Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SSPC Tu 8
SSPC Tu 8
SSPC Tu 8
February 1,2000
1
--``,,,,````,```,,```,,`,,`,`,,-`-`,,`,,`,`,,`---
COPYRIGHT 2003; The Society for Protective Coatings Document provided by IHS Licensee=Aramco HQ/9980755100, User=, 02/09/2003
06:04:19 MST Questions or comments about this message: please call the Document
Policy Management Group at 1-800-451-1584.
SSPC-TU 8
February 1,2000
That is, all of the isocyanate groups are chemically changed (PEL), an ACGIH(2)Threshold Limit Value (TLV), a NIOSH(31
to polyurethane groups prior to packaging for shipment. Recommended Exposure Limit (REL), or a Manufacturer’s
Examples of such coatings would be most one-package, Guideline Limit (MGL). Most commonly, the 8 hour Time
clear, polyurethane wood varnishes sold at retail home Weighted Average (TWA) airborne concentration guideline
improvement stores. Polyurethane coatings used for in- or standard for diisocyanates is five parts per billion paris
dustrial maintenance painting usually contain unreacted of air (ppb). For HDI monomer, this is equal to 0.034
isocyanates at the time of application to the substrate. The milligrams/per cubic meter of air (mg/m3). Polyisocyanates
two-package types have a “paint“ side that needs to be are less toxic and therefore can have a higher allowable
mixed with a hardener, activator or “catalyst”, just before TWA exposure, The MGL (and Oregon OSHA PEL) for HDI
application. The hardener is the pari that typically contains polyisocyanates is usually 0.5 mg/m3 as an 8-hour TWA
the unreacted isocyanate. Because these two paris of the and 1.O mg/m3 as a 15 minute Short Term Exposure Limit
paint system are packaged and shipped separately, the (SIEL). MSDSs often list the applicable airborne concen-
supplier often provides two different MSDSs, one for the tration guidelines/standards. Another source for
“paint” side and one for the “catalyst” side. Both MSDSs diisocyanate monomer exposure standards is the ACGIH
must be reviewed in such a case because the “paint” side publication entitled “Guide to Occupational Exposure Val-
MSDS will typically not mention that “free” isocyanates may ues.”
be present. Monitoring of the workplace air to determine concen-
Another type of polyurethane coating typically used in trations of isocyanates is a key step in determining the
industrial maintenance is the one-package, moisture-cure effectiveness of engineering controls as well as in deter-
system. This type does contain the isocyanate ingredient in mining the type of respiratory protection and other personal
the single can. This type of paint cures by reaction of the protective equipment which may be required. Specific sam-
unreacted isocyanate with atmospheric moisture once the pling and analytical techniques have been developed to
can has been opened to the ambient environment. determine these levels.
Specific words and acronyms to look for on labels and At present, the recommended method for sampling
MSDSs are: isocyanate, polyisocyanate, aliphatic isocyan- and analysis of HDI, TDI, and IPDI polyisocyanates in spray
ate, aromatic isocyanate, hexamethylene diisocyanate applications is Bayer Method 1.4.4.(4) Samples are col-
(HDI), diphenyl methane diisocyanate (MDI), isophorone lected using impingers containing 2 x 10.‘ M N-(4-
diisocyanate (IPDI), toluene diisocyanate (TDI), nitrobenzy1)-propylamine (nitroreagent) in toluene. Analy-
dicyclohexylmethane diisocyanate (HMDI), TMXDI sis is by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC)
(tetramethylxylene diisocyanate), HDI homopolymer, iso- and ultraviolet detection at 254 nanometers. Bayer has
cyanate prepolymer, isocyanate oligomer, isocyanate mono- developed Method 1.4.4 independently and used it suc-
mer, etc. cessfully for 20 years. In terms of current NIOSH methods,
If the applicator suspects that a particular coating the one which is perhaps most similar is Method 5521
contains isocyanates but cannot find any mention of them which uses an impinger containing methoxyphenyl pipera-
on the label or MSDS, a second step would be to call the zine (MOPP) reagent in toluene.(5)This NIOSH method
paint supplier and ask to speak to a product safety special- uses both electrochemical and ultraviolet (UV) detectors.
