Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Wearable Antennas For Medical Application: A Review
Wearable Antennas For Medical Application: A Review
Wearable Antennas For Medical Application: A Review
Application: A Review
Abstract Wearable devices for monitoring different biological signals are now
gaining huge interest now a day. Use of textile material as substrate material for
antenna design is growing rapidly. In order to reduce the effect of human body the
performance of antenna several different antenna structures have been proposed.
This article reveals research on different designs and development of wearable
antennas for biomedical application at different frequency bands.
1 Introduction
In 2003 author of [1] have presented smart cloth made of fabric material. The
substrate of the antenna is made of low cost fleece fabric. The radiating element and
ground plane is made up of knitted copper. The length and width of the antenna is
56 and 51 mm respectively. Dielectric constant of the material at 2.45 GHz is 1.04.
The ground plane dimensions are 76 mm 71 mm. Substrate thickness is 3 mm.
The antenna is flexible to operate in different frequency bands.
In 2004 authors of [2] have presented a circularly polarized textile antenna for
wearable applications. The proposed antenna Fig. 1 uses single inset microstrip
feed line. Circular polarization is achieved through truncated corners and single slit
in patch. Polymide spacer of 6 mm thickness is used as substrate material. Its
permittivity is 1.15 at 2.4 GHz. Nickel plated woven textile is used for patch and
the ground plane. Nickel has high resistance in contradiction of oxidation as well as
corrosion. The antenna structure including the patch and the ground plane were
mounted to the spacer fabric by means of textile based on ammonia. The SMA jack
was electrically connected to two-component glue which is conductive.
In 2005, authors of [3] presented a study on the design, simulation and evalu-
ation of wearable antennas. The antenna operates with a centre frequency of
868 MHz. Substrate material used here is glass epoxy having relative permittivity
4.8, thickness 1.6 mm. The conducting element used is cooper. The ground plane
limits the backward wave towards the wearer. In 2006, authors of [4] have
presented small low cost printed antenna operating at frequency less than 1 GHz.
The proposed antenna is tested to operate at 430 MHz. It is co planner waveguide
fed to provide uni-planner solution. Proposed antenna, shown in Fig. 2 provides
near omnidirectional pattern with 5% band width. The proposed structure is shown
in Fig. 2. The overall size of the antenna is 4.5″ 3″. The total length of the slot
given is 29″, width is 6 mm and gap between adjacent slots is 3 mm. Material used
for antenna is 1.6 mm thick FR4.
In the year 2006 [5] author Sanz-Izquierdo et al. presented wearable button
antenna (Figs. 3 and 4) for WLAN application. The antenna operates at 2.4 and
5 GHz with omni-directional radiation pattern.
Table 1 depicts the different dimensions of proposed small size wearable button
antenna.
In the year 2007 [6] author Kim et al. presented embedded UHF RFID tag
antenna. The antenna has been designed using flexible thread or textile material.
T matching method is used for the impedance matching between tag antenna and
RFID chip. The size of the proposed antenna is about 120 9 mm.
In 2009 author of [7] presented flexible wearable antennas operating between
100 MHz and 1 GHz. Three antenna designs are considered here spiral (Fig. 5),
bowtie (Fig. 6), and broadband wire dipole. The broadband wire dipole can cover
the frequencies, from 100 to 250 MHz. This element consists of a wire dipole with
lumped loads placed in each arm to produce a broadband antenna. The spiral and
bowtie both are capable of covering the band from 250 to 800 MHz. Scaled ver-
sions of the spiral and bowtie can cover higher bands as required. These antennas
were designed using finite difference time domain (FDTD) tool.
Wearable Antennas for Medical Application: A Review 119
antenna was tested in five different bending angles 20°, 30°, 40°, 45°, 60°.
Simulation result shows that −10 dB bandwidth spans from less than 3.1 to
10.6 GHz and hence covers whole UWB frequency band for any bending positions.
In [9] authors have proposed smart cloths. Antenna is designed using textile
material. The proposed antenna is a circular patch of radius 26.3 mm (shown in
Fig. 7) with a rectangular ground plane. Substrate material used here is indigo
jeans. Permittivity is calculated by experimental method and the value is 1.67 and
loss tangent 0.03. Thickness of the substrate used here is 2.84 mm. The proposed
antenna resonates at frequency of 2.45 GHz.
Lee et al. of [10] presented electrically coupled LC (ELC) resonator resonating at
2.45 GHz. The designed antenna used two layered substrate (FR4, with relative
permittivity 4.4). These substrates have thickness of 1.6 and 0.8 mm respectively.
The area of the patch is 27.8 mm2. The resonant frequency achieved here is
2.45 GHz. The designed antenna has been tested on a body model of size
200 200 50 mm3. The body model is having electrical properties like: per-
mittivity of 52.7, conductivity 1.95 S/m and loss tangent 0.27. The SAR value of
the designed antenna when placed on flat body model is obtained as 0.005 W/kg.
