Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Japanese Ethnopole As Determinant TH
The Japanese Ethnopole As Determinant TH
The Japanese Ethnopole As Determinant TH
Presented at: Hard Times in the Arkansas Delta: 1942-1945: The Japanese American
Examining the lives lived by nisei during their formative youth demonstrates that those who
grew up in the shadow of a Japantown developed a unique and strong "Nisei Mindset" that could
not be identified as truly Japanese or truly American. Unlike their rural, farming counterparts,
nisei who grew up within or near a Japantown were raised in a more eclectic atmosphere that
exposed them to both their parent's strict sense of upbringing and their community's more
permissive and worldly nature. These nisei were often raised to respect traditional roles and
social mores, but were also exposed to both American culture as well as the cultures of a city's
many ethnic minorities. Because of their location, Japantowns allowed Nisei to grow up
relatively protected from the racial strife surrounding them, but still within full view of its vitriol.
Nihonmachi allowed nisei to easily contrast their parents traditional neo-Confucian worldview
with the more permissive culture of the American city surrounding them. The result was that
nisei were cross-pollinated by their surroundings and became a hybrid species that took on
Who were the nisei? If defined by their numbers, the nisei are a sizable group that were
born over a short period of time. By 1940, there were roughly 72,000 Nisei living on the west
coast and at least one-half of these had grown up with connections to the various west coast
Nihonmachi.1 Thus, Japantowns were directly involved in the upbringing of roughly 36,000 nisei.
However a cultural definition for nisei is rather difficult to fix. Even nisei who attempted to
characterize the group found this to be complicated and problematic to attribute. By virtue of
their American education and training they discern great differences between themselves and the
first generation, and they find, as they mature, that they cannot identify themselves with the
broader community of American citizens of European descent."2 Many found that there was a
Bruce Makoto Arnold - Page |2
distinctive nisei personality that was defined by a blend of issei tradition and American cultural
both in a city's public education system (which was usually muti-ethnic near the J-Towns) and
through a system of Japanese grammar schools. Because of this, the nisei's exposure to Japanese,
American, and other cultures started from a very early age and continued throughout their
educational years. Classroom photographs taken after 1920 in schools such as Rafael Weill
Elementary School on the edge of San Francisco's Japantown showed an ethnic mix of Japanese,
Chinese, and Caucasian.3 In Portland, Japanese students attended two schools located near the
Nihonmachi, which were also attended by a large contingent of Chinese students. The teachers at
Atkinson were mostly Caucasian-American, and none spoke Japanese. Children were often given
approximations of their names such as "Mary" for "Masuko" and "Kowalski" for Kawasaki.4 The
nisei had a low incidence of dropouts and often excelled in areas such as art and music, that were
mostly neglected by the average, Japanese school. By 1937, nisei in Seattle were doing so well
In order to educate their children in Japanese language and cultural mores, issei in many
curriculum that stressed Japanese language, geography, history, and cultural values. Although
the grammar schools followed the curriculum prescribed by the Japanese Ministry of Education,
gakuen also worked to ensure that the schools helped acculturate their children as Japanese-
Americans. One of the primary directives for teachers was to help their students "feel pride in
being Japanese-Americans," and nisei were "not forget that" they were "American citizens."6
Gakuen teachers were further instructed to learn more about American culture, politics, and
Bruce Makoto Arnold - Page |3
industry in order to" help their children to hone "select character traits" such as patriotism and
Many nisei described their educational experiences in this system as dual-natured. One
nisei remembered that she found herself "switching" her "personality back and forth daily like a
chameleon." At her public school, she found that she was a "jumping, screaming roustabout
Yankee," but at three o'clock, she became a "modest, faltering, earnest little Japanese girl with a
small, timid voice." On the playground at the gakuen, she and the other children "behaved
cautiously" and made sure to avail themselves of filial customs such as bowing to the teacher
"slowly and sanctimoniously."8 At home, Japanese parents continually stressed acculturation into
the American system, but did so through the lens of traditional Japanese values. Steeped in the
language of acculturation and filial piety, issei parents often encouraged their children to
"continue with American higher education…show the Americans your ability…that is your duty
to your parents."9
Outside of school, young nisei were exposed to the American cultural mainstream was
through ever-present civic and cultural organizations that began to form in the Nihonmachi
during the 1920s. In the beginning, these organizations were run by issei, but in time, nisei began
to take over the reins in earnest and adapted the organizations to the needs of their peer group.10
These social venues were "especially important in the context of relations…and provided a vital
alternative for nisei who were often excluded from" other non-Japanese clubs "or unable to
Many of the early organizations set up for Nisei were associated with established national
organizations or local church bodies. Troop 12, the first Japanese-American troop was founded
in1915.12 Although the troop remained fairly small during its initial decade, and influx of nisei
Bruce Makoto Arnold - Page |4
boys in the mid-1920s saw the troop swell and divide to accommodate the newer members.