ist. Often the MSDS itself will list the name of the contact. However, if only the UV detector is used and the calibration
Gurues are run using diisocyanate monomer and commer-
2.2 EVALUATION: Once it has been established that cial polyisocyanate, the method would be quite similar to
a particular paint system does contain an isocyanate ingre- Bayer 1.4.4. In addition, OSHA Method would be
dient, the workplace atmosphere should be characterized similar to Bayer 1.4.4 if an impinger jet inlet were used
to determine the airborne concentration. Most diisocyanate instead of the fritted glass bubbler inlet specified in OSHA
monomers have an OSHA(’) Permissible Exposure Limit 18.
(‘1 US Dept. of Labor, OSHA, Officeof Public Affairs - Room N3647, 200 Constitution Ave., Washington DC 20210, or contact via internet
at http://www.osha.gov/readingroom/html
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists, 1330 Kemper Meadow Drive, Suite 600, Cincinnati OH 45240 (http://
www.acgih.org).
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, 200 Independence Avenue, SW, Washington, DC 20201. (http://www.cdc.gov/
niosh).
(4) Bayer Product Safety Department at Bayer Corporation, 100 Bayer Road, Pittsburgh, PA 15205-9741, Phone: (412) 777-2867. (Contact
/www.osha.gov/readingroom/html)
2
--``,,,,````,```,,```,,`,,`,`,,-`-`,,`,,`,`,,`---
COPYRIGHT 2003; The Society for Protective Coatings Document provided by IHS Licensee=Aramco HQ/9980755100, User=, 02/09/2003
06:04:19 MST Questions or comments about this message: please call the Document
Policy Management Group at 1-800-451-1584.
SSPC-TU 8
February 1,2000
For situations in which only HDI, TDI, IPDI, HMDI, There are several engineering controls available to
TMXDI monomer vapors would be present, such as in non- reduce exposure to vapors and mists generated by the use
spray handling and use, Bayer Method 1.7.6 is recom- of these products. The most common is a properly de-
mended. Samples may be collected using a 1-(2-pyridyl) signed and ventilated enclosure. General dilution ventila-
piperazine impregnated glass fiber filter with analysis by tion, local exhaust ventilation, or isolation may prove ad-
HPLC. Bayer 1.7.6 is OSHA Method 42 modified by coating equate under certain conditions. “Adequate” generally
the filter with 2 mg of derivatizing reagent instead of 0.1 mg means ventilation sufficient to keep airborne concentra-
and by loading the filter in the cassette with a stainless- tions of contaminants below their respective Threshold
steel backup screen in place of the mixed-cellulose ester Limit Values (TLVs), Permissible Exposure Limits (PELS)
back-up pad. Both of these modifications are designed to and Manufacturer’s Guideline Limits (MGLs). Whenever
prevent the loss of derivatizing reagent. Such a depletion of possible, local exhaust ventilation should be provided in
reagent can result in under-estimation of airborne isocyan- accordance with the guidelines provided in Industrial Ven-
ate concentrations. tilation, A Manual of Recommended Practice.
Air monitoring for MDI can be performed using Bayer Use of alternative application equipment (e.g., airless,
Method 1.7.7. This method is similar to Method 1.7.6 above HVLP, or electrostatic spray equipment) may help reduce
but uses a 13 millimeter (mm) diameter glass fiber filter spray mist generation during spray painting. In addition, the
instead of a 37 mm filter. use of spray gun extenders may help reduce the amount of
Continuous or direct reading monitors for diisocyanate spray mist in the breathing zone of the painter.
monomer vapors have recently been developed. It must be The likelihood of overexposure in non-spray, non-
pointed out, however, that these units may not be suitable heated applications of coatings containing polyisocyanates
for monitoring in spray application environments since the is reduced due to the low volatility of these materials.
