Professional Documents
Culture Documents
53 G30118064 Dewi KQ
53 G30118064 Dewi KQ
Received: July 2019; Revision: December 2019; Accepted: June 2020; Available online: August 2020
Abstract
The potential corrosion inhibitor properties of xanthone compounds and its derivatives (gartanin, 8-
desoxygartanin, α-mangostine, and β-mangostine) can be demonstrated through Density Functional Density
Theory (DFT) at the theoretical level B3LYP/6-31G(d, p). Quantum chemical parameters such as the energy of
the highest molecular orbital occupied by electrons (E HOMO), the energy of the lowest molecular orbitals not
occupied by electrons (ELUMO), energy gap (Egap / ΔE), dipole moment (µ), and total energy (E tot) can be
calculated using DFT method. The DFT data analysis equation can determine the value; potential energy (I),
electron affinity (A), absolute electronegativity (χ), global hardness (η), global softness (σ), number of transfer
electrons (ΔN), electrophilicity (ω), and corrosion inhibition efficiency (IE%) . The results of quantum chemical
parameter calculations show the potential inhibitory properties of gartanin > α-mangostine > β-mangostine > 8-
desoxygartanin > xanthone, with the calculated corrosion inhibition efficiency value of gartanin of 86.54%.
DOI: 10.15408/jkv.v6i1.11953
process of chemical reactions with the use inhibitors derived from extracts of natural
environment. The environment can be in the ingredients (Umoren et al., 2011). Various
form of water, air, solution, soil, and biology organic compounds containing heteroatoms (N,
which are often referred to as corrosive media. S,O) which can donate electrons have been
Thermodynamic corrosion events occur when used as corrosion inhibitors. The use of organic
the environment has a more positive standard inhibitors to prevent corrosion is a promising
electrode potential than metal (Trethewey et al., alternative. These inhibitors are usually
1988). Corrosion inhibitors are an excellent adsorbed on the metal surface by forming
method for preventing corrosion. Generally, coordination bonds (chemical adsorption) or
corrosion inhibitors come from synthetic electrostatic interactions between metals and
chemicals which are dangerous chemicals, the inhibitors (physical adsorption) (Obayes et al.
price is relatively expensive and not 2014).
environmentally friendly. One alternative is to
Figure 1. Molecular structure of Xanthones and its derivatives (Walker et al., 2007).
96
Theoretical Study of Xanthone Derivative Corrosion Inhibitors Using Density Functional Theory (DFT) Ramadhani, et.al.
corrosion, and good inhibition for Fe metals studies, xanthones have been used as
(Obot et al., 2011). Gartanin, 8-desoxygartanin, antioxidants (Chiang et al., 2003; Jung et al.,
α-mangostine and β-mangostine are derivatives 2006), anti-malaria (Likhitwitayawuid et al.,
of xanthone compounds, xanthone compounds 1998), anti-acne activities (Chomnawang et al.,
and their derivatives have been tested for their 2005), and not only for health, xanthones also
compounds contained in mangosteen plants have anti-corrosion ability (Obi et al., 2011).
where other content obtained by xanthone All of these xanthones derivatives can be
derivatives is α-mangostine, β-mangostine, and obtained in the garcinia mangostana plant
their derivatives have been tested for their known as mangosteen fruit, which in this plant
compounds contained in mangosteen plants contains quite a number of xanthones
where other content obtained by xanthhone derivatives (Walker et al., 2007). Mangosteen
derivatives is α-mangostine, β-mangostine, 8 - plants themselves are effective as corrosion
desoxygartanin, and xanthones that have been inhibitors, while the chemical structure of
analyzed using HPLC (Walker et al., 2007) xanthones forms the main core of various
The main objective of this research is natural compositions such as mangostin, which
to determine the efficiency of inhibition of are sometimes collectively referred to as
xanthone molecules and their derivatives xanthones (Obi et al., 2011).
