M:9J86I DC6BDC 6,6B GDQ (6GI6,: HQ (6G 96"6HE6G9: (6IDHQ %Dhyak:H C Oq

Available online at www.sciencedirect.
com
Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 29 (2011) 493 – 502
$CI:GC6I>DC6ADC;:G:C8:DC 9J86I>DC6C9 9J86I>DC6A+HN8=DAD<N$ +-2
-:M:9J86I>DC6BDC<+DGIJ<J:H:69DA:H8:CIHIJ9:CIH
']8>6,6B>GDQ7 (6GI6,:>HQ7(6G<6G>96"6HE6G9:(6IDHQ7%DHYAK:H>C>OQ7
6
!#3*26-&3+!,),%2)#1%#(,)#!*,)4%01)26-&)1"-,-023'!*
7
(. '$CHI>IJI:D;#N<>:C:6C9.GDE>86A(:9>8>C:+DGIJ<6A
#$"$
.=: EJGEDH: D; I=>H HIJ9N L6H ID 6HH:HH I=: >BEDGI6C8: D; H:M :9J86I>DC >C H8=DDA 8DCI:MI 6C9 >IH :;;:8IH >C H:MJ6A
7:=6K>DJG @CDLA:9<: 6C9 6II>IJ9:H G:<6G9>C< #$0 6BDC< 69DA:H8:CIH
.=: H6BEA: >C8AJ9:9 +DGIJ<J:H: 69DA:H8:CI
HIJ9:CIH ;GDB I=: +DGIJ<J:H: #- HIJ9N
.=>H HIJ9N JH:H 6 HJ7H:I D; I= 6C9 I= <G69:GH C
,:HJAIH H=DL:9
69DA:H8:CIH L=D =69 H:M :9J86I>DC 8A6HH:H B:CI>DC:9 BDG: D;I:C CDI =6K>C< =69 H:MJ6A >CI:G8DJGH: 7:II:G @CDLA:9<:
G:<6G9>C< #$0 6C9 BDG: EDH>I>K: 6II>IJ9:H 67DJI #$0 >C;:8I:9 E:DEA:
.=>H HIJ9N HJ<<:HIH EDH>I>K: 6HHD8>6I>DCH 7:IL::C
G:8:>K>C<H:M:9J86I>DC6C9EGDI:8I>K:H:MJ6A7:=6K>DJGH@CDLA:9<:6C96II>IJ9:H
© 2011 Published
P by Elsevier
+J7A>H=:97N Ltd. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license.
AH:K>:G'I9
-:A:8I>DC6C9DGE::G G:K>:LJC9:GG:HEDCH>7>A>IND; G
36;:G :@>GD<JAA6G>
Selection and/or peer-review under responsibility of Dr Zafer Bekirogullari.

H:MJ6A:9J86I>DC @CDLA:9<:6II>IJ9:H H:MJ6A7:=6K>DJG 69DA:H8:CIH
$"!%$!
9DA:H8:C8:>H6HI6<:I=6I>CKDAK:H<G:6I8=6C<:H9:K:ADEB:CI6C9DEEDGIJC>I>:H
.NE>86AAN>I>H6AHDI=:E:G>D9
L=:C E:DEA: >C>I>6I: I=:>G H:MJ6A 68I>K>IN K:GN '6O96C: :K:C I=DJ<= I=:N 6G: HI>AA >C I=: EGD8:HH D;
:BDI>DC6A6C98D<C>I>K:9:K:ADEB:CIL=>8=B6NG6>H:I=:G>H@D;C:<6I>K:DJI8DB:HHJ8=6H-.$`HDGJCEA6CC:9
EG:<C6C8N"D9:6J:I6A
:HE:8>6AAN6H6G:HJAID;B>HJH:DGCDCJH:D;I=:8DC9DBDG8DCIG68:EI>DC
#$0CJB7:GH6G:9:8G:6H>C<>CBDHI8DJCIG>:H7JINDJC<E:DEA:8DCHI>IJI:6B6?DG8DC8:GC7:86JH:I=:N6G:6I
<G:6I:G G>H@ ;DG >C;:8I>DCH /)$- I=6C 69JAIH BDHIAN 9J: ID I=:>G E=NH>86A :BDI>DC6A 6C9 8D<C>I>K:
>BB6IJG>IN
.=: CJB7:G D; E:DEA: A>K>C< L>I= #$0 >C8AJ9>C< NDJC< E:DEA: >H 9:8A>C>C< >C BDHI 9:K:ADE:9
8DJCIG>:H 7:86JH: E:DEA: 6G: 69DEI>C< BDG: EG:K:CI>K: 7:=6K>DGH C6B:AN 8DC9DB JH: /)$-
$I >H
8DBBDCAN 688:EI:9 I=6I I=: 8DC9DB >H I=: BDHI :;;:8I>K: B:I=D9 ID EG:K:CI 6C -.$
.=: A6I:HI 6K6>A67A: 96I6
8DC8:GC>C< 69DA:H8:CIHHJ<<:HII=6I8DC9DBJH:6IA6HIH:MJ6A>CI:G8DJGH::M8::9HH>MINE:G8:CI>CL:HI:GC8:CIG6A
,6B>GD'
+!)*!$$0%11AG6B>GD;B=
JIA
EI
1877-0428 © 2011 Published by Elsevier Ltd. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license.
Selection and/or peer-review under responsibility of Dr Zafer Bekirogullari.
doi:10.1016/j.sbspro.2011.11.268
494 L√∫cia Ramiro / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 29 (2011) 493 – 502
6C9:6HI:GC JGDE:K:GN'6O96C: 6C9>CI=:/C>I:9-I6I:H:CI:GH;DG>H:6H:DCIGDA6C9+G:K:CI>DC

,:<6G9A:HH8DC9DBJH:>HHI>AA >C8DCH>HI:CI"D9:6J:I6A
6C9>HHJ7?:8IIDI=:69DA:H8:CIH`:;;>868N
ID JH: >I ID I=: L6N =: E:G8:>K:H =>H E::G 6II>IJ9:H 6C9 =>H DLC 6HH:GI>K:C:HH 6:A: JHH:A9DGE (6:H
>>DG>D:I6A
&>G7NK6C9:G-AJ>?HJGG>: ,D7>C:I6A

$C G:A6I>DC ID EG:<C6C8N <AD76AAN 67DJI B>AA>DC 69DA:H8:CIH <>K: 7>GI= :K:GN N:6G 1#*
.=:
8DCIG68:EI>K:E>AA>HH6;:6C9HJ>I67A:;DGLDB:C6AA6<:H>C8AJ9>C<69DA:H8:CIH.=:#:CGN%
&6>H:G!6B>AN
,:EDGIHK6GN >CG:A6I>DCIDI=:8DCIG68:EI>K:E>AAJH:
-DB:G:EDGIH9D8JB:CI>I6HI=:BDHI8DBBDCAN8DCIG68:EI>K:
B:I=D9JH:9>C9:K:ADE:98DJCIG>:H1#*
#:C8: :6GAN >C>I>6I>DC D; H:MJ6A 68I>K>IN =6H 7::C >9:CI>;>:9 6H 6 8GJ8>6A >C9>86IDG >C I:GBH D; H:MJ6A =:6AI=
:CI:GH ;DG >H:6H: DCIGDA 6C9 +G:K:CI>DC /)$- 1#*
99>I>DC6AAN >I =6H 7::C
9D8JB:CI:9I=6I:6GANH:MJ6A68I>K>IN>H6HHD8>6I:9L>I=DI=:GG>H@7:=6K>DGHHJ8=6HHJ7HI6C8:JH:(69@DJG:I6A

->B>A6GAN >C +DGIJ<6A EG:<C6C8N 7>GI= 6C9 -.$H G6I:H 6BDC< 69DA:H8:CIH G:EG:H:CI 6 H:G>DJH EJ7A>8 =:6AI=
8=6AA:C<:
.=DJ<=688DG9>C<IDI=:7GD69:HIC6I>DC6AHIJ9N _ I=:#-#:6AI=7:=6K>DG>CH8=DDA 6<:98=>A9G:C _
I=:G:>H6C>C8G:6H:>C8DC9DB6C98DCIG68:EI>K:E>AAJH:;GDBID
>C
>C6C9