spray paint mist droplets can coat the optics and/or the Hence, the use of brush, roller, or squeegee for coating
treated paper tape and give erroneous readings. These application reduces the likelihood of inhalation overexpo-
instruments may provide information as to airborne sure.
diisocyanate monomer vapor concentrations during non-
spray applications such as: mixing, repackaging, 3.2 RESPIRATORY PROTECTION: One manufac-
batchmaking, coil coating, and brush/roller/squeegee ap- turer of polyisocyanates recommends air-supplied respira-
plication. To date, no direct reading instrument has been tors for spray apptication if the airborne concentrations are
developed which can be used to accurately determine unknown or if they exceed ten times the appropriate air-
--``,,,,````,```,,```,,`,,`,`,,-`-`,,`,,`,`,,`---
airborne concentrations of polyisocyanates in spray appli- borne concentration standards/guidelines.’ However, the
cation of c ~ a t i n g s . ( ~ . ~ ) same manufacturer states that air-purifying respirators
The technology for evaluating skin exposure to isocy- may be used under the following conditions:
anates is not as advanced as that for airborne monitoring. if airborne concentrations are known to be less
Check for any visual evidence of deposition of paint onto than 1O times the standard/guideline concentra-
the skin. Usually, this is rather obvious because of the paint tion;
pigmentation and/or a feeling of stickiness on the skin. If if the spraying is not being done in a confined
the user wishes to check a surface to determine if isocyan- space;
ate residue has been removed, such as after a spill clean- i f pre-filters are changed as needed to prevent
up, he should consider purchase and use of SwypeTMTest excessive breathing resistance; and
kits which are manufactured by Colorimetric Laboratories, if appropriate change schedules are implemented
ln~.(~> for the organic vapor cartridges (OVCs) in accor-
dance with 29 CFR 1910.1 34.
3. Control of Health Hazards Studies have shown that HDI polyisocyanates are
essentially non-volatile and become airborne only as me-
3.1 ENGINEERING CONTROLS: Ideally, hazard con- chanically generated aerosols during spray application.2
trol of vapor or spray mist is accomplished through engi- Furthermore, these aerosols are efficiently collected by the
neering controls. Effective engineering controls should be particulate pre-filters of a spray painting air-purifying respi-
used whenever possible to reduce and/or eliminate worker r a t ~ r . ~The. ~ . same
~ , ~ studies show that these pre-filters did
exposure to all respiratory hazards. not fail by allowing breakthrough of the aerosol. Rather,
(7iormationconcerning direct reading diisocyanate vapor monitors can be obtained from: Zellweger Analytics, 405 Barclay
Blvd., Lincolnshire, IL 60069, (847) 634-2800 or (800) 323-2000, or Bacharach Inc., 625 Alpha Drive, Pittsburgh, PA
15238, (412) 963-2200 or (800) 736-4666.
(8) Information on the Bayer methods mentioned above can be obtained by contacting the Bayer Product Safety Department
at Bayer Corporation, 100 Bayer Road, Pittsburgh, PA 15205-9741, Phone: (412) 777-2867.
(9) Colorimetric Laboratories (CLI Labs)., 1261A Rand Road, Des Plaines IL 60016 (http://www.clilabs.com).
COPYRIGHT 2003; The Society for Protective Coatings Document provided by IHS Licensee=Aramco HQ/9980755100, User=, 02/09/2003
06:04:19 MST Questions or comments about this message: please call the Document
Policy Management Group at 1-800-451-1584.
SSPC-TU 8
February 1,2001
they simply became increasingly clogged until airflow re- out of the skin and can cause secondary reactions. If
sistance was too great to allow easy breathing. Therefore, coating is accidentally splashed onto the skin, the worker
when breathing resistance becomes noticeably higher dur- should stop work immediately and scrub it off with soap and
ing use, the respirator wearer need only replace the used water. If some paint does cure onto the skin, it is better to
pre-filters with new ones. let it wear off than to try to remove it by drastic means such
A recent study7 has shown that: as harsh solvents.