Other Japanese Boy Scout Troops were sponsored by nikkei businesses and issei parents, but
expeditions, and marched in parades throughout the community with other regional troops
comprised of majority and minority Americans, as well as boys who were recent immigrants to
the area.13
Nisei girls joined girls’ clubs such as the Junior Girl Reserves and the Girl Scouts of
America, which involved them in activities such as hiking, swimming, handicrafts, music, and
indoor and outdoor sports.14 The Japanese YWCA founded and run by more senior nisei women,
beginning in the 1930s, gave young Japanese-American women skills in civic responsibility and
leadership. A pamphlet promoting YWCA programs explained that the organization was "doing
its part in the preparing of young people for the responsibility they will be expected to carry as
While the Boy Scouts and YWCA were teaching their versions of "universal" values to
nisei, many nisei organizations were also interested in teaching Japanese-American children
about issues that were not central to issei, such as American cultural customs and holidays. Nisei
clubs would often have parties centered around holidays such as Christmas, Thanksgiving, and
Halloween. In one example, in 1926, a Halloween party included a "costume parade, bobbing for
apples in a tub of water, and eating treats such as homemade fudge."16 Organizers of a
Nihonmachi Christmas party ensured that the nisei were exposed to more than one cultural
tradition when they not only ate a traditional Christmas meal, but capped that evening's
For both genders, organizations planned leisure activities that issei parents were too busy
to organize for their families. Visits to the beach or to a park for a picnic were common for nisei
groups. One girls' group went to an ice cream factory where they learned "how they made
Eskimo pies, sundaes, bricks, and last by not least ice cream."18 Recreation for nisei consisted of
both American and Japanese athletics and games. Baseball, golf, basketball, football, and
bowling were sponsored by Japanese businesses and civic and religious organizations.
Additionally, judo, kendo, Odori (dance), sumo (Japanese wrestling), and koto (Japanese harp)
were also very popular with nisei youth.19 One nisei, Brian Niya noticed that the "Japanese-
American…teams and leagues all observed a social function, allowing young nisei…to meet and
social with" their counterparts "in other communities."20 One girl remember watching nisei boys'
club members play and who, in turn, would come to watch the girls play, giving nisei boys and
girls a chance to interact outside the watchful gaze of their more traditional, issei parents, who
Nisei children were also exposed to public civic events in which they would demonstrate
aspects of both their American and Japanese heritage. Organizations such as the Japanese
Association Marching Band, made up of nisei youth from San Francisco's Japantown, performed
both American and Japanese music within and outside of the community.22 Floats such as those
sponsored by the Portland Japanese Community and the Oregon Japanese Farmers' Association
appeared in several of the local Rose Parades. Organizations such as the San Francisco
Japantown community fielded floats and cultural exhibits for the 1939 Golden Gate International
Exposition.23 These floats stressed Japanese-American integration into the community and often
featured American flags and patriotic themes integrated with Japanese cultural icons such as
As group interaction between the sexes became more popular, particularly between sister
organizations such as boys' and girls' clubs and the YMCA and YWCA. A resident of the Seattle
Nihonmachi noted that the dances had to be organized by nisei "totally independent of issei
supervision since the latter had little concept of how such events were fashioned in America."
