Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chamblee Mercy Housing
Chamblee Mercy Housing
Chamblee Mercy Housing
Attachment: PZ2021-808 4041 Clairmont Rd DRB memo (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT
DRB STAFF REPORT
DRB Meeting Date: May 26, 2021
Item #: PZ2021-808
5h St
Clairmont Rd
6th St
Page 1 of 6
Case Number: PZ2021-808
DRB Meeting: May 26, 2021
City Council Work Session (Public Hearing): June 10, 2021
City Council Regular Meeting: June 15, 2021 Packet Pg. 10
3.1.a
Attachment: PZ2021-808 4041 Clairmont Rd DRB memo (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
Current Zoning: Neighborhood Commercial 2 (NC-2) – This zoning district is
intended primarily for mixed-use development and related uses
at a medium density. This district provides a location for
residences and convenient goods and services not directly
adjacent to single-family neighborhoods that will satisfy the
common and frequent needs of the residents of nearby
residential neighborhoods. Design standards and design
parameters encourage a pedestrian-friendly traditional urban
form, oriented to pedestrians, which limits the conflicts between
vehicles and pedestrians.
Site Description:
The 2.79-acre site is located between 5th St and 6 St along Clairmont Rd. The site is comprised of
five parcels and currently vacant land. There are large boulders along the south property line and
scattered throughout the site, particularly on the centered west portion of the property where
there is a ditch and significant grade change of approximately 16 ft. Two fire hydrants are in the
right-of-way on the northwest and southwest corners of the site. There is one curb cut on
Clairmont Rd, and a curb cut on the northeast corner of the site on 5 th St. Concrete curbing and a
5 ft sidewalk span the length of Clairmont and round the corners of both 5 th St and 6th St. Three
on-street stormwater drop inlets are on the east side of the property along Clairmont Rd. Above-
ground utilities span the length of the streets on Clairmont, 5th St, and 6th St. The site has
significant topographical changes and slopes up approximately 22 ft from west to east and down
Page 2 of 6
approximately 8 ft from south to north. The parcel on the northeast portion of the site is partially
Attachment: PZ2021-808 4041 Clairmont Rd DRB memo (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
surrounded by a 6 ft chain link fence. There are some mature trees on the site along the lot lines.
Page 3 of 6
2. Variance from Sec. 230-26(g)(1)(a)(5) to exceed the height of the supplemental zone
Attachment: PZ2021-808 4041 Clairmont Rd DRB memo (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
adjacent to the sidewalk from 2ft to 3.3ft.
3. Variance from Sec. 230-27(a)(3) to allow cementitious fiberboard lap siding on a building
of the 3-stories or more.
4. Variance from Sec. 230-27(a)(6) to reduce the required fenestration on a Boulevard from
65% to 48%.
5. Variance from Sec. 230-27(a)(12)(c) to not provide a 5 ft wide pedestrian walkway from
entrances to the sidewalk for buildings with more than four residential units.
6. Variance from Sec. 230-28(a)(1) to not construct the building using non-combustible
materials.
7. Variance from Sec. 230-30(a)(3) to reduce the required publicly accessible open space
from 50% to 37%.
8. Variance from Sec. 240-13(b)(3)(b) to reduce the required heated and finished floor area
for one-bedroom units from 790 SF to 650 SF; two-bedroom units from 1,000 SF to 850
SF; three-bedroom units from 1,200 SF to 1,100 SF.
9. Variance from Sec. 240-13(b)(3)(c) to allow residential uses on the ground floor within 100
ft of a street.
10. Variance from 240-13(b)(3)(d) to eliminate the requirement for balconies on at least 60%
of the units.
11. Variance from Sec. 240-13(b)(3)(g)(1) to reduce the required percentage of brick on the
exterior building façade from 60% to between 6% and 49%.
12. Variance from Sec. 250-2(a)(4) to reduce the required number of parking spaces from 158
to 138.
13. Variance from 250-7 (a)(8) to not provide inter-parcel connectivity.
The applicant requests the following concurrent waiver from Title 3 of the UDO:
1. Sec. 350-25 Underground electric and communication utilities.
Attachments:
Attachment 1 – Exhibit A: DCI Plan Book, dated received May 12, 2021
Attachment 2 – Application
Attachment 3 – Maps
Attachment 4 – DeKalb County School Report
Page 4 of 6
Packet Pg. 14
Attachment: PZ2021-808 4041 Clairmont Rd DRB memo (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
PZ2021-808 – Mercy Housing Clairmont
Page 6 of 6
3.1.a
Packet Pg. 15
Attachment: PZ2021-808 4041 Clairmont Rd DRB memo (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
3.1.b
66' - 4"
FAMILY HOUSING
STREET
TREES
PHASE 1
6 Publicly Accessible Open Space
8 Required (50%): 18,972 sf
Provided: (37%*): 14,180 sf
80' - 0"
BENCH TYP.
Attachment: 1 - DCI Plan Book (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
6 Parking Spaces
EXTERIOR Required
198' - 8"
AMENITY
AREA
EV Housing (1.5/Unit &
22' - 0"
1/Unit, Age Restricted): 156
WALKING TRAIL
WITH FITNESS Community Room (Misc.
STATIONS
Semi-Public Facility): 0
10
Daycare (2/Classroom): 2
Clairmont Rd
Total: 158
40' - 0"
TYP.