(gartanin, 8-desoxygartanin, α-mangostine, and Experiments have been proven
β-mangostine) using the DFT method. xanthone has good inhibiting properties and
Quantum chemical parameters to be calculated environmentally friendly, where xanthone
namely; EHOMO, ELUMO, gap energy (ΔE), molecules have carbonyl groups, oxygen
dipole moment (μ), total energy, electron atoms, and aromatic rings with several bonds
affinity (A), ionization potential (I), global that can be used as active sites for the inhibitor
hardness (η), global softness (σ), process. Xanthones also have a large molecular
electronegtivity (χ), electropylicity (A) ω), and mass (196.19 g / mol) which effectively has
the number of transfer electrons (ΔN) of many surfaces for the process of adsorption
xanthone compounds and their derivatives. with mild steel (Obot et al., 2011)
The best-known acid inhibitors are
2. MATERIALS AND METHODS organic compounds that contain nitrogen,
All quantum mechanical calculations sulfur, and oxygen atoms. In general, organic
have been achieved using the Gaussian09 molecules resist corrosion by adsorption on
package (frisch et al., 2009). The geometry of metal surfaces. Furthermore, adsorption
all systems investigated by xanthone, gartanin, depends on the electronic structure of
8-desoxygartanin, α-mangostine, and β- molecular inhibitors, steric factors, aromaticity
mangostine shown in Figure 1 is optimized at and electron density at the donor site, there are
the level of functional function theory using functional groups such as C=O, N= N, R-OH
functional B3LYP (a combination of exchange and other groups, molecular areas, many
from Becke with three parameters of hybrid molecules, and electrochemical potential on
exchange function (B3) using the dynamic metal solutions or interfaces (Obot et al.,
correlation function Lee, Yang and Parr 2011).
(LYP)). The triple-zeta quality base regulated Table 1 distributes HOMO and LUMO
by polarization and diffuse functions denoted energy molecular orbitals in the composition of
6-31G(d, p) has been used. In this study, the Xanthones and its derivatives show electrons
electronic properties of the inhibitors were located in all C=O, O-H, C-O-C bonds and in
investigated by calculating the energy of the the benzene ring. The distribution of EHOMO
highest molecular orbitals occupied by and ELUMO is shown by the two positive and
electrons (EHOMO), the energy of the lowest negative phases of the orbitals represented by
molecular orbitals not occupied by electrons two colors. The green area represents an
(ELUMO), energy gap ( ΔE), dipole moment (µ), increase in electron density and the red color
and energy total. represents a decrease in electron density. The
HOMO distribution of xanthones, α-
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION mangostin, and β-mangostin is seen as
Gartanin, 8-desoxygartanin, α- electrons located in C-C bonds found in the
mangostine, and β-mangostine are derivatives benzene ring, C-O-C bonds, and C=O bonds,
of xanthone composition. As in previous whereas in gartanin and 8-desoxygartani
97
Jurnal Kimia Valensi, Vol. 6, No. 1, May 2020 [95-103] P-ISSN : 2460-6065, E-ISSN : 2548-3013
compounds the electrons are not located in the binds O-H, which is caused by another
bonds C=O but located in another bond. The benzene group there is a 2-pentene subtituent
distribution of LUMO molecular orbitals in that causes electrons to push towards the
combination of xanthones and electron benzene group which has many O-H bonds.
derivatives is spread throughout the benzene Organic compounds that contain oxygen bonds
ring, C-O-C bonds, C=O bonds, C-C bonds, C- are in great demand as corrosion inhibitors due
H bonds and also in O-H bonds. to the contribution of π bonds from double or
Table 1 also shows gartanin triple bonds they have (Obayes et al., 2017).
compounds for the distribution of molecular The existence of this π bond will help the
orbital densities in HOMO showing a very formation of complexes between organic
significant difference in form compared to compounds and metal surfaces by coordinating
xanthones and other derivatives. In the picture, covalent bonds (chemical adsorption) or
it can be seen that the electrons are more electrostatically (physical adsorption) (Noor et
located in the part of the benzene group that al., 2005).
Table 1. Frontier molecular orbitals (MO) of Xanthones and its derivatives at B3LYP/6-31(d,p) level of theory
Xanthone
Gartanin
8-Desoxygartanin
α-Mangostine
β-mangostine
98
Theoretical Study of Xanthone Derivative Corrosion Inhibitors Using Density Functional Theory (DFT) Ramadhani, et.al.
Table 2. Quantum chemical properties of Xanthones and its derivatives using the DFT method
99
Jurnal Kimia Valensi, Vol. 6, No. 1, May 2020 [95-103] P-ISSN : 2460-6065, E-ISSN : 2548-3013
Table 3. Quantum chemical parameters of Xanthones and their derivatives using calculations
The ionization potential (I) for dedicates that gartanin is a compound that will
gartanin compounds shown in Table 3 has a easily interact with metal surfaces.