Most issei had ultra-conservative views of dating and supervised the relationships of their
children very closely. Many issei considered dances vulgar, particularly during slow numbers
which forced children to come together in an embrace.25 However, urban issei were also
generally unwilling to cut their children off from an experience that was identifiably "American,"
which meant that these dances and activities "were often settings for the Nisei's first boy-girl
relations."26
As the nisei matured, they began to face considerable dating roadblocks erected both by
their parents and the community. In the Japantowns, many issei parents tried acting, or recruited
other neighborhood issei to act, as intermediaries (baishakunin) between nisei females and males,
but this met with a great deal of resistance by nisei who had grown up in the public schools, fully
aware of more liberal American courting rituals.27 In one incident, nisei Charles Kamayasu was
invited to a dinner party and was seated across from another nisei, Yuki Kuwahara. The issei
host of the banquet turned to him during the meal, pointed to Yuki and asked "Charlie, do you
like her?" Here, the intersection of two cultures clashed, and although he "wasn't particularly
interested in getting married at that time" he relented, remembering "she was sitting across the
table, looking down at her lap. How could I answer no when she was right there?" The host was
pleased and said "Okay, you two get married," and Charlie shook Yuki's hand.28 One couple
began their courtship after meeting during a nisei camping trip. They "got together on different
occasions, parties, or…the YMCA." Later, they started "meeting outside the YMCA" as
Bruce Makoto Arnold - Page |7
"couples" However, in the end, the woman's parents would not consent to a marriage.29 It turns
out that the male suitor was from a rural farming family that no one in the Nihonmachi knew.
The woman's parents eventually relented when the rural couple sent intermediaries to ask for her
hand in marriage.30 Weddings in Nihonmachi were often dualistic. There was often an American
service to begin with the bride wearing a traditional white wedding dress and then wearing a
The nisei who grew up in Japantowns were often the children of business proprietors or
on-site managers. Issei-run businesses rarely catered only to ethnic Japanese because they were
often located next to financial, industrial, or transportation centers that brought individuals of
many races into the area. Grocery stores and restaurants run by issei were often frequented by the
locals and blue-collar workers or businessmen during the day while hotels were often the homes
Nisei were usually involved in their parents' businesses before they even knew how to
read or write. Because of the various anti-alien acts, issei were unable to purchase land or own
businesses. Issei would purchase land and register it and their businesses in the names of their
nisei children.32 In order to appear "less threatening," these businesses' livery and signs were
often painted and printed without Japanese characters.33 Some went as far as to take American
sounding names, such as Jimmy's Clothes Shop, owned by Masaaki Usuda in Portland, Oregon.34
Japanese grocers such as the Yoshitomis ran the "Rose City Brand" booth at the Portland Public
market.
Churches and other religious organizations in the various Japantowns frequented by the
nisei also displayed similar cultural dualisms to their secular counterparts. The Japanese
government initially recommended and sponsored the establishment of churches to help reduce
Bruce Makoto Arnold - Page |8
the immoral and vice-ridden lives of the early Japanese men who flocked to an area. In San
Francisco, organizations like the Japanese Presbyterian Church (established in 1885) were
created "teach Japanese immigrants good character and values, which they could take back to
Japan for the advancement of the country."35 Although Christian churches and the various
Japanese religions often bickered with each other in Japan, relationships between the various
Since the churches and missions set up for the early issei stressed harmony and stability
over religious doctrine, many issei came to see them as social rather than religious organization.