Joshi et al. of [11] presented polyester substrate based microstrip patch antenna
using inter digital capacitor and rectangular stub for wireless body area network
applications. The antenna is fabricated using copper tape and polyester substrate.
The designed antenna resonates at 2.45 GHz with bandwidth 40 MHz and gain of
5 dBi. The dimension of the rectangular patch is 30 mm 4 mm, substrate
thickness 3.14 mm, permittivity of 1.39 and loss tangent 0.01. The proposed
antenna has been simulated using IE3D.
Sabban of [12] in his paper presented compact dual polarized microstrip antenna
with high gain (0–2 dBi) at 434 MHz. The proposed antenna has dimension of
5 5 0.05 cm3. Authors of [13] have presented CPW fed rectangular monopole
patch antenna for wearable applications operating at 2.45 GHz (ISM band). The
ground plane and patch of the antenna is made up of graphene and carbon
Wearable Antennas for Medical Application: A Review 121
frequency. Simulations are carried out in HFSS platform. Results show a return loss
of −16.69 and −15.53 dB for the designed antennas respectively. Vatankhah et al.
of [18] proposed in their report a compact antenna which is capacitively fed using
inverted L shape feed for wearable wireless sensors. The antenna operates at 2.4–
6.4 GHz band. The total size of the sensor and the elevated antenna is 35 mm
22 mm 9 mm. The proposed antenna is designed using FR4 substrate with full
ground plane at the bottom and microstrip feed line at the top. A large via is created
in the middle to connect the feed line with SMA connector for antenna parameter
measurement. Jiang of [19] presented co-designed filtering antenna which is cir-
cularly polarized. The proposed antenna composed of patch radiator and bandpass
filter. The patch in this case functions as both the radiator and last stage resonator of
the filter. The filtering circuit not only provides frequency discrimination but also
performances as impedance matching circuit. Figures 10 and 11 depicts the pro-
posed antenna. The antenna operates in the frequency range of 3.77–4.26 GHz. The
proposed antenna is designed as a square patch truncated at corners on the top and
planner strip line microwave circuit at the bottom. As the antenna operates in close
vicinity to human body, the strip line shape isolates the band pass resonators from
the loading effect of human tissue.
124 S. Manna et al.
Jose and Kappan of [20] in their paper presented UWB wearable textile antenna
with coplanar waveguide feed shown in Fig. 12. Coplanar feed is used to provide
the antenna a uniplanar structure.
The antenna operates in the band of 3.1–10.6 GHz. The antenna is made-up on
jeans substrate having relative permittivity 1.9. Conductive patch is designed using
copper. Artificial magnetic conductor (AMC) is used at the back side of the antenna
to give high gain over the entire range of operation. It provides high gain and
reflection of the back lobes of back lobes. It acts as high impedance ground surface.
Velan et al. of [21] presented in their report a dual band fractal monopole
antenna. The patch antenna is combined with electromagnetic band gap arrange-
ment. The prototype antenna covers the GSM band of 1800 MHz and ISM band of
2.45 GHz. The EBG substrate creates a barrier for radiation into human body, also
reduces the effect of frequency shifting due to human body.
Figure 13 represents the proposed fractal design of the monopole antenna. Here
also the antenna is fabricated on jeans substrate having dielectric constant 1.7 and
loss tangent 0.085. The antenna is backed with a EBG substrate of 150 150 mm2
dimension. For the whole frequency band the EBG substrate acts as band reject
filter. The result is also analyzed under bending condition of the proposed antenna.
SAR of the prototype is measured using three layer model of human body.
The SAR value at 1.8 GHz with EBG is 0.024 and without EBG is 5.77 W/kg. At
2.45 GHz, the corresponding SAR values are 0.016 and 6.62 W/kg. Using EBG
structure a significant reduction in SAR has been obtained in both the bands.
