dB,dBC(0N %!#;#<;FB,<;#'<%*WE#<;
!9 9
B,o'D:n46!Xu <;%E"B,oED4A;D;#%$&%*?E#;BC(_^ I%!#%*WEX()%.);>mn *Cp*
=.R4Z$&I%EX:@WB, %'<@A1,+,.)I< A=B,Ip*,()B46*;8.R4Z+n46!XEX() =,<;XE =
'<@A$-+n46!#I<fwg.R4g$&I%EX:@WB,oB,9!#I<;#@A.01,EX()@A*\+,!#I<'<I<B,%$-$&%*WEv(0$-+,.)I%$&%*WE#I<fB46*;F.)d'<@WB,dB,d'>46.)'%1,.
{
2c[fTFJCm
Q
O
2
cQ
'
"!$#"%&#"'(")+*,!.-0/1324!566.6.76.66.6.66.6.66.6.66.6.66 89
:<;=:<;=: >@?,AB$CEDGFIHGJKC0LNMB7J=OPFIHQCRLNMS;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; WRX
:<;=:<; W >@?,AB$CEDGFIHGJKC0LNMY0HGZ<C0O[J]\<LP?,A^;U;T;U;T;U;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; WR_
:<;=:<; X >@?,AB$CEDGFIHGJKC0LNM`0F,Z0FIDGCRL[Ma;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; WR_
b8 "!$#"%&#"'(")+*,!.cd(eGf3/g)+*,!"eh.76.66.6.66.6.66.6.66.6.66 8i
:<; W[;=: jPY0OPklDmJKY0OPAonNLpB7Y0HmDmJK?IH$;U;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; WR_
:<; W[; W qrJts+FIHG?IOuDQAoB$CEDmF,HmJ]CRL[MklY0B7v Y<AGCROuDow=?UB7Y0HmDmJK?IHT;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; W<x
]9 yU1z#"!3")+*,{N*3g&/ )|cd"!7cdg&}#u1Eu)+*3"!6'~{[0/ )d)u1Eg&"!6.6.66.6.66.6.66 8
K
={[2d24{N1E"g&%66.6.66.6.76.66.6.66.6.66.6.66.6.66 9@
:<; ;=: 4Y<AmJ=DmJKY0OpnN?,AoF,w=F,B7?IOuDGAon[C0OPAw C0v[vPCRHG?IJKwKwKC0Z0?;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; X<W
:<; ; W o,Z0wK?,Aon CRvPvPCRHG?IJKw=w]CRZ<?V6HG?,Amv?3kDG?IH;U;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; XR
b Kd)2/ g&)+*7cpd'~#u-<{[)g&
T%"!.#"%&#"'(")+*3!.-</P1z24!6.6.66.6.66 9 i
:<; [;=: AGAGCRJ]A?lD
HGF,AmL[wtDQCEDQAonN?UwKC7HGF,AmJKADGC0OPkl?V?IO kIY0B7v[HG?,AGAJKY0O5LPO[JKCRMNJKC0w=?S;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; Xux
:<; [; W AGAGCRJ]A?lD
HGF,AmL[wtDQCEDQAonN?UwKC7HGF,AmJKADGC0OPkl?U6wKC.DGHGC<kDmJKY0O¢¡£B7FIDm¤[YNnN?TJKOPnNJKHm?3kDG?3¥¦;T;U; X0§
:<; [; X ¨rJtDG?,AGA?nN?3AY0OPn[?,AFIw]C0ADmJ]\uL[?,A©;T;U;T;U;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; 0
:<; [; ª«¤[Y<JtM
nN?,AoB$CRDmFIHGJ]CRLNM$¬?IMN?IB7v[wK?UAmL[HoL[OP?ADGHmLPklDmL[HG?UB$C0®lY<O[O[F,?6¯NLPO[?klY<L[v°<w=? u
:<; [; ª«Y<OPklwKLPAmJ=Y<O ;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; <_
]i Kd)2/ g&)+*7cpd'~#u-<{[)g&
T%"!.#"%&#"'(")+*3!±f3/ g&)+*,!
²4%& '(/1z*,g<1³.66 +i
:<; _P;=: ´rL[`"HQCRµ[JKwKJtDGF¶;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; "x
:<; _P; W ·HGJ]A? ;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; <¸
:<; _P; X oF3AJ]ADGCROkl?,AB7F3kICROPJK\uL[?3A¹;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; <¸
bº yU1z/21zg#u*,#"!7cd%=g)+*,u1E»{P-0 .76.66.6.66.6.66.6.66.6.66
:<;¼xN;=: ½¾OuDm?,H¿&C<kl?Uµ[wKYNk3ÀzµPw=YNk;T;U;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; 0W
:<;¼xN;=:<; C ª«Y<B7vY<HDG?IB7?IOuDoB7F,kIC0O[J]\<LP?Un[L.ÁY<J=OuD;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; RX
:<;¼xN;=:<; µ ª«Y<B7vY<HDG?IB7?IOuDo?IOpklY<B6vPHm?3AmAmJ=Y<O;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; RX
:<;¼xN;=:<; k ª«Y<B7vY<HDG?IB7?IOuD
CRLpklJ]AmC0J=wKwK?IB7?IOuD;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; E
:<;¼xN;=:<; n ª«HGJ=DmIHG?UnN?THmLPvNDmL[HG?Â;T;U;T;U;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; 0
:<;¼xN;=:<; ? «AmAGCRJ]AnN?TwKC0µY<HGCRDmY<J=HG?;U;T;U;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; R_
:<;¼xN; W ½¾OuDm?,H¿&C<kl?Uµ[wKYNk3ÀzB7Y<HDGJ=?,H;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; <x
:<;¼xN; W[; C
L[vNDmLPHm?UvPC0HDmHQC0kDGJ=Y<O '~/cd"Ã ;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; <x
:<;¼xN; W[; µ
L[vNDmLPHm?UvPC0H
klJ]AmC0J=wKw=?,B7?IOuD '(/cuÃzà ;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; R§
23
j~ , P
n h
~
~
O
22
n vn3
< O9 9
{4\$h4 <@A*,*%!X()3<;XEfB,Ip*,()3'<@A$-$& .bKM46!XEB,&Sn6EX(0! -1,*&'<@A*;XEX!X1'%EX()@A*+n46!g4A;#;#%$gS,.R46u <;gB,hBC(_^ I%!#%*WE#;
I%.)I%$&%*WE#;>mn .0.)<;XE"'<@A*;X()B,I%!#I<f'<@A$-$&.R4ZE#<'#:,*,()qW1B,o'<@A*;XEX!X1'%EX()@A*.R4j+,.01;8!#I%+n46*BC1Jm
{
<;vI%.)I%$&%*?E#;9BK 1,*f'<@A*;XEX!X1'%EX()@A*;D@A*?Ev'%.R4A;#;DI<;"%*LB,%1CGL'>46E#I%u @A!X()<;
9 9
.)<;dI%.)I%$&%*WE#;fBC(0E#; %'<@A!X+; PO'<@A*;#EX(0EX1%*?Eo.bKi@ASCX%Ed<;D;#%*?EX()%.B,Z.R4h'<@A*;#EX!X1'%EX()@A*
mTV<;9I%.)I%$&%*WE#;f;#@A*WE
B,d•EX!#@A();vEH+O<;fC.)<;"$h46E#I%!X(R461CGL$-(0*I%!D461CG =,.)<;"$h46E#I%!X(R461CGU@A!Xu?46*,()q?1<;%E8.)<;8$h46E#I%!X(R461CGLN I%u I%ED461CG m
O9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9
.)<;hI%.)I%$&%*WE#;YBC(0E#; X@A(0*?E#; s;#@A*?E3.) X@A(0*?E U;D46*;&$&@A!XEX()%!c` @A1 X@A(0*?EY;#<' >ej%Eh.)
@A(0*WE 4>N <'
9 9 9 9
$&@A•!XEX()%!g` @A1
@A(0*WEvB,o$&@A!XEX()%! >emOTV<;vI%.)I%$&%*?E#;+O%!X$&%EXE#%*WEv.R4Z.0(R46();#@A*U%*WEX!#o.)<;"I%.)I%$&%*WE#; %<' @A!X+; Am
<
{
<;/@A1,NW!D46u <;/!#I>46.0();#I<;/%*h$h4 <@A*,*%!X()9;#@A*?EBC(0N %!#;V%EsNJ46!X()I<;v?$1,!#;>=W'%.)@A();#@A*;>=J+,(0.0()%!#;V%E'<@A.)@A*,*<;>=?N @ ,E#<;
?
%E"'<@A1,+ A.)<;>m0m0m
m
<
] 46*;'<%EXE#F+n46!XEX()J=J@A*-B,Ip*,(0E.)<;BC(_^ I%!#%*WE#;sI%.)I%$&%*?E#;'<@A*;XEX(0EX1n46*?E#;1,*/$h4 <@A*,*%!X()J=?%*jB,I%ED46(0.0.R46*WEs.R4
d
@
*n46EX1,!#oB,<;FI%.)I%$&%*?E#;'<@A!X+;8%E8B,<;VI%.)I%$&%*WE#;X@A(0*?E#;>m *\GC+O@J;#9%*;X1,(0E#J=,BK 1,*Y+ @A(0*?E"B,9NW19$&I<'>46*,()qW1J=
<
.bK (0$-+ @A!XED46*'<fBC1L'#:@A(_G\B,<;8$h46E#I%!X(R461CGLB46*;81,*d$h4 <@A*,*%!X()Jm s*Cp*
=@A*\$&@A*?EX!#o.)o'<@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?E9B,<;
<
$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;v4A'<fwjBC(0N %!#;D<;v;#@A.0.0()'%(0ED46EX()@A*;GHE#I%!X()%1,!#<;>m
Zm
©
¥ ¥ ©= q̳ q[
¢46!X$-(f.bKi%*;#%$gS,.) B,<;Y$h46E#I%!X(R461CG$-(0*I%!D461CGaGC();XED46*WE#;>="@A*GH+ @J;#5()'%(o.)<;\BC(_^I%!#%*?E#<;'>46E#I%u @A!X()<;UB,
S,!X()qW1<;"%EvB,d+,()%!X!#<;>m
•
" ) 1IJ,
{4S,!X()qW15<;XE31,EX(0.0();DI<tB,%+,1,();\B,<;P$-(0.0.)I%*n46(0!#<;>m8 s.0.)t<;#EP'<@A*;XEX(0EX1I<cBKM46!XuJ(0.)J=F'<%.0.)'%(f<;XEP1,*t!#@W'D:
;#I<BC(0$&%*WED46(0!#J=O$&I%.R46*,u I<Zw-BC1t;D46S,.)Jmn{4jb46S,!X()'>46EX()@A*tB,.R4-S,!X()qW1;#db46();D46(0E9%*UEX!#@A();"E#%$-+;Zn%.0.)gI%ED46(0E
E#@A1,EoBKM46S @A!#B5$&@A1,.)I<-B46*;oB,<;o'>46();#;#%EXE#<;o;D46*;@A*B*,('<@A1,N %!#'%.)-+ @A1,!d.R43!#%EX(0!#%!d4A'%(0.)%$&%*WE>=%*;X1,(0E#
I%ED46(0E9$-();#jwh;#I<'D:%!+ %*B46*?Ed+,.01;X()%1,!#;/X@A1,!#;%Ed%*Cp*5I%ED46(0E9'%1,(0E#-461L@A1,!>mTV%.0.)ZqW1,(I%ED46(0E9+,.R4A'<I<Z+,!#l<;
BC1\%1
=,I%ED46(0E"+n46!
@A();"B,I@A!X$&I<f%EvB,I<'<@A.)@A!#I<f+n46!8.R4&'#:n46.)%1,!>=.R4Z+,.01;I%.)@A(0uJ*I<o+ @A1,NA46(0E"*d+n4A; %EX!#o+n46!
b46(0E#%$&%*?Ej'%1,(0E#J=ED46*BC();ZqW1h'<%.0.)hBC1$-(0.0()%1I%ED46(0E1;#E#hw\+ @A(0*?E>m|{
<;gS,!X()q?1<;gI%ED46()%*?EjEX!X()I<<;g;D%.)@A* .R4
<
qW1n46.0(0E#IL` 1,*,(_ @A!X$-(0E#I-B,ZED46(0.0.)-%EoB,j'<@A1,.)%1,!¡e=!#I<;#%!XNJ46*?Eo.)<;9+,.01;oS %.0.)<;9+O@A1,!d.R43b4 >4AB,Z%Edu?46!#B46*WEf.)<;
/?
461,EX!#<;v+O@A1,!8.)<;"' AE#I<;B,d.bK (0$-$&%1,S,.)%E".bK (0*WE#I%!X()%1,!BC1L$g1,!>m
] %1CGPEW+ <;vB,dS,!X()qW1<;";#@A*WEvBC();XEX(0*,uJ1I<;
d
.R4jS,!X()qW1f'%!#%1;#J=(0*?N %*?E#I<j461 e ;X()l<'%.)<;XE"B,o*@J;X@A1,!#;8.R4jS,!X()qW1f.R4Z+,.01;v1,EX(0.0();#I<J=n'<@A$-+n46!#I<Zwj.R4
S,!X()qW1o+,.)%(0*fqW1,(
<;XE81,*L$h46!XE#XIX I%!X(R461EX!D4ABC(0EX()@A*,*%.EX!#l<;v46*'%()%*
m
*t'<@A*;XEX!X1'%EX()@A*
=O.R4-S,!X()qW1f+,.)%(0*+O%1, E %EX!#%$-+,.)@> I<j'<@A$-$&g1,*U$h46E#I%!X(R4615B,f+n46!#%$&%*WE-`
b4A'<GCE#I
44
!X()%1,!VBK 1,*3$g1,!¡ev` '<@A$-$&(0.0.01;XEX!#I9;X1,!s.R4dpuJ1,!# m emH{4oNH(0.0.)vB,@A1,.)@A1;#9<;XE/'<@A*,*W1v+ @A1,!.bK 1,EX(0.0();¡46EX()@A*
2 £Y
j~ , P
n h
~
~
O
u I%*I%!D46.0();#I<B,o.R4ZS,!X()q?1g46+,+n46!#%*?E#ZB46*;8.R4Z+,.01,+n46!XEB,<;"'<@A*;#EX!X1'%EX()@A*;>m
•
" '1:
7s@A()'%(qW1%.)qW1<;"GC%$-+,.)<;B,d!#@W'D:<;vqW1,(
;#@A*?Ev.)<;8+,.01;"1,EX(0.0();#I<<;v%*U'<@A*;XEX!X1'%EX()@A*
v.)huJ!D46*,(0E#!#@W'D:&$h46uJ$h46EX()qW1h+,.01,E#@A*,()qW1YwL;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#P'<@A$-+O@J;DI<hB,&uJ!D46(0*;ZB,@A*?EZ.R4\ED46(0.0.)3<;XE
4
;X1,+ I%!X()%1,!#w $-$L=
s.)f'>46.)'>46(0!#&,!#@H'#:;#I<BC(0$&%*?ED46(0!#J=
s.)ouJ!#l<;f,!#@H'#:B,I%EX!X(0EX()q?1fqW1,(
<;XE81,*o!#@H'#:'<@A$-+O@J;#I<BKM461L$&@A(0*; B,fB,I%S,!X();>=
50%
4 A0A
F.R43+,()%!X!#j$&%1,.0()l%!#\ !#@H'#:j;#I<BC(0$&%*WED46(0!#&;X(0.0()'<%1;#j1,EX(0.0();#I<
1;#qW1
KM461CGt%*?NH(0!#@A*;fB, JP+ @A1,!b4
S,!X()qW1%!vB,<;8$&%1,.)<;9wZuJ!D46(0*
=
*9 9
s.R4Z$h46!X* <46+,+O%.)I<f461;#;#(O+,()%!X!#B,o,!D46*'< jC!#@W'D:o;#I<BC(0$&%*?ED46(0!#g'<@A*?E#%*n46*WEBC1L'>46.)'>46(0!#
CaCO3
%E"B,o.bKM46!XuJ(0.)%*Uq?1n46*WEX(0E#I<;wZ+ %1L+,!#l<;"I<qW1,(0NA46.)%*WE#<;>=
s.bKM46!#B,@A();#%E8.)f$h46!XS,!#Jm
<
*}$h4 <@A*,*%!X()J=.R4U+,()%!X!#Y<;XEZB,Ip*,()P+n46!-BC(_^I%!#%*?E#;jE#%!X$&<;-B,3N @W'>46S,1,.R46(0!#Jm{
<;Z+,!X(0*'%(0+n461CGQE#%!X$&<;
;#@A*WE
.R4f+,()%!X!#d46*,uJ1,.R46(0!#-` @A13+,()%!X!#9BKi%*'<@A(0uJ*?1,!#~eVqW1,(b=H'<@A$-$&;#@A*P*@A$ .bK (0*BC()q?1J=H<;XEV+,.R4A'<I<9w.bKM46*,uJ.)
BK 1,*UI<BC(_pn'<%E"+n46!XEX()'%(0+Ogwj;#@A*L;#@A1,E#l%*%$&%*?E-` ;#@A.0()BC(0E#I~e=
E9 9
.R4j+,()%!X!#gB,o.0(R46();#@A*
=I<q?1,(0NJ46.)%*?Ed461LE#%!X$& S @A1,EX();#;#o+n46!X+n46(0uJ* A=O<;XE8.R4&+,()%!X!#o.R4-+,.01;vuJ!D46*B,B,
.bKiI<BC(_pn'<JmO .0.)<;#E"+,.R4A'<I<g%*SO@A1,EX();D;#f'JKi<;XE
wBC(0!#Zq?1;D4-.)@A*,uJ1%1,!9;#fEX!#@A1,N gB46*;v.bKiI%+n46();#;D%1,!BC1U$g1,!
%E";#<;vB,%1CGYS @A1,E#;"%*\+n46!#%$&%*WEZ`
pum m e= 4 75
2
n vn3
<
¢|@A1,!3$&@A*WEX!#%!Y.bK (0$-+O@A!XED46*'<5B,L.R4r+,()%!X!#B46*;3.R4'<@A*;XEX!X1'%EX()@A* BKi@A1,NH!D46u <;P$h4 <@A*,*I<;>=V@A*+,!#I<;#%*WE#
EX!#@A();8EW+ <;"B,o+,()%!X!#h
9 9
%k!XEf@A1,N >461 &BC1r$&@A1,N %$&%*?EZB,j.bKiI<'<@A.)&B,&d46*'%546(0*;X(sqW1j.R4P+,.01,+n46!XEgB,<;fSn6EX(0$&%*?E#;'<@A*;#EX!X1,(0E#;
461 e ;X()l<'%.)J=W.R4Sn4A;X(0.0()q?19B,fC46(0*?E
()'<@A.R4A;
B,¢|@A!XEg` XV I e e=?.R4g'>46EX:I<BC!D46.)C46(0*?E
sEX()%*,*fB,@A1,.
` XIX e=,.)<;"Sn6EX(0$&%*WE#;B,g;XEH.)f s'<@A.)fB,g946*'%Y%*UB,%:@A!#;9B,o.R4jNH(0.0.)Jm¢|@A1,!v.)<;vI<BC(_pn'<<;9B,
XIII e − XV I e
¢46!X();>=O'<@A$-$&.bKM46(0.)gBC1{
@A1,NH!#gI<BC(_pnI<Z;#@A1;946+ @A.)I<@A*#D¡=C.)j[9!D46*B¢46.R46();o46(0*;X(qW1o.)g¢%EX(0Eo¢46.R46();>=
.bKi@A+ I%!D4h[o46!X*,()%!>=,.R4Zu?46!#B,o.bKi s;XE>m
¥ ¥
©=qÌ ¾ ·
•
H
<;#E1,*3;#H;XE#l%$&v'<@A*;XEX!X1'%EX(_$&@A*@A.0(0EX:,()qW1%*3E#%!X!#'%!X1'<@A$-+n4A'%E#I<9B46*;/1,*3'<@6^ !D46u Jm?{4
E#%!X!#f'%!X1I%ED46*?E".)oE#%!X$&f1,EX(0.0();#Io+ @A1,!"B,I<;X(0uJ*%!".R4jE#%!X!#f%*\ED46*WEvqW1o$h46E#I%!X(R461UB,f'<@A*;XEX!X1'%EX()@A*
m
{
d+,();DI9<;#EV1,*9E#<'D:,*,()q?146*'%()%*,*J=,qW1,(
4j'<@A*,*?1\1,*Y!#%u?46(0*LBK (0*?E#I%! %EB46*;8.)9$&@A*B,o@W'<'%()B,%*WED46.;X1,(0E#
-<
461CG\EX!D4<NJ461CGB,g,!D46* <@A();dTV@A(0*WE#%!#>461CG}`46!#'D:,(0E#<'%E#g.0 @A*,*n46();
XV II e sicle
emn *t,!D46*'<J=@A*EX!#@A1,N f1,*
uJ!D46*B,-qW1n46*?EX(0E#I&B,ZSn6EX(0$&%*WE#;f!X1,!D461CGc%*c+,();#IjB46ED46*?EB,<; e %EfB,I%S,1,EfBC1 e ;X()l<'%.)
-?
B46*;g.R4\!#I%uJ()@A*}": A*k.0+O<;3;#l%!#J=
NJ46.0.)I<hB,h.R4C4 A*P%EgXV ? BC1QIII
e
-?
": A,*XIX
J=%E#'JmVm{&+,();#I3<;XEgXX
!#I%+n46*BC1 4612546!#@H'J=V%* T/:,(0*J=v%*kv$&I%!X()qW1cBC1 W1Bm8{4QE#<'#:,*,()qW1r'<@A*,*n4 )EUBC1;#1'<'<l<;\B46*;LB,<;
1,EX(0.0();D46EX()@A*;'<@A*?E#%$-+ @A!D46(0*<
I%u?46.)%$&%*WE
¥ ¥
©=qÌ N
•
" )"-M M
< ;#EZ.R4+n46!XEX()\B,Y.R4EX(0u \B,\'<%!XED46(0*<;-uJ!D46$-(0*I<<;>=BC(0E#<;h'<I%!#I>46.)<;hw+n46(0.0.)r` S,.)IJ=@A!Xu J=
4>N @A(0*J=;#%(0uJ.)J=n!X(0e=n'<@A1,+ I<f.)@A!#;9B,f.R4&$&@A();#;#@A*U%E!#
%E#I<J=OB,I%Sn46!D4A;#;#I<gB,<;"uJ!D46(0*;9;X1,!v.)g'#:n46$-+t+n46!v.R4
$&@A();#;D@A*,*%1;#bSn46EXE#%1;#;D@A1;F @A!X$&oBKM46*B46(0*;~m
" , K
<;#Ev.)f+,!#@HBC1,(0EB,.R4j@J;#;X(0.0();D46EX()@A*tB,B,I%S,!X();9N I%u I%ED461CGm TV%EXE#$h46EX()l%!#J=+n46!
@A();v'<@A*;#(_
,B I%!#•I<9'<@A$-$&9!#@W'D:9@A1Y'<@A$-$&9;#@A.b=W<;#EV'<@A*;XEX(0EX1I<9B, gw
20%
4 B,$h46EX()l%!#9N I%u I%ED46.)+ %1YB,I<'<@A$-+O@J;#I<J=
.)d!#<;XE#I%ED46*?Ev'<@A$-+ @J;#IfBKi>461
m
{4ZE#@A1,!XS f;#%!XE8B,o$h46E#I%!X(R461B,o'<@A*;XEX!X1'%EX()@A*UB46*;8.)<;8!#I%uJ()@A*;v@\.)dSO@A();Fb46(0E8B,I461,E>mnkv1\2t@> %*Cku J=
%*\;X.R46*B,J=W%.0.)o4gS >461'<@A1,+YI%E#I91,EX(0.0();#I<9+ @A1,!/.R4Z'<@A*;XEX!X1'%EX()@A*LB,%!X$&< ; HB,<;/S,!X()qW1<;8B,9E#@A1,!XSO<;F;#@A*WE
46.)@A!#;v46u %*'<I<<;+ @A1,!F @A!X$&%!".)<;"$1,!#;>m
9 :9
¢46!X$-(.)<;LI%.)I%$&%*WE#; %'<@A!X+; A=".R4Q+,()%!X!# %EU.R4QS,!X()q?1cEX()%*,*%*WE1,*r+,.R4A'<cEX!#l<;L(0$-+ @A!XED46*?E#B46*;L.R4
@ !9
'<@A*;XEX!X1'%EX()@A*tBKi@A1,NW!D46u <;~m *L+,!#I<;#%*WE#fB46*;".R4j;X1,(0E#d.)<;I%.)I%$&%*?E#;B,
@A(0*WE#; Am 9
Zm
© u q ©
9 :9
{
<;VI%.)I%$&%*?E#;VB, X@A(0*?E#; ";#@A*WE/%*hu I%*I%!D46. '<@A*;XEX(0EX1I<;VB,"$&@A!XEX()%!/$h46();(0.46!X!X(0N d461;#;X(q?1
Ki@A*P;#"BC();X+ %*;#
B,d.bK 1,EX(0.0();D46EX()@A*tBC1L$&@A!XEX()%!g` @A*L+n46!X.)g46.)@A!#;"B,FX@A(0*?E#;"NH(_;8@A1L;#<'<;¡em
<
*}!#l%uJ.)3u I%*I%!D46.)J=.)h$&@A!XEX()%!&w$h4 <@A*,*%!X()\<;XEg1,*Q$h46E#I%!X(R461}+ @A.0WNJ46.)%*?E>=|+ @A1,NA46*WE-;D46EX();
b46(0!#PwU1,*
NJ46!X()I%E#IfBKiGC(0u %*'<<;v+n46!
@A();"'<@A*?EX!D4ABC()'%E#@A(0!#<;~mO.
;#%!XEvB,f.0(R46*?E%*WEX!#f.)<;8$h46E#I%!X(R461CG` +,()%!X!#<;~=S,!X()qW1<;¡eFB,
'<@A*;XEX!X1'%EX()@A*cB,<;9$1,!#;~mO{Z'<@A*'<%+,E#%1,!d*g+O@A1,!X!D4P'D:@A();X(0!d.)$&I%.R46*,u \` .)g+,.01;d4AB46+,E#I~e9qW1Z;>K (0.|4h1,*
S @A*,*/'<@A*,*n46();D;D46*'<FB,<;$h46E#I%!X(R461CGjq?1,(H%*?EX!#%*?EsB46*;|.R4'<@A$-+O@J;#(0EX()@A*ZBC1Z$&@A!XEX()%!%E|B,/.)%1,!#;|+,!#@A+,!X()I%E#I<;>m
¥ ¥ ªo a'
¾'\q
<
{4@A*'%EX()@A*j+,!X(0*'%(0+n46.)"BC1j$&@A!XEX()%!s<;XEB,F.0(R46();#@A*,*%!.)<;I%.)I%$&%*?E#;B,/$h4 <@A*,*%!X()vB,/$h46*,()l%!#w'<FqW1
K (0.);
'<@A*;XEX(0EX1%*WE1,*t;#%1,.
S,.)@H'Jm¢46!d46(0.0.)%1,!#;>=n.)o$&@A!XEX()%!d;#I%+n46!#f.)<;I%.)I%$&%*?E#;9%Ev!#%$-+,.0(0EvE#@A1,E#<;.)<;8%*?E#<;9%E
2P
n vn
¥ ¥
) qÌ9~=qÌ + T u 9 \ ¾'\y
•
M"-&
<
{
Y.0(R46*WE-+O%1,E %EX!#\BC1y'%(0$&%*WE&¢@A!XEX.R46*B=/B,3.R45'D:n461CG =BC1 %' (0$&%*WEhB,P$h4 <@A*,*%!X()L@A1 1,* B,<;-BC(0N %!#;
$&I%.R46*,u <;gB,&'<<;o$h46E#I%!X(R461CGm|TV<;oEX!#@A();g;#@A!XE#<;fB,-.0(R46*WEB,@A(0N %?* EZ;D46EX();
b46(0!#h461CGt*@A!X$&<;!#<;X+ <'%EX(0N <;B,
.bKik9 gm @
<
{
'%(0$&%*WEV¢|@A!XEX.R46*BYB,@A*,*9461P$&@A!XEX()%!FB,"$h4 <@A*,*%!X()d;D4o!#I<;#();XED46*'<v$&I<'>46*,()qW19%*h+n46!XEX()'%1,.0()%!8;D4
!#I<;X();#ED46*'<o(0*,(0EX(R46.)qW1,(<;XE"(0*BC();#+O%*;D46S,.)Jm TV%+O%*B46*WE>=.)<;v$&@A!XEX()%!#;B,f'%(0$&%*WE¢|@A!XEX.R46*BU$h46*qW1n46*?EdB,
+,.R4A;XEX()'%(0E#I@A*?E"1,*\b46(0S,.)o+ @A1,N @A(0!vB,d!#I%E#%*?EX()@A*tBKi>461
=%Ev;#@A*WEvB,@A*'o$&@A(0*;Fb4A'%(0.)<;wZEX!D4>NA46(0.0.)%!>m
<
g{
L'%(0$&%*WEPB,L$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;XEh1,*y+,!#@WBC1,(0E3B,I%+O@J;#IU'<@A*?E#%*n46*?E\BC1z'%(0$&%*WE3¢|@A!XEX.R46*B=V1,* ¡p.0.)%! 9 9
$-(0*I%!D46.)d(0*%!XE#&` '>46.)'>46(0!#~eF%E8B,<;"4AB6
1,NA46*WE#;FE#%.);8q?1dB,<;"46u %*WE#;8$&@A1,(0.0.R46*?E#;>=nB,<;"46u %*?E#;8:WHBC!#@6 1,u <;"%E
B,<;"%*WEX!D4 )*%1,!#;BKM46(0!>m
{
<;o4AB6
1,NA46*WE#;dB,@A*,*%*?Eo.R4h+,.R4A;XEX()'%(0E#Ig%E9.)g+O@A1,N @A(0!dB,!#I%E#%*WEX()@A*rBKi>461cq?1g'<@A*C l%!#Z.R43'#:n461CGt461t$&@A!
<
EX()%!"B,f'%(0$&%*WE>mTV%!XED46(0*;v'%(0$&%*WE#;vB,o$h4 <@A*,*%!X();#@A*?EvB,<;"$&I%.R46*,u <;vB,o'%(0$&%*?E¢@A!XEX.R46*Bt%E"B,o'#:n461CG
:WHBC!D46E#I<Z4<N <'J=%*L+,.01;~=,B,<;v4AB61,NJ46*?E#;~m
•
1 "-3,M"
@ A05 7>08
{
g;D46S,.)<;#E".)ouJ!D46*?1,.)Z%$-+,.)@> IZ.)o+,.01;v !#I<q?1%$&%*WE>m.<;XE"(0*%!XE#g%E;#%!XEvE#@A1,EBKM46S @A!#Bwh4A'<'%!#@ )EX!#g.R4
'<@A$-+n4A'%(0E#IJmCH<;s.0(0$-(0E#<;suJ!D46*W1,.)@A$&I%EX!X()q?1<;F;#@A*WEs(0*BC()qW1I<<;B46*;s.R4o*@A!X$&"k zk Cm Cm?2546.0:%1,!#%1C
;#%$&%*WE>=,.R4Z+,.01,+n46!XEvB,<;8uJ!D46*W1,.R46E#;;D@A*?E"'#:@A();#();"+ @A1,!"B,<;8!D46();#@A*;"B,o'<@ ,E#;%E"B,oBC();X+O@A*,(0S,(0.0(0E#I<;~m.+ %1,E
\4<N @A(0!"1,*o'<%!XED46(0*NA46!X(R46EX()@A*UuJ!D46*?1,.)@A$&I%EX!X()qW1;D46*;"qW1d.)<;8+,!#@A+,!X()I%E#I<;BC1\$&@A!XEX()%!v;#@A()%*?E" @A!XE#%$&%*WE
46.0E#I%!#I<<;v$h46();";D4jqW1n46.0(0E#If;#%!D46(0Ev'<%!XED46(0*%$&%*WEd46$&I%.0()@A!#I<f;#(.)ouJ!D46*?1,.R46E9I%ED46(0Ev'#:@A();X(|4<N <'o+,.01;B,o;#@A(0*
m
2
j~ , P
n h
~
~
O
• '"-,
?
{sKi>461PX@A11,*cB,@A1,S,.)Z! A.)Y%.0.)j;#%!XE>=OBK 1,*Z+n46!XEfw&:WHBC!D46E#%!o.)Z'%(0$&%*?Ef%EdBKM461,EX!#j+n46!XEdwP'<@A*WEX!X(0S,1%!
wY;#@A*c@A1,NH!D46S,(0.0(0E#IJm
{
<;fGC(0u %*'<<;o!#%.R46EX(0N <;wP.bKi>461rB,ju?A'D:n46u &BC(_^l%!#%*?EfS >461'<@A1,+r+ @A1,!o.)<;d$&@A!XEX()%!#;
%E&.)<;&SOI%E#@A*;>m{<;&$&@A!XEX()%!#;hB,@A(0N %*WE3'<@A*WE#%*,(0!h1,*LqW1n46*?EX(0E#IBKi>461y$h4GH(0$h46.)J=/'<@A$-+n46EX(0S,.)4>N <'\1,*
@A1,NH!D46S,(0.0(0E#I$h4GC(0$h46.)Jm ¢@A1,! %EX!#1,EX(0.0();#I<J=n.bKi>4615B,@A(0
E %EX!#+,!#@A+,!#Z%E*g'<@A*?E#%*,(0!f461'%1,*t+,!#@WBC1,(0E9*@W'%(_
E#%.);"qW1oB,<;4A'%()B,<;~=,B,<;46.)'>46.0();"%EvB,<;"$h46EX()l%!#<;v@A!Xu?46*,()qW1<;>m
{
<;h+,!#%$-()%!#;&$&@A!XEX()%!#;PI%ED46()%*?Eh46(0E#;&B,LSO@A1L@A1BKM46!XuJ(0.)J=s'<<;&$h46E#I%!X(R461CGzI%ED46()%*WEh1,EX(0.0();#I<;3%* !D46();#@A*
B,Z.)%1,!oBC();X+ @A*,(0S,(0.0(0E#I-%EdB,Z.)%1,!#;b46(0S,.)<;o'<@ ,E#;>m {
<;oI%uJW+,EX()%*;d1,EX(0.0();¡46()%*?Eo.)<;d$&@A!XEX()%!#;oB,ZuJW+;Dg+ @A1,!
.01,S,!X(_pn%!-.bKM4A;#;#();#YB,<;juJ!#@J;#;#<;j+,()%!X!#<;&%E&46(0*;X(F.)<;-B,I%+,.R4A'<%!&+ @A1,!j.)<;j$&%EXEX!#\%* +,.R4A'<Jm@A1,E#@A();>='<<;
$h46E#I%!X(R461CGU*
KiI%ED46()%*WE+n4A;EX!#l<;9h'>4A'<<;%*+,!#I<;#%*'<gBK :W1,$-()BC(0E#IjI%.)%N I<g%E9BKi>461
mn{
g+,!#%$-()%!1;¡46u B,
!=
.R4o'D:n461CG&'<@A$-$&"$h46E#I%!X(R4613B,8'<@A*;#EX!X1'%EX()@A*3!#%$&@A*WE#wd%*?NH(0!#@A* ?JJ46*;/4<N m m T9m0=H46.)@A!#;sqW18.)<;s uJH+C
5 4
EX()%*;.bK 1,EX(0.0();D46()%*?EV+O@A1,!+,.R6EX!#%!/.)<;+?H!D46$-()B,<;9` xF@>H*?E#@A*c` JJ eXem?{vB,I%S,1,EB,v.bK 1,EX(0.0();D46EX()@A*3B,v.R4o'#:n461CG
B46*;.)<;s$&@A!XEX()%!#;>mW{sKi $-+,(0!#9v@A$h46(0*h1,EX(0.0();¡46(0E/'<@A1,!D46$-$&%*?EF.R4o'D:n461CGhB46*;s.)<;$&@A!XEX()%!#;>m 79(0EX!X1,NW(01;~= 1,*
46!#'D:,(0E#<'%E#o!#@A$h46(0*\B,@A*,*n46(0E8.)<;FuJ!D46*B,<;F.0(0uJ*<;F+O@A1,!F.R4g+,!#I%+n46!D46EX()@A*LB,<;F$&@A!XEX()%!#;8B,d'#:n461CGr` 7(0EX!X1,NH(01;>m
4 06 4 ` eXem
{
<;Z$&@A!XEX()%!#;>=|'<@A*?E#%*n46*WE-1,*,()q?1%$&%*WE-B,h.R4'#:n461CG%EjBC1};D46S,.)J=*I<'<<;D;X(0E#%*?EjBC1QBC()@>GHCB,PB,3'>46!XS @A*
'<@A*WE#%*?1cB46*;9.bKM46(0!+ @A1,!"b46(0!#f+,!X();#J=!#%+,!#%*BC!#Z.R4j@A!X$&gB,.R4-+,()%!X!#j'>46.)'>46(0!#Z%EBC1,!#'%(0!>m {
<;$&@A!XEX()%!#;
B,o;D46S,.)o%E"B,o'D:n461CGYBC1,!#'%();D;#%*?E".)%*WE#%$&%*?E9$h46();F*oBC1,!#'%();#;#%*WE"+n4A;";#@A1;F.bKi>461
m{<;"v@A$h46(0*;"@A*WE"'%!#I<I
B,<;$&@A!XEX()%!#;/:WHBC!D461,.0()qW1<;>=Hq?1,('<@A*?E#%*n46()%*?E"B,v.R4o'#:n461CGP%E/B,<;s+ @A1,<>@A.R46*<;VE#%.0.)<;/qW18.R4f+O@A1;#;#()l%!#vB,
S,!X()qW1"%Es.R4o'<%*BC!#"N @A.)'>46*,()q?1JmCTV<;s$&@A!XEX()%!#;I%ED46()%*WEVB,<;#EX(0*I<;woB,<;/46+,+,.0()'>46EX()@A*;V@&.R4d+,!#I<;D%*'<"BKi>461
4 08 4
*\+ %!X$&%EXED46(0E&+n4A;h1,*L'>46!XSO@A*n46ED46EX()@A*a4AB,I<q?1n46E#UBC1y$&@A!XEX()%!t` ]o4<N %` eXem/{
<;-+,!#@AuJ!#l<;&.)<;h+,.01;
(0$-+ @A!XED46*?E#;ZB,j.bK 1,EX(0.0();D46EX()@A*B,<;f+O@A1,<>@A.R46*<;ZB46*;o.)<;f$&@A!XEX()%!#;g;#@A*?Eg;X1,!XN %*?1;Z461 '<@A1,!#;fBC1
4 ;>08
;X()<'%.)Jmn * C=?46$&<;dW$&>46E#@A*4j+ %1,E
%EX!#o$-();v461L+ @A(0*?Ev.)d+,!#%$-()%!v+,!#@HBC1,(0EvB,o'#:n461CG\:?CBCXV !D461,.0III
()qW1
e
%*r'>46.)'%(0*n46*WEB,j.R4P+,()%!X!#-'>46.)'>46(0!#&xV.01-{(R4A;f'<@A*WE#%*n46*?EgB,Z.bKM46!XuJ(0.)Jm
¢|@A1,!B,@A*,*%!f+,.01;oB,j!#I<;#();XED46*'<J=
4 05;
(0.
I%ED46(0E4X@A1,E#IfB,d.R4jE#%!X!#f+O@A1,<>@A.R46*,()qW1fBKiED46.0()h`bTV@ 8+ %!g` JeXemOTVd$&I%.R46*,u gB,d$&@A!XEX()%!94j;#%!XNH(w
4 ; 05
'<@A*;XEX!X1,(0!#g.)f+,:n46!#Z sB,BCC;XE#@A*Z%* A O?46$&<;d¢|46!X %!f4-S,!#%N %E#Ig1,*U+,!#@HBC1,(0Eo46+,+O%.)Ig'%(0$&%*?Ed!#@A$h46(0*
4 ; 08
@A1 '%(0$&%*?E-*n46EX1,!#%.8%* A Cm{
Y'%(0$&%*?E-*n46EX1,!#%."I%ED46(0Ej+,!#@HBC1,(0Ej%*}S,! ,.R46*WE&%*;#%$S,.)Y1,*}$&I%.R46*,u \B,
+,()%!X!#f'>46.)'>46(0!#g%E"BKM46!XuJ(0.)B46*;"B,<;" @A1,!#;v;X(0$-(0.R46(0!#<;461CGP @A1,!#;"1,EX(0.0();#I<;"+ @A1,!8.R4-'#:n461CGm{
f+,!#@WBC1,(0EvqW1,(
%*-!#I<;X1,.0ED46(0E/I%ED46(0EsS,!#@> I%Es%*?EX!#%+ @J;#I"B46*;sB,<;s'<@A*WE#%*n46*?E#;FI%ED46*'#:<;~m {
<;'%(0$&%*WE#;s*n46EX1,!#%.);/'<@A*?E#%*n46()%*?E
u I%*I%!D46.)%$&%*WE+,.01;oBKM46!XuJ(0.)-qW1g.)<;d+,!#@HBC1,(0E#;fB,j'#:n461CG5:?CBC!D461,.0()qW1<;>=
'<jq?1,(@6^ !D46(0Eo1,*j+,.01;duJ!D46*B,
<
!#I<;X();#ED46*'<Jm6{<;$&@A!XEX()%!#;B,V'%(0$&%*?E*n46EX1,!#%.CI%ED46()%*?E1,EX(0.0();#I<;B46*;|.R4'<@A*;XEX!X1'%EX()@A*j.)@A!#;#q?1/.R4v$h4 <@A*,*%!X()
I%ED46(0Ev;D@A1,$-();#fw-B,d.bK :?1,$-()BC(0E#IJm
C < 4 A051=
@J;D%+,:Yk9;X+ BC(0*
=H1,*Y'<@A*;#EX!X1'%E#%1,! $h4 <@A*46*,uJ.R46();8S,!#%N %ED46(0E"%* j1,*P$h46E#I%!X(R461U46+,+ %.)Id'%(0$&%*?E"+ @A!XE
.R46*Bm6{sKM4X@A1,E|BC1Z'%(0$&%*?E¢@A!XEX.R46*B-461CGf$&@A!XEX()%!#;B,'D:n461CGZ4A'<'<I%.)l%!#.R4"NW(0E#<;D;#BC1g+,!#@W'<<;#;#1;B,/'<@A*;XEX!X1'
<
EX()@A*UB,<;vI<BC(_pn'<<;vB,d$h4 <@A*,*%!X()guJ!DA'<wZ.bKi@AS,E#%*?EX()@A*+,.01;"!D46+,()B,fBK 1,*o!#I<;#();XED46*'<o$&I<'>46*,()qW1Jm
? <
{ <;+,!#@HBC1,(0E#;sB,F'#:n461CG-@A*?E
@A1IV1,*j! A.)F(0$-+O@A!XED46*WEB46*;.R4d'<@A*;XEX!X1'%EX()@A*hB,<;$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;s+O%*B46*WEB,<;
4 06 <
$-(0.0.0()%!#;FBKM46*,*I<<;>mHkNJ46*?E JC=W.R4f+,.01,+n46!XEFB,<;F'<@A*;XEX!X1'%EX()@A*;F%*3$h4 <@A*,*%!X()91,EX(0.0();D46()%*WEFB,<;V$&@A!XEX()%!#;8w
Sn4A;#ZB,Z'#:n461CGm{43'#:n461CG5@6^O!#g1,*ZBC1,!D46S,(0.0(0E#IZI%+,!#@A1,N I<j'<@A$-$&j%*tE#I%$&@A(0uJ*%*?EfB,<;9;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#<;dE#%.0.)<;
4=
qW18.R4g[d!D46*B,v21,!D46(0.0.)vB,T/:,(0*Z`
pum m We=?qW1,(nGC();XE#"B,%+,1,();VB,<;'<%*WED46(0*<;VBKM46*,*I<<;~m?{
<;/!D46();#@A*;qW1,(
5
1;XEX(_p46()%*?E.bK 1,EX(0.0();D46EX()@A*hB,F.R4d'#:n461CG&B46*;.)F$&@A!XEX()%!(0.,Z4 JJJf46*;;#@A*WEsE#@A1AX@A1,!#;NA46.0()B,<;/461A
@A1,!#BK :W1,(bm
2 Y
~
H n \
4 m= {43[9!D46*B,f21,!D46(0.0.)fB,T/:,(0*
E9 :9
k+,!#l<;g4>N @A(0!gB,I%ED46(0.0.)I&.)<;gI%.)I%$&%*?E#;g*I<'<<;#;D46(0!#<;ZwY.R4L'<@A*;XEX!X1'%EX()@A*a` I%.)I%$&%*?E#;jBC(0E#; %'<@A!X+; -%EI%.)I%$&%*?E#;
9 9 <
BC(0E#;
@A(0*WE#; >e=
N @~ @A*;Z$h46(0*?E#%*n46*?Ej.)<;ZBC(_^ I%!#%*WE#;EW+ <;ZB,&$h4 <@A*,*%!X()Pq?1h.bKi@A* + % 1,Ef!#%E#%*,(0!ZB,3'<<;
BC(0N %!#;#<;v'<@A$S,(0*n46();#@A*;>m
2Q
j~ , P
n h
~
~
O
<
'<@A*;XEX!X1'%EX()@A*c46();#I%$&%*WE9$h46*,(0+,1,.R46S,.)ZBC146(0EvB,Z;#@A*L+ @A()B,;9%EB,;¡4j@A!X$&~e=nB,fS,.)@H'<;>=B,B46.0.)<;>=S,!X1,E#;
@A1LI%Sn461'D:I<;>=n;D46*;461'%1,*f+,!#I<;#%*'<fB,d$&@A!XEX()%!+O@A1,!8$&@A*WE#%!v1,*\$g1,!>=1,*oN @ ,E#Jm0m0m0m
TVZEH+ ZB,Z$h4 <@A*,*%!X()-<;XEo%$-+,.)@~ Ij+O@A1,!d.R4P'<@A*C <'%EX()@A*cBK 1,*j+n46!XEoB,Z$1,!#;oGCE#I%!X()%1,!#;h` B,j'%. AEX1,!#J= ?
B,ZB,I%$h46!#'>46EX()@A*
=B,g;D@A1,E#l%*%$&%*?E>=BKiI%+,()%!X!#%$&%*?E>m0m0m e=BKM461,EX!#g+n46!XEdB,<;9$1,!#;dBK :n46S,(0ED46EX()@A*;d!X1,!D46.)<;o%E
B,dSn6EX(0$&%*WE#;946*,*G,<;>m
{
f$h46E#I%!X(R461L1,EX(0.0();#If<;XE8u I%*I%!D46.)%$&%*WEv1,*L$h46E#I%!X(R461U+,!#@>N %*n46*?EdB,d>@A*<;"+,!#@H'#:<;B,d.R4j;X1,!
b4A'<oBC1U;#@A.b=
;#@A(0Ev();#;X1LBC1UB,I%!#@H'#:%$&%*WE9.)@A!#;B,o.R4j!#I>46.0();D46EX()@A*tB,f'#:n46$-+;9@A1UB,oE#%!X!D4A;D;#<;>=;#@A(0E" @A1,!X*,(
+n46!v.bKiI%+,()%!X!#
$&%*WEB,<;+n46!#'<%.0.)<;'%1,.0EX(0N I<<;>mA¢.01;|!D46!#%$&%*?E>=J'JKi<;#E1,*Z$h46E#I%!X(R461&GHEX!D46(0EB,/B,I<'<@A1,N %!XE#<;@A1jB,V'>46!X!X()l%!#<;>m
<
f4A;#;#%$gS,.)%$&%*?EhB,<;Z+,()%!X!#<;jB,34 <@A* wL @A!X$&%!j1,*\4A;#;X();#t` !D46*,ucB,h+,()%!X!#<;-B,3$ %$&P:n461,E#%1,!¡e
4 78
`
puJ1,!# m e=
BC();X+ @J;X(0EX()@A*UB,<;F@A*B46EX()@A*;".)@A!#;#qW1o.)o;#@A.
<;#E"B,oE#%!X!#f@A1LB,f'>46(0.0.)@A1,EX();>=
.bKiI<BC(_pn'>46EX()@A*YBKM4A;#;X();#F:@A!X(0>@A*WED46.)9461,ED46*WEVqW1F.)8$h46E#I%!X(R461h.)"+O%!X$&%E>=J+,1,();Dq?18.R4f'#:n46!Xu "EX!D46*;#$-();#
<;XE8N %!XEX()'>46.)J=
<
.R4Z+ @J;#oB,<;"+,()%!X!#<;B46*;8.)f;#%*;"BC1\.0(0EB,f'>46!X!X()l%!#<;vB,o$h46*,()l%!#@A!#B,@A*,*I<B,db4 <@A*wj'<fqW1
Ki%.0.)<;
<
*
KiI<'%.R46E#%*WEv+n4A;v;D@A1;F.)o+O@A()B,;vB,d.R4j$h4 <@A*,*%!X()J=
<
s1,*4
1;XED46u f;#%!X!#IoB,<;8+,()%!X!#<;B,db4 <@A*Uw&4<N @A(0!vB,<;
@A(0*WE#;"!#I<BC1,(0E#;461\$-(0*,(0$g1,$L=
.)d!#%$-+,.0();D;D46u oB,<;F(0*?E#%!#;XEX()'<<;v%*?EX!#o.)<;F+,()%!X!#<;8+n46!"B,<;8I<'%.R46E#;8B,o'>46.R46u &` (0*;D%!XEX()@A*LB,o'>46.)<;8;#@A1;
@A1L%*WEX!#f.)<;8+,()%!X!#<;v+O@A1,!8.)<;8(0$-$&@AS,(0.0();D%!¡e=N @A(0!#fB,o.R4ZE#%!X!#J=
<
s.bK (0$S,!X()'>46EX()@A*tN %!XEX()'>46.)B,<;8+,()%!X!#<;B,db4 <@A*Uwj@AS,E#%*,(0!B,<;X@A(0*?E#;'%!#@A();#I<;` @A1UB,I<'<@A1,+ I<;¡e=
.)v+ %*B46u 9B,<;+,()%!X!#<;>=C;>K (0.O<;XE(0*WE#I%!X()%1,!>=4ABC$&%E/1,*$&%(0.0.)%1,!#9!#I<;X();XED46*'<o461CG&+ @A1;#;#I<<;/.R46E#I%!D46.)<;
` + @A1,!".)<;"$g1,!#;B,;#@A1,E#l%*%$&%*?E¡ev@A1
=;>K (0.<;#EvGHE#I%!X()%1,!>=n+O%!X$&%Ev1,*f$&%(0.0.)%1,!#f(0$-+ %!X$&I>46S,(0.0(0E#IZBC1L+n4
!#%$&%*WEZ` + @A1,!8.)<;8$1,!#;B,f;#@A1,E#l%*%$&%*?E9I%u?46.)%$&%*?E¡e=
<
.R49+O@J;D8B,FS,.)@W'<;+,.01;s.)@A1,!#B,;s%E+,.01;46.0.)@A*,u I<;B46*;s.)<;sB,%1CGjB,%!X*,()l%!#<;V4A;#;X();#<;B,84 <@A*hw9!#%*C@A!#'<%!
.)d.0(R46();#@A*,*%$&%*WE>m
/£
n
<
[9.)@ASn46.)%$&%*WE>=n1,*d$h4 <@A*,*%!X()Z%*\+,()%!X!#<;v;Dl<'#:<;"!#<qW1,()%!XE"1,*U'D:@A(_GU46(0*;X(qW1
K 1,*\+O@J;X(0EX()@A*,*%$&%*WE
1BC(_
'%()%1CG\BC1L$h46E#I%!X(R461
=$h46();461;#;X(1,*4
1;XED46u d$-(0*?1,EX()%1CGU%Ev1,*L%$S @ )E#%$&%*?E9+,!#I<'%();vB,<;"I%.)I%$&%*WE#;>m
/£
j~ , P
n h
~
~
O
4 7A
m ]dI%ED46(0.fB,5.R4Q+O@A!XE# C46(0*WE
kv*BC!#IrB,5.bKi%*'<%(0*WE#Q[o46.0.)@6@A$h46(0*cBKikv1,EX1,*
mv{4Q+n46!XEX()rB,
u?461'D:9<;#EV%*PuJ!D46*B\46+,+n46!#%(0.O!#I%uJ1,.0()%!>=C'<%.0.)dBC1Y'<%*?EX!#d%*3+ %EX(0E846+,+n46!#%(0.O!#I%uJ1,.0()%!>mnTV+n46!#%$&%*?EV@A!X$&
1,*U'<@6^ !D46u o+ @A1,!8.)dS,.)@W'>46u B,fBC!#@A(0E#h` +,()%!X!#<;"*@~ I<<;vB46*;BC1L'%(0$&%*?E¡e
•
M "%)"%:N M
/E 0JM KH'N =nqW1n46*B\.)<;"+,()%!X!#<;9@A*?E9B,<;vBC(0$&%*;X()@A*;E#%.0.)<;>=q?1
Ki@A*(0$h46uJ(0*
$h46.'<@A$-$&%*WE%.0.)<;"@A*WEvI%E#Io$-();#<;v%*L+,.R4A'<Jm
2H'<l%*<;I%ED46(0Es1,*8EX!#l<;/46*'%()%*,*'%(0E#I8uJ!#<'<qW1";X(0EX1I<";X1,!1,*v'<@A.0.0(0*461-*@A!#BH<;XEVB,F.R4d+,.R46(0*vBKik!Xu @J;>=
B46*;8.)¢I%.)@A+ @A*,*l<;#Jm
<
T/(0*qZEH+ <;BKiI%.)I%$&%*?E#;VB,"$h4 <@A*,*%!X()vED46(0.0.)I<v@A13$&@A1,.)I<g` +,()%!X!#<;B,"ED46(0.0.)J= $&@H%.0.)@A*
= S,!X()qW1J=?%E#'Jm e;#@A*WE
BC();XEX(0*,uJ1I<;%*Y @A*'%EX()@A*B,o.)%1,!#;8+ @J;X(0EX()@A*;vB46*;8.bKM46+,+n46!#%(0.bm
" )"-'1'
<
='JKi<;#E
wBC(0!#f+,()%!X!#o+,.R4A'<I<fB46*;".R4j$h4 <@A*,*%!X()g4>N <'f;D4Z.)@A*,uJ1%1,!%*\+n46!#%$&%*WE>=
M "%1:"-,
•
<
=|I%.)I%$&%*?E-B,3$h4 <@A*,*%!X()\B,@A*?EZ.)<;jBC(0$&%*;X()@A*;jB,h+n46!#%$&%*WEj;D@A*?EZ(0$-+O@A!XED46*WE#<;j+n46!
<
!D46+,•+ @A!XE&461CG b4A'<<;ZB,gX@A(0*?E-@A1 B,Yq?1%1c` +n46!XEX()\BK 1,*}$&@W%.0.)@A* *@~ I<\B46*;Z.R4U$h4 <@A*,*%!X()J=B,@A*?E-.R4
.)@A*,uJ1%1,!9;#d$&<;X1,!#oB,%+,1,();".)f+n46!#%$&%*?E¡e=
/£ 2
n
<
s.bKi@A+,1;"(0*'<%!XEX1,$L=q?1,(.01,(<;#E";X1,!XE#@A1,Ev%$-+,.)@> I+O@A1,!8.)<;8 @A*B46EX()@A*;Z` uJ!#l<;>=,uJ!D46*,(0E>=,$&%1,.0()l%!#~e=
s.R4j$h4 <@A*,*%!X()B,f$&@W%.0.)@A*;fC$&@J;¡4 bq?1o$&@HB,%!X*f%E46+,+n46!#%(0.0.R46u <;d4A;#;X();DI<;f`
puJ1,!# m em 44
4 m4
2@J;D4 bqW1d$&@HB,%!X*f%E4A;#;X();D!#I%uJ1,.0()l%!#
/££Y
j~ , P
n h
~
~
O
<
{ <;+,()%!X!#<;v;D@A*?EBC();#+O@J;#I<<;9wj.bK (0*?E#I%!X()%1,!d%E%*U+n46!#%$&%*?E#;dB,o.R4j$h4 <@A*,*%!X()ZB,fE#%.0.)g;#@A!XE#fqW1
KM461'%1,*
•
X@A(0*?E"N %!XEX()'>46.*o+n4A;#;#fwZEX!D4>N %!#;B,<;"B,%1CGL4A;#;X();D<;`
puJ1,!# m em 4 45
/£
n
/£
j~ , P
n h
~
~
O
4 m 4 = d 46!X+n46u
{ 4\@A*'%EX()@A*}B,<;"X@A(0*?E#;j%*?EX!#P.)<;g+,()%!X!#<;j<;XEZB,h+O%!X$&%EXEX!#P1,*3EX!D46*;X$-();#;X()@A*Q1,*,(_@A!X$&3B,<;j^@A!XE#;
•
BK 1,*4A;D;X();#fwZ.bKM461,EX!#J=,$h46.0uJ!#l<;v.)<;8(0!X!#I%uJ1,.R46!X(0E#I<;B,<;"+,()%!X!#<;
s.bKiI%+n46();#;#%1,!vB,<;s
@A(0*WE#;"<;XE8+,!#@A+ @A!XEX()@A*,*%.0.)Z461CGY(0!X!#I%uJ1,.R46!X(0E#I<;9B,d.R4j+,()%!X!#Jm
'<%EXE#fI%+n46();#;#%1,!B,@A(0E %EX!#o!#I<BC1,(0E#461L$h4GC(0$1,$L='JKi<;XE
wBC(0!#o(0*CI%!X()%1,!#gw A'%$Lm 6
N5[ © u
u u
Å
9
{
<;9<;#;D46();$&I<'>46*,()qW1<;!#I>46.0();DI<;%*.R46SO@A!D46E#@A(0!#j;X1,!9B,<;I%+,!#@A1,N %EXE#<;9:@A$&@Au l%*<;o'<@A*;XEX(0EX1%*WE9.)+,!X(0*'%(_
+n46. @A1,EX(0.OB,9B,I%E#%!X$-(0*n46EX()@A*LB,<;V.)@A();FB,'<@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?E>=,B,<;V;#@A.0()B,<;F%*3u I%*I%!D46.%EFB,<;u I<@A$h46E#I%!X(R461CG\%*
+n46!XEX()'%1,.0()%!>m {sK :@A$&@Au I%*I%(0E#IjB,g.bKiI%+,!#@A1,N %EXE#g<;XE1,*Lb4A'%E#%1,!(0$-+ @A!XED46*?Eo'>46!9%.0.)f+ %!X$&%E9B,gB,I%E#%!X$-(0*%!
9 9
.)'<@A$-+O@A!XE#%$&%*WE8$&I<'>46*,()q?1 $&@> %* 9B,.R4o!#@H'#:JmH *3$&I<'>46*,()qW1dB,<;!#@H'#:<;F%EVB,<;/;#@A.);~= .)<;VB,@A*,*I<<;
GC+OI%!X(0$&%*WED46.)<;91,EX(0.0();#I<<;v+ @A1,!B,Ip*,(0!9'<<;v.)@A();B,'<@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?Ed+,!#@>NH()%*,*%*?EoBKi<;#;¡46();vEX!X(R4GC(R461CGU'%.R4A;
;X()qW1<;j` 1,*t<;#;¡46(|B,Z'<@A$-+,!#<;#;X()@A*51,*,(R4GC(R46.)g'<@A!X!#<;X+ @A*Bcw&1,*5<;#;D46(EX!X(R4GH(R46.s4>N <'1,*c'<@A*Cp*%$&%*?Eo*W1,.
e
@A15BKi<;#;D46();d;X+ I<'%(R461CG =OB,gEH+OZ@W<B,@A$&I%EX!X()qW1-@A15B,EW+ S,!#I<;#(0.0()%*
mTVgB,%!X*,()%!d+ %!X$&%E9.R4h$&<;X1,!#J= B,
<
b4 <@A*L(0*BC(0!#<'%E#J=B,o.R4Z!#I<;#();XED46*'<wZ.R4jEX!D4A'%EX()@A*
m
¢|@A1,!-B,I<'%!X(0!#3.)<;g+,!#@A+,!X()I%E#I<;j$&I<'>46*,()qW1<;-BK 1,*h!#@H'#:c` .R4U!#@W'D:J=1,*h @A();jGCEX!D46(0E#3B,%N %*n46*WE-+,()%!X!#~e=
.)ZBC();X+ @J;X(0EX(_GH+ I%!X(0$&%*?ED46..)+,.01;91,EX(0.0();#Ij<;XEv.R4h!#I<;X();XED46*'<-w-.R43'<@A$-+,!#<;#;X()@A*51,*,(R4GC(R46.)Jm {4&!#I<;#();XED46*'<
$&I<'>46*,()qW1dBK 1,*d!#@W'D:9B,I%+ %*BYB,v+,.01;#()%1,!#;F+n46!D46$&l%EX!#<;>=CE#%.0.)dq?1.R4 @A!X$&9%EF.R4fED46(0.0.)dB,<;FuJ!D46(0*;>=H.R4
'<@A$-+ @J;X(0EX()@A*L$-(0*I%!D46.)@AuJ()qW1J=.bKM46*,();#@AEX!#@A+,()E#GHEX1,!D46.)Jm0m0mm
kN <'v.)9E#%$-+;>=H.)<;V+,()%!X!#<;F+ %1,N %*?E8B,%N %*,(0!F+O@A!#%1;#<;~=H'JKi<;#E
wBC(0!#9qW1
Ki%.0.)<;F*9;#@A*?EF+,.01;F(0$-+ %!X$&I>46S,.)<;
b4A'<vwd.bKi>46 5 08
1 W'<@A$-$&".)";#@A1,.0(0uJ*vxV<'DU` xF<'#L` JJ eXe= .)<;/'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();XEX()q?1<;/$&I<'>46*,()qW1<;/%*h'<@A$-+,!#<;D;X()@A*
b4A'%E#%1,!*jB,@A(0EdB,@A*'Z+n4A
%E-%*QEX!D4A'%EX()@A*yB,<;g$h46E#I%!X(R461CG}+ @A!#%1CG;#@A*?Ej+,.01;-@A1Q$&@A(0*;-B,I%+O%*B46*WE#<;&B,P.)%1,!gE#%*%1,!&%*}>461
mTV
<
; %EX!#g*I%uJ.0(0u IZ+O@A1,!d'<@A*,*n4 )EX!#-B,4 <@A*t!X(0u @A1,!#%1;#Z.R4&!#I<;#();XED46*'<jB,.R4h+,()%!X!#
;#@A1,$-();Dfwj1,*f'#:n46!Xu f+n46!vGC%$-+,.)Jm
¢46!8.R4;#1,(0E#J=H@A*\B,I<'%!X(0EF.bKi%*;#%$gS,.)fB,<;FBC();X+O@J;#(0EX(_ ;FGC+OI%!X(0$&%*WED461CGP$-();F%*Y+,.R4A'<9+O@A1,!8B,Ip*,(0!8.)<;F'>46!D4A'
E#I%!X();XEX()qW1<;8$&I<'>46*,()qW1<;B,<;"+,()%!X!#<;>m
/£ P
Q |
?n vn3
4 4>
]o46*;V'<%E/<;#;D46(b= .bKiI%+,!#@A1,N %EXE#9<;#E+,.R4A'<I<9%*?EX!#.)<;s+,.R46E#>461CG3BK 1,*v+,!#<;#;#g`
puJ1,!# m e%E/.R4d@A!#'<4GC(R46.)
<;XEZ461,uJ$&%*?E#I<1;#qW1
KMwY.R4Y!X1,+,EX1,!#3B,&.bKiI%+,!#@A1,N %EXE#Jm[dI%*I%!D46.)%$&%*?E>=|.bKiI%+,!#@A1,N %EXE#P<;XEB,j@A!X$&&'%H.0(0*C
BC!X()qW1Jm
Rc =
Fmax
=
Fmax 4 7> 4
` m Cm e
S Πr 2
kN <'J=
C!#%+,!#I<;#%*WE#f.R4Z!#I<;X();XED46*'<gwj.R4j'<@A$-+,!#<;#;X()@A*` %*2¢4 e=
Rc
,.R4g @A!#'<f$h4GH(0$h46.)46+,+,.0()qW1I<o.)@A!#;"B,f.R4Z!X1,+,EX1,!#3` %*Uoe=
Fmax
C.R4-;#1,!
4A'<oBKM46+,+,.0()'>46EX()@A*5B,d.R4Z@A!#'<&` %* e=
S mm2
!f<;#E8.)d!D4< @A*B,d.R4&;#<'%EX()@A*UB,d.bKiI%+,!#@A1,N %EXE# '%H.0(0*BC!X()qW1Jm
•
'
'1 & )OM '
"- '!:H
,)M+"
5 '= NA
*I%+,!#@A1,N %EXE#o'%H.0(0*BC!X()qW19BKiI%.R46*'<%$&%*WE"I%u?46.
w P` BC(R46$&l%EX!#- ?6$-$ %EF:n461,E#%1,!o J6$-$3e/<;XEV+,.R4A'<I<
0> EC
N % !XEX()'>46.)%$&%*WE>=H;D@A1,$-();#wd1,*P^ @A!XE/B,v'<@A$-+,!#<;#;X()@A*P'%!#@A();#;D46*WE9` NH(0E#<;#;#"B,'#:n46!Xu %$&%*?EoHCmM 6$-$ $-(0*e=
> 6
B46*;.bKM4GC8B,8.bKiI%+,!#@A1,N %EXE#s1;Dq?1
KMw9.R4d!X1,+,EX1,!#Z` %*?EX!# d%E J9$-(0*?1,E#<;¡emW{sKi<;#;D46(<;XE!#I>46.0();#I";X1,!1,*";#I%!X()
B,EX!#@A();9I%+,!#@A1,N %EXE#<;dB,I<'<@A1,+ I<<;dB46*;.)g;#%*;+n46!D46.0.)l%.)Z461t.0(0EB,g.R4-+,()%!X!#j%Ev1,*Z;#I%!X()ED46(0.0.)I<gB46*;9.)
/£
j~ , P
n h
~
~
O
;#%*;"+O%!X+ %*BC()'%1,.R46(0!#Jm
{
<;h<;#;D46();j$&I<'>46*,()qW1<;&;#@A*?Eh!#I>46.0();#I<;&;X1,!-B,%1CG}+,()%!X!#<;-E#%*BC!#<;hB,\'<@A*;XEX!X1'%EX()@A*
=/w5;D4<N @A(0!-.)YEX1C^>461
S,.R46*'h` !#@H'#:'>46.)'>46(0!#fS,.R46*'#:n6EX!#J=.R46!Xu %$&%*?E9%$-+,.)@> I<gB46*;".)<;"'<@A*;XEX!X1'%EX()@A*;9BC1\746.B,f{@A(0!#~eF%E".R4
+,()%!X!#fB,HI%Sn4A;#E#@A+O@A.` qW1,(
<;XE"461;#;X(1,*d!#@H'#:f'>46.)'>46(0!#J=EX!#l<;81,EX(0.0();#I<o%*\!#I%uJ()@A*L+n46!X();X()%*,*~emOTV%!XED46(0*<;
B,9.)%1,!#;F'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();XEX()qW1<;";#@A*?E"4A;#;D%9;#%$gS,.R46S,.)<;8'<@A$-$&d.R4f+ @A!#@J;X(0E#I9E#@AED46.)d@A1\%*'<@A!#.)%1,!#;F!#I<;#();XED46*'<<;
$&I<'>46*,()qW1<;>m
?
TVjqW1,(%*c!#<;D;#@A!XEoB,g.bKiI%EX1B,-<;#EdqW1Z.R43+,!#I<;#%*'<-BKi>461Y
@A1Z1,*c! A.)Z(0$-+ @A!XED46*?EB46*;d.R4P'#:W1,E#&B,j.R4
!#I<;X();#ED46*'<jwh.R43'<@A$-+,!#<;#;X()@A*c1,*,(R4GC(R46.)JmO{4h+,!#I<;D%*'<ZBKi>461cB46*;9.)<;9+O@A!#<;dB,g.R43!#@W'D:Z'<@A*BC1,(0Efwh1,*
!#I<BC1'%EX()@A*-B,V.R4"!#I<;#();XED46*'<$&I<'>46*,()qW1J=6+O@A1,NJ46*?E;>KiGC+,.0()qW1%!+n46!1,*VBC(0$-(0*?1,EX()@A*&B,/.bKiI%*%!XuJ()8B,/;X1,!
b4A'<
B,j'<@A*?ED4A'%Eg%*?EX!#-.)<;duJ!D46(0*;f'<@A*;#EX(0EX1,EX(_ ;d+n46!f'<@A*;#I<qW1%*?E1,*g$&@HBC(_pn'>46EX()@A* B,<;d.0()%*;o(0*WE#%!XuJ!D46*?1,.R46(0!#<;
@ 4 5 ?
` X@j%EFxV!#@H@At` JJ e=C]d<;#;D46*BC()%!"%E"46.bm` JJJ eXem,{
d! A.)dBK 1,*d+,!#<;#;X()@A*Y(0*?E#%!#;#EX()'%()%.0.)J=,.)@A!#;8B,9.bKi<;#;D46(b=
;#%!D46(0E9461;#;X(w-46*n46.0C;#%!>m
4 48
m vI<;X1,.0ED46E#;9B,<;d<;#;D46();9B,g'<@A$-+,!#<;D;X()@A*1,*,(R4GC(R46.)Yn!#I<;#();XED46*'<Zwh.R43'<@A$-+,!#<;#;X()@A*5%E$&@HBC1,.)
BKiI%.R4A;XEX()'%(0E#IJ=xF<'# 5 08
46.` xF<'#r` JJ eXe
4 48
*WEX!#d.bKiI%ED46E8;D46EX1,!#Id%EFwZ;#<'j`
puJ1,!# m e=C.R4f+ %!XE#dB,v!#I<;X();#ED46*'<d46EXE#%(0*WE >0A
+O@A1,!V.)9EX1C^ >461PS,.R46*'o%E
608 + @A1,!".R4Z+,()%!X!#fB,gHI%Sn4A;#E#@A+O@A.bm %
TV%%
Ef<;#;¡46(|$&%EZ461;#;X(%*rI%NW()B,%*'<&.bKM46*,();#@AEX!#@A+,()&B,<;d$h46E#I%!X(R461CGrq?1,(s<;#EdB, *5 4 + @A1,!o.)jEX1C^>461cS,.R46*'
%E"B, 4> %
+ @A1,!8.R4Z+,()%!X!#fB,HI%Sn4A;XE#@A+ @A.sC.R4Z!#I<;X();XED46*'<fwZ.R4j'<@A$-+,!#<;#;#()@A*U<;XE8+,.01;"I%.)%N I<oB46*;8.)o;D%*;
+ %!X+O%*BC% ()'%1,.R46(0!#Z461\.0(0EvB,d.R4j+,()%!X!#Jm
4 4;
{
<;g'<@A1,!XSO<;~= !#%+,!#I<;#%*?E#I<<;Z;X1,!f.)<;dpuJ1,!#<; m H=$&@A*?EX!#%*WEg.bKiI%N @A.01,EX()@A*QB,-.R4YB,I@A!X$h46EX()@A*%*c@A*'%EX()@A*
B,d.R4-'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#g(0$-+O@J;DI<o%EvB,<;"BC(_^I%!#%*?E#;vI%ED46E#;v:?CBC!X()q?1<;~m
{
<;EX!#@A();uJ!D46*B,<;VI%ED46+ <;sEH+,()qW1<;/BC1h'<@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?EF$&I<'>46*,()qW1vBK 1,*!#@W'D:v;#"!#%EX!#@A1,N %*?E>=Cwf;D4>N @A(0!
E#@A1,EsBKM46S @A!#B=J1,*F+,:n4A;#FB,F$-();#8%*&'D:n46!Xu J= ;X1,(0NH()VBK 1,*3'<@A$-+O@A!XE#%$&%*WE/I%.R4A;XEX()qW18%E%*Cp*hBK 1,*"46.0.01,!#
4 05
I%.R4A;XE#@6b+,.R4A;#EX()q?1oB,.R4Z'<@A1,!XSO/
1;#q?1
KMwg.R4!X1,+,EX1,!#oBC1Y$h46E#I%!X(R461 `b[91I%u %*L%EV¢46.)'%(R461;XJ4A;` J eXem,]o46*;
.)o'>4A;B,d.R4-'<@A$-+,!#<;#;X()@A*L1,*,(R4GC(R46.)J=,.)<;"'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#<;9+,!X(0*'%(0+n46.)<; %E ;D@A*?E"*W1,.0.)<;>m
σ2 σ3
/£ Y
Q |
?n vn3
4 4;
m TV@A1,!XSO<;F'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#B,I@A!X$h46EX()@A*U.)@A!#;FB,v.bKi<;D;D46(%*Y'<@A$-+,!#<;#;X()@A*Y1,*,(R4GC(R46.)+ @A1,!FBC(_^ I%!#%*WE#;
I%ED46E#;8:WHBC!X()qW1<;vBC1UEX1C^ >461U%E"B,f.R4Z+,()%!X!#fB,gHI%Sn4A;XE#@A+ @A.b=xF<'#
5 08
46./` xF<'#c` JJ eXe
¥ ¥
u£q \Ng
" ; V[ a' 3 q Æ/ Ê\' at
5 1=
{sKi<;D;D46(B,f!#I<;#();XED46*'<wj.R4&EX!D4A'%EX()@A*U(0*BC(0!#<'%E#J=nBC(0Ed461;#;X(<;D;D46(S,!#I<;X(0.0()%*Q` 46*,uP%E946.bm` JJ We=n46(0!X:?1,!#;#E
4 081=
` WeXe=<;XE9!#I>46.0();#I-%*c'<@A$-+,!X(0$h46*?Eg%*?EX!#j.)<;9+,.R46E#>461CG5B,Z.R4h+,!#<;#;#Z1,*jI%+,!#@A1,N %EXE#-.)g.)@A*,uLB,ZB,%1CG
4 4A
u I%*I%!D46EX!X()'<<;d@A+,+ @J;#I<<;g`
puJ1,!# m eon.R4j!X1,+,EX1,!#g<;#Ev@AS,E#%*?1Z+n46!"EX!D4A'%EX()@A*c461'<%*WEX!#gB,.bKiI%+,!#@A1,N %EXE#Jm
TV@A$-$&v+O@A1,!s.bKi<;D;D46(wd.R4'<@A$-+,!#<;#;X()@A*h1,*,(R4GC(R46.)J= .bKiI%+,!#@A1,N %EXE#9<;XEsu I%*I%!D46.)%$&%*WEVB," @A!X$&v'%W.0(0*BC!X()qW1Jm
/£ Q
j~ , P
n h
~
~
O
Rt =
F 4 7> 75
` m Cm e
πrH
kN <'J=
C.R4Z!#I<;X();XED46*'<gwj.R4ZEX!D4A'%EX()@A*Q` %*L2t¢|4 e=
Rt
,.R4g @A!#'<f$h4GH(0$h46.)46+,+,.0()qW1I<o.)@A!#;"B,f.R4Z!X1,+,EX1,!#3` %*Uoe=
Fmax
*<;#;¡46(/B,&EX!D4A'%EX()@A*}(0*BC(0!#<'%E#P<;XEg'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();DI3+n46!g.)<;g'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#<;-+,!X(0*'%(0+n46.)<; = %E
σ1 = Rt σ2 = 0
σ3 = −kRc
xF<'# 46.F@A*WEh461;#;X(F$-();-%*}+,.R4A'<Y1,*yBC();X+ @J;X(0EX(_GC+OI%!X(0$&%*WED46.v'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();D46*?Eh.bKi<;#;D46(8B,PEX!D4A'%EX()@A* (0*C
&
BC(0!#<'%E#& @ 1= ='505 @ 5 4
` ;#%.)@A*\.R4Z*@A!X$&ok9 ¢/ A L` *@A!X$&fk9| ` JJ eXem{
<;8<;D;D46();8;#@A*?E8!#I>46.0();DI<;8B46*;8.)<;
$ %$&<;'<@A*BC(0EX()@A*;vqW1d+O@A1,!".R4j'<@A$-+,!#<;D;X()@A*U1,*,(R4GC(R46.)Jm
•
'
'1 & )OM '
"- '!:H
,)M+"
*&I%+,!#@A1,N %EXE#P'%W.0(0*BC!X()qW1hBKiI%.R46*'<%$&%*WEjI%u?46.Vw 4 3= J=
` BC(R46$&l%EX!#t ?6$-$ %E:n461,E#%1,!3 ?6$-$3e=+,.R4A'<I<
:@A!X(0>@A*WED46.)%$&%*?E>=|<;XEo;#@A1,$-();#&wP1,*c^ @A!XEfB,-'<@A$-+,!#<;D;X()@A*r'%!#@A();#;D46*WE;#%.)@A*cB,%1CGtu I%*I%!D46EX!X()'<<;gBC(R46$&I
EX!D46.)%$&%*WEv@A+,+O@J;DI<<;>=1;#qW1
KMwg.R4g!X1,+,EX1,!#Jm @A!X$-();F.)<;F>@A*<;8B,d'<@A*?ED4A'%E94<N <'d.)<;F+,.R46E#>461CG=C.bKiI%+,!#@A1,N %EXE#
;#"EX!#@A1,N 946.)@A!#;V%*hE#%*;X()@A*Y4<N <'1,*&$h4GC(0$1,$ B,"E#%*;X()@A*Y4613'<%*WEX!#J=W%E/.)8+O@J;#(0EX()@A*,*%$&%*?EF+n46!!D46+,+ @A!XE
461\.0(0EvB,f+,()%!X!#f;#9b46(0E"%*U'<@A*,*n46();#;D46*'<fBC1L;D%*;"B,<;8>@A*<;v%*UE#%*;X()@A*
m
{
<;V!#I<;X1,.0ED4A;FEX!#@A1,N I<;8'<@A*WN %!Xu %*?E4>N <'d'<%1CG3B,<;8<;#;D46();V%*\'<@A$-+,!#<;#;X()@A*
=,w;¡4<N @A(0!8q?19.R4+,!#I<;#%*'<dBKi>461
?
X@A181,*&! A.)v(0$-+O@A!XED46*WEVB46*;.R4d!#I<;X();XED46*'<BC1&$h46E#I%!X(R461t`
@A!XE#vBC(0$-(0*W1,EX()@A*PB,8.R4f!#I<;X();XED46*'<"%*3EX!D4A'%EX()@A*
%*WEX!#o.bKiI%ED46E;#<'o%E8.bKiI%ED46E;D46EX1,!#If%*U>461em
*80A
{4L+O%!XE#3B,&!#I<;X();#ED46*'<PwL.R4\EX!D4A'%EX()@A*
=|%*?EX!#3.bKiI%ED46Eg;#<'3%E.bKiI%ED46Ej;D46EX1,!#IJ=
+ @A1,!.)hEX1C^ >461}46EXE#%(0*?E
60A%E
%
44
+ @A1,!8.R4Z+,()%!X!#fB,HI%Sn4A;XE#@A+ @A.` N @A(0!8puJ1,!# m emTV%E"<;#;¡46(
'<@A*Cp!X$&461;#;X(.bKM46*,();#@AEX!#@A+,()f$&I<'>%
4
*,()qW1& C.R4Z!#I<;X();XED46*'<<;XE8+,.01;8@A!XE#oB46*;".)o;#%*;"+n46!D46.0.)l%.)461L.0(0EvB,d.R4j+,()%!X!#Jm
Q |
?n vn3
4 m4 vI<;X1,.0ED46E#;vB,<;"<;#;D46();"B,dEX!D4A'%EX()@A*(0*BC(0!#<'%E#J=nxF<'#
5 08
46.` xF<'#r` JJ eXe
4 75
{
<;g'<@A1,!XSO<;~= !#%+,!#I<;#%*?E#I<<;Z;X1,!f.)<;dpuJ1,!#<; m JC=$&@A*?EX!#%*WEg.bKiI%N @A.01,EX()@A*QB,-.R4YB,I@A!X$h46EX()@A*%*c@A*'%EX()@A*
B,d.R4-'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#g(0$-+O@J;DI<o%EvB,<;"BC(_^I%!#%*?E#;vI%ED46E#;v:?CBC!X()q?1<;~m
TV@A$-$&h!#%+,!#I<;#%*?E#I3;X1,!f'<<;fB,%1CGcEH+O<;B,&'<@A1,!XSO<;~=.R4P!X1,+,EX1,!#h;#j+,!#@HBC1,(0Eg4A;#;D%-*%EXE#%$&%*?Ej;#%.)@A*r.)
BC(R46$&l%EX!#N %!XEX()'>46.B,o.bKiI<'#:n46*WEX(0.0.)@A*t'%H.0(0*BC!X()qW1J='JKi<;XE
wBC(0!#;#1,!8.R4Z.0(0uJ*fB,oE#%*;X()@A*L$h4GC(0$h46.)Jm
j~ , P
n h
~
~
O
4 75
m J TV@A1,!XS <;"'<@A*?EX!D46(0*WE#B,I @A!X$h46EX()@A*5.)@A!#;"B,d.bKi<;#;¡46(S,!#I<;X(0.0()%*\+O@A1,!"BC(_^I%!#%*?E#;I%ED46E#;8:?CBC!X()qW1<;
BC1LEX1C^>461L%EvB,d.R4j+,()%!X!#B,gHI%Sn4A;XE#@A+ @A.b=xF<'#
5 08
46.` xF<'#r` JJ eXe
4 4 4 75 4 76
{
<;VEX!#@A();VED46S,.)>461CG m = m %E m g;X1,(0NA46*WE#;FGH+ @J;#%*?EdW.)<;NJ46.)%1,!#;FB,<;!#I<;X();#ED46*'<<;Fw.R4g'<@A$-+,!#<;#;X()@A*
σc
=
B,<;8!#I<;#();XED46*'<<;wj.R4-EX!D4A'%EX()@A* =B,<;"$&@WBC1,.)<;B,
@A1,*,u3 46(0*;X(
q?1B,<;"'<@Wh'%()%*WE#;B,f+O@A();#;D@A* B,
4 ;:=
BC(0N %!#;#<;sEH+O<;sB,F$h46EX!X()'<<;!#@W'Dσ:t %1;#<;` '>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();#EX()q?1<;/B,@A*,*I<<;B46*;sxV()%*n4 ";#W(` xV()%*n4";XW(|` WνeXeXem
2
Q |
?n vn3
£Y
j~ , P
n h
~
~
O
T/:n4AqW1Z+,()%!X!#&43;D<;9'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();#EX()q?1<;o$&I<'>46*,()qW1<;d+,!#@A+,!#<;>m{
gb46(0S,.)Z$&@WBC1,.)jB,
@A1,*,uLB,j'<%!XED46(0*<;
4 0A08
!#@H'#:<;V` !#@W'D:<;
E#%*BC!#<;/` ]d@AS %!#%(0*%!%E]ds!#%(0ED4A;/` eXe'<@A$-$&.)
1C^>461g@A1f.R48+,()%!X!#sB,/HI%Sn4A;XE#@A+ @A.
