Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Workpiece Surface Modification Using Electrical Discharge Machining
Workpiece Surface Modification Using Electrical Discharge Machining
Received 23 August 2002; received in revised form 10 September 2002; accepted 19 September 2002
Abstract
Electrical discharge machining (EDM) is a widely used process in the mould / die and aerospace industries. Following a brief
summary of the process, the paper reviews published work on the deliberate surface alloying of various workpiece materials using
EDM. Details are given of operations involving powder metallurgy (PM) tool electrodes and the use of powders suspended in the
dielectric fluid, typically aluminium, nickel, titanium, etc. Following this, experimental results are presented on the surface alloying
of AISI H13 hot work tool steel during a die sink operation using partially sintered WC / Co electrodes operating in a hydrocarbon
oil dielectric. An L8 fractional factorial Taguchi experiment was used to identify the effect of key operating factors on output
measures (electrode wear, workpiece surface hardness, etc.). With respect to microhardness, the percentage contribution ratios (PCR)
for peak current, electrode polarity and pulse on time were ~24, 20 and 19%, respectively. Typically, changes in surface metallurgy
were measured up to a depth of ~30 µm (with a higher than normal voltage of ~270 V) and an increase in the surface hardness
of the recast layer from ~620 HK0.025 up to ~1350 HK0.025.
2002 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction piece rather than the tool suffers the majority of erosion
(~50–95%), however, some material is inevitably lost by
Since its development in the mid 1940s, EDM has the tool electrode. The last decade has seen significant
become widely used for the manufacture of components development of EDM technology in terms of generator
such as moulds / dies and aeroengine parts. The process design, with the use of fuzzy logic, high frequency
is thermal in nature with material removal occurring via ‘nano-pulse’ operation, EDM ‘milling’ using simple
the discharge of energy between a tool and workpiece electrodes, etc. [2]. There is also growing interest in the
electrode, which are separated by a small gap (~5–100 use of ‘greener’ more eco-friendly water-based dielec-
µm depending on electrical parameters) filled with a trics [3]. Similarly, the range of applications has
dielectric fluid, typically a hydrocarbon oil or deionised expanded to encompass the growing requirement for
water. A DC pulse generator is used to initiate discrete micro-scale features including holes down to 5 µm in
sparks which have a duration in the region of 0.2–100 diameter [4,5].
µs, followed by a similar period during which deionis- A number of EDM process configurations are cur-
ation of the dielectric occurs and the gap is flushed of rently employed in industry, involving die sinking and
debris [1]. Preferred polarity arrangements for different wire cutting, together with more specialised formats such
electrode and workpiece materials ensure that the work- as electrical discharge texturing (EDT) [6] and electrical
discharge grinding (EDG). The latter process is increas-
ingly being used for the manufacture of polycrystalline
∗
Corresponding author. Tel.: +44-121-414-3541; fax: +44-121- diamond (PCD) cutting tools [7,8], however, while there
414-3541. are hybrid machines which utilise both abrasive grinding
E-mail address: j.m.t.simao@bham.ac.uk (J. Simao). and spark erosion, the vast majority of commercial sys-
0890-6955/03/$ - see front matter 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
PII: S 0 8 9 0 - 6 9 5 5 ( 0 2 ) 0 0 1 8 7 - 6
122 J. Simao et al. / International Journal of Machine Tools & Manufacture 43 (2003) 121–128
tems employ no abrasives and here the term is a mis- Typically, the properties / characteristics of materials
nomer, stemming primarily from the use of a rotating chosen for tool electrodes when EDM particularly die
wheel electrode and similarity with a tool and cutter sinking, relate primarily to electrical conductivity, melt-
grinder configuration. With such machines, material ing / sublimation temperature and wear resistance. The
removal is entirely due to the spark discharge, either rapid degradation of tool electrodes is in general not a
when using the face or periphery of the graphite / cop- desirable feature. Under such circumstances mould / die
per wheel. accuracy and possibly integrity may be significantly
At present, the available techniques for enhancing the compromised, in the latter case due to debris accumu-
surface mechanical / physical / topographical properties lation in the spark gap and subsequent arcing. There are
of components subject to wear, corrosion / oxidation, also obvious adverse effects in terms of the higher costs
etc. include: carburising, nitriding, chromium plating and associated with electrode supply, workpiece productivity
in some instances, chemical / physical vapour deposition and dielectric filtration. Nevertheless, research has been
(CVD / PVD), ion beam techniques and plasma arc carried out in recent years to determine the possibility
spraying [9]. Such processes can offer significant pro- of using electrodes as feed stock material, in an effort
perty enhancements, however, they are secondary oper- to produce significant workpiece surface alloying and in
ations which either require expensive in-house equip- so doing, enhance the wear (abrasion) and corrosion /
ment or the use of sub-contract companies. They oxidation resistance of the machined surface [17–28].