Wearable Antennas for Medical Application: A Review 125
3 Conclusion
Ref. Author and year Method used for size reduction Size Frequency of Dielectric Dielectric
No. operation material used constant
[1] Salonen and High frequency operation and use of Patch is 56 mm 51 mm, Flexible to operate at Textile 1.04 at
Hurme (2003) textile material Ground plane is different frequency 2.45 GHz
76 mm 71 mm bands
[2] Klemm et al. Truncated corner along with single slit Patch width 48 mm, length 2.29–2.36 GHz, Spacer fabric 1.15 at
(2004) in patch and single inset microstrip 5 mm, feed width 14 mm center textile 2.4 GHz
feed line frequency 2.32 GHz
[3] Noury et al. Introducing input stub Antenna length and width both Centre frequency Glass epoxy 4.8
(2005) are 86.4 mm, thickness 868 MHz
1.6 mm
[4] Waterhouse et al. Coplanner waveguide fed meander line 4.5 in. 3 in. Centre frequency FR4 4.4
(2006) slot 430 MHz
[5] Sanz et al. Cylindrical structure Standard denim button size Dual band of 2.4 and Velcro 1.37
(2006) 5 GHz substrate of
1.8 mm thick
[7] Mathews et al. Bowtie structure, Spiral structure Standard size Band of 250– Nylon, liquid 2.9
(2009) 800 MHz crystal
polymer
[8] Sagor et al. Coplanner waveguide fed UWB 6 mm 16 mm 0.068 mm 3.1–10.6 GHz Liquid crystal 2.9
(2009) antenna polymer
[9] Sankaralingam Circular disk structure Radius 26.3 mm 2.45 GHz Indigo jeans 1.67 at
et al. (2009) cotton fabric 2.45 GHz
[24] Fang et al. Rectangular spiral patch Patch width 4 mm 402–406 MHz Patch-Cu, 10.2
(2011) Diele.-Roger
RO 3210
(continued)
S. Manna et al.
Table 3 (continued)
Ref. Author and year Method used for size reduction Size Frequency of Dielectric Dielectric
No. operation material used constant
[25] Duan et al. Rectangular Spiral patch 27 mm 14 mm 1.27 mm 433.9–542.4 MHz Roger 6010 10.2
(2012)
[26] Kiourti et al. vertically stacked circular structure 6 mm radius ground plane, 402–406 MHz, 902– Roger 3210 10.2
(2012) two 5 mm radius meandered 928 MHz
patch
[27] Wnuk et al. Truncated corners 51.262 mm 51.262 mm 1.8 GHz Roger RT 2.6
(2012)
[11] Joshi et al. Inter digital capacitor and rectangular 0.213 ʎ 0.246 ʎ 2.45 GHz Polyster cloth 1.39
(2013) stub
[28] Sagor et al. Cu radiating patch 6 mm 16 mm 0.068 mm 3.1–10.6 GHz Liquid crystal 2.9
(2013) polymer
[29] Dwibedi (2013) Symmetric L shaped arms are joined 90 mm 90 mm 1.31–3.21 GHz Bed sheet 1.8
together fabric
[15] Mondol et al. Split ring shaped slot is designed 18.11 mm 18.11 mm Centre frequency Transparent 2.8
Wearable Antennas for Medical Application: A Review
Ref. Author and year Method used for size reduction Size Frequency of Dielectric Dielectric
No. operation material used constant
[21] Velan et al. Electromagnetic band gap structure 150 mm 150 mm 1800 MHz and Jean fabric 1.7
(2015) 2.45 GHz
[22] Agarwal et al. Use of Artificial Magnetic Conductor 50 mm 50 mm 2.4 GHz Latex 3.31
(2016)
[23] Jiang et al. Truncated anisotropic metasurface 50 mm 50 mm 2.4 GHz PDMS 2.8
(2016)
S. Manna et al.
Wearable Antennas for Medical Application: A Review 129
References
1. Salonen, P., Hurme, H.: A novel fabric WLAN antenna for wearable applications. In: Antenna
and Propagation Society International Symposium, IEEE (2003)
2. Klemm, M., Locher, I., Troster, G.: A novel circularly polarized textile antenna for wearable
applications. In: European Conference on wireless technology, Amsterdam, (2004)
3. Noury, N., Barralon, P., Flammarion, D.: Preliminary results on the study of Smart Wearable
Antenna. In: Proceedings of the IEEE (2005)