+n46!G,%$-+,.)~e<;XEs;#(0uJ*"BK 1,*8uJ!D46*B,"'>46+n4A'%(0E#I9wd;#8B,I @A!X$&%!/;#@A1;.bKM4A'%EX()@A*3B,8'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#<;V$&I<'>46*,()qW1<;>m
<
TV-+n46!D46$&l%EX!#P<;XEf(0$-+ @A!XED46*?Ej'>46!f.R4L!#I<;X();XED46*'<hBK 1,*h;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#h$h4 <@A*,*I<3<;XEBC(0!#<'%E#%$&%*WEZ.0()I<3w\.R4
9 9 9
!#I<;X();#ED46*'<fB,o'<<;"I%.)I%$&%*?E#;9'<@A*;XEX(0EX1,EX(_;g` %'<@A!X+; f%E
@A(0*WE#; >em 9
¥ ¥
%
( Æ ' Æ
.R4hED46(0.0.)g%E.bKi@A!X()%*?ED46EX()@A*rB,<;dB,Ib461,E#;vE#%.);dqW1B,<;9+O@A!#<;9%EB,<;pn;#;#1,!#<;%EdB,f.R4h+,!#I<;#%*'<Z@A1*@A*5B,<;
1,()B,<;j(0*WE#%!#;XEX()'%()%.);>m{
<;j+,!#@A+,!X()I%E#I<;&I%.R4A;#EX()q?1<;Z+ %1,N %*?E %EX!#YB,I%E#%!X$-(0*I<<;hw+n46!XEX(0!-B,<;j$&<;X1,!#<;-;XED4
EX()qW1<;/B,<;V'<@A*?EX!D46(0*WE#<;8%E/B,<;VB,I @A!X$h46EX()@A*;F@A1P+n46!/B,<;/$&I%EX:@WB,<;FBCH*n46$-()q?1<;~m?]o46*;/'<<;VB,%!X*,()%!#;F'>4A;>=
.)<;9NH(0E#<;#;#<;d;X();X$-()qW1<;oB,<;d@A*B,<;oI%.R4A;XEX()q?1<;o;D@A*?Edu I%*I%!D46.)%$&%*?Eg$&<;X1,!#I<<;>= %*51,EX(0.0();D46*?EfB,<;9$&I%EX:@HB,<;
Sn4A;#I<<;;X1,!.)<;$&@HB,<;B,F!#I<;#@A*,*n46*'<B,<;sI<'#:n46*WEX(0.0.)@A*;/@A1h;#1,!.R49+,!#@A+n46u?46EX()@A*PB,<;s@A*B,<;I%.R4A;XEX()q?1<;/B46*;
.)<;"I<'D:n46*?EX(0.0.)@A*;>m
(Vp )2 =
(λ + 3µ) %E
(Vs )2 =
µ 4 7> 76
` m Cm e
ρ ρ
{
f!D46+,+O@A!XE Vp *db46(0E8+n4A;8(0*?E#%!XN %*,(0!.R4-B,%*;X(0E#IJm
Vs
(
Vp 2 (λ + 2µ)
) =
4 7> =
` m Cm We
Vs µ
{
<;9NH(0E#<;#;#<; %E
;#@A*?E9E#@A1,E#<;9.)<;B,%1CGt4^<'%E#I<<;9+n46!.R4&+,!#I<;#%*'<jB,$-()'%!#@6pn;D;X1,!#<;dB46*;v.)g$-(0.0()%1
I%.R4A;XEX()qW1f@LV%.0p.)<;;#Vds+,!#@A+n46u %*?E>m{sK (0* 1%*'<gB,<;vBC();#'<@A*?EX(0*W1,(0E#I<;;X1,!
BC(0!#<'%EX()@A*5B,f+,!#@A+n46u?46EX()@A*c<;XE+O%!X+ %*BC()'%1,.R46(0!#Z461+,.R46*tB,fpn;#;X1,!D46EX()@A*
m Vp
<;XE8EX!#l<;"(0$-+O@A!XED46*WE#f.)@A!#;#qW1o.R4
<;XE"+n46!
'<@A*?EX!#Z+ %1t4^<'%E#I<
Vp
.)@A!#;#qW1o'<%EXE#o+,!#@A+n46u?46EX()@A*5;>Ki^<'%EX1oB46*;v'<d+,.R46*
m
4 0A06
{4U+ @A!#@J;X(0E#I&*` -eg4\1,*Q^ %Eg(0$-+O@A!XED46*WEj;#1,!.R4\NH(0E#<;#;#3B,<;g@A*B,<;Y` BC1} >46*Q%Ej46.bmV` eXem|{
<;g+,!#
4 0>0A
$-()%!#;FEX!D4>NA461CG\;#@A*?EF+,!#@ASn46S,.)%$&%*WEBC1;"w cW.0.0() 46.s` cW.0.0()d%E[o46!#BC*%!f` J4 e= cH.0.0()d%Ev[o46!#BC*%!
4 0>0A
` 6SeXem"TV<;Y461,E#%1,!#;3$&<;#1,!#%*?E `4<N <'1,*UE#<'D:,*,()q?15BK 1,.0EX!D4A;#@A*;¡ehB46*;31,*uJ!D46*B*@A$S,!#5B,
Vp
$h46E#I%!X(R461CG5+O@A!#%1CG= *n46EX1,!#%.);f%Ef;XH*?EX:I%EX()qW1<;>=
w3E#%$-+ I%!D46EX1,!#h46$S,(R46*WE#h%Eo;#@A1;d+,!#<;#;X()@A*
m{<;fI%+,!#@A1C
N %EXE#<;g;#@A*?EZ;#@A(0Ef;#l<'#:<;~=;#@A(0Ef;D46EX1,!#I<<;Z%* BC(0N %!#; 1,()B,<;3` >461
=
.0()qW1,()B,<;@A!Xu?46*,()qW1<;>m0m0m em{sKi%*;#%$S,.)PB,
Q |
?n vn3
%Ev.R4ZNW(0E#<;#;DoB46*;".) 1,()B,f;D46EX1,!D46*WE
VM
+ @A1,!#'<%*?ED46u gB,o+O@A!#@J;#(0E#IoB,o.R4Z!#@W'D:o* P=,.R4ZNH(0E#<;#;#oB,<;"@A*B,<;¢ ` B,f'<@A$-+,!#<;#;#()@A*eFB46*;".)d$-(0.0()%1L7j=
.R4ZNH(0E#<;#;#oB,o.R4Z$h46EX!X()'<g;#@A.0()B, m
VF
¥ ¥
º
=qÌ ®@
Æ a'
y +
A
5
=
{43;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#j<;XE1,*N @ ,E#j%*t+,()%!X!#gB, 6$ B,ZBC(R46$&l%EX!#j%E J$ B,:n461,E#%1,!>m .0.)j;>K (0*;D'%!X(0E9B46*;1,*
B; =
B,%$-(_;X+,:l%!#Jm .0.)o!#%+ @J;#o;X1,!"'%(0*q3+,(0.0()%!#;"B, 6$ B,o:n461,E#%1,!>=Cm A6$ B,d.R46!Xu %1,!%EvCm ?6$ BKiI%+n46();D;#%1,!>m
&?
H%.)@A*5.R4h.)@W'>46.0();D46EX()@A*cB46*;9.R43'<@A1,+ A.)J=O.)<;S,.)@W'<;-` +,()%!X!#<;¡e@A*?EoB,<;d'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();XEX()qW1<;d$&I<'>46*,()q?1<;oBC(_^I
!#%*WE#<;>m .C<;#E46(0*;X(A1BC()'%()%1CG&B,8'D:@A();X(0!s1,*F+,()%!X!#8+,.01;.)@A1,!#B,J= +,.01;!#I<;X();XED46*WE#v461CGZ+,()<B,;%E+,.01;.)I%u l%!#
<
4615*,(0N >461rBC1c;#@A$-$&%Ed+O@A1,!d!#I<BC1,(0!#Z.)<;o'<@A*?EX!D46(0*WE#<;B,Z+ @A()B,;9;~KiGC%! >46*WEf;X1,!d.R4hSn4A;DJmTV%EXE#j'<@A1,+ A.)J= ?
1,*d@A();8'<@A*;XEX!X1,(0E#J=;#%!D4jGH+ @J;#I<f461CGU46uJ!#<;#;X()@A*;v'%.0(0$h46EX()q?1<;Z` +,.01,()J=,*%(0u ~em
{
ZED46(0.0.)%1,!fB,g+,()%!X!#J=%*t @A*'%EX()@A*cB,<;9+,!#@A+,!X()I%E#I<;fB,j'#:n4AqW1Z+,()%!X!#J= NA4P46(0*;X('<@A*;XEX!X1,(0!#j.R4P;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#Jm
]o46*;.)8'>4ABC!#8BK 1,*"I%EX1B,8qW1F*@A1;4>N @A*;%*?EX!#%+,!X();Dv4<N <'8.)FED46(0.0.)%1,!/B,F+,()%!X!#"]d%.0E#@A1,!>=?49I%E#Iv4AB,@A+,E#I<
4 75 4
.)d+,!X(0*'%(0+ fB,f'<@A*;XEX(0EX1,EX()@A*}`
puJ1,!# m eFB,o.R4j'<@A1,+ A.)f;X1,(0NJ46*?Eg ?
;#@A$-$&%EgC+,()%!X!#fB,fJ1,*n4A;
4A;#;#();#<;8;X1,+ I%!X()%1,!#<;C+,()%!X!#fB,fxF>461,.0()%1
5 6()l%$&4A;D;X();#-C+,()%!X!#fBKi s;#ED46(0.0.R4AB,
4 %!#4A;D;X();#j,+,()%!X!#fB,oJ1,*n4A;
46!#'D:<;v%Ev;#@A$-$-()%!#;,+,()%!X!#fB,o{
%*;
+,()<B,;f+,()%!X!#fB,o{
%*;
4 75 4
m ]9();X+ @J;X(0EX()@A*;hB,<;3+,()%!X!#<;P;#%.)@A*z.)%1,!#;P'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();XEX()qW1<;h$&I<'>46*,()qW1<;YB46*;h1,*;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#
<
$h4 <@A*,*I<3C1,*f'<@A1,+ A.) &?
?
TV%EXE#f'<@A1,+ A.)f;#%!D4Z$&@HB,I%.0();#I<fB46*;v.)o'#:n46+,(0EX!# Cm >
j~ , P
n h
~
~
O
¥ ¥
t
{ <;9+,()%!X!#<;dB,'<@A*;#EX!X1'%EX()@A*5;D@A*?EdB,<;XEX(0*I<<;ow %EX!#g$-();#<;9%*t@H%1,NW!#gB46*;91,*g;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#JmO¢|@J;#I<<;oB46*;
1,*tSn6EX(0$&%*?E>=%.0.)<;d;#%!#@A*WE9;#@A1,$-();D<;dwhB,f@A!XE#<;d'<@A*?EX!D46(0*WE#<;o$&I<'>46*,()q?1<;~=OqW1'<Z;#@A(0Ed%*t'<@A$-+,!#<;D;X()@A*
@A15%*5EX!D4A'%EX()@A*
mO{KiI%EX1B,-;X1,!.)j'D:@A(_GU$&I<'>46*,()q?1-B,<;9+,()%!X!#<;d+n46!D46(0EoB,@A*'ZEX!#l<;9(0$-+O@A!XED46*WE#-%E9B,I%+ %*B
B,-+,.01;#()%1,!#;+n46!D46$&l%EX!#<;P+ @J;X(0EX()@A*B46*;.R4\;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#J=|GH+ @J;X(0EX()@A*wY.R4\+,.01,()J=wY.R4L*%(0u Jm0m0m
+ @A1,!f1,*
;XED46S,(0.0(0E#I@A+,EX(0$h46.)B,d.R4-;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#g461L'<@A1,!#;vBC1LE#%$-+;>m
{
<;v'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();XEX()q?1<;+,!X(0*'%(0+n46.)<;vB,<;v$&@A!XEX()%!#;v;#@A*WEf
.)%1,!v@A1,NH!D46S,(0.0(0E#I
•
.)%1,!"+,!X();#
•
.)%1,!#;8!#I<;X();XED46*'<<;v$&I<'>46*,()q?1<;
•
.)%1,!#;"'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();XEX()qW1<;B,d!#%EX!D46(0E%EvB,du @A* n%$&%*?E>=|m0m0m
m
•
¢ @A1,!d+O@A1,N @A(0!dI%NA46.01%!9.)<;9'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();XEX()q?1<;oB,<;$&@A!XEX()%!#;>=O@A*+,!#%*Bt;#@A1,N %*WEd'<@A$-$&g!#II%!#%*'<g.)$&@A!
|
4 C6 6
EX()%! P'<@A$-+ @J;#I-%*5+O@A()B,;oB,Y 1,*Z+n46!XEX()-B,j.0(R46*?Ef%E 3+n46!XEX()<;fB,-;D46S,.)Z*@A!X$h46.0();#I-B,@A*WEo.)<;duJ!D46(0*;
A
;>KiI<'D:%.)@A*,*%*?EdB, Jj$-()'%!#@A*;vw Z$-$L=,%E *5 4 7505
BK 1,*f+n46!XEX()fBKi>461`
puJ1,!# m em{o!D46+,+O@A!XE'%.R4A;#;X()qW1
C
>461 .0(R46*WE<;XEv46(0*;X(B,fCm Cm ='> 45%
TVd$&@A!XEX()%!v<;#E8$h46.R4GCIf%E8$-();v%*\+,.R4A'<oB46*;vB,<;F$&@A1,.)<;"$&I%ED46.0.0()qW1<;v;#1,(0NA46*WE"B,<;8$&I%EX:@WB,<;"*@A!X$h46.0(_
;#I<<;~mH]d<;8<;#;¡46();/!X:I<@A.)@AuJ()qW1<;v;D@A*?EF!#I>46.0();#I<;";X1,!8'<9$&@A!XEX()%!>m N %*WEX1%.0.)%$&%*?E>=O@A*\'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();#o.R4g+,!X();#o%E
.R4j'D:n46.)%1,!BK :?CBC!D46ED46EX()@A*
m
&P
Q |
?n vn
?
¥ ¥ ®[ Ê Ë
E% = 100
Dr − D i 4 78 4
` m Cm e
Di
@ #! %+,!#I<;#%*WE#f.)oBC(R46$&l%EX!#op*n46.b=
Dr
!#%+,!#I<;#%*WE#o.)fBC(R46$&l%EX!#f(0*,(0EX(R46.bm
Di
•
M #"-)" ) M 1#,
(0.<;#Ef'<@A*;XEX(0EX1I-BK 1,*c$&@A1,.)j+n46!D46.0.)I%.)I%+,(0+OI<BC()qW1h'<@A$-+ @A!XED46*?E
•
M &
6B46*;.)V'>4A;BK 1,*Z$&@A!XEX()%! 1,()B,J=A@A*j+ %1,E$&<;X1,!#%!.)/E#%$-+;BKiI<'<@A1,.)%$&%*?E/BK 1,*8'<%!XED46(0*
j~ , P
n h
~
~
O
¥ ¥
Ì
{
jE#%$-+;B,g+,!X();D-;#Z$&<;X1,!#j:n46S,(0EX1%.0.)%$&%*?Ej;X1,!d1,*j+n6E#j+,1,!#-B,-'%(0$&%*?EB,j'<@A*;X();#ED46*'<-*@A!X$h46.)
51= G6
` cw J BKi>461ef%Ej'<@A*C@A!X$&I%$&%*?E&wL.R4L*@A!X$&Y'<@A*'<%!X*I<5`wL.bKM46()B,YB,&.bKM46+,+n46!#%(0.8B,h79()'>46E¡em|.V<;XE
+ @J;#;X(0S,.)f%BKi@AS,E#%*,(0!-` :@A!#;*@A!X$&~e8.)oE#%$-+;9B,f+,!X();DBK 1,*U$&@A!XEX()%!o4<N <'.)f$ %$&Z46+,+n46!#%(0.0.R46u g$h46();9%*
< ;
+,.R4 >46*WEZ1,*3;X1,!#'#:n46!Xu PB, AJ\uJ!D46$-$&<;j;X1,!.)h+,.R46E#>461Q;#1,+OI%!X()%1,!>m|{
&+ @A()B,;ZB,&.bKM46(0uJ1,(0.0.)3+OI%*I%EX!D46*WE
4
B46*;8.)f$&@A!XEX()%!v<;XE"B, JJjuJ!D46$-$&<;~m{
fB,I%S,1,EvB,d+,!X();Df<;XE8.bK (0*;XED46*WEv@L.bKM46(0uJ1,(0.0.);~KM46!X! %E#w C= 6$-$ 5 7>
BC1 @A*BQ` ED46(0.0.)jB,<;v+,.01;9uJ!#@J;uJ!D46(0*;9B,Z;D46S,.)~ev%E.R4-p*tB,g+,!X();#J=O<;XEv.bK (0*;#ED46*?Eo@.bKM46(0uJ1,(0.0.)j;>KM46!X! %E#jw
5 7> C= 6$-$ BC1U*,(0N >461U;X1,+ I%!X()%1,!>m
¥ ¥
" ;( +
G= N= 4 8
20◦
xF>461'<@A1,+aBKi<;#;D46();PB,L.R46S @A!D46E#@A(0!#<;P;D\@A*?E3;#1,!h.)<;3+,!X();X$&<;3B, AG AG r'%$ '<@A*;#%!XN I<;PB46*;h.bKi>461w
4 7508
`
puJ1,!# m em{<;gI%+,!#@A1,N %EXE#<;j;#@A*WE!#@A$-+,1<;Z%* EX!D4A'%EX()@A* +n46! nGH()@A*+,1,();%*Q'<@A$-+,!#<;#;X()@A*
m|{
<;
!#I<;X();#ED46*'<<;>=|461;D;X(/S,()%* %*QEX!D4A'%EX()@A* +n46! nGC()@A* q?1
Ki%* '<@A$-+,!#<;#;#()@A*
=+,!#@AuJ!#<;D;#%*?E&wU+O%1}+,!#l<;j'<@A$-$&
4 05 A
.)@Au?46!X(0EX:,$&gBC1LE#%$-+;` %*?EX!# %E X@A1,!#;¡ed`
puJ1,!# m Jem 4 75;
{
<;s!#I<;X();XED46*'<<;B,<;s$&@A!XEX()%!#;` '<@A$-$&vB46*;s.)8'>4A;sB,<;sS I%E#@A*;¡e|B,I%+ %*B,%*?E/B,FEX!#l<;*@A$S,!#%1CGjb4A'%E#%1,!#;v
*n46EX1,!#f%EvB,@J;D46u o%*'%(0$&%*?E
•
C C
!D46+,+O@A!XE JT ` >461 6'%(0$&%*?E¡e
•
uJ!D46*?1,.)@A$&I%EX!X()Z%E8*n46EX1,!#BC1L;D46S,.)
•
I%*%!XuJ()fB,o$h46.R4G46u f%E8$-();#f%*L@H%1,NH!#
•
+,!#@AE#<'%EX()@A*U.)<;8E#@A1;"+,!#%$-()%!#;X@A1,!#;` '%1,!#~em
•
Y
Q |
?n vn
?
4 m75;
]9();X+ @J;X(0EX(_+ @A1,!".bKi<;#;¡46(
B,d!#I<;X();XED46*'<wj.R4 nGC()@A*
@ 4;
{4h*@A!X$&Zk k Ah;~KM46+,+,.0()q?1Zwh'%(0*qYEW+ <;B,$&@A!XEX()%!#;d@+ %1,N %*?E%EX!#g'<@A$gS,(0*I<;oBC1'%(0$&%*WE
< 4 750A
+ @A!XEX.R46*BU%EvBC1'%(0$&%*?EB,$h4 <@A*,*%!X()3` N @A(0!vpuJ1,!# m emn{o$&@A!XEX()%!B,oEW+ f2 '<@A*?EX()%*WE9;#1,!XE#@A1,EBC1
'%(0$&%*WE+ @A!XEX.R46*B %Ef+ @J;#;#l<B,j1,*j@A!XE#-!#I<;X();#ED46*'<3wP.R4\'<@A$-+,!#<;#;#()@A*
m{
<;$&@A!XEX()%!#;gB,-EW+ 3O=iZ= %E @
<
'<@A*?EX()%*,*%*WEB,<;V+,!#@A+ @A!XEX()@A*;8+,!#@AuJ!#<;#;X(0N %$&%*WE"+,.01;8I%.)%N I<<;8B,o'#:n461CGY@A1YB,d'%(0$&%*WEvB,9$h4 <@A*,*%!X()Jm
{
<;"NA46.)%1,!#;v$-(0*,(0$h46.)<;vB,o!#I<;X();#ED46*'<o$&I<'>46*,()q?1;#@A*?E"(0*BC()qW1I<<;"+ @A1,!v'D:n4A'%1,*B,<;"'%(0*q3EH+O<;B,d$&@A!
EX()%!>mx/()%*q?1o.)<;vNA46.)%1,!#;B,o!#I<;X();XED46*'<$&I<'>46*,()q?1gBC(0$-(0*?1%*WEdBC1U$&@A!XEX()%!2 461L$&@A!XEX()% ! -= .R4&*@A!X$&
;
GC(0u h1,*}+ @A1,N @A(0!-B,3!#I%E#%*WEX()@A*yBKi>461}$-(0*,(0$h46.FB, A m|{
<;j$&@A!XEX()%!#;j+ %1,N %*?E %EX!#Y'%.R4A;#;#I<;j;#%.)@A*}.R4
+,!#@A+ @A!XEX()@A*B,<;"'<@A$-+ @J;D46*WE#;"Sn4A;#I<f;#1,!".)<;8+,!#@A+,!X()I%E#I<;9'<%@A*,*?1<;vB,<;v.0(R46*?E#;%EvB,<;8uJ!D46*?1,.R46E#;9qW1,(%*?EX!#%*WE
B46*;8.R4&'<@A$-+O@J;X(0EX()@A*B,<;8$&@A!XEX()%!#;>=@A1LS,()%*;#%.)@A*\.)<;"+,!#@A+,!X()I%E#I<;B,<;8$&@A!XEX()%!#;v%1CGHb$ %$&<;>m
&Q
j~ , P
n h
~
~
O
4 750A
{ 4gpuJ1,!# m Z(0*BC()q?1oE#@A1,E#f.R4j;#I%!X()oB,d+,!#@A+,!X()I%E#I<;vB,<;8$&@A!XEX()%!#;vB,o'%(0$&%*?E%E"B,o'D:n461CGL'%(0E#I<;"B46*;8.R4
@ 4;
*@A!X$&gk k ACmn]o46*;".)f'>4A;GHEX! %$&J=@A*U@AS,EX()%*?E91,*L$&@A!XEX()%!9'<@A*?E#%*n46*?Eo;X1,!XE#@A1,E9BC1U'%(0$&%*?Ed%E
+ @J;#;#I<B46*WE"1,*d@A!XE#d!#I<;X();XED46*'<wZ.R4-'<@A$-+,!#<;D;X()@A*U%E81,*\b46(0S,.)o+ @A1,N @A(0!vB,d!#I%E#%*?EX()@A*tBKi>461
m
4 75
m J %.R46EX()@A*%*WEX!#.R4h'<@A$-+O@J;X(0EX()@A*5BC1t$&@A!XEX()%!>=n.R4&!#I<;X();XED46*'<jw-.R4&'<@A$-+,!#<;D;X()@A*t%E.)f+ @A1,N @A(0!
B,d!#I%E#%*WEX()@A*tBKi>461
=;D@A1,!#'<fk k A @ 4;
@ * '>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();#}46.)@A!#;.)L
@A(0*WEt'<@A$-$&1,*(0*?E#%!
b4A'<+n46!5;#@A*'<@A$-+O@A!XE#%$&%*WEc*@A!X$h46.Z%* EX!D4A'%EX()@A*C
'<@A$-+,!#<;#;#()@A*
=%Ev;#@A*L'<@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?E9ED46*,u %*?EX()%.|%*U'%();D46(0.0.)%$&%*?E>m
d46$-()B
` k!X$h46*&
4 ;
]d<;9EX!D4<NJ461CGt@A*WEfI%E#Ig!#I>46.0();DI<;o'<@A*'<%!X*n46*?Eo.)j'<@A$-+O@A!XE#%$&%*WEfED46*,u %*?Ef;D@A1;9;D@A.0.0()'%(0ED46EX()@A*;f'%H'%.0()qW1<;9+n46!
4 ;
46.d` d46$-()BQ%Ej46.bmF` A eXe=kFEXW(0*;#@A* 4 0A
46.d` kFEXH(0*;#@A*}%Ej46.bmF` J eXeg%Eg+n46!jkv!X$h46*B
BL%E46.bm
` J JeXe"'<@A*'<%!X*n46*?Ev.)<;"$&@A!XEX()%!#;&46*'%()%*;>m &
46.
C
v(0u @A1,!#%1;#%$&%*?E>=F.bK (0*WE#%!
4A'<c<;XEYB,Ip*,()c'<@A$-$&t.R4 ;#1,!
4A'<5B,t'<@A*?ED4A'%E\S,.)@H' S,.)@W'5@A1a.R4 ;#1,!
4A'<5B,
C
'<@A*WED4A'%EvS,.)@H' $&@A!XEX()%!>m
3
j~ , P
n h
~
~
O
C
]o46*;f.)3'>4A;BC1Q'<@A*?ED4A'%EZS,.)@W' S,.)@H'J=
.R4L!X1,u @J;X(0E#IhBK 1,*U
@A(0*WEZ4\;#@A*(0* 1%*'<Jm s*^%E>=.R4\!X1,u @J;X(0E#I3<;XE
B,Ip*,()\wU.bKiI<'#:%.0.)\BC1}uJ!D46(0*}.)<;g(0!X!#I%uJ1,.R46!X(0E#I<;hB,3;X1,!
b4A'<YB,h.R4U+,()%!X!#Jm *Q+O%1,E-'%(0E#%!j.)<;ZEX!D4<NJ461CGQB,
4 ;0;
x846!XE#@A*r` x846!XE#@A*Y%E"T/:@A1,S %` JeXe/q?1,( '>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();#9.bKiI%ED46E8B,;X1,!
b4A'<9BK 1,*v+,()%!X!#9+n46!F.)?8T ` @A(0*WE
@A1,uJ:,*<;#;dTV@Hh'%()%*?E¡em .GC();XE#B,%1CGL$&I%EX:@HB,<;9+O@A1,!9B,I%E#%!X$-(0*%!.)g "T n.bK 1,*NH();X1%.0.)%E.bKM461,EX!#
%$-+,(0!X()qW1Jm
x846!XE#@A*
{4L+,!#%$-()l%!#P$&I%EX:@WB,P'<@A*;X();XE#3%* 1,*h'<@A$-+n46!D46();D@A*QNH();X1%.0.)3%*?EX!#3.)&+,!#@6p.FI%EX1BC()I3%Eg.)<;+,!#@6p.);jB,
4 ;0; 4 76
46.o` x846!XE#@A* %EhT/:@A1,SO%a` JeXemW1,!j.R4\puJ1,!# m JC=|.)<;jBC(_^ I%!#%*WE#;&I%ED46E#;-B,Y;X1,!
b4A'<3;#@A*WE
B,@A*,*I<;94<N <'o.)f'<@Hh'%()%*?E9B,o "TaI<qW1,(0NA46.)%*WE>m
4 76
σ
m J s¢ !#@6p.VB,3!X1,u @J;X(0E#IPB,&.R4U+,()%!X!#3%EgNA46.)%1,!jBC1 "T I<q?1,(0NJ46.)%*?E>=x846!XE#@A* 46.9` x846!XE#@A* %E
4 ;0;
T/:@A1,S %r` JeXe
*dNA46.)%1,!B,o "Ta<;XEv46(0*;X(4^<'%E#I<wZ1,*L+,!#@6p.bm
2
JRC =
αs − φ r 4 B; 4
` m Hm e
log10 (JCS/σn0 )
@
=
TV@Hh'%()%*?E9WT85,<;XE8.R4j!#I<;#();XED46*'<f%*L'<@A$-+,!#<;#;X()@A*1,*,(R4GH(R46.)BC1\$h46E#I%!X(R461
=
,<;XE8.bKM46*,uJ.)gBK (0*'%.0(0*n46();#@A*U+ @A1,!8.)<qW1%.
.)duJ.0();#;#%$&%*WEB,<;"B,%1CGYS,.)@W'<;v'<@A$-$&%*'<J=
αs
<;XE8.R4j'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#g*@A!X$h46.)g461jX@A(0*?EvqW1n46*B\.)duJ.0();#;D%$&%*?E;Dd+,!#@WBC1,(0E>=
σn0
,<;XE".bKM46*,uJ.)fB,9 !#@AEXE#%$&%*?E!#I<;X()BC1%.bm
φr
{4&'<@A*?EX!D46(0*?E#g*@A!X$h46.)f<;XE"'>46.)'%1,.)I<+n46!
σn0 =
W cosβs 4 B; 75
` m Hm e
A
@
=
<;XE8.)d+ @A()B,;"BC1LS,.)@H'o;X1,+OI%!X()%1,!>=
W
<;XE8.R4j>@A*fB,o'<@A*WED4A'%EvS,!X1,E>=
A
<;XE8.bKM46*,uJ.)BK (0*'%.0(0*n46();D@A*
m
βs
4 76 4
W1,!Y.R4 puJ1,!# m =8q?1%.)qW1<;YGC%$-+,.)<;\B,t+,()%!X!#c;#@A*WEP+,!#I<;D%*?E#I<<;U4>N <'.)%1,!#;\?8T '<@A!X!#<;X+ @A*B46*?E#;
5 1= 5 06
` xV:@ 8$-(0L%E"]91,EXED4L` JJ We=O[9!D4A;#;#%.0.0(%E" suJu %!g` JJ eXem
σn =
un kn0 Vm 4 B; 76
` m Hm e
Vm − u n
£Y
j~ , P
n h
~
~
O
4 76 4
σ
m
xV:@8$-(0
GC%$-+,.)<;B,/+,()%!X!#<;|4>N <'/.)%1,!#;|'<@Hh'%()%*?E#;B,s!X1,u @J;#(0E#I "T9=WT8%E46*,uJ.)/B,s !#@AEXE#%$&%*WE>=
5 1=
46.` xV:@ 8$-(0L%E"]1,EXED4U` JJ WeXe
@
=
B,I<;X(0uJ*f.R4g %!X$&%EX1,!#o$h4GC(0$h46.)BC1jX@A(0*?E>=
Vm
<;XE"B,Ip*,(E#%.q?1-
kn0
kn0 =
dσn
(un = 0)
4 B; =
` m Hm We
dun
E#I%!X();#I<f+n46!8.bKM46*,uJ.)B\B,fBC(0.R46ED46*'<&
d = Arctan
dun 4 B; 7>
` m Hm e
dut
x846!XE#@A*
4 ;0;
46.g` x846!XE#@A*%EYT/:@A1,S %` JeXe-@A*WE3B,Ip*,(v.bKiI<qW1n46EX()@A*a;X1,(0NA46*WE#\+ @A1,!h.bKi<;XEX(0$h46EX()@A* B,L.R4
C
!X(0uJ()BC(0E#Io$h4GC(0$h46.)B,o'%();¡46(0.0.)%$&%*?EZ` 2t¢4 $3o
e
Ks =
100
σn tan[JRClog10 (JCS/σn ) + φr ]
4 B; 78
` m Hm e
Lx
@
=
<;#E8.R4Z.)@A*,uJ1%1,!BC1-X@A(0*?Ev%*\$&l%EX!#Jm
Lx
4 7605
{4fpuJ1,!# m ;X1,(0NJ46*?E#$&@A*?EX!#9.)9B,I%+,.R4A'<%$&%*?E8ED46*,u %*WEX()%.
BC1h$&@HB,l%.)%*3 @A*'%EX()@A*YB,.R4'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#oB,
'%();D46(0.0.)%$&%*WEv+ @A1,!vBC(_^I%!#%*?E#;vI%ED46E#;vB,f;X1,!
b4A'<oB,f'<@A*?ED4A'%Ej` "T8em
4 7605
m v%+,!#I<;#%*WED46EX()@A*B,<;8'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#<;9B,o'%();D46(0.0.)%$&%*?E#%E9B,oB,I%+,.R4A'<%$&%*?Ev+ @A1,!"BC(_^I%!#%*?E#;"'<@H-
'%()%*WE#;vB,o!X1,u @J;X(0E#I "T9m i2
$&@HB,%. i¢
+,!#@AE#@AEW+ J=nx846!XE#@A*
46.` xF46!XE#@A*%E9T/:@A1,SO%c` JeXe 4 ;0;
.R4Z.)@A(
τ = c + σn tanφ
4 B; B;
` m Hm Je
@
=
<;XE8.bKM46*,uJ.)fB,9 !#@AEXE#%$&%*?E9BC1-X@A(0*?E"+,.R46*
=
φ
<;XE8.R4j'<@A:I<;X()@A*
m
c
{
$&@HB,l%.)B,tx846!XE#@A*CxF46*BC();UB,Ip*,(0E3.bKiI<qW1n46EX()@A*a+O@A1,!P.R4r!#I<;#();XED46*'<t461a'%();D46(0.0.)%$&%*WELBK 1,* X@A(0*?E\B,
<
!#@H'#:fB,f.R4g4 <@A*U;#1,(0NA46*WE#&
τ = σn tan[φb + JRClog10 (
JCS
)]
4 B; 7A
` m Hm e
σn
@
=
<;XE8.bKM46*,uJ.)fB,o !#@AEXE#%$&%*WEB,d.R4-;X1,!
b4A'<oB,d!X1,+,EX1,!#J=
φb
5 1=
79(0.0.)%$1;5` 7(0.0.)%$g1;c` JJ WeXe&4c$-();3%*z+,.R4A'<U1,*zBC();X+ @J;X(0EX(_fGH+ I%!X(0$&%*?ED46.9+O@A1,!P'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();#%!P.)L'<@A$j
<
6 %6
+ @A!XE#%$&%*?E8BC1g
@A(0*WEF461P'%();D46(0.0.)%$&%*?E>m,{
v+,!X(0*'%(0+Od<;XEVB,"+,.R4A'<%!F1,*"+,()%!X!#dB,I<'<@A1,+ I<J=?+ @A1,!/;~KM4^O!D46*'D:,(0!
B,<;+,!#@AS,.)l%$&<;dB,f!X1,u @J;X(0E#IJ=B46*;v1,*gB,%$-(_bSO@ )E#g(0*C I%!X()%1,!#Y` BC(0$&%*;X()@A*5B,f.R4&SO@ )E# JA'%$jG JA'%$3e= B,
b4 <@A*tw3'<qW1f.R4h;X1,!
4A'<ZB,f.R4&+,()%!X!#g'<@A!X!#<;#+O@A*B,j461+,.R46*5B,'%();¡46(0.0.)%$&%*?EoB,f.R4hSO@ )E#Jm *;X1,(0E#J=O1,*
461,EX!#\I<'D:n46*?EX(0.0.)@A*zB,P$ %$&YED46(0.0.)Y<;XEj+O@J;DI3;X1,!j.R4+,!#%$-()l%!#Y+,()%!X!#J=B46*;j1,*YB,%1CGH()l%$&YS @ )E#c` N @A(0!
puJ1,!# m em 4 7606
σn
fcisaillement
s;D;D46(
B,fk!X$h46*B
46./` k!X$h46*BL%Ev46.bm` J JeXed 4 ;
]o46*;g.)h'>4A;ZB,<;"X@A(0*?E#;ZNH(_ ;>=
.)h'<@A*?ED4A'%E-%*WEX!#3.)<;gS,.)@H'<;g<;XEZBC(0!#<'%EZ%Eg.R4L;XED46S,(0.0(0E#IPB,3.R4L;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#P<;XE
4A;#;#1,!#I<o+n46!".R4ZuJ!D4<NH(0E#I%Ev.R4Z!#I%+n46!XEX(0EX()@A*tB,<;"^@A!XE#;461L;D%(0*L$ %$&fB,o.R4-;#EX!X1'%EX1,!#Jmn{4ZpuJ1,!#;X1,(0NA46*WE#
$&@A*WEX!#fB,<;8<;#;D46();F!#I>46.0();#I<;"+n46!Fk!X$h46*B 4 ;
46.%* J Z;X1,!8B,%1CGPS,.)@H'<;8B,d+,()%!X!#oB,o]9()@A*?C;#@J;F+ @A1,!"B,<;
NH(0E#<;#;#<;8B,f'%();¡46(0.0.)%$&%*?E%EB,<;8+,!#<;#;X()@A*;8&*@A!X$h46.)<;vNA46!X(R46S,.)<;~m
"* 1
VE
]o46*;"'<<;"<;D;D46();>=C(0. <;XEv'<@A*;#ED46E#Ifq?1-
<
{ K (0*WE#%!
4A'<Z%*?EX!#g.)fS,.)@H'f%E.)o$&@A!XEX()%!9<;#Ev;#@A1,N %*?E9.)o+,.R46*tB,ob46(0S,.)<;#;#fB,<;$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;>mO{4-!#I%+ @A*;#
s
C
*@A*Cb.0(0*I>46(0!#fB,<;X@A(0*?E#;>=,qW1,(<;XE846.)@A!#;8'<@A*?EX!#@A.0.)I<o+n46!8.bK (0*WE#%!
4A'<dS,.)@H' $&@A!XEX()%!>=<;XEV1,*oB,<;V+,.01;8;X(0uJ*,(_p,
< -< -< 5 08
'>46EX(0N <;d'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();XEX()qW1<;oBC1'<@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?EfB,<;9$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;>m {
@A1,!#%* <@c` {
@A1,!#%* <@c` JJ eXe94-$&@A*WEX!#I
qW1
K (0.sGH();#E#ZB,%1CGt+,:I%*@A$&l%*<;f+ @A1,NA46*WE;#Z+,!#@HBC1,(0!#&wh.bK (0*WE#%!
4A'<U .)j+,!#%$-()%!o$&@WB,-<;XEf4A;#;D@W'%()I-wP.R4
!X1,+,EX1,!#o+n46!vEX!D4A'%EX()@A*
#3)
=H.)fB,%1CGC()l%$&o$&@HB,o<;XE4A;#;#@H'%()Iowj.R4Z!X1,+,EX1,!#f+n46!"'%();¡46(0.0.)%$&%*?E
4 0808
.4-I%E#Ig@AS;#%!XN If+n46! 9%H$h46*,*Q` 9%W$h46*,*}` eXe8qW1
K (0.GC();XE#o1,*LEX!#@A();X()l%$&EH+OgB,o!X1,+,EX1,!#ZB,o.bK (0*C
E#%!
b4A'<&+n46!Z'<@A$-+,!#<;#;X()@A*
m|TV%+ %*B46*?E>=|'<&$&@HB,&B,h!X1,+,EX1,!#h<;XEg!D46!#%$&%*?Ej@AS,E#%*?1};X1,!B,<;;#EX!X1'%EX1,!#<;
#3)
m
!#I<%.0.)<;>m
`
%*B46u ~ef%EZB,<;<;#;¡46();B,&EX!D4A'%EX()@A*}BC(0!#<'%E#5`
puJ1,!# 4 m760> em¢@A1,!Z.R4L;X(0$g1,.R46EX()@A**W1,$&I%!X()q?1J=|.bKi<;#;¡46(/B,
j~ , P
n h
~
~
O
EX!D4A'%EX()@A*cBC(0!#<'%E#j<;XE9.)$-()%1CGt4AB46+,E#IZ+ @A1,!.R4h!#%+,!#I<;#%*WED46EX()@A*r'<@A$-+,.)l%E#ZBC1cBC(R46uJ!D46$-$&jB,I%+,.R4A'<%$&%*?E
'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#Jm
4 760> C
m %+,!#I<;#%*?ED46EX()@A*-B,VBC(_^ I%!#%*WE#;|EH+O<;|BKi<;#;D46();|B46*;|.bK (0*?E#%!
b4A'<S,.)@H' $&@A!XEX()%!>mA s;#;D46();+O@J;D;X(0S,.)<;
6 =
B, nGC()@A*
=` ~eF<;#;¡46();"B,o'<@A$-+,!#<;#;X()@A*
={
@A1,!#%* <@-<
+ @A1,!'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();#%!/.R49!#I<;X();XED46*'<w9.R4oEX!D4A'%EX()@A*n`4 e%Ev` Se s;#;D46(); b+O@A(0*WE#;>=n` '~e<;#;¡46(); Ab+O@A(0*WE#;>=n` Bne<;D;D46();
-< 5 08
46.` {
@A1,!#%* <@5` JJ eXe
4 ; <
746*t]9%!d¢.01,(
$ ` 746*5]d%!¢.01,(
$ ` J JeXe4-E#<;#E#IB,<;+O%EX(0E#;9I<'#:n46*WEX(0.0.)@A*;fB,f$h4 <@A*,*%!X()J= '<@A$-+ @J;#I<;
4 7608
+n46!vB,<;"S,.)@W'<;>=,BKM46!XuJ(0.)@A1UB,f'>46.)'>46(0!#h`
puJ1,!# m em
4 7608 C
m TV@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?EoB,.bK (0*?E#%!
b4A'<gS,.)@H' $&@A!XEX()%!ow&.R4&EX!D4A'%EX()@A*Q|`4 eFEX!D4A'%EX()@A*cBC(0!#<'%E#J=|` Se"BC(R4
uJ!D46$-$&F'<@A*?EX!D46(0*WE#B,I%+,.R4A'<%$&%*?Eo`
pn;#;X1,!#~e+O@A1,!|1,*S,!X()qW1/+,.)%(0*/'<@A$-+ @J;#I<VBKM46!XuJ(0.)d` .bKM46(0!#/!#%+,!#I<;#%*WE#
=
.bKi%*WN %.)@A+,+OgB, &<;#;D46();¡e=C746*]9%!"¢s.01,( $ ` 746*]9%!¢.01,( $ ` J JeXe 4 ;
.4-'<@A*;XED46E#IJ=%*4AB,@A+,ED46*?E9B,<;v^@A!XE#;"B,oEX!D4A'%EX()@A*t46.0.R46*WEB, 2 w 2 qW1o.R4-;X1,!
b4A'<
B,&pn;#;X1,!D46EX()@A*<;#E'<@A*'<%*?EX!#I<YB46*;f.R4L+n46!XEX()h'<%*WEX!D46.)PB,&.bK (0*?0.3N/mm C
E#%!
b4A'<3S,.)@H' 0.9N/mm
$&@A!XEX()%!>m|¢|46!Z'<<;g<;#;¡46();>=(0.
4r$&@A*?EX!#I5q?1U.R4r;X1,!
b4A'<UBKM46!X!D4A'D:%$&%*?EU<;#EPwc+ %1z+,!#l<;PI%u?46.)5w B,U.R4r;X1,!
b4A'<LE#@AED46.)JmF *Cp*
=
(0./4L+,!#@6
%E#I3'<%EXE#h'<@A*;XED46ED46EX()@A* wY.bKiG,%$-+,.)hBK 1,*$1,!Z+O@A1,!%*Q'<@A*35% '%.01,!#hqW1
Ki%* *I%uJ.0(0u >46*WEg.)<;"
@A(0*WE#;
Y
4 ;0;
$&@A!XEX()%!"%*\'%();D46(0.0.)%$&%*WE>mTV%1CGW'%((0*'%.01%*WEvB,<;8<;#;D46();FBC(0!#<'%E"B,d'%();D46(0.0.)%$&%*WEg`bW(0*,:n4j%E %*BC!X5` e=
4 0A08 G9 :9
9@6 $h46*,*y%EYWE#@W'DW.` eXej%E3B,<;-E#<;XE#;&BC(0E#; EX!X(0+,.)I<; r`bW$-(0EX:z%E3TF46!XE#%!` Je= 9%*BC!X` eXe=
]9(_^I%!#%*?E#;dE#<;XE#;o@A*WEfI%E#Ig$-();d%*5+,.R4A'<j+ @A1,!9.R4P'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();D46EX()@A*rBC1c'<@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?EB,Z.bK (0*WE#%!
4A'<-S,.)@H'
4 0808
4 ;A
qW1,(s(0*?E#l%uJ!#%*WEgEX!#@A();S,.)@W'<;+O@A1,!g'%();D46(0.0.)%!gB,%1CGc(0*?E#%!
b4A'<<;jwY.R4P@A();>m
¢|@A1,!g@AS,E#%*,(0!1,* !#I%uJ(0$&&+ @J;XE
b+,()'J=
.)g+,!#@AS,.)l%$&jGH+ I%!X(0$&%*?ED46.<;XE9B,u?46!#B,%!d'<@A*;XED46*?E#j.R4h'<@A*?EX!D46(0*WE#j*@A!X$h46.)Z;#1,!.)<;
@A(0*WE#;9:@A!X(0>@A*?ED461CG
4 760A
`
puJ1,!# m em
Q
j~ , P
n h
~
~
O
4 760A
m
5 08
` JJ eXe
s;D;D46();/B,'%();D46(0.0.)%$&%*?EoO`4 e<;#;D46();/'<@A1,+,.)I<;>= ` Se<;#;D46(); 9 EX!X(0+,.)I<;9A=H{
@A1,!#%*-<<@
-<
46.|` {@A1,!#%* <@
4 06
]o46*;s;#@A*&46!XEX()'%.)` 746*&]d%!s¢.01,(
$ ` J eXe=J746*&B,%!s¢s.01,( $ +,!#I<;D%*?E#81,*8'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();D46EX()@A*3'<@A$-+,.)l%E#vBC1
<
'<@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?E8%*Y'%();D46(0.0.)%$&%*?E8B,".R4$h4 <@A*,*%!X()J=C'<@A$-+O@J;DI<vB,S,.)@W'<;VBKM46!XuJ(0.)<;V+,.)%(0*;/%EVB,;X(0.0()'>46E#9B,
4 76
'>46.)'%(01,$Lm{Ki<;#;D46(B,d.R4puJ1,!# m JZ+O%!X$&%E"B,9u?46!#B,%!81,*d+,!#<;#;X()@A*LB,d'<@A*Cp*%$&%*WEv*@A!X$h46.)o'<@A*;XED46*WE#
;X1,!9.)'%();¡46(0.0.)%$&%*?E>m]d<;d'<@A*?EX!D46(0*?E#<;&` B,j'<@A$-+,!#<;#;#()@A*;¡e"B,Z'<@A*Cp*%$&%*?Ef;D@A*?Eo46+,+,.0()q?1I<<;-OCm = Cm 3%E 4 7>
4 m
N/mm2
4=
*h+,:I%*@A$&l%*dB,v46EX(0uJ1%EVBK 1;X1,!#9<;XEV@AS;#%!XN IZ` N @A(0!/puJ1,!# m ?f$&@A*WEX!D46*?EF1,*946.0.01,!#9GC+O@A*%*WEX()%.0.)
@
B,P.R4t'<@A1,!XSO~em *y4A;#;X();#E#Pw1,*YBC(0$-(0*?1,EX()@A*yB,P.R4t'<@A:I<;X()@A* B46*;j.)<;Z$&@WB,l%.)<;-B,LTV@A1,.)@A$S
m{sKM46(0!#
B,Ip*,()U+n46!&.)LBC(R46uJ!D46$-$&t'<@A*?EX!D46(0*?E#B,I%+,.R4A'<%$&%*WEU%E&.)\*,(0N >461 B,L'%();D46(0.0.)%$&%*WE3BC1 !#@AEXE#%$&%*?EY;#<'
!#I<;X()BC1%."<;#E-46+,+ %.)I<P.bKiI%*%!XuJ() II B,P!X1,+,EX1,!#\BC1
Gf
#3) =|4>N <'\B,<;jNA46.)%1,!#;-;>KiI%E#%*B46*WEhB,
0.01
w
+ @A1,!B,<;NJ46.)%1,!#;sB,8.R4o'<@A:I<;X()@A*h(0*,(0EX(R46.)v'8;>KiI%E#%*B46*WE/B, w 2 mJ{4dNJ46.)%1,!
0.25N mm/mm2
B,d.bKiI%*%!XuJ()gB,o!X1,+,EX1,!#fB,I%+ %*BLI%u?46.)%$&%*?E9B,o.R4ZNA46.)%1,!B,o.R4j'<@A*?EX!D46(0*WE#gB,0.1 o'<@A*C1.8N/mm
p*%$&%*WE>m
4 76
m J s;D;D46();8B,f'%();D46(0.0.)%$&%*WEg
`4 eVI<'#:n46*WEX(0.0.)@A*
=|` Se@A!#'<<;v46+,+,.0()qW1I<<;v;X1,!8.bKiI<'D:n46*?EX(0.0.)@A*
=746*LB,%!
¢.01,(
$ ` 746*U]d%!"¢.01,(
$ ` J eXe 4 06
P
3
4= C
m ? 2t@WB,8D
B,8!X1,+,EX1,!#"B,F.bK (0*WE#%!
4A'<vS,.)@W' $&@A!XEX()%!v`4 e](R46uJ!D46$-$&v'<@A*?EX!D46(0*?E#B,I%+,.R4A'<%$&%*WE
!6
-<
+ @A1,!BC(_^I%!#%*?E#;ZI%ED46E#;B,&'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#<;\` .bKM46(0!#-!#%+,!#I<;#%*WE#h.bKi%*WN %.)@A+,+O3B, \<;#;D46();e=` SedI%*%!XuJ() II B,
!X1,+,EX1,!#J={
@A1,!#%* <@ -< 5 08
46.` {
@A1,!#%* <@t` JJ eXe Gf
<
{4&!#I<;X();XED46*'<Zw-.R4-'<@A$-+,!#<;#;#()@A*tB,.R4j$h4 <@A*,*%!X()jB46*;"1,*BC(0!#<'%EX()@A*t*@A!X$h46.)j461CGY+,.R46*;9B,8X@A(0*?E#;d4
;#@A1,N %*WEoI%E#IZ'<@A*;#()B,I%!#I<Z'<@A$-$&Z.R43+,!#@A+,!X()I%E#IZ$&I<'>46*,()q?1Z$h4X%1,!#Jm {
j'<@A$-+O@A!XE#%$&%*WEf%*5'<@A$-+,!#<;D;X()@A*
<
1,*,(R4GC(R46.)fBK 1,*o$h4 <@A*,*%!X()g<;XE8EX!D4ABC(0EX()@A*,*%.0.)%$&%*?Eo@AS,E#%*?1+n46!81,*U<;#;D46(
B,o'<@A$-+,!#<;D;X()@A*U;X(0$-+,.)o+ %!
+ %*BC()'%1,.R46(0!#%$&%*?Eo461CGP+,.R46*;B,V
@A(0*WE#;>m
*\EH+OBKi<;#;D46(
+ @A1,NA46*WE %EX!#o!#I>46.0();#If+O@A1,!"()B,%*WEX(_pn%!v.)f'<@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?Ed%*U'<@A$-+,!#<;#;#()@A*L1,*,(R4GH(R46.)gB,<;
< 4=4
$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;j<;XEf.bKi<;D;D46(/{
2 ` *@A!X$h46.0();DI~e%` N @A(0!puJ1,!# m em|TV%EZ<;#;D46(<;XEZ;#@A1,N %*?Eg!#I>46.0();#Ih;#1,!1,*
> %50> -8
4A;#;D%$S,.R46u o$g1,.0EX(_'<@A1'#:jB,dS,.)@W'<;vB,fBC(0$&%*;X()@A*;"E#@AED46.) JJG JG JJ
mm 3m
4=4 <
m TV@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?Eh1,*,(R4GC(R46.vB,<;-$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;3;#@A1;&'D:n46!Xu %$&%*?Eh*@A!X$h46.9461 +,.R46*zB,Z
@A(0*WE>m
%+,!#I<;#%*?ED46EX()@A*
=|;X1,!.R4\puJ1,!#hB,hu?461'#:PB,&.bKiI<'#:n46*WEX(0.0.)@A* v{
s2Qmv%+,!#I<;D%*?ED46EX()@A*
=|;X1,!f.R4YpuJ1,!#PB,
-<
BC!#@A(0E#J=BC1rBC(R46uJ!D46$-$&-'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#B,I%+,.R4A'<%$&%*?EU` <;#E9.R4P!#I<;#();XED46*'<&w3.R43'<@A$-+,!#<;D;X()@A*rBC1c$&@A!XEX()%!>=
{
@A1,!#%* <@ -< 5 08
46./` {
@A1,!#%* <@t` JJ eXe fm0
PJ
j~ , P
n h
~
~
O
4 08
]d%+,1,();V.)"EX!D4>NA46(0. +,()@A*,()%!FB, (0.);#B,@A!
/` (0.);#B,@A!
V` J eXe=H.R4f'<@A$-$g1,*n461,E#IoB,v.bKiI%EX1B,dBC1Y'<@A$-+O@A!XE#%$&%*WE
<
$&I<'>46*,()qW1oB,<;8$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;v4ZNJ46.0()B,Ioq?19.R4ZBC(_^I%!#%*'<fB46*;F.)<;F+,!#@A+,!X()I%E#I<;vI%.R4A;XEX()qW1<;8%*?EX!#f.)S,.)@H'o%E
<
.)s
@A(0*WEFB,v$&@A!XEX()%!8<;XE.R4g'>461;#vB,.R4o!X1,+,EX1,!#dBK 1,*$h4 <@A*,*%!X()Jm,{4f'<@A$-+,!#<;D;X()@A*Y1,*,(R4GH(R46.)9B,v.R4f$h4
< C
S,(R4GC(R46.)/B46*;|.)/S,.)@W'Jm6{
<;|EX!D4<NJ461CGZB,V2546*,*
<@A*,*%!X()$&l%*wd1,*PI%ED46E/B,"'<@A$-+,!#<;D;X()@A*3EX!X(R4GC(R46.B46*;.)"$&@A!XEX()%!V%E1,*3I%ED46EVB,"'<@A$-+,!#<;#;X()@A* EX!D4A'%EX()@A*
46.H@A*WE@AS;#%!XN I/qW1J=A461ZB,I%+n46!XE>=AB,<;pn;#;X1,!#<;46+,+n46!D46();#;#%*WE
B46*;.)<;vS,.)@H'<;9%*t;X1,(0NJ46*?E9.R4-.0(0uJ*g$&@> %*,*jB,g.bKiI<'#:n46*WEX(0.0.)@A*
='JKi<;XE
wBC(0!#j%*'<@A*?EX(0*W1,(0E#I-BC1&X@A(0*?E9N %!
EX()'>46.bm{
@A!#;jBK 1,*YB,I @A!X$h46EX()@A*y'%!#@A();D;D46*?E#c` 'JKi<;XE
wBC(0!#\%* 461,uJ$&%*?ED46*WE&.)Y'#:n46!Xu %$&%*?E¡e=B,<;pn;D;X1,!#<;
N %!XEX()'>46.)<;v4AB,BC(0EX()@A*,*%.0.)<;46+,+n46!D46();#;#%*?E";#1,!V.bKiI%+n46();D;#%1,!8B,.bKiI<'D:n46*?EX(0.0.)@A*U4>N @A!X();D46*?Ev46(0*;X( .R4g!X1,+,EX1,!#9+n46!
!D4A'%EX()@A*,*%$&%*?E>m
-< 4 0A0A
xV(0*B4 46.` xV(0*B45%Eh46.bm"` eXej@A*?Eh$&@A*?EX!#I\.bK (0$-+ @A!XED46*'<LB,Y.R4t!#I<;X();XED46*'<Lwt.R45'<@A$-+,!#<;D;X()@A*zBC1
$&@A!XEX()%!v'<@A$-$&(0* 1%* >46*?Ev @A!XE#%$&%*WE'<%.0.)fB,o.bKiI<'D:n46*?EX(0.0.)@A* ` N @A(0!8puJ1,!# m em 4=4
{
<;V<;#;D46();B,v'<@A$-+,!#<;#;X()@A*31,*,(R4GH(R46.)9B46*;s.R4BC(0!#<'%EX()@A*3+n46!D46.0.)l%.)9461CG&+,.R46*;B,s
@A(0*WE#;/@A*WE/;X1;#'%(0E#I"$&@A(0*;
<
BKM46EXE#%*WEX()@A*QB,h.R4Y+n46!XEgB,-.R4U'<@A$-$1,*n461,E#IP;#'%()%*?EX(_pnqW1JmTV%+O%*B46*WE>=.R4Y$h4 <@A*,*%!X()3!#I%uJ1,.0()l%!#P<;XEf1,*
$h46E#I%!X(R461c46*,();#@AEX!#@A+ %E>=B46*;.)f'>4A;vBK 1,*f46(0S,.)+,!#<;#;X()@A*L.)@A*,uJ(0EX1BC(0*n46.)jB,<;vS,.)@W'<;>=.R4j!#I<;X();XED46*'<Zw-.R4
'D:n46!Xu hB,&'<@A$-+,!#<;#;#()@A* +n46!D46.0.)l%.)3461CGc+,.R46*;gB,d
@A(0*WE#;+ %1,Eg4>N @A(0!1,* ^%EB,I<'%();X(_";X1,!o.R4\'D:n46!Xu h+ @A!
4 1=
E#%1;#JmH%.)@A* 9@6^O$h46*,* 46.s` @6^ $h46*,*\%E8H'D:?1,S %!XEg` J WeXe=C.)v!D46+,+ @A!XE8%*?EX!#d.R4Z'#:n46!Xu o'<@A$-+,!#<;D;X(0N
75 7A
1,*,(R4GC(R46.)o+n46!D46.0.)l%.)%E8+ %!X+ %*BC()'%1,.R46(0!#3` *@A!X$h46.)~e"461U+,.R46*LB,F
@A(0*WEv;>KiI%E#%*BLB,fC= hw-C= Cm
.
<;XEvwj;#@A1,.0(0uJ*%!9q?1d.R4j'<@A$-+,!#<;#;#()@A*L1,*,(R4GH(R46.)g<;XE8!D46!#%$&%*?E+,(0.)@AE#I<f%*UB,I%+,.R4A'<%$&%*WE>m
¥ ¥
T¾@ 9 Æ~ qÌ\£[ a'
ÊÆ \
4 m ='5
<;XEsB,VEX!D4A'%EX()@A*&B46*;.R4dBC(0!#<'%EX()@A*-+n46!D46.0.)l%.)"461j+,.R46*&B,X@A(0*?E>=Jx84A'D <; a46.` x84A'D <;v` 4 0A0> eXe
P&2
3
4 ='6
¢|@A1,!-.)Y+,!#%$-()%!-$&@WB,YP` N @A(0!jpuJ1,!# m J4 e=.R4Lpn;D;X1,!#P46(0Ej1,*}<(0uJ~46ur%*?EX!#Y.)<;9X@A(0*?E#;&:@A!X(0>@A*?ED461CG
%EgN %!XEX()'>461CG m{
3BC(R46uJ!D46$-$&PB,PB,I%+,.R4A'<%$&%*?E
'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#U$&@A*?EX!#P1,*h'<@A1,!XS hEW+,()qW1PBK 1,*Q<;#;¡46(/B,
'%();D46(0.0.)%$&%*WE>=,4<N <'1,*'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#9!#I<;X()BC1%.0.).)@A!#;/B,.bKM461,uJ$&%*?ED46EX()@A*LBC1PB,I%+,.R4A'<%$&%*?E>m,{
v!#I%uJ(0$&v+ @J;XE
+,()'Z<;XEvS,()%*t+,(0.)@AE#Ig+n46!.bKiI%*%!XuJ()jB, !D4A'%EX1,!D46EX()@A*cB,<;
@A(0*WE#;N %!XEX()'>461CGt%E.)g!#I%uJ(0$&+ @J;XE
b+,()'Z%*$&@HB,
#/B,<;X@A(0*?E#;":@A!X(0>@A*WED461CG m
4 ='6
]o46*;F.)d;#<'<@A*BPEH+OdB,d!X1,+,EX1,!#J=C.R4 !D4A'%EX1,!#d+n4A;#;#+n46!8.)<;|
@A(0*WE#;FN %!XEX()'>461CGc` N @A(0!VpuJ1,!# m 6SeV%EFEX!D4
N % !#;#f.)<;8S,.)@W'<;~mkv+,!#l<;".R4j+,!#%$-()l%!#BC();#'<@A*WEX(0*?1,(0E#IgNW();#(0S,.)oB46*;".)fBC(R46uJ!D46$-$&gB,I%+,.R4A'<%$&%*?E
'<@A*?EX!D46(0*WE#J=
.)8!#I%uJ(0$&"+O@J;XE
b+,()'v;#8B,I<'%.)%*'#:+n46!s1,*F !D4A'%EX1,!D46EX()@A*3B,<;S,.)@W'<;>m *"B,%1CGC()l%$&"BC();#'<@A*WEX(0*?1,(0E#Id46+,+n46!D46(0E
46.)@A!#;
1;#qW1
KMwZ.R4Z !D4A'%EX1,!D46EX()@A*BC1\$&@A!XEX()%!>m
4 ='6
m ]9(R46uJ!D46$-$&/'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#B,I%+,.R4A'<%$&%*?EV;#@A1;B,<;<;#;D46();B,EX!D4A'%EX()@A*ZB46*;.R4"BC(0!#<'%EX()@A*g+n46!D46.0.)l%.)
461-+,.R46*hB,
@A(0*WEv`4 e|!X1,+,EX1,!#"BC1oX@A(0*?E/%*-<(0uJ~46u=` Se!X1,+,EX1,!#"N %!XEX()'>46.)vB,<;X@A(0*?E#;s%EB,<;sS,.)@W'<;>=Jx84A'D <;
46./` x84A'D <;g` eXe 4 0A0>
¥ ¥
T¾@ 9 Ê® ~ qÌ
<
{
-'<@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?ES,(R4GH(R46.sB,<;d$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;o*j+ %1,Ed+n4A; %EX!#-B,I<'%!X(0Ef;#%1,.)%$&%*?EwP+n46!XEX(0!fBC1c'<@A$-+ @A!
<
E#%$&%*WEZ1,*,(R4GC(R46.bm|{4\$h4 <@A*,*%!X()YI%ED46*?EZ1,*Q$h46E#I%!X(R461}46*,();#@AEX!#@A+ J=.)<;g'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#<;j*3+O%1,N %*WEg+n4A;Z;#
!#I<BC1,(0!#Yw\1,*P'<@A*?EX!D46(0*WE#3+,!X(0*'%(0+n46.)P$h46();jw\1,*}%*;#%$S,.)PB,h'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#<;>mTV<;Z'<@A*?EX!D46(0*WE#<;>=q?1h.bKi@A*
4 =0= <
4 0A
+ %1,EgNH();X1n46.0();#%!j;X1,!Z.R4\puJ1,!# m @A*WEg1,*y46*,uJ.) 4>N <'3.)<;Z+,.R46*;jBKi<;#;D46();jB,3.R4L$h4 <@A*,*%!X()Jm]d%1CG
P £Y
j~ , P
n h
~
~
O
4 =0= <
m TV@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?ELS,(R4GC(R46.oB,<;P$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;ro`4 e&'D:n46!Xu %$&%*?EU1,*,(R4GC(R46.b=o` Se3'#:n46!Xu %$&%*?E
S,(R4GC(R46.b=¢46u
46.` ¢46u 3` eXe 4 0A 4
{ 5+,!#@H'<I<B,IrGC+OI%!X(0$&%*WED46.f.)5+,.01;L'<@A$-+,.)%EL+ @A1,!\.R4}'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();D46EX()@A*BC1'<@A$-+O@A!XE#%$&%*WES,(R4GC(R46.fB,<;
< 4 0A 4 4 0A06
$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;Z<;XE'<%.01,(B,h¢|46u 5` ¢|46u t` e=¢46u ` eXem{
<;<;#;¡46();o!#I>46.0();#I<;'<@A*;#();XE#%*?Ejw\B,Ip*,(0!
<
1,*Z%*?N %.)@A+,+ -B,!#I<;#();XED46*'<gB,g.R4h$h4 <@A*,*%!X()L` e9%* @A*'%EX()@A*cB,g.bK (0*'%.0(0*n46();#@A*cB,<;X@A(0*?E#;-` N @A(0!
4 ='>
puJ1,!# m em σ1, σ2
.%* !#<;#;#@A!XEYq?1.bKi@A!X()%*?ED46EX()@A*B,<;Y'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#<;\+,!X(0*'%(0+n46.)<;Y+n46!P!D46+,+O@A!XE\461CG 4G,<;3BC1 $h46E#I%!X(R461%E
.)<;NA46.)%1,!#;gB,<;'<@A*?EX!D46(0*WE#<;Z+,!X(0*'%(0+n46.)<;Z@A*WE1,*-(0* 1%*'<P;X1,!f.)&$&@WB,3B,-!X1,+,EX1,!#h%Ef.)<;NA46.)%1,!#;ZB,
!#I<;X();#ED46*'<fBC1\$1,!E#<;XE#IJm
P
3
4 ='> <
m *WN % .)@A+,+O3B,j!#I<;X();XED46*'<-B,j.R4P$h4 <@A*,*%!X()h%*5@A*'%EX()@A* B,j.bK (0*'%.0(0*n46();#@A*BC1r'#:n46!XuJ!X$&%*?E
S,(R4GC(R46.b=¢46u
46
. ` ¢46u 3` eXe 4 0A 4
<
7s@A()'%(.)<;fBC(_^I%!#%*?E#;f$&@WB,<;fB,j!X1,+,EX1,!#hB,g.R4P$h4 <@A*,*%!X()t` N @A(0!dpuJ1,!# 4 m ='8 e=B,@A*,*I<;o+n46!f]9:n46*n4A;#%J46!
4 0A0>
` ]9:n46*n4A;#%J46!v%E"¢46u 3` eXem
P
j~ , P
n h
~
~
O
4 ='8 <
m ](_^I%!#%*?E#;v$&@WB,<;B,o!X1,+,EX1,!#B,f.R4j$h4 <@A*,*%!X();#@A1;v'#:n46!Xu %$&%*?EdS,(R4GC(R46.b=]9:n46*n4A;#%J46!
4 0A0>
46.` ]9:n46*n4A;#%J46!v%Ev¢46u 3` eXe
{
<;v<;#;D46();8$&%*I<;v+n46!"kvS B,@A1
5 0>
46./` kSOB,@A1 ` JJ eXe8'<@A*BC1,();#%*?Edw-B,%1CGPEW+ <;"B,o!X1,+,EX1,!#h
s.R4Zpn;D;X1,!D46EX()@A*UB,<;8S,.)@H'<;"%E"BC1L$&@A!XEX()%!>=
C
s.R4j!X1,+,EX1,!#g461L*,(0N >461UB,d.bK (0*?E#%!
b4A'<fS,.)@H' $&@A!XEX()%!B,<;
@A(0*WE#;>m
TV<;8$&@HB,<;"B,o!X1,+,EX1,!#;#@A*?E8@A*'%EX()@A*UB,o.bKM46*,uJ.)BKi@A!X()%*?ED46EX()@A*5B,<;
@A(0*WE#;
s+ @A1,! ◦ ,!X1,+,EX1,!#o+n46!8pn;D;X1,!D46EX()@A*LN %!XEX()'>46.)o.)o.)@A*,u3B,<;8S,.)@W'<;v%E"BC1L$&@A!XEX()%!>=
V+O@A1,! a <◦ 30 !X1,+,EX1,!#g+n46!vpn;#;#1,!D46EX()@A*UN %!XEX()'>46.)Z.)f.)@A*,uPB,<;vS,.)@H'<;%E9BC1$&@A!XEX()%!9$h46();d461;#;X(
30 < a < 45◦
C
!X1,+,EX1,!#461U*,(0N >461UB,o.bK (0*?E#%!
b4A'<fS,.)@H' $&@A!XEX()%!>=
s+ @A1,! ◦
45 < a < 70◦
C
C!X1,+,EX1,!#Z461\*,(0N >461B,d.bK (0*?E#%!
b4A'<fS,.)@H' $&@A!XEX()%!>m
k1CB,%.RwjB, ◦ ` ◦ e=C.R4Z!X1,+,EX1,!#4Z.0()%1\.)d.)@A*,uhB,<;FS,.)@H'<;"%E"BC1\$&@A!XEX()%!"+n46!Fpn;#;#1,!D46EX()@A*\N %!XEX()'>46.)
$h46();v461;D;X(4680
1L*,(0N a>46>1U80 C
B,o.bK (0*WE#%!
4A'<S,.)@W' $&@A!XEX()%!>m
PP
~
4 =;
5 0>
46.` kSOB,@A1Q` JJ eXe
<
m * 1%*'<fB,o.bKi@A!X()%*?ED46EX()@A*tB,<;X@A(0*?E#;";X1,!8.)dEW+ oB,d!X1,+,EX1,!#B,d.R4Z$h4 <@A*,*%!X()J=kvS B,@A1
Q
Å
<
] 46*;8.)<;8+n46!D46uJ!D46+,:<;+,!#I<'<I<B,%*?E#;~=n@A*4Z+,!#I<;#%*WE#If.)<;"BC(_^I%!#%*?E#;'<@A*;XEX(0EX1n46*?E#;9BK 1,*o$h4 <@A*,*%!X()3
o
9 :9
s.)<;"I%.)I%$&%*WE#; %'<@A!X+; -CS,!X()q?1J=+,()%!X!#J=
m0m0m0=
9 :9
s.)<;"I%.)I%$&%*WE#; X@A(0*?E#; -6
@A(0*WE"NH(_@A1jX@A(0*?EvB,f$&@A!XEX()%!>m
{
<;vBC(0N %!#;#<;"!#l%uJ.)<;BKM46+,+n46!#%(0.0.R46u @A*?EI%E#I46SO@A!#B,I<<;~m
]jK 1,*L+ @A(0*?EvB,dNH1d$&I<'>46*,()qW1J=n@A*U;>Ki<;#E8(0*?E#I%!#<;#;#Ig461CGY'<@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?E#;9B,o.R4Z+,()%!X!#f%EvBC1\$&@A!XEX()%!>m
¢|@A1,!d.R4&+,()%!X!#J=O.R4h+,!X();#g%*5'<@A$-+,E#jB,.R4h+ @A!#@J;X(0E#Ig%EdB,@A*'ZB,g;D4h!#I<;X();XED46*'<g$&I<'>46*,()qW1ZB46*;91,*5I%ED46E
*9
:WHBC!X()qW1-B,@A*,*I-<;XE9EX!#l<;d(0$-+O@A!XED46*WE#Jm
*r^%E>=.R43+,()%!X!#-<;XE9$&I<'>46*,()qW1%$&%*?E+,.01; ¡ !D46uJ(0.) ZB46*;o1,*9
I%ED46E8;D46EX1,!#IdBKi>461\q?1
KMwg;#<'JmC]dv+,.01;~=HB,<;V(0*C@A!X$h46EX()@A*;8;X1,!F.)<;V!#I<;X();XED46*'<<;8wg.R4fEX!D4A'%EX()@A*
=w.R4Z'<@A$-+,!#<;
&?
;X()@A*;#@A*?Ef*I<'<<;D;D46(0!#<;g4>NA46*WEgBK (0*?E#I%uJ!#%!Z'<<;f+,()%!X!#<;gB46*;f1,*&;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#Jm{
h'>4A;fB,&.R4\'<@A1,+ A.)h<;XEf1,*
G,%$-+,.)J=,.)<;8S,.)@H'<;"B,@A(0N %*? E %EX!#o+,.R4A'<I<;v;D%.)@A*\.)%1,!#;v'>46+n4A'%(0E#I<;vB,d!#I<;#();XED46*'<Jm
<
¢|@A1,!F.)sX@A(0*?E>=H.bK (0*?E#%!
b4A'<o%*?EX!#9.)S,.)@W'9%EV.)v$&@A!XEX()%!8<;XEF;#@A1,N %*?EF.)+,.R46*PB,b46(0S,.)<;#;#B,<;/$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;~m
{
<;BC(_^ I%!#%*WE#;<;#;D46();$&%EXE#%*WE%*&I%NH()B,%*'<"q?1F.R4!X1,+,EX1,!#8+ %1,E46+,+n46!D4 )EX!#461-*,(0N >461&;D@A(0EsB,F.bK (0*?E#%!
b4A'<
;#@A(0E"BC1U$&@A!XEX()%!>m
<
]d%1CG\'<@A$-+O@A!XE#%$&%*WE#;v+,!X(0*'%(0+n461CGU;#@A*WE4A;#;#@H'%()I<;"461CG\$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;
h.bKi@A!X()%*WED46EX()@A* B,<;U'<@A*?EX!D46(0*<;t+,!X(0*'%(0+n46.)<;t+n46!L!D46+,+ @A!XEt461CG 4G,<;UBC1$h46E#I%!X(R461%EL.)<;NA46.)%1,!#;B,<;
'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#<;&+,!X(0*'%(0+n46.)<;h@A*?Ej1,*Y(0* 1%*'<\;X1,!Z.)3$&@HB,YB,P!X1,+,EX1,!#\%EZ.)<;ZNJ46.)%1,!#;-B,P!#I<;X();XED46*'<c`
p,
4 ='8
uJ1,!# m em
P
j~ , P
n h
~
~
O
<
]o46*;d.R43;X1,(0E#J=4p*5B,Z$&@HB,I%.0();#%!d1,*Z$h4 <@A*,*%!X()J=
@A*c;>K (0*?E#I%!#<;#;Dj461CG5@A1,EX(0.);d*?1,$&I%!X()qW1<;fBC();X+ @A*,(0S,.)<;
%Ev4AB46+,E#I<;gm
P Y
5
a Q
'
8 S /c#u%g&!3{N*,g/)©-0/ )+*,g)dc"!7'({[0/ ))du1Eg&"! 66.6.66.6.66.6.66 º 8
W[;=:<;=: YNnNF,w=J]AGCEDmJKY0O
vPC0HoL[OpB6JKwKJ=?,Lp6L[OP?Tv[¤PC0Am?7¯NB$C0klHGYR¬ B7YNnNFIwKJKAGCEDGJ=Y<O;U;T;T;U;T;U; xEX
W[;=:<;=:<; C ª±C0wKkIL[w"
w]C HGL[vNDGL[Hm?
3C0OPCR
w NA?w=JKB7JtDG?±?ID
Y0¬ d?IOPAmJKY0O CRDm?IHGJ]CRw+¡ ¥xEX
W[;=:<;=:<; µ Y"n[FIwKJKAGCEDGJ=Y<O Cz`0?3kV?IOPnNY<B7B7C0Z0?,B6?,OuDa;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; xR
W[;=:<;=:<; k v[v[HGYNkQ¤[?UvPCRHwK?,AoB7JKw=JK?ILNMpnN?ª«Y<AGA?,HGCRD;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; xE_
W[;=:<; W YNnNF,w=J]AGCEDmJKY0O
vPC0HoL[OpB6JKwKJ=?,Lp6v[wKLPAmJ=?,L[HQAv[¤PC0Am?,AU¯NB7J]klHGYR¬ B7Y"n[FIwKJKAGCEDGJ=Y<O;U;T;U; xE¸
W[;=:<; W[; C v[v[HGYNkQ¤[?UvPCRH¤[Y<B6Y<Z0F,O[FIJ]AmCRDmJKY0O vF,HmJKYNnNJK\uL[?r;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; xE§
W[;=:<; W[; µ >dC6B6FIDm¤[YNnN?TnN?3AoFIwKFIB7?,O<DQAonNJ]AmkIHm?IDGA ;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; ¸0X
8b8 / g ~c%&{ '(#u* /c c'(/@cd#"%&g!,{[*,g&/ ) .66.6.66.6.66.6.66
8]9
#u)#u1E{[%&g&*,#"!7!,d15%&"!7'(#u* /cu!2{[1 #"%&#"'(")+*,!.cdg!,-01E<*3! .6.66.6.66 i
W[; XP;=: FIDm¤[YNnN?3A
AmB6Y"Y0Dm¤
;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; ¸0_
W[; XP; W FIDm¤[YNnN?3AoO[Y<ON¬ AmB7Y"YRDm¤ ;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; §
W[; XP; X ª«Y<OPklwKLPAmJ=Y<OPAoALPHow=?3AB6FIDm¤[YNnN?3A
AmB6Y"Y0Dm¤
?lD
O[Y<O
AmB7YuY0Dm¤ ;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; §[:
8K S/c#u%g&!3{N*,g/)©cdg!,-01 <*3 cd"!$'({P0/ )d)u1zg"!T.66.6.66.6.66.6.66 +8
W[; ;=: o?,wKCRDmJKY0OPAon[?klY0OuDQC0kD¿£HGYRDmDGCROuD;U;T;U;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; §<W
W[; ;=:<; C ª«Y<OPnNJ=DmJKY0OpnN? !"JKZ0O[Y<HmJKO[J ;T;U;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; §<W
W[; ;=:<; µ >@Y0JnN?V¿£HGYRDmDm?IB7?,O<Dh;T;U;T;U;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; §0X
W[; ; W qr?,AGklHGJ=v[DmJKY0OpnNLpB6Y<L[`0?,B7?IOuD
n LPOpkIY0HGvPA?IO
v[HGF,Am?IOPkI?TnN"? lkIY0OuDGC<kDG#A ;T;U;T;U; §R
W[; ; W[; C ½¾OuDGFIZ0HQCEDGJ=Y<O5DG?IB7vY<Hm?,w=wK?p;T;U;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; §R
W[; ; W[; µ ½¾OuDGFIZ0HQCEDGJ=Y<O nN?Uw]C7$n "OPCRB7J]\<LP?TO[Y0ON¬ HGFIZ0LPw=JKIHG?T;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; §<
W[; ; W[; k Z<qrw=J]Y<AmµPkICRHmFIwK?,DmAJ]AmCR;VDmJK;TY0O ;U;Tn[?,;TAU;UHG?I;Tw]CE;UDmJK;TY0O;UAr;TnN;V?7;TvP;TC<Am;UAGCR;TZ<;U?.;T?,Ou;UDmHG;T?.;T`E;UCRHG;TJ]CR;Vµ[wK;T?,AV;UwK;TY"k,;TCR;UwK?,;TAV;U?lD ; §<
W[; ; W[; n qrJ]AmkIHmFIDmJ]AmCRDmJKY0OPAnN?3AHm?,wKCRDmJKY0OPAonN?TkIY0OuDGC<kD¿£HmY0DDQCROuDo;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; §0_
W[; ; W[; ? %±JKwKC0O
n[?,AF,\uLPCRDmJKY0OPAon[JKAGklHGFlDGJKAmFI?3Ar;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; §ux
W[; ; W[; ¿ ª«Y<OPnN?,OPAmCRDmJKY0O
nNL &A NADmIB7? ;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; §ux
W[; ; X FIDm¤[YNnN?n[?THmF3AY<w=LNDGJ=Y<O ;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U; §0¸
W[; ; XP; C
F,AmY0wKLNDmJKY0O WRqÂnNLpv[HGY0µPw=,B6?TnN?kIY0OuDGC<kD±¿£HmY0DDQCROuD ADQCROPnPCRHQn ;U;T;U; §0¸
W[; ; XP; µ
F,AmY0wKLNDmJKY0OpX0qÂnNLpv[HGY0µPw=,B6?TnN?kIY0OuDGC<kD±¿£HmY0DDQCROuD ADQCROPnPCRHQn ;U;T;U; §0§
W[; ; YNnNF,w=J]AGCEDmJKY0OpnNL klY<OuDGC0klD
Cz`0?,kVklY<¤[F,AmJKY0O ;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U;':
W[; ; ; C C0HDGJ=?UO[Y<HmB$CRwK?;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U;':
W[; ; ; µ C0HDGJ=?VDGC0O[Z0?,OuDm? ;U;T;U;T;U;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U;': [:
PQ
z ? ~n
n
<
< G9 <
{4\$h4 <@A*,*%!X()&+ @J;#;#l<B,-BC(0N %!#;#<;+,!#@A+,!X()I%E#I<;BC(0!#<'%EX()@A*,*%.0.)<;-wY'>461;#&BC1\X@A(0*?EgB,j$&@A!XEX()%!gqW1,(s'<@A*;XEX(_
EX1h1,*r+,.R46*B,&46(0S,.)<;#;D&B,-.R4L;#EX!X1'%EX1,!#Jm]o46*;f.)h+,!#%$-()%!g'#:n46+ )EX!#J=1,*&+,!#I<;D%*?ED46EX()@A*};X1'<'%(0*?E#PB,<;
9
BC(_^I%!#%*?E#;EH+O<;fB,j$h4 <@A*,*%!X()3GH();#ED46*?E#h4YI%E#IZb46(0E#Jm
{
jE#%!X$& $h4 <@A*,*%!X() &!#<'<@A1,NW!#&1,*-uJ!D46*B,
'>46E#I%u @A!X()8B,V$h46E#I%!X(R461&BC1j+O@A(0*WEsB,VNW1FBC1-'<@A$-+O@A!XE#%$&%*WEs$&I<'>46*,()qW18%E|'<<'%(,+,!X(0*'%(0+n46.)%$&%*WE%*j!D46();#@A*
B,d.R4-BC(0N %!#;#(0E#IfB,<;"'<@A*;XEX(0EX1n46*WE#;%EvB,d.)%1,!#;946!X!D46*,u %$&%*?E#;>m
<
{4v$&@HB,I%.0();D46EX()@A*ZBKi@A1,NH!D46u <;|$h4 <@A*,*I<;|+O%1,E|;>KM4<N I%!#%!B,I%.0()'>46EBC1fb46(0EB,/.R4"BC(0$&%*;X()@A*jB,<;S,.)@H'<;>=~.bKM46*,();#@6
<
EX!#@A+,()J=6.bKiI%+n46();#;#%1,!B,<;
@A(0*WE#;>=6.bKM46!X!D46*,u %$&%*?EsB,<;|S,.)@H'<;>m0m0m %*ju I%*I%!D46.b=6.R4v$h4 <@A*,*%!X()8<;XE1,*&4A;#;#%$gS,.R46u
46*,();XEX!#@A+ f%E8(0*I%.R4A;XEX()qW1Jm
-< -< 5 08
{
@A1,!#%* <@L` {@A1,!#%* <@L` JJ eXe/4$&@A*?EX!#IoqW1
K 1,*P$&@WB,l%.)dB,@A(0EF(0*'%.01,!#d'%(0*q-EH+O<;FB,$&I<'>46*,();X$&<;8B,9Sn4A;#
<
+ @A1,!"'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();#%!v.R4-$h4 <@A*,*%!X()h
pn;#;#1,!D46EX()@A*UBC1-X@A(0*?Ev%*\EX!D4A'%EX()@A*
=
uJ.0();D;#%$&%*?E/.)8.)@A*,uBK 1,*fX@A(0*?E/BKM4A;#;X();#"@A13BK 1,*o
@A(0*WE/;X1,+ I%!X()%1,!s+ @A1,!s.)<;b46(0S,.)<;sNJ46.)%1,!#;sB,'<@A*?EX!D46(0*?E#<;
*@A!X$h46.)<;>=
<
pn;#;#1,!#oB,o.bKiI%.)I%$&%*?E9B,o$h4 <@A*,*%!X()f+n46!"EX!D4A'%EX()@A*BC(0!#<'%E#J=
<
opn;#;#1,!D46EX()@A*yBC(R46u @A*n46.)\+n46!-EX!D4A'%EX()@A*zB,<;-I%.)I%$&%*?E#;3B,Y$h4 <@A*,*%!X()L+ @A1,!-B,<;-NA46.)%1,!#;hB,\'<@A*?EX!D46(0*?E#<;
*@A!X$h46.)<;;X1Ch;D46*?E#<;v+O@A1,!B,I%N %.)@A+,+O%!vBC1L !#@AEXE#%$&%*WEB46*;8.)<;X@A(0*?E#;~=
9 9
%;#'%();#;X()@A* gB,<;I%.)I%$&%*WE#;o%*EX!D4A'%EX()@A*5!#I<;X1,.0ED46*WEoB,f.R43BC(0.R46ED46*'<ZBC1t$&@A!XEX()%!9+O@A1,!dB,uJ!D46*B,<;9NJ46.)%1,!#;
B,d.R4-'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#g*@A!X$h46.)Jm
54 <
Cm 2tI<'>46*,();X$&<;B,V!X1,+,EX1,!#FBK 1,*F$h4 <@A*,*%!X()o,`4 epn;D;X1,!#FBC1X@A(0*?E%*jEX!D4A'%EX()@A* n` SeuJ.0();#;#%$&%*WE
BC1U
@A(0*WEV` '~edpn;#;X1,!#hBC1S,.)@W'h+n46!EX!D4A'%EX()@A*}BC(0!#<'%E#V` Bneopn;#;X1,!#hBC1S,.)@H'&+n46!gEX!D4A'%EX()@A*QBC(R46u @A*n46.)F` ~e
<
'<@A$-+,!#<;#;#()@A*UB,o.R4Z$h4 <@A*,*%!X()J=n{@A1,!#%* <@ -<
46.` {
@A1,!#%* <@t` JJ eXe-< 5 08
&
z ? ~n
n
<
.GC();XE#fB,%1CGLuJ!D46*B,<;v'%.R4A;D;#<;"+ @A1,!'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();#%!.)<;v$&@HB,l%.)<;"$h4 <@A*,*I<;Z.)<;v$&@WB,l%.)<;'<@A*?EX(0*W1;9%E.)<;
$ @HB,l%.)<;"BC();#'%!#%E#;g
&
<
d.)<;j$&@WB,l%.)<;j'<@A*WEX(0*?1;h;D@A*?Ej1,EX(0.0();#I<;jB46*;j.)Y'>4A;ZB,<;Z$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;&'<@A$-+ @J;#I<<;-B,PS,.)@H'<;Y` S,!X()qW1<;-@A1
+,()%!X!#<;¡eV%E"BK 1,*jX@A(0*?E"B,9$&@A!XEX()%!>m{4Z.)@A(
B,9'<@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?E9B,<;F$&@WB,l%.)<;v'<@A*?EX(0*?1;<;XE8B,I<'%!X(0E#o+n46!F1,*
C
.)@A(OB,vEW+ v'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E# 6B,I@A!X$h46EX()@A*Uq?1,(OB,I%!X(0N BK 1,*P$&@HB,l%.)wo1,*9@A13B,%1CG&+,:n4A;D<;>=` xF<;X @J;d` J 9@ 4 06
5 4 8 4 1= *5 4 ;
C= J 3@ JeXe=
8.)<;9$&@WB,l%.)<;oBC();D'%!#%E#;o;#@A*?E4AB46+,E#I<;d+ @A1,!oI%EX1BC()%!o1,*Z;#EX!X1'%EX1,!#-%*tuJ!D46*Bc46+,+n46!#%(0.b=s` k8'>46!X ` JJ eXem 5 4
]o46*;j'<3'>4A;~=.)<;ZS,.)@H'<;Z;D@A*?E-;X1,+,+ @J;#I<;!X(0uJ()B,<;-@A1}B,I@A!X$h46S,.)<;-%Eg.R4t;X1,!
b4A'<3B,P'<@A*?ED4A'%E&<;#EZ;#@A1,N %*WE
!#I%uJ()o+n46!v1,*d.)@A(B,f'<@A*?ED4A'%E" !#@AEXED46*WEv1,*,(0.R46E#I%!D46.bm
@ <
* +,!#I<;D%*?E#gE#@A1,EvBKM46SO@A!#BU.R4j$&@HB,I%.0();D46EX()@A*B,<;v$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;+n46!v.R4-$&I%EX:@HB,B,<;vI%.)I%$&%*WE#;"p*,();Z` $&I
L
@
EX:@HB,F*?1,$&I%!X()qW1".R4d+,.01;s!#I%+n46*BC1~e= +,1,();+n46!.R4d$&I%EX:@HB,"B,<;sI%.)I%$&%*WE#;BC();#'%!#%E#;~m *j %!D4o1,*&'#:@A(_G&;X1,!