10
Provided: 138*
7 7
22' - 0" 22' - 0"
Clairmont Road: Boulevard
RETAINING WALL, MAX HEIGHT 8'
5th & 6th Street: Local
22' - 0"
SPACES TRASH
10'
SUPPLEMENTAL
FAMILY HOUSING UNIT MIX
169' - 10"
ZONE
EXTERIOR
AMENITY 7
6 22' - 0"
AREA
1 BR 12
7
2 BR 38
7
3 BR 17
Total 67
22' - 0"
SENIOR HOUSING 6
68' - 10"
PHASE 2
10
SENIOR HOUSING UNIT MIX
1 BR 40
2 BR 15
170' - 7" Total 55
5' LANDSCAPE ZONE
24' - 0"
6th St 5' CLEAR ZONE
COMBINED UNIT MIX
5' SUPPLEMENTAL ZONE BUILDING
ENTRANCE
1 BR 52
2 BR 53 TE
OF GEOR
A G
T
3 BR 17
IA
S
Total 122 ROBYN
ZURFLUH
CE
7
69
RE
RT
T
12
FI 0
EC
CA A
T E N O. R
G
S IT
TE
I
RED ARC H
Master Plan | 1" = 30'-0" Mercy Housing - Clairmont Road | May 12, 2021
Packet Pg. 16
3.1.b
TREE CALCULATIONS
Know what'sbelow.
Callbefore you dig 1736 Liberty Lane
Liberty Lofts
Roswell, Georgia 30075
P: 404-780-2170
W: Viridianstudiosatl.com
REVISIONS
NO. DATE ISSUE
5th St
LS STRIP
(20) 4" CALIPER OVERSTORY PARKING LOT TREE
10'
NUTTALL OAK
PROJECT NAME
MERCY
Attachment: 1 - DCI Plan Book (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
5' WIDE PERIMETER LANDSCAPE STRIP HOUSING-
(8) 4" CALIPER OVERSTORY STREET TREE 1 TREE PER 40 LINEAR FEET
PRINCETON ELM 1 EVERGREEN SHRUB PER 5 LINEAR FEET
80% COVERAGE OF LIVING GROUNDCOVER, TYPICAL.
CLAIRMONT
FAMILY HOUSING ROAD
6 PROJECT ADDRESS
8
STREET TREE REQUIREMENT:
1 OVERSTORY TREE PER 40 LINEAR FEET
CLAIRMONT
(13) 4" CALIPER LANDSCAPE STRIP TREE
YELLOWWOOD ROAD AT
5TH AND 6TH
6 HEAD TO HEAD PARKING REQUIREMENT: STREET
EXTERIOR
1 OVERSTORY TREE, 10 SHRUBS PER 50 LINEAR FEET
AMENITY 5' WIDE LANDSCAPE ISLAND.
AREA 70% COVERAGE OF LIVING GROUNDCOVER, TYPICAL. CITY OF CHAMBLEE
(8) 4" CALIPER COLUMNAR OVERSTORY TREE DEKALB COUNTY
FRANS FONTAINE EUROPEAN HORNBEAM
TREE FORM LIMBED UP TO 6'
OWNER
10
Clairmont Rd
PARKING LOT REQUIREMENT:
(14) 4" CALIPER UNDERSTORY STREET TREE 1 OVERSTORY TREE, 10 SHRUBS PER 200 SQUARE FOOT
PARROTIA LANDSCAPE ISLAND.
80% COVERAGE OF LIVING GROUNDCOVER, TYPICAL.
10
7 7
(20) 4" CALIPER PERIMETER LANDSCAPE STRIP TREE/
EVERGREEN PRIVACY SCREEN
YOSHINO CRYPTOMERIA
FURNITURE ZONE 10
SHEET TITLE
103 TOTAL (4" CALIPER) MEDIUM TO LARGE TREES @ 412 INICHES PROVIDED
10
CLEAR ZONE LANDSCAPE
132 PARKING TRASH PERMIT
SUPPLEMENTAL SPACES
ZONE PLAN
6 7
7 7
SENIOR HOUSING 6
DATE 04/28/2021
LS STRIP
10
10'
PROJ. NO. 2021040
PROFESSIONAL SEAL
6th St
SHEET
STREET TREE REQUIREMENT:
UNDERSTORY TREES PROVIDED BELOW POWER LINES
ALL NEW LANDSCAPE MATERIAL TO BE IRRIGATED WITH AUTOMATIC IRRIGATION SYSTEM.
IRRIGATION DESIGN TO BE PROVIDED UPON ARBORIST APPROVAL OF SITE PLAN.
