Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mixed Use Litrature (3rd Yea) R
Mixed Use Litrature (3rd Yea) R
e vi e w
r atu re R
L it e
w Simachew
By-Misgana
/08
ARC/R/035
Submitted to - Amanuel
- Assebe and
By- Misganaw S. 1 - Thitina
Date 26/2/2010 Ec
2017
Table of contents
Introduction-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------1
site planning----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------4
Building Placement--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------4
Street Orientation----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------5
Parking Orientation-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------6
Site Amenities------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 7
Building Height-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------10
General conciderations---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------18
Referances------------------------------------------------22
By- Misganaw S. 1
2017
MIXED-USE DEVELOPMENT
Introduction
Mixed use development is defined as:
-A mixed-use development is a real estate project with planned integration of some combination of
retail, office, residential, hotel, recreation or otherfunctions. It is pedestrian-oriented and contains
elements of a live-work-playenvironment. It maximizes space usage, has amenities and architectural
expression and tends to mitigate traffic and sprawl (Niemira, 2007).
-Development which comprises a mixture of two or more land uses, either comprised
within a single building (horizontally or vertically) or multiple buildings of different uses
with in a distinct development site.
The primary design issue related to mixed-use projects is the need to successfully balance the
requirements of residential uses, such as the need for privacy and security, with the needs of
commercial uses for access, visibility, parking, loading, and possibly extended hours of operation.
1. Types of mixed-use
There are two basic types of mixed-use with residential projects;
- 1;T he first type is vertical mixed-use, which is typified by residential use over commercial uses in
the same
building.
-2; The second, called horizontal mixed use, combines residential and commercial uses
on the same site, but in separate buildings.
1, 1 vertically mixed use
A vertical mixed use building contains a mix of residential and commercial uses. Typically,
commercial uses (i.e. retail shops, restaurants, offices) are located on the ground floor, while
residential units (condominiums or apartments) are located on upper levels. Below, are some
examples of a vertical mixed use building:
.
Fig. 1
Example of
vertically mixed
use
By- Misganaw S. 1
2017
The
Benefits
of
Mixed
use
Benefits
to the
Developer/ Investor:
• An adaptable building product which, subject to the necessary planning and building
requirements, contains flexibility to change uses
• The opportunity to offer ‘green developments’ that use environmentally efficient materials and
designs
• Quicker take up rates of both residential and commercial/ retail tenancies due to tenants residing
and working within the same building creating efficiencies
Social benefit
•Pedestrian Friendly
•Social Connectivity
•Civic Amenities/ Spaces
•Public Safety
Economic benefit
•Shared Public Infrastructure
•Shared Parking
•Higher Rents/ ROI
Environmental benefit
•Less Auto-dependent
•Focused Density (vs Sprawl)
•Supports Transit
Requirements for mixed use buildings
- Must have a mix of uses
By- Misganaw S. 2
2017
By- Misganaw S. 3
2017
3 site
planning
The design
of each
mixed-use
project site
shall
contribute
to the
evolving
sense of
place and
character in
the City of
Antioch.
Site
planning
guide lines
consider
the internal
organization of a development project and the external relationship with the public right-of-way and
other projects.
3.1 Building Placement
One of the most important elements of new mixed-use development is the way the project is integrated
physically and functionally into the public realm. Properly executed building placement and
orientation can enliven adjacent public spaces, encourage pedestrian activity, and strengthen the link
between
businesses and residences.
A, Buildings shall be constructed near or along the front property line(s). A “zero setback” from the
front property line(s) is encouraged.
B. Variations in the zero setback from the property line(s) may be appropriate when the resulting
setback provides greater accommodation for pedestrian circulation, sidewalk dining areas, enhanced
entries, and improves the pedestrian realm.
C. When a front setback is necessary, a majority of the setback shall be hard scaped with limited
landscaping to accommodate uses that keep the public realm active, such as outdoor dining and
seating.
D. Create a dynamic, uninterrupted pedestrian zone by avoiding excessive side yard setbacks between
buildings. A zero setback from the side property line(s) is encouraged wherever possible.
E. At least 30 percent of the linear frontage on a major arterial (excluding driveways and pedestrian
connections) shall be designed in order to accommodate pedestrian-oriented, neighborhood serving
commercial uses. The minimum interior depth of these commercial spaces shall be 25 feet.
By- Misganaw S. 4
2017
.Fig;
Outdoor
furniture
clearly
signals
Street Orientation
Mixed-use buildings shall be sited and oriented so that the primary commercial building entry is
located along the public sidewalk, which is the main pedestrian route.
The main pedestrian access point to the building shall be located along the facade that is oriented to
the primary street.