.R4d$&I%EX:@HB,vqW18*@A1;1,EX(0.0();#%!#@A*;+ @A1,!s.R4;X1,(0E#"B,8*@J;EX!D4<NJ461CGh%*hE#%*?ED46*WEVB,"$&@A*?EX!#%!V.)<;s$&@AEX(0NJ46EX()@A*;>m
d
Å 9 © u u
u Å
5 75
H %.)@A*&.)"*,(0N >461hB,8+,!#I<'%();X()@A*P%EsB,";X(0$-+,.0(_pn'>46EX()@A*3;D@A1,:n46(0E#Ig` Cm e=J(0.n<;#E+O@J;#;#(0S,.)8BK 1,EX(0.0();#%!.)<;s;#EX!D46E#I%uJ()<;
B,d$&@HB,I%.0();D46EX()@A*;"+n46!B,%1CGYEW+ <;"BKM46+,+,!#@H'#:<;g
v1,*346+,+,!#@W'D:hB,-EW+ -$h4A'%!#@6b$&@HB,I%.0();D46EX()@A* 'JKi<;XEf.bKiI<'#:%.0.)3B,-.R4\;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#J=%.0.)&<;XEB,&.bKi@A!#BC!#hBC1
$&l%EX!#Jm6]o46*;|'<EH+OVBKM46+,+,!#@H'#:J=A@A*+ %1,E|'<@A*;#()B,I%!#%!.R4;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#V'<@A$-$&/I%ED46*WE|:@A$&@Au l%*F%E|'<@A*?EX(0*?1Jm
*j.)@A(B,-'<@A$-+O@A!XE#%$&%*WE:@A$&@Au l%*-t<;XE4A;#;#@H'%()I<J=O!#%.0(R46*?E'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#<;Z%EfB,I @A!X$h46EX()@A*;$h4A'%!#@J;#'<@6
+,()qW1<;>m
1,*"46+,+,!#@H'#:8B,FEH+ /$-()'%!#@6b$&@HB,I%.0();D46EX()@A*UA(0.,B,%NH()%*?EsBC(_h'%(0.)8B,F+n46!X.)%!sB,V$-(0.0()%1CG-'<@A*?EX(0*?1;~=J.)<;$h4
< <@A*,*%!X()<;+,!#I<;D%*?E#%*?E1,*@A!XE#V:I%E#I%!#@Au I%*I%(0E#Iv'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();#I<F+n46!1,*F$-()'%!#@J;#'%EX!X1'%EX1,!#wv.R4v@A();'#:n4A@AEX()qW1
%E"46.)I>46E#@A(0!#JmTV%EXE#d$&@HB,I%.0();D46EX()@A*UB,@A(0E8(0*'%.01,!#d.)o'<@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?EvB,o'D:n4Aq?1o'<@A*;#EX(0EX1n46*?EC.)<;FS,.)@H'<;>=H.)<;
C
X@A(0*?E#;-B,Y$&@A!XEX()%!&%Ej.bK (0*?E#%!
b4A'<\S,.)@H' $&@A!XEX()%!>m/TV%EXE#L46+,+,!#@H'#:L<;XEjS,()%*y4AB46+,E#I<U461CG};XEX!X1'%EX1,!#<;&%*
+ %EX(0Ev46+,+n46!#%(0.bm
-2
W
H
P
n
5 4
k8'>46!X ` k8'>46!X` JJ eXe\B,@A*,*51,*+n46*@A!D46$h4 GH:n461;#EX(_jB,<;\BC(_^I%!#%*?E#<;t46+,+,!#@W'D:<;UB,5$&@HB,I%.0();D46EX()@A*
<
B,<;";#EX!X1'%EX1,!#<;"$h4 <@A*,*I<<;>m
¥ ¥
Ëu= E Ë\
!V ;[ ug'
]o46*;/.bKM46+,+,!#@W'D:9wf1,*"+,:n4A;#J=W@A*3'<@A*;XEX!X1,(0EV1,*h$&@HB,l%.)"$h4A'%!#@6b$&I<'>46*,()qW19Sn4A;#Iv;X1,!VB,<;'<@A*;X()B,I%!D46EX()@A*;
$-()'%!#@6b$&I<'>46*,()qW1<;>m @ *EX!D46(0E#ZB,@A*'f.bKi%*;D%$S,.)jB,<;vS,.)@H'<;9BK 1,*546+,+n46!#%(0.0.R46u j'<@A$-$&g1,*$-(0.0()%1t:@A$&@6
u %I *I%();#II<q?1,(0NJ46.)%*?E>m]dd*@A$gS,!#%1;#<;v.)@A();vB,f'<@A$-+O@A!XE#%$&%*WE@A*WEvI%E#IfI%EX1BC()I<<;>=%E8*@A1;946.0.)@A*;8+,!#I<;#%*WE#%!
S,!X()l%N %$&%*WEv.)%1,!#;":WW+ @AEX:l<;#<;v46*;#(q?1d.)<;4<NJ46*?ED46u <;9%E8(0*'<@A*?N I%*,()%*?E#;~m
2 " "-M ,M #M" 1,,1 "-"-M J
M +O
" 1"-M
{ Ki@ASCX<'%EX(_9B,Y'<%EXE#P$&I%EX:@HB,\<;XEZB,YB,Ip*,(0!-1,*}'>4ABC!#\;X1Ch;D46$-$&%*WE&;X(0$-+,.)J='>46+n46S,.)\B,h@A1,!X*,(0!-B,<;
s
!#I<;X1,.0ED46E#;&46*n46.0HEX()qW1<;-%EZ*W1,$&I%!X()q?1<;~=s4<N <'Y1,*Q$-(0*,(0$1,$ B,P+n46!D46$&l%EX!#<;&'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();D46*WE&.)3$h46E#I%!X(R461
m
TV%EXE#46+,+,!#@H'#:Z4-46SO@A1,EX(|wjB,%1CGYEW+ <;"B,d$&@HB,I%.0();D46EX()@A*;vBC(_^I%!#%*?E#<;Z
•
MG"-M',)M #M " ,,:
4 A08;
4 ;5
` ]91,!D46*BHT/.R4< 3` 4 A0A
Je=,]1,!D46*BHT/.R4> h` J eXeVB,@A*?E"@A*YEX!#@A1,N %!D4ZB,<;"46*n46.0C;#<;V+,!#I<'%();#<;F+n46! %H$h46*,*
` 9%W$h46*z` eXeh` %H$h46*,* 4L46+,+,.0()qW1I-.R4P$&I%EX:@HB,-+O@A1,!o.)<;f+O@A*WE#;>=N @ ,E#<;f%Ef'>46EX:I<BC!D46.)<;¡ef%Eo+n46!
4 0A 4
]d%.0S <'<qt` ]d%.0S <'<q5` eXem
{4P$&I%EX:@HB,j+ %!X$&%Eo.bKi@AS,E#%*?EX()@A* BK 1,*rB,@A$h46(0*-B,-'D:n46!Xu %$&%*?E#;Z;X1,+,+O@A!XED46S,.)<;o;¡46*;f4<N @A(0!BK (0*C@A!X$h4
EX()@A*;3;X1,+,+,.)I%$&%*?ED46(0!#<;>mV{
<;3B,@A$h46(0*<;hB,\!#I<;X();#ED46*'<L;>KM46+,+,1,()%*?EPu I%*I%!D46.)%$&%*?EY;X1,!-.R4cB,@A*,*I<BK 1,*
!#I<;X();#ED46*'<".0(0$-(0E#dwo.R4f'<@A$-+,!#<;D;X()@A*
=?BK 1,*!#I<;X();XED46*'<"46(0S,.)%*hEX!D4A'%EX()@A*c` ;#@A1,N %*?EV*?1,.0.)~e/%EBK 1,*Y'%!X(0E#l%!#
B,9 !#@AEXE#%$&%*?E9B,gTV@A1,.)@A$S
m
E9
TV%+ %*B46*?E>=%.0.)Z*g+O%!X$&%Ed+n4A;dB,j'<@A*'%.01,!#-;X1,!.R43;XED46S,(0.0(0E#IjB,<;d'#:n46!Xu %$&%*WE#; + @AE#%*?EX()%.0.)%$&%*?EZ;X1,+C
9
+ @A!XED46S,.)<; A='<@A$-$&&'<%.R4P+ %1,E %EX!#-.)j'>4A;f%* 46*n46.0C;#j.0(0$-(0E#J=
@c.)Z+,!X(0*'%(0+OhB,-BC();#;X(0+n46EX()@A*c+,.R4A;XEX()qW1
$h4GC(0$h46.)f<;XE8N I%!X(_pnIJm
•
M "-"-M J
OM L O!M'
{
<;j:WW+ @AEX:l<;#<;-'<@A*'<%!X*n46*WE&.)<;j82 @A*?E-I%E#IP @A!X$g1,.)I<<;j+n46! %H$h46*` %H$h46*,* ` eXeZB46*;j;#<; 4 0808
54
EX!D4>NA461CGLBKM46*n46.0C;#o.0(0$-(0E#JmTV<;8:WW+ @AEX:l<;#<;;X1,+,+,.)I%$&%*?ED46(0!#<;9;#@A*?E9461L*@A$S,!#fB,fEX!#@A();f
<
C.R4j$h4 <@A*,*%!X()f*
KM4h461'%1,*o!#I<;X();XED46*'<wZ.R4-EX!D4A'%EX()@A*
=
<
6 YC.R4j$h4 <@A*,*%!X()g4Z1,*f!#I<;X();XED46*'<o(0.0.0(0$-(0E#I<w-.R4j'<@A$-+,!#<;#;X()@A*
=
<
Y461'%1,*LuJ.0();#;#%$&%*WEv*d+ %1,E4<N @A(0!v.0()%1UB46*;".R4Z$h4 <@A*,*%!X()Jm
TV<;8:WW+ @AEX:l<;#<;;#@A*?E4A;D;#%o!#<;XEX!X()'%EX(0N <;,'%.R4A;D;#oB,<;8$h46E#I%!X(R461CGU982m
p*,() @
@
]dY*@A$S,!#%1CG EX!D4>NA461CG @A*?EhI%E#IY!#I<'<%$-$&%*WE3B,I%N %.)@A+,+ I<;&B46*;-.)\'>4ABC!#LB,P.R4t$&I%EX:@HB,LB,<;-I%.)I%$&%*?E#;
4 ;
; H@A*P+O%1,EF'%(0E#%! *n46E# 46.` *n46E#9%E846.bm ` J JeXe=Hk.0N <; 46.` k.0N <;V%EFk.0N <;d` J JeXe=T/1@A$&@
5
4 ;
4
46.`bT/1@A$&@3%E87s%*?EX1,!D4U` JJJ eXem
{sK :WW+ @AEX:l<;# (0$-+,.0()q?1-qW1Z.R43'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#h*@A!X$h46.)
;#@A!XED46*WEvB,o.R4j;X1,!
b4A'<J=B,@A(0E %EX!#d*I%u?46EX(0N g@A1L*?1,.0.)h tn = σn
@5*5<;#E91,*5N <'%E#%1,!o*@A!X$h46.s1,*,(0ED46(0!#
£Y
z ? ~n
n
<
T %EXE#:?H+O@AEX:l<;#!#%*B'<@A$-+,E#gB,f.R4-46(0S,.)o!#I<;#();XED46*'<Zw-.R4-EX!D4A'%EX()@A*5B,o.R4-$h4 <@A*,*%!X()Jm[dI%*I%!D46.)%$&%*?E
V
5
.bK (0*WE#%!
4A'<g<;XE8EX!#l<;";#%*;X(0S,.)Jm
<
{sK :WW+ @AEX:l<;# t*
K (0$-+ @J;#L461'%1,*L'<@A*BC(0EX()@A*z;X1,!-.)<;h'<@A*?EX!D46(0*?E#<;~m{4t!X1,(0*LB,Y.R4t$h4 <@A*,*%!X()U*
Ki<;XE
6
#46$h46();v46EXE#%(0*?E#+n46!vI<'%!D4A;#%$&%*WEB,<;8S,.)@H'<;>m
*Cp*
=s.bK :?H+O@AEX:l<;# 5qW1,(v4&!X$&LqW1
KM461'%1,*yuJ.0();#;#%$&%*WE&*Y+O%1,Eh4>N @A(0!h.0()%1z461y*,(0N >461B,<;9
@A(0*WE#;U
.)<;jB,I@A!X$h46EX()@A*;&;#@A*?E-B,I<'<@A$-+ @J;#I<<;-%*}1,*P+n46!XEX()PI%.R4A;#EX()q?1Y%E-%*}1,*3+n46!XEX()P(0*I%.R4A;XEX()qW1J=BC1<;&461
B,I%N %.)@A+,+ %$&%*?E9B,d.bK (0*,(0EX(R46EX()@A*B,d.bKi@A1,N %!XEX1,!#fBC1jX@A(0*?E"+ %!X+ %*BC()'%1,.R46(0!#%$&%*?Eo461\+,.R46*LB,d.R4j'<@A*?EX!D46(0*?E#
$h4GC(0$h46.)&` *@A*\*I%u?46EX(0N ~emTV%EXE#oB,I@A!X$h46EX()@A*\*d+O%1,EF+,!#@>N @HqW1%!"q?1dB,<;8BC(0.R46ED46EX()@A*;>=B46*;8'<d'>4A; a
*d+ %1,E"+n4A <
; %EX!#o*I%u?46EX(0N Jm{4j'<@A*BC(0EX()@A*;~KiI<'%!X(0!D4-B,o.R4gb4 <@A*U;X1,(0NJ46*?E#&
= e + a 5 4 75
` Cm m e
aij ni nj ≥0 ∀ni i ∈ [1, 3]
5 4 75
]91-b46(0EsB,8.bKiGC();XE#%*'<vBK 1,*";DI%+n46!D46EX()@A*3I%N %*?EX1%.0.)J=W.bKiI<qW1n46EX()@A* Cm m d+ %1,E;>KiI<'%!X(0!#J= %*& @A*'%EX()@A*PBC1h;D461,E
B,oB,I%+,.R4A'<%$&%*WE 1 /
[|u|].n ≥ 0
5 4 76
` Cm m e
@ 54=
*L!#<'<@A*,*n46(0Ev.R4-'<@A*BC(0EX()@A*B,W(0uJ*@A!X(0*,(F` Cm m Wem
{sKM46*n46.0C;#o.0(0$-(0E#g;>KM46+,+,.0()qW1f;X1,!"1,*L$&@HB,l%.)o!X(0uJ()B,gB,o+,.R4A;XEX()'%(0E#Io+n46!
b46(0E#g4p*UBKiI%NJ46.01%!v.R4&'>46+n4A'%(0E#IB,
'D:n46!Xu %E8.)o$&I<'>46*,();X$&B,o!X1,+,EX1,!#fB,o.R4j;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#Jm
<
{sKM46+,+,.0()'>46EX()@A*\B,v.bKM46*n46.0H;#v.0(0$-(0E#;#1,!.)<;;#EX!X1'%EX1,!#<;/$h4 <@A*,*I<<;~=?$&@HB,I%.0();#I<<;V'<@A$-$&"1,*\4A;#;#%$S,.R46u 9B,
@
-< 5 06
S,.)@H'<;V!X(0uJ()B,<;/.0(R46();D@A*,*I<;8%*?EX!#d%1CGh+n46!8B,<;
@A(0*WE#;>=WB,I%+ %*BYB,qW1%.)qW1<;/:WW+ @AEX:l<;#<;VSn4A;X()qW1<;o`X` !#BC1,*n4
5 06 @ ` JJ eXe=
` !#BC1,*n4j%E8{
@A1,!#%* <@L` JJ eXe=,I%*@A*'<I<<;"%EFBC();#'%1,E#I<<;8+n46! 9%W$h46*r` 9%W$h46*,*r` eXe9W.bK (0*C 4 0808
E#%!
b4A'<d%*?EX!#oB,%1CG3S,.)@H'<;V*9!#I<;X();XE#+n4A;"wB,<;8^@A!XE#;FB,EX!D4A'%EX()@A*
=C!#I<;#();XE#9wZB,<;8^@A!XE#;FB,9'<@A$-+,!#<;D;X()@A*
@
(0.0.0(0$-(0E#I<j%Ed.R4&!X1,+,EX1,!#j%*c'%();D46(0.0.)%$&%*WEf<;XE9'<@A*WEX!#@A.0.)I<j+n46!d.R4&.)@A(B,&TV@A1,.)@A$S
m *tEX!#@A1,N %!D4YBC(_^ I%!#%*WE#;
@ -< @ -< 5 4 @
G,%$-+,.)<;oBKM46+,+,.0()'>46EX()@A*;oB46*; !#BC1,*n4P%E9{
@A1,!#%* <@r` !#BC1,*n4Y%Ed{
@A1,!#%* <@r` JJ 4 e= !#BC1,*n4Y%Ed{
@A1C
-< 5 4
!#%* <@h` JJ SeXe= @A!X$g1,.R46EX()@A*3'<@A$-+,.)l%E#"BKM46*n46.0C;#8.0(0$-(0E#"+O@A1,!1,*34A;D;#%$S,.R46u "B,"S,.)@W'<;!X(0uJ()B,<;9` !#BC1,*n4 @
-< 5 0> @ -< 5 0>
%E"{
@A1,!#%* <@t` JJ J4 e= !#BC1,*n4-%E{
@A1,!#%* <@` JJ 6SeXem
{sKM46*n46.0C;#h.0(0$-(0E#&+ %1,EB,@A*' %EX!#&'<@A*;#()B,I%!#I<h'<@A$-$&31,* @A1,EX(0.(0*C@A!X$h46EX()q?1h+,!D46EX()q?1J=+,1,();#qW1&BK 1,*
+n46!XE8%.0.)9GH(0u 91,*P*@A$S,!#oB,+n46!D46$&l%EX!#<;F$h46E#I%!X(R461CGP!#I<BC1,(0E8%EFBKM461,EX!#+n46!XEV@A1,!X*,(0EVB,9S @A*;!#I<;#1,.0ED46E#;
;X1,!8.R4&'#:n46!Xu o.0(0$-(0E#f%Ev.)d$&@WB,l%.)fB,f!X1,+,EX1,!#Jm
@ 5 06
` !#BC1,*n43` JJ eXe+,!#I<;#%*WE#"1,*8!#<'D:%!#'#:9;X1,!s.)<;+ @J;#;X(0S,(0.0(0E#I<;/B,8.bKM46*n46.0H;D8.0(0$-(0E#"B46*;B,<;V4A;#;#%$gS,.R46u <;
5 4
< 5 76
B,PS,.)@H'<;g!X(0uJ()B,<;&4p*yBKiI%NJ46.01%!j.R4t;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#\B,<;Z$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;h46*'%()%*,*<;U` N @A(0!jpuJ1,!# Cm em%!X!X();
46."` %!X!X();f%EoF(0*C{
@A(v` JJ eXe+,!#@A+ @J;#%*WEo1,*5;D'#:I%$h4P*?1,$&I%!X()qW1-;X(0$-+,.)Z+ @A1,!9!#I<;D@A1BC!#j.)<;d+,!#@AS,.)l%$&<;
BKM46*n46.0C;#o.0(0$-(0E#o+ @A1,!"B,<;";XEX!X1'%EX1,!#<;'<@A$-+O@J;DI<<;vB,dS,.)@H'<;"B,ouJ!D46*B,<;"ED46(0.0.)<;~m
W
H
P
n
5 76 @
Cm kv*n46.0C;#F.0(0$-(0E#Jm`4 e2U1,!'D:n46!Xu I":@A!#;/BC1&+,.R46*
= '<@A*?EX!D46(0*WE8;X1,!1,*&S @A!#BU` !#BC1,*n4f%E{@A1,!#%* <@ -<
5 0> 5 4 G5 @
` JJ 6SeXe |` SeV¢(0.)fB,oS,.)@H'<;` %!X!X();%EvF(0*C{
@A(/` JJ eXe |` '~eF¢@A*WE%* A] ` !#BC1,*n4L` JJ eXe 5 06
C
{sK (0*WE#%!
4A'<LS,.)@W' $&@A!XEX()%!h%E-.)Y'<@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?EP%*y'%();D46(0.0.)%$&%*?EhB,<;jS,.)@H'<;&;#@A*WE&B,Ip*,();j+n46!-.)\'%!X(0E#l%!#
!5 =
B,-2t@A:,!
TV@A1,.)@A$S` $&@A*WEX!#Ih;X1,!d.R4hpuJ1,!# Cm We=%*5E#%*n46*?Eg'<@A$-+,E#&B,Z.R4Y'<@A*?EX!D46(0*?E#h*@A!X$h46.)h4615+,.R46*
B,VX@A(0*?E>m
]o46*;h{@6 EX(
4 1= ?
46.Z` .)@6 EX(%E\W:,(0*,u ` J WeXe=/.)U'%!X(0E#l%!#B,U46*,H(0*U'<@A*WEX! A.)U.bK (0*,(0EX(R46EX()@A*aB,<;3$-()'%!#@6pn;
;X1,!#<;~mH{@A!#;#q?19.R4Z'<@A*?EX!D46(0*WE#o+,!X(0*'%(0+n46.)46EXE#%(0*WE8.)9;D%1,(0. B,9!#I<;X();#ED46*'<o%*PEX!D4A'%EX()@A*
=C.)<;F$-()'%!#@6pn;D;X1,!#<;8;#
B,I%N %.)@A+,+ %*?EVB46*;s.R4dBC(0!#<'%EX()@A*h+ %!X+ %*BC()'%1,.R46(0!#wo'<%EXE#"'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#JmH{
8$h46E#I%!X(R461&();D@AEX!#@A+O"B,%NH()%*?EF46.)@A!#;
@A!XEX:@AEX!#@A+ J=.)<;"'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();#EX()q?1<;I%ED46*?EB,Ip*,()<;v+O@A1,!8.)<;vBC(0!#<'%EX()@A*;"+n46!D46.0.)l%.)%Ev*@A!X$h46.)wZ.R4Zpn;#;X1,!#Jm
z ? ~n
n
5=
Cm s *B,@A$-$h46u %$&%*?E>mT/!X(0E#l%!#YB,h946*,W(0*J=T/!X(0E#l%!#3B,P2@A:,!
TV@A1,.)@A$gS
={
@6 EX(
4 1=
W:,(0*,u` J WXe e
46.d` .)@6 EX(F%E
s
{ K :@A$&@Au I%*I%();¡46EX()@A* +n46!\.)<;Y$-(0.0()%1CGB,cTV@J;D;#%!D46EU46+,+n46!D4 )EL'<@A$-$&c1,*c46.0E#%!X*n46EX(0N 461CG46+,+,!#@W'D:<;
+n46!9$&@WB,l%.)<;dBC();#'%!#%E#;-` qW1f*@A1;9+,!#I<;#%*WE#%!#@A*;oB46*;.R43;X1,(0E#~e".)@A!#;#qW1f.)<;9$&I<'>46*,();X$&<;o46uJ();#;D46*WEo461*,(_
?
N >461tB,f.R4-$-()'%!#@J;#EX!X1'%EX1,!#g@A*WE1,*L! A.)+,!#I%+O@A*B,I%!D46*WEo;X1,!".)'<@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?Ed$h4A'%!#@J;#'<@A+,()qW1JmO¢@A1,!9.)<;
$-(0.0()%1CG-uJ!D46*?1,.R46(0!#<;+n46!G,%$-+,.)J=J.R49EX:I<@A!X()"B,vTV@J;#;#%!D46EV4dI%E#IF1,EX(0.0();#I<8+ @A1,!sI%EX1BC()%!s.R49.)@W'>46.0();¡46EX()@A*hB,<;
4 0A; 4 0>
B,I@A!X$h46EX()@A*;-` 2U1,:,.0:n461;d%Ev746!#B,@A1,.R46H();-` Je=n746!#B,@A1,J46.0();d%EoW1,.)%$ ` J eXev%Ev.)Z'<@A$-+O@A!XE#%$&%*WE
5 4
B,<;8(0*WE#%!
4A'<<;Z` x8461%!%E 1n46*,u` JJ e=]doxF@A!#;XEv%Ev46.bm` J eXem 4 06
{ 4ZEX:I<@A!X()oB,fTV@J;#;D%!D46E"<;XEF1,EX(0.0();#I<d+O@A1,!8B,I<'%!X(0!#o.)d'<@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?EvB,<;"$-(0.0()%1CG3uJ!D46*?1,.R46(0!#<;v*@A*L'<@A:I
!#%*WE#;"'<@A$-$&d.)<;8;D46S,.)<;8+ @A1,!F.)<;#q?1%.);F.R4g+,!X();#o%*L'<@A$-+,E#oB,9.R4Z!#@AED46EX()@A*LB,<;8uJ!D46(0*;"wZ.bK (0*WE#I%!X()%1,!vB,d.R4
Sn46*B,fB,'%();D46(0.0.)%$&%*?E9<;XE8(0$-+O@A!XED46*WE#Jm
@
{
<;|!#%.R46EX()@A*;'<@A*;XEX(0EX1,EX(0N <;BK 1,*Z$-(0.0()%1j$-()'%!#@6b+ @A.R46(0!#8I%.R4A;XEX()qW1.0(0*I>46(0!#F;#@A*WEB,Ip*,()<;B46*;.R4;X1,(0E#Jm *
5 7>
'<@A*;X()B,l%!#1,*3'<@A!X+;V!X(0uJ()B,+,.R46*P'<@A$-$&+,!#I<;#%*WE#I;X1,!/.R4opuJ1,!# Cm CmW{<;.)@A();FBK (0*?E#%!
b4A'<<;F;#@A*?EFI%.R4A;XEX()qW1<;
.0(0*I>46(0!#<;>m
%P
W
H
P
n
M32
S22
S12
x2 , u 2
P2 S11
P1
ψ3
µ3
x1 , u 1
S21 M31
Sαβ,β + pα = 0
(0*
Ω
(0*
5 4 7>
` Cm m e
M3α,α + 3αβ Sβα + µ3 = 0 Ω
Ev.)<;"'<@A*BC(0EX()@A*;461CGY !#@A*?EX()l%!#<;
Sαβ nβ − Salpha = 0
@A*
@A*
dΩ 5 4 78
` Cm m e
M3α nα − m3 = 0 dΩ
@
= %E ;D@A*?EF!#<;X+ <'%EX(0N %$&%*?E".R4@A!#'<9GCE#I%!X()%1,!#o%EF.)d'<@A1,+,.)f46+,+,.0()q?1I<;v461\;#@A.0()B, %E ;#@A*WE
.)<;o'<p@Aα$-+ @J;Dµ463*?E#<;gB,j.R43*@A!X$h46.)&GHE#I%!X()%1,!#3wP.R4& !#@A*?EX()l%!# %E ;#@A*?Eo.)<;dEX!D4A'%EX()n@A*1 ;g%Eon.)2<;d.)<;
'<@A1,+,.)<;Z+,!#IB,Ip*,()<
; m|{
hEX!D4>NA46(0.VNH(0!XEX1%./GCE#%dΩ
!X*J=S*@AαE#I m3 %E.)&EX!D4>NA46(0.VNH(0!XEX1%./(0*WE#%!X*J=
α, β = 1, 2 We
*@AE#I =,;#@A*WEvB,Ip*,();"+n46!f
Wi
We =
Z
(pα uα + µ3 ψ3 )dV +
Z
(Sα uα + m3 ψ3 )dA
5 4 B;
` Cm m Je
Ω dΩ
Wi =
Z
(Sαβ Eαβ + M3α K3α )dV
5 4 7A
` Cm m e
Ω
We = W i
5 4 7> 5 4 78
%E".)<;"I<qW1n46EX()@A*;vBKiI<qW1,(0.0(0S,!#B,Ip*,()<;v+n46! Cm m &%E Cm m &$&l%*%*?EdwZ.R4-B,Ip*,(0EX()@A*B,<;vE#%*;#%1,!#;
z ? ~n
n
B,o'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#<; %E
Eαβ K3α
1
544
Es = (u1,2 + u2,1 )
2
1 ` Cm m e
Ew = (−u1,2 + u2,1 )
2
Eψ = E w − ψ 3
]jKi@
=
E12 = Es − Eψ 5 4 404 e
` Cm m
E21 = Es + Eψ
<
¢|@A1,!o1,*j$h4 <@A*,*%!X()&B,@A*?Eo.R43E#GCEX1,!#-B,<;dS,.)@W'<;o<;#E9+ I%!X()@HBC()q?1J=O.)<;d!#%.R46EX()@A*;f'<@A*;XEX(0EX1,EX(0N <;+O%1,N %*WE
%EX!#fI<'%!X(0E#<;Z`
!#@~NA46.01;#'%(|%E"2t4A;#(R46*,(/` JJ eXed 4
Sαβ = Cαβγθ Eγθ 5 4 45e
` Cm m
M3α = D3α3β K3β
5 05
W1,.)%$ 46.g`bW1,.)%$ %EPC46S` JJ eXej+,!#I<;#%*WE#L1,*y$&@HB,l%.)U'<@A*WEX(0*?1aB,TV@J;#;#%!D46E&+ @A1,!&.)<;&;#EX!X1'%EX1,!#<;
<
,B Z$h4 <@A*,*%!X()Jm
{sK (0*WEX!#@WBC1'%EX()@A*BK 1,*j!#@AED46EX()@A*rB,-TV@J;D;#%!D46Eo%EdB,j'<@A1,+,.)<;fB,j'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#<;f+ %!X$&%EfB,
+,!#%*BC!#f%*\'<@A$-+,E#o.R4g!#@AED46EX()@A*L(0*BC(0NH()BC1%.0.)fB,<;FS,.)@H'<;8%E8.)%1,!8!X(0uJ()BC(0E#Io%* nGH()@A*rH(0.);F$&@A*WEX!#%*?EqW1d.)
B,@A$h46(0*dB,"NJ46.0()BC(0E#I9B,'<%EXE#:@A$&@Au I%*I%();D46EX()@A*L<;XEVI%E#%*BC1Y461Y'>4A;/B,9;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#<;F'<@A$-+ @A!XED46*?EF1,*&b46(0S,.)
*@A$gS,!#B,dS,.)@H'<;>m
¥ ¥
Ëu=
E Ë\
t\
%U ;[
Ëu=
<
!D4ABC(0EX()@A*,*%.0.)%$&%*?E>=A.R4F$h4 <@A*,*%!X()V<;XE
+,!X();#'<@A$-$&s1,*$-(0.0()%1g:I%E#I%!#@Au l%*'<@A$-+ @J;#I<B,sS,.)@W'<;|46!X!D46*,u I<;
!#I%uJ1,.0()l%!#%$&%*WE9%E";#I%+n46!#I<;v+n46!vB,<;X@A(0*?E#;>m
]o46*;.bKM46+,+,!#@W'D:g+n46!9$-()'%!#@6b$&@HB,I%.0();D46EX()@A*
=O.R4&+,()%!X!#Z%Ev.)$&@A!XEX()%!d;D@A*?E9$&@WB,I%.0();#I<;9;#I%+n46!#I%$&%*WE9+n46!91,*
$-(0.0()%1L'<@A*WEX(0*?1U!#I%uJ(+n46!81,*d.)@A(B,o'<@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?Ed46+,+,!#@A+,!X()I<h` +,!#%*n46*?Ev%*L'<@A$-+,E#f.)<;F+n46!D46$&l%EX!#<;vB,
!#@AEXE#%$&%*?E>=!D46()B,%1,!>=@A1,N %!XEX1,!#~em
{sK (0*?E#%!
b4A'<J=%*WEX!#j.R4P+,()%!X!#-%Eo.)Z$&@A!XEX()%!3` @A1Y
@A(0*WEfB,Z$&@A!XEX()%!¡ed<;XE
!#%+,!#I<;#%*WE#I<J=J;#@A(0E|+n46!|B,<;I%.)I%$&%*?E#;'<@A*WEX(0*?1;>=J;D@A(0E+n46!B,<;I%.)I%$&%*?E#;BC();#'<@A*WEX(0*?1;>=A+ @A1,NJ46*?E%1CGZ461;#;X( %EX!#
!#I%uJ();8+n46!v1,*o.)@A(
B,f'<@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?E-`
!#@AEXE#%$&%*WE>=!D46()B,%1,!>=@A1,N %!XEX1,!#Jm0m0m emO{
o$&@HB,l%.)o$-()'%!#@6b$&I<'>46*,()qW1
+ @A1,!X!D4 %EX!#o$&@HB,I%.0();#Id+n46!vB,%1CG\@A1LEX!#@A();8+,:n4A;#<;Z` ]jm 946EX<(0u <@A!XuJ()@A1t%E46.bm
` JJ eXem 4
{
s$&@WB,l%.)w"B,%1CGd+,:n4A;D<;+,!#%*B%*'<@A$-+,E#s.)s'<@A$-+O@A!XE#%$&%*WE(0*I%.R4A;#EX()q?1s%E.bKM46*,();#@AEX!#@A+,()%*WEX!#s.)<;B,%1CG
<
'<@A$-+ @J;D46*?E#<;gB,-.R4P$h4 <@A*,*%!X()` .)&S,.)@W'-%Ef.)j$&@A!XEX()%!¡em{
&'<@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?Eg$&I<'>46*,()q?13B,j.bK (0*?E#%!
b4A'<
C ` S,.)@H' $&@A!XEX()%!¡ej<;XEj+,!X();-%*y'<@A$-+,E#\B46*;-.R4.)@A("BK (0*?E#%!
b4A'<Jms{
Y$&@HBC1,.)YB,
@A1,*,u=.)\'<@Wh'%()%*WEhB,
¢|@A();#;#@A*\%EFI%N %*?EX1%.0.)%$&%*?Ev.)<;+,!#@A+,!X()I%E#I<;F(0*I%.R4A;XEX()qW1<;FBC1Y$&@A!XEX()%!V%EFB,<;VS,.)@W'<;F;#@A*WE/+,!X();#<;F%*Y'<@A$-+,E#Jm
TV<;g$&@WB,l%.)<;j@A*WEZI%E#I3B,I%N %.)@A+,+OI<;jB46*;g.)3'>4ABC!#PB,&.R4UE#<'#:,*,()qW13BK :@A$&@Au I%*I%();¡46EX()@A*y%*'<@A*AX@A*'%EX()@A*
4>N <'F.R4"$&I%EX:@HB,8B,<;I%.)I%$&%*?E#;p*,();>mA]d/*@A$S,!#%1CGjEX!D4<NJ461CG =AB46*;.)F'>4ABC!#FB,V'</$&@HB,l%.)Fw9B,%1CGZ+,:n4A;#<;>=
Y
W
H
P
n
4 ;
@A*WEvI%E#Io!#I>46.0();#I<;` ¢|%u @A*%Ekv*WEX:@A(0*h` J JeXe=` {1'%(R46*@3%EC4A'<'<@U` J eXem 4 0A
{
P$&@HB,l%.)LwLEX!#@A();j+,:n4A;D<;j+O%!X$&%E&B,YB,Ip*,(0!j1,*Y$-()'%!#@6b$&@WB,I%.0();¡46EX()@A*y+,.01;-B,I%ED46(0.0.)I<Jm]o46*;-'<3EW+
B,h$&@WB,l%.)J=.)<;fS,.)@H'<;g%Eg.)<;8X@A(0*?E#;jB,&$&@A!XEX()%!j;#@A*WE!#%+,!#I<;#%*WE#I<;g+n46!ZB,<;gI%.)I%$&%*WE#;gp*,();g%Eg.bK (0*?E#%!
b4A'<
C
S,.)@H' $&@A!XEX()%!Z<;#Ef!#%+,!#I<;#%*?E#I3+n46!1,*QI%.)I%$&%*?EjBC();#'<@A*?EX(0*W1
m
!#I<;Z;#@A1,N %*?E>=.)<;8X@A(0*?E#;Z@A*?EZI%E#I&$&@HB,I%.0();#I<;
4 ;A
+n46!vB,<;vI%.)I%$&%*?E#;"(0*WE#%!
4A'<<;j` ¢46u 3` eXem
EX1,!#BC();#'<@A*?EX(0*W19%EV;#<;'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();#EX()q?1<;/:I%E#I%!#@Au l%*<;>=H¢()%EX!X1;X>'%~46
<
.R46$-(0*I<;Z<;XEg%*;#1,(0E#&1,EX(0.0();#I<h+O@A1,!gE#@A1,E:@A$&@Au I%*I%();#%!>m|¢|46!j;D4P@A!X$&h;#EX!X1'%EX1,!#%.0.)h+ I%!X()@WBC()qW1J=;¡4Y*n4
4 05
46.` ¢()%EX!X1;X>'%~46h%EVv(015` J eXe
'<@A*;X()B,l%!#%*WE/.R4o$h4 <@A*,*%!X()'<@A$-$&v1,*h$-(0.0()%13;#EX!D46EX(_pnIv'<@A$-+ @J;#I"B,vB,%1CG-$-(0.0()%1CGh;X1,+ %!X+ @J;#I<;sB,@A*?E/.bK 1,*
<;XE/:@A!X(0>@A*?ED46. :@A$&@Au I%*I%();#IJ=H%E/.bKM461,EX!#<;XE1,*P$-(0.0()%1P4>?46*?E8B,<;/+,.R46*;sb46(0S,.)<;N %!XEX()'>461CG5` .)<;
X@A(0*?E#;/N %!
EX()'>461CGnemn{4-+,!#@W'<I<BC1,!#gBK :@A$&@Au I%*I%();D46EX()@A*t<;#EvB,@A*'ob46(0E#f%*UB,%1CGLI%ED46+ <;,1,EX(0.0();D46EX()@A*tB,o.R4j$&I%EX:@HB,
B,o2t@A!X(%E"46*n46J4C=C+,1,();8.R4gEX:I<@A!X()fB,<;F.R46$-(0*I<;>m,{sKi%*;#%$gS,.)<;XE"46(0*;X($&@HB,I%.0();#Id%*LI%.)I%$&%*?E#;"p*,();F+n46!
1,*L$&@HB,l%.)f46*,();#@AEX!#@A+ fI%.R4A;XE#@6 !D46uJ(0.)Jm
k.0+n4
4 1= 4 1=
46.b= J ` k.0+n4c%Eh2t@A*%EXE#@` J WeXeh@A*?E3B,Ip*,(.R4c;X1,!
b4A'<\.0(0$-(0E#4ABC$-();D;X(0S,.)UB46*;h.bKi<;X+n4A'<
<
B,<;3'<@A*?EX!D46(0*?E#<;\%*z!#%+,!#I<;#%*?ED46*WEP1,*U$h4 <@A*,*%!X()%*z+,()%!X!#<;3;#l<'D:<;t` X@A(0*?E#;hNW(_;¡ej'<@A$-$&B,<;&S,.)@H'<;
4>?46*?EBC1L !#@AEXE#%$&%*WE%*?EX!#%1CG m
k N <'Z1,*&46+,+,!#@W'D:-;X(0$-(0.R46(0!#J=
]djx/1,:n46*
4 ;
46."` ]d-xV1,:n46*r%Ed]dj%.0()'<U` J JeXe9@A*WEo1,EX(0.0();#Ij1,*Z$&I
EX:@HB,f+,!#I<'<I<B,%$-$&%*WEdB,I%N %.)@A+,+ I<g+O@A1,!.)<;;#@A.);v!#%*C @A!#'<I<;~=+ @A1,!v.)<;"$h4A;D;X(_ ;v!#@W'D:%1CGUBC();#'<@A*?EX(0*W1;d+,1,();
<
!#I<'<%$-$&%*WE+O@A1,!|.)<;|+,!#@AS,.)l%$&<;B,$h4 <@A*,*%!X()Jm?TV%EXE#846+,+,!#@H'#:F<;XEBC(0!#<'%E#%$&%*?E46+,+,.0()'>46S,.)"461CGg'>4A;@
.R4f!X1,+,EX1,!#vB,<;/S,.)@W'<;/B,@A(0EV461;#;X( %EX!#"+,!X();#%*h'<@A$-+,E#B46*;.bKM46*n46.0H;DJm?{4fE#<'#:,*,()qW1BK :@A$&@Au I%*I%();D46EX()@A*
<;XEjSn4A;#I<Y;X1,!j.bK :@A$&@Au I%*I%();D46EX()@A* B,<;j$-(0.0()%1CGQ+ I%!X()@HBC()q?1<;j:I%E#I%!#@Au l%*<;&%Ej+ %!X$&%E&B,Y'<@A*;XEX!X1,(0!#\1,*
<
'%!X(0E#l%!#fB,d!X1,+,EX1,!#d$h4A'%!#@J;D'<@A+,()q?1o+ @A1,!8.)<;8$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;'<@A*;X()B,I%!#I<<;"'<@A$-$&o1,*U4A;#;D%$S,.R46u fB,dS,.)@H'<;
;#I%+n46!#I<;+n46!B,<;(0*?E#%!
b4A'<<;>m TV'%!X(0E#l%!#g$&@A*?EX!#g.)<;'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();XEX()qW1<;o46*,();#@AEX!#@A+ <;BC1$-(0.0()%1tI<qW1,(0NA46.)%*WE>=
BC1<;v461CGL@A!X()%*WED46EX()@A*;v+,!#II%!#%*?EX()%.0.)<;9B,<;X@A(0*?E#;>m
%Q
z ? ~n
n
5 78
Cm 5 2 46E#I%!X(R461c:I%E#I%!#@Au l%*j+OI%!X()@HBC()q?1Z%EoB,Ip*,(0EX()@A*rBC17jmi "mig=O]dZxV1,:n46*
4 ;
]do%.0()'<P` J JeXe
46.8` ]dZxV1,:n46*c%E
] KM46+,!#l<;j{1'%(R46*@
j
4 ;
46.f` {1'%(R46*@5%E&C4A'<'<@ ` J JeXe=.)3$&@HB,l%.)h$-()'%!#@6b$&I<'>46*,()qW1\BKi%*B,@A$-$h46u %$&%*?E
+ %1,E%EX!#fI%*?1,$&I%!#Ig%*LEX!#@A();"I%ED46+ <;f
W
H
P
n
5 B; <
Cm 9] (_^I%!#%*?E#;f%*B,@A$-$h46u %$&%*WE#;+ @J;#;X(0S,.)<;oB46*;d.)<;d$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;~={1'%(R46*@
4 ;
C4A'<'<@U` J JXe e
46."` {1'%(R46*@L%E
<
BC();X+ @J;X(0EX(_;F+O%1,N %*WE %EX!#f;D%1,.)%$&%*?E;#1,(0NW();8B46*;v1,*d$h4 <@A*,*%!X()f!#I<'<%*?E#Jm
<
{sKM46*n46.0C;#&BK 1,*&$h4 <@A*,*%!X()P46*'%()%*,*h+O%!X$&%EB,-'<@A*;#ED46E#%!gqW1
Ki%.0.)&<;XEf'<@A*;XEX(0EX1I<h+n46!B,<;oS,.)@H'<;B,
BC(_^I%!#%*?E#<;oBC(0$&%*;X()@A*;~=O46!X!D46*,u I<;dB46*;91,*$&@HB,l%.)g*@A*Cb+OI%!X()@HBC()q?1Jm ]df+,.01;~=n.)v
@A(0*WEd4&1,*gI%+n46();D;#%1,!
<
B,o$&@A!XEX()%!dBC(_^I%!#%*?E>mOk"p*UBKM46+,+,.0()qW1%!v.R4&EX:I<@A!X()BK :@A$&@Au I%*I%();D46EX()@A*rw-'<EH+OB,o$h4 <@A*,*%!X()J=O(0.<;XE
*I<'<<;#;¡46(0!#fBKi%$-+,.)@> %!1,*46+,+,!#@W'D:BC(_^I%!#%*?E#Jm
•
M ,LGHNM HN#N&"- 1 :1H'
N&"
z ? ~n
n
s.R4-;#EX!X1'%EX1,!#o+,!#I<;#%*?E#f1,*L*@A$S,!#g;X1Ch;D46*?EB,oS,.)@W'<;~=
s.R4jED46(0.0.)B,<;8S,.)@W'<;"!#<;XE#d*I%uJ.0(0u >46S,.)gB,%NJ46*?Ev.)<;"BC(0$&%*;X()@A*;"uJ.)@ASn46.)<;B,d.R4-;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#Jm
5 7A <
Cm 7s@A.01,$&8I%.)I%$&%*WED46(0!#8!#%+,!#I<;#%*WED46EX(_B46*;.)F'>4A;B,<;$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;>=J]dFxV1,:n46* a46.` ]dFxV1,:n46*
4 ;
%E"]df%.0()'<3` J JeXe
{
<;|+,!#@A+,!X()I%E#I<;BC1j$-(0.0()%1j:@A$&@Au l%*F+O%1,N %*WE % EX!#VB,Ip*,()<;|+n46!.R4v$-();#/%*j+,.R4A'<FBK 1,*Z79 s`
puJ1,!# Cm e/ 5 7A
%*PB,I%ED46(0.b=?1,*!#%.R46EX()@A*P%*WEX!#9.)<;NJ46.)%1,!#;$&@~ %,* *<;FB,<;/'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#<;"%EVB,B,I@A$h46EX()@A*;F<;XE/I%ED46S,.0()Jm,TV<;
NJ46.)%1,!#;8$&@> %*,*<;NJ46.)%*?E
5 4 46e
1
Z
¯ij = ij dV
V V ` Cm m
1
Z
σ¯ij = σij dV
V V
T <;8+,!#@A+,!X()I%E#I<;+ %1,N %*?E %EX!#fB,Ip*,()<;%*U46+,+,.0()q?1n46*WEBC(_^I%!#%*?E#<;9'<@A*BC(0EX()@A*;461CG\.0(0$-(0E#<;"BC1L7d s
V
%*LE#%!X$&<;B,oB,I%+,.R4A'<%$&%*?E =
ui
ui = ◦ij xj
5 4 4=
` Cm m We
@
◦ij
;#@A*?Ev.)<;"B,I @A!X$h46EX()@A*;9'<@A*;XED46*WE#<;v%E
xj
.)<;"'<@H@A!#B,@A*,*I<<;vBC1L+ @A(0*?E>m
%*LE#%!X$&<;B,o'<@A*?EX!D46(0*WE#<; =
ti
◦
ti = σij nj
5 4 4>e
` Cm m
@ ◦
σij
;#@A*?Ev.)<;"'<@A*?EX!D46(0*WE#<;9'<@A*;#ED46*?E#<;v%E
nj
.)<;"'<@A$-+ @J;D46*?E#<;BC1LN <'%E#%1,!"*@A!X$h46.|wZ.R4g !#@A*?EX()l%!#Jm
2
W
H
P
n
5 4 4=
{
<;gNJ46.)%1,!#;$&@~ %*,*<;-B,<;B,I@A!X$h46EX()@A*;>=B46*;.)<;Z'<@A*BC(0EX()@A*;jB,&.bKiI<qW1n46EX()@A* Cm m 5;#@A*?EP m
5 4 4 >
{
<;/NJ46.)%1,!#;/$&@~ %*,*<;FB,<;/'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#<;"B46*;/.)<;/'<@A*BC(0EX()@A*;FB,.bKiI<q?1n46EX()@A* Cm m g;#@A*?Ed ¯ij = ◦ij
W
m
O
. <
X
; E
G5 4 4 =
◦
+ @J;#;X(0S,.)dB,9EX!#@A1,N %!8.)<;FNA46.)%1,!#;F$&@~ %*,*<;"B,<;8'<@A*?EX!D46(0*WE#<;vB46*;8.)<;F'<@A*BC(0EX()@A*;"B,d.bKiI<qW1nσ46¯ijEX()@A=* σCijm m &%E
5 4 4>
.)<;8NJ46.)%1,!#;8$&@~ %*,*<;B,<;"B,I@A!X$h46EX()@A*;9B46*;8.)<;"'<@A*BC(0EX()@A*;9B,d.bKiI<q?1n46EX()@A* Cm m jE#%.0.)<;"qW1&
<
¢|@A1,!o1,*5$h46E#I%!X(R461r'<@A$-+O@J;#IjB,ZB,%1CG+,:n4A;#<;&` S,.)@H'Z%E9$&@A!XEX()%!¡e='<@A$-$&j1,*Z$h4 <@A*,*%!X()J= .)<;oGC+,!#<;
;X()@A*;vB,o'<@A*?EX!D46(0*?E#<;9$&@~ %*,*<;%E"B,fB,I@A!X$h46EX()@A*;"$&@~ %*,*<;;D@A*?EvB,Ip*,()<;v+n46!
(1)
σ̄ij = c1 σ̄ij + c2 σ̄ij
(2)
5 4 4;
` Cm m Je
(1) (2)
¯ij = c1 ¯ij + c2 ¯ij
@
=
c1 c2
%E ;D@A*?Et!#<;X+O<'%EX(0N %$&%*WEcB,<;'<@A*'<%*WEX!D46EX()@A*;5+n46!XEX()%.0.)<;+n46!tN @A.01,$&QB,<;U+,:n4A;#<; 4 5
%E C=
m * I<'%!X(0NA46*WE3.)<;3!#%.R46EX()@A*;P%*?EX!#.)<;3'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#<;\%Eh.)<;PB,I@A!X$h46EX()@A*;3B46*;3.)<;h+,:n4A;D<;
c1 + c 2 = 1
'<@A$-$&&
(1) (1)
σij = Cijkl kl ; ij = Sijkl σkl
(2) (2)
(1)
(2) (2)
(1)
5 4 4Ae
` Cm m
σij = Cijkl kl ; ij = Sijkl σkl
.)<;|!#%.R46EX()@A*;;X1,(0NJ46*?E#<;%*WEX!#/.)<;'<@A*WEX!D46(0*?E#<;s$&@~ %*,*<;uJ.)@ASn46.)<;%E|.)<;|B,I@A!X$h46EX()@A*;$&@> %*,*<;suJ.)@ASn46.)<;
B46*;8.)<;vB,%1CGY+,:n4A;D<;8+O%1,N %*WE;>KiI<'%!X(0!#h
(1) (1)
σ̄ij = c1 Cijkl ¯kl + c2 Cijkl )¯
kl
(2 (2)
544
` Cm m e
(1) (1) (2 (2)
¯ij = c1 Sijkl σ̄kl + c2 Sijkl )σ̄kl
@ *5+ %1,EdB,@A*'-B,I<BC1,(0!#j.)<;d!#%.R46EX()@A*;%*?EX!#j.)<;d$&@> %*,*<;;X1,!d1,*Z;D%1,.)g+,:n4A;D-%E9.R43$&@~ %*,*-uJ.)@ASn46.)
'<@A$-$&f'<<'%(/
(2)
5 4 75
` Cm m J e
σ̄ij = Bijkl σ̄kl ; σ̄ij = Bijkl σ̄kl
{
<;"E#%!X$&<; (1) (2) (1) (2) ;#@A*WE"B,<;8$h46EX!X()'<<;>=,@ % E mC
A ,A ,B ,B c1 A(1) + c2 A(2) = I c1 B (1) + c2 B (2) = I
I%ED46*WE".R4j$h46EX!X()'<o()B,%*WEX(0E#IJm
<
|
¢ @A1,!-.)<;j$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;&%*}uJ!D46*By46+,+n46!#%(0.` +O@A*WE&J1,.0()%*
=s4AqW1<BC1'\BKikv!X.)<;¡e=|(0.8<;XE-BC(_h'%(0.)\B,YB,Ip*,(0!
1,*L7d sqW1,(
!# nl%E#%*WEv.)o'<@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?E9$&I<'>46*,()q?1fB,f.R4j;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#ouJ.)@ASn46.)Jm
£Y
z ? ~n
n
Qu
u u
¯
<
]do*@A$gS,!#%1CGU@A1,NW!D46u <;B,du I%*,()'%(0NH(0.
;#@A*?EvB,<;;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#<;"$h4 <@A*,*I<<;~mO[dI%*I%!D46.)%$&%*WE>='<<;";#EX!X1'%EX1,!#<;
;#@A*WEI%EX1BC()I<<;Z'<@A$-$&&B,<;f$-(0.0()%1CGr'<@A*?EX(0*W1;>m|{4Y$&I%EX:@HB,hB,<;fI%.)I%$&%*WE#;fp*,();*@A*r.0(0*I>46(0!#<;*
Ki<;#Ef+n4A;
E#@A1AX@A1,!#;g'>46+n46S,.)PB,PB,I<'%!X(0!#hE#@A1;g.)<;f+,:I%*@A$&l%*<;j+ @A1,NA46*WEZ;D-+,!#@WBC1,(0!#PB46*;Z'<&EH+ 3B,3;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#J=
<
+n46!9GC%$-+,.).)<;"$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;d%*LuJ!D46*B546+,+n46!#%(0.@U.R4&BC();#'<@A*?EX(0*W1,(0E#Ig+,:WH;#()q?1g<;XEvI%NH()B,%*?E#JmO]9+,.01;>=
.)<;h$&@WB,l%.)<;3'<@A*?EX(0*?1;P+,!#I<;#%*WE#%*?EP1,*LuJ!D46*B,L46(0S,.)<;#;DY4A'<w5.R4cB,<;#'%!X(0+,EX()@A*aB,\.R4cBCH*n46$-()q?1B,<;
<
;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#<;v$h4 <@A*,*I<<;v%*L!D46();D@A*UBC1L'<@A$-+O@A!XE#%$&%*WE9BC();D'<@A*?EX(0*?1tB,<;X@A(0*?E#;v%*WEX!#oS,.)@H'<;`
puJ1,!# CmM em 5
54
Cm 71Zu I%*I%!D46.)-B,Z.bKM4AqW1<BC1'-BKikv!X.)<;o%EoB,Z.bKM4Aq?1<BC1'jB,<;d$&@A1,.0(0*;>=4615NJ46.0.)@A*rB,<;9k!#'<;>=w
@A*WEXNW()%(0.0.)Jm
5 404 <
Cm 2t@WB,l%.)fB,<;v$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;d%*UuJ!D46*B46+,+n46!#%(0.%*L+n46!XEX()g(0*C I%!X()%1,!#J=%E%*L+ %EX(0E946+,+n46!#%(0.%E
<
$h4 <@A*,*%!X()3B,jS,.)@W'>46u &%*c+n46!XEX()h;X1,+OI%!X()%1,!#J=BC1 B,%1CGH()l%$&34Aq?1<BC1'&BKik!X.)<;>=
461cNJ46.0.)@A* B,<;fk!#'<;>=
w
5 4
@A*WEXNW()%(0.0.)P`bTV@AEXE#f%E46.bm
` JJ eXe
m
z ? ~n
n
]o46*;F.)o'>4ABC!#oB,<;8I%EX1B,<;8%*?EX!#%+,!X();D<;v;#@A1;F.bK (0$-+,1,.);X()@A*LB,d.R4Z]9(0!#<'%EX()@A*UI%uJ()@A*n46.)oB,<;8k"^
46(0!#<;vT/1,.0EX1C
5 45
!#%.0.)<;/B,".R4d!#I%uJ()@A*P{46*,uJ1<B,@W'9v@A1;D;X(0.0.)@A*
= '<@A*'<%!X*n46*?EV.)<;/46!#l%*<;VB," )$&<;`
puJ1,!# Cm e=?(0.n<;#E/46+,+n46!X1
<
*I<'<<;#;¡46(0!#/B,/$&@WB,I%.0();D%!.)/Sn6EX(0$&%*?EB,4 <@A*-w"@AS,E#%*,(0!B,<;+,.R46*;|B,V'<@A1,+ J=B,/!#<'<@A.0.)%$&%*?EsBK (0*WE#%!XN %*C
<
EX()@A*;F%E/B,<;V(0*BC()'>46EX()@A*;V!#I>46.0();XE#<;F%*PE#%!X$&<;VB,v$h4A;#;#<;VB,v$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;F$-();D<;/%*Y@W%1,NH!#J=?B,<;D'<%*?E#<;8B,
5 45
'D:n46!Xu <;>= ;X1,(0NH();B,<;+n46EX:@A.)@AuJ()<;>=J%E#'Jm,mJ{49!#%.R46EX(0N 8'<@A$-+,.)GC(0E#I"B,F.R4u I<@A$&I%EX!X()`
puJ1,!# Cm e=J!#I<%.0.)%$&%*WE
EX!X()BC(0$&%*;X()@A*,*%.0.)ZB,f.bKiI<BC(_pn'<J=n.bKM46u %*'<%$&%*?Ed+n46!XEX()'%1,.0()%!dB,<;"S,.)@H'<;vB,f+,()%!X!#1,EX(0.0();#I<;"+ @A1,!".R4&+n46!XEX()f.R4
+,.01;GCE#%!X*FB,/.bKiI<BC(_pn'<f` u?46.)%!X()<;GHE#I%!X()%1,!#<;>=J%EB,V.bKM46EXEX()qW1~e=A.)<;E#<'#:,*,()qW1<;sB,F'<@A*;XEX!X1'%EX()@A*&B,<;s46!#'<;
<
B,"B,I<'D:n46!Xu %*&4 >4AB,J=W%EB,<;s.0(0*WE#>461CGhB,8.R4du?46.)%!X()vGCE#I%!X()%1,!#vBC1h+,!#%$-()%!/I%ED46u "*v;#@A*?EVI%NW()B,%$-$&%*WE
+n4A;8+,!X();D<;"%*U'<@A$-+,E#fB46*;v1,*\$&@WB,l%.)f'<@A*WEX(0*?1tI%.R4A;XEX()q?1Jm
5 45 <
Cm ¢:@AE#@PB,u?461'D:P71g+n46!XEX()%.0.)ZB,<;o46!#l%*<;dB,Z )$&<;>=B,I%ED46(0.B,$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;o%*tuJ!D46*B
46+,+n46!#%(0.bm¢:@AE#@&B,fBC!#@A(0E#&,k!#l%*<;"B,f )$&<;>m, G,%$-+,.)fB,ou I<@A$&I%EX!X()$&@WB,I%.0();DI<Jm
•
'M )G"-M',)M HMHL&
.
GH();#E#oB,d*@A$S,!#%1CGL.)@AuJ()'%()%.);vBKiI%.)I%$&%*WE#;"p*,();g` s{
sZ=OH8vk99]Z=,{ dHkoO=,kxFk oO=H8vk oO=
]dk9kg=Ck9d
O=nTVkoH8 s25emOTV<;".)@AuJ()'%()%.);"+ %1,N %*?EvEX!D46(0E#%!vB,o*@A$S,!#%1CGL+,!#@AS,.)l%$&<;v+,:?C;X()qW1<;>m
TV%+ %*B46*?E>=C
1;#qW1
KMwP+,!#I<;#%*?Ef'<<;f.)@AuJ()'%()%.);f s *
Ki@A*?Ef+n4A;o%1c.R4P+,1,();D;D46*'<-B,j$&@WB,I%.0();D%!o1,*-;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#
<
B,d$h4 <@A*,*%!X()Z%*LB,I%ED46(0.bm
u
ºE
>46*
5 4
46.` ?>46*P%EVTF46$gSO@A1c` JJ eXes+,!#@A+O@J;#%*WE1,*'%.R4A;#;X(_pn'>46EX()@A*3B,v$&I%EX:@WB,<;VB,"!#I<;D@A.01,EX()@A*3%*3B,%1CG
,+ !X(0*'%(0+n46.)<;'>46E#I%u @A!X()<;g
.)<;V$&I%EX:@WB,<;8;X$&@H@AEX:
=W+O@A1,!V.R4Aq?1%.0.)9.)<;V.)@A();FBK (0*?E#%!D4A'%EX()@A*U%*WEX!#9+n46!XEX()'%1,.)<;8;#@A*?E8B,<;/ @A*'%EX()@A*;F'<@A*WEX(_
*W1<;v%E"B,I%!X(0NJ46S,.)<;>=
.)<;V$&I%EX:@WB,<;F*@A*C;X$&@H@AEX:
=H+O@A1,!V.R4AqW1%.0.).)<;V.)@A();FBK (0*?E#%!D4A'%EX()@A*;%*?EX!#9uJ!D46(0*;8;#@A*WEV!#I%uJ()<;V+n46!8B,<;V.)@A();
B,o'D:@W'<;>=w-;#%1,(0.);>=,%*WEX!D4 )*n46*?EdB,<;";D461,E#;"B,dNH(0E#<;#;#<;"%E"B,<;;#%1,(0.);"B,9@A!#'<<;>m
{ <;V$&I%EX:@HB,<;8;X$&@H@AEX:P'<@A*;X()B,l%!#%*WE"B,<;V(0*?E#%!D4A'%EX()@A*;"'<@A*WEX(0*?1<;"%EFB,I%!X(0NA46S,.)<;8%*WEX!#9+n46!XEX()'%1,.)<;>=CB,I<'%!X(0E#<;
@
+n46!oB,<;9@A*'%EX()@A*;&` (0*?E#%!#;XEX()'<<;f%EdNH(0E#<;#;#<;9!#%.R46EX(0N <;¡e!#I%uJ1,.0()l%!#<;>m *c'%(0E#-B,%1CG5GC%$-+,.)<;oB,j'<%EXE#Z$&I
EX:@HB,&
M"
"-LIJ, & M H',)M "-1
= (0*,(0EX(R46.0.)%$&%*?Eg$-();#-%*r@H%1,NW!#j+ @A1,!fB,<;oS,1,.0.)<;fB,ju?46h%EfqW1,(
P
WR P
W 3 vn ~ ,
;>Ki<;#E&+n46!&.R4r;#1,(0E#L'<@A$-+,.)GH(_pnI<Q` '<@A*;X()B,l%!#tB,<;&+n46!XEX()'%1,.)<;P;X+,:I%!X()q?1<;em/TV%EXE#46+,+,!#@H'#:54tb46(0E&.bKi@ASC
X%EvBKiGCE#%*;X()@A*t4p*tB,o$&@WB,I%.0();D%!v.bKiI<'<@A1,.)%$&%*?EoB, 1,()B,g'<@A*?E#%*n46*WEdI%u?46.)%$&%*WE9B,<;+n46!XEX()'%1,.)<;9;#@A.0()B,<;
5 4
` {
<@A*%*, @3%E"79(0*@AuJ!D4AB,@W'h` JJ eXe=
mẍi = Fi + Fia
%E
I ẇi = Mi − αIwi
5 76 4
` Cm Cm e
kN <'J=
,.R4- @A!#'<gBKM46$&@A!XEX();#;#%$&%*?EdB,Ip*,()Z'<@A$-$&I%ED46*?E91,*o !D4A'%EX()@A*B,.R4-;#@A$-$&gB,<;"@A!#'<<;v;X1,S,()<;v+n46!
Fia
.R4Z+n46!XEX()'%1,.)J=
9C$&@A$&%*?E9BK (0*%!XEX()B,d.R4j+n46!XEX()'%1,.)J=
,!#@AED46EX()@A*UB,o.R4Z+n46!XEX()'%1,.)J=
wi
4A'<'<I%.)I%!D46EX()@A*5B,d.R4j+n46!XEX()'%1,.)J=
ẍi
CNW();D'<@J;X(0E#IJ=
α
$&@A$&%*?Ev!#I<;#1,.0ED46*?E>m
Mi
T9Ki<;XEouJ!DA'<3w3'<%EXE#&:?H+O@AEX:l<;#-BKM46$&@A!XEX();D;#%$&%*?EgNW(0!XEX1%.qW1jB,<;o$-(0.0()%1CGc;#@A1,$-();wP1,*-B,I@A!X$h46EX()@A*
qW1n4A;X(_;XED46EX()qW1;#@A*WE'<@A!X!#<'%E#%$&%*WE9!#%+,!#I<;D%*?E#I<;+n46!'<'<@HB,fB,g'>46.)'%1,.Sn4A;#Ig;X1,!vB,<;v'<@A*;#()B,I%!D46EX()@A*;9BCW
*n46$-()qW1<;>m
•
"%
!G#)
] 146(0EZB,h.R4U*n46EX1,!#3GC+,.0()'%(0E#YB,h.bKM46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&YB,3!#I<;#@A.01,EX()@A*}*?1,$&I%!X()qW1Y%EZB,h.R4L$&@HB,I%.0();D46EX()@A* B,<;
9
!#I>4A'%EX()@A*;-B,P'<@A*?ED4A'%E>=.R4;XED46S,(0.0(0E#IYB,h.R42t s] <;#EZ'<@A*BC(0EX()@A*,*I<Y+n46!Z.)h+n4A;jB,3E#%$-+;-B,3BC();D'%!#I%EX();D4
EX()@A* m|{
P+n4A;ZB,3E#%$-+;-'%!X(0EX()qW13B,I%+ %*B}B,<;g+,!#@A+,!X()I%E#I<;j$&I<'>46*,()qW1<;-B,<;ZuJ!D46(0*;>m{
<;Z(0*?E#%!D4A'%EX()@A*;
%*WEX!#&uJ!D46(0*;f+ %1,N %*?EZ%*r+,!#%$-()l%!#346+,+,!#@>GH(0$h46EX()@A* %EX!#h4A;#;#(0$-(0.)I<<;gwP1,* ;XC;XE#l%$&-$h4A;D;#b!#<;#;#@A!XE>m *
δt
'<@A*BC(0EX()@A**I<'<<;#;D46(0!#&;X1,! <;XEfqW1-.R4YNH(0E#<;#;#-B,j+,!#@A+n46u?46EX()@A*}B,-.bKi@A*B,-*?1,$&I%!X()qW1P;#@A(0Ef;X1,+ I%!X()%1,!#
δt
z ? ~n
n
∆tcrit = min[
r
m
i
,
s
I
i
]
5 76 75
` Cm Cm e
ktran krot
kN <'J=
$ < ;XEv.R4Z$h4A;#;#oB,o.R4Z+n46!XEX()'%1,.)J=
V;#@A*L;#@A$-$&%EvBK (0*%!XEX()3` +n46!XEX()'%1,.);X+,:I%!X()qW1~e=
ktran i
%E i ;#@A*?E".)<;"!D46()B,%1,!#;vB,dEX!D46*;X.R46EX()@A*t%E"B,o!#@AED46EX()@A*UB,o.R4Z+n46!XEX()'%1,.)Jm
./46+,+n46!D4 k)rot
EgqW1-+ @A1,!$-(0*,(0$-();#%!g.)-E#%$-+;ZB,&'>46.)'%1,.b='JKi<;XE
wBC(0!#Y461,uJ$&%*?E#%!Z.)-+n4A;ZB,-E#%$-+;>=(0.<;XE
+,!#II%!D46S,.);D@A(0EVB,9B,Ip*,(0!VB,<;/!D46()B,%1,!#;FB,'<@A*WED4A'%EV46(0S,.)J=H;#@A(0E/B,9B,Ip*,(0!8B,<;$h4A;D;#<;(0$-+ @A!XED46*?E#<;F+ @A1,!
.)<;+n46!XEX()'%1,.)<;>mW{<;!D46()B,%1,!#;VB,v'<@A*WED4A'%EV;#@A*WEs@A*'%EX()@A*3BC13$h46E#I%!X(R4613+,!X();/%*3'<@A$-+,E#J=HBKM461,EX!#"+n46!XE>= (0.O<;XE
*I<'<<;#;¡46(0!#fq?1f.R4j!D46()B,%1,!v*f;D@A(0E"+n4A;"EX!#@A+\b46(0S,.)g4p*BKiI%NW(0E#%!9B,<;8(0*?E#%!X+ I%*I%EX!D46EX()@A*;f461U'<@A*?ED4A'%EEX!#@A+
(0$-+ @A!XED46*?E#NW();
wbNH();"B,<;"BC(0$&%*;#()@A*;vB,<;8+n46!XEX()'%1,.)<;>m
•
3 M
* &'1"%0
{
'<@WB,oB,f'>46.)'%1,.B,T/1,*B46.0.+ @J;#;#l<B,%*?EB,%1CGP.)@A();"B,'<@A*?ED4A'%EI%.R4A;#EX()q?1&
s1,*U'<@A*WED4A'%EI%.R4A;XEX()qW1d.0(0*I>46(0!#J=
s1,*U'<@A*WED4A'%EI%.R4A;XEX()qW1d*@A*L.0(0*I>46(0!#gB,dEH+Of'<@A*WED4A'%EvB, 9%!XEX%2U(0*BC.0(0*
m
.
<;XE8+ @J;#;X(0S,.)oBK (0*?E#I%uJ!#%!9BKM461,EX!#<;"EW+ <;"B,o.)@A(%*\+,!#@AuJ!D46$-$h46EX()@A*rT Zm
& ) &&"%0!HNM "%
IJ, M H'"-1
5 4 6 emkv(0*;#(b=,.)<;
{ '<•@A*?ED4A'%E9.0(0*I>46(0!#I%.R4A;XEX()qW1o!#%.0()f.R4j @A!#'<fB,'<@A*?ED4A'%Eo461CGP(0*WE#%!X+OI%*I%EX!D46EX()@A*;&`
puJ1,!# Cm
@A!#'<<;8*@A!X$h46.)<;v%EvED46*,u %*?EX()%.0.)<;d461U'<@A*?ED4A'%E9;#@A*?E"B,Ip*,()<;v+n46!
Fin = K n U n ni
%E
δFit = −K t δUit
5 76 76
` Cm Cm e
kN <'J=
C(0*?E#%!X+ I%*I%EX!D46EX()@A*c461U'<@A*?ED4A'%E>=
Un
C(0*'%!#I%$&%*WEB,fB,I%+,.R4A'<%$&%*WEvED46*,u %*WEX()%.b=
δUit
,.R4Z!D46()B,%1,!vED46*,u %*WE#g461L'<@A*WED4A'%E>=
Kt
K n C.R4Z!D46()B,%1,!*@A!X$h46.)461U'<@A*WED4A'%E>m
{
<;L!D46()B,%1,!#;LB,c'<@A*?ED4A'%EU;D@A*?E\@A*'%EX()@A*B,<;\!D46()B,%1,!#;LB,Ip*,()<;\+ @A1,!\.)<;LB,%1CGa+n46!XEX()'%1,.)<;U4}%E\S%*
'<@A*WED4A'%EvE#%.0.)<;"qW1&
Kn =
kan kbn %E
Ks =
kas kbs 5 76 =
` Cm Cm We
kan + kbn kas + kbs
.
<;XEvwZ*@AE#%!vqW1&
+ @A1,!B,<;v+n46!XEX()'%1,.)<;9+,!#I<;#%*?ED46*WE9.R4-$ %$&f!D46()B,%1,!>=.R4-!D46()B,%1,!B,g'<@A*?ED4A'%Ed<;XE".R4&$&@A(0EX()IB,f.R4&!D46()B,%1,!
B,Ip*,()o+ @A1,!v'D:n4Aq?1o+n46!XEX()'%1,.)J=
"B46*;d.)j'>4A;dBK 1,*r'<@A*?ED4A'%EfBK 1,*j+n46!XEX()'%1,.)&4<N <'j1,*5+,.R46*
=O.)<;d$ %$&<;d!#%.R46EX()@A*;f;#@A*WEf46+,+,.0()q?1I<<;4>N <'
Y
WR P
W 3 vn ~ ,
n %E s %*\.0()%1U%E8+,.R4A'<fB, m
Kmur Kmur kb
Ra
~ni
Rb
5Cm 4 6
Un
{
@A(B,o'<@A*?ED4A'%E9I%.R4A;XEX()qW1o.0(0*I>46(0!#JmTV@A*?ED4A'%E9%*?EX!#gB,%1CGP+n46!XEX()'%1,.)<;
•
& ) &&"%0!HNM "%
IJ, & M H"-: ( M
5 76 76
{4L.)@A(B,h'<@A*WED4A'%Eg*@A*Cb.0(0*I>46(0!#Y4Y.R4Y$ %$&3GH+,!#<;D;X()@A*qW1-.R4Y.)@A(/.0(0*I>46(0!#J=
.)<;GC+,!#<;#;X()@A*; Cm Cm L;#@A*WE
46+,+,.0()qW1I<<;>mV *a!#%NA46*'D:J=/.)<;PGC+,!#<;#;X()@A*;YB,<;h!D46()B,%1,!#;Y*@A!X$h46.)<;Y%EPED46*,u %*?EX()%.0.)<;U461a'<@A*?ED4A'%E\;#@A*WE
BC(0!#<'%E#%$&%*WE3.0()I<<;h461CG '>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();XEX()qW1<;h+,:WH;#()q?1<;&%E&BC(0$&%*;#()@A*;hB,<;&+n46!XEX()'%1,.)<;3%*y'<@A*?ED4A'%E3+n46!&.)<;
!#%.R46EX()@A*;;X1,(0NA46*WE#<;
n
K =
√
2G 2R √ n
U
%E
Kt =
2(3RG2 (1 − µ))1/3 n 1/3
|F |
5 76 7>
` Cm Cm e
3(1 − µ) 2−µ
kN < 'J=
[ C $&@HBC1,.)fB,f'%();¡46(0.0.)%$&%*?Ev$&@~ %*B,<;8+n46!XEX()'%1,.)<;94j%E"SL%*U'<@A*WED4A'%E>=
G=
(Ga + Gb ) 5 76 78
` Cm Cm e
2
C.)f'<@Hh'%()%*?EvB,¢@A();#;D@A*L$&@> %*tB,<;8+n46!XEX()'%1,.)<;4-%E8S%*L'<@A*?ED4A'%E>=
µ
µ=
(µa + µb ) 5 76 B;
` Cm Cm Je
2
,<;XEF @A*'%EX()@A*B,o.R4ZED46(0.0.)fB,<;"B,%1CG\+n46!XEX()'%1,.)<;g` %E e
Ra Rb
R=
(2Ra Rb ) 5 76 7A
` Cm Cm e
Ra + R b
Q
z ? ~n
n
.
<;XEvwZ*@AE#%!vqW1&
'<oEW+ oB,f'<@A*WED4A'%Ev*
Ki<;XE"B,Ip*,(qW1d+ @A1,!vB,<;8+n46!XEX()'%1,.)<;v;#+,:I%!X()q?1<;>=
s.R4j$-();Do%*L+,.R4A'<fB,o'<oEW+ oB,f'<@A*?ED4A'%E9<;XE8uJ!D46*B,%$&%*?E9'<@A*;#@A$-$h46E#%1,!B,fE#%$-+;vB,o'>46.)'%1,.bm
•
3 MO 1 -/L&*) JK & ,M
{ & !#@AEXE#%$&%*WE-%*?EX!#PB,%1CG I%.)I%$&%*?E#;j<;XEgB,I<'%!X(0EjB,&$h46*,()l%!#Yw\.0(0$-(0E#%!g.R4\NJ46.)%1,!j46EXE#%(0*WE#h+n46!Z.R4Y@A!#'<
ED46*,u %*WEX()%.0.)fB,'<@A*WED4A'%Ev;X1,(0NJ46*?EF.)9'%!X(0E#l%!#oB,dTV@A1,.)@A$gS
m{4 @A!#'<ED46*,u %*?EX()%.0.)g461Y'<@A*WED4A'%E8*9+O%1,E %EX!#
;X1,+ I%!X()%1,!#w t B,I%+O%*B46*WEv.0(0*I>46(0!#%$&%*WEB,o.R4g@A!#'<o*@A!X$h46.)461U'<@A*WED4A'%E>m
Fmax
F t ≤ Fmax
t
= µ|F n |
5 76
` Cm CmM e
{ <;V$&I%EX:@HB,<;V*@A*C;X$&@W@AEX:r`bTV@A*WED4A'%E"]H*n46$-()'<;"TV]fes'<@A*;X();#E#%*?E"wf1,EX(0.0();D%!FB,<;/.)@A();FBK (0*?E#%!D4A'%EX()@A*U%*WEX!#
uJ!D46(0*;>=C*@A*\*I<'<<;D;D46(0!#%$&%*?E"!#I%uJ1,.0()l%!#<;~=,'JKi<;XE
wBC(0!#db46();D46*?E8(0*WE#%!XN %*,(0!vB,<;";D461,E#;8B,9NH(0E#<;#;#d@A1LB,<;F.)@A();
w-;D%1,(0.);>m,.
;~KM46uJ(0E"+,!X(0*'%(0+n46.)%$&%*?EoB,d.R4j$&I%EX:@HB,f9@A*tW$&@W@AEX:5TV@A*?ED4A'%E]9H*n46$-()'<;"(0*,(0EX()I<g%EvB,I%N %.)@A+C
4 0A0A 4 1= 4 ;
+ I<h+n46!j2t@A!#>461` 2t@A!#>461` e=2@A!#>461` J We=2@A!#>461` J Je=2@A!#>461` JJJ eXeg%Ej >46*` >46* 5
4 06 4 4 05 5 4
` J e= >46*` JJ eXeP` >46* %EZm|2t@A!#>461a` J e= >46*}%E-TF46$gSO@A1` JJ eXem .0.)P<;XEZ+n46!
46(0E#%$&%*WE
4AB46+,E#I<F+ @A1,!s;X(0$1,.)%!.)F'<@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?EV%E|.bKiI%N @A.01,EX()@A*3BCW*n46$-()qW18BK 1,*&%*;#%$S,.)vB,/+n46!XEX()'%1,.)<;s!X(0uJ()B,<;
B,gED46(0.0.)<;dBC(_^ I%!#%*WE#<;>=4<?46*?Ed1,*Zu I<@A$&I%EX!X()j'<@A*?N G,Z(0*?E#%!D46uJ();#;D46*WEd+n46!d'<@A*WED4A'%E>m *t^%E>=O%.0.)+ %!X$&%E
+n46!f;#@A*r;D'#:I%$h4Y*W1,$&I%!X()q?1-(0$-+,.0()'%(0E#3B,j+,!#%*BC!#&%*r'<@A$-+,E#-.)<;oI%N %*WEX1%.);g'D:@W'<;f%Eo.)<;d(0!X!#I%uJ1,.R46!X(0E#I<;
qW1,("+ %1,N %*?Eh%*zB,I<'<@A1,.)%!>mV{
<;h4A'%EX()@A*;3(0*?E#%!3uJ!D46*?1,.R46(0!#<;PB,L'<@A*?ED4A'%Eh !#@AEXED46*WE3;#@A*WEhB,I<'%!X(0E#<;3+n46!hB,<;
'<@A*BC(0EX()@A*;v1,*,(0.R46E#I%!D46.)<;` .)@A(
B,W(0uJ*@A!X(0*,(
e=BC1Y !#@AEXE#%$&%*?EvB,TV@A1,.)@A$gSU%E"B,<;F.)@A();8B,o'#:@H'<;"I%.R4A;XEX()qW1<;
%Ej(0*I%.R4A;XEX()qW1<;>m]jKM461,EX!#<;-.)@A();>=|E#%.0.)<;-q?1P.)Y'<@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?Eh'<@A:I<;X(_d%*?EX!#YS,.)@H'<;>=4<N <'Y1,*P.0(0$-(0E#\B,
!#I<;X();#ED46*'<461L'%();D46(0.0.)%$&%*?Eo4ABC$-();#;X(0S,.)o%*WEX!#f.)<;8S,.)@H'<;"@A*WEvI%E#IfGC+OI%!X(0$&%*WE#I<<;>m
1,$&I%!X()q?1%$&%*WE>=.R4Z$&I%EX:@HB,fo,TV] <;XE8(0$-+,.)I%$&%*WE#I<B46*;8.)o'<@HB,oB,o'>46.)'%1,.{
2c[fTFJ ,'<@A*WEX!D46(0!#
$&%*WEwP.R4h$&I%EX:@HB,-B,hT/1,*B46.0.b=
'<%EXE#j$&I%EX:@HB,j*ZE#@A.)l%!#&461'%1,*-(0*?E#%!X+ I%*I%EX!D46EX()@A*%*WEX!#j.)<;duJ!D46(0*;>=
;D461C%!X!#%1,!"*W1,$&I%!X()q?1Jm
{
8;D'#:I%$h4oB,F!#I<;#@A.01,EX()@A*3<;XESn4A;#I8;X1,!.)V+,!X(0*'%(0+O8 @A*B46$&%*WED46.B,F.R49BCW*n46$-()qW1J=J(0.<;XEs46(0*;X(,*I<'<<;D;D46(0!#
B,-B,I%E#%!X$-(0*%!f.)<;fNW(0E#<;#;D<;9%Ed@A!#'<<;fB,j'<@A*?ED4A'%Eg+O@A1,!o'D:n4Aq?1&'<@A*WED4A'%E'#:n4AqW1&'%C'%.)-B,j'>46.)'%1,.bmTV%EXE#
!#I<;#@A.01,EX()@A*c<;XE!#I>46.0();#I<ZB,$h46*,()l%!#Z(0$-+,.0()'%(0E#Z+n46!9'<@A*WN %!Xu %*'<-BK 1,*546.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&j(0E#I%!D46EX(_d` +O@A1,!d'#:n4AqW1
'<@A*WED4A'%E>=C.)<;8;#@A.01,EX()@A*;8;#@A*?E"B,I%E#%!X$-(0*I<<;v%*3b46();D46*WEV.bK :WW+ @AEX:l<;#oB,<;FNJ46.)%1,!#;V+O@A1,!F.)<;"461,EX!#<;8'<@A*?ED4A'%E#;em
•
"%
!G#)
¢|@A1,!u %I !#%!f.bKiI%N @A.01,EX()@A*}%*rE#%$-+;gB46*;o.)&'>4A;f*@A*Cb!#I%uJ1,.0()%!>=B,%1CG 46+,+,!#@W'D:<;g;#@A*WEf+ @J;#;X(0S,.)<;h` 2t@A!#>461
4
` JJJ4 eXf
e
;XED46EX1,E#;/B,<;'<@A*WED4A'%E#;*8NJ46!X()%*?E/+n4A;` +n46!XEX()v!#I%uJ1,.0()l%!#~emCTV<;(0*;#ED46*?E#;VB,8EX!D46*;X(0EX()@A*3B,I%.0(0$-(0E#%*WEVB,@A*'B,<;
(0*WE#%!XNA46.0.)<;VB,8E#%$-+;v .)8$&@A1,N %$&%*?EFBC1h;XC;XE#l%$&8<;XEs!#I%uJ1,.0()%!>mCTV%EXE#8E#<'#:,*,()qW19<;XEsh'>4A'<vB46*;.)"'>4A;
@.)o*@A$S,!#guJ.)@ASn46.|B,fEX!D46*;X(0EX()@A*;;#1,!XN %*n46*?E9+O%*B46*WE.bKiI%N @A.01,EX()@A*5BC1;XC;XE#l%$&o*
Ki<;#Ev+n4A;"EX!#@A+uJ!D46*B
%Ef+ %!X$&%E.bK 1,EX(0.0();¡46EX()@A*QB,-$&I%EX:@HB,<;ZBK (0*?E#I%uJ!D46EX()@A*}BKi@A!#BC!#3I%.)%N I& @A1,!X*,();#;¡46*?EB,<;g!#I<;X1,.0ED46E#;f+,!#I<'%();Z%E
B,@A*,*n46*WEs.R49+O@J;D;X(0S,(0.0(0E#IFB,8;#FB,I%+,.R4A'<%!!D46+,()B,%$&%*?E/%*WEX!#8.)<;EX!D46*;X(0EX()@A*;>m?TV%+ %*B46*?E>= .)@A!#;#q?1F.)V*@A$gS,!#
B,'<@A*?ED4A'%EFB,%NW()%*WE/EX!#@A+3uJ!D46*B=W'<%EXE#v$&I%EX:@WB,9<;XEs(0*W1,EX(0.0();D46S,.)-` .)"E#%$-+;V%*?EX!#9B,%1CGhI%N I%*%$&%*?E#;V*@A*C
!#I%uJ1,.0()%!#;<;XE8EX!#@A+L+ %EX(0E¡e=
¥ ¥
t Æ \(
Æ " "
,EM"##H'F3) ) ), )"-M M
<
TV<;g(0*'<@A*?N I%*,()%*WE#;&'<@A*?EX!X(0S,1%*WE-wL.R4UB,I%uJ!D4AB46EX()@A*}B,3.R4Yp46S,(0.0(0E#IPB,<;!#I<;X1,.0ED46E#;Z%E.bKi@A*}'<@A*;XED46E#Y46.)@A!#;
qW1d;X( .bKih'>4A'%(0E#Io*?1,$&I%!X()qW1fB,o'<%EXE#d$&I%EX:@HB,o'<@A*;XEX(0EX1d1,*U4<NJ46*?ED46u o$h4X%1,!>=,;#@A*\'<@ ,E"%*YE#%!X$&fB,
+ %!XE#oB,fqW1n46.0(0E#IfB,<;8!#I<;X1,.0ED46E#;<;XE"I%.)%N IJm
,EM"##H'F3)
QJ
z ? ~n
n
d
Å ºg u
u Å
gN ≥ 0, RN ≥ 0, g N RN = 0
5=4
` Cm m e
UN
Q&2
W
H ~ , 3
Signor(UN , RN )
5 = 76
` Cm m e
.0.)<;XE"B,I%E#%!X$-(0*I<f+n46!".R4Z!#%.R46EX()@A*t;X1,(0NJ46*?E#&
` @A*UuJ.0();#;#%$&%*?E¡e
5==
UT = 0, kRT k < µRN
` Cm m We
R
UT = −λ T , kRT k = µRN
`b[d.0();#;#%$&%*?E¡e
kRT k
]o46*;9.R4&+,!#%$-()l%!#Z!#%.R46EX()@A*
=O.R43'<@A$-+O@J;D46*WE#Z*@A!X$h46.) B,g.R4&!#I>4A'%EX()@A*c<;XE9'<@A*;X()B,I%!#I<j'<@A$-$&g+ @6
;X(0EX(0N \`wY'>461;#jB,j.bK 1,*,(0.R46E#I%!D46.0(0E#I~ef%E !#%+,!#I<;#%*WE#-.)jR'<N@Wh'%()%*WEB,g !#@AEXE#%$&%*WE>m
.0.)j(0*BC()qW1-B,j+,.01;
qW1d.R4j!#I>4A'%EX()@A*U E#%.0.)fq?1 ~
R = R~N + R~T
µ
/? /?