1 TREE PER 40 LINEAR FEET
0' 30' 60'
NORTH
L1.1
ISSUED FOR DCI REVIEW ONLY
Packet Pg. 17
3.1.b
LONG #0050-0430
REVISIONS
REQUESTED BY
DESCRIPTION
OHE
FH
OHE
DATE
OHE
REV #
OHE OHE OHE
, FAX 770.951.2496
2550 HERITAGE COURT, STE 250
W
978
OHE
ATLANTA, GA 30339
994
996
976
986
980
OHE
982
990
984
992
988
G
OHE OHE
www.longeng.com
W OHE
998 100
0
99
8
TEL 770.951.2495
OHE
974 996
OH
E
FAMILY HOUSING
STREET LEVEL FFE = 980
OHE
W
PARKING LOT FFE = 992
Attachment: 1 - DCI Plan Book (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
FH
SS 994
976
OHE
992.00
978
994
STORMWATER DETENTION
980
OHE
GA
998
982
OHE
CHAMBLEE PROJECT
BIORETENTION OR SIMILAR
984
5TH STREET
994
986
992.00
OHE
988
SENIOR HOUSING
FFE = 992
990
OHE
E
OH
FH
LL 279
W
W
992
992
OHE OHE
SS
OHE OHE OHE
SS SS
SS
OHE
OHE
OHE OHE OHE OHE
DATE 5/5/2021
UTILITY DISCLAIMER DESIGN QC:
CADD QC:
NOTE: UTILITIES MAY EXIST WHICH ARE NOT SHOWN ON THE PLANS. THE DESIGNED BY: ----
TOTAL SITE AREA = ---- Ac CONTRACTOR SHALL BE RESPONSIBLE FOR CONTACTING ALL UTILITY DRAWN BY: MF
NO GRADED SLOPE COMPANIES HAVING UTILITIES WITHIN OR ADJACENT TO THE WORK AREA. 0 30 60
DISTURBED AREA = ---- Ac THE CONTRACTOR SHALL HAVE THE UTILITIES FIELD LOCATED AND
SHEET
SHALL EXCEED 2H:1V COORDINATE WITH UTILITY COMPANIES TO HAVE THEM RELOCATED WHEN
C-4.0
NECESSARY OR ADAPTED FOR TIE-INS. 15 45
SCALE: 1"=30'
Packet Pg. 18
3.1.b
LONG #0050-0430
REVISIONS
REQUESTED BY
DESCRIPTION
OHE
FH DOMESTIC WATER SERVICE
WITH METER & BACKFLOW
OHE
DATE
OHE
REV #
OHE OHE OHE
, FAX 770.951.2496
2550 HERITAGE COURT, STE 250
W
OHE
ATLANTA, GA 30339
OHE G
OHE OHE
www.longeng.com
W OHE
TEL 770.951.2495
OHE
EXISTING SEWER
OH
E
FAMILY HOUSING
STREET LEVEL FFE = 980
OHE
W
PARKING LOT FFE = 992
PROPOSED SEWER
Attachment: 1 - DCI Plan Book (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
FH
CONNECTION
SS
OHE
OHE
GA
OHE
CHAMBLEE PROJECT
CHAMBLEE, GA, 30341 DEKALB COUNTY
UTILITY PLAN
5TH STREET
OHE
SENIOR HOUSING
FFE = 992
OHE
E
OH
DOMESTIC SERVICE WITH
FH
METER & BACKFLOW
LL 279
W
EXISTING SEWER
OHE OHE
SS
OHE OHE OHE
SS SS
SS
PROPOSED SEWER
CONNECTION
E OH
OH E
OHE
OHE
OHE OHE OHE OHE
DATE 5/5/2021
UTILITY DISCLAIMER DESIGN QC:
CADD QC:
UTILITIES MAY EXIST WHICH ARE NOT SHOWN ON THE PLANS. THE DESIGNED BY: ----
CONTRACTOR SHALL BE RESPONSIBLE FOR CONTACTING ALL UTILITY DRAWN BY: MF
COMPANIES HAVING UTILITIES WITHIN OR ADJACENT TO THE WORK AREA. 0 30 60
THE CONTRACTOR SHALL HAVE THE UTILITIES FIELD LOCATED AND
SHEET
COORDINATE WITH UTILITY COMPANIES TO HAVE THEM RELOCATED WHEN
C-5.0
NECESSARY OR ADAPTED FOR TIE-INS. 15 45
SCALE: 1"=30'
Packet Pg. 19
3.1.b
BUILDING ENTRANCE
37' - 0"
BUILDING ENTRANCE
COMMUNITY
Attachment: 1 - DCI Plan Book (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
ROOM
1556 SF
RR RR
3 BR
197' - 8"
2 BR
2 BR
3 BR
OF GEOR
ATE G
T
IA
S
ROBYN
ZURFLUH
CE
7
69
RE
RT
T
12
FI 0
EC
CA A
T E N O. R
G
S IT
TE
I
RED ARC H
Architectural Design - Family Housing | 1" = 20'-0" Mercy Housing - Clairmont Road | May 12, 2021
Packet Pg. 20
3.1.b
5th St
169' - 8"
2 BR 2 BR 2 BR 2 BR
Attachment: 1 - DCI Plan Book (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
3 BR
66' - 4"
OPEN TO
BELOW
MAINTENANCE
PROPERTY MANAGEMENT & 2 BR 1 BR
AMENITIES
3 BR
108' - 8"
1 BR
EXTERIOR AMENITY
198' - 8"
AREA
2 BR
2 BR
129' - 8"
2 BR
2 BR
Clairmont Rd
1 BR
3 BR
TRASH
67' - 0"
OF GEOR
ATE G
T
IA
S
ROBYN
ZURFLUH
CE
7
69
RE
RT
T
12
FI 0
EC
CA A
T E N O. R
G
S IT
TE
I
RED ARC H
Architectural Design - Family Housing | 1" = 20'-0" Mercy Housing - Clairmont Road | May 12, 2021
Packet Pg. 21
3.1.b
169' - 0"
2 BR 2 BR 2 BR 2 BR
Attachment: 1 - DCI Plan Book (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
3 BR
66' - 4"
ELEC.