Buildings on corner lots shall have the primary entry facing the intersection. Corner entries help create
an active public realm and reinforce significant street and sidewalk intersections.
Entries that face the primary street shall be directly connected to the street’s sidewalks. Secondary and
residential entrances can be connected to interior courtyards and parking lots.
By- Misganaw S. 5
2017
The most
active
ground
floor uses
such as
storefronts, lobbies, and restaurant dining areas shall front the public sidewalk. Private amenities, such
as courtyards, that are not accessible to the public shall be located within the project site or on upper
floors and not along the street.
For buildings sited on less significant intersections, such as a major arterial and a collector, at least
50% of the side street ground floor elevation shall include storefront design features.
By- Misganaw S. 6
2017
3.3
Parking
Orientation
A well planned circulation system efficiently moves vehicles in a well-defined manner while avoiding
and reducing potential conflicts between pedestrians and vehicles. On-site surface parking between the
front property line and the building is strongly discouraged. Instead, parking shall be located to the
rear of the site in a parking lot, within the building, or in a separate structure.
Vehicular access shall be provided from side streets, adjacent alleys, and parallel streets whenever
possible.
The number of curb cuts for vehicular entry into the site shall be minimized so that pedestrian and
bicycle areas are safe, secure, and passable.
Where possible, rear parking lots shall be designed and located contiguously so vehicles can travel
from one private parking lot to another without having to enter the street. This may be achieved with
reciprocal access agreements.
By- Misganaw S. 7
2017
Consolidation of parking is encouraged to reduce the number of access drives from major roadways.
Shared driveway access is encouraged whenever practical to further reduce vehicle/pedestrian
interactions and safety concerns.
Pedestrians shall have a clear and direct route from on-site parking to the building entry and public
sidewalk system. The circulation path shall be direct, continuous, and free of barriers (e.g., site
equipment, signage, utility poles, etc.).
Any paving pattern, color, and material used to articulate pathways and pedestrian areas shall continue
when driveways intersect with these areas. Where pedestrian circulation paths cross vehicular
circulation paths, a material change, contrasting color, or slightly raised crossing shall be used to
clearly delineate the continuing pedestrian path.
By- Misganaw S. 8
2017
Rooftop
By- Misganaw S. 9
2017
Private outdoor courtyard areas for residents only are strongly encouraged.
Semi-
private
plaza areas
for visitors
shall also be
provided in
areas
adjacent to
the
retail/commercial uses. Semi-private areas shall be centrally located and be designed as courtyards or
outdoor rooms. Outdoor furnishings, community amenities, public gathering spaces, trees, shrubs, and
trellises for shade shall be provided where appropriate.
Mixed-use projects shall include a minimum 10% of public and private open space in the form of
courtyards and plazas. Access shall be provided from both the public right-of-way sidewalk and
ground floor commercial spaces.
All Courtyards and plazas shall be designed and oriented in a way that allows the majority of the space
to have direct sunlight for the duration of the day to eliminate damp, dark corridors for the health and
safety of the pedestrian. Shade trees or other sun-screening elements shall be incorporated in the
design to provide areas of rest and relief from the sun. Focal elements such as sculptures, art,
or water features shall be incorporated into courtyard and plaza design.
By- Misganaw S. 10
2017
Seating
shall be
provided
in the
courtyard/plaza. Where applicable, users shall be provided with a choice between social and quiet
seating.Site Furniture When plazas are adjacent to the public right-of-way, paving and furniture style
shall complement the public streetscape elements and be constructed of durable materials.
Site furniture shall be carefully placed to not create pedestrian/vehicular conflicts. There shall be
adequate circulation space surrounding site furniture. Graffiti resistant material and/or coating and
skateboard deterrents shall be required to retain the furniture’s attractiveness.All outdoor seating areas
shall leave at least five feet of unobstructed pedestrian space and dining furniture and umbrellas in the
public right of way shall be removed and stored inside during hours of non-operation.
Mixed-use projects shall include a minimum 10% of public and private open space in the form of
courtyards and plazas. Access shall be provided from both the public right-of-way sidewalk and
ground floor commercial
spaces.
All Courtyards and plazas shall be designed and oriented in a way that allows the majority of the space
to have direct sunlight for the duration of the day to eliminate damp, dark corridors for the health and
safety of the pedestrian. Shade trees or other sun-screening elements shall be incorporated in the
design to provide areas of rest and relief from the sun.
Focal elements such as sculptures, art, or water features shall be incorporated into courtyard and plaza
design.
Seating shall be provided in the courtyard/plaza. Where applicable, users shall be provided with a
choice between social and quiet seating.