!#<;XE#oB46*;81,*' A*46+,+O%.)I' A*fB,TV@A1,.)@A$S
m
TV@A*'<%!X*n46*WEs.R4vB,%1CGC()l%$&F!#%.R46EX()@A*
=J@A*j!#%$h46!#q?1FqW1F;X(W1,*juJ.0();#;D%$&%*?E;#/+,!#@WBC1,(0E>=J'JKi<;XE
wBC(0!#F.R4vNH(0E#<;#;#
ED46*,u %*WEX()%.0.) =n46.)@A!#;8.R4j!#I>4A'%EX()@A*LED46*,u %*WEX()%.0.)g@A1Y@A!#'<fB,9 !#@AEXE#%$&%*?E9;>Ki@A+,+O@J;Df461LuJ.0();#;#%$&%*WE>m
UT 6= 0
{
fuJ!D46+,:fB,o.R4Z.)@A(B,TV@A1,.)@A$gS<;XE8!#%+,!#I<;#%*WE#I;X1,!v.R4gpuJ1,!# Cm Cm 5 4>
µ
µ
0 0
−µ
[9!D46+,:B,gTV@A1,.)@A$S ?
T A*fB,gTV@A1,.)@A$S
5Cm 4 > [9!D46+,:fB,o.R4Z.)@A(B,TV@A1,.)@A$S
¢|@A1,!d1,*5'<@A!X+;9!X(0uJ()B,J=O.bKiI<qW1n46EX()@A*5;Df!#I<BC1,(0EfwhBC(0!#jqW1.)gE#@A!#;#%1,!dBCW*n46$-()qW1j<;XEdI%u?46.461tE#@A!#;#%1,!oB,<;
^@A!XE#;"GCE#I%!X()%1,!#;v%EvB,o'<@A*WED4A'%E#;>mn{
;XH;#E#l%$&oBC(_^ I%!#%*WEX()%.|wZ!#I<;#@A1BC!#f<;#E"'<%.01,(B,f9 8E#@A*C 1,.)%!g
(
mu̇ = P (t) + r 5 = 7>
` Cm m e
I ẇ = −w ∧ (Iw) + Mp(t) + Mr
{
<;3(0*?E#I%!D4A'%EX()@A*;\%*WEX!#5'<@A!X+;3;#@A*WEP;#1;#'<%+,EX(0S,.)<;3B,Uu I%*I%!#%!\B,<;3BC();#'<@A*WEX(0*?1,(0E#I<;\;X1,!3.)<;hNH(0E#<;#;#<;~m *
'D:%!#'#:gw&@AS,E#%*,(0!"1,*f;#@A.01,EX()@A*UBC();D'%!#l%E#fB,<;"I<qW1n46EX()@A*;vB,d.R4-BCH*n46$-()q?1Jm
@
¢|@A1,!E#@A1,E %EvEvB46*; =i =.R4jNH(0E#<;#;#f1U<;XEv'<@A*;X()B,I%!#I<g(0*?E#I%uJ!D46S,.)Z;X1,!".bK (0*WE#%!XNA46.0.) = E |%Ev!#%.0()I<gw-q
+n46!".R4Z!#%.R46EXτ()@A*t;X1,(0NJ46*?E#& τ
q(t) = q(τ ) +
Z t
uds
5 = B;
` Cm m Je
τ
Q
W
H ~ , 3
'1 ,: N 1L'
*)OL'
,1'
H'1&M M'
@
* '<@A*;X()B,l%!#B,<;v+n4A;B,E#%$-+;
t B,f.)@A*,uJ1%1,! h = ti+1 − ti m *U(0*WE#I%uJ!D46*?Ed.)<;vB,%1CG\$&%$S,!#<;
5 = 7>
B,d.bKiI<qW1n46EX()@A* Cm m -;#1,!8.bK (0*?E#%!XNJ46.0.)B,oE#%$-+;
ti , ti+1
t ,t
=,@A*4Y
i i+1
ti+1
5 = 7A
Z Z
M(u(ti+1 ) − u(ti )) = P (t)dt + rdν
ti ]ti ,ti+1 ] ` Cm m e
Z t
q(t) = q(τ ) + uds
τ
{sK (0$-+,1,.);#()@A*U$&@> %*,*
r(i + 1) =
1
Z
rdν
5=
` Cm mM e
h ]ti ,ti+1 ]
46+,+n46!D46(0E9'<@A$-$&o1,*o(0*'<@A*,*?1*n46EX1,!#%.0.)Jm
2 +2
:H'
"
*:NM" &
! )"%
" ON&:%"%1" M
!M3"-M'
E M "-M'
]jKM46+,!#l<;o.)-;XC;XE#l%$&-BKiI<qW1n46EX()@A*; 5Cm =m 4 C=.)<;oNJ46!X(R46S,.)<;f'%(0*I%$h46EX()qW1<;%*5p*rB,j+n4A;h` 'JKi<;#E
wBC(0!#&I%N %*C
5 = 404 e
q, u ←−−−−−−−−−−−−−−−− r
H ∗ (q)y
x
H(q) ` Cm m
v(0N >461L.)@H'>46.
Uα − − −− −−−−−−−−−−→
!
Rα
Q
z ? ~n
n
{
<;"!#%.R46EX()@A*;%*WEX!#f'<<;8*,(0N >461CGL;>Ki^<'%EX1%*?EvuJ!DA'<g461CG\46+,+,.0()'>46EX()@A*;
H ∗ (q)
%E Z` q,em
¢|@A1,!v1,*L'<@A*WED4A'%E =
@A*L+ %1,Ev46(0*;Xα(I<'%!X(0!#o.R4ZNH(0E#<;#;#d!#%.R46EX(0N Z461L'<@A*?ED4A'%E%*L @A*'%EX()@A*UB,d.R4-NW(0E#<;#;DoB,<;"'<@A!X+;f
U α = H ∗α (q)u
5 = 45e
` Cm m
r α = H α (q)Rα
5 = 46e
` Cm m
5 = 4=
X
α α
H : R = [R , α = 1..nc ] → r = H α (q)Rα
α ` Cm m We
Xnc
H ∗α : u = [ui , i = 1..nddl ] → U = H ∗α (q)u
α
{
<;9NH(0E#<;#;#<;!#%.R46EX(0N <;o;#@A*?E9!#%.0()I<<;o461CGU!#I>4A'%EX()@A*;d.)@H'>46.)<; α +n46!.)<;9.)@A();9BK (0*?E#I%!D4A'%EX()@A*;3OW(0uJ*@A!X(0*,(s%E
R
TV@A1,.)@A$gS
m
5 = 4=
{
<;"!#%.R46EX()@A*;'%(0*I%$h46EX()q?1<; Cm m 3;>KiI<'%!X(0N %*WE
α
Ui+1
α
= H ∗α (q̂)ui+1
α α
5 = 4>e
` Cm m
ri+1 =H (q̂)Ri+1
{4-NA46!X(R46S,.) B,I<;X(0uJ*o.R4j'<@A*CpuJ1,!D46EX()@A*5qW1,(
;#%!XEvwjB,I%E#%!X$-(0*%!v.)<;v!#%+Ol%!#<;8.)@H'>461CGc
q̂
q̂ = qi + h(1 − θ)q̇i
5 = 48e
` Cm m
α
(ġα )i+1 = UN
5 = 4;
` Cm m Je
2 +2
1H
"
*)'
1M"
*)G&&"%0 1 -/"-&
{4j @A!X$&oBC();#'%!#l%E#B,o.R4j'<@A*BC(0EX()@A*B,gW(0uJ*@A!X(0*,(;>KiI<'%!X(0E
Rα (i + 1) = 0
5 = 4Ae
` Cm m
QP
W
H ~ , 3
C461C;X(1,*U'<@A*WED4A'%E<;XE"I%ED46S,.0(b=n46.)@A!#;@A*U4\
α
UN (i + 1) ≥ 0, α
RN (i + 1) ≥ 0, α
UN α
(i + 1)RN (i + 1) = 0
5=4
` Cm m e
{4j @A!X$&oBC();#'%!#l%E#B,o.R4j'<@A*BC(0EX()@A*B,gW(0uJ*@A!X(0*,(;>KiI<'%!X(0E
α
Signor(UN α
(i + 1), RN (i + 1))
5 = 75
` Cm m J e
2 +2
M "-
*H'IJ,"
*
:H'
H'
@
*\b46(0E81,*f;XH*?EX:l<;DoB,<;"BC(_^ I%!#%*WE#<;I<qW1n46EX()@A*;vBC1\$&@HB,l%.)&
sqW1n46EX()@A*;vBC1\$&@A1,N %$&%*?Ej
•
M(ui+1 − ui ) = h[(1 − θ)Pi + θPi+1 ] + hri+1
qi+1 − qi = h[(1 − θ)ui + θui+1 ]
v%.R46EX()@A*;"B,f+n4A;#;D46u -
•
α = H ∗α (q̂)u
Ui+1 i+1
ri+1 = α H α (q̂)Ri+1α
P
[9!D46+,:<;"B,<;v.)@A();"B,o'<@A*?ED4A'%EZ
•
Signor(UN α (i + 1), Rα (i + 1))
N
Coulµα RαN (i+1) (UTα (i + 1), RTα (i + 1))
{4d;D@A.01,EX()@A*hB,F*@AEX!#F+,!#@AS,.)l%$&vB,@A(0EN I%!X(_pn%!s1,*&;#H;XE#l%$&8BKiI<qW1n46EX()@A*;sB,F.R4dBCH*n46$-()q?1"uJ.)@ASn46.)` Cm m e
%EFB,<;V.)@A();VBK (0*WE#I%!D4A'%EX()@A*;8.)@H'>46.)<;d` qW1n4A;X(_'D:@W'fW(0uJ*@A!X(0*,(b=W !#@AEXE#%$&%*WE"B,dTV@A1,.)@A$gSem, *P1,EX(0.0();D46*?E8.)<;/!#
5 = 4> 5=4
.R46EX()@A*;'%(0*I%$h46EX()q?1<;Z` Cm m e8%E8.R4Z@A!X$&oBC();#'%!#I%EX();#I<fB,f.bKiI<q?1n46EX()@A*UB,f.R4jBCW*n46$-()qW1h` Cm m e=n@A*U4L
X
U α (i + 1) = Ufαree + W αβ hRβ (i + 1)
β 5 = 7505 e
` Cm m
Ufαree =H ∗α
(ui + M −1
P (i))
αβ ∗α −1 β
W =H M H
4>N <'J=
9@A+OI%!D46E#%1,!B,f]d%.R4A;#;X1;>=
α
Uf ree
!#%+,!#I<;#%*?E#.R4ZNA46.)%1,!vB,
U α (i + 1)
em
%*L;X1,+,+ @J;D46*?Ev.)<;8(0$-+,1,.);X()@A*;vB,'<@A*?ED4A'%E#;"*W1,.0.)<;g` d
Q
z ? ~n
n
{
fE#%!X$& α <;#E"B,Ip*,(0Ev+n46!f
Ulocf ree
α
Ulocf α
ree = Uf ree +
X
W αβ hRβ (i + 1) 5 = 751=
` Cm m We
β6=α
{
+,!#@AS,.)l%$&oB,oW(0uJ*@A!X(0*,(b=nTV@A1,.)@A$SL;#vEX!D4ABC1,(0EV+n46!F1,*Y;XC;XE#l%$&BKiI<qW1n46EX()@A*;8@P(0.O;>KM46uJ(0E8B,EX!#@A1,N % !
U
%E E#%.);vqW1-
R
5 = 750> e
α α αα
U = Ulocf ree + W hRα
` Cm m
α α
Signor(UN , RN )
CoulµRαN (UTalpha , RTα )
5 = 750>
{sKi%*;D%$S,.)vB,F'<<;sI<qW1n46EX()@A*; Cm m d;#F'<@A$-+ @J;#8BK 1,*F@A!X$&F.0(0*I>46!X();#I<8B,F.bKiI<qW1n46EX()@A*hB,V.R4dBCW*n46$-()qW1
B,@A*,*n46*WE.R4&NW(0E#<;#;Df!#%.R46EX(0N j461'>46*BC()B46E '<@A$-$&g1,*o@A*'%EX()@A*t4&*ZB,;D@A*U(0$-+,1,.);X()@A*5%EvB,<;!#%.R4
α
EX()@A*;"B,'<@A*?ED4A'%E" !#@AEXED46*?E>m
5 75 6 76
<;#EZ1,*P$h46EX!X()'<\B,YBC(0$&%*;X()@A*` C= eZ@A1` C= eg%EZ.)<;ZE#%!X$&<; = %E ;#@A*WE-B,<;jN <'%E#%1,!#;
46+,+n46!XE#%*n46*WEdw 2 @A1 3 ;D%.)@A*Uq?1d.)d+,!#@AS,.)l%$&g<;XEvwjB,%1CGL@A1\EX!#@AU();vR BC(0$&%*U;X()locf
@A*;~ree
m
R R
*L+ %1,E"@AS,E#%*,(0!vGC+,.0()'%(0E#%$&%*?E91,*f;#@A.01,EX()@A*LuJ!DA'<gwZ1,*o(0*?E#%!#;#<'%EX()@A*tB,ouJ!D46+,:<;>m
@ *L+ @J;#9.R4j$h46EX!X()'< ` @A+ I%!D46E#%1,!B,o]d%.R4A;#;X1;¡e9
W αα
=
WTαα
T WTαα
N
, α
hRlocstick = −W αα−1 Ulocf
α 5 = 7508 e
` Cm m
WNααT WNααN ree
−1 < −µ
WNααT
<1
5 = 75;
` Cm m Je
WNααN
Q Y
W
H ~ , 3
W(b=
α =
• Ulocf reeN > 0
46.)@A!#;8+n4A;'<@A*?ED4A'%EZ %E m
hRN = 0 hRT = 0
α %E α α =
• Ulocf reeN ≤ 0 (Rlocstick )T + µ(Rlocstick )N < 0
46.)@A!#;8(0.Y4ZuJ.0();#;D%$&%*?E8 !#@AEXED46*?Ed4<NJ46*?Eg α =− 1 α %E
hRN W αα Ulocf reeN RTα = −µRN
α
(1−µ W N T αα
)WN
αα N
%E =
NN
α
• Ulocf α α
reeN ≤ 0 (Rlocstick )T − µ(Rlocstick )N > 0
46.)@A!#;8(0.Y4ZuJ.0();#;D%$&%*?E8 !#@AEXED46*?Ed46!X!X()l%!#& α =− 1 α %E
hRN W αα Ulocf ree RTα = µRN
α
(1+µ W N T αα
)WN
αα N
%E %E
NN
α
• Ulocf α α
reeN ≤ 0 (Rlocstick )T + µ(Rlocstick )N ≥ 0 RT − µRN ≤ 0
46.)@A!#;8*@A*CbuJ.0();D;#%$&%*?Ej
Rα = Rlocstick
α
0
!
0
¢4A;vB,f'<@A*WED4A'%E
−µ
[9.0();D;#%$&%*?E4>NA46*WE
TV@A*BC(0EX()@A*B,W(0uJ*@A!X(0*,( [9!D46+,:fB,ZTV@A1,.)@A$S
5Cm 4 8 I<;#@A.01,EX()@A*UBC1L+,!#@AS,.)l%$&fB,'<@A*?ED4A'%E" !#@AEXED46*?E;XED46*B46!#BL%*O5A]
2 £ H'
&M, £
), 1 M
L O&"% 1 -/"-&*
/"-)"%:
5Cm = m750-> <;XE8!#I<I<'%!X(0Ev;#@A1;".R4Z @A!X$&d$-(_GCE#&
{ ;XH;#E#l%$&
5 = 750A e
α α αα α
U − Ulocf ree − W hR = 0
` Cm m
α α α
RN − projR+ (RN − ρ N UN )=0
α
RT − proj(DµRαN ) (RT − ρN UTα ) = 0
α
QQ
z ? ~n
n
2.4.28 ⇔ φ(U α , Rα ) = 0
5 = 75
` Cm m J e
@ <;XE81,*d@A*'%EX()@A*,*%.0.)f*@A*Cb.0(0*I>46(0!#Jm
φ
E#@A*u I%*I
{
<;!D4A'%(0*<;9B,'<%EXE#ZI<q?1n46EX()@A**@A*Cb.0(0*I>46(0!#Z;D@A*?EdB,@A*''>46.)'%1,.)I<<;9+n46!v1,*546.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&ZB,g 8
!D46.0();#Ig461CG3@A*'%EX()@A*;"*@A*Cb!#I%uJ1,.0()l%!#<;j` kv.R46!XE"%EdT/1,!X*,()%!g` eXem 4 0A0A
¥Æ¥
Ëu=
+ 9N a~ º + t
] 46*;F'<%EXE#9+n46!XEX()J=W@A*Y+,!#%*BY%*P'<@A$-+,E#9.bKM4ABC:I%!#%*'<oB46*;V.)9'>4ABC!#9B,.R4$&I%EX:@WB,do,TV]Z=H%*Y'<@A*;X()B,I
o
k8'>46!X
5 4
!D46*WEv'#:n4AqW1f+ @A(0*?EvB,o'<@A*WED4A'%E'<@A$-$&o1,*f>@A*f'<@A:I<;X(0N Jm
5 4 5 4
46.` k8'>46!X` JJ e=?k8'>46!X&%EV >46*c` JJ eXe%E/2t@A*%!X()
5
5 4
46.|` xV!#%E#%.0.)9%EV46.bmn` JJ e=H >46*Y%EV46.bm
` JJ e=CxV!#%E#%.0.)%E846.bm ` JJJ eXe@A*WEF+,!#@A+O@J;#I1,*v @A!X$g1,.R46EX()@A*LBCW*n46$-()qW1%EV1,*!#I<;#@A.01,EX()@A*Y*?1,$&I%!X()qW1
BC1P+,!#@AS,.)l%$&o4<N <'dB,<;>@A*<;F'<@A:I<;X(0N <;V !#@AEXED46*?E#<;~mH{v$&@HB,l%.)v(0*WEX!#@WBC1,(0EF1,*NA46!X(R46S,.) q?1,(!#%+,!#I<;#%*?E#
4
.bK (0*WE#%*;X(0E#IoBKM4ABC:I<;X()@A*
=;D4NJ46.)%1,!"<;XEV'<@A$-+,!X();Do%*?EX!#fZ%E m,TV%EXE#dNJ46!X(R46S,.)f4ZI%E#IdB,Ip*,β()d+n46!F!#I%$&@A*B
` ,!#%$&@A*BQ` eXem 4 0A05
¢|@A1,!>=
.R4Z>@A*fB,'<@A*?ED4A'%E<;#E8NW()%!Xu J=
•β=1⇒
.R4Z>@A*fB,'<@A*?ED4A'%E<;#E8!#@A$-+,1J=
•β=0⇒
.R4j>@A*B,o'<@A*?ED4A'%E<;#E8+n46!XEX()%.0.)%$&%*?E9!#@A$-+,1Jm
• 0 < β < 1⇒
@ * BC(0!D4jqW1o.R4ZNJ46!X(R46S,.) + %1,E%EX!#4A;#;#@H'%()I<fwZ1,*oNJ46!X(R46S,.)fBKi%*B,@A$-$h46u %$&%*?E>m
U
β
{
f$&@WB,l%.)f'<@A*;#()B,l%!#wZ.R4Z @A();F.)f'<@A*?ED4A'%E1,*,(0.R46E#I%!D46.b=.)9 !#@AEXE#%$&%*?E;D<'oB,gTV@A1,.)@A$St%E8.bKM4ABC:I<;X()@A*
m
{
'<@A*?ED4A'%E'<@A:I<;#(_|+ %1,E";>KiI<'%!X(0!#f'<@A$-$&o1,*'<@A*BC(0EX()@A*B,o'<@A$-+,.)I%$&%*?ED46!X(0E#Ij%E81,*o.)@A(B,9 !#@AEXE#%$&%*WE
<
B,d.R4Zb4 <@A*U;X1,(0NJ46*?E#Jm
{4&'<@A*BC(0EX()@A*;X1,!8.)<;8NJ46!X(R46S,.)<;8*@A!X$h46.)<;9BC1L'<@A$-+O@A!XE#%$&%*WE9B,o'<@A*WED4A'%Ev*@A!X$h46.|;>KiI<'%!X(0E"B,@A*'&
@
=
!#%+,!#I<;#%*WE#f.)f;D461,E"B,B,I%+,.R4A'<%$&%*?Ev*@A!X$h46.b=
[|uN |]
!#%+,!#I<;D%*?E#f.R4-!#I>4A'%EX()@A*L*@A!X$h46.)g461L'<@A*WED4A'%E>=
RN
!#%+,!#I<;#%*WE#f.bK (0*WE#%*;X(0E#IBKM4ABC:I<;X()@A*
=
β
.R4Z!D46()B,%1,!v(0*?E#%!
b4A'%(R46.)f*@A!X$h46.)J=:@A$&@Au l%*gwZ1,*L$&@HBC1,.)fBKiI%.R4A;XEX()'%(0E#Io+n46!v1,*,(0E#IfB,o.)@A*,uJ1%1,!>m
cN
W
H ~ , 3
*I<'%!X(0NA46*WE".)f'#:n46*,u %$&%*WE9B,dNJ46!X(R46S,.)&
R̃N = RN + β 2 cN [|uN |]
5 = 76 4 e
` Cm m
RT = RTr + RTir
5 = 7606 e
` Cm m
RTir
UT
kUT k ≥ 0, kRTir k = µ(β)(RN + β 2 cN [|uN |]), ir
=− ,
kRT k kUT k
kUT k = 0, kRTir k < µ(β)(RN + β 2 cN [|uN |])
@
=
!#%+,!#I<;#%*?E#.R4j'<@A*?EX!X(0S,1,EX()@A*5BC1\ !#@AEXE#%$&%*WE;#<'oB,TV@A1,.)@A$gStwj.R4Z!#I>4A'%EX()@A*ED46*,u %*?EX()%.0.)Jm
RTir
!#%+,!#I<;#%*?E#.R4jNW(0E#<;D;#9ED46*,u %*?EX()%.0.)J=
UT
{4&'<@A*?EX!X(0S,1,EX()@A*5B,d.bKM4ABC:I<;X()@A* r =
RT = −β 2 cT [|uT |]
!#%+,!#I<;#%*?E#.)f;D461,E"B,oB,I%+,.R4A'<%$&%*?E9ED46*,u %*?EX()%.b=
[|uT |]
.R4j!D46()B,%1,!"(0*WE#%!
4A'%(R46.)ED46*,u %*?E#J=:@A$&@Au l%*wj1,*\$&@HBC1,.)fBKiI%.R4A;XEX()'%(0E#I+n46!"1,*,(0E#IfB,d.)@A*,uJ1%1,!>m
cT
*I<'%!X(0NA46*WE".)f'#:n46*,u %$&%*WE9B,dNJ46!X(R46S,.)&
R̃T = RT + β 2 cT [|uT |]
5 = 761=
` Cm m We
@
=
SL<;XE81,*fNW();#'<@J;#(0E#IJ=
!#%+,!#I<;#%*WE#o.bKiI%*%!XuJ()oBC();#;X(0+ I<oB46*;F.)d+,!#@H'<<;#;X1;8B,o'<@A:I<;X()@A*Uwg.bKiG,'<%+,EX()@A*UB,dE#@A1,E#oBC();#;X(0+n46EX()@A*\NH();
qW1%1;#&` .R4j.0(0$-(0E#fB,f.bKiI%*%!XuJ()fB,fB,I<'<@A:I<;X()@A*e=
+\1,*U%*WEX()%!B,I%E#%!X$-(0*n46*WEv.R4j+,1,();#;¡46*'<fB,d.R4j.)@A(
B,fBC();#;#(0+n46EX()@A*U;X1,! =
<;XE"1,*9@A*'%EX()@A*Uq?1,(+O%!X$&%E"B,o+n46!D46$&I%EX!#%!.R4g @A!X$&B,o.bKiI%*%β̇!XuJ()fBC();#;X(0+ I<o%*\@A*'%EX()@A*UB, =
h(β) β
J
z ? ~n
n
Y<;XE81,*f'<@A*;XED46*WE#o:@A$&@Au l%*gw-1,*oI%*%!XuJ()Jm
{ f$&@WB,l%.)4>N <'f'<@A:I<;X()@A*U;DdEX!D4ABC1,(0E"+n46!"1,*U;XC;XE#l%$&oBKiI<qW1n46EX()@A*;v;X1,(0NJ46*?Eg
5 = 76;
α α αα
U = Ulocf ree + W hRα
` Cm m Je
φN (UN , R̃N )
φT (UT , R̃T )
<;XE8!#I<I<'%!X(0E;#@A1;8.R4Z@A!X$&d$-(_GHE#h
5 = 760A e
U α − Ulocf
α
ree − W
αα
hRα = 0
` Cm m
α α α
R̃N − projR+ (R̃N − ρ N UN )=0
R̃α − proj
α (R̃
α
− ρ U α) = 0
T (DµRN ) T N T
¥Æ¥
Æ Æ* u Æ < ®' [ dT + º N a [t@ 9
qÌ ;V ¾)
{4c+,!X();#\%*z'<@A$-+,E#LB,\.bKM4ABC:I%!#%*'<B46*;&.)<;-+,!#@AS,.)l%$&<;3B,L'<@A*?ED4A'%Eh !#@AEXED46*WEh;#Y!#I>46.0();#wt.bKM46()B,UB,
'D:n46*,u %$&%*?EdB,oNA46!X(R46S,.)h
R̃ = R + Radh , Radh
<;XE81,*o @A!#'<fB,d!#I<;#();XED46*'<f;X1,+,+,.)I%$&%*WED46(0!#
.
5 = 76
` Cm m J e
4>N <'J=
2 %E =
R̃N = RN + RadhN
%E RadhN = β2 cN [|uN |]
R̃T = RT + RadhT RadhT = β cT [|uT |]
*^ <'%EX1n46*WEv1,*L'#:n46*,u %$&%*WE9B,fNA46!X(R46S,.)o+ @A1,!Fb46(0!#46+,+n46!D4 )EX!# R̃
U α − Ulocf
α
ree − W
αα
h(R̃α − Radh
α
)=0
5==
` Cm m ? e
*I<'%!X(0NA46*WE".R4jNH(0E#<;#;#d.)@H'>46.)d.0(0S,!#h` $&@WBC(_pnI<f+n46!".R4-'<@A:I<;X()@A*eV+n46!g
α
Ũlocf α
ree = Ulocf ree − W
αα α
hRadh
5 = =4e
` Cm m
@ 5 = 76 E#@A*C
* @AS,EX()%*WE1,*g;XH;#E#l%$&sI<q?1,(0NJ46.)%*?E461+n46!D46uJ!D46+,:d` Cm m Cm SeqW1,(?;#!#I<;D@A1Bo+n46!1,*g46.0u @A!X(0EX$&VB,s9 8
u I%*I%!D46.0();#IJm
&2
~ , n n
Q
Å º
<
{
<;f$&I%EX:@WB,<;gB,j!#I<;#@A.01,EX()@A* ;X+ I<'%(_pnq?1<;g461CGt$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;gB,I%+O%*B,%*WEgB,j.bKiI<'#:%.0.)3'<@A*;X()B,I%!#I<Jm
k(0*;X(b=
.)<;8!#I<;#1,.0ED46E#;"+ %1,N %*?E"*o+n4A; %EX!#o+,!#I<'%();"@A1L$ %$&fB,%N %*,(0!9'<@A*?E#<;XED46S,.)<;~m
k .bKiI<'#:%.0.)$h4A'%!#@J;#'<@A+,()q?1J='JKi<;XE
wBC(0!#gwZ.bKiI<'D:%.0.)B,o.R4&;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#J=,.R4-B,<;#'%!X(0+,EX()@A*U$&I<'>46*,()q?1g<;XE8uJ.)@6
<
Sn46.)Jm{4U$h4 <@A*,*%!X()\<;XEj'<@A*;X()B,I%!#I<\'<@A$-$&P1,*$h46E#I%!X(R461 :@A$&@Au l%*Y%Ej.bKi@ASC
<'%EX(_9<;XEZB,PB,Ip*,(0!-1,*
'%!X(0E#l%!#jB,Z!X1,+,EX1,!#j+O@A!XED46*WEf;X1,!dB,<;uJ!D46*B,%1,!#;f$h4A'%!#@J;#'<@A+,()q?1<;~mk '<%EXE#jI<'#:%.0.)J= (0.GH();#E#EX!#@A();dEW+ <;
B,d$&@HB,I%.0();D46EX()@A*BK 1,*;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#&
f.)<;j$&@HB,l%.)<;&B,PEH+O\982QmTV<;j$&@WB,l%.)<;&;D@A*?E-Sn4A;#I<;-;X1,!&B,<;j:WW+ @AEX:l<;#<;j@A!X$1,.)I<<;h+n46! %H$h46*
4 0808
` 9%W$h46*,*a` eXe=
.)<;:?H+O@AEX:l<;#<;g1,EX(0.0();#I<<;g;#@A*?Eg!#<;XEX!X()'%EX(0N <;g%E.)%1,!#;f@A!X$1,.R46EX()@A*;g$h46EX:I%$h46EX()q?1<;
;#@A*WE4A;#;#%f'<@A$-+,.)G,<;>m
".)-$&@HB,l%.)&I%.R4A;XE#@6b+,.R4A;#EX()q?1 +,!X();#&%* '<@A$-+,E#&B,&.bKM46*,();#@AEX!#@A+,()h%EfB,-.bKi%*B,@A$-$h46u %$&%*WE&461r*,(0N >461
B,<;8(0*WE#%!
4A'<<;~m
<
*v!#<'D:%!#'#:fGC+ I%!X(0$&%*?ED46.)f<;XEV*I<'<<;#;D46(0!#9+ @A1,!8'<@A*,*n4 )EX!#d.)<;V'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();#EX()q?1<;8$&I<'>46*,()qW1<;8B,<;V$h4
E#I%!X(R461CGc%$-+,.)@> I<;>m]d46*;d.)jB,@A$h46(0*&B,<;d$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;~=
B46*;o.)<;#qW1%.0.)<;d.R4PBC();#'<@A*?EX(0*W1,(0E#I&+,:?C;X()qW1-<;XE
I%NH()B,%*?E#J='<<;8$&@WB,I%.0();¡46EX()@A*;"$h4A'%!#@J;#'<@A+,()qW1<;"*f;D@A*?E"+n4A;v4AB46+,E#I<<;~m
C
46+,+,!#@H'#:-$h4A'%!#@A$&I<'>46*,()qW1 $-()'%!#@A$&I<'>46*,()qW1\@c.)-$&@WB,l%.)-'<@A*WEX(0*?1};#ZSn4A;#-;X1,!o.bK :@A$&@Au I%*I%();D46EX()@A*
+ I%!X()@WBC()qW1Jm,TV%EXE#v:@A$&@Au I%*I%();D46EX()@A*\'<@A*;X();#E#9wB,Ip*,(0!V1,*379 ` 7s@A.01,$&d .)I%$&%*WED46(0!#ov%+,!#I<;#%*WED46EX(_em
{
d7d s<;#E8!#%+,!#I<;#%*?ED46EX(_sB,<;F:I%E#I%!#@Au I%*I%(0E#I<;9B,d.R4j;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#Jm,{sK (0*'<@A*?N I%*,()%*WE9<;#E"B,oB,Ip*,(0!"'<@A!X!#<'%E#
$&%*WE".R4jED46(0.0.)fBC1L7d sgm
.)v$&@WB,l%.)vBC();#'%!#%E/<;XE+n46!
46(0E#%$&%*WE84AB46+,E#Iv+O@A1,!/;X(0$1,.)%!V.)"'<@A$-+ @A!XE#%$&%*?E8%Es.bKiI%N @A.01,EX()@A*YBCW*n46$-()qW1
BK 1,*Y%*;#%$S,.)9B,"+n46!XEX()'%1,.)<;V!X(0uJ()B,<;FB,"ED46(0.0.)<;VBC(_^I%!#%*?E#<;>=,4<?46*WEF1,*"u I<@A$&I%EX!X()d'<@A*?N G,v(0*WE#I%!D46uJ();#;D46*WE
+n46!v'<@A*WED4A'%E>m
<
]o46*;-1,*\$h4 <@A*,*%!X()J=.R45B,I%E#<'%EX()@A*B,<;&'<@A*WED4A'%E#;h<;XE-EX!#l<;&(0$-+O@A!XED46*WE#<;3%* NH1\B,Y.R45$&@HB,I%.0();D46EX()@A*
B,<;F(0*WE#%!D4A'%EX()@A*;"+ @A*'%EX1%.0.)<;>=,.0(0*I>46(0!#<;"@A1\+,.R46*<;>mC *L^%E>=,'<%EXE#oB,I%E#<'%EX()@A*U'<@A*BC(0EX()@A*,*o.R4jqW1n46.0(0E#IoBC1
'>46.)'%1,.B,;XED46S,(0.0(0E#IfB,<;";XEX!X1'%EX1,!#<;~m
]o46*;9.)'D:n46+,(0EX!#-;X1,(0NA46*WE>=@A*t+,!#@A+ @J;#1,*t*@A1,N %.46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&-B,gB,I%E#<'%EX()@A*cB,<;9'<@A*?ED4A'%E#;>=O(0$-+,.)I%$&%*?E#I
B46*;.)v'<@WB,8B,"'>46.)'%1,.{
25[TFJCmWTV8*@A1,N %.46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&v+,!#%*B&%*&'<@A$-+,E#"E#@A1,E#<;.)<;;X+OI<'%(_pn'%(0E#I<;/BK 1,*
<
$h4 <@A*,*%!X()Jm
£Y
z ? ~n
n
'
9 2#"-<g4-0g£*3#"!6c"!7!I*,1z-R*3@1E"!$'({[</))#u"! .66.6.66.6.66.6.66 i
XP;=:<;=: rL[?,wK\uL[?3AoCRwKZ0Y<HmJ=Dm¤[B7?3A«v Y0LPHowKC7nNFIDm?,klDmJKY0O nN?3A
klY<O<DQC0klDGA ;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U;:'0§
XP;=:<; W v[v[HGY"kQ¤P?UkQ¤PY0J]AJK?;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U;:<:0:
9b8 yU1z#<Qcd#u*,"-0*,g&/ )cd"!$-</)+*3{[-R*3!76.66.6.66.6.66.6.66.6.66 [8
9]9 #u*,"-0*,g&/ )Âe 4)+e
c"!$-0/ )+*,{[-0*,!5!,2#"-0g {[ ©'({[</))<1Egu!6.6.66 N9
XP; XP;=: J]Am?T?IO
v[wKC<kl?Tn L[Opv[w]CRO AF,vPCRHQCEDG?IL[HvPC0HwKC7B7FlDG¤[YNnN?nN?ª«L[OPnPCRwKw³;T;T;U;T;U;:<:,X
XP; XP; W w=Z<Y0HGJtDG¤[B7?Vv Y0LPHovYuAJ=DmJKY0O[OP?IHowK?Tv[wKC0O
AmFIvCRHQCEDm?,L[H|;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U;:<:I
XP; XP; W[; C ½¾OPJtDGJKC0w=J]AmCRDmJKY0O ;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U;:<:I
XP; XP; W[; µ ª±C0wKkIL[wnN?3AonNJKADGC0OPkl?3AonN?,A AY<B6B7?IDGA ;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U;:<:I
XP; XP; W[; k JKAm?U?IOpv[w]C0kl?TnN?Uv ?IHmDmL[HGµPCRDmJKY0OPA ;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U;:<:3
XP; XP; W[; n dHQCROPAmwKCRDmJKY0O
nNL v Y0JKOuD nN?THGFl¿£FIHG?IOkl? ;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U;:<:zx
XP; XP; W[; ? w=Z<Y0HGJtDG¤[B7?TnN?UvYuAJ=DmJKY0O[OP?IB7?IOuD nNLpv[w]CROpAF,vPCRHQCEDG?IL[H ;T;U;T;T;U;T;U;:<:,¸
XP; XP; X ·HGYRÁ?3kDGJ=Y<O
nN?3AoAY<B7B6?IDGA
AmL[HowK?Uv[wKC0O AF,vPCRHQCEDG?IL[H ;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U;:<:,§
XP; XP; XP; C ª«Y<OuDGC0klDVÁY<J=OuDo`"Jt¿p;T;U;T;U;T;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U;:<:,§
XP; XP; XP; µ ª«Y<OuDGC0klDVÁY<J=OuD
nN?TB7Y0HmDmJK?IH ;V;T;T;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U;:zW0W
9K {P%&-0%cd %=")+"%/P22p-0/ )+ .66.6.66.6.66.6.66.6.66 N8P
XP; ;=: FIDm¤[YNnN?TL[DmJKw=J]AF,?TvY<L[HowK?kICRw]klLPwnN?Uw ?IO"`0?,w=Y<v[v ?UkIY0O"`0?IMN? ;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U;:zWE
XP; ; W qrFlDG?IHGB6JKOPCRDmJKY0O nN?UwK
C ,Y0O[?TnN?UHG?,kIY0L[`"HG?IB7?IOuDr;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U;:zWR_
9b
2/ %&/ g&pcd"!$!3g£*3d{N*3g&/ )d!6c-0/ )+*,{[-0*,!6.66.6.66.6.66.6.66 N8
9]i %7={P1E% g /Pg&)1Eg£{['* %&dg&*,'~# c%¢cd{ "!7'~!,/*Icd1Ed#"%-0g&*,!3d{N1E*,u!g/7)~1E#"2d"%1E&/%u!26/!3")#" 9Pu* 5."'6.246%&"!66.c6K{N.226%6g&-0.{[*,6g&/ .)6c6 N8
XP; _P;=: !uDGHmLkDmLPHm?3AHmF,?IwKw=?3Ao.Z<HGC0OPn O[Y0B.µ[Hm?UnN?Tµ[wKYNkIAo;U;T;U;T;U;T;T;U;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U;:zWR§
XP; _P; W !uDGHmLkDmLPHm?3AHmF,?IwKw=?3Av[HmF3klY<O<DGHGC0J=OuDG?,Ar¯[?,AGkIC0w=JK?IHooJ]nNY0w ?lD kIY0L[v °0wK?TnN? 0L[OC0A ;U;:3X<W
XP; _P; X !uDGHmLkDmLPHm?C<kIC0n[FIB7JK\uL[?VJKB6vPw=J]\uLPCROuD
L[O[?TF,vPCRJ]AGA?,L[HonN?±ÁY0JKO<D³;T;V;T;U;T;T;U;T;U;:3X0_
9bº / )-0%&!3g&/ ) 6.6.66.6.76.66.6.66.6.66.6.66.6.66 "9+º
R n 3 O |
W
?
C
n3
{4B,I%E#<'%EX()@A*PB,<;V'<@A*?ED4A'%E#;V%*?EX!#9B,%1CGh'<@A!X+;V<;XEs(0$-+ @A!XED46*?E#9+O@A1,!V4A;#;X1,!#%!.R4;XED46S,(0.0(0E#I"$&I<'>46*,()qW19B,".R4
<
$h4 <@A*,*%!X()Jm .,<;XEB,@A*'F(0*BC();X+ %*;D46S,.)8q?1F.bKM46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&vB,I%E#<'%E#FS,()%*-.)<;$-(0.0.0()%!#;sB,8'<@A*?ED4A'%E#;sGC();XED46*WE#;
B46*;91,*Z;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#j'<@A$-+,.)l%E#Z'<@A$-$&j'JKi<;XE9.)Z'>4A;+n46!dG,%$-+,.)g+ @A1,!9.)+ @A*?EdJ1,.0()%*
m
TV%EXE#j;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#
'<@A$-+ @A!XE#o1,*LuJ!D46*B\*@A$gS,!#B,dS,.)@H'<;"%Ev;D4ZE#%*W1f<;XEvB,I%$&@A*WEX!#I<B,%+,1,();B,<;";X()l<'%.)<;>m
{
S,1,EB,/'<s'#:n46+,(0EX!#F<;XEB,+,!#I<;#%*?E#%!|1,**@A1,N %.C46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&FB,sB,I%E#<'%EX()@A*ZB,<;|'<@A*?ED4A'%E#;%*WEX!#s+ @A.0 l<BC!#<;
<
'<@A*WN GC<;!X(0uJ()B,<;EX!X(_BC(0$&%*;#()@A*,*%.);4AB46+,E#IV461CGf;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#<;$h4 <@A*,*I<<;|%*uJ!D46*BZ46+,+n46!#%(0.b=>$&@A*WE#I<<;4>N <'
BC1P.0(R46*?E"@A1\w8X@A(0*?E#;FNH(_;>m?.+ %!X$&%E8B,B,I%E#%!X$-(0*%!";~K (0.34g'<@A*?ED4A'%E"%*WEX!#oB,%1CG3'<@A!X+;F%E8B46*;V'<9'>4A;8B,
B,@A*,*%!"B,<;F(0*C@A!X$h46EX()@A*;8*I<'<<;#;D46(0!#<;8%E8;X1Ch;¡46$-$&%*?E"+,!#I<'%();#<;"4p*\B,d+ @A1,N @A(0!F!#I<;#@A1BC!#d.)9+,!#@AS,.)l%$&Jm
TV<;8(0*C@A!X$h46EX()@A*;9;#@A*?Ef
s.)<;"'<@H@A!#B,@A*,*I<<;9B46*;8.bKi<;X+n4A'<fB,oEX!D4>NA46(0.BC1L@A1UB,<;8+ @A(0*?E#;vB,o'<@A*WED4A'%E#;>=
s.)o!#%+ l%!#d.)@H'>46.B,o'<@A*?ED4A'%E>m
C
]jK 1,*c+ @A(0*?EB,jNH1ju I<@A$&I%EX!X()q?1J=.)<;f'<@A*?ED4A'%E#;g;#@A*?Ef<;D;#%*?EX()%.0.)%$&%*WEZB,jEW+ Z4A'< ~b4A'<-%Eg46!#l%E# ~b4A'<Jm C
C C
TV%!XED46(0*<;;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#<;|+ %1,N %*?E|*I>46*,$&@A(0*;+,!#I<;D%*?E#%!B,<;'<@A*WED4A'%E#;|B,/EH+ /46!#l%E# A46!#l%E#F%E|46!#l%E# ~b4A'</qW1
.)d*@A1,N %.46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&g<;XE"'>46+n46S,.)B,du I%!#%!>mnkv+,!#l<;v4>N @A(0!v'<@A$-+n46!#If.)<;vBC(_^ I%!#%*WE#;46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&<;vGC();XED46*WE#;
%Eo!#%E#%*W1'<%!XED46(0*;B,j.)%1,!#;Z4<NJ46*?ED46u <;>=@A*r;#I%.)<'%EX()@A*,*h'<%!XED46(0*;g;#@A$-$&%E#;fB,<;o+ @A.0 l<BC!#<;%*cNH();
wbNH();>m
@ *c^<'%EX1Z%*;#1,(0E#j1,*g+,!#@6X<'%EX()@A*c+n46!XEX()'%1,.0()l%!#-B,j'<<;o;#@A$-$&%E#;o;X1,!9.)Z+,.R46*5B,j'<@A*WED4A'%E>=
B,g4 <@A*rw <
@AS,E#%*,(0!".)<;"*@W%1B,;B,o'<@A*?ED4A'%E#;>m
@ <
*L+,!#I<;D%*?E#%!D4-.bKM46+,+,.0()'>46EX()@A*tB,o'<%E46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&;#1,!8EX!#@A();v;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#<;v!#I<%.0.)<;8$h4 <@A*,*I<<;%E81,*'>4A;v4A'>4
B,I%$-()qW1Jm
P
OC
&>
O
U
C461;#;X(0* 5 1= 5 1=
46.3`bC461;D;X(0*y` JJ We=C461;#;X(0* %EU46.bmf` JJ WeXeY@A*?EUB,I%N %.)@A+,+ Ic1,* 46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&B,
B,I%E#<•'%EX()@A*tB,<;"'<@A& *?ED4A'%E#;Sn4A;#If;X1,!8.bK (0*WE#%!#;#<'%EX()@A*5B,<;"S,.)@H'<;>m,{
f;XC;XE#l%$&fB,dEX!X(%E".)f'#:@A(_GLB,<;v+O@A(0*WE#;vB,
'<@A*WED4A'%E#;VqW1
K (0.);/1,EX(0.0();#%*?E8%*?EX!#+ @A.0 l<BC!#<;V'<@A*WN GC<;/@A*'%EX()@A*,*v!#%.R46EX(0N %$&%*WEFS,()%*PqW1n46*B3@A*P<;XE/%*3+,!#I
C C
;#%*'<ZBKM46*,uJ.)<;9NW(_;g` <;D;#%*?EX()%.0.)%$&%*WEf'<@A*?ED4A'%E#;oB,fEW+ Z;#@A$-$&%E ~4A'<Z%E;D@A$-$&%E 6;#@A$-$&%E¡em.|'<@A*,*n46(0E
C
'<%+ %*B46*?EfqW1%.)q?1<;dBC(_h'%1,.0E#I<;fqW1n46*B5@A*c<;XE9%*5+,!#I<;#%*'<jB,j'<@A*?ED4A'%E#;B,gEW+ 4A'< ~b4A'<Z+O@A.0Hu @A*n46.)
<
`46+,+n46!#%(0.!#I%uJ1,.0()%!v%*L$h4 <@A*,*%!X()~em
@ *L+,!#I<;D%*?E#fB,%1CGL;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#<;v!#I<%.0.)<;8+O@A1,!v(0.0.01;XEX!#%!vB,%1CG\'>4A;"B,f'<@A*?ED4A'%E#;%*?EX!#S,.)@W'<;f
6 75
.R4UpuJ1,!# Cm C=!#%+,!#I<;D%*?ED46*?Eh.)<;&46!#l%*<;-B,3 )$&<;>=|$&@A*?EX!#Y1,* '<@A*?ED4A'%EhwhX@A(0*?E-B,P$&@A!XEX()%!L` %*C
'>4ABC!#•If;#1,!8.R4j+,:@AE#@?em
R n 3 O |
W
?
C
n3
•
6 76
R. 49puJ1,!# Cm C= !#%+,!#I<;#%*WED46*?EV.)"+ @A*?EBC1\[o46!#B= $&@A*WEX!#"1,*P'<@A*?ED4A'%E8wV
@A(0*WENH(_ ;#1,!s.)"uJ!D46*BP46+,+n46!#%(0.
` %*'>4ABC!#Ig;X1,!8.R4Z+,:@AE#@?em
<
{4BC(_h'%1,.0E#I9+O@A1,!/$&@WB,I%.0();#%!FB,"E#%.0.)<;V;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#<;F%*h$h4 <@A*,*%!X()9!#I<;X()B,B46*;.bKi@AS,E#%*WEX()@A*LBK 1,*h*@A$gS,!#
B,/+O@A(0*WE#;B,'<@A*?ED4A'%E#;s4AB46+,E#IF%E+,!#%*n46*?Es%*g'<@A$-+,E#V.)<;|;X+ I<'%(_pn'%(0E#I<;|BC1Z+,!#@AS,.)l%$&F'JKi<;XE
wBC(0!#V.)'<@A*WED4A'%E
C
B,dEW+ db4A'< ~4A'<J='<@A$-$&;#'#:I%$h46EX();#Ig;X1,!8.R4gpuJ1,!# Cm m 6=
Y
OC
&>
O
U
T @A*WED4A'%E9wX@A(0*?E"NH(_
V TV@A*WED4A'%E9wX@A(0*?EvB,o$&@A!XEX()%!
¢|@A.0 l<BC!#k*?ED46u @A*,();XE# ¢@A.0 l<BC!#Zk*?ED46u @A*,();XE#
+n46();#;D%1,!vBC1\$&@A!XEX()%!
Q
R n 3 O |
W
?
C
n3
%*WEX!#fB,%1CG\(0E#I%!D46EX()@A*;v;X1'<'<<;#;#(0N <;>=C.R4-BC();XED46*'<f%*WEX!#o.)<;vB,%1CG\'>46!D4A'%E#I%!X();XEX()qW1<;v'D:@A();X()<;vBC(0$-(0*W1Jm
TV%E46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&-*-B,@A*,*j.)<;oB,%1CG5+ @A(0*?E#;o.)<;d+,.01;o+,!#@H'#:<;q?1Z.)@A!#;#qW1j.)<;oB,%1CGt+ @A.0 l<BC!#<;f;#@A*WEf;#I
+n46!#I< ; (0.s*j@A*'%EX()@A*,*3qW1-+ @A1,!B,<;g+O@A.0 l<BC!#<;g'<@A*?N G,<;gqW1,(s*h;~K (0*?E#%!X+ I%*l%EX!#%*?Ej+n4A;>m
.s+ %1,E %EX!#
1,EX(0.0();#I+n46!9G,%$-+,.)f+ @A1,!v.R43B,I%E#<'%EX()@A*5B,f.R4&'<@A.0.0();#()@A*
=%*t'>46.)'%1,.R46*?Ed.R4&BC();XED46*'<Z%*?EX!#ZB,%1CGL+ @A.0 l<BC!#<;
G6%* A]j=B46*;8.)B,@A$h46(0*fB,o.R4Z!#@AS @AEX()q?1Jm
£ · r u ( 4 1=
« ¾Ì\ Æ . E , ¥ `b[o46!#'%(R4kv.)@A*;D@&%Ev46.bm` J WeXeV!#%+,!#I<;#%*?E#%*WEv.bKi@ASCX%E
+n46!"+,.01;#()%1,!#;8*,(0N >461CGr
.)o+,!#%$-()%!"*,(0N >461tB,o!#%+,!#I<;#%*WED46EX()@A*t<;XEv1,*L+n46!D46.0.)I%.)I%+,(0+Ol<B,gB,@A*?E.)<;8b4A'<%EXE#<;v;#@A*WE"+n46!D46.0.)l%.)<;9461CG
6
4G,<;gB,3'<@W@A!#B,@A*,*I<<;ZuJ.)@ASn46.)<;jBC1;#H;XE#l%$& A]jm|TV&+n46!D46.0.)I%.)I%+,(0+ l<B,Y<;XEZ46+,+ %.)I3SO@ )E#h$-(0*Cb$h4G ` N @A(0!
6 7>
puJ1,!# Cm e=
9 9
.)ZB,%1CGH()l%$&g*,(0N >4615B,!#%+,!#I<;#%*WED46EX()@A*c<;XEv.) %'<@A*?ED46(0*%! ZqW1,(|<;XE.)f+n46!D46.0.)I%.)I%+,(0+ l<B,Z$-(0*,(0$h46.qW1,(
'<@A*WEX()%*?Ev.)f+O@A.0 l<BC!#f%EB,@A*?E".)<;v4G,<;8+,!X(0*'%(0+n461CGL'<@ *'%()B,%*?E>=
.)YEX!#@A();X()l%$&Y*,(0N >461zB,Y!#%+,!#I<;#%*WED46EX()@A*<;XE-.R45B,I<'<@A$-+ @J;X(0EX()@A*zBC1y'<@A*WED46(0*%!3%* +,.01;X()%1,!#;&N @<G,%.);>m
TV%EXE#9B,I<'<@A$-+O@J;#(0EX()@A*P<;XE/$&@WB,I%.0();DI<v+n46!/1,*v$h46EX!X()'<EX!X(_BC(0$&%*;X()@A*,*%.0.)Jm *hN @<G,%. <;XEV46(0*;X( 4^ <'%E#I9B,
4
.R4ZNJ46.)%1,! ;>K (0.'<@A*WEX()%*?E1,*o+n46!XEX()fB,o.bKi@ASCX%E"@A1L.R4ZNJ46.)%1,!jB46*;".)o'>4A;'<@A*?EX!D46(0!#Jm
{
@A!#;Dq?1o.)<;vB,%1CGP+ @A.0 l<BC!#<;v;#@A*WE4A;#;#%fI%.)@A(0uJ*I<;~=,1,*U;X(0$-+,.)oE#<;#E8+O%!X$&%EvB,o'>46.)'%1,.)%!.R4jBC();XED46*'<%*WEX!#
.)%1,!#;8S @ )E#<;"$-(0*Cb$h4Gm 1n46*B\.)<;vSO@ )E#<;"$-(0*Cb$h4G\;D@A*?Ev%*L'<@A*WED4A'%E>=n.bKM46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&N I%!X(_pnf;X(.)<;"'<@A*WED46(_
*%!#;9;#@A*?E9%*U'<@A*?ED4A'%E>m ]o46*;v'<g'>4A;>=,.bKM46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&j'>46.)'%1,.)f.bK (0*WE#%!#;#<'%EX()@A*cB,'<<;B,%1CGU'<@A*?ED46(0*%!#;>mTV%EXE#
(0*WE#%!#;#<'%EX()@A*Q'<@A!X!#<;#+O@A*BQwLB,%1CGr%*;#%$S,.)<;jB,-N @>GC%.);~m¢|@A1,!Z'D:n4Aq?1P'<@A1,+,.)hB,hN @<G,%.);>=@A* B,I%E#<'%E#3.)
'<@A*WED4A'%E%*?EX!#%1CG\%E"@A*B,I%E#%!X$-(0*f.)<;Fb4A'<%EXE#<;"qW1,(
'<@A!X!#<;X+O@A*B,%*WE9w-'<<;"N @<G,%.);>m
'<@A*WED46(0*%!#;
S @ )E#<;8$-(0*Cb$h4G
G G
6 7>
Cm {<;"S @A(0E#<;"$-(0*Cb$h4G=,.)<;v'<@A*WED46(0*%!#;%E".)<;"N @<G,%.0();D46EX()@A*;>mnk.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&B,Z[o46!#'%(R4kv.)@A*;D@
4 1=
46.`b[o46!#'%(R4k.)@A*;#@3%Ev46.bm` J WeXe
£ · r 5 1=
« ¾Ì\ Æ£
tÆ `bC461;#;X(0*v` JJ WeXe
<;XE(0$-+,.)I%$&%*?E#IVB46*;
.)'<@WB,sB,'>46.)'%1,.H{
2c[fTFJCm
T %Ed46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&ZB,I%E#%!X$-(0*Z;>K (0.|GH();XE#1,*U+,.R46*E#%.qW1B,%1CGL+ @A.0 l<BC!#<;9;D@A()%*?E'<@A*WE#%*?1;oB46*;.)<;B,%1CG
V
B,%$-(_<;X+n4A'<<;9B,@A*?Ev(0. @A!X$&f.R4g !#@A*WEX()l%!#JmOTV%EXE#I%ED46+ d*o+ %!X$&%E"+n4A;vB,o;#ED46EX1%!;>K (0.\4-'<@A*?ED4A'%E$h46();
B,LB,I%E#%!X$-(0*%!P1,*LBC(0!#<'%EX()@A*+O@A1,!&.R4AqW1%.0.)L.bKi@~N %!X.R46+ %*WEX!#UB,%1CG + @A.0 l<BC!#<;h<;XE&.)L+,.01;&+ %EX(0E>m/TV%.R4
+ %!X$&%EVB,;#I%.)<'%EX()@A*,*%!V.)<;sb4A'<<;/B,<;/+ @A.0 l<BC!#<;/'>46*BC()B46E#<;"461P'<@A*?ED4A'%E>mC{
<;4A'<<;VI%ED46*?EFBC();#'%!#I%EX();#I<<;F%*
EX!X(R46*,uJ.)J=O.)Z'<@A*?ED4A'%Ef46+,+n46!D46(0Ed.)@A!#;#q?1g.bK (0*?E#%!#;D<'%EX()@A*rB,g'<<;EX!X(R46*,uJ.)<;o<;XEv*@A*5*W1,.bm TV%Ef46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&j<;XE
4AB46+,E#If461CGhuJ!D46(0*;8B,9Sn46.0.R4A;XEf` +,!#I<;#%*WED46*?EvB,<;"46*,uJ.)<;FNH(_;¡e=?1,EX(0.0();DI<;VB46*;F.)<;FN @A()%!X()<;8B,d'D:%$-(0*LB,v%!
`bOmiZm T9misem
«£ ·¾Ì\r Æ
4 0A0A
b` T/1,*B46.0.&` J4 eXe3<;XEPSn4A;#I<U;#1,!3.R4r!#<'#:%!#'#:cBK 1,* +,.R46*;#I%+n4
OC
&>
O
U
9
+ %!XEX1,!XSn46EX()@A*;>m{sKM46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&-+ %1,Eo'<@A*;X()B,I%!#%!o.)<;dEX!#@A();o;X(0EX1n46EX()@A*;oB,j'<@A*?ED4A'%Eg;X1,(0NA46*WE#<;- (0*?E#%!X+ I%*I
9 9 9 9
EX!D46*WE A=n'<@A*?ED4A'%E <4h%1,!D46*?E %E *@A*C'<@A*?ED4A'%E Am 9
]o46*;8.R4-;#1,(0E#J=,'<%E46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&;#%!D4jB,I%ED46(0.0.)I+,1,();8$&@HBC(_pnIJm
£ · r 5 1=
« ¾Ì\ 5 ¥ ` %~46$-(%EL46.bmf` JJ We=89%~46$-(f%EU46.bmf` JJ eXeP<;XEY1,* 5 08
A4 B46+,ED46EX()@A*cB,f.bKM46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&jB,jT/1,*B46.0.B,@A*WE.)S,1,E9<;#EBKi@A+,EX(0$-();#%!9.)f+,.R46*5;#I%+n46!D46E#%1,!d%*U!#I<BC1,();D46*WE
.R4Z!#<'D:%!#'#:ZB,<;8+O@J;D;X(0S,.)<;8+ @J;X(0EX()@A*;"BC1L+,.R46*UB46*;".bKi<;X+n4A'< A]jm 6
{sKiI%EX1B,UB,<;&BC(_^ I%!#%*WE#;346.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&<;3B,\B,I%E#<'%EX()@A*z$&@A*?EX!#Uq?1
K (0.);-*\;D@A*?EhqW1Y+n46!XEX()%.0.)%$&%*?EY4AB46+,E#I<;
<
461CGY;XEX!X1'%EX1,!#<;8%*Y$h4 <@A*,*%!X()&H(0.);/*d;#@A*WE8+n4A;84A;#;#%d!#@AS,1;XE#<;F$&I<'>46*,()qW1%$&%*?E>=@A1Y(0.);F*
KM4A;#;X1,!#%*WE8+n4A;
C
.R4d'<@A*BC(0EX()@A*hBK 1,*,(0.R46E#I%!D46.0(0E#IJ=H@A1&%*Cp*&(0.);*8;#@A*WEs+n4A;4AB46+,E#I<;+ @A1,!.)FEX!D46(0E#%$&%*?EFBC1&'<@A*?ED4A'%Es4A'< ~b4A'<Jm
¥ ¥
, P Æ
ºt
5 ; <
{
PB,I%N %.)@A+,+ %$&%*?E-BK 1,**@A1,N %.846.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&c` ¢%!D46.)<;-%Ej46.bmV` JJ JeXe;X+ I<'%(_pnq?1P461CGr$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;-<;XE
46+,+n46!X1c'<@A$-$&j1,*Z*I<'<<;#;X(0E#IJm
TV%Eo46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&J=(0$-+,.)I%$&%*?E#I-B46*;d.)Z'<@WB,jB,j'>46.)'%1,.{
2c[fTFJC=O+n4A;#;#
+n46!vB,%1CGY+,:n4A;#<;"B,B,I%E#<'%EX()@A*
9
1,*o+,:n4A;#oB,o+,!#IB,I%E#<'%EX()@A*tB,<;"'<@A*?ED4A'%E#;j` @A1UB,I%E#<'%EX()@A* uJ!#@J;D;X()l%!# >e=9
•
•
9 9
1,*o+,:n4A;#oB,fB,I%E#<'%EX()@A* ¡p* fB,<;"'<@A*WED4A'%E#;>m
C C C C
.v;>KM4AB46+,E#UwcE#@A1,E#<;h.)<;3;X(0EX1n46EX()@A*;hB,'<@A*?ED4A'%E#;t4A'< ~b4A'<J=46!#l%E# ~b4A'<J=/;D@A$-$&%E ~4A'<J=V46!#I%E# A46!#l%E#J=
C C
;#@A$-$&%E 6;D@A$-$&%E9%Ed;#@A$-$&%E A46!#l%E#J=O%Ev+ %!X$&%E9B,EX!D46(0E#%!.)g'<@A*?ED4A'%EowdX@A(0*?E9NW(_s%E9wo
@A(0*WE9B,$&@A!XEX()%!
6=
` N @A(0!8puJ1,!# Cm Wem
{
<;o;#1,!
4A'<<;oB,<;dS,.)@H'<;9*
KiI%ED46*?Ef+n4A;d*I<'<<;#;¡46(0!#%$&%*?Ef+n46!D46.0.)l%.)<;>= .R4PB,<;#'%!X(0+,EX()@A*BC15'<@A*WED4A'%Ef%*?EX!#&B,%1CG
+ @A.0 l<BC!#<;8;#v46(0EF+n46!F.R4g$-();#d%*P+,.R4A'<dBK 1,*Y+,.R46*L;#I%+n46!D46E#%1,!f` $&I%EX:@HB,oB,oT/1,*B46.0.
eV'<dqW1,(+ %!X$&%E"B,
'<@A*;XEX!X1,(0!#d1,*Y+,.R46*LB,9uJ.0();#;#%$&%*WEv46(0*;X(q?1
K 1,*9*@A!X$h46.)oB,9+,!#@6X<'%EX()@A* ` *@A!X$h46.)461Y+,.R46*Y;DI%+n46!D46E#%1,!¡em
@ *Y%*,!X()'#:,(0E8.bKM46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&oB,oT/1,*B46.0.
4p*PB,u I%!#%!F.)<;V'<@A*CpuJ1,!D46EX()@A*;vB,'<@A*WED4A'%E846+,+n46!D46();D;D46*?E8.)@A!#;FB,
<
.R4Z$&@HB,I%.0();D46EX()@A*UB,<;8$h4 <@A*,*%!X()<;~mn{4-;#+OI<'%(_pn'%(0E#IfB,d.bKM46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&gB,oB,I%E#<'%EX()@A*U+,!#@A+ @J;#Id+n46!"!D46+,+ @A!XEw
'<%.01,(OB,dT/1,*B46.0. '<@A*;X();XE#%*h.R4fB,I%E#<'%EX()@A*YB,<;V;#@A$-$&%E#;/B,<;/+ @A.0 l<BC!#<;/B,@A*WEV.)<;s4A'<<;V;#@A*WE/%*hNH();
wbNH();>=
%*r1,EX(0.0();¡46*?Ej'<-+,.R46*;#I%+n46!D46E#%1,!>m{
<;Z;#@A$-$&%E#;;#@A*WEg%*;X1,(0E#<;+,!#@6
%E#I<;g;X1,!f.)h+,.R46* ;#I%+n46!D46E#%1,!>m|]9%1CG
;XEX!D46E#I%uJ()<;B,d+,!#@6
<'%EX()@A*t;#@A*?Ev+O@J;#;#(0S,.)<;o
@ 6 78
* +,!#I<;#%*WE#5.bKi@A!Xu?46*,(0uJ!D46$-$&cuJ.)@ASn46.o;X1,!3.R4 puJ1,!# Cm Q'<@A*'<%!X*n46*?EL*@AEX!#5'<@A*WEX!X(0S,1,EX()@A*+O@A1,!Y.)tB,I
a
N %.)@A+,+ %$&%*?E9B,o.bKM46.0u @A!X(0EX:,$&B,fB,I%E#<'%EX()@A*B,<;v'<@A*?ED4A'%E#;~m
R n 3 O |
W
?
C
n3
Phase de pré−détection
validée
Détection fine
Algorithme de Cundall
Mise en place du plan séparateur
Détermination de la normale moyenne (principe des perturbations)
Mise en place d’un point appartenant au plan séparateur suivant que le contact est
"affleurant", "interpénétrant" ou "non−contact"
P. antagoniste
Calcul d’une distance/plan séparateur
P.candidat
Epaisseur du joint
P. antagoniste P.candidat
Calcul intersection
segment/segment
BDC FEHGIE . J K
GLJE ME
!
z
y
x
=-5
p %15S/1*[*-.'*-+91%15U'%)7We2>* ,.%05.*-,S'9d_+4%15S=S'%;3ri=O*- [,.5S%dr,.9;#X3r>j#%$<\ n c %;,#'&\ n c ,.%;7 74%153+%
\^.%15= f<)j ( c o
P 1x = min(OS.Ox, S ∈ V ert(A))
\^.%15.= f<)j ( c
N *-+54'9;.*-+5'%;3r=>*-7 f<h1'.%15sn \ ,"<*-45,.% c %;
P 2x = max(OS.Ox, S ∈ V ert(A))
, * \ /T+'4'+, c j'*-,S74%15
2fY/1%;[,.%155.*-[, G %;, G
p %(,.%15,s5.%;74*- 7@?~r% Ox /1*-+5.45,.%Pqe9;:!7 3+%;Z\^.%15= Oy, Oz c A B
o
If OA OB .Ox > 0
,A+%;
If (P 1x (B) − P 2x (A)) > 0 ,A+%;, +U*m /1*-,"-/;,
- 745"%
\ & $ c
If (P 1x (B) − P 2x (B)) < 0
,A+%;, +U*m /1*-,"-/;,
- +, ' .@z
2 FEHGIE . J KG KGFJE IE
KG
FJZG C . G
4343
576 9 8:8 )8 ; <[=>8?< < = ?8 ?8A@
ms)Kim
~ moy
N ~z
~ moy
N
Pantagoniste Pcandidat
Gant C
Gcan
C
~y
O
~x #7Wx5"9;=",.%;3
8 JI # +/; =O%P'3 =7W65.9;=",.%;3Tj N 3+'+7 7 7 \ N 3+'+7 78\$ I>I cc
4343
·< 6 = 8 T < T 6 = 6
8< 8 r<P =>8 <
?
K K
6'9;,.%;#$ +%
mi3 =O*- [,wo '%g.9dz 9;.%;+/1%l+*-,.9 N jS#$ 7 4%;3 '3 5.%;!#&%;,w.%;7 W[, 74%15V'%;3r /1%;,.%15w'%l!"1:Y ,.915
j o
C = G +G ant can
dant
.%;=.915.%;,.%P7W$'45,"+/1%P7 <9;24[3+%('%
i=1,..,Nant
Siant
qK7W&'.*- ,.%
y*- ![,s74%15s/1%;[,.%15 Gant
%;, Gcan
ms,+ m
m =O*-3S74%)=O*-7 f<h1'.%(/T+'4'+,
o
dcan = min {N ~ can
~ moy .CS j }
dcan
.%;=j=1,..,N
.915.%;,.%P7W$'45,"+/1%P7 <9;24[3+%('%
can
Sjcan
qK7W&'.*- ,.%
y*- ![,S74%15s/1%;[,.%15 Gant
%;, Gcan
p ?R9;,"=>%53 :-[,.%]/1*-+5.45,.%]q6% >%1/;,3+%;K'%15P.*-,",4*-+5 \^=>%;,32,4*-+5 c '3x=7Wg5"9;=",.%;3$3,.*-3e'3
=>*- ,)'%(.9dz 9;.%;+/1% N N %15=O%;,32,4*-+5U:<*-,)=>%;#&%;,,.%Z'%P=O*!5. ,4*-+%;U'++5U7@?R%15=-/1%P74%P=7W 5.9;=~m
",.%;3S'%0z -u1*-6qeM? [,.%;.5.%1/;,.%;U3+/;36=O*-7 f<h1'.%15
K K &
$ #
(
#
p ?7 <*- ,A#&%w/1*-+5.45,.%wqg==7 4[3+%; 3,.%V=>%;,32,4*-+563 :<%1/;,.%;3 ~ p ? [,.%;.5,4/1%w%15,i'9d_+
/1*-#$#&%07W$:-74%;3`#X~r #X74%P'% [d − d ] '%15S3,.%0=>%;,32,4*-+5 Nmoy
6'9d_+ ,'%;3r:<%1/;,.%;3.5*-,A+*-<*-can
3r>jant
+*-,.915 ~t %;, ~s z *-#X[,S3 ,4h1'.%PT:<%1/ N~
#F*-3('9;,.%;#$ +%;(74%K:<%1/;,.%;3 ~j>*-w=.*y%;,,.%Z3}5"*-#$#&%;,)'3w=>*-7 f<h1'.%&,"<*-45.,.%$ moy
53)74%e=7W 5"9;="~m
,.%;3 t
==>%;7 74% / =l7@?R%;+5"%;#P274% '%15$5.*-#$#&%;,.5$'3 =>*-7 f<h1'.%i/1*-+54'9;.9!jk=.*y%;,.915$5.3K74%=7WMj / $3D=O*- [,
[3+%;74/1*-+3+%P'%07@?R%15=-/1%(%;, N 3 =>*- ,U==,.%;,03 =7W
691/; ,S7WK=.*y%1/;,4*-
o
~ = OS1 ~ + S1Sp ~ \ $ c
OSp
nI:<%1/!j
~ = S1C
~ + CSp
~ = ((S1O
~ + OC).
~ N ~ moyen ).N
~ moyen + (CSp.
~ N ~ moyen ).N
~ moyen
- ,Tj S1Sp
~ N ~ moyen = 0
H ?R*Mj CSp.
~ = OS1
~ − ((−OC
~ + OS1).
~ N ~ moyen ).N
~ moyen \ & c
OSp
$z *-#&% +5.+3&:<%1/;,.%;3 ~t .%;7 W,874%s5.*-#$#&%;, =.*y%;,.9 / =X%;, 74%`=>*- , N ,.%;7H[3+% ~t = SpC ~ 74%S:<%1/;,.%;3
~s ~t
~
Nmoy
#
H M4h1'.%Z'9d_+I53`74%0=7W 5.9;=",.%;3Tj N 3+'+7 7 78\ N 3+'+7 7 \$ I>I cc
msm
~t ~t
~
tnouveau
~
tnouveau
Nmoy~nouveau
~s θ ~ ~s
Nmoy ~
Nmoy
−θ
*-,",4*-$'% θ
*-,",4*-e'% −θ
Nmoy~nouveau
H $ F# %;,32,4*-+503,.*-3'3 :<%1/;,.%;3 ~s j N 3+'+7 7 7 \ N 3+'+7 7 \$ I>I cc
~s ~s
snouveau
~ snouveau
~
Nmoy~nouveau
~t θ ~t ~
~
Nmoy Nmoy
−θ
Nmoy~nouveau
*-,",4*-e'% θ
*-,",4*-$'% −θ
H $>$ F# %;,32,4*-+503,.*-3S'3 :<%1/;,.%;3 ~tj N 3+'+7 7 7 \ N 3+'+7 7
\$ I>I cc
#F*-3]9;:Y ,.%;X'% 5.*-, $=.9;#X,3.9;#&%;[, '% 7@?7 <*- ,A#&%!j 74%15~r%15&'% =O%;,32,4*-+5]5.*-,&,.*-3+915'%
30◦
H +5Z74%X/T-5K/1*-," .%!jk/!?R%15,m q~m ' .%i5|7@? [,.%;.5,4/1%%15,P=7 3+5K=>%;, ,Z*-3g9;7`3x=.91/191'%;[,Tj*-x.9T7 45.%]74%
# ;#&%=.*[/191'9'%s=>%;,32,4*-+5`1:<%1/3+%s+*-3:<%;7 74%:-74%;38'%s7@?[!74% θ ,.%;7 74%S[3+% θ = θ p ?7 <*- ,A#&%
5T? ;,.%P5 θ < θ *- *-2,4%;[,U +5I7WK+*-#X74%(#&*Tf<%;+%Z'*-,7@? ,.%;.5,4/1%P#X~rY 2#X7
p %15k="#&h;,.%15 θmin%;, θ 5.*-,k_r9153$'9;23,k'%87@?7 <*- ,A#&%`%;,k:!74%;,k.%15=>%1/;, :<%;#&%;, θ = θ = 5◦
%;, θ = 0.01◦ \ N 3+min '+7 78\ $ I>I ccd max
K K
#(
(
#
,
$
I.*-45S/T-5s5.%)=.915"%;,.%;,$\^:<*- `_+!3.%
$ & c o
•
5.*- ,i7Wl' >9;.%;+/1% (d − d ) %15, 5,4/;,.%;#&%;, +9;, :<%!j`74%15i'%;3r 274*[/15i5T? [,.%;=O9;+h;,.%;[, %;,i74%
=>*- ,S'%(.9dz 9;.%;+/1% N 1% 5.can,s'9d_+Mant= C = C + (d +d )∗N j
o 2
can ant moymax
•
5"*- ,|7W(' Q9;.%;+/1% (d − d ) %15,|[37 74%!j74%158'%;3r&274*[/1585.*-[, %;i/1*-,"-/;,`DCX%;3",`%;,|74%=O*- [, '%S.9dm
can ant
z 9;.%;+/1% %15,M74% #$ 7 4%;3P'%15I'%;3r(5.*-#$#&%;,.5I74%15Q=7 3+5M=.*Y/.A+%15L'3(=7WP5.9;=",.%;3 C = [S +S ]j
ant(max) can(min)
o 2
i j
#
#
#
N *-,"-/;, X ,.%;=>9;+9;,", N *-,"-/;, DCX%;3", U
+ *-m /1*-,"-/;,
#7Wx5.9;=",.%;3
msXm
On recalcule l’interstice
Rotation du trièdre
t et s
H $ ]n7 <*- ,A#&%P'%0=>*!5 ,4*-+%;#&%;,U'3 =7W65.9;=",.%;3e\ N 3+'+7 7 \$ I>I cc
msim
4343
<D8 = 6
?8
8= <!8<=>8?<
N %;,,.%0=,4%(=O*-,.%(5.3`74%0/.A+*-{r '%15S5.*-#$#&%;,.5S53+5./1%;=, 274%15S'Q? ;,.%(=.*y%;,.91553`74%)=7W
K! K! K (
#"%$"(
'&
m +%$#&9;,A+*['%]'%$=.*y%1/;,4*-x%drY45.,.% /.A+*-{r}'%15(z -/1%15('*-[,P74%15P+*-#X74%15P5.*-[,P74%150=7 3+5K7 !+91%15
\ /; ,.h;.%('%(,.*-749;"+/1%P'% +x '%;!.915 c 1:<%1/07Wo $+*-#X74%0#&*Tf<%;+%K3 =7W
/ 74%15Pz@-/1%15P%;}:Y45m q~m@:Y45P−5.*-[,P="7 74h;74%15e1:<%1/&74%X=7WMjM7Wi#&9;,A+*Y'%%15,Z-5.5.% (X"=4'%X%;,Z%dtX/T-/1% =m
/1*-[,.%!j|5`74%15ez@-/1%15&5.*-[,X53tX5"#$#&%;[,& +/;7 +91%15 \^:-74%;3X2+5.*-7 3+%6'3 /; ,.h;.% 53=>9;4%;3]q r '%;!.915 c j
/1%;," +5`5.*-#$#&%;,.5
45"3+%;[,s'%S+%U=-5 ;,.%U=45`%;/1*-#$=,.%(74*-.5`[3M? 745
5.*-,`+91/1%15"5" .%158=O*-3
7WK'9;,.%;m
#$ ,4*-V'%15S-/;,4*-+5S'%0/1*-[,"-/;,
+ ! +
#
/ -* #$#&%;,.5S=.*y%;,.915
/ *-#$#&%;,.5S+*- =.*y%;,.9;5
)
+* $-,/.n7 !+%;#&%;,U'%15`+*-#X74%15T:<%1/(7WK+*-#X74%(#&* f<%;+%
~y
~x #
+
- '45.,
−
-'45.,
)
+* $102. H 9;,.%;#$ ,4*-V'%)7W&'45,"+/1%('Q?74%;,.%
ms43im
N *-45.5v,&7W '45,"+/1% 7 <9;24[3+% #$ #X74% =>*-3$74%=O*-7 f<h1'.%6/T+'4'+,&+*-,.9 '
%;,$7W '45,"+/1%
7 <9;24[3+%0#X~r #X74%(=>*-3`74%0=O*-7 f<h1'.%Z,"<*-45,.%P+*-,.9('
j'9d_+4%15s= N 3+'+7 7
o
'
•
= min {N ~ moy .CS ~ can } .%;=.915.%;[,.% 7Wg'45,"+/1%w7 <9;24[3+%V'3 =7 3+5]=.*[/"A+%V5"*-#$#&%;,
+*-,.9 (
'3 =>j=1,..,N
*-7 f<h1'.%(/T+'4'+,U3 =7W 5"9;=",.%;3Tj
j
can
'
•
= max {N ~ moy .CS ~ ant .%;=.915.%;,.%(7We'45,"+/1%(7 <9;243+%0'3 =7 3+5
=.*Y/.A+%05"*-#$#&%;,`+*-,.9
i }
(
'3 =O*-7 f<h1'.%Z,"<*-45,.%K3 =7W65.9;=",.%;3
i=1,..,N ant
6%15.,s/1*-z^.*-[,.915qK,.*-45S5. ,3,4*-+5
o
/ *- ,s7We' Q9;.%;+/1%X\ d − d c %15.,s5,4/;,.%;#&%;,=O*!5 , :<% *-6$74*-.F
5 0d+*-m /1*-,"-/;,E0-j
•
/ *- ,s7We' Q9;.%;+/1%X\ dcan − dant c %15.,`37 74% *- $74*-.5S3 o /1*-,"-/;,B01DCX%;3",E0-j
•
/ *- ,|7WZ' >9;.%;+/1%e\ d can− d antc %15,85,4/;,.%;#&o %;,
+9;, :<% *-iZ74*-.5 3/1*-[,"-/;, 0d [,.%;=O9;+9;,.90
• can ant o
p %6= +/; =O% %15,X'% '9;,.%;#$ +%;]3+% '45.,"+/1% #&*Tf<%;+% 0;' 0-j [,.9;!",i74%15X'%;3r '45,"+/1%15i7 <9dm
24[3+%15S3r3+%;7 74%15%15,S~y*-3,.91%(3+%('45,"+/1%('Q?74%;,.%
o
' = +( dcan − dant )+adist = +A+adist \ <c
− 2 − − −
msim
* *
I.*-45P/1*-_+!3",4*-+5e'%$/1*-,"-/;,
N *-,"-/;,0 . [ ,.%;=O9;+9;,.90
#
+U*-m N *-,"-/;,
#
A 6= 0
#
'
= +max[0, d −d
'
= −max[0, d −d ] +adist
'
can ant
2
2
can ant
] −adist A=0 '
N *-[,"-/;, 0;n%CX%;3",E0
#
#
'
=0+
- '45,
'
= 0 − -'45, '
# = +max[0, dcan −d
2
ant
]
#
−
-'45, −adist
− − '
'
'
'
#
#
/ *-#$#&%;,.5Zqi=.*y%;,.%;
)
* . -/1%15'%15`=>*-7 f<h1'.%15S%; :Y45m q~m@:Y45s1:<%1/(74%)=7W 5.9;=",.%;3
$ a
•
#L*-3S7@?,"<*-45,.%K'
#L*-3S74%(/T+'4'+,'
>=''
j
•
<=
msQ&m
#L*-3S74%0=O*-7 f<h1'.%Z,"<*-45,.%
•
N *-45.5v,i74% 2f/1%;,.% '3 =O*-7 f<h1'.%
%;,]74%6=>*- ,i/; ,4[3+% '9d_+U= N 3+'+7 7$\^74%V5.*-#$#&%;,
+*-,.9/(
74%K=7 3+5U=.*[/"A+%$'3V=7Ww5.9;=",.%;3 c jQ*-w'9d_+ ,)3+%e'45,"+/1% \^+*-#&%$'Q?R*-.'.% & c %;[,.%$/1%15
'%;3ri=O*- [,.5
o
H
= ||Gant~Vant ||
Gant
Vant
)
+* $ I . H 45,"+/1%(%;[,.%
%;, (
#L*-3S74%0=O*-7 f<h1'.%P/T+'4'+,
•
z@ ,s'%)# ;#&%0=>*-3s74%)=>*-7 f<h1'.%(/T+'4'+,/!?R%15,m q~m ' .%P3+%!j*-6/T74/;374%(7WK+*-#&%P'Q?R*-.'.% &e%;[,.%(74%
2f/1%;,.%Z'3 =O*-7 f<h1'.%0%;,s74%)=>*- ,s/; ,4[3+%('9d_+M= N 3+'+7 78\^74%05.*-#$#&%;,s+*-,.9 (
74%)=7 3+5`=.*[/"A+%
'3 =7W 5"9;=",.%;3 c j*-6%; '91'3 ,s7W&'45,"+/1%(%;,.%Z/1%15s'%;3ri=O*- [,.5
H o
= ||Gcan~Vcan ||
/.A+*-45 , 7Wg'45,"+/1% 'Q?74%;,.%V:-W274% /1*-#$#&% 9;,",i7Wg:!74%;3]#$ #X74%w%;[,.% 7Wg'45,"+/1% D
%;, D -'45, = min(D , D ) $ +5Q36*-.'.%('%)!"+'%;3)qe+%)=-5s'9;=-5.5"%; an
H ?R*
m >= *-3so 74%0/T+'4'+,'
can −dant
2 ] − ∗ min(Dan , Dcan )
K! K! K (
$ " $
'
msHm
* *
-'45,
-'45,
2
#7W65"9;=",.%;3
-/1%15S%;6:[45m q~m@:Y45
/ *-#$#&%;,.5S.91/;3=>9;.915
)
+* $2. H 9d_+ ,4*- '%07@?R9;=45"5.%;3S'3ey*- ,
p } '9;,.%1/;,4*- 0v_++%0 %15, +5s9;,"27 4% V 3 %;+5.%;#P274% '% =O*- [,.56\ 5.*-#$#&%;,.5]'% 7@?,"<*-45,.%V%;,
5.*-#$#&%;,.5'3 /T+ '4'+, c =.*y%;,.915s53s74%)=7W .5 9;=",.%;3
6%15.,S74*-.5
z -/1%Zqe'%;3ri5 ,3,4*-+5
o
5.*- ,$74%i+*-#P2.% '% 5"*-#$#&%;,.5&%15,$ z 9;4%;3X*-3 9;7SqV,.*-45 -* .91/;3=>h;.% ' .%1/;,.%;#&%;,]7WV7 45,.%
*-.'*-+91%Z'%15s5.*-#$#&%;,.5P\^7 45,.%
%;,s7 45.,.%
c j
• o
5.*- ,74%(+*-#Z2.%Z'%Z5.*-#$#&%;,.5%15.,S5,4/;,.%;#&%;,053=>9;4%;3Uq$,.*-45 -* %; /T74/;374%K74*-.5S7@?R%;[:<%;74*-==O%
/1*-[:<%dr%(%;,*- *-2,4%;,U +5.M3+%07 45,.%0*-.'*-+91%Z'%15s5.*-#$#&%;,.5
• o
msKim
G GsG J]G
JsG
(G
p ?R*-2y%1/;,{z%15,`'%0/T74/;374%;`7W 0;53z -/1% 0e\ *-3 0 (T*-+%0 c '%U.%1/1*-3:Y.%;#&%;,U'%7@?R%;+5"%;#P274%('%)=>*- ,.5TjY=.* :<%dm
[,S'%15S5.*-#$#&%;,.5S'%07@?,"<*-45,.%Z%;,S'3 /T+'4'+,
l/1*-#$#&%;+/1%]=K/T74/;374%;e7@?R%;:<%;74*-==>%/1*-[:<%dr%'%X/"A-3+%%;+5.%;#Z274%'%]5.*-#$#&%;,.5 nS=.h15K3+*-@jF*-
/T74/;374%;"&7@? ,.%;.5.%1/;,4*- '%15S'%;3r /1*-,.*-3.5 - _+MjH*- =>*!5 ,4*-+%;"$74%15S=O*- [,.5S'%P/1*-[,"-/;,.5'++5/1%;,,.%
53z@-/1%
nS_+ '%6z@-/; 7 ,.%;]7Wx.915.*-7 3,4*- '% /1%15i' Q9;.%;,.%15 9;,"=>%15Tj8*- ,"T:- 7 74% '++53 .%;=>h;.% 7 49V3 =7W
5.9;=",.%;3
3 ?3 5 =! ?8 ?= 6 6 8 ?< !8 4 8 ; 8 G8 ! 8 4 G8#" 8
p ? 7 <*- ,A#&%P3, 7 45.90%15,s/1%;7 3I'%%$[:[45P\ p %;.*Tf %;, M #&*-.%T3D\ & c jHK? *-3'&<%&\$ I<c j# 4*-g\$ c j
U3 !3+%]\ & <ccd
"V9;,A+*['%P'%)7@?R%;#P27 7W<%K'%)=-3+%;,.5
7@?7 <*- ,A#&%e'%$:Y45TjO==O%;749K3+5.5I=o ./1*-3.5U'%($[:[45TjH/T74/;374%P7@?R%;[:<%;74*-==O%K/1*-:<%dr%K'Q? 3 %;+5.%;#Z274%
'%S=O*- [,.5 = 7W0,.%1/"A43+%)'3X=-[3+%;,
/T-'%T3 \ /1%;7 74%dm /;>5 #P374%7@?R%;.*-374%;#&%;,s'%S7@?R%;+5.%;#P274%U'%15 =O*- [,.5
=s3+%U_/1%;7 74% cd
m - &=,",
'Q? 3X5.*-#$#&%;,8'%`7@?R%;:<%;74*-==>%!j[*-] % >%1/;,3+%S3&27W1f<%U/; ./;37W .%T:<%1/s3+%s'.*- ,.% y 3+5.[3M?q
.%;+/1*-[,.%;3 +*-3:<%T3 =O*- [,S3L'%;:[4%;[,s74%(5.*-#$#&%;,S5.3 :-[, 7@?7 <*- ,A#&%Z5 ? ;,.%074*-.5.[3M?R*- ,.*-#P2>%
53`74%(=O*- [,S'%0'9;=,
m N *-#$#&%X=>*- ,K'%]'9;=,TjF*-x=>%;3,Z/"A+*-45 Z3g=O*- [,Z'*-[,Z7@? 3+%'%15Z/1*Y*-.'*-+91%15e%15,(#$ #X74%i*-3
#X~r #X74%
m p ?7 <*- ,A#&%V%15,X5. #$ 7W .%63 ,s=X5"9;74%1/;,4*- * Mj|qw/"A-3+% 9;,"=>%!j *- 5"9;74%1/;,4*-+% 74% =>*- ,X[3
#$ #$45.%(74%(/.A<%;#&%;[,U'Q?!74%
m p ?!74%P=O%;3, ;,.%Z==.*1r #&9(=s3+%)z *-+/;,4*- ,A+%;,"
)
+
* & 2. "V9;,A+*Y'%('%)7@?R%;:<%;74*-==>%Z/1*-[:<%dr% 3<%P'%)=>*- ,.5
o
N %3<%6'%]=>*- ,.5]67WV=,4/;37W ,.96'Q? ;,.% /1*-:<%dr% %; % >%;,TjF7WV=.*y%1/;,4*- '%15$5.*-#$#&%;,.5&53e74%
=7Wi5.9;=",.%;3`%15,8.9T7 45.91%UqP=,
'%S7W(z -/1%U/1*-:<%dr%0,"<*-45,.%)%;:[45m q~m@:[45
1:<%1/U7W(z -/1%U/1*-:<%dr%
/T+'4'+,.%
x/"A+*-45 ,(74%e=>*- ,ZTf,K7W=7 3+50!"+'%]2>/;45.5.%e+*-,.