LAUNDRY
2 BR
3 BR 1 BR
3 BR
102' - 8"
198' - 0"
1 BR
2 BR
2 BR
129' - 8"
2 BR
2 BR
1 BR
3 BR
TRASH
64' - 0"
LEVELS 3, 4 & 5
OF GEOR
ATE G
T
IA
S
ROBYN
ZURFLUH
CE
7
69
RE
RT
T
12
FI 0
EC
CA A
T E N O. R
G
S IT
TE
I
RED ARC H
Architectural Design - Family Housing | 1" = 20'-0" Mercy Housing - Clairmont Road | May 12, 2021
Packet Pg. 22
3.1.b
ROOF
1042' - 2"
STUCCO (52%)
WINDOWS WITH
FIBER CEMENT TRIM
LEVEL 5
1024' - 0"
53' - 2"
LEVEL 4
1013' - 4"
BRICK (30%)
LEVEL 3
1002' - 8"
CANOPY
LEVEL 2
992' - 0"
AVG. GRADE
989' - 0"
Attachment: 1 - DCI Plan Book (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
2' - 2 1/2"
LEVEL 1
980' - 0"
ROOF
1042' - 2"
SIDING
LEVEL 5
1024' - 0"
53' - 3"
LEVEL 4
1013' - 4"
BRICK (40%)
LEVEL 3
1002' - 8"
Material Legend
CANOPY BRICK
LEVEL 2
992' - 0"
AVG. GRADE
989' - 0"
FIBER CEMENT SIDING
BUILDING ENTRANCE
STUCCO
LEVEL 1
3' - 3"
980' - 0"
IA
S
WEST ELEVATION - CLAIRMONT ROAD
ROBYN
STOOP TO MITIGATE GRADE ZURFLUH
CE
7
69
RE
RT
T
12
FI 0
EC
CA A
T E N O. R
G
S IT
TE
I
RED ARC H
Architectural Design - Family Housing | 1" = 10'-0" Mercy Housing - Clairmont Road | May 12, 2021
Packet Pg. 23
3.1.b
ROOF ROOF
1042' - 2" 1042' - 2"
STUCCO (54%)
STUCCO
53' - 3"
53' - 3"
LEVEL 4 LEVEL 4
1013' - 4" 1013' - 4"
BRICK (30%)
BRICK (33%)
LEVEL 3 LEVEL 3
1002' - 8" 1002' - 8"
Attachment: 1 - DCI Plan Book (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
LEVEL 2 LEVEL 2
992' - 0" 992' - 0"
AVG. GRADE AVG. GRADE
989' - 0" 989' - 0"
STUCCO (55%)
LEVEL 5 LEVEL 5
1024' - 0" 1024' - 0"
STUCCO (76%)
53' - 3"
53' - 3"
LEVEL 4 LEVEL 4
1013' - 4" 1013' - 4"
LEVEL 3 LEVEL 3
1002' - 8" 1002' - 8" Material Legend
WINDOWS BRICK
LEVEL 2 LEVEL 2
992' - 0" 992' - 0"
AVG. GRADE AVG. GRADE FIBER CEMENT SIDING
LOBBY ENTRY STAIR EXIT 989' - 0" 989' - 0"
STUCCO
IA
S
ROBYN
ZURFLUH
CE
7
69
RE
RT
T
12
FI 0
EC
CA A
T E N O. R
G
S IT
TE
I
RED ARC H
Architectural Design - Family Housing | 1" = 10'-0" Mercy Housing - Clairmont Road | May 12, 2021
Packet Pg. 24
3.1.b
BUILDING ENTRANCE
65' - 0" 65' - 0"
2 BR 2 BR
1 BR 1 BR
Attachment: 1 - DCI Plan Book (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
1 BR 1 BR 1 BR 1 BR
103' - 6"
103' - 6"
1 BR
1 BR 1 BR 1 BR
EXTERIOR
169' - 10"
169' - 10"
GATHERING
AREA
1 BR 101' - 7" 1 BR 1 BR 101' - 7"
1 BR
STORAGE
LAUNDRY
MAINTENANCE
ELEC.
DAYCARE
LAUNDRY
2 BR 1 BR 1 BR
2 BR 1 BR 1 BR 1 BR 1 BR RR
GATHERING
GATHERING
AREA
LOBBY
AREA
67' - 10" RR
67' - 10"
2 BR
2 BR 2 BR
1 BR 1 BR 1 BR 2 BR 1 BR 1 BR 1 BR 2 BR
2 BR
BUILDING ENTRANCE
170' - 7" 170' - 7"
OF GEOR
A TE G
T
IA
S
ROBYN
ZURFLUH
CE
7
69
RE
RT
T
12
FI 0
EC
CA A
T E N O. R
G
S IT
TE
I
RED ARC H
Architectural Design - Senior Housing | 1" = 20'-0" Mercy Housing - Clairmont Road | May 11, 2021
Packet Pg. 25
3.1.b
BRICK (29%) STUCCO (60%) SIDING (11%) BRICK (42%) SIDING (58%)
ROOF ROOF
1029' - 4" 1029' - 4"
LEVEL 3 LEVEL 3
1012' - 4" 1012' - 4"
40' - 4"
40' - 4"
LEVEL 2 LEVEL 2
1001' - 8" 1001' - 8"
BUILDING
ENTRANCE
LEVEL 1 LEVEL 1
991' - 0" 991' - 0"
163' - 8" AVERAGE GRADE AVERAGE GRADE
989' - 0" 989' - 0"
82'-6" FENESTRATION (50%)
Attachment: 1 - DCI Plan Book (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
ROOF ROOF
1029' - 4" 1029' - 4"
WINDOWS WITH
FIBER CEMENT TRIM
LEVEL 3 LEVEL 3
1012' - 4" 1012' - 4"
40' - 4"
40' - 4"
LEVEL 2 LEVEL 2
1001' - 8" 1001' - 8"
LEVEL 1 LEVEL 1
991' - 0" 991' - 0"
AVERAGE GRADE AVERAGE GRADE
989' - 0" 989' - 0"
STUCCO (31%)
WINDOWS WITH
FIBER CEMENT TRIM
LEVEL 3 LEVEL 3
1012' - 4" 1012' - 4"
40' - 4"
40' - 4"
LEVEL 2 LEVEL 2
1001' - 8" 1001' - 8"
BRICK (6%)
LEVEL 1 LEVEL 1
991' - 0" 991' - 0"
AVERAGE GRADE AVERAGE GRADE
4' - 0"
989' - 0" 989' - 0"
4' - 0"
1' - 8"
BRICK VENEER ON STEM WALLS
3' - 5"
IA
S
ENTRANCE ROBYN
FIBER CEMENT SIDING PLANTER WALLS IN ZURFLUH
CE
7
69
RE
SUPPLEMENTAL ZONE TO
RT
T
12
FI 0
EC
CA A
T E N O. R
G
S IT
TE
I
STUCCO MITIGATE GRADE CHANGE RED ARC H
Architectural Design - Senior Housing | 1" = 10'-0" Mercy Housing - Clairmont Road | May 11, 2021
Packet Pg. 26
3.1.b
Attachment: 1 - DCI Plan Book (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
NORTHWEST CORNER SOUTHWEST CORNER
OF GEOR
A TE G
T
IA
S
ROBYN
ZURFLUH
CE
7
69
RE
RT
T
12
FI 0
EC
CA A
T E N O. R
G
S IT
TE
I
RED ARC H
Architectural Design - Perspective Views | Mercy Housing - Clairmont Road | May 12, 2021
Packet Pg. 27
3.1.c
Packet Pg. 28
Attachment: 2 - Application (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
3.1.c
Packet Pg. 29
Attachment: 2 - Application (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
3.1.c
Packet Pg. 30
Attachment: 2 - Application (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
3.1.c
Packet Pg. 31
Attachment: 2 - Application (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
3.1.c
Packet Pg. 32
Attachment: 2 - Application (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
3.1.c
Packet Pg. 33
Attachment: 2 - Application (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