Organic vapor respirator cartridges demonstrated a
collection efficiency for HDI vapors greater than 99.6% 3.3.1 Guidance Concerning Protective Coveralls:
--``,,,,````,```,,```,,`,,`,`,,-`-`,,`,,`,`,,`---
Table 1
Coverall Suggestions for Applicators
(in ascending order of protective value)
COPYRIGHT 2003; The Society for Protective Coatings Document provided by IHS Licensee=Aramco HQ/9980755100, User=, 02/09/2003
06:04:19 MST Questions or comments about this message: please call the Document
Policy Management Group at 1-800-451-1584.
SSPC-TU 8
February 1,2001
bronchial attacks, or indications of allergic responses or rently, EPA has not established standards or methodolo-
recurrent eczema or sensitization conditions of the skin gies for measuring ambient isocyanate concentrations.
should not handle or work with isocyanates.
If a worker develops respiratory distress when working 4.2 CONTROL OF ENVIRONMENTAL AND PUBLIC
with these products, he/she should be removed from expo- HEALTH RISKS: Several studies conducted by a major
sure and be examined by a physician. If hypersensitivity to polyisocyanate manufacturer showed that natural dilution
isocyanates has developed, the worker must be removed reduced airborne isocyanate concentrations to below work-
from any further exposure to any isocyanate-containing place guidelines within 50 feet downwind of the spray gum8
coating. At present, there is no conclusive screening test In addition, a physical barrier such as a containment screen
suitable for detecting persons most likely to become sensi- (e.g., air penetrable tarps, screens, or curtains) was shown
tized to isocyanates. Therefore, it is essential to examine to be quite effective in preventing overspray drift and thus
all cases of absence due to illness, especially if related to reducing airborne isocyanate levels below accepted guide-
the respiratory system, to determine an individual’s ability lines. Of course, workers within the containment area still
to continue work with isocyanate containing products. needed respirators, gloves, eye protection, and coveralls
to prevent overexposure to isocyanates and other paint
4. Environmental/Public Health Rick ingredients.
The public health risk associated with isocyanate- 4.3 HANDLING PRACTICES: Suggested handling
containing paints includes the potential of human respira- practices to reduce potential isocyanate exposures through
tory sensitization through repeated or high exposures to spills and releases include:
isocyanates in the ambient air. Although unlikely, skin Automatically pump isocyanates from drums to the
irritation and allergic reactions might occur through direct process equipment where possible.
skin contact. Public health risk is difficult to quantify. The Store new product and removed materials in tightly
likelihood that the public adjacent to a painting project closed containers in cool, well-ventilated area. Do not
would develop an allergic sensitization is remote. However, tightly reseal opened isocyanate containers if moisture
an allergic respiratory reaction in a previously sensitized contamination is suspected. The isocyanate-water re-
person might occur at exposures below the odor threshold action produces carbon dioxide gas that can pressur-
(¡.e. when a person smells the material) and Threshold ize sealed containers and may cause explosive rup-
Limit Value(s) (TLVs) for the specific isocyanate involved. ture.
The environmental risk associated with isocyanate- Keep isocyanate-containing coatings and removed
containing paints appears to be minimal under normal materials separate from potential ignition sources.
application and removal conditions. There is no evidence Spill Control Procedure:
that the application or removal of isocyanate-containing Evacuate area and remove ignition sources.
paints creates any significant risk to the environment pro- Don personal protective equipment.
vided that basic control on spills and clean up of removed Control source and dike spill (if applicable).
materials is performed. This is because isocyanates react Use absorbent material to collect liquid material,
with environmental moisture to produce essentially non- Dispose of absorbent material (may be hazard-
toxic polyureas. ous).
Most isocyanate-containing coatings are classified as Decontaminate surface with decontaminating so-
hazardous air pollutants (HAPS) under the Clean Air Act lution or surfactant to assist in the absorption of
(CAA) as pari of the volatile organic compound (VOC) the spilled material.
regulations. Introduction of isocyanate-containing rnateri-
als into the water is prohibited by both the Clean Water Act 5. Waste Management
(CWA) and the Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA).