4. Waterhouse, R., Novak, D.: Small uniplanar antenna suitable for body wearable applications.
In: IEEE Military Communication Conference (2006)
5. Sanz-Izquierdo, B., Huang, F., Batchelor, J.C.: Small size wearable button antenna. EuCAP
(2006)
6. Kim, Y., Lee, K., Kim, Y., Chung, Y.C.: Wearable UHF RFID tag antenna design using flexible
electro thread and textile. In: IEEE Antennas and Propagation Society Symposium (2007)
7. Matthews, J.G.G., Pettitt, G.: Development of flexible, wearable antennas. In: 3rd European
Conference on Antenna and Propagation (2009)
8. Sagor, M.H., Abbasi, Q.H., Alomainy, A., Hao, Y.: Compact conformal ultra-wideband antenna
for wearable applications. In: 5th European Conference on Antennas and Propagation (2009)
9. Sankaralingam, S., Gupta, B.: A circular disk microstrip WLAN antenna for wearable
applications. In: IEEE India Conference (2009)
10. Lee, S., Kim, U., Kwon, K., Seo, W., Choi, J.: Design of on-body antenna for wireless body
area network. In: Advance Communication Technology (ICACT), pp. 300–303 (2012)
11. Joshi, J.G., Pattnaik, S.S.: Polyester based wearable microstrip patch antenna. In: IEEE
conference (2013)
12. Sabban, A.: New wideband printed antennas for medical application. IEEE Trans. Antennas
Propag. 61(1), 84–91 (2013)
13. Mansor, M.M., Rahim, S.K.A., Hashim, U.: A CPW-fed 2.45 GHz wearable antenna using
conductive nanomaterials for on-body applications. In: IEEE Region 10 Symposium (2014)
14. Lim, E.G., Wang, Z., Wang, J.C., Leach, M., Zhou, R., Lei, C.-U., Man, K.L.: Wearable
Textile Substrate patch antennas. Eng. Lett. 22:2, EL_22_2_08 (2014)
15. Mondol, B., Chatterjee, A., Parui, S.K.: A wearable button antenna with FSS superstrate for
WLAN health care applications. In: RF and Wireless Technologies for Biomedical and
Healthcare Applications (IMWS-Bio), IEEE (2014)
16. Hammoodi, A.I., Al-Rizzo, H.M., Isaac, A.A.: A wearable dual-band square slot antenna with
stub for ISM and WiMAX applications. In: IEEE Conference (2015)
17. Shubair, R.M., AlShamsi, A.M., Khalaf, K., Kiourti, A.: Novel miniature wearable microstrip
antennas for ISM-band biomedical telemetry. In: Loughborough Antennas & Propagation
Conference (LAPC) (2015)
18. Varnoosfaderani, M.V., Thiel, D.V., Lu, J.: A wideband capacitively fed suspended plate
antenna for wearable wireless sensors. In: International Symposium on Antenna and
Propagation, IEEE (2015)
19. Jiang, Z.H., Werner, D.H.: A compact, wideband circularly polarized co-designed filtering
antenna and its application for wearable devices with low SAR. IEEE Trans. Antenna Propag.
63, 3808–3818 (2015)
20. Jose, A., Kappan, S.J.: High gain coplanar feed ultra-wide band wearable antenna using
artificial magnetic conductor. In: Fifth International Conference on Advances in Computing
and Communications, IEEE (2015)
21. Velan, S., Sundarsingh, E.F., Kanagasabai, M., Sarma, A.K., Raviteja, C., Sivasamy, R.,
Pakkathillam, J.K.: Dual band EBG integrated monopole antenna deploying fractal geometry
for wearable applications. IEEE Antennas Wireless Propag. Lett. 14, 249–252 (2015)
22. Agarwal, K., Guo, Y.-X., Salam, B.: Wearable AMC backed near end-fire antenna for on
body communications on latex substrate. In: IEEE Transactions on Components, Packaging
and Manufacturing Technology (2016)
130 S. Manna et al.
23. Jiang, Z.H., Werner, D.H.: A compact and robust circularly polarized wearable antenna using
an anisotropic metasurface. In: IEEE/ACES International Conference on Wireless Information
Technology and Systems (ICWITS) and Applied Computational Electromagnetics (ACES)
(2016)
24. Fang, Q., Lee, S.Y., Parmana, H., Ghorbani, K., Cosic, I.: Developing a wireless implantable
body sensor network in MICS band. IEEE Trans. Inf. Technol. Biomed. 15(4), 567–576
(2011)
25. Duan, Z., Guo, Y.X., Xue, R.F., Je, M., Kwong, D.L.: Differentially fed dual band
implantable antenna for biomedical applications. IEEE Trans. Antennas Propag. 60(12),
5587–5595 (2012)
26. Kiourti, A., Nikita, K.S.: Miniature scalp implantable antennas for telemetry in MICS and
ISM bands: design, safety considerations and link budget analysis. IEEE Trans. Antennas
Propag. 60(8), 3568–3575 (2012)
27. Wnuk, M., Bugaj, M., Przesmycki, R., Nowosielski, L., Piwowarczyk, K.: Wearable antenna
constructed in microstrip technology. In: Progress in Electromagnetics Research Symposium
Proceedings (2012)
28. Sagor, M.H., Abbasi, Q.H., Alomainy, A., Hao, Y.: Compact and conformal ultra wideband
antenna for wearable applications. In: EuCAP (2013)
29. Dwibedi, K., Patel, P., Poonkuzhali, R., Thiripurasundari, D., Alex, Z.C.: Dual band CPW fed
wearable monopole antenna. In: ICT (2013)
30. Chisca, S., Sava, I., Musteata, V.E., Bruma, M.: Dielectric and conduction properties of
polymide films. In: CAS 2011 Proceedings (2011 International Semiconductor Conference),
pp. 253–256, IEEE (2011)