3.1.c
Packet Pg. 34
Attachment: 2 - Application (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
3.1.c
EXHIBIT “A”
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
Tract 1
Attachment: 2 - Application (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
ALL THAT TRACT OR PARCEL OF LAND LYING AND BEING IN LAND LOT 279
OF THE 18TH DISTRICT, DEKALB COUNTY, STATE OF GEORGIA, AND BEING
KNOWN AS PARCEL ONE, AND CONTAINING 0.375 ACRE, AND BEING MORE
PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS:
This page is only a part of a 2016 ALTA® Commitment for Title Insurance issued by Fidelity National Title Insurance. This
Commitment is not valid without the Notice; the Commitment to Issue Policy; the Commitment Conditions; Schedule A; Schedule B,
Part I—Requirements; and Schedule B, Part II—Exceptions; and a counter-signature by the Company or its issuing agent that may
be in electronic form.
27C165B10
ALTA Commitment for Title Insurance 8-1-16 w- GA Mod
Copyright American Land Title Association. All rights reserved.
The use of this Form (or any derivative thereof) is restricted to ALTA licensees and
ALTA members in good standing as of the date of use. All other uses are prohibited.
Reprinted under license from the American Land Title Association.
Page 11 of 18
Packet Pg. 35
3.1.c
Attachment: 2 - Application (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
Tract 2
All that tract or parcel of land lying and being in Land Lots 270 and 279 of
the 18th District, DeKalb County, Georgia, and being more particularly
described as follows:
LESS AND EXCEPT the property contained in Rural Post Roads Right of Way
Deed between Michael W. LaPaglia and DeKalb County filed and recorded
July 25, 1984 in Deed Book 5030, Page 193, aforesaid records.
Tract 3
All that lot, tract or parcel of land situate, lying and being in Land Lot 279, of
the 18th District, DeKalb County, Georgia, and being more particularly
described as follows:
This page is only a part of a 2016 ALTA® Commitment for Title Insurance issued by Fidelity National Title Insurance. This
Commitment is not valid without the Notice; the Commitment to Issue Policy; the Commitment Conditions; Schedule A; Schedule B,
Part I—Requirements; and Schedule B, Part II—Exceptions; and a counter-signature by the Company or its issuing agent that may
be in electronic form.
27C165B10
ALTA Commitment for Title Insurance 8-1-16 w- GA Mod
Copyright American Land Title Association. All rights reserved.
The use of this Form (or any derivative thereof) is restricted to ALTA licensees and
ALTA members in good standing as of the date of use. All other uses are prohibited.
Reprinted under license from the American Land Title Association.
Page 12 of 18
Packet Pg. 36
3.1.c
Attachment: 2 - Application (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
235.34 feet to the TRUE POINT OF BEGINNING; thence North 00 degrees 12
minutes 43 seconds East a distance of 193.84 feet to a point; thence south
89 degrees 43 minutes 51 seconds East a distance of 104.00 feet to a point;
thence South 00 degrees 12 minutes 43 seconds West a distance of 193.79
feet to the North right-of-way of 6th Street, thence following the North right-
of-way line of 6th Street North 89 degrees 45 minutes 29 seconds West a
distance of 104.00 feet to the TRUE POINT OF BEGINNING; said tract
contains 0.4527 acres of land, more or less.
This is the same property identified as Tract II on the Final Plat prepared for
the U. S. Small Business Administration filed and recorded in Plat Book 93,
Page 91, DeKalb County records, which plat is incorporated herein by
reference.
LESS AND EXCEPT the property contained in Rural Post Roads Right of Way
Deed between Kyriakos Loumakis and DeKalb County filed and recorded
February 8, 1985 in Deed Book 5149, Page 734, aforesaid records.
Tract 4
ALL THAT TRACT OR PARCEL OF LAND LYING AND BEING IN LAND LOT 279,
OF THE 18TH DISTRICT, DEKALB COUNTY, STATE OF GEORGIA, AND BEING
KNOWN AS PARCEL TWO, AND CONTATNING 0.445 ACRES, AND BEING
MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS:
This page is only a part of a 2016 ALTA® Commitment for Title Insurance issued by Fidelity National Title Insurance. This
Commitment is not valid without the Notice; the Commitment to Issue Policy; the Commitment Conditions; Schedule A; Schedule B,
Part I—Requirements; and Schedule B, Part II—Exceptions; and a counter-signature by the Company or its issuing agent that may
be in electronic form.
27C165B10
ALTA Commitment for Title Insurance 8-1-16 w- GA Mod
Copyright American Land Title Association. All rights reserved.
The use of this Form (or any derivative thereof) is restricted to ALTA licensees and
ALTA members in good standing as of the date of use. All other uses are prohibited.
Reprinted under license from the American Land Title Association.