9 #$$%;,P*-w,"-/1%&3+%$'.*- ,.%X:<%;,4/T74%$=-5.5"[,
= #$ '%6/1*Y*-.'*-+91%15 \ r $!j f $ c %;,X74% =O*- [,]ne\^74% =O*- [,]n 74%15]/1*[*-.'*-+91%15i53 :!,.%15V\ r $!j f $) $ c
ms+ m
*!* ,
A
P1
~_+&'Q?R9;:Y ,.%; 3+%
74%15/1*Y*-.'*-+91%15|'% # +%`5.*-4%;, 9;74%15|q)/1%;7 74%15|'% #$ #L*-3 /1%;7Wj<*-$/T74/;374%`7WU+*-#&%
%;[,.%074%(5.*-#$#&%;% , #%$(%;,`74%15s5.*-#$#&%;,.5 # 7>z@3,S3+%)7WK+*-#&%Z5.*- ,s53=>9;4%;3.%Pq \ cd
+%)z *-45s74%(=>*- , # &$,.*-3:<9!jH*-6,"-/1%P3o +%P'.*- ,.%P%;[,.%P74%P5.*-#$#&%;, #$Z%;,S74%(5"*-#$#&%;, ># & 0 *-6.%dz@ ,S74%
,.%15,ST:<%1/(7@?R%;+5.%;#Z274%P'%15s5"*-#$#&%;,.5
P2
P1
)
+
* &>&2." 9;,A+*Y'%0'%07@?R%;:<%;74*-==>%P/1*-[:<%dr% o O= *- [,S5.%1/1*-+'+ .% #'&
P3
Pi
P2
P4 P1
Pi + 1
)
* & . "V9;,A+*Y'%0'%07@?R%;:<%;74*-==>%P/1*-[:<%dr% 7 <*- ,A#&%(<9;+9;"7 45.9Pq$ =O*- [,.5
o
ms
m
3 ?3 =>8< 6 = 6 8 8 ?8:<84 4< 8 8=
p ?R%dr%;#$=74%('%)7WK_+!3.% & X
, 7 7 3+5,.%)36/T-5`'%(/1*-[,"-/;,S3+%)+*-3+5s=O*-3:<*-+5`.%;+/1*-[,.%;U'++5S'%15`5,3+/dm
,3.%15s%;6#X-u1*-+%;4%
- :<%;74*-==>%Z/T+'4'+,.%
-* +%(/1*-#$#P3+% - [:<%;74*-==O%K,"<*-45,.%
/ *-#$#&%;,.5U[,"<*-45,.%15
/ *-#$#&%;,.5S/T+'4'+,.5
/ *-#$#&%;,.5s.91537 ,"[,.5S'%07@? [,.%;.5.%1/;,4*-
)
+
* & ,'. *-+%P'%0.%1/1*-3:[.%;#&%;[,'%15s5.3z -/1%15s'9;,.%1/;,.91%15
7 45.,./T~I\ y c
/ *-#$#&%;,.5[,"<*-45,.%15
/ *-#$#&%;,.5S/T+'4'+,.5
)8 +
* & 0/.I%15,S'Q?==,.%;+/1%K'%15s5.*-#$#&%;,.5UqK7W (T*-+%('%0.%1/1*-3:Y.%;#&%;,
ms i
m
*!* ,
/ *- ,Tj
m|7 45,"I\^ c 7 45,.%0*-.'*-+91%P'%15s5"*-#$#&%;,.5,"<*-45.,.%15Tj
m|7 45,./TI\ y c o 7 45,.%0*-.'*-+91%Z'%15s5.*-#$#&%;,.5/T+'4'+,.5Tj
o
m U~ = listan(i)listan(i j
~ + 1)
m V~ = listan(i)listcan(j) ~
/ Q=>*-3 j
#F*-3S,.*-3, *-3 ~ ≥ 0⇒ S can ∈ [%;:<%;74*-==>%]/1*-#$#Z3+% ]
j ∈ [1, nb sommets can]
~ .V
~ ≤0 ~ .V
p ( % ,.%15,s%15,`i.∈9T[1,
7 45.9(nb'++sommets
5s7@?3,.%P5.%;ant]
+5 U U j
/ Q=>*-3 j o
#F*-3S,.*-3, *-3 ~ ≥ 0⇒ S ant ∈ [%;[:<%;74*-==O%/1*-#$#P3+% ]
i ∈ [1, nb sommets ant]
j ∈ [1, nb sommets can] ~ .V
U ~ ≤0 ~ .V
U i
2
'
P1
P2
/
P3
2
/
ms Xm
e'*-+/(74%15`="#&h;,.%155`%;,S,s'9d_+45s=
5 [a (d − c ) + c (a − d ) + d (c − a )]/D o
, −[a 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 1 1
5-(ǔ(&#
5-(Ǔ(&#
9 $&:;:<"467(&#
2 ! 3" 4&(+! 3"
9 $&:;:<" 0 CD#$&.="!E?"!
9 $&:;:<" 0 (+=(+>?$&,%
9 $&:;:<" @#A(+.B%.(+ 2 ! 3" 468(&#
2 ! 3" 468(&#
)
* & a ]
. n7 <*- ,A#&%P'%('9;,.%1/;,4*- '%15s/1*-,"-/;,.5U5=>91/;{_3+%15 , f[=>*-74*-!4%P'%15S5 ,3,4*-+5S'%0/1*-[,"-/;,
o
p %P+*-3:<%;7F7 <*- ,A#&%K'%('9;,.%1/;,4*- /1*-3:[.%07@?R%;+5"%;#P274%K'%15S5 ,3,4*-+5U'%P/1*-[,"-/;,.5%;,s=>%;#&%;,U +5.L'%
<9;.%;s7WK=7 3=,U'%15S-5.5.%;#Z27W<%15S%; #X-u1*-+%;4%
#k#$k7@?R%;+5.%;#P274%K'%15U=O*- [,.5'%Z/1*-,"-/;,Tj>*-V%;V/1*-+5.%;:<%e36#X~r #P3# 3,.%Z=5.3z -/1%Z'9;,.%1/;,.91%
N %15 [3,.%
=>*- ,.5|'%`/1*-[,"-/;, =>%;#&%;,,.%;, '%
.%;=.915"%;,.%;|7WU<91*-#&9;,4%S'%
7W)53z -/1%`'%S/1*-,"-/;,|[3+%15,
5.*-3:<%;[,'%)z *-#&%0=>*-7 f[<*-74%Z'++5s74%15S#X-u1*-+%;4%15 H %0=7 3+5Tj7W$5,"2 7 ,.9(%15.,s#$4%;3r <9;.91%P%;,s=>%;#&%;,
ms i
m
E
&
53z@-/1%0'%(/1*-[,"-/;,
n3 _+7@jM7@?7 <*- ,A#&%X.%;,.*-3+%&74%15P/1*Y*-.'*-+91%15P'%15P+*[%;3+'5P'++5(74%$.%;=>h;.%$<9;+9;"7@jM7W +*-#X74%]3
=7W65"9;=",.%;3S%;,s3 .%;=>h;.%P-5.5.*Y/;49(3 =7W65.9;=",.%;3
E G
C =
J E .J C J]J G FG E G
(G
G
ms3im
)
* & . 9;=, ,4*-6'%15s'9;=7W-/1%;#&%;[,.5U'%15s274*[/15s'++5s74%0=O*-[,
70000
60000
50000 No_contact
Contact_stick
Contact_slide
40000
Contact_number
Contact_number
30000
20000
10000
-10000
0 0,1 0,2 0,3 0,4 0,5
Time
ms MK &m
343 =>< = <8 <8 !8 <4= < 6 = 8 '8 4 6 8<
6
8=
4 8 ?8
•
$ #
H-/1%('%0/1*-,"-/;,e\ c
+*Y%;3+'5`'%
/1*-,"-/;,e\^2 c
)
* ,'. 9;=, ,4*- '%15s'9;=7W-/1%;#&%;[,.5'%15S274*[/15s'++5s7@?R%15./T7 4%;
ms K Kim
800
600 No_contact
Contact_stick
Contact_slide
Contact_number
Contact_number
400
200
)8 +
* 02. +*-#Z2.%('%(/1*-[,"-/;,.5%;iz *-+/;,4*-6'%074%;3`,3.%\ %15./T7 4%; 4'*-7{_ c
•
( (
N *-#$#&%)7@?R%15./T7 4%;Tj7WK/1*-3= -74%) 7 7 3+5,.%U7WK=O*!5"5 2 7 ,.9)'Q? ,.9;!.%;s3+%U=.91/1*-," [,.% H %U=7 3+5Tj7WK/1*-+/1%;=m
,4*-V'%(/1%;,,.%P5,3+/;,3.%ee7We=,4/;37W ,.9e'Q?T:<*- U'%15/1*-,"-/;,.5U%15.5.%;,4%;7 74%;#&%;[,0'%(, fY=>%P.h;,.% z -/1%K%;,
.h;,.% -.h;,.%\ _+!3.% !<cd
p ]5,3+/;,3.%e%15,)/1*-+5, ,3+91%e'%P274*Y/15)%; !"+'w==.%; 7@j>5"+5U#&*-,4%;Tj>%;,.%;z *-./191%K=)3V/ 274%e'%
=.91/1*-[," ,.%Z=O%;#&%;,,"[,S7W$5,"2 7 ,.9P'%07We5,3+/;,3.%
•
= 6
?8 < <>= 6 = 6 8 )8A8G= 8
4 8
p %8,.%;#&% ( (`'%87W`_+!3.% <a .%;=.915.%;[,.%
7Ws:Y ,.%15.5.%8'3e274*[/
'++5F7WU' .%1/;,4*-$:<%;,4/T74% p %15k45.*m@:Y ,.%15.5.%15
#&*-[,.%;,)3M?3+/;3 274*Y/)M?e2>*-3<9('3",S7W$5 #P37W,4*-MjH'%Uz -u1*-6=Af543+%;#&%;[,S+*-,"274%
N *-#$#&%6=O*-3&7@?R%dr%;#$=74% '3 #F*-, $!37 4%;Mj|7WV_+!3.% > I .%;=.915"%;,.% 7@?R9;:<*-7 3,4*- 3 /1*-3.5X'3 ,.%;#$=+5
' 3 +*-#P2.%X'%K/1*-[,"-/;,.5(%;Vz *-+/;,4*-}'%K74%;3),3.% \^!7 45.5"[,TjQ/1*-7 7W,P*-3 +*-m /1*-[,"-/;, cd w.%;,.*-3:<%
74%150#;#&%15Z/1*-+/;7 3+54*-+5P[3+%$'++5(7@?R%dr%;#$=74%$=.91/191'%;[,Kq 5"T:<*- P[3+%e7W#X~y*- ,.9]'%15(/1*-,"-/;,.5Z%15,P'%
, f[=>% 0;/1*-7 7W[E, 0Z%;,U3+%P74%15 0d+*-m /1*-[,"-/;E, 0e5.*-,036+*-#Z2.%e'% p X5,3+/;,3.%K5.%Z5,"2 7 45.%Z3 2O*-3,)'%
, K ,.9;",4*-+5e\ cd
h = 10−4 s
ms K m
2000
1500
1000
Contact_number No_contact
Contact_stick
Contact_slide
500 Contact_number
-500
-1000
0 0,5 1
Time
343 =>< = <84 6 ?8 6 6 = ?8 6 98?< ?8 6 G=
ms K im
**
p % '9;=7W-/1%;#&%;,
'%15 274*Y/15|53 :!, 7W):<%;,4/T74%S%15., +9;!7 <%T274%K\ _+!3.% cd p ?7 <*- ,A#&%!jY'++5 74%s/T-5
'
% 0d+*-m /1*-[,"-/;,E0-jH#&*-[,.%Z +5M5"*- %dtX/T-/; ,.9
J
.J
N %V,"1:! 7(=.915.%;[,.% 3 +*-3:<%;7P7 <*- ,A#&%}'% '9;,.%1/;,4*- '%15 /1*-,"-/;,.5 %;,.% =>*-7 f<h1'.%15 !4'%15 H
1/ *-[:<%dr%15`'*-[,`7@?R*- ! 7 ,.9(/1*-+545,.%0qZ/1*-+54'9;.%;s'%15`/1*-,"-/;,.5s5.3z -/;4[3+%15
%;,`qZ74%158," ,.%;s'%U#X4h;.%
=,4/;37 4h;.% p %158/1*-,"-/;,.58'++5|3+%S#X-u1*-+%;4%5.*-[, %15.5"%;,4%;7 74%;#&%;,
'%s, f[=>%
z@-/1% z -/1%%;,8.h;,.% z@-/1%
p %P/.A+*-{r 5T?R%15,`=>*-,.9053`7We=45.%0%; /1*-#$=,.%P3 #X~r #P3# '%([3,.%0+*Y%;3+'5s'%0/1*-,"-/;,.5=S53z@-/1%
'9;,.%1/;,.91% :<%;"]'++574%P/.A= ,.% 0X3+%P74%(+*-#P2.%e'%P+*[%;3+'5U'%P/1*-[,"-/;,.5)=O%;3, +3+%;+/1%;U7WX5,"~m
2 7 ,.90[3#&9;43+%Z'36/1*-,"-/;,%;,S'*-+/('%)7W$5,3+/;,3.%
p ]5=>91/;{_/; ,.9P'%Z7@?7 <*- ,A#&%K=.*-=O*!5.9Z/1*-+545,.%Z%; 7WX'9;,.%1/;,4*- '%15U5.*-#$#&%;,.5U'%15S=>*-7 f<h1'.%15)'*-,U74%15
z@-/1%15|5.*-[,|%;X:Y45m q~m@:Y45 %;&3, 7 45"[, 74%s=7W]5.9;=",.%;38'% N 3+'+7 7 p %15|5.*-#$#&%;,.5 5.*-,8%;+53 ,.%s=.*y%;,.915
53(/1%e=7W p %15(%;:<%;74*-==>%15P/1*-[:<%dr%15Z'%$=,(%;,('Q?3,.%X'3w=7Wg5.*-,('9d_+4%15 74%;3.50 ,.%;.5.%1/;,4*-+5
/T"-/;,.9;45.%;[,S7WB (T*-+%(=O*-7 fY<*-74%('%0/1*-,"-/;,U'*-,74%15s5.*-#$#&%;,.5s5.*-[,s74%15`+*Y%;3+'5S'%0/1*-[,"-/;,.5
H %15|5. #P37W,4*-+583#&9;4[3+%15 *-[, =>%;#$45|'%S:<9;{_%;|7@?R%dtX/T-/; ,.9U'%s7@?7 <*- ,A#&%)q('9;,.%1/;,.%; 74%15 /1*-[,"-/;,.5
'++5e3+%i5,3+/;,3.% q !"+'D+*-#P2.%6'%]274*Y/15 \^=>*-, $!37 4%; c j=.91/1*-[," ,.%g\ %15"/T7 4%; 4'*-7{_ c jF=.9dm
/1*-[," ,.%$1:<%1/P3+%0<91*-#&9;,4%Z'%Z/1*-,"-/;,U/1*-#$=74%dr%\ /1*-3= -74%Z'( % $!3-5 c jH*-3653s3 /T-5-/T-'9;#$4[3+%
[,.9;!",U3+%09;=45.5.%;3S'%
y*- ,
p ?==.*Y/.A+%(=.*-=O*!5.91%U=>*-3
7@?R9;:-7 3,4*- '%15`'9;=7W-/1%;#&%;[,.5S'++5
74%15
5,3+/;,3.%15`#X-u1*-+915s==>*-,.%0'%15
z *-#X,4*-+5P=7 3+5P=.91/;45.%15K3+%$74%15P#&9;,A+*['%15Z/;7W-5.54[3+%15 N %X+*-3:<%;787 <*- ,A#&%]=O%;#&%;,K'Q?R%;:Y45"<%;
7@? [,.9;!",4*-V'Q? 3+%074*-M'%P/1*-,"-/;,/1*-A+915. :<%0=O*-3`#&*Y'9;7 45.%;s7W$=.915.%;+/1%('Q? 3 #&*-,4%;
p 1% 5|53z -/1%15|'%s/1*-,"-/;,.5 /1*-+'345.%;,85.*-3:<%;,
qU3$=.*-274h;#&%S5,",4[3+%;#&%;, +'9;,.%;#$ +9Z\^+*-#P2.%'Q? m
/1*-[3+%15P'Q?R% Q*-,.50=7 3+5) #$=O*-,"[,.5P[3+%e74%e+*-#P2.%&'Q?R91[3,4*-+5 cd N %;,P-5.=O%1/;,Uz@ ,07@?R*-2y%;,('3}/"A= ,.%
,
m
ms K X
ms K im
#! "!$ & %'()!*,+-% #
)./.10,,!2345"6 ) %87 )92"/ 5
6 <8
ÉÊ Ë 3 É
!*
!"
5Kmn@0,4B>D$V>D$g5Kmn@&W-BDE;5;E;\D31$g31$05.M,4EJu%4B'&'&$&%1%4EJt>D$V'1T.+W-B$V%1)+5;E7>D$c>D$Z5._%4,434B'0,4BD31$Cl
•
•
5.e'&)+*D*.ME7%1%/.M*'&$>D$&%X.M8D8D31)b[]E;Fr.M,4E7)+*%_%4B'&'&$&%/%4E S $&%c>D$&%aE;*,1$03/.+'0,4E7)+*%`31@&>?BDE;,1% j BD*$.+'0,4E7)+*z8)+*'
,4B$05;57$Cl
É
BD*$g31@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*Y*)]$0B>R8.M32*)]$0B>Y>D$V'&)+*-,/.+'0,bP
w .M*•%G'&$034,/.ME;*$&%h.M8D8D5;E7'b.M,4E7)+*%blu57$Jd31)+,4,1$0FG$0*,$0,G57$h*)+Fc\D31$f>D$R*)]$0B>D%G>D$Y'&)+*,/.+'0,'&)+*>?BDE7%1$0*, j BD*$
g
E;*>D@0,1$034F_E;*.M,4E7)+*>?B%4:?%4,1<0FG$a>mn@&W-B.M,4E7)+*%_xdyf)+31$b.MB
xOCC 0 ~4~qP?.M*%LJ31)+,4,1$0FG$0*-,bl
BD*$a5;E.ME7%/)+*f8D5.M*$X>D)+E;,
N0,431$R>D@qs*DE7$h8.M3_,431)+E7%G'&)+*-,/.+'0,1%_8)+*'0,4B$057%_8
)+BD3GN0,431$hE7%/)C%4,/.M,4E7WB$h$0,G>.M*%`57$R'b.+%G. S $&'J31)+,4,1$0FG$0*-,blu57$
8D31)+\D57<0FG$a$&%4,H>D@ j %1,/.M,4E7WB$0FG$0*-,E;*>D@0,1$034F_E;*@CP
i6mn$&%4,28)+BD31W-B)+EKlD*)+B%H8D31)+8)C%1)+*%2BD*$g*)+B S 0$ 5;57$a.M8D8D31)-'/T$cW-BDE'&)+*%4E7%4,1$G
É >m BD*$Z8.M34,blD$0*hBD*$6FG)->D@05;E7%.M,4E7)+*Y>D$&%9'&)+*-,/.+'0,1%%4BD3|JK.+'0E7W-B$&%9$0,(5;E;*@0E7W-B$&%2%1)+B%9JO)+34FG$6>mn@057@0FG$0*-,>D$
'&)+*-,/.+'0,@ S E;,/.M*-,k5Km E;*>D@0,1$034F_E;*.M,4E7)+*r57)]'b.M57$ClM8
$034FG$0,4,/.M*-,>D$2'b.M57'0BD57$03k57)-'b.M57$0FG$0*-,u57$&%tE;*'&)+*D*B$&%>D$(5;E.ME7%1)+*%
$0*-,431$V>D$0B?[Y%1)+5;E7>D$&%bl
É>mv.MBD,431$a8.M34,bl$0*eBD*.M5;A=)+34E;,4TDFG$a>D$c31@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*f>?Bf8D31)+\D57<0FG$VBD,4E;5;E7%/.M*-,LBD*$V%1,43/.M,1@0ACE7$c>mv.+'0,4E S .M,4E7)+*
%4B'&'&$&%/%4E S $g>D$&%H5;E.ME7%1)+*%H8
$034FG$0,4,/.M*-,L>D$g57$ S $03H5Km E;*>D@0,1$034F_E;*.M,4E7)+*>?BR8D31)+\D57<0FG$VAC57)+\.M5KP
( c 1
1 X X2 /
1 a
2
ÉÊ-¨ É
!* * §
Lb
L
Fy
NA Fx NB
2
TAx TBx
α
θ
#$28.M3/.M5;57@057@08DE;8<&>D$$&%4,u'&)+*%1E7>D@031@231$&%4,/.M*,,1)+B+|)+BD31%^$0*G'&)+*,/.+'0,uJd31)+,4,/.M*,9%1$&'CPC#umv.+'&'&@057@03/.M,4E7)+*T)+34E;¢b)+*
,/.M57$L$&%4,uE;*'&)+*D*B$6$0,8$0BD,N0,431$*BD5;57$L.ME;*%1EW-B$25. S E;,1$&%1%1$H>D$H,43/.M*%45.M,4E7)+*>.M*%57$'b.+%^>mv.+>?T@031$0*'&$CP-#$&% ,
É
E;*'&)+*D*-B$&%6%/'b.M5.ME;31$&%>D$&%L31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%L>D$a'&)+*,/.+'0,L%/)+*,Xx ~($0,Xx ~qP#
.G57)+E
>D$gJd31)+,4,1$0FG$0*,Z$&%4,
TAx , NA TBx , NB
5.X57)+E
>D$Xi9)+BD57)+Fc\lDJk@0,/.M*,57$V'&)-$ r'0E7$0*-,>D$ZJd31)+,4,1$0FG$0*,bP L)+B%H%/)+F_FG$&%2JK.+'&$ j >D$0B?[R'b.+%c
x , P;{CP;{§~
TAx + TBx + Fx = 0
x , P;{CPv=~
NA + N B + F y + P = 0
a b x , P;{CPvU=~
−(TAx + TBx ) + (NA − NB ) = 0
2 2
# $L*)+Fc\D31$6>mn@&W-B.M,4E7)+*%^*mn$&%1,^8.+%9%4Br%/.M*-,8)+BD3^31@&%1)+B>?31$L57$%1:]%4,1<0FG$CPL)+B%(.4)+BD,1)+*%BD*$L31$05.M,4E7)+*
É
%4BD8D8D57@0FG$0*-,/.ME;31$Z*)+* 5;E;*@b.ME;31$Z$0*GJK.ME7%/.M*,^5Km T:]8
)+,4T<&%1$6>m BD*$L8D31)+8
)+34,4E7)+*D*.M5;E;,1@g>D$&%9'&)+F_8
)C%.M*,1$&%9,/.M*DA=$0*
,4E7$05;57$&%8.M323/.M8D8
)+34,L.MB?[Y'&)+F_8)C%/.M*,1$&%*)+34Fr.M57$&%>.M*%25.G>?E;31$&'0,4E7)+* ~
É
AB
a P Fy x , P;{CP=~
NA = − Fx − −
2b 2 2
ÉÊ-¨Ê²É
!*
!"
NB x , P;{CP C~
TBx = −Fx ( )
NA + N B
NB x , P;{CP =~
TAx = −Fx + Fx ( )
NA + N B
#$&% , 31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%>D$g'&)+*-,/.+'0,L%1)+*-,>D)+*'V>D@0,1$034F_E;*@&$&%bP
•
1% )+E;,G5.Jd)+31'&$f.M8D8D5;E7WB@&$f$&%4,r%4Br%/.M*-,1$Y8)+BD3GFG$0,4,431$e$0* FG)+B S $0FG$0*,57$Y%1)+5;E7>D$Y'Cmn$&%1, j >?E;31$fW-B$
5.f57)+EH>D$AC5;E7%1%1$0FG$0*-,r>D$Yi9)+BD57)+Fc\
ÉÉ
$&%4, S @034Es@&$Clt57$R%1)+5;E7>D$\
)+BDA=$xd'b.+%_>D$hAC5;E7%1%/$0FG$0*,~qPk#$
É
%4:?%4,1<0FG$H>mn@&W-B.M,4E7)+*%9'0E >D$&%1%1)+B%9%1$231T@&%1)+=B>r
P ∗f
E;,1@03/.M,4E S $0FG$0*,bP?#um E;*>?E7'&$L*r'&)+3431$&%48)+*> j 5.g*BDFG@031)+,/.M,4E7)+*Y>D$
5Km E;,1@03/.M,4E7)+* TR57$g8.+%H>D$g,1$0F_8%H>D$V5Km E;,1@03/.M,4E7)+*f$0,2Bo?5. S E;,1$&%1%1$g>?Be%/)+5;E7>D$g%4BDE S .M*-,H5Kmv.[D$ ~ P
Ox
i )+F_8D,1$X,1$0*B>D$&%Z>?E7%1'&)+*,4E;*-BDE;,1@&%g>D$&%LJd)+*'0,4E7)+*% S E;,1$&%1%1$c$0,Jd)+31'&$&%§l57$&%6>D@034E S @&$&%6,1$0F_8
)+31$05;57$&%Z%1)+*-,LE;*-,1$03
9
8D31@0,1@&$&%9.MBr%1$0*%u>D$&%u>?E7%1,434E;\DBD,4E7)+*%bP#$&%^@&WB.M,4E7)+*%^%bmn@&'034E S $0*,(.M57)+31%$0*_,1$034FG$&%^>D$2FG$&%4BD31$&%>?Ep@031$0*,4E7$05;57$&%§P
É
QL*e'&)+*%1E7>D<031$V>D$&%28.+%H>D$g,1$0F_8% >D$Z57)+*DACB$0BD3 PD#$&%@&WB.M,4E7)+*%L%bmn@&'034E S $0*,X
]ti , ti+1 [ h = ti+1 − ti
É
i9)+F_FG$g8)+BD3257$g'b.+%2*)+* AC5;E7%1%.M*,blD57$V%1:]%4,1<0FG$6*mn$&%4,28.+%>D@0,1$034F_E;*@xE7'0EKl?BD*$gE;*'&)+*D*-B$V%4BD8D8D57@0FG$0*,/.ME;31$
b% mv.4)+BD,1$.MB %4:?%4,1<0FG$>mn@&WB.M,4E7)+*%95. S E;,1$&%1%1$*)+,1@&$B~qP L)+B%R.4)+BD,1)+*%e.M57)+31%R>D$0B?["31$05.M,4E7)+*%Y%4BD8
8D57@0FG$0*-,/.ME;31$&%R5Km T:]8
)+,4T<&%/$>m BD*$r8D31)+8
)+34,4E7)+*D*.M5;E;,1@h>D$&%X'&)+F_8
)C%/.M*-,1$&%X,/.M*DA=$0*,4E7$05;57$&%X8.M3c3/.M8D8)+34,`.MB?[
É
'&)+F_8)C%/.M*,1$&%*)+34Fr.M57$&%L>.M*%H5.`>?E;31$&'0,4E7)+* ~ PD#$VFr.M,1@034E.MBf$&%4,H%4BD8D8)C%1@ZE7%1)+,431)+8$Cl$0*R3/.M8D8)+34,L. S $&'c5.
'&)+*>?E;,4E7)+*>D$ZAC5;E7%1%1$0FG$0*,6>D$ci9)+BD57)+Fc\l)+*eAB>D@qs*DE;,>D$0B?[R31$05.M,4E7)+*%%4BD8D8D57@0FG$0*-,/.ME;31$&%a
1 1 x , P;{CP;{ , ~
u= TAx .sign(TAx ) = TBx .sign(TBx )
−f.NA −f.NB
ÉÊ-¨ ÀÉ
!* * §
Lb
L
h x , P;{CP;{ 0 ~
un+1 − un = (f.P sign(u) + Fx )
m
8DBDE7%blD>mv.M8D31<&%57$&%H@&W-B.M,4E7)+*%ax , P;{CPv}=~ql x , P;{CP;{b=~2$0,ax , P;{CP;{C{§~ql
P Fy a a x , P;{CP;{ = ~
NB = − − + Fx − m.(un+1 − un )
2 2 2b 2h.b
P Fy a a x , P;{CP;{§C~
NA = − − − Fx + m.(un+1 − un )
2 2 2b 2b
$0*?s*l>mv.M8D31<&%57$&%H@&W-B.M,4E7)+*%ax , P;{CP;{bU=~ql
x , P;{CP;{ =~
TAx = −f sign(u).NA
x , P;{CP;{b}=~
TBx = −f sign(u).NB
)+BD,1$&%257$&%(E;*'&)+*D*B$&%blD>D$Z'&)+*-,/.+'0,1%H$0,H>D$6FG)+B S $0FG$0*,bl%1)+*-,2>D@0,1$034F_E;*@&$&%bPi9$08$0*>.M*,bl'&$0,4,1$6T:]8)+,4T<&%1$
>D$Z31@08.M34,4E;,4E7)+*>D$&%231@b.+'0,4E7)+*%H,/.M*DA=$0*-,4E7$05;57$&%*$V8
$034FG$0,H8.+%>D$ZA=@031$03H5Kmv.M8D31<&%H\.+%1'0BD57$0FG$0*-,bP
É
¡)+BD3LE;5;5;B%1,431$03L57$c31@&%4BD5;,/.M,L>D$&%6'b.M57'0BD57%L%/$057)+*e*)C%LT:]8
)+,4T<&%1$&%§l>.M*%L57$&%L'b.+%L*)+* AC5;E7%1%/.M*-,6$0,LAC5;E7%1%/.M*,bl
)+*
8D31@&%1$0*-,1$VBD*Y$q[D$0F_8D57$g*BDFG@034E7W-B$x S )+E;3HsACBD31$ , P;{§~qP
6)+B%. S +) *%L'1T)+E7%4E
57$&%28.M3/.MFG<0,431$&%*-BDFG@034E7WB$&%L%4BDE S .M*,1%c
É 57)+*DACB$0BD36>?BY%1)+5;E7>D$G?\
É Fr.+%1%/$g>?Be%1)+5;E7>D$G?F ?PvMFYl
É b
{ & A l
É 8.+%H>D$V,1$0F_8%c −3 l
É .+'&'&@057@03/.M,4E7)+*>D$gh5.X=8
$&10%.M*,1s$0BD3a l
É '&)+*>?E;,4E7)+*%LE;*DE;,4E.M57$&%c g = −9.81ms−2
m∗g
NA = N B = − 2
u = 0ms−1
P
•
"!$#%&')(
!*!*++,
i9$h'b.+%G.@0,1@ S M. 5;E7>D@Y. S $&'h8D5;B%4E7$0BD31% S .M57$0BD31%_>D$JO)+31'&$R.M8D8D5;E7WB@&$R$0* * $8
$034FG$0,4,/.M*-,G8.+%_>D$h>D@08D5.
'&$03H57$g%/)+5;E7>D$CP£ 4, E;,431$c>mn$q[?$0F_8D57$Cl)+*f'1T)+E7%4E;,H5Kmn$q[D$0F_8D57$g*-BDFG@034E7WB$a%4BDE S .M*-b, P
É
¡)+BD3BD*$6JO)+31'&$c.M8D8D5;E7W-B@&$c.MBe'&$0*,431$c>D$gAC3/. S E;,1@ >?Be%/)+5;E7>D$g,1$05;57$gWB$
Fx = +20N
x $0, ~qP
||F || < ||T || ||T || = P.f = 39.24N
ÉÊ-¨VË É
!*
!"
l
NB = 54.05N
l
NA = 44.05N
l
TBx = −11.02N
l
TAx = −8.98N
#
.c%1)+F_FG$>D$&%31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%*)+34Fr.M57$&% $0, >D)+*D*$H57$H8)+E7>D%>?B\D57)-'CP#$H3/.M8D8)+34, TAx TBx
NA NB
É
$&%4, S @034Es@CP-#$&%u31@&%1BD5;,/.M,1%>?Br'b.+%*)+* AC5;E7%1%/.M*,9%1)+*,^'&$0B?[G.M,4,1$0*>?B%§l=>.M*%u57$H'b.+>?31$>D$&%uNTA:]8=)+,4TN<&B%1$&=
%kJK0.204
.ME;,1$&%bP
•
"!$#% (
!*!* ,
wg.M*%X57$'b.+%XAC5;E7%1%.M*,bl 5.Y57)+E(>D$J31)+,4,1$0FG$0*-,`>D$Ri9)+BD57)+Fc\ |T | $&%4, S @034Es@&$CP#
$&%X>?E7%/'&)+*,4E;*BDE;,1@&%>D$
É
S E;,1$&%1%1$&%cE;F_8D5;E7WB$0*-,`W-B$r'&$05;57$&% '0E9%1)+E7$0*-,a,43/.ME;,1@&$&%_.MB %1$0*%a>D$&%X>?E7%4,434E;\DBD,4E7)+*%RxFG@0,4T)]>D$ gDi9w $ $b.M*
N = f
x|{b}C} 0 \~ql?y)+31$b.MBx|{b} =~ql $ $b.M*R$0,(yf)+31$b.MBx|{b}C}C=~4~qP?#$&%(%4E;FcBD5.M,4E7)+*%(*-BDFG@034E7WB$&%2%/)+*,(31@b.M5;E7%1@&$&%2. S $&'657$
'&)]>D$gy.M,1# .M\P
i9$Z'b.+%2.X@0,1@ S .M5;E7>D@g. S $&'Z8D5;B%4E7$0BD31% S .M57$0BD31%(>D$LJd)+31'&$g.M8D8D5;E7W-B@&$6$0* 8$034FG$0,4,/.M*,H>D$Z>D@08D5.+'&$03257$6%1)+5;E7>D$CP
£ ,4E;,431$V>mn$q[D$0F_8D57$Cl)+*e'1T)+E7%1E;,H5._%4E;FaBD5.M,4E7)+*e*BDFG@034E7W-B$V%4BDE S .M*,1$CP
0.8
Valeurs de a (m/s2)
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Itérations sur 1 pas de temps
#
.Y'&)+BD34\
$G>D$`5.hsACBD31$ , PvhFG)+*,431$WB$G57$`FG)->D<057$_8D31@&>?E;,c\DE7$0*57$_FG)+B S 0$ FG$0*,_.M,4,1$0*>?B 57$_%/)+5;E7>D$G%1$
>D@08D5.+'&$V>.M*%5.`>?E;31$&'0,4E7)+* 8
)C%4E;,4E S $0FG$0*-,XxsACBD31$ , Pv=~qP
O~x
#
. S .M57$0BD3H>D$g5Kmv.+'&'&@057@03/.M,4E7)+* $&%4,H$0*Y$qp$0,'&)+*%4,/.M*,1$x $0, ~H'b.M325.`Jd)+31'&$
Fx − T = ma T = P.f = 39.24N
ÉÊ-¨¨ É
!* * §
Lb
L
$q[?,1@034E7$0BD31$_$&%4,V'&)+*%4,/.M*-,1$CP#
. S E;,1$&%1%1$`$&%4,Z8
)C%1E;,4E S $X%/$057)+*5Kmv.[?$ '&)+*?JO)+34FG@0FG$0*, j 5.>?E;31$&'0,4E7)+*z>D$`5.
O~x
JO)+31'&$g$q[],1@034E7$0BD31$CP#$V%1)+5;E7>D$ZAC5;E7%/%1$g>D)+*'V%4BD3H5Kmv.[D$ P
O~x
−5
−5
Valeurs de TA
Valeurs de TB
−10
−10
−15
−15
−20
−20 −25
0 2 4 6 8 10 0 2 4 6 8 10
Itérations sur 1 pas de temps Itérations sur 1 pas de temps
48 58
Valeurs de NA
Valeurs de NB
46 56
44 54
42 52
40 50
38 48
0 2 4 6 8 10 0 2 4 6 8 10
Itérations sur 1 pas de temps Itérations sur 1 pas de temps
ÉÊ-¨ÀÉ
!*
!"
'&)+*-,/.+'0, 57$a'b.+%>D$c'&)+*-,/.+'0,6%1BD3|JO.+'0E7W-B$c%bmn$qp$&'0,4B$c%1BD3HBD*e8D5.M*$0,57$V'&)+*-,1)+BD3Z>D$V5._¢b)+*$c>D$a'&)+*,/.+'0,Z$&%4,
¨ Ê
,
*"
$!* !
*+ ,
' #%+
!*
#%!$ "
, !
+!
¡)+BD3kFG)->D@05;E7%/$03BD*_8D31)+\D57<0FG$2'&)+F_8)+34,/.M*,k8D5;B%k>m E;*'&)+*D*-B$&%u*)+34Fr.M57$&%uW-B$(>mn@&WB.M,4E7)+*%§lM)+*`8D31@&%1$0*-,1$2BD*
É
'b.+%H.+'b.+>D@0F_E7W-B$CPi9$05;BDE '0E$&%4,(BD*R'b.M3431@g>D$Z' ,1@_{`x S )+E;3(sACBD31$ , P , ~qPD#
$&%2WB.M,431$g%1)+F_FG$0,1%2>?BR'b.M3431@g%1)+*-,
57$&%*)-$0B>D%9>D$'&)+*-,/.+'0, $0, P-QL*'&)+*%4E7>D<031$6WB$57$2FG)->D<057$L@ S )+5;B$L%1BD357$28D5.M* %/.M*%
A1 , A 2 , A 3 A4
Jd31)+,4,1$0FG$0*,9$0,u5.Z'1T.M34A=$ *)+34Fr.M57$ $&%1,^.M8D8D5;E7WB@&$L.MB_8
)+E;*-,(i6PC¡)+BD3FG)]>D@05;E7%1$03uBD*G@ S $0*,4B$0(O, 5
AC5;x,
E7%1%1y)
$0FG$0*-,bl
)+*e.M8D8D5;E7W-B$VBD*$6JO)+31'&$ ~ .MBe'&$0*-,431$V>D$gAC3/. S E;,1@ >?Bf'b.M3431@g,1$05;57$VW-B$ ~ P
F F = Fx .~x + Fy .~y
¢
N1
N É
z
N4 ¢
:?' b : :
A1 A4
Q
N2 [D' [
N3 a
A2 A3
[
) * , P ,'. y)]>D@05;E7%/.M,4E7)+*e>D$&%231@b.+'0,4E7)+*%*)+34Fr.M57$&%L$0*hJO)+*'0,4E7)+*e>m BD*$V'/T.M34A=$a.M8D8D5;E7W-B@&$
#$&% , E;*'&)+*D*B$&%6>D$g'&)+*,/.+'0,6%1)+*,H*)+,1@&$&% P
(Ni )i=1,4
#$V8D34E;*'0E;8
$ZJO)+*>.MFG$0*,/.M5>D$g5.`>?:]*.MF_E7WB$V%§mn@&'034E;,c
x , P;{CPvC=~
N1 + N 2 + N 3 + N 4 + N = 0
x , P;{CPv?{§~
Fx = m.γx
x , P;{CPvC=~
Fy = m.γy
ÉÊ-¨ É
!* * §
Lb
L
x , P;{CPvCU=~
b.N3 + b.N4 = −N.yc
x , P;{CPv , ~
a.N2 + a.N3 = −N.xc
x , P;{CPv = ~
N1 − N2 + N3 − N4 = 0
1
N1 = N
4
1
N2 = N x , P;{CPv =~
4
1
N3 = N
4
N4 = 1 N
4
#$8D34E;*'0E;8$r>D$31@08.M34,4E;,4E7)+* 5;E;*@b.ME;31$%48.M,4E.M57$>D$&%c31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%X*)+34Fr.M57$&%X8$0BD,a%bmv.M8D8D5;E7W-B$03 j BD*o*)+Fa\D31$
>D$6*)]$0B>D%2%4BD8
@034E7$0BD3 j , Pi^T.+W-B$Z*)-$0B>h%4BD8D8D57@0FG$0*-,/.ME;31$c.MB?[hUa*)]$0B>D%(8D34E;*'0E;8.MB?[R$0,(5Km T-:-8)+,4T<&%1$g>D$
ÉÊ-¨ÆÉ
!*
!"
31@08.M34,4E;,4E7)+*eJd)+BD34*DE;31)+*-,31$&%48$&'0,4E S $0FG$0*,X{ZE;*'&)+*D*B$X$0,V{g@&WB.M,4E7)+*%4BD8D8D57@0FG$0*,/.ME;31$CP
I5=$&%4,'&$08$0*>.M*,
8D5;B%E;*,1@031$&%1%/.M*-, >m BD,4E;5;E7%1$03 5Kmv.M5;A=)+34E;,4TDFG$>D$u>D@0,1$&'0,4E7)+*x S )+E;3
'1T.M8DE;,431$(U=~8
)+BD3 %1$t3/.MFG$0*$03
j BD*e*)+Fa\D31$_>D$V*)]$0B>D%6@0A.M5 j , 8D5;BD, ,gWB$a>D$a'&)+*%/$03 S $03LBD**)+Fc\D31$`>D$a*)-$0B>D%68f%1BD8
@034E7$0BD3 j , $0,
>D$Z31@&%1)+B>?31$c8Y@&WB.M,4E7)+*%§P
¨ Ê
,
*"
&
*+ ,
' #%+
!*
#%! "
, !
* ( ,
+
!
¡)+BD3g57$ S $03g5Km E;*>D@0,1$034F_E;*.M,4E7)+*z>?B%4:?%4,1<0FG$Cl
*)+B%g%1)+F_FG$&%V.MFG$0*@&% j 8D31)+8
)C%/$036BD*$`T-:-8)+,4T<&%1$`>D$X8D31)
8)+34,4E7)+*D*.M5;E;,1@c>D$&%231@b.+'0,4E7)+*%,/.M*DA=$0*,4E7$05;57$&%bP
É
¡)+BD32FG$0,4,431$Z$0*8D5.+'&$6*)C%9T:]8
)+,4T<&%/$&%2>D$8D31)+8)+34,4E7)+*D*.M5;E;,1@Cl)+*h'&)+*%4E7>D<031$Z57$L'b.+%(>D$L5.csACBD31$ , PX)57$&%
31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%6>D$V'&)+*,/.+'0,6%1)+*,L57)-'b.M5;E7%/@&$&%$0*Y,431)+E7%*)-$0B>D%bP#$g31$08<031$VA=@0*@03/.M5 $&%1, D57$g31$08<031$
ÉÉ
{O, x0 , y0 , z0 }
FG)+\DE;57$Cl^'Cmn$&%4, j >?E;31$e5;E7@f.MB %1)+5;E7>D$Y34E;ACE7>D$f$&%4 , l [l :=l ¢ P 6)+B%G,43/. S .ME;5;57)+*%>.M*%r57$Y31$08
<031$RFG)+\DE;57$Cl^5.
É
ES ;,1$&%1%1$a>D$c'&$05;BDE '0Et8.M33/.M8D8)+34,Z.MB31$08<031$VA=@0*@03/.M5k$&%4,L>D@qs*DE7$a8.M3657$ S $&'0,1$0BD3 S E;,1$&%/%1$ ~
$0,657$ S $&'0,1$0BD3Z31)+,/.M,4E7)+* ~ ~ 57$&%6E;*>?E7'&$&%LEt$0,^L'&)+3431$&%48)+*>D$0*,g31$&%48$&'0,4E S $0FG$0*V,c(G)
.MB*=BDFG(u, v, 0)
@031)R >?B
*)]$0B>e.ME;*%4EW-Bm j 5._>?E;31Ω$&'0= ,4E7)+(0,
* x0,
sACΩBD31$ , P =~qP
¡)+BD3BD*$g>?E;31$&'0,4E7)+*>D)+*D*@&$(0l?57$V3/.M8D8
)+34, T $&%4,257$ZFGN0FG$a$0*Y'1T.+W-B$g*)-$0B>P
N
NB TB j
NA
B
TAj j
A
) * , P 0/. 5;5;B%4,43/.M,4E7)+*f>m BD*$gT:]8
)+,4T<&%/$V>D$g8D31)+8)+34,4E7)+*D*.M5;E;,1@c$0*,431$XX*)-$0B>D%
#umn$qp)+34,bl$0*e'/T.+WB$V*)-$0B>l$&%1,H>D@&'&)+F_8 )C%1@c$0*e$qp)+34,2,/.M*DA=$0*-,4E7$05$0,H$0*f$qp)+34,2*)+34Fr.M5
x , P;{CPvUC=~
F~i = T~i + N
~i
ÉÊ-¨ É
!* * §
Lb
L
F3
N3
T33
A3 T3
F1
¢ T32
N1 N2 F2
e3
¢§ e2
T13 T1 :
:? [
[ Q e1
A1
T11 T21
A2
T2
T22
) * , P . #)]'b.M5;E7%/.M,4E7)+*e>D$&%231@b.+'0,4E7)+*%Z.MB?[*)]$0B>D%H$0,H31@08.M34,4E;,4E7)+*>D$&%231@b.+'0,4E7)+*%H,/.M*DA=$0*-,4E7$05;57$&%
e~2
e~3
T13
T1
T1y e~1
T11
A1 T1x
ÉÊ-¨ 3 É
!*
!"
•
!$
& "!$#%&')(
!*!*++,
|T | < f
N
QL*e>D@qs*DE;,6.M57)+31%2BD*$gT:]8)+,4T<&%1$V>D$g8D31)+8)+34,4E7)+*D*.M5;E;,1@c$0*-,431$V57$&%231@b.+'0,4E7)+*%,/.M*DA=$0*,4E7$05;57$&%X
#$&%G31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%G,/.M*DA=$0*,4E7$05;57$&%§l>D@qs*DE7$&%r>.M*%G57$h31$08
<031$RFG)+\DE;57$
8<031$YFG)+\DE;57$ l [l :=l ¢P^£,4E;,431$>mn$q[D$0F_8D57$.MB *)-$0B> l57$&{e
%'&1)+, F_
e2 , e3 }
lk%1)+*,r8D31)M|$0,1@&$&%G>.M*%G57$h31$
8)C%/.M*-,1$&%R'&) S .M34E.M*,1$&% $0,
É
A1 T11 T13
x31$08<031$c.+%1%1)]'0E7@_ ~(%bmn@&'034E S $0*-,L>.M*%257$V31$08
<031$gFG)+\DE;57$ l [l :=l ¢M~g
{e1 , e2 , e3 }
T11 = (T1x .~x + T1y .~y ).e~1 = T1x .cos(T~1x , T~11 ) + T1y .sin(T~1y , T~11 ) x , P;{CPvU , ~
T13 = (T1x .~x + T1y .~y ).e~3 = T1x .cos(T~1x , T~13 ) + T1y .sin(T~1y , T~13 )
>mn)l>m BD*e8
)+E;*-,>D$ S B$VA=@0*@03/.M5
x , P;{CPvU 0 ~
Tij = (Tix ~x + Tiy y~ )e~j = Tix .cos(T~ix , T~ij ) + Tiy .sin(T~iy , T~ij )
•
!$
& "!$#% (
!*!* ,
|T | = f
N
#$&%HT:]8
)+,4T<&%1$&%L>D$Z8D31)+8
)+34,4E7)+*D*.M5;E;,1@X%1)+*-,>?E;31$&'0,1$0FG$0*,Z>D@qs*DE7$&%H>.M*%H57$Z31$08<031$gFG)+\DE;57$ l [l :=l ¢
ÉÉ
'Cmn$&%4, j >?E;31$ x , P;{CPvUC}=~
q
2 2
T~ix + T~iy = f.Ni 2
Tix 2
+ Tiy = f 2 .N 2
ÉÊ É
!* * §
Lb
L
Vi
Vix
Tiy :
Viy
Tix
Ti
[
) * , P . $08D31@&%/$0*,/.M,4E7)+*R>D$25.V>D@&'&)+F_8)C%4E;,4E7)+*h>?B S $&'0,1$0BD39,/.M*DA=$0*,4E7$05$0,^>?B S $&'0,1$0BD3 S E;,1$&%1%1$cx57$L'&$031'057$
$&%4,25._,43/.+'&$V>?BY' * $V>D$ai9)+BD57)+Fa\~
w`mn)l
x , P;{CP , U=~
vix = u − Ω.GAiy
x , P;{CP , , ~
viy = v + Ω.GAix
£LE;*%4E$0*Y'1T.+W-B$V*)]$0B>R)+*Y8$0BD,H@&'034E;31$r
u − Ω.GAiy x , P;{CP , 0 ~
Tix = − .f Ni
||v~i ||
ÉÊ Ê²É
!*
!"
v + Ω.GAix x , P;{CP , = ~
Tiy = − .f Ni
||v~i ||
#$V8D31)+\D57<0FG$V$&%4,H\DE7$0*Y>D@0,1$034F_E;*@CP
A3
A4
A1
A2
) * , Pv} .
,/.ME;31$&%
:]8
)+,4T<&%1$6>D$Z8D31)+8)+34,4E7)+*D*.M5;E;,1@g,/.M*DA=$0*,4E7$05;57$ É Ua*)]$0B>D%(8D34E;*'0E;8.MB?[ ) *)]$0B>D%2%4BD8D8D57@0FG$0* É
-E)+*R8D31$0*>h5Kmn$q[D$0F_8D57$V>D$Z5.asACBD31$ , Pv}?l$0*h8D5;B%H>D$&%H>?E;31$&'0,4E7)+*%8D34E;*'0E;8.M57$&% 0$ , 0$ , l?E;5
JK.MBD,H$q[]8D34E;FG$0357$&%H31$05.M,4E7)+*%%1BD8D8D57@0FG$0*,/.ME;31$&%6>.M*%H57$&%H>?E;31$&'0,4E7)+*% $0, A1 A2P A2 A3 A3 A1
A3 A4 A4 A1
•
#%!
+!*!
É :]8)+,4T<&%1$g>D$g31@08.M34,4E;,4E7)+*f>.M*%HBD*$V>?E;31$&'0,4E7)+*f>D)+*D*@&$V>D$&%H31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%,/.M*DA=$0*-,4E7$05;57$&%bl
É
'b.+%H>D$Z*)+* AC5;E7%1%1$0FG$0*-,
¡k31)+8)+34,4E7)+*D*.M5;E;,1@6>D$&%9'&)+F_8)C%/.M*,1$&%9,/.M*DA=$0*,4E7$05;57$&%(8.M3^3/.M8D8
)+34,2.MB?[r'&)+F_8)C%/.M*,1$&%9*)+34Fr.M57$&%(>.M*%
BD*$c>?E;31$&'0,4E7)+*f>D)+*D*@&$(g
É :]8)+,4T<&%1$g>D$g31@08.M34,4E;,4E7)+*e5;E;*@b.ME;31$c%48.M,4E.M57$V>D$&%H31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%*)+34Fr.M57$&%bl
¡)+BD3RBD*$%1BD3|JO.+'&$>D$'&)+*,/.+'0, j * *)]$0B>D%bl9'&$0,4,1$T:]8
)+,4T<&%1$>D@qs*DE;,RW-B$f57$&%h$q[?,431N0F_E;,1@&%R>D$&%
31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%L*)+34Fr.M57$&%H8.+%/%1$0*,H8.M32BD*eFGN0FG$g8D5.M*P
ÉÊ ÀÉ
!* * §
Lb
L
yeE7%/$g$0*R8D5.+'&$V>?BY8D31)+\D57<0FG$
•
QL*'&)+*%4E7>D<031$`BD*8.M3/.M5;57@057@08DE;8
<&>D$r>D$X'&$0*-,431$_>D$XAC3/. S E;,1@ $0*'&)+*-,/.+'0,c. S $&'`BD*8D5.M*P#$`31$08
<031$X5;E7@_.MB
8D5.M*`>D$^'&)+*-,/.+'0,u$&%4, P+#$31$08<031$^5;E7@9.MB`%1)+5;E7>D$($&%4, P=#$^8.M3/.M5;57@057@08DE;8
<&>D$(8)+BD343/.LN0,431$
{0, xO , yO } {G, x, y, z}
$0*_FG)+B S $0FG$0*-,^)+B_E;F_FG)+\DE;57$CP I5?*mn$&%4,u%1)+BDF_E7%uW-Bm j %1)+*`8
)+E7>D%u8D31)+8D31$Vx . S $&' −2 l
F ]Fr.+%1%1$6>?BY%1)+5;E7>D$§~9.MBh*DE S $b.MBY>D$6%/)+*h'&$0*-,431$g>D$6AC3/. S E;,1@CPD#$g'&)+*,/.+'0P,H$0= *-,431m∗g
$Z57$6%/)+5;E7>D$6g$0=,(57−9.81m.s
$68D5.M*Y$&%4,2>D$
,I:-8$6J31)+,4,/.M*-,bl. S $&'ZJ57$c'&)-$ r'0E7$0*-,>D$ZJd31)+,4,1$0FG$0*,bP
zi
#$&%'&)-)+31>D)+*D*@&$&%6>?BY'&$0*,431$a>D$ZAC3/. S ;E ,1@ @0,/.M*-,c
n
X xi
i=1 p
n yi x , P;{CP 0 {§~
X
~
OG =
i=1 p
n
Xz
i
p
i=1
ÉÊ <Ë É
!*
!"
#$&%H31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%L>D$g'&)+*-,/.+'0,57)]'b.M5;E7%1@&$&%.MB?[R*)-$0B>D%%1)+*,H*)+,1@&$&%a
Tix
~i = x , P;{CP 0 =~
R Tiy
Ni
6)+B%g'&)+*%4E7>D@031)+*%cW-B$X,1)+BD,1$&%g57$&%Z31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%c$q[?,1@034E7$0BD31$&%g:'&)+F_8D34E7%V57$&%6JO)+31'&$&%g>m E;*$034,4E7$&%c%1)+*-,g31@&>?BDE;,1$&%
.MBY'&$0*-,431$c>D$gAC3/. S E;,1@V>?Be8
)+5;:=<&>?31$c. S $&'V'&)+F_FG$g31@&%4BD5;,/.M*-,1$VA=@0*@03/.M57$
Fx
x , P;{CP 0 U=~
F~ = Fy
Fz
k,57$ZFG)+FG$0*,L$q[?,1@034E7$0BD3c
L
x , ;P {CP 0 , ~
M (F~ )/G = M
P
QL*h,43/. S .ME;5;57$Z%4BD3957$31$08<031$6FG)+\DE;57$Cl-57$Z'b.M57'0BD5>D$&%9FG)+FG$0*,1%H>D$&%^JO)+31'&$&%($0*'/T.+WB$6*)]$0B>l]$0,2>D$&% S E;,1$&%1%1$&%
%1)+*-,H31@b.M5;E7%1@&%28.M33/.M8D8
)+34,L.MBY'&$0*-,431$c>D$gAC3/. S E;,1@ >?BY8)+5;:=<&>?31$CP
¨ ÊË %
!*
, #% % + ') !*,
#%!
, ! !
*
! #% !
31$&%4,4E;,4BD,4E7)+*e*)+34Fr.M57$§~qP QL*Y31@&%1)+B>f.M57)+31%2BD*Y8D31)+\D57<0FG$V%4,/.M,4E7W-B$CP
p
X x , P;{CP 0 0 ~
Tix + Fx = 0
i=1
p
X x , P;{CP 0 = ~
Tiy + Fy = 0
i=1
p
X x , P;{CP 0 C~
Ni + F z = 0
i=1
#$_%/)+5;E7>D$_@0,/.M*,V34E;ACE7>D$Cl57$&%ZFG)+FG$0*-,1%c$0*'/T.+WB$_*)]$0B>'b.M57'0BD57@&%V8.M3g3/.M8D8)+34,c.MB'&$0*,431$r>D$`AC3/. S E;,1@
31$&%4,1$0*-,'&)+*%4,/.M*-,1%6.MBY'&)+BD31%L>?BY'b.M57'0BD5KP
p p
X zi X yi x , P;{CP 0 =~
Tiy ( (1 − p)) − Ni ( (1 − p)) + L = 0
p p
i=1 i=1
ÉÊ ¨ É
!* * §
Lb
L
p p
X xi X zi x , P;{CP 0 }=~
Ni ( (1 − p)) − Tix ( (1 − p)) + M = 0
p p
i=1 i=1
p p
X yi X xi x , P;{CPC=~
Tix ( (1 − p)) − Tiy ( (1 − p)) + P = 0
p p
i=1 i=1
#$&%LU`*)-$0B>D%H8D34E;*'0E;8.MB?[o{Cl`$0,LU`%1)+*,L'1T)+E7%4E7%bP
#$&%aF¦@&W-B.M,4E7)+*%X%4BD8D8D57@0FG$0*,/.ME;31$&%`31$05.M,4E S $&%_.MB?[E;*'&)+*D*B$&%X*)+34Fr.M57$&%`%4BD8D8D57@0FG$0*-,/.ME;31$&%_%1)+*,X>D@qs*DE7$&%
8.M3c
x1 x2 x3 xj
8)+BD32,1)+B%H57$&% x , P;{CP?{§~
y1 y2 y3 yj
=0 j[1, m]
N1 N2 N3 Nj
1 1 1 1
#$&%H31$05.M,4E7)+*%L>D$g'&)+F_8.M,4E;\DE;5;E;,1@a8
)+BD3257$&%LUX*)-$0B>D%8D34E;*'0E;8.MB?[R%/)+*,>D@qs*DE7$&%8.M3c
ÉÊ ÀÉ
!*
!"
#)+31%/WB$`57$&%g'&)+F_8)C%/.M*,1$&%c,/.M*DA=$0*,4E7$05;57$&%a%1)+*,V>D@&'&)+F_8)C%1@&$&%V>.M*%g57$X31$08<031$
8)C%/.M*,1$&%L'&) S .M34E.M*,1$&%6%1)+*,L>D)+*D*@&$&%H8.M3V {G, x, y, z}
.M57)+31%g57$&%g'&)+F É
x , P;{CPC}=~
Tij = (Tix .~x + Tiy .~y ).e~j = Tix .cos(T~ix , T~ij ) + Tiy .sin(T~iy , T~ij )
•
#+!$
!
#$&%@&W-B.M,4E7)+*% 5;E;*@b.ME;31$&%Hx , P;{CP 0 C~ql?x , P;{CP 0 =~ $0,9x , P;{CP 0 }=~.+%1%1)]'0E7@&$&%t.MB?[c@&WB.M,4E7)+*%t%4BD8D8D57@0FG$0*-,/.ME;31$&%x , P;{CP?{§~
¨ ÊË !*,
#+!$
!$#
! #% !
& +
wg.M*%^57$'b.+%9>D$5.c>?:-*.MF_E7W-B$Cl->D$&%JO)+31'&$&%^>m E;*$034,4E7$LJK.ME7%/.M*,9E;*,1$03 S $0*DE;3(57$&%9'&)+F_8
)C%/.M*-,1$&%(>D$H5. S E;,1$&%1%/$>?B
'&$0*-,431$c>m E;*$034,4E7$V$0,>D$Z5._31)+,/.M,4E7)+* S E7$0*D*$0*-,L%bmv.4)+BD,1$03L.MBY%4:?%4,1<0FG$g>mn@&W-B.M,4E7)+*%%4,/.M,4E7W-B$&%bP
£ ,4E;,431$h>mn$q[D$0F_8D57$Cl 8)+BD3X57$rFG)+B S $0FG$0*-,G>m BD* %1)+5;E7>D$$0* '&)+*,/.+'0,_8$031%4E7%4,/.M*,`%4BD3XBD*z8D5.M*zsD[D$Cl
57$&%h{b
E;*'&)+*D*-B$&%L>?BR8D31)+\D57<0FG$a%1)+*,c
É 57$&%}G'&)+F_8
)C%/.M*-,1$&%>D$&%231@b.+'0,4E7)+*%L>D$V'&)+*,/.+'0, l
É (Tix , Tiy , Ni , i = 1, 3)
57$&%UE;*'&)+*D*B$&%h'0E;*@0Fr.M,4E7WB$&%xOo'&)+F_8
)C%/.M*-,1$&%h>D$ S E;,1$&%1%1$oxBl S lv=~4~r$0,f{e'&)+F_8)C%/.M*-,1$f>D$f31)+,/.M,4E7)+*
xO?lv?l ~gx31)+,/.M,4E7)+*f%4BDE S .M*-,H5.`*)+34Fr.M57$c.MBe8D5.M*e>D$g'&)+*,/.+'0,~qP
Ω
#$&%`@&W-B.M,4E7)+*%`8
$034FG$0,4,/.M*-,_5.f31@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*%1)+*,_>D)+*D*@&$&%`8.M3X57$&% e@&W-B.M,4E7)+*%_>D$r5.>?:]*.MF_E7WB$h$0,X57$&%
@&W-B.M,4E7)+*%Xx , P;{CP , 0 ~qltx , P;{CP , =~>D$V'&)+F_8.M,4E;\DE;5;E;,1@`>D$VAC5;E7%1%1$0FG$0*-,bP#m E;*DE;,4E.M5;E7%/.M,4E7)+*>?BY8D31)-'&$&%/%4B%>D$c31@&%1)+5;B
,4E7)+*E;,1@03/.M,4EJ $&%4,9>D)+*D*@&$8.M3957$L'b.+%9%4,/.M,4E7W-B$LW-BDE>D)+*D*$L57$6%1$0*%>D$&%931@b.+'0,4E7)+*%9,/.M*DA=$0*,4E7$05;57$&%H.+>?F_E7%1%1E;\D57$&%bP
É
É
#$c%4:]%1,1<0FG$g>mn@&WB.M,4E7)+*%L'0E >D$&%1%1)+B%H%1$Z31@&%/)+B>RE;,1@03/.M,4E S $0FG$0*,bP
#$c'&)+*,/.+'0,L%/$6JO.ME;,H%4BD32BD*$c%4BD3|JO.+'&$Z8D5.M*$c>D$g*)+34Fr.M57$ P
$&%1,V57$_FG)+FG$0*,X>m E;*$034,4E7$r%4BDE S .M*,a5.h*)+34Fr.M57$.MBo8D~z5.M*lF 5.hFr.+%1%/$G>?Bo%1)+5;E7>D$ *z'&)+3431$&%48
)+*> j 5.
Izz
*-BDFG@031)+,/.M,4E7)+*
>D$r5Km E;,1@03/.M,4E7)+* $0,a8 '&)+3431$&%48)+*> .MBz*)+Fc\D31$h>D$8
)+E;*-,1%c*)]>.MB?[ To57$8.+%X>D$r,1$0F_8%`>D$
5Km E;,1@03/.M,4E7)+*P
i9)+F_FG$R8)+BD3_57$Y'b.+%G$0*
>D$0B?[>?E;FG$0*%4E7)+*%bl)+* @&'034E;3/.57$&%G@&W-B.M,4E7)+*%G>D$R5.>?:]*.MF_E7WB$e$0*,1$034FG$&%r>D$
W-B.M*,4E;,1@&%L>D$gFG)+B S $0FG$0*,bP
#$&%@&WB.M,4E7)+*%L>D$g5.`>?:-*.MF_E7W-B$V%bmn@&'034E;31)+*-,a
p
X
n+1 x , P;{CP +=~
h∗ Tix + h ∗ Fx = m ∗ (un+1 − un )
i=1
p
X
n+1 x , P;{CP ]{§~
h∗ Tiy + h ∗ Fy = m ∗ (v n+1 − v n )
i=1
p
X x , P;{CP +=~
Nin+1 + Fz = 0
i=1
ÉÊ É
!** § z
p p
n+1
X zi X yi x , P;{CP +U=~
h∗ Tiy ( (1 − p)) − h ∗ Nin+1 ( (1 − p)) + h ∗ L = m ∗ (v n+1 − v n )
p p
i=1 i=1
p p
X xi X zi x , P;{CP , ~
h ∗ Nin+1 ( n+1
(1 − p)) − h ∗ Tix ( (1 − p)) + h ∗ M = −m ∗ (un+1 − un )
p p
i=1 i=1
p p
n+1
X yi n+1
X xi x , P;{CP 0 ~
h ∗ Tix ( (1 − p)) − h ∗ Tiy ( (1 − p)) + h ∗ P = Izz ∗ (Ωn+1 − Ωn )
p p
i=1 i=1
k,57$&%H@&WB.M,4E7)+*%L%4BD8D8D57@0FG$0*,/.ME;31$&%X
u − Ω.GAiy x , P;{CP = ~
Tix = − .f Ni
||v~i ||
x1 x2 x3 xj
8)+BD32,1)+B%H57$&% x , P;{CP =~
y1 y2 y3 yj
=0 j[1, m]
N1 N2 N3 Nj
1 1 1 1
(
Z
t
/ X
,1$0F_8%bl8
)+BD32BD*e%/)+5;E7>D$ZE;F_FG)+\DE;57$CP
É
# $&%aE;,1@03/.M,4E7)+*%`>.M*%c57$'b.+%a>D$r*)+* AC5;E7%1%1$0FG$0*-,XA=<031$0*-,a5.eF_E7%1$$0*o8D5.+'&$>D$&%c'&)+*,/.+'0,1%_$0*oJd)+*'0,4E7)+* >?B
#$&%HE;,1@03/.M,4E7)+*%>.M*%(57$g'b.+%H>D$ZAC5;E7%1%/$0FG$0*,HA=<031$0*-,H5.XF_E7%1$g$0*R8D5.+'&$g>D$&%H'&)+*-,/.+'0,1%$0*hJO)+*'0,4E7)+*Y>?BR,1$0F_8%bl
8)+BD32BD*e%1)+5;E7>D$V$0*RFG)+B S $0FG$0*-,bP
ÉÊ ÆÉ
!*
!"
-BD3|JK.+'&$V>D$V'&)+*-,/.+'0,
j , *)-$0B>D%
¡ _
@&W-B.M,4E7)+*% ¡ w _
@&W-B.M,4E7)+*%
>.M*%BD*$g>?E;31$&'0,4E7)+*f>D)+*D*@&$ >.M*%BD*$g>?E;31$&'0,4E7)+*f>D)+*D*@&$
É5;E;*{Z@bT.M:]E;318$V)+%4,48T.M<&,4%1E$V.M57>D$ $Z31@08.M34,4E;,4E7)+* É5;E;*{Z@bT-.M:-E;318$V)+%1,48T.M<&,4%1E$V.M57>D$ $Z31@08.M34,4E;,4E7)+*
>D$&%231@b.+'0,4E7)+*%H*)+34Fr.M57$&% >D$&%231@b.+'0,4E7)+*%*)+34Fr.M57$&%
Eu?E;,1@03/.M,4E7)+*%6%4BD3V{Z8.+%H>D$g,1$0F_8% Eu?E;,1@03/.M,4E7)+*%L%4BD3V{Z8.+%>D$g,1$0F_8%
yf3VDFr.M,434E7'&$g3/.ME7>D$0BD3 0 %1,/.M,4E7WB$ yf3V?Fr.M,434E7'&$V3/.ME7>D$0BD3 0 >?:-*.MF_E7W-B$
( %4F S &$ '0,1$0BD3L%/$&'&)+*>hFG$0Fc\D31$ ( %4F S &$ '0,1$0BD36%1$&'&)+*>hFG$0Fc\D31$
( 31$&%V S $&'0,1$0BD3H31@&%/)+5;BD,4E7)+* ( 31$&%c S $&'0,1$0BD3H31@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*
( 31$&%§x(;l E ) {§~ E;* S xdyf3~ 1( %4Fex;l E ) {§~ ( 31$&%x(;l E ) {§~ ;E * S xdye3~ 1( %4FexL;l E ) {§~
@&%/)+5;BD,4E7)+*YE;,1@03/.M,4E S $
@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*YE;,1@03/.M,4E S $
(
( /
a
QL*X@0,4B>?E7$u57$u'b.+% >m BD*c8D34E7%4FG$^>?31)+E;,
8)C%1@u%4BD3BD*a8D5.M*a$0*c'&)+*%1E7>D@03/.M*,t%1$&%
%1)+F_FG$0,1%'&)+F_FG$@0,/.M*-, 57$&%
,431)+E7%
*)]$0B>D% >D$^'&)+*,/.+'0,1%bPCi9$0, $q[D$0F_8D57$u8$034FG$0,t>D$ S .M5;E7>D$03
57$&%T-:-8)+,4T<&%1$&%
JO.ME;,1$&% 8)+BD3
57$ S $03
5Km E;*>D@0,1$034F_E;*.M,4E7)+*
>D$&%231@b.+'0,4E7)+*%,/.M*DA=$0*,4E7$05;57$&%bP
ÉÊ É
!* * -
-
#$V,1)+31%1$0BD3'0E;*@0Fr.M,4E7W-B$V$&%4,V
vx 0 x , PvU?Pv=~
T = v 0
y
0 Ωz
#$V8D34E7%4FG$V$&%4,H'&)+*%4E7>D@031@V31$&%4,/.M*,H,1)+B+4)+BD31%$0*Y'&)+*-,/.+'0,bP
.
[
:
A3
A2 [
zo A1
Q yo
xo
) * , P;{C{ . @&)+FG@0,434E7$c>?BY8D34E7%4FG$
6)+B%28D31$0*)+*%H57$&%H8.M3/.MFG<0,431$&%*-BDFG@034E7WB$&%L%4BDE S .M*-,1%c
É i9)]$r'0E7$0*,6>D$ZJ31)+,4,1$0FG$0*-,a]J ?P , l
É .MBD,1$0BD3>?Be%1)+5;E7>D$_. {0FYl
É y.+%1%1$g>?BY%1)+5;E7>D$r?F {bCC & AP
É i9)])+31>D)+*D*@&$&%L>D$&%H*)-$0B>D%V √ √ √
É
A1 = (− 33 , −1, −1) A2 = ( 2 3 3 , 0, 1) A3 = (− 33 , 1, −1)
¡t.+%>D$g,1$0F_8%c
É ÉÉ
>.M*%57$X'b.+%L*)+* AC5;E7%1%/.M*,bl
57$X%4:?%4,1<0FG$c>mn@&W-B.M,4E7)+*%Z$&%4,31@&%1)+5;B>D$cJO.&)+*fE;,1@03/.M,4E S $X'Cmn$&%1, j >?E;31$XW-B$
57$a'b.M57'0BD5k>D$&%631@b.+'0,4E7)+*%V.MB?[Y*)]$0B>D%6>D@08$0*>>?Bf,1$0F_8%§P
#
$c8.M3/.MFG<0,431$X,1$0F_8%ZT$&%4,Z.M57)+31%68D34E7%Z$0*
'&)+F_8D,1$a>.M*%25._%4BDE;,1$Cl
>.M*%257$g'b.+%AC5;E7%1%/.M*,bl %Vx8.M36.M*.M57)+ACE7$a. S $&'V57$V'&)->D$g>D$c'b.M57'0BD5
#y i(}C=~qP
h = 10−4
ÉÊ 3 É
!*
!"
34E7$0BD31%L$&%4,2,1)+B+|)+BD31%L.M8D8D5;E7WB@c.MBf'&$0*,431$c>D$ZAC3/. S E;,1@a>?BY%1)+5;E7>D$CP
É
Q *
.M8D8D5;E7WB$BD*$Jd)+31'&$$q[?,1@034E7$0BD31$ ~
L l5.f%4E;FcBD5.M,4E7)+**-BDFG@034E7WB$h>D)+*D*$57$&%X31@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%
• F = 3000~x
%4BDE S .M*,1%c
5000
−200
4500 Noeud1
Noeud2
Noeud3 −400
4000
3500 −600
3000
−800
2500
2000 −1000
1500
−1200
1000
−1400
500
0 −1600
2 4 6 8 10 2 4 6 8 10
Itérations sur 1 pas de temps Itérations sur 1 pas de temps
) * , P;{b . @b.+'0,4E7)+*%*)+34Fr.M57$&%$0,2,/.M*DA=$0*,4E7$05;57$&%g.MB?[h*)-$0B>D%>?BY8D34E7%4FG$g8)+BD3
Fx = 3000N
# $6,1)+31%1$0BD3H'0E;*@0Fr.M,4E7W-B$V.a,1)+BD,1$&%H%1$&%('&)+F_8)C%/.M*,1$&%2*-BD5;57$&%V]57$Z%1)+5;E7>D$631$&%4,1$ZE;F_FG)+\DE;57$CPi9$631@&%4BD5;,/.M,H@0,/.ME;,
8D31@ S E7%4E;\D57$Cl$0*e.+'&'&)+31>. S $&'g5. S .M57$0BD3H>D$g5.aJO)+31'&$V$q[?,1@034E7$0BD31$c.M8D8D5;E7WB@&$CP
#$&%'&)+BD34\
$&%L>D$Z5.XsACBD31$ , P;{b_%1)+*-,H,43/.+'&@&$&%H8)+BD3V{b`E;,1@03/.M,4E7)+*%bP
i9)+F_FG$Z8)+BD325Kmn$q[?$0F_8D57$g$0*YX>?E;FG$0*%4E7)+*%bl57$&%(31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%2,/.M*DA=$0*,4E7$05;57$&%L%bmn)+8D8
)C%/$0*, j 5.cJd)+31'&$g$q[?,1@034E7$0BD31$
$0,H57$&%L31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%6%1)+*,L8D5;B%@057$ S @&$&%Z.MBe*DE S $b.MBf>?Bf*)-$0B> W-Bmv.MB?[R*)-$0B>D% $0, P#
.G>?E;31$&'0,4E7)+*>D$
5.GJd)+31'&$`$q[?,1@034E7$0BD31$`$&%4,Z8
)C%4E;,4E S $X%4BDE S .M*,Z5Kmv.[D$ ~ P#$`%1)+A5;E72>D$a%§mv.M8D8DBDE7$a8D5;B%gA%1BD136%1)+A *3*)]$0B> WBmv.MB?[
Ox A2
>D$0B?[o.MBD,431$&%V*)]$0B>D%bP# .R%1)+F_FG$G>D$&%g31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%a *)+34Fr.M57$&% l $0, >D)+*D*$G57$_8
)+E7>D%a>?B \D57)-'CP
#
.
É
N1 N2 N3
'&)+*>?E;,4E7)+* >D$_*)+* AC5;E7%1%1$0FG$0*-, q 2 2 xE {ClvU=~c$&%4, S @034Es@&$CP#$&%c31@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%a>?Bz'b.+%a%4,/.M,4E7W-B$
T + T < f Ni
%1)+*-,'&)+T@031$0*,1%Z. S $&'V57$&%2T:]8
)+,4T<&%/$&ix%2JK.ME;,1$&iy%bP
#
.%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*%4,/.M,4E7W-B$a'&)+* S $034A=$_.MBf\)+BD,6>D$`UrE;,1@03/.M,4E7)+*%6$0,Z%1$X%4,/.M\DE;5;E7%1$ j 5. S .M57$0BD3Ls*.M57$CP¡ )+BD3Z57$X'b.+%
>?:]*.MF_E7WB$(57$98.+%k>D$(,1$0F_8%k$&%4,k'/T)+E7%4E j −4 %blE7'0ED57$&%t*)-$0B>D%k>D$('&)+*,/.+'0,1%31$&%4,1$0*,kE;F_FG)+\DE;57$&%$0,u%4,/.M\D57$&%
>?BD3/.M*-,957$&%9E;,1@03/.M,4E7)+*%bPQL*R'1T)+E7%1E;,2.M57)+31%9BD10*8.+%(>D$,1$0F_8%2>D$ −3 %98.M3(.M*.M57)+ACE7$g. S $&'657$Z'&)]>D$L>D$6'b.M57'0BD5
10
#y i(}C?P
ÉÊ É
!* * -
-
#$c'b.M57'0BD5
>D$&%231@b.+'0,4E7)+*%$&%1,.M3431N0,1@a. S $&'VBD*Y,1$&%4,H>D$g'&)+* S $034A=$0*'&$CPQL*RJO$03/.`>D$gFGN0FG$g8.M3H5.`%1BDE;,1$CP
w .M*%25.`>D$0B?[]E7<0FG$a%4E;FcBD5.M,4E7)+*l)+*e.MBDACFG$0*,1$a5. S .M57$0BD3L>D$Z5.XJd)+31'&$g$q[?,1@034E7$0BD31$ ~
g
• F = 10000~x
#
.G'&)+BD34\
$V>D$Z5.`sACBD31$ , P;{bU`FG)+*,431$aWB$Z57$ZFG)]>D<057$g8D31@&>?E;,H\DE7$0*e57$gFG)+B S $0FG$0*,Z.M,4,1$0*>?BP
0.08
7
0.06
6
0.04
Accélération suivant axe Ox
4 0
−0.02
3
−0.04
2
−0.06
1
−0.08
0 −0.1
2 4 6 8 10 2 4 6 8 10
Itérations sur 1 pas de temps Itérations sur 1 pas de temps
Fx = 10000N
#
. S .M57$0BD3u>D$(5Kmv.+'&'&@057@03/.M,4E7)+*G5;E;*@b.ME;31$ %1BDE S .M*-,k5Kmv.[?$ ~ $&%4,k'&)+*%4,/.M*,1$cx ~ $0,t8)C%4E;,4E S $CP
#$c%1)+5;E7>D$g%1$g>D@08D5.+'&$c%1BDE S .M*-,H5.`>?E;31$&Γ'0,4xE7)+* ~ xd'b.+%2AC5;Ox E7%1%/.M*-,~qP Fext = constante
Ox
ÉÊ Ê²É
!*
!"