>C >C
>C6C9
>C G:HE:8I>K:AN9JG>C<A6HIH:MJ6A>CI:G8DJGH:6BDC<
I= 6C9 I= <G69:HIJ9:CIHCDI6AA69DA:H8:CIH=6K:H:MJ6AEG:K:CI>K:7:=6K>DGHN:I(6IDH:I6A

9J86I>DC >H I=: BDHI :;;:8I>K: L6N ID >BEGDK: 69DA:H8:CIH` @CDLA:9<: 6II>IJ9:H 6C9 67>A>IN ID EGDI:8I
I=:BH:AK:H
.=:G:;DG: H:M :9J86I>DC >H :HH:CI>6A ID I=: EG:K:CI>DC D; H:MJ6A G>H@ 7:=6K>DJGH 6C9 I=:>G 6HHD8>6I:9
C:<6I>K:DJI8DB:H
G:H:6G8= 86GG>:9 DJI 7N (J:AA:G "6K>C 6C9 &JA@6GC> 9:BDCHIG6I:9 I=6I 69DA:H8:CIH L=D G:EDGI:9
=6K>C< =69 H:M :9J86I>DC 6I H8=DDA BDG: ;G:FJ:CIAN JH:9 I=: E>AA 6I ;>GHI H:MJ6A >CI:G8DJGH: 6C9 A:HH ;G:FJ:CIAN
G:EDGI:9 JCEA6CC:9 EG:<C6C8>:H
*I=:G G:H:6G8=:GH &>G7N '6G>H ,DAA:G> =6K: HIJ9>:9 I=: 9:K:ADEB:CI
>BEA:B:CI6I>DC 6C9 8DCH:FJ:C8:H D; #$0 6C9 H:M :9J86I>DC EGD<G6BH B6>CAN >C H8=DDA 8DCI:MI
.=:>G G:H:6G8=
9:BDCHIG6I:9 I=6I B6CN EGD<G6BH 9:A6N:9 >C>I>6I>DC D; H:M >C8G:6H:9 8DC9DB 6C9 8DCIG68:EI>K: JH: >BEGDK:9
@CDLA:9<:G:A6I:9ID#$0>C;:8I>DC:C=6C8:969DA:H8:CIH`6L6G:C:HHD;6II>IJ9:H67DJIE:DEA:A>K>C<L>I=#$06C9
>C8G:6H:9I=:>G:;;>868NIDJH:8DC9DBH6C9G:;JH:JCL6CI:9H:M6BDC<DI=:GH
#:C8:H8=DDA 76H:9H:M:9J86I>DC
86CCDI7:A>C@:9ID>C8G:6H:9H:MJ6A68I>K>IN&>G7N'6G>H,DAA:G> (J:AA:G"6K>C&JA@6GC>
$BEGDK>C<@CDLA:9<:G:A6I:9ID#$0EG:K:CI>DC6C96II>IJ9:H67DJIE:DEA:A>K>C<L>I=#$06G:DI=:G>BEDGI6CI
6>BH D; H:M :9J86I>DC
-DB: I=:DG>:H 69KD86I: I=6I 7:>C< L:AA >C;DGB:9 67DJI IG6CHB>HH>DC 6C9 EG:K:CI>K:
7:=6K>DGH G:<6G9>C< #$0 6C9 DI=:G -.$H 6H L:AA 6H =6K>C< 6 EDH>I>K: 6II>IJ9: IDL6G9H #$0 >C;:8I:9 E:DEA: 6G:
:HH:CI>6A ID 8=6C<: E:DEA:`H 7:=6K>DGH
):K:GI=:A:HH >I >H CDL 7GD69AN 688:EI:9 I=6I I=:H: 6G: CDI :CDJ<=
88DG9>C< ID I=: BD9:A D; >C;DGB6I>DC BDI>K6I>DC 7:=6K>DG6A H@>AAH !>H=:G !>H=:G 7:H>9:H >BEGDK>C<
@CDLA:9<:>I>H6AHDC::9:9IDEGDBDI:69DA:H8:CIH`BDI>K6I>DCL=>8=>C8AJ9:H 6II>IJ9:H7:=6K>DG6A>CI:CI>DCH6C9
HJ7?:8I>K: CDGBH 6H L:AA 6H I=:>G 7:=6K>DG6A H@>AAH >C DG9:G ID :ME:8I 6 IG6CH;DGB6I>DC >C I=:>G 6II>IJ9: 6C9
HJ7H:FJ:CIAN >C I=:>G H:MJ6A 7:=6K>DJG
&>G7N '6G>H 6C9 ,DAA:G> >9:CI>;>:9 EGD<G6BH I=6I L:G: 76H:9 DC
I=:DGN:BE>G>86AANHJEEDGI:96HDC:D;I=:8=6G68I:G>HI>8HD;HJ88:HH;JAH:M:9J86I>DCEGD<G6BH
L√∫cia Ramiro / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 29 (2011) 493 – 502 495
->C8: H:M :9J86I>DC >C +DGIJ<6A =6H 7::C 8DBEJAHDGN >C :A:B:CI6GN 6C9 B>99A: H8=DDA 6C9 ;GDB
DCL6G9H >C =><= H8=DDA IDD
.=DJ<= I=: <DK:GCB:CI =6H 9DC: 6 <G:6I :;;DGI ID G:<JA6I: 6AA C:8:HH6GN 6HE:8IH 6C9
EJ7A>H=:968DC8:EIJ6A;G6B:LDG@;DGH:M:9J86I>DC>CCDI6AAH8=DDAH8DBEANL>I=I=:+DGIJ<J:H:(>C>HIGND;
9J86I>DC<J>9:A>C:H?JHIN:I
88DG9>C<IDI=:<J>9:A>C:HH8=DDAHH=DJA9 EGDK>9:H:M:9J86I>DC6HE6GID;67GD69:G
6G:6 =:6AI= :9J86I>DC >C 6 CDC 9>H8>EA>C6GN 8JGG>8JAJB 6G:6 6H L:AA 6H 8GDHH H:8I>DC6AAN 7N >9:CI>;N>C< >C 6AA
8JGG>8JA6H:M:9J86I>DC8DCI:CIH6C98G:6I>C<6CD;;>8:;DGEGDK>9>C<HJEEDGI6I>C9>K>9J6AA:K:A
,:8:CIANI=:CDC
9>H8>EA>C6GN8JGG>8JAJB6G:6L=>8=8=>A9G:C6C969DA:H8:CIHG:EDGI>C#- 6H7:>C<I=:BDHIG:A:K6CI>C
I:GBHD;H:M:9J86I>DC(6IDH:I6A
L6H:MI>C<J>H=:96C9>CC:MIH8=DDA N:6G>I L>AA CDADC<:G7:E6GID;
H8=DDAHJ7?:8IH
.=:EJGEDH:D;I=>HHIJ9NL6H ID6HH:HHI=:>BEDGI6C8:D;H:M:9J86I>DC>CH8=DDA8DCI:MI6C9>IH:;;:8IH>CH:MJ6A
7:=6K>DG HJ8= 6H H:MJ6A >C>I>6I>DC 6<: D; ;>GHI H:MJ6A >CI:G8DJGH: 6C9 8DC9DB 6C9 E>AA JH: 9JG>C< A6HI H:MJ6A
>CI:G8DJGH:@CDLA:9<:G:<6G9>C<#$0$-IG6CHB>HH>DCEG:K:CI>DC6C96II>IJ9:HIDL6G9HE:DEA:A>K>C<L>I=#$0
6BDC<+DGIJ<J:H:69DA:H8:CIH
$!#

!+.*%
6I6 L:G: 8DAA:8I:9 I=GDJ<= 6 H:A; 69B>C>HI:G:9 FJ:HI>DCC6>G: ;GDB I=: +DGIJ<J:H: H6BEA: D; I=: #:6AI=
:=6K>DG >C -8=DDA 6<:9 =>A9G:C #- D; 6 1DGA9 #:6AI= *G<6C>O6I>DC 1#* 8DAA67DG6I>K: 8GDHH
C6I>DC6A HIJ9N JGG>: %2 !*
(6IDH %2 !*

