Professional Documents
Culture Documents
California Edition: Blue Shield Cancels Pending Hike
California Edition: Blue Shield Cancels Pending Hike
California Edition
Calendar Blue Shield Cancels Pending Hike
Insurer Was Under Pressure To Moderate Stance
March 22 Blue Shield of California had the numbers to average increase per policyholder to 30%
support its third rate hike on its 194,000 since last fall.
individual policyholders in the past seven However, the Los Angeles Times reported
:-**&!O-*M+P!Q/+;2-+1*)6!(F-2-5&!(40! months, but apparently overwhelming public last week that hundreds of enrollees would
*)2(</-4+3/FR!'*).)4<!G)0/;(2!G(2F*(;</;)!
;2(/G+@!?-+2)&K:(2.(<-*/!8-49)*)4;)! disapproval prompted the abrupt cancellation see their premiums climb more 80% or more
8)4<)*6!S--0!:(G(*/<(4!=-+F/<(26!7-+! of the last increase this week. when all three rate hikes were factored
>45)2)+@!:F-4+-*)0!%&!<3)!=-+F/<(2! The San Francisco-based insurer together, and nearly a quarter of its customers
>++-;/(</-4!-9!:-1<3)*4!8(2/9-*4/(@!H$I#K announced Wednesday it would back off the would experience increases exceeding 50%.
H$TI@! rate hike scheduled to go into effect on May 1, That disclosure was an apparent tipping point
82/;M!=)*)!D-*!?-*)!N49-*G(</-4 and would impose no further rate increases on for Blue Shield’s decisionmakers, according to
its individual policyholders in 2011. some observers.
"As long-time advocates for universal “There was a lot of public shock that this
March 24-25 healthcare coverage, we are also deeply could be happening,” said Judy Dugan,
committed to the success of health reform. The research director for Consumer Watchdog, a
best way to fulll our mission and make Santa Monica-based advocacy group that
=)(2<3;(*)!D/4(4;/(2!?(4(5)G)4<! reform work is to keep costs down,” said Blue organized a protest at Blue Shield’s
>++-;/(</-4!U-*<3)*4!8(2/9-*4/(!83(F<)*! Shield Chief Executive Ofer Bruce Bodaken. headquarters earlier this year over the
>441(2!:F*/45!8-49)*)4;)@!:3)*(<-4! “By agreeing not to raise rates this year, we are premium increases. The group has also been
S*(40!=-<)26!:(;*(G)4<-@!B)9-*G!(40!/<+! helping to make coverage more affordable for critical of Blue Shield’s mushrooming cash
)99);<+!-4!3)(2<3;(*)!9/4(4;)!/+!(G-45!<3)! our members during tough economic times. reserves, which total about $2.3 billion, up
<-F/;+@!HVIKHWII@
It's a nancial risk for us, but a risk that's from $400 million in 2002.
82/;M!=)*)!D-*!?-*)!N49-*G(</-4 worth taking." Dugan said Blue Shield’s reserves – which
Blue Shield said foregoing the rate hike are about four times the amount legally
would save its individual policyholders required for solvency purposes – are not being
between $35 million and $40 million this used for the purpose of protecting the insurer
April 8-10 year. However, the insurer claims its losses in from economic uncertainties or a catastrophic
2011 from this segment would top the $27 avalanche of medical claims.
8(2/9-*4/(!:-;/)<&!9-*!=)(2<3;(*)! million hit it took in 2010, noting that “it continued to grow even in the deepest
><<-*4)&+6!>441(2!?))</45@!A)**(4)(! skyrocketing medical costs are among the part of the recent economic downturn,” she
B)+-*<6!B(4;3-!'(2-+!C)*0)+@!D-;1+!-4! reasons for the mounting losses. said.
4)E!3)(2<3;(*)!2(E+!(40!-<3)*!
0).)2-FG)4<+@!HIJIKHLII@ Blue Shield’s latest rate hike was to
average 6.5%, bringing the cumulative
82/;M!=)*)!D-*!?-*)!N49-*G(</-4
Continued on Next Page
E-Mail
info@payersandproviders.com with
the details of your event, or call
(877) 248-2360, ext. 3. It will be
published in the Calendar section,
space permitting.
!!!"#$$!%&!'(&)*+!,!'*-./0)*+!'1%2/+3/456!778
Payers & Providers NEWS Page 2
!!!"#$$!%&!'(&)*+!,!'*-./0)*+!'1%2/+3/456!778
Payers & Providers NEWS Page 3
!!!"#$$!%&!'(&)*+!,!'*-./0)*+!'1%2/+3/456!778
Payers & Providers OPINION Page 4
9-21:)!;6!<++1)!$$
Seniors To Be Hit Hard By Budget Cuts
'(&)*+!,!'*-./0)*+!/+! State And Federal Plans Would Hurt Nursing Facilities
=1%2/+3)0!).)*&!>31*+0(&!%&!
'(&)*+!,!'*-./0)*+!'1%2/+3/456!