Site Furniture
When plazas are adjacent to the public right-of-way, paving and furniture style shall complement the
public streetscape elements and be constructed of durable materials.
Site furniture shall be carefully placed to not create pedestrian/vehicular conflicts. There shall be
adequate circulation space surrounding site furniture. Graffiti resistant material and/or coating and
skateboard deterrents shall be required to retain the furniture’s attractiveness.All outdoor seating areas
By- Misganaw S. 11
2017
shall leave at least five feet of unobstructed pedestrian space.All outdoor dining furniture and
umbrellas in the public right of way shall be removed and stored inside during hours of non-operation
4 Street Environment and Building Frontage
Mixed-use development is compact in design and efficiently uses the site. Building plans, facades, and
architectural details shall create visual interest at the street level (e.g., staggering the frontage of the
building, recessing doors and windows, providing awnings and canopies for weather protection and
scale, and visually extending interior spaces outside through paving and glazing to create the concept
of an indoor/ outdoor room, etc.)
Projects
located at
intersections shall ensure the design treatments are continued around the corner. Development located
at signalized intersections of major streets shall include pedestrian-oriented, community serving
commercial uses such as a bookstore, coffee shop, or local market. Whenever possible, parcels shall
be consolidated along corridors to ensure a mixed use project is at least 10,000 square feet of ground
floor space. This allows for heightened design criteria, more efficient design, and an improved
pedestrian experience.
By- Misganaw S. 12
2017
Over
By- Misganaw S. 13
2017
6.Building
Height
Building
height
must be
sensitive
to the
context of
the site
and
consider
adjacent
uses.
Three
stories are
preferred
to ensure
sufficient
bulk at a
major
intersection. Additional floors may be considered, depending on individual site considerations and
overall design.
The first floor height to the finished ceiling shall be at least 14 feet to ensure appropriate scale of the
base of the building in relation to the upper floors. Building height shall transition from the maximum
building height to a lower height when directly adjacent to a single-family residential zoned district.
In order to accommodate the desired ceiling heights of ground floor retail/commercial uses, new
mixed-use development shall be allowed to exceed the currently allowed building heights by four feet.
Heights greater than three stories may be considered for a compact mixed-use project development
that includes underground parking, public open space adjacent to the street, and is sensitively designed
to be
compatible with adjacent properties.
The three-story limit will be strictly adhered to when the mixed-use project is directly adjacent to
single-family residences.
Variations in building height and massing as well as articulated facades are strongly encouraged as
they contribute to community image and improve the pedestrian experience.
By- Misganaw S. 14
2017
Radical
roof
pitches
that create
overly
prominent
or out-of-
character
buildings
(e.g., A-
frames,
geodesic
domes, or
chalet-
style
buildings)
are not
allowed.
The
following
roof types
are
By- Misganaw S. 15
2017
5.4.6
Mixed-use
projects
shall be
designed
to
minimize
vehicular
circulation
on streets
through
local
single-family neighborhoods. Guest parking areas shall be located and designed to be convenient to
minimize spillover to adjacent residential neighborhoods. Parking for residents, visitors, and/or
employees shall be accommodated on site or on adjacent public streets that are not serving single-
family residences.
Parking and loading/unloading areas shall not create stacking/queuing issues at ingress/egress points.
Site design must ensure that vehicles entering and exiting the site do not adversely impact adjacent
streets and neighborhoods.
Facades and garages that face existing single-family homes shall be designed to be compatible with
the setbacks and scale of the existing development. The design shall clearly delineate between public
space and private space.
By- Misganaw S. 16
2017
In order
to
integrate
new
buildings
with the
existing
urban
fabric,
new
buildings
are
encouraged to incorporate passageways and attractive plaza areas between buildings that allow light to
reach adjacent buildings. Parking shall be separated from adjacent residences and buildings by no less
than five feet.
storefront design
Storefront design shall be reflective of the building’s overall architectural style, yet highlight the
individual character and personality of the use. A successful storefront with inviting display windows
will attract passersby and contribute to the overall quality of the streetscape.
A well-designed storefront facade is comprised of:
- an inviting recessed entry door;
- transparent display and transom
- windows and/or doors that allow shoppers to look into the retail or commercial space;
- bulkheads beneath the windows to mirror traditional development;
- piers that frame the windows and/or door openings; and
- a decorative cornice treatment.
By- Misganaw S. 17
2017
At least
70 percent
of the
ground
floor
facade of
a
commercial/retail use shall be devoted to transparent windows and/or doors. Windows shall be large
glazed panels, possibly with small upper transoms. Window patterns shall have a slight inset and not
appear flat. Glass shall be clear (88% light transmission) and not heavily tinted.