.=: HIJ9N EGDK>9:H C6I>DC6A G:EG:H:CI6I>K: 96I6 D;
+DGIJ<J:H:69DA:H8:CIH G6C9DBAN8=DH:C;GDBI=DH:6II:C9>C<I=I= 6C9 I= <G69:HD; =><=H8=DDA
.=:B6?DG>IN
D;69DA:H8:CIH6G:D;+DGIJ<J:H:C6I>DC6A>IN

6II:C9:9I=: I= <G69:
6II:C9:9I=:I= <G69:6C9

6II:C9:9 I=: I= <G69: 6C9 6G: 9>HIG>7JI:9 EGDEDGI>DC6AAN 7N 6AA I=: :9J86I>DC6A +DGIJ<J:H: G:<>DCH
.=>H
HIJ9NJH:H6HJ7H:ID;I= 6C9 I= <G69:GHC
.=>HH6BEA:>C8AJ9:9
<>GAH6C9
7DNHL=DH: B:6C
6<:L6H
N:6GHHI6C96G99:K>6I>DC

0-#%$30%
.=>H)6I>DCL>9:-JGK:NL6H8DC9J8I:99JG>C< H8=DDAN:6G7NI=:.:8=C>86A/C>K:GH>IND;'>H7DC;DG
I=: (>C>HIGN D; +DGIJ<J:H: #:6AI= 6C9 ;DG I=: )6I>DC6A DDG9>C6I>DC ;DG #$0$- $C;:8I>DC
.=: H6BEA>C< JC>I
JH:9>CI=>HHJGK:NL6HI=:8A6HH
.=: H8=DDAH>CI=: H6BEA:L:G:G6C9DBANH:A:8I:9;GDBI=:D;;>8>6AC6I>DC6A
A>HI D;EJ7A>8H8=DDAHHIG6I>;>:97NG:<>DC
$C:68=H8=DDA8A6HH:H L:G:G6C9DBANH:A:8I:9;DG:68=<G69:688DG9>C<
IDI=:>CI:GC6I>DC6AG:H:6G8= EGDID8DAJGG>: %2!*

.=:FJ:HI>DCC6>G: L6H86GG>:97NH8=DDAI:68=:GH
.=>H
HIJ9N=6HI=:6EEGDK6AD;6H8>:CI>;>88DBB>II::6C:I=>86AC6I>DC6A8DBB>II::6C9I=:C6I>DC6A8DBB>HH>DC;DG96I6
EGDI:8I>DC6C9;DAADL:9HIG>8IAN6AAI=:<J>9:A>C:H;DG=JB6CG><=IHEGDI:8I>DC
$CI=:FJ:HI>DCC6>G:L=>8=8DK:GH6
L>9: G6C<: D; FJ:HI>DCH 67DJI 7:=6K>DGH 6C9 A>;:HINA:H >C 69DA:H8:C8: >I L6H H:A:8I:9 >HHJ:H I=6I G:A6I: ID HD8>D
9:BD<G6E=>8 8=6G68I:G>HI>8H H:MJ6A 7:=6K>DG @CDLA:9<: G:<6G9>C< #$0$- IG6CHB>HH>DCEG:K:CI>DC 6C9
6II>IJ9:HIDL6G9HE:DEA:A>K>C< L>I=#$0$-
#%"#
.=: #- FJ:HI>DCC6>G: 8DCH>HIH D; B6C96IDGN >I:BH JH:9 7N 6AA I=: E6GI>8>E6I>C< 8DJCIG>:H 6C9 DEI>DC6A
>I:BH L=>8= 6G: >C8AJ9:9 688DG9>C< ID C6I>DC6A >CI:G:HI
!DG I=: EJGEDH: D; I=>H HIJ9N I=: ;DAADL>C< >I:BH L:G:
JH:9
!>K:H:M:9J86I>DC>I:BH 9>9 NDJ =6K: H:M:9J86I>DC 8A6HH:H 6IH8=DDA>CI=:A6HI N:6GH2:H)D 9>9NDJ
;::A>C;DGB:9 L>I=I=:>HHJ:HI=6IL:G:9>H8JHH:9>CH:M:9J86I>DC8A6HH:HL:AA>C;DGB:9G:6HDC67AN>C;DGB:9CDI
6I6AA>C;DGB:9H:M:9J86I>DC=:AEHNDJ
=6K:7:II:G@CDLA:9<:EG:K:CI#$0>C;:8I>DC=6K:7:II:GG:A6I>DCH=>EH

L>I= DI=:G E:DEA: L>I= NDJG JC8:GI6>CI>:H EG:K:CI EG:<C6C8N 6CDI=:G DEI>DC BJAI>EA: 8=D>8: ;DGB6I =DL
8DB;DGI67A:9DNDJ;::AI6A@>C<67DJIH:M:9J86I>DCIDE>8H L>I=
NDJG;G>:C9H NDJGE6G:CIH NDJG8DAA:6<J:H6C9

NDJGI:68=:GH)DI6I6AA8DB;DGI67A:CDIK:GN8DB;DGI67A:G:6HDC67AN8DB;DGI67A:6C9K:GN8DB;DGI67A:6C9>;
NDJL:G:LDGG>:9DGL6CI:9IDA:6GCBDG:67DJI#$0$-DGDI=:G-.$HL=6ILDJA9 NDJ9D _ DEI>DCH;DG
:M6BEA:G:6967DJI>I>C67DD@DGB6<6O>C:H:6G8=:9I=:L:7I6A@:9IDE6G:CIH;G>:C9G:A6I>K:DGI:68=:GL:G:
A>HI:96C969DA:H8:CIH=69ID6CHL:G6AA DEI>DCH2:H)D(6N7:
!DJGH:MJ6A7:=6K>DJG>I:BH=6K:NDJ:K:G=69 H:MJ6A>CI:G8DJGH:2:H)D=DLDA9L:G:NDJL=:CNDJ

=69NDJG;>GHIH:MJ6A>CI:G8DJGH:L=>8=8DCIG68:EI>K:B:I=D99>9NDJJH:9JG>C<A6HIH:MJ6A>CI:G8DJGH:8DC9DB
E>AA
6C9=6K:NDJ:K:G=69H:MJ6A>CI:G8DJGH:7:86JH:NDJ9G6C@IDDBJ8= 6A8D=DADGIDD@9GJ<H2:H)D
&CDLA:9<: G:<6G9>C< #$0$- IG6CHB>HH>DCEG:K:CI>DC

9DA:H8:CIH L:G: 6H@:9 ID G:HEDC9 ID C>C:
HI6I:B:CIH 67DJI #$0$- IG6CHB>HH>DCEG:K:CI>DC
a>I >H EDHH>7A: ID 7:8DB: >C;:8I:9 L>I= #$0$- 7N
H=6G>C< C::9A:Hb
a>I >H EDHH>7A: ID 7:8DB: >C;:8I:9 L>I= #$0>9H ;GDB 8DJ<=>C< 6C9 HC::O>C<b
a6C #$0
>C;:8I:9EG:<C6CILDB6CB6NE6HHI=:K>GJHID=:G767Nb
a>I>HEDHH>7A:ID7:8DB:>C;:8I:9L>I=#$0$-7N
=J<<>C<HDB:DC:>C;:8I:9b
aI=:DG6A8DCIG68:EI>K:86CEGDI:8I6<6>CHI#$0$->C;:8I>DCb
a>I>HEDHH>7A:ID
7:8DB: >C;:8I:9 L>I= #$0$- 7N :C<6<>C< >C JCEGDI:8I:9 H:MJ6A >CI:G8DJGH: L>I= HDB:DC: ?JHI DC8:b