The general attitude presented to nisei children indicated that church was a "community activity"
designed for socialization and acculturation. Many issei did not even care whether the religion
was an Eastern or a Western one. One Seattle issei parent "told [his] children that it didn't matter
whether they went to a Christian church or a Buddhist church, but that they should go to some
kind of a church." This issei went to a Congregational Church, but allowed his children to attend
Many of the first churches attended by nisei were often subsets of larger white churches
or were run by white missionaries. These churches or missionary societies held classes that
ranged from basic Bible studies to "lessons in American ways of behavior which the parents
were unable to provide."38 As they grew older, nisei began to take over the instruction of Sunday
began promote the involvement of nisei through all stages of their childhoods. For instance,
young nisei women became active in the church generally through clubs known as fujinkai. They
oversaw the social activities within the church,40 which included "refreshments…visitations to
Bruce Makoto Arnold - Page |9
patients in hospitals, congratulatory obligations, and janitorial services for the hall"41 Fujinkai
were also responsible for charity drives, supplying kitchens, and furnishing a minister's home.42
the nisei to interpret the world around them in ways that were separate from both their issei
parents and their Caucasian-American counterparts. Nisei often recalled that their experiences
within or near the Nihonmachi were often conflicted and associated these with their difficulties
forming a stable and true identity. Difficult communication between issei parents and their nisei
children strained interpersonal relationships. As one nisei woman bluntly stated: "I feel that I
couldn't make them understand me nor could they make me understand them." She went on to
say that "because of this difficulty…I have to work out my problems by myself."43 Of course,
there was not only a language barrier, but an underlying cultural barrier, as well.
Many issei parents rankled at the lifestyles their nisei children led. One, in particular,
noted disdainfully that Japanese girls growing up in the Nihonmachi "adopted the language and
attire of their [non-Japanese] peers.” But, apparently, the devil lived next door because the issei
also noted that it was the "Japanese-run department stores and beauty salons” that were selling
them the clothes and styling their hair.44 An issei community leader, Akasuki Sakano wrote a
[those] painted, red-hot shebas that strut about the streets of Little Tokio."45
Many nisei tried to choose one culture over the other struggled because their siblings or
close friends often demonstrated the opposite cultural characteristics. One male, conflicted
between his parents' traditional values and the looser urban values around him, worried about his
year-younger brother who "broke away" just like "young people…in America." The older
B r u c e M a k o t o A r n o l d - P a g e | 10
brother was in high school and he had "to watch [the younger brother] to see that he [went to
school]; he would rather go fishing."46 He also watched his younger sister "who was married in
America make her own arrangements" while, at the same time, viewed his older sister in Japan,
who "was married there according to arrangements made by the family."47 Another eighteen year
old nisei, educated in the U.S., but returned to Japan after her high school graduation, found that
she was thought a "wicked, unruly girl" who felt hat she was not indebted to her mother and
father "for a single thing."48 In the end, she attempted to go back to America even though her
"aunts, father's half sister" and other family members were "trying to do everything in their
Many nisei felt confused when they found that their peers within the education system
were often accepting of them, while Caucasian adults and the rest of the world around them was
not. This is particularly notable if one compares the experiences of young nisei to their
experiences just a few years later. For instance, one nisei who went to high school near Seattle's
Nihonmachi found that "white people as a rule are very pleasant."50 Another who went to a
school near Los Angeles' Japantown "mingled almost entirely with the American children" when
he was younger but "began to gravitate toward the Japanese pupils" in high school as he “began
to feel slightly uneasy among the Americans."51 Another felt Another Nisei felt that he had
"encountered few, practically no prejudiced feelings among [his] friends" and "was treated with
kindness and equality."52 However, in college, he felt that "professors and the students treat the
Oriental students with some kind of pity, and not with understanding."53After graduation
however, he "bought a bungalow in Belvedere" but was asked within "two weeks" by "two
gentlemen" asked him"politely, but not too cordially, to leave the house as [they] cannot live
B r u c e M a k o t o A r n o l d - P a g e | 11
among white people."54 Another nisei who went to Stanford "mingled entirely with American