5.1 IDENTIFICATION OF HAZARDOUS WASTE:
4.1 EVALUATION OF THE HAZARD: Regulated area Hazardous wastes are regulated as part of the Resource
monitoring can be conducted around the areas where field Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA), 40 Code of Fed-
application occurs to quantify the potential risk to the eral Regulations (CFR) -281. These regulations require a
public. This could be conducted using low or high flow waste to be considered hazardous if it poses a potential
personal sampling pumps in accordance with previously hazard to human health or the environment. Wastes are
identified NIOSH, OSHA, and Bayer sampling methods. classified as hazardous if they are specifically listed by the
Typically, exposures below the Action Level (1/2 of the PEL EPA in the regulation or ifthey are characteristic wastes as
or TLV) are considered acceptable levels of exposure to identified by laboratory testing (40 CFR 261).
unprotected workers and therefore could be extrapolated Listed wastes are automatically identified as hazard-
to identify the potential for public exposures based upon ous by the EPA and require no additional testing. Solid and
their proximity to the work area during application. Cur- liquid (e.g. excess paint) wastes generated from the use of
--``,,,,````,```,,```,,`,,`,`,,-`-`,,`,,`,`,,`---
5
COPYRIGHT 2003; The Society for Protective Coatings Document provided by IHS Licensee=Aramco HQ/9980755100, User=, 02/09/2003
06:04:19 MST Questions or comments about this message: please call the Document
Policy Management Group at 1-800-451-1584.
SSPC-TU 8
February 1,2001
toluene diisocyanate (TDI) are considered listed wastes section should include residues of waste in empty contain-
(EPA 10 No. U223), and should be treated as hazardous ers, container and storage area criteria, and labeling and
from the point of generation through disposal. However, signage requirements.
most industrial maintenance coatings do not contain TDI. Transportation and Disposal - This section should
No other isocyanates used in these coatings are listed address who will obtain the EPA ID number (¡.e. who is the
RCRA hazardous wastes. generator) and use of licensed transporters and permitted
Characteristic wastes are categorized as hazardous if disposal and incineration facilities.
they exhibit characteristics of ignitability, corrosivity, reac- Contingency Plan and Training - This section should
tivity, or toxicity. Some isocyanate containing wastes may include a description of the Preparedness, Prevention, and
meet the characteristic of ignitable waste. Ignitable wastes Contingency Plan (PPCP); spill control procedures: worker
are liquids having a flash point of less than 60°C (140 OF). training; and record keeping.
Wastes generated from the use of isocyanates should be Implementation Forms - The section should include
subject to flash point testing in accordance with RCRA implementation forms addressing site storage inspections,
requirements to determine if they are hazardous. labeling requirements, emergency phone numbers, and
Additionally, the RCRA requirements discussed above hazard release documentation forms.
apply to containers where hazardous materials could be Training - Contractors may also wish to incorporate
poured, pumped, or aspirated from the container; or con- hazard communication, flammable and combustible liq-
tain more than 1 inch of residue; or contain more than three uids, and personnel protective equipment training require-
percent (3%) by weight of the capacity of containers 426 ments as part of its program and training in compliance with
liters (1 10 gallons) or less; or contain more than 0.03% by the OSHA regulations relative to isocyanate exposures and
weight of the capacity of containers greater than 426 liters handling of wastes.
(1 1O gallons).
In two component polyurethanes, once the isocyanate 6. References
catalyst has been added to the “paint“ component, the
material will gel in the can within several hours. Once the Desmodur N, Hexamethylene Diisocyanate Based
paint has completely hardened, the isocyanate has reacted Polyisocyanates: Health and Safety Information, (Pitts-
to form the polyurethane and the disposal decision is based burgh, PA: Bayer Corporation, December 1999).
on the amount of potentially ignitable residue solvent still J. Rando and H. G. Poovey, “Development and
entrained in the material, the presence of heavy metals or application of a dichotomous vapor/aerosol sampler for
the presence of TDI. HDI-derived total Reactive Isocyanate Group,” Am. Ind.