aHDB:DC: L=D ADD@H =:6AI=N 86C 7: #$0 >C;:8I:9b
a>I >H EDHH>7A: ID 7:8DB: >C;:8I:9 L>I= #$0$- 7N
H=6G>C< 6 <A6HH ;DG@HEDDCb
a>I >H EDHH>7A: ID 7:8DB: >C;:8I:9 L>I= #$0$- 7N 7ADD9 IG6CH;JH>DC >C 6
+DGIJ<J:H: =DHE>I6Ab
$I:BH L:G: G6I:9 DC 6 I=G:: G:HEDCH: DEI>DCH 2:H)D$ 9D CDI @CDL
*CAN G:HEDCH:H I=6I
H=DL:98DGG:8I>C;DGB6I>DCH8DG:96C9HD;>C6AH8DG:HG6C<:9;GDBID L>I=I=:=><=:HIH8DG:7:>C<6C>C9>86IDG
D;=><=:G@CDLA:9<:G:<6G9>C<-.$H
II>IJ9:H IDL6G9H E:DEA: A>K>C< L>I= #$0 L:G: 6HH:HH:9 I=GDJ<= >I:BH
a$ LDJA9CI 7: 6 ;G>:C9 D;
HDB:DC: >;=:DGH=:=69$-b
a9DA:H8:CIHL>I=$- H=DJA97:6AADL:9ID<DIDH8=DDAb
a$LDJA9H>IC:6G
6C >C;:8I:9 HIJ9:CI >C 8A6HHGDDBb
a$ LDJA9 K>H>I 6 ;G>:C9 >; =: DG H=: =69 $-b 6C9
a#$0 >C;:8I:9 E:DEA:
H=DJA9A>K:6E6GID;I=: G:HID;E:DEA:b
$I:BHL:G:G6I:9DC 6 ED>CIG6I>C<H86A: 9>H6<G::ID 6<G::
;I:G
G:8D9>C<>I:BH 6C9;>C6AH8DG:HG6C<:9;GDBID L>I==><=H8DG:HHJ<<:HI>C<BDG:EDH>I>K:6II>IJ9:H
$ '##
.=: 96I6 L:G: 6C6ANO:9 JH>C< I=: -I6I>HI>86A +68@6<: ;DG -D8>6A -8>:C8:H -+-- K:GH>DC
(:6CH HI6C96G9
9:K>6I>DCH;G:FJ:C8>:H6C9DI=:G9:H8G>EI>K:HI6I>HI>8HL:G:E:G;DGB:9ID8=6G68I:G>O:I=:H6BEA:
-:MJ6A7:=6K>DJG
@CDLA:9<:6C96II>IJ9:H >I:BH L:G:8DBE6G:97:IL::CI=:HIJ9:CIH L=DG:EDGI:9=6K>C< =696C9CDI=6K>C< =69
H:M:9J86I>DCJH>C< => HFJ6G:Î:HIH
$CDG9:GID>9:CI>;N B:6C>C<;JA9>;;:G:C8:H>C@CDLA:9<:6C96II>IJ9:H
H8DG:H 7N=6K>C<CDI=6K>C<=69H:M:9J86I>DC . I:HIHL:G:E:G;DGB:9
.=:A:K:A;DGHI6I>HI>86AH><C>;>86C8:L6HH:I
6IE

#%$#
.=:;>C9>C<HH=DLI=6I
D;69DA:H8:CIHG:EDGI=6K>C<:K:G=69H:MJ6A>CI:G8DJGH:6C9=69I=:>G;>GHIH:MJ6A
>CI:G8DJGH:6I;DJGI::CDGBDG:
DCH>9:G>C<I=DH:L=DG:EDGI=6K>C<=69H:MJ6A>CI:G8DJGH:
G:;:GG:9=6K>C<
JH:9 8DC9DB 6C9
I=: 8DCIG68:EI>K: E>AA 9JG>C< A6HI H:MJ6A >CI:G8DJGH:

HI6I:9 I=:N =6K: =69 H:M
7:86JH:I=:N =69I6@:C9GJ<HDGIDDBJ8=6A8D=DA
,:HJAIHH=DL:9I=6I>C <:C:G6A
69DA:H8:CIH8DCH>9:G
H:M:9J86I>DCL>AA=:AEI=:B=6K:7:II:G@CDLA:9<:
HI6I:9I=:N=696AG:69N=69H:M:9J86I>DC8A6HH:H9JG>C<
I=: A6HI H8=DDA N:6GH 6C9 I=6I I=:N ;::A L:AA >C;DGB:9 7N >I

):K:GI=:A:HH I=:N EG:;:G ;::A BDG:
8DB;DGI67A:IDI6A@67DJIH:M:9J86I>DCIDE>8HL>I=;G>:C9H
6C98DAA:6<J:H
I=6CIDE6G:CIH

6C9I:68=:GH

,:<6G9>C<I=:HDJG8:HD;>C;DGB6I>DC
8=DH:I=:>CI:GC:I
$CI:GBHD;9:8>9>C< L=:C
>I`HI=:G><=II>B:ID>C>I>6I:I=:>GH:MJ6AA>;:8DCH>9:GI=:7DN6C9I=:<>GAI6@:I=:9:8>H>DCID<:I=:G
C9 6H;DG
I=:G:6HDCH;DG>C>I>6I>C<I=:>GH:MJ6AA>;:I=:N7:A>:K:>I>H7:86JH:I=:NL6CIIDIGN>I6C97:86JH:I=:N6G:>C
ADK:

*K:G6AA69DA:H8:CIHB:CI>DC:9I=6II=:N=69=69H:M:9J86I>DC8A6HH:H6IH8=DDA9JG>C<I=:A6HIN:6GH
*;
I=:H: G:;:GG:9 I=6I I=:N =69 C:K:G =69 H:MJ6A >CI:G8DJGH:
H><C>;>86CI K6G>6I>DC L6H ;DJC9 7:IL::C
=6K>C<CDI=6K>C<=69H:M:9J86I>DC>CI:GBHD;=6K>C<=69CDI=6K>C<=69I=:>G;>GHIH:MJ6A>CI:G8DJGH:

E
L>I= HIJ9:CIH L=D =6K: =69 H:M :9J86I>DC G:EDGI>C< 6 ADL:G G6I: D; =6K>C< =69 I=:>G ;>GHI H:MJ6A
>CI:G8DJGH:
,:<6G9>C<I=DH: L=D =6K:=69I=:>G;>GHI H:MJ6A>CI:G8DJGH: BDG:D;I:CI=:DC:H L=D =6K:=69H:M:9J86I>DC

8A6HH:H=6K:>C>I>6I:9I=:>GH:MJ6AA>;:DA9:G6I 6C96I DGBDG:I=6CI=DH:L=DG:EDGI:9CDI=6K>C<=69H:M
:9J86I>DC 8A6HH:H I=DJ<= K6G>6I>DCH 6G: CDI HI6I>HI>86AAN H><C>;>86CI

.=>H >H BDHI K>H>7A: L=:C 8DCH>9:G>C< I=:
;G:FJ:C8ND;69DA:H8:CIHL=DG:EDGI:9=6K>C<=69I=:>G;>GHIH:MJ6A>CI:G8DJGH:6I DGNDJC<:GH>C8:H><C>;>86CIAN
;:L:G69DA:H8:CIHL=D=6K:=69H:M:9J86I>DCG:EDGI:9=6K>C<9DC:HD>C8DBE6G>HDCIDI=:DC:HL=D=6K:
CDI=69H:M:9J86I>DC8A6HH:H

AHD69DA:H8:CIHL=DG:EDGI:9=6K>C<=69H:M:9J86I>DC8A6HH:H6G: I=:DC:HL=D=6K:6=><=:GG6I:D;8DC9DB
JH:
_
6C9I=:E>AA
6IA6HIH:MJ6A>CI:G8DJGH:
!JGI=:GBDG:69DA:H8:CIHL=D=69H:M
:9J86I>DC8A6HH:HG:EDGI:9A:HHH:MJ6A>CI:G8DJGH:6HHD8>6I:9ID6A8D=DA6C99GJ<H
I=6CI=DH: L=D=69CDI

):K:GI=:A:HHI=:H:K6G>6I>DCH6G:CDIHI6I>HI>86AANH><C>;>86CI H::I67A:
.67A: >;;:G:C8:H7:IL::C=6K>C<CDI=6K>C<=69H:M:9J86I>DC6C9H:MJ6A7:=6K>DJG
#6K>C<=69H:M )DI=6K>C<=69
.DI6A
:9J86I>DC H:M:9J86I>DC
)
) )
) ) )
K:G=69H:MJ6A>CI:G8DJGH:8DBEA:I:

H6BEA:
2:H
)D

<:D; HI H:MJ6A>CI:G8DJGH:

DGA:HH

6C9

6C9

DGBDG:

(JH:9>CA6HIH:MJ6A>CI:G8DJGH:
DC9DB

+>AA

#6K>C<=69H:MJ6A>CI:G8DJGH:JC9:G

I=:>C;AJ:C8:D;6A8D=DADG9GJ<H
2:H

)D

-6BEA:DCANI=DH:L=DG:EDGI:9=6K>C<=69I=:>G;>GHIH:MJ6A>CI:G8DJGH:
E
E
E

$C7DA9 _ K6AJ:HI=6I8DGG:HEDC9ID6C69?JHI:9G:H>9J6A de
e
.=: B:6C IDI6A H8DG: ;DG @CDLA:9<: G:<6G9>C< #$0$- IG6CHB>HH>DCEG:K:CI>DC L6H
-
L>I=
69DA:H8:CIHL=DG:EDGI:9=6K>C<=69H:M:9J86I>DC8A6HH:H6IH8=DDAH=DL>C< H><C>;>86CIANBDG:@CDLA:9<:(

-
I=6C 69DA:H8:CIH L=D G:EDGI:9 CDI =6K>C< =69 H:M :9J86I>DC 8A6HH:H 4(
-
I

E
5
(DG:DK:G I=:H: 9>;;:G:C8:H L:G: HI6I>HI>86AANH><C>;>86CI;DG6AA>I:BH H::I67A:
.67A: >;;:G:C8:H7:IL::C=6K>C<CDI=6K>C<=69H:M:9J86I>DC6C9 @CDLA:9<:G:<6G9>C<#$0$-

IG6CHB>HH>DCEG:K:CI>DC
#6K>C<=69H:M )DI=6K>C<=69 .DI6A

:9J86I>DC H:M:9J86I>DC )
) ) )(
) ) )
$I>HEDHH>7A:ID7:8DB:>C;:8I:9L>I=#$0$-7N

H=6G>C<C::9A:H
2:H

)D

$9DCDI&CDL

$I>HEDHH>7A:ID7:8DB:>C;:8I:9 L>I=#$0>9H

;GDB8DJ<=>C<6C9HC::O>C<
2:H

)D

$9DCDI&CDL

C #$0 >C;:8I:9EG:<C6CILDB6CB6NE6HHI=:

K>GJHID=:G767N
2:H

)D

$9DCDI&CDL


=J<<>C<HDB:DC:>C;:8I:9
2:H

)D

$9DCDI&CDL

.=:DG6A8DCIG68:EI>K:86CEGDI:8I6<6>CHI

#$0$->C;:8I>DC
2:H

)D

$9DCDI&CDL

:C<6<>C<>CJCEGDI:8I:9H:MJ6A>CI:G8DJGH:L>I=

HDB:DC:?JHIDC8:
2:H

)D

$9DCDI&CDL

-DB:DC:L=DADD@H=:6AI=N86C7:#$0>C;:8I:9

2:H

)D

$9DCDI&CDL


H=6G>C<6<A6HH;DG@HEDDC
2:H

)D

$9DCDI&CDL


7ADD9IG6CH;JH>DC>C6+DGIJ<J:H:=DHE>I6A
2:H

)D

$9DCDI&CDL

#6K>C<=69H:M )DI=6K>C<=69
.DI6A
( - ( - (-!
.DI6AH86A:

E
E
E

e
.=:B:6CIDI6AH8DG:;DG6II>IJ9:HIDL6G9HE:DEA:A>K>C<L>I=#$0L6H
-
L>I=69DA:H8:CIHL=D
G:EDGI:9 =6K>C< =69 H:M :9J86I>DC 8A6HH:H 6I H8=DDA H=DL>C< H><C>;>86CIAN BDG: IDA:G6CI 6II>IJ9:H (

-
I=6C69DA:H8:CIHL=DG:EDGI:9CDI=6K>C<=69H:M:9J86I>DC8A6HH:H4(
-
I

E
5
(DG:DK:G I=:H: 9>;;:G:C8:H L:G: HI6I>HI>86AANH><C>;>86CI;DG6AA>I:BH H::I67A:
.67A: >;;:G:C8:H7:IL::C=6K>C<CDI=6K>C<=69H:M:9J86I>DC6C9 6II>IJ9:H IDL6G9HE:DEA:A>K>C<L>I=#$0
#6K>C<=69H:M )DI=6K>C<=69 .DI6A

:9J86I>DC H:M:9J86I>DC )
) ) )(
) ) )
$LDJA9CÌ7:6;G>:C9D;HDB:DC:>;=:=69$-

<G::

$`BCDIHJG:

>H6<G::

9DA:H8:CIHL>I=$-H=DJA97:6AADL:9ID<DID

H8=DDA
<G::

$`BCDIHJG:

>H6<G::

$LDJA9H>IC:6G6C>C;:8I:9HIJ9:CI>C8A6HHGDDB

<G::

$`BCDIHJG:

>H6<G::

$LDJA9K>H>I6;G>:C9>;=:DGH=:=69$-

<G::

$`BCDIHJG:

>H6<G::

#$0>C;:8I:9E:DEA:H=DJA9A>K:6E6GID;I=:

G:HID;E:DEA:
<G::

$`BCDIHJG:

>H6<G::

#6K>C<=69H:M )DI=6K>C<=69
.DI6A
( - ( - (-!
.DI6AH86A:

E
E
E

e
! %#! #
!>C9>C<H H=DL I=6I I=: B6?DG>IN H6>9 I=6I I=:N =6K: C:K:G =69 H:MJ6A >CI:G8DJGH:
DCH>9:G>C< I=: DC:H L=D
=6K: I=: B6?DG>IN G:;:GG:9 =6K>C< JH:9 8DC9DB 6C9 I=: 8DCIG68:EI>K: E>AA 9JG>C< A6HI H:MJ6A >CI:G8DJGH: 6C9 CDI
=6K>C<=69H:M7:86JH:I=:N=69I6@:CIDDBJ8=6A8D=DADG9GJ<H
,:H:6G8=:GH (J:AA:G "6K>C &JA@6GC> 8DCH>9:G I=6I H:MJ6A 68I>K>IN 9JG>C< 69DA:H8:C8: >H 6 G>H@N
7:=6K>DJG7:86JH:69DA:H8:CIH6G:HI>AAB6IJG>C<E=NH>86AAN:BDI>DC6AAN6C98D<C>I>K:ANHDH:M:9J86I>DCH=DJA9
6>B6IEDHIEDC>C<H:MJ6A>C>I>6I>DC
!>C9>C<HH=DLI=6I69DA:H8:CIHL=D=69H:M:9J86I>DC8A6HH:HB:CI>DC:9A:HH
;G:FJ:CIAN=6K>C<>C>I>6I:9I=:>GH:MJ6AA>;:I=6CI=DH:L=DG:EDGI:9CDI=6K>C<=69H:M:9J86I>DC8A6HH:H6IH8=DDA
$C 699>I>DC L=:C 8DCH>9:G>C< 6<: D; ;>GHI H:MJ6A >CI:G8DJGH: A:HH N:6G DA9H L=D =69 H:M :9J86I>DC 8A6HH:H
G:EDGI:9>I
.=:H:9>;;:G:C8:H6G:HI6I>HI>86AANH><C>;>86CI
.=:G:;DG:H:M:9J86I>DCB6N 7:68=>:K>C<I=6IE6GI>8JA6G
<D6A
,:H:6G8=:GH6AHD68@CDLA:9<:9I=:8DCIG>7JI>DCD; H:M:9J86I>DC>C8G:6H>C<8DCIG68:EI>K:6C98DC9DB JH:
&>G7N'6G>H,DAA:G>(J:AA:G"6K>C&JA@6GC>6HL:AA6H9:8G:6H>C<H:MJ6A>CI:G8DJGH:6HHD8>6I:9
ID 6A8D=DA DG 9GJ<H JH: (69@DJG :I 6A