Many nisei stressed their "Americanness" over their Japanese culture, which gave rise to
a sense of alienation from their mother race. One nisei college student felt a sense of disdain
toward native Japanese, saying that "some of these Japanese students called me snob because I
did not mingle with them…most of them were Japan born and I did not enjoy their company."56
He thought that "in America the young [ethnic Japanese] people tend to break away from their
parents," which he considered a sign of maturity, unlike those who were raised in Japan who
were “immature” by comparison. The same student found that "when any discussion involving
Japan and America comes up, I find myself taking the part of the latter" especially "in connection
with the anti-Oriental agitation; I feel that the Japanese have many faults because they do not
understand the Americans."57 Another deplored the nisei students who came from more
traditional and insular farming communities, saying: "at times I feel sorry for certain
Japanese…as I have gone through the farming districts where I have seen them at their toil and
have considered how narrow their lies must be as they work along day after that, I have really
pitied them."58
The varied and often confusing cultural experiences of the nisei who grew up in or near
America’s multiple Nihonmachi propelled them into a cultural no-man’s-land. Nisei longed for
but also demonstrated a sense of Eastern filial piety, long-suffering, and quiet acceptance. Frank
Miyamoto, a nisei himself, wrote a summary in the 1930s that defined the nisei as men and
women of "industry" who had "respect for authority…acute sensitivity to the attitudes of others
and a consequent restraint of…behavior in the effort to avoid disapproval" and led lives of
B r u c e M a k o t o A r n o l d - P a g e | 12
"cleanliness." Miyamoto noted that nisei often had blunted affects and a tendency to shy away
from emotional duress. Nisei had a "tendency to react inflexibly to new situation" and had
Miyamoto said that Nisei demonstrated "a high degree of sensitivity to the attitudes of others
toward him, and a tendency to constrain his behavior in order to minimize the risk of
criticism.”59
Further research is needed to more fully understand the gap that existed between urban
nisei and their rural counterparts. Most of the leaders of important nisei organizations, such as
the Japanese American Citizens League, were raised in or around Nihonmachi, as were many of
the successful nisei business, political, civic, and religious leaders before the Second World War.
Most of the leaders who fought against the United States government to bring it to accountability
for its actions during the Second World War were led by men who grew up in Nihonmachi. Nisei
such as Minoru “Min” Yasui, who grew up in Portland’s Nihonmachi, Fred Korematsu, a
product of the small Japanese J-Town in Oakland, and Gordon Hirabayashi, born and raised in
Seattle’s Japanese community, all brought cases against the United States. These nisei brought
closure to the lives of over 120,000 issei, nisei, and sansei (third-generation) Japanese and
Japanese-Americans who were forcibly moved away from their homes, businesses,
neighborhoods, and friends into internment camps located in the most desolate corners of
America. Ironically, but perhaps not uncharacteristically, it was also urban nisei who helped
arrange for the removal of the ethnic Japanese along the coast and encouraged the evacuees to go
peacefully.
B r u c e M a k o t o A r n o l d - P a g e | 13
The many Nihonmachi that existed before the Second World War left the United States
with an indelible legacy. They molded and shaped the lives of an entire generation of Americans
who integrated themselves into the fabric of their nation, despite their struggles with what it
many nisei, they also contributed to the diversity of the urban landscape as well as the American
national character. In this way, the nisei who grew up in the Japantowns were, in fact, wholly
integrated into the myriad experiences that have taken advantage of a mythical, but very real,
national ideal, despite having to endure an equally mythical, but entirely real, American
immigrant experience.
B r u c e M a k o t o A r n o l d - P a g e | 14
1
Thomas, et. al, 578.
2
Forrest Emanuel LaViolette, Americans of Japanese Ancestry (New York: Arno Press, 1978), 9.
3
Ibid, 46.
4
George Katagiri, Cannon Kitayama, and Liz Nakazawa, Nihonmachi: Portland's Japantown Remembered,
Edited by Doug Katagiri (Portland: Oregon Nikkei Legacy Center, 2002), 12.
5
Ibid, Daniels, 174, and Glenn 56.
6
Kazu Ito, Issei: A History of Japanese Immigrants in North America, trans. Shinichiro Nakamura and Jean
S. Gerard (Seattle : Japanese community Service, 1973), 589-90 and quoted in Paul R. Spickard, Japanese
Americans: The Formation and Transformations of an Ethnic Group (New York: Twayne Publishers, 1996), 73.
7
Spickard, 73.
8
Monica Sone, Nissei Daughter (Boston: Little, Brown, 1955), 22-23.
9
S. Frank Miyamoto, Social Solidarity Among the Japanese in Seattle (Seattle: University of Washington
Press, 1984), 108.