Page 13 of 18
Packet Pg. 37
3.1.c
Attachment: 2 - Application (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
SOUTHERN RIGHT-OF-WAY SOUTH 89 DEGREES 26 MINUTES 26 SECONDS
EAST A DISTANCE OF 99.29 FEET TO A IRON PIN FOUND AT THE
NORTHEASTERN MOST POINT OF TRACT 1; THENCE LEAVING SAID RIGHT-
OF-WAY SOUTH 00 DEGREES 24 MINUTES 27 SECONDS WEST A DISTANCE
OF 194.89 FEET TO A IRON PIN FOUND; THENCE NORTH 89 DEGREES 39
MINUTES 05 SECONDS WEST A DISTANCE CF 99.61 FEET TO A IRON PIN
FOUND; THENCE NORTH 00 DEGREES 23 MINUTES 22 SECONDS EAST A
DISTANCE OF 100.12 FEET TO A IRON PIPE FOUND; THENCE NORTH 00
DEGREES 36 MINUTES 15 SECONDS EAST A DISTANCE OF 95.41 FEET TO A
IRON PIN FOUND AT THE SOUTHERN RIGHT-OF-WAY OF FIFTH STREETS
SAID POINT BEING THE, TRUE POINT OF BEGINNING.
Tract 5
All that tract or parcel of land lying and being in Land Lot 279 of the 18th
District, DeKalb County, Georgia, being more particularly described as
follows:
This page is only a part of a 2016 ALTA® Commitment for Title Insurance issued by Fidelity National Title Insurance. This
Commitment is not valid without the Notice; the Commitment to Issue Policy; the Commitment Conditions; Schedule A; Schedule B,
Part I—Requirements; and Schedule B, Part II—Exceptions; and a counter-signature by the Company or its issuing agent that may
be in electronic form.
27C165B10
ALTA Commitment for Title Insurance 8-1-16 w- GA Mod
Copyright American Land Title Association. All rights reserved.
The use of this Form (or any derivative thereof) is restricted to ALTA licensees and
ALTA members in good standing as of the date of use. All other uses are prohibited.
Reprinted under license from the American Land Title Association.
Page 14 of 18
Packet Pg. 38
3.1.c
degrees 12 minutes 43 seconds west for 193.84 feet to the north right-of-
way of 6th Street; thence following the north right-of-way of 6th Street
north 89 degrees 45 minutes 29 seconds west for 235.34 feet to the point of
beginning; said tract being identified as Tract III containing 1.1165 acres as
Attachment: 2 - Application (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
shown on final plat prepared for the U.S. Small Business Administration filed
and recorded in Plat Book 93, Page 91, DeKalb County, Georgia Records,
which plat is incorporated herein by reference.
This page is only a part of a 2016 ALTA® Commitment for Title Insurance issued by Fidelity National Title Insurance. This
Commitment is not valid without the Notice; the Commitment to Issue Policy; the Commitment Conditions; Schedule A; Schedule B,
Part I—Requirements; and Schedule B, Part II—Exceptions; and a counter-signature by the Company or its issuing agent that may
be in electronic form.
27C165B10
ALTA Commitment for Title Insurance 8-1-16 w- GA Mod
Copyright American Land Title Association. All rights reserved.
The use of this Form (or any derivative thereof) is restricted to ALTA licensees and
ALTA members in good standing as of the date of use. All other uses are prohibited.
Reprinted under license from the American Land Title Association.
Page 15 of 18
Packet Pg. 39
3.1.c
Attachment: 2 - Application (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
City of Chamblee DCI Application
April 29, 2021
Revised May 12, 2021
DCI BOOKLET
Packet Pg. 40
83 POPLAR ST NW, ATLANTA, GA, 30303 • ATLANTA, GA 30308-2805 • TEL: 404.892.2443 • FAX: 404-892-2470 WWW.SMITHDALIA.COM
3.1.c
Attachment: 2 - Application (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
Table of Contents
Narrative
Location Map
Master Plan
Landscape plan
Utility Plan
Packet Pg. 41
83 POPLAR ST NW, ATLANTA, GA, 30303 • ATLANTA, GA 30308-2805 • TEL: 404.892.2443 • FAX: 404-892-2470 WWW.SMITHDALIA.COM
3.1.c
Narrative
Attachment: 2 - Application (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
preservation, management, and financing of affordable, program-enriched housing across the country.
The proposed project is an affordable multi-family housing campus on Clairmont Road between Fifth
and Sixth Streets. The current assemblage of parcels will be combined into one development.
The vision of this project is to build a multigenerational community that encourages residents to utilize
common areas and reduce social isolation. Therefore, the residents are intended to intermingle and to
use common areas in both buildings.
The Family Building consisting of 67 one, two, and three bedroom apartments for individuals or families.
Sitting on the corner of Clairmont Road and Fifth street, the building will adjust to significant
topographical changes along Fifth Street. The façade along Clairmont will be five stories, reducing to
four on Fifth Street. A flexible and tech enabled community room that allows adults and teens to
work/study socialize outside the unit community space will be provided on the ground floor with direct
access to the sidewalk on Clairmont Road. A playground will be provided on site, as well as a walking
trail with fitness equipment.
The Senior building will be a three story, 55 unit affordable multi-family building consisting of 1 and 2
bedroom units catering to seniors. A child daycare program will be integrated into the Senior Building.
The parking and outdoor amenities will be shared by both buildings.
Mercy Housing proposes affordable housing for families and seniors to live safe, social, independent
lives. Integrated amenities focus on health and social connections. Both buildings will have dynamic
street frontage and street visible entrances , dedicated parking, and pedestrian friendly streetscape. The
proposed project is a medium density, mixed use project in accordance with the City of Chamblee’s
Unified Development Ordinance.
