Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chapter 4 Dispute Resolution: 1. A. B. C. D. Ans: C PTS: 1 DIF: Easy REF: 75 BLM: Remember 2
Chapter 4 Dispute Resolution: 1. A. B. C. D. Ans: C PTS: 1 DIF: Easy REF: 75 BLM: Remember 2
MULTIPLE CHOICE
9. Dante is a senior risk manager who has been assigned the task of
determining the viability of obtaining an enforceable remedy regarding the
non-payment of a customer’s account. Which of the following questions
must initially be answered in the positive in order for Dante to proceed
further?
a. If litigation is successful, will the
offending party’s assets satisfy
the judgment?
b. Is the offending party willing to
negotiate a compromise in good
faith?
c. Does the significance of the
dispute justify the expenditure of
time and resources?
d. What priority will the offending
party give to providing an
effective negotiator?
ANS: A PTS: 1 DIF: ChallengingREF: 89
BLM: Analyze
14. Which of the following would be a valid criticism of the use of arbitration
clauses in contracts between investment brokers and their clients?
a. A code of conduct includes
legislated procedures for
resolving consumer complaints.
b. Clients are unable to ensure the
independence and expertise of a
suggested arbitrator.
c. Arbitration firms favour brokers
and deny the clients due process.
d. An arbitration procedure requires
clients to pay a fee to have their
complaint remedied.
ANS: C PTS: 1 DIF: Medium REF: 80
BLM: Evaluate
15. What is the role of common law and statue law with regard to the litigation
of a commercial dispute?
a. Both provide a source of the
objective rules applicable to the
disputed matter.
b. Each provides a source of the
substantive rules applicable to
the contested matter.
c. Both provide rules governing the
legal foundation for determining
how trials proceed.
d. Each contains rules that
determine what the process
leading up to trial will be.
ANS: B PTS: 1 DIF: Medium REF: 82
BLM: Understand
17. What difference between litigation in Canada and litigation in the United
States causes concern for Canadian companies that do business in the U.S.
marketplace?
a. American lawyers are not usually
trained in the same way as
Canadian lawyers are.
b. Unlike in Canada, most U.S.
jurisdictions do not require a
losing party to pay a portion of
the winner’s costs.
c. Unlike in Canada, most U.S.
jurisdictions have not embraced
alternative dispute resolution as
a means for resolving disputes.
d. Unlike in Canada, most U.S.
jurisdictions do not have
limitation periods that restrict
plaintiffs from suing after the
passage of a considerable
amount of time.
ANS: B PTS: 1 DIF: ChallengingREF: 90
BLM: Evaluate
20. Davey Jones Law Offices acts as legal counsel to a large commercial client.
The client has instructed Mr. Jones to prepare and file a litigation claim
naming a competitor as the opposing party in the lawsuit. What title is
given to Davey Jones’s client in the initiating document?
a. respondent
b. petitioner
c. plaintiff
d. defendant
ANS: C PTS: 1 DIF: Easy REF: 85
BLM: Understand
21. Davey Jones Law Firm has filed a claim with the court on behalf of its
client, naming Gaston’s Commercial Fabricators Inc., as the opposing party.
What title is given to Gaston’s in the initiating document?
a. plaintiff
b. defendant
c. respondent
d. petitioner
ANS: B PTS: 1 DIF: Easy REF: 85
BLM: Understand
22. NoTangles Wireless Connections Inc. enters the details required on the
claim form provided by the small claims court: each party’s name and
address, the nature of the dispute, and the claim amount of $25,050. Why
will the court clerk refuse to register NoTangles’s claim?
a. the jurisdiction’s small claims
court dollar limit is $2,500
b. the amount claimed exceeds the
court’s jurisdiction
c. the court lacks jurisdiction to
hear commercial disputes
d. all litigation claims must be filed
by law firms
ANS: B PTS: 1 DIF: Medium REF: 84
BLM: Analyze
25. What is the role of the pleadings stage of the litigation process?
a. to allow time for the parties to
plead the basis of their case
before a judge
b. to prepare a document
containing the allegations
supporting the claim
c. to allow time for the defendant to
concede and allow default
judgment
d. to facilitate the exchange of
formal documents stating the
basis of the suit
ANS: D PTS: 1 DIF: Medium REF: 85
BLM: Analyze
26. Sian has been named in a lawsuit alleging a large balance owed on an
automobile lease. Sian believes the contract was voided when the
vehicle’s motor ceased operating the day after signing the lease
agreement. Sian is still owed the compensation the dealership promised to
pay her as reimbursement of the towing cost to have the vehicle returned
to the dealership after it broke down. If Sian wants to avoid a default
judgment and recover her losses, how should she proceed?