high ionization potential value (0.19216 au). It = (3)
can be concluded that gartanin can act as a
good inhibitor. From Table 3 it is also seen that = (4)
a low electronegativity (χ) will give a good ω= (5)
electrophile where a low electronegativity
value will indicate that the compound has a σ= (6)
high electronegativity so that it will make it
ΔN = (7)
easier to accept electrons. Table 3 shows the
electronegativity value of the gartanin
compound which has a lower value compared Global chemical hardness basically
to the xanthone compound which is 0.12224 signifies resistance to deformation or
eV. Another derivative that has a low polarization of electron clouds from atomic or
electronegativity value is the 8-desoxygartanin molecular ions under slight interference to
compound which has the lowest value chemical reactions. Global hardness molecules
compared to other derivatives that is 0.12160 have a small tendency to react, whereas for
eV which can be seen in Table 3. global softness, molecules have a large
From the parameters of quantum tendency to react (Pearson, 1986). Global
chemical calculations it is concluded that hardness (η) and global softness (σ) which are
gartanin can also act as a good inhibitor which also calculated and can be seen in Table 2
will interact with metal surfaces later. With a show measures of molecular stability and
low potential value of gartanin compounds and inhibitor reactivity. Global violence has a large
a low electronegativity value will provide high ΔE and global tenderness has a small ΔE (Obi
stability in the interaction between inhibitors et al., 2011). Electron polarizability also called
with ferrous metals, and inhibitor compounds global softness is a measure of the capacity of
will have a higher strength to bind to the atoms or groups of atoms to receive electrons
surface of Fe metals (Wazzan et al., 2014). (Senet, 1997). The small value of global
In numerical applications, the chemical hardness will make molecules easier to react
potential of dipole moments (μ) and global with metal surfaces and also the high value of
hardness (η) is generally expressed based on global softness will also make molecules easier
differences in estimates in terms of ionization to react with Fe metal surfaces.
potential I and electron affinity A. In equations Table 3 also shows the very high
3 and 4. The electropility index (ω) and global electropicity value of gartanin is 470,33824
softness (σ) can be expressed in equations 5 D2eV-1. Electrophilicity provides information
and 6 (Gece et al., 2017). about the nucleophilic or electrophilic nature
In Table 3 we can see the value of of a molecule. High electrophilicity will act as
gartanin compounds for the value of global electrophilic while low electrophilicity values
hardness obtained by the smallest value will act as nucleophilic (Kalaiselvi et al.,
(0.06992 eV) and high global softness value 2014). In accordance with the values obtained,
(14.30206 eV-1) compared to xanthone gartanin has a high electrophilicity value so
compounds and other derivatives. This that it can act as a good electrophile with the
surface of Fe later.
100
Theoretical Study of Xanthone Derivative Corrosion Inhibitors Using Density Functional Theory (DFT) Ramadhani, et.al.
Table 4. Corrosion inhibitor efficiency (IE%) for Xanthones compounds and their derivatives
The number of transfer electrons (ΔN) theoretical calculations using the DFT method
can also be seen in Table 3 which is calculated (Obayes et al., 2014).
using equation 7, if ΔN < 3.6, the inhibitory Table 4 shows the results of the
efficiency will increase if the number of calculation of the efficiency of corrosion
electron transfers is not too high, thus inhibitors of Xanthone compositions with their
increasing the electron contribution of the derivatives. The efficiency value of Xanthones
inhibiting compound to the metal surface derivatives was obtained using equations 8.9
(Wazzan et al., 2014). In Table 2 it can be seen and 10. According to Obot et al, (2011). The
that all electron transfer values in Xanthone calculation results show that the ratio for
compounds and their derivatives have values gartanin composition is the highest compared
<3.6, but all gartanin optimized compounds are to the composition of Xanthones and other
compounds with the lowest electron transfer derivatives. In Table 4 it can be seen that the
values compared to other compounds. So it can efficiency of the composition of gartanin is
be concluded that this gartanin compound 86.54% which is a higher value compared to
which will act as an inhibitor, will make an the efficiency of the composition of Xanthones
increase in the ability of electron donors on the and other derivatives. So it can be concluded
metal surface. that the gartanin compound has a very high
Xanthones compounds have an potential to act as a corrosion inhibitor which
efficiency value of 74.08% which has been will be reacted on the metal surface.
done experimentally by Obot et al., (2011).