+6GI>8>E6CIH L=D G:EDGI:9 =6K>C< =69 H:M :9J86I>DC 8A6HH:H 6AHD
H=DL:9 =><=:G G6I:H D; 8DC9DB 6C9 E>AA JH: 9JG>C< A6HI H:MJ6A >CI:G8DJGH: 6C9 G:EDGI:9 A:HH H:MJ6A >CI:G8DJGH:
6HHD8>6I:9ID6A8D=DA6C99GJ<H I=6CI=DH:L=D9>9CÌG:EDGI=6K>C<=69H:M:9J86I>DC8A6HH:H
):K:GI=:A:HHI=:H:
9>;;:G:C8:H6G:CDIHI6I>HI>86AANH><C>;>86CIL=>8=EGD767AN>C9>86I:HI=6I;:LN:6GH=6K:E6HH:9H>C8:H:M:9J86I>DC
=6H7::C>CIGD9J8:9>CH8=DDA8DCI:MI6C9>IH8DCIG>7JI>DCID7:HI6I>HI>86AANH><C>;>86CI
.=:;G:FJ:C8ND;HIJ9:CIH
L=D G:EDGI:9 I=:N =6K:CÌ =69 H:MJ6A :9J86I>DC 6I H8=DDA N:I H::BH ID 8DC;>GB I=>H >9:6
$C DI=:G LDG9H >I >H
EGD767ANIDDHDDCID:K6AJ6I:I=::;;:8IHD;H:M:9J86I>DC>CH8=DDA8DCI:MI
.=:G6I:HD;#$0$-=6K:7::C68DCHI6CILDGGNE6GI>8JA6GAN>CNDJI=L=>8==6HB69:I=:B6I6G<:I<GDJE
;DG EG:K:CI>DC /)$-
DCH:FJ:CIAN @CDLA:9<: 67DJI IG6CHB>HH>DC GDJI:H 6C9 EG:K:CI>DC 6H L:AA 6H 6
IDA:G6CI 6II>IJ9: IDL6G9H #$0 >C;:8I:9 E:DEA: =6K: 7::C =><=A><=I:9 6H >BEDGI6CI 6>BH D; H:M :9J86I>DC &>G7N
'6G>H ,DAA:G>
.=>H HIJ9N G:K:6AH I=6I 69DA:H8:CIH =6K: G:6HDC67A: @CDLA:9<: G:<6G9>C< #$0$-
IG6CHB>HH>DCEG:K:CI>DC6C9I=:N6AHDH=DLEDH>I>K:6II>IJ9:HIDL6G9H #$0>C;:8I:9E:DEA:
$CDG9:GID6HH:HHI=:
:;;:8I>K:C:HH D; H:M :9J86I>DC H:K:G6A 6HE:8IH B6N 7: ED>CI:9 DJI
9DA:H8:CIH L=D G:EDGI:9 =6K>C< =69 H:M
:9J86I>DC8A6HH:H=69=><=:GB:9>6CH8DG:HD;DK:G6AA@CDLA:9<:6C96II>IJ9:HBDG:D;I:C8=DH:I=:8DGG:8IDEI>DC
>C>I:BHG:A6I:9ID@CDLA:9<:HI6I>HI>86AANH><C>;>86CI9>;;:G:C8:H>C6AA>I:BH6C9BDG:;G:FJ:CIANH=DL:9EDH>I>K:
6II>IJ9:HIDL6G9H#$0>C;:8I:9E:DEA:HI6I>HI>86AANH><C>;>86CI9>;;:G:C8:H>C6AA>I:BH
(DG:DK:G69DA:H8:CIHL=D
HI6I:9 CDI =6K>C< =69 H:M :9J86I>DC 8A6HH:H BDG: D;I:C G:EDGI:9 CDI @CDL>C< I=: 6CHL:G ID >I:BH G:A6I:9 ID
@CDLA:9<:HI6I>HI>86AANH><C>;>86CI9>;;:G:C8:H>C6AA>I:BH6HL:AA6HCDI7:>C<HJG:D;I=:>G6II>IJ9:IDL6G9H#$0
>C;:8I:9E:DEA:HI6I>HI>86AANH><C>;>86CI9>;;:G:C8:H>C6AA>I:BH
.=:H:G:HJAIHH::BHJ<<:HI>K:D;H:M:9J86I>DC`H
:;;:8I>K:C:HH
.=:H:G:HJAIH=6K:7::C;DJC9>CDI=:GHIJ9>:H&>G7N'6G>H,DAA:G>
CDI=:G6HE:8I>C;6KDJG D;H:M:9J86I>DC>HI=6I>C <:C:G6A69DA:H8:CIH8DCH>9:G H:M:9J86I>DC L>AA =:AEI=:B

=6K:7:II:G@CDLA:9<:
.=:DC:HI=6IHI6I:9=6K>C<=69H:M:9J86I>DC8A6HH:H9JG>C<I=:A6HIH8=DDAN:6GHG:EDGI:9
;::A>C< L:AA >C;DGB:9 7N >I
,:<6G9A:HH I=:N 9D CDI >9:CI>;N I:68=:GH 6H 6<:CIH L=D B6@: I=:B ;::A K:GN
8DB;DGI67A:L=:CI=:NC::9IDI6A@67DJIH:M:9J86I>DCIDE>8H
.=:N8=DDH:I=:>G;G>:C9H6C98DAA:6<J:HID9DHD
.=>H B6N 7: 9J: ID I=: ;68I I=6I I=: H:M :9J86I>DC IDE>8H L:G: CDI A>HI:9 >C I=: FJ:HI>DCC6>G: 6C9 I=:>G B6?DG
8DC8:GCH B6N 7: G:A6I:9 ID >HHJ:H I=:N LDJA9 EG:;:G ID 9>H8JHH L>I= HDB:DC: I=:>G DLC 6<: 6C9 CDI 69JAIH
(DG:DK:GL=:C6H@:967DJII=:>G;6KDG>I:HDJG8:HD;>C;DGB6I>DCBDHI8=DH:I=:>CI:GC:I
.=:H:G:HJAIH=6K:7::C
;DJC9>CDI=:G HIJ9>:H"DDA916G96GA>C
C96H;DGI=:G:6HDCH ;DG>C>I>6I>C<I=:>GH:MJ6AA>;:I=:N
E:G8:>K:69DA:H8:CIH9D>I7:86JH:I=:NL6CIIDIGN>I6C97:86JH:I=:N6G:>CADK:
.=:H:FJ:HI>DCHL:G:6CHL:G:9
7N6AA69DA:H8:CIHG:<6G9A:HH=6K>C<DGCDI>C>I>6I:9I=:>GH:MJ6AA>;:
.=:H:G:HJAIH=6K:6AHD 7::C;DJC9>CEG:K>DJH
#-HIJ9>:H(6IDH:I6A