−100
5500
−300
5000
Noeud1
Noeud2 −500
4500
Noeud3
−700
4000
−900
3500
−1100
3000
−1300
2500
−1500
2000
−1700
1500
−1900
1000 −2100
500 −2300
0 −2500
2 4 6 8 10 2 4 6 8 10
Itérations sur 1 pas de temps Itérations sur 1 pas de temps
T-:-8)+,4T<&%1$&%(JK.ME;,1h$&%%1)+*-,H'&)+*?Jd)+34FG$&%L$&%4,25.`31@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*e*BDFG@034E7W-B$c>D$g5Kmn@&W-B.M,4E7)+*zx , PvU?PvU=~ZP
ÉP (un+1 −un ) l
É£LE;*%4EKl
h = 6.05m.s−2
Ti x = −3950N
l
$0, P#umn@&W-B.M,4E7)+*
P (un+1 −un )
Fx + Ti x = 10000 − 3950 = 6050N m∗ = 1000 ∗ 6.05 = 6050N
x , PvU?PvU=~($&%1, S @034Es@&$CP h
#$&%(31@&%1BD5;,/.M,1%2>?Bh'b.+%(AC5;E7%/%/.M*,H%1)+*-,2'&)+T@031$0*,1%L. S $&'Z57$&%9T:]8
)+,4T<&%1$&%9JK.ME;,1$&%(8)+BD3957$ S 0$ 325Km E;*>D@0,1$034F_E;*.M,4E7)+*P
#
.G%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*e>?:]*.MF_E7WB$V'&)+* S $034A=$a.MBR\)+BD,>D$VU`E;,1@03/.M,4E7)+*%L$0,%1$g%4,/.M\DE;5;E7%1$ j 5. S .M570$ BD32s*.M57$CP
ÉÊ ÀÉ
!* * -
-
3000 30 30
2750
2500
10 10
2250
2000 0 0
1750
−10 −10
1500
−20 −20
1250
750
−40 −40
500
−50 −50
250
0 −60 −60
2 4 6 8 10 2 4 6 8 10 2 4 6 8 10
Itérations sur 1 pas de temps Itérations sur 1 pas de temps Itérations sur 1 pas de temps
#$&%2'&)+F_8)C%/.M*-,1$&%>?Bh,1)+31%1$0BD3H'0E;*@0Fr.M,4E7W-B$V%1)+*,2,1)+BD,1$&%(*-BD5;57$&%V?57$Z%1)+5;E7>D$Z31$&%4,1$6E;F_FG)+\DE;57$CP#
. S .M57$0BD3H>?B
FG)+FG$0*-,L$q[?,1@034E7$0BD3L.M8D8D5;E7WB@V*mn$&%4,H8.+%H%4Br%.M*,1$g8)+BD3>D@08D5.+'&$03H57$V%/)+5;E7>D$CP
#$&%'&)+BD34\
$&%L>D$Z5.XsACBD31$ , P;{ 0 %1)+*-,H,43/.+'&@&$&%H8)+BD3V{b`E;,1@03/.M,4E7)+*%bP
AC5;E7%1%/$0FG$0*,
T1y + T3y = −T2y
#
.e%1)+F_FG$r>D$&%c31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%c*)+34Fr.M57$&%
N1 N2
l $0,
N3
>D)+*D*Oy
$0*,X57$_8)+E7>D%c>?Bo\D57)]'CP
# .Y'&)+*>?E;,4E7)+* >D$_*)+* É
2 + T 2 < f N xE {ClvU=~9$&%4, S @034Es@&$CP#$&%(31@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%H>?BR'b.+%H%1,/.M,4E7WB$Z%1)+*-,H'&)+T@031$0*,1%L. S $&'
q
Tix i
57$&%2T-:-8)+,4T<&%1$&%HJO.ME;,1$&%bPiy
i $&%g31@&%1BD5;,/.M,1%V%1)+*,a'&)+*?Jd)+34FG$&%c. S $&'_5.hA=@&)+FG@0,434E7$G>?B%/)+5;E7>D$CP#$_%4E;AC*$G>D$&%Z31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%c,/.M*DA=$0*,4E7$05;57$&%X>D@
9
8$0*>_>?BG%4E;AC*$2>?B_FG)+FG$0*,^$q[],1@034E7$0BD3^.M8D8D5;E7W-B@2$0,k5. S .M57$0BD3u>D$&%k31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%u,/.M*DA=$0*-,4E7$05;57$&%>D@08$0*>G>D$(57$0BD31%
É
8)C%4E;,4E7)+*%28.M3H3/.M8D8)+34, j 5Kmv.[D$V>D$Z31)+,/.M,4E7)+*f$0,H>D$&%L.[?$&% ~ $0, ~ P
Ox Oy
#
.G%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*e%4,/.M,4E7W-B$g'&)+* S $034A=$X.MBY\
)+BD,H>m BD*$cE;,1@03/.M,4E7)+*e $0,%1$g%1,/.M\DE;5;E7%1$ j 5. S .M57$0BD32s*.M57$CP
ÉÊ IË É
!*
!"
−1
0.8
−2
0.6
−3
Accélération suivant axe Ox et Oy
0.4
0.2
−5
0 −6
−7
−0.2
−8
−0.4
−9
−0.6
−10
−0.8
−11
−1 −12
2 4 6 8 10 2 4 6 8 10
Itérations sur 1 pas de temps Itérations sur 1 pas de temps
>?BY8D34E7%1FG$Z8
)+BD3
Mz = −60000N m
ÉÊ ¨ É
!* * -
-
1750 0
300
1500 −200
100
1250
−400
1000 −100
−600
750
−300
−800
500
−1000 −500
250
0 −1200 −700
2 4 6 8 10 2 4 6 8 10 2 4 6 8 10
Itérations sur 1 pas de temps Itérations sur 1 pas de temps Itérations sur 1 pas de temps
+
+
#+!$!
!
ÉÊ ÀÉ
!*
!"
−1000
3500
−1150
3000
−1300
2500 −1450
−1600
2000
−1750
1500 −1900
1000 −2050
−2200
500
−2350
0 −2500
2 4 6 8 10 2 4 6 8 10
Itérations sur 1 pas de temps Itérations sur 1 pas de temps
) * , P;{ . L@b.+'0,4E7)+*%2*)+34Fr.M57$&%L$0,2,/.M*DA=$0*-,4E7$05;57$&%6.MB?[R*)]$0B>D%H>?BY8D34E7%4FG$Z8)+BD3
Fx = −m ∗ g ∗ f
QL*@0,4B>?E7$Fr.ME;*-,1$0*.M*,257$'b.+%9>m BD*'0BD\$H8)C%1@L%4BD3BD*8D5.M*r8)+BD3FG)]>D@05;E7%1$039W-B.M,431$H*)]$0B>D%9>D$'&)+*,/.+'0,1%§P
i9$0,t$q[?$0F_8D57$98$034FG$0,k>D$ S .M5;E7>D$03t57$&% T-:-8)+,4T<&%1$&%8)+BD3 57$ S $03t5Km E;*>D@0,1$034F_E;*.M,4E7)+*r>D$&%31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%t*)+34Fr.M57$&%k$0,
,/.M*DA=$0*-,4E7$05;57$&%bP¡t.M3H3/.M8D8
)+34, j 5Kmn$q[D$0F_8D57$g>?Bh8D34E7%4FG$Cl?5Km T:]8
)+,4T<&%/$g>D$L31@08.M34,4E;,4E7)+*e5;E;*@b.ME;31$g%4BD3(57$&%H.+'0,4E7)+*%
*)+34Fr.M57$&%L$&%4,.|)+BD,1@&$CP
ÉÊ É
!* * -
-
#$V,1)+31%1$0BD3'0E;*@0Fr.M,4E7W-B$V$&%4,V
v 0
x x , PvU?P 0 ~
T = vy 0
0 Ωz
#$c'0BD\ $g$&%4,H'&)+*%1E7>D@031@V31$&%4,/.M*-,H,1)+B+|)+BD31%L$0*Y'&)+*,/.+'0,bP
.
[
A4 A3
\
zo [
A1 A2
Q yo
xo
) * , P;{b} . @&)+FG@0,434E7$a>?BY'0BD\
$
6)+B%28D31$0*)+*%H57$&%H8.M3/.MFG<0,431$&%*-BDFG@034E7WB$&%L%4BDE S .M*-,1%c
É i9)]$r'0E7$0*,6>D$ZJ31)+,4,1$0FG$0*-,a]J ?P , l
É .MBD,1$0BD3>?Be%1)+5;E7>D$_. {0FYl
É #
.M34A=$0BD36>?Be%1)+5;E7>D$_?\ {0FYl
É y.+%1%1$g>?BY%1)+5;E7>D$r?F {bCC & AP
É i9)])+31>D)+*D*@&$&%L>D$&%H*)-$0B>D%V
É
¡t.+%>D$g,1$0F_8%c'&)+F_FG$g8)+BDA3215Kmn= $q[?$0(0,
F_8D0,57$c−1)
8D31@&'&@&A>D2$0*=,bl (1, 0, −1) A3 = (1, 1, −1) A4 = (0, 1, −1)
É
>.M*%V57$_'b.+%c*)+* AC5;E7%1%/.M*-,bl57$G%4:?%4,1<0FG$_>mn@&W-B.M,4E7)+*%c$&%4,c31@&%1)+5;Bo>D$XJK.&)+*E;,1@03/.M,4E S $CP
#$G8.M3/.MFG<0,431$
,1$0F_8%HTY$&%4,28D34E7%L$0*Y'&)+F_8D,1$Cl
>.M*%257$g'b.+%AC5;E7%1%/.M*,bl −4 %Vx8.M36.M*.M57)+ACE7$a. S $&'V57$V'&)->D$g>D$c'b.M57'0BD5
#y i(}C=~qP
É i9)+*>?E;,4E7)+*%_E;*DE;,4E.M57$&%R h = 10
AC5;E7%1%.M*,~qP N1 = N2 = N3 = N4 = − m∗g 4
u = v = 0m.s−1
$0,
Ω = 0rad.s−1
xd'b.+%
#
.6A=@&)+FG@0,434E7$>?B`'0BD\$2$&%4,k%4:]FG@0,434E7WB$H.MBD,1)+BD3u>D$2%/)+*_.[D$(>D$(31)+,/.M,4E7)+*P=#$(,1)+31%1$0BD3u>D$&%k$qp)+34,1%k$q[?,1@034E7$0BD31%
ÉÊ ÆÉ
!*
!"
$&%4,2,1)+B+4)+BD31%L.M8D8D5;E7W-B@&$c.MBe'&$0*-,431$V>D$gAC3/. S E;,1@V>?Bf%1)+5;E7>D$CP
Q *R.M8D8D5;E7WB$6BD*$LJd)+31'&$6$q[?,1@034E7$0BD31$V.MB'0BD\$ ~
L xE;*'05;E;*@&$ j ◦ 8.M3(3/.M8D8)+34,2.MB?[
' ,1@&%H>?Bf'0BD\
$§~qlD5.`%1E;FcBD5.M,4E7)+*e*-BDFG@034E7WB$a>D)+*D*$g57$&%231@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%L%4BDE S .M*,1%c
• F = 1000~x − 1000~y 45
800 −240 80
600 −260 60
400 −280 40
200 −300 20
0 −320 0
2 4 6 8 10 2 4 6 8 10 2 4 6 8 10
Itérations sur 1 pas de temps Itérations sur 1 pas de temps Itérations sur 1 pas de temps
−1000N
#$6,1)+31%1$0BD3H'0E;*@0Fr.M,4E7W-B$V.a,1)+BD,1$&%H%1$&%('&)+F_8)C%/.M*,1$&%2*-BD5;57$&%V]57$Z%1)+5;E7>D$631$&%4,1$ZE;F_FG)+\DE;57$CPi9$631@&%4BD5;,/.M,H@0,/.ME;,
8D31@ S E7%4E;\D57$Cl$0*e.+'&'&)+31>. S $&'g57$&% S .M57$0BD31%>D$Z5.`Jd)+31'&$g$q[?,1@034E7$0BD31$c.M8D8D5;E7W-B@&$CP
#$&%'&)+BD34\
$&%L>D$Z5.XsACBD31$ , PvC_%1)+*-,H,43/.+'&@&$&%H8)+BD3V{b`E;,1@03/.M,4E7)+*%bP
i9)+F_FG$_8)+BD3V5Kmn$q[D$0F_8D57$G>?B8D34E7%4FG$Cl57$&%g31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%V,/.M*DA=$0*-,4E7$05;57$&%a%bmn)+8D8)C%1$0*-, j 5.JO)+31'&$G$q[],1@034E7$0BD31$CP
#
.
>?E;31$&'0,4E7)+*h>D$H5.gJd)+31'&$L$q[],1@034E7$0BD31$6$&%4,u8)C%4E;,4E S $%1BDE S .M*-,5Kmv.[D$ ~ $0,*@0A.M,4E S $6%4BDE S .M*,^5Kmv.[?$ ~ P k*r3/.ME7%/)+*
>D$Z5.`%4:]FG@0,434E7$Z>?BY'0BD\
$g$0,H>D$Z5Kmv.M8D8D5;E7'b.M,4E7)+*f>D$Z5.aJd)+31'&$g%4BDE Ox Oy
S .M*,25.`>?E.MA=)+*.M57$c>D$Z5.`%4BD3|JO.+'&$Z>D$g'&)+*-,/.+'0,bl
57$&% S .M57$0BD31%G>D$&%`31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%r%/)+*,_57$&%`8D5;B%G@057$ S @&$&%r.MB*DE S $b.MB
>?B*)]$0B> ltE7>D$0*-,4E7WB$&%.MB *DE S $b.MB >D$&%
A2
*)]$0B>D% $0, l
$0,57$&%6FG)+E;*%6@057$ S @&$&%g.MBf*DE S $b.MB>?Bf*)]$0B> P#$a%/)+5;E7>D$a%bmv.M8D8DBDE7$X>D)+*'a8D5;B%L%4BD3657$
*)]$0B> A1W-B$VA%4BD3 3257$Z*)]$0B> P A4
#
.r%1)+F_AFG2$c>D$&%31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%*)+34AFr4.M57$&%
AC5;E7%1%/$0FG$0*, q 2
x E C
{ l 9
~
l
N1 N2 N3
&
$ 4
% ,
l
0
@ 4
3
E
s &
@
$0,
C
$
P
N4
# &
$ (
%
>D)+*D*$c57$V8)+E7>D%>?BY\D57)]'CP# .G'&)+*>?E;,4E7)+*>D$g*)+*
31@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%H>?BR'b.+%H%1,/.M,4E7WB$Z%1)+*-,H'&)+T@031$0*,1%L. S $&'
É
Tix + Tiy 2 < fN , S
i
57$&%2T-:-8)+,4T<&%1$&%HJO.ME;,1$&%bP
#
.X%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*R%4,/.M,4E7W-B$6'&)+* S $034A=$V.MBh\
)+BD,(>D$gUVE;,1@03/.M,4E7)+*%2$0,(%1$6%4,/.M\DE;5;E7%1$ j 5. S .M57$0BD3^s*.M57$CPDi9)+F_FG$Z8)+BD3
5Kmn$q[D$0F_8D57$V>?BY8D34E7%4FG$Cl57$Z8.+%H>D$g,1$0F_8%H8.M323/.M8D8)+34,L.MBe'b.+%HAC5;E7%1%/.M*,8
$0BD,HN0,431$c.MBDACFG$0*-,1@r −3 %bP h = 10
ÉÊ É
!* * -
-
3.5 −0.5
3 −1
Accélération suivant axe Ox
2 −2
1.5 −2.5
1 −3
0.5 −3.5
0 −4
2 4 6 8 10 2 4 6 8 10
Itérations sur 1 pas de temps Itérations sur 1 pas de temps
$0,
Fx = 40000N Fy = −40000N
#
.G'&)+BD34\
$V>D$Z5.`sACBD31$ , Pv?{gFG)+*,431$cWB$g57$ZFG)]>D<057$g8D31@&>?E;,H\DE7$0*e57$ZFG)+B S $0FG$0*,g.M,4,1$0*>?BP
#$&% S .M57$0BD31%^>D$&%(.+'&'&@057@03/.M,4E7)+*%(5;E;*@b.ME;31$&%
Γx
%4BDE S .M*,^57$&%9.[D$&% ~ $0,
Ox Γy
%4BDE S .M*,957$&%(.[?$&% ~ %1)+*,931$&%48$&'
,4E S $0FG$0*-,L'&)+*%4,/.M*-,1$c8)C%4E;,4E S $V$0,H'&)+*%4,/.M*-,1$c*@0A.M,4E S $CP#$V%1)+5;E7>D$c%1$g>D@08D5.+'&$c%4BD3BD*$g,43/.|Oy
$&'0,1)+E;31$cE;*'05;E;*@&$
É
>D$ ◦ 8.M33/.M8D8
)+34,L.MB?[R>?E;31$&'0,4E7)+*%HE;*DE;,4E.M57$&%L>D$V%1$&%2' ,1@&%bl>.M*%H57$Z31$08<031$gA=@0*@03/.M5KP
45
ÉÊ 3 É
!*
!"
3750
1100
3500
−200 1000
3250
3000 900
2750
−400 800
2500
700
2250
1750
500
1500
−800 400
1250
1000 300
750
−1000 200
500
100
250
0 −1200 0
2 4 6 8 10 2 4 6 8 10 2 4 6 8 10
Itérations sur 1 pas de temps Itérations sur 1 pas de temps Itérations sur 1 pas de temps
−40000N
ÉÊ É
!* * -
-
QL*8D31)+8)C%1$r>mv.M8D8D5;E7W-B$03cFr.ME;*-,1$0*.M*,`BD*FG)+FG$0*-,X$q[?,1@034E7$0BD3a>D$_FG)]>?BD57$ ~ ~ 8)+BD3
@S 34Es•$03V%4Et57$&%Z31@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%c%1)+*,V'&)+T@031$0*-,1%a. S $&'_'&$0B?[8D31)+8
)C%/@&%Z8.M3g57$`8D34E7%4FG$CP#
.h%4ME;Fc(BDF5).M,4=
0 −400~z
E7)+*o *BDFG@034E7W-B$
>D)+*D*$G
150 150
2500
100 100
2000
Réactions tangentielles Tix
50 50
1500 0 0
−50 −50
1000
−100 −100
500
−150 −150
0 −200 −200
2 4 6 8 10 2 4 6 8 10 2 4 6 8 10
Itérations sur 1 pas de temps Itérations sur 1 pas de temps Itérations sur 1 pas de temps
#$&%2'&)+F_8)C%/.M*-,1$&%>?Bh,1)+31%1$0BD3H'0E;*@0Fr.M,4E7W-B$V%1)+*,2,1)+BD,1$&%(*-BD5;57$&%V?57$Z%1)+5;E7>D$Z31$&%4,1$6E;F_FG)+\DE;57$CP#
. S .M57$0BD3H>?B
FG)+FG$0*-,L$q[?,1@034E7$0BD3L.M8D8D5;E7WB@V*mn$&%4,H8.+%H%4Br%.M*,1$g8)+BD3>D@08D5.+'&$03H57$V%/)+5;E7>D$CP
#$&%'&)+BD34\
$&%L>D$Z5.XsACBD31$ , PvCU_%1)+*-,H,43/.+'&@&$&%H8)+BD3V{b`E;,1@03/.M,4E7)+*%bP
i9)+F_FG$h8)+BD3_5Kmn$q[?$0F_8D57$R>?B8D34E7%1FG$Clk$0* 3/.ME7%/)+*
>D$h5.eA=@&)+FG@0,434E7$e>?B '0BD\$Clt57$&%_W-B.M,431$h31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%_*)+3
Fr.M57$&%R%1)+*-,hE7>D$0*,4E7W-B$&%bP2#$&%h31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%h,/.M*DA=$0*,4E7$05;57$&%f%1)+*,R%4:]FG@0,434E7W-B$&%%1BDE S .M*-,R57$&%h.[D$&% ~ l ~ $0,
É
Ox Oy
l P
T1x + T2x = −(T3x + T4x ) T1y + T4y = −(T2y + T3y )
# . %1)+F_FG$>D$&%31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%R*)+34Fr.M57$&%
l l $0, >D)+*D*$57$f8)+E7>D%h>?B"\D57)-'CP(#
. '&)+*>?E;,4E7)+* >D$
É
N1 N2 N3 N4
*)+* AC5;E7%1%/$0FG$0*, q
2 + T 2 < f N xE {Cl , ~H$&%1, S @034Es@&$CP#$&%31@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%>?B'b.+%H%4,/.M,4E7W-B$c%1)+*-,'&)+T@031$0*,1%
Tix i
. S $&'g57$&%2T:]8)+,4T<&%1$&%2JK.ME;,1$&%biyP
i9$&%231@&%1BD5;,/.M,1%%1)+*-,'&)+*?Jd)+34FG$&%6.MB?[RT:]8
)+,4T<&%1$&%>D$V%4:]FG@0,434E7$V>?BY%1)+5;E7>D$CP#$c%4E;AC*$V>D$&%231@b.+'0,4E7)+*%L,/.M*DA=$0*
,4E7$05;57$&%k>D@08$0*>`>?B`%1E;AC*$9>?B`FG)+FG$0*-,u$q[],1@034E7$0BD3.M8D8D5;E7W-B@($0,5. S .M57$0BD3k>D$&% 31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%u,/.M*DA=$0*,4E7$05;57$&%u>D@08$0*>
É
ÉÊ VʲÉ
!*
!"
0.8
−1
0.6
−2
Accélération suivant axe Ox et Oy
0.4
0 −4
−0.2
−5
−0.4
−6
−0.6
−7
−0.8
−1 −8
2 4 6 8 10 2 4 6 8 10
Itérations sur 1 pas de temps Itérations sur 1 pas de temps
>?Be'0BD\$Z8)+BD3
Mz = −40000N m
#
. S .M57$0BD3>D$R5Kmv.+'&'&@057@03/.M,4E7)+* >D$e31)+,/.M,4E7)+* %1BDE S .M*-,r5Kmv.[D$ ~ $&%1,r'&)+*%4,/.M*,1$f$0,r*@0A.M,4E S $CP^#$e'0BD\$Cl
>?BRJK.ME;,H>D$g%/.`%4:]FG@0,434E7$g8.M3H3/.M8D8)+34, j %1)+*eΩ̇.[Dz $g>D$g31)+,/.M,4E7)+*l,1Oz
)+BD34*$V%4BD325;BDE FGN0FG$a.MBD,1)+BD3L>D$ ~ P É Oz
ÉÊ ÀÉ
!* * -
-
Noeud1
Noeud2 600 600
Noeud3
2000 Noeud4
400 400
200 200
1500
0 0
1000
−200 −200
−400 −400
500
−600 −600
0 −800 −800
2 4 6 8 10 2 4 6 8 10 2 4 6 8 10
Itérations sur 1 pas de temps Itérations sur 1 pas de temps Itérations sur 1 pas de temps
ÉÊ aË É
!*
!"
3750
−100
3500 Noeud1
Noeud2 −200 1000
3250 Noeud3
3000 Noeud4 −300
2750
−400 800
2500
−500
2250
1750
−700
1500
−800 400
1250
1000 −900
750
−1000 200
500
−1100
250
0 −1200 0
2 4 6 8 10 2 4 6 8 10 2 4 6 8 10
Itérations sur 1 pas de temps Itérations sur 1 pas de temps Itérations sur 1 pas de temps
Fy = m ∗ g ∗ f
i9)+F_FG$_8)+BD3Z5Kmn$q[?$0F_8D57$r>?B8D34E7%1FG$Cl57$&% S .M57$0BD31%g>D$&%V31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%g*)+34Fr.M57$&%V$0,g,/.M*DA=$0*,4E7$05;57$&%X>D$X5.sACBD31$
, Pv g%/)+*,kE7>D$0*,4E7W-B$&%^.MB?[ S .M57$0BD31%k,431)+B S @&$&%>.M*%k5.LsACBD31$ , PvC?P=#
.6,43/.M*%4E;,4E7)+*r>?B'b.+%u>D$(*)+* AC5;E7%1%1$0FG$0*-,
.MBY'b.+%L>D$ZAC5;E7%1%1$0FG$0*,6%1$6JK.ME;,H>D$6JO. &)+*e'&)+*-,4E;*B$CP
É
( + #%! !
!
#$&%GT:]8
)+,4T<&%1$&%_%1BD8D8D57@0FG$0*,/.ME;31$&%>D$h8D31)+8
)+34,4E7)+*D*.M5;E;,1@Y>D$&%G31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%_,/.M*DA=$0*,4E7$05;57$&%$0,_>D$h31@08.M34,4E;,4E7)+*
5;E;*@b.ME;31$V>D$&%H31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%H*)+34Fr.M57$&%)+*-,@0,1@g,1$&%4,1@&$&%>.M*%257$&%H'b.+%H%4,/.M,4E7W-B$g$0,>?:]*.MF_E7WB$V8
)+BD32BD*R*)+Fa\D31$
>D$Z*)]$0B>D%@0A.M5 j U`$0, , P
¡)+BD3 S .M5;E7>D$03H'&$&%HT-:-8)+,4T<&%1$&%V
É É
>D$&%H'&)+*>?E;,4E7)+*%6>D$Z*)+* AC5;E7%1%1$0FG$0*-,6$0,2AC5;E7%/%1$0FG$0*,6%1)+*, S @034Es@&$&%bl
É É
5.r%1E;FcBD5.M,4E7)+*%4BD365._,43/.M*%4E;,4E7)+**)+* AC5;E7%1%/.M*-, AC5;E7%1%/.M*-,g31@b.M5;E7%1@&$X8
)+BD3657$&%L'b.+%Z>?B8D34E7%4FG$X$0,6>?B'0BD\
$`.
FG)+*-,431@cW-B$Z57$&%231@&%4BD5;,/.M,1% j 5._5;E;F_E;,1$V>?BRAC5;E7%1%1$0FG$0*-,L%1)+*-,@&WBDE S .M57$0*,1% j '&$0B?[h>?BeAC5;E7%1%1$0FG$0*,bl
É W-B$057WB$c%1)+E;,25Km E;*DE;,4E.M5;E7%/.M,4E7)+*l57$&% S .M57$0BD31%L>D$&%231@b.+'0,4E7)+*%'&)+* S $034A=$0*, S $031%2BD*$V%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*YBD*DE7W-B$Cl
É )+*e.X31$08D31@&%1$0*-,1@c%4BD3(5.asACBD31$ , Pv=`5.X31@b.+'0,4E7)+*Y,/.M*DA=$0*,4E7$05;57$ q
2 2 .MBR*DE S $b.MBe>?BR*)]$0B>
||T || = T1x + T1y
ÉÊ ?¨ É
!* * -
-
{g>?Be'0BD\$g$0*RJO)+*'0,4E7)+*e>D$Z5. S .M57$0BD3>D$Z5.XJO)+31'&$g$q[],1@034E7$0BD31$ ~ P
Fext = Fx ~x
10000
9000
8000
6000
5000
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 9000 10000
Force extérieure (N)
) * , Pv= .
3/.M*%4E;,4E7)+*f*)+* AC5;E7%1%/.M*, C
É
A 5;E7%/%/.M*,Z.MBY*DE S $b.MBe>?BY*)]$0B>{V>?BY'0BD\$
#
. S .M57$0BD36>D$g5.`31@b.+'0,4E7)+*e,/.M*DA=$0*-,4E7$05;57$a'031)7,`xd'b.+%>D$g*)+* AC5;E7%/%1$0FG$0*,bl
'Cmn$&%4, j >?E;31$ j 5Km E;*,1@034E7$0BD3Z>?Be' *$
>D$Hi9)+BD57)+Fc\~
B%1W-Bm j .M,4,1$0E;*>?31$2BD*$ S .M57$0BD3k%1$0BDE;5
xd'b.+%k>D$9AC5;E7%1%/$0FG$0*,bl j %/. S )+E;3u%4BD3 57$2' *$(>D$i9)+BD57)+Fa\~qP
É ÉÉ
P
É
#$Z8.+%/%/.MA=$V$0*,431$V57$&%H'b.+%2*)+* AC5;E7%1%/.M*-,$0,2AC5;E7%1%/.M*-,%1$Z8D31)]>?BDE;,2E7'0E8)+BD3 ~
Fext = −m ∗ g ∗ f~x
'Cmn$&%4, j >?E;31$ ÉÉ
Fx = 3924N
Ox~ θ
31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%,/.M*DA=$0*,4E7$05;57$&%Z.MBY*)-$0B> >?Be'0BD\$CP
A1
Fy
1500
1000
valeurs des réactions T1x et T1y
500
θ
Fx 0
-500
θ -1500
0 25 50 75 100 125 150 175 200 225 250 275 300 325 350
Fx angle de rotation
Fy
) * , Pv . * B $0*'&$c>D$Z5. S .M57$0BD3L>?BRFG)->?BD57$V>D$ 0$ , %4BD3257$&% S .M57$0BD31%H>D$&%H31@b.+'0,4E7)+*% 0$ ,
Fx Fy Tx Ty
ÉÊ À É
!*
!"
i9)+*>?E;,4E7)+*%E;*DE;,4E.M57$&%a?8)+BD3 ◦l $0, P
# $&%'&)+BD34\
$&%(8D31@&%1$0*-,1@&$&% j >?31θ)+E;=,1$V0%4BD3(F5x.a=
,4E7)+*%6%1)+*,631@b.M5;E7%1@&$&%Z.MBe*)]$0B>
sAC10000N
BD31$ , Pv X*$gF%1y)+*-=,280N
.+%2'&$0*,431@&$&%L$0*ea'b.M3257$&%'b.M57'0BD57%H>D$&%(31@b.+'
>?B'0BD\
$CPi9$V*)]$0B>e$&%4,6$q[?'&$0*-,431@c8.M363/.M8D8
)+34,Z.MBf'&$0*-,431$X>D$cAC3/. S E;,1@
É
A1
P
QL*Y8$0BD,2*)+,1$03H57$V>D@&'b.M5.MA=$c>D$ ◦ %4BD3257$&%H'&)+BD34\$&% $0, ◦ P
90 T1x T1y T1x (θ) = T1y (θ + 90 )
QL*%bm E;*-,1@031$&%1%1$`Fr.ME;*-,1$0*.M*, j BD*'b.+%Z5;E;F_E;,1$Y
57$_%1)+5;E7>D$X,1$0*> S $031%g57$X\.+%1'0BD57$0FG$0*-,bP
¡)+BD3c'031@&$03V'&$`>D$03
*DE7$03bl)+*Y'&)+*%1E7>D<031$gBD*R8.M3/.M5;57@057@08DE;8
<&>D$a>D)+*,L57$&%H>?E;FG$0*%4E7)+*%H%1)+*-,>D@0,1$034F_E;*@&$&%6%4BD3(5.XsACBD31$ , PvC}?PD¡)+BD3
É
.+%1%1BD31$03u8DT:?%4E7W-B$0FG$0*,957$2FG)+B S $0FG$0*,(>D$H\.+%1'0BD57$0FG$0*-,9>?B%1)+5;E7>D$Cl=)+*.V'1T)+E7%4E
>D$(JO.ME;31$ S .M34E7$03u5.VT.MBD,1$0BD3
>?BY8.M3/.M5;57@057@08DE;8<&>D$V8D5;BD, ,LWB$g'&$05;57$V>D$V5.aJd)+31'&$c.M8D8D5;E7W-B@&$CP
#$V,1)+31%1$0BD3'0E;*@0Fr.M,4E7W-B$V$&%4,V
v 0
x x , PvU?P C~
T = vy 0
0 Ωz
#$c'0BD\
$g$&%4,H'&)+*%1E7>D@031@V31$&%4,/.M*-,H,1)+B+|)+BD31%L$0*Y'&)+*,/.+'0,bP
'
zo :
A4 A3
yo \
xo [
.
A1 A2
) * , PvC} . yf)]>D@05;E7%/.M,4E7)+*e>?BR\.+%/'0BD57$0FG$0*,
ÉÊ É
!*!*
§ D
6)+B%28D31$0*)+*%H57$&%H8.M3/.MFG<0,431$&%*-BDFG@034E7WB$&%L%4BDE S .M*-,1%c
É i )]$r'0E7$0*,6>D$ZJ31)+,4,1$0FG$0*-,a]J ?P , l
9
É %4BD3|JK.+'&$V>D$g'&)+*-,/.+'0,a. {0F \ , FYl
É
>?BY=%/)+0m.s
5;E7>D$
−1 xd'b.+%>D$gAC5;E7%1%1$0FG$0*-,~qP
P
Fx = 10000N
5000
A1 A2
A2 A2
4000
A3 A4 N3 ou N4
N1 ou N2
A4 A4
Réactions normales (N)
~
Fext 3000
¢
2000
F~ext '
1000
[
0
2 4 6 8 10 )+B )+B
Hauteur du solide (m) A3 A4 A1 A2
- BD3X'&$0,a$q[D$0F_8D57$Cl5.hT.MBD,1$0BD3X5;E;F_E;,1$r>D$r\.+%1'0BD57$0FG$0*,`$&%4,c>D$f{bMFYP
¡)+BD3X'&$0,4,1$rT.MBD,1$0BD3bl
57$&%c31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%
*)+34Fr.M57$&%g>D$&%L*)-$0B>D% $0, %1)+*-,L*-BD5;57$&%g$0,L57$a8
)+E7>D%6>?B8.M3/.M5;57@057@08DE;8
<&>D$_$&%4,631$08D34E7%68.M3L57$&%6*)]$0B>D%
N3
$0, %1)+E;, P]N#
4.cFG@0,4T)->D$Z>D$L31@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*h8
$034FG$0,(>mv.M,4,1$0E;*>?31$Z5.V5;E;F_E;,1$Z>D$L\.+%1'0BD57$0FG$0*,
N1 N2
'Cmn$&%4, j >?E;31$c5Kmv.MN ÉÉ
*D*1BD+5.MN =P
,4E7)+2 * >D$&%2*)-$0B>D% $0, P
N3 N4
(
1
'
ÉÊ ÆÉ
!*
!"
57$&%2\D57)]'&%H>.M*%5.`%4,434B'0,4BD31$CP
É
#
.FG@0,4T)]>D$h>D$h31@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*BD,4E;5;E7%1@&$R>.M*%_'&$h'1T.M8DE;,431$e$&%4,`BD*$FG@0,4T)]>D$ 0'&)+BD8D57@&$ +P^i9$05;57$ '0E28$034FG$0,bl
.MB*DE S $b.MBR>D$5.X%4BD3|JK.+'&$L>D$6'&)+*,/.+'0,blD>D$6'b.M57'0BD57$03(5Kmn$0*%1$0Fc\D57$g>D$&%931@b.+'0,4E7)+*%H.MB?[r*)]$0B>D%(>D$L'&)+*-,/.+'0,bPi9$&%
31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%L%1)+*,%1,1)-' & @&$&%>.M*%2BD*$gFr.M,434E7'&$Cl.M8D8
$057@&$gFr.M,434E7'&$ q3/.ME7>D$0BD3 +l$0,H%1)+*-,H5;E7@&$&%bP
#umn@0,4B>D$R>D$&%`>D$0B?[z'b.+%_.+'b.+>D@0F_E7W-B$&%blt8D34E7%4FG$$0,_'0BD\
$Clt.f8
$034F_E7%`>D$,1$&%4,1$03`5.YFG@0,4T)]>D$CP 5($0* 31$&%1%1)+34,
$&%1%/$0*,4E7$05;57$0FG$0*,ZW-B$g57$&%231@b.+'0,4E7)+*%L,/.M*DA=$0*,4E7$05;57$&%Z%bmn)+8D8)C%1$0*,H,1)+B+4)+BD31%L.MBf%1$0*%H>D$gAC5;E7%1%/$0FG$0*,L>?Bf%1)+5;E7>D$Cl
'&)+*?JO)+34FG@0FG$0*,c.MB?[Y57)+E7%Z'05.+%1%4E7W-B$&%6>D$Xi9)+BD57)+Fc\PwZ$c8D5;B%bl57$0BD31% S .M57$0BD31%L>D@08$0*>D$0*,V>?B'b.+%Z'&)+*%4E7>D@031@Cl
%1)+E;,H%1,/.M,4E7WB$V%/)+E;,H>?:-*.MF_E7W-B$Cl$0,>D$Z57$0BD31%8
)C%4E;,4E7)+*%>.M*%25._%4BD3|JK.+'&$g>D$V'&)+*,/.+'0,bP
ÉÊ É
4%/ /% !#"6 . " 4 !2)/,+e%
¸4%/! 4% 0,05 2 30,,/345"6
e%/ ,+e% 4,/, / &5"/0,05
=
ÉÊ 3 É
OL-
#$&%
FG)->D@05;E7%.M,4E7)+*%
*-BDFG@034E7WB$&% 8.M3 .M8D8D31)]'1T$>?E7%/'031<0,1$>mn)+B S 3/.MA=$&%Fr.&)+*D*@&% ,434E7>?E;FG$0*%4E7)+*D*$057%t$0*VAC3/.M*>
.M8D8.M31$0E;5
%1)+*,u8$0BG8D31@&%1$0*-,1$&%^>.M*%5.Z5;E;,4,1@03/.M,4BD31$CPDQL*r$&%4,u>D)+*''&)+*-,43/.ME;*,(>D$H>D@qs*DE;3BD*$%4,43/.M,1@0ACE7$>D$ S .
5;E7>.M,4E7)+*P k*$qp$0,blCE;5
$&%4,u*@&'&$&%1%/.ME;31$L>D$ S @034Es$0395.Z31)+\DB%4,1$&%1%1$L>D$H5Kmv.M5;A=)+34E;,4TDFG$6>D$H>D@0,1$&'0,4E7)+*h>D$&%^'&)+*-,/.+'0,1%
É
$0,257$&%T:]8
)+,4T<&%1$&%>D$g31@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*e$0*Y%1$Z8D5. b.M*-,L>.M*%L>?Ep@031$0*-,1%'b.+%H$q[?E7%4,/.M*,1%§P
i9$V>D$034*DE7$03L'1T.M8DE;,431$c%§mv.M34,4E7'0BD57$c.ME;*%4E .MBD,1)+BD3>D$V,431)+E7%28.M34,4E7$&%c
wg.M*%5.o>D$0B?[?E7<0FG$8.M34,4E7$Cl957$&%FG)]>D@05;E7%/.M,4E7)+*%h31@b.M5;E7%1@&$&%h8$034FG$0,4,1$0*,Y>D$%4BDE S 31$5.o>D$&%1'&$0*-,1$>D$
ÉÉ
'/T.M34•A=$e'Cmn$&%4, j >?E;31$f57$&%G¢b)+*$&%r57$&%G8D5;B%r'&)+*-,43/.ME;*,1$&%Y.MB %/$0E;* >m BD*$e%4,434B'0,4BD31$CP(QL* %bm E;*-,1@031$&%1%1$YE7'0E j 5.
S .M5;E7>.M,4E7)+*>D$&%9FG)]>D@05;E7%/.M,4E7)+*% j 8.M34,4E;3(>D$&%931@b.+'0,4E7)+*%9)+\D,1$0*-B$&%bPQL*@ S .M5;B$*)+,/.MF_FG$0*-,25.g,43/.M*%4F_E7%/%4E7)+*
>D$&%9$qp)+34,1%9>.M*%9>D$&%^%4,434B'0,4BD31$&%98D31@&'&)+*-,43/.ME;*,1$&%H)+B j AC3/.M*>*)+Fc\D31$6>D$\D57)]'&%9$0,^)+* S @034Es$L5.c31@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*
*-BDFG@034E7WB$a>?BY'&)+*,/.+'0,bP
wg.M*%V5.h,431)+E7%1E7<0FG$_8.M34,4E7$Cl
)+* S @034Es$%4BD3c>D$&%V'b.+%X.+'b.+>D@0F_E7WB$&%a57$&%g31@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%a)+\D,1$0*B%a8.M3a>D$0B?[
FG@0,4T• )]>D$&%r>D$R31@&%/)+5;BD,4E7)+* *BDFG@034E7W-B$CP#
$R\DBD,r$&%4,r>D$Y,1$&%4,1$03G5Kmn$r'b.+'0E;,1@e$0,>D$Y'&)+F_8.M31$03r57$&%_31@&%1BD5;,/.M,1%
)+\D,1$0*-B%V. S $&'X57$&%g.MFG@05;E7)+3/.M,4E7)+*%g>D$c5.rFG@0,4T)->D$`>D$a31@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*>D$&%31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%V.MB*)]$0B>e8D31)+8)C%1@&$`>.M*%
57$g'/T.M8DE;,431$ , l j '&$0B?[Y)+\D,1$0*B% j 8.M34,4E;3L>D$Z5.`FG@0,4T)]>D$gE;F_8D57@0FG$0*-,1@&$a>.M*%257$g'&)]>D$V#y i(}C?P
57)+\.M57$0FG$0*-,bl)+*R@0,4B>?E7$g>.M*%('&$6'/T.M8DE;,431$gBD*R$0*%1$0Fc\D57$g>mn)+B S 3/.MA=$&%bP?#$&%2%4E;FaBD5.M,4E7)+*%2*BDFG@034E7W-B$&%H%1)+*-,
31@b.M5;E7%1@&$&%LAC3 '&$`.MB'&)]>D$c>D$a'b.M57'0BD5#y i(}C?P
#
.>D@0,1$&'0,4E7)+*>D$&%6'&)+*,/.+'0,1%Z$&%4,LFG)->D@05;E7%/@&$a$0*fBD,4E;5;E7%/.M*,Z57$
*)+B S $05 .M5;A=)+34E;,4TDFG$a>D$ S $057)+8D8
@a>.M*%257$g'1T.M8DE;,431$XU?P#$&%2\D57)]'&%H%1)+*-,%4BD8D8)C%1@&%234E;ACE7>D$&%bP
1 X
,431$0Fc\D57$0FG$0*-,1%6>D$Z,1$03431$Cl
•
.MBDACFG$0*,/.M,4E7)+*>D$&%2,43/.s'&%%1BD3H>D$&%28
)+*-,1%bl
•
• S E;,1$&%/%1$g$0,2Fr.+%1%1$g>D$&%H'/T.M34A=$&%31)+BD5.M*-,1$&%bl
JO.+'0,1$0BD31%HFG@0,1@&)+31)+57)+ACE7WB$&%bl
•
$0,1'CP
•
wZ$&%HW-B$&%4,4E7)+*%H%1)+*-,L.ME;*%4EJd31@&W-B$0F_FG$0*,H8)C%1@&$&%bP
ÉÊ É
§
r§- L
É ÉÉ É
i9)+F_FG$0*-,g5.%1,434B'0,4BD31$a31@b.MACE;, $05;57$aJK.+'&$ j >D$&%Z%1)+5;5;E7'0E;,/.M,4E7)+*%g$q[?,1@034E7$0BD31$&%r
mn$qp)+*>?31$ , $05;57$-BD\DE;, $05;57$
D> $&%u>D@0A ,1%E;3431@ S $031%4E;\D57$&%L£ 57)+*DAV,1$034FG$ClC57$&%ts%/%4BD31$&%k8D31) S )]W-B@&$&%8.M3u57$(8.+%/%/.MA=$H>m BD*G,43/.ME;*r%1BD3kBD*G8
)+*-,
É
8$0B S $0*, $05;57$&%6N0,431$V'b.M,/.+%4,431)+8DTDE7W-B$&% qFG@&'b.M*DE7W-B$0FG$0*,c8
)+BD35.X,1$0*B$c>D$Z5.G%4,434B'0,4BD31$
¡)+BD3L,1$0*-,1$036>D$c'&)+F_8D31$0*>?31$a57$&%8DT@0*)+FG<0*$&%68DT:?%4E7WB$&%LWBDE)+*,L5;E7$0Bf>.M*%LBD*$c%4,434B'0,4BD31$a$0,,1$0*,1$03Z>D$
31@08)+*>?31$ j '&$&%HW-B$&%4,4E7)+*%blD>D$&%(FG)]>D<057$&%$q[?8
@034E;FG$0*-,/.MB?[Y$0,2*BDFG@034E7W-B$&%%1)+*-,HF_E7%H$0*Y)]$0B S 31$&%bPQL*Y8$0BD,
8.M3Z$q[?$0F_8D57$`'0E;,1$03657$&%6,43/. S .MB?[f%4BD3657$a'0E7%/.ME;5;57$0FG$0*-,G#
)+BD31$0* &) .M52xd#)+BD31$0* &)xOCC =~4~qlQL31>?BD*. .M5
xKQL31>?BD*.fxOCCCU=~4~qlD57$Z,/.+%1%1$0FG$0*-,L>?Ep@031$0*,4E7$05^D¥9E7@0*DE7@ .M59xd¥^E7@0*DE7@c$0,.M5KP
xOCCC=~4~ql5Kmn@0,4B>D$V>D$&%H8
)+*-,1%$0*
Fr. &)+*D*$034E7$aCw6)+FG<&>D$ .M5
xdw6)+FG<&>D$XxOCC =~4~ql .M*D*DE;*DA
.M5
x .M*D*DE;*DAa$0,u¥()])+,4T\:YxOCC?{§~4~ql57$2%1@0E7%4FG$g
y)+5;E;*. .M5xdyf)+5;E;*.6$0,k.M5KP]xOCC?{§~4~ql+#$9¡.M8$ .M5xd#$9¡.M8$($0,t.M5KP?xOCC?{§~4~qlM5.H31$&%1,/.MBD3/.M,4E7)+*`>mn)+B S 3/.MA=$&%2
¥9E;*>. .M5^xd¥9E;*>._$0,L?.ME7%1E^xOCC?{§~4~qlD5Kmv.M*.M5;:?%1$g5;E;F_E;,1$G E;5;\$034, .M5^x E;5;\
$034,H$0,L.M5KPxOCC =~4~qP
K
9C uD Y M
^ =
=
#$&%'&)+*%4,434B'0,4E7)+*%^.M*-,4E7WB$&%k31@b.M5;E7%/@&$&%u$0*Z|)+E;*-,1%%1$&'&%k%/)+*,k8D31@&%1$0*-,1$&%>.M*%k57$(FG)+*>D$2$0*-,4E7$03bP]i9$&%k)+B S 3/.MA=$&%
%1)+*-,9%/)+B S $0*,2>D$AC3/.M*>D%9FG)+*-BDFG$0*,1%V])+*8$0BD,^'0E;,1$03(8.M3($q[?$0F_8D57$L57$&%9FG)+*BDFG$0*-,1% 31$&'&%bl )+Fr.ME;*%bl-57$&%
Fr.&)+*D*$034E7$ j 4)+E;*,(%1$&'CP#
$H\DBD,^>D$6'&$0,4,1$@0,4B>D$6$&%4,>D$L'b.M3/.+'0,1@034E7%1$03(5.g31@08)+*%1$HFG@&'b.M*DE7W-B$6>D$&%@057@0FG$0*,1%
>D$Fr. &)+*D*$034E7$ j 4)+E;*,1%`%1$&'&%X%1)+BDF_E7% j >D$&%X'1T.M34A=$0FG$0*-,1%G8D5.M*% S $034,4E7'b.MB?[ xd'/T.M34A=$&%_'&)+F_8D31$&%1%4E S $&%~a$0,
T)+34E;¢b)+*-,/.MB?[zxd'0E7%/.ME;5;57$0FG$0*,~qP
•
!*
#% #%
!* !
+ ,
*
£s*>D$L'&)+*,434E;\DB$03 j .MFG@05;E7)+31$03(5.c'&)+*D*.ME7%1%.M*'&$L>?Bh'&)+F_8
)+34,1$0FG$0*-,H>D$5.VFr.&)+*D*$034E7$ j 4)+E;*,1%(%1$&'&%bl-BD*
$0*%1$0Fa\D57$>mn$q[?8
@034E7$0*'&$&%^$&%4,k31@b.M5;E7%1@H>.M*%u57$25.M\
)+3/.M,1)+E;31$>D$Li9)+*%4,434B'0,4E7)+* $&'1TD*)+57)+ACE7W-B$L>D$H5Km BD*DE S $031%4E;,1@
¡)+5;:-,1$&'/TD*DE7WB$X>D$ci(.M,/.M57)+AC*$CP
#$&%>?E;FG$0*%4E7)+*%>D$Z5._%1,434B'0,4BD31$V%1)+*,28D31@&%/$0*,1@&$&%%1BD325.XsACBD31$ 0 P;{CPD#$gFaBD3$&%4,H'&)+F_8)C%1@g>D$ 0 0 \D34E7W-B$&%
.+%1%/$0Fc\D57@&$&%_$0* {be'&)+B'/T$&%bPk#$&%X\D34E7W-B$&%`BD,4E;5;E7%1@&$&%`)+*,`BD*$h>?E;FG$0*%4E7)+*
>D$C[C[{b P#umv.M*DAC57$R>D$
cm3
Jd31)+,4,1$0FG$0*,2$0*,431$6>D$0B?[r\D34E7W-B$&%bl=FG$&%1BD31@L$q[?8
@034E;FG$0*-,/.M57$0FG$0*,blD$&%4,(>D$ P]i9$0,2.M*DAC57$L>D$HJ31)+,4,1$0FG$0*-,
= 33◦
$&%4,r.MB%/%4E S .M5.M\D57$Y$0*-,431$R5.8)+BD,431$Y%4BD8@034E7$0BD31$R$0,_57$&%_\D34E7WB$&%§Pk#$RFcφBD3 $&%4,_%1)+5;5;E7'0E;,1@ S $034,4E7'b.M57$0FG$0*,h$0*
'&)+F_8D31$&%1%1E7)+*PD#$&%^Jd)+31'&$&% S $034,4E7'b.M57$&%H$q[D$031'&@&$&%(%4BD3(5.a8
)+BD,431$Z%1)+*-,2UC?l{bC?lDCCX$0,H 0 & @&W-BDE S .M57$0*-,1$&% j
>D$&%H'&)+*-,43/.ME;*,1$&%Z>D$V?P;{ 0 l?P 0 l{g$0,a{CPv 0 yf¡t.?P
•
+!%
*
*! + ,
*
w`m BD* 8)+E;*,h>D$ S B$e$q[?8@034E;FG$0*,/.M5Kl^57$Y,/.M\D57$b.MB 0 P;{Y8D31@&%1$0*-,1$f5. S .M57$0BD3>D$Y5.o'1T.M34A=$fT)+34E;¢b)+*,/.M57$xd'0E
%/.ME;5;57$0FG$0*-,~ j .M8D8D5;E7W-B$03L$0*hJO)+*'0,4E7)+*e>D$g5. S .M57$0BD3>D$Z5._'/T.M34A=$ S $043 ,4E7'b.M57$rxd'&)+F_8D31$&%1%1E7)+*~qP
É
ÉÊ Ê²É
OL-
xOCC?{§~4~
- BD3Y5.zsACBD31$ 0 Pv?l257$&%RFcBD31%"UC?P;{o$0,f"UC?Pv)+*-,Y57$&%RFGN0FG$&%f'b.M3/.+'0,1@034E7%4,4E7WB$&%eA=@&)+FG@0,434E7WB$&%$0,
FG@&'b.M*DE7W-B$&%bPwZ$g8D5;B%bl?E;57%%1)+*,%/)+BDF_E7%.MB%1%4E
.MB?[hFGN0FG$&%'/T.M34A=$&%bP
QL*'&)+*%4,/.M,1$RW-B$5.e34BD8D,4BD31$R%/$r8D31)+8.MA=$R57$57)+*DA>?B FcBD3blk>.M*%`5.>?E;31$&'0,4E7)+*
>?B'0E7%/.ME;5;57$0FG$0*-,bP^i9$0,4,1$
@ S )+5;BD,4E7)+*f8
$0BD,HN0,431$V)+\D,1$0*-B$V8.M3HBD*R3/.ME7%/)+*D*$0FG$0*,ZWB.M5;E;,/.M,4EJ4P
i9$08$0*>.M*,bl?57$&%9s%1%1BD31$&%^*$Z%1$L8D31)+8.MA=$0*,8.+%2>D$L5.aFGN0FG$LJK. &)+*h>.M*%(57$&%(>D$0B?[FcBD31%bPD#$Z>?E7%48)C%4E;,4EJ $q[
8@034E;FG$0*,/.M5 j FG$0,4,431$6$0*h)]$0B S 31$L8
$0BD,98)C%1$039W-B$057W-B$&%^8D31)+\D57<0FG$&%H.MB*DE S $b.MBR>D$&%^'&)+*>?E;,4E7)+*%H.MB?[5;E;F_E;,1$&%
É
É
$0,(>?BrJd31)+,4,1$0FG$0*,H$0*-,431$657$&%\D57)]'&%bPDi9$05;57$&% '0E8
$0B S $0*-,2.M57)+31%98$034,4BD34\
$03957$6>D@08D5.+'&$0FG$0*,>D$&%9\D57)]'&%^$0,(>D)+*'
>D$Z5.`34BD8D,4BD31$CP
ÉÊ ÀÉ
§
r§- L
k*f'&)+F_8D57@0FG$0*,L>D$V5Kmv.M*.M5;:]%1$c$q[]8@034E;FG$0*,/.M57$ClBD*$c.M*.M5;:]%/$Z*BDFG@034E7W-B$c$&%4,231@b.M5;E7%1@&$CP
•
%
, !$% +
! !*+! " +
" ,
31$0*-,1$&%c
wXm BD*h8)+E;*,H>D$ S B$L*-BDFG@034E7WB$Cl57$&%9%1E;FcBD5.M,4E7)+*%%/)+*,(\.+%1@&$&%2%4BD32>D$0B?[FG@0,4T)]>D$&%(*BDFG@034E7W-B$&%>?Ep@ É
É #
)+BD31$0* &) .M59xd#)+BD31$0* &)$0, )+,1%cx|{b}C}=C~4~28D31)+8
)C%1$0*-,BD*YFG)]>D<057$V\.+%/@V%4BD3>D$&%L@057@0FG$0*,1%6>m E;*,1$03|JK.+'&$
É
qFaBD5;,4E %4BD3|JO.+'&$ +l>.M*%kBD*$^Jd)+34FaBD5.M,4E7)+*r@057@0FG$0*,1%us*DE7%bP+#$(FG)->D<057$931$08)C%1$2%4BD3t5.L,4T@&)+34E7$2>D$(5.L8D5.+%4,4E7'0E;,1@
L@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%2*BDFG@034E7W-B$&%
•
¡)+BD3g5Kmn$0*%1$0Fc\D57$_>D$&%631@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%Z*-BDFG@034E7WB$&%§l57$`>D@08D5.+'&$0FG$0*-,c>D$c5.8)+BD,431$Cl%4BDE S .M*-,Z5Kmv.[?$X>D$X5.r'/T.M34A=$
T)+34E;¢b)+*-,/.M57$X.M8D8D5;E7W-B@&$Cl$&%4,H@ S .M5;B@ j $0* S E;31)+*z{ 0 F_FYP
ÉÊ IË É
OL-
É3/.M¡E;,4)+31BD$V3r>?E57p$h@0Fa31$0BD*3h,1$&% s%1C%4CBD
3/.Mx,4sE7)+AC*BD%31$ >?BY0 P Fc, ~qBDlk35.>.M%4*E;Fa%HBD57$V5.M'b,4.+E7)+%H* >m *-BDBD*FG$V@0'/34TE7.MW34BA=$e$ 8DS 31$0)+348
,4E7)C'b%1.M@&57$c$Y>D8$V.M3CCi( .M& 31X)+5 P
.M52JK.ME;,r.M8D8. É
ÉÊ ¨ É
§
r§- L
•
%
#%&
* #%+
!*
""% #!
*
i $0,4,1$R.M8D8D31)]'1T$Cl\.+%1@&$h$&%1%1$0*-,4E7$05;57$0FG$0*,G%4BD3X57$31$&%48
$&'0,`>D$5Km E;F_8
@0*@0,43/.M\DE;5;E;,1@Y>D$&%`@057@0FG$0*-,1%_$0,a5Km T-:-8)
9
,4T<&%1$L>?BGJd31)+,4,1$0FG$0*,(%1$&'>D$Zi9)+BD57)+Fc\R$&%4,^.+>.M8D,1@&$ j 5.VFG)->D@05;E7%.M,4E7)+*>D$,1$05;57$&%^%4,434B'0,4BD31$&%§P#$L'b.M3/.+'0,1<031$
É
>?E7%1'031$0,.MBD,1)+34E7%1$Y$0* $qp$0,_5.8D31)+8.MA.M,4E7)+* >D$&%_s%1%4BD31$&%G$0,G5.%/@08.M3/.M,4E7)+* '&)+F_8D57<0,1$Y>D$&%@057@0FG$0*,1%bP^#$&%
%4E;FaBD5.M,4E7)+*%L%/)+*,H)+\D,1$0*B$&%LAC3 '&$c.MBe'&)]>D$g>D$V'b.M57'0BD5
#
y i(}C?P
#$6FaBD3($&%1,(@0,4B>?E7@Z>.M*%(57$&%9FGN0FG$&%2'&)+*>?E;,4E7)+*%(A=@&)+FG@0,434E7W-B$&%H$0,^FG@&'b.M*DE7W-B$&%HW-B$L'&$05;BDE8D31@&%1$0*-,1@Z8D31@&'&$
>D$0FG$0*-,bl$q[?8
@034E;FG$0*-,/.M57$0FG$0*,Z$0,H*BDFG@034E7W-B$0FG$0*,bP
É
É>D$&¡%9)+'&BD)+3_*,/57.+$r'0Fa,1%2BD%438@&'0"EsUCW- B$Lxs.MACB?BD[r31Fr$ .0 &P 0 )+~q*Dl*5$0.34E7%4$&E;%9Fc31BD$0*5.M>,4E7'&)+)+*F_8D8D31,1)+$68>D)C$%1@&5K$Rmn$q[]. S8$&@0'h34E7$057$*'&*$6)+8DB 5;S B$0%u5Hs.M>D5;A=<0)+57$034FGE;,4TD$0*-FG,2$RW>DB$h$L57>D$H@0FG,1$&)]'0,4>DE7<0)+57* $
8D31@&'&@&>D$0*-,bP
É>D$a¡5K)+mn$qBDp3Y$0,657$8DFc31)]BD>?3fBDE;,L 8.MC36C 57$ax'0sE7%AC.MBDE;315;57$ $0FG0 P$0=*~q,Vl^>D5. $V5%1.rE;Fc8BD)+5BD.M,4,431E7)+$a* %4BD*36BD57FG$a@0Fc34E7BDW-3ZB$$0,L>D8$$0345.oFG$0s,ZACBD.ME;31*$ %1E0 >DP z$a318D$031*@&>">?E;31\D$XE7$08D* 5;B'&%6)+$qF_[8D.+,1' $
,1$0FG$0*-,57$&%H>D@08D5.+'&$0FG$0*-,1%L>D$&%\D57)-'&%H>D)+*'g>D$&%L@ S $0*,4B$05;57$&%L34BD8D,4BD31$&%bP
É
#
.G%1$&'&)+*>D$Zs%1%4BD31$g$&%1,H$0*'&)+31$V8D5;B%.+'&'&$0*-,4B@&$Cl>.M*%'&$g'b.+%§lWB$Z8)+BD3257$gFG)]>D<057$V>D$Z5.XsACBD31$ 0 P , P
ÉÊ À É
OL-
•
#%
#
* # +
%
-BD35.osACBD31$ 0 P ]l957$&%h'&)+BD34\
$&%h$q[?8
@034E;FG$0*-,/.M57$&%R$0,h*BDFG@034E7W-B$&%R>D$e5.Jd)+31'&$fT)+34E;¢b)+*,/.M57$ j .M8D8D5;E7W-B$03
8)+BD3HWB$V5.X8
)+BD,431$V%/$g>D@08D5.+'&$V%1)+*,31$08D31@&%1$0*,1@&$&%bP
QL*f.h
É %1BD357$&%'&)+BD34\$&%6>D$gA.MB'1T$X$0,8)+BD3H57$VFaBD3g UC`BD*$a%4E;F_E;5;E;,4B>D$a$0*-,431$V57$&%L31@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%$q[?8@034E;FG$0*,/.MB?[
$0,257$gFG)]>D<057$g*-BDFG@034E7WB$c8D31)+8
)C%1@Z8.M3L#)+BD31$0* &) .M5Kl
É %4BD3257$&%2'&)+BD34\$&%2>D$g>?31)+E;,1$g$0,28
)+BD3(57$ZFaBD3L "CC?l?BD*$g%4E;F_E;5;E;,4B>D$c$0*,431$Z57$&%231@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%2$q[?8@034E;FG$0*,/.MB?[
$0,257$gFG)]>D<057$g*-BDFG@034E7WB$c8D31)+8
)C%1@Z8.M3Zi(.M31)+5 .M5KP
ÉÊ É
§
r§- L
) * 0 P . w6E.MAC3/.MF_FG$_'1T.M34A=$&%VT)+34E;¢b)+*,/.M57$&%c$0*JO)+*'0,4E7)+*>D$&%g>D@08D5.+'&$0FG$0*,1%gT)+34E;¢b)+*-,/.MB?[lxd#
)+BD31$0* & )
$0, L)+,1%cx|{b}C}=C~4~2$0,cxKi(.M31)+5
$0,6.M5KPxOCC?{§~4~
.M5;A=)+34E;,4TDFG$a>D$g>D@0,1$&'0,4E7)+*f%1)+*-,H31$08D31@&%1$0*,1@&$&%§P
25 90
75
20
Force de cisaillement (KN)
60
15 45
30
10
15
SW30 SW200
5 0
0 3 6 9 12 15 0 3 6 9 12 15
Déplacement horizontal (mm) Déplacement horizontal (mm)
) * 0 P . w6E.MAC3/.MF_FG$^'/T.M34A=$&%
T)+34E;¢b)+*-,/.M57$&%k$0*gJO)+*'0,4E7)+*a>D$&%>D@08D5.+'&$0FG$0*,1%T)+34E;¢b)+*,/.MB?[lC. S $&'u57$*)+B S $05
.M5;A=)+34E;,4TDFG$a>D$g>D@0,1$&'0,4E7)+*f>D$&%H'&)+*-,/.+'0,1%
ÉÊ ÆÉ
OL-
# $&%,/.+%1%/$0FG$0*,1%R>?Ep@031$0*,4E7$057%R>.M*%57$&%h)+B S 3/.MA=$&%h%1)+*-,BD*$%1)+BD31'&$eJ31@&W-B$0*,1$>D$>D@&%1)+31>?31$CP(#$0BD3h)+34E
ACE;*$31@&%4E7>D$%1)+B S $0*-,^>.M*%5. S .M34E.M\DE;5;E;,1@%48.M,4E.M57$L>D$&%8D31)+8D34E7@0,1@&%9>D$&%%1)+57%§l=%1)+B S $0*,9E;F_8.M3|JK.ME;,1$0FG$0*,(8D34E7%1$
É
$0*Y'&)+F_8D,1$Cl*BDE7%/.M*-,6.ME;*%4E j 57$0BD38D31@ S E7%4E7)+*P
£ ,43/. S $031%L5Kmn$q[?$0F_8D57$c%4BDE S .M*-,bl)+*YE;5;5;B%1,431$gBD*Y,/.+%1%1$0FG$0*-,>?Ep@031$0*,4E7$05k.s*e>D$ S @034Es$03W-B$g5Kmv.M343/.M*DA=$0FG$0*,
>D$&%2\D57)]'&%231@&%4BD5;,/.M*-,L>?BRFG)]>D<057$g*BDFG@034E7W-B$c%1E;FcBD57@V$&%4,8D31)-'/T$V>D$&%2FG$&%4BD31$&%L$q[]8@034E;FG$0*,/.M57$&%bP
•
!*
#% #%
!* !
+ ,
*
¥9E7@0*DE7@ .M5_xd¥9E7@0*DE7@$0,Y.M5KPgxOCCC=~4~)+*,RFG)]>D@05;E7%1@BD*",/.+%1%1$0FG$0*,Y>D$%1)+5g%4BD3BD*"FcBD3bPH#mn$q[]8@034E7$0*'&$
'&)+*%4E7%1,1$ j @0,4B>?E7$03cBD*z.+%/%1$0Fc\D5.MA=$G$0*o\D57)-'&%a>D$`\D34E7WB$&%bl31$08
)C%/.M*-,c%4BD3V,431)+E7%V8D5.M,1$qJd)+34FG$&%bP #
.R'&$0*-,43/.M57$
$&%4,XFG)+\DE;57$8
$034FG$0,4,/.M*-,_BD*z,/.+%/%1$0FG$0*,_%4BD3X5.Y8.M34,4E7$h'&$0*-,43/.M57$>?B FaBD3bP#
$rFaBD3`$&%1,X'&)+*%4,4E;,4B@h>D${b 0
\D34E7W-B$&%c.+%1%1$0Fa\D57@&$&%c$0* {bh'&)+B'/T$&%bP
# .hFr.+%1%1$ S )+5;BDF_E7W-B$G>D$_5.\D34E7W-B$G$&%4, P#mv.M*DAC57$
µ = 2000kg/m3
>D$J31)+,4,1$0FG$0*-,H$0*,431$g>D$0B?[r\D34E7W-B$&%($&%4,(>D$ 0
$ 2
, 1
% &
$ 9
% ?
> ;
E G
F 0
$
* 4
% 7
E +
)
* 2
% 1
% +
)
* H
, ?
v
P
[ ?
;
P q
{ D
[ ?
v
P 0 x +
) E;39sACBD31$
φ = 20◦ m3 S
0 Pv}=~gxd¥934E7'&'&)+5;E .M5Kl{b}C} 0 ¥934E7'&'&)+5;E
$0,L.M5KPx|{b}C} 0 ~4~qP
£ 8.M34,4E;3V>D$_5Kmn$0*%1$0Fa\D57$G>D$&%V>D)+*D*@&$&% j *)+,431$_>?E7%18
)C%4E;,4E7)+*lE;5u$&%4,c.M8D8.M34BE;*,1@031$&%/%/.M*,c>D$G31@b.M5;E7%1$03V'&$0,4,1$
$q[?8
@034E7$0*'&$Y. S $&'RBD*FG)]>D<057$Y>D$h'&)+348%_34E;ACE7>D$&%G,434E7>?E;FG$0*%4E7)+*D*$057%§P^i9$0,r$q[D$0F_8D57$Y.8
)+BD3_\DBD,G>mn@ S .M5;B$03
5.e31)+\DB%4,1$&%1%1$>D$5Kmv.M5;A=)+34E;,4TDFG$R>D$>D@0,1$&'0,4E7)+*
>D$&%X'&)+*,/.+'0,1%G$0,`>D$ S @034Es$03X5.e31@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+* *BDFG@034E7W-B$R>?B
8D31)+\D57<0FG$a>D$g'&)+*,/.+'0,HJd31)+,4,/.M*,bP
t[?8@034E;FG$0*,/.M57$0FG$0*,bl
5.8D5.M,1$qJd)+34FG$_'&$0*-,43/.M57$_%bmn$&%4,V.p.ME7%/%1@&$a>D$ , '0FYP#$&%Z31@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%Z*-BDFG@034E7WB$&%c$0,Z$q[
8@034E;FG$0*,/.MB?[e%1)+*-,>D@&'034E;,1%H%4BD35.asACBD31$ 0 Pv}?P
É
ÉÊ É
§
r§- L
CC
]u K
31<&%L8$0B>D$c31$&'/T$031'1T$&%ZBD*DE S $031%4E;,/.ME;31$&%g)+*-,Z@0,1@a8DBD\D5;E7@&$&%Z>.M*%657$a>D)+Fr.ME;*$`>?Bf'b.M57'0BD5k>D$&%L8
)+*-,1% S ) ,1$&%
$0*R,431)+E7%L>?E;FG$0*%4E7)+*%bPi^E;,1)+*%57$&%2,43/. S .MB?[Y>D$ .M*D*DE;*DA .M5x .M*D*DE;*DA$0,¥()])+,4T\:xOCC?{§~4~(W-BDEBD,4E;5;E7%1$0*-,
5.ry x57)+ACE7'0E7$05£ g VD~28
)+BD36%4E;FcBD57$03657$a'&)+F_8)+34,1$0FG$0*,ZFG@&'b.M*DE7W-B$`>D$&%8)+*,1%6$0*f8DE7$03431$CP
#um E;*-,1@031N0,
>D$X'&$0,4,1$X31$&'1T$031'1T$r$&%4,6>D$XFG$0,4,431$`$0*@ S E7>D$0*'&$X5.'&)+F_8D57$q[]E;,1@_>D$&%68DT@0*)+FG<0*$&%gE;*-,1$034*$&%Z,43/.M*% S $031%/.MB?[
$0,25.`8.M34,4E7'0E;8.M,4E7)+*>D$g,1)+BD,1$&%H57$&%H8.M34,4E7$&%H>D$g5Kmn)+B S 3/.MA=$ j 5.`%4,/.M\DE;5;E;,1@gAC57)+\.M57$CP
É
wZ)+FG<&>D$ .M5gxdwZ)+FG<&>D$xOCC =~4~a>D@ S $057)+8D8
$0*-,_BD*$rFG@0,4T)]>D$h>D$ q31$ W-B.M5;Es'b.M,4E7)+* h>D$&%X8
)+*-,1% S ) ,1$&%
$0*Fr. &)+*D*$034E7$CP i9$0,4,1$`FG@0,4T)]>D$G.@0,1@`F_E7%1$`$0*)]$0B S 31$X%1BD36BD*$ S ) ,1$`%4BD34\.ME7%/%1@&$Cl'&)+*%4,434BDE;,1$_$0*{ =+
ÉÊ 3 É
OL-
É
#$G,1$034FG$ q31$ W-B.M5;Es'b.M,4E7)+* r%4E;AC*DEs$G5Kmn@0,4B>D$rW-BDEu'&)+*%4E7%4,1$ j %§mv.+%1%4BD31$03V>D$_5Kmv.M8D,4E;,4B>D$Cl.MBo%1$03 S E7'&$G>mn)+B
S 3/.MA=$&%$q[?E7%4,/.M*-,1%$0, S E7$0E;5;5;E7%1%/.M*,1%h$0,h>D$e5.31@&%4E7%4,/.M*'&$>D$Y5.z%4,434B'0,4BD31$%1)+BDF_E7%1$ j BD*$@ S )+5;BD,4E7)+* >D$&%
É
%1)+5;5;E7'0E;,/.M,4E7)+*%VxO.MBDACFG$0*-,/.M,4E7)+*f>?B,43/.s'Cl]3/.M8DE7>?E;,1@g>D$&%^,43/.M*%18
)+34,1%~qPi9$0,4,1$6FG@0,4T)]>D$6$&%1,98$03|JO)+34Fr.M*,1$Z'b.M3
$05;57$_'&)+F_8D31$0*>,431)+E7%V8DT.+%1$&%g%4B'&'&$&%4E S $&%bP# .8D31$0F_E7<031$G@0,/.M8
$_'&)+*%1E7%4,1$ j 3/.+%1%1$0Fa\D57$03g8.M3gBD*$`31$&'1T$031'1T$
TDE7%4,1)+34E7W-B$hxA=@&)+FG@0,434E7$ClFr.M,1@034E.MB?[~,1)+BD,1$&%657$&%6E;*?Jd)+34Fr.M,4E7)+*%Z*@&'&$&%1%.ME;31$&%6%1BD35Km TDE7%4,1)+E;31$`>D$a5Kmn)+B S 3/.MA=$`$0,
%/.h'&)+F_8)C%4E;,4E7)+* P
#
.h>D$0B?[]E7<0FG$@0,/.M8
$_$&%1,c$q[]8@034E;FG$0*,/.M57$CP k5;57$r.8)+BD3V\DBD,c>D$_>D@0,1$034F_E;*$03aBD*$_57)+E>D$
'&)+F_8)+34,1$0FG$0*,(T)+FG)+A=@0*@0E7%1@&$Z>D$&%^Fr. &)+*D*$034E7$&%9'&)+*%1,4E;,4BD,4E S $&%2>D$H5Kmn)+B S 3/.MA=$L$0,^BD*$57)+E
>m E;*,1$03|JK.+'&$6$0*-,431$
57$&%Z\D57)]'&%Z$0,g57$&%4)+E;*,1%c>D$aFG)+34,4E7$03bP u*?s*l>.M*%Z5.,431)+E7%4E7<0FG$`@0,/.M8
$Cl>D$&%g%4E;FaBD5.M,4E7)+*%g*BDFG@034E7W-B$&%V%1)+*-,
$qp$&'0,4B@&$&%bl$0*,431)+E7%g>?E;FG$0*%4E7)+*% j 5Kmv.ME7>D$_>D$a5.FG@0,4T)]>D$_.MB?[@057@0FG$0*,1%gs*DE7%bP#umn)+34E;ACE;*.M5;E;,1@G$&%4,Z5.8D34E7%1$
É
$0*Y'&)+F_8D,1$a>D$&% 0@057@0FG$0*,1%|)+E;*-,1% g$0,H>D$&% qFr.+'031) @057@0FG$0*-,1% aT)+FG)+A=@0*@0E7%1@&%bP
•
!* !
#%!$!
%
, !
#
.FG)]>D@05;E7%/.M,4E7)+*8D31$0*>o$0*'&)+F_8D,1$GWB.M,431$GFr.&)+*D*$034E7$&%c>?Ep@031$0*,1$&%r S ) ,1$Cl\.M*>D$b.MB?[$0,V%/)+F_F_E7$031%bl
FaBD31%$0,H'0BD57@&$&%blD31$0F_8D5;E7%/%/.MA=$rx S )+E;32sACBD31$ 0 P;{C{§~qP
ÉÊ 3 É
§
r§- L
•
%
, %
#
.G%4E;FcBD5.M,4E7)+*$&%4,2\.+%1@&$g%4BD3H5.XFG@0,4T)]>D$V>D$&%H@057@0FG$0*-,1%Hs*DE7%§P
#
.`sACBD31$ 0 P;{b`8D31@&%1$0*-,1$g5._>D@qJO)+34FG@&$V>?BY8)+*,H)+\D,1$0*B$cAC3 '&$ j i9£g uy P
ÉÊ 3 ʲÉ
OL-
#
.G'&)+BD34\
$V>D$Z5.`sACBD31$ 0 P;{bU`31$08D31@&%1$0*-,1$g5._'1T.M34A=$c,1)+,/.M57$ j .M8D8D5;E7W-B$03H8
)+BD3L>D@08D5.+'&$03H5._'0BD57@&$CP
•
,
*
"
#%+
!*
#% ,,
6)+,431$h'&)+*,434E;\DBD,4E7)+* E7'0E2$&%4,_>D$FG)]>D@05;E7%1$03`57$8)+*,_8.M3`5.fFG@0,4T)]>D$R>D$&%_@057@0FG$0*,1%G>?E7%1'031$0,1%§l$0* ,1$0*.M*-,
'&)+F_8D,1$g>D$&%H'b.M3/.+'0,1@034E7%1,4E7WB$&%2Fr.M,1@034E.MB?[ox,/.M\D57$b.MB 0 Pv=~9$0,2>D$&%H'b.M3/.+'0,1@034E7%1,4E7WB$&%2FG@&'b.M*DE7W-B$&%H>?BY'&)+*-,/.+'0,
$0*-,431$g57$&%H\D57)]'&%cx,/.M\D57$b.MB 0 PvU=~ql
É
£LB_*DE S $b.MBr>?Bg4)+E;*,bl=)+*rBD,4E;5;E7%1$(BD*$257)+E'&)+T@&%4E S $>D$(, :]8
$Hy£i i
y x $ $b.M*r$0,^.M5KPxOCC?{§~ql-¥931$0,1$05;57$H$0,^.M5KP
xOCC?{§~4~qPi9$0,4,1$c57)+EE;*,1<0AC31$a>D$&%23/.ME7>D$0BD31%HE;*DE;,4E.M57$&%,/.M*DA=$0*,4E7$05;57$X$0,2*)+34Fr.M57$CP
#
._sACBD31$ 0 P;{ , JK.ME;,L.M8D8.M3/. 7,431$a57$V>D@08D5.+'&$0FG$0*,ZT)+34E;¢b)+*-,/.M5>D$g5.r'0BD57@&$c$0*RJO)+*'0,4E7)+*f>D$V5._'1T.M34A=$`.M8D8D5;E
W-B@&$CP
É
ÉÊ 3 ÀÉ
§
r§- L
•
#%
#
* # +
10
7
Charge totale (MN)
0
0 1 2 3 4 5
Déplacement horizontal ux (mm)
ÉÊ 3 Ë É
OL-
C ]=z
= 6 ^
#$&%g.+W-B$&>?B'&%g>mn£3457$&%Z$0,Z>D$`¥(.M34\$0A.M5t%1)+*,g>D$&%Z)+B S 3/.MA=$&% L)+Fr.ME;*%Z8D31@&%1$0*,1%Z>.M*%Z5.r31@0ACE7)+*>D$ )+*-,
S E7$0E;5;57$e$0* 3/.M*'&$f$0,>.M,/.M*,R>?B 1er %4E7<&'057$. S .M*,h$0, 1er %4E7<&'057$f.M8D31<&% $ P i 31$&%18
$&'0,4E S $0FG$0*-,bP9wg.M*%57$&%
É
.+W-B$&>?B'&%^.M*-,4E7WB$&%bl=5Kmn$b.MBr'0E;31'0BD57$%1)+B%u5Kmn$qp$0,>D$H5.6AC3/. S E;,1@CP¡)+BD3Fr.ME;*,1$0*DE;3^5.g'b.M*.M5;E7%/.M,4E7)+* j *DE S $b.MB +l
5.'&)+*%4,434B'0,4E7)+*>mn)+B S 3/.MA=$&%g>mv.M34,Z$&%4,6*@&'&$&%1%/.ME;31$CP])+B S $0*,bl
E;5t%4B G,Z>m BD*%1E;F_8D57$cFaBD3Z>D$X%1)+BD,1<0*$0FG$0*-,
'&)+*%4,434BDE;,H%/$057)+*5.X,1$&'/TD*DE7WB$g>?Bh\D57)]'b.MA=$C l
>D$&% L)+Fr.ME;*%bP?#)+31%1W-Bm E;5>D$ S E7$0*-,2*@&'&$&%
I5
.`@0,1@V)+\%1$03 S V
@ %1BD3257$g%4E;,1$VW-B$g'&$&%H>D$0B?[Y)+B S 3/.MA=$&%bl?FG$&%1BD3/.M*,L'/T.+'0BD* 0 MF >D$Z57)+*DAl%1)+*,$0*e34BDE;*$CP
•
%
, !$% +
!
QL*E;5;5;B%4,431$H5.V34BDE;*$L>D$&%9.+WB$&>?B'&%^8.M35.VF_E7%1$$0*8D5.+'&$>m BD*h%1@0E7%4FG$ q*-BDFG@034E7WB$ +P?£ 8.M34,4E;39>D$5Kmn@0,4B>D$
31@b.M5;E7%1@&$a8.M3Zi^T$0,1)+B.M*$RxKi^T$0,1)+B.M*$RxOCC , ~4~ql57$&%L$&%1%.ME7%L)+*-,6@0,1@a%4E;FcBD57@&%Z>.M*%L57$c\DBD,6>D$c'&)+F_8.M31$03Z57$&%
31@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%2)+\D,1$0*-B%(8.M3(5Kmv.M5;A=)+34E;,4TDFG$V>D$L>D@0,1$&'0,4E7)+*Y>D@qs*DE8.M3?.MB%1%1E;*$XxK?.MB%1%1E;*$`xOCC , ~4~Zx S )+E;32'/T.M8DE;,431$
U=~9$0,'&$0B?[R)+\D,1$0*B%6$0*RBD,4E;5;E7%/.M*-,57$Z*)+B S $05.M5;A=)+34E;,4TDFG$a>D$g>D@0,1$&'0,4E7)+*f>D$&%H'&)+*-,/.+'0,1%bP
#$&%%4,434B'0,4BD31$&%H%1)+*-,%1)+BDF_E7%1$&%(8$0*>.M*,Z+% j >D$&%H%1)+5;5;E7'0E;,/.M,4E7)+*%>?:]*.MF_E7W-B$&%H@&WBDE S .M57$0*,1$&% j BD*$c.+'&'&@057@
3/.M,4E7)+*%4E;*-B%1) K>.M57$_>mv.MF_8D5;E;,4B>D$r?PvUMAxA@0,/.M*-,g5Kmv.+'&'&@057@03/.M,4E7)+*o>D$a5.r8$&%/.M*-,1$0BD3~ql>D$cJd31@&W-B$0*'&$` ¢=P
#$
É
'&)]$ r'0E7$0*,6>D$6J31)+,4,1$0FG$0*-,L$0*,431$c57$&%28DE7$03431$&%$&%1,H@ S .M5;B@ j ?P ?P
ÉÊ 3 ¨ É
§
r§- L
5Kmv.M5;A=)+34E;,4TDFG$a>m E;*,1$031%1$&'0,4E7)+*>D$c?.MB%1%4E;*$Cl
xKi^T$0,1)+B.M*$xOCC , ~4~
•
%
#%&
* #%+
!*
#$&%X%4E;FaBD5.M,4E7)+*%a)+*-,X@0,1@r31$08D31)->?BDE;,1$&%X>.M*%c57$&%cFGN0FG$&%a'&)+*>?E;,4E7)+*%§PtQL*o)+\%/$03 S $%4BD3c5.hsACBD31$ 0 P;{§R57$&%
>D@0A ,1%L'b.MB%1@&%28.M3H57$g%1@0E7%1FG$CP
ÉÊ 3 ÀÉ
OL-
i9$0,4,1$V%1E;FcBD5.M,4E7)+*YJK.ME;,.M8D8.M3/. 7,431$r
É 5.`FGN0FG$V8
)C%4E;,4E7)+*RA=@&)+FG@0,434E7W-B$c>D$V5.X34BDE;*$VWB$Z5Kmn@0,4B>D$c*BDFG@034E7W-B$V8D31@&'&@&>D$0*-,1$Cl
É BD*$g34BDE;*$V,1)+,/.M57$V>D$&%H>D$0B?[e.M31'1T$&%L>D$&%.+WB$&>?B'&%L>mn£3457$&%$0,>D$g¥2.M34\
$0A.M5KP
+
wg.M*%(57$g'1T.M8DE;,431$aU?l])+*Y. S @034Es@ j ,43/. S $031%L>D$&%2%4E;FcBD5.M,4E7)+*%%4,/.M,4E7WB$&%(5Kmn$r'b.+'0E;,1@c>?BR*)+B S $05
.M5;A=)+34E;,4TDFG$
j >D@0,1$&'0,1$03L57$&%28
)+5;:=<&>?31$&%L$0*,431$V$0B?[R$0,H8$034FG$0,4,431$gBD*$g\)+*D*$V%4,/.M\DE;5;E;,1@V>D$&%%4,434B'0,4BD31$&%'&)+*%4E7>D@031@&$&%§P
wg.M*%L57$c'b.+%6>?:-*.MF_E7W-B$Cl'&$&%6>D$034*DE7<031$&%68D31@&%1$0*,1$0*-,g%1)+B S $0*,Z>D$&%8DT@0*)+FG<0*$&%Z'&)+F_8D57$q[D$&%bl8.M3|Jd)+E7%6>?E
'0E;57$ j 8D31@&>?E;31$Cl]FG$0,4,/.M*, j 5Kmn@08D31$0B S $657$&%^>?Ep@031$0*,1%957)+ACE7'&$057%(>D$L'b.M57'0BD57%($q[?E7%4,/.M*,1%§P-#umv.M*.M5;:?%1$6>D$&%31@&%1BD5;,/.M,1%
É
$q[?8
@034E;FG$0*-,/.MB?[Y$0,2*BDFG@034E7W-B$&%28D31)+8
)C%/@&$&%28.M325.X5;E;,4,1@03/.M,4BD31$V)+BY)+\%1$03 S @&$&%H>?E;31$&'0,1$0FG$0*-,%4BD3H%4E;,1$_xO.+W-B$
>?B'&%~.Z8$034F_E7%>D$ S .M5;E7>D$035.g31)+\DB%4,1$&%1%1$L>D$25Kmv.M5;A=)+34E;,4TDFG$L>D$L>D@0,1$&'0,4E7)+*%18
@&'0EsW-B$.MB?[_Fr. &)+*D*$034E7$&%bP k*
É
$qp$0,bl.M8D31<&%%1)+5;5;E7'0E;,/.M,4E7)+*%§l)+*R31$0,431)+B S $V57$&%HFGN0FG$&%L.M343/.M*DA=$0FG$0*,1%6>D$&%2\D57)]'&%bP
ÉÊ 3 É
** §
L
- !
c 1
t
1
a X
2 1
a
( 1
#umn)+34E;ACE;*.M5;E;,1@c>D$5.a31@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*h8D31)+8)C%1@&$6E7'0E'&)+*'&$034*$Z5.c8)C%1%4E;\DE;5;E;,1@Z>D$L%1E;FcBD57$03H>D$&%(%4,434B'0,4BD31$&%2$0*hAC3/.M*>
.M8D8.M31$0E;5u8D31@&'&)+*-,43/.ME;*,1$&%`. S $&'_BD*$`A=@&)+FG@0,434E7$r8.M34,4E7'0BD5;E7<031$G>D$_'&)+*,/.+'0,1%a$0, )+Bo'&)+F_8)+34,/.M*,VBD**)+Fa\D31$
E;F_8)+34,/.M*,6>D$Z\D57)-'&%bP
wg.M*%6'&$0,4,1$c8.M34,4E7$Cl
WB.M,431$a)+B S 3/.MA=$&%6Fr. &)+*D*@&%Z%1)+*-,L8D31@&%1$0*-,1@&%`BD*e8)+*,blBD*.+WB$&>?B'ClBD*$&%1'b.M5;E7$03Z$0,
BD*$L'&)+BD8 57$CP-¡.M34F_E'&$&%%1,434B'0,4BD31$&%bl=,431)+E7%Zx8
)+*-,bl$&%1'b.M5;E7$03($0,'&)+BD8 57$§~u)+*-,^@0,1@L@0,4B>?E7@&$&%9>.M*%57$'/T.M8DE;,431$
U`.s*R>D$6FG$0,4,431$g$0*h@ S E7>D$0*'&$Z5Kmn$ r'b.+'0E;,1@g>?Bh*)+B S $05
.M5;A=)+34E;,4TDFG$V>D$Z>D@0,1$&'0,4E7)+*Y>D$&%2'&)+*,/.+'0,1%bl?8)+BD3(A=@031$03
>D$&%2A=@&)+FG@0,434E7$&%L8.M3|JO)+E7%H'&)+F_8D57$q[?$&%§P
#umn)+\?4$&'0,4EJ$&%4,u5Kmn@0,4B>D$L>D$H'&$&%u)+B S 3/.MA=$&%$0*G,1$034FG$&%^>D$231@b.+'0,4E7)+*%bl>mn$qp)+34,1%bl=$0,*)+,/.MF_FG$0*,98
)+BD3%§mv.+%1%4BD31$03
>D$Z5._'&)+T@031$0*'&$a>D$&%H'b.M57'0BD57%L. S $&'g57$&%H'b.M3/.+'0,1@034E7%4,4E7W-B$&%L8DT:?%4E7WB$&%>?BYFG)->D<057$CP
•
,,
%
+ !* #% Ë
!