This value is a reference to get the xanthone 4. CONCLUSION
derivative value using the equation below. The DFT method using functional
B3LYP / 6-31G (d, p) in the gaussian09
(8) program can be used to determine the potential
of xanthone and their four derivatives
(9) compounds consisting of gartanin, 8-
(10) desoxygartanin, α-mangostine, and β-
mangostine as corrosion inhibitors. Inhibition
Where Iadd% is the percentage of potential efficiency obtained through quantum chemical
ionization of Xanthone derivatives, obtained calculations from these inhibitors shows an
from the value of ionization potential (I) in increase with increasing EHOMO values,
xanthone compounds (Iinh) and the value of decreasing ELUMO values and low energy gap
ionization potential in xanthone derivatives (Ix- values (ΔE) and from this analysis it can be
inh). Whereas for the Ieadd% equation is the concluded that gartanin is the best inhibitor
percentage of xanthone derivative corrosion compared to other compounds in this study.
inhibitor efficiency obtained by multiplying Electronic parameters such as global hardness
the percentage value of xanthone derivative (η) and global softness (σ) confirm the
ionization potential (Iadd%), IEinh% is the inhibitory efficiency in the order of gartanin >
percentage of inhibitor efficiency (IE%) from 8-desoxygartanin > α-mangostin > β-
the experimental results obtained by Obot et. mangostine > Xanthones. Gartanin also
al, and IE theory is the percentage of showed the highest inhibitor efficiency (IE%)
Xanthones corrosion inhibitors derived from at 86.54%.
101
Jurnal Kimia Valensi, Vol. 6, No. 1, May 2020 [95-103] P-ISSN : 2460-6065, E-ISSN : 2548-3013
Emriadi, Diah R.G, Admin A, Mai E. 2015, Water Obot IB, Egbedi NO. 2011. Anti-corrosive
extract of cassava leaf as corrosion properties of xanthone on mild steel
inhibitor for mild steel in suluric and corrosion in sulphuric acid: experimental
solution. JCPRC5. 7(12) : 398-405 and theoritical investigations. Journal of
Current Applied Physics. 11: 382-39.
Gece G. 2008. The use of quantum chemical https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cap.2010.08.007.
methods in corrosion inhibitor studies.
Corros. Sci. 50: 2981–2992: Obi-Egbedi NO, Obot IB, El-Khaiary MI. 2011.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.corsci.2008.08.04 Quantum Chemical Investigation and
3. Statistical Analysis of relationship
Gece G, Bilgic S. 2017. Acomputational study of between corrosion inhibition eficiency and
two hexitol borates as corrosion inhibitor molecular structure of xanthene and its
for steel. J.Corros.ScaleInhib. 6(4): 476- derivatives on mild steel in sulphuric acid.
484. https://doi.org/10.17675/2305-6894- Journal of molecular structure. 1002: 86-
2017-6-4-7. 96. https://doi.org/10.1016/j-
moistruc.2011.07.003.
Kalaiselvi K, Brindha T, Mallika J. 2014. Quantum
chemical studies on the corrosion Pearson RG. 1986. Absolute electronegativity and
inhibition of mild steel by piperidin-4-one hardness correlated with molecular orbital
derivatives in 1M H3PO4,” O. J. Metal. 4: theory. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 83: 8440-
73-85. 8441.https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.83.22.84
https://doi.org/10.4236/ojmetal.2014.4400 40.
9.
102
Theoretical Study of Xanthone Derivative Corrosion Inhibitors Using Density Functional Theory (DFT) Ramadhani, et.al.
Senet P. 1997. Chemical hardnesses of atoms and Walker. 2007. HPLC analysis of selected
molecules from frontier orbitals. Chem. Xanthones in mangosteen fruit. J. Sep. Sci.
Phys. Lett., 275(5): 527- 30: 1229–
532:https://doi.org/10.1016/s0009- 1234.https://doi.org/10.1002.jssc.2007000
2614(97)00799-9. 24.
Trethewey, Kenneth R. 1988. Corrosion, for Wazzan NA, Mahgoub FM. 2014. DFT calculations
students science and engineering. for corrosion inhibition of ferrous alloys
Longman Group UK Limited. ISBN- by pyrazolopyrimidine Derivatives,
13:978-0582450899. J.OJPC. 4(4): 6-14.
https://doi.org/10.4236/ojpc.2014.41002.
Umoren SA, Obot IB, Obi-Egbedi NO. 2011.
Corrosion Inhibition and Absorption Wolinski K, Hinton JF, Pulay P. 1990. Efficient
Behaviour For Alumunium by Exract of implementartion of the Gauge-Independent
Aningeria Robusta in HCL Solution: atomic orbital method for NMR chemichal
Synergistic Effect of Iodide Ions. shift calculation. J.Am.Chem. Soc. 112:
University of Uyo. Nigeria: 21- 8250-8260.
22:https://doi.org/10.1.1.718.6805. https://doi.org/10.1021/ja00179a005.
103