Packet Pg. 42
83 POPLAR ST NW, ATLANTA, GA, 30303 • ATLANTA, GA 30308-2805 • TEL: 404.892.2443 • FAX: 404-892-2470 WWW.SMITHDALIA.COM
3.1.c
Location Map
Attachment: 2 - Application (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
Packet Pg. 43
83 POPLAR ST NW, ATLANTA, GA, 30303 • ATLANTA, GA 30308-2805 • TEL: 404.892.2443 • FAX: 404-892-2470 WWW.SMITHDALIA.COM
6.01
3.09
3.1.c
Packet Pg. 44
Attachment: 2 - Application (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
3.1.c
Letter of Intent:
Attachment: 2 - Application (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
The project is designed to integrate with the scale and character of the surrounding residential
neighborhood while providing density and diverse affordable housing options for the community. The
project seeks to improve an underutilized stretch of land along the Clairmont Road corridor by activating
the streetscape and providing a safe and pleasant pedestrian experience in line with the City of
Chamblee’s Unified Development Ordinance and Comprehensive Plan. Outdoor amenities will be a
major part of the program of the project and include several outdoor gathering areas, a playground, and
an exercise walking path.
Sec. 280-24(a)
(1) The design achieves harmony with the character of the surrounding neighborhood. The
massing of the buildings is broken up both vertically and horizontally to create visual interest
and break down the scale of the buildings.
(2) Simple, strong, residential design components sit on top of a masonry base, with commercial
proportions and materials along the sidewalk. The forms and materials create a cohesive
design aesthetic and a campus feel.
(3) No scenic views would be negatively impacted by the proposed buildings.
(4) The design protects adjacent properties from negative visual and functional impacts with
screening and landscaping.
(5) The design compliments the surrounding character of the neighborhood and no historic
structures or spaces would be impacted.
(6) The simple design reduces the need for exterior forms. Where they do exist, they will be
materially cohesive and conform with the main building.
(7) As a primarily residential development, its use is appropriate in the area. It compliments the
adjacent residential and light commercial properties.
(8) The development does not adversely affect the existing use or usability of the adjacent
commercial and residential properties. Access and visibility to both are maintained and any
additional traffic from Clairmont Road would enter the project before passing the nearby
properties.
(9) The modest apartment buildings on a main thoroughfare will not cause an excessive burden
on the existing streets, utilities, or school.
(10) The proposed Multifamily development is allowed in the current NC-2 zoning subject to the
Supplemental Use Standards.
(11) The proposed Medium Density Residential development is in conformance with the provisions
of the City’s Comprehensive Plan.
However, in order for the project to provide the desired housing density and to be financially viable, the
following variances are proposed.
Proposed Variances:
Packet Pg. 45
83 POPLAR ST NW, ATLANTA, GA, 30303 • ATLANTA, GA 30308-2805 • TEL: 404.892.2443 • FAX: 404-892-2470 WWW.SMITHDALIA.COM
3.1.c
Attachment: 2 - Application (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
VARIANCE REQUEST
The project seeks variance approval to increase the allowable height of the retaining walls in the
supplemental zone along Clairmont Road due to the severe topographical changes along the
length of Clairmont Road.
VARIANCE REQUEST
The project seeks variance approval that the entrance stoop to the Community room and
certain planting areas in the supplemental zone be more than 24” higher than the adjacent
sidewalk. The topography changes significantly along Clairmont Road and 5th Street. The
entrance stoop at the Family Building will have access on both sides and will provide a level,
accessible entrance into the building. The planters along the Senior Building are used to reduce
the effect of the topography change and create a more pleasant pedestrian experience along
Clairmont Road. Heights are indicated on the attached elevations.
VARIANCE REQUEST
The project seeks variance approval that the buildings may use cementitious fiberboard lap
siding as the product is attractive, durable, and cost effective. The façade is broken up and
varied to avoid large expanses of lap siding and uses multiple materials.
VARIANCE REQUEST
Since units are proposed on the ground floor of both buildings, the project seeks a variance to
reduce the fenestration requirements to a more typical amount in residential construction and
to reduce the exposure of the interior units for privacy. Fenestration calculations are shown on
the attached Elevations.
Packet Pg. 46
83 POPLAR ST NW, ATLANTA, GA, 30303 • ATLANTA, GA 30308-2805 • TEL: 404.892.2443 • FAX: 404-892-2470 WWW.SMITHDALIA.COM
3.1.c
VARIANCE REQUEST
Due to the topographical challenges of the site and the desire for security for the residents, the
project seeks a variance approval that individual unit entrances on the street will not be
provided. Main entrances to the buildings from the street will be visible and have direct
connections to the sidewalks.
Attachment: 2 - Application (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
6. Sec. 230-28. Non-combustible materials (a)(1)
“Except as provided below, all buildings three or more stories in height, excluding all single-
family dwellings (attached or detached), shall be constructed with concrete and steel framing
materials (Type I or Type II in accordance with the 2012 International Building Code).”
VARIANCE REQUEST
The project seeks variance approval that the buildings be constructed of wood framing materials
consistent with industry standard for affordable and market rate housing projects.
VARIANCE REQUEST
The project seeks variance approval that the amount of open space required to be accessible to
the public be limited to the planting zones, sidewalks & supplemental zones along the adjacent
streets. The development is required to keep the open space private by the Georgia Department
of Community Affairs due to its affordable financing. The shaded area in the diagram below is
the anticipated open space available to the public. Clairmont Park is across Clairmont Road and
provides a large amount of public open space for this area.