therefore add to costs and lead times, in some instances, The electrodes employed are generally produced using
significantly so. In addition, components that have been
a PM route, in order to achieve the necessary combi-
manufactured using standard EDM techniques may
nation of operating characteristics. Fig. 1 details deliber-
require prior removal of the white / recast layer before
ate surface alloying using an appropriate PM tool elec-
applying or depositing a hardmetal or ceramic coating
trode and a hydrocarbon dielectric fluid for the texturing
because of adverse residual stress conditions or
and surface alloying of a workpiece, in this instance a
unfavourable mechanical properties. An alternative
approach is deliberate surface alloying / modification cold mill work roll, however, it could also be a mould
during EDM which dispenses with the need for sup- / die cavity or alternatively an aeroengine component
plementary processing / coating following machining, such as a snubber contact area on a low pressure com-
thereby providing lower costs and more flexibility. pressor blade.
A wide range of powders with alternative compo-
sitions can be used for the manufacture of tool elec-
2. EDM surface alloying / modification method trodes. These tend to be materials which can form /
Spark discharge temperatures of up to 20,000 °C have transfer hard particles such as carbides and may incor-
been reported [1]. Consequently, surface alloying is larg- porate a secondary binder phase, e.g. WC/Co,
ely unavoidable albeit at a low level, even when using TiC/WC/Co, W/CrC/Cu, etc. By using electrodes made
standard electrodes with preferred polarity. Deliberate from different materials, the possibility exists to ‘engin-
alloying requires the use of appropriate electrodes, eer’ one or more alloyed layers (which may be func-
and/or the addition of powders suspended in the dielec- tionally graded) with different mechanical properties.
tric fluid which itself plays a key role. The former The compacting and sintering conditions under which
approach is the most widely published. Use of powders the PM electrodes are produced greatly affect their per-
has grown in recent years as a means of increasing pro- formance. Fig. 2 details measurements of density and
ductivity and reducing workpiece surface roughness / electrical resistivity for various green compact, partially
associated microcracks, due to greater electrical conduc- sintered and fully sintered PM electrodes produced from
tivity in the spark gap / reduction in the breakdown volt- WC / 6 wt.% Co binder. While electrodes sintered to
age and higher discharge frequency. Lower electrode full density may offer high conductivity and consistent
wear with water dielectrics containing a powder suspen- sparking, the release of material is generally low and
sion is also possible [10–13]. The powders (typically consequently, surface alloying limited.
⬍ 100 µm) include graphite, silicon, silicon carbide, The aim of the present work was to identify the effect
aluminium, aluminium oxide, nickel, titanium, chro- of relevant EDM operating parameters (voltage, current,
mium and copper. While academic and industrial work pulse on-time, polarity and capacitance) on material
indicates significant benefits, little is detailed on possible removal rate (MRR), electrode wear, workpiece surface
problems associated with the cost / life of powders, fluid roughness and surface microhardness, in order to achieve
concentration / circulation / filtration, agglomeration and enhanced surface alloying.
arcing. Surface alloying work using this technique for
the accretion of titanium carbide layers is detailed by
[14,15], while [16] used nickel powders to double the
surface hardness of an aluminium bronze.
J. Simao et al. / International Journal of Machine Tools & Manufacture 43 (2003) 121–128 123
3. Experimental work
Table 2
L8 orthogonal array
A B AB C AC E (BC) D (ABC)
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
2 1 1 1 2 2 2 2
3 1 2 2 1 1 2 2
4 1 2 2 2 2 1 1
5 2 1 2 1 2 1 2
6 2 1 2 2 1 2 1
7 2 2 1 1 2 2 1
8 2 2 1 2 1 1 2
Table 1
Rationalised factors and levels for L8 orthogonal array
∗
Only 2.9 A available with the ~270 V generator.
J. Simao et al. / International Journal of Machine Tools & Manufacture 43 (2003) 121–128 125
Table 3
Taguchi experiment—results
Volumetric tool wear VTW Workpiece MRR Workpiece surface roughness Workpiece surface microhardness (HK
(mm3) (mm3/min) Ra (µm) 0.025)
Table 5
Confirmation test—results
Output measures
Volumetric tool wear VTW Workpiece MRR (mm3/min) Workpiece surface roughness Workpiece surface
(mm3) Ra (µm) microhardness HK 0.025)
Takawashi, K. Kobayashi, EDM by Powder Suspended Working [21] N. Mohri, N. Saito, H. Momiyama, Y. Tsunekawa, Surface Modi-
Fluid, in: Proceedings of the 9th International Symposium for fication by EDM—Composite Electrode Method, in: Proceedings
Electro Machining (ISEM-9), Nagoya, Japan, April 1989, 5–8. of the 10th International Symposium on Electro Machining
[12] Y.-F. Tzeng, C.-Y. Lee, Effects of powder characteristics on elec- (ISEM-10), 1992, 587–590.