a. issue a request for a discovery of
documents
b. issue a request for a pretrial
conference
c. immediately file a defence and
counterclaim
d. file a statement of claim based
on her losses
ANS: C PTS: 1 DIF: Medium REF: 85
BLM: Evaluate
27. John is hoping for an opportunity to settle his lawsuit based on the
strength of his evidence before an actual trial takes place. How should he
instruct his lawyer to proceed with respect to the litigation process?
a. undertake the informal pre-trial
discovery of evidence process
b. complete formal discovery
involving the disclosure of
supporting evidence
c. file formal evidence for
presentation to the judiciary to
support a claim
d. initiate the informal disclosure
process of all supporting
evidence
ANS: B PTS: 1 DIF: ChallengingREF: 85
BLM: Evaluate
28. What is a counterclaim?
a. It formally sets out judiciary
evidence filed to counter the
plaintiff’s claim.
b. It documents the response to a
defence claimed by the
countering party.
c. It documents the claim for loss
filed against the party initiating
the process.
d. It formally sets out facts to be
relied in defence against the
plaintiff’s claim.
ANS: C PTS: 1 DIF: ChallengingREF: 85
BLM: Analyze
31. In addition to setting out the details of who must pay how much to whom,
which of the following is required in a court’s decision in a civil case?
a. The court’s account of events
and application of relevant case
law.
b. The identification of relevant
legal guidelines for interpretation
of contracts.
c. Appropriate justification based on
the evidence and legal rules.
d. Details about the provincial
jurisdictions where enforcement
is possible.
ANS: C PTS: 1 DIF: ChallengingREF: 87
BLM: Understand
32. The Ultimate Caterer Inc. did not fare well in court. In addition to damages,
the company was ordered to pay costs to the young couple whose
wedding dinner left them and many of their guests very ill. Which of the
following correctly describes the meaning of costs in these circumstances?
a. the legal fees incurred by the
defendant in a lawsuit
b. the amount the loser must pay
toward the winner’s expenses
c. the legal fees incurred by the
plaintiff in a lawsuit
d. the amount of court fees charged
for litigating the lawsuit
ANS: B PTS: 1 DIF: Medium REF: 87
BLM: Understand
33. What litigation term is used to describe the party that has a judgment
registered against them?
a. judgment indebted
b. the judgment creditor
c. judgment proof
d. the judgment debtor
ANS: D PTS: 1 DIF: Medium REF: 89
BLM: Understand
34. For how long, and under what circumstances, would a losing party’s
personal income and other assets such as land, houses, and vehicles be at
risk?
a. for as long as 20 years in some
provinces, to satisfy the payment
of a judgment
b. for as long as 20 years in some
provinces, beginning on the
dissolution of a partnership
c. for up to a 10-year period in
cases of commercial bankruptcy
d. for up to a 10-year period in
cases of corporate insolvency
ANS: A PTS: 1 DIF: Medium REF: 89
BLM: Understand
36. Martha’s lawyer is not satisfied with the court’s decision, so he is urging
her not to accept it. What step in the litigation process is Martha’s lawyer
recommending she take?
a. appeal
b. adjudication
c. litigation
d. ADR
ANS: A PTS: 1 DIF: Easy REF: 89
BLM: Understand
37. What term is given to the losing party who will be filing an appeal within
30 days of the date of a trial court’s decision?
a. defendant
b. appellant
c. petitioner
d. respondent
ANS: B PTS: 1 DIF: Easy REF: 89
BLM: Remember
TRUE/FALSE
7. Procedural rules dictate how a claim is carried through the civil justice
system.
10. The filing and service of a defence is part of the pleadings stage of a legal
action.
11. The party ordered by the court to pay a specified amount to a winner of a
lawsuit is known as a judgment debtor.
12. A commercial business should seek to manage the risk of loss by securing
a basic coverage insurance policy with a reputable insurance company.
13. If a debt owed by a customer is not large and the customer is in financial
difficulty, negotiating a payment plan or even writing off the debt may be
more practical than spending money to try to collect on the account.
15. It is unusual and not advisable for the defendant to insist that a
confidentiality clause be incorporated into a settlement agreement or
release.