*K:G6AAH:MJ6A>IN>H6I=:B:I=6IC::9H>CI:GK:CI>DC
'6I:AN<DK:GCB:CIH=6K:7::C9:KDI>C<6<G:6I6BDJCID;
I>B: 6C9 BDC:N ID H:MJ6A 6C9 G:EGD9J8I>K: =:6AI= >HHJ:H ;DG L=>8= +DGIJ<6A >H CD :M8:EI>DC
.=:G: =6H 7::C 6C
:;;DGI >C :K6AJ6I>C< I=: EGD8:HH 7JI CDI I=: G:HJAIH D; H:M :9J86I>DC
-:M :9J86I>DC H=DJA9 7: >BEA:B:CI:9 6C9
:K6AJ6I:9 >C 6 BDG: HNHI:B6I>8 L6N
*JG 6C6ANH:H HJ<<:HI I=6I ;DGB6A H:M :9J86I>DC >C H8=DDA 8DCI:MI EGDBDI:H
EGDI:8I>K: H:MJ6A 7:=6K>DJGH 7JI I=:G: >H HI>AA 6 ADI ID 7: 9DC: H>C8: CDI 6AA 69DA:H8:CIH G:;:G =6K>C< EGDI:8I>K:
7:=6K>DJGH6C9I=6I86C7G>C< B6?DGC:<6I>K:DJI8DB:H>C I:GBHD;EJ7A>8 =:6AI=,6B>GD,:>H (6IDH>C>O
->B\:H
*CI=:L=DA:I=>H HIJ9NHJ<<:HIHI=6IH:M:9J86I>DC>HB6@>C<69>;;:G:C8:>CI=:H:MJ6A7:=6K>DJGH
D;+DGIJ<J:H:NDJI=
.=:;>C9>C<HD;I=>HHIJ9NBJHI7:8DCH>9:G:9>CA><=ID;I=:HIJ9N`HHIG:C<I=H6C9A>B>I6I>DCH
.=>HG:H:6G8=L6H
86GG>:9 DJI L>I= 6 C6I>DC6AAN G:EG:H:CI6I>K: H6BEA: >C
):K:GI=:A:HH >I G:A>:9 DC H:A; G:EDGI:9 B:6HJG:H 6C9
G:86AA 7>6H
AHD I=: FJ:HI>DCC6>G: 9>9CRI 8DCI:BEA6I: B:6HJG:H 67DJI 69DA:H8:CIH` BDI>K6I>DC 6C9 7:=6K>DJG6A
H@>AAHI=6I6G:E6GID;I=:$(BD9:A!>H=:G!>H=:G HDCDI6AAK6G>67A:HD;I=:$(BD9:AL:G:6HH:HH:9
$IL6HCÌEDHH>7A:ID>C8AJ9:I=DH:>CI=:FJ:HI>DCC6>G:7:86JH:>I6HH:HH:H6A6G<:H8DE:D;HJ7?:8IHG:A6I:9ID=:6AI=
=:6AI= G:A6I:97:=6K>DJGHHJ8=6HID7688DJH:9>:I6GN7:=6K>DJGE=NH>86A68I>K>IN6C96A8D=DAJH:6C9I=:HD8>6A
8DCI:MIHD;NDJC<E:DEA:`H=:6AI=
!JIJG:G:H:6G8=:HH=DJA96HH:HHBDI>K6I>DC6C97:=6K>DJG6AH@>AAH6HHD8>6I:9ID
H:MJ6A =:6AI=IDD
CDI=:G>BEDGI6CI6HE:8I>H I=6IH:M:9J86I>DC =6HCDI7::C69DEI:97N6AAH8=DDAH9:HE>I:6AA
<DK:GCB:CI6A :;;DGIH HD >I >H 9>;;>8JAI ID 9:8>9: I=: BDB:CI ;GDB L=>8= >I >H EDHH>7A: ID :K6AJ6I: >I
$I`H 6AHD
>BEDGI6CIID:K6AJ6I:I=:8JGG>8JA66C9I=:H8=DDAH`8DBB>IB:CIIDI=:8JGG>8JA6
.=>HG:H:6G8=L6H86GG>:9DJIL>I=6C6I>DC6AANG:EG:H:CI6I>K:H6BEA:>C 6C96>B:9ID<>K:>CH><=IIDI=:
7:C:;>IHD;H:M:9J86I>DC>CH8=DDA8DCI:MI
.=:;>C9>C<HHJ<<:HIH:K:G6AEDH>I>K::;;:8IHD;H:M:9J86I>DCC6B:AN
I=: 67>A>IN ID :;;:8I>K:AN EDHIEDC: H:MJ6A 9:7JI 6C9 >BEGDK: @CDLA:9<: 6C9 6II>IJ9:H I=:G:;DG: ;>C9>C<H 6G:
EGDB>H>C<
!& $#
.=:;>GHIILD6JI=DGH=6K:H8=DA6GH=>EH<G6CI:97N!. _ -!,#-!,#

-!(#/.'(. /)'
" #
K:GN'
'6O96C:"

1=6I9DL:@CDL67DJIH:MJ6A 6C9G:EGD9J8I>K:=:6AI=D;69DA:H8:CIH>C JGDE:
(%30-.%!,-30,!*-&-,20!#%.2)-,!,$%.0-$3#2)4%%!*2(!0% -- -
6:A:%
JHH:A9DGE
(6:H-

DC9DBJH:H:A; :;;>868N:;;:8IDC>CI:C9:96C968IJ6A8DC9DBJH:>C
69DA:H8:CIH
-30,!*-&$-*%1#%,2%!*2( _
:CI:GH ;DG >H:6H: DCIGDA 6C9 +G:K:CI>DC

2DJI= ,>H@ :=6K>DG -JGK:>AA6C8: _ /C>I:9 -I6I:H
-JGK:>AA6C8:-JBB6G>:H
:E6GIB:CID;#:6AI=6C9#JB6C-:GK>8:H

JGG>:
#JGG:AB6CC&
-:II:GID7JAI:1
-B>I=,
.D99%

%!*2(!,$(%!*2("%(!4)-30!+-,'
6-3,'.%-.*%
DE:C=6<:C1DGA9#:6AI=*G<6C>O6I>DC
>>DG>D
J9A:N1
&:AAN(
-D:I%
(7L6G6%
-=6GE:+DII:G%

-D8>6A8D<C>I>K:8DGG:A6I:HD;
H:MJ6A:ME:G>:C8:6C98DC9DB JH:6BDC< I=GDJ<= N:6G DA969DA:H8:CIH
-30,!*-&$-*%1#%,2%!*2(
_
!>H=:G1
!>H=:G%

/C9:GHI6C9>C<6C9EGDBDI>C<$-EG:K:CI>K:7:=6K>DJG8DC8:EIJ6ABD9:A6C9
:9J86I>DC6AIDDAH
(% !,!$)!,-30,!*-&3+!, %53!*)26 _
"D9:6J
0><C:H
J8ADH (
)6K6GGD !
6NA6 !

"G6C9?:6C #

!68I:JGH 6HHD8>YH S JC:
>C>I>6I>DC H:MJ:AA: EGY8D8: 8=:O A:H ;>AA:H 9DCCY:H !G6CW6>H:H 9: A`:CFJZI: >CI:GC6I>DC6A: #:6AI= :=6K>DJG >C
-8=DDA 6<:9=>A9G:C#-*(-
6,7#-*-')%"12720)/3%%02)*)27 _
"D9:6J
)>8"67=6>CC-
0><C:H
,DHH%
DN8:1
.D99%

DCIG68:EI>K:JH:7N N:6G DA9
HIJ9:CIH 6I I=:>G A6HI H:MJ6A >CI:G8DJGH: _ G:HJAIH ;GDB 8DJCIG>:H
0#()4%1 -& %$)!20)#1 !,$ $-*%1#%,2
%$)#),% _
"DDA9+
16G9(
6GA>C

6CI=:$CI:GC:I7:JH:9ID>BEGDK:H:MJ6A=:6AI=6L6G:C:HH>CL:7 L>H:
NDJC<E:DEA: -30,!*-&!+)*6*!,,),'%.0-$3#2)4%%!*2(!0%
&>G7N
'6G>H

,DAA:G>'

-:M6C9 #$0:9J86I>DCEGD<G6BH.=:>G>BE68IDC H:MJ6A7:=6K>DGHD;
NDJC<E:DEA:I=GDJ<=DJI I=:LDGA9
-30,!*-&$-*%1#%,2%!*2(
&>G7N %
06C 9:G -AJ>?H 1
JGG>:

#- G>:;>C< +6E:G 7 _ II>IJ9:H IDL6G9H 8DC9DB JH:
#-G>:;>C<+6E:G-:G>:H
&D=A:G+
&
(6C=6GI'

'6;;:GIN1

7HI>C:C8: DCAN6C98DBEG:=:CH>K:H:M :9J86I>DC6C9I=:
>C>I>6I>DCD;H:MJ6A68I>K>IN 6C9I::CEG:<C6C8N
-30,!*-&$-*%1#%,2%!*2(
(69@DJG
!6G=6I.
#6AE:GC
"D9:6J
"67=6>CC-

6GAN9DA:H8:CI-:MJ6A$C>I>6I>DC6H6
+GD7A:B:=6K>DGDBE6G6I>K:-IJ9ND;!>K:)6I>DCH
-30,!*-&$-*%1#%,2%!*2(
(6IDH (
"
->B\:H
.DBY "
6B68=D $
!:GG:>G6 (
,6B>GD '
,:>H (
FJ>E6 K:CIJG6 -D8>6A
!:$% $-1 $-*%1#%,2%1 -023'3%1%1 ; %*!290)- $- 123$-
-!(#/.'(.
/)'
(J:AA:G.

"6K>C'

&JA@6GC>
.=:6HHD8>6I>DC7:IL::C H:M:9J86I>DC6C9NDJI=`H:C<6<:B:CI
>C H:MJ6A >CI:G8DJGH: 6<: 6I ;>GHI >CI:G8DJGH: 6C9 7>GI= 8DCIGDA JH: 6I ;>GHI H:MJ6A >CI:G8DJGH:
-30,!* -&
$-*%1#%,2 %!*2(
,6B>GD '
,:>H (
(6IDH (
"
>C>O %
->B\:H

9J86WUD -:MJ6A DC=:8>B:CIDH G:CW6H
I>IJ9:H:DBEDGI6B:CIDHCDH69DA:H8:CI:H
%4)12!-023'3%1!$%!:$%:"*)#!