trodischarge machining efficiency, International Journal of [22] N. Mohri, N. Saito, Y. Tsunekawa, N. Kinoshita, Metal surface
Advanced Manufacturing Technology 17 (8) (2001) 586–592. modification by electrical discharge machining with composite
[13] M.L. Jeswani, Effects of the additive of graphite powder to kero- electrode, Annals of the CIRP 42 (1) (1993) 219–222.
sene used as the dielectric fluid in electrical discharge machining, [23] Y. Tsunekawa, M. Okumiya, N. Mohri, I. Takahashi, Surface
Wear 70 (1981) 133–139. modification of aluminium by electrical discharge alloying,
[14] K. Furutani, A. Saneto, H. Takezawa, N. Mohri, H. Miyake, Sur- Materials Science and Engineering A174 (1994) 193–198.
face Modification by Electrical Discharge Machining with [24] K. Masui, K. Demizu, Y. Satu, T. Stone, Surface Modification
Titanium Powder Suspended in Working Fluid, in: Proceedings of Tool Steels by Alloying Method using EDM Process, in: Pro-
of 14th Annual Meeting of American Society for Precision Engin- ceedings of the 11th International Symposium on Electro Machin-
eering, Monterey, California, USA, 1999, 159–162. ing (ISEM-11), 1995, 419–426.
[15] K. Furutani, A. Saneto, H. Takezawa, N. Mohri, H. Miyake, [25] A. Gangadhur, M.S. Shunmugam, P.K. Philip, Surface modifi-
Accretion of titanium carbide by electrical discharge machining cation in electrodischarge processing with a powder compact tool
with powder suspended in working fluid, Journal of the Inter- electrode, Wear 143 (1991) 45–55.
national Societies for Precision Engineering and Nanotechnology
[26] D.I. Pantelis, N.M. Vaxevanidis, A.E. Houndri, P. Dumas, M.
25 (2001) 138–144.
Jeandin, Investigation into the application of electrodischarge
[16] Y. Uno, A. Okada, Y. Hayashi, Y. Tabuchi, Surface modification
machining as steel surface modification technique, Surface
by EDM with nickel powder mixed fluid, International Journal
Engineering 14 (1) (1998) 55–61.
of Electrical Machining 4 (1999) 47–52.
[27] O. Lecomt, M. Jeandin, M. Frainais, Surface Modification of a
[17] A. Goto, T. Moro, K. Matsukawa, M. Akiyoshi, N. Saito, N.
Conventional Steel by Electro-discharge Machining, in: Proceed-
Mohri, Development of Electrical Discharge Coating Method, in:
Proceedings of the 13th International Symposium for Electro ings of the Conference on Advances in Materials and Processes,
Machining (ISEM-13), Bilbao, Spain, May 2001, 2, 581–588. Bombay, India, 1992, pp. 525–536.
[18] A. Goto, T. Magara, T. Moro, H. Miyako, N. Saito, N. Mohri, [28] J. Simao, D.K. Aspinwall, M.F. El-Menshawy, K. Meadows, Sur-
Formation of Hard Layer on Metallic Material by EDM, in: Pro- face alloying using PM composite electrode materials when elec-
ceedings of the 12th International Symposium for Electro Mach- trical discharge texturing hardened AISI D2, Journal of Materials
ining (ISEM-12), Aachen, Germany, May 1998, 271–278. Processing Technology, 2002, Article in press.
[19] M.P. Samuel, P.K. Philip, Properties of compacted, pre-sintered [29] J. Simao, I. Ong, D.K. Aspinwall, Electrical Discharge Roll Tex-
and fully sintered electrodes produced by powder metallurgy for turing (EDT) using Different Generator and Dielectric Flushing
electrical discharge machining, Indian Journal of Engineering and Arrangements, in: Proceedings of the 32nd International Matador
Materials Sciences 3 (1996) 229–233. Conference, Manchester, 10–11 July 1997, 1997, pp. 411–416.
[20] Y. Fukuzawa, Y. Kojima, T. Tani, E. Sekiguti, N. Mohri, Fabri- [30] D.K. Aspinwall, M.L.H. Wise, K.J. Stout, T.H.A. Goh, F.L.
cation of surface modification layer on stainless steel by electrical Zhao, M.F. El-Menshawy, Electrical discharge texturing, Inter-
discharge machining, Materials and Manufacturing Processes 10 national Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture 32 (1/2)
(2) (1995) 195–203. (1992) 183–193.