#$8)+*, $ DB 5;E7$0*$&%4,XBD*z8)+*,`31)+Fr.ME;*lt>D$5Kmv.M* U. S .M*, $ P i6lt%4E;,4B@h.MB>D@0\
)+B'/T@>?B >D@qs57@h>D$ )]WB$
JdBD31$ j & F M. BY*)+31>R>D$V¥()+*D*DE7$0B?[oxd>D@08.M34,1$0FG$0*,Z>?B .MB'05;B%1$§~2$0, j & F j 5Km u%4,L>D$g5. S E;5;57$g>mn£L8D,bP
ÉÊ'& ÆÉ
OL-
•
, #%&
%"
#+!$
*!$# !$
,,
£ 5.as*e>?BY'b.M57'0BD5Kl5.`%1,434B'0,4BD31$c.G.M,4,1$0E;*,6%/.X8)C%4E;,4E7)+*Y>mn@&WBDE;5;E;\D31$x S )+E;3'1T.M8DE;,431$XU=~qP
! " P;{b}%$
L@08.M34,4E;,4E7)+*f>D$&%H$qp)+34,1%H>.M*%257$g8)+*,
$ BD5;E7$0*
ÉÊ'& É
" "
§
L
- !
8e+06
7e+06
6e+06
Réaction au bloc (N)
5e+06
4e+06
3e+06
2e+06
1e+06
0
0 5 10 15 20
Hauteur du pilier (m)
#
.6>D$&%1'&$0*-,1$H>D$('1T.M34A=$&%u$&%1,t>mn$0* S E;31)+* 6 L$ 2,1)+*G%4BD3t57$98D5.M*_%4BD8D8)+34,u'&)+3431$&%48
)+*>.M*-, j BD*$(Fr.+%1%1$
?> B8DE;5;E7$032>D$Z+UCc,1)+*D*$&%bP]#
.c>D$&%/'&$0*,1$g7, >D$63.10
'1T.M34A=$6,1)+,/.M57$ClD.MB*DE S $b.MBh>D$&%98DE;5;E7$031%9$0,(>D$&%('0BD57@&$&%bl-8
$034FG$0,2>D$
31$0,431)+B S $03257$68)+E7>D%9>D$65.X%4,434B'0,4BD31$g$0*h31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%2>mv.M8D8DBDEKlD'&)+3431$&%48)+*>.M*, j BD*$6Fr.+%1%1$Z>D$g=+U `,1)+*D*$&%bP
i9$g31@&%1BD5;,/.M,$&%4,H'&)+T@031$0*,Z. S $&'g57$&%'b.M3/.+'0,1@034E7%4,4E7WB$&%L8DT:?%4E7W-B$&%H$0,2A=@&)+FG@0,434E7W-B$&%L>D$Z5._%1,434B'0,4BD31$CP
•
"!!*++,
# +,
+
wZ$08DBDE7%G%/.'&)+*%4,434B'0,4E7)+*l5.%4,434B'0,4BD31$R$&%4,G$0* q\)+* h@0,/.M,r.M8D8.M31$0*,bP^¡ )+BD3G8D31@&%/$03 S $03G57$h8
)+*-,blt5.'0E;3
'0BD5.M,4E7)+* .MBD,1)+FG)+\DE;57$$&%4,r31<0AC57$0FG$0*-,1@&$>D$08DBDE7%{b}C}C}?P2QL* FG)->D@05;E7%/$eBD* ,/.+%1%1$0FG$0*-,h>D$f%1)+5Z%4BD3rBD*">D$&%
É
8DE;5;E7$031%L>D$Z5._%4,434B'0,4BD31$CP
i9$0,4,1$R@0,4B>D$R8$034FG$0,G>D$R%bm E;*-,1@031$&%1%1$03r.MB
'&)+F_8)+34,1$0FG$0*,rFG@&'b.M*DE7W-B$Y>m BD*$R%4,434B'0,4BD31$e'&)+F_8
)+34,/.M*-,rBD*
AC3/.M*>R*)+Fa\D31$c>D$g\D57)]'&%(JK.+'&$ j BD*$V>D@0*DE S $05;5.M,4E7)+*f>mv.M8D8DBDEKP
ÉÊ'& & É
OL-
L É
Q *31$0Fr.M31W-B$Cl
.MB*DE S $b.MB>D$&%gE7%1) >D@08D5.+'&$0FG$0*-,1%xsACBD31$ Pv?{§~qlWB$`57$`8DE;5;E7$03g57$`8D5;B%V'/T.M34A=@G%bmn$qp)+*>?31$
$0*-,4E7<031$0FG$0*,Z>D$ZJO.&)+*RFG)+*)+5;:],4TDE7W-B$CP
i9$0,$qp)+*>?31$0FG$0*,JO.ME;,.M8D8.M3/. 7,431$L>D$&%ts%1%4BD31$&%$0*,431$25.6\.ME7$H$0,k5.V'1T.MB%1%1@&$ax8.M34,4E7$H%4BD8@034E7$0BD31$H>?B_8
)+*-,~
ÉÉ
$0,L.MB?[Y*DE S $b.MB?[e>D$&%6.M31'1T$&%bP
#$&%\D57)-'&%L>D$V5.`8.M34,4E7$X%4BD8@034E7$0BD31$V31$&%4,1$0*-,L%1)+5;E7>.ME;31$&%6'Cmn$&%4, j >?E;31$cW-Bm E;5
*m :
.X8.+%H>D$VAC5;E7%1%1$0FG$0*,L$0*,431$V57$&%%4BD3|JO.+'&$&%>D$V'&)+*,/.+'0,1%L>D$&%2\D57)-'&%§P
#$&%a.M31'1T$&%c%§mn$qp)+*>?31$0*-,c8D31)+AC31$&%1%4E S $0FG$0*-,cFr.ME7%c8D5;B%g57$0*,1$0FG$0*-,XW-B$`57$`8DE;5;E7$03bP#$&%g¢b)+*$&%a>D$XJO.ME;\D57$&%/%1$&%
É
.MB?[R*DE S $b.MB?[e>D$&%Z.M31'1T$&%6%1)+*,L\DE7$0*e31$08D31@&%1$0*-,1@&$&%L8.M3L57$&%HE7%1) >D@08D5.+'&$0FG$0*-,1%bP#$&%'0BD57@&$&%6$0,5Kmv.MBD,431$c8DE;5;E7$03
31$&%4,1$0*-,%4,/.M\D57$&%,1)+BD,L.MBR57)+*DAr>?BY'b.M57'0BD5KP
L*f>D$0B?[?E7<0FG$a$q[D$0F_8D57$X>D$c%4,434B'0,4BD31$X'&)+F_8
)+34,/.M*-,ZBD*eAC3/.M*>f*)+Fc\D31$`>D$V\D57)]'&%L$&%1,8D31@&%1$0*-,1@57$&%6.+W-B$
>?B'&% L)+Fr.ME;*%bP
É
•
+!$" +#% ! ! !*,,
!*+! # IË
!
wg.M*%V5.Y8.M34,4E7$G8D31@&'&@&>D$0*-,1$Cl 57$&%X.+WB$&>?B'&% )+Fr.ME;*%X%1$_34BDE;*$0*-,XW-B.+%4E;FG$0*-,X$0*,1)+,/.M5;E;,1@57)+31%1W-Bm E;57%c%1)+*-,
É
É
" "
§
L
- !
•
, #%&
%"
#+!$
*!$# !$
!$"# !
£ 5.as*e>?BY'b.M57'0BD5Kl5.`%1,434B'0,4BD31$c.G.M,4,1$0E;*,6%/.X8)C%4E;,4E7)+*Y>mn@&WBDE;5;E;\D31$CP
! " PvC%$
L@08.M34,4E;,4E7)+*e>D$&%$qp)+34,1%H>.M*%257$&%.+W-B$&>?B'&% L)+Fr.ME;*%
#
._31@08.M34,4E;,4E7)+*f>D$&%H$qp)+34,1%cxsACBD31$ PvC=~2$&%4,2T)+FG)+A=<0*$c$0,H%4:]FG@0,434E7W-B$CPi9$Z31@&%4BD5;,/.M,$&%4,28D31@ S E7%4E;\D57$CP
•
,
+!
$ ! #% Ê
!
i9$0,($q[?$0F_8D57$6E;5;5;B%4,431$L5.a8
)C%/%4E;\DE;5;,1@>m E;*-,1@0AC31$032BD*$L8D31@&'&)+*-,43/.ME;*,1$V>.M*%9BD*$6%4,434B'0,4BD31$Cl j 5Kmn@0,/.M,2>mn@0,4B>D$`
%/.'&)+*%4,434B'0,4E7)+* >D@0\DBD,1$03/.$0* CC ?P^i9$h8D31)M4$0,_8
$034FG$0,G>D)+*'YBD*$Y.M*.M5;:]%1$R'&)+F_8D57<0,1$e>D$h5.%4,434B'0,4BD31$
.s*>D$`>?E;FG$0*%4E7)+*D*$03V%1$&%6>?Ep@031$0*-,1%V'&)+*%4,4E;,4B.M*-,1%g8
)+BD368$034FG$0,4,431$_%/.r%1,/.M\DE;5;E;,1@CP
#
$a\DBD,g$&%4,65Kmn@0,4B>D$_>D$
5Kmn$ r'b.+'0E;,1@a$0,H>D$g5.`'&)+T@031$0*'&$c>D$&%231@&%1BD5;,/.M,1%)+\D,1$0*B%§P
wZ$05;,1)+BD3blDFG$0Fa\D31$V>D$g5Kmn£6%1%1)]'0E.M,4E7)+*Y>D$&%i9)+F_8.MAC*)+*%L¡t.+%1%/.M*-,1% .ME;5;57$0BD31%L>D$Z8DE7$03431$Cl.X8D31)+8)C%1@g>D$Z8.M3
,4E7'0E;8$03 j 5.'&)+*'&$08D,4E7)+*o>m BD*$`'&)+BD8 57$_$0*8DE7$03431$CP
i9$a8D31)M4$0,Z31$0*,431$_>.M*%Z57$`'b.+>?31$_>D$&% $0*'&)+*-,431$&%V>D$
É
5.r8DE7$03431$`>D$ $ BD*.+%6W-BDEKl>D$08DBDE7%`{b} ?l3/.+%/%1$0Fc\D57$0*-,V>D$&%L,/.ME;5;57$0BD31%g>D$a8DE7$03431$`$0,g>D$&%L8D31)MJO$&%1%4E7)+*D*$057%Z>D$X5.
É ²Ê É
OL-
! #" PvCU $
@&)+FG@0,434E7$V>D$g5.`'&)+BD8 57$V>D$ $ BD*.+%
•
+ #% #
+,
L*$a@0,4B>D$_.M*-,1@034E7$0BD31$G%4BD365.r%4,/.M\DE;5;E;,1@`>D$X5.'&)+BD8 57$_.>D@ j @0,/.ME;,Z$qp$&'0,4B@&$YxKi^T$0,1)+B.M*$YxOCC -~4~qPwZ$&%
31@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%_)+*-,`FG)+*,431@RW-B$57$h'/T)+E[ >m BD*%1$0BD5(Fr.M,1@034E.MB 8
)+B S .ME;,_$0*DA=$0*>?31$03G>D$&%_>D@0A ,1%Yxs%1%4BD31$&%`>D$&%
\D57)]'&%bP;P;P ~(>?B% j >D$&%%1)+5;5;E7'0E;,/.M,4E7)+*%L8.M3|Jd)+E7%H,431)+8f@057$ S @&$&%bP#
$V'1T)+E[e>D$&%28DE7$03431$&%L$0,H57$0BD31%H8)C%4E;,4E7)+*%L>.M*%H5.
%4,434B'0,4BD31$c$&%4,2,431<&%HE;F_8)+34,/.M*,H8)+BD3$0*e.+%1%1BD31$03H5.`%4,/.M\DE;5;E;,1@rxd'/T.M8DE;,431${§~qP
w $05;,1)+BD3R.31$08$0*%1@f5.%4,1@031@&)+,1)+F_E7$$0,R.8D31)+8)C%1@e>D$ S .M5;E7>D$0357$&%h%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*%31$0,1$0*B$&%R'&)+*'&$034*.M*-,1%h57$&%
Z
Fr.M,1@034E.MB?[RBD,4E;5;E7%1@&%L$0,25._%4,1@031@&)+,1)+F_E7$g31$0,1$0*-B$c$0,>D$g>D@0,1$034F_E;*$03L57$&%2¢b)+*$&% j 31$0*?JO)+31'&$03bP
•
,
* ,
*! !*+!$%"
+
,
$
$# %
#
.fA=@&)+FG@0,434E7$Y$0,`57$&%`>?E;FG$0*%4E7)+*%G>D$5.%4,434B'0,4BD31$h>D)+E S $0*,N0,431$'&)+*%/$03 S @&$&%bPk#
.%4,1@031@&)+,1)+F_E7$Clt57$h'1T)+E[
>D$&%2Fr.M,1@034E.MB?[e$0,257$0BD31%H31@08.M34,4E;,4E7)+*%L>D)+E S $0*-,6.MB%1%4EN0,431$c'&)+*%1$03 S @&%bP
#
.X57)+E >D$g'&)+F_8
)+34,1$0FG$0*-, j 5Km E;*,1$03|JK.+'&$c$0*-,431$g57$&%28DE7$03431$&%L$&%4,H>D$Z, :]8
$6Jd31)+,4,1$0FG$0*,6%1$&'Z>D$ai9)+BD57)+Fc\%4,/.M*
>.M31>e. S $&'gBD*e'&)]$ r'0E7$0*,6>D$6J31)+,4,1$0FG$0*-,L>D$c?P ?P
É
ÉÉ
•
!
*
#
.G%4,434B'0,4BD31$ j FG)]>D@05;E7%1$03$&%4,2BD*$ S ) ,1$V$0*e8DE7$03431$V>D$ MF >D$g>?E.MFG<0,431$c$0, CF >D$ZT.MBD,1$0BD3WBDE %bm E;*%1'034E;,
É
É ÀÉ
" "
§
L
- !
Ék54m >D$g8DE7$03431$&%>D$V¥($b.MBD5;E7$0BP
;57$&%L%1)+*,L>?E7%48
)C%/@&$&%2>.M*%H5.`%4,434B'0,4BD31$V>D$V5.aJO. &)+*e%1BDE S .M*-,1$rx S )+E;32sACBD31$ Pv -~qP
3
#$a'1T)+E[f>D$c5._31@08.M34,4E;,4E7)+*>D$&%H8DE7$03431$&%Z$&%4,6$qp$&'0,4B@a$0*YJO)+*'0,4E7)+*>D$c57$0BD31%L'b.M3/.+'0,1@034E7%1,4E7WB$&%6FG@&'b.M*DE7W-B$&%
xFr.+%1%/$ S )+5;BDF_E7WB$ClFG)->?BD57$V>m )+BD*DAP;P;P ~qP
! #" Pv $
HBDE;*$g>D$V5.`'&)+BD8 75 $
£ 5 .as*e>?BY'b.M57'0BD5Kl5.`%1,434B'0,4BD31$V$&%4,H,1)+,/.M57$0FG$0*-,34BDE;*@&$CP
É
QL*G)+\%1$03 S $HBD*$H'&)+*'&$0*,43/.M,4E7)+*h>D$2'&)+*,43/.ME;*-,1$&%(.MB_*DE S $b.MB>D$&%k8DE7$&>D%bP-i9$0B?[ '0E%bmn@&'b.M34,1$0*-, S $031%u5Kmn$q[?,1@034E7$0BD3
$0,H5;E;\<031$0*,657$&%H8D31$0F_E7<031$&%L8DE7$03431$&%6WBDE,1)+Fa\
$0*-,Z.MB'&$0*,431$a>D$&% &.M31'1T$&% +P#$&%Z.MBD,431$&%L.+%/%4E7%1$&%%§mv.p.ME7%1%/$0*,
Fr.ME7%2*$c%1$g>D@0,434BDE7%1$0*,L8.+%2,1)+,/.M57$0FG$0*,bP
É Ë É
OL-
*DE;,1@&%axL$ 2,1)+*~
])+F_F_E7$031%a{ U
tp)+34,1% 2[
0, 104.105 0, 101.105 0, 368.105 −0, 304.105 −0, 269.105
:
0, 341.105 −0, 314.105 0, 935.103 −0, 228.105 0, 212.105
H¢
−0, 465.105 −0, 445.105 −0, 444.105 −0, 457.105 −0, 436.105
y)+FG$0*,1%LyY[
−0, 537.104 −0, 245.104 −0, 187.104 0, 512.103 0, 522.104
ye:
0, 703.104 −0, 270.103 −0, 100.103 0, 101.105 0, 527.104
yf¢
0, 715.103 −0, 120.104 −0, 895.104 −0, 498.103 0, 448.104
" P $ .M57$0BD31%>D$&%H$qp)+34,1%H%4BD3257$&%L%1)+F_F_E7$031%H>D$g5.`'&)+BD8 57$
#
.G%4E;FcBD5.M,4E7)+*eJO.ME;,.ME;*%4E
.M8D8.M3/.ME;,431$c57$&%2¢b)+*$&%>D$gJO.ME;\D57$&%1%/$V.ME;*%4EWBm BD*f$qp)+*>?31$0FG$0*-,L>D$g5.`%4,434B'0,4BD31$CP
i9$0,4,1$_FG)]>D@05;E7%/.M,4E7)+*o%§mv. S <031$G*@&'&$&%/%/.ME;31$_8)+BD3g\DE7$0*o'&)+F_8D31$0*>?31$G5Kmn@ S )+5;BD,4E7)+* >D$G'1T.+W-B$_\D57)]'_$0,VFG$0,4,431$
$0*R8D5.+'&$cBD*R31$0*?Jd)+34,bP
•
!
,
#% ! ,++,
#&!*
! #&!*
+
w $&%_%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*%G%/)+*,G>D)+*' j $0* S E7%/.MA=$03G%4BDE;,1$ j 5Km E;*%1,/.M\DE;5;E;,1@Y>D$5.'&)+*%4,434B'0,4E7)+*Pu£LB*DE S $b.MB
>D$&%G%1)+F
Z
F_E7$031%bl)+*Y)+\%1$03 S $gBD*$V'&)+*'&$0*-,43/.M,4E7)+*>D$g'&)+*-,43/.ME;*,1$&%bP
É
¡)+BD32>D@0,1$034F_E;*$03('&$&%(>D$034*DE7<031$&%bl-BD*$6%4E;FcBD5.M,4E7)+*R$&%4,($qp$&'0,4B@&$6$0*\D57)-W-B.M*,957$&%(%1)+F_F_E7$031%bPDQL*8D31$0*>57$&%
S .M57$0BD31%Z>D$&%HJO)+31'&$&%g.MB?[?W-B$05;57$&%6E;57%L%1)+*-,6%1BD8D8
)C%1@&%L31@&%4E7%4,1$03bP
#$&%Z$qp)+34,1%L,43/.M*%1F_E7%6%/)+*,68D31@&%1$0*,1@&%g>.M*%657$
,/.M\D57$b.MB P P
#
.a'&)+F_8)C%/.M*,1$6T)+34E;¢b)+*,/.M57$g>D$6'1T.+W-B$6$qp)+34,9*$8$0BD,98.+%^%bmv.M*D*-BD57$03. S $&'L5.c%/$0BD57$31@&%4E7%1,/.M*'&$L>?B8DE;5;E7$03bP
i^T.+W-B$8DE;5;E7$03`$&%1,`%/)+BDF_E7% j BD*$qp)+34,X3/.+>?E.M5(T)+34E;¢b)+*-,/.M5>D$ S .M57$0BD3 1 31$08D31@&%1$0*,/.M*-,GBD*$
(Rx2 + Ry 2 ) 2
8)+B%1%1@&$ S $031%25Kmn$q[?,1@034E7$0BD3bP
É
i9$05;57$ '0E*@&'&$&%/%4E;,1$ZBD*h31$0*?Jd)+34, )+*R8$0BD,(8.M3H$q[?$0F_8D57$VE;Fr.MACE;*$032BD*$g'&$0E;*,4BD31$VFG@0,/.M5;5;E7W-B$Z8.+%1%/.M*-,H8.M3257$
'&$0*-,431$c>D$ZAC3/. S E;,1@c>D$g'/T.+WB$c%1)+F_F_E7$03bP
#
.(Jd)+31'&$k3/.+>?E.M57$ j '&)+F_8$0*%1$03bl§.MBV*DE S $b.MBX>D$u'1T.+W-B$%1)+F_F_E7$03bl$&%4,>D$H 1 l
F r = (Rx2 +Ry 2 ) 2 = 0, 4.105 N
%1)+E;,2BD*$c'1T.M34A=$c@&W-BDE S .M57$0*,1$ j BD*$ZFr.+%/%1$V>mn$0* S E;31)+*eW-B.M,431$g,1)+*D*$&%bP
É
¨ É
" "
§
L
- !
•
+!
%+ ,
#%&
,
# .z'1T.M34A=$%1$e31@08.M34,4E;,h%1BD3r57$&%'0E;*W%1)+F_F_E7$031%bP9#
.o'&$0E;*-,4BD31$>D)+E;,>D)+*'f31@&%4E7%4,1$03 j BD* $qp)+34,,/.M*DA=$0*
Ftangentielle x Pv?P;{§~
S=
Rt
£ S &$ 'Cl
$qp)+34,2,/.M*DA=$0*-,4E7$05Kl
Ftangentielle = 200kN
D31@&%4E7%1,/.M*'&$ j 5.X,43/.+'0,4E7)+*l
Rt = 800M P a
2 %1$&'0,4E7)+*l
QL*e$0*Y>D@&>?BDE;,57$V>?E.MFG<0,431$V>D$g5.`'&$0E;*-,4BD31$aw {§]l CF_FYP
S = Π D4 = 250mm2
\D5.M34A=$0BD3L>?BY\D57)-'Cl
>>?E7%1,/.M*'&$V$0*,431$g57$c'&$0*,431$V>D$gAC3/. S E;,1@c>?Be%1)+F_F_E7$03$0,25Kmv.M8D8D5;E7'b.M,4E7)+*>D$Z5.XJO)+31'&$ l
Fp
]Jd)+31'&$c>D$g8D31@&'&)+*,43/.ME;*-,1$CP
Fp
¡)+BD3HWB$65.aJO)+31'&$g.M8D8D5;E7WB@&$ 8h31$&%4,1$g>.M*%(57$6*)§:.MBe'&$0*,43/.M5KlD>h>D)+E;,HN0,431$ZE;*?JO@034E7$0BD31$g)+Bh@0A.M5 j b P?wg.M*%
*)+,431$V'b.+%§l?\ U CMF_FYl>mn) P 6
d ≤ 0.06m
•
+!
%+ ,
#%&
% + ,
* ,
*
#
.`Jd)+31'&$g>D$g8D31@&'&)+*-,43/.ME;*,1$X$&%4,.M57)+31%
ÉÉ
QL*e'/T)+E7%4E;,H57$g'b.+%57$Z8D5;B%H>D@qJO. S )+3/.M\D57$c'Cmn$&%4, j >?E;31$a> ?Pv MFYP
P
Fp = 7000 = 117kN
#
.a'&)+*>?E;,4E7)+*R>D$%1@&'0BD34E;,1@ j 31$&%48
$&'0,1$03($&%4, 0.06 PDi9$0,4,1$Jd)+34FaBD57$L8$034FG$0,(>D$ S @034Es$032WB$5.gJO)+31'&$
>D$L8D31@&'&)+*,43/.ME;*-,1$g'b.M57'0BD57@&$6$&%1,9%4B r%.M*,1$L8
F)+BDp39≤Frα.Re.S
.ME;*,1$0*DE;3(BD*$6%4,/.M\DE;5;E;,1@CP?#$L'&)]$r'0E7$0*,2>D$6%1@&'0BD34E;,1@ $&%4,
α
8D34E7%2E7'0E j ?P
£ S $&'Cl
L$ +yf¡t.RD31@&%4E7%1,/.M*'&$V$0*Y'&)+F_8D31$&%1%4E7)+*e>D$V5.X8DE7$03431$V>D$V#$0*%bl
%4BD3|JK.+'&$Z,1)+,/.M57$V>D$V'&)+*-,/.+'0,L$0*,431$V57$&%28DE7$03431$&%bl
S = 0.36 ∗ 0.7 = 0.252m2
57$_'b.M57'0BD5>D$ >D)+*D*$ CC & XP#
.JO)+31'&$_>D$`8D31@&'&)+*,43/.ME;*-,1$$&%1,6\DE7$0*oE;*?Jd@034E7$0BD31$ j '&$0,4,1$ S .M57$0BD3bl
$05;57$V$&%1,.M8D,1$ α.Re.S
j Fr.ME;*,1$0*DE;3LBD*$g8D31@&'&)+*,43/.ME;*-,1$X%1B r%/.M*,1$g8)+BD325._%4,/.M\DE;5;E;,1@c>D$&%H%1)+F_F_E7$031%bP
É ÀÉ
OL-
•
#%&
#%+ #
#
.cF_E7%1$Z$0*h'1T.M34A=$6*BDFG@034E7W-B$g>D$5.a'&)+BD8 75 $6$&%1,^31@b.M5;E7%1@&$L*DE S $b.MBh8.M3(*DE S $b.MBh$0*h%4BDE S .M*,(BD*8D31)-'&@&>D@Z>D$
'&)+*%4,434B'0,4E7)+*f31@b.M5;E7%4,1$CP
•
, #%&
%"
#+!$
*!$# !$
£ 5.as*e>?BY'b.M57'0BD5Kl5.`%1,434B'0,4BD31$c.M,4,1$0E;*,6%/.X8
)C%1E;,4E7)+*e>mn@&WBDE;5;E;\D31$x S )+E;3'1T.M8DE;,431$XU=~qP
! #" Pv=%$
@08.M34,4E;,4E7)+*f>D$&%$qp)+34,1%H>.M*%5.`'&)+BD8 75 $
#
._A=@&)+FG@0,434E7$c>D$Z5._'&)+BD8 57$V$&%4,H%4:]FG@0,434E7W-B$g$0,'&)+F_8D57$q[?$CP
#
.r31@08.M34,4E;,4E7)+*>D$&%L$qp)+34,1%`xsACBD31$ Pv=C~$&%4,T)+FG)+A=<0*$`$0,6%4:-FG@0,434E7W-B$a.MB*DE S $b.MB>D$&%8DE7$&>D%6>D$c5.r'&)+B
8 57$CP
É
#$9' \D57$(>D$8D31@&'&)+*-,43/.ME;*,1$28)+BD3t57$&% %1E;FcBD5.M,4E7)+*%k*-BDFG@034E7WB$&%blC.8
$034F_E7%5.L%4,/.M\DE;5;E;,1@(>D$5.L%4,434B'0,4BD31$CP+¥9E7$0*
W-B$_57$&%V'&)+*-,/.+'0,1%a%1)+*-,c$&%1%1$0*-,4E7$05;57$0FG$0*,_>D$_,I:-8$G.M31<0,1$ .M31<0,1$$0,X.M31<0,1$ JO.+'&$xd'&$GWBDEk*mn$&%1,V8.+%c'&)+F_FaBD*
>.M*%57$&%HFr. &)+*D*$034E7$&%~ql5._,43/.M*%4F_E7%1%1E7)+*e>D$&%$qp)+34,1%>?Be%/)+F_FG$0,L>D$g5._'&)+BD8 57$(|B%1W-Bm j %1$&%28DE7$&>D%6._@0,1@
$ r'b.+'&$CPQL*f@0,4B>?E7$V>.M*%H5.`%4BDE;,1$VBD*$g>D$&%1'&$0*,1$a>D$V'1T.M34A=$c.MBe*DE S $b.MBe>m BD*Y8DE;5;E7$03bP
É
É
" "
§
L
- !
•
#% #%! #
!
£ 8D31<&%25Kmn@0,4B>D$V>D$&%H'&)+*-,43/.ME;*,1$&%Z$0,H>D$&%$qp)+34,1%H$0*DA=$0*>?31@&%8.M3H5.`%4,434B'0,4BD31$Cl)+*e%§m E;*,1@031$&%1%1$VFr.ME;*,1$0*.M*, j
L
5.h'&)+*'&$08D,4E7)+*o>D$&%gJd)+*>.M,4E7)+*%VW-BDEu%4BD8D8)+34,1$031)+*,V5Kmn@&>?Es'&$CP #
.sACBD31$ Pv 31$08D31@&%1$0*-,1$_BD*$_>D$&%1'&$0*-,1$r>D$
60
50
40
Réaction au bloc (KN)
30
20
10
0
0 1 2 3 4
Hauteur de la coupole (m)
•
"!!*++,
# +,
+
Q *
.%4E;FcBD57@hBD* ,/.+%1%/$0FG$0*,G>D$h%1)+5(%4BD3 S $0*.M*,r%1BD3aBD*>D$&%`8DE7$&>D%`8)+BD3XFG)+*-,431$03_5Kmn$r'b.+'0E;,1@Y>D$5Kmv.M5;A=)
L
34E;,4TDFG$`$0,Z5.G*@&'&$&%/%4E;,1@`>D$c5.8D31@&'&)+*,43/.ME;*-,1$CP i9$0,4,1$`%4E;FcBD5.M,4E7)+**mn$&%1,L8.+%Z31$08D31@&%1$0*-,/.M,4E S $_>D$`'&)+*>?E;,4E7)+*%
É
31@&$05;57$&%bP]#$&%('&)+*>?E;,4E7)+*%2%1)+*-,98D34E7%/$&%9$0*h'&)+F_8D,1$68.M3^5Kmv.M8D8D5;E7'b.M,4E7)+*Y>m BD*R>D@08D5.+'&$0FG$0*-, S $034,4E7'b.M5%1BD3^BD*h>D$&%
8DE7$&>D%bP
É ÆÉ
OL-
#$&%'&)+*,43/.ME;*-,1$&%*mn@0,/.M*-,8D5;B%r%4:-FG@0,434E7W-B$&%blk5.%4,/.M\DE;5;E;,1@YFGN0FG$f>D$R5Kmn@&>?Es'&$e$&%4,r31$0F_E7%1$Y$0* 'b.MB%1$CP k*
$qp$0,blD57$Z8DT@0*)+FG<0*$c>D$V31$08
)+34,$0,H>D$c'&)+F_8
$0*%/.M,4E7)+*>D$&%28)+B%1%1@&$&%H>.M*%257$&%H8DE7$&>D%>D$g5.`%4,434B'0,4BD31$c*mn$&%4,
8D5;B%68D31@&%1$0*-,bP¡.M3g'&)+*%1@&W-B$0*,blE;5t$&%4,6*@&'&$&%1%/.ME;31$`>D$c31$0*>?31$`5.'&)+BD8 57$ q34E;ACE7>D$ X$0, qFG)+\DE;57$ `>.M*%Z%1)+*
$0*%1$0Fa\D57$CP# .G%4E;,4B.M,4E7)+*f*@qJO.+%4,1$c) f'&$034,/.ME;*%6>D$&%H8DE7$&>D%6%bmn$0*?Jd)+*'&$0*-,8D5;B%6>.M*%H57$a%1)+5
W-B$g57$&%L.MBD,431$&%6$&%4,
j 8D31)C%1'034E;31$CPi9$X'b.+%6$0*DA=$0*>?31$03/.ME;,V>D$&%Z'&)+*,43/.ME;*-,1$&%g8D5;B%E;F_8)+34,/.M*,1$&%§l8
@0*.M5;E7%/.M*-,1$&% S )+E;31$X>D$&%1,434B'0,434E7'&$&%
8)+BD325Kmn@&>?Es'&$CP I5JO.MBD,H>D)+*'c'&)+*'&$ S )+E;3BD*$ZJO)+*>.M,4E7)+*
V'&)+*,4E;*-B$a%1)+B%H5Kmn@&>?Es'&$CP
£s*Y>D$g31$0*>?31$g5._'&)+*%1,434B'0,4E7)+*Y31@&$05;57$0FG$0*,Z%1)+5;E7>.ME;31$ClDE;5$&%4,E;F_8
)+34,/.M*-,>mn$0*'b.+%4,431$035.`'&)+BD8 57$c.MBe%/)+5KP
@05.+%4,4E7W-B$Cl5;E;*@b.ME;31$Cl$0,VE7%1)+,431)+8$r>?BD3/.M*-,a5.e%4E;FcBD5.M,4E7)+*Pki9$05;57$ '0E9.YFG)+*,431@WBmn$0*z5Kmv.M\%1$0*'&$r>D$r8D31@&'&)+*
,43/.ME;*-,1$Cl5.`%4,434B'0,4BD31$c,4E7$0*,bP
•
#% # % +!*
! # " ! !*,
Ë
!
"%
* Ë
É
É
" "
§
L
- !
#$&%6'b.M3/.+'0,1@034E7%4,4E7W-B$&%L>D$a'&$0,L$&%1'b.M5;E7$036)+*,Z@0,1@gJO)+BD34*DE7$&%8.M3L5.XJK.+'0BD5;,1@c>mv.M31'1TDE;,1$&'0,4BD31$_>D$a¥2.M34E9xdw`mv.MFr.M,1)
xOCC ~4~qPC#umn)+B S 3/.MA=$ClC8D31@&%1$0*-,1@ j 5. ◦ JO)+E;31$9E;*,1$034*.M,4E7)+*.M57$L>D $ Z@031)+*$($0*rCC lC$&%4,FG)+*,1@ j %1$&'($0,u.M34FG@
É
. S $&'L>D$&%9' \D57$&%^$0*h.+'0E7$03bP]i9$0B?[ '0E40 8$034FG$0,4,1$0*,(>mn)+\D,1$0*DE;3(BD*$H8D31@&'&)+*-,43/.ME;*,1$V.s*>mv.M,4,1$0E;*>?31$65Kmn@&W-BDE;5;E;\D31$
>D$L5.X%4,434B'0,4BD31$Z$0*5Kmv.M\%1$0*'&$Z>D$LFcBD32>D$Z%1)+BD,1<0*$0FG$0*,bPi9$0,2)+B S 3/.MA=$L'&)+*-,434E;\DB$ j FG)+*,431$03(5.a31@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*
>D$X'&$034,/.ME;*%68D31)+\D57<0FG$&%6'034E;,4E7W-B$&%ZWBDE'&)+*'&$034*$0*,g5Kmn$0F_8D57)+Et>D$c5.G8DE7$03431$`>.M*%5Kmv.M31'/TDE;,1$&'0,4BD31$_'&)+*,1$0F_8)
3/.ME;*$CP
É
•
,
#
#
.e57)+E2>D$'&)+F_8)+34,1$0FG$0*, j 5Km E;*,1$03|JK.+'&$R$0*,431$57$&%XFr.M31'1T$&%_$&%1,a5.e57)+E9'&)+T@&%1E S $y£i i
y P#
$'&)]$ É
'0E7$0*-,Z>D$cJd31)+,4,1$0FG$0*,V$0*,431$X57$&%6\D57)]'&%6$&%1,6>D$`?P r$0,65.'&)+T@&%4E7)+*$&%4,LFr.M,1@034E.M5;E7%/@&$`8.M3L5.r8D31@&%1$0*'&$`>m BD*$
É
JO$0BDE;5;57$V>D$Z8D57)+Fc\$0,H>m BD*YFG)+34,4E7$03 j 5Km E;*-,1$03|JO.+'&$CP
wZ$0B?[R' \D57$&% q8.+%1%4EJO% Z$0*e.+'0E7$03H8.+%/%1$0*,H8.M35Kmn$q[],431N0F_E;,1@V>D$&%HFr.M31'1T$&%`xd%1'1T@0Fr.e{6sACBD31$ PvUC=~qP
L*Y' \D57$ &.+'0,4EJ g$0*e.+'0E7$03H8.+%1%1$Z8.M325Kmn$0*%/$0Fc\D57$c>D$&%'&$0*,431$&%>D$VAC3/. S E;,1@V>D$&%2Fr.M31'1T$&%Xxd%1'1T@0Fr.asACBD31$
PvUC=~8$034FG$0,4,/.M*,H>mn)+\D,1$0*DE;3(BD*$68D31@&'&)+*,43/.ME;*,1$V*@&'&$&%1%/.ME;31$6$0,(%1B r%/.M*,1$68)+BD39%4,/.M\DE;5;E7%/$03^5.X%4,434B'0,4BD31$Z$0*
.+%1%1BD3/.M*,uBD*$(8D31$&%1%1E7)+*G>D$H'&)+*,/.+'0,$0*-,431$H>D$0B?[_Fr.M31'1T$&%^'&)+*%1@&'0BD,4E S $&%bP-i9)+F_FG$28)+BD3k5.Z'&)+BD8 57$ClC57$2' \D57$
]'1T@0Fr.e{G?FG)]>D@05;E7%/.M,4E7)+*e>D$g5. ]'/T@0Fr.rR?FG)]>D@05;E7%/.M,4E7)+*e>D$V5.
8D31@&'&)+*,43/.ME;*,1$XE;*DE;,4E.M57$ 8D31@&'&)+*,43/.ME;*-,1$XBD,4E;5;E7%1@&$
! " PvUC%$hi
\D57$c>D$g8D31@&'&)+*,43/.ME;*-,1$a>.M*%25Kmn$&%/'b.M5;E7$03
É & É
OL-
! #" PvU?{ $
$08D31@&%/$0*,/.M,4E7)+*f>?Bf' \D57$V>D$Z8D31@&'&)+*,43/.ME;*-,1$X$0*-,431$V>D$0B?[RFr.M31'1T$&%L>D$g5Kmn$&%1'b.M5;E7$03
•
#%&
&#& ,
*
,
*
#
.`Jd)+31'&$ 8.`@0,1@V>D@qs*DE7$g8.M3w`mn£LFr.M,1)exdw`mv.MFr.M,1)exOCC 4~ ~(,1$05;57$VW-B$_
x Pv?Pv=~
m.g 1
Fp = min ; A.Rc
sinα 3
£ S &$ 'Z57$&%2*)+,/.M,4E7)+*%6%4BDE S .M*-,1$&%V
?8$0*,1$V>D$g5Kmn$&%/'b.M5;E7$03blDF DFr.+%1%1$g>D$Z5Kmn$&%/'b.M5;E7$03axOU?lv`,1)+*D*$&%~ql
α = 17
.+'&'&@057@03/.M,4E7)+*f>D$g5.X8$&%/.M*,1$0BD3bl
g = 9.81m.s−2
1
% D
B 3|JO.+'&$Z,1)+,/.M57$V>D$c'&)+*,/.+'0,L$0*-,431$g57$&%2Fr.M31'/T$&%bl
A = 0.06m2
?31@&%4E7%1,/.M*'&$ j 5.`'&)+F_8D31$&%1%4E7)+*eFG)b:=$0*D*$c>D$V5.X8DE7$03431$CP
Rc = 10M P a
# ._Jd)+31'&$a>D$V8D31@&'&)+*-,43/.ME;*,1$_$&%4,6>D)+*'c@0A.M57$ j
Fp = 107
& aP u5;57$a$&%4,,43/.M*%4F_E7%1$aAC3 '&$a.MBf' \D57$X>.M*%L5.
>?E;31$&'0,4E7)+*h>D$&%'&$0*-,431$&%9>D$HAC3/. S E;,1@L>D$&%^>D$0B?[GFr.M31'1T$&%(.+>M4.+'&$0*-,1$&%bP-#
$' \D57$H*$,43/.M*%4FG$0,8.+%^>D$HFG)+FG$0*-,bP
•
#%&
#%+ #
¡ .M3>D@qs*DE;,4E7)+*l
t )Y>][h$&%1,25Kmv.M5;57)+*DA=$0FG$0*,Z>?Be' \D57$CP
Fp = k.dx
#
.G>D@qJd)+34Fr.M,4E7)+* $&%4,2,1$05;57$VW-B$_ lD)R[R$&%4,25.`>?E7%4,/.M*'&$V$0*-,431$c>D$0B?[R'&$0*,431$&%6>D$ZAC3/. S E;,1@CP
= dx
QL*e$0*Y>D@&>?BDE;,LWB$g5.X3/.ME7>D$0BD3L$&%4,>D@qs*DE7$g8.M3c
x
F P
•
, #%&
%"
#+!$
*!$# !$ !*
£ 5.as*e>?BY'b.M57'0BD5Kl5.`%1,434B'0,4BD31$c.M,4,1$0E;*,6%/.X8
)C%1E;,4E7)+*e>mn@&WBDE;5;E;\D31$x S )+E;3'1T.M8DE;,431$XU=~qP
É \Ê É
" "
§
L
- !
y.M31'1T$g*-BDFG@031)e{
])-'057$
! #" PvUC%$
@08.M34,4E;,4E7)+*e>D$&%L$qp)+34,1%>.M*%257$&%2Fr.M31'1T$&%6>D$Z5Kmn$&%1'b.M5;E7$03
#$&%c$qp)+34,1%g>.M*%g57$&%VFr.M31'1T$&%c%/)+*,g,1)+B%V>?BFGN0FG$_)+31>?31$_>D$`AC3/.M*>D$0BD3bPti9$`31@&%4BD5;,/.M, S E7$0*-,V>?BJO.ME;,VW-B$
5.c8D31@&'&)+*,43/.ME;*-,1$c$&%4,9E;F_8
)+34,/.M*-,1$ClD$q[?'&$08D,1@&$Z5.cFr.M31'1T$Z*-BDFG@031)D{gWBDE$&%4,(5.c8D5;B%2'1T.M34A=@&$Gxd$0*'b.+%4,431$0FG$0*-,
>.M*%257$c%1)-'057$§~qP
•
# +
& + &% #& ,,
* ,
*
*
#
.8D34E7%1$e$0* '&)+F_8D,1$e>m BD*$f8D31@&'&)+*,43/.ME;*-,1$f,431)+8 JO.ME;\D57$ x & g~qlk*$Y8$034FG$0,r8.+%>mv.+%1%4BD31$03BD*
É
@&W-BDE;5;E;\D31$V>D$g5.`%4,434B'0,4BD31$CP
i9$05;57$ '0E %1$Z34BDE;*$rx S )+E;3HsACBD31$ FPvUCp =U =
~qP 60
! #" PvUCU%$
u%1'b.M5;E7$0334BDE;*@g8.M3>D@qJK.MBD,>D$Z8D31@&'&)+*,43/.ME;*-,1$
É \ÊIʲÉ
OL-
•
# +
& + &% "! #& " (
y@&'b.M*DE7WB$0FG$0*-,bl5Kmn$&%1'b.M5;E7$036$&%4,H%4,/.M\D57$g%1)+B%H8
)+E7>D%28D31)+8D31$CP
¡)+BD3Z,1$&%4,1$036%._,1$0*B$aJK.+'&$ j BD*$a'/T.M34A=$Cl)+*..|)+BD,1@aBD*$aFr.+%1%1$c>D$ & A%4BD36'1T.+W-B$XFr.M31'1T$RxsACBD31$
PvU -~qP
! #" PvU $
u%/'b.M5;E7$03L. S &$ 'cBD*$g'1T.M34A=$c>D$ & A_8.M3HFr.M31'/T$
É
£ 5.as*e>?BY'b.M57'0BD5Kl5Kmn$&%/'b.M5;E7$03$&%4,2,1)+B+4)+BD31%%4,/.M\D57$CPD£LB >D$05 j >D$V'&$0,4,1$V'/T.M34A=$Cl5Kmn$&%1'b.M5;E7$03L%1$Z34BDE;*$CP
É \Ê ÀÉ
" " Lb L
L
E;*DE;,4E.M57$CPQL*f)+\D,4E7$0*,6.ME;*%1EBD*$g31$08D31@&%1$0*,/.M,4E7)+*8D5;B%28D31@&'0E7%1$c>D$g5Kmv.+'0,4E7)+*e>?Be' \D57$CP
#
.6FG)]>D@05;E7%/.M,4E7)+*G8.M3u@057@0FG$0*-,1%ks*DE7%t*mv.68.+%k8$034F_E7%k>mn)+\D,1$0*DE;3>D$&%k31@&%1BD5;,/.M,1%u%4BD3t5Kmn$&%1'b.M5;E7$03$0*-,4E7$03 j 'b.MB%1$
*)+,/.MF_FG$0*-,6>D$Z8D31)+\D57<0FG$&%L>D$V'&)+* S $034A=$0*'&$X$0,H>D$g,1$0F_8%H>D$V'b.M57'0BD5.+%1%1$0¢gE;F_8)+34,/.M*,Xx|{b j {bXT$0BD31$&%~qP
t
+
# $&%a%4E;FcBD5.M,4E7)+*%a8D31@&%1$0*-,1@&$&%a>.M*%g57$&%a'b.+%V>mn)+B S 3/.MA=$&% j AC3/.M*>*)+Fc\D31$r>D$G\D57)-'&%a$0,V8D31@&'&)+*,43/.ME;*-,1%X)+*-,
FG)+*-,431@cW-B$_
#um E;*>D@0,1$034F_E;*.M,4E7)+*"57)]'b.M57$e$&%4,.+%1%1)]'0E7@&$e.MB?[*)+Fc\D31$&%>D$Y'&)+*,/.+'0,1%8)+*'0,4B$057%r>D@qs*DE7%1%/.M*-,BD*$Y5;E.ME7%1)+*
8D5.M*$CPt?.M*%VJd31)+,4,1$0FG$0*,bl BD*$G5;E.ME7%1)+*z8D5.M*$>D)7,XN0,431$r>D@qs*DE7$r8.M3c,431)+E7%X'&)+*,/.+'0,1%X8
)+*'0,4B$057%a8)+BD3cN0,431$
E7%1)C%1,/.M,4E7WB$CPwg.M*%257$g'b.+%L. S $&'gJd31)+,4,1$0FG$0*,bl57$Z8D31)+\D57<0FG$c$&%4,H>D@ j %4,/.M,4E7W-B$0FG$0*,E;*>D@0,1$034F_E;*@CP
wg.M*%k57$H'/T.M8DE;,431$LU?lC)+*.LJK.ME;,u57$2'/T)+E[_>D$H8D31$0*>?31$HWB.M,431$H*)-$0B>D%u>D$'&)+*,/.+'0,1%u8.M3^%4BD3|JO.+'&$H8
)+BD3k5.+W-B$05;57$
)+*'1T$031'1T$a5Kmn$q[?E7%4,1$0*'&$c)+Bf*)+*e>D$c'&)+*-,/.+'0,1%bPQL*eFG)+*,431$Cl
>.M*%L'&$0,4,1$c8.M34,4E7$Cl5Km E;* B$0*'&$X>?Be*)+Fc\D31$X>D$
*)]$0B>D%c>D$_'&)+*-,/.+'0,1%c8.M3c>D@0,1$&'0,4E7)+* %4BD3g5.h,1$0*-B$GFG@&'b.M*DE7W-B$r$0,g5.R%1,/.M\DE;5;E;,1@r>D$`5.R%4,434B'0,4BD31$CP wg.M*%VBD*
'&)+*-,/.+'0,V>D$a,I:-8$cJO.+'&$ JK.+'&$Cl
,431)+E7%Z*)-$0B>D%Z>D$`'&)+*,/.+'0,1%V%1B r%1$0*,Z8)+BD3LFr.ME;*-,1$0*DE;3V57$a'&)+*-,/.+'0,c%4,/.M\D57$CPQL*
'/T)+E7%4E;,u>D)+*'2>.M*%u'&$0,4,1$(8.M34,4E7$2>D$(%4E;FcBD57$03^>D$0B?[X$q[D$0F_8D57$&%. S $&'2,431)+E7%t*)]$0B>D%k>D$2'&)+*,/.+'0,1%u8.M3u>D@0,1$&'0,4E7)+*P
QL*Y8D31@&%/$0*,1$V$0*%4BDE;,1$VBD*YFcBD3>D)+*-,H5.`31@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*e*BDFG@034E7W-B$c$&%4,231@b.M5;E7%1@&$c%4BDE S .M*-,>D$0B?[RFG@0,4T)->D$&%c
É 31@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*f*BDFG@034E7W-B$c>?E;31$&'0,1$V>D$Z5.G%4,434B'0,4BD31$Cl
É 31@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*f*BDFG@034E7W-B$c$0*Y%4BDE S .M*,BD*Y8D31)-'&@&>D@Z31@b.M5;E7%1,1$V>D$V'&)+*%4,434B'0,4E7)+*P
QL* S $0343/.h%4BD3ZBD*$_>D$&%1'&$0*-,1$_>D$_'1T.M34A=$&%aWB$`%4BDE S .M*,g57$X8D31)]'&@&>D@_>D$_'&)+*%4,434B'0,4E7)+*o'1T)+E7%1EKl5.31@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*
*-BDFG@034E7WB$a>D)+*D*$V>D$&%231@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%L>?Ep@031$0*-,1%bP
QL*aFG)+*,431$9$0*?s*aW-B$u57$&%31@&%1BD5;,/.M,1%
*-BDFG@034E7WB$&%t$0*c,1$034FG$&%>D$u31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%,/.M*DA=$0*-,4E7$05;57$&%$0, *)+34Fr.M57$&%bl+.MBV*DE É
S $b.MBG>D$&%u@057@0FG$0*-,1%>D$(31@&>?B'0,4E7)+*fxd%1BD3|JO.+'&$2>D$2'&)+*-,/.+'0,~ql=%1)+*,^@&WBDE S .M57$0*,1%u>.M*%u57$&%k'b.+%u>D$(*)+* AC5;E7%1%1$0FG$0*-, É
$0,HAC5;E7%/%1$0FG$0*,6$0*,431$V57$&%FG@0,4T)->D$&%6>D$g31@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+* 0'&)+BD8D57@&$ c$0, 0'05.+%1%4E7W-B$ ZDi9w +Pi9$08$0*>.M*,bl57$&% S .
57$0BD31%H>D$&%31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%bl.MBY*DE S $b.MBf>D$g'1T.+W-B$V*)]$0B>l?8
$0B S $0*-,LN0,431$V>?Ep@031$0*,1$&%L>m BD*$gFG@0,4T)->D$ j 5Kmv.MBD,431$CP
É
^
O u
=
?u
]
u
=Y
t
?.MB%1%1E;*$ .M52xK?.MB%1%4E;*$hxOCC -~4~6)+*,ZFG)+*,431@X5Km E;* B$0*'&$_>?B'&)-$r'0E7$0*-,V>D$VJd31)+,4,1$0FG$0*,V%4BD365.r,1$0*B$ j
5Kmn@&W-BDE;5;E;\D31$Z>m BD*$g%4,434B'0,4BD31$_xd> FG$§~qPQL*h.X'1T)+E7%1E>D$68D31@&%1$0*-,1$0325Km E;* B$0*'&$g>?B*)+Fa\D31$g>D$6*)-$0B>D%(%4BD3(5.
%4,/.M\DE;5;E;,1@c>?Be'&)+*,/.+'0,bP#
.`%4BD3|JK.+'&$V>D$g'&)+*,/.+'0,6$&%4,2E7'0E
>D@qs*DE7$g8.M3H,431)+E7%H*)-$0B>D%bP
•
"!$" "#%+
#$FG)]>D<057$'&)+*'&$034*$5. F_E7%1$$0* 8D5.+'&$>m BD* \D57)-'%4BD3RBD* .MBD,431$
xsACBD31$ PvU ~qP6i9$&%R>D$0B?[ \D57)]'&%R*$
É \ÊbË É
OL-
%1)+*-,%1)+BDF_E7% j .MB'0BD*$a%1)+5;5;E7'0E;,/.M,4E7)+*P
#
._57)+E
>m E;*,1$03/.+'0,4E7)+*$&%4,H>D$Z, :]8$ZJ31)+,4,1$0FG$0*-,L%1$&'g>D$Xi9)+BD57)+Fc\f%1,/.M*>.M31>l. S $&'VBD*e'&)-$r'0E7$0*-,L>D$6Jd31)+,4,1$
FG$0*-,>D$c?P P
É
#$LFG)]>D<057$L.M,4,1$0E;*,(3/.M8DE7>D$0FG$0*-,(%.g8)C%4E;,4E7)+*>mn@&W-BDE;5;E;\D31$`xsACBD31$ PvU ~qP]#$L,1$034FG$ Fr.MAa>D$L5.ZsACBD31$ PvU
! " PvU $
I* B $0*'&$V>?BR*)+Fa\D31$c>D$g*)]$0B>D%H>D$V'&)+*-,/.+'0,a?FG)]>D<057$V>D$g'&)+*,/.+'0,L\D57)-' D\ 57)]'
31$08D31@&%1$0*-,1$X57$c>D@08D5.+'&$0FG$0*,ZFG)§:=$0*>D$&%\D57)-'&%6>.M*%L57$&%,431)+E7%6>?E;31$&'0,4E7)+*%Z>D$V5Kmn$&%48.+'&$CP
w6BD3/.M*,Z5.G%4E;FaBD5.
,4E7)+*l.MB'0BD*eAC5;E7%1%1$0FG$0*,6$0*,431$g57$&%H\D57)-'&%2*$c%bmn$&%4,28D31)]>?BDE;,bP
É
•
%
, !% &!
*
,
*
,
*
Q *"$q[D.MF_E;*$Fr.ME;*-,1$0*.M*,R5Km E;* B$0*'&$>D$f5.8D34E7%1$$0*"'&)+F_8D,1$>D$&%,431)+E7%*)-$0B>D%h%4BD35.z'&)+BD8 57$f8D31@
L
%1$0*-,1@&$V>.M*%(5.X8.M34,4E7$g8D31@&'&@&>D$0*-,1$CP#$&%28.M3/.MFG<0,431$&%FG@&'b.M*DE7WB$&%%1)+*,HE7>D$0*-,4E7WB$&% j '&$0B?[h>?BY'/T.M8DE;,431$aU?P
É
#$gJO.ME;,H>D$g8D31$0*>?31$VBD*$V%4,434B'0,4BD31$g8D31@&'&)+*-,43/.ME;*,1$a8
$034FG$0,>D$ S @034Es$03%4Eu
É Fr.M5;AC31@_BD*o*)+Fc\D31$r>D$`*)]$0B>D%c>D$_'&)+*-,/.+'0,c31@&>?BDE;,1% j ,431)+E7%V8.M3V@057@0FG$0*,1%X>D$_31@&>?B'0,4E7)+*l5.Y%4,434B'0,4BD31$
31$&%4,1$g%1,/.M\D57$Cl
É Fr.M5;AC31@H>D$&%uAC5;E7%1%1$0FG$0*,1%^$0*,431$57$&%t\D57)-'&%bl+5.g8D31@&%1$0*'&$H>D$(5.68D31@&'&)+*,43/.ME;*-,1$^|)+B$2%1)+*_3 57$H8
)+BD3kFr.ME;*-,1$0*DE;3
5.`%4,434B'0,4BD31$a%4,/.M\D57$CP
#
.`sACBD31$ PvU `FG)+*,431$aWB$Z5.`%1,434B'0,4BD31$a.M,4,1$0E;*,L%/.X8
)C%1E;,4E7)+*e>mn@&WBDE;5;E;\D31$ j 5.as*e>?BY'b.M57'0BD5KP
É \Ê]¨ É
" " Lb L
L
I
=
u
^
" C
C
É
¡)+BD3^E;5;5;B%1,431$03^>D$0B?[_8D31)-'&@&>D@&%^>D$'&)+*%4,434B'0,4E7)+*l-57$H'b.+%^>m BD*rFcBD39$&%4,'&)+*%4E7>D@031@CPDi9$05;BDE '0E$&%1,'&)+F_8
)C%/@>D$
h\D57)]'&%6$0,V.r8
)+BD3Z8.M34,4E7'0BD5.M34E;,1@_>m E;*-,1@0AC31$03VBD*f5;E;*-,1$b.MB>D$GG8DE7$03431$&%g>D$a,/.ME;5;57$`8$034FG$0,4,/.M*,g5.'031@b.M,4E7)+*
>m BD*$V)+B S $034,4BD31$CP
•
"# # %
wZ$0\D31$b.MB?[ltFG$0Fc\D31$Y>D$h5Kmn£6%1%1)]'0E.M,4E7)+*>D$&%ri9)+F_8.MAC*)+*%r¡t.+%1%/.M*,1% .ME;5;57$0BD31%r>D$8DE7$03431$Cl.f8D31)+8)C%1@R>D$
,43/. S .ME;5;57$036%4BD325.`%4,1@031@&)+,1)+F_E7$c>D$&%H8DE7$03431$&%>D$g,/.ME;5;57$V>D$&%H5;E;*,1$b.MB?[P
w`m BD*8)+E;*,c>D$ S B$`*BDFG@034E7W-B$Cl5.57)+Eu>D$r'&)+F_8
)+34,1$0FG$0*-, j 5Km E;*,1$03|JK.+'&$r$0*-,431$_57$&%g\D57)]'&%V>?BFcBD3X$&%4,V>D$
,I:-8$6J31)+,4,1$0FG$0*-,L%1$&'g>D$Xi9)+BD57)+Fc\f%1,/.M*>.M31>P#$V'&)]$ r'0E7$0*,6>D$ZJ31)+,4,1$0FG$0*-,L$&%4,28D34E7% j ?P ?P
É \Ê ÀÉ
OL-
#
.31@08.M34,4E;,4E7)+* >D$&%$qp)+34,1%$&%1,%4:]FG@0,434E7WB$CP BDFG@034E7W-B$0FG$0*,bl95.o>D@0,1$&'0,4E7)+*"$&%1,.+'0,4E S @&$f%/@&WB$0*-,4E7$05;57$
FG$0*-,%4BDE S .M*,HBD*Y8D31)]'&@&>D@g31@b.M5;E7%4,1$xd$q[?$0F_8D57$V>?BeFr.&)+*eWBDE8)C%1$g%1$&%H\D57)-'&%257$&%HBD*%.M8D31<&%257$&%L.MBD,431$&%q~qP
É
¡ )+BD3`5.RF_E7%1$$0*z8D5.+'&$>D$&%c\D57)]'&%X%/.M*%c8D31)]'&@&>D@>D$r'&)+*%4,434B'0,4E7)+*lt)+*oBD,4E;5;E7%/$r5.YFG@0,4T)->D$'05.+%1%4E7W-B$CP
•
ÉÉ
LBDFG@034E7WB$0FG$0*-,bl5.V>D@0,1$&'0,4E7)+*>D$&%'&)+*-,/.+'0,1%^$&%1,u31@b.M5;E7%1@&$ 0>?E;31$&'0,1$0FG$0*-,L'Cmn$&%1, j >?E;31$W-B$(5Kmn$0*%1$0Fc\D57$6>D$&%
'&)+*-,/.+'0,1%L$&%4,H>D@0,1$&'0,1@c>D<&%257$g8D31$0F_E7$03H8.+%H>D$V,1$0F_8%H8)+BD325.X,1)+,/.M5;E;,1@c>D$Z5._%4,434B'0,4BD31$CP
#
.G%4,434B'0,4BD31$c.M,4,1$0E;*,L3/.M8DE7>D$0FG$0*,L5._%4,/.M\DE;5;E;,1@rxsACBD31$ PvUC}=~qP
É \Ê É
" " Lb L
L
! #" PvUC}%$h-E;FcBD5.M,4E7)+*>?BYFcBD3L%/.M*%28D31)]'&@&>D@V>D$g'&)+*%4,434B'0,4E7)+*
i9$08$0*>.M*,bl 5.h31@08.M34,4E;,4E7)+*z>D$&%a$qp)+34,1%c*mn$&%4,V8.+%V%1:-FG@0,434E7W-B$CPi9$0,4,1$G>?E7%18.M34E;,1@r$0*,431$r57$&%V31@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%a>D$&%
>D$0B?[8D31)-'&@&>D@&%(8$0BD,2N0,431$Z5;E7@&$ j BD*R8D31)+\D57<0FG$g>m T-:-8$031%4,/.M,4E7'0E;,1@CP k*R$qp$0,bl]5.X31@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+* 0>?E;31$&'0,1$ Z>m BD*$
%4,434B'0,4BD31$L8$0BD,$0*DA=$0*>?31$032>D$&%u8D31)+\D57<0FG$&%(>m T:]8
$031%1,/.M,4E7'0E;,1@8D5;B%^E;F_8
)+34,/.M*-,1%(WB$L>.M*%u57$'b.+%9)r5.VF_E7%1$
$0*8D5.+'&$Z>D$5.a>D@0,1$&'0,4E7)+*R>D$&%9'&)+*-,/.+'0,1%2$&%4,931@b.M5;E7%1@&$Z%1@&WB$0*-,4E7$05;57$0FG$0*,H>m BD*h\D57)]' j 5Kmv.MBD,431$Xx S )+E;32'/T.M8DE;,431$
-~qP
k*`%4BDE S .M*, BD*$^>D$&%1'&$0*-,1$^>D$^'1T.M34A=$2.MBc*DE S $b.MB`>m BD*$^5;E;AC*$ S $034,4E7'b.M57$^8
)C%1E;,4E7)+*D*@&$9.MB`'&$0*,431$9>?Ba' ,1@9>?31)+E;,
>?BaFcBD3blb57$AC3/.M8DT$ P H8D31@&%1$0*,1$9'05.ME;31$0FG$0*,5Kmn$ r'b.+'0E;,1@*-BDFG@034E7WB$9>D$u5.HF_E7%1$u$0*a8D5.+'&$ q8D31)+AC31$&%1%4E S $ ^>D$
5.a>D@0,1$&'0,4E7)+*R>D$&%9'&)+*-,/.+'0,1%28D5;BD, ,(WB$L5.VF_E7%/$L$0*h8D5.+'&$ 0>?E;31$&'0, +PD#
.c>D$&%/'&$0*,1$Z>D$Z'1T.M34A=$Z$&%4,(WB.+%4E;FG$0*-,
5;E;*@b.ME;31$>.M*%X57$r'b.+%X>D$r5.YF_E7%1$$0*z8D5.+'&$r8D31)+AC31$&%/%4E S $.M57)+31%XW-B$r8)+BD3c5Kmv.MBD,431$'b.+%bl 5.R31@08.M34,4E;,4E7)+*>D$&%
'/T.M34A=$&%6$&%1,'1T.+)+,4E7W-B$hP 6)+,1)+*%W-B$V57$&% S .M57$0BD31%6>D$&%H31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%_x S )+E;3HsACBD31$ P =~)+\D,1$0*B$&% j 5.`s*>?B
'b.M57'0BD5
%/)+*,W-B.+%4E;FG$0*,E7>D$0*,4E7W-B$&%bP
É \Ê ÆÉ
OL-
6000
Réaction au bloc (N)
4000
2000
0
0 1 2 3 4
Hauteur du mur (m)
! " P $
i9)+F_8.M3/.ME7%1)+* >D$5.>D$&%1'&$0*,1$R>D$R'/T.M34A=$&%G$0*,431$h57$&%`FaBD31%G'b.M57'0BD57@&% 0 >?E;31$&'0,1$0FG$0*-,Y$0,G$0*
%4BDE S .M*,BD*R8D31)-'&@&>D@g31@b.M5;E7%1,1$V>D$V'&)+*%4,434B'0,4E7)+*
#$&%%4E;FcBD5.M,4E7)+*%6%1)+*,31@b.M5;E7%1@&$&%28)+BD3>D$&%H'b.+%2*)+* AC5;E7%1%.M*,L$0,AC5;E7%1%/.M*,bP
É \Ê É
" " Lb L
L
•
"!$" "#%+ ,,
*"
,
* &# , #% +!
QL*o'&)+*%1E7>D<031$G57$G'0BD\$G>?Bo'/T.M8DE;,431$Y8)C%1@G%1BD3gBD*o8.M3/.M5;57@057@08DE;8<&>D$$0,V57$&%V*)+,/.M,4E7)+*%cBD,4E;5;E7%1@&$&%X%1)+*-,V57$&%
FGN0FG$&%bP
#$c'0BD\
$g$&%4,H'&)+*%1E7>D@031@V31$&%4,/.M*-,H,1)+B+|)+BD31%L$0*Y'&)+*,/.+'0,bP
.
[
A4 A3
\
zo [
A1 A2
Q yo
xo
! #" P { $
@&)+FG@0,434E7$a>?BY'0BD\
$
#$&%H8.M3/.MFG<0,431$&%*-BDFG@034E7WB$&%6'1T)+E7%4E7%>.M*%H57$g'1T.M8DE;,431$ r%1)+*-,V
É i9)]$ r'0E7$0*,6>D$ZJ31)+,4,1$0FG$0*-,a]J ?P l
É .MBD,1$0BD3>?Be%1)+5;E7>D$_. {0FYl
É #
.M34A=$0BD36>?Be%1)+5;E7>D$_?\ {0FYl
É y.+%1%1$g>?BY%1)+5;E7>D$r?F {bCC & AP
É i9)])+31>D)+*D*@&$&%L>D$&%H*)-$0B>D%V
É
A1 = (0, 0, −1) A2 = (1, 0, −1) A3 = (1, 1, −1) A4 = (0, 1, −1)
¡t.+%>D$g,1$0F_8%c
É
>.M*%257$g'b.+%*)+* AC5;E7%1%/.M*,bl
>.M*%257$g'b.+%AC5;E7%1%/.M*,bl
h = 10−3
%§l
−4 %§l
É i9)+*>?E;,4E7)+*%_E;*DE;,4E.M57$&%R h = 10
AC5;E7%1%.M*,~qP N1 = N2 = N3 = N4 = − m∗g 4
u = v = 0m.s−1
$0,
Ω = 0rad.s−1
xd'b.+%
#
.6A=@&)+FG@0,434E7$>?B`'0BD\$2$&%4,k%4:]FG@0,434E7WB$H.MBD,1)+BD3u>D$2%/)+*_.[D$(>D$(31)+,/.M,4E7)+*P=#$(,1)+31%1$0BD3u>D$&%k$qp)+34,1%k$q[?,1@034E7$0BD31%
É
$&%4,6,1)+B+4)+BD31%Z.M8D8D5;E7W-B@&$G.MB'&$0*,431$_>D$aAC3/. S E;,1@X>?B%1)+5;E7>D$CP
)+B%Z57$&%631@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%g>.M*%657$&%Z'b.+%bl*)+* AC5;E7%1%/.M*-,
$0,2AC5;E7%1%.M*,bl%/)+*,28D31@&%1$0*-,1@&%6.MBR\)+BD,>D$_{b`8.+%H>D$Z,1$0F_8%§P
•
"!$#%&')(
!*!*++,
£ 4, E;,431$Y>mn$q[D$0F_8D57$Cl)+* .M8D8D5;E7W-B$e.MB '&$0*-,431$e>D$RAC3/. S E;,1@f>?B '0BD\
$hBD*$YJd)+31'&$R$q[?,1@034E7$0BD31$
Fx = 1000N
$0,2BD*e'&)+BD8D57$c$q[],1@034E7$0BD3 P
#$&%31@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%9)+\D,1$0*B%^8.M357$H'&)]>D$H>D$H'b.M57'0BD5
y.M,1#
.M\%1)+*,^8D31@&%1$0*,1@&%9>.M*%^57$2,/.M\D57$b.MB P $0,u8 .M3u57$'&)]>D$
Mz = −100N m
>D$g'b.M57'0BD5#y i(}C_>.M*%257$g,/.M\D57$b.MB P ?P
É \Ê & É
OL-
L*DE;,1@&%cx6$ 2,1)+*~
.M57$0BD31%L.MB S .M57$0BD31%.MB S .M57$0BD31%L.MB S .M57$0BD31%.MB
)+,/.M5
*)]$0B>{ *)-$0B> *)-$0B>U *)-$0B>
L@b.+'0,4E7)+*%
u:
[
−201.95 −247.79 −303.18 −247.08 É {bC C
−24.87 24.87 24.87 −24.87
} ?{b
2202.50 2702.50 2702.50 2202.50
" P $hi(.+%(*)+* É AC5;E7%1%/.M*-,bP .M57$0BD31%2>D$&%(31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%%1BD3('/T.+WB$Z*)]$0B>h>?BY'0BD\
$ É FG@0,4T)]>D$ 0'&)+BD8D57@&$
*DE;,1@&%Xx L$ 2,1)+*~
.M57$0BD31%6.MB S .M57$0BD31%6.MB S .M57$0BD31%.MB S .M57$0BD31%6.MB )+,/.M5
*)-$0B>{ *)]$0B> *)]$0B>U *)]$0B>
@b.+'0,4E7)+*%
[
É {bC}?CP;?{b}P C}
−0.024 37.491 −12.171 −1026.185
É
:
−0.012 621.646 −33.319 −597.513
} CC}?Pv}C
0.067 4405.405 499.543 4904.890
" P
$ i(.+%(*)+* AC5;E7%1%/.M*,bP .M57$0BD31%2>D$&%931@b.+'0,4E7)+*%H%1BD39'/T.+WB$Z*)]$0B>h>?Bh'0BD\$
É É FG@0,4T)]>D$ 0'05.+%1%4E7W-B$
gDi9w
QL*Y8$0BD,231$0Fr.M31W-B$03WB$c'&$&%231@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%H%1)+*-,H,431<&%HE;F_8)+34,/.M*,1%8 )+BD35.X8D31@&>?E7'0,4E7)+*f>?BY\.+%1'0BD57$0FG$0*-,bP
•
"!$#% (
!*!* ,
QL*.M8D8D5;E7W-B$aFr.ME;*-,1$0*.M*,bl.MB'&$0*-,431$_>D$aAC3/. S E;,1@_>?B'0BD\$Cl8.M3g$q[D$0F_8D57$`BD*$aJd)+31'&$X$q[],1@034E7$0BD3V>D$
Fx =
$0, P#$g'0BD\$gAC5;E7%1%1$g%1BD3257$g8.M3/.M5;57@057@08DE;8
<&>D$CP
#$&%31@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%9)+\D,1$0*B%^8.M357$H'&)]>D$H>D$H'b.M57'0BD5
y.M,1#
.M\%1)+*,^8D31@&%1$0*,1@&%9>.M*%^57$2,/.M\D57$b.MB P V$0,u8.M3u57$'&)]>D$
10000N F y = −9000N
>D$g'b.M57'0BD5#y i(}C_>.M*%257$g,/.M\D57$b.MB P ?P
É
É
" " Lb L
L
*DE;,1@&%cx6$ 2,1)+*~
.M57$0BD31%6.MB S .M57$0BD31%.MB S .M57$0BD31%L.MB S .M57$0BD31%.MB
)+,/.M5
*)-$0B>{ *)]$0B> *)]$0B>U *)]$0B>
@b.+'0,4E7)+*%
:
[
−707.49 −1141.08 −750.85 −317.26 É CC}? { ?PvP?{
:
[
−52.115 −973.245 −96.092 −1790.508 É CC}? {C{CP Pv} C
E;F_8)+34,/.M*,1$&%a$0*,431$`57$&%Z31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%V>D$&%g>D$0B?[FG@0,4T)->D$&%§P 57)+\.M57$0FG$0*,V5.31@&%4BD5;,/.M*-,1$_A=@0*@03/.M57$G$&%4,gW-B.+%4E
FG$0*-,E7>D$0*-,4E7WB$CP+w`mv.MBD,431$&%k'b.+%,1$&%4,1%)+*,k@0,1@^@0,4B>?E7@&%t$0,*mn)+*,t8.+%FG)+*,431@2>m E;*'&)+T@031$0*'&$2>.M*%57$&%'b.M57'0BD57%bP
#$VFG)->D<057$V$&%1,2FG)+*,431@c%1BD325.asACBD31$ P ?P
A2 A3
A1 A4
F~ext
¢
F~ext '
[
)+B )+B
A1 A4 A2 A3
! #" P %$y)->D<057$g>D$g\.+%/'0BD57$0FG$0*,
É Ê²É
OL-
L*DE;,1@&%cx6$ 2,1)+*~
.M57$0BD31%L.MB S .M57$0BD31%.MB S .M57$0BD31%L.MB S .M57$0BD31%.MB
)+,/.M5
*)]$0B>{ *)-$0B> *)-$0B>U *)-$0B>
L@b.+'0,4E7)+*%
u:
[
−0 −1962.00 −1962.00 −0 É UC}C
0 0 0 0
} ?{b
0 4905.00 4905.00 0
" Pv} $oi(.+%_>D$\.+%1'0BD57$0FG$0*-,bP.M57$0BD31%_>D$&%X31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%G%4BD3`'1T.+W-B$*)]$0B> >?B *)+B S $b.MB8
)+5;:=<&>?31$ É
F @0,4T)]>D$ 0'&)+DB 8D57@&$
G
L*DE;,1@&%cx6$ 2,1)+*~
.M57$0BD31%L.MB S .M57$0BD31%6.MB S .M57$0BD31%.MB S .M57$0BD31%L.MB
)+,/.M5
*)]$0B>{ *)]$0B> *)]$0B>U *)]$0B>
L@b.+'0,4E7)+*%
u:
[
−0 −1943.262 −1980.015 0 É UC}C?CP U?=Pv= C
0
0
0
4858.156
0.326
4950.039
0.341
0
} C ?P;{b}
" P;{b $i(.+%V>D$_\.+%1'0BD57$0FG$0*-,bP
.M57$0BD31%a>D$&%g31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%a%1BD3V'1T.+W-B$_*)-$0B>o>?B*)+B S $b.MBo8)+5;:=<&>?31$ É
FG@0,4T)]>D$ 0'05.+%1%4E7W-B$ gDi9w
+
#
. FG@0,4T)]>D$>D$31@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+* 0'&)+BD8D57@&$ W-B$*)+B%e. S )+*%e>D@ S $057)+8D8
@&$$0,Y$q[?8
)C%/@&$>.M*%h57$'/T.M8DE;,431$
8D31@&%1$0*-,1$0*,H57$&%(FGN0FG$&%H31@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%2WB$65.XFG@0,4T)]>D$g>D$631@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+* 0'05.+%1%4E7W-B$ ZDi9w +l?E;F_8D57@0FG$0*,1@&$a>.M*%
57$a'&)->D$V>D$a'b.M57'0BD5 #y i(}C?P#$&%31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%§l.MBe*DE S $b.MB>D$c'/T.+WB$c*)-$0B>l%1)+*,L8D5;B%L%4,/.M\D57$&%LWB$a'&$05;57$&%
)+\D,1$0*-B$&%a8.M3a5.RFG@0,4T)]>D$>D$r31@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+* 0'05.+%1%4E7W-B$ gDi9w r) z%1$0BD57%a57$&%c@057@0FG$0*-,1%_>D$G31@&>?B'0,4E7)+* >D$&%
$qp)+34,1%2>D$Z'&)+*,/.+'0,H%4BD3(57$68D5.M*R8
$0B S $0*-,HN0,431$Z'&)+*%4E7>D@031@&%2'&)+3431$&'0,1%bPD#
.XFG@0,4T)]>D$Z>D$L31@&%/)+5;BD,4E7)+* 0'&)+BD8D57@&$
._.ME;*%4E
FG)+*,431@c%/)+*Y$ r'b.+'0E;,1@CP
1
#$&%(>?Ep@031$0*,1%($q[D$0F_8D57$&%(,43/.ME;,1@&%9>.M*%('&$L'1T.M8DE;,431$g)+*,98$034F_E7%9>D$ S @034Es$03(5. S .M5;E7>?E;,1@6$0,^5.c31)+\DB%4,1$&%1%1$6>D$
5Kmv.M5;A=)+34E;,4TDFG$a>D$V>D@0,1$&'0,4E7)+*e>D$&%'&)+*-,/.+'0,1%bP
#$&%a%4E;FcBD5.M,4E7)+*%`>?:]*.MF_E7WB$&%a)+*,aFG)+*,431@5Kmn$r'b.+'0E;,1@r>mn@ S .M5;B$03c5Kmn$r'b.+'0E;,1@>D$G5Kmv.M5;A=)+34E;,4TDFG$>D$G>D@0,1$&'
,4E7)+*$0*e3/.ME7%1)+*>D$&%L*)+Fc\D31$0B%1$&%g%4E;,4B.M,4E7)+*%Z>D$a'&)+*,/.+'0,1%V. S $&'X>D$&%LJO.+'&$&%L8$0348
$0*>?E7'0BD5.ME;31$&%Z$0,68.M3/.M5;57<057$&%bP
É
#umn$q[D$0F_8D57$`>D$c5.>D$&%4,434B'0,4E7)+*>D$&%g.+WB$&>?B'&%Z%1)+BDF_E7% j BD*f,431$0Fa\D57$0FG$0*,c>D$a,1$03431$`.GF_E7%Z$0*@ S E7>D$0*'&$X5.