Based on the above criteria, many isocyanate residues Hyg. ASSOC.J. 60(6): 737-746 (1999).
and leftover isocyanate-containing paints may be consid- V. Dharmarajan, P. M. Uhrin, and D. R. Hackathorn,
ered hazardous waste and must be characterized, handled, “Evaluation of air purifying respirators in simulated isocy-
and disposed of appropriately. anate based paint spraying operations,” unpublished study
(Pittsburgh, PA: Bayer Corporation (formerly Mobay Cor-
5.2 HANDLING, STORAGE, TRANSPORTATION, poration). 1982).
AND DISPOSAL: Store isocyanate-containing waste in 4J. F. Vasta, “Respirator Cartridge Evaluation for Iso-
tightly sealed containers, unless moisture contamination is cyanate Containing Imron” and Centari” Enamels,” Am.
suspected. Store in a cool, well-ventilated area. Comply Ind. Hyg. Assoc. J. 46, 1, p.39-44 (1985).
with 40 CFR 260-268 regulations regarding handling, stor- C. Rosenberg and T.Tuomi, “Airborne Isocyanates in
age, and disposal. Comply with 49 CFR 170-179 regula- Polyurethane Spray Painting: Determination and Respira-
tions relative to transportation of isocyanate-containing tor Efficiency,“ Am. Ind. Hyg. Assoc. J. 45, 2, p. 117-121
materials. (1984).
Implement a Hazardous Waste Management Plan in- 6G.V. Croshaw and S. W. Horstman, “Air-purifying
cluding procedures for: Respirator Performance Against a Two-component Poly-
Waste Minimization - This section should include a urethane Spray Paint Aerosol,” Poster Session at the
description of the waste minimization efforts implemented. American Industrial Hygiene Conference and Exposition,
Waste Sampling, Testing, and Classification - This May 21-26, at St. Louis, MO, 1989.
section should describe how liquid and solid isocyanate- V. Dharmarajan, R. D. Ling and H. E. Myer, “Evalua-
containing wastes will be characterized (¡.e. through analy- tion of Organic-Vapor-Respirator Cartridge Efficiency for
sis or declaration), the sample collection method, number Hexamethylene Diisocyanate in the Presence of Organic
of samples to be collected, and the type of laboratory Solvents,” Accepted for publication in Applied Occupa-
analysis to be conducted. tionaland Environmental Hygiene (expected in February or
Paint and Solvent Waste Handling and Storage -This March 2001 issue).
a Bayer Corporation, unpublished internal study.
--``,,,,````,```,,```,,`,,`,`,,-`-`,,`,,`,`,,`---
6
COPYRIGHT 2003; The Society for Protective Coatings Document provided by IHS Licensee=Aramco HQ/9980755100, User=, 02/09/2003
06:04:19 MST Questions or comments about this message: please call the Document
Policy Management Group at 1-800-451-1584.
SSPC-TU 8
February 1,2001
--``,,,,````,```,,```,,`,,`,`,,-`-`,,`,,`,`,,`---
ht t p:llw ww. os ha - s lc. gov/Os hSt d-da t a/ and Notification
1910-0134.html (January, 2001). 40 CFR 355, Emergency Planning and Notifica-
U S . Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) Title 40 “Protec- tion.
tion of the Environment,” Washington, DC: Office of U.S. Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) Title 33
the Federal Register. Many of these CFRs are avail- “Navigation and Navigable Waters”, Chapter 26, (Clean
able from local U.S. Government Printing Offices or by Water Act). Text of this Act is available at http://
downloading from the internet. The search page for www4.law.cornell.edu/uscode/unf ramed/33/ch26. html
(January, 2001).
7
COPYRIGHT 2003; The Society for Protective Coatings Document provided by IHS Licensee=Aramco HQ/9980755100, User=, 02/09/2003
06:04:19 MST Questions or comments about this message: please call the Document
Policy Management Group at 1-800-451-1584.