Generally, the most appropriate storefront design shall be comprised of a lower bulkhead not
exceeding two feet above sidewalk grade.
By- Misganaw S. 18
2017
The design of surface parking lot lighting fixtures shall be compatible with the architecture
Adjacent
properties
shall be
adequately
screened
from the
parking
structures
and lots. Parking provided to the general public (visitors to commercial or residential uses) shall be
clearly marked and separate from private resident parking spaces.
Secure, covered bicycle parking in residential mixed-use projects shall be provided.
Commercial bicycle racks shall be in public view, close to building entrances, with high visibility and
sufficient lighting. The design of surface parking lot lighting fixtures shall be compatible with the
architecture used in the development and not be on poles over 25 feet high.
In public parking lots, a higher foot-candle level shall be provided at vehicle driveways, entry throats,
pedestrian paths, plaza areas, and other activity areas.
Parking and security lights will not be obtrusive to neighboring residential properties.
By- Misganaw S. 19
2017
is an activity in which a customer browses the available goods or services presented by one or more
retailers with the intent to purchase a suitable selection of them In some contexts, it may be considered
a leisure activity as well as an economic one.
In modern days’ customer focus is more transferred towards online shopping; worldwide people order
products from different regions and online retailers deliver their products to their homes, offices or
wherever they want. The B2C (business to consumer) process has made it easy for consumers to select
any product online from a retailer's website and have it delivered to the consumer within no time. The
consumer does not need to consume his energy by going out to the stores and saves his time and cost
of travelling.
Office
An office generally, a room or other area where administrative work is done, but may also denote a
position within an organization with specific duties attached to it (see officer, office-holder, official);
the latter is in fact an earlier usage, office as place originally referring to the location of one's duty.An
office is an architectural and design phenomenon; whether it is a small office such as a bench in
thecorner of a small business of extremely small size (see small office/home office), through entire
floors of buildings, up to and including massive buildings dedicated entirely to one company
The main purpose of an office environment is to support its occupants in performing their job. Work
spaces in an office are typically used for conventional office activities such as reading, writing and
computer work. There are nine generic types of work space, each supporting different activities. In
addition to individual cubicles, there are also meeting rooms, lounges, and spaces for support
activities, such as photocopying and filing. Some offices also have a kitchen area where workers can
make their lunches. There are many different ways of arranging the space in an office and whilst these
vary according to function, managerial fashions and the culture of specific companies can be even
more important. While offices can be built in almost any location and in almost any building, some
modern requirements for offices make this more difficult, such as requirements for light, networking,
and security.
The primary purpose of an office building is to provide a workplace and working environment
primarily for administrative and managerial workers. These workers usually occupy set areas within
the office building, and usually are provided with desks, PCs and other equipment they may need
within these areas.
Open office:
An open work space for more than ten people, suitable for activities which demand frequent
communication or routine activities which need relatively little concentration.
Team space:
A semi-enclosed work space for two to eight people; suitable for teamwork which demands frequent
internal communication and a medium level of concentration
Cubicle:
A semi-enclosed work space for one person, suitable for activities which demand medium
concentration and medium interaction
Private office:
An enclosed work space for one person, suitable for activities which are confidential, demand a lot of
concentration or include many small meetings
Shared office:
An enclosed work space for two or three people, suitable for semi-concentrated work and
collaborative work in small groups
Team room:
An enclosed work space for four to ten people; suitable for teamwork which may be confidential and
demands frequent internal communication
Study booth:
An enclosed work space for one person; suitable for short-term activities which demand concentration
or confidentiality
Work lounge:
A lounge-like work space for two to six people; suitable for short-term activities which
demand collaboration and/or allow impromptu interaction
Touch down:
An open work space for one person; suitable for short-term activities which require little
By- Misganaw S. 20
2017
GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS
Orientation During the preliminary design stage considers the relationships of different parts of the
resort hotel and the effects of noise and pollution. However, restrictions imposed by the site,
particularly in a town, may determine the building’s orientation regardless of other considerations.
General arrangement
Determine and agree pedestrian and vehicular access at an early stage. The main hotel entrance is a
critical commercial feature determining the location of the main frontage. Site value usually
determines the height of the development. In a cheap rural setting, costs favor a low building. There
are savings in foundation and structural work, lifts are not currently obligatory up to three stores
although this may change with disabled access regulations, and could incur considerable later costs).