17. One of the most important factors to be considered when deciding whether
to proceed with a litigation of a conflict that failed to be remedied through
negotiation is whether the business can devote the necessary resources to
proceed with the dispute.
18. According to the rules provided for under the Arbitration Act, an
arbitrator’s binding decision may be referred for appeal before a judge
presiding in a superior court.
SHORT ANSWER
ANS:
Negotiation is a tool that business owners and managers use to assess,
evaluate, and develop resolutions to legal disputes on a relatively informal
and inexpensive basis. The process of negotiation is not governed by
technical rules, which allows the process to operate in whatever way the
parties wish in order to solve their problem. Negotiation should occur at
the senior management level, and legal advice will be required. In order
for a negotiated resolution or settlement to be reached, all parties must
agree to a compromise and negotiate in good faith.
PTS: 1 DIF: Medium REF: 75-78 BLM: Remember
2. Identify the party on whom the burden of proof rests with respect to a trial
of a commercial dispute. Briefly explain what satisfying the burden of proof
will entail in the trial process, how the opposing party is entitled to respond
at this stage, and what is required of the judge presiding over the litigation
of the matter.
ANS:
At trial, the burden of proof falls on the plaintiff, who must formally
introduce evidence according to established rules to prove its case on the
balance of probabilities. To satisfy this requirement, the plaintiff must
provide that there is a better than 50 percent chance that the
circumstances of the contract are as it has contended they are. The
plaintiff must also prove that it is entitled to receive the compensation it
has claimed to be entitled to. The defendant has the opportunity to
challenge the plaintiff’s witnesses and documents and to introduce its own
account of events to oppose the claim. The judge must decide what
happened between the parties and whether their claims are justified. Once
the facts have been established, the judge will then consider and apply the
relevant case law to arrive at a decision.
3. Discuss what a class action lawsuit is, including a brief description of the
requirements that must be met under legislation passed in some provincial
jurisdictions that would enable a class action law suit. Also include a brief
explanation of how a determination is made as to whether a class action
may proceed in a province that has not passed specific legislation
governing the process.
ANS:
A class action is a lawsuit launched by one person representing a larger
group whose members have similar claims against the same defendant.
Generally, the legislation enables a class action to be certified or approved
by the court if the class can be clearly defined, there are common issues of
fact or law, success for one class member means success for all, and the
proposed representative adequately reflects the common interests of class
members. In provinces without class action legislation, class actions may
be allowed to proceed based on similar common law criteria.
ANS:
Alternative dispute resolution offers a number of advantages to parties in a
business relationship:
i) the parties control the process
ii) the parties control the selection of the facilitator
iii) the facilitator is typically chosen based on expertise in the disputed
subject
iv) the process is faster and less expensive than litigation
v) the outcome of the process can be kept confidential
5. How does a person who wins a case in civil court actually collect on the
judgment? What limitations are there on his/her ability to collect?
ANS:
After the judge makes the judgment and order, the judgment creditor (i.e.,
winner) is allowed to take enforcement proceedings against the judgment
debtor (i.e., loser). Depending on the jurisdiction, a court official or other
public official (e.g., the sheriff) will proceed against the assets of the
judgment debtor. Assets that can be seized include all types of personal
property and real property, subject to legislative limitations that protect
the judgment debtor from being left destitute as a result. If the judgment is
not fully satisfied, it remains on the books and can be enforced later if the
judgment debtor’s financial circumstances change.
ANS:
Electronic documents can be very useful in that they can be easier to
access, organize, and distribute. However, it can also be very challenging
to locate electronic documents that may be relevant as well as to control
them.
7. Identify and briefly describe matters that will influence the best courses of
action a business may choose to take with respect to dispute resolution.
Include an indication of the key element involved in approaching this
process.
ANS:
The best courses of action with respect to the approach a business should
take to dispute resolution will be influenced by the following:
i) the objectives each party has in relation to a particular dispute
ii) the attitudes of the parties: are they interested in a resolution or in
making a point?
iii) the amount of money that is at stake
iv) the resources the parties are prepared to devote to the dispute
v) risk analysis and cost-benefit analysis of prolonging the dispute
vi) the nature of the relationship between the parties
8. Identify the stages of a lawsuit and briefly describe the parties who would
typically be involved.
ANS:
There are four stages of a lawsuit:
i) pleadings
ii) discovery
iii) trial and decision
iv) enforcement
The parties typically involved in a lawsuit are the plaintiff, who is the party
initiating the lawsuit against another party, and the defendant, the party
being sued.