778?!@4!(441(2!/40/./01(2! For low-income Californians who rely on $336,000 a year.! Strict regulations must still
+1%+A*/=B/-4!/+!CDD!(!&)(*! the government for their long-term care be met.! Cost components like food, and
EC$FD!/4!%12G!1=!B-!$#! needs (two-thirds of elders in skilled patient supplies must be purchased.! Rent has
+1%+A*/%)*+H?!<B!/+!0)2/.)*)0!%&! nursing homes receive assistance from to be paid. Twenty-four hour care must
)I:(/2!(+!(!'JK!(BB(A3:)4B6! Medi-Cal) there’s a trio of disturbing continue, but since labor represents 70% of
-*!(+!(4!)2)AB*-4/A!4)L+2)BB)*? financial proposals that threaten patient facility costs, the options for providers will be
safety and the delivery of to reduce wages or cut
quality care.! jobs.!
!On the federal level, Both choices are
@22!(0.)*B/+/456!+1%+A*/%)*!(40! the Obama onerous. Wage reductions
)0/B-*/(2!/4M1/*/)+N administration will end would have a negative
the unprecedented impact on those on the
EOPPH!"FOI";Q# amount of economic front lines of patient care
/4R-S=(&)*+(40=*-./0)*+?A-: stimulus funding that’s – certified nursing
been flowing to assistants – who are
T(/2/45!(00*)++N
California and other responsible for bathing,
O$O!U?!V-22&L--0!W(&6!X1/B)!Y states since 2008 as part grooming, feeding and
Y1*%(4G6!8@!D$Z#Z of the American Recovery providing important social
and Reinvestment Act.! interaction and emotional
W)%+/B) Of the $51 billion that support for patients.
LLL?=(&)*+(40=*-./0)*+?A-: has been awarded to the Worse, job eliminations
K(A)%--G state so far, $13 billion would cut into
LLL?R(A)%--G?A-:[=(&)*+=*-./0)*+ has been dedicated to improvements made in
>L/BB)* funding California’s direct-care staffing ratios
LLL?BL/BB)*?A-:[=(&)*+=*-./0)*+ Medi-Cal program. In which have brought more
June, the stimulus money workers into facilities over
will disappear even as the recession By Jim the past decade. If an average 99-bed
continues to ravage the state. ! Gomez skilled nursing facility chose to absorb
\0/B-*/(2!Y-(*0 In addition, in his $3.7 trillion the 10% cut by shrinking its
budget for FY 2012, President Obama workforce, the jobs of 9 full-time direct-care
XB).)4!>?!9(2)4B/4)6!'*)+/0)4B6! would squeeze healthcare providers by staffers – out of 55 – would be eliminated.!
>3)!8(:0)4!]*-1= lowering Medicaid payments to states by Taken together, these reductions will have
$1.8 billion a year for the next decade. significant consequences for the typical
^-++!]-20%)*56!<::)0/(B)!'(+B! Ironically, Medicaid programs in states nursing home resident – an 86-year-old
83(/*:(46!7-+!^-%2)+!V-+=/B(2!,!
across the country already underfund widow just released from the hospital who
T)0/A(2!8)4B)*
nursing homes to the tune of $5.6 billion. requires multiple medications, skilled nursing
@4B3-4&!W*/53B6!\_)A1B/.)! Put another way, Medicaid programs care and continuous professional oversight to
J/*)AB-*6!V)(2B3!@AA)++!8(2/R-*4/(! pay facilities an average of $7.17 per hour treat an assortment of medical and behavioral
per patient – less than the minimum wage. issues.
V)4*&!7-1%)B6!83/)R!XB*(B)5&! Finally, in his proposed budget, Gov. Jerry This is an unacceptable state of affairs for
`RR/A)*6!a))4(4 Brown wants to slash $1.7 billion from the members of the Greatest Generation. Times
state’s Medi-Cal program, resulting in a are tough and providers are willing to do
T(*G!K/41A(4)6!T(4(5/45! 10% across-the-board cut for nursing home their part, but they already carry more than a
J/*)AB-*6!@2.(*)b!,!T(*+(2 providers and operators of small fair share of the burden. !
community-based six-bed homes for the
developmentally disabled. !
The continued underfunding of Medi-
Jim Gomez is CEO/President of the California
'1%2/+3)*[\0/B-*I/4I83/)R Cal will have a traumatic impact on poor
Association of Health Facilities.
and elderly seniors. Last year, skilled
^-4!X3/4G:(4 nursing providers were paid 93% of their
)0/B-*S=(&)*+(40=*-./0)*+?A-: projected costs. With a 10% cut they would Op-ed submissions of up to 600 words are
be paid 84 cents on the dollar. For a typical welcomed. Please e-mail proposals to
99 bed facility, a loss of $17 per patient day editor@payersandproviders.com,
would translate into a revenue reduction of
!!!"#$$!%&!'(&)*+!,!'*-./0)*+!'1%2/+3/456!778
Payers & Providers MARKETPLACE/EMPLOYMENT Page 5
"#$%&'!(!"&)*+,%&'!#-,!./01!2&%'%-3!4
4)5-,3#67%!8-3%]+*%:!83!,%653'!.#&9;!<=>>!+-!3;%!"#$%&'!(!"&)*+,%&'!?#3+)-#7!%,+3+)-:!!