There may be also being savings in maintenance costs. On the other hand, long corridors with more
staircases are needed, and engineering services may be more expensive. On a town site, cost may
By- Misganaw S. 21
2017
By- Misganaw S. 22
2017
installation of fixed equipment to detect fires, raise the alarm, and put them out. There must be access
for fire brigade vehicles and appliances, and provision of firemen’s lifts. Special water storage tanks
and fixed fire mains and hydrants may be required. Automatic sprinklers, electromagnetic door
releases, dampers in ventilation ducts and portable fire extinguishers may all be required. Means of
escape Current building regulations require:
Maximum travel distances from bedrooms or points in public rooms to a protected escape route
Alternative directions of escape, normally at least two from any point Protected escape routes to be of
adequate width and unobstructed Final escape must be free; not into a closed courtyard, and Maximum
times are laid down for the complete evacuation of the building. Security; Security involves the
protection and control of property, and the safety and supervision of all persons occupying, entering or
leaving. In planning, consider the following Control of property, i.e. prevention of theft this covers
strength of construction of doors and walls, burglar alarms, CCTV, and controlling unauthorized exit
through fire escapes Control of entry to bedrooms this covers access to windows and balconies, and
the lock mastering system. Access of guests, cleaners, manager and security personnel have to be
controlled and locks have to be changed regularly to prevent later access using old keys. Electronic
card key systems facilitate frequent code changes Provision of safes and strong rooms for valuable
items, both in bedrooms and centrally Surveillance of everyone entering or leaving Entrances must be
planned so that they are always watched. Side or garage entrance routes must not by-pass reception
desks. Goods entrances should have roll-down shutters Baggage handling and checking Baggage
rooms should be isolated and have explosion relief Security of hotel grounds Motels, holiday village
or condominium developments may have substantial grounds. Climbable perimeter fences and
floodlighting are common.
Intruder detection appliances may be used Ensure that criminals cannot escape by setting off fire
alarms and using unsupervised fire exits a critical component of large commercial developments.
.
ACCESSIBILITY
Entrances
Entrances with waiting areas to prevent traffic
Parking
I. Normally 1 per 5 to 10 spectators.
ii. The size will depend on the location and the number of seats in the cinema hall, the number of
venues.
iii. Local laws will determine the number of handy capped and their location.
. CIRCULATION
Staircases
Staircase design is dictated by fire escape requirements. The main stairs should be beside the lift bank
to enable guests to find them easily, with secondary stairs at the end of each corridor.
LIFTS
Lifts are expensive. They should be wider than they are deep to facilitate entry. Tough surfaces are
required to resist damage by baggage. The main lift bank must be visible on entering the reception
area.
LOBBIES
i. Lobbies mediate between the outdoors and the interior space itself
ii. A successful lobby must be sized to allow comfortable circulation and seating spaces
iii. Rest rooms, public phones & ATM machines, drinking fountains, concessions
And merchandising should be provided and located within easy access.
RECEPTION
i. Information desk
ii. For cinema Ticket booths requires multiple windows and areas for computer work stations.
iii. Multiple windows must be available for both current displaying and future displaying.
AISLES
i. Straight radial aisles are better for seeing purposes (scan from time saver p731)
ii. They must be employed in many localities because
By- Misganaw S. 23
2017
By- Misganaw S. 24
2017
References
Angotti, T. and Hanhardt, E. (2001). Problems and Prospects for Healthy Mixed-use
Communities in New York City. Planning Practice & Research, 16(2): 145-54.Atlantic Station. (2011).
Atlantic Station - About. Retrieved 4/1/2011, from
http://www.atlanticstation.com/concept.php.Bergeron, A. (2007). Mixed-Use Developments: New
Construction Trend Invades South
Central Region. South Central Construction. Retrieved 2/15/2011, from
http://southcentral.construction.com/features/archive/2007/0708_feature2.asp.Brown, W. (2009). In
Herndon J. (Ed.), Personal communication.Buntin, S. (2005). Glenwood Park - Atlanta, Georgia.
Terrain.org. Retrieved 4/1/2011,from http://www.terrain.org/unsprawl/17/.City of Atlanta (2002). Code
of Ordinances: Part 3-Land Development Code. Sec.16-34.002.Bruegmann, R. (2005). Sprawl: A
Compact History. Chicago, University of ChicagoPress.Cooperative Conservation America. (2011).
Atlantic Station Redevelopment: Using
Smart Growth Studies to Lower Emissions. Retreived 4/8/2011, from
http://www.cooperativeconservationamerica.org/viewproject.asp?pid=498.Coupland, A. (1997).
Reclaiming the City: Mixed Use Development. London, E & FNSpon.Dannenberg, A., Edwards, R., et
al. (2007). Leveraging Law and Private Investment for
Healthy Urban Redevelopment. The Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics 35:101-105.
By- Misganaw S. 25