É
*)+* E;*-,1$0348
@0*@0,43/.M,4E7)+*>D$&%2\D57)]'&%H$0*,431$c$0B?[xd'&)+*>?E;,4E7)+*>D$c-E;AC*)+34E;*DE~qP
É
#$&%2%1E;FcBD5.M,4E7)+*%H>.M*%(57$Z'b.+%9*)+* AC5;E7%1%/.M*-,H)+*,2FG)+*,431@Z5Kmn$ r'b.+'0E;,1@c>mn@ S .M5;B$03(5.a,43/.M*%4F_E7%1%4E7)+*R>D$&%2$qp)+34,1%
É ÀÉ
" "
§
QL*
.f'&)+*%4,/.M,1@hWB$57$8D31$0F_E7$03_8D31)-'&@&>D@h>D)+*D*$h>D$&%X31@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%`8D5;B%_%4:]FG@0,434E7WB$&%`$0,XT)+FG)+A=<0*$RWB$57$
%1$&'&)+*>P
QL*.'&)+*'05;BW-B$a5.>?E7%48.M34E;,1@_>D$&%Z31@&%1BD5;,/.M,1%g8
)+B S .ME;,gN0,431$`5;E7@&$ j BD*8D31)+\D57<0FG$_T-:-8$031%4,/.M,4E7W-B$CP
k* $qp$0,blu5.F_E7%1$Y$0* 8D5.+'&$e>?E;31$&'0,1$e>D$&%\D57)]'&%_8
$0BD,$0*DA=$0*>?31$03>D$&%r8D31)+\D57<0FG$&%>m T-:-8$031%4,/.M,4E7'0E;,1@f8D5;B%
E;F_8)+34,/.M*,1%LWB$V>.M*%H5.`F_E7%1$g$0*Y8D5.+'&$V%1B'&'&$&%1%4E S $CP
i9$08$0*>.M*,bl
57$a8D31)-'&@&>D@a31@b.M5;E7%4,1$`$&%4, q*-BDFG@034E7WB$0FG$0*-, _>D@05;E7'b.M, j FG$0,4,431$`$0*8D5.+'&$a>.M*%6BD*$X%4,434B'0,4BD31$
j AC3/.M*>e*)+Fc\D31$a>D$g\D57)-'&%L) Y57$&%'&)+*-,/.+'0,1%L%/)+*,HT)+34E;¢b)+*-,/.MB?[f$0, S $034,4E7'b.MB?[l$0,H8D31@&%1$0*-,1%L%1E;FcBD5;,/.M*@0FG$0*,
%4BD328D5;B%1E7$0BD31%2JK.+'&$&%H>?BR8
)+5;:=<&>?31$c'&)+*%4E7>D@031@CP
#
.RFG@0,4T)->D$G>D$G31@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+* 0'&)+BD8D57@&$ +l
>D@ S $057)+8D8@&$r$0,g,1$&%1,1@&$r. S $&'_57$r'&)->D$_>D$G'b.M5;B'05^y.M,1#
.M\z>.M*%V57$
'/T.M8DE;,431$ l+8D31@&%1$0*,1$>D$&%k31@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%u%4BD3k57$&%k@057@0FG$0*-,1%>D$(31@&>?B'0,4E7)+*rW-B.+%4E;F_FG$0*-,E7>D$0*,4E7W-B$&% j 5.6FG@0,4T)]>D$
>D$`31@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+* 0'05.+%1%4E7W-B$ ZDi9w XE;F_8D57@0FG$0*-,1@&$>.M*%g57$_'&)]>D$_>D$G'b.M57'0BD5#
y i(}C?P
#$&%g31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%a.MB?[
*)]$0B>D%g%1)+*,Z8D5;B%Z31@0ACBD5;E7<031$&%V$0*3/.ME7%1)+*>D$&%ZT-:-8)+,4T<&%1$&%g>D$X31@08.M34,4E;,4E7)+*P#
.8$034,4E;*$0*'&$_>D$a5.FG@0,4T)]>D$
0'&)+BD8D57@&$ c$&%4, S .M5;E7>D@&$CP
É <Ë É
É ¨
É
D
É À É
6)+B%
. S )+*%
8D31)+8
)C%/@u>mn@0,4B>?E7$03
57$&%%1,434B'0,4BD31$&%Fr . &)+*D*@&$&% 8.M35.9FG@0,4T)->D$>D$&%
@057@0FG$0*,1%>?E7%1'031$0,1%bP&#mv. S .M*
,/.MA=$a>m BD*$V,1$05;57$a.M8D8D31)]'1T$X$&%4,>D$c8
$034FG$0,4,431$Cl8.M35Km E;*-,1$034FG@&>?E.ME;31$X>D$c8
$0Bf>D$V8.M3/.MFG<0,431$&%L8DT:?%4E7WB$&%6$0,
É
FG@&'b.M*DE7W-B$&%bl>D$FG)->D@05;E7%/$03^>D$&%%1,434B'0,4BD31$&%9.MB'&)+F_8
)+34,1$0FG$0*-,('&)+F_8D57$q[D$CP#
$HFG)]>D<057$$&%4,^\.+%1@H%4BD3^5.ZFG@
,4T)]>D$ gDi9w E;*DE;,4E7@&$X$0,Z>D@ S $057)+8D8
@&$X8.M3Zyf)+31$b.MB$0, $ $b.M*xdy)+31$b.MBxOCCC=~ql $ $b.M*$0,Vi(.MFc\)+B
xOCC?{§~4~qP
É
k5;57$^$&%4,8.M3|JK.ME;,1$0FG$0*,k.+>.M8D,1@&$8)+BD3
%4E;FaBD57$03
57$^'&)+F_8
)+34,1$0FG$0*-,$0, 5Kmn@ S )+5;BD,4E7)+*X>?:]*.MF_E7WB$^>m BD*c$0*%1$0Fa\D57$
>D$V%/)+5;E7>D$&%234E;ACE7>D$&%bl>D$V,/.ME;5;57$&%>?Ep@031$0*,1$&%bl
.&:.M*,LBD*$gA=@&)+FG@0,434E7$c'&)+* S $q[?$cE;*,1$03/.MACE7%1%.M*,68.M3'&)+*,/.+'0,bP k*
$qp$0,blD$05;57$68
$034FG$0,28.M3H%1)+*JO)+34Fr.M5;E7%4FG$ZFr.M,4T@0Fr.M,4E7W-B$V$0,H%1)+*R%1'1T@0Fr.X*-BDFG@034E7WB$VE;F_8D5;E7'0E;,1$V>D$Z8D31$0*>?31$
$0*'&)+F_8D,1$`57$&%Z@ S $0*,4B$057%g'1T)]'&%g$0,657$&%LE;3431@0ACBD5.M34E;,1@&%a.MB%/$0*%LFG@&'b.M*DE7W-B$`WBDE8$0B S $0*,g$0*>D@&'&)+BD57$03bP#$&%
É .+'0,4E7)+*%E;*,1$03 AC3/.M*BD5.ME;31$&%2>D$2'&)+*-,/.+'0,1%uJd31)+,4,/.M*,1%^>.M*%uBD*$2Fr. &)+*D*$034E7$L%1)+*,^>D@&'034E;,1$&%u8.M3>D$&%^'&)+*>?E;,4E7)+*%
BD*DE;5.M,1@03/.M57$&%Gx57)+Et>D$`-E;AC*)+34E;*DE~ql>?BfJ31)+,4,1$0FG$0*-,g>D$`i9)+BD57)+Fa\$0,Z>D$&%L57)+E7%6>D$a'1T)]'&%Z@05.+%4,4E7WB$&%Z$0,LE;*@05.+%
,4E7W-B$&%bPDwg.M*%257$V'b.+%H>D$2|)+E;*-,1%2Fr. &)+*D*@&%bl)+*RE;*-,431)->?BDE;,L5.X57)+E
>D$V'&)+F_8)+34,1$0FG$0*,6>?B_|)+E;*-,bP
É
#$VFG)->D<057$V>D@ S $057)+8D8@g8$034FG$0,c
É >m BD*$g8.M34,L>m BD,4E;5;E7%1$03>D$&%28.+%H>D$Z,1$0F_8%8D5;B%257)+*DA=%H$0,>D$Z,43/.ME;,1$03L>D$&%28D31)+\D57<0FG$&%'&)+F_8)+34,/.M*,LBD*Y8D5;B%
AC3/.M*>`*)+Fa\D31$H>D$(\D57)-'&%kW-B$('&$0B?[aBD,4E;5;E7%1@&%>.M*%t5Kmv.M8D8D31)-'/T$H>D@ S $057)+8D8
@&$(8.M3^i^BD*>.M5;5xKi^BD*>.M5;5
x|{b} C.=~4~ql
É
>mv.MBD,431$G8.M34,bl
>D$G%bmv.+>.M8D,1$03`.MBo'b.+%V>D$&%a'&)+*,/.+'0,1%a8D5.M*%V8D31@08)+*>D@03/.M*,1%X>.M*%V57$G>D)+Fr.ME;*$r8.M34,4E7'0BD5;E7$03
>D$&%2Fr. &)+*D*$034E7$&%§P
#$&%Z%4,434B'0,4BD31$&%Z@0,4B>?E7@&$&%g%1)+*-,6'&)+F_8)C%1@&$&%Z>D$a\D57)-'&%L8
)+5;:=@&>?34E7W-B$&%g'&)+* S $q[D$&%Z$0,6%/)+*,6FG)->D@05;E7%1@&$&% j 5Kmv.ME7>D$
>?Be'&)]>D$g>D$g'b.M57'0BD5 #
y i(}C
#$&%9FG)+*-BDFG$0*,1%H@0,4B>?E7@&%bl?'&)+F_FG$g.M8D8D5;E7'b.M,4E7)+*R>D$65.VFG@0,4T)]>D$8D31)+8)C%1@&$Cl S )+*,2>D$&%(%4,434B'0,4BD31$&%($0*8DE7$03431$&%
Fr.+%1%1E S $&%bl'b.+%Z>?B%4E;F_8D57$`.M8D8.M31$0E;5k31@0ACBD5;E7$03GxFcBD3~L)+BE;3431@0ACBD5;E7$03_x8)+*, $ BD5;E7$0*~Z.MB?[%4,434B'0,4BD31$&%Z8D31@&'&)+*
,43/.ME;*-,1$&%axd'&)+BD8 57$c>D$ $ BD*.+%bl$&%1'b.M5;E7$03 HE7>D)+5s
~qP
É
#
.>?E r'0BD5;,1@h8)+BD3`FG)->D@05;E7%1$03_>D$,1$05;57$&%_%4,434B'0,4BD31$&%`31@&%4E7>D$h>.M*%`5.f>D@qs*DE;,4E7)+*
>m BD**)+Fc\D31$R>D$8
)+E;*-,1%
>D$Z'&)+*,/.+'0,1%L.+>.M8D,1@Z8
)+BD3(BD*$65;E.ME7%1)+*R$0*,431$g>D$0B?[8
)+5;:=<&>?31$&%bP?#um BD,4E;5;E7%.M,4E7)+*e>D$65Kmv.M5;A=)+34E;,4TDFG$V>D$Z?.MB%/%4E;*$
.M5xK?.MB%1%1E;*$exOCC -~4~qlE;F_8D57@0FG$0*,1@>.M*%g57$_'&)]>D$_>D$_'b.M57'0BD5#y i(}C?l
.FG)+*,431@ j ,43/. S $031%a>?E S $031%1$&%
É
%4E;FaBD5.M,4E7)+*%V>D$&%Z>D@0,1$&'0,4E7)+*%g8$03|Jd$&'0,4E;\D57$&%Z>.M*%Z57$X'b.+%g>D$a'&)+*-,/.+'0,1%g8D5.M*%bP#
.*)+* >D@0,1$&'0,4E7)+* xd'1T-BD,1$_>D$&%
\D57)]'&%~c)+Bz57$&%`)+B S $034,4BD31$&%_>D$c|)+E;*-,1%YxAC5;E7%1%1$0FG$0*,_>D$&%X\D57)]'&%X$0*-,431$h$0B?[~c%1)+*,_>D$&%`$q[D$0F_8D57$&%X>D$5.fF_E7%1$
$0*>D@qJK.MBD,V>D$X'&$0,V.M5;A=)+34E;,4TDFG$CP#
$&%Z8
)+E;*-,1%V>D$`'&)+*,/.+'0,1%V%1)+*-,gA=@&)+FG@0,434E7WB$0FG$0*-,cFr.M5t8)C%4E;,4E7)+*D*@&%V%4BD3Z5.
%4BD3|JK.+'&$`>D$`'&)+*,/.+'0,ZJK. S )+34E7%/.M*-,gE;*'&)+3431$&'0,1$0FG$0*,c57$aAC5;E7%1%1$0FG$0*-,V$0,g@ S $0*,4B$05;57$0FG$0*,a57$X\.+%1'0BD57$0FG$0*,c$0*-,431$
>D$0B?[R\D57)]'&%bPwZ$g8D5;B%bl5Kmn@0,4B>D$c>D$V>?Ep@031$0*,1%Z.M5;A=)+34E;,4TDFG$&%Z$q[]E7%4,/.M*-,1%>.M*%L5.`5;E;,4,1@03/.M,4BD31$Cl
%48
@&'0EsW-B$&%L.MB?[
>D)+Fr.ME;*$&%6>D$V5.G31)+\
)+,4E7W-B$c$0,6>D$V5.`31@b.M5;E;,1@ S E;34,4B$05;57$Cl
._FG)+*-,431@c57$0BD31%LE;*.+>.M8D,/.M,4E7)+*%g.MBf>D)+Fr.ME;*$X>D$V5.
Fr. &)+*D*$034E7$CP
6)+B%8D31)+8)C%1)+*%(>.M*%('&$,43/. S .ME;557$L>D@ S $057)+8D8
$0FG$0*-,H>m BD**)+B S $05.M5;A=)+34E;,4TDFG$g>D$6>D@0,1$&'0,4E7)+*h>D$&%('&)+*-,/.+'0,1%
$0*-,431$`8
)+5;:=<&>?31$&%V'&)+* S $q[?$&%Z34E;ACE7>D$&%§P#umn)+34E;ACE;*.M5;E;,1@G'&)+*%4E7%4,1$ j '&)+*%4E7>D@031$03V>D$&%g'&)+*-,/.+'0,1%V%4BD3|JK.+'0E7WB$&%g$0*-,431$
57$&%\D57)]'&%$0,R. S $&'BD* ,43/.ME;,1$0FG$0*,e%48@&'0EsW-B$CP^#umv.M5;A=)+34E;,4TDFG$$&%1,E;F_8D57@0FG$0*-,1@>.M*%57$'&)]>D$f>D$'b.M57'0BD5
É É
D
>D$0B?[_8)+5;:=<&>?31$&%bP#
.V,43/.M*%4F_E7%1%4E7)+*>D$&%kJO)+31'&$&%^.MBr*DE S $b.MB>?Br'&)+*,/.+'0,($&%4,u31@b.M5;E7%/@&$%1$0BD57$0FG$0*-,9%4BD3BD*G8
)+E;*-,
>D$Z'&)+*,/.+'0,V-E;5$&%4,H.M57)+31%9>?E r'0E;57$g>D$6>D@qs*DE;3H'&)+3431$&'0,1$0FG$0*,57$L'&)+BD8D57$CP L*$FG)]>?Es'b.M,4E7)+*e.a@0,1@L*@&'&$&%/%/.ME;31$
8)+BD3H)+\D,1$0*DE;3BD*RFG)]>D<057$V'&)+3431$&'0,L>D$g'&)+*-,/.+'0,8D5.M*P
#
.%48@&'0Es'0E;,1@c>D$a5Kmv.M5;A=)+34E;,4TDFG$X8D31)+8
)C%1@a'&)+*%4E7%4,1$a$0*f5.r>D@0,1$&'0,4E7)+*>D$&%6%1)+F_FG$0,1%6>D$&%8)+5;:=<&>?31$&%Z>D)+*,657$&%
ÉÉ
JK.+'&$&%k%1)+*,k$0* S E7% j S E7%$0*`BD,4E;5;E7%/.M*-,u57$98D5.M*G%1@08.M3/.M,1$0BD3k8D31)+8)C%1@98.M3^i^BD*>.M5;5KPC#$&%k%1)+F_FG$0,1%u%1)+*-,k$0*%4BDE;,1$
8D31)M4$0,1@&%%4BD357$28D5.M*P=#$&%^$0* S $057)+8D8$&%^'&)+* S $q[?$&%9>D$&%tJK.+'&$&%>D$28.M34,$0,^>mv.MBD,431$>?BG8D5.M*r%/)+*,^>D@qs*DE7$&% C57$0BD3
E;*-,1$031%1$&'0,4E7)+*'b.M3/.+'0,1@034E7%1$5.Z¢b)+*$28)+5;:-A=)+*.M57$>D$2'&)+*,/.+'0,^>D)+*-,57$&%u%/)+F_FG$0,1%%1)+*-,u57$&%k*)]$0B>D%>D$2'&)+*,/.+'0,1%§P
#$&%2$q[D$0F_8D57$&%2,43/.ME;,1@&%28$034FG$0,4,1$0*,L>D$ S .M5;E7>D$0325.a57)+ACE7WB$g$0,(5.X31)+\DB%4,1$&%/%1$Z>D$Z5Kmv.M5;A=)+34E;,4TDFG$V>D$Z>D@0,1$&'0,4E7)+*P
wZ$&%2%4E;FaBD5.M,4E7)+*%L%4,/.M,4E7W-B$&%Vxd%1)+B%28)+E7>D%28D31)+8D31$§~98$034FG$0,4,1$0*,L>D$ZFG$0,4,431$V$0*Y@ S E7>D$0*'&$V5Kmn$ r'b.+'0E;,1@V>D$Z5Kmv.M5
A=)+34E;,4TDFG$L8
)+BD3(>D@0,1$&'0,1$03957$&%^'&)+*-,/.+'0,1%2>.M*%BD*$L%4,434B'0,4BD31$ j AC3/.M*>*)+Fc\D31$Z>D$H\D57)]'&%6x8)+*, $ BD5;E7$0*l?UC =
É
\D57)]'&%~9)+BY8D31@&'&)+*-,43/.ME;*,1$hxd$&%1'b.M5;E7$03 HE7>D)+5sCCU`\D57)-'&%§lD'&)+BD8 57$V>D$ $ BD*.+%c{ C`\D57)]'&%~qP
ÉÉ
i9$&%^5;E.ME7%1)+*%9>D$'&)+*,/.+'0,1%('&)+*>?BDE7%1$0*-,2%1)+B S $0*, j BD*8D31)+\D57<0FG$L%1,/.M,4E7WB$0FG$0*-,^E;*>D@0,1$034F_E;*@Cl?'Cmn$&%4, j >?E;31$ j
BD*f*)+Fc\D31$`>m E;*'&)+*D*B$&%g>mn$qp)+34,1%L>D$a'&)+*,/.+'0,1%Z8D5;B%LE;F_8
)+34,/.M*-,gWB$c57$V*)+Fc\D31$X>mn@&W-B.M,4E7)+*%bPwg.M*%LBD*$
%4,434B'0,4BD31$VFr. &)+*D*@&$Cl5Km E;*>D@0,1$034F_E;*.M,4E7)+*8
$0BD,N0,431$Z57)]'b.M57$V)+BYAC57)+\.M57$CP
#um E;*>D@0,1$034F_E;*.M,4E7)+* 57)-'b.M57$_$&%4,c.+%/%1)-'0E7@&$_.MB*)+Fa\D31$r>D$_'&)+*,/.+'0,1%c8
)+*'0,4B$057%c>D@qs*DE7%1%/.M*,cBD*$`5;E.ME7%1)+*
8D5.M*$CP
?.M*%6Jd31)+,4,1$0FG$0*,blBD*$X5;E.ME7%1)+*8D5.M*$`>D)+E;,gN0,431$_>D@qs*DE7$X8.M3cUr'&)+*-,/.+'0,1%g8
)+*'0,4B$057%V8
)+BD3gN0,431$XE7%1)
%4,/.M,4E7W-B$CP£ S $&'6J31)+,4,1$0FG$0*-,bl57$g8D31)+\D57<0FG$c$&%4,2E;*'&)+*>?E;,4E7)+*D*$05;57$0FG$0*,V%4,/.M,4E7W-B$0FG$0*,LE;*>D@0,1$034F_E;*@CP
É
#um E;*>D@0,1$034F_E;*.M,4E7)+*AC57)+\.M57$$&%4,`.+%1%1)]'0E7@&$ j 5.Y8D34E7%1$r$0* '&)+F_8D,1$>D$5Kmn$0*%1$0Fa\D57$>D$&%a5;E.ME7%1)+*%a8D5.M*$&%
$0*-,431$g57$&%H\D57)]'&%H>D$Z5._%4,434B'0,4BD31$CP
AC*@&$6 •
¡)+BD35.`31@&%/)+5;BD,4E7)+*fAC57)+\.M57$Cl)+*eBD,4E;5;E7%1$g5Km TDE7%1,1)+E;31$c>?Bf'/T.M34A=$0FG$0*,bl>D)+*,L5Km E;F_8
)+34,/.M*'&$`._@0,1@V%/)+BD5;E
8.M32yf)+31$b.MBxdy)+31$b.MBxOCC ~4~qP k5;57$Z'&)+*%4E7%4,1$ j FG$0,4,431$g$0*8D5.+'&$657$&%(\D57)-'&%957$&%9BD*%2.M8D31<&%(57$&%2.MBD,431$&%
É
$0*%4BDE S .M*-,^BD*8D31)-'&@&>D@L31@b.M5;E7%4,1$6>D$'&)+*%4,434B'0,4E7)+*P?£ '/T.+WB$L8.+%^>D$,1$0F_8%bl-5Km E;*DE;,4E.M5;E7%/.M,4E7)+*>D$&% S .M34E.M\D57$&%
j 8.M34,4E;3>D$&%31@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%H)+\D,1$0*-B%8$034FG$0,>D$ZA.M3/.M*,4E;3L5.`8$034,4E;*$0*'&$V>D$g5.`%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*P
-BD3H5Kmn$0*%/$0Fc\D57$c>D$&%%4E;FcBD5.M,4E7)+*%31@b.M5;E7%1@&$&%HAC3 '&$c.MBf'&)->D$gy.M,1#
.M\l)+*f. S @034Es@cWB$G
É ÆÉ
É %457$&ED%2BD31*@b.+%1)+'05;,4E7E7>D)+$(*%LAC5;,/E7%1.M%1*D$2A=%/$0.M**,4E7%u$05;\57$&.+%6%1'0%bBDmn)+57$08DFG8$0)C*%1$0,9*>,.M,1*)+%uB+BD|)+*BD$231>?%E;.M31$&Bf'0,4%1E7$0)+**%H>D>D)+$Z*DAC*5;@&E7%1$C%1l-$0WFGB$0$0*-5;57,b$2l W-B$2%1)+E;,u5.
É>D$(5.6JO)+31'&$2$q[?,1@034E7$0BD31$.M8D8D5;E7WB@&$6.MBG'&$0*,431$L>D$(AC3/. S E;,1@H>?Br%1)+5;E7>D$Cl+57$&% S .M57$0BD31%>D$&%u31@b.+'0,4S E7)+.M*57$0%uBD,/3.M>?*DB_A=$0FG*,4)]E7$0>?5;BD57$&57$%
$0,X*)+34Fr.M57$&%X31$&%4,1$0*,`E7>D$0*,4E7W-B$&%bPtwg.M*%X57$'b.+%X)z5Kmn)+*
.M8D8D5;E7W-B$rBD* '&)+BD8D57$Cl57$&% S .M57$0BD31%`>D$&%X31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%
%1)+*-,'&)+T@031$0*,1$&%Z. S $&'V5._%4:]FG@0,434E7$g$0,H5Kmv.[?$g>D$V31)+,/.M,4E7)+*e>?Be%1)+5;E7>D$g'&)+*%4E7>D@031@Cl
É %1EBD*e%1)+5;E7>D$cAC5;E7%1%1$V%4BDE S .M*,6>D$0B?[Y>?E;31$&'0,4E7)+*%bl57$&% S .M57$0BD31%L>D$&%H31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%L,/.M*DA=$0*,4E7$05;57$&%Z>D@08$0*>D$0*,Z>D$V5.
S .M57$0BD3>?BRFG)]>?BD57$V>D$g5.aJO)+31'&$V$q[],1@034E7$0BD31$a.M8D8D5;E7WB@&$Cl
É É
5.`,43/.M*%1E;,4E7)+*e$0*,431$c57$&%2FG)->D<057$&%H*)+* AC5;E7%1%/.M*,6$0,2AC5;E7%1%/.M*-,$&%4, S .M5;E7>D@&$Cl
É É
5._'&)+* S $034A=$0*'&$Cl>.M*%H57$&%H'b.+%2*)+* AC5;E7%1%/.M*-,L$0,2AC5;E7%1%.M*,bl$&%1,2,431<&%23/.M8DE7>D$rx|{ j UXE;,1@03/.M,4E7)+*%~qP
£s*>D$ S .M5;E7>D$03_5.fFG@0,4T)->D$R>D$31@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*lk)+*
.'&)+F_8.M31@h57$&%`31@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%`*-BDFG@034E7WB$&%>D$5.fFG@0,4T)]>D$
0'&)+BD8D57@&$ h. S $&'h'&$05;57$BD,4E;5;E7%1@&$cB%1W-Bm j 8D31@&%/$0*,`8.M3X#
y i(}C?P#
.fFG@0,4T)]>D$$q[?E7%4,/.M*,1$>.M*%`#y i(}C
'&)+*%4E7%1,1$ j 31@&%1)+B>?31$57$Y8D31)+\D57<0FG$>?B '&)+*-,/.+'0,R>m BD*$f5;E.ME7%/)+* 8D5.M*$ 0%1@&W-B$0*,4E7$05;57$0FG$0*,*)-$0B>".M8D31<&%
*)]$0B>P
#$&%X%4E;FaBD5.M,4E7)+*%_%4BD3a>?Ep@031$0*,1%`'b.+%`.+'b.+>D@0F_E7WB$&%XFG)+*,431$0*-,G>D$&%c31@&%1BD5;,/.M,1%a>D$&%X@057@0FG$0*,1%_>D$r31@&>?B'0,4E7)+*
W-B.+%4E;F_FG$0*,LE7>D$0*,4E7W-B$&%bP#
$&% S .M57$0BD31%L>D$&%H31@b.+'0,4E7)+*%6.MB?[h*)]$0B>D%H>D$g5._FG@0,4T)->D$ 0'&)+BD8D57@&$ c%1)+*,FG)+E;*%
S .M34E.M\D57$&%Z$0,6>D@0,1$034F_E;*@&$&%V>m BD*$aFr.M*DE7<031$XBD*DE7WB$_.M57)+31%ZW-B$c'&$05;57$&%6JO)+BD34*DE7$&%L8.M365.rFG@0,4T)->D $ 0'05.+%1%4E7W-B$
gDi9w `8
$0B S $0*-,XN0,431$G,431<&%c>?Ep@031$0*,1$&%X$0*JO)+*'0,4E7)+*o>D$G5Km E;*DE;,4E.M5;E7%/.M,4E7)+*P¡)+BD3c5.h8D31@ S E7%4E7)+*z>?Bo\.+%1'0BD57$
FG$0*-,bl5.XFG@0,4T)]>D$g8D31)+8
)C%/@&$gE7'0E$&%4,28D5;B%2s.M\D57$CP
É
#
. S .M5;E7>.M,4E7)+*>?BYFG)]>D<057$V,434E7>?E;FG$0*%4E7)+*D*$05*mn$&%4,8.+%,434E S E.M57$CP#$&%'&)+F_8.M3/.ME7%/)+*%6. S $&'c>D$&%$q[?8@034E7$0*'&$&%
$qp$&'0,4B@&$&%%4BD32>D$&%2Fr.&)+*D*$034E7$&%§l,4E;31@&$&%H>D$g5.X\DE;\D5;E7)+AC3/.M8DTDE7$Cl>D)+*D*$0*,6>D$Z\
)+*%231@&%1BD5;,/.M,1%axd>D@qJO)+34Fr.M,4E7)+*%
>m BD*GFaBD3^>D$2\D34E7W-B$H%1)+BDF_E7% j BD*r'0E7%/.ME;5;57$0FG$0*-,bl->m BD*rFcBD3^>D$H\D34E7WB$H%/)+BDF_E7% j BD*G,/.+%/%1$0FG$0*,9>?Ep@031$0*-,4E7$05
$0,2>m BD*R8)+*,L gi %1)+BDF_E7% j BD*$g'/T.M34A=$Z5;E;F_E;,1$§~qPi9$&%(E;* S $&%4,4E;A.M,4E7)+*%FG$0,4,1$0*,$0*R@ S E7>D$0*'&$Z5Kmn$ r'b.+'0E;,1@
$0,25.`31)+\DB%1,1$&%1%1$g>D$g5Kmv.M5;A=)+34E;,4TDFG$a>D$V>D@0,1$&'0,4E7)+*P
#
.G31@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+**BDFG@034E7W-B$aBD,4E;5;E7%.M*,65._FG@0,4T)]>D$c$q[?E7%4,/.M*,1$ 0'05.+%1%4E7W-B$ gDi9w c._8)+BD3\DBD,6>mn@ S .M5;B$0365.
,43/.M*%4F_E7%/%4E7)+*e>D$&%H$qp)+34,1%H>.M*%H>D$&%H%1,434B'0,4BD31$&%H8D31@&'&)+*,43/.ME;*-,1$&%bl
'&)+F_8
)+34,/.M*-,BD*YAC3/.M*>R*)+Fa\D31$c>D$Z\D57)]'&%
$0, j A=@&)+FG@0,434E7$&%^'&)+F_8D57$q[?$&%§P=¡.M3^5Kmv.M*.M5;:]%/$H>D$&%u>D$&%1'&$0*-,1$&%>D$H'/T.M34A=$Cl=57$(8)+E7>D%u>D$25.Z%4,434B'0,4BD31$L'&)+*%4E7>D@031@&$
$&%4,g31$0,431)+B S @CP
#
.F_E7%1$_$0*)]$0B S 31$_>m BD*FG)]>D<057$`*BDFG@034E7W-B$G8)+BD3V%4E;FaBD57$03V5Kmn$qp)+34,V>m BD*$G8D31@&'&)+*,43/.ME;*,1$
*@&'&$&%1%.ME;31$ j 5.c%1,/.M\DE;5;E;,1@6>D$L5.a%4,434B'0,4BD31$Z$&%4,^31@b.M5;E7%/@&$CP]#
$L>?E;FG$0*%4E7)+*D*$0FG$0*-,>D$L5.V8D31@&'&)+*-,43/.ME;*,1$Cl j 8.M3
,4E;3H>D$g'b.M57'0BD57%,4T@&)+34E7WB$&%H'&)+*D*-B%blD8$034FG$0,>D$ S .M5;E7>D$03H'&$0,4,1$gF_E7%1$g$0*Y)]$0B S 31$CPD#$&%H31@&%4BD5;,/.M,1%H)+\D,1$0*B%8.M3
É
'b.M57'0BD5
%/)+*,'&)+T@031$0*-,1%6. S $&'g57$&%H'b.M3/.+'0,1@034E7%4,4E7W-B$&%8DT-:]%1E7WB$&%H$0,2A=@&)+FG@0,434E7W-B$&%6>D$&%H)+B S 3/.MA=$&%L'&)+*%4E7>D@031@&%bP
¡)+BD35.`%4BDE;,1$c>D$&%231$&'1T$031'/T$&%bl)+*Y8$0BD,V
É j '&)+BD34,G,1$034FG$ClE;*,1@0AC31$03G5.FG@0,4T)->D$ 0'&)+BD8D57@&$ e>.M*%_57$R'&)]>D$Y>D$R'b.M57'0BD5#y i(}C?Pu#$Y\DBD,r$&%4,G>D$
'&)+F_8.M31$03R'&$0,4,1$YFG@0,4T)]>D$. S $&'f5.FG@0,4T)]>D$f$q[?E7%4,/.M*-,1$f$0* ,1$034FG$f>D$e31@08.M34,4E;,4E7)+*">D$&%$qp)+34,1%%4BD3BD*$
%4,434B'0,4BD31$CP?#$68D34E;*'0E;8$Z%1$03/.ME;,^8.M3($q[D$0F_8D57$6>m E;*DE;,4E.M5;E7%/$03257$&% S .M57$0BD31%(>D$&%931@b.+'0,4E7)+*%bl],/.M*DA=$0*,4E7$05;57$&%H$0,9*)+3
Fr.M57$&%blAC3 '&$ j 5.hFG@0,4T)]>D$ 0'05.+%/%4E7WB$ ZDi9w `8DBDE7%a>mv.M8D8D5;E7WB$03a5.R*)+B S $05;57$GFG@0,4T)]>D$r>D$G31@&%1)+5;BD,4E7)+*
É
É
0'&)+BD8D57@&$ +Pi9$05;57$ '0E
>D$ S 3/.ME;,8
$034FG$0,4,431$a>D$ S @034Es$03WB$V57$&%231@b.+'0,4E7)+*%>D$ S E7$0*D*$0*,LT)+FG)+A=<0*$&%bl
É 8D31)+57)+*DA=$03V'&$0,4,1$`FG@0,4T)]>D$G.s*>D$aA=@031$03g57$X8D31)+\D57<0FG$_>D$X5Kmv.M8D31<&%g\.+%1'0BD57$0FG$0*-,bP£2'0,4B$05;57$0FG$0*,bl
5Kmv.M5;A=)
34E;,4TDFG$g8$034FG$0,>D$g31@&%/)+B>?31$gBD*R8D31)+\D57<0FG$c>D$V'&)+*-,/.+'0,2Jd31)+,4,/.M*,u|B%1W-Bm j 5.X5;E;F_E;,1$V>?BY\.+%1'0BD57$0FG$0*-,bl
É
É É
E;*-,1@0AC31$03GBD*$hE;*,1$03|JK.+'&$e. S $&'YBD*$R@08.ME7%1%1$0BD3G*)+* *-BD5;57$Y$0*,431$Y>D$0B?[ 8)+5;:=<&>?31$&%bP^i9$05;57$ '0E28)+BD343/..ME;*%4E
31$ @0,1$03H57$c'&)+F_8
)+34,1$0FG$0*-,FG@&'b.M*DE7W-B$c>D$Z5Km E;*,1$03|JK.+'&$c>m BD*$VFr. &)+*D*$034E7$V31@&$05;57$Cl
É
É BD,4E;5;E7%/$03c>D$&%g8)+5;:=<&>?31$&%c>D@qJO)+34Fr.M\D57$&%a>.M*%cBD*$G%4,434B'0,4BD31$r.s*o>mn)+\D,1$0*DE;3X>D$&%VE;*?JO)+34Fr.M,4E7)+*%a%1BD3V%/.31@
%4E7%1,/.M*'&$_E;*,1$034*$CPti9$08
$0*>.M*-,bl5.R%4E;FaBD5.M,4E7)+*z>D$G%1,434B'0,4BD31$&%a. S $&'>D$&%g8)+5;:=<&>?31$&%c>D@qJO)+34Fr.M\D57$&%bl . S $&'GBD*
É
Fr.ME;5;5.MA=$cAC31)C%1%4E7$03blD8D31$0*>`|B%1W-Bm j WB.M,431$VJd)+E7%H8D5;B%H>D$g,1$0F_8%>D$c'b.M57'0BD5 W-B$Z5._%4E;FcBD5.M,4E7)+*f8.M3H\D57)]'&%H34E É
É É
D
É & É
É OË É
10,5") ./5
£L\
>D)+Bl#uP;l£LF_E
?.C.+>.?l aP;l=y$qJ,/.MTl P;l=y$0\.M3 & EKl=£aP;l-CC ?P t[?8
$034E;FG$0*-,/.M5E;* S $&%4,4E;A.M,4E7)+*%()MJ,4T$t|)+E;*-,
FG)+34,/.M3L\
$0T. S E7)+BD3bPy$&'1T.M*DE7'&% $&%/$b.M31'1Tfi9)+F_FcBD*DE7'b.M,4E7)+*%`lD8D8PU=+ $]U P
É
£L\
)+B>?EKl $ P;l{b}C}?{CPy$&'1T.M*DE7'&%9)MJ'&)+F_8
)C%1E;,1$2Fr.M,1$034E.M57%L-.ZBD*DEs$&>GF_E7'031)+FG$&'/T.M*DE7'b.M5.M8D8D31)=.+'/TP u57%1$0E S $03bl
£LFG%4,1$031>.MF P
£2'b.M34:=l `P;lCC?{CPui9)+*,434E;\DBD,4E7)+* j 5.fFG)]>D@05;E7%/.M,4E7)+* FG@&'b.M*DE7WB$h$0,`*BDFG@034E7W-B$R>D$&%`@&>?Es'&$&%`Fr.&)+*D*@&%bP
É
¡kTw (T $&%1E7%bl L*DE S $031%4E;,1@g>D$g5.`y@&>?E;,1@03/.M*D*@&$Cl£LE[ y.M31%1$0E;5;57$Cl 3/.M*'&$CP
É
£L5.M34,bl^¡P;lHi^BD34*DE7$03bl2£aP;l6{b} ?P(£A=$0*$03/.M5;E;¢b$&>"*$ 2,1)+*"FG$0,4T)-> JO)+3'&)+*-,/.+'0,8D31)+\D57$0FG%2E;,4T Jd34E7'0,4E7)+*P
$ )+BD34*.M5>D$Vy@&'b.M*DE7WB$ (T@&)+34E7W-B$V$0,H£L8D8D5;E7WB@&$c%4BD8D8D57@0FG$0*,L*)Y{Z,1)]l?8D8P = $ C?P
É
£L*,4T)+E;*$Cl
£aP;l {b}C} PwZ$034E S .M,4E7)+*)MJk,4T$VE;* 8D5.M*$X$05.+%4,4E7'a'1T.M3/.+'0,1$034E7%4,4E7'&%Z)MJuFr.+%1)+*D34:R,4TD31)+BDACTT)+FG)+A=$
*$0E;¢§.M,4E7)+*Y,4T$&)+34:=P I*,1$034*.M,4E7)+*.M5 $ )+BD34*.M5)MJt])+5;E7>D%.M*>Y-,434B'0,4BD31$&%bl k57%/$ S E7$03]'0E7$0*'&$g¡kBD\D5;E7%4T$031%#,1>
É
UC?lD8D8P
{bU= ${ CU?P
£L34Fr.M*>l P;l
¥9)+BD57)+*l $ Pi6P;l ¡.M8.+>D)+8)+BD57)C%blki6P;l¡kE7'b.MB>l P;l L$ S $0E;5;57$0,bl
y P;l $0:=l¥ZP;lu$031>?:]%bl $ P P;l
£(, & ;E *%1)+*l cP P;l]£Fr.+>D$0EKl?¥ZP]¡ ;P l?.+$0\l
P;l?-,4BD31$Cl
P;l
{b} C}?P $&%48)+*%1$)MJ Fr.+%1)+*D34:G\$&>V4)+E;*,1%(E;*h>?E;31$&'0,
%4T$b.M3bP $ )+BD43 *.M5 )MJ-,434B'0,4BD3/.M5 k*DACE;*$&$034E;*DAl£aP
P i6P {C{ lD8D8PC= $]CC} ?P
¥2.M*>?E7%bl
P
i6P;l#BDFG%/>D$0*l£aPi6P;l¥2.M34,1)+*lXP cP;lk{b} ?{CP t[?8
$034E;FG$0*-,/.M5^%4,4B>?E7$&%c)MJ9%1'b.M57$_$qp$&'0,1%g)+*,4T$
8D8P{ $]?{CP
CU?{
t
¥2.M34,1)+*l XP;li^T)+BD\$0:=l`P;l2{b}=C]P (
T$Y%4T$b.M3%4,431$0*DACT,)MJ631)]' & 4)+E;*,1%GE;* ,4T$&)+34:.M*>
8D3/.+'0,4E7'&$CP )]' &
y$&'1T.M*DE7'&%X{b?l?8D8P{ $ P
É
¥($&' & l_P;l2£L5 yeB & T,/.M3blHy P;lHCC P (T$FG$&'/T.M*DE7'b.M5c31$&%4E7%4,/.M*'&$8D31)+8$034,4E7$&%e)MJX,9)5;E;FG$&%4,1)+*$&%RJd31)+F
3/.M*'&$Cl,4B?p$b.MB.M*>f%1@0\.+%4,1)+8)+5KP I*o¡k34E & 34:-5Kl cP
x >P ~qlw6E;FG$0*%4E7)+*-,1)+*$XCC f 6$ ¡$0348
$&'0,4E S $&%
JO)+3.`,43/.+>?E;,4E7)+*.M5
\DBDE;57>?E;*DArFr.M,1$034E.M5KP£XPn£aPD¥2.M5 & $0Fr.?lD8D8P}= ${bC?P
É É
¥($&' & l_P;l9£L5 yeB & T,/.M3bl9yzP;l9CC PyfBD5;,4E %1'b.M57$'1T.M3/.+'0,1$034E7%/.M,4E7)+* )MJg,9) 31$0*'/T 5;E;FG$&%1,1)+*$&%B%/$&>
E;*
TDE7%4,1)+34E7'g'&)+*%1,434B'0,4E7)+*%bP I*,1$034*.M,4E7)+*.M5 $ )+BD34*.M5)MJ $&%1,1)+3/.M,4E7)+*Y)MJt¥9BDE;57>?E;*DA=%.M*>Ry)+*BDFG$0*-,1%c{C{_x -~ql
8D8P?{b} $]C ?P
¥($0*%1)+B%1%.M*l£aP;l#uP
#E7)+*%bl $ P;l¡t.M8.M*DE7'&)+5.MBl P;lk{b}= ?P£6%4:-F_8D,1)+,4E7'.M*.M5;:]%4E7%gJd)+3g8$034E7)->?E7'_%1,434B'0,4BD31$&%bP
É
¥($&% & )C%blw`P HP;l {b}C}CU 6)?{ ?l {b}C} 6)?{§]P L%1$a)MJts*DE;,1$X.M*>e\
)+BD*>.M34:e$057$0FG$0*-,1%LJd)+3L,4T$a.M*.M5;:?%4E7%L)MJ
FG)+*-BDFG$0*,1%L.M*>%48$&'0E.M5\DBDE;57>?E;*DA=%§P]¥9BD5;5KP 31$&$ & P?])]'CP;P?i^E S E;5 k*DACE;*$&$034E;*DAl£(,4T$0*%Zl{b}C}CUa8D8P?U?{ $ U?l
{b}C} G8D8P
{ $]UC?P
¥9E;*>.?l#uP;l )+*,/.M*.?l
£aP;l 34E;A=$034E7)Dl P;l{b} ?Pyf$&'/T.M*DE7'b.M5u\
$0T. S E7)+BD3g)MJ\D34E7' & Fr.+%1)+*D34E7$&%g>D$034E S $&>Jd31)+F
BD*DE;,V.M*>fFG)+34,/.M3Z'/T.M3/.+'0,1$034E7%4,4E7'&%bP I*zi9)+BD31'0:=l>P $ P Ptx u>P ~ql M,4T I*,1$034*.M,4E7)+*.M5u¥934E7' & .M*>¥^57)]' &
y.+%1)+*D34:Yi9)+*?Jd$031$0*'&$CP k57%1$0E S $03£L8D8D5;E7$&>f]'0E7$0*'&$Cl#
)+*>D)+*l8D8PC $]?{ ?P
É
¥()b:]*,1)+*l aP+
P;lCCC?{CP=i^T$0F_E7%4,434:_.M*>
$&'1TD*)+57)+AC:_)MJ#E;FG$(.M*>`#E;FG$&%1,1)+*$CP E;57$0: *-,1$031%1'0E7$0*'&$]$&'&)+*>
É
u>?E;,4E7)+*l8D8P }C?l 4]¥ {bh -]{bC=C]{ P
É
¥931$0,1$05;57$Cl£aP
P;li9)]'0Bly P;ly)+*$034E7$Cl `P;lCCC?P )+34FcBD5.M,4E7)+*>?B'&)+*,/.+'0,c. S $&'_.+>?T@031$0*'&$`$0*@05.+%4,4E7'0E;,1@
É
*)+* 5;E;*@b.ME;31$L$0*,431$>D$0B?[_%1)+5;E7>D$&%u>D@qJO)+34Fr.M\D57$&%bP-i9)+F_FaBD*.MBD,1@ L)b:.M5£2'b.+>D@0F_E7$Z]'0E7$0*'&$H¡.M34E7%9UC ?l+8D8P
CCU $]C ?P
É OË ÀÉ
É
¥931$0,1$05;57$Cl£XP
P;l]i9)]'0Bly P;l=y)+*$034E7$Cl _P;lCC?{CP *DE;5.M,1$03/.M5'&)+*,/.+'0, 2E;,4T.+>?T$&%4E7)+*h.M*>_Jd34E7'0,4E7)+*r\$0,9$&$0*
, ^)GT-:-8$031$05.+%4,4E7'g\)]>?E7$&%bP *-,1$034*.M,4E7)+*.M5 $ )+BD34*.M5
)MJ u*DACE;*$&$034E;*DAR]'0E7$0*'&$cUC}?l8D8PC?{ $]CCUC?P
¥934E7'&'&)+5;EKl
P;l¡t.M3/.+>?E7%1)DlyzP;l
$0F_8$&%4,/.?l P;l
{b}C} P LBDFG$034E7'b.M58D31)]'&$&>?BD31$cJd)+3L,4T$X.M*.M5;:?%4E7%6)MJu\D34E7' & ^)+3 &
(.M5;57%bP *-yfE7>D>?57$0,1)+*lD¡t.M*>D$Gx u>D%bP ~qli9)+F_8DBD,1$032yf$0,4T)]>D%9E;*Y-,434B'0,4BD3/.M5y.+%1)+*D34:=P]¥ $ *-,1$034*.M,4E7)
*.M5KlD8D8PUCCU $]U?{b?P
É
i(.M31)+5Kl qP;l#)+8$0¢=lVi6P;l L)=.?lZQXP;lZCC?{CPLyfE7'031)+FG$&'1T.M*DE7'b.M5.M*.M5;:]%4E7%)MJW-B.+%4E \D34E;,4,457$ rÉ F .M,1$034E.M57%B%4E;*DA
É
Jd3/.+'0,4BD31$ \.+%1$&>E;*-,1$03|JO.+'&$G$057$0FG$0*-,1%bP I*,1$034*.M,4E7)+*.M5 $ )+BD34*.M5)MJ LBDFG$034E7'b.M5uy$0,4T)->D% u*DACE;*$&$034E;*DA ?l
{b}CU $]?{ P
$&'/TP31$08P;lM¡k31)M4$0,
57)+*DAr>D$V5Kmn@&'&)+57$V>D$&%2F_E;*$&%>mn£L57<&%bP
i9)+BD57)+Fa\li6P £XP;l^{§C+U?P u%/%/.ME6k-BD3`BD*$R.M8D8D5;E7'b.M,4E7)+*
>D$&%a31<0AC57$&%`>D$Fr.[]E;F_E7% _ F E;*DE;F_E7% j WB$057W-B$&%
8D31)+\D57<0FG$&%L>D$g%4,/.M,4E7WB$Cl]31$05.M,4EJO% j 5Kmv.M31'1TDE;,1$&'0,4BD31$CP
$&'/TPD31$08P;lDyf@0FG)+E;31$Z8D31@&%/$0*,1@ j 5Kmv.+'b.+>D@0F_E7$g31)§:.M57$
>D$&%L%1'0E7$0*'&$&%bP
i9) 28
$03bl£XPw`P;l{b}C=]P#E;FG$a.M*>Y#E;FG$Vy)+34,/.M31%bPwZ)+*DT$b.+>lD8D8P} ? l |]¥
É {bh{ =+UCUC} C}C?P
É É
i^BD*>.M5;5Kl-¡ P-£aP;lD{b} C.?P )+34FcBD5.M,4E7)+*h)MJ.g,4TD31$&$ >?E;FG$0*%4E7)+*.M5KP->?E7%1,4E;*'0,^$057$0FG$0*,^FG)->D$05 8 .M34,uEKP.g%1'/T$0FG$
,1)`>D$0,1$&'0,.M*>31$08D31$&%1$0*,H'&)+*-,/.+'0,1%2E;*Y.X%4:]%1,1$0F '&)+F_8)C%1$&>h)MJ
Fr.M*:8)+5;:-T$&>?3/.M5\D57)]' & b% P *-,1$034*.M,4E7)+*.M5
$ )+BD34*.M5)MJ L)-' & y$&'1T.M*DE7'&%6.M*>YyfE;*DE;*DA]'0E7$0*'&$&%L l?8D8P{b= ${C{ ?P
É É
i^BD*>.M5;5Kl-¡ P=£XP;lD{b} M\P )+34FaBD5.M,4E7)+*)MJ.Z,4TD31$&$ >?E;FG$0*%4E7)+*.M5KP->?E7%4,4E;*'0,$057$0FG$0*-,FG)]>D$05 8 .M34,uEKP=.g%1'/T$0FG$
,1)`>D$0,1$&'0,.M*>31$08D31$&%1$0*,H'&)+*-,/.+'0,1%2E;*Y.X%4:]%1,1$0F '&)+F_8)C%1$&>h)MJ
Fr.M*:8)+5;:-T$&>?3/.M5\D57)]' & b% P *-,1$034*.M,4E7)+*.M5
$ )+BD34*.M5)MJ L)-' & y$&'1T.M*DE7'&%6.M*>YyfE;*DE;*DA]'0E7$0*'&$&%L l?8D8P{b= ${C{ ?P
i^BD*>.M5;5KlD¡P?£aP;l?#$0FG)C%bl $ P'`P;l{b}C}C?P
LBDFG$034E7'b.M5%4E;FcBD5.M,4E7)+*Y)MJ JO.MBD5;,9E;*%4,/.M\DE;5;E;,4E7$&%2E;,4TY.X'&)+*,4E;*-B)+B%45;: É
:]E7$057>?E;*DAu4)+E;*, FG)->D$05KP )]' & \DB%4,1% .M*>a%1$0E7%4F_E7'0E;, :gE;*cF_E;*$&%
8D31)]'&$&$&>?E;*DA=%M*> *-,1$034*.M,4E7)+*.M5]%1:-F_8)C%4E;BDF
lD8D8P{ - ${ ?P
i^BD*>.M5;5Kl¡P£XP;l
-,43/.+' & l
QXPwXP#uP;l{b}=+}?P£ >?E7%1'031$0,1$`*-BDFG$034E7'b.M5FG)]>D$05tJd)+3ZAC3/.M*BD5.M3X.+%1%1$0Fc\D5;E7$&%§P $&)
,1$&'/TD*DE7WB$XC}?lD8D8P - $ P
É
É OËIË É
t
É
l |]¥ }C?{bU C U {CP É É
wg. S $0:=l a
P;l{b} ?
{CP£ TDE7%4,1)+34:h)MJt\DBDE;57>?E;*DAGFr.M,1$034E.M57%bP $&'1TD*)+57)+AC:e.M*>fi^BD5;,4BD31$XURxOU=~qlUCCU ]$ UC P
wZ$g¥()+31%4,bl cP;l-5;BD:?%bl?#uP $ P;lyfBDTD5;T.MB%bl P?¥6P;lD¡t.MF_E;*l $ P;l{b}C}CU?P BD*>.MFG$0*,/.M5E7%1%4B$&%(E;*hs*DE;,1$g$057$0FG$0*-,
.M*.M5;:?%1$&%H)MJt57)-'b.M5;E;¢§.M,4E7)+*)MJt>D$qJO)+34Fr.M,4E7)+*P u*DACE;*$&$034E;*DAhi9)+F_8DBD,/.M,4E7)+*%X{b?lD8D8P}C} ${b?{CP
É
wZ)+FG<&>D$Cl XP;lCC ?Py@0,4T)->D$r>D$_31$ WB.M5;Es'b.M,4E7)+* D> $&%g8)+*,1%a$0*Fr.&)+*D*$034E7$CP $&'1TP
31$08P;l#
.M\)+3/.M,1)+E;31$
y.M,1@034E.MB?[Y$0,w6BD3/.M\DE;5;E;,1@V>D$&%6i9)+*%4,434B'0,4E7)+*%§l g] £
)+BD57)+B%1$CP
>?B $ $b.M*lyzP;lD£L\
>D$05 & .+>D$03bl£XP;lD¡. S )+*$Clw`P;l{b} CU?P u,4B>D$V>D$g>?E S 0$ 31%1$&%H31)]'1T$&%L.MBY5.M\
)+3/.M,1)+E;31$V8.M3H)+*>D$&%
BD5;,43/.+%1)+*)+31$&%§P¥9BD5;57$0,4E;*e)MJ k*DACE;*$&$034E;*DA $&)+57)+AC:Y.M*>R,4T$ k* S E;13 )+*DFG$0*,g Rx|{§~qlD8D8P{bUCU ${bUC}?P
É O˨ É
w6BD3/.M*> ^
{ $ ? P É
i 5.&:=$Cl^£aP;l({ C?P-,/.M\DE;5;E;,1@R>D$&% S ) ,1$&%G$0,_>D$&%r.M31'&%§P£L*D*.M57$&%_>D$&%`8)+*,1%G$0,_'1T.MB%/%1@&$&%Y{Cl8D8P
É
u%15.MT'1TDEKl aP;ly.+%d|$&> $ .MFG$0EKlyzP;l
¥(.M\)+5;E.M*l HP;l CC PQL**-BDFG$034E7'b.M5^E;F_8D31) S $0FG$0*,`)MJ(A.MB%/% 57)+\.M,4,1)
W-B.+>?3/.M,4BD31$V34BD57$&%bPD£L8D8D5;E7$&>Yy.M,4T$0Fr.M,4E7'&%6.M*>i9)+F_8DBD,/.M,4E7)+*z{ fxOU=~ql?8D8P+= $?]{§]P
É
.ME;34T-BD31%4,blCi6P;l{b} PMQL*a,4T$ S .M5;E7>?E;, :V)MJ,4T$ q\D3/.M¢&E;5;E.M* u,1$&%4,Jd)+3 \D34E;,4,457$uFr.M,1$034E.M57%bP *-,1$034*.M,4E7)+*.M5 $ +) BD34*.M5
)MJ )]' & yf$&'/T.M*DE7'&%L.M*>YyfE;*DE;*DA]'0E7$0*'&$&%al?8D8P U $ ?P
É
.M*D*DE;*DAl
¡ P $ P;l¥()])+,4T\-:=lgP HP;lCC?{CP (TD31$&$ >?E;FG$0*%4E7)+*.M5^FG)->D$05;5;E;*DAf.M*>JdBD5;5 %1'b.M57$X,1$&%4,4E;*DAY)MJ2%4,1)+*$
.M31'/Te\D34E7>?A=$CPi9)+F_8DBD,1$031%Z.M*>e-,434B'0,4BD31$&%Z+}?l?8D8P $] C?P
É
É
$03434E7%§ly Pki6P;l (E;* #
)+EKl P;lkCC?{CPt#E;F_E;,G.M*.M5;:]%1E7%X)MJJ34E7'0,4E7)+*.M5(\D57)]' & .+%/%1$0Fc\D5;E7$&%_.+%_.fFr.M,4T$0Fr.M,4E7'b.M5
8D31)+AC3/.MF 2E;,4Th'&)+F_8D57$0FG$0*,/.M34E;, :R'&)+*%4,43/.ME;*-,1%bP *-,1$034*.M,4E7)+*.M5 $ )+BD34*.M5)MJ
yf$&'/T.M*DE7'b.M5]'0E7$0*'&$&% U?l8D8P
CC} $]C P
31$0FG)+*>ly P;l {b} C?P uW-BDE;5;E;\D31$`>D$&%L%4,434B'0,4BD31$&%gW-BDE.+>?T<031$0*-, j 57$0BD3Z%4BD8D8)+34,bPi9)+F_8D,1$ 31$0*>?B>D$a5Kmv.+'b.
>D@0F_E7$V>D$&%L%1'0E7$0*'&$&%C} xK]@034E7$ |~ql?8D8P}?{bU $]}?{ ?P
É É
É
.M31'0E. £L57)+*%1)Dl £aP;l ]$0343/.M*)Dl X
'&)+5;5;E7%4E7)+*e8D31)+\D57$0FYP i9)+F_8DBD,1$03 3/.M8DTDE7'&%L.M*>e£8D8D5;E7'b.M,4E7)+*%a{ lD8D8PU U?P
P;l 5.+WB$03bl $ P;l{b}C} P $b.M5u,4E;FG$rA=$&)+FG$0,434E7'rE;*-,1$03|Jd$031$0*'&$>D$0,1$&'0,4E7)+*oJO)+3
$
E;5;\$034,bl HP;l +) *DAl_
P;lr{b} C}?P`£ *$ .M5;A=)+34E;,4TDF JO)+3z>D$0,1$&'0,4E;*DA 4, T$ '&)+5;5;E7%4E7)+* M) JYFG) S E;*DA )+\?4$&'0,1%bP
I*,1$034*.M,4E7)+*oi9)+*?JO$031$0*'&$V)+* L)+\
)+,4E7'&%.M*>R£LBD,1)+Fr.M,4E7)+* 4i £ `{Cl ${ P
E;5;\$034,bl HP P;l $
+) TD*%/)+*lw`P P;l g$&$034,4TDEKl
P
P;l{b} ?P£ JK.+%4,H8D31)]'&$&>?BD31$gJO)+3'&)+F_8DBD,4E;*DA,4T$c>?E7%4,/.M*'&$
É É
É
*)+* .+%1%/)-'0E.M,4E S $eJ34E7'0,4E7)+*.M5|)+E;*-,1%GB%4E;*DAz5;E;*$b.M3r8D31)+AC3/.MF_F_E;*DAP2i9)+F_8DBD,1$031%R.M*> -,434B'0,4BD31$&% lk8D8P
=+U $ =]P
É
E7'&$Cl 3/.M*'&$CP
])+8DTDE. £L*,4E;8)+5;E7%bl L
BDE;5;5.MBDFG$Cl $ P;lCC P#
._8DE7$03431$a>.M*%H5Kmv.M31'1TDE;,1$&'0,4BD31$a34BD3/.M57$c$0*e57)+343/.ME;*$CP I*o $ S B$V>D$g5Km E;* S $0*,/.ME;31$Cl
*)
?PyfE;*DE7%4,1<031$V>D$Z5.G'0BD5;,4BD31$V$0,H>D$g5.`'&)+F_FcBD*DE7'b.M,4E7)+*l
8D8P?8D8P{ ${ ?lED { CCU +UC P É
B@0A=$0*l `
P;l¡.M57'0E.MB% & +. %bl XP;l{b}C}C?P I*,431)]>?B'0,4E7)+* j 5.8DT:?%4E7WB$f>D$&%G31)]'1T$&%bP $034Fr.M*D*l |]¥
É {b
=+ ?{bU =]P
.MF_E7>l
£XP£aP;l
wL34:?%1>.M57$Cl aP ;P lu{b} ?{CPti9)+*'031$0,1$GFr.+%1)+*D34:BD*>D$03X'&)+Fc\DE;*$&> %4T$b.M3a.M*>o'&)+F_8D31$&%/%4E7)+*
.M57)+*DAG,4T$VFG)+34,/.M3k|)+E;*-,1%bP£i $ +) BD34*.M5^l?8D8PU?{ $]UCC?P
É OË ÀÉ
t
$0*>?34:=l
£XP P;lu{b}= ?P
£ *)+,1$)+*o,4T$%4T$b.M3a%4,431$0*DAC,4T )MJ2\D34E7' & ^
)+3 & E;* '&)+Fc\DE;*$&> 3/.+' & ;E *DAf%4T$b.M3`.M*>
'&)+F_8D31$&%1%1E7)+*P
-,434B'0,4BD3/.M5
Fr.+%/)+*D34:h=]lD8D8P - $ ?P
$0:-Fr.M*l $ ;P l{b}=+?Pi9)+BD57)+Fc\mn%LFG$0FG)+E;3L)+*Y%1,/.M,4E7'&%bP
É
BD34FcBD¢&5;Bl _P;lt{b}C} ?P£L*$0*$034AC: \.+%1$&>'&)]$r'0E7$0*,a)MJ^31$&%4,4E;,4BD,4E7)+*JO)+3Z8D5.M*.M3gE;F_8.+'0,1%V)MJ2%457$0*>D$03g\.M31%
2E;,4TYFr.+%/%4E S $V$q[?,1$034*.M5
%4BD3|JK.+'&$&%bP $ )+BD34*.M5 )MJk£L8D8D5;E7$&>Yyf$&'/T.M*DE7'&% lD8D8P} $]} C?P
$ $b.M*lyzP;l{b}C}CU?P-E;FaBD5.M,4E7)+*e*BDFG@034E7W-B$V>D$&%28D31)+\D57<0FG$&%L>D$g'&)+*,/.+'0,L. S $&'ZJd31)+,4,1$0FG$0*,bP
*@&$&%L>D$Z5._%1)]'0E7@0,1@ 34E;\)+57)+ACE7WB$a>D$ 3/.M*'&$Cly.M,1@034E.MB?[Y$0,
$&'1TD*DE7W-B$&%bP
$&'1TPD31$08P;l $ )+BD3 É
$ $b.M*lyzP;l{b}C} .?P 34E7'0,4E7)+*.M5'&)+*-,/.+'0,E;*Y'&)+5;57$&'0,4E7)+*%6)MJ34E;ACE7>f.M*>Y>D$qJd)+34Fr.M\D57$c\
)]>?E7$&%V?*-BDFG$034E7'b.M5%4E;FaB
5.M,4E7)+*)MJtA=$&)+Fr.M,1$034E.M57%§P I*o?.M5.+>?BD3/.MEKl
£aPD¡P
P;l¥()+BD57)+*l $ Py P
x u>D%§P ~qly$&'1T.M*DE7'&%6)MJtA=$&)+Fr.M,1$034E.M57%
É
I*,1$03|JK.+'&$&%bP k57%/$0E S $03Z]'0E7$0*'&$ClD8D8P CU $ ?P
$ É
$b.M*lCy P;l]{b}C}C}?P (T$(*)+* %1FG)-)+,4T_'&)+*,/.+'0,u>?:]*.MF_E7'&%tFG$0,4T)]>Pi9)+F_8DBD,1$03uyf$0,4T)]>D%k.M8D8D5;E7$&>_yf$&'/T.M*DE7'b.M5
k*DACE;*$&$034E;*DA{§CRxOU -~qlD8D8PCU $] ]P
É
$ $b.M*lDy P;l?£2'b.M34:=l XP;l?y)+*$034E7$Cl `P;lDCC?{CP
6)+* %4FG)])+,4Th'&)+*-,/.+'0,>?:]*.MF_E7'&%H.M8D8D31)=.+'1Te)MJt'&)+T$&%4E S $ZFr.M,1$
É É
34E.M57%bP¡k31)-'&$&$&>?E;*DA=% )§:.M5])-'0E7$0,I:R£¤U }?lD8D8P }= $] { ?P
É
É OË É
É
Z3/.M5 &l¥ZP;l¡t.M*>D$Cl P XP;lDyfE7>D>?57$0,1)+*l $ P;l{b}C}?{CPQL*Y,4T$gFG$&'/T.M*DE7'&%L)MJtJd31)C%4,H>.MFr.MA=$V,1)_\D34E7' & Fr.+%1)+*D34:=P
i9)+F_8DBD,1$031%Z.M*>f-,434B'0,4BD31$&% {Cl8D8P U $ ?P
#$g¡t.M8$Cl `P;l?£L*,4T)+E;*$Cl£aP;l?¡$0A=)+*l¡P;lCC?{CP]$0E7%4F_E7'V.+%1%1$&%/%4FG$0*,H)MJtFr.+%1)+*D34:h%4,434B'0,4BD31$&% FcBD5;,4E /% 'b.M57$
*-BDFG$034E7'b.M5FG)]>D$05;5;E;*DAP I*e=#)+BD31$0* &)Dl-¡ P-¥ZP;l )]'b.?lC¡ P
x u>D%bP ~ql E7%4,1)+34E7'b.M5'&)+*%4,434B'0,4E7)+*%bP=8D8P-} CU $]=} +?P
É É
#$0Fr.ME;,431$Cl $ P;lDi^T.M\)-'/T$Cl $ P-#uP;l
{b} P?yf@&'b.M*DE7W-B$6>D$&%Fr.M,1@034E.MB?[h%1)+5;E7>D$&%bl?ME7<0FG$L@&>?E;,4E7)+*P?w6BD*)->l]¡t.M34E7%
P
#$&)+*$0* & )Dl `P;l 6E;*)+AC3/.+>D)]'ClQXP;lCC?{CP£ FG)+57$&'0BD5.M3L>?:]*.MF_E7'&%.M8D8D31)=.+'1TfE;*e%4E;FcBD5.M,4E7)+*%L)MJ DB E7> %/)+5;E7>D% É
8.M34,4E7'057$&% ) VP $ )+BD34*.M5 )MJ 3/.M*BD5.M3y.M,4,1$03LU?lD8D8P{ ${b}?{CP
#$031)§:=l£aP;l34E;FG)+31$b.MBl
P;lCCC?P r'0E7$0*'0:.M*>e31)+\DB%1,4*$&%1%L)MJu,4T$X'b.M57'0BD5.M,4E7)+*.M5;A=)+34E;,4TDF )MJ$0* S $057)+8$
'&)+* S $q[P *-,1$034*.M,4E7)+*.M5 $ )+BD34*.M5)MJ L)-' & y$&'1T.M*DE7'&%6.M*>YyeE;*DE;*DAh]'0E7$0*'&$&%L l?8D8P{b= ${C{ ?P
#E;*ly P
i6P;l i(.M*D*:=l $ P P;l {b}C}?{CP£ JO.+%4, .M5;A=)+34E;,4TDF JO)+3 ;E *'031$0FG$0*,/.M5 >?E7%1,/.M*'&$ 'b.M57'0BD5.M,4E7)+*P
I*,1$034*.M,4E7)+*oi9)+*?JO$031$0*'&$V)+* L)+\
)+,4E7'&%.M*>R£LBD,1)+Fr.M,4E7)+* 4i £ `P
T$&%1E7%bl .+'0BD57>.+>D$Z>D$
#)+BD31$0* &)Dl]¡P¥ZP;l-CC ?P?i9)+F_8DBD,/.M,4E7)+*.M5%1,43/.M,1$0ACE7$&%uJO)+3uFr.+%1)+*D34:G%4,434B'0,4BD31$&%§P¡kTw (
k*DA=$0*DT.M34E.>. L*DE S $031%4E7>.+>D$Cl¡)+34,1)Dl¡)+34,4BDA.M5KP
É
#B'0E.M*)Dl aP;l??.+'&'&)Dl P;l
{b}C}=]P )+FG)+A=$0*DE;¢§.M,4E7)+*Y,1$&'1TD*DE7W-B$V.M*>h>.MFr.MA=$ZFG)->D$05
JO)+39)+57>Fr.+%1)+*D34:Fr.M,1$
34E.M5KP I*,1$034*.M,4E7)+*.M5 $ )+BD34*.M5
)MJ])+5;E7>D%L.M*>-,434B'0,4BD31$&%bl¡$034A.MFG)+*¡k31$&%/%blD#>?,LU lD8D8PU?{b}?{ $]UCC ?P
É
#B'0E.M*)Dl aP;l?.+'&'&)Dl HP;l{b}C} ?P .M34E.M,4E7)+*D*.M5kFG$0,4T)]>D%LJd)+36,4T$aT)+FG)+A=$0*$0E;¢§.M,4E7)+*o)MJu8
$034E7)]>?E7'aT$0,1$031)+A=$ É
*$&)+B%FG$&>?E.?P kBD31)+8$b.M* $ )+DB 34*.M5
)MJky$&'1T.M*DE7'&%6£ ])+5;E7>D%Vl8D8P }C} $ ?{§]P
É OË ÆÉ
t
6$0¢§.MF_EKl HP P;l .+%4T.+%4Tl `PyzP=£XP;l T.+)Dl-w`P;l T.M\)+B%1%4EKl $ P;l-CC ?P?-T)+34,1$&%4,^5;E;* & FG$0,4T)]>GJO)+3'&)+*-,/.+'0,
>D$0,1$&'0,4E7)+*RE;*h>?E7%1'031$0,1$6$057$0FG$0*,2FG$0,4T)]>P I*,1$034*.M,4E7)+*.M5?4)+BD34*.M5Jd)+39*BDFG$034E7'b.M5
.M*>h.M*.M5;:-,4E7'b.M5FG$0,4T)]>
E;*YA=$&)+FG$&'/T.M*DE7'&%al8D8P CU $ C?{CP
*)+34FG$Z£ g
Q cl]CCC?P?wL,1$034F_E;*.M,4E7)+*R>D$L5.V31@&%1E7%4,/.M*'&$ j 5.a'&)+F_8D31$&%1%4E7)+*hBD*DE.[?E.M57$Cl-31@qJO@031$0*'&$ ¡} É
C?P
31@qJO@031$0*'&$ ^
Q4)DlQXP;l ¥^31)]) & l XP;l{b}C}C?P (T$$qp$&'0,a)MJHFG)+E7%4,4BD31$)+*z%1)+FG$rFG$&'1T.M*DE7'b.M5(8D31)+8$034,4E7$&%X)MJ231)]' &
P yfE;*DE;*DA
%1'0E7$0*'&$a.M*>R,1$&'1TD*)+57)+AC:{b?lD8D8P{ ${ ?P
QL*.M,1$Cl HP;l .M*DA.M*BlD£XP;l-¥2.M34\.M,bl?£aP;lDQL5;57$03bl
P;l 6E;,/.M5;E.M*DEKl cP `P;lD?.+$0,4,/.?lD£XP;l?]'&)+,4,/.?l cP;l
{b}C}=]P-,434B'
É
,4BD3/.M5.M*.M5;:?%4E7%H.M*>>?BD3/.M\DE;5;E;,I:h.+%/%1$&%1%4FG$0*-,()MJ TDE7%4,1)+34E7'b.M5'&)+*%4,434B'&'0E7)+*RB%4E;*DAG.gs*DE;,1$g$057$0FG$0*-,H>.MFr.MA=$
FG)]>D$05KP * L)-'b.?l ¡ P(x u>P ~qlu-,434B'0,4BD3/.M5.M*.M5;:]%1E7%a)MJHTDE7%4,1)+34E7'b.M52'&)+*%4,434B'&'0E7)+*%§lki y ¤¥2.M31'&$057)+*.?P
8D8P{ C} $]C P
É OË É
É
QL31>?BD*.?l £aP;l#
)+BD31$0* &)Dl ¡P¥ZP;l
CC .?P (TD31$&$ >?E;FG$0*%1E7)+*.M595;E;F_E;,X.M*.M5;:]%4E7%a)MJ234E;ACE7>57)-' & %X.+%1%1$0Fa\D5.MA=$&%bP
8.M34,ZE(
)+31%1E7)+*JO.ME;5;BD31$X)+*eJd34E7'0,4E7)+*.M5
|)+E;*-,1%g.M*>e5;E;F_E;,V.M*.M5;:?%4E7%LJd)+34FaBD5.M,4E7)+*P I*,1$034*.M,4E7)+*.M5 $ )+BD34*.M5
% ?lD8D8P { $ { C?P
)MJ])+5;E7>D%L.M*>f-,434B'0,4BD31$&
QL31>?BD*.?l £aP;l#)+BD31$0* &)Dl ¡ P Z É
¥ P;lCC \P (TD31$&$ >?E;FG$0*%4E7)+*.M595;E;F_E;,a.M*.M5;:?%4E7%V)MJ(34E;ACE7>57)]' & %c.+%1%1$0Fa\D5.MA=$&%bP
É
8.M34,gE;E2#)=.+> 8.M,4TJO)+5;57) 2;E *DAe%/)+5;BD,4E7)+*8D31)-'&$&>?BD31$G.M*> S .M5;E7>.M,4E7)+*P *-,1$034*.M,4E7)+*.M5 $ )+BD34*.M5)MJ2])+5;E7>D%
.M*>f-,434B'0,4BD31$&% ?l?8D8P { ?{ $ { C?P
QXm L)+BD3 & $Cl $ ;P lu{b}C} ?Pti9)+F_8DBD,/.M,4E7)+*.M5 $&)+FG$0,434:E;* i6l%1$&'&)+*>z$&>?E;,4E7)+*Pi(.MFa\D34E7>?A=$ L*DE S $031%4E;, :¡u31$&%1%bl
8D8PUC}C?P
¡t.MA=$ClD£aP ;P l{b}= ?P E;*DE;,1$g$057$0FG$0*-,2FG)->D$05JO)+3(Fr.+%1)+*D34:=P $ +) BD34*.M5
)MJu-,434B'0,4BD3/.M5wLE S E7%4E7)+*R£XP
P i6P {b l
8D8P{b = $b{ P
JO)+32,4TD31$&$ >?E;G
F $0*%4E7)+*.M5Fr.+%1)+*D34:R%4,434B'0,4BD31$&%bPi9)+F_8DBD,1$031%6.M*>f-,434B'0,4BD31$&%bl%1BD\DF_E;,4,1$&>P
¡kE7$0,434B%1¢b'0¢§. & H
l
P;l E;Bl ;P lL{b}C}C?P9£ Fr.M,4T$0Fr.M,4E7'b.M5V>D$&%1'034E;8D,4E7)+* )MJcFr.+'031)C%1'&)+8DE7'\$0T. S E7)+BD3R)MJc\D34E7' &
Fr.+%1)+*D34:=P -* ,1$034*.M,4E7)+*.M5 $ +) BD34*.M5)MJu])+5;E7>D%L.M*>f-,434B'0,4BD31$&%bl¡$034A.MFG)+*f¡u31$&%1%bl#>?,6C}?l?8D8P U?{ $ ?P
¡kE7)+*l?
P;lD{b}C}C}?PwZ$(5.ZA=@&)+FG@0,434E7$6.M5;A=)+34E;,4TDF_E7WB$6.MBr'b.M57'0BD5A=@&)+FG@0,434E7W-B$CP¡kT>G,4T$&%4E7%bl L*DE S $031%4E;,1@H>D$ L
E7'&$
É
?.MFr.M3/.+%4E;*DACT$Cl ¤P;l $0*>?34:=l2£XP ¤P;lg{b} C?P (T$%1,431$0*DAC,4T M) JX\D34E7' & 9)+3 & BD*>D$03Y\DE.[]E.M5c,1$0*%4E;57$.M*>
É
?.M*'/T$0¢ ¡.M57$0*'0E.?l HP;l-{b} C?P 6)+*aT)+FG)+A=$0*$&)+B%tFG$&>?E.6.M*> S E;\D3/.M,4E7)+*`,4T$&)+34:=P &$ '1TPM31$08P;l+#$&'0,4BD31$9*)+,1$&%
E;*Y8DT-:]%1E7'&%bl S )+5=+?l
-8D34E;*DA=$03bl¥($0345;E;*P
É OË & É
t
É
?.M*'/T$0¢ ¡.M57$0*'0E.?l P;l {b} =]P )+FG)+A=$0*$0E;¢§.M,4E7)+*,1$&'/TD*DE7WB$&%LJO)+3L'&)+F_8)C%4E;,1$aFG$&>?E.?P $&'1TP
31$08P;l#
$&'0,4BD31$
*)+,1$&%E;*R8DT:?%4E7'&% 6G
) =+?l-8D34E;*DA=$03bl¥($0345;E;*l $034Fr.M*:=P
?.MB%1%1E;*$Cl P;lCC Pi9)+*-,434E;\DBD,4E7)+* j 5.FG)]>D@05;E7%/.M,4E7)+*>D$XAC3/.M*BD5.M,1%V,434E7>?E;FG$0*%1E7)+*D*$057%r.M8D8D5;E7'b.M,4E7)+*z.MB
\.M5;5.+%4,bP¡kT>R,4T$&%4E7%bl *DE S $031%4E;,1@c>D$&%H%1'0E7$0*'&$&%H$0, $&'1TD*DE7W-B$&%L>?BY# .M*DACB$&>D)-'Clyf)+*-,48
$05;5;E7$03bl 3/.M*'&$CP
?.MB%1%1E;*$Cl P;li^T)+57$0,bli6P;l .MBD,4E7$03bl¡ P HP;l
w6BD\
)+E7%bl P;l¥()+T.M,4E7$03bli6P;lyf)+31$b.MBl $ P $ P;lCC P
yf)]>D$05;5;E;*DA
É
É
-E;*DT.?lC¥ZPC¡P;l $0*>?34:=lC£XP ¤P;lD{b} ?P BD34,4T$03E;* S $&%4,4E;A.M,4E7)+*%^)MJ\)+*>a,1$0*%1E7)+*lC\
)+*>`%4T$b.M3.M*>`,4T$2$qp$&'0,
)MJt8D31$&'&)+F_8D31$&%1%4E7)+*)+*Y,4T$g%4T$b.M3%4,431$0*DAC,4Tf)MJFG)]>D$05\D34E7' & Fr.+%1)+*D34:h'&)+BD8D57$0,1%bP¥ZP i9$03/.MFYP cPn£ P
.MAC5;E7)DlCCC?P $ .MBDFG)+*, É 8DE7$03431$`>D$g%1)+57$0E;5Kl%1E;,1$ZE;*,1$034*$0,bl qT-,4,48z VP 8DE7$03431$ É >D$ É 1.MBDFG)+*,bP Jd3 +P
.M*ewZ$0*e¥($034A=$0*l P;l{b}C}C}?P£ JK.+%4,.M*>R31)+\DB%4,HA & E;F_8D57$0FG$0*-,/.M,4E7)+*fJO)+3'&)+5;5;E7%4E7)+*f>D$0,1$&'0,4E7)+*f)MJu'&)+* S $q[
)+\?4$&'0,1%bP $ +) BD34*.M5)MJ 3/.M8DTDE7'&%
)])+57% l?8D8P $] P
.M*w6$03L¡k5;BDE FYl cP;l{b}C}CU?P-T$b.M3\$0T. S E7)+BD36)MJk\$&>`4)+E;*,1%bP I*o .MF_E7>l£XP£XP;l .M3434E7%bl P P
x >D%bP ~ql
)+34,4Te£LFG$034E7'b.M*ey.+%1)+*D34:Ri9)+*?JO$031$0*'&$CP8D8P{b ${bU ?P
M,4T 6
É
)+* 5;E;*$b.M3L\
$0T. S 7E )+BD3L)MJFr.+%1)+*D34:hBD*>D$03H,1$0*%1E7)+*P $031)+* ?l8D8P $ P
.M31>D)+B & .M5;E7%bl qP;lk-BD57$0FYl $ P;l2{b}C} k
P ¥^EJdBD31'b.M,4E7)+*E;*A=$&)+FG$&'1T.M*DE7'&%§Pu¥95.+' & 7E $R£2'b.+>D$0F_E7' ¡k31)MJd$&%/%4E7)+*.M5Kl
5.+%1A=) Vl u*DAC5.M*>lD8D8P }?P
.M31<0*$Cl¡ É
;P l9{b}C}C?P#umn$0*'&$0E;*,1$hA.M5;57) 31)+Fr.ME;*$h>D$ 7FG$&%bl$&>?E;,4E7)+*%a>?B '&$0*,431$*.M,4E7)+*.M52>D$G5.Y31$&'1T$031'1T$
%1'0E7$0*-,4EsWB$ u>?E;,4E7)+*P u>?E;,4E7)+*%>?Br'&$0*-,431$H*.M,4E7)+*.M5
>D$25.Z31$&'1T$031'/T$L%/'0E7$0*,4EsW-B$CP?QLB S 3/.MA=$28DBD\D5;E7@L. S $&'
57$V'&)+*'&)+BD31%L>?BRF_E;*DE7%4,1<031$c>D$Z5.G'0BD5;,4BD31$Cl |]¥ CC -+CU P É É É
6E;5;57$0FcB%bl¥ZP;lCC P k,4B>D$r>D$&%ZFcBD31%V>D$_%1)+BD,1<0*$0FG$0*-,a$0*Fr.&)+*D*$034E7$r>D$X8DE7$03431$&%a%1<&'1T$&%bP¡uT>,4T$&%4E7%bl
I*%4,4E;,4BD,H*.M,4E7)+*.M5
>D$&%L%1'0E7$0*'&$&%.M8D8D5;E7W-B@&$&%>D$V#:=)+*l#:=)+*l 3/.M*'&$CP
6E;,434B S E;B%§P;l{b}CU?{CPwZ$V.M31'1TDE;,1$&'0,4BD3/.?P
¥()-) & P 3/.M*
ql ` & 3/.M*DA=$03bmn%H,43/.M*%15.M,4E7)+*P $0E;*$0Fr.M*D*oP
É D¨
É
o.M*DAlXP
P;l $ E.?l Py P;l L)+Bl
PXP;l T.M*DAl P P;l#E;*>DW S E7%1,bl¡ P£aP;lCC P (T$ .M,4,1$0*$&>e\D3/.M¢&E;5;E.M*
?> E7%1'Z%48$&'0E;FG$0*RB%1$&>JO)+39,1$&%1,4E;*DAG$05.+%4,4E7'6FG)->?BD5;B%bl?,1$0*%1E;57$6%1,431$0*DAC,4Te.M*>J3/.+'0,4BD31$6,1)+BDACTD*$&%1%H)MJ\D34E;,4,457$
31)]' & %.M*.M5;:-,4E7'b.M5H.M*>o*BDFG$034E7'b.M5231$&%4BD5;,1%bP *-,1$034*.M,4E7)+*.M5 $ )+BD34*.M52)MJ )]' & yf$&'/T.M*DE7'&%G.M*>oyfE;*DE;*DA
% {ClD8D8P $] U?P
]'0E7$0*'&$&
:]5;5;E7$Cl?yzP cP $
P;l .M31>?*$03bl P P P;l{b} C.?P(T$6A=$0*$03/.M5;E;¢b$&> & )+¢b$0*:h'b.M34Fr.M*R$&WB.M,4E7)+*R8.M34,(EKP )+3457>
QLE;5 l?8D8P
{b?{ ${b ?P
:]5;5;E7$Cly P aP $
P;l .M31>?*$03bl P P P;l{b} M\P(T$LA=$0*$03/.M5;E;¢b$&> & )+¢b$0*:r'b.M34Fr.M*h$&WB.M,4E7)+*8.M34,E;EKP )+3457>
QLE;5 l?8D8P?{b $]C ?P
É D¨Ê²É
!
"# $&%')(+*,")-
./)0
1" !2
!
3
-"#)4+45) 7648")!9
:)(/)24;")8<(/-)2>=?+?=!
@
:
("(
8
A
B"(+"!
AC-
A=+ ,
/+D4 #6*8(! 8E!
245)+
GF!9
D 6
8
H-)2"!
I!
+!
JE4;"9 -)")!8 45)
$K5+!"!L&%M(
*!(3 29") N4
8"#"POQ@RST)24;8<2U)+ V9(T3
:PK5
:)(2
B"(+"(+
6
4W(+YX"1( ?45):
Y
,
:V,(+W
!8N!Z)24;8:
Y=+ ,
<N!(
8B[
) +
.\*)
G=!
Z*)
!
6]45)^O_)"291
(`a4
?
+
POQ@Sb?)(
U*
c:d
9!
c,!
S45)eT2"
,<
f 29
e+
"
gb3Hh,)"
I8d)
i?j,5)
@;RS
19(8"
3(
Z
81
Z
("(
1k4!
?/)
P*
6W
4 J)4+45)
-( !El_>("mI(n -(+ Elo4;82p)(! 5mG
("(
48")!9
qlo
U# 6f(4;r Um@
iI%M(>45#U6;(D)(+*f)!-P"
^>+" k+
18d)"
^"I*) )44WI4W(+Z-?
8")
(+Oo) V9(
6
4WPK5V9(
N#(s/#0+!
@i?!*
N)4+4 !U#
g
(+
)
<
6
?45))
?U*G
Zs4W!
1!
(+
Z+I P"t"()65818"G =(
B"
I
u%') -)P"
)@R
f
(Pd#
c="9(
c45)c7%v#5)!j,
:
f
8"
w:d
5)-
f
8g)
8"
gU*)
ZU#")"
14+
9j,
V9(
Z1-) V9(
Z
1(+*,)-
?+
+
@]iI%v#(+">45)BU6x
Z )
8d)"
>(!
9>
(+*)8yq(L4+=!2
Bd# V9(29I +" 2)(LP*)(z ,U#u@
b?(+
HU*
H4+4;
/(A"
+2
) (+ zV9(<")!/
!>(Pd)28G(
>!
>,(+
&%M(J #
)A4)+)@xRg%'"(+I
(+?
?)
?)U)+ V9(
? 4W
T^"
"Z 4;B"!G+G
2"
,#@&{?+45)"#
)D Oo#!"IU* 2"
,>
) (+ k4+[|s
Bd)8)6&!24![
28".5#
3Re}q~GY@
I> ?DC_ K \ t
52
8u
u _
u ^ M
KH
- Co
k= ! \ u8 O=
]e -
§C
]T\N
&
)
"
g,! +-)O,"
[!2
!5)t=(!!&:9
^ )-c
")
(+
#6W4+[|
a)?8d)! -22 )-)J9(I=WZ)Og=+ ,d,
@WN
+
I
"((
^)G
([
"!
H2)E)O1
B"+=+ ,d,
6w4W
!=!j=W(+=8jqF!8"
)O1Bd)@cN
H"
[!2
!5)
-)2"!
<>#-) Pj) !\"
+ZK5! 2)OI4
8d#!*)1!8d)Bj *!(2#@9N
2d
5)!U)8=;
\*,!e#O"
:=( ! +-
S
("(
6#U)G=W<
(!>=8j."
+
T
!d
>+
P[
f
Y=;
5U*, )f)O;= ,d9
g)>
!f 8"#"!
cTP"
>+U)=9j>= ,d9
6)=8jIjGO_ "!Ic >"
+
4
1#O&)
!*3")@3
9(
:d
+
3"J2,
=8j "
+Zb3h,2,)"
28")i?j8[
5)
N
"J!832"
,&@N
J
(!29(8
Z).
"((
?!$2)
!*).
")
6
T!
q
!24+ .-(#?(
AlY)!mY? -(+)N(
Elup)(+ #$= -)\mT)q4+
B"
a
([
"(
El_
") U)
)6(4;m@e1/
5)&6eq) -)P"
#ON" )z)ON"
+/)9")
I)
*)!4W2I2)5)-Y
34))w8d#"
69
4;PK53 /)
@9iZ!*)
1#44 !U# +
f/U)
U)
69) 45)
cTP"
Hs4; 8"
g
=; !>"
N!!#"()6t
\:"
N=(
B"
)O"
J)!-P"
@9N
.
(P"
T=+") E=9j/"
J)5#!j,
!
Y)O"
. )A
B" =(+ ).)
8
T!
"
$4
8j,
)1#-2" U#Nd
5)"#"!
"!
2)O^"
$+
+)9
@Y^"
k#"
5)]6+"
.24+(+d# +
Y)O8")3) +
Y)O"E U#E H
dt" ) Pj K5P"^4= t
"
J ,U#& *7@J44W)
q
,$)Oc
!(+"!T
+ d
q4+,
Z
!>(Pd)(
!jA# &"
+
,
:)OJxtY)"!&@,N
1
(+j2A))2!3)
T) !\2"J"
Y
Z *#)?)OS"
+
2"
,&@545)
)
3/#JTP"
E"
J"
+$)Of4[|s
B"8Z
(" )&6 4!8"
A"
+GR}k~JYH,#@
D IDS}$) V9(
J}q#0+!:>-)H)4+45) 76\2U)!V9(:+[-(+ #6t+" G
f8d)"
6
8")
3
(Oo# V9(
6x4)9")!8")65-)!^!*,!u@
C= u e
u ¡
ko
+ w¢c£1¤ K`¡ ^K u
¥ u e u _¦ #65§2U*)9(JGU*,
6x¨¨+©\>?
Zs