05&!&%#,%&'!#7@#$'!@#-3!3)!A-)@!@;#3!+'!)-!3;%!B+-,'!)C!;%#73;9#&%D'!9E'5+3%!%F%953+*%':!/)-C%&%-9%'!#-,!3&#,%!%*%-3'!)C3%-!
)-7$!#77)@!C)&!9&59+#7!B)B%-3'!3)!+-3%]!@+3;!3;%'%!3;)5G;3!7%#,%&':!H+3;!4)5-,3#67%!8-3%]+*%I!$)5D77!953!3;&)5G;!3;%!
2&%7+B+-#&+%'!#-,!+BB%,+#3%7$!A-)@!@;#3D'!)-!3;%+&!B+-,:!!
J*%&$!4)5-,3#67%!8-3%]+*%!@+77!C%#35&%!#!K(L!'%''+)-!9)-,593%,!6$!"#$%&'!(!"&)*+,%&'!"567+';%&!4)-!M;+-AB#-:!N+'!
,%9#,%'!)C!%F2%&+%-9%!+-!O)5&-#7+'B!#-,!3;%!;%#73;9#&%!+-,5'3&$!@+77!2&)B+'%!9)-9+'%!#-,!&%*%#7+-G!+-3%&*+%@':!
P)2+9'!C)&!529)B+-G!4)5-,3#67%!8-3%]+*%'!+-975,%Q!
!! 8-3%G%,!M$'3%B'!*':!"&+*#3%!"]+9%Q!!P)!@;#3!,%G&%%!@+77!2;$'+9+#-'!-)3!#7&%#,$!+-!7#&G%&!B%,+9#7!G&)52'!)&!+-3%G%,!
;%#73;!'$'3%B'!&%B#+-!+-!2&+*#3%!2]+9%!,5&+-G!3;+'!,%9#,%I!#-,!@;$:!H;#3!#&%!3;%!#,*#-3#G%'I!,+'#,*#-3#G%'!#-,!
+B27+9#3+)-'!+-!3),#$R'!%-*+&)-B%-3S!!
!! .%,+9#+,!"7#-'!#-,!T%7+*%&$!M$'3%B'Q!!N)@!B59;!+'!3;%+&!97)53!G&)@+-G!#'!.%,+9#+,!%-&)77B%-3!+'!2&)O%93%,!3)!')#&!#'!
2#&3!)C!&%C)&BS!H+77!.%,+9#+,!+-9&%#'+-G7$!6%!5'%,!#'!#!*%;+97%!C)&!'%33+-G!;%#73;9#&%!2)7+9$S!P)!@;#3!,%G&%%!@+77!B#O)&!
;%#73;!27#-'!#-,!'$'3%B'!3&$!3)!+-9&%#'%!';#&%!#-,!9)-9%-3+)-!+-!3;+'!B#&A%3S!!
!! L99)5-3#67%!/#&%!0&G#-+U#3+)-'Q!!L&%!3;%$!)*%&;$2%,S!H;#3!3$2%!)C!;%#73;!9#&%!'$'3%B'!';)57,!6%!25&'5+-G!L/0'I!#-,!
@;#3!'$'3%B'!';)57,!6%!'+33+-G!)-!3;%!'+,%7+-%'!C)&!-)@S!N)@!3+%,!+'!3;%!L/0!B)*%B%-3!3)!3;%!'599%''!)&!C#+75&%!)C!
.%,+9#&%!L/0!2+7)3'S!T)%'!3;%!,%C+-+3+)-!)C!L/0'!-%%,!B)&%!'2%9+C+9+3$I!)&!+'!+3!2&%C%C%!3)!;#*%!#!6+G!3%-3!)C!
+-975'+)-S!
T)!$)5!@#-3!3)!2&)2)'%!)&!2#&3+9+2#3%!+-!#!C535&%!4)5-,3#67%!8-3%]+*%S!"#&3+9+2#3+)-!+'!%-3+&%7$!)-7+-%I!@+3;!#!9)BB+3B%-3!)C!
-)!B)&%!3;#-!)-%!;)5&:!/#77!4)-!M;+-AB#-!#3!VWWE<XVE<YZ=I!%F3:!>I!)&!%EB#+7!;+B!#3!%,+3)&[2#$%&'#-,2&)*+,%&':9)B:!
! !
Or visit: www.payersandproviders.com
*New England Journal of Medicine, 2004.
!!!"#$$!%&!'(&)*+!,!'*-./0)*+!'1%2/+3/456!778
Payers & Providers MARKETPLACE/EMPLOYMENT Page 6
!!!"#$$!%&!'(&)*+!,!'*-./0)*+!'1%2/+3/456!778