,D7>C '
>IIJH +
1=>I6@:G
GDH7N ,
I=>:G &
(:OD;; %
+6EE6H :AJ86 &

:=6K>DJG6A
>CI:GK:CI>DCHIDG:9J8:>C8>9:C8:D;#$0-.6C9EG:<C6C8N6BDC<69DA:H8:CIH69:869:>CG:K>:L
-30,!*-&
$-*%1#%,2%!*2( _
.=: #:CGN %
&6>H:G !6B>AN

-6;:G H:M DC9DBH 6C9 aI=: E>AAb
-:M -B6GIH
88:HH:9 >C
=IIELLL
@;;
DG<:CIE6GIC:GH=>EHJEAD69-:M-B6GIH -JGK:N -6;:G -:M DC9DBH 6C9 I=: +>AA -JBB6GN
E9 ;
/)$-

"AD76A ,:EDGI /)$- G:EDGI DC I=: "AD76A >9H :E>9:B>8
%D>CI /C>I:9 )6I>DCH
+GD<G6BB:DC#$0>9H
1#*'>7G6GN6I6AD<J: >C +J7A>86I>DC6I6
1#*

+DH>I>DC E6E:G DC B6>CHIG:6B>C< 69DA:H8:CI EG:<C6C8N >C :;;DGIH ID B6@: EG:<C6C8N H6;:G
:E6GIB:CID;(6@>C<+G:<C6C8N-6;:G
1#*D8JB:CI+GD9J8I>DC-:GK>8:H":C:K6-L>IO:GA6C9
1#*

-C6EH=DID;I=:#:6AI=D; 2DJC<E:DEA:>C JGDE:
1#*,:<>DC6A*;;>8:;DG JGDE:

M:9J86I DC6BDC 6,6B GDQ (6GI6,: HQ (6G 96"6HE6G9: (6IDHQ %Dhyak:H C Oq

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

You might also like

M:9J86I DC6BDC 6,6B GDQ (6GI6,: HQ (6G 96"6HE6G9: (6IDHQ %Dhyak:H C Oq

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Description:

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

M:9J86I DC6BDC 6,6B GDQ (6GI6,: HQ (6G 96"6HE6G9: (6IDHQ %Dhyak:H C Oq

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Available online at www.sciencedirect.

Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 29 (2011) 493 – 502

$CI:GC6I>DC6ADC;:G:C8:DC 9J86I>DC6C9 9J86I>DC6A+HN8=DAD<N$ +-2 

 H:MJ6A:9J86I>DC @CDLA:9<:6II>IJ9:H H:MJ6A7:=6K>DJG 69DA:H8:CIH

6C9:6HI:GC JGDE:K:GN'6O96C: 6C9>CI=:/C>I:9-I6I:H:CI:GH;DG>H:6H:DCIGDA6C9+G:K:CI>DC

=6K:7:II:G@CDLA:9<: EG:K:CI#$0>C;:8I>DC =6K:7:II:GG:A6I>DCH=>EH

NDJG;G>:C9H NDJGE6G:CIH NDJG8DAA:6<J:H6C9

 !DJGH:MJ6A7:=6K>DJG>I:BH=6K:NDJ:K:G=69 H:MJ6A>CI:G8DJGH:2:H )D=DLDA9L:G:NDJL=:CNDJ

6C9=6K:NDJ:K:G=69H:MJ6A>CI:G8DJGH:7:86JH:NDJ9G6C@IDDBJ8= 6A8D=DADGIDD@9GJ<H2:H )D

 &CDLA:9<: G:<6G9>C< #$0 $- IG6CHB>HH>DC EG:K:CI>DC

,:<6G9>C<I=DH: L=D =6K:=69I=:>G;>GHI H:MJ6A>CI:G8DJGH: BDG:D;I:CI=:DC:H L=D =6K:=69H:M:9J86I>DC

:9J86I>DC 8A6HH:H I=DJ<= K6G>6I>DCH 6G: CDI HI6I>HI>86AAN H><C>;>86CI

.67A: >;;:G:C8:H7:IL::C=6K>C< CDI=6K>C<=69H:M:9J86I>DC6C9H:MJ6A7:=6K>DJG

.67A: >;;:G:C8:H7:IL::C=6K>C< CDI=6K>C<=69H:M:9J86I>DC6C9 @CDLA:9<:G:<6G9>C<#$0 $-

#6K>C<=69H:M )DI=6K>C<=69 .DI6A

$9DCDI&CDL       

    

.67A: >;;:G:C8:H7:IL::C=6K>C< CDI=6K>C<=69H:M:9J86I>DC6C9 6II>IJ9:H IDL6G9HE:DEA:A>K>C<L>I=#$0

#6K>C<=69H:M )DI=6K>C<=69 .DI6A

CDI=:G6HE:8I>C;6KDJG D;H:M:9J86I>DC>HI=6I>C <:C:G6A69DA:H8:CIH8DCH>9:G H:M:9J86I>DC L>AA =:AEI=:B

.=:;>GHIILD6JI=DGH=6K:H8=DA6GH=>EH<G6CI:97N!. _ -!,#    -!,#    

:CI:GH ;DG >H:6H: DCIGDA 6C9 +G:K:CI>DC

You might also like

$CI:GC6I>DC6ADC;:G:C8:DC 9J86I>DC6C9 9J86I>DC6A+HN8=DAD<N$ +-2

H:MJ6A:9J86I>DC @CDLA:9<:6II>IJ9:H H:MJ6A7:=6K>DJG 69DA:H8:CIH

6C9:6HI:GC JGDE:K:GN'6O96C: 6C9>CI=:/C>I:9-I6I:H:CI:GH;DG>H:6H:DCIGDA6C9+G:K:CI>DC

=6K:7:II:G@CDLA:9<:EG:K:CI#$0>C;:8I>DC=6K:7:II:GG:A6I>DCH=>EH

NDJG;G>:C9H NDJGE6G:CIH NDJG8DAA:6<J:H6C9

!DJGH:MJ6A7:=6K>DJG>I:BH=6K:NDJ:K:G=69 H:MJ6A>CI:G8DJGH:2:H)D=DLDA9L:G:NDJL=:CNDJ

6C9=6K:NDJ:K:G=69H:MJ6A>CI:G8DJGH:7:86JH:NDJ9G6C@IDDBJ8= 6A8D=DADGIDD@9GJ<H2:H)D

&CDLA:9<: G:<6G9>C< #$0$- IG6CHB>HH>DCEG:K:CI>DC

,:<6G9>C<I=DH: L=D =6K:=69I=:>G;>GHI H:MJ6A>CI:G8DJGH: BDG:D;I:CI=:DC:H L=D =6K:=69H:M:9J86I>DC

:9J86I>DC 8A6HH:H I=DJ<= K6G>6I>DCH 6G: CDI HI6I>HI>86AAN H><C>;>86CI

.67A: >;;:G:C8:H7:IL::C=6K>C<CDI=6K>C<=69H:M:9J86I>DC6C9H:MJ6A7:=6K>DJG

.67A: >;;:G:C8:H7:IL::C=6K>C<CDI=6K>C<=69H:M:9J86I>DC6C9 @CDLA:9<:G:<6G9>C<#$0$-

$9DCDI&CDL

.67A: >;;:G:C8:H7:IL::C=6K>C<CDI=6K>C<=69H:M:9J86I>DC6C9 6II>IJ9:H IDL6G9HE:DEA:A>K>C<L>I=#$0

CDI=:G6HE:8I>C;6KDJG D;H:M:9J86I>DC>HI=6I>C <:C:G6A69DA:H8:CIH8DCH>9:G H:M:9J86I>DC L>AA =:AEI=:B

.=:;>GHIILD6JI=DGH=6K:H8=DA6GH=>EH<G6CI:97N!. _ -!,#-!,#

:CI:GH ;DG >H:6H: DCIGDA 6C9 +G:K:CI>DC