Packet Pg. 47
83 POPLAR ST NW, ATLANTA, GA, 30303 • ATLANTA, GA 30308-2805 • TEL: 404.892.2443 • FAX: 404-892-2470 WWW.SMITHDALIA.COM
3.1.c
Attachment: 2 - Application (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
VARIANCE REQUEST
The financing for the affordable units is subsidized to ensure quality housing with long term
affordability, and the buildings are provided with a robust amenity program for residents to
engage outside of their units. This project will follow the Georgia Department of Community
Affairs standards for affordable housing, which sets minimum floor areas for affordable units.
These minimums are: studio: 375 sf; efficiency: 450 sf; one bedroom: 650 sf; two bedroom: 850
sf; three bedroom: 1,100 sf. The project seeks relief from the minimum finished floor area for
multifamily dwelling units in order to be in line with industry standards.
VARIANCE REQUEST
The project seeks variance approval that ground floor units may be permitted on this site. The
buildings will be designed to prioritize the pedestrian experience with character lines and
variation in the facades to promote walkability on all streets. The units will provide an active use
along the street and conceal the parking beyond.
VARIANCE REQUEST
The project will provide several programmed outdoor amenity spaces to promote healthy living
and social interaction among residents. These spaces are intended to be used by the residents in
lieu of private balconies. The building will also be broken up with character lines and the use of
architectural elements to create visual interest along the facades. The project seeks relief from
the requirement to have a minimum of 60 percent of units with a balcony.
VARIANCE REQUEST
As an affordable housing project, this project will follow the Georgia Department of Community
Affairs standards for affordable housing, which requires 30% of the facades be brick or stone.
The buildings will be broken up with character lines and other architectural elements in
accordance with the UDO and will utilize high quality, durable materials on all façades. The
project seeks relieve from the minimum amount of exterior brick or stone on the facades.
Packet Pg. 48
83 POPLAR ST NW, ATLANTA, GA, 30303 • ATLANTA, GA 30308-2805 • TEL: 404.892.2443 • FAX: 404-892-2470 WWW.SMITHDALIA.COM
3.1.c
VARIANCE REQUEST
The project seeks variance approval to reduce the amount of parking required. The parking
Attachment: 2 - Application (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
provided will be in line with the applicant’s experienced parking needs for affordable housing
developments in Chamblee. Parking areas will be designed to meet the open space and planting
requirements of the UDO.
VARIANCE REQUEST
The project seeks variance approval to not provide interconnected parking lots. On 6th street,
the adjacent commercial property’s limited parking is between the building and the street.
Connecting to it would create an undesirable pedestrian experience along the sidewalk. The
adjacent property on 5th Street is a single family detached house.
WAIVER REQUEST
The project seeks waiver to not bury utilities as this would cause a major financial burden on the
project.
Packet Pg. 49
83 POPLAR ST NW, ATLANTA, GA, 30303 • ATLANTA, GA 30308-2805 • TEL: 404.892.2443 • FAX: 404-892-2470 WWW.SMITHDALIA.COM
3.1.c
Attachment: 2 - Application (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
Packet Pg. 50
83 POPLAR ST NW, ATLANTA, GA, 30303 • ATLANTA, GA 30308-2805 • TEL: 404.892.2443 • FAX: 404-892-2470 WWW.SMITHDALIA.COM
3.1.c
Attachment: 2 - Application (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
Packet Pg. 51
83 POPLAR ST NW, ATLANTA, GA, 30303 • ATLANTA, GA 30308-2805 • TEL: 404.892.2443 • FAX: 404-892-2470 WWW.SMITHDALIA.COM
3.1.d
4041 Clairmont Rd, et. al. - Aerial Map
Attachment: 3 - Maps (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
1:2,257
5/2/2021, 2:06:23 PM
0 0.01 0.03 0.06 mi
Address DeKalb County Tax Parcels Green: Band_2
0 0.03 0.05 0.1 km
Streams (DeKalb County) 2020 Aerial Imagery Blue: Band_3 © OpenStreetMap (and) contributors, CC-BY-SA
Attachment: 3 - Maps (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
NC-1
NC-2
1:2,257
5/2/2021, 2:09:29 PM
0 0.01 0.03 0.06 mi
Address I NR-1
0 0.03 0.05 0.1 km
Zoning Districts NC-1 Streams (DeKalb County)
© OpenStreetMap (and) contributors, CC-BY-SA
Attachment: 3 - Maps (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
1:9,028
5/2/2021, 2:08:13 PM
0 0.05 0.1 0.2 mi
Runway Protection Zones DeKalb County Tax Parcels
0 0.1 0.2 0.4 km
Streams (DeKalb County) © OpenStreetMap (and) contributors, CC-BY-SA
Attachment: 4 - Dekalb County School Report (2987 : PZ2021-808: Mercy Housing Clairmont DCI - 4041 Clairmont Road, et. al.)
Description: Affordable multi-family with 67 family units (and 55 senior units)
Impact of Development: When fully constructed, this development would be expected to generate 32 students: 12 at
Ashford Park Elementary School, 7 at Chamblee Middle School, 6 at Chamblee Charter High
School, 7 at other DCSD schools, and 0 at private school. Enrollment at Ashford Park and
Chamblee HS is already above capacity. Additional students from this development may cause
additional strain on the facilities' capacity.
Ashford Park Chamblee Chamblee
Elementary Middle Charter Other DCSD Private
Current Condition of Schools School School High School Schools Schools Total
Capacity 553 1,053 1,691
Portables 14 0 4
Enrollment (Fcast. Oct. 2021) 810 1,028 1,895
Seats Available -257 25 -204
Utilization (%) 146.5% 97.6% 112.1%
Student Calculations
Proposed Units 67
Unit Type APT
Cluster Chamblee Charter
Attend Attend other
Home DCSD Private
Units x Yield School School School Total
Elementary 11.60 5.06 0.11 16.77
Middle 6.52 1.52 0.00 8.04
High 6.07 0.91 0.00 6.98
Total 24.19 7.49 0.11 31.79
Packet Pg. 55