10
Valerie J. Matsumoto “Japanese American Girls’ Clubs in Los Angeles During the 1920s and 1930s,” in
Asian/Pacific Islander American Women: A Historical Anthology, ed. by Shirley Hune and Gail M. Nomura (New
York: New York University Press, 2003), 176.
11
Ibid.
12
The Japantown Task Force, Inc., 21.
13
Katagiri, et. al., 19.
14
Matsumoto, 177.
15
Quoted in Matsumoto, 176.
16
Ibid., 177.
17
Ibid.
18
Rafu Shimpo, August 9, 1926.
19
Katagiri, et. al., 22-27.
20
Brian Niiya, “Introduction,” in More than a Game: Sport in the Japanese American Community, ed.
Brian Niiya (Los Angeles: Japanese American National Museum, 2000), 39.
21
Quoted in Matsumoto, 178.
22
The Japantown Task Force, Inc., 46.
B r u c e M a k o t o A r n o l d - P a g e | 15
23
Ibid., 48.
24
Katagiri, et. al., 19.
25
Bill Hosokawa, Nisei: The Quiet Americans (New York: William Morrow and Company, Inc., 1969),
179.
26
Miyamoto, Social Solidarity, xvii.
27
Ibid., 57.
28
Hosokawa, 179-80.
29
Glenn, 57.
30
Ibid., 57-58.
31
Ibid., 57.
32
Quoted in Shelia Muto, "3 Generations of S.F. Japantown." Asian Week, March 8, 1991, 14.
33
Ibid.
34
Ibid., 5.
35
The Japantown Task Force, Inc., 25.
36
Daniels, 174.
37
Quoted in Daniels, 174.
38
Miyamoto, “An Immigrant Community in America,” 233.
39
Ibid.
40
Mei T. Nakano, Japanese American Women: Three Generations, 1890-1990 (Berkeley: Min Press
Publishing, 1990), 53.
41
Ibid.
42
Ibid.
43
Anonymous interview, “An American Born Japanese (Hopeful in Spite of Difficulties and
Disappointments),” in Orientals and Their Cultural Adjustment: Interviews, Life Histories and Social Adjustment
Experiences of Chinese and Japanese of Varying Backgrounds and Length of Residence in the United States
(Nashville: Social Science Institute, Fisk University, 1946), 102.
44
Quoted in Matsumoto, 174.
45
Ibid.
46
Anonymous interview, “Experiences of an American Born Japanese,” in Orientals and Their Cultural
Adjustment: Interviews, Life Histories and Social Adjustment Experiences of Chinese and Japanese of Varying
Backgrounds and Length of Residence in the United States (Nashville: Social Science Institute, Fisk University,
B r u c e M a k o t o A r n o l d - P a g e | 16
1946), 91.
47
Ibid., 91.
48
“Quotations From a Letter from a Japanese Girl,” in Orientals and Their Cultural Adjustment: Interviews,
Life Histories and Social Adjustment Experiences of Chinese and Japanese of Varying Backgrounds and Length of
Residence in the United States (Nashville: Social Science Institute, Fisk University, 1946), 93.
49
Ibid., 93.
50
Anonymous interview, “A High School Japanese Student’s Opinion of the Race Problem,” in Orientals
and Their Cultural Adjustment: Interviews, Life Histories and Social Adjustment Experiences of Chinese and
Japanese of Varying Backgrounds and Length of Residence in the United States (Nashville: Social Science Institute,
Fisk University, 1946), 105.
51
“An American Born Japanese (Hopeful in Spite of Difficulties and Disappointments),” 101.
52
“An American Born Japanese in America,” 95.
53
Ibid., 96.
54
Ibid., 96.
55
“Experiences of an American Born Japanese,” 88.
56
“Experiences of an American Born Japanese,” 88.
57
Ibid., 91.
58
“An American Born Japanese (Hopeful in Spite of Difficulties and Disappointments),” 103.
59
S. Frank Miyamoto, “Problems of Interpersonal Style among the Nisei,” American Journal 13, no. 2
(